The Nation 1882-09-28: Vol 35 Iss 900
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 28, 1882 The Week. Tue Herald, the Times, and the Journal of Commerce had leading articles on Saturday of a somewhat alarming character on the sub- ject of the relations of the Associated Press with the Western Union Telegraph Company and its present controller, Mr. Jay Gould. The substance of the matter, as stated, is that Gould and the telegraph company have manifested a desire and purpose to have a voice in the collection as well as the trans- mission of the news for the press, and to supplement their functions as common car- riers with those of news agents. This atti- tude on the part of Gould and the telegraph company, the Herald imforms us, has been supported or acquiesced in by three mem- bers of the New York Association—viz., the Tribune, the World, and the Hapress—and, up to arecent period, opposed by four mem- beis—viz., the Herald, Times, Sun, and Jour- nal of Commerce. The Journal of Com- merce says also that offers for the purchase of that paper were lately made, which it be- lieves to have been made with-.a view to obtaining another vote in furtherance of this scheme. Some time after this offer had been made and declined it is stated that the Sun ex- hibited signs of wavering and of going over to the Gould side, but has stopped short of actually doing so. The 7imes publishes sun- dry extracts from the Sun on the subject of Gould and his political projects which lead the former to indulge the hope that Mr. Dana is not under Gould’s influence to any alarming extent. The Journal of Com- merce, on the other hand, appears to take a very serious view of the Sun’s attitude, and the Herald thinks that the time has nearly come for the Government to consider the expediency of taking the telegraph busi- ness of the country into its own hands. The attitude of the Western Associated Press is also commented on as not so decidedly op- posed to the Gould plan as it might be and ought to be. Supposing the information given by these papers to be correct, the only comment the case admits of is that any partnership between the newspaper press and the Western Union Telegraph Company (whether controlled by Jay Gould or by any other man), in the busi- ness of collecting and preparing the news by which the people are guided ia their daily aifairs, is not to be thought of. Such a project will be resisted by every journal with the least grain of independence—every one whose opinions are of any value or conse- quence. We have not the least idea that the Sun will yield upon that issue an inch more than the Herald, or the Zimes, or the Journal of Commerce. Nor have we any ap- prehension that the Western Associated Press will ever consent to such a partnership. There 4s, we believe, another issue involved in the con- troversy—whether the Associated Press shall allow itself to be forced into an exclusive con- tract with the Western Union Telegraph Com- pany, binding all its members and clients to give all their business, general and special, to the Western Union Telegraph Company, under a threat that if such a contract is not made the latter will take the news business into its own hands. We can understand how the Sun may desire to avoid a quarrel of this kind without intending ever to admit the telegraph company into a partnership in the news busi- ness. The ‘‘ exclusive contract” system, how- ever, is manifestly a species of tyranny, and ought to be resisted upon grounds of public as well as private policy. The results obtained at the Saratoga Con- vention cannot be considered a fair expression of the wishes of the Republican voters of New York. Setting aside the small tricks and trades so effectively employed after the Con- vention met, by which the mastery of the State Committee was obtained and the Dutch- ess County delegation taken from Governor Cornell, the nominal victory achieved by the Administration party was based upon the virtual disfranchisement of four-fifths of the Republican voters of New York city. The rotten boroughs of Manhattan Island nomi- nated Folger and Carpenter. The disgraceful condition of the party machinery in this city has long been the opprobrium of State poli- tics, and to some extent of national politics. Last year the State Convention, controlled by the opponents of the Administration, seem- ed to be in the mood to order a reténrolment. of the electors, to the end that all Republicans within the respective Assembly districts en- titled to vote might participate, if they chose to do so, in the selection of delegates to nomi- nating conventions. The resolution looking to this reform was defeated by a small majori- ty. A year has passed by, and the rotten boroughs have ground out their customary grist of misrepresentation. We are perfectly convinced that the large majority of the Re- publicans of New York city were opposed to the nomination of Mr. Folger, or of any can- didate wearing the badge of the Washington Administration. If the votes of those who were not allowed to participate in the primaries cannot be claimed for the candidates on any other ground, they can certainly not be claimed, even under the prevailing rules of party ethics, for a ticket so nominated, on the ground of or- dinary party obligation. The question whether Mr. Folger should, and whether he will, resign his position as Secretary of the Treasury at once, or whether he may be permitted to wait until after the New York State election, seems to agitate the poli- ticiansin Washington severely, and presumah'y those elsewhere who in some way or another expect to be benefited by a change. Some persons, probably belonging to the latter class, seem to be very anxious that the change should take place as soon as possible, and al- though perhaps not very punctilious as to political propriety under ordinary circum stances, they insist that Mr. Folger cannot with decency remain at the head of the Treasury while he is a candidate for the Governorship of New York. Why not? Be cause it may be said that he will use the power and patronage of his office to further his canvass inthe State? It is just as prob able that the Treasury patronage would be used for him by his successor as by him self. We see no reason why Mr. Folger should resign on that account. When a Pre sident or a Governor is nominated for retlec tion, he 1s not expected to give up his place during the campaign. The same rule applies to the Secretary of the Treasury. Besides, Mr. Folger, 1f he wants to remain in official life at all, had better wait and see how the elecuon will turn out. There is no want of candidates for Mr. Fol ger’s place. In the first line Mr. New, of In diana, now Assistant Secretary of the Trea sury, is mentioned; and it is reported from Washington that he not only has * set his heart upon it,” but that he beheves he has a ‘*sure thing.” The reason offered quite seri, ously by a Washington paper why, according to the fitness of things, Mr. New should be given the Treasury Department, is a very curi ous one. It says that the success of the Re publicans in Indiana at the last Presidential election was mainly owing to three men: ex Senator Dorsey, Mr. Dudley, and Mr New. One of these, it says, had an of fer of a place in the Cabinet (ex-Senator Dorsey); one was put at the head of a large and influential office, the Pension Bureau (Mr. Dudley); and now, Dorsey and Dudley having had their chance, it is no more than fit and proper that the third one, Mr. New, should be made Secretary of the Treasury. This is con clusive, and ought to settle it. That Mr. New is a man of a calibre rather small for the Trea sury Department might be overlooked under such extraordinary circumstances. But from a variety of symptoms we must conclude that the Stalwarts of this State are blind to the eternal fitness of things, and look upon Mr. New’s elevation to the head of the Treasury with great disfavor. They do not want anybody there who might manage the Treasury patronage from a Western point of view. They insist that the Treasury should continue to be in the hands of a New York man. Their voices are, therefore, for Mr. Crowley, of this State, now a member of Congress, to whom, however, some Stal- warts of influence prefer ex-Senator ‘* Tom"’ Platt. There is evidently a chance for states- men. No wonder some of them are getting impatient at Mr. Folger’s backward ess in re. signing. The shrewdest and most important piece of work done by the Democratic Convention at Syracuse consisted in the nomination of Mayor Cleveland, an able and highly respected lawyer of Buffalo, for the Governorship. Mr. Cleveland is not a man of national reputation, but he has just that kind of standing before the people
Page 2
IHL we Qe Lhe Nation. [ Number 900 which is apt to tell in a campaign like this. A popular uprising against Republican ring rule lifted him into the mayoralty of the city of Buffalo, a Republican city, by a majority of many thousands. He has therefore the ad- vantage of having already once, as a Demo- crat, been elected to an important place by Republican votes, and all reports agree that he has fully justified the expectations of his constituents by crushing dishonesty and evil practices, Democratic and Republican, right and left, with an iron hand, and taking care of the interests of the city in every direction with excellent judgment. There does not seem to be any impression anywhere that Mr. Cleveland’s nomination was brought about by any illegitimate influences, or that he owes it to anybody in particular. His character as a citizen and as a public officer, and his success as a politician in this nomination, seem to be equally unimpeachable. The principal Republican paper in Buffalo has declared in fa- vorof Mr. Cleveland, anda telegraphic despatch reports that thousands of Republican citizens there are offering him theirsupport. In other parts of the State signs of great disaffection among Republicans are constantly appearing. On their side, the Democrats are united again and will act harmoniously for the first time in many years. It is true that the admission of Tammany will in the course of time bear a large crop of trouble and confusion to the Democrats. But at present, at least, they will act together, probably with much vigor and enthusiasm. Will it be surprising if the out- come of all this is a disastrous Republican de- teat? If so, the party will have to thank for it that overbearing faction whose selfish, dicta- torial, and demoralizing rule has for a long time made many good Republicans think that temporary defeat would be a wholesome lesson. That thought may become an impor- tant factor in this year’s contest. The Massachusetts Convention got over the difficulty about the River and Harbor Bill very successfully. There was no mention of it either in Mr. Hoar’s speech as Chairman, nor, as we telieve out of courtesy to him, was there any in the platform. But con- demnation of it was very clearly expressed by the nomination of Mr. Bishop for the Governorship over Mr. Crapo, one of the late members of Congress who voted for the bill, and who, but for this disturbing force, would undoubtedly have obtained it. His failure to get it appears to be generally taken as an in- dication that Mr. Hoar’s own chance of re- election is small, or, in other words, that the disapproval of his vote on the River and Harbor Bill felt by his constituents has not been modified or overcome by his print- ed defence of it. was strongly protectionist, and, indeed, treat- ed protection in an extreme form as a fundamental Republican doctrine, and in this probably revealed the real source of his error with regard to the River and Har- of the value of a high tanff must be even un- consciously disposed to lax views as to the manner in which the surplus thus accumu- lated in the Treasury should be spent. The Convention dealt with this aspect of the case gently but tirmly, by saying that “it is clearly the duty of Congress to act speedily to reduce taxation in all its forms, and to lighten the burders of the people. More revenue than is needed for the public uses the Government should not take. An overflowing treasury offers tempting inducements and a_plau- sible excuse for inordinate expenditure.” As the result is held to indicate the triumph of the younger generation of Republicans over those who have had the party in charge since the war, and who, however progressive, are still somewhat dominated by its ideas and in- fluences, there is apparently enough discordant feeling created to give some comfort to the Democrats, but Butler’s nomination is a plas- ter which would probably heal any possible amount of soreness or dissension among Re- publicans. The Connecticut Republicans also abstained | from touching the River and Harbor Bill, but His own opening speech | they heartily endorsed President Arthur, and also said a good word, though not quite so strong a one, for civil-service reform. Both denounce assessments, which is hard on the Congressional Committee, who are circulating a defence of them by a New England Senator as a campaign document. The Connecticut Republicans are more outspoken about prohi- bition, as they recommend the submission of an amendment to the Constitution prohibiting the manufacture and sale of intoxicating drinks ; while the Massachusetts men only ask for the ‘‘candid consideration of all propositions in aid of temperance and good order ”—one of the mildest requests and most difficult to re- fuse ever put forth by a political organization. Massachusetts, however, asks for the same candid consideration for propositions ‘‘touch- ing equal rights of suffrage, independent of sex,” a matter which Connecticut overlooks, but atones for the omission by a dig at ‘‘the growing influence of the great corporations of the country.” We do not believe a demand for ‘‘candid consideration” will do in plat- forms in lieu of a formal expression of opi- nion, though it sounds like a convenient mode of escape. It is in reality an exhortation to intellectual integrity, which is not the func- tion of a party or its convention. What we want to know of a party is what legislation it means to enact or retain, not what virtues either of heart or head it thinks worthy of commendation. The spirit of revolt in the Republican ranks seems to be by no means confined to the East. In Oregon, ex-Senator Mitchell was nomi- nated for the United States Senate by a ma- jority of a caucus of the Republican mem- bers of the Legislature, whereupon the mi- nority flatly refused to vote for him; and as the majority which nominated him is not | strong enough to elect him, and the Demo- | erats will give their votes to a man of their own, Mr. Mitchell will probably fail. The _ country will certainly lose nothing by his de- bor Bill. A man who is profoutdly convinced | feat. It should not be difficult for the Republi- cans of Oregon to find and unite upon a much better man—of course, not ex-Attor- ney-General Williams, who was one of Mr. Mitchell’s competitors for the place. The bet- ter class of Republicans will also have learned with great satisfaction of the final downfall of Chauncey I. Filley, the Republican ‘‘ boss ” of Missouri, one of the most reckless and unscrupulous Machine operators and spoils- mongers in the country. He was Chairman of the State Commuttee, and resolved that this year the Republican party should hold no Con- vention, but vote for the State candidates of the Greenbackers, and thus amalgamate with them. He induced a majority of the members of the State Committee to support him in this scheme, whereupen the rank and file of the party took the bit in their mouths, revolted against this usurpation of the ‘‘ boss” and the majority of the State Committee, called a convention by general consent, in which all parts of the State were represented, nominated an excellent ticket, made an un- commonly good platform, and appointed a new State Committee. Thus ‘‘ Boss” Filley all of a sudden finds himself without a purty, and, we trust, even without a considerable fraction of one. Mr. Stephen B. French, of this city, the Police Commissioner, and intimate friend of President Arthur, and known in politics as ‘‘Steve” French, has got himself into what would be to men outside politics an exceeding- ly unpleasant scrape. He appears to have been for some time much troubled in his mind as to the course Collector Robertson was likely to take in the nominating Convention. Would Robertson, Steve asked himself, support the Administration as a member of the State Com- mittee ? Would he support it as ‘‘ controller” of the Westchester County delegates, whom, ac- cording to Steve, he has long held ‘in the hollow of his hand”? Steve watched Robertson and waited on him a good deal with the view of obtaining some clew to his designs, but apparently without result. At last, having to leave town without having unmasked the Collector, he went to the Convention, and presented him- self at the meeting of the State Committee with what purported to be a telegram au- thorizing him to act as his (Robertson’s) proxy, and he did so act. His vote as such proxy did not, itistrue, change the majority in the Committee, but it was very influential as a sign of a débicle among the Half-Breeds, which promised the Stalwarts a happy issue to all their undertakings. It now appears that the telegram was a forgery, that no such despatch was ever sent, and that it was not even written on a delivery blank. Steve, in fact, admits that 1t was a forgery, but one by which he himself was deceived. Who gave it to him he cannot tell, nor can he give any good reason for expecting Mr. Robertson to select him as his proxy. Moreover, he has been making statements about Mr. Robertson which the latter pronounces false, and which Mr. French’s own witness has not only failed to sustain, but flatly contradicts. Now, Steve, as we have said, stands very high among ‘the boys” who manage the affairs of the Republican party in this city. In fact, he stands at the top. He is, we believe, the only one who enjoys unlimited access to the President ; and then, too, as a Police Commissioner he is a guardian of public morals, and an official example of probity to the youths in the public
Page 3
Sept. 28, 1882] schools and in the College of the City of New York. Consequently his fall is a serious mat- ter, though one would never think so to see the way people laugh when it is mentioned. It is, however, almost worse for what it sug- gests than for what it reveals. Thoughtful men are asking themselves, If Steve be capable of this sort of thing, what must be the moral condition of Jake, Mike, Barney, Ed, and Johnny, and Bob, who are Steve's trusted subordinates, and drink deep at the same well of practical politics? - Is this a fair specimen of the ‘‘ American system” as prac- tised in this city by these estimable men? If Steve fails in veracity or worse on a pinch, what does Jake or Mike do when he finds himself in a tight place, or in sore need of something he has not got ? . Mr. McKeon, the District-Attorney, made an excellent order the other day prohibiting any of the subordinates in his office from quitting their posts to attend either of the Conventions. The gravity of the evil against which it was directed was well illustrated in the trial last week before Recorder Smyth, in the Court of General Sessions, of the boy McCabe, who shot his stepmother. When in- quiry was made for the articles found on the prisoner, it was discovered that they had been left at the Coroner’s officein charge of a ‘‘man,” but ‘‘the man” was gone to Syracuse. The prisoner’s coat had been taken from him at the station-house, but ‘‘the man” had also given it to the prisoner’s father. It then appeared that both the Coroner and Deputy Coroner had gone to Syracuse, and the court had to ad- journ in order that they might be telegraphed to and brought back. It 1s to be observed, too, that these minor officials, who abandon their posts to go to conventions, are hardly ever either delegates or alternates. They go as ‘‘ heelers,” or henchmen of some boss, and simply tout for him in the hotel corridors, or shout for him in the gallery of the Conven- tion. Mr. Henry George is having a curious kind of success. His book—‘ Progress and Poverty’ —has attracted a good deal of attention as an eloquent and striking presentation of some of the evils of modern society. His remedy, and the sole one, is the confiscation of the land of the country by the Government, and its conversion into public domain. He is going about nowin England and Ireland, where there is much trouble about property in land, with somewhat of the air of a man who has dis- covered a sure cure of which people are be- ginning to see the value, and appears to think that it will first be tried in this country. The truth is, we believe, that he has not made a convert of a single owner of land in the civilized world. If he could produce one human being who was willing that his farm should be taken from him by the state without compensation, or who would not regard such a thing as robbery, to be sub- mitted to only because resistance was useless, it would show that he was making some pro- gress, however small. But we do not believe he can produce one such case of genuine con- version. The landholders of every civilized nation would, in fact, resist his scheme to the The Nation. 258 death, and they are so large a proportion of every civilized nation that their will in such a matter issupreme. Mr. George is probably cheered up by the adhesion of a considerable number of persons who own neither real estate nor any other kind of property, but we warn him that when confiscation day arrives they will make themselves scarce. As to the morality of the plan, it happily does not, as yet, need discussion, and Mr. George will get no one to discuss 1t with him. Whether a man or woman who has put a life’s savings into a farm or lot ought not to forfeit the land and have the rent of it goto pay taxes for another man who put his savings into Government bonds, or into a steamboat, is a question which has not as yet become practical, and cannot be- come so without a complete revolution in the ideas of the race about social justice. It is a great pity that a man with Mr. George’s powers of statement should be taken up with such a chimera, The ‘‘subscribers” to the Irish ‘‘ Skirmish- ing Fund” have held another meeting, at which the Committee of Investigation made a report, which substantially recommended that nothing more be done in the matter at present, because an ‘‘eminent Nationalist” has pro- mised to ‘‘ use all his energies and his best in- fluence toward an honorable settlement of the question.” The Committee was very glad to accept his offer, being naturally “ anxious to have the matter taken from tbe public gaze.” The public, we can assure the Committee, de- sires nothing better, as its ‘‘ gaze” is very tired of the matter. But the ‘‘ eminent Nationalist,” if he expects to settle it, must be a man of ftor- tune and leisure, for he has many years of un- remunerative toil before him, unless, indeed, he expects to be paid out of subscriptions yet to come in for finding out what has become of those already received. Harper's Weekly recently reminded those natives who are amused by the Irish difficulties with their Skirmishing Fund, that Americans too have raised a skirmishing fund, of the disposition of which no account is rendered, and about which it would be well for that ‘‘ eminent Nationalist,” Mr. Jay Hubbell, to give some in- formation to the subscribers. As long as he withholds all information as to what he does with the money, and the subscribers put up with his reticence, the Irish skirmishers seem less idiotic than they really are. The feature of the week in Wall Street was a demonstration which was made on the money market by a clique of speculators who had arranged their books so as to profit by a decline in the price of stocks. This demonstra- tion to establish high rates for money was made possible by the low reserve of the New York banks, which had fallen last week to $2,271,825 less than 25 per cent. of the deposit liabilities of the banks. The amount of money which the New York banks have sent away this season ‘‘ to move the crops” is less than usual ; it is true that the foreign exchanges have so ruled for several months as to take money from rather than bring it to New York, but the banks have accommodated their cre- dits to this movement step by step, so that this could not justiy be ascribed as the reason for the low percentage of bank reserves. The drain of money into the Treasury bas been much in excess of the Treasury payments, and in the close working of the other influ- ences affecting the supply of loanable funds the Treasury absorption of cash had been sufficient to give the stock speculators the op portunity which they impreved. On Monday they sent the rate for call loans on stocks up to plain 15 per cent. per annum, and en deavored to retstablish the old custom of quoting money per diem by making a few loans at 1-16 of 1 per cent. per day, which is equal to 224 per cent. perannum. On Tues day they ran the rate per annum up to 20 per cent., and again made loans among themselves at 1-16 per cent. per day. At this point the Treasury came in and ordered the prepayment each week, without rebate, of $5,000,000 of any of the called bonds, including the $25,000,000 recently called for December 28, the prepay. ment to begin on the 27th instant. This broke up the plans of the money-squeezers, and the rate for call loans began to fall, and soon reached plain 6 per cent. per annum, some loans having been made .n the afternoon of that day as low as 3@4 per cent. Stocks and securities at the Stock Exchange which had begun to tumble, immediately stopped in their decline and advanced. Mercantile paper which could not be sold became salable, and con fidence took the place of distrust and appre hension. Railroad earnings continue large, and general trade, although threatened by the money stringency, also continues large and profitable. It 1s doubtful whether the experi ment of tightening the money market to affect Stock Exchange speculation will be tried again this season, so unprofitable has the first attempt turned out. The deposition and imprisonment of the Grand Shereef of Mecca by orders from Con- stantinople, coming so soon after the murder of his predecessor, which was believed to have taken place also by orders from Constan- tunople, seems to show that the Sultan is still not easy in his mind about the Arab move- ment for his deposition from the Caliphate, and its restoration to the Arab line from which the Turks took it on the conquest of Egypt in the sixteenth century. That such a movement exists and is formidable, and receives a fresh stimulus from each sign of the decline of the Turkish Empire, there is no doubt, and it is especially annoying to the Sultan from the fact that one of his dreams just now is said to be the strengthening of his spiritual sway, as a compensation for the decline of the temporal. Any suspicion of sympathy with the new school will there- fore, probably, make Mecca ‘“ unhealthy,” as they say in New Mexico, for the Grand Shereef, whoever he may be, as long as the Sultan can reach the city with armed force. It is a misfortune for the reformers that they must, in order to have any standing in the Mussulman world, keep possession of the Prophet’stomb, and that, in order to have : Caliph of their own, they must drive away the Turkish troops, who, owing to the breech- loaders and the new drill, are much more formidable to the Arabs than they used to be in old times, eerne:
Page 4
EVA SUMMARY OF THE WEEK’S NEWS. WEDNESDAY, Sept. 20, to TUESDAY, Sept. 26, 1882, inclusive. | DOMESTIC, THe New York Republican State Conven- tion met at Saratoga, on Wednesday, and after the usual preliminary proceedings proceeded to ballot for Governor. The three most promi- nent candidates for the nomination were Charles J. Folger, Alonzo B. Cornell, and James W. Wadsworth. Mr. Folger was the so-called ‘‘ Administration candidate,” the other two being the nominees of the Anti-Administra tion or ‘‘ Half-Breed ” wing of the party. Mr. Folger was nominated on the second ballot, receiving 257 votes, eight more than was necessary for a choice, and his nomination was then made unanimous. On Thursday the ticket was completed, by the nomination of B. Platt Carpenter for Lieutenant-Gover nor; Charles Andrews for Chief Judge ot the Court of Appeals; and A. Barton Hepburn for Congressman-at-large. The platform an- nounces that the partv has no new doctrines to present upon the questions of honest money, pure elections, the regulation of traflic 1 intoxi- cating liquors, the protection of home indus- try, and the necessity of restricting the power and intluence of corporations ; denounces mo- nopolies and the Democratic party ; urges the people of the State to *‘ examine with intelh- gent care the constitutional amendments sub- mitted to them”; discourages the practice of appealing to the Legislature to overrule the action of the local authorities ; recommends the submission of the liquor question to the popular vote; points with pride to the finan- cial achievements of the Republican Adminis- tration ; recommends competitive tests for ad- mission to the civil service, together with a fixed term for incumbents, ‘‘ removal from office during the term of appointment to be only for cause”; approves the recent law of Congress designed to suppress polygamy ; praises Governor Cornell’s administration ; and approves President Arthur’s veto of the River and Harbor Bill Judge Folger’s nomination has been received with rather lukewarm approval bv all that portion of the New York Republican press which represents the Anti-Administration wing of the party, and since the results of the Demo- cratic Convention, the general feeling seems to be that the Republicans will have an uphill fight. The Democratic State Convention met at Syracuse on Thursday, and adopted a platform arraigning the last Republican Congress for its shortcomings and extravagance ; recom- mending a reform in the tariff ; favoring the immediate passage of a civil-service reform bill by Congress ; condemning the assessment of Government employees for political pur- poses; denouncing monopolies and demanding the repeal of all laws which tend to make ‘the rich richer and the poor poorer”; favor- ing a diffusion of education ; demanding a re- vision of the laws relating to shipping and the carriage of, ocean freights ; favoring self-gov- ernment for cities; opposing child-labor in factories ; recommending laws regulating pri- mary elections ; and favoring the free-canal amendment. On Friday the ticket was nomi- nated, which is as follows: for Governor, Grover Cleveland; for Lieutenant-Governor, David B. Hill; Chief Judge of the Court of Appeals, William C. Ruger ; Congressman-at- large, Henry W. Slocum. The Republican State Convention of Mis- souri, called in opposition to the decision of the State Central Committee, met at Jefferson City on Wednesday and nominated a State ticket by acclamation. The Nebraska Republican State Convention met on Thursday and nominated J. W. Dawes for Governor. The platform reaffirms the faith of the party in free labor, free speech, und free schools; advocates currency on a specie basis and a protective tariff ; demands , The Nation legislative control of corporations ; and main- tains that legislation should prevent unjust discrimination on the part of railway com- panies, At an adjourned meeting of the Colorado Democratic State Convention on Friday, reso- lutions were adopted declaring that reform in the civil service is absolutely necessary. The spoils system and the assessment of public ser- vants for political purposes were denounced, and penal legislation demanded to destroy these evils. The resolutions insist that the remnant of the public domain shall be reserved exclusively for actual settlers as homesteads ; recommend a tariff for revenue only, and de- nounce the Tariff Commission. An immense meeting of Germans convened in Cincinnati on Sunday evening, under a call of the Association of Independent Citizens, who avow that they aim at guarding personal liberty, and the right to remain ‘‘ free men on Sunday ”—meaning to eat and drink what they please ; to allow each one to observe Sunday in his own way; and to obtain legal protec- tion for every branch of business, and uniform taxation. The call disavows all intention to form a new party. The press throughout the country has been agitated during the week on the subject of the relations of the Associated Press with the Western Union Telegraph Company and Jay Gould, its present controller. tt is said that Mr. Gould and the telegraph company desire and propose to collect, as weli as transmit, the news for the press. The New York J/erald stated in a leading article that this purpose of Mr. Gould’s had been agreed to by three of the newspapers composing the New York Associated Foun —naiaity, the 7Zribune, the World, and the Mai and Express—and that there was danger of certain other of the news- papers composing the Associated Press being bought over by Mr. Gould, thus giving that gentleman the control of all the news which is distributed to the newspapers. In view of this danger, the New York //ere/d thinks that the time has come for the Government to con- sider the expediency of taking the telegraph business of the country into 1ts own hands. There was a Cabinet meeting at Washing- ton on Wednesday, at which were present the President and Secretaries Frelinghuysen, Lincoln, Teller, and Folger. Only routine business was transacted. President Arthur will be unable to be in Boston on October 3, the day set for the cele- bration of the Webster centennial. The cele- bration has therefore been postponed until October 11, at which date the President will be able to be present. A reception to Engineer Melville took place at Washington on Saturday evening. Assist- ant-Secretary-of-State Jobn Davis presided, and the orator of the evening was Mr. R. W. Thompson, ex-Secretary of the Navy. Up te Sunday last the money value of dona- tions to the Garficld Memorial Hospital fund amounted to about $80,000. General Hazen, Chief of the Signal Bureau at Washington, has received advices that the supply expedition which sailed July 8 from St. John’s, Newfoundland, with additional stores for Lieutenant Greely’s party, returned on Saturday last to St. John’s, having failed in the attempt to reach them on account of the ice. Depots were established, however, to secure their safe retreat should it become necessary a year or two hence. . By an agreement between the United States and Swiss Post-office Departments, executed in Washington on a the 19th inst., the limits of weight and dimensions of sample packets exchanged between the two countries are increased to 350 grains in weight, thirty centimetres in length, twenty centimetres in breadth, and ten centimetresin depth. This increase goes into effect on the 1st of October. The Secretary of the Treasury on Saturday issued a call for ~~ bonds of the acts of July 14, 1870, and January 20, 1871, which [ Number 900 —_———— will be paid at Washington on the 23d of De- cember, 1882. District-Attorney Corkhill and his assistants were occupied on Tuesday in taking testimony as to the alleged attempts to corrupt the Star- route jury. The proceedings were private. Mr. Henry George’s letter to the President has been referred to Secretary Frelinghuysen. It is learned at the State Department that Mr. Lowell in August acted upon this case, as well as that of Mr. Meany, and that the two cases. have been the subject of correspondence by telegraph since the time of the arrests. The first of the four parties which the Com- mission appointed by the United States Gov- ernment has selected to observe the forthcom- ing transit of Venus from the southern hemi- sphere sailed for Liverpool on Wednesday. The party consists of Prof. Simon Newcomb, Lieut T. R. Casey, Ensien J. H. L. Hol- combe, and Prof. Julius Ulke. These gentlemen will observe the transit from the neighborhood of Cape Town. The three other parties will witness the planet’s projection on the sun’s surface from Santa Cruz, Patagonia; Valpa- raiso, Chili ; and New Zealand, respectively. General Kimball, a member of the Utah Commission, arrived in New York on Monday nigit, and reports the fight against Mormon- ism to have been fairly begun. He said that the effect of the Commission’s work was already apparent in various actions of the Mormons, many of whom were beginning to separate their tamilies with a view to avoiding the cohabitation clause of the law, and large numbers of them are taking out naturaliza- lion papers. A great rain-storm began on Friday morning and inflicted some damage in New York, Brooklyn, and the surrounding country, and serious damage in some parts of New Jersey. The extraordinary nature of the storm is shown by the tact that more than nine inches of rain fell in fifty-six hours. Extensive floods resulted on Saturday in the neighborhood of Paterson, Plainfield, Elizabeth, Newark, and other New Jersey towns, demolishing a great number of bridges, flooding houses, carrying away dams, and causing washouts in all direc- tions, and many thousands of dollars will be needed to repair the damages. Several per sons lost their lives. Despatches from various points in the North- west report more or less heavy frosts in eastern Iowa, vorthern and central Illinois, and north- ern Indiana. In only a few places, however, was the frost heavy enough to injure the corn crop. The steamship Lepanto, of the Wilson line from Hull, arrived at New York on Sunday with her bows badly smashed in—the result of her having run into and sunk the steamship Edam, of the Netherlands-American Steam Navigation Company, on Thursday last, dur- ing a dense fog, in latitude 41° and longitude 66° 34’. All the passengers and crew of the Edam were mek with the exception of the assistant and third engineers. A bad accident occurred in the tunnel of the Harlera Railroad, at Eigh'y-sixth Street, New York, on Friday. The Portchester spe- cial train being forced to take the Harlem track by some obstruction on the Hudson River track, was run into by a Harlem train. ‘The last car of the Portchester train was wrecked, and two passengers were killed and twenty- one persons hurt more or less seriously. FOREIGN On Wednesday reports of outrages and dis- turbances in the interior of Eexpt continued to arrivein Alexandria. All the k uropean houses and factories in Tanta and a few houses in Benha and Birket-el-Saba were reported to have been looted. An examination of the Treasury at Cairo proved that about £200,000 were taken by Arabi Pasha, of which £18,000 have been discovered at the War Office. It is probable that other deficits will be found m the Department of the Interior. A despatch from Alexandria on Friday night announced
Page 5
SERENE NLL LTT GUANO DERG ELE 8 0d 5 sian SAO ES Sept. 28, 1882] The Nation. t that Damietta had surrendered to General Wood. Of the original garrison of 7,000 at Damietta, however, only 800 negroes remained on Friday night, and they fled without surren- dering, after having plundered the town. A despatch from Alexandria on Saturday said that it was disgusting to witness the enthusi- asm of the natives for the Khedive and to hear the expressions of loyalty of many who have been notoriously the friends of Arabi Paska. Arabi Pasha and his accomplices, both mili- tary and civil, will be tried by a court-martial, in which British officers of high rank will sit. The Khedive has issued a decree appointing a special commission to inquire into and prose- cute the authors of the outrages committed in Alexandria in June last. This commission is to consist of four Europeans and three natives, and is to be under the presidency of Abderrah man Rushdi Bey, a Maltese renegade and Minister of Finance in Arabi Pasha’s last Min- istry. There will also be another commission, which will sit at Tanta, to investigate the crimes committed in other parts of Egypt dur- ing the rebellion. The Khedive’s Government is making wholesale arrests of the supporters of the National party ; all who signed the proclamation authorizing Arabi Pasha to con- tinue the war are being imprisoned. The Princes Ibrahim, Hamed, and Kamil, who signed the petition prepared by Arabi Pasha last May for the deposition of the Khedive, arrived on Friday to pay their respects to the Khedive, but he refused to receive them. Some of the princesses of the Khedive's family are said to have been seriously compromised by the re- volt. It 1s generally believed that property valued at £1,000,000 will be contiscated and applied to the indemnification of sufferers by the mas- sacres, The Khedive has issued a manifesto stating that England has great interests in Egypt, both in regard to finances and trattic through the Suez Canal; that for the protection of those interests she was compelled to interfere, but that she has no intention of annexing the country. The Khedive also announces that he has authorized General Wolseley to repre- sent him in restoring order and punishing the rebels, and all loyal Egyptians are called upon to render him every assistance. The Khedive has offered Sir Edward Malet, the British Consul-General at Alexandria, the Grand Cross of the Order of the Osmanli, the highest decoration he can bestow. On Tuesday the Khedive arrived at Cairo. He was received at the depot by the Duke of Connaught and General Woiseley with all possible military honors. The streets through which the Khedive passed were densely crowd- ed, and the natives gave him a friendly wel- come. A grand reception was held at the Ghezireh Palace on Tuesday by the Khedive. Nearly 1,000 representatives of different villages were present. The Khedive refused to receive many implicated pashas and beys who came to pro- fess loyalty, and warned the Ulemas and other high personages that they would be severely punished if they relapsed into disloyalty. Arabi Pasha is reported to have said that the best thing the English could do for Egypt would be to send the Notables and other leading men cut of the country, for if they do not, ven- geance will surely be wreaked upon them after the departure of the British. Arabi says he is sorry he fought the British, and asserts that he never thought they would send so large an armv to assist the Khedive, else he would not have gone into the war. He denies that he had apy communication with the Sultan dur- ing the war. The Khedive, with the approval of England, has offered Baker Pasha the task of reorganiz- ing the Egyptian Army. The latter has ac- cepted the task. A solemn service of thanksgiving for the British pacification of the country was beld in the Roman Catholic Church at Alexandria on Sunday. There wasan immense congrega- tion present. Thanks for the success of the British troops were also given in the churches in London and the provinces on Sunday. It is officially announced in England that General Wolseley and Admiral Seymour will be raised to the peerage, in acknowledgment of their services in Egypt. A despatch from London says that members of a committee disapproving Mr. Gladstone’s Egyptian policy having, with a view of dis- crediting his opinions on foreign politics, reiter- ated the charge that he sympathized with the South during the American Civil War, Mr. Gladstone, replying through his secretary to an inquiry on the subject, writes that the statement attributing such sympathy to him is untrue, and contrary to authentic facts long ago made public. The Grand Shereef of Mecca has been de- posed and imprisoned at Taife, where Midbat Pasha was a prisoner. Abdatlah Atricun has been appointed Grand Shereef. He isa brother to the Shereef who was murdered some time ago, as was then supposed by orders from the Sultan, because he was favorable to the British. The Sultan of Turkey has ordered the im- mediate surrender to Greece of the whole frontier fixed by the International Commis- sion. The representatives of the Powers who, at the invitation of Count Corti, the Italian Ambassador, had assembled at Constantino- ple on Sunday to discuss the Turco-Greck frontier question, dissolved their meeting on hearing of the settlement of the difliculty. The Czar and Czarina arrived in Moscow ou Wednesday. Immense crowds lined the streets through which they passed from the depot to the Kremlin palace, and they were received with the utmost enthusiasm. On Thursday the Czar held a reception in the Kremlin, at which he expressed thanks for the cordial welcome and the many assurances of loyalty which he had received. The object of the visit is to view the exhibition, which is to close on the Ist of October. A despatch from St. Petersburg to the North German Gazette says that the idea of an improvised coro- nation is out of the question. On Sunday the Czar and Czarina returned to St. Petersburg. A despatch from St. Petersburg says that a recent speech of General Drenteln, Governor of Kieff, against the Jews, has been taken as a signal by the peasants and minor officials of the provinces for the renewal of hostilities against the Israelites. From all sides accounts are received showing a revival of anti-Semitic animosity. It is reported that the German Government intends to devote its attention to the execution of a project for the construction of a canal to connect the North Sea with the Baltic. A despatch from Berlin says that on Satur- day the entire pre-s congratulated Prince Bis- marck on the twentieth anniversary of his entrance into the Prussian Ministry. The Opposition journals, while condemning Prince Bismarck’s home policy, warmly referred to the services he had rendered the nation. The Emperor William of Germany has written a letter to the King of Saxony, in which he says it affords him sincere satisfaction to again assure himself how entirely the King’s views coincide with his own respecting the im- portance of keeping the troops in a state of readiness for war. A despatch from Dublin states that owing to the release of a number of prisoners conse- quent upon the immediate expiration of the Coercion Act, the authorities have sent away certain persons suspected of informing, fear- ing that they would be murdered if they re- mained. On Thursday the last of the ‘‘sns- pects ” were released from Kilmainham jail. Patrick Walsh was hanged on Friday for the murder of Martin Lyden. A Conference of Irish Nationalists will meet in Dublin on the 17th of October, Toward the end of the year there will be a great Irish National Convention to review the position and condition of the country. The delegates to this Convention will be elected by the people. A scheme has been propounded by Mr. Davitt for the formation of a gigantic or ganization whose leading objects will be the improvement of the social and political condi tion of the Irish, and the prevention of emi eration from Ireland by obtaining prefitabl employment for laborers and evicted tenants The scheme is to be discussed at the Conven tion of Irish Nationalists, Mr. Parnell, how ever, refuses to sanction the project, on the ground that the formation of such an organ: zation would be impossible under the existing Coercion Act. The Dublin Freeman's Journal states that Mr. Dillon will retire from Parliament owing to ill health. In a letter announcing this in tention, Mr. Dillon says it will not be possibl for him to take any part in Irish politics for the next few years, Mr. E. Dwyer Gray has written a letter to Lord Mayor Dawson regarding the develop ment of Irish manufactures. He advocates the holding of an exhibition in 1888 and th: formation of an association to push the sale of Irish manufactures. He also advocates the holding of an Irish exhibition in the United States, and suggests that the United States should modify their tariff in favor of Lrish productions. Mr. Gladstone, replying to a correspondent, reiterates the declaration that he is unable to interfere with the operations of the Mormons in England, as he presumes their converts go with them willingly. The Earl of Derby, the Right Hon. Hugh Childers, the Right Hon, William EF. Forster Sir Henry James, and other prominent men, have joined the Longfellow Memorial Com mittee. A meeting was held in London on Wedves day evening to discuss the proposed introdu tion of Chinese labor into Great Britain, A motion calling upon the Government to frame measures to prevent the importation of Chinese was adopted. Delegates representing 20,000 miners, at a conference at Rotherham, England, on Mon day, decided to demand an advance of fifteen per cent. in wages. Overdank has confessed that he drew lots with his confederates to decide who should attempt to take the life of Francis Joseph, and that he intended to throw a bomb into the garden of Miramar Castle. The High Court of Venice has given an opinion in the case of the recent arrests, that the extradition of per- sons conspiring against the life of the Empe ror of Austria on Itahan territory is allowabie. The Emperor of Austria has subscribed 100,000 florins for the relief of the sufferers by the recent floods mm the Tyrol. Baron van Lynden, the Dutch Minister of Finance, announced in the States-General on Monday that he estimated there would be a deficit in the budget of 26,000,000 florins. Ata consistory held at Rome on Monday Monsignor Czaki, Papal Nuncio at Paris, and Monsignor A. Bianchi, Nuncio at Madrid, were created Cardinals. The Mexican Congress has adopted a con stitutional amendment declaring that in the event of the death or removal of the Presi- dent, his successor shall be the Senator who presided over the Senate during the month preceding the vacancy. When the Senate is not in session, the President of the Permancnt Committee, who is alternately a Senator or Deputy, is to succeed. In the case of a per- manent vacancy, the elections are to be held immediately. Hitherto the Chief Justice has been ex-officio Vice-President. The exhibition building at Sydney, New South Waies, has been totally destroyed by fire with ail its contents. The loss 1s estimated at £500,000.
Page 6
256 MR. FOLGER’S NOMINATION. THERE is no reason for surprise at the result of the New York Republican Convention, The struggle which preceded the nomination was vir- tually a struggle between two Machines—the National Administration Machine on one side, naturally strong by its patronage, and in this instance reinforced by Jay Gould and Mr. Conkling’s ‘legal practice,” and on the other side the State Administration Machine, rein- forced by an honest public sentiment recog- nizing the good features of Governor Cornell’s official conduct during the latter part of his term. IHad the decision of the question, who should be the Republican candidate for the Gov- ernorship, been in the hands of the masses of the party, the relative strength of the Machines as such would not have turned the scale. But as it was 1n the bands of the politicians who “fix” and ‘‘run” primaries, and who get themselves elected as delegates to conven- tions, and who are under the influence of the Machines all the time during the different stages of the proceeding, there could scarcely be any doubt as to which Machine would eventually prove the strongest. If there was anything calculated to cause surprise, it was that the number of delegates to the Conven- tion elected with the expectation that they would vote for Cornell or Wadsworth, was so large. But it was not surprising at all that a number of them, sufficient to give the National Administration Machine the ascend- ancy, should in the Convention have been won over, probably much to the disappoint- ment of those who sent them there. There is much cheap material among New York politicians in both parties, and that material shows itself in its true character when power passes from one faction or one leader to another. The nomination of such a man as Mr. Folger would, as such nominations go, be considered a strong one were the nominee permitted to stand on his own merits. As a member of the Legislature and as a Judge, Mr. Folger made a very creditable record. As Secretary of the Treasury he has done some very reprehensible things, of which the ap- pointment of the notorious Mike Dady isa specimen, while he has credit for having re- fused to do things still worse. His management of the business affairs of the Department has been, on the whole, respectable, too. But as the Republican nominee for the Governor- ship he appears under decidedly unfavor- able circumstances. The rapidity with which he skipped from a high judicial position into the Treasury and then tried to skip from the Treasury into the Governor’s chair of this State, all within one year, is calculated to produce the impression either of great un- steadiness of purpose on his part, or of readi- ness to let himself be used as an instrument for the purposes of others. He appears, more- over, as the candidate of the national Ad- ministration for a State office, and if anything should be odious to the popular mind, it is an intrusive interference of the Federal power with State affairs. Such interference has, indeed, not been unusual in this State, but there is certainly a growing sentiment against it. It is scarcely necessary to add that the The Nation. appearance of Jay Gould and the legal practi- tioner Conkling, with wires and _ leading- strings in their hands, is not a captivating background to Mr. Folger’s candidacy. What the general effect of his nomination on the masses may be, we can as yet, of course, only guess. The leaders of Mr, Cornell’s forces in the Convention naturally gave in their adhesion without hesitation. It is quite probable that the professional politicians on that side are perfectly sincere in their assur- ancesof support. It is, indeed, reported from Saratoga that some of the non-professionals, especially Wadsworth men, complain of the use of corrupt means in making up a majority for Mr. Folger, and threaten to ‘‘ bolt.” How much there may be in this, time will show. But as to the rank and file of the party, we are persuaded that thousands of good Repub- licans in this State, when they read the news of the nomination, laid down their paper with a languid sort of equanimity, saying, ‘‘ Well, now let us wait to see what the other side will do.” The stories which are being told of the way in which the nomination was brought about —of the bargaining, intriguing, purchasing, and even forging which attended it or pro- cured it—must place Judge Folger in a position of someembarrassment. In fact, the situation is one in which it1s hard fora man of high cha- racter to know howto act. He is reported by an interviewer to have expected the nomina- tion, if it cameto him at all, as the free and practically unanimous offer of the Conven- tion, brought about after a fair comparison of views and trial of strength. It has come to him, however, as the result of a victory of one faction, achieved, the minority says, by foul means, and leaving behind so much openly avowed discontent as to make his election even now seem very doubtful. Moreover, his small majority undoubtedly came from this city, which has now no real representation in any Republican Convention, and whose dele- gates have few or no relations of any kind with nine-tenths of the voters for whom they undertake to speak. This is a state of things which must make the inconveniences of the rdle Judge Folger kas taken on himself seem greater to him every day, owing to the very qualities which led the Stalwarts to select him. An ordinary politician would not have answered their pur- pose. The reputation of their leaders is such that it 1s impossible for them to succeed in any enterprise dependent on the moral sense of the community without producing a stan- dard-bearer with a better one. To have had a man like Mr. Folger within their reach was, therefore, a piece of luck forthem which might not happen to them again in twenty years. But, sagacious as he is and long as his experience of politics has been, he can hardly have real- ized the way in which the party regards them, and the small amount of moral weight which conventions controlled by them carry, when he put himself into their hands. He can afford to be Governor of New York, but can he afford to seek the Governorship, or seem to seek it, or be made to seek it, for any other purpose than filling it with the highest efficiency and integ- rity? Will Judge Folger be just the same after half the voters of the State have satisfied [Number 900 themselves that a set of political jobbers have put him in nomination partly to cover up their own shortcomings and partly to restore their Machine? No matter how sure he may feel that he would make a good Governor if elected, it must be of moment to him what people think about the way he became Governor. He can- not, hke Mr. Cornell, better his condition be- fore the people by being a good Governor. His character needs no rehabilitation or vindi- cation. His capacity and integrity are both sufficiently established to enable him to forego the additional lustre which any fresh office could give them. But he may encounter an enormous deal of discomfort by having, as an upright man, to quarrel with his backers, and may bring great discredit on his perspicacity by having to plead that he did not know them when he allowed them to run him. There was a time when a man of high standing could console himself for accepting a nomination from doubtful hands by the re- flection that he was going to stand on a plat- form which contained a genuine political pro- gramme. But Judge Folger’s friends do not furnish candidates with any such platforms nowadays. Their platforms do not contain their own high resolves, but exhortations to other people to be good. The things they commend to popular consideration are al- most always things which they are them- selves determined to avoid ; so that their can- didate can never flatter himself that he is charged with a mission or has the care of a great cause. If Judge Folger really meant what he said, that a nomination to be accept- able to him must be brought about by worthy means, he must, we repeat, read the current news about the proceedings which brought about this one with great perplexity as well as amazement, while making up his mind what answer to make. The public will certainly expect from him in this matter some practical illustration of what he considers fair in poli- tics. THE DISAPPOINTMENT IN EGYPT, WHETHER the telegraphic reports from Cairo on Tuesday of the way in which Arabi Pasha is crying craven be correct or not, there is no doubt that the manner of his surrender and the behavior of the popula- tion since the surrender are an immense mortification to those who had vouched for him as a fanatical patriot and the head of a genuine national movement. The enthu- siastic and brilliant reception of the Khe- dive at Cairo, the Mohammedan clergy being among the first to receive him at the rail- road station, is certainly, considered as the termination of a two months’ campaign on behalf of national independence, almost wor- thy of opéra-bouffe, and must fill Egyptian sympathizers like M. de Lesseps, Mr. Wil- frid 8. Blunt, and Mr. Keay with honest shame. Poor M. de Lesseps is doubtless in a worse position than any of them, be- cause he promised more terrible fighting on behalf of the Egyptians than any of the others. They said that Arabi’s cause was just, and that he had the Egyptian people at his back, but M. de Lesseps said he would die in the last ditch, and one of his DR pat Oe AR Ee Pen re aed
Page 7
eT ee eed i Th OCEAN A SEE RT FOOSE ee Grea ees nid BS nts Marrncsin ak Sse eS Sept. 28, 1882] The Nation. friends predicted that even the Bedouins, who ‘‘can see a hare behind a tuft of grass a kilometre off,” ‘‘would pluck the English sentinels like flowers,” and that 80,000 men at least would be required to restore the Khe- dive. But Arabi, the people, the Bedouins and all, have betrayed their frends. Prob- ably the most extraordinary failure of all was that of the Bedouins on the night before the attack, when they let the invading army get within 1,000 yards of Arabi’s position in the open desert without giving the alarm, For men who could see a hare a mile off this certainly showed a distressing want of vigi- lance. But every other incident of the cam- paign was in keeping with this one, and now the abject submission of the chief gives what ought to be a tragedy the air of a rather broad burlesque. How this impression of Egyptian despera- tion got abroad, it is not easy to see if we ex- amine Egyptian history only. Egyptian troops have never made a respectable figure in any war, and those who know the fellah best are most emphatic in denying him all military qualities. He has all sorts of good stuff in him, but he has not the stuff of a good soldier. Nor is there much support for the expectations about him to be found in the history of other Mohammedan peoples. It is more than two centuries since any Moham- medan force was considered formidable on account of its morale. The Persians and the Indian Mussulmans have, during that pe- riod, displayed nothing but feebleness and want of enterprise in the field. The Turks have, since the siege of Vienna, shown none of their old martial fire, and have constantly receded before Christian aggression. The defence at Plevna was rather an accident than a revival. Their success during the four- teenth, fifteenth, and sixteenth centuries was due—as any one may see who reads Bus- becq’s ‘Memoirs ’—rather to their superiority to Europeans in discipline, in organization, and in armament, than to religious zeal. In other words, the Europe they terrified was a collection of poor barbarous and disorderly states, in which the military art was hardly cultivated at all. The success of the Turks was therefore enormous, and there can hardly be a better illustration of the terror they in- spired in Christendom than the continuance to our own day of the old belief that a fanati- cal Mussulman is a formidable soldier. The oniy Mussulman people who in recent times have done anything in war to sustain this belief are the Afghans, and yet they have never shown real tenacity ona set field. They have shown, however, wonderful tenacity in continuing hostilities. They have the uncon- queruble hate, and the courage never to submit or yield, which are supposed to be characteris- tics of all Mohammedan zealots, but they do not show it under arms. They fly nearly as readily as the Egyptians, but they do not throw away their arms, and they are always ready to try again, and they never kiss a con- queror’s hand. They make their submission with dignity. The suddenness and completeness of the Egyptian collapse will probably have some effect on European diplomacy in the East, by diminishing the impression of the intracta- bility and ferocity of Mohammedan popula- tions, which has really had considerable influ- ence thus far in upholding the Turkish Em- pire. Down to the Russo-Turkish war of 1877 it was quite common for the Turkish Ministers to repress the troublesome importu- nity of foreign Ministers by hinting at an out- break of fanaticism which would put Chris- tian lives and property in danger, and which the Government would be unable to con- trol. Ove argument, too, and a very ef- fective one, used against the introduction of reforms into Asia Minor by extraneous pressure, has been that the population being mainly Mussulman, it would be difficult for any power but the Porte to control them, and that, deplorable as their lot was under Turk- ish rule, they must be left to their fate as long as their master did not care to improve it. What has occurred in Egypt is therefore not unlikely to make the ambassadors at Constan- tinople less gingerly in using pressure, and less troubled by the accounts the pashas wil give of the effect on the Turkish people of concessions to infidels. ARABI AND HIS ARMY. KNOXVILLE, TENN., Sept. 16, 1882. It was my fortune—good or ill, it is hard to say—to spend something over two years in Egypt, in the service of the late Khedive, Is- mail Pasha, as an ofticer of Engineers in bis Army. I lived in Cairo with my family, was daily in intimate association with the native population, and had charge, as Chief of the Third Section, of the General Staff of the Topo- graphical Bureau. I trust that the opportuni- ties offered for observation have made me some- what familiar with the country and its people. Since the days of Mehemet Ali, and his great warrior son, Ibrahim Pasha, Egypt has entirely lost her military prestige ; she has had no recent victories of any importance. It is true that dur- ing the reign of the Khedive Ismail Pasha the boundaries of Egyptian dominion were extended, apparently by military conquest, over a part of Nubia, Darfur, Kordofan, and up the Nile al- most to the Equatorial Lakes. But these con- quests were really not won by fighting success- ful battles ; they were the results of creating dissensions among the native tribes, of purchase and bribery, of superior diplomacy and treach- ery, of following up the march of trade by de- tachments of troops, and converting trading stations into forts and military posts. In 1876 the Egyptian troops under Rauf Pasha made a successful attack upon Harrar, a walled town of the Sumalis. With this single exception, all of their recent military efforts have been most dis- astrous failures. I need only mention the series of terrible catastrophes attending the abortive attempts at conquest in Abyssinia during the years 1875 and 1876. The writer was one of the unfortunates who participated in those inglori- ous undertakings, and knows whereof he speaks. The first expedition into Abyssinia was under Colonel Arendrup, a Danish officer in the ser- vice of the Khedive. He commanded a column of troops of all arms, numbering about 3,500 men. They were apparently excellent troops, were well organized, well drilled, well armed, and well equipped in every way ; and yet on the very first encounter with the Abyssinians the entire force engaged was literally wiped out of existence. Only a few desperately wounded, maimed, and mutilated men, who were left as dead by their ruthless foes, were the survivors of that bloody fight, These wretched sufferers, 257 with wonderful vitality, crawled off the field of carnage, hid themselves by day in the caves and jungles, fed on wild fruits and berries, dragged their festering limbs along at night, and reached Massowah, some of them weeks after the battle, and told the horrible tale. To wipe out this disgrace and avenge this de- feat, a large army, which ultimately numbered fully 20,000 men, equally as well appointed in all respects as the other force, was sent into Abys- sinia. They reached the Abyssinian plateau without resistance, and about 12,000 of them at one time were engaged with the hordes of King John. Of all that met the King in the open field, but very few returned to the two forts which formed the flanks of their position. Ihave no intention of giving a description of this battle of Gura, as it is called, but simply of showing the fighting capacity of the Egyptian troops. The position occupied by the Egyptian Army was an excellent one; they were on an open, nearly level plain, themselves posted on the rising ground ; they were splendidly equip- ped with Remington breech-loading rifles ; their artillery was composed of French mountain howitzers, English steel guns, and German Krupps, besides a fine rocket battery ; their cavalry was magnificently mounted and per fectly armed; they were commanded by the Commander-in-Chief of the Egyptian Army, and his best officers ; they had some dozen or more American and European staff officers to encourage them, exhort them, and set them a guvod example. King John attacked them squarely in front, with bis host of naked, bare- footed, bare-headed warriors, who had but few fire-arms, no artillery, no organization—nothing military, in fact, but courage. And yet, in one hour and a half, all of 7,000 troops who were outside of the forts, except a bare handful, were killed or captured by the Abyssinians,. who rushed upon them with sword and spear and shield, and slaughtered them like sheep in the shambles. The loss of the Abyssinians was about 150 men ! This bare statement of facts makes comment How it all happened it is diffi- cult to tell. Colonel Dye, who was in the battle, wrote a book to explain it, but did not succeed, I think, even to his own satisfaction. Why it so happened is easier to answer, and the answer is this: the Egyptians will not, cannot fight. A disaster equally complete, but on a smaller scale, occurred to a column of Egyptian troops under Munzinger Pasha, nearly contemporaneously with the Arendrup tragedy. This column was marching through the Galla country to coipe- rate with Arendrup, aud, when several days’ journey from Tajurrah, was attacked at night by the natives, and absolutely annihilated, The writer saw one of the victims of this catastropbe, who escaped because his wounds were thought to be certainly fatal. He was an officer of Engi- neers, and will be mentioned again. The events thus briefly epitomized plainly demonstrate the lack of fighting qualities of the Egyptians. Now, the question naturally srises, Why are they thus utterly worthless as soldiers ¢ That question it is the main object of this article to answer, There are two classes of soldiers in the ranks of the Egyptian Army. The smeller class consists of Nubians, Darfurians, Sudanese, and Berbers from up the Nile. Many, in fact it is said that most of them, are slaves, either taken or bought from the regular slave-hunters and traders of the interior, and liberated by the late Khedive Ismail, by being placed in the Army. However recruited, they constituted the only fighting part of the Army in the Abyssinian campaign, and they were vastly inferior to the colored troops of the Union Army during tie late Civil War. They have some soldierly quali- unnecessary.
Page 8
QHS ties : they are strong, hardy, able-bodied men, can stand heat and hard work and long marches well ; they are docile, obedient, and seemed to learn the routine duties of military life readily, and perhaps under good officers might make fairly good soldiers, Some of these negro troops went with Prince Hassan to Turkey, and parti- cipated in the Russo-Turkish war; but there was no mention made of any brilliant achievements accomplished by them, and it was said they suf- fered terribly from the coldness of the climate of the mountain regions of Turkey, and were therefore of little service. The larger part of the Egyptian Army is made up of recruits taken by conscription from the villages and fields of the lower delta. These fellaheen are the most abject of slaves, and have been so for hundreds of years. They are not slaves of a single owner who would be responsi- ble for their welfare, and would profit by their well-being, as was the case with the former slaves of the South. They are the slaves of the soil upon which they live, and of every man who occupies a higher position in life than they, from their own sheik-el-beled to the Khedive. Every effendi, bey, and pasha with whom they come in contact in any way whatever looks upon them as different beings from himself, calls them habitually ‘‘ebn-el-kelb,” sons of dogs, and kicks, cuffs, and beats them ad libitum. In consequence of this bad treatment, and by heredity, they are low, mean, cowardly, and cringing beyond any people on the face of the earth. And the manner in which they are drafted into the Army, and the way they are subsequently treated by their officers, does not in the least improve them. They are dragged from their fields while at work, or snatched from their mud huts, chained togetber in gangs, and carried to the citadel, and there kept in close imprisonment until they are drilled and uni- formed. They are not allowed to settle their own affairs, to make any provision for their families, or even to bid their wives and children farewell, when the time for their conscription comes. When the recruiting sergeants lay hands upon them, it is as if a sudden and terrible death had claimed them ; and they are mourned and wept over by friends and relatives as if they were dead, Once become soldiers, and branded as it were by the uniform, escape from the ranks, until term of servige expires, isimpcssible. Desertion me Séherally punished by death, even in time of peace. They are treated by their officers no better than they were by their taskmasters in the fields, The courbash is the instrument of punishment for every trivial offence, in spite of the fact that flogging is prohibited by law. Not only is the common soldier whipped by his com- pany officers, from sergeant to captain, but even the subaltern officers are subjected to the same indignity by their superiors. The writer once saw a lieutenant held down by two men of his own company, while his colonel beat him un- mercifully with a walking-cane. When the beating was finished by the bey’s becoming ex- hausted, the lieutenant arose, took off his sword and handed it to his superior, and said : ‘‘ You have disgraced me in the presence of my own men; I am no longer worthy to be an officer— put me in the ranks.” For this—the only manly act I ever witnessed among these people—the lieutenant was charged with insubordination and mutinous conduct, was tried by court-mar- tial, was sentenced to be shot, and I saw the sentence put into execution. This was during the Abyssinian campaign.; and on another occasion I witnessed the novel sight of a colonel giving his own major a good thrashing with a walking-cane, and the major took it like a lamb, without a murmur or even The Nation. a grunt of disapprobation. The lieutenant of Engineers mentioned above as having escaped from the Munzinger massacre, had receipted to the Government for some engineer stores and a small sum of money for engineering purposes, Although he came back to Cairo desperately wounded, and brought back a few of his en- gineer troops, yet he was tried for the loss of the property and money, and his pay was stopped until the loss was made good. This is not hear- say. This lieutenant was in my own corps of Topographical Engineers. I was his chief, and had to approve his pay-account, and I know all the circumstances just detailed to be facts. No wonder, then, that such a people—so treated when in civil life that every spark of manhood is crushed out of them, and so abused as soldiers that they have not even the courage of a crushed worm, which strives to sting the heel of its de- stroyer—no wonder such a people will not fight. And the inglorious termination of Arabi Pasha’s wretched attempt at revolution is but the legiti- mate result of his and his deluded followers’ antecedents. No one who knew him and his people had any doubt how the affair would end from its very incipiency. I made Arabi Bey’s acquaintance in Abyssinia. He was then a lieu- tenant-colonel. After the Egyptian Army was defeated by King John, Arabi Bey was made an envoy, and sent to the King with presents and bribes, and propositions for peace. He was so far successful in his mission that King John gave the Egyptian Army an opportunity to retreat from his country without molestation. For this brilliant achievement Arabi Bey was promoted to the rank of colonel, made a bey of the first class, and decorated with the order of the Medjidieh. This cumulation of honors turned his head. He was probably, at that time, the only native Arab who held so high a rank—the beys and pashas being universally Turks or Cir- cassians. He imagined himself a great man, and thought he was chosen of fate as the de- liverer of his people. A few words as to the conduct of the campaign on both sides. Arabi Pasha has done better than I ever thought he would. He held his troops to- gether quite well, and manceuvred them well, for a man whose natural ability is not great, whose education is meagre, and whose military experience has been small. It is my opinion that Arahi Pasha has received. instructions from a source little suspected by most people. That he should have made his first serious stand at Tel-el-Kebir, with his back as it were resting on Zagazig, shows that some one wiser than him- self put the idea into his head that that position was the key to the Nile delta. He must have learned that from General Stone—not since the General has cast his fortunes with the Khedive, of course, but before that time, and before Arabi Pasha put himself in the attitude of open rebellion. It was a favorite idea of General Stone’s that Tel-el-Kebir and Zagazig would one day be of great moment in Egyptian affairs. I have frequently heard him speak of their strate- gic importance ; and when I tendered my re- signation in 1875, the General teld me he regret- ted my leaving before I had helped him fortify these two places. Sir Garnet Wolseley has conducted the attack upon the Egyptians in a manner altogether ad- mirable. In view of all the difficulties he has had to encounter, his progress has been remark- ably rapid. His taking Ismailia for his base of operations put him on the shortest line of march to Cairo. His gradually forcing the enemy back until he could get all of his forces together at their strongest point may have looked to some unwise and unmilitary, but it was exactly the right thing to do with the foe he had. In this way he was enabled to deal one deadly blow [ Number 900 -- and end the war at once. This he knew he would be able todo. Finally, the manner of engaging the Egyptians showed his perfect knowledge of their calibre, and his consummate skill. He went at them with a rush, as the Abyssinians did, and that was the end of the whole matter. S. H. L. THE RELIGIOUS CONDITION OF ENG- LAND—THE SALVATION ARMY. Lonpon, September 7, 1882. THE doings of a body which calls itself the Salvation Army have, during the last few months, excited an amount of attention from the educated classes in England which is chiefly remarkable as showing how little those educated classes seem to have previously known, or cared about, the religious phenomena which manifest themselves among the humbler part of the popu- lation. I will not attempt to write the history of the movement, which for the matter of that has lately been set forth in one of our best maga- zines, the Contemporary Review, by its founder and dictator, General Booth; but the occasion is a suitable one for saying something about the state of religious belief and practice among the masses in England, and considering how far such organizations as this are calculated to amend it. Amendment it certainly needs. Whether the poorest class, the day laborers in town and country, were in the habit of attending church and shaping their conduct with some reference to what they heard there, even in Roman Catho- lic times, may be doubted; it is at any rate not so certain as Roman Catholic writers are apt to assume in talking of “‘ ages of faith.” But since the Reformation there seems to have been always a section of the poor who lay outside religious agencies, and with the growth of great towns this section has naturally grown vastly jarger. At present, of the artisan and labor- ing class in the towns—the class which lives by weekly or daily wages for manual labor—cer- tainly less than a half, and perhaps only a fourth, can be said to belong to any church or denomination: that is to say, to be in the habit of regularly attending any place of worship. The more intelligent and active-minded artisans are chiefly Dissenters, and for the most part Methodists—we have, like you, several different Methodist bodies—or Baptists. The Lrish are, of course, Roman Catholics, and a certain number— small but capable of being increased when- ever an energetic clergyman appears on the scene—still adhere to the Established Church. In the purely agricultural parts of England the proportion of churchgoers is larger, and the strength of the Anglican establishment greater; in Scotland, too, religion bas, even in the towns, a stronger hold on the mass of the people than in the manufacturing or mining districts of Eng- land. To return, however, to these last-men- tioned districts, their condition is a very dis- heartening one. To what extent atheism, or secularism, as it is now usually called, prevails among them, cannot easily be determined, though the small support which Mr. Bradlaugh and other lecturers of his type receive seems to show that the secularist organizations do not count many members. But there isa vast sec- tion of the working class which, whether or not it has any theological or anti theological opi- nions, lives practically uninfluenced by religion, and comes in contact with the ministers of reli- gion only on the occasion of baptisms, weddings, and funerals. Add to this that there is also among our poorer classes, as well in country as in town, a vast deal of wretchedness, chiefly caused by intemperance, and a good deal of vio- lent crime directly arising from intoxication.
Page 9
Sept. 28, 1882] 259 The various churches, and especially the Church of England, have, within the last thirty or forty years, become much more uneasy and ashamed in the face of this state of things, which they feel that they have failed to grapple with. Constant efforts are being made by religious and philan- thropic agencies, by town missionaries, Scrip- ture readers, parochial Bible women, temperance societies, bands of hope, ragged schools, and in- numerable other similar means, to get hold of the intemperate or criminal class; but the results, although in some directions encouraging, remain small when compared with the magnitude of the evil. In spite of the vigor of religious life among the upper and middle classes in England, the ten- dency has of late years been to rely rather on what may be called social and philanthropic than on purely religious modes of action, appa- rently because people felt (though they did not like openly to acknowledge) that neither the decorous and dignified composure of the Anglican service, nor the dogmatic Calvinism which still, although its sterner aspects have largely vanished, characterizes the ordinary Dissenting pulpit, was well suited for the igno- rant and indifferent mass, which is substan- tially heathen, caring for this world only and the pleasures it affords. It is indeed true that the extremer High Churchmen, those whom it is the fashion to call Ritualists, niaintain that the elaborate ceremonies which they have en- grafted on, or restored to, the public worship of the Church of England, do succeed in at- tracting and moving the humblest and least instructed classes, which can be most easily touched through their eyes. But although some of these Ritualistic clergymen have done admira- ble work among the poor and outcasts of the great towns, it hasnot yet been shown that they can create large permanent congregations from these elements or bring them into their ecclesi- astical fold. Things being such, it is natural that the rise of a movement which undertakes to reclaim the heathen part of the population should be watched with interest, and even received with sympa- thy. Tobe sure, there is nothing novel in such movements, Severai of the humbler Dissenting bodies have always used violent preaching, the passionate singing of lively tunes, and other modes of exciting an audience, and under such modes there have often been the physical mani- festations of overwrought feelings—women fall- ing into convulsions, men crying out, people be- lieving that they bad suddenly freed themselves from the devil and emerged into light and peace. Street preaching, too, is not new among us, but has been pretty common for the last twenty years or so, at least since the days of the Irish revival in 1858. However, ordinary English society has not realized this, and is therefore more surprised than it need have been by the appearance of the Salvation Army, in which there is little or nothing new, beyond the more elaborate organization, with its military titles, and the subjection of all its branches to the dictatorship of one energetic man. The Army first came into notice by the attacks made on its processions—marching in processions with ban- ners flying and the singing of hymns is a main feature in its programme. Whoever joins it must become a total abstaiver: its presence is therefore unwelcome to the liquor-sellers, and they are suspected of having in many places organized opposition to it. Whether owing to their action, or to the natural disposition of the British rough to molest any one who looks peculiar, or does anything unusual in a public place, these processions were frequently attacked, theprocessionists hustled, stones thrown at them, the column sometimes broken and chased off the streets by gangs of vagabonds, while the “ sol- diers ” themselves, faithful to the non-resistance principles which they profess, did not defend themselves, but only sang the louder. When these disorders were brought to the notice of the local magistrates, they, whether from sympathy with the publicans (the brewing interest is often strong among the unpaid magistracy), or, as it is more charitable and more reason- able to suppose, in the idea that the blame of disturbances ought to be laid on those who give occasion for them by parading in an unusual fashion, mostly punished the Salva- tionists, and tried to stop the processions altogether. The Army, however, found useful allies in some active temperance members of the House of Commons, who, regarding it as a powerful agency on behalf of teetotalism, plied the Home Secretary with questions and re- monstrances, and forced him, rather against his will, to admit that the magistrates had been wrong in their view of the law; that Englishmen have a perfect right at common law to parade the streets in any decent garb they please to as- sume, and are entitled to be protected against assaults by bystanders. Thus the magistrates were pulled up, and the tables have been turned completely in favor of the Salvationists, whose good behavior under great provocation has gained public favor for them. They are rapidly becoming a large and powerful organization, with a “corps” in nearly every considerable town, and are erecting ‘‘ barracks” for their meetings with the proceeds of the subscriptions they receive, notonly from the soldiers, who are of course mostly poor people, but from well- wishers in the richer classes. Their special de- light is to purchase some large tavern or music ha)], or other questionable place of public amuse- ment, and turn it into a hall for their meetings, since they thus not only establish an agency for good, but extinguish one for bad, And in this way they have recently acquired some valuable properties in London. It must be well understood that this movement has nothing new in the way of theology to teach. Its idea and purpose simply is to bring religious influences to bear on the English heathen, the people who, living in the midst of churches and chapels, enter neither set of places ; and more particularly on those among these heathen who get drunk, beat their wives, and are genergijy in conflict with the law. This is doubtless one reason why the ciec¢y of all denominations are either friendly or ueutral. ‘* General” Booth does not aim at laying hold of people who now attend either the Church of England or any Nonconformist place of worship; and although, of course, a certain number of: his followers come from the Dissenting chapels, still the at- tendance at those chapels is not diminished: one does not cease to be a Methodist or a Baptist by being also a Salvationist. All intention of founding a sect to rival the existing sects is strenuously disclaimed: the object of the Army is to do by its military and aggressive organiza- tion what the denominations from the Anglican establishment downward have failed to do; and the converts it most values are those who have hitherto lived in flagrant and outrageous sin. When I went to one of their meetings in the town of Scarborough a few weeks ago, the chief attraction was an old woman named Jane John- son, said to be over eighty years of age, and who was announced to have keen in prison two hun- dred and forty-three times (if I recollect aright) for being drunk and disorderly and assaulting the police. The poor old thing, whose ageseemed to refute the doctrine that intemperance shortens life, gave a sort of address, which, so far as one could follow it—for she had lost her teeth and spoke an exceedingly strong North-country dia- lect—was a narrative of various adventures that had befallen her in ‘‘ getting tight,’ as she ex pressed it, and of consequent conflicts with the officers of the law, all of which excited great merriment among the audience. There was also a lady, described on the wall posters as ‘the Yorkshire Nightingale,” who sang hymns in a strong and sweet voice, the Army joining in chorus ; and a good many short extempore prayers were offered, and addresses delivered by various persons, while ejaculations of ‘~ Bless the Lord !” and ‘ Hallelujah !” resounded from all quarters of the hall. In fact, it was much like one of your camp-meetings. The striking thing was the absence of anything that could be called theology or dogma. Ai though the doctrines of the Army are just those which are to be heard in our Methodist and Baptist pulpits, and which were preached by Mr. Moody when he came bere on his revivalist mission, there was far less attempt to set them forth connectedly, much less to prove them out of the Bible, than Mr. Moody made. Considered as a contribution to reli gious life and thought, the Salvation Army has no importance, and it is one of the most curious symptoms of our condition that when a movement of this kind arises, it should have ab solutely nothing new to say. As to its practical value, people’s opinions of course differ as they are more or less shocked by its offences against good taste, such as the motto ** Blood and Fire,” which it has adopte’!. Some apprehend mis chief from the violent physical excitement into which it throws the newly-converted, or hold that by producing antinomianism it may even increase vice. Others think that the reclama tion of a certain number of drunkards and criminals, even for a time, is clear gain which may outweigh contingent evils. Meantime the Archbishop of Canterbury subscribes £5 to help it to turn a low theatre into “barracks”; and General Booth, its commander-in-chief, origi- nally a Methodist minister, is one of the most conspicuous figures of our day. . # as most THE COMING PRUSSIAN ELECTIONS, BERLIN, September 1, 1882. THE elections for the next Prussian Landtag will take place in the course of October, prob “ably toward the middle of that month. Asthey are not held under the tiie"otwiversal suf- » re- frage, but under an indirect system whiff } scribes three classes of electors, each of which has the same representation, although only a few taxpayers may constitute the first or second class, the agitation of the parties thus far is rather secret and the participation of the people rather small. The candidates of the different parties have mostly been nominated, but their names will not be published before the com- mencement of the campaign, in September, which measure will shield them a few weeks longer against the calumniations and slanders of the opposite party. Do not imagine that our political elections are carried on with that can- dor and fairness which becomes an educated people; on the contrary, in this respect we have but too soon imitated the man- ners and customs of the oldest nolitical constituencies. The tone of a Berlin election, for instance, will not stand much behind a pri mary of a New York ward, with the sole excep- tion of revolver-shooting, to which the German is not yet accustomed. And what is worse here than with you, if I am permitted to finish the comparison of Berlin with New York, is that here it is not only the small fry, the political rabble, which attends to the mean business of electioneering ; but clergymen, like the notorious court-preacher Sticker, officials, so-called young noblemen and officeholders in high positions,
Page 10
260 The Nation. who wish to draw attention to their patriotic merits, and to be rewarded accordingly, strike the keynote in the Conservative camp. For the last Reichstag election the Conservatives, although they ought to have known beforehand that they could not conquer a single seat in this city, gave free theatrical representations, con- certs, public amusements, and free lager to the voters, in order to win them to their side. In the rural districts the parties regort to other means. Thus, in the immediate neighborhood of Berlin the adversaries of a Liberal candidate who was very popular with the farmers as well as in the small towns, and who had been sent to the Reichstag in three consecutive elections, spread and even publisbed the rumor that if the said gentleman were elected for a fourth time, his constituency would have to pay him a life- long pension of 4,500 marks a year (about $1,100). Now, the members of the Reichstag receive no salary, which fact, if there were no other con- sideration, would prove that a member of that body who serves gratuitously is not entitled to any emolument; but naming the exact amount of the pension, and the positive assurance that it would not have to be paid except after a fourth election, made so great an impression on the minds of the farmers and small-town tradespeople that they defeated their own old candidate and helped to elect a Conservative. The Liberals, on the opposite side, having less means at their command, must raise every cent among themselves, and number less influential persons in their ranks, but they work with great- er energy and with more method. Their country press is better organized, and gives the people plain traths, which every voter understands, while the Cor servatives’ pamphlets, except those which indulge in abuse and personal attacks, are written in a professoriul tone, unintelligible to the masses. The Liberals, too, agitate better in the rural districts, and attract greater crowds to their meetings, In consideration of the fact that a successful Deputy has not a single tide- waitership to bestow on his most trusted and en- ergetic friend, and that the Liberal rank and file, who for their positions are dependent on the Gov- ernment, or even on the Landrath or gendarme, can every day be punished or ill-treated by their superiors, too much praise cannot be bestowed on the great mass of the electors, who risk “o78 vy © in yor." : than they can gain, Yeryoften suffer heavily, but P°vértheless stick to the Liberal platform. To return, however, to the impending elec- tions for the Landtag, there is every reason to anticipate a Liberal victory. While on former occasions the Liberals of all shades marched alone and worked for themselves, thus splitting their votes and weakening their influence, they are this time appreciating the old wisdom of acting harmoniously together. It is the merit of an able parliamentarian, Professor Haenel, of Kiel, to have brought this homely truth to the minds of the leaders and of the masses, * Let us stand by eack other, and, without breaking up existing party ties, offer a united front to the Conservatives. Such is the appeal which resounds from all parts of the coun- try. Let the differences which separate the several organizations among the Liberals re- main untouched, but let us not lose sight of the main point—i, e., the common fight against the Conservatives, and the creation of a Liberal majority. Do away with the patriotism, or, rather, the particularism, of cliques and factions, ignore or suppress the jealousies of the real or imaginary party leaders, but, in the common inte- rest, help to build up a Liberal party which, if every one does his duty, will and must rule the councils of the nation.” This parole will animate the exertions of the Liberals. In the elections for the last House of Deputies of the Landtag, [ Number 900 the Party of Progress had lost forty-two per cent., and the National Liberals about the same num- ber. Among 432 members there was a Liberal minority of 145. Now, if the Liberals wish to regain their influential position, they must re- conquer some seventy or eighty seats. As un- der less auspicious circumstances they in the last elections for the Reichstag won some forty seats, there is little doubt that they will succeed if they fully do their duty. 1f now all side issues be left alone, an honest understanding of all Liberal organizations can easily be realized and their victory secured, the more as they all agree in their opinions on the three leading questions which will determine the character of the next Landtag. These three questions comprise the relation of the State to the Church, the regulation of internal taxes, and administrative reform. I explained in my last letter the difficulties which the Government has created for itself by its yielding to the Pope. The overbearing tone of the Clerical combatants shows that they even expect more than Prussia has surrendered. The claims of the Church always increase when it is sure to deal with a weak adversary, but they grow very elastic when it must settle terms with a strong and independent enemy. While the Pope, for instance, at present courts and flatters Republican France, which threatens the existence of the Catholic clergy in its foundations, he is cooland arrogant toward Prussia, which, judg- ing from the tone of the Conservatives, he be- lieves unconditionally dependent upon his help. I do not believe that the unnatural alliance of Centre and Conservatives will last, and I doubt if they will be able to reach any positive re- sults. The Conservatives, certainly, are ready to sacrifice the independence of the school upon the Church, and even the sovereignty of the State, to Clerical insolence. On the other hand, the Li- berals of all shades, willing as they may be to conclude peace, unanimously insist on three ab- solute conditions on which it must be based—viz. : the control of public schools by the Govern- ment; the maintenance of the law of civil mar- riages; and the sovereignty of the State, which, of course, has to prescribe the boundary line between itself and the Church. ‘The Conserva- tives, even with Bismarck at their head, will never succeed in making our Protestant people accept a total submission to the Pope and his tools. Tbe Liberals, therefore, represent the real feelings of the country, 2’¥i have a-good chance of being elected on such a platform. The second question, on which all the Libe- rals agree, and on which a union will easily be effected, is the policy of taxes and internal reve nue. While the Government wants the Reichs- tag to raise an indefinite number of millions from indirect taxes, in order to use them fora tax reform in Prussia and in the smaller States, the Liberals bave treated and still treat this demand with the utmost distrust, which has been justified by the experience of late years. The Reichstag granted 145,000,000 marks by in- creasing duties and passivg a stamp act. Of this amount, which was distributed among the several States of the Empire, Prussia obtained 67,000,000, and of these 67,000,000 she has, in two successive years, abated fourteen and six (or together twenty) millions of marks in taxes. These, however, she was forced to raise by a loan, as the new inccme had been spent for other purposes. In order to conceal the failure of its pet measure, the Government demanded 115,000,000 for the last year but one, and 188,000,000 more for the next coming year ; but the one will be refused just as the ‘other has been rejected. Thus far the poorer classes have been saddled with new taxes, while the richer ones have been eased; now it is the purpose of the Government still to in- crease to an unlimited extent the indirect taxes and still more to reduce the direct ones. The Liberals, like one man, have withstood this mea- sure as well as this other, that the individual States be supported (alimentirt) by the Empire, and the towns and communities by the several States—a system which kills personal responsibi- lity and freedom and creates extravagance. There remains the question of administrative reform. In 1872 a beginning was made with the limited introduction of self-government and other lesser reforms into the counties of the eastern provinces, but it soqn came to au end. Instead of starting with the towns and villages, the second step was taken before the first. The consequence is that the partial reform, unsup- ported by other institutions, hangs in the air; and now that the western provinces ought to be benefited by the same democratic reform, it is found impossible to effect it. It is true, consid- erable progress has been made in destroying the greatest drawbacks of the feudal compo- sition of county and provincial representation ; the participation of all classes of the people in the administration has been achieved, and even legal protection and the enforcement of the law for or against administrative mea- sures have been laid down as a basis for public life. The progress is enormous, if you bear in mind that our eastern provinces were first conquered by the nobility and afterward settled by the people. Whatever political divi- sion is found there was created by and in the in- terest of the gentry. In the newly acquired and western provinces, however, it is different. There, some Roman Catholic districts perhaps excepted, a highly civilized population forms the marrow of society, while the nobility is of not so greatimportance, so that the people will consequently master the reforms to be introduced much more easily than the farmers and small- townspeoplein the East. You have the difference in a nutshell by comparing in this respect the eastern provinces with your former slave States, and the other old provinces with your New England States. The Government appre- ciates the above-mentioned fact, and for this reason it tries to do away with or cripple the en- tire progress, instead of extending it over the whole country. With bureaucratical schemes which defy all historical development it tries to introduce a bogus reform, which, in fact, will net do away with the jurisdiction of the law over administration. These are the most important differences which separate the Liberals from the political tendencies of the Government. The Liberals will insist on and fight for the sovereignty of the State over the Church, the justice and eco- nomy of the taxes, as well as the introduction of self-government in town, city, county, pro- vince, and State, and they will be supported herein by the people in the next coming elec- tions. A bired press, fed by the so-called ‘* Rep- tile Fund ” (interest of the money derived from the confiscated property of the late King George of Hanover), will not be strong enough to coun- teract the popular opposition. Weare approach- ing better times. +44 Correspondence. DORSEY AND THE PROTECTIONISTS, To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION : Str: Your prejudice against Western men has, I think, caused you to do Mr. Dorsey an injustice. The manner in which you have often referred to him leads one to suppose that you consider him but little better than a thief, when
Page 11
—_ he has simply followed the example of men whom you delight to honor. In my business of farming I use barbed fence wire to fence my field, and wire to bale my hay ; I have to pay twice as much for these articles as they are worth, because Mr. Hoar, of Massachusetts, has entered into a conspiracy with other officers of the Government to enable some of his constitu- ents to get rich at my expense, by compelling me to pay more for an article than it is worth. This is just what you charge Mr. Dorsey with doing. When three men stop me on the high- way and vote that I must give them my money, it is called robbery. When the people vote at an election that I must pay the Massachusetts manufacturer twice what his goods are worth, it is merely protection, vet the result is the same : I do not get a fair return for my money. I confess that I feel more respect for the man who steals openly than for one who gets unjust laws passed to protect him while his hands are in my pocket. Were it not for your prejudice against West- ern methods, you would, I think, have taken the ground that Dorsey’s ‘‘ infant industry ” was entitled to protection. SUBSCRIBER. DENVER, COL., Sept. 10, 1882, THE TRAFFIC IN VOTES. To THE EpiToR OF THE NATION : Sir : Although your readers must be familiar with the general evils of modern political ma- chinery, they may be as startled asI have been to hear of the concrete results of its working as shown in this part of the country. Of the demo- ralizing influence of the Portsmouth Navy-yard itis hardly necessary to speak. At thismoment an election is approaching, and literally hun- dreds of ‘‘doubtful” voters are lounging away their days there, on higher wages than they could get elsewhere. Carpenters, for example, are said to receive $3 a day, when their regular wages are $2, and to pass a good deal of their time ‘‘skulking around corners,” to use the lan- guage of an intelligent mechanic with whom I have just been talking. What is more, the re- cent visit of the President and of the Secretary of the Navy is thought by the common people to have some connection with this state of things— a pleasing instance of the popular estimate of national dignitaries, Of all this, however, your readers must have heard evough. Certainly, I have heard of it for some years. But until very lately I was un- aware that the country people hereabouts, and the lower classes in Portsmouth, habitually con- sider the actual sale of votes as a matter-of- course feature of an election. Of actual in- stances this is hardly the place to speak. A thousand actual instances could not show the extent of the evil so clearly as the common talk of the people, who speak of open bribery in much the same way that they speak of iippling. It is not a good thing, of course; but que voulez- vous ? It exists, and, provided a man does not do too much of it, 1t is not remembered against him. In short, the people have grown so used to it that the respectable mechanic of whom I spoke before — who is reputed, and seems to be, an honest man—remarked, with a sage grin : “ This election’s coming hard on the Democrats. They can't assess for their votes, and I don’t see where they’ll find the money to get ’em.” B. W. NEWCASTLE, N, H., Sept. 16, 1882, . DUTY ON FOREIGN PUBLICATIONS. To THe Epiror oF THE NaTION : Str: My attention bas been called to an article in your issue of August 31, in which are set forth the arguments used by Mr. Houghton in defence The Nation. of a high duty on foreign publications, and espe- cially on those the most elevated and influential in their character. Now, without discussing the merits or demerits of Mr. Houghton’s reason- ing on this question, I am constrained to point out an inconsistency between his precept and his practice. I believe he is the senior partner in the house of Houghton, Mifflin & Co., who have been engaged in importing English editions of leading periodicals, invoiced at about one-half the prices charged by the English publishers to English dealers, and at a proportionately di- minished duty, such methods of importation being made all the more easy by the shipment of the publications in printed reams of paper unfolded and unbound. And now, under a late arrangement with the English publishers, the entire duty is avoided by forwarding the peri- odicals through the post-office instead of the custom-house. If, as Mr. Houghton contends, American literature and American authors would be injured by the admission of foreign publications at low rates of duty, how can he be justified in pursuing a course intended to bring about this result, and in commending to Ameri- can readers—as he is, in his advertisements, con- tinually doing—this same class of literature for its excellence and its cheapness / L. TARIFF REFORM AND TEMPERANCE IN OHIO. TO THE EpIToR OF THE NATION : Sir: The short editorial comment by the Na- tion, in the issue of September 14, in regard to the Congressional campaign in this district, was read with interest by some Republicans, at least, who are sick of the “‘iniquities of the existing tariff” and really desire a revenue reform. Of these there are, perhaps, not many; but the un- certainty as to their numbers causes some dis quietude to the Republican managers. Party lines on national questions seem hopelessly con- fused, and it would be difficult to show any very good reason, from a national standpoint, why Republicans in sympathy with the tariff-reform movement should not vote for Mr, Frank Hurd. As the Nation remarks, ‘‘ It cannot be said that the rights of any human being, white or colored, will be put in jeopardy by his election.” Doubt- less some apprehensions of unwise financial legislation exist, but they are probably more than couaterbalanced by the necessity of taking some steps toward the attainment of a normal condition of foreign trade and domestic produc- tion. But, unfortunately, the campaign is so com- plicated by the importance of the liquor ques- tion, which is a leading issue in the State, that the tariff-reform Republican who would be in- dependent is placed in a somewhat embarrassing position. The attitude of the Republican party on this question is strong and decided ; that of the Democrats, shuffling and evasive. The re- cent ‘Pond Law,” heavily taxing the liquor- sellers, shattered on the constitutional provision forbidding any license of the traffic. The Re- publicans have come out squarely in favor of putting before the people a constitutional amend- ment striking out this clause, so as to leave the whole matter open to legid ation, in which case the Pond law, or something similar, would not be obnoxious to the same objections, and would undoubtedly be carried by a Republican Legis- lature. The position of the Democratic party on this point is defined (?) in their platform as follows : “ Resolved, That the Democratic party .. . is opposed to legislation merely sumptuary.” This means, if it has any meaning, that the De- mocrats are in favor of letting things remain as they are, But to this the great mass of the ad- herents of “law and order” are strongly op- posed, It is an open secret that the liquor men have furnished funds to the Democratic Campaign Committee, of which Mr. Hurd presumably gets his share. And although the liquor question is local, the feeling on it runs high, and will éxert a marted influence on the Congressional vote, Mr. Hurd will probably, on this account, lose more votes among independent and intelligent citizens than he will gain on the score of free trade ; besides which, there are some Democrats who are by no means in accord with him on the latter subject. On the other hand, he will un doubtedly gain many German votes, The result of the campaign will of course hinge on the com- parative strength of these elements, which is at present purely a matter of conjecture. Mr. Hurd, while doubtless sincere in his advo cacy of free trade, is a thorough Democratic politician ; and it is not surprising that Repub- licans are a little afraid of him, even though they agree in the main with his views on the tariff. Perhaps the best solution of the difficulty would be, remembering that in politics not the best conceivable, but the best attainable, should be our immediate aim, to support Mr. Hurd for Congress, inasmuch as the good he may effect seems likely to overbalance any evil which might possibly result from his election. Ss. TOLEDO, O., Sept. 19, 1882. POLITICAL ECONOMY IN GERMAN UNI VERSITIES. To THE EpIToR OF THE NATION ; Sr: The notice, in a recent number of the Nation, of Professor Fredericq’s report on in- struction in history in the German universities, suggests the thought that perhaps a short ac- count of the instruction in political economy in these schools would be of interest to your read ers. I describe the work as it is laid out in the University of Halle, both because I am better acquainted with that institution and because, in the opinion of competent critics, the work there is, on the whole, better organized than at any other similar school in Germany. Instruction in political economy is given, in the first place, by lectures. There are three pro- fessors in this department. In the course of a year they offer several series of lectures on the following subjects: History of Political Econo- my, Theoretical Political Economy, Practical Political Economy (the discussion of the economic problems of modern society), Science of Finance, Statistics, Police Supervision, and Administra- tion. Lectures upon other subjects are occasicn- ally given, especially upon economic topics of current interest. These lectures are supplemented (1) by the po- litico-economic Seminar, and (2) by the politico- economic debating society. The former is or- ganized as a department of the University ; its object is to provide opportunities for those who wish to make a specialty of economics. It is a society of students under the direction of, a pro- fessor. It meets for two or three hours, regu- larly, once a week, sometimes oftener. The exercises consist of essays by the students on subjects suggested by the director, followed by discussion and criticism of them. At the begin- ning of the term the professor prepares a list of subjects, theoretical, practical, and historical, from which each of the members of the Seminar chooses two or more which he agrees to present during the term. A programme is made out, and one or two of these essays assigned to each session, The subjects being known beforehand, each member of the society is expected to pre- pare himself for the discussion which follows the reading. Such subjects as the following are
Page 12
ia fe A 262 assigned: Value, Banks of Issue, Double Stan- dard, Income-Tax, State Ownership of Railways, ete. The student is expected to know, for in- stance, in the first case, the opinions of all pro- minent economists in reference to the subject, and their definitions of it. He must be able to give reasons for his own view, accompanied with refutation of the views he rejects, ete. It will be seen that the director has an excellent oppor- tunity in his questions to test the thoroughness and extent of the student's investigation and to form an opinion of his ability. The object of the society is really to promote original work in economics. A liberal amount of money is appropriated to the purchase of all recent publications of value in any language for the Seminar library. The society, although not yet fifteen years old, has done valuable original work, and its publications are rapidly acquiring an enviable reputation in Germany. A recent pamphlet by one of the members on ‘‘ American Competition in European Markets” attracted the attention of the Government, and the young man who wrote it was offered a place on a com- mission which was to come to America and in- vestigate the whole subject and report to the Imperial Government, but he was prevented from accepting by his election to the Reichstag. All possible assistance is given to those who aim to do original work, and the keen but sympa- thizing criticism of professor and fellow-student isnosmall aid in preventing mortifying blunders and mistakes. Professor Conrad, who now has charge of the society, is a really great teacher, able to iaspire enthusiasm for his work, and wisely to direct the efforts of his students. There is also a statistical Seminar under his charge, which makes a specialty of original work in statistics. The politico-economic debating society is un- der the control of the students, and discusses economic questions in the form of resolutions. It occupies itself, naturally enough, rather with practical questions of current interest than with purely theoretical problems. Its work is more serious and valuable than the work of corre- sponding organizations with us, because each of the members has had a tolerably complete course in political economy before be enters it. It will be seen that the advantages offered the liberally-trained student who desires to specialize are excellent. Such a system would, of course, be of no value in our ordinary colleges, whose students need the drill and training of school- boys much more than they do opportunities for original research. E, J. JAMES. NORMAL, ILL., Sept. 12, 1882. THE BEGGING OF DRINKS BY POLICE- MEN. To Tae Epiror or THE NATION: Sir: If Mallock ever establishes his ‘‘science of human character,” it is hoped that one of its effects will be to prevent the Nation from pub- lishing such comments on a New York policeman as are to be found in its last number. The case is this: A policeman was detailed to accompany a distinguished foreigner through the low lodg- ing-houses of New York. During the quarter of an hour so occupied, the policeman twice hinted that he would like to be treated. So the visitor treated him to a drink, and he also gave him a dollar, remembering, by way of contrast, that a Parisian gendarme had once refused to accept a napoleon when the service performed was much greater. The Nation thinks this performance ‘*is calculated to bring the blush of shame to the cheek of patriotism,” and assumes that said po- liceman expected five dollars. Now, this policeman certainly is not any credit to the force; but is not the Nation, by the , The Nation. [ Number goo sweeping assumption which it makes, doing more to bring the “‘ blush of shame” than the original statement of fact as contained in the book? The extent to which its foreign readers are influenced by the utterances of the Nation in regard to Americans has been recently illustrated by the comments called forth by its statement that not one person in one hundred thousand here ate with a fork. In the case of the police- man, there is strong evidence that no gratuity in money was expected ; for had there been, the hint at a drink would not have been given. ‘*To stand the drinks,” although the Nation and distinguished foreigners may not know it, is, among the classes from which policemen are drawn, an exceedingly common way of requit= ing obligations which are so small, or which are of such a social character, that a payment in money seems out of place. It is far more likely that the payment of the dollar surprised the policeman (especially after they had drunk to- gether) than that he expected a larger sum ; and yet, precisely because he was a European, M. D’Haussonville probably expected all the time, as a matter of course, to pay the dollar, and, notwithstanding his Parisian experience to the contrary, it was not so much the acceptance of the money as the fact of drinking atrocious Sicilian wine with a common policeman that impressed him. If the Parisian gendarmes, as a class, or any other class in Europe, set the Ame- ricans a good example in refusing gratuities, then many Americans who have travelled abroad will be greatly surprised and interested to know it. E. F. 8. New York, Sept. 26, 1882. [There is one fatal flaw in our correspon- dent’sargument. He fails to show that among ‘the classes from which policemen are taken” it is “‘ exceedingly common” or permissible to beg drinks. It is only among the classes which this policeman took M. D’Haussonville to see in their hideous lairs in the low lodging-houses that it is customary to remind a friend or com- panion that it is time to drink at his expense. In the policeman class, the usual attitude with regard to gratuitous liquor is one of dignified, silent, and, let us add, carefully concealed ex- pectation. Of course a member of it who was craving for a drink from a friend would not avoid taking him past a grogshop, but he would not for worlds direct attention to the grogshop unless he himself meant to be the giver of the treat. This is so elementary a drinking rule that it is almost painful to have to point out its existence to a writer who pro- fesses to speak on the subject with a certain authority.—Ep. NATION. } DEFORESTING THE ADIRONDACKS. To THE EpiTorR oF THE NATION: Sir: There is probably no writer whose opi- nion is more highly and deservedly respected, on the subjects he has specially treated, than the late George P. Marsh. His great work, ‘The Earth as Modified by Human Action,’ is a won- derful exposition of the dangers to which na- tions are exposed by ignorance or want of a realizing appreciation of certain laws of nature which cannot be violated with impunity, though the penalty may be so long delayed that it is only by such careful examination as he has given that the consequences can be traced back to the original cause. But the course of nature is as certain as the passage of time, and at this day, when results have been so clearly demon- strated, it is disgraceful if we incur punishment which cannot be averted simply because its in- fliction does not immediately follow the trans- gression. It isa remarkable fact that a supposed case cited by Mr. Marsh in the above-named work, the results of which he foretells by comparison with what has actually happened elsewhere, has now been literally fulfilled in its incipient stage by act of the State of New York. After de- scribing the terrible results which have followed the clearing the forests from the mountains of southeastern France—which the Government is now endeavoring, at great cost, not to retrieve, for that is hopeless, but simply to check—he goes on to say: “Tt is evidently a matter of the utmost impor- tance that the public, and especially landown- ers, be roused to a sense of the dangers to which the indiscriminate clearing of the woods may we oe not only future generations, but the ve soil itself. Some of the American States, as well as the Governments of many European colonies, still retain the ownership of great tracts of pri- mitive woodland. The State of New York, for example, bas in its northeastern counties a vast tract of territory in which the lumberman has only here and there established his camp, and where the forest, though interspersed with per- manent settlements, robbed of some of its finest ine-groves, and often ravaged by devastating res, still covers far the largest proportion of the surface. ‘‘Through this territory the soil is generally poor, and even the new clearings have little of the luxuriance of harvest which distinguishes them elsewhere. The value of the land for agri- cultural uses is, therefore, very small, and few purchases are made for any other purpose than to strip the land of its timber. It has been often proposed that the State should declare the re- maining forest the inalienable property of the commonwealth ; but I believe the motive of the suggestion has originated rather in poetical than in economical views of the subject. Both these classes of considerations have a real worth. It is desirable that some large and easily accessible region of American soil should remain, as far as possible, in its primitive condition—at once a museum for the instruction of the student, a gar- den for the recreation of the lover of nature, and an asylum where indigenous tree, and humble plant that loves the shade, and fish and fowl] and four footed beast, may dwell and perpetuate their kind, in the enjoyment of such imperfect protection as the laws of a le jealous of re- straint can afford them. e immediate loss to the public treasury from the adoption of this policy would be inconsiderable, for these lands are sold at low rates. The forest alone, econo- mically managed, would, without injury and even with benefit to its permanence and growth, soon yield a regular income larger than the pre- sent value of the fee. “The collateral advanta; of the preserva- tion of these forests would far greater. Na- ture threw up those mountains and clothed them with lofty woods, that they might serve as a reservoir to supply with perennial waters the thousand rivers and 1ills that are fed by the rains and snows of the Adirondacks, and as a screen for the fertile plains of the central coun- ties against the chilling blasts of the north wind, which meet no other barrier in their sweep from the Arctic Pole. The climate of New York pre- sents even now greater extremes of temperature than tbat of southern France. The long-con- tinued cold of winter is more intense, the short heats of summer even fiercer, than in Provence, and hence the preservation of every influence that tends to maintain an equilibrium of tem- pereture and humidity is of cardinal importance. he felling of the Adirondack woods would ulti- timately involve, for northern and central New York, consequences similar to those which have resulted from the laying bare of the southern and western declivities of the French Alps, and the spurs, ridges, and detached peaks in front of them.” In spite of this warning, the deed has been done. A very large tract of the Adirondacks has been sold for the express purpose of strip- ping it of its wood. It is to be presumed that neither party to the bargain would give a mo- ment’s heed to whaf Mr. Marsh calls the ‘‘ poeti- cal view ” of the subject, and it‘is evident that those who have thus disposed of the tract are too ignorant to take any but a very limited view of the actual results involved in the issue. There is, however, no excuse at this day for such
Page 13
Sept. 28, 1882] The Nation. ignorance on the part of those who assume such a responsibility. The actual necessity of pre- serving a due proportion of forest throughout the country, and the ruinous consequences of stripping the woods from the mountain tops and sides, are familiar to every man who has studied the subject; and no man who is not thus in- formed should presume or be allowed to give a vote on a question of such momentous impor- tance. There is nothing so difficult as to induce people to think and form an opinion for themselves on any matter outside of their immediate personal interests. And it is for want of the watchful- ness which can only come of such thoughtful de- cision, that such outrages become possible. It is to be hoped that the indignation it has excited in the minds of all who appreciate its practical as well as poetical aspects, will continue to be expressed with sufficient force to prevent the possibility of its repetition or further perpetra- tion, If it should lead to the appropriation of a portion of the same region as an experimental forest for practical illustration of forest culture under proper management, the evil which has been done would not be entirely without com- pensation. H. W. 8S. CLEVELAND. CHICAGO, Sept. 11, 1882. THE THEATRE OF EPIDAUROS.* To THE EpITOoR OF THE NATION: Sir: After the excavations of the Germans at Olympia, and of the French in Delos, it was natural that the attention of archeologists should be turned to Epidauros, the greatest ancient sanctuary of Asklepios, and especially to its theatre, which, in the opinion of Pausanias, was ‘‘eminently well worth seeing—for what architect could compete in harmony and beauty of design” with him who planned this theatre, the great Polykleitos ? In March, 1881, the Greek Ephor of Antiqui- ties in charge of the islands of the Agean, Mr. P. Kavvadias, was commissioned by the Council of the Archzological Society of Athens to ex- plore the sanctuary of Epidauros. Mr. Kavva- dias began work at once, and carried on his in- vestigations steadily until the beginning of July, when he was despatched by the Government to superintend the new excavations of the French school at Athens in Delos. During this period of over three months, Mr. Kavvadias laid bare nearly the whole auditorium of the theatre, and part of the remains of the stage foundations. In March of the present year the work was re- sumed. The exploration of the theatre was soon completed, and that of the other monu- ments of the sanctuary was begun, and is still going on. Among these monuments were num- bered, besides several temples and other build- ings described by Pausanias, a remarkable cir- cular building called the tholos, designed by Polykleitos, and a beautiful fountain. Among these ruins much that is of interest in architec- tural, sculptural, and epigraphic remains has been found already ; but the work is still too in- complete to demand a comprehensive summary of its results. I propose, therefore, to confine myself to a review of the features of the theatre, which not only was one of the largest and finest of Greek theatres, but is one of the oldest and most perfect in many ways of surviving ex- amples. Mr. Kavvadias found the site of the theatre covered so thickly with trees and underbrush that it was impossible to force one’s way from * Reports of Mr. P. Kavvadias, in the Mpaxrixa THs év "APjwais “Apxarodoyixys “Eraipias, ard "lavevapiov, 1881, wéxpe "lavovapiov, 1882—év "AGyvas, 1882; and in we ov, Tonos I’, revxos G’ (March and April, the bottom to the top of the auditorium. His first week was spent, therefore, in clearing out this luxuriant growth ; but even then, merely the general form of the auditorium was visible —the edges of the stone seats appearing only in a few places, in the lower part and at the ex- tremities of the hemicycle, above the thick bed of soil washed down from the slopes of Mount Kynortios above. Henceforth, therefore, the work of exploration consisted almost wholly of excavation. This work has demonstrated the ineorrectness of the descriptions and plans of the theatre given by Donaldson, Leake, Blouet, and others, which were necessarily in great part conjectural, on account of the condition of the site described above. The theatre of Epidauros was situated without the sacred peribolos of Asklepios, upon the northwestern slope of Mount Kynortios, in a wide ravine, which was of such shape that it required but little labor to give it the requisite form of the auditorium, The rows of ordinary seats, and the seats of honor, or thrones, of the xoiAov, are constructed of the white limestoné of the neighborhood, while the supporting-walls at the extremities of the wings, and the surviving substructions of the stage, are built of tufa. The arc of the auditorium is greater than a semicircle, and its curve deviates but little from that of a geometrical circle. The auditorium is divided by a diazoma into two zones, of which the upper consists of twenty-two rows of seats, according to the interesting topographical draw- ings of Captain Solomos, of the Greek Army, which are given in the Mpaxrx«d. According to the text, this upper zone contains only twenty rows of seats, besides a sort of bench above the diazoma, upon which the spectators placed upon the lowest row of seats rested their feet. The lower zone contains thirty-two rows of ordinary seats. Besides the ordinary seats, there are three rows of thrones. The diazoma which separates the upper and lower zones of the theatre presents an arrange- ment which has not been found elsewhere. It consists of two passages paved with slabs of stone, one of which is upon a higher level than the other. The lower passage is 1.90 metre broad. On the side nearest the stage it is bor. dered by a row of thrones immediately above the uppermost row of seats of the lower zone. On the side away from the stage is a supporting- wall 1.36 metre high, crowned by elegant mouldings, and forming a base for the second row of thrones. The upper passage of the dia- zoma lies between this row of thrones and the bench beneath the lower seat of the upper zone, and is only 60 centimetres wide. The third row of thrones is below the lowest seat of the lower zone, and forms the immediate enclosure of the orchestra. The thrones and seats were con- structed of blocks of hewn stone fastened to each other by iron clamps set in lead. Instead of being divided into separate seats for each spectator entitled to a place of honor, as in the Dionysiac theatre at Athens, the thrones of Epi- dauros extend unbroken, in each cepxis, from cAiuag tO xAiuag, thus resembling modern sofas. Unlike the Athenian thrones—which are, it is true, of very much later date—they bear no in- scriptions designating the privileged persons for whom they were reserved. The three rows of thrones differ in height and in amount of sculp_ tured ornament, those nearest the orchestra being the most ornate and the highest (90 centimetres). The ordinary seats of the lower zone are exactly similar in design and in height to those of the Dionysiac theatre ; those of the upper zone are higher, and have square faces. The lower zone was divided into twelve «xepxises by thirteen cdiuaxes, Which were continued through the sup- porting-wall of the thrones of the &4¢oua to the 263 terrace above the upper zone of seats. Between each two of these «A(uaxes in the upper zone was another stairway, so that the upper zone was divided into twenty-four xepxises by twenty-five cAiuaxes. The design of the theatre of Epidauros is thus entirely different from that given as typi- cal of the Greek theatre by Vitruvius, who as signed eight stairways to the lower zone, thus placing the axis of the theatre in the middle of a xepxis Of this zone—not in a «Aiuag, as at Epi dauros. The xotAov was surrounded above by a wall, leaving a terrace 2.15 metres wide beyond the upper row of seats. There was probably di rect access to this terrace by doors, and to the didfwua by stairways along the supporting-walls of the wings, to facilitate access to the theatre, which would have been difficuit if confined to the approaches leading from below through the orchestra. Contrary to the indications of Vitru vius, no remains of a portico exist along this upper terrace, either in the theatre of Epidauros or in any other theatre of purely Greek arrange ment. The orchestra is about 26 metres in diameter. It consists of two parts—a passage paved with stone before the base of the lower row of thrones, and a circle, with a radius of 12.16 metres, ex tending toward the stage beyond the plan of the coidov, The floor of the passage is 21 centimetres lower than that of the circle, and is so arranged as to collect and discharge outside the theatre through drains the rain-water falling in the auditorium. The periphery of the circle is con structed of stone ; its surface, however, is not paved, but is formed of a carefully-laid bed of sand or ashes (xérs). We have here, without doubt, the explanation of the hitherto doubtful term, xoviorpa, applied by the ancients to the orchestra of the Hellenic theatre as distin- guished from that of the Romans, which was paved with stone. At the centre of the circle is embedded a circular stone, in which is a deep, circular hole. This marks the place of the thy- mele—the altar of Dionysos—in a circle about which the chorus moved, continuing thus the early traditions of worship from which the Greek drama derived its origin. At a distance of 38 centimetres beyond the circle of the orchestra, and parallel to the chord of the arc of the auditorium, are the foundations, built of white limestone, of the wall of the hypo- skenion. This wall was decorated with eighteen Ionic semi-columns of Attic design. The bases of six of these columns remain in position ; and one of the capitals has been found (this spring), and some fragments of the Ionic cornice. The foundations survive of the double doors at either side which gave access to the orchestra and to the buildings of the stage, and formed at the same time the architectural connection between the stage and the auditorium. The foundations of the stage seem to indicate that there were only three doors in the wail behind the Aoyeiov ; nothing, however, remains of the Hellenic foun- dations, except the lower courses. Above these, the stage buildings appear to have undergone entire modification at several periods—the last probably during the Middle Ages, when they seem to have been adapted to the needs of habi- tation. Mr. Kavvadias does not give the general di- mensions of the xoiAovr. According to the plans of Captain Sclomos, its greatest diameter is about 415 feet, English ; and the length of the axis of the theatre, from the centre of the circle of the orchestra to the wall above the upper terrace, 205 feet. In the course of the excavation of the orchestra and the stage, Mr. Kavvadias found a number of statues of both male and female figures—all headless, and many of them otherwise mutilated. Sept. 28, 18821] Tha Nratiann. oOfR
Page 14
~ 264. sume of these are of fine workmanship, but nearly all are of comparatively late date. One of them has been identified as the statue of the Empress Livia, dedicated by the people of | Mpidauros, of which the base, with its inscrip- tion, was found in position. The most interest- ing artistic discovery made by Mr. Kavvadias, however, is a statue of Hygieia, which, for ar- tistic and critical reasons, he believes to be by the hand of Polykleitos himself. This statue, like the others found, has been deprived of its head—doubtless by the zeal of the Christians in the time of Theodosius or Justinian. Mr. Kav- vadias describes this statue carefully in his re- port, and sets forth at length his reasons for be- lieving it to be a work of Polykleitos. Unfor- tunately, it has not yet been published, though found more than a year ago ; and artistic criti- cism cannot but be unsatisfactory and inconclu- sive in the absence of a graphic representation of the object under discussion. J am, sir, very respectfully, THomas W, LUDLOW. CoTTaGE LAWN, YONKERS, N. Y. Notes. WE take from the Publishers’ Weekly the fol- lowing supplementary announcements of forth- coming books from the houses respectively named. D. Appleton & Co.: ‘Fifty Perfect Poems,’ selected and edited by Charles A. Dana and Rossiter Johnson; ‘Hours with Art and Artists,’ by G. W. Sheldon; Austin Dobson’s ‘Eighteenth Century Essays’; and Arabella B. Buckley’s ‘The Great Backboned Family, and How it Has Spread over the Earth.’ Harper & Bros.: A translation of Dr. Franz von Reber’s ‘History of Ancient Art,’ by Joseph Thaccher Clarke; ‘The Friendships of Mary Russell Mit- ford,’ edited by the Rev. A. G. L’Estrange; ‘Travels in South Kensington,’ with notes on decorative art and architecture in England, by Moncure D. Conway; ‘Highways and By- Ways’ (of New England), by W. Hamilton Gib- sop, with the author’s own illustrations; ‘The Story of the New York Volunteer Fire Depart- ment,’ by George W. Sheldon; ‘Eras and Cha- racters of History,’ by William R. Wiliams; ‘ A History of Wood Engraving,’ by Prof. George E. Woodberry; and ‘ New Games for Parlor and Lawn,’ by George B. Bartlett. Henry Holt & Co.: Bernhard Ten Brink’s ‘Early English Lite- rature,’ translited by Horace M. Kennedy; Heine’s ‘ Harzreise and Das Buch Le Grand,’ an- notated by Prof. James A. Harrison, and his ‘Romantic School,’ translated by 8. L. Fleisch- mann; J. A. Symonds’s ‘Italian Literature’; the second part of Cory’s ‘Guide to Modern Eng- lish History,’ and the second volume of Fyffe’s ‘History of Modern Europe’; J. A. Doyle’s ‘English Colonies in America’; and ‘* Politi- cal Economy,’ by Gen. Francis A. Walker (in the ‘‘ American Science” series). Charles Scrib- ner’s Sons: ‘Corea, the Hermit Nation,’ by Prof. W. E. Griffis; Lenormant’s ‘Origines de Histoire,’ translated by Mary Lockwood, under the title, ‘The Beginnings of History According to the Bible and the Traditions of Oriental People’; ‘Ildyls of Norway,’ poems by Prof. H. H. Boyesen; and Sidney Lanier’s ‘The Boys’ Percy.’ -A. 8S. Barnes & Co.: ‘ Anatomical Technology,’ with reference to the domestic cat, by Professors Wilder and Gage, of Cornell Uni- versity. Dodd, Mead & Co.: A new historical series, ‘‘ The Minor Wars of the United States,” beginning with the War of 1812 and the Old French War, by Rossiter Johnson; ‘Cradle Songs of Many Nations’; Schaff and Gilman’s ‘ Library of Religious Poetry’; and Hesse-War- tegg’s ‘Tunis.’ George Routledge & Sons; A , new illustrated and complete edition of George MacDonald’s novels ; ‘ Pan-Pipes,’ a book of old songs arranged by Theodore Marzials and illustrated by Walter Crane; ‘Randolph Cal- decott’s Graphic Pictures’; and ‘Lattie Ann,’ Jane and Ann Taylor’s rhymes, illustrated by Kate Greenaway. Fowler & Wells: ‘Traits of Representative Men,’ by George W. Bungay; and ‘Forty Years in Phrenology,’ by Nelson Sizer, a ‘‘ practical examiner.” Fords, Howard & Hulbert: A series of reprints from Our Con- tinent, including E. C. Gardner’s ‘The House that Jill Built after Jack’s had Proved a Fail- ure’; and ‘ Bullet and Shell; or, War as the Sol- dier Saw It,’ by George F. Williams. Ginn, Heath & Co., Boston: ‘ Elements of Geology,’ and ‘Geology,’ text-books by Prof. N. S. Shaler; a ‘Spanish Grammar’ and ‘ Readings from Spanish Literature,’ by Prof. G. Knapp; ‘ Reader’s Guide to English History,’ by Prof. W. F. Allen ; ‘A Science of Mind,’ by President Seelye; and ‘Introduction to the Study of Philosophy.’ by G. Stanley Hall. Little, Brown & Co.: ‘A Treatise on the Principles and Practice of the American Law of Patents for Useful Inven- tions,’ by Prof. W. C. Robinson, of Yale, a work much needed since the decision of the Su- preme Court in the case of Miller vs. the Bridge- port Brass Co. Estes & Lauriat: A juvenile ‘History of New York,’ by Mrs. Martha J. Lamb. S. E. Cassino: New editions of Goethe’s works, revised and edited by Dr. F. H. Hedge and Prof. Leopold Noa, and of Schiller’s, uni- form with the foregoing ; Fergusson’s ‘ History of Architecture in all Countries’; and ‘ Flowers of the Field and Forest,’ by the Rev. A. B, Her- vey. J. B. Lippincott & Co.: An illustrated edition of ‘New England Bygones,’ by E. H. Arr (the late Mrs. Ellen H. Rollins); and a new illustrated edition of T. Buchanan Read’s Poeti- cal Works. Robert A. Tripple: ‘ Historical and Biographical Sketches,’ by Samuel Whitaker Pennypacker. S. C. Griggs & Co., Chicago: ‘A Practical German Grammar,’. by Prof. Wesley C. Sawyer; and ‘The Development of English Literature and Language,’ by Prof. A. H. Welsh. Rand, McNally & Co.: The second volume of Lalor’s ‘ Cyclopedia of Political Science, &c.’ ; and ‘American Etiquette and Rules of Polite- ness,’ by Profs. W. R. Houghton, J. K. Bach, and P. J. A. Woodburn. The Publishers’ Weekly, on its own account, announces several handy little books uniform with its ‘Reading Diary’ and ‘Books of All Time,’ such as, ‘Readers and Libraries,’ by W. E. Foster; ‘Schools and Libraries,’ by S. S. Green; ‘A Descriptive Catalogue of Historical Novels and Tales,’ by H. Courthope Bowen; ‘Books for the Young,’ by Miss C. M. Hewins, etc., etc. Harper & Bros. have brought out in the Frank- lin Square Library (No. 271) Mr. Smiles’s ‘ Self- Help,’ which might naturally have come some- what earlier upon the list. We hope, by the way, that the *‘ two-column edition” (8vo) of this Library, with neat yellow paper covers and no increase in price, will commend itself so as to encourage a reversion to ordinary book form. Macmillan & Co. have issued at a reduced price the third revised and corrected edition, with fresh notes, of Butcher and Lang’s prose version of the Odyssey. Three poems of Bryant’s, ‘‘ Thanatopsis,” ‘‘The Flood of Years,” and ‘‘ Among the Trees,” here- tofore issued separately, with illustrations, by G. P. Putnam’s Sons, have been united in a sin- gle holiday volume. The designs of the first two are by Mr. W. J. Linton; of the last, by Jar- vis McEntee. ‘The Charles Dickens Birthday Book,’ of which T. Whittaker is the American publisher, is not only peculiar in having been compiled, edited: [Number 900 and illustrated in the author’s own family, but in the neglect to indicate the source of the nu- merous extracts. No great names are inserted under the several dates, and some odd juxtapo- sitions may ensue, as when a young lady in- scribes her name under December 4, and reads opposite—“‘I like your appearance, old fellow.” Ginn, Heath & Co. publish a new edition of Wentworth’s ‘Elements of Algebra.’ The first 380 pages are a reprint of the first edition, which was reviewed in the Nation of September 22, 1881. To this second edition ten new chapters, comprising 130 pages, have been added, treating of ‘Continued Fractions,” “Imaginary Num- bers,” and other subjects which are usually con- sidered as belonging to the higher algebra. The general execution of these additions is in keep- ing with the previous part of the work. They perhaps justify the title of ‘Complete Algebra’ stamped on the back and sides, though the origi- nal title-page remains unaltered. We can only repeat the opinion expressed in regard to the first edition, that it isa very practical and usa- ble book for a school. R. G. Hutchinson, No. 44 Maiden Lane, sends us a convenient index for a small private library of say 2,000 works. It is a bound volume, crown 4to, of 240 pages, with ruled spaces for title, author, particulars of publication, size, binding, ete. Itis available for either author or title- indexing, but not for both. From L.W. Schmidt, 7 Barclay Street, we have the catalogue of the Johannes Paul art col- lection to be sold at auction at Cologne on Octo- ber 16. Following a most practical custom, the catalogue is provided with numerous comprehen- sive heliotype views of plates, vases, tankards, keys, cups, flagons, coffers, ete., etc., which speak for themselves. B. Westermann & Co. have received parts 2- 5, of Diintzer’s illustrated edition of Goethe’s works, already described by us. The engravings show no falling off in quality, and are so abun- dant as to meet the needs of even the most indolent imagination. Griffith & Farrar, says the Atheneum, own- ing most of Bewick’s wood blocks for ‘ The Look- ing-Glass for the Mind,’ will complete the set, and shortly bring out a reprint of the edition of 1792, under the editorship of Mr. Charles Welsh. Mr. Christern sends us the prospectus of Oud Holland, a journal of researches in the archives of Amsterdam made by Drs. A. D. de Vries and N. de Roever. It will be illustrated ina manner to please the historian and antiquary. The pub- lishers of this quarterly review are Frederik Muller & Co., Amsterdam, M. Tamizey de Larroque, says the Revue Cri- tique, has made a curious discovery. In a hitherto unknown pamphlet which be found in the library of Carpentras and published in the Revue des Bibliophiles, called ‘ Entrée de Charles IX. a Bordeaux,’ it is said that the livery of the King was “ blanc, pers, et rouge ”—that is, white blue, and red, or that very tricolor which now is to Royalists like a red flag before a bull’s eyes. Mr. E. Steiger, 25 Park Place, with character- istic energy and earnestness, has reprinted his letter, on the abolition of the duty on books, to the Evening Post last August, together with Mr. Houghton’s argument in a contrary sense before the Tariff Commission and the Nation’s comments upon it, and sends them broadcast with a petition, returnable to himself, praying Congress to remove the duty in question. No better employment than obtaining signatures to this petition could occupy any one’s leisure dur- ing the next two months, —The large and valuable library left by the late Mr. George P. Marsh, United States Minis- ter to Italy, has been sold by the Rev, Dr, Nevin,
Page 15
Sept. 28, 1882] | The Nation.
on the part of the executors of Mr. Marsh’s estate, to Mr. Frederick Billings, whose residence is at Woodstock, Vermont, Mr. Marsh’s tirth- place. It is said to be the intention of Mr. Bil- lings to present this library to the University of Vermont at Burlington, of which he is himself an alumnus, and of which Mr. Marsh was for some time one of the Trustees, while his home was at Burlington. These facts lend a special interest and fitness to this gift. Mr. Marsh had at one time made a will by which he left his li- brary to the University of Vermont, but later his circumstances were so impaired by what he spent in the public service that he was unable to earry out his original intention. Mr. Billings has done a generous and delicate act in thus securing the library for the institution with which Mr. Marsh himself had wished to place it. —Mr. John Bigelow’s “ Railway Invasion of Mexico” in Harper’s for October contains a mine of information for the investor who is now put- ting his savings into the hands of the financiers engaged in ‘‘ developing the resources ” of that country. Mr. Bigelow’s facts amount toa de- monstration that the railroads now under con- struction cannot for years and years pay large dividends or a heavy interest, because there is not enough business for them to do, anda future increase cannot be relied upon as 1t has been in our Western States, because there is no flow of emigration into Mexico, and no reason to think that emigrants will want to go there as long as they can come to the United States. The mere building of railroads will not bring them. What is being done in Mexico is very like what was done years ago in Peru and other South Ameri- can countries; and the results must be the same, except that the state of society in Mexico is now peaceful and settled, and there is reason to believe that her interval improvement will not be interfered with in the future by revolu- tions. The emigration of which we have heard as ‘‘ pouring” into Mexico during the last year or two, has chiefly consisted of 5,000 or 10,000 Italians or negroes, who have been brought in by the railroad contractors themselves to work on the new roads. To Mexico the construction of a number of lines with foreign capital is a great thing; to the contractors and the capital- ists who place the bonds on the market it is a great thing; but the investor ought to under- stand that the scheme as a whole is a specula- tion of which the profits are less likely to come to him than to any one in the wide world, and that if he wants to see what is probably in store for him, he has only to recollect what the early investors in *‘Peruvians” and “ Egyptians” found in store for them. —M. E. W. Sherwood contributes an illustrated article on “‘ Certain New York Houses,” the in- teriors of which show the pitch of luxury and taste at which we have arrived, and suggest to the pessimistic reader that the palaces of New York differ from ail the palaces which have pre- ceded them in other countries, or now rival them, in being inhabited, to a large extent, by a class whose occupations are not naturally associated with palace life at all. <A life of money-getting in the United States is now usually wound up by the construction of a palace in which a successful dry-goods man, or pork-packer, or operator in stocks drags out the evening of his days in the midst of taste and splendor for the enjoyment of which he has neither a natural or acquired capacity. He knows that it is his duty to have an esthetic interior, and he likes to beat his neighbor on the opposite corner by having a little more estheticism in it than he; but in his secret soul he must feel that these are rather things for ‘the girls” and artists, and that the place for him
265
is in his counting-room or watching the tape of the stock-ticker. Mr. W. H. Bishop, always a good observer and describer, writes on ‘* South- ern California,” and those who are interested in the once much-talked-of ‘‘ Symmes's Hole,” as well as those who never heard of either Symmes or the hole, will find B, F. Madden’s paper on the subject a curious bit of reading. The Rev. D. Stevenson contributes to literature Chief-Justice Marshall’s ‘Eulogy upon his Wife,” which has never seen the light before; and we may take this opportunity to say that the eulogies on wives by their husbands, even when distinguished men, though they pander to a morbid curiosity, are seldom of any real inte- rest, because they are all alike utterly uncriti- cal, and, as they are the products of affection rather than intellect, ought to be sacred, at any rate unless, as in Mill’s case, the survivor him- self insists on taking the world into his confi- dence. All that can be said of the Chief-Jus- tice’s eulogy is that it shows Mrs. Marshall to have been very like Mrs. Mill, in the esti- mation of her busband; but that she was so in fact is improbable, to say the least. —The Century, as usual, is full of illustrated articles, the best of which, perhaps, are ‘ Life in a Mexican Street,” by 8. G. W. Benjamin, and Charles H. Farnham’s ‘“ Gibraltar of America,” the illustrations of the latter being by Henry Sandham and F, Hopkinson Smith, who have managed to reproduce the main Quebec ‘‘ effects ” with great success. David C. Barrow, jr., de- scribes in an entertaining manner a Georgia **corn-shucking,” one of those plantation insti- tutions which have flourished and expanded since the war, and the survival of which shows that the hilarity and gregariousness of the ne- gro have not been so much affected by the pos- session of civil rights or the suffrage that we need yet dread his losing the power to amuse us. Mr. E. E. Farman, who, as American Con- sul-General, conducted the negotiations with the Egyptian Government which led to the gift of the Obelisk, makes a detailed state- ment of what he did in the matter, and pub- lishes the letter he received with regard to it from Sherif Pasha. This shows that the latter regarded the Obelisk as given to the city of New York, and not, as seems to be the belief of those who have charge of it, to the United States. It is a matter of small consequence, however, as it is evident from Mr. Farman’s own account that the Khedive in giving it hard- ly cared to know to whom the title was to be transferred. A good many people wondered at the time the negotiations began why, if the Khedive wanted to give us an obelisk, there should be so much delay over it; but it appears from what Mr. Farman has to say that the Khedive never had any intention of giving it at all. We sent out and asked for it, and the Egyptian Government finally gave it because they found that we wanted so much to have it. An enterprising journalist started the negotia- tions by announcing that the Khedive was all ready to give an obelisk “‘upon a proper ap- plication,” all of which shows that good things may often be got by insisting on having them, though in the intercourse of na- tions the procedure described by Mr. Far- man is certainly novel. There is something rather funny in his account of the persistent way in which he argued to the Khedive that we really must have an obelisk in New York, because then our entire population of 50,000,000 could see it, whereas only a small proportion of them would ever be able to visit Egypt. The Cen- tury, which is now perhaps the most judiciously edited magazine in the world, has a few words said for it by its editor in this number, and it
will surprise no one who is accustomed to look through it to learn that its circulation during the past year has been larger than ever, and that it has a large circulation in England. —The Atlantic contains a pleasant description, by Mr. F. H. Cushing, of acurious tribe of In dians who inhabit a cafion of Rio Colorado Grande. The ‘Nation of the Willows” is a tribe very unlike, inmany of its characteristics, any of the Indians that we know anything about in the East, and among other peculiar traits has an abnormal sense of humor. They find humor, it seems, in all sorts of out-of-the-way places, where ic is often hard for the Caucasian, even when gifted with more than a Scotch capacity for the comprehension of a joke, to follow them. A dead horse, and the difficulties in which his death placed his owner, were enough to set them wild with merriment; and many were the jests that they extracted for the owner's benefit from this unpromising subject. They are great mimics, as well as great wags, and hiked to watch and imitate the motions of Mr. Cushing's hand and pencil in writing, though they had not the slightest comprehension of what he was doing, and could only produce as the result of their efforts a meaningless scrawl, of which their love of a joke led them to * read off a ridiculous, usually obscene, rendering.” Mr. Cushing, who isan Indian by adoption, will, we presume, co! lect the Indian articles be is now contributing to the magazines in a book, as they have a permanent anthropological as well as liters:y interest. ‘Storm on Lake Asquam” isa poem by Whit tier, which is characteristic of him, and, it is hardly necessary to say, true to na ture as he sees it—that is, to nature seen with the eye of faith, and never as an indifferent spectator. Mr. Harrison's “Stu dies in the South” is continued, and contains this time some rather good negro stories. One very curious effect of emancipation is seen in the antics the negroes now play with their old names, for the purpose of magmfying them and making them more like white names, ‘Thus Roineo Jones of the old times now signs his name Romey O. Jones; Pericles Smith writes himself down Perry Clees Smith; and a boy who was always known as Polly’s Jim, having, learned to read the New Testament, is now Mr. Apollos James.” Toa Northerner, however, the South- ern whites are often as amusing as the negroes. The story of a Kentucky election dispute, told by Mr. Harrison, throws a flood of light on those queer “affairs of honor” which are always com- ing off in the South, and which are called there “tragedies” or ‘‘duels,” and elsewhere are looked upon as murders. The disputants were editors of rival newspapers, and were rival can- didates -for the nomination to the Legisla- ture. They began the canvass with a bargain not to use money or whiskey “as a motive power”; but, as a leading citizen said, in the course of the canvass there were ‘‘ some very seri- ous developments.” One candidate published a ecard, in which he charged the other with the use of whiskey as a motive power; upon which the other made a careful reply, beginning with a full biographical notice of himself, and conciud- ing with the following remarks upon his oppo- nent: ‘ Idesire to say, clearly and explicitly, that his course towards me has been the result of delirium tremens, or of the most fiendish and vicious feeling of jealousy and envy. Heisa liar and a cowardly puppy. He is not in my way, and is hereafter welcome to do whatever the promptings of a soul which professes to be- lieve there is no God, may suggest.” Now, the curious part of all this was that the place in which it happened grew wild with excitement about it, and it was generally believed that nn oe WS
Page 16
266 blood would flow like water. One of the editors, who were both arrested, shrewdly refused to give bail, and was sent to jail, and it was gene- rally conceded that his ‘ incarceration” would give him a decided political advantage over his opponent. Lippincott’s opens with an illustrated article on “ Norfolk, Old and New,” by Charles Burr Todd; and Annie Porter writes of ber escape from the Mississippi floods of last spring, with that ready sort of descriptive power which is perhaps the most marked gift of feminine au- thorship. ‘ Bark Canoeing in Canada,” by ‘*Kanuck,” is a readable article; and there is the usual supply of fiction and poetry. Lippincott’s of this month can hardly be compared with the other magazines, because in it little or no attempt has been made to give serious literary or social articles, or to discuss or criticise. The pabulum provided is of a lighter sort than that furnished by its rivals. ~—Mr. Rose’s corrections of the Census, which have been published in the past five issues of the Nation, have not received from the press the at- tention which they merited. No doubt this has been partly owing to their want of ‘‘ quotabili- ty,’ for in the nature of the case they did not lend themselves readily to the scissors. Confin- ing himself to the Population volume, Mr. Rose has demonstrated in general such a contradic- tion between the tables (with the text) and the corresponding maps that if either be taken as a standard, the other is not to be trusted. Further, that the tables abound in errors, many of them huge and palpable, and all highly discreditable to the editing of this delicate and important work. He has shown that many of these errors recur in various com- binations without detection, and he makes it seem probable that if his tests were protracted an indefinite number of errors might still be un- earthed. Now, the journalist may pass this ex- posure by, but the Census Bureau itself cannot afford to be silent, even if there is no help for the botchwork of the volume already issued. The Baltimore American says: ‘Mr. Walker, the Superintendent of the Census, should at once take steps to correct what is wrong: at least, he should in some manner refute the charges made, or endeavor to explain how they could have occurred.” We do not, for our part, know who is responsible for the defects point- ed out, but considering the extent to which they vitiate the entire work, one recalls the epi- thets ‘gross and ridiculous” applied to the Cen- sus of 1840. It must not be forgotten that the results now given to the world will be used for comparison by the makers of the eleventh and of each following Census, and will thus become end- lessly misleading. With the earlier and cruder Censuses nothing could be done but to take them as they were, and contrast them one with another and with subsequent returns; but there ought to have come a time when we could rest with abso- lute confidence in the statistics, not only as gathered but as printed, and make them the sure basis of deductions as to the national growth and development. Improved methods of taking the Census are of small account if the figures are to be subject to careless compilation, computation, and typography. Perhaps it will appear that we have undertaken too much for our imperfect statistical organization, and that a large number of the tabulated phases of the re- turns have rather a curious interest than a prac- tical value; while all will agree that a minutely accurate and trustworthy, even if meagre, Cen- sus is far better worth the enormous outlay df each decade than a multitude of faulty or sus- pected manipulations of data not fundamentally called for, On this last head at least we are [ Number goo = The Nation. sure General Walker could speak inteliigently and with authority. —The American Commission has just issued ‘Instructions for Observing the Transit of Venus, December 1, 1882, prepared by the Com- mission authorized by Congress, and printed for the use of the observing parties by authority of the Hon. Secretary of the Navy ” (Washing- ton: Government Printing Office). organized by the Secretary of the Navy are in- vested with naval character, and subject to naval | rules, regulations, and discipline. The command of each party is assigned to the Chief Astrono- mer, the order of rank and authority in each party being as follows: Chief Astronomer, Assistant Astronomer, Chief Photographer, As- sistant Photographer. The instructions were pre- pared primarily for the use of the parties organized by the Commission, but as the Transit will be visible in this country, they have also been adapted to the use of amateur observers who desire to be made acquainted with the methods by which they may make observations of value. Detailed directions are given for the selection of observing stations, and for setting up instruments. The success of the American system of photography, on the occasion of the Transit of 1874, has led the Commission to rely chiefly on this method of observing the coming Transit. A very considerable portion of the ‘Instructions’ is therefore devoted to the pho- toheliograph, the instrument by which the pic- tures of the Transit are taken. The pamphlet of instructions contains explicit memoranda re- garding the photoheliograph and its adjustments, the heliostat, the exposing-slide, the photographic tube, the plate-holder plumb-line, the batteries and electrical connections, the measuring rod, errors of the photoheliograph, fittings of the photographic house, care of the sensitive emul- sion, selecting and marking glass, cleanmng and albumenizing glass, coating plates, exposure of plates in the photoheliograph, the development, fixing and varnishing, blistering and lifting of the film,spots and other defects, preliminary practice, preparation for the Transit, photographing the Transit, development and packing the Transit- plates, wet emulsion-plates, bath wet-plates, and general precautions. Other sections treat of time-observations and chronometer-comparisons, exchange of time with other parties, latitude and longitude of station, the employment of the equa- torial telescope, and the observation of occulta- tions of stars by the moon for finding the longi- tude of stations not otherwise determinable. —Under the head of general instructions re- specting observations of contacts, it is said that, with regard to the determination of time, ar- rangements will be made with the Western Union Telegraph Company to transmit time-signals from the Naval Observatory to every part of the country. The aperture of telescope to be pre- ferred in the observations is from five to six inches. Apertures as small as four inches may be used withuut serious detriment, and three inches may be regarded as the smallest with which observations of real value can be made. The eyepiece should have a magnifying power of not less than 150, nor much more than 200. An equatorial mounting is nearly indispensable to ac- curate observation, and a clock-motion is desira- ble. A regular filar micrometer will not be of any use as an instrument of measure- ment. If shade-glasses are used, they should he made of three thicknesses of glass, the piece next the eye being thickest and darkest in color, all being fitted loosely into their cell so as to allow freeexpansion. An aperture of fiveinches may then be used without danger of splitting the sunshade. The observer must attend care- fully to the firmness of the telescope, to his abil- The parties | ity to move it so as to keep any part of the sun’s edge steadily in the centre of the field, and to the accuracy of the focal adjustment. The de- gree of brillianey of the sun’s disk as seen by the | eye is to be particularly attended to; and the American instructions suggest a simple modifi- cation of the method of reducing this brilliancy recommended by the Paris International Con- ference. The conditions necessary to the making of a really good observation of external contact of the planet and sun are such that but few ob- servers will be able to secure anything worth recording. From the time of external contact to that of internal, a period of about twenty minutes, the observer should have little or no- thing to attend to, in order that he may be pre- pared,optically and mentally, for the important observation of internal contact. All the confus- ing difficulties attendant upon this observation are specifically dealt with, and mention made of every precaution which may lead to a successful and valuable observation. The final sections of the pamphlet relate to methods of recording con tacts, measures of the diameter of Venus, data required in reducing the observations, the records of observations and operations, and the transmission and publication of observations. Appended are four lithographic plates showing (1) the lines of synchronous internal contact at ingress, (2) egress ; (3) the illuminated hemphi- sphere of the earth at the middle of the Transit, (4) paths described by several stations through diurnal motion, as seen from the sun during the Transit. —We have received from Dietrich Reimer, Berlin (New York: L. W. Schmidt), several admirable maps, of which we will first name one physical and one political of the British Isles. These are both wall-maps, for school use, edited by Richard Kiepert, and are published in four sheets. The scale is one inch to about sixteen miles (1 : 1,000,000), and the elevation of the sur- face, the depths of the neighboring waters, the population of towns and cities according to the census of 1881, etc., are all clearly represented without excessive detail. Ireland is given entire on one sheet in each series. A map useful not only for schools of the higher grades, but also for merchants, students, and statesmen, is Dr. Heinrich Kiepert’s ‘‘ General Map of South America” (Mapa general de la América Meridi- onal). This beautiful production is on a single large sheet (folio by doubling), and on a scale of 1 : 10,000,000, with numerous side maps for al- most every country and for the outlying Gala. pagos archipelago, forever associated with the triumphs of Darwin, whose nominal monument, however, is a peak in Tierra del Fuego. No- thing is more impressive than the longitudinal way in which South America, in contrast with our own continent, has been settled and politi- cally split up. Cyhili’s snake-like extension bids fair to reach the equator, and there is a prospect of endless wars over disputed boundaries among every one of her neighbors to the north: Ecua- dor, for example, between the claims of Co- lombia and Peru, being reduced to a mere wedge. But as regards not only boundaries but natural features like the course of rivers, the glorious uncertainty of South American geography is well exhibited by the broad differences between Kiepert’s delineation and that of the larger-scale maps in the new Stieler’s Atlas. Between two such eminent authorities the layman cannot un- dertake to decide. We have finally to mention this learned cartographer’s editing of Professor C. Haussknecht’s journeys in Northern Syria, Southern Armenia, Mesopotamia, Kurdistan, and Central and Southern Persia. These jour- neys were made at private expense in the inte- rest of botany, but advantage was taken of the
Page 17
Sept. 28, 1882] The Nation. opportunity to add to our knowledge of districts heretofore little visited and therefore most pro- mising for botanical research. Prof. Hauss- knecht’s intelligent observations and second- hand information have been supplemented and checked by Dr. Kiepert from various sources, public and private, and are mapped under the auspices of the Berlin Geographical Society, with the aid of the Carl Ritter fund. The Turkish portion is the most original and valuable. The work fills four sheets, on a scale of 1 : 6,000,000 and 1:8,000,000 for each pair respectively. From the traveller and his editor we have short introductions explaining the circumstances of the undertaking, in a small quarto pamphlet ac- companying the maps ; but Prof. Haussknecht promises a detailed description of the interesting region traversed by him as soon as possible. —Dr. von Reber, the celebrated archeologist and art-historian, publishes in the Augsburg Allgemeine Zeitung for August 10 a highly com- plimentary notice of the investigations at Assos of the expedition of the Archzological Institute of America, as described in Mr. Clarke’s first report. Dr. von Reber notes the beauty of the representations of animals among the temple sculptures, and the comparative inferiority, in general, of those of the human figure. He calls attention, however, to the head of a sphinx from the epistyle frieze, which is in a remarkable state of preservation, and which approaches very nearly the type of the Apollo of Tenea and similar monuments, All earlier students have placed the date of the temple of Assos before 500 B. c. —some of the most eminent of them even before 600 B. c. The earlier the date the more impor- tant is the building in the history of Doric archi- tecture, as thus its influence upon the later and fully developed style may have been considera- ble. Mr. Clarke, however, thinks that the build- ing of the temple was due to the art-impulse which followed the Greek victories over the Per- sians in the first quarter of the fifth century, and that it is contemporary with the temple of Agina. He accounts for its many archaic fea- tures by the position of Assos, remote from the centres of Hellenic thought, and by the strong Oriental influences of the neighborhood. Mr. Clarke’s opinion has great weight, as his knowledge of the temple is necessarily far greater than that of his predecessors; and certain confirmation of it will be received with much interest. Dr. von Reber thinks that the exploration of the Street of Tombs of Assos, now in progress, promises especially important archeological results. He mentions with much satisfaction the recent discovery there of a Doric stele-column, provided with a base like, those of Egyptian models, and resembling closely the proto-Doric shafts of Beni-Hassan. He looks upon this stele as an important evidence in support of his theory that the want of a base is not an original characteristic ef the Doric column, but that it resulted from the use of stone in the place of wood in the epistyle, and the consequent closer placing of the columns. This, he thinks, caused the bases, extending out beyond the shafts, to lie so incon- veniently near each other that the old architects preferred to give them up, or, rather, to combine them with the stylobate. —Americans who were ashamed at the conduct of the audience at the Guiteau trial may derive an unsatisfactory consolation from the accounts of the proces Fenayrau at Versailles. Thecrime was a hideous murder, for which one of the ac- cused was condemned to death and his wife to imprisonment for life ; a piece of the victim’s skull was exhibited in court, as the President's bones were, and yet, just as in the American trial, we read of hilarité prolongée, rires, hilarité générale, on rit. Thackeray has described in one of his sketches the intense popular enjoy- ment of a hanging, and intimated his belief that such scenes encouraged rather than deterred men from crime. Public executions have been in a measure abolished. Can anything be done to render trials for murder less hilarious? With many of the spectators laughter is only a necessary unbending after strained attention, a reaction from pity and horror ; with others it is part of the amusement which was their object in coming to the trial. In either case it ought to be deferred till they are outside of the court-house. But how ? The audience can no more be gagged than the prisoner. ENGLAND AND IRELAND. A Short History of the Kingdom of Ireland, from the Earliest Times to the Union with Great Britain. By Charles George Walpole, M.A., Barrister-at-Law. London: Kegan Paul, Trench & Co.; New York: Harper & Bros. Mr. WALPOLE’s ‘History of the Kingdom of Ireland’ is about as melancholy and as instruc- tive reading as any book one can take up. The annals of that country are, from beginning to end, the record of failure and misery. Their special sadness consists in the fact that calami- ties spreading over centuries appear on a first view to be caused solely either by human folly, selfishness, and stupidity, or by the special per- versity and unkindness of fate. The kingdom of which Mr. Walpole tells the story seems, on cursory observation, the one spot on earth where no system of government has been able to produce anything but misery. The vigor of Wentworth, the despotism of Cromwell, the energy of William, achieved at least as little permanent good as the enlightenment of Grattan and all the attempts at improvement made by statesmen who believed that the evils caused by oppression and intolerance could be removed by freedom and religious equality. It is natural enough for any one who realizes the failure of statesmanship to remove the hundred evils under which Ireland has suffered, to assume that if energy and policy have failed to bear good fruit, the cause of this want of success lies in the spe- cial wickedness either of the Government or of its subjects. Hence Irishmen are apt enough to believe, and not without considerable show of reason, that the misfortunes of their country may be ascribed to the wickedness of England, in the same sense in which a definite crime may be charged upon an individual criminal. We have known men who, in other respects possessed of sense and judgment, could not get quit of the feeling, if not of the belief, that the Englishmen of to-day—Mr. Gladstone, Mr. Bright, and others—were, in spite of their endeavors to do justice to Ireland, constructively responsible for “the curse o’ Crummell,” the breach of the Treaty of Limerick, the cruelties of 1798, and the corruption which procured the passing of the Act of Union. Englishmen, on the other hand, assume that the most conspicuous of Eng- land’s failures is due to the innate folly, indo- lence, or crookedness of Irish nature. Which of us has not heard that the calamities of Irishmen are due to the vices of the “‘ race”? How many of us have reflected that the formula which at- tempts to explain everything by reference to blood is, in ninety-nine out of a hundred cases, no better than a restatement of the very fact whieh requires explanation, or that the refer- ence to “race” is singularly unsatisfactory when applied to a country which has beet planted and colonized more than once with men 267 of Scotch and English blood? If ‘‘ race” be the solution of the problems presented by Irish his tory, it were well to consider the question why it is that the descendants of Cromwell's Puritans have furnished evev more than their due quote to Irish discontent. The plain truth is, that if the melancholy his tory of the kingdom of Ireland is to yield any instruction to the philosophic investigator into the course of human affairs, his first step must be to get rid of the delusions caused in the do main of history, aselsewhere, by personification. He must cease to think of England and Ireland as persons who may be charged with individual and continuous responsibilty for the crimes or follies of the past. He must also carefully check the natural but delusive tendency of the human mind to conceive that when anything goes wrong you can always lay your finger on definite | assignable wrongdoers—that is, upon some man or men who can be held responsible for faults and errors as a murderer may be held guilty of murder or a robber of theft. No one who re flects on the profound truth of the dictum (at tributable, by the way, to an Irishman) that “history is at the best but an old almanac,” can hope that investigations into the past will do much to guide the future relations of Eng land and Ireland. One thing, however, the careful study of history may perhaps achieve— it may slightly modify the historical animosities which still divide Ireland from the rest of the United Kingdom. It is at any rate worth while for serious students to turn their minds away from hopeless and interminable disputes about individual responsibility for the errors of the past, and to examine how far the miseries of Ireland and the failures of England may be the effect of causes too general to be in any way identified with the intentional wrong-doing of given persons. Whoever looks at the facts re corded by Mr. Walpole, and as far as possible neglects the colar which that author's natural feeling or sentiment gives to these facts, will be able to draw from the events with which he deals several conclusions of considerable specu lative importance. First. England and Ireland have from the beginning of their ill-starred connection been countries standing at a different level, or a dif- ferent stage, of civilization. This has been the fruitful source of a thousand ills. Hence has arisen (among other evils) the whole crop of difficulties connected with the tenure of land. When James I. determined that the ‘‘old Brehon law was to be utterly abolished, and the means of appealing to English law brought within the reach of every one,” he and his ministers really meant to introduce a beneficial reform, They hoped that out of the old tribal customs a regular system of landholding according to the English tenure would be developed. In forcing on this change, English statesmen probably felt con- vinced not only that they were carrying out a reform, but that they were promoting the cause of justice. To men trained under the teaching of lawyers like Coke, and accustomed to regard the tenure which prevailed in England as some- thing good in itself, it must have appeared that to pass from the irregular dominion of uncertain customs to the rule of clear, definite law, was little less than a transition from anarchy and injustice to a condition of order and equity. They acted in precisely the spirit of their de- scendants, who are absolutely assured that the extension of English maxims of government throughout India muSt be a blessing to the popu- lation of the country, and are at this moment shaping their Eastern policy upon their unwaver- ing faith in the benefits which the European Control must of necessity confer on the Egyptian peasants. If, however, it is probable that King
Page 18
268 —- —_— — — James meant well to his Irish subjects, it is absolutely certain that his policy worked gross wrong. His ‘‘scheme only provided for the more powerful members of the tribes, and took no account of the inferior members, each of whom in their degree had an undeniable, if somewhat indefinite, interest in the tribal land. It never occurred” to Sir John Davis, who carried out the plan, ‘‘ that the humblest member of the tribe should, if strict justice were done, have received his allotment out of the common territory ; and the result of his settle- ment accordingly was that the tribal land was cut up into a large number of freehold estates, which were given to the most important person- ages among the native Irish, and the bulk of the people reduced to the condition of tenants at will.” An intended reform led to injustice, litigation, misery, and discontent. This case is worth notice, for it is a type of a thousand sub- sequent English attempts to reform and improve Ireland. The rulers of the country were in- fluenced by ideas different from those of their subjects. Ignorance and want of sympathy produced all the evils of cruelty and injustice. The history of the religious reformation of Ireland is in principle much the same as the his- tory of the reform of Irish land tenure. The singular inappropriateness, not to say absurdity, of attempting to impose Anglican Protestantism upon a people who had not reached the stage of development which was absolutely essential for even the understanding of Protestant doctrine, conceals from us the strength of the pleas which may be urged in excuse of a policy which to critics of the nineteenth century seems as ini- quitous as it was absurd. Till very near the end of the seventeenth century, it was the all but universal belief of the best and wisest men of the age that the religion of a country was the concern of the Government, and that a king who neglected to establish and enforce the “ truth "— or, in other words, his own theological beliefs— neglected his obligations to his subjects and in- curred the displeasure of Heaven. From this point of view, the conduct of the Tudors and their successors must appear to us as natural under their circumstances as to themselves it appeared wise and praiseworthy. That Eng- land should have been ripe for Protestantism at a time when the majority of the Irish people had hardly risen to the level of Roman Catholicism, was to each country a grievous misfortune. That English Protestants of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries should have believed that toleration of Papists was a grievous sin, and should have acted on the belief, was the cause of immense calamities. But inevitable ignorance or prejudice is not the same thing as cruelty or wickedness. Secondly. The virtues no less than the vices of Englishmen have rendered them singularly incapable of conciliating the good-will of depen- dencies. It will always remain a curious para- dox that the nation which has built up the British Empire has combined great talent for legislation and government with a remarkable want of power to consolidate its subjects into one state. The éxplanation of this paradox lies, it may be plausibly conjectured, in the aristo- cratic sentiment which has given the tone to the policy, and to a great extent moulded the insti- tutions, of England. An aristocracy is far more prone than a despotic or democratic government to respect the rigbts of individuals ; but an aris- tocracy identifies right with privilege, and is essentially based on a belief in the inequality of men and of classes. ‘‘ Privilege” is the key-note of English history ; the tendency to cling to privileges has preserved English freedom, but it has made England slower than almost any other civilized country to adopt ideas of equality. ’ The Nation. [ Number goo This love for privilege has vitiated the English government of Ireland in more ways than one. The whole administration rested, avowedly down to 1829, and unavowedly to a later pe- riod, on the inequality of Catholics and Protes- tants ; and Protestant supremacy itself meant (except during the short rule of Cromwell), not Protestant equality, but Anglican privilege. The spirit which divided Ireland into hostile bodies prevented Englishmen who dwelt in Eng- land from treating as equals Englishmen who settled ir Ulster. When the Protestant Volun- teers claimed Irish independence, and the Ame- rican colonists renounced connection with the mother-country, the same cause produced the same effects. In each case English colonists re- volted against English sovereignty because it meant the privilege of Englishmen who dwelt in Great Britain to curtail the rights and hamper the trade of Englishmen who dwelt abroad ; for even the monstrous and iniquitous restrictions on the trade of Ireland, which are morally far the most blameworthy of the wrongs done by England to Irishmen, were not precisely the acts of deliberate selfishness which they seem to mo- dern writers. The grievance under which I[re- land suffered was in character the same as the grievances in respect of trade inflicted on the American colonies ; yet it is certain that but for the insane attempt to subject the colonies to Im- perial taxation, the War of Independence might have never broken out, or would, at any rate, have been long deferred. Even the sufferers from a vicious commercial policy did not see its essential iniquity. It is hardly a subject for wonder that the generation of Englishmen who at any rate supposed themselves to gain greatly by controlling or extinguishing the colonial or Irish trade, should not have realized the full iniquity of a policy which in itself hardly seemed intolerable to many of those who suffered the wrong. English selfishness was masked from Englishmen by English ignorance ; but let no one fancy that to palliate the moral guilt of England is in any way to lessen the reality of Irish grievances. Injustice is as hard to bear when it results from ignorance as when it results wholly from greed or rapacity. Thirdly. The English Constitution has wrought almost as much evil to Ireland as it has conferred bene®. upon England. Mr. Froude and others who point tc the misgovernment of Ireland as a proof that the Parliamentary system is radically bad, prove something, though what they prove is not the point which they intend to establish. A representative government is in many cases an excellent form of government for the people who are represented. It is a thoroughly vicious form of government for any nation whom it does not represent. The assailants of Parlia- mentary government do not make out that Eng- land has suffered from the power of the English Parliament. They do show that a Parliamentary despotism is a worse government for a depend- ency than a Royal despotism. This is so for two reasons. Parliament, in the first place, is less capable than a king of compensating for the evils of tyranny by the benefit of good adminis- tration. Parliamentary government, in the second place, means, or has always meant in England, government by parties; and what- ever the merit of party spirit in a free country, its disastrous effect when applied to the admin- istration of a dependency is patent. Down to 1783 Ireland was avowedly ruled under a Parlia_ mentary despotism. At every turn the interest of the country was sacrificed to the exigencies of English politicians. Between 1783 and 1800 the nominal independence obtained by the Volun- teers placed some check on the power of the English Parliament ; yet no one can fail to see that in substance the Parliament of England remained the true sovereign of the kingdom of Ireland. If Pitt could have carried the King and the English Parliament with him, he would, we may feel sure, have carried out his policy of Catholic emancipation in spite of any resistance which could have been offered at Dublin by the adherents of Ascendancy. A calm observer may even at the present day doubt whether under the Parliament of the United Kingdom Ireland obtains the real benefits of the British Constitution. A hundred representatives from Ireland sit, it is true, in the House of Commons; but any one who is determined to look facts in the face must feel far from certain whether Ire- land is, for any practical purpose, represented at London in the same sense as Middlesex or Midlothian. The last, the most inevitable, the worst and the least blameworthy, of the evils caused to Treland by England has been the artificial sup- pression of revolution. The crises we call revo- lutions are the ultimate and desperate cures for fundamental social disorganization. The issue of the revolutionary struggle shows what is the really sovereign power in the revolutionized state. The interest of mankind (at least, in any Eurvpean country) in favor of some kind of settled rule is so strong that civil disturbance will, if left to itself, end in the supremacy of some power which by securing the safety at last gains the attachment of the people. The Reign of Terror begets the Empire. Even the wars of religion at last produce peace, albeit peace may be nothing better than the iron order of despotism, Could Ireland have been left for any lengthened period to herself, some form of rule adapted to the needs of the country would have been established. Whether Protestants or Catholics would have been the predominant ele- ment in the state ; whether the landlords would have held their own, or whether the whole English system of tenure would have been replaced by one more in conformity with his- torical traditions ; whether the different classes of the community would have established some modus vivendi under which individual free- dom might have been secured, or whether some despotic form of government would have been sanctioned by the acquiescence of its sub- jects—are matters of pure speculation. What, however, is certain is, that Ireland would, if left to herself, have, like every other country, arrived at some permanent settlement of her difficulties. The British connection has been fatal to such a settlement. Revolution has been suppressed at the price of permanent disorder, and a nation which has never been independent has never borne the burdens or learnt the lessons of national responsibility. Disastrous as this result has been, it were difficult to say who it was that at any given point was to blame for it. Had France been attached to, and dependent upon, a more powerful neighbor, the governing state must have checked the agonies of the Reign of Terror ; but it is almost certain that the forcible defeat of Jacobinism through an external power would have been fatal to the progress and prosperity of France. A FRENCH VIEW OF GERMAN SCHOOLS. Excursions Pédagogiques. Par Michel Bréal, Membre de l'Institut. Paris: Hachette et Cie. 1882. THE total impression produced by M. Bréal’s valuable essays is painful. The new France is moving forward, but the progress is slow and every step disputed. The Clericals have the ad- vantage of tradition, of definite method, definite aims. M. Bréal, himself a prominent and able advocate of progress, is too clear-sighted not to see through the wily tactics of the other party,
Page 19
ae ae ee ee a Sept. 28, 1882] The Nation. 269 and the volume is full of facts and suggestions of the highest interest to those who are studying the history of the Third Republic, and not with- out value for our own présent and future. One can hardly parallel the readiness with which France has set herself to study the methods of her victorious enemy both in civil and in military education. It is easy enough to talk about learning from an enemy, but it is hard to practise it. The defeated would often prefer to stay defeated rather than be successful as the enemy has been successful. Imitation seems to involve assimilation, and assimilation is too high a price to pay. But France defeated did not hesitate to copy Germany victorious, and those French scholars who had long been familiar with German systems pressed this op- portunity of introducing needed reforms. In his preface M. Bréal takes occasion to enter a protest against the wholesale introduction of German methods, but he finds, as we should all find, much to learn from the management of gymnasium and university in Germany. The German gymnasium, M. Bréal remarks, is more simple in its organization than the French lycée ; it does not admit so great a va- riety of studies. In the lycée some follow the regular course, others prepare for the Army, the Navy, the polytechnic school. In the German gymnasium all follow the same curriculum. The French lycée often assumes enormous pro- portions. In Germany every large town has several gymnasia, several Fealschulen. Thus, Breslau, with 150,000 inhabitants, has three Realschulen and five gymnasia, so that the schools are of moderate size. Provision for lodging and boarding the pupils (the internat), which is the rule in France, is almost unknown in Germany, with the exception of a few old foundations, of which Schulpforta is by far the most famous. The specialization of teachers is not so marked in Germany as in France, where specialization has been developed by centraliza- tion. The French specialist is despatched by the central authority to any point where his services may be needed. The German teacher covers more ground, and M. Bréal thinks that the in- struction is no less exact, no less profound. The gymnasium teacher works harder than a profes- sor ina lycée. Even the highest of them think it nothing extraordinary to give from eighteen to twenty-two lessons a week, the lesson being some forty-five or fifty minutes. But then the gymnasium teacher is better paid ; and, as M. Bréal naturally remarks, nothing costs more in the long run than an underpaid faculty. Sec- ondary occupations ever multiply, and consume the time and the strength that are needed for the principal work. In his chapter on classical studies in the gym- nasium, M. Bréal notes especially the thorough drill in grammar, as, for instance, the varied practice in the Greek accidence with the good old fashion of head and foot, classically called certatio ; and he expresses his amazement at the accuracy of the young students in Greek accen- tuation. In this respect the French boy is ata sad disadvantage, and, we might add, the Eng- lish boy as well. The German learns accent by the ear, the French and English by the eye— which is, of course, a pure counter-sense. High praise is given by M. Bréal to the off-hand trans- lations of German into Latin and Greek, but it seems that attempts to transplant the extempo- rale into France have failed. In order that the exercise should be thoroughly effective, the scho- lars must have had good preliminary training, and the teacher must be a master of the lan- guage that he teaches, so as to be ready for any emergency. Under these conditions extempo- raneous translation into Latin and Greek is of the highest value. The works on Latin style used in German gymnasia are far superior to the French text-books on the same subject, but M. Bréal, who has found so many points of superiority in Germany, observes at least one in France: the French boy, it appears, far sur- passes his German rival in Latin verse. Indeed, M. Bréal goes so far as to say that Latin verse- making has disappeared from the list of subjects taught in the German gymnasium, and it must be confessed by the most enthusiastic admirers of German training that the verses produced on festal occasions are mostly of very inferior workmanship, and that of late years Latin prose has b2en sinking to the level of Latin verse. Certainly Latin speaking has gone down very perceptibly in the last two or three decades, and it might seem safe to predict an utter extinction of the use of Latin as a vehicle for modern thought if it were not for the multiplication of philological literature in all manner of outlying languages. This will in all probability bring about a reaction, and it is to be hoped that Dutch scholars will continue to write readable Latin, and keep alive the secret of an art which is well-nigh lost. In his chapter on the character of German teaching, M. Bréal makes a general observation, which is well worth considering in the develop- ment of our university life. In France, he says, one is rarely the pupil of a man: one is the pupil of the Ecole Normale, of the Ecole des Chartes,of the Ecole Polytechnique. In Germany one is the pupil of Boeckh, of Hermann, of Ritschl, of Haupt. How is it to be in America? As yet our university life has not been fully de- veloped. We are still in the college stadium, and we must still speak of Harvard, Yale, Prince ton. But wherever a great master has arisen, and real university work has been done in this country, the man and not the school is recognized as the teacher. Thus we spoke of pupils of Agassiz; thus we are speaking of pupils of Sylvester. And this will be more and more the case as time goes on, for the type of our higher work is German, and not French, while the ten- dency of common-school education is rather to excessive centralization and mechanical subdi- vision, which, as we have seen, are apt to go together. In commenting on the career of the great men who made German preéminence in the classics possible—Ernesti, Gesner, Heyne, and Wolf—M. Bréal stops to comment on the youth of these professors when they began their work. Wolf was but twenty-four when he took charge of instruction in ancient literature. In France no one can make a beginning as a lecturer until he is twenty-five; no one can become titular lec- turer until he is thirty. Practically, matters are even worse than that. The lecturer must have passed his best years, his most fruitful years, in occupations of a different nature and of a different order ; and yet one must be young to attract the young, to fire them with enthusi- asm. True, youth is not simply a matter of years—it is often a matter of temperament ; but the average teacher is himself kept alive by the vitality of his earlier training. The philological world will long mourn for Charles Graux, who died famous at an age when American scholars are scarcely out of their pupilage. The physiolo- gists of England are plunged in grief for the untimely death of Balfour, and we picture to ourselves what these men would have become had they been spared. Perhaps as teachers they were at their best when they were taken, for every teacher of long experience can confirm the statement that the first fruits ripened by the heat of an unchilled enthusiasm are often the fairest of all: And so M. Bréal thinks. The French system assigns to the work of superior in- struction men who are already fagged, men who have already given out the best that they have ¢ a striking contrast to the universities of Switz- erland, which seek men of rising reputation and give them up to other countries when they have become recognized celebrities. The German teacher stands nearer to his pu- pils than are the French professors to theirs, and M. Bréal attributes this, in a measure, to the fact that the German student pays lecture-fees and the French student does not. They seems to be at first something crude in this way of put- ting it, but M. Bréal goes on to explain : the fee gives the students a right to the services of the professor ; the French hearers seem to receive everything from the professor's condescension. Payment for lectures was instituted, not by reason of the professors, nor in their interest, but by reason of the students and in their favor. In America, a few instituticns make the remu- neration of each professor depend directly and in large measure on the fees paid by the students in his department ; but the most important of these institutions, the University of Virginia, has abandoned the plan, and the fees are now merged in a common fund. The Scotch univer sities follow the German method, and, owing to the large number of students, the Scotch profes- sorships are great prizes. The whole question is one of much complexity, and cannot be discussed in a running commentary on M. Bréal'’s book. It may be said, however, that if the professor is to receive the fees in his department, a reason- able counterbalance should be arranged in the way of salary. A professor of Hebrew is as necessary to the completeness of a university as a professor of French, and yet the remuneration might be glaringly unequal. The professor of Sanskrit at Edinburgh and the professor of botany—an obligatory medical study—must be in very different financial zones. It is not plea- sant to remember that some of the most illus- trious men in Europe, at the height of their renown, have had to give private lessons on very modest conditions—for example, the eminent scholar Bopp himself. As human nature is con- stituted, direct remuneration for direct exertion is stimulating, and until that principle is intro- duced, M. Bréal thinks that French professors will not exert themselves as do their German colleagues. But it must always be borne in mind that the German fees are low, and that the stimulus of a small increment to the regular in- come is sufficient to incite a salaried officer to a disproportionate amount of extra work, In closing his account of classic studies in Ger- many, M. Bréal notes, as every one must note, that mere erudition is far too dominant, and that certain literary qualities which are indis- pensable for good teachers of youth are kept down too much. ‘But for the development of special lines of work, for the awakening of the scientific spirit, these four years of university life are of inestimable value.” The elevation of university instruction in Germany has had for its consequence the advance of secondary in- struction, and so our French reformer desires to see the good work begin in the university life of France. M. Bréal has much to say about the final ex- amination of the gymnasium, the examination which tests the studezt’s preparation for the university. Among the points in favor of the German method are the absence of cramming and the large share taken by the teachers of the gymnasium in the examination. The French baccalaureate degree is conferred upon the recommendation of outside judges, and the pre- vious faithfulness of the candidate has no infiu- ence in determining the result. As for the pre- vention of cramming, that has been professedly the aim of all teachers, and various devices have been resorted to in order to counteract the
Page 20
237O tendency—most of them with as little result as Count Rumford’s scheme of leisurely mastica- tion in the Bavarian Army. Some men—and those whose judgment is not least worthy of re- | spect—have maintained that the dead strain of reading up for an examination is not a bad pre- paration for the work that is often to be done in | The { Number goo England judge, himself the ‘‘ owner of a beauti- ful farm adjoining,” had been engaged in mow- ing her grass, Turning to the English portion of the book, it is full of entertaining anecdote and criticism be worth extracting. toward the stage. Her criticism is acute and impartial; she has no illusions about the profes- sion; she loves it, and is deeply interested in everything connected with it, yet she regards it | as a career with something not far removed of persons more or less well known—Sydney | Smith, Rogers, Macready, Rachel, Charles Gre- | ville, and a host of others. Some of these may | As to the effect produced | by Macaulay’s marvellous gift of discourse, she | | pages of it without perceiving that we are in the mentions him, while on a visit at the house of a | friend, standing, whenever at any time during life—the gathering up of all the faculties fora | prolonged effort. Tosay that learningso acquired does not stick, is a feeble objection. Forgetting has its own use, and, in many things, to have | learned how to learn is all that is needed. A sketch of the origin, history, and constitu- tion of the Realschule closes the section entitled portion of the interesting volume that can be considered here. M. Bréal gives a very sad ac- | the day she bappened to look into the draw- | ing-room, “‘ always in the same position on the | ‘Un Voyage Scolaire en Allemagne,” the only | count of the state of things in Belgium, and his | excursions in France, to which half the volume is given up, are full of severe criticisms, tem- pered, it is true, by warm commendations of individuals, and hearty recognition of reforms which have been introduced since these peda- | yogical rambles were undertaken. For the book, in its substance, is not of yesterday, and in this | | sion Mrs. Kemble’s sister Adelaide was sitting review only those points have been touched on which are of standing interest. Records of Later Life. ble. Henry Holt & Co. Mrs. KEMBLE has almost every gift as a corre- spondent that a letter-writer of the letter-writ- ing sex can have—a simple, straightforward style; a love of detail, and a capacity for dis- tinguishing between the interesting and the tedious in detail; a knowledge of character, the knack of telling a story, a keen sense of humor and sensitive imagination, and in everything perfect naturalness and freedom from affecta- tion. By Frances Ann Kem- 1882. Her letters present a most pleasing picture | of her character, and she has shown a wonderful | reserve in suppressing everything which might cause the least pain or even annoyance to per- sons whose names appear in her pages. No- thing could have been easier for her, with her wide acquaintance on both sides of the Atlantic, than to make her book a storehouse of doubt- ful gossip and amusing scandal ; but with all her humor and love of anecdote, and knowledge of society, she has no malice, and of the many peo- ple who must have opened her book (as all such books are opened now) with dread, not one but must have given asigh of relief in discovering that it is a collection of letters in which nothing that could wound or distress any one is printed. Yet itis a book filled witb ‘‘ veracity.” Mrs, hearth-rug, always talking, always answering everybody’s questions about everything, always rule of Lady Holland at Holland House, and tells several stories of her manners which show what a mistake it is to think that having a **pleasant house” always depends on considera- tion for the feelings of the guests. On one occa- near Lady Holland, when the latter dropped her handkerchief. ‘‘ Reflecting,” continues Mrs. Kemble, ‘‘ upon her age and size, which made it difficult for her to stoop for it herself, my sister picked it up and presented it to her, when Lady Holland, taking it from her, merely said, ‘ Ah! I thought you'd doit.'” However, it was very much a case of give and take at Holland House, for we hear of Rogers sneering at his hostess’s loss of hair, and causing an ‘‘exultant gig- | gle” round the festive board. The manners of Holland House were not the manners of our day, or indeed any day, and it is as dangerous to make general inferences from the remarkable sayings and doings that went on in it as it is to make such inferences from the table-talk of Dr. | Johnson as to the general condition of society in Kemble, for instance, describes life as it existed | in the United States forty or fifty years ago | without touching up the picture at all ; and that the facts which she records do not produce any sense of offence is due not merely to the fact that his time. Mrs. Kemble knew Sydney Smith very well, and manages in a page or two to give a good idea of the humorous drollery of bis con- versation, in which wit and humor certainly often received great aid from sheer nonsense. With Rogers she became in later years very inti- mate, and she used to read to him; in connection with this she mentions the curious fact that she never asked him what she should read without his putting into her hands his own poems, which always lay by him on the table—a trait which re- called to her recollection the fact that Rogers had once declared of Wordsworth that he (Words- worth), in a visit to a friend’s house, had beén found daily in the library, but always with a volume of his own poetry in his hand. Mrs. Kemble’s connection with the theatrical | and musical world is the source of a good many ' anecdotes. An encounter of wits between Ma- the American public is less sensitive to foreign | She patronized Thalberg, but, having invited criticism than it was, but to the tact and good temper which make it impossible to attribute what she says to a desire to blacken or ridicule. This part of her book, though it is a small part, has considerable value, as it reproduces in very vivid colors the impression made by American society and manners on the mind of a person born and brought up in an entirely European milieu, yet really desirous of finding good in everything American. It was a period when there was a vastly greater difference between dame de Metternich and Liszt is rather amusing. them both to her house on one occasion, ad- dressed to Liszt several impertinent questions about a professional visit he had been paying to | Paris, winding up with: “ Enfin, avez-vous fait | de bonnes affaires lA-bas ?” To which he reptied, the European and American way of looking at | life and way of living than there is now, when we had no large cities, no wealthy and idle class, no society struggling to be as English as possible. We are not such good democrats as we were then, and if Mrs. Kemble were living in Lenox to-day, she would hardly be likely to record that one of her friends, the son of a much respected New ‘‘Pardon, Madame la Princesse, j'ai fait un peu de musique; je laisse les affaires aux banquiers et aux diplomates.” Later in the evening she sneeringly complimented him on bis freedom from jealousy of his rival, to which Liszt, who was very sallow, replied: “‘Mais, Madame la | Princesse, je suis furieusement jaloux de Thal- berg ; regardez donc les jolies couleurs qu’il a!” The musical and dramatic criticism scattered through the book is all interesting, and the | reader cannot help wondering, when he remem- bers Mrs. Kemble’s great natural gifts, that she takes such an habitually external attitude ' society of a superior mind and character. from loathing. ! The correspondence, which is accompanied by a good deal of explanatory comment, makes a very charming addition to the literature of “reminiscences.” It is impossible to read ten The ' letters have just that amount of personal interest which makes us feel that we are taken into the confidence of the writer, and for the time being | are even enjoying her friendship. pouring forth eloquent knowledge; and I used to | listen to him till I was breathless with what I | thought ought to have been his exhaustion.” | She gives a very good picture of the despotic | The State in Relation to Labour. By Prof. W. Stanley Jevons, LL.D., F.R.S. London and New York: Macmillan & Co, 1882. Pp. 165. No book could better illustrate the period of transition through which the study of political economy is passing than the one which lies before us. Its avowed purpose is to deal with the | proper methods and limits of legislation in mat- ters relating to labor. Had an English econo- mist of thirty years ago been asked to write such a book, he would probably have replied: It is against accepted principles that lawmakers should interfere at all in matters of industry, and it would therefore be futile to spend time in considering the ‘‘ proper methods and limits” of such interference. Indeed, the appearance of this little work upon the ‘ Relation of the State to Labor’ is not only itself a contradiction of tne claims of classical economy, but, coming as it does from a successful publishing house, shows that the English reading public is in some degree prepared for such a study. Professor Jevons takes it for granted that his readers will agree with him in denying the character of a principle to free competition. He conceives it to be a maxim, rather, or a general rule which may or may not apply to any specific case. He assumes, what is coming to be regarded as tena- ble ground, that free play of economic forces may effect evil as well as good, and where evil is observed to result this freedom should be curbed by the only agency capable of exercising that power—namely, the state. That this correctly represents him may be learned from the first chapter of his book, which is devoted to a consideration of the principles of industrial legislation. The position assumed here is that there is no principle which may be followed in all cases. ‘‘ The first step,” says the author, ‘‘must be to rid our minds of the idea that there are any such things in social matters as abstract rights, absolute principles, indefea- sible laws, unalterable rules, or anything what- ever of an external or inflexible nature.” If one ask what criterion then remains for judging of industrial legislation, the reply is, that the legis- lator is thrown back upon his sense of what is appropriate in specific cases. The rule is, Salus populi, suprema lex, and there can be no logic machine for its application. In another place we read: “No law i ave ooeacsed thes Gay suagr oak te take eneg with, if it can be clearly shown that they stand in the way of the greatest happiness. Ae conceive that the state is justified in ing any law, or in doing any single act which, without ulterior consequences, adds to the sum total of happiness. Good done is sufficient justification of any act, in the absence of evidence that equal or greater evil will subsequently follow.” What then becomes of our liberty? “The libe of the subject,” says Professor Jevons, “‘is only the means toward the end; it is not the end itself; hence, when it fails to pro-
Page 21
Sept. 28, 1882] The duce the desired end, it may be set aside and other mears empleyed,” (Pp. 12, 13.) It is from this standpoint—that laws are to be judged by what they effect, and not by any prin- ciple they involve, that “ restrictions on indus- try are not good nor bad per se,” but according as they are imposed wisely or foolishly—that the author proceeds in his study. In this light he considers the Factory Acts, Trades-Union Legis- lation, The Law of Industrial Conspiracy, Codp- eration, and Arbitration. Of these questions, perhaps the most pertinent is that of the law of industrialconspiracy. This is usually discussed from the standpoint of work- men only, but Professor Jevons shows his ap- preciation of its extent by treating it in a man- ner equally applicable to a conspiracy of rail- road magnates. Any one acquainted with the history of this question will remember tnat in the early part of this ceutury combination among workmen to enforce any demand was characterized as conspiracy, and punished as such. These laws, however, have been repealed, and many appear to regard this repeal as fur- nishing license to unlmited ‘‘ boycotting.” What is now the legal status of a combina- tion among men to effect, in the course of business, that which no one of them alone could accomplish? To arrive at just con- clusions respecting this question, one must recognize the fact that the common law, as well as the great majority of legal enactments, rests on the assumption that *‘ individuals will act as individuals, pursuing independent and usual courses of action.” ‘‘ The essence of ille- gality,” says our author in another place, “is in- jury to other people.” If, then, the entirety of a country’s laws be drawn upon the supposition that men will act for and by themselves, and if men refuse so to act, but organize and in a body enforce their demands to the detriment of the body politic, there is nothing in the repeal of the Con- spiracy Acts which would forbid our calling such acts illegal. The common law still remains, The maxim of McCulloch, that ‘‘a criminal act cannot be generated by the mere multiplica- tion of acts that are perfectly innocent,” does not here apply, for the simple act of a single per- son changes its character when becoming the act of a thousand persons organized for carrying through a definite purpose. We cannot speak further in detail of the va- rious questions treated. The author endeavors to preserve impartiality, but it is doubtful if he will give satisfaction either to interested parties or to publicists. The book itself is somewhat fragmentary and ill-jointed, and does not indi- cate that grasp of thought or depth of feeling which a consideration of this, the most important of the permanent questions now before the world, calls for. Highly as we esteem Professor Jevons for work done in the past, we cannot refrain from saying that in this treatise he fails from the outset to discern the true meaning of legis- lative interferencg, The question is, Why should the state interfere in matters of industry? The answer does not consist in an array of indi- vidual cases of misfortune or suffering, as, for example, a workman torn by an unprotected fly- wheel, children working through their tender years, or a set of laborers threatening and co- ercing their fellow-laborers. but not the answer. The answer, which com- prehends in itself all cases, is that under the un- restricted play of economic forces, the worst possible, not the best possible, form of industrial society comes to exist. The moral tone imparted to it is that of the worst and nut of the best com- peting elements. The state, therefore, should interfere, in order to raise the plane upon which competition may take place, and render it pos- sible for the moral standards of the better com- Nation. — peting elements to realize themselves. Thus, for an example, suppose, in the absence of Fac- tory Acts, ten manufacturers competing for the supply of a market. Nine of these would not wisb, could they control affairs, to weave into their fabrics the lives of helpless children, but the moral sense of the tenth is indifferent to the rights of childhood. This tenth man has it in his power to force the nine down to his conscienceless level, or drive them out of the market. Thus the worst possible business tone is realized, though the good is to the evil as nine to one. The state must step in and raise the plane of competition, saying to the few, You must do business as the better elements of society wish it done. Judicious state interference, then, is defensible, because it conserves all the benefits, while permitting none of the evils, which arise from free competition among men of different moral calibre. A book upon the subject of in- dustrial legislation which does not point out this fact appears to us to be incomplete. It must be a source of satisfaction to those who admire Professor Jevons—and the writer is of that number—that his reputation, now that uvhappily he has been taken from us, will not rest upon the merits of this book, which was doubtless prepared hastily. and for general read- ing. There are other works from his pen which exhibit, as this does not, his acuteness and in- deed brilliancy of thought. Perhaps nothing has appeared in England since the day of John Stuart Moll which may be ranked in economic literature by the side of Professor Jevons’s ‘Theory of Political Economy.’ This book, it is true, contains but the outline of a theory, but it is a theory which, worked out, will greatly in- fluence industrial thought. Indeed, there could be no more fitting memorial to a scholarly life prematurely cut off than a full development of the suggestions found in the chapters upon Utili- ty, Labor, and Capital. A Holiday in South Africa, By R. W. Ley- land. With maps and illustrations. London: Sampson Low, Marston & Co, 1882. Pp. viii.-362, 8vo. Mr. LEYLAND’s holiday lasted a little more than three months, during which time, by dint of hard travelling, he was able to pass through a large part of the settled country lying to the north of the Cape. It is hard to conceive, how- ever, of a region less fitted for a mere pleasure excursion than this. Rough roads, execrable food and lodgings the rule even in the larger towns, long stretches of sandy plain uninhabited by man or beast, would seem to offer few attrac- tions for the holiday-seeker, intent on neither business nor sport. Occasionally there are to be found bits of picturesque scenery, and here and there a pretty village with trees, gardens, and running streams, but these are the rare excep- tions. Our author's route into the interior was by steamer to Port Elizabeth, ‘* the Liverpool of South Africa,” and thence due north by rail and coach. Near this place is one of the largest ostrich farms in the cclony, two thousand acres | being laid out in “breeding eamps,” in which | are about two hundred birds. Of this industry, | which “seems likely to make more radical 1 These are answers, | | | | changes in the pastoral and commercial features of the country than any other discovery or in- novation that has been made since the Cape was first discovered, with the exception of the open- ing up of the diamond-fields in 1867,” the author gives many interesting particulars. The ave- rage price of a pair of good breeding birds is $750, though there are some which ‘‘ would be vastly more expensive to buy,” as they bring to their ownersan annual revenue of over $2,000, ‘through the number of eggs they produce and by the sale of their feathers.” On this farm the eggs are hatched by incubators, and the chickens, when only three days old, are sold for $25 a piece. Kimberley, the principal town of the diamond fields, proved very unattractive. *‘‘ Diamonds, Drink, and. Dirt appeared to be the chief cha racteristics of the place,” and accordingly Mr Leyland hastened to leave it. A three-days’ and three-nights’ ride by stage, during a part of which it was impossible to get food, as the route was new, brought Mr. Leyland to Pretoria, the capital of the Transvaal. ‘‘A comparatively small number of houses, and a large number of gardens bordered by hedgerows of roses in luxu- riant profusion, oleanders, and willow-trees, gave the town a charming appearance w hen first seen ; and the agreeable impression was materi ally strengthened by a further acquaintance with the place and its inhabitants.” Though he details at some length the causes which led to the annexation of the Transvaal, yet he makes no allusion to the revolt of the Boers, whick broke out shortly after his visit. This is the more strange as he refers to a ‘‘ very interesting conversation ” which he had with the Governor on ‘‘the condition and prospects of the Trans vaal,” in which he reports that this functionary “did not appear to attach much importance to the present attitude of the Boers. He regarded their mutterings and threatenings as so miuch vaporing, which would probably soon die out.” Were it not that in describing a steep mountain pass on the borders of Natal he says, ‘ Though not intimated to me at the time, I presume the portion of the road to be Laing's Nek,” we should imagine him to be in entire ignorance of the events which doubtless every Englishnian would be glad to forget. The most interesting part of the book is the account of a visit to Rorke’s Drift, where was the hospital and supply camp so beroically de- fended by a hundred British soldiers during the afternoon and night succeeding the massacre of Isandhlwana. Sheltered behind walls of biscuit- boxes and meal bags, they successfully resisted for twelve hours the attacks of an enemy thirty times their number. Isandhlwana, about ten miles distant, and now the*site of a mission ste- tion, was still thickly strewn with evidences of the slaughter of the English troops. On his re- turn to Cape Town, Mr. Leyland was enabied, through the assistance of Bishop Colenso, to see Ketchwayo. Among other questions, he asked him, ‘“*‘ Why, when Natal was at your mercy, after the battle of Isandhlwana, did you not overrun the colony ¢’ ‘Because I had no desire to fight the English,’ replied the King. ‘I wished to act on the defensive only, all through, not on the offensive. I was extremely angry with my people for crossing the river to Rorke’s Drift house after the battle.’ Considerable space is given toa refutation of the charges of cruelty and hostile intent made by Sir Bartle Frere against the Zulu King; but so little literary skill has been employed in arranging the mate- nals at the author’s disposal, that it is well-nigh unintelligible. It seems very clear from his stateménts, however, that it was a great mis- take to hold Ketchwayo a captive. Deprived of their leader, whom they trusted and implicitly obeyed, the Zulus were at that time demoralized to an extent which threatened their destruction by famine and misrule. Very touching are the expressions of love for the King by some of his chiefs given in these pages; ‘‘ There has never been known one like him among us Zulus before —so good, so kind, so merciful.” ‘‘Then my prayer was that I might be with him—that, wherever they took him to, I might go and be killed, if he was killed, by the same death with which they killed him. And that is my prayer
Page 22
27 still. And, truly, without him, we have no wish to remain above ground.” The English Govern- ment were finally convinced of the wisdom of re- storing the King to his people. First, however, he must be taken to England to see for himself the power of the nation against whom he was pre- sumptuous enough to fight, and even to win a ‘The Nation. The forms of so-called decorative art which it produces will be pleasing only as the fashions of , the moment, and will soon be thrown aside in battle. This visit would hardly seem to have been | necessary, judging from the following anecdote: two places near the Zulu frontier. ‘* When shown to the Zulu chief Usbebo, some short time since, who, of course, could not understand it, natives, ‘Death alone is the white man’s con- queror.’” the Household. Harper & Bros. Beauty in By Mrs, T. 1882, W. Dewing. Tals little book is not one of which we can speak in terms of commendation. The authoress treats the subject of beauty in the household wholly as if it were a matter of merely external form. Considered in this way, the subject can never, we think, be rightly understood or usefully treated. The pursuit of beauty, as thus under- stood, inevitably leads to meaningless fancies and ridiculous pretensions. Beauty in the house- hold, as everywhere else, is essentially and strictly an outgrowth and expression of beauti- ful conditions of life and feeling—not at alla matter of mere external form. That education of the feelings which makes people appreciative of beauty, and capable of producing what is beautiful in their surroundings, is not to be ob- tained from books of this character, nor through the productions of sophisticated wsthetic move- ments, but rather by cultivating habits of simple integrity and good sense, and through familiarity with the beauty of nature and of those works of art which are the outcome of true and disci- plined feeling. Not clearly and practically recognizing these facts, Mrs. Dewing has—as, indeed, have most other recent writers on house- hold taste—given her book largely the form of a series of mere directions for furnishing and adorning apartments. But such directions must always be useless, since,taste is a matter of indi- vidual cultivation. racter, tending home life all those humbler domestic employ- ments upon which, in our view, the higher ac- complishments should rest as on their proper foundation. of moderate means relegate the family cooking and washing to the public caterer and laundry. After setting forth the supposed advantages of this arrangement, she exclaims : “‘ How many a woman who now patiently devotes her life to the merely sordid realisms, would feel like a re- leased prisoner under such a system!” The prisoner thus released, both from actual domestic usefulness and even from superintendence of domestic affairs, she would have occupy her- selt only ‘ with the more ornamental portions of life.” We cannot imagine a more unwhole- some doctrine of domestic economy than this, nor one more sure to quench, and render for ever impossible, all right and healthful sense of beauty, and all beauty itself in the household. The state of. mind, as regards beauty, which such a system engenders is precisely that which ** Patience” so keenly satirizes, and which we had hoped it might tend to cure. The fact is, that by far the larger part of what is known as the aesthetic movement, both in England and in this country, is essentially of this quality ; and on this account contains nothing to recommend it seriously, and no element of permanence. , their turn like other mere fashions. Of the illustrations to the book, nothing better can be said. There is not a good line or a good form in one of them. Take the proportions and treatment of the frontispiecee—a ‘‘ Mantel for | Nursery ”"—the design for a glass panel facing A telephone had been put in operation between | page 16, the designs for bas-reliefs facing page 22, the ‘Tile for a Nursery” on page 157, and others. | which the grace and beauty of a natural object he made use of the expression, common among | depend laid hold of. In the design for a ** Pat- tern for Cushions for Drawing-room,” page 111, for instance, the swan’s wing is utterly unor- ganized. The plumes have no functional ar- | rangement, no power of united action, no elastic grace of curvature, and consequently the wing has no beauty. These qualities are precisely among those which lend themselves to decora- tive uses, and they are those which all good de- signers are quick to seize. A comparison of this drawing with any design of a bird’s wing on the cheapest Japanese fan will make our meaning clear. It would be a vast gain to the growth of taste, and to all forms of art among us, if the | present ambition to write books on esthetics, and to produce decorative art, might, in some greater measure, give place to more of serious and modest study of nature and standard art, as a means of cultivation and for the sake of cul- tivation. La Poésie Alexandrine sous les trois premiers Ptolémées (324-222 B.c.). Par Auguste Conat, Doyen de la Faculté des Lettres de Bordeaux. Paris: Hachette et Cie. 1882. Tue Alexandrian school of poetry, clearly de- fined as it was in its aims, manner, and even diction—enclosed, too, within a tolerably defined period, which may be stated roughly as from 340 to 200 B.c.—has hitherto found no adequate expositor in any modern language except Ger- man. Even in German, no work, so far as we know, deals with this part of Greek literature exclusively, though it is well handled by Bern- | hardy in his History, and not badly by Donald- | son in his continuation of Miiller’s well-known The sentiments of the chapter on small apart- | ments we regard as of decidedly pernicious cha- | as they do to exclude from | manual. M. Conat has thus undertaken a task which needed doing, and, on the whole, he has done his task well, even if many points in his | book are open to criticism and many grave Mrs. Dewing would have persons | omissions mar its completeness. It is natural that the author of a work on Ca- tullus (1875) should be led to the study of the Alexandrian poets. Little as that poetry can be taken as a gauge of the splendid inspiration of the Roman lyrist, and false as is the language of some critics who, on the strength of a splenetic passage of Cicero’s letters, rank Catullus as one of the ‘“‘chanters of Euphorion,” it is neverthe- less true that in form of every kind—not metri- cal only, but throughout—in a finish of detail which could not be contented with anything rough, and hated prolixity as the sin of sins, the Alexandrians were the models by the close study of which the Romans, only after a long struggle with the difficulties of their language and the hard and unyielding temper of their na- tional genius, at last emerged to a really great literature, This it is which makes these poets so important m the history of literary develop- ment, Callimachus and Apollonius of Rhodes were, as compared with the great names of Greek literature, very minor geniuses indeed ; but Callimachus was the model of Catullus, of Propertius, of Ovid ; Apollonius, more than any single author it would be possible to mention, moulded the diction and the cast of thought of the ‘ Aneid.’ | Number 900 | M. Conat begins with an Introduction on the foundation of Alexandria, and the Museum and Library, which under the patronage of the Ptole- mies became the most celebrated in the world. It is an indication of the peculiar lines which Alexandrian literature followed, that its most typical representatives in poetry were succes- sively librarians in the Museum. Callimachus | and Apollonius, master and pupil, rivals in In no case are those qualities upon | | cal success. | poetry--and jealous rivals—each died holding the librarianship. Erudition was, in fact, at this time an indispensable qualification for poeti- The poet was, as a rule, also a voluminous author in prose. We learn this from Suidas, but it is quite palpable in the re- mains of either poet. As M. Conat shows, the Hymns of Callimachus are stuffed with learn- ing ; the most recondite stories connected with the cult he celebrates are brought in to set off the power of the god. The “‘ Argonautica” of Apollonius are obviously written partly with the archeological object of recording the local legends associated with the northern coast of Asia Minor, along which the Argo sailed ; and the nearest approach to simplicity to be found in the poems is the directness with which he adds, at the end of each such legend ; ‘‘ Whence to the present day a custom still exists.” This, by the way, was no doubt one cause of his popu- larity, as it certainly is one cause of the occa- sional tediousness which at the present day readers of this undeniably fine poem—among them M. Conat—confess to experfemeing. The second chapter of the Introduction ex- amines the chronology of the chtef Alexandrians, who are arranged in the following order : Phi- letas (340-285), Hermesianax, Zenodotus, Theo- critus, Aratus., Callimachus, Eratosthenes, Apol- lonius, Aristophanes, Aristarchus (217-145). Whatever doubts may occur to the reader in perusing this chapter—and if he has read Ritschl’s essay on the subject, they will—it would be unfair to deny that the author is independent enough and forms his conclusions on arguments of his own. And this is true throughout. M. Conat is nowhere merely the exponent of the views of others ; even Schneider, to whose dull erudition and often perverted judgment, if to any one, he is disposed to bow, is sometimes criticised se- verely, though we hold our author, on the whole, to be far too deferential to this particular scholar, and, as a corollary thereto, far too little inclined to give due consideration to others as great, if not greater, in erudition, and in judgment incomparably superior—such men, e.g., as Niike, Hecker, and Meineke. There is more of substantial worth in one page of Meineke’s ‘Analecta Alexandrina '—an admira- ble work, which philologists would do well to read over and over again—than in six of Schneider’s verbose and windy ‘Callimachea,’ with its conjectural stitchings of scattered frag- ments and its miserable supplementa, recalling an extinct period of philology. The bulk of M. Conat’s volume is divided into five books, discussing severally the Alexandrian elegy as represented by Philetas, Hermesianax, Phanocles, Alexander Aetolus, and, lastly, Cal- limachus ; the hymns of CalJlimachus (191-291) ; the epics of Apollonius and Rhianus, and the epyliion “ Hecale” (294-390) ; the pastorals of Theocritus (891-444); the didactic poems of Aratus and Eratosthenes. A chapter on the literary quarrel of Callimachus and Apollonius, which produced the ‘Ibis’ of the former poet, concludes the volume. We have learnt a great deal from all these chapters, and they are written in a sufficiently good style to interest more than the special student. It is, however, only fair to say that the author is unduly biassed in some particular directions, notably in favor of Calli- machus against Apollonius. This, indeed, is
Page 23
Sept. 28, 1882] quite patent from the disproportionate space assigned to each, but it betrays itself unequivo- cally in the criticism of the ‘‘ Argonautica.” This poem contains four books, averaging 1,500 or 1,600 lines each. The language is terse and condensed ; the pathos of the Medea episode is great, far beyond Catullus’s “ Ariadne,” ap- proaching the tragic heights of Euripides and Virgil ; the metre is elaborately varied with all the artifice of the school, whose efforts had, as M. Conat excellently shows, concentrated them- selves particularly on the hexameter ; the inci- dents follow each other with remarkable rapidity ; and the total eftect is always pleasing, and some- times profoundly moving. Yet M. Conat can talk of this chef-d’@uvre of Alexandrianism as a “* vaste récit,” and declares that some of its most interesting episodes may be removed without seriously affecting either the poet or the reader. In the same spirit, he devotes many puges to the reconstruction not only of the ‘Aina” and “ Hecale” of Callimachus (of which only some fragments remain), but of the highly unimpor- tant ‘‘ Messeniaca ” of Rhianus, which he assumes to be practically identical with the account of Pausanias of thesecond Messenian war. Surely this is mere wilfulness, and wilfulness of a very provoking kind. To turn from the rich banquet of Theocritus and Apollonius to the crumbs of Callimachean and Rbianic fragments ; to ex- haust ingenuity in conjecturing what a dull but lost poem may have been, instead of analyzing what a great but extant poem really is, is no healthy sign of philological activity, or rather, it is a sign of the inordinate influence of Ger- many—of that restless, speculative spirit which delights in impalpable food, and in that combi- nation of the fragment of fact with the vast superstructure of hypothesis which produces so endless and so resultless a literature. How thankfully would we accept from M. Conat, in place of these unsubstantial possibilities, a single 273 well-considered chapter on Lycophron. Of him and of his ‘*‘ Alexandra,” a unique phenomenon in the literature of Greece and Rome, not one word. And yet the poem and the scholia which elucidate its ‘“‘deep and dreadful night "—for surely even India cannot surpass the profundity of its obscurity—contain a fund of mythologi- cal, and even historical, allusion unsurpassed by any poem of antiquity. Moreover, it has been excellently edited, and it raises critical problems of the greatest interest. If our author would make his valuable labors complete, we would suggest to him a careful study of this. No task could be a better training in Greek, and it isa task which the tyros in this literature have a right to claim from their instructors. BOOKS OF THE WEFEK. Allen, J. H. The Liberal Movement in Theology. ton : Roberts Bros. $1 25. Arnauld, Allis. Bachelors and Butterflies. W. B. Smith Co, 25 Bos- 25 cents. Beard, J. C. Painting on China: a Handbook of Prac- tical Instruction. Dick & Fitzgerald. $1. Billy Blew-Away’s Alphabetical, Orthographical, and Philological Picture-Book. Boston: James RK. Osgood Brehm’s Thierleben. termann & Co. Butcher, S. H., and Lang, A. Done into English Verse. Macmillan & Co. $1. Butler, C. B. Red Cloud, the Solitary Sioux. Boston: Keberts Bros. $1.50. Caruthers, W. A. The Knights of the Horseshoe. Har ver’s Franklin Square Library. 20 cents. Chapel Hymnal, with Tunes. Biglow & Main. 50 cents. Cobve, Frances Power. The Peak in Darien: an Octave of Essays. Boston: Geo. H. Ellis. Cobb, J. F. The Watchers on the Longships. Thomas Y. Crowell & Co. $1 50, Cox, Gen. J.D. The March to tne Sea, Nashville. Chas. Scribner’s Sons. $1. Crummell, A. Tne Greatness of Christ, and other Ser- _ mons. Thomas Whittaker. Cuyler, T. L. God’s Light on Dark Clouds. ter & Bros. Dippold, G. T. Great Epics of Mediwval Germany. Bos- ton : Koberts Bros. 50, Doctor Ben. [Kound-RKobin Series.] Boston: James R, Osgood & Co. Eben, C. T. A Comparative German Primer. mann & Co. 25 cents. Ewell, M.D. Blackstone’s Commentaries, for the Use of Students at Law and the Gencrai Keader. Boston: Soule & Bugbee. Field, Kate. Charles Albert Fechter. series, ] ston : James R. Osgood & Co. Freeman, A.C. American Decisions. Vol. xxxvii. Francisco: A, L. Bancroft & Co. Parts 28-44. New York: B. Wes- The Odyssey of Homer, = Franklin and Robert Car- B. Wester- {American Actor San NEW BOOKS. FANNY KEMBLE’S Records of Later Life. 12mo (uniform with ‘ Records of a Girlhood’), $2 50. NEW, CHEAP EDITION OF GOODHOLME’S Domestic Cyclopedia. 8vo, $2 50. MRS. ALEXANDER’S Look Before You Leap. 16mo (Leisure-Hour Series), $1. Kinley Flollow. By G. H. Hollister. 16mo (Leisure- Hour Series), $1. eS nth The Portable Bookcase PATENTED) In Ebony, Cherry, Black Walnut, or Ash. Solid and Permanent. No room where Books are used complete without it. For descriptive circular and price-list, address the sole | Lockwoop, Brooks & Co., 381 Washington St. On. THE WESTERN Farm Mortgage Co., LAWRENCE, KANSAS. FIRST MORTGAGE LOANS Upon improved productive farms in the best localities in the West negotiated for banks, colleges, estates, and private individuals. Coupon Bonds. Interest and prin- cipal paid on day of maturity at the TaHirpD NATIONAL BANK IN NEW York City. Funds promptly placed. Large experience. No losses. Investors compelled to take no land. No delays in payment of interest. Only the very choicest loans accepted. Full information given to those seeking SAFE AND PROFITABLE INVESTMENTs. Send for circular, references, and sample documents. F, M. PERKINS, Pres. L, H, PERKINS, Sec. J.T. WARNE, Vice-Pres. Cc. W. GILLETT, Treas. N. F. HART, Auditor. Missouri [Trust Co. Offers the safest securities in the market. a specialty of 7 Per Cent. Farm Loans, secured by DEED OF TRUST, being a first lien upon the property. Interest payable semi-annually at the CHEMICAL NATIONAL BANK, N.Y. Collection laws effective and speedy. Safety proved by ten years’ ex- perience. For full particulars and references address O. A. CRANDALL, President, Sedalia, Mo. A? . TURNER & CO., % 207 WALNUT PLAcE, PHILADELPHIA, DEALERS IN RAILWAY BONDS. Orders executed at all the exchanges. Correspondence solicited. ALLS, VESTIBULES, BATH- f £ rooms, and Dining-rooms are finished in SPURR’S VENEERS. They are more durable and handsomer than solid woods, and are cheaper. S$ and estimates furnished. HAS. W. SPURR, 300 Fourth Avenue, City. Also makes Frothingham, 0. B. George Ripley. [Amerftan Men of Letters.} Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. § Harte, Bret. Flip, and Found at Blazing Star. Bb Houghton, Mifflin & Co. §1. Hunter of the Shagreen: a Descriptive Poem. Cleve land : Wm. W. Williams. Ireland, Mrs. Mary F. Timothy : His Neighbors and His Friends. Philadelphia : J. BU Lippincott & Co. 81 Se. Kemble, Frances Ann. Records of Later Life. Henry Holt & Co. $2 5v. Landor, W.S. Imaginary Conversations tion, in 5 vols. Boston Matthews, BR. Well-nigh Novel. E, J. Hale & Son. Munk.S, Philosovhy and Philosophical Authors of the Jews. Cincinnati: Bloch & Co.'s Printing House, Munro, R. Ancient Scottish Lake-Dweilings or Cran nogs. Edinburgh: David Douglas. Osborne, E, The Children’s Saviour. & Co. $1. Oswald, F. L. Zodlogical Sketches. Philadelphia: J. 0 Lipvincott & Co. $2. Parry, Emma Louise. Woman in the Reformation. Philadelphia : Lutheran Publication Society. Passages from the Life and Writings of W iam Penn Philadelphia: Friends’ Book -store. Philbrook, H. B. Astronomy Corrected. hemus. Plum, W, R. ston Popular edi Roberts Bros. $5. Reconstructed: a Political FE. & J. B. Young John Poi The Military Telegraph during the Civil ar. 2vols. Chicago: Jansen, McClurg & Co. $5 Poetical Works of Alice and Phoebe Cary, Household edition. Boston: Houghton, Mimin & Co Praise and Blame of Love. Glasgow: Wilson & MeCor mick, Prime, 8.1. Prayer and Its Answer. Charles Scribner's sons. ° Robinson, P. Under the Sun. Boston: Roberts Rros Romanes,G. J. The Scientific Evidences of Organic Evo lution. Macmillan & Co. 50 cents, Schaff, P. A Popular Commentary on the New Testa ment. Ry English and American Scholars. In four vols. Vol. iii, The Epistles of Paul. Charles Scribner's Sons, Seudder, H. E. The Book of Fables. MiMiin & Co, 50 cents. Shaw, Frances E. The Art of Vratory sarte. Albany: Edgars. Werner Smith, F. H Rocks, Minerals, and Stocks. Railway Review. Smith, J. Dictionary of Economic Plants. Macn Co, $3 50, Stanton, Flizabeth Cady, and Others. man Suffrage. in three vols. Vol. it Boston : Houghton, System of Del Chicago tilian & History of Wo Fowler & Wells $5. Sterne, S. Constitutional History and Political Develoy ment of the United States. Cassell, Petter, Valpin & Co. 1 2. Stoddard, W. O. Saltillo Boys. Charles Scribner's Sons. $l fayior, J. A. FExonerative Insanity. S. S. Peloubet & Co, : The Burman: His Life and Notions. 2 vols. Macmillan & Co, $3. Tilton, T. Swabian Stories. R. Worthington Walpole, 8S. Foreign Relations. Macmillan & Co, $1. A Treatise on Proceedings in Rem {The English Citizen Waples, R, Chica- zo: Callaghan & Co, Wentworth, G, A, Elements of Algebra. Boston; Ginn Keath & Co. Sl 55, W ister, Owen. The New Swiss Family Robinson. Cam bridge, Mass, : Charles W. Sever. POUNTZE BROTHERS, BANKERS, No, 120 BROADWAY (EQUITABLE BUILDING), NEW YORE DEPOSITS RECEIVED, subject to check at sight, and interest allowed on balances. Government and other bonds and investment securt- ties bought and sold on commission. Telegraphic transfers made to London and to various places in the United States. Bills drawn on the Union Bank of London. LETTERS OF CREDIT and Circular Notes issued for the use of travellers in all parts of the world. a INCE & WHITELY, No. 64 Broadway, New York. (Branch Office, 180 Fifth Avenue.) All classes of Railway and Mining Stocks bought and sold on Commission. e Private telegraph-wires to Philadelphia, Wilmington, Baltimore, Washington, Boston, Bridgeport, and New Haven. —_ Issvzk COMMERCIAL anp TRAVELLERS’ CREDITS For use in BROTHERS & 59 WALL STREET; CO., THis COUNTRY AND ABROAD. K "IDDER, PEABODY = CO.,, 1 Nassau St., N. Y.: 113 Devonshire St., Boston. EXCHANGE AND LETTERS OF CREDIT ON GREAT BRITAIN AND THE CONTINENT. Correspondents : BarinG RRoTHERS & Co., London; PERIER Freres & Co., Paris: MENDELSSOHN & Co., Berlin. UNMOUNTED PHOTOGRAPHS Of ANCIENT and MODERN WORKS of ART, embracing reproductions of famous origina! paintings, scu/pture architecture, etc. Price, cabinet size, $1 560 per doz. ben 6-cent stamp for catal e and supplement of 4,760 sut- ects. SO Hi RAPF CO, (successors to John . Soule), Publishers, 338 Washington St. Boston, Mags.
Page 24
. 4 The Nation. [ Number 900 274 ' Schools. Continued from page ill. New York, Suspension Bridge. : E VEAUX COLLEGE.—Prepares for the Universities, etc. Terms, $350 per annum. WILFRED A. MunRo, rh @ President. New York, Utica. ] RS. PIATT’S SCHOOL for Young d Ladies. The next school year begins Monday, Sept. 18, 1882. Applications should be made early. Onio, Cincinnati, Walnut Hills. : | TSS NOURSE'’S English and French i Family School, in connection with the Day- School of Miss Storer and Miss Lupton, reopens Sept. 20. Pupils fitted for the Harvard examinations and for col- leze, The best advantages of the city for the study of music and art are made available. For circulars explaining plan of scnool, address Miss Lurron, 166 Seventh Street, Cincinnati. Ono, Cincinnati. E . _ \f *. AUBURN YOUNG LADIES’ IN- d stitute, Cincinnati, Ohio. Carefully-arranged courses of study, Collegiate, Aca- demic, and Elective. Special advantages in Literature, French, Music, and Art. Forty-ninth session will open September 27. J, Moss Smiru, Principal. H. THANE MILLER, President. PENNSYLVANIA, Haverford College P.O. 44 VERFORD COLLEGE, under the care of the Society of Friends (Orthodox). Tuomas Cuase, LL.D., President. For catalogues apply to Prof. ALLEN C. THOMAS, Prefect. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 1707 Chestnut St. N EVENING SCHOOL for Ladies and ’ 4 Gentlemen will open Sept. 11, 7 p.m. English branches only taught, the selection of which will be optional with pupil. For particulars apply at building from Sept. 5, 6 to 7 P.M. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 1615 Chestnut St. “HESTNUT STREET SEMINARY. . Miss Bonney and Miss DILLayYe, Principals. e thirty-third year of this Boarding and Day School will open Sept. 20, 1882. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 3005 Locust Street. “EORGE F. MARTIN’S SCHOOL.— J Six boys will be taken into the family of the Prin- cipal, PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 1350 Pine Street. } ISS ANABLE’S Boarding and Day d School will reopen September 20. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, Norwood Avenue Chestnut Hill, ; A RS. WALTER D. COMEG YS and Miss Bell’s French and English Boarding and Day School for Young Ladies will reopen, Sept. 21. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 1416 and 1418 Chest- nut Street, 7 Aj TIONAL SCHOOL of ELOCUTION l ' and Ouatory.—-Minetoon teachers and lecturers, specialists in their departments. Thorough and sys- tematic culture in voice, enunciation, and action, in their application to conversation, reading, recitation and oratory. Chartered 1875. Grants dipiomas. Fall term opens October 2, Send for catalogue and prospec- tus to J. H. BecuTe., Secretary. : PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 1833 Chestnut St. "THE MISSES L. V. SMITH and R. S. Ashbridge’s rome and Day School for Young Ladies and Children will reopen September 20, 1882, Address as above. PENNSYLVANIA, Philadelphia, 1707 Chestnut St. JEST CHESTNUT STREET SEMI- j nary for Young Ladies and Children, and Pre- paratory School for bors from 6 to 12 years of age, with- out Kindergarten. Will reopen Boys’ School Sept. 18, and Seminary October 2. Miss M. B. Cocuran, Principal SourH CAROLINA, Columbia. l JFJINTER HOME SCHOOL, near Co- Y —‘-lumbia, 8. C.—This school is established on plan of the European Home Schools. Kesident French, Eng- lish, and German Governesses. Special courses of study given. The climate is particularly adapted to youn girls who cannot pass the winter at the North. uilchest references. Address Mrs. MARY PRESTON Darpsy, P. O, Box 19, Columbia 8, C. _ Wants. FEW FAMILIES, desiring a good Yi school for their children, yet wishing to be near them, may find large rooms and good board by applying to Box 170, Florida, Orange Co., N. Y. | HARVARD GRADUATE, trained for P 4 the Episcepal ministry, with highest references and success in teaching backward boys, will receive two or three again this year, in Boston or elsewhere, as desired, or would travel with them. Address, at once, GrRabpvuate E., Daily Advertiser office, Boston, Mass. PUPIL WANTED by a Harvard Se- ss nior, to prepare for college. Best of references. Address Wn. H. PaGeE, Jr., Cambridge, Mass. UTHORS and PUBLISHERS who wish Y «¢ to contract for the em | of books will find it to their advantage to negotiate with W. W. WrILLiaMs, 145 and 147 St. Clair Street, Cleveland, O. ‘OLORADO.—A gentleman, proprietor of a fine stock ranche and cattle range, desires a part- ner with capital to extend the business. Highest Boston or New York references required and given, Address RANCHERO, Office of Nation, y¥DPDWARD H. STROBEL and JAMES . _Byrne will prepare, in New York, a pupil for col- lege. Five years’ experience in fitting men for Harvard, Address, Cambridge, Mass. A R. WALTER H. RHETT (Harvard, *80) wishes, in Cambridge or New York, a pupil to prepare for college. Four years’ experience ; good references ; terms high. Address in Cambridge, Mass. 4 #4 CHERS wanting positions, or colleges, schools, and families wanting competent instruc- tors, apply to Brockway TEACHERS’ AGENCY, 10 Times Building, Chicago, U1. “T’HE RECTOR OF CHRIST CHURCH, Cambridge, of large experience in teaching, would prepare one or two boys for college, or would give private instruction in selecved college studies. Kefe- rences: Profs Goodwin and Langdell, Harvard Uni- versity; Mr. L. R. Williston, late Master Cambridge High school; Mr. George Dexter and Mr. Horace Ek. Scudder, Cambridge. JAMES F. SPALDING 13 Follen Street, Cambridge, Mass. i UNION TEACHERS’ AGENCY provides well-qualified teachers for any position; sells or rents school property ; aids feachers in obtaining situations, ete. Send tor circular. A. Lovet, & Co., Managers, 42 Bond Street, New York. oo ae situation by an English Lady, to teach the usual branches. French and German acquired on the Continent. Keferences given and required. Address Box 53, Gainesville, Alachua Co., Florida, WwW ANTED, for a young lady of 14 years, a place in the family of a lady who receives not more than ten pupils for instruction. Whole room wanted: elegant and refined surroundings; situation in city or country a hundred miles or more from New York. The object is to combine the advantages of home and school. Address JAMES CHRISTIF, Pinckney’s Agency, peg: ed Building, Broadway and Fourteenth Street, ew Tork, Lmportant New Text-Books. FRENCH SYNTAX. Onthe Basis of Edouard Matzner. By James A. Harrison, Profes- sor- of Modern Languages in Washington and Lee University, Author of a ‘ History of Spain,’ and Edi- tor of Beowulf, Selections from Heine etc., etc., etc. 2m.o, cloth extra, $2 50. THE SCIENCE and ART of ELO- cution; or, How to Read and Speak. A Series of Exercises for Gesture, Calisthenics, and the Cultiva- tion of the Voice; and a Collection of nearly One Hundred and Fifty Literary Gems for Reading and Speaking. New and enlarged edition. By Frank H. Fenno, of the National School of Oratory. 12mo, cloth extra, #1 25. THE ARTIST and his MISSION. A Study in Asthetics. Designed for the use of Schools and Colleges. By Kev. William M. Reily, Ph.D., Professor of Ancient Languages, Palatinate College. 12mo, cloth extra, $1 50. A MANUAL of the GERMAN Language. By Augustin Knoflach, Teacher of Lan- guages. 12mo, cloth extra, $1. AN INTRODUCTION TO THE Study of English Literature and Literary Criticism. Designed for the use of Schools, Seminaries, Col- leges, and Universities. Vol. I. POETRY. By Prof. James Baldwin. 8vo, cloth extra, $2 50. +,* For sale by all booksellers, or copies sent, post- paid, on receipt of price. JOHN E. POTTER & CO., Publishers, __ PHILADELPHIA. Plymouth Pulpit THE WEEKLY PAMPHLET PUBLICATION OF Henry Warp BEECHER’S SERMONS Will be resumed Saturday, October 14, 1882. Single copies, 7 cents, to be had of Booksellers and Newsdealers. Yearly subscription, $2; to Clergymen, $1 70. All who subscribe before October 14 will receive the weekly numbers for one year and four weeks—i, e. from Oct. 14, 1882, to Nov. 12, 1883. FORDS, HOWARD & HULBERT, 27 Park Place, New York. SCHOOL BOOKS In the Foreign and Classical Languages. One of the largest stocks in the country. Catalogues on application. CARL SCHOENHOF, Importer, 146 Tremont Street, Boston. LONDON BOOKS. (ESTABLISHED 1840.] A. i, LUIS ee, No. 98 NASSAU STREET, OFFERS A VERY LARGE AND CHOICE COLLECTION Linglish and Foreign Books, In all Departments of Literature, in various and fine bindings, and of sterling worth and permanent value. Having a London Branch, we are enabied to offer our importations, less the various commissions and charges paid to agents by other dealers, affording in this respect a favorable opportunity to American buyers. NOW READY: DESCRIPTIVE LIST, with prices annexed, of a large and valuable invoice re- cently received, comprising every variety of books. Catalogues mailed gratis on application to subscriber. A. L. LUYSTER, IMPORTER OF ENGLISH AND FOREIGN BOOKS, No. 98 Nassau Street, N. Y. ; No. 10 Silver Street, London, Eng. NEW LAW BOOKS ~ PUBLISHED BY Little, Brown & Co. Robinson's Elementary Law. ELEMENTARY LAW. By William C. Robinson, LL.D., Professor of Elementary Law in Yale College. 120, leatherette, $2 50, net ; law sheep, $3, net. This work is intended to serve three purposes * (1) To form a text-book for tbe use of students in law schools, and of others who are under competent instruction ; (2) To guide private students in their investigation of the rules and definitions of the law; (3) To vender students familiar with sume of the leading treatises upon the principal topics of the law. It contains « statement of the principles, rules, and definitions of American Common Law, both civil and criminal, mets in logical order, with references to treatises in which such definitions, rules and principles are more extensively discussed. “ This little volume covers the entire field of theory and practice, both in law and equity. Its pur is to answer, simply and intelligibly, the thousand elemen- tary questions which perplex a student at the outset of his work. ‘he plan of the book is admirable, aud its execution correspondingly good. It satisfactorily meets a want that has long been felt by law students and long recognized by thoughtful practitioners.”— Boston Courier. SCHOULER ON THE LAW OF DOMESTIC RELA- TIONS. Third Edition. &vo, $6. WALKER’S INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN LAW. Eighth Edition. With Notes by Hon. M. F. Force. 8vo, $6. GENEVA AWARD ACT. With Notes and References to Decisions of the Court of Commissioners of Ala- bema Claims. By Frank W. Hackett. 8vo, cleth $2 50. HEADQUARTERS FOR School-Books & Stationery. The best place in the city to get School and College Text-Books, Blank-Books, and Stationery of all kinds, is G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS, 27 and 29 West Twenty-third Street, who keep a full stock of all books in general use, and supply schools and students at low prices. Any cook not in stock promptly obtained. Orders from out of town receive prompt attention. *,* Circulars of desirable schools mailed on request. THIRD OLD BOOK caTALoers OF RARE An. STARDARD noe. oO a! ions, many e n bound, selec’ Mr. Lauriat during a ten-weeks’ trl in Europe. 4 ge Just Ready, Free to any address. Send postal. ESTES & LAURIAT, 301-305 Washington St., Boston. CATALOGUE of Rare, Curious, Scientific, Out - of - the - Way, etc., BOOK S—Awmerican & Foreign— Sent on application, by ~ LEON & BRO., 78 E, Washington Square, New York. ts
Page 25
%