The Nation 1882-08-24: Vol 35 Iss 895

Page 1

The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, AUGUST 24, 1882. ta Weak. Tue seizure of the Suez Canal by Sir Garnet Wolseley has some lessons which may be of service to our Government in the matter of the proposed canal across the Isthmus of Panama. The British have taken possession of it from end to end, and are apparently going to use it as a base for their operations against Cairo. Now, the neutrality of the Canal has been guaranteed by the Sultan, within whose do- minions, technically considered, it lies; but it turns out, as might have been expected, that his guarantee is not of the slightest value, in- asmuch as he has no power to enforce it, were he never so desirous of doing so. He weighs in the matter about as much as M. de Les- seps, who is protesting valiantly. Whether a joint guarantee of the Powers would have been any more effective 1s very doubtful. It could only have been made effective by combined opposition to the British plans on the part of the naval Powers, but this it would have been almost impossible to bring about. Guarantees of neutrality, like other joint treaties, are apt to be enforced only when it suits everybody concerned. In any such combination Germany would have been a lead- ing factor, and it suits Germany just now to let England have her way; and in the presence of this attitude of Bismarck the French and Italian fleets count for nothing. One thing the whole affair teaches is, in fact, that nothing but a very powerful fleet at each end of an in- teroceanic canal, or very powerful army along its banks, can guarantee its neutrality. An- other is that threats of what will happen if it is violated are not likely to be much regarded by a belligerent. Belligerents seldom care much about consequences. They trust to luck, and think only of to-morrow or the day after. Asa matter of fact, most of the bold, unscrupulous strokes in war succeed. By the time those who feel outraged by them get ready to chastise ‘the insult, their anger has blown over. Almost the only exception to this rule in recent times has been the Russian invasion of Turkey in 1853. If we want to have a perfectly sure hold of the Panama Canal, we shail have to own it, and have enough force on the spot to repel any attempt to seize it, besides guaranteeing its neutrality on paper. remote The plan of campaign in Egypt, as now re- vealed by Sir Garnet Wolseley, bids fair to justify the anticipation attributed to him that active operations will be over by September 15. It may be described very briefly by saying that Arabi had made all his preparations to resist an advance on Cairo, the capital, from Alexandria, and had constructed extensive and formidable earthworks for this purpose, and that the British are ignoring these alto- gether and have established a base substan- tially in his rear, which will compel him to abandon his present position and fight, if he fights at all, somewhere northeast of Cairo, probably at Tel-el-Kebir, on the railroad from Ismailia, The British are now in possession of the whole Canal, and have established themselves at Ismailia, the little half-way city created by the late Khedive, and there is evi- dently to be a rapid concentric advance both from that point and from Suez to Cairo, a distance of about sixty miles. There is no sign as yet of any such fighting power on the part of the Arabs as to lead us to expect that the march across the desert will be seriously impeded. Thus far there has been substan- tially no resistance to the invaders in the open, and but a feeble one behind the works. The defeat and slaughter of the intrenched garrison of Shaluff by a comparatively small party of British, shows that the Egyptian troops have not improved in quality since the Crimean war, or the Russo-Turkish war of 1876. In both of these they were practically worthless, even when supported by men of sterner stuff. In the meantime the state of things in Tur- key is very curious. Lord Dufferin has been trying to force the Sultan into signing a con- vention binding him to send troops to Egypt to aid in subduing Arabi Pasha, but placing them practically under Sir Garnet Wolseley’s orders. This the Sultan and the Pashas can not make up their minds to do, almost cer- tainly for the very simple reason that their object in going to Egypt is not to fight, but to get at Arabi’s treasury, which they believe to be pretty full, as the fellaheen are much bet- ter taxpayers than the Sultan’s own subjects. The reason why the English want to keep the Turks under their own orders is that they know the Turkish fighting will not amount to anything, but wish to the na tives that the head of the Mohammedan world is on their side. There is, too, some very reasonable fear that if the Turks were allowed to wander about loose, they would, if they helped anybody, help the Egyptians. The Sultan is accordingly in a very perplexing situation, and apparently also in a very bad humor, for he has issued a decree forbidding the sale of mules to the British commissariat. This 1s not surprising, for the court is credibly reported to be in worse straits for money than ever before, so that a second stoppage of the palace mutton is not unlikely. The Galata bankers will lend no more at any rate of inte- rest, and the London Truth has an amusing story, which is not improbable, that one of the officers has been selling some of the impe- rial furniture to raise the wind for himself. In fact, it may be said that the treatment of this crew of swindling debauchees and eu show nuchs.as a regular government, to be nego- tiated with and deferred to, is one of the odd- est phenomena in modern history, when we consider that it is the result of a sort of con- cert between the leading civilized Powers of the world. Mr. Gustav Schwab, while giving his views on the subject of the wool trade before the Tariff Commission, said, in the innocence of his heart, that if he were to follow his own convictions, he would make ar argument in favor of free wool, but that he supposed it woud not be acceptable to the Commission This remark was made in the course ot a colloquy with Mr. A. M. Garland, the President of the National Wool-Growers’ As sociation, who enjoys a place on the Commis The National Wool-Growers’ Associa tion is an organization whose chief business is to look tariff. Probably Mr Schwab was aware of this fact, and hastily drew the inference that an argument fer free wool would be out of place then and there. Mr. Kenner, of Louisiana, was so impressed with Mr. Schwab's frankness that he insisted upon knowing how the latter came to imagine that an would not be mission. Mr. learned at sion. after the wool for free wool acceptable to the Com Schwab replied that he had Washington that the wool-growers had great influence in lation, that this fact was in his mind when he made the observation which excited Mr. Ktnner's curiosity. No allusion to Mr. Kenner’s colleague, Mr. Gar land, was intended,or to any interests he might Mr. Schwab's po liteness was as graceful as his former frank We trust that Mr argument city egis and uppermost be supposed to represent. ness had been charming Kenner was soothed by it. Before he made the formal statement of his views on wool duties, Mr. Schwab had had an informal conversation on the subject both with Mr. Garland and with Tariff Commis- sioner Hayes, a member of the same National Wool - Growers’ Association and a_ repre the wool manufacturers. It might be hastily assumed that these par ticular sentative also of wool-growers were associated sole ly for the purpose of promoting the rais- ing and shearing of sheep, but that would be a great mistake, The chief object of ihe so ciety 1s to maintain a satisfactory protective duty on imported wool, and the associates are far more concerned about members of Con- gress than about sheep. Mr. Hayes has made himself so useful in securing these Ingh duties, in connection with high duties on manufactured wool,that he would be entitled to life-member- ship of the Association even if he should take no further interest in the wool question. A further and proper recognition of these ser- vices is his selection for President of the Tariff Commission. Mr, Schwab might be excused for taking for granted that these eminent wool-growers were not friendly to free wool. To assume that, after so long and so openly maintaining the patriotic and commercial duty of putting a high tariff on wool, they would prove false to their convictions and betray the trust of the Na- tional Association, simply because they had been appointed members of a commission to revise the tariff laws, would be an act of dis- courtesy of which we are sure Mr. Schwab is altogether incapable. But if there had been any doubt as to their position, these celebrated wool-growers removed it in the course of the conversation, when Mr. Garland and Mr. Hayes both spoke of the abolition of the duty “‘as au

Page 2

146 [ Number 89 impracticable measure, which, of course, Mr. Schwab would not even mention.” So when he addressed the Commission, instead of rais- ing the unworthy imputation that an honora- ble wool-grower could undergo an economic transformation and abandon the opinions of a lifetime upon the calling of the Commission to order, Mr. Schwab politely assumed that these Commissioners believed then what they believed ten minutes before, and said that, while he was himself for free wool, he did not think it worth while to discuss the subject from that point of view. In an interview reported on Thursday Repre- sentative Carlisle, of Kentucky, said that the meetings of the Tariff Commission ‘‘ remind- ed him very much of the sessions of the Com- mittee of Ways and Means.” That Commit- tee listens regularly to the ‘selfishly in- terested” people who want ‘“‘the tariff adjusted to suit their own objects and views.” This is what the Tariff Commission 1s doing. Mr. Carlisle predicted that the Commission would simply ‘‘send to Congress three or four thousand printed pages of testimony which not a half-dozen members would read.” This is just what the Committee of Ways and Means would do if it should be directed to sit during the recess. The testimony will be almost wholly of the selfishly-interested kind which Mr. Carlisle describes. While the various witnesses will have particular interests to serve, there will be substantial unanimity of protest against a reduction of duties If it be asked why so much testimony of this sort will be taken, the answer is that it 1s generally understood that the Commission was organized for the very purpose of gather- jag such evidence. It is equally well under- stood that evidence of a different kind is not wanted. Neither Mr. Kenner nor any other rational man can suppose for a mo- ment that the Commission was formed with a view to free wool or free anything else. If the design had been to reduce duties and enlarge the free list, a majority of the Com- mission would have been composed of men inclined to such a policy; or at least half of it would have been so made up. Certainly that policy would not have been altogether denied representation. At Saratoga on Thursday Mr. Bonney, of Chicago, gave the Bankers’ Convention some account of what is known as the ‘‘ equity ” bankruptcy scheme, reported favorably in the Senate at the last session. The scheme is sim- ply to put the whole business of winding up bankrupt estates in the hands of the United States courts, leaving them, as in all other mutters over which they have jurisdiction, to make their own rules of practice and pro- cedure. This plan has never been tried, certainly in this country, where we have al- ways had an elaborate system provided in the Bankrupt Act itself, with a special set of officials, minute regulations as to fees, etc. The act, when one is in force, is always amended every year, so that the proce- dure never becomes entirely stable. Now, this instability would undoubtedly be avoided by turning the whole matter over to the courts ; aud, taking the United States courts as they are, and Congress as it is, there can be little doubt that bankrupts and creditors would be better satisfied in the long run with having the matter wholly regulated by the judges in each circuit than by members of Congress. At any rate, the other plan, whenever it has been tried, has failed, while this plan may work well. If it does not, Congress can always interfere, and pass an old-fashioned bankrupt act, while, if it begins with one, it is not likely to go back to the equity plan ; for, with an ordinary bankrupt act, owing to the number of officials interested in its being continued in force, the pressure against any change which would sweep them out of existence would be very great. According to a cable despatch published the other day, Mr. Lowell has abandoned all hope of the international copyright negotia- tions coming to anything. Nobody is likely to be very much surprised at the news; it was anticipated by all who have followed the negotiations with any attention. The pirates have now a great opportunity, which they prob- ably will not neglect, to reap a rich harvest, and we trust they will do so, for nothing but unli- mited piracy will ever convince the great pub- lishers that their attempts to establish interna- tional copyright on the basis of protection to the American book manufacturers will not work. The “‘ Harper” treaty has broken down be- cause the publishers have attempted, under pretence of making literary property sacred, to compel the foreign author to publish his book in America. Sooner or later the pub- lishers will find out that they must all come into the market on equal terms, or else that they will be permanently driven out of the market by the pirates. The authors’ best friend at present is the pirate, for it is the pirate alone who can bring the publishers to their senses. He has already half-converted most of the publishers, and in time he will make his work of regeneration complete. The international law reformers have held their tenth annual conference of the Interna- tional Congress at Liverpool, and discussed, among other things, the possibility of intro- ducing an international form of bill of lading. It was voted, as the principle of liability, that the shipowner, whether of steam or sailing ship, should be liable for the faults of his ser- vants in all matters relating to the ordinary course of the voyage, such as the stowage and right delivery of the cargo, and other matters of this kind; but, on the other hand, the shipowner should be exempt from liability for everything which comes under the head of ‘‘ accidents of navigation,” even though the loss from these may be indirectly attributable to some fault or neglect of the crew. This change seems very objection- able. It makes the responsibility of @ carrier at sea different from that of a land-carrier, and without any good reason. A more sensi- ble vote was that on the retention of the words ‘‘ act of God,” which some of the mem- bers objected to, incredible as it may seem, on the ground of ‘‘ irreverence,” and others because they were not sufficiently definite. The fact is that the term has acquired, by the decisions of judges, a perfectly definite legal meaning, and the sure way to unsettle it would be to in- troduce a new phrase, which would call for more interpretation. The Conference took this view, and the motion to strike out the words was lost by a vote of 27 to 12. Another subject discussed by the Conference was that of marriage. The conclusion said to have been reached 1s, that the rule that a mar- riage valid in the place where contracted should be valid everywhere ought to be made interna- tional. This is the rule of our courts, but the fact that it is shows at once how very slight an improvement would be effected by making it universal. The rule has prevailed here since the settlement of the country, and yet there is no country in the world where divorce is so easy and the marriage tie so loose. In fact, in the modern world this country produces more marital troubles and complications than all the rest put together. Much of it comes from the ease with which foreign divorces are obtained on short resi- dence, and this evil cannot be reduced by mak- ing a marriage good in one place good in all. Another Southern ‘‘ outrage” has been dis- covered in an election law passed by the Le- gislature of Louisiana. According to the ac- count given by the alarmists, this statute pro- vides that nu ballot shall be received by the inspectors or counted by the canvassers ‘‘ un- less it is printed on paper furnished by the Secretary of State,” and ‘‘so distinguished from all other paper as to be readily and un- erringly identified.” This is described: as ‘‘the crowning manifestation” of ‘‘ Demo- cratic folly and recklessness and corruption,” inasmuch as it leaves it for the Secretary of State ‘‘to say who shall cast a vote in Louisiana.” We should be extremely reluc- tant to fix a limit to Democratic ‘folly and recklessness,” in Louisiana or elsewhere ; and certainly, if the Secretary of State should refuse to furnish the official paper to any- body but his friends, he might possibly pre- vent a good many people from voting. Any law may be abused, but it cannot be taken for granted that the officer entrusted with its execution will abuse it. Under such an assumption it might be necessary altogether to stop the making of laws. We suspect that this Louisiana law is very like the one under which elections are now held in the State of New York, and which prescribes the size of ballots, and the color and quality of paper on which, and the kind of type with which, they shall be printed. Some objection was made to this measure when it was proposed, but it is found to work well. Instead of pro- moting fraud, the intent and the effect are to prevent it. The tissue-ballot swindle is im- possible under it, and as for the ready and unerring identification on which stress is laid by the critics of the Louisiana law, the truth is that, as the outside of all ballots of all par- ties will be alike, it will really be impossible to identify them for the purpose of intimida- tion or other unlawful object. The principal financial event of the week was the advance in the posted discount rate of the Bank of England to four per cent. from three per cent, Although the reserve of the

Page 3

Aug. 24, 1882] Th e Nation. Bank is not high, yet nothing in the present situation demanded the advance. It was there- fore construed as a premonition or notice to the commercial world, and particularly to this country, that an effort will be made to prevent gold leaving London during the remainder of the year. It is now tolerably clear that Eng- land will need more of our breadstuffs and cotton than last year, and there was a good prospect that we should draw gold from her. The importance of the action of the Bank is that it weakens this expectation. Here the Treasury continues to take in more money than it pays out, and some currency is going to the interior from the Atlantic cities. The surplus reserve of the New York banks was reduced to less than $2,000,000, and is falling. The rate for call loans did not, however, fairly advance above 4@44 per cent. Foreign exchange advanced for short-date remittances. At the Stock Exchange the tendency of prices for railroad stocks was, with few exceptions, to lower figures, and the decline ranged from } to 4} points. The general trade of the coun- try is looking well and promises to be extraor- dinarily good during the autumn. The rail- road tonnage does not yet show an increase, for the reason that the movement of the new crops has not yet beco:ne important. Mr. James W. Fitch, of Ohio, has written a letter to the New Haven Palladium to pro- test against the ‘‘ Walter Malley March” being played on the green, and against the Walter Malley jury having picnics in honor of saving Blanche and the Malley boys from the gallows. The Palladium thinks that ‘disgrace enough” has been brought upon New Haven by the trial, and insists that the ‘‘Walter Malley March” must not be played any more. The Palladium and Mr. Fitch do not analyze the reasons for objecting to such performances, but if they did, they would no doubt say that the whole Malley trial was a very disgusting and repulsive inquiry; that “the boys” are cold-blooded young villains, apparently destitute of shame; that their ac- complice, Blanche, is an outcast of a very de- praved type; that much of the testimony in the case was so disgusting as to be unfit for publication; and that consequently the whole affair is one which everybody in New Haven dislikes to hear mentioned or alluded to. The leader of the American band who plays the ‘‘ Walter Malley March,” however, draws exactly the opposite conclusion—that these facts make the case replete with human interest, and that there is nothing that the citizen of New Haven likes better, when he takes his pleasure, than to listen to inspiriting strains which recall the villany of the boys, the vileness of Blanche, and the excitement produced by the mass of filth and perjury which made up the evidence in the case. If the leader of the band could be induced to give his views about the matter to the press, they would constitute a contribution to psy- chology and sociology of great interest. Mr. Wilde’s lecture at Long Beach on the useful and the beautiful is said to have caused a great deal of ill-feeling, and from the reports of the lecture which have appeared, this must have been due to his uncalled-for attack on the 7 a cast-iron stove. He denounced it in very plain language, and declared that it was the stove which had most shocked and disgusted him in America. He found himself able to stand the architecture of the houses, and the dressing, and the insincere furniture ; but the stove, the -ast-iron stove, with its meaningless shape and its ornamentation of cast-iron roses, he pro- tested against. That this should have caused some feeling in the audience is only natura}, considering the important part that the stove plays in American life. The iron stove is a great national institution, and if the public is to be weaned from it, it should be gently and gradually, and not by violent denunciation and abuse. Other countries get along with- out stoves ; but then they get along without a great many things that we have. The Frenct, for instance, although their attention has often been called to the matter, get along without any word for ‘‘home ” in their language, but we cannot. We are accustomed to the stove. We have it in the country store, and round it cluster a thousand interesting political and religious associations. The store ‘ base-burner” has been in every town and village of the United States the nursery of political agitation and political harmony. Then there is the ‘‘ air- tight” stove, at the glowing sides of which the solitary village Tweed, sent huagry to bed, warms himself while maturing schemes of adult pillage and spoliation. Then there 1s the railroad stove, which has slain its thou- sands, and tens of thousands, and the gas- stove, which has rendered the atmosphere hideous in many a happy American home. We may suffer from the stove, but our suf- ferings endear it to us, and therefore the re- former should rouse us from our dream gently. It seems to be time that the somewhat ridi- culous controversy which has been raging in England over the Nateon's statement that not over ‘‘one man in one hundred thousand,” in this community, ‘‘ had the manners or cultiva- tion of a gentleman, changed his shirt more than once a week, or ate with his fork,” should cease. Mr. Matthew Arnold seized on it asa bit of statistics illustrating the low condition of American manners, in an article on Ameri- “an Society, and ever since then it has formed a subject of heated discussion between the friends and enemies of American institutions, which is continued in the last number of the Spectator. The article in which the shirt-and- fork illustration appeared in our columns was suggested by a protest of the Pall Mall Gazette against the luxurious habits and ideas iv which boys who have no pecuniary expostit- tions, and will have to earn their own bice. are brought up in English schools and colleges, We said this protest was as applicable totiis country as to England ; that here, too, youa: men in college get into wealthy men’s Va; looking at life, although, after leaving cXt_.gp, they will have to work for a living in a society which is, as to shirts and forks, in the condition we described, and to which they will have to adapt themselves. It was no more a statistical statement than that old one about the knowledge possessed by ‘‘ every school-boy,” and the crushing calculation which some of its critics have made, that_this would leave oniy fv. hundred clean-shirted and fork-using men in the United States, is about as useful as the production of several school-boys ignorant of what ‘every school. boy knows.” The British J‘arliament has adjourned unt: the 24th cf Octoler, after a lively but entirely inconclusive de. ate on the arrest of Mr. Gray. In this Mr. Gladstone plainly indicated that he regarded the action of Mr. Justice Lawson in imprisoning Mr. Gray as oppressive; but very truly said that he knew of no way in which even a Parliamentary committee could secure his release. If, as we suppose, the punish ment has nothing to do with coercion, but 1s simply an excessive punishment for a com- ioen-law contempt of court, there is nothing shoit of an address to the Crown for the re- mov of the Judge which would be of any avi.l Mr. Gladstone went so far as to suggest suciia course, amid loud cheers from the Irish mubers. Nothing could better show the »: Larrassing position in which the hasty ac nof the Judge places the Government than ‘debate which followed. Mr, Sexton in sisted that he ought to have allowed Mr. Gray to uuce a defence, and read telegrams relat- ing to one of the convictions commented upon Ly Mr. Gray’s newspaper (the Hynes case), 1ccitiny affidavits declaring several of the jurymen to have been drunk, and repeating the accusations of jury-packing in Ireland, Mr. Gray of course ought not to have had a severe and unusual punishment inflicted upon him without being given leave to show that there was some basis of tact for his publica- tion, and obviously it would be a gross out rage ‘9 carry out the sentence on Hynes if his convic on could be sroved to have been pro- cured ft ma dru cen jury, tv When these facts came out, Mr. Johnson, Attorney-General for Ireland, was obliged to enter into a defence of the composition of lish juries, and to promise that Earl Spencer sould investigate the charge with regard to the Hynes jury. Thus, while Mr. Gray is being locked up in Ireland for making the charge, the Attorney-General is promising in Varhameut to have it at once investigated—a state of affairs only calculated to bring into greater contempt the administration of the law in Ireland. The publicity of the debate lefeats any object that might be gained by the imprisonment itself. On this account the adjournment of Parliament will strength- en Mr. Gladstone’s hands for the time being, Whatever is done in Ireland by hasty judges or over-zealous prosecuting officers—and prob- ably mapy oppressive things will be done --the Government will escape the dangerous attacks of the [rish party in the House. The adjournment will also be an advan tage in the Egyptian campaign, for an at- mosphere of Parliamentary debate and criti- cism at home is not that in which any Government likes to carry on a foreign war. If, as now seems probable, the Egyptian cam- paign proves short and decisive, the prestige of Mr. Gladstone --for he is the Government -will be greatly increased when Parliament reconvenes.

Page 4

148 The Nation. [ Number 895 SUMMARY OF THE WEEK’S NEWS. | WEDNESDAY, August 16, to TurRspay, August 22, 1882, inclusive. } DOMESTIC. PresIDENT ARTHUR remained in this city until Tuesday, when he went to Newport. A Cabi- net meeting was held at his house on Lexing- ton Avenue on Monday afternoon. Nothing of particular public interest was discussed. Considerable excitement has been caused in political circles in this State by a recent edito- rial article in the Albany Hvenwng Journal, charging Mr. Conkling, in the interest of Jay Gould, with having endeavored to influence Governor Cornell's action on the Elevated tailway and Pacific Mail Steamship Tax Bills, offering him his (Conkling’s) support in the Governorship contest, and also an oppor- tunity to profit by the probable rise of the stocks. The article is supposed to have been ‘inspired ” by Governor Cornell, and it will have a great influence on the coming political campaign for the Governorship in this State. Mr. Jay Gould added his mite to the Conkling- Cornell controversy by asserting, in an inter- view published in a Sunday newspaper, that Governor Cornell promised to sign the Ele- vated Railroad Tax Bill, but that, after the bill bad been passed, he discovered some con- stitutional objections, and expressed a wish that Mr. Conkling should be employed by the company to give a legal opinion on them. Mr. Conkling was employed, and the Gover- nor vetoed the bill. Mr. Gould also asserts that Governor Cornell got up a blind pool in American District Telegraph stock, with his assistance and that of Mr. Russell Sage and Sid- ney Dillon ; that after inducing his friends to buy stock he ‘“‘ went the other way” and made a large sum of money by selling. Governor Cornell denies that he promised to sign the Tax Bill, but makes no explanation in regard to the blind pool. The Albany Journal, in an editorial article on Monday, reiterated its charges, and also asserted that Mr. Cornell was promised Mr. Conkling’s support, and that of all the Gould newspapers, if he would make a favorable decision on the Tax Bill. The conventions of the First, Second, and Third Assembly Districts of Albany County, N.Y., were held on Tuesday, to select delegates to the Republican State Convention. Pro- nounced anti-Cornell delegates were elected throughout. In the Second District a reso- lution to endorse Governor Cornell’s admin- istration was overwhelmingly veted down. Secretary Folger was a favorite candidate among the politicians at the conventions. Senator Mahone, of Virginia, is seriously troubled by the open revolt of Congressman Fulkerson, of the Ninth District, who has broken loose from the coalition, and declares himself an Independent candidate for Con- oTeSS. The Ohio Democrats, on Wednesday, nomi- nated F. D. Walker for Secretary of State, John Foley for Treasurer, and minor State offi- ers. The platform demands civil-service re- form and a reduction of taxation in national affairs. In State affairs the Democrats declare that they will use all legal means to eliminate the prohibition amendment from the Constitu- tion. They demand State regulation of railway freight charges. On Friday the Greenbackers of Massachu- setts nominated General Benjamin F. Butler for Governor, George Dutton, of Springfield, for Lieutenant-Governor, and other minor State officers. The platform demands a check upon the power of wealth, and a system that will secure to the laborer the profits of his toil ; that the national debt shall be paid as rapidly as the revenues will allow ; that the general Government shall coin and issue all money, whether metallic or paper, make it a full legal tender for all debts, without exception, and receive it in payment of all taxes, and that it shall abolish the national banks as banks of issue. A board of arbitration for the settle- ment of labor troubles in the State is recom- mended, and Minister Lowell’s course at the Court of St. James is condemned. The State Committee of the Anti-Monopoly party of New York held a meeting in thiscity on Wednesday and decided to hold their State Convention on September 13, at Saratoga. Governor Foster, of Ohio, made a speech before a Republican County Convention on Wednesday, in which he denounced the whis- key dealers’ rebellion in that State in strong terms. At a meeting of the Western Distillers’ As- sociation in Chicago, on Thursday, resolutions were passed favoring the enforcement of the Sunday laws, and asking no special privilege for their business in that respect. They ap- prove a well-digested license law, with the fee placed high enough to yield a large reve- nue and reduce the number of drinking-places. They oppose arraying themselves against either of the great political parties. Before the Tariff Commission, during the week, pleas have been heard from the repre- sentatives of a great number of industries, most of them in favor of increased duties. A notable exception was Mr. Gustav Schwab, of this city, who remarked that he would advo- cate free wool, except that such an argument would not be acceptable to the Commission. This remark was resented by Commissivner Kenner, who said that they were willing to hear free-trade as well as protection argu- ments. William 8. Rice, of New York, on Thursday, urged the removal of the ten per cent. duty on hay, A programme has been ar- ranged by the Commission to hold meetings in a number of the prominent cities during the next few weeks. The Bankers’ Association opened its anntial Convention at Saratoga on Wednesday with a large attendance from all sections of the coun- try. The President, Mr. George 8S. Coe, made an opening address, in which he discussed the question of bi-metallism, the functions of a bank, and the best basis of a bank currency. A valuable paper was read by Professor At- water, of Princeton College, on the means of securing a safe, elastic currency when Govern- ment bonds are no longer obtainable. Mr. W. H. Perkins, cashier of a bank in Jackson, Miss., read a paper, on Thursday, on the in- dustrial growth of that State. The Convention adjourned on Thursday, after re&lecting Mr. George 8. Coe President. The American Bar Association, at its meet- ing on August 11, adopted the majority report of the Select Committee on a bill for relief of the Supreme Court of the United States, which approved the general scheme of the Davis bill, passed by the Senate on May 12, establishing an Intermediate Court of Appeal. It was erroneously asserted in the Summary of last week that Mr. Evarts approved of the.plan adopted. On the contrary, Mr. Evarts favor- ed the minority report, for a division of the Supreme Court into three Committees. Arguments in the Star-route trial, at Wasb- ington, proceeded slowly according to the pro- gramme announced last week. Mr. Carpenter spoke for the defence on Wednesday, conclud- ing his argument, and Mr. Chandler, counsel for Brady, followed. Colonel Bliss began his argument for the prosecution on Thursday afternoon, and finished on Friday. Mr. Wil- liams and Colonel Totten spoke for the defence on Mondav, the latter gentleman being suc- ceeded by Mr. McSweeny on Tuesday. Several more letters from ex-Senator Dorsey to the late President Gartield have been pub- lished. They are of a similar impertinent character with the first one, and are full of advice to him to give ample acknowledgment to the Stalwarts in all his nominations. It is estimated that the Government receipts for the present fiscal year will amount to $450,000, 000 The State Department, at Washington, is informed of the release of Messrs. McSweeny and Slattery, two of the alleged American ” ‘‘suspects”” who have been for some time imprisoned in Ireland. Secretary Lincoln, of the War Department, on Thursday appointed 200 new clerks for the pension service. The White House, at Washington, 1s being thoroughly renovated. The sewerage and ventilation are undergoing improvement. Secretary Chandler, of the Navy, 1s making a tour of inspection of the Navy-yards, in the United States steamer Tallapoosa. He visited Wilmington, Del., on Wednesday, and in- spected the unfinished monitor, Amphitrite. Several Government expeditions, to observe the transit of Venus, in December, left this country for the Southern Hemisphere during the week. Crop reports from the West continue to be favorable in the main. Oats are turning out well, but the crop will not meet the large esti- mates of a fortnight ago. The corn has been somewhat injured by cool weather. In New York State an increased yield is pro- mised in all crops, with the exception of corn. The Wampanoag Mills at Fall River, Mass., were compelled to shut down on Friday, on account of the strike of the spinners. The strike is extending among the driver-boys of the Pennsylvania coal mines. The strike at the Cohoes, N. Y., mills has virtually ended in favor of the mill-owners. Serious trouble was apprehended at the Pine Ridge Agency of the Sioux Indians last week. Troops were ordered to the seat of the diffi- culty. The trouble arose from dissatisfaction of Red Cloud with Agent McGillicuddy. The sentiment of the greater part of the tribe was against him, and he was forced to submit on Monday. He isnow on parole, and the chiefs and police of the tribe are responsible for his conduct. From Choctaw County, Alabama, it is re- ported that a bundle of papers recently found disclosed a plot on the part of negroes to kill all the white people in the county on a certain day, when a majority would be congregated ata camp-meeting. A meeting of the citizens of the county was held on Saturday last, at which 700 were present, 150 of them being negroes. After hearing the papers read it was decided by an almost unanimous vote that one of the negro leaders, Jack Turner, was a dangerous character, and that the public de- manded his immediate death. He was accord- ingly hanged that afternoon. Six other negroes are 1n jail awaiting further developments. Mr. Herbert Spencer arrived in this city, from England, on Monday afternoon. He is the guest of Prof. E. L. Youmans. His visit to this country is solely for his health. He will visit Chicago, St. Louis, Boston, and parts of Canada. Mr. Frederic de Peyster, LL.D.,one of the oldest and best-known citizens of New York, died at Tivoli, Dutchess Co., on Thursday night. He was eighty-six years of age. He was one of the oldest members of the Histori- cal Society, and was the author of a number of essays on historical and antiquarian sub- jects By profession he was a lawyer. Senator Benjamin Harvey Hill, of Georgia, died, at his home in Atlanta, on Wednes ay morning, surrounded by the members of his family. His illness began more than a year ago, but was not considered serious at first. He submitted to several operations upon his tongue, in Philadelphia, last fall, and a cure was predicted. But the cancer could not be conquered and finally resulted in his death. He was fifty-nine years of age. As a lawyer he was very successful; as an orator he was fervent and effective ; as a Senator he was pug- nacious, often inconsistent, but always sin- cere. At his home he was admired and re- spected for his manliness. His term in the Senate would have expired pext March. Dur- ing the war he was a member of the Confede- rate Senate. He was buried on Saturday with great ceremonies.

Page 5

Aug. 24, 1882] FOREIGN, After the arrival of Sir Garnet Wolseley, the British commander, at Alexandria, on August 15, military affairs in Egypt became more interesting. On Wednesday, General Wolseley, with the authority of the Khedive, issued a proclamation to the people of Egypt representing that the sole object of the British was to restore the authority of the Khedive, and that all peaceful inhabitants would be kind- ly treated. He then held a conference with Admiral Seymour and all the generals, in or- der to consult in regard to future action. An incident of the day was an encounter between a British mounted patrol and a party of 500 Bedouins, near Ramleh. Five of the latter were killed. On Thursday it was reported that General Wolseley had decided upon an early attack on the Abukir forts. Various reports were pub- lished as to his plans for the attack, but no- thing definite was known. On Friday a num- ber of the troops began to embark on the fleet in the harbor of Alexandria, and by evening the whole expedition was on board ready to start. At 1:15 Pp. mM. on Saturday the fleet steamed out of the harbor to the eastward. Ina few hours fighting was begun by the troops, along the Mahmudieh Canal, under the command of General Wood. He pushed a sharp reconnoissance of seven companies within 700 yards of the earthworks of Arabi, near Ramleh. A close examination of the works reveals that they are excellent, and that there are deep cuttings in advance of the en- trenchments. It was supposed that, simulta- neously with the fighting on land, the fleet would bombard the Abukir forts. The vessels arrived there on Saturday afternoon, but at half-past ten at night quietly steamed to the vastward. On Sunday morning they unex- pectedly arrived at Port Said, about three o'clock, and occupied it with 600 men. The Government of the Khedive was reinstated, and the Canal closed to merchant vessels. It then became evident that General Wolseley had made a very important movement, which the rumored bombardment of Abukir had effectually covered. Not even the brigade commanders were aware of the plan until they opened their sealed orders on Sunday morning. The occupation of the Canal occasioned a warm protest from M. de Lesseps. The French Government, on Monday, sent him an official communication inviting him to employ pru- dence and circumspection 1n his language. On Monday the whole fleet entered the Canal and steamed away to Ismailia. The traffic on the Canal will only be temporarily suspended. On Monday evening there was a slight skir- mish at Ismailia. All the shops at Port Said were opened on Monday afternoon, and the Arabs began to fraternize with the Europeans. The outposts at Ramleh made a demonstration in the after- noon, and some artillery shots were exchanged. The English met with no loss. On Tues- day Arabi’ began to erect fresh earthworks at Ramleh, and to strengthen his position. It is reported that the Arab tribe holding the terri- tory eastward of Bengazi, in Tripoli, is pre- paring to assist Arabi. A powerful chief, who is at the head of the national movement in Tripoli, is also reported to favor him. The majority of the French newspapers com- ment unfavorably on the action of the British in occupying Suez. Little has been accomplished by the Confer- ence at Constantinople during the week. The draft of the military convention pro- posed pe Porte to England was as follows : “The Turkish Army undertakes the pacifica- tion of Egypt without foreign assistance, the British to remain in their present positions and not to participate in the operations. The Turks shall be allowed to use Alexandria as a base of operations, and the Turks and British both to withdraw after the pacification of the country.” Lord Dufferin, the British Ambas- sador, rejected this and proposed in its stead that the Turks should not undertake opera- The Nation.

tions without the previous consent of the Bri- tish commander ; that British officers should be attached to the Turkish headquarters ; and that evacuation should be the subject of a spe- cial convention. Lord Dufferin was instruct- ed, on Thursday, not to press the Porte for a reply concerning the military convention. <A special Cabinet council was held in Constanti- nople on Saturday, and the Porte agreed to modify the Turkish dratt of the convention by the following additions: that an English general shall be attached to the Turkish camp to facilitate communications between the Turks and the British ; that the manceuvres of the troops shall be mutually carried out so as not to interfere with each other ; that a date shall be fixed for the evacuation of Egypt by the English. Lord Dufferin on Sunday assured Said Pasha that he was unable to accept the Turk- ish proposals, even in their new form. On Monday, Said promised Lord Dufferin that he would urge the Sultan to accept the British proposals. Sympathy is growing in Constantinople with Arabi Pasha, and the Sultan is understood to be more averse than ever to the issuance of the proclamation against him. The American Admiral Nicholson writes to the War Department denying that he warn- ed the Egyptians, betore the bombardment of Alexandria, that if they fired on any of his vessels, he would return the fire; he also denies that after the engagement he steamed around the English vessels and cheered them on their work, Mr. Long, the American Consul, was attack- ed on Friday, inside the Gabarri Gate at Alex- andria, by about forty natives. Some soldiers arrived and dispersed the crowd, and the ring- leaders were arrested. The only canse for the attack known is that Mr. Long refused to be stopped when he was driving, and, urging on his horse, injured some of the party. The report that the Ulemas of Egypt have deposed the Sultan is untrue. On the con- trary, they sent congratulatory telegrams to him from all parts of Egypt, on the Feast of Bairam. A deserter from Arabi’s camp arrived at Alexandria on Thursday, and gave a graphic description of the misery prevailing there. The wounded are uncared for, and even shot to end their misery. Many Egyptians have been compelled against their will to fight. The Khedive has summoned Riaz Pasha from’ France to join with Sherif Pasha in forming a combination Ministry under the Presidency of the Khedive.) Omar Pasha Luft: will probably retain the post of Minister of War. Great excitement was caused in Dublin on Wednesday, the day following the opening of the Exhibition, by the sentence of Mr. E. Dwyer Gray, member of Parliament and pro- prietor of the Freeman’s Journal, to three months’ imprisonment, and to pay a tine of $2,500, for contempt of court in publishing a letterot Mr. O’Brien, accusing the jury which recently convicted Francis Hynes of the mur- der of John Doloughty, of intoxication on the night previous to rendering the verdict, and in commenting thereon. Mr. Gray was then conveyed to Richmond prison. He was Lord Mayor of Dublin in 1880, At the presentation of the freedom of Dublin to Messrs. Parnell and Dillon, on Wednesday, great excitement was shown over the arrest. Mr. Parnell made a speech, advising calmness, and a proclamation was issued, sigued by the Lord Mayor and Messrs. Parneil, Dillon, and Davitt, urging the necessity of temperance in the emergency. In the House of Commons on Thursday, a letter was read by the Speaker, announcing the committal of Mr. Gray. Mr. Gladstone asserted that precedents in similar cases show that the appointment of a committee is the proper course. At the present period of the session, however, it was too late to secure the appointment of a representative commit-

tee. He did not, moreover, Know any way in which the committee could release Mr. Gray if they wished to doso. He therefore made a purely formal motion that the letter of Judge Lawson be placed on the table. A passing reference of Mr. Gladstone to an address to the Crown for the removal of Judge Lawson as one of the possible alternative courses was received with loud cheers from the Irish mem- bers. An animated debate ensued, in which the fact was brought out that Judge Lawson, who sentenced Mr. Gray, had prevented him from making a defence, and refused an ad- journment of the case. The debate was not resumed in the evening, and the matter was dropped. Mr. Gray’s newspaper, the Dublin Free- man’s Journal, on Friday said ; *‘ Mr. Gray's sentence is absolutely unparalleled. He only received notice of the nature of the proceed- ings against him on Tuesday night, and was without any time to prepare tus defence, which would probably have consisted of atti- -davits sustaining the truth of his published assertions.” It 1s generally anticipated that Mr. Gray will soon be released by Karl Spen- cer, and his fine remitted, On Thursday evening Mr. Gladstone moved, in the House of Commons, an adjournment from Friday until October 24. Lt was carried wthout adiscussion. Accordingly, on Friday, both Houses adjourned without any formality. A man named Joyce, and his family, con- sisting of his wife, mother, and daughter, were fired at and killed by a party of men in County Galway, Ireland, on Thursday eve- ning. It is believed in that locality that the Joyces gave information in regard to the mur der of the bailiffs of Lord Ardailoun. Alarming rumors were telegraphed from Paris and St. Petersburg on Friday that Rus sia was concentrating an army of 78,000 men in the Caucasus, and that she was about to oc- cupy the whole of Asia Minor to the Bospho- rus. An official denial of the reported con- centration of the troops was promptly issued at St. Petersburg. There was a concentration of Greek and Turkish troops on the frontier of Thessaly re- cently, near the border as settled by the Com- mission. Hostilities seemed imminent, but satisfactory explanations ensued, and the Turks withdrew. General Ducrot, a French soldier who took a prominent part in the Franco-Prussian war, died in Paris on ‘Thursday, at the age of sixty- tive. He was a grand oiticer of the Legion of flonor, and the author of several works on mili- tary subjects, among them a history of the de- tence of Paris in 1870-71. The steamer Hope, commanded by Sir Allen Young, C. B., which left England in Junc last in search of the steamer ‘i7a, has arrived at Peterhead, Scotland, with the entire crew of that vessel. The //ope picked them up in Matotchkin Straits, Nova Zembla, on the 3d of August, they having lost their ship ofi Franz-Josef Land and journeyed in boats to the straits through the ice. The ‘ira sailed from England in June, 1881, for Barentz Sea, the expedition being a private exploring enter- prise of her owner, Mr. Leigh Smith. Engineer Melville, and the seamen, Ninder- man and Noros, /eannette survivors, were given a grand reception at Moscow on their ar- rival there on Wednesday. Admiral Feodor Litke, the celebrated Rus- sian navigator, died on Monday, at the age of eighty-five. He accompanied Captain Golov- nin in his voyage round the world in 1817-1. He was the founder of the Russian Geographi- cal Society. The intention of the British Government to restore Cetewayo to his kingdom causes cov - sternation at Durban, South Africa. The troubles in Corea have culminated in an insurrection, and the King and Queen have been assassinated. The Japanese legation was attacked by the natives belonging to the anti- foreign party,

Page 6

150 DORSEY S CAREER. THE Heraw yocished on Tuesday some letters of L) iscy’s to an Arkansas postmaster, written in 1877, but relating to a transaction revented from furnishing mute- rials for pro ‘ution by the statute of limita- tions. Inthe he invites the postmaster, oue Clendenning,t 0 ©: in a batch of surety bonds to be signed by a.ysoatv, and to certify to “the pecuniary ability sna responsibility ” of this anybody, and then sena tacn. on to Wash- ington to be used by Dorsey in gei i, Hi8 fraudulent contracts. The correspondeue is a perfect specimen of the swirfdler’s ur!. The first letter is very affectionate, an! only introduces the subject of the bonds which he desired ‘‘ made for a friend, »itet some expressions of friendly interest and hints how to keep his office so that ‘‘ there would be no trouble,” but concludes with a solemn warn- ing ‘‘ under no possible circumstances to let any one know from whom they (the bonds) came.” Clendenning, however, proved to be an honest man, and pointed out to the Senator that he was inviting him to commit a crime. This drew from Dorsey what is probably as good a detected criminal’s letter as ever was written. He knew nothing about these bonds whatever. The request he Lad made was simply to oblige a friend, and, having failed, he cared no more about the mattcr. But he was surprised that the tone of Clendenning’s letter should have been a ‘‘li''2e harsh.” ‘It sounds,” says he, ‘‘as if tad asked you to do an unlawful act, whic:: yeu proposed to decline with implied indig sition.” He was shocked at this imputation, ic] he showed the harsh letter to another po ‘t.vaster, who said there was nothing in Clen !esiaing’s scruples, and that he certified bondsia this way by the hundred. So Mr. Dorsey c'osed with a gentle reproach to Clendennin « for doubt'ng his in- tegrity, and told him to sen.l the bonds to some one e'se or burn them up, it being “a matter of tote. indifference” to him (Dor- sey) what becai of them. Curiously ¢no.yi. another letter of his of exactly the same daic - s the letter to Clenden- ning, and adtiressed t. another postmaster, whcse confirmation was made while the letter Was en its way, Is a'so been unearthed, making precisely th» same request, almost in the same terms, also for ‘‘ an intimate friend,” but as ‘‘a special favor to him,” and also *‘unaer no circumstances ” to be made known reanybody. Whether le succeeded better in | 3¢case than in the other does not appear; but the correspondence in both shows clearly that the man was really ap habitual criminal, and vas pursuing fraud on the Government through politics as a profession, and with all the dodges, in the way of tones, and gestures, and cant, of the regular pickpocket. What is most interesting in his case is not, however, his rascality, for nothing is commoner than this. His little yames as a criminal could be carried on just as successfully and neatly by scores cf confidence men in all the great cities of the Umion. What makes his case a remark- able one is the fact that he was able to bring nigh official position to the support of his real occupation. Great interest was excited some years ago by the cxtiaordinary cleverness of which was ,

[Number 895

sone Ancrican swindlers in England, who, simply :a order to defraud a London bank, actually forme a partnership in a provincial town, and wok the trouble to carry on a legitimate business for two years. This was a very remarkable example of far-reaching forethought and persistence on the part of members of the criminal class, but it really falls short of Dorsey's in brilliancy and tenacity, for he seems te have climbed into the United States Senate, and to have suc- cessfully assumed and played the rdéle of a statesman and party leader, for the simple purpose of stealing the public money; and by stealing we do not mean corruption in the ordimary serse cf the term, but the plain frau: o: the police courts, committed through pertacy and .orgery. We cannot recail anythin “ike *#'3 in modern times. “Met. of high potitics pos'tion have before now fallen victims to pecuu ary temptation, but they had attained their high political position through their political talents and attainments before they fell. They rose, in short, because they weie worthy to rise, and were overcome by 3 rovel strain on their in- tegrity. But Dorsey seems to have risen and become one of the great men of the state for the purpose of swindling ; which is very much as if a man were to pursue a laborious career at the bar in order to reach the bench and thus have decisions to sell. His case is certainly, therefore, a very in- teresting one, and one which will repay the study of other people besides political re- formers. ‘Pe these it is most interesting, as showing the way in which the spoils system keeps Senators constantly on the verge of transactions which, even if they do not take the form of ordinary fraud, will not bear ex- amination. The systemis one, in short, which some men may carry on and remain pure, but to which no wise man will expose himself if he can help it, and of which any corrupt man may readily make use for the worst a STATE OWNERSHIP OF RAILWAYS IN ITALY. Tue Italian Government, having purchased all the railways in Italy, finds an elephant on its hands. In order to get at all the facts bearing on the case, a Railroad Commission was constituted in 1878 to ascertain, if pos- sible, how far the present railroad system served the interests of the state, and whether any other system was better. After nearly three years’ work, during which sessions were held in almost all the principal Italian cities, the Commission made its report in seven large folio volumes. The last volume contains a summary of the arguments and conclusions of the Commission and is espe- cially worthy of notice. We depend for our points upon a review of the work in a Ger- man economic periodical. At the close of the year 1879 there were in operation in Italy 8,348 kilometres of railroad, of which the state owned 5,384 kilometres, was part owner of 444 kilometres more, and operated 564 kilometres belonging to private parties. By the close of 1880 the state had practically come into possession of all the

railways on the peninsula of any importance, without, however, being altogether satisfied with the result. As far back as 1874, the pro- position was made by the Government to lease the railways then owned to private par- ties, but 1t was rejected by Parliament; and, on a renewal of it in 1877, when it was again rejected, the Railroad Commission was consti- tuted to investigate the question. The report first discusses the railroad as an industrial en- terprise. The operation of railways cannot state. He who cowstfers it as such has a Fase conception of the state, is, if logical, a So- cialist, and would end by favoring the abso- lutism of the state. The operation of a rail- way is aseries of processes partly industrial and partly commercial. It is in every respect a mere branch of business. It is objected that this business is a monopoly. But it is tem- pered by the competition of other transporta- tion agencies. And, even where this is not the case, since it is the function of the state to protect the interests of the public against the abuse of the railroads, they are naturally better protected when the state is not at once interested party and judge. Some have expected that freight tariffs would be lower on public railways, but facts disappoint the expectation. The state has, on the contrary, in some countries actually in- creased freight rates by the introduction of a tax on transportation. In Italy, during the five years following the establishment of the tax, the consequent increase in rates amounted to 73,000,000 lire. In several instances where the management of the roads proposed to lower the rates the Government refused to allow it, lest the burden of paying the interest on the bonds should prove too heavy; and ‘in many states the financial condition would jus- tify such a fear; The state might also treat the freight tariff as a tax and increase it ad liitum. For 1876 the expenses of operating amounted to the following per cent. of the gross income in the countries named : Public Private roads. roads. ED aE re 59 53 Austria-Hungary.... ...... 7 50 Re Re 63 59 ES din s5s5s<6ue%eee 71 55 +149 bodgaaaneke.caeank 74 63 See 63 57 On the average, the running expenses of state roads amounted to 67 per cent., and of private roads to 56 per cent., of the gross in- come. On the basis of these facts the Frenci Railroad Commission declared in 1878 that the comparative study of these two systems of management, and the tables exhibiting its re- sults, proved that everywhere, in Italy, Ger- many, Austria, Belgium, state management had been more costly. It has been objected, again, that private railroads, in the pursuit of their own selfish ends, will be likely to sacrifice the permanent interests of the community for the sake of some temporary advantage to themselves. But it must be remembered that the interests of the railroads and those of the community | are in the long run identical. Railroads can be permanently prosperous only so Tong as the community is prosperous. Moreover, the railroads, being generally chartered for a long or indefinite period, can afford to make tem- porary sacrifices for the sake of future advan-

tages, and are therefore not likely to come in

Page 7

Aug. 24, 1882] The Nation. conflict with the permanent interest of the community, even if they are left without state control. On the other hand must be considered the influences which work against economy under state management, such as the constantly increasing demands of the gene- ral public for better accommodations, greater speed, and more frequent trains. Parliament- ary governments are rarely able to withstand such pressure. Already trains are run on the Italian railways with little or no business. The public demands much and wishes to pay but little. The report considers with great detail the political and economical dangers connected witha state system of railways. The concen tration of power in the hands of the Govern- ment, and the abuse of that power in the spheres of production, exchange, and con- sumption, lead toinnumerable inconveniences, darken and confuse the simple relation be- tween state and subject, make parliamentary control difficult, and render even an approxi- mately correct budget impossible. The Italian railroads employ more than 54,000 officers, who, with the other public officers, represent an army of 120,000 men. These are scattered throughout the land, appear at elections as political factors, and depend upon the Gov- ernment, from which alone they have to ex- pect favors. In the year 1879 the Alta Italia gave notice of 120 places to be filled by competition. 2,731 candidates ap- peared. Of these 2,731, 2,611 had to be re- jected. Is it not probable that these discon- tented persons appeared at election time as dangerous elements? Nor must we forget that nowadays every one who aspires to even the most unimportant position takes care to provide himself with recommendations from influential politicians, and that the Govern- ment is compelled in its choice of candidates to strengthen its own party. As a conse- quence, neither rewards nor punishments are fairly distributed. If, therefore, a state bu- reaucracy 1s, under the best conditions, poorly adapted to undertake business enterprises, a set of officers who are neither rewarded nor punished as they deserve will certainly perform their services indifferently. When the Alta Italia passed into the hands of the state, there was a marked deterioration in the disci- pline and industry of a formerly very excel- lent body of employees. The state, again, acquires too large powers of interference in the whole economic life of the nation. It becomes the greatest under- taker, and thus it will determine prices and usages. Other undertakers must follow suit; but there is a great difference between them and the state. The state simply shifts its losses upon the taxpayers; but what are the private undertakers to do, who in the long run must bear both their own losses and those of the state (in the form of higher taxes)? Besides, many difficulties will arise from the laborers themselves, In the workshops alone of three great Italian railroads there are over 9,000 laborers employed. The state will, of course, as railroad operator, own coal and iron mines, and thus have control of an army of workmen. If they demand higher wages, the state will often be compelled to yield. As a strike against the state assumes the character of a riot, in the absence of an impartial judge the state (which is an interested party) must proceed against the laborers with its own police or, perhaps, military. This the Gov- ernment would be slow to do, at the expense of its own popularity. And what would the taxpayers have to say to all this? It can easily be seen how, under such circumstances, the relations between state and subject would be come strained. Further, a great economical interest is en- trusted to an administration whose head changes with every change in the parliamen- tary majority. Parliamentary control is no control at all. Even now the final balances in the public accounts remain unsettled for years, to be disposed of in two or three hours. Besides, as a matter of fact, the railroad bureaus undertake enterprises and make contracts without any authority from Par- liament. And how is it possible to hamper and cripple the management, with its ever- varying necessities, by tying it fast to a budget? But if this is impossible, of what value is parliamentary control when a budget of two milliards (as, for instance, in France) is withdrawn from its supervision? From all these considerations the Commission concludes that the system of state railways endangers political freedom; the power of the Ministry is enormously increased ; personal interests be- come hopelessly involved with those of the public welfare, of politics and administration ; they corrupt each other, and thus the form of liberty may be preserved while its substance has been lost. The Commission recommends, therefore, that the state should lease its rail- ways to private companies, the latter to pay all running expenses and outlays for repairs, and also the interest on capital invested by the state. The companies might either pay a certain fixed rent or a given per cent. of their gross income. We have no space for a discussion of the views above presented. Many of them are just, some exaggerated, and one or two proba- bly false. The Commission evidently has large faith in the results of free competition, and, as it seems to us, too great a fear of state interference. The Italian civil service we might infer to be in much the same condi- tion as our own, from the distrust of the efficiency and honesty of the Government sys- tem which the Commission evidently has, and which is quite as evidently based on Italian experience. The report is worthy our careful study. SOCIETY AND ADVERTISING. THE announcement that a young London club man, well known in Society, is going on the stage, following close upon the heels of Mrs. Langtry’s engagement, has caused some excitement in London, and the usual discus- sion as to whether he is likely to ‘‘ succeed” in his new venture. Of course, speculations of this sort are not worth much except among those who have actually had some means of judging, but it should be observed that suc- cess in such a case has two entirely different meanings. A “society” man or woman who takes to acting may make a hit from having real dramatic talent ; on the other hand, what the French call a success of curi- 151 osity is almost certain, from the mere fact that Society is interested in the event. The success will be in proportion to the amount of social notoriety the person who makes the attempt enjoys ; but almost any one is sure of a certain share of it. It is evident, from the discussions in the Lon- don papers, that London Society enjoys having Mrs. Langtry become an actress, and for a variety of reasons. It has one more thing to talk about, and its own importance 4s increased by one of its leading members doing something eccentric and original, If, after the disturbance which took place some time ago in the Union Club in this city, Mr. Loubat or Mr. Turnbull had suddenly gone on the stage, he would undoubtedly have had an immediate and phenomenal success, though whether either of them has any dramatic abili- ty, it 1s of course impossible for any one to tell. The reformers who are always urging a rapprochement between Society and the stage, and the impossibility of actors leading good and pure lives unless their art is recognized as entitling them to an assured position in Society, ought to be pleased with such at tempts as Mrs. Langtry’s and Mr. Farquhar’s If they were to become common—and there is every probability that a good many of them will be made—it would be impossible for Society to regard its life as something apart from that of actors and actresses. Society can hardly give better proof of the feebleness of the old social prejudice against the stage than by its members adopting it as a profession It may be said that the notoriety attendant upon débuts of this kind is very offensive, and that Society, being based on the principle of seclusion and reserve, must in the long run discountenance them and cast off such of its members as make them. But this view is based on the antique theory of Society asa close corporation, governed by strict rules, transmitted mainly by inheritance—a body which only exists by rigidly excluding those who do not conform to its code. But Society as it now exists is not like this at all. For ex- clusiveness and reserve it has substituted no- toriety and advertising. It has in England, from which country we derive at present our social ideas, a regularly organized machinery for the purpose. In fact, it is hardly too much to say that Society is getting to be something like a circus, in which the So- ciety newspapers play the part of advertising wagons and brass bands. It announces and describes its parties, balls, dinners, games, rides, drives, with the same publicity that Bar- num gives his performances. Its leading per- formers acquire the same world-wide noio- riety that attaches to the ‘‘ queens of the air” who are able to take flying leaps through six hoops, and their photographs are to be bought at the same stores. The notion that Society is managed by a very exclusive and fastidious body, which has a holy horror of publicity and sensationalism, is a survival from a period when it really was exclusive, and is wholly unsupported by the facts as they exist. It enjoys and promotes just the same sensationalism that we lament so much in the Church, but which is, after al}, characteristic of the Church as it exists. It

Page 8

152 rejoices in anything that will bring its per- formances tothe notice of the world at large, and imagines that its interests are advanced by this. This tendency must often suggest a wonder as to what is going to become of Society in the future. of the sort in the world, thing more than the orgamzed pursuit of pleasure. But now that it has become recog- nized that a great part of the pleasure consists in being seen in the act of taking it, and that Society has become a show, and advertises its attractions, it many op- portunities which it never had before. The esthetic tour of Oscar Wilde, under the ma- nagement of a showman who also ran a burlesque of him, gives us a hint of what we have to look for in the social world. Mr. Wilde took up estheticism much as Mrs. Langtry and Mr. Farquhar are taking up the stage. Mr. Wilde’s whole capital as a reformer comes from Society, which first took him up from its liking for anything odd, and then caricatured him into notoriety. Society is capable of producing many more such attrac- tions, and would really offer a fine field to Barnum, were it not that, from the nature of the case, it has to be its own showman. There always must be something for Society is no- has a great THE PARLIAMENTARY CRISIS. Lonpon, August 10, 1882. As the strong point of the British Constitution is its flexibility, its indefiniteness, its capability of being stretched and twisted to suit the exi- gencies of an unexpected case, so its weak point is the existence in it of a variety of powers which are expected to work in harmony with one another, but which may by their discord and collision bring about a deadlock. The House of Lords, as everybody knows, is in theory a co- ordinate power with the House of Commons. Its consent is equally necessary to every act of legis- lation (setting aside the different functions of the two bodies as regards money bills), and no means exists of overriding its resistance to a measure which the House of Commons may have passed by the most overwhelming majorities, except the extraordinary one of creating Peérs sufficient to change the balance of parties in the Upper House. Practically, it has be- come of late years a received maxim that when the country has been appealed to by a general election, and has given its decision be- tween the programmes placed before it by the two rival parties, the House of Lords ought to bow to that decision. But of course it is often inconvenient to have a general election, both because it is a very heavy fine upon members and because it disturbs the regular course of government at home and abroad. When, there- fore, a Prime Minister cannot dissolve Parlia- ment, and finds himself in conflict with the ma- jority of the House of Lords, he is really without any constitutional remedy. He can only appeal to public opinion, and if the Peers deem that public opinion is against them, or are willing to defy it, they can checkmate him—checkmate him for the moment; for, of course, there is a fear of penalties which may result in future. Such a deadlock between the two Houses has often been dreaded, and has several times seemed on the point of straining the Constitution beyond what its aged frame could bear. The most famous instance was before the passing of the Reform Bill of 1832, when it was with the great- est difficulty, and only by fears of a revolution, that the Lords were brought to yield. We had The Nation. another a year ago, apropos of the Irish Land Act, when the Lords introduced amendments to which the Commons objected as destroying the value of the measure. For two days the crisis was very acute, and then it became known that the Peers would yield in substance, while re- ceiving some formal concessions to soothe their feelings. We have now just had asimilar crisis, very like the last in most of its features, and specially like in the behavior of Lord Salisbury and Mr. Gladstone respectively. The occasion was a smaller one, because the Irish Arrears Bill of this year is a far less considerable measure than was the Irish Land Bill of last year, but the situation was in some respects more complicated and more dangerous, for Mr. Gladstone’s Govern- ment is not so strong now as 1t was then, so that there was a greater temptation to the Tory lead- ers to play for a dissolution of Parliament, while at the same time the state of foreign affairs, with a war just beginning in Egypt, and a possibility of diplomatic difficulties with Turkey and per- haps other European Powers, makes a dissolution a far more inconvenient and even dangerous course. It is not worth while to trouble you with the minor points of difference between the two Houses as to this Arrears Bill. The principal were these two: Ought the application to the Land Court for the benefit of the Act to be open to either the landlord alone or the tenant alone, as the bill proposed, or ought it, as Lord Salis- bury’s amendment insisted, to be made only by landlord and tenant jointly, so that the landlord would have the power, if he chose, of preventing the tenant from applying? Ought the value of the ‘‘tenant-right,” as it is called—that is, the proceeds of the sale of the tenant’s interest when it may come to be sold—to stand charged with the payment of the arrears from the present payment whereof the Act relieves the tenant ? The bill of the Government, while giving the Court a discretion as to whether they would or not take into account the value of the tenant- right in estimating the tenant’s ability to pay, did not charge the arrears upon the tenant-right when a sale should take place. The House of Lords proposed that such a charge should exist. The bill went up to the House of Lords in the end of July. It was read a second time without a division, Lord Salisbury, as leader of the Op- position, announcing that he proposed to amend it in Committee; and when Committee came, these two amendments, with others of less mag- nitude, were passed not only by considerable majorities, but with a good deal of strong and bold language, Lord Salisbury denouncing the bill in vehement words, and some of his hotter followers declaring that this time there must be no surrender; that the bill was a disgraceful concession to Irish agitators; that the House of Commons was far too subservient to Mr. Glad- stone; that the country would support the Peers in resisting his dictatorship, with much more to the same effect. This attitude startled and alarmed the Lower House, who had by this time become very weary of the Arrears Bill, of all Irish affairs, and in- deed of legislation altogether—no more unprofit- able session having been seen for many years past. Even the most careless were anxious to get away from work and London altogether, and in no mood for a fresh struggle, while serious politicians felt that the time was a bad one for a crisis which might weaken or even paralyze the executive. The usual course would have been for the House of Commons to proceed forthwith to consider the Lords’ amendments. Mr. Glad- stone, however, adjourned them for some days, prudently desiring to take time to consider what course his Ministry should pursue, and also to allow the opinion of the country to be fully ex” | Number 895 pressed and to tell upon the House of Lords. He doubtless also hoped that an interval of re- flection would sober down the passion for com- bat, if not of Lord Salisbury himself, at least of a part of his supporters. An anxious week elapsed, everybody asking everybody else what the Lords would do, and the barometer, so to speak, falling and rising from day to day. The hotter Tories argued thus: Mr. Gladstone’s Ministry has been discredited by the barrenness of the present session, by its Irish policy, by the outbreak of hostilities in Egypt. It has lost its hold on the country. If it ventures to dissolve Parliament, it may be defeated, and wiil at any rate come back witha greatly dimimshed ma- jority. If when stopped by the House of Lords it does not dissolve Parliament, it may resign; and in that case we can come in, carry on the administration for some months, keep Ireland in order by stringently using the Prevention of Crime Act, have a successful campaign in Egypt, and then, on the strength of these achievements, dissolve and get a majority from the country. If, finally, Mr. Gladstone neither dissolves nor re- signs, he will at any rate be damaged by the check the Lords will have given him;.and a measure wrong in principle and not likely to do any permanent good to Ireland will have been averted. The country is far too much disgusted with legislative remedies for Irish ills to care what becomes of this bill, or to resent the con- duct of the Peers in rejecting it. These arguments were zealously urged by minor Tory speakers, and still more by Tory newspapers, our Conservative press generally going further and faster than its leaders do. On the other hand, the more cautious Conservative statesmen pointed out that if the resistance of the House of Lords provoked a dissolution, the blame of it and of all the injury to our foreign policy which it might involve would be thrown on the Lords; that the chief cry at the election would be a cry against the House of Lords; that this would in fact rehabilitate the Liberal Min- istry and make its shortcomings forgotten. Even if Mr. Gladstone were to resign, the time was not a good one for the Tories to come in and succeed him. They could not count on a major- ity, and to be in office with the House of Com- mons against them, or even with a very small majority, would be an unfortunate position, dangerous to their future prospects. These reasonings had their effect: the Tory leaders in the House of Commons showed no alacrity for a contest; the feeling of the Tories throughout the country did not promise much zeal in case of a general election; at last the Tory Peers them- selves who had supported Lord Salisbury began secretly to waver and doubt whether the ground was a good one on which to give battle to the Commons. When on the evening of Tuesday, the 8th of August, Mr. Gladstone brought the Lords amendments before the House of Com- mons, it was already beginning to be understood that the crisis was virtually over. Nobody could say that anything had happened; nobody could give any good reason for his belief; yet everybody felt that the thunder-cloud was moving away. The Prime Minister’s speech was an instance of that wonderful skill, tact, and delicacy which he can put forth on great occa- sions; it was eminently respectful and concilia- tory toward the House of Lords, and spared all their susceptibilities, while yet intimating a firm resolve to stand by all the essential points of the bill. Some of their minor amendments were to be accepted; others were to be recast; they were to be dealt with neither hostilely nor, as he expressed it, ‘‘in a huxtering spirit.” This moderate and dignified attitude partly contri- buted to the largeness of the majority—one hun- dred and thirty-six—by which his dissent from

Page 9

Aug. 24, 1882] Lord Salisbury’s principal amendment was car- ried. When the numbers were announced it was felt that the struggle was ended, not so much on account of the mere difference in numbers, as because it was plain that the Tory party had not put forth its full strength. Some of its most judicious and respected members refused to vote, and it was certain that the feelings which moved them would move the Peers also. So it has now turned out. This evening, after a previous private meeting with his supporters in the House of Lords, Lord Salisbury has de- clared that though he retains all his objections to certain parts of the Bill, and would reject them if he could, the bulk of his party does not agree with him, so that he has no choice but to give way, while disclaiming all responsibility for “an act of robbery.” We are thus in smooth water again. The remaining business of the ses- sion will be chiefly formal. The country will breathe again after the mingled excitements and vexations of the last six months. Nothing will remain from this latest constitutional crisis ex- cept a strengthened distrust of Lord Salisbury’s leadership by the more moderate Tories, and a strengthened desire to agitate against the exist- ence of the House of Lords among the less moderate Whigs. ¥. “PARSIFAL” AT BAYREUTH. A RETROSPECT. BAYREUTH, August 1, 1882. Franz Liszt wrote to a friend in 1875, after listening to about twenty rehearsals of the “Ring of the Nibelung” at Bayreuth: ‘‘ It over- tops and commands our whole art-epoch as Mont Blane does the other mountains.” In “ Parsi- fal” a new summit has been raised by the vol- canic force of genius, but it belongs to another chain. Itis the culminating point of religious music, which has only once before, in Bach’s Passion Music, reached to a similar height. An agnostic confessed to me, after listening to ‘‘ Par- sifal,” that in this dramatic apotheosis of religious music he had for the first time realized what was meant by religious emotion. Those unfamiliar with the details of Wagner's life are apt to imagine that old age, which naturally turns men’s thoughts toward religious affairs, explains the choice of such a subject for his last drama. But Wagner’s interest in religious symbolism is of much older standing, as his oft-expressed ad- miration for Palestrina and Bach alone would have sufficed to show. In 1843 he composed for a music festival a Biblical scene, ‘‘ Das Liebes- mabl der Apostel,” and six years later he con- ceived the plan of writing a work on the subject of Jesus of Nazareth, which, however, he subse- quently laid aside asimpracticable. The former work has probably, and the latter beyond doubt, furnished some of the poetic motives for ‘‘ Parsi- fal.” By transferring his conceptions to the mystic regions of mythology, they became avail- able for theatrical purposes, and the result was “ Parsifal,” which its author appropriately called neither a music drama nor simply a festival drama, but a festival-consecration drama—why, only those can appreciate who have heard it; for it is a matter of feeling, not of intellect. A German critic has already expressed his fears that.the religious feelings of some people will be offended by some of the scenes and pro- ceedings in “ Parsifal.” I cannot believe this, unless religion be synonymous with the crudest bigotry and ignorance. Nevertheless, it is doubt- ful if Herr Neumann could obtain permission to produce this work on the London stage next spring, or as long as the present laws in regard to the exclusion of religious subjects from the theatrical stage prevail in England. On the concert or oratorio stage, of course, Biblical per- 4 The Nation. sonages may appear in dress coat and kid gloves and sing those love songs which Handel transfer- red from his worldly operas to his oratorios; but they may not, on the dramatic stage, walk and act in appropriate costumes singing appropriate music. The distinction is one of those profound subtleties which my feeble mind is utterly un- able to comprehend, all the more as the modern drama is generally derived from medizval reli- gious miracle plays, The stage, it is true, is often, or let us even admit commonly, used for frivolous purposes; but is that any reason why, therefore, any class of pure and noble subjects, which cannot but refine the audience, should be excluded from it altogether ? surd. As given at Bayreuth the performances of ‘*Parsifal” extend over six hours—from 4 to 10 —ouly four of which, however, are devoted to the drama, the remaining time being devoted to recreation in the open air or refreshments in a restaurant, whence the hearers are summoned to their seats again by the Parsifal or Grail motive blown by trombones and a trumpet on the bal- cony. These long intermissions suggest the per- formances in the davs of Bach, when part of a long religious work was given in the morning and part in the afternoon. Over-fatigue is thus avoided, and the third act, which is the grandest of all, is much more appreciated than would be possible in any other place where such an ar- rangement would not be feasible. That the four hours of music are not exclusively of a religious character is self-evident, as Wagner is too great a dramatist to overlook the necessity of contrasts. In the second act we have the weird, gloomy sce- nery and music of the wizard Klingsor, followed by the brilliant colors of the magic flower garden (suggesting the Venusberg in ‘Tannhiiuser”’), the captivating forms of the flower-decked girls, and the sensuous charm of their song. In the first we have remiaiscences of ‘‘ Lohengrin,” the death of the swan, followed by the reproaches of Gurnemanz, which are expressed in poetic language of the greatest beauty, introducing a most touching episode. Kundry’s mysterious character, with its various psychic transforma- tions—now as the wandering, unhappy bearer of a great curse, now as the submissive servant of the Grail, and again as the lovely, alluring slave of Klingsor—gives scope for effective con- trasts aud bold situations. Parsifal unites with the character of a saviour that of a second Steg- fried, who grows up in a forest, ignorant of the world and its ways and of any but the natural love of woman, until he meets Kundry, whom he relieves from her curse by resisting her blind, delusive temptations, The unhappy Am/fortas, a modern Philoctetes. appeals to our pity, even as the wounded Tristan in the drama of that name. Gurnemanz is an admirably- drawn character, to whom some of the most melodious and expressive music is allotted, notavly the sublime benediction motive after the anointment of Parsifal—one of those scenes which make the poor critic realize most vividly the immense superiority of musical expression to the written words which fain would give an idea of its beauty. It has been repeatedly asserted that Wagner bas in ‘“‘ Die Meistersinger,” and again in “ Parsi- fal,” ‘‘ gone back on himself” to a certain extent by abandoning some of his theoretical notions and reverting to his second, semi-operatic period. He has done no such thing. ** Parsifal” is in its form as perfect an embodiment of his theories as is “ Tristan,” with which it has much in com- mon, especially in harmonic structure and in the Amfortas music. Nowhere has the skeleton of the music-drama, the system of leading motives, reached such absolute formal perfection as in “ Parsifal.” These leading motives characterize The logic is ab- 153 the general emotional aspect of each person in the drama as vividly as the poem itself. They are usually assigned to the orchestra, but are not played each time a person speaks or acts. Parsi fal may sing for ten minutes and his own motive not be heard once, unless reference is made to his own peculiar mission in the dramatic plot. These motives have a three-fold import. They are al ways admirably adapted to the prevailing ‘*tone” of each character, be it frivolous, senti mental, heroic, gloomy, tender, or ferocious; and no one succeeds better than Wagner in em bodying each person’s “tone” in tones, Then they gain a great psychological value in the drama by calling up a presentiment of a com- ing event, as when Aundry in the first act falls into her sleep of exhaustion, while Alingsor’s magic motive is heard; and in the second act we behold KAlingsor invoking her to the same music ; whereby the two events are at once connected in the mind. Thirdly, a leading motive can serve as a reminiscence, and thus associate the past with the present in one moment, while it would require many minutes to explain the same situation in words or by a scenic change. In these three elements lies the epoch making value of the leading motives, Wagner's motives are of great rhythmic, melo dic, or harmonic beauty, and almost always of plastic simplicity, so that they can be easily re tained in the memory. Often, however, they possess no particular charm in their primitive skeleton form, and no more suggest the gor geously colored instrumental tapestry the com poser weaves with them than themes suggest the wonderful builds on them. The vocal parts of the actors are in “ Parsi fal” in the same accordance with the style of “Tristan” and the ‘** Nibelungen.” We have here neither old-fashioned melody or tune nor recitative, but something intermediate between the two, which allows the words to be clearly spoken while retaining a melodious flow. The proper word for it is melodious declamation. But there is also a good deal of choral music in ‘*Parsifal ”; and in this it might seem as if there were a case of ‘ reversion” to the ‘* Lohengrin” period. Wrongagain. Wagner does not assert that choral music should be banished altogether from the stage, but only when its introdu tion has no other aim than that of producing “effect,” by making music the end and the drama the means, instead of vice versa. The stage isa mirror of life, and in its proper place a chorus can be as dramatic as anything else. Even the florid melodies we hear in Italian operas might under some conditions be called dramatic ; if, for instance, the scene were laid in the room of a singing-teacher giving a lesson in trills, runs, and fioriture in general to one of his pupils. In an otherwise appreciative notice of ‘Die Meistersinger,” an English critic lately said that ‘inthe final scene the three choruses of shoemakers, tailors, and bakers, most charming and genuinely comic as they are, can hardly be justified by the compos- er’s theories.” Yes, they can. If Wagner brings a Volksfest on the stage, nothing can be more dramatic than the introduction of such proces- sions, songs and dances, for they are an exact reproduction of the scenes which have often been witnessed in that Niirnberg meadow, famous for its historical processions. So, in ‘ Par- sifal,” the choruses of knights, youths, and boys are highly dramatic in effect, as they help the hearer to realize fully the ecclesiastic situation and to forget that he is a mere specta- tor before the stage. Even the ‘ four-storied” arrangement of these choruses is justifiable ; for when the Grail motive is taken up successively in a higher position first by the knights on the hearer’s Bach's fuga! structures he

Page 10

154 stage, then by the youths midway up the cupola, then by the boys at the top, and finally by the violins in their highest position, down in the mystic abyss, the effect is quite ethereal and superterrestrial ; it is an effect with a cause, and in accordance with the situation, and not an ‘effect without a cause,” as in the operas of Meyerbeer and others. in its dramatic structure “ Parsifal” is equal to the best of its predecessors. It would be a mere truism to say to-day that no dramatic poet ever had a more admirable instinct for stage effect than Wagner, Shakspere not excepted. Even the long episodic narratives which contain the exposition are exceedingly interesting if every word is as distinctly pronounced as it is by some of the vocalists assembled here, notably by Scaria, who is the lion of the present festival, although Materna, Brandt, Hill, and Winkel- mann are very close approaches to him. The poetry of “ Parsifal” is, of course, devoid as a rule of rhetorical embellishments, figures of speech, and similes, for these are here supplied by the music, which is like the soul breathed into the dramatic body. There are some beautiful exceptions to this statement, which space alone forbids my quoting. A ‘‘reversion” might be imagined in the fact that rhyme is introduced, were it not that in this ‘“‘ Christian” drama this is quite in place, as Wagner himself has ex- plained that rhymed verse is the characteristic form of Christian poetry. Alliteration, on the other hand, is not resorted to in this drama. The repetition of a number of soft or harsh consonances in one word intensifies the general tone of softness or harshness of the situation, and is therefore desirable in a drama like Tristan,” but not in a religious drama like ‘** Parsifal,” where the tone must be more quiet and subdued, even as the music itself, which is more solemn, majestic, and ethereal than in Wagner’s worldly dramas. “ Parsifal,” I re- peat, rightly bears the name of ‘“‘stage-conse- crating play,” for by it the stage is consecrated for religious purposes, I cannot close my Bayreuth correspondence without a parting reference to the theatre in which these performances are taking place. Of the successful ensemble I have already spoken, and it would not be worth while at this distance to compare the merits of the singers who alter- nate in their rdles. But to the theatre itself at- tention cannot be often enough called, for it is the only existing theatre in which a complete il- lusion is attained ; and if at the present day an architect undertakes to build an opera-house on any old-fashioned system, be can only be accused of either great wilfulness or gross ignorance. I earnestly hope that if a new opera-house is to be built in New York, the Bayreuth model may be taken into consideration. The very en- trance puts the spectator in an artistic mood. The whole theatre is one parquet, in the shape of an amphitheatre, each row rising above its predecessor, so that up to the royal boxes in the background one seat is about as good as another. There are no boxes at the sides, their places being taken by simple but handsome columns, between which are the twelve exits by means of which the whole house can be emptied in two minutes. Especially advantageous is the absence of a proscenium box connecting the stage with the auditorium. Its place is taken by an open space between the last columns and the stage, leading down into the mystic abyss in which the invisible orchestra is at work. The effect of this open space is that it makes the stage seem further removed, while the figures on it are as large as before, and, in consequence, by a familiar optical illusion, everything seems larger and more distinct, the difference between our ordinary stages and that of the Wagner The Nation. {Number 895 theatre being similar to that between a photo- graph and a stereoscopic view. This optical illusion is rendered the more complete by the invisibleness of the musicians and the con- ductor to the audience, although the conductor is visible, of course, to the vocalists. The sounds rising from the mystic abyss are not localized by the hearer. They seem to come from the stage itself—to hover about the singers as its fragrance does about a rose; and the music thus gains that exquisite charm which alone be- longs to invisible music, as all those know who have ever been waked up in the morning by a serenade. The sounds, too, are somewhat sub- dued, so that the singers are never ‘ drowned,” as so often happens in ordinary theatres. The only disadvantage of the present arrangement is that the brass, being actually placed under the stage, is a little too much subdued, for which reason the stirring fortissimo passages lose some of their accustomed splendor and glory. But this shortcoming can probably be remedied by a somewhat different acoustic arrangement, while retaining all the present advantages. Three performances have now been given, and the house has been full each time, while the en- thusiasm has steadily increased. I have already written that on the first night Wagner begged the audience not to applaud after the first and second act, so as not to spoil the “‘ Stimmung.” This request was respected by the audience on the second night, when the majority still be- longed to the society of patrons. On the third night, however, the audience was of a more mis- cellaneous character, and, in spite of the efforts of the faithful, the applause broke out like a storm after the second act. Que voulez-vous? The people are accustomed to express their ap- proval by clapping their hands, and it is not easy to cure them of this habit, although it certainly would be more artistic to wait till the end. The fact, however, that the hearers—and those not the full-blooded Wagnerites—would applaud in spite of Wagner, proves better than any adjectives of my own the beauty and im- pressiveness of ‘‘ Parsifal.” Many who came to hear only one performance left Bayreuth after securing tickets for a later performance, and there are some who have tickets for all the six- teen nights. THE RESTORED CASTLE OF CHAN- TILLY.—Il. Paris, August 4, 1882. I HAVE attempted to describe the Chateau of Chantilly in its present state. I have left aside, however, the principal room in the new ChAteau, which has received the name of the Tribune, as it somewhat recalls, by its dimensions, the famous Tribune at Florence. This room is cir- cular, and placed in one of the three towers which flank the great polygon of the Castle. The gem of this choice collection is the famous **Vierge d@’Orléans,” by Raphael. This picture belonged once to the Regent, and adorned for a long time the Orléans gallery ; it was sold at the time of the Revolution, and came into the posses- sion of M. Delessert, the banker. At his death it was sold at public auction in Paris, and the Duc d’Aumale, who was at the time in exile in England, had it bought for the sum of 150,000 francs. Such treasures have really no price. The “ Vierge d’Orléans” is a picture of modest dimensions ; it has all the freshness, the youth, the grace of the péruginesque manner of Ra- phael, while it has already the perfection, the solidity, the grand style of the Raphael of the third manner. It is a sort of connecting-link between the end and the beginning—a résumé of all the qualities of this ever-admirable master. — sion which was so intensified in the great Ma- donna which is now admired in Dresden. The Virgin is perhaps the prettiest of all the Madon- nas painted by Raphael. The color is as fresh as on the first day—no hand has ever touched this delicate masterpiece ; it can safely be said that it is now exactly as it was when it came from the hand of the greatest painter of all times. This picture is placed on a little stand by itself; close by it are two portraits placed also apart. One of them is a picture which has been, so to speak, rediscovered. It was part of a collection of portraits, called the Collection Lenoir, which was formed at the end of the eighteenth century by a M. Lenoir, who was a great amateur, and sold by him in England to the Duke of Suther- land. These historical portraits for a long time adorned the rooms of Sutherland House ; they did not attract much notice, as they were chiefly portraits of Frenchmen and Frenchwomen. Many were by Janet, called Clouet, and Clouet has only become the fashion again lately, since the revival of the French historical school. A few years ago the present Duke of Sutherland sold the Lenoir collection to the Duc d’Aumale, who valued it chiefly on account of its histcrical character. Among the rest, there was a portrait which much attracted the notice of those who first saw it in France. It was evidently painted by one of the earliest painters in oil ; it recalls the manner of Van Eyck or of Antonello da Messina. The Duc d’Aumale had a very good copy made of the famous head of a condottiere by Antonello, which is in the Salon Curré of the Louvre. It is impossible not to be struck with a certain similarity between the picture by Antonello and the portrait I am now speaking of. On looking closely at this portrait, which is painted on wood, curious traces were found on the back, which was quite blackened by dirt and by age. It was washed carefully, and on it were found monograms and emblems, and a device : ‘*Nul ne s’y frotte.” There was no doubt now : the portrait represented a prince of the House of Burgundy who is called the ‘“‘Grand Bitard de Bourgogne.” He wears the Golden Fleece, the curious black pointed cap over long hair. In my opinion, it was painted by a pupil of Van Eyck rather than by Antonello da Messina. Whatever be its origin, it is a most curious relic, and nothing can exceed the perfection of it, ina technical point of view. The young Prince has a hard, wicked, stubborn expression ; he seems alive, and I doubt if ever life has been represented with a more extraordinary degree of realism. The third picture placed apart is a portrait of the Cardinal de Bourbon, a great-uncle of Henri IV., not the Cardinal de Bourbon of the Ligue. This picture is much older than the preceding ; it is also very interesting, both historically and technically. Among the pictures of the Tribune, I will mention at once a portrait of Moliére, as it was also sent from England in the Collection Lenoir. This portrait had been quite forgotten, and the French amateurs were not aware of its existence. It was thought that the best likeness of Moliére was his portrait by Mignard, which may be seen in the foyer of the Théatre-Fran- cais. There isa very interesting life of Mignard, which was written after his death, in which it is related that this painter was extremely fond of | Molitre, and that he made his portrait three times. We have now the portrait of the French Theatre and the portrait in possession of the Duc d’Aumale (which is undoubtedly, in my eyes, by Mignard) ; what has become of the third? I have tried in vain to discover it: it has prob- ably been lost or destroyed. The portrait of the French Theatre represents Moliére in one of his costumes as an actor, rouged, with a false mous- The child has on its little face the stern expres- tache, and with a wig. The portrait which be-

Page 11

Aug. 24, 1882] 155 longs to the Duc d’Aumale represents Moliétre as he was—as a man ; and in this respect it is in- valuable. You see there the true Moliére, the unfortunate husband, the worn-out, sad, melan- choly creator of so many immortal types. His mouth, with thick lips, has a curious curve, as if even smiling had become painful ; his eyes are heavy and red, with an indescribable sweetness and sadness. I know of nothing more pathetic than the face of this true Molitre ; it makes you love the man, it fills you with pity. If Mignard had only painted this picture and the portrait of his daughter, which is in the gallery of Ver- sailles, he would be a very great artist. There is no mignardise in it ; it is nature itself. The Tribune of Chantilly has some pictures of the early Italian painters, which come chiefly from a collection formed by M. Reiset, formerly custodian of the Louvre (the eatalogue of this collection was published by M. Reiset when he intended to sell it at public auction ; but the Duc d’Aumale bought the whole collection before the sale took place). One of the finest pictures in it is a portrait of the famous Simonetta by Pal- lajuolo. It has all the qualities of the precur- sors: it is bold, original, and has an intense individuality. I must cite also an allegorical figure of Spring, by Sandro Botticelli. Spring is represented by a tall young woman, with flowers in her arms and children clinging to the folds of her gown. The children are somewhat grotesque, as is often the case in Botticelli’s pic- tures ; but the young woman is very charming. She has all the grace, the elegance, of the best figures of this extraordinary painter, who was at the same time a naturalist and an idealist. I cannot cite here all the ancient pictures of this collection. There are some beautiful por- traits of the sixteenth and of the eighteenth cen- tury. The modern school is represented by some very remarkable specimens. I will name first a portrait of Bonaparte, then First Consul, by Gérard. It is perhaps the best portrait of the greatest man of our times. The face has a clas- sical beauty, and is full of genius ; at the same time, the brow and the clear eyes have a hard- ness which verges on cruelty. The First Consul wears the very simple green uniform of the Con- sular Guards. The Duc d’Orléans, the eldest son of Louis Philippe, was a great patron of literature and of art. He was acquainted personally with Musset, with Decamps, and many others; he ordered once two pictures of moderate dimensions from Ingres and from Delaroche. The price was to be 6,000 francs apiece, which was thought very generous in the year 1830. Ingres made for the Duke his ‘‘ Stratonice,” and Delaroche his ‘‘ As- sassination of the Duc de Guise,” which is by far his best picture. The Duke was so satisfied with the pictures that he sent to each of the painters 12,000 francs—double what had been agreed on. The Duc d’Aumale is now the possessor of these two pictures, which are very good specimens of the school of 1830. The ‘‘Stratonice” does not find as many admirers as it did once: Alma- Tadema and others have shown us Greece and antiquity in truer colors. Still, it cannot be de- nied that the composition is very noble, and that the zsthetic effect is considerable. The ‘ Assas- sination of the Duc de Guise” is truly a magnifi- cent picture ; it has every quality—line, color, truth ; it is a page of history. Delacroix is rep- resented in the Tribune by one of his best pic- tures, the “‘ Two Foscari,” a most pathetic com- position. The old Doge is obliged to deliver his own son to the torturers. The color of this great scene is very much admired by all artists. In order to be complete, I should have to make a real catalogue. I will only say that Watteau and Prudhon are very well represented in this room, where every picture is a choice one. = ° : : of artists ; he is never satisfied. The Nation. Thus far I have only spoken of the show- rooms, if I may so express myself, of the new Castle. There is, besides, a great corps de logis, which forms what is called the Apartment—that is to say, it is destined for the most distinguished guests who will be received at Chantilly. This part is not quite finished, and is not visible to the public.” Many works of art, tapestries, pic- tures, bronzes, etc., have already found a place in the fine rooms, which look out on the enor- mous parterre planned by Lenétre. In the centre of this parterre one sees a statue of the Grand Condé, in a sort of Roman dress. The Duc d’Aumale has ordered other statues, which will be near the statue of Condé. Bossuet has already been finished by M. Guillaume ; he was a great friend of Condé, and delivered his fune- ral oration, as everybody knows. The other statues will be those of La Bruyére (who was a preceptor in the house of Condé, and who com- posed his immortal ‘Caractéres’ at Chantilly), Molitre, and Lenétre. There are, besides, in the parterres several allegorical statues. Chapu has just finished two very pretty ones, “ Pluto” and “Proserpine.” Proserpine is seen gathering flowers, and Pluto watches her at a distance, concealing himself among marine plants. These statues give a very noble character to the old French parterres, which are made a sort of con- tinuation of the architecture of the great Castle. In our artistic world great curiosity is felt on the subject of the statue which Dubois is prepar- ing for the Constable’s Terrace. The model already set up there, and to which I alluded in my last letter, is a rough sketch, which Dubois only made so as to get a true impression of the scenery, of the height of the pedestal, of the general effect of the work. But, as I have said, it would not be fair to judge his future work by this maquette. Dubois is the most conscientious In fact, he is in danger of spoiling the work of his inspiration by over-correcting. We may feel sure that he will spare no pains to produce an equestrian statue of the Constable worthy of the great name of Montmorency, worthy of Chantilly and of its present proprietor, who is doing his best to make of Chantilly a kind of museum of French his- tory. Correspondence. ERRORS OF THE CENSUS. To THE Eprror OF THE NATION : Sir: I should like to call your attention to some errors in the Population Volume of the Tenth Census Table I d, on page 5, purports to give the number of inhabitants to the square mile of land surface in each of the States and Territories at the date of each enumeration. From this table we learn that in 1870 Connecticut bad, for every square mile of her surface, 110.9 inhabitants, and that in 1880 this number had decreased to 107.8, The natural supposition would be that the popu- lation of the State was less in the latter year thanin the former. But Table I c, on the same page, indicates that the population had increased during tiie decade to the extent of 15.8 per cent. ; and Table Ib, on the opposite page, gives the number of inhabitants in Connecticut in 1870 as 537,454, and in 1880 as 622,700. According to the Special Census Bulletin which gives the area of the States and Territories, the land surface of Connecticut is 4,845 square miles. Experiment will show that if the population of the State at each Census be divided by this number, the quotient will be identical with the figures which Table I d gives as the number of persons to the square mile at that date, except in 1880. In that year the quotient will be 128.5, and, as we have already seen, the figures in the table are 107.8. As Connecticut bas not increased in area in the last ten years, it follows that the table is wrong, and that instead of 107.8 inhabitants to the square mile in 1880, as is asserted by it, Con- necticut really had 128.5, In the same table (Id, p. 5) the number of persons to the square mile in the District of Columbia in 1870 is stated to have been 2,191.0 ; in 1860, 750.8 ; and in 1850, 516.9. The increase of population between 1860 and 1870 thus ap pears to have been about 181 percent. Table Ic, on the same page, however, says that the increase was only 75.4. The area of the District is 60 square miles (see Special Census Bulletin on Areas). The population in S70 was 151,700 ; in 1860, 75,080 ; and in 1S50, 51,687, Lf the popula tion at any period be divided by 60, the quotient will be the number of inhabitants to the square mile at that period. The results obtained in this way are below contrasted with those given in the Census : Resu't of Division Census Result 2,105.0 et) 1g70 1860 1,251.38 MALS 1850 SOL ride The error of 4 in 1870 is apparently a mere slip. The mistakes in 1860 and 1850 are of a more interesting character. It will be noticed that the figures for those years given by the Census are the exact ones which would be ob tained if the population in those years had been divided by 100. The area of the District of Columbia was originally 100 square miles, In 1846, however, Alexandria County was receded to Virginia, Since that time the area has been, as above stated, 60 square miles. The Census Office kept on using the old area till ISTO. . It is not speaking harshly to say that this error is evidence of great carelessness, Among other maps in this volume is one show- ing the curves of mean annual temperature. On page 17, Table Im purports to give the number of persons in each State and Territory living between the several curves. The map and the table correspond in form and intention, but, as will presently appear, they frequentiy contradict instead of confirming each other. Thus the map places a considerable tract in northern Arkansas between 55° and 60° of mean annual temperature. If this tract be carefully measured, it will be found that it must comprise the counties of Ben- ton, Baxter, Boone, Carroll, Fulton, Madison, Marion, Washington, and parts of several others. The population of the counties named is 107,861 (see p. 50), whereas, according to the table (1 m, p. 17), that part of Arkansas having a mean temperature of 55-60 has a population of only 12,647. According to the same table, the entire popu- lation of Maryland lives in the belt of country in which the mean annual temperature does not fall below 50° ; but on the map the curve corre- sponding to a mean temperature of 50° crosses the State at about the longitude of Hagerstown. All the State west of this curve has a mean an- nual temperature of 45°-50°. Garrett, Alleghany, and partof Washington Counties are west of this line. The population of the first two alone is 50,187 (see p. 64). The same map indicates that the temperature of something more than one-half the area of West Virginia is 45°-50°. Measurements will show that this part of the State comprises coun- ties whose aggregate population is rather above than below 210,000. Yet the table (I m, p. 17) gives its population as 22,193. On the same map, the curve corresponding to 55° mean annual temperature divides Missouri into two unequal parts. Aiwcut three-fifths of the State lying north of this curve have 50°-55" mean annual temperature, and about two-fifths

Page 12

156 lying to the south of ita mean annual tempera to 60°, Just on the northern boundary there is a small piece, made up of parts of Putnam, Harrison, Mercer, and Worth Coun- ties, in which the mean temperature is 45°-50°. ture of from 55 Thirty thousand would be a very large estimate of the population of this tract. The entire popu- lation of the four counties named is only 56,735 In the extreme southeast corner of the State there is a strip of land which, as closely as can be judged, is about coterminous with Dunklin and Pemiscot Counties, in which The aggregate popu- lation of these counties is 13,905 (see pp. 68, 69). Now, the table (I m, p. 17) puts 1,323,176 people in that small section of northern Missouri in which the mean annual temperature is 45°-50° ; 831,301 are assigned to the three-fifths of the State where the mean temperature is from 50 to 55’; and only 13,903 people are given as the inhabitants of the southern two-fifths of the State in which the mean of the thermometer is 55 to 60. This last-named portion of the State, as represented on the map, contains the city of St. Louis, whose population is 350,518 (see p. 246), No population at all is credited to the small area in Dunklin and Pemiscot Counties It is plain (see pp. 68, 69). the temperature is 60°-65°. which has a temperature of 60-65. that there is an error somewhere. It will be noticed that the population credited to the 55-60" belt —viz., 13,903—while absurdly too small for it, is exactly the population of the two counties in the tract having a mean tempe- rature of 60°-65°, 831,301 seems rather a small population for the thickly-settled counties in the northern three-fifths of the State, but it is just about what we should expect to find in the 55°-60 section. 1,525,176 is an impossible population for a belt of country taking in parts of only four counties, the aggregate population of which is, as we have seen, only 56,735, but it is a very rea- sonable number for the inhabitants of the 50°-55 belt of the State. In short, the figures for Mis- souri in this table (I m, p. 17) have all been moved one column to the left of their proper positions. It is true that if this explanation be accepted, it would appear that it had not been intended to credit any population at all to the part of the State having a mean temperature of 45 -50° ; but the proof is too plain that the error arose in the manner suggested for this circum- stance to cast any serious doubt upon that ex- planation, especially as we have already seen that omissions in this table of even more impor- tant groups of population are by no means rare. The blame for this misplacement of figures can- not be saddled upon the broad shoulders of the printer, for it is carried through no less than four tables (Il, p. 16; Im, p.17; In, p, 18; Lo, p. 19). It certainly seems that a very little vigilance would have sufficed for the discovery and correction of so patent a slip. This is but the first instalment of the errors and inconsistencies discovered by me in this vol- I may soon call your attention to others. JOHN C, RosE. ume ; BALTIMORE, MD., Aug. 15, 1882. THE MANUFACTURE OF HAY. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Referring to your remarks on bay in this week's issue, may I, as a practical yeoman, ask how the article may be ‘‘ cured,” or manu- factured, by ‘‘only lying in the sun”? Such simplicity would materially lighten the labor and expense of harvesting a crop which, to a New England farmer, is of some value during the long winter.— Yours, H, 8. RussELL, HomME FARM, MILTON, August 12, 1882. [The hay is cured by ‘only lying in the The Nation. sun.” What the practical yeoman does is to make it lie in such manner that the sun can get atit. Nothing else that we know of is done, except cart it home to the barn ; but if this constituted ‘‘ manufacture,” coal would be a manufactured article, and so would sea- weed used as manure. At all events; we have the authority of the courts for saying that baymaking is not ‘‘ manufacture,” and main- tain that it consists in exposing cut grass to the sun’s rays. We greatly doubt, however, whether this explanation will be of much use to the practical farmer.—Ep. Natron. ] THE DUTY ON BICYCLES. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION : Sm: You mention that a manufacturer of bicycles only asks to be ‘let alone, .. . being neither helped nor hindered.” According to the newspaper accounts, this is exceedingly inaccurate. The manufacturer of bicycles asked to have the duty on steel lessened, but not the duty which falls on bicycles. He did not ask to have the 35 per cent. ad valorem duty on bicycles remitted, or inform the committee that by means of this heavy duty, and $10 royalty charged for patents, the Pope Manufacturing Co. has established a monopoly which, even for an “‘infant industry,” is exceedingly oppressive. It was truly ‘‘a very unreasonable position for an infant to take.”—Respectfully, M. B. TF. MILWAUKEE, August 16, 1882. THE LANDING OF THE PILGRIMS. To THE EpIToR OF THE NATION : Sir: Your valued correspondent, Dr. Dexter, in his communication of the 20th of July, has briefly referred to a number of authors whose testimony hedid notcite. Some of this evidence seems to me too valuable not to be laid before your readers. Some additional facts and reflec- tions suggested by the discussion follow. In Dr. Belknap’s sketch of the life of Governor Carver, published in the second volume of his ‘ American Biography,’ issued in the year of his death, 1798, he says, in reference to the landing from the shallop, ‘‘ Monday, December 11th” : ‘* The rock on which they first stepped ashore, at high water, is now enclosed with a wharf. The upper part of it has been separated from the lower part, and drawn into the public square of the town of Plymouth, where it is distinguished by the name of T'he Forefathers’ Rock, The 22d of Dec. (Gregorian style) is regarded by the people of Plymouth as a festival.” Dr. Belknap was born in 1744, twenty-five years before the Old Colony Club instituted the celebration of the landing on the 22d of Decem- ber. And he says here that the people of Ply- mouth celebrate that day as expressing, in the Gregorian calendar, the day of the landing. Dr. James Thacher, an Old Colony man, in his ‘ History of Plymouth,’ 1832, pages 24, 25, has a long account of the landing from the shallop, ‘‘on Monday, the 11th day of December, O. 8.,” after which he proceeds to say : ‘‘ This, then, is to be considered as the first stepping on the Rock of the Pilgrims from the shallop belonging to the Mayflower, and this is the birthday of our nation.” He then says that the day usually celebrated, the 22d of December, has hitherto been supposed to correspond to the 11th, O. 8. ; that this is an error, and that the 21st should hereafter be commemorated. He then proceeds to give a long history of the introduction of the Gregorian calendar, and the reason for the blunder which the Old Colony Club made in 1769 in assigning the 22d of December instead of { Number 895 the 2Ist, as the true day for celebrating the landing. . Dr. Thacher was born in 1754, fifteen years before the Old Colony Club was instituted, of which he gives a history, and he may reasonably be supposed to have been informed on all the questions here discussed. He lived in Plymouth nearly all his life. As he could not have been ignorant himself of the significance of the day celebrated as that of the Landing, so he must have known the views of others who were equally intelligent with himself. Judge John Davis, the editor of Morton’s ‘ Me- morial,’ was emphatically the antiquary of the Old Colony. What he and his brother, Samuel Davis, the author of ‘ Ancient Vestiges,’ did not know about the antiquities of Plymouth was not worth knowing. Judge Davis was born in Ply- mouth in 1761. He must have known all about the Old Colony Club, and about all its members, and about all the orators, of which he himself was one, of Forefathers’ Day. He must have known, himself, the day he was commemorating, or the event he was commemorating. In a note to his edition of Morton’s ‘ Memorial,’ 1826, page 48, he quotes from ‘‘Mourt” the well-known passage of the landing from the shallop on Mon- day, the 21st of December. After saying that the place of the landing is satisfactorily ascer- tained, he says: “The 22d of December, corresponding to the llth, Old Style, has long been observed at Ply- mouth, and occasionally at Boston, in com- memoration of the landing of the Fathers. The New England wn in the city of New York, annually celebrate this day by an appropriate festival. At Plymouth it has universally the familiar appellation of Forefathers’ Day.” Judge Davis says nothing here about the error of one day in reckoning from old to new style ; e but in a later manuscript note in his own copy of the memorial, now before me, written on this page, he says : ‘‘ In 1620, December 11, O.8., cor- responded to December 21, N.S. When the anni- versary was instituted at Plymouth, in 1769, eleven days were added for difference, instead of ten, the true difference. The difference be- tween old and new style then existing was incor- rectly assumed in determining the day of cele- bration,” etc. Why should we seek to relegate to the region of myths the well-known facts of history ‘ There are myths enough already woven into our his- tory against which we may sharpen our wits while we expose them ; so we can afford to let the facts that have an historical basis stand. We see here how the celebration of the 22d of December came about. There was a landing of the Plymouth fathers on the 11th (21st) of De- cember, 1620; and any one who wishes to cele- brate the day may be sure of its genuineness, There was no landing there on the 22d, old style or new style, of which there is any record. Why, then, confuse the minds of people by get- ting up or perpetuating a celebration on that day? Why introduce an element of myth into Plymouth history where the facts are clear ? The story of the landing upon a rock is tradi- tional. It has been handed down from an early period, but it does not rest on contemporaneous record, But the landing from the shallop sume- where within the Bay, and the marching into the land on Monday, the 11th of December, O.58., 1620, is a matter of record at the time. Some surprise has been expressed, mingled with incredulity, that the Old Colony Club, in 1769, should have so blundered on the subject of the old and new style; but as wise persons as they have blundered since, and continue to blun- der, aboui the same thing. Dr. Belknap deliv- ered in Boston, in 1792, before the Historical So- ciety, a discourse to commemorate the discovery

Page 13

Aug. 24, 1882] The Nation. of America three hundred years before, on Octo- ber 12, 1492 ; and the day selected for the cele- bration was October 25—eleven days being add- ed, after the reckoning of the Old Celony Club, whereas, for the year 1492, but nine days were required to represent the difference. The American Autiquarian Society was found- ed in 1812, and in the following year they insti- tuted an annual celebration to be held October 23—that being, they say, the anniversary of the discovery of America by Columbus. The an- nual meetings of that Society continued to be held on that day till, about thirty years ago, after Mr. Savage’s report to the Pilgrim Society, the 21st of October was, by a vote of the Society, substituted. The Essex Historical Society in 1828 celebrated the two hundredth anniversary of the arrival of Endicott at Salem, September 6, 1628, and they selected the 18th of September as the true day, thus adding twelve days to represent the diffe- rence of style. Being asked, a few days before the festival, in the street, what is the difference between old and new style, Dr. Bowditch, the greatest mathematician in the country, correctly replied, in his prompt way, “* Twelve days.” But Dr. Bowditch afterward said, when it was too late, the question should have been, ‘‘ What was the difference two hundred years ago ?” (Sav- age’s ‘Report on the Day for Celebrating the Landing of the Pilgrims,’ Boston, 1850, p. 10). The Essex Institute, the successor of the Essex Historical Society, celebrated, in 1878, the two hundred and fiftieth anniversary of Endicott’s landing, and they still adhered to the day adopted fifty years before, September 18, in- stead of selecting the true day, the 16th; the President of the Society, in his opening address, saying they did not. wish to discredit the judg- ment of their predecessors, nor ‘‘express an opinion on a subject that has agitated so much the minds of scholars and historical students.” When John Quincy Adams was asked, in 1843, to deliver an address before the Historical So- ciety, on the ‘‘ Confederation of the Four New England Colonies of 19th May, 1643,” it at first occurred to him—perhaps from his long resi- dence in Russia, where the old calendar is still in use—that twelve days would be required to represent the true date; but he soon saw, or was led to see, his error, and the address was deliv- ered on the 29th (Savage’s ‘ Report,’ pp. 10, 11). C. D. CAMBRIDGE, Mass. [The argument of our correspondent cuntro- verts no statement made by the Nation. It shows clearly enough that learned historians and societies of historians ‘‘ blundered on the subject of the old and new style,” and that wise persons ‘‘continue to blunder about the same thing”; all which, in view of the sim- plicity of the subject, is strange indeed. But the *‘blundering” (the candid reader will ex- cuse the word, seeing that we take it from the pen of our much-esteemed correspondent) of Dr. Belknap and Judge Davis must not be shifted over to the Old Colony Club. That very respectable club had no occasion to ‘‘insti- tute” the anniversary called Forefathers’ Day, and consequently had no occasion to confuse the calendar. To cite Dr. Thacher’s ‘History of Plymouth,’ second edition, 1835, page 29: ‘‘ Tradition says that Elder Faunce was in the habit, on every anniversary, of placing his children and grandchildren on the rock, and conversing with them respecting their forefathers.” Elder Faunce died in 1746, when in the ninety-eighth year of his age, and as he ‘‘bid an everlasting adieu ” to the rock in 1741, when he is reported to have ‘‘ bedewed it with his tears,” his ‘‘ habit” of taking his descendants thither on the anniversary of the landing of the forefathers was formed many years before the Old Colony Club came into existence. The club was established in 1769, in which year it ‘‘ instituted” the first public celebration of Forefathers’ Day in Plymouth. It had nothing to do with “instituting” the anniversary, for that, in 1769, was already a time-honored day, and had been celebrated, in a quiet way, as was his ‘‘habit,” by Elder Faunce, and we know not by how many others. Our correspondent holds that what Judge Davis ‘‘did not know about the antiquities of Plymouth was not worth knowing,” and yet all the Judge’s marvellous knowledge failed him in his reckoning of old and new styles. He was a Forefathers’ Day orator and ode-maker, and we willingly admit that he must have known ‘‘the day he was commemorating, or the event he was commemorating.” In 1813 the Massachusetts Historical Society voted to ‘‘celebrate the anniversary of the Landing of the Forefathers on the 22d of December,” and elected Judge Davis to deliver a discoarse. The discourse was printed, and having ¢are- fully searched its pages, we can say that it contains no mention of the ‘‘ shallop” landing. On the contrary, the Judge’s reference to ‘the little band whom we this day commemo- rate,” points distinctly to the landing of ‘‘ the whole number of the company,” which he puts down as ‘‘one hundred and one.” And in his ‘‘ Ode for the 22d of December, com- posed for the anniversary festival, 1792," we find that his povtic vision was in harmony with the sentiment of his oration. We have room for one verse only of that ode : “ By yon wave-beaten rock See the illustrious flock, To seek suntan ee, Their faithful partners move, Dear pledges of their love, In either hand.” Neither.the oration nor the ode will apply tothe landing of an exploring party on the 11th of December. The real question for dis- cussion is not about the landing of the “ shal- lop” party (we haye alluded to that event, as a matter of fact, over and over), but it is whether Forefathers’ Day commemorates the landing of a few sailors and adventurers, or a subsequent landing of the entire body of the Leyden Pilgrims—the landing from the May- flower, on Plymouth Rock. Our “ view” of Forefathers’ Day, as it was presented in the Nation of July 6, has not been shaken by any quotations from Mourt, or Belknap, or Davis, or Thacher; and believing it to be the true one, we have no hesitation in reproducing it : ‘* Whether the disembarkation [from the May- flower) was made in one day, or occupied several days, is not so material. lt is the idea of a gene- ral landing of men, women, and children that has made any one day remarkable; and the stream of literature sets in one plain direction— to the ‘consecration’ of the landing of the Pil- grims from the Mayflower on the 22d of Decem- ber, 1620.” —Ep. NATION. ] Notes. CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS send us vols. xiv. of their so-called ‘‘ Subscription Edition” of the ‘Encyclopedia Britannica,’ beautifully ~ Py 15% —rr bound in half-morocco. The impression has been made from the original plates, and one only misses the broad pege-margins: but this, while a loss to the eye, ismore than offset by the greater ease in handling the at best heavy vol umes. A welcome new feature of the * tion Edition” is a series of United States maps designed to replace those which have alreacy appeared. Their merit does not lie in engraving. but in clearness and accuracy Subser ip artist The selection of names of towns has been determined by the populations of the last census, The road lines are delineated in red—sometimes, we observe, a little in advance of the actua! rail laying, as in the depicted junction of the Oregon and California roads. Many will find the semes in a detached form convenient. Of the latest volume, the 14th, we must take another occa sion to speak in detail. A work of no ordinary interest, * The Letters of Lydia Maria Child,’ with a biographical in troduction by J. G. Whittier, and an appen by Wendell Phillips, is in the press of Houghton, Mifflin & Co. Harper & Bros, will have ready next month Mr. Wm. H. Gibson's ‘ Highways and By ways,’ with his own illustrations ; and in October, Mr Abbey’s illustrated Herrick. The second volume of Mrs, Stanton’s * History of Woman Suffrage’ will be published immedi ately by Fowler & Wells. G. P. Putnam's Sons’ fall list embraces * Social Equality: a Study in a Missing Science,’ by W H. Mallock; *The Development of Constitu tional Liberty in the English Colonies,’ by Eben G, Scott; ‘The Political Conspiracies preceding the Rebellion, with the true stories of Fort Sum ter and Fort Pickens,’ by Lieut.-Col. Thomas M Anderson; ‘Six Months in Persia,’ by E, Stack ‘Travels and Researches among the Lakes and Mountains of Eastern and Central Africa,’ by J Frederick Elton; ‘A History of English Prose Fiction,’ by Bayard Tuckerman: ‘Songs of Lake Geneva, and other Poems,’ by John Bray- shaw Kaye; ‘Sheaves,’ a volume of poems by Harriette Converse; ‘A School Atlas of Astro nomy,’ by A. Keith Johnston; a second series of ‘ Best Reading,’ for the five vears ending Decem ber 31, 1882, edited by L. E. Jones; and a curious symposium, ‘How to Succeed,’ to which Sena- tors Bayard and Edmunds, novelists, soldiers, politicians, and inventors contribute their expe- rience—shall we say /—or belief. Houghton, Mifflin & Co., in issuing the com- plete ‘Pcems of Thomas Bailey Aldrich,’ have taken exceptional pains with the illustrations, which for the sake of harmony have been exe- cuted by members of the Paint and Clay Club of Boston, in mutual understanding and criti- cism. Mr. W. B. Closson engraves two of his own designs. Pére Didon’s lectures on ‘ Science without God,’ translated by Rosa Conder, will be issued in September by T. Whitaker. Macmillan & Co. have repurchased from Henry Holt & Co. their ‘‘ Elementary Classics,” of which a list was given in last week’s Nation. Wentworth’s ‘Elements of Algebra,’ with the addition of half its bulk devoted to-the discus- sion of subjects usually found in the higher algebras, will compose his ‘Complete Algebra ’ promised immediately by Ginn, Heath & Co. We receive from Ithaca, N. Y., a ‘ Bibliogra- phia Psiupsilonica,’ issued by the Chi Charter—a small pamphlet of seventeen pages, compiled, doubtless, by Prof. Willard Fiske, of Cornell. Its fifty-eight numbers are pronounced nearly complete. A bibliographical list of the English transla- tions and annotated editions of Goethe’s Faust, compiled by William Heinemann, is begun in the August Bibliographer (J. W. Bouton). The dix

Page 14

~ 158 same number reviews a work by J. H. Hessels, ‘Gutenberg: Was he the Inventor of Printing ?’ to which Dr. Van der Linde’s reply will be in teresting reading. A sketch of the late Stephen 8. Foster, by Parker Pillsbury, is printed in the current num- ber of the Granite Monthly (Concord, N. H.). Mr. Christern will receive subscriptions for a charming art-work, on the Estense Gallery at Modena, by Inspector Venturi, who in the text will trace the origin of this collection, and its varying fortunes of war and of necessity, with the aid of fine illustrations. The widow of Professor Cairnes is desirous of obtaining copies of his letters, many of which were written to fnends in America. She will be very grateful to any correspondent of her late husband who will send such copies to her, or the originals, which she will carefully return after making copies of them. Address Mrs. Cairnes, 46 Oseney Crescent, London, England. Our endeavor last week to explain briefly a technical term in the extract from Minister Marsh’s letter from Vallombrosa was not quite successful. Ueberwallung, in its dendrological sense, of which the common dictionaries take no cognizance, means “the covering over with a growth of bark the top of the stump of a tree which had been entirely cut down; this growth being formed without the aid of leaves, and so without the elaborated sap on which the forma- tion of wood largely depends.” The phenomenon is of very rare occurrence, and the writer has never witnessed it in this country. —‘*A Summer at York,” by Sara D. Clark, and ‘‘ Spanish Vistas—Mediterranean Ports and Gardens,” by George P. Lathrop, are the chief illustrated articles m Harper's for Septem- ber. They will be found worth reading as well as looking throngh, both baving some literary as well as pictorial value. Mr. Lathrop gives an account of a gypsy dance, the flamenco, as danced in Malaga, which seems to have the pe- culiarity of being an Oriental dance performed in Western costume, ‘Two other illustrated arti- cles are ‘The Weibertreue,” by Elise Alien, and the “ Visit of the Vikings,” by T. W. Higginson, whose conclusion with regard to the Vikings’ visit to this country—that there is very little hope of ever identifying a single spot where they landed, or of ever being sure of anything about it beyond the bare fact that they came here before Columbus did —is one not likely to be quarrejled with. ‘‘In Surrey,” by Mrs. Jobn Lillie, is founded partly on a trip to that county and partly on Madame D’Arblay’s Me- moirs. For more serious contributions, Mr, Ed- win P. Whipple writes on Emerson, and dwells a good deal on a trait which many of his disci ples failed for very good reasons to notice—his humor. This serves to explain, or balf explain, a good many things that have passed with the untranscendental for pure extravagance or non- sense. We should be inclined to doubt whether his ‘‘ Nay, Margaret, it is religion,” was said with the entire seriousness that is always attributed to it, and certainly it would be unsafe to take Margaret Fuller’s word for it. David A. Curtis contributes an article on “‘ The Mississippi River Problem,” in which no attempt, however, is made at a solution of the stated problem, “how to keep within fixed bounds a stream that flows in varying volume over a bed of mud, without banks that can be called banks.” It is at present one of the grandest fields for the theorist and for an appropriation in the world. The Mississippi River Commission, a body created by the Forty-sixth Congress, be- lieves in keeping the river within bounds by arti- ficial means, and proposes to narrow the river to a uniform width of 3,000 feet, te strengthen The Nation. [ Number 895 the banks, and regulate the shape of the bottom. The critics of this plan say that it cannot be done—that the river must overflow, and that the proper thing to do is to provide auxiliary chan- nels and outlets which shall guide the surplus water to the sea. The cost of the work of the Commission has been put by one of its members at $33,000,000, while its critics say that $460,000,- 000 would not complete it satisfactorily. The poetry of the number consists of ‘‘ A Garden Secret,” by Philip Bourke Marston; and ‘‘ Marit and I—a Norse Idy1,” by Hjalmar H.Boyesen. Mr. William Black’s ‘‘ Shandon Bells” is continued, and Mr, Curtis contributes two or three graceful essays in the ‘“‘ Easy Chair,” the best of them being on that universally-conceded American good nature which leads us in travelling and elsewhere to submit to so many impositions that Englishmen cannot be brought to endure. — The September Cenfury, hke the other Sep- tember magazines, is stronger in prose than poetry. Mr. 8.G. W. Benjamin contributes an illustrated article on ocean steamships, which brings out in a striking way the extraordinary reduction in the length of ocean voyages effected within the past generation by ‘the introduction of the screw, the compound engine, and the in- creased size of steamers, and in which he calls attention to the curious fact that stern-propul- sion, suggested by the earliest inventors of the marine steam-engine, is, after many experiments, and a long trial of lateral propulsion, the plan upon which the world has finally settled down for marine navigation. Other illustrated articles are ‘“* The Original of Rebecca in ‘ Tvan- hoe,” in which Mr. Gratz Van Rensselaer shows by what seems very conclusive evi- dence that the idea of the daughter of Isaac of York was suggested to Sir Walter Scott by Irving, through the account given by the lat- ter to the novelist of a certain Rebecea Gratz, a Philadelphia Jewess ; ‘‘An Old Town with a History ” (Castine, Maine), by Noah Brooks ; ‘“The Academic Career of President Woolsey,” by Prof. George P. Fisher, an article of some intrinsic biographical value; ‘ Dante Gabriel Rossetti,” by Edmund W. Gosse, who adds a de- tail here and there to our knowledge of a very singular man—singular, among other things, in the fact that his medizvalism in art and poetry was not, as was the case with others of his time, the result of study or reflection, but a pure case of what Darwinians would call reversion, for his imagination, born in an English and modern and utilitarian and formal milieu, had a dis- tinctly Italian and medieval character; and *Ningpo and the Buddhist Temples,” by Con- stance F. Gordon Cununing. The serials go on as usual, and there are two or three serious and critical articles, as well as a short story by Joaquin Miller. Mr. E. V. Smalley’s second paper on the ‘‘ New Northwest” is a very good bit of description, in which he points out what he thinks is a radical difference between the railroad and tbe pre-railroad genesis of towns in the West. ‘‘ Formerly the coun- try was settled first, and the towns grew up to supply the needs of the rural popu- lation. Now the towns are created by spe- culators far in advance of the farming settle- ment; and by the conveniences they afford for selling crops, and buying implements, lumber, and household supplies, they attract farmers to their vicinity. Each new frontier town is an advertisement of the surrounding country, upon the settlement of which it must depend for its existence.” As an instance of this process, he cites the town of Billings, on the Yellowstone, where the bare prairie was staked out with . streets, avenues, and parks on a scale for a city of 20,000 inhabitants, a “Billings boom” was started in the real-estate market, and blocks in the new city were sold in Chicago and New York. Within sixty days after Billings had been born, $220,000 worth of lots bad been sold within its imaginary limits. The town of Duluth was, if we remember right, placed on the market in much the same way, but in such speculations the chances of a financial crash have to be taken into the account, and 1873 was too much for Duluth. General McClellan writes a very in- conclusive article on ‘The War in Egypt,” and Mr. Howells a pleasant essay on Mark Twain, an engraving of whom makes the frontispiece of the magazine. Mr. Howells somewhat exaggerates the importance of Mr. Clemens in literature, for although we may be ready to grant all that is said of his native powers, the use to which he puts them is, in estimating his literary rank, a serious matter. Mr. Howells thinks that Mark Twain will last. ‘* All fashions change,” he says, ‘‘and nothing more wholly and quickly than the fashion of fun; as any one may see by turning back to what amused people in the last generation; that stuff is terrible. As Europe becomes more and more the playground of Americans, and every scene and association becomes insipidly familiar, the jokes about the old masters and the legends will no longer be droll to us. Neither shall we care for the huge Californian mirth when the surprise of the picturesquely mixed civilization and barbarism of the Pacific Coast has quite died away; and Mark Twain would pass with the conditions that have made him intelligible, if he were not an artist of uncommon power as well as a humorist.” We wonder what Mr. Clemens himself would say to this. Mr. Smal- ley, by the way, contributes a new Western waiter story, which might have come out of Mark Twain. The waiter inquires patronizing- ly of the guest if he is hungry, and on the guest’s replying that he is, ‘‘ I am glad of it,” says the waiter; ‘I like a hungry man.” —Mr. Austin Dobson’s illustrated paper on “Thomas Bewick,” with which the Century opens, has not only the literary finish we expect from this writer, but also the merit of orderly exposition and of a certain originality. Mr. Dobson has visited the engraver’s birthplace and his haunts in country and city, and compares his impressions with those recorded by Bewick in his autobiography. He shows us in modern woodcuts what remains of Cherryburn, the Ovingham parsonage and church, with its me- morial tablets, the Newcastle workshop of Bewick & Son. Then, proceeding to trace the artist’s career, he settles a moot point concerning his early work for Saint’s ‘Select Fables’ in 1776. The rest is for the most part not new, excepting a few details of considerable personal interest. Add to all this twenty specimens of Bewick’s art, the largest one being printed from the origi- nal block. We have examined these some- what curiously to see whether they have gained or lost by the Century’s presswork, It is well known that when Bewick had mas- tered the difficulties of engraving on wood, he had to overcome the printer’s inability to deal with cuts, for an instance of which take the twelfth edition of Croxall’s ‘ sop,’ printed for the foremost houses in London in 1782. He accordingly lowered the surface of his blocks in sucha way that the darker portions protected the lighter against the rough usage of the press, while the proper effects of light, shade, color, and distance were preserved. We could criti- cise the Century’s prints more intelligently if we knew which of them were recut and which re- produced by ‘‘ process”; but we have not found one of them superior to the originals, while, what is most singular, the loss of ‘‘ atmosphere ” is ap-

Page 15

Aug. 24, 1882] The Nation. = parent in several (e. g., *‘The Farmyard,” the tail-piece to ‘‘The Beaver,” and “ The Common Snipe”). The prevailing defects are that the abso- lute blacks are made grays,though in “ The Star- ling” the black of the head is ruinously over- done and extended; and that the finer details are often half or wholly obliterated (see especially the two owls). This last is bad enough when the background is in question, but when plumage is involved the effect is meagre on the one hand and mussy on the other. We appre- hend that the ink has something to do with the matter; but, without disparaging the pressman or the ever-watchful supervision of him, we in- cline to think that Bewick’s work will suffer more by excess than by neglect of “‘ overlaving.” On the whole, Mr. Dobson’s favorite ‘Old Eng- lish Hound ” comes off best. — The Atlantic for September has a very small supply of poetry—a sonnet to ‘‘ Darkness ” by Julia C. R. Dorr, and three verses called “Tears of Isis” by Francis L. Mace, being all. R. Fellow contributes an article on ‘‘ American History on the Stage,” in which he suggests one or two subjects for serious treatment ; amoug others, the expedition of Sir William Phips against Quebec, and the life and death of John Brown. Nobody can say that a subject is not a good one till it has been tried, but we confess that to our minds it is difficult to imagine any- thing of importance being done with either. His- tory is the stumbling-block of the playwright. Picturesque, romantic, and dramatic incidents in it attract and delude him at the same time. The best proof of this is that very little really good historical drama has ever been written. The great Greek tragedians employed legend rather than history as the groundwork of their drama; the French classical school took classi- cal subjects as far as possible. Shakspere wrote “histories”; but they can hardly be said to have held the stage. The romantic drama of France, of which ‘* Hernani” may be taken as a type, made use of historical names, but hardly came much nearer actual history than does such a play as ‘‘ Adrienne Lecouvreur.” It must be remembered that in Shakspere’s time the drama performed a good many functions which fall to literature now. Audiences which came to see ‘“‘ Henry V.,” for instance, came to have the story told them. This they would now get out of a book ora magazine. The modern familiarity with history, the fact that every American boy, for instance, learns the history of his country at school, is a reason the more for thinking it unadapted to dramatic representation. Nobody who could get hold of Parkman’s de- lightful volumes would care to go to see Sir Wil- liam Phips or Frontenac given by a star actor at the Grand Opera House, or even at Booth’s. Another reason why American history seems to make poor material for the drama is that many of its most serious persons and events have been turned into general ridicule and have had an air of burlesque thrown over them by a variety of causes, which need not here be gone into, but which have permanently impaired their gravity. Washington on any stage would be a failure. They do these things better in France, and they made the experiment there and failed. Against one thing it is safe to warn the play- wright—that is, against attempting to write his- torical drama assuch. Let him try producing a good play, and, if it turns out to be historical too, no one will have a word to say. If it is bad, its historical character will not help it. Elizabeth Kobins writes on ‘‘ Evil in the Greek Mythology,” and shows how different a part evil plays in mediseval Christianity: ‘“** From Harz to Hellas, cousins we discover!’ cries Mephistopheles, There were in Greece 159 creatures as grotesque, as improbable, as hideous as any to be found in India or in Scandinavia. There were dragons with seven heads, and great aw with but one eye in the middle of their oreheads. Strange beings—partly birds, partly women—haunted hill and valley, and the calm blue sea concealed terrible monsters. At first it seems as if sirens and lami, griffins, hell- hounds, and cyclopes must be the same in every respect as the asuras of the East, or the grotesque demons of medieval Europe, whom they resem- ble in outward form. But they are in reality as distinct from them as classic is from Oriental and romantic poetry. Goethe, in pointing out the likeness, has also analyzed the difference between Greek and Northern demons. This dualism has never been so tersely explained as when he makes Mephistopheles, on the mountains of Hellas, miss the smell of pitch and brimstone, to which he is accustomed on the Blocksberg, while he wonders what can be the nature of their hell-fire.” — Another instalment of ‘‘ Studies in the South” contains a discussion of what is being done for the education of the negro. Mr. Harrison criti- cises the plan of national aid, which he thinks would be a positive evil. The poverty of the Southern States is not, he says, so great as to render it at all necessary, and it is very desirable that both whites and blacks should be accus- tomed and remain accustomed to a full local re- sponsibility for the results of ignorance if they permit it. Mr. Harrison, it should be said, is very sceptical on the subject of common-school education. What the negroes need, he thinks, isindustrial and moral training. These the pub. lic schools do not give. The negroes must, of course, be taught the rudiments of knowledge— reading, writing, and arithmetic. But what they must actually do in life is work, and no- thing taught them at school ought to produce a dis- like in them for manual labor. They are “‘serfs,” says Mr. Harrison bluntly, and serfs they must remain, aud it is mere cruelty to give them an education such as Northern common schools fur- nish, which ‘‘ tends very generally to produce in the pupils a dislike of manual labor, and a dispo- sition to regard those who live by it as an infe- rior class.” Alexander C. McClurg contributes a readable war article called ‘‘The Last Chance of the Confederacy,” and the three serials are car- ried bravely forward by Mr, Hardy, Mr. Bishop, and Miss Phelps. They are all three full of charac- ter. Doctor Zay is the most tremendous woman doctor that has yet appeared in fiction. Swithin St. Cleeve as the lover of science cannot be matched anywhere, and for fastness it would be hard to beat young Kingbolt, of Kingboltsville. Mr. F. H. Cushing’s “ Nation of the Willows” is interesting and valuable, as everything he writes about the Indians is. —Lippincott’s for September opens with an illustrated article describing ‘‘ An Antwerp Printing House,” by Rose G. Kingsley. Amelia E. Barr contributes an article on ‘Songs that have Made History,” such as “ Lillibullero,” “Ca Ira,” and the Marseillaise, but her material is very well worn. A curious collection might have been made of the songs that were popular in our Army and among the rebels during the war, as well as of the songs which it was at- tempted to nationalize here without much suc- cess. As music the successful and popular songs had little value, except in the case of one or two old and familiar tunes. All of them were ex- tremely simple melodies. ‘‘ John Brown's Body,” and ‘‘ Maryland, My Maryland,” and “ March- ing through Georgia,” and ‘ Dixie” were those which probably had most moral military effect; but we fear the result of the examination would show us to be a most unmusical nation. The current instalment of ‘Fairy Gold,” a novel published anonymously, is not at all bad, and there is further provision of fiction in the form of short stories—‘‘ Guy's Legacy,” by William O. Stoddard, and ‘“ Mrs. Witherell’s Mistake,” by Edward Lassetter Bynner, ‘‘ Animal Electri- cians,” or in other words animals provided with “stored” electricity, such as the torpedo and the electric eel, are written about: by C. F. Holder. Octave Thanet gives an account of a trip ‘“ Through Great Britain on a Drag,” which seems to be that noticed in the news papers some mouths ago as having been taken by Mr. Andrew Carnegie and his friends. Mr. Charles Wood gives an account of his invasion of the ‘‘Temple of Heaven” in Peking, and A. Granville Bradley gives some valuable informa tion about a most interesting part of Virginia im an article called ‘‘ Round about the Peaks of Otter.” Louise Chandler Moulton and Mary B. Dodge furnish the poetry of the month in * At War” and “ Interchange.” In “ Our Monthly Gossip” we always find some extraordinary statement. This month it is the suggestion that hospitality is dying out. We should like to be in formed where. Is it in Philadelphia, and is the phenomenon connected in any way with protec tion to American industry ? —Mr. Clarence Cook has a very depressing article in the current number of the North American Review on * Architecture in Ame rica.” The only houses in the country which satisfy him are the ‘‘ cottages and small houses of the last century” scattered over eastern Massachusetts and ‘found plentifully in New Jersey.” As far as we understand what he says, the reason why these are good specimens of architecture is that when they were built there were no architects in America. ‘The general excellence that marks the dwellings of any peo ple is a proof of the non-existence of profes sional architects among that people”; and con- versely, ‘‘when architects abound the art of . buiiding always deteriorates.” Again: ‘It is to architects that we owe all the ugly building that offends us in our large cities and in our country towns and fashionable summer quarters.” So far all is plain sailing. Before there were any architects there were, of course, nothing but builders, and it is to the honest, unpretending builder that we owe all the good early Colonial structures that Mr Cook finds so satisfac- tory. This is something like the view that Carlyle took of the matter, as may be seen in his lamentations over the decay of the art of masonry, in which his father was such a profi- cient. But in the next sentence Mr. Cook de- stroys the whole fabric of his argument by declaring that ‘it is to architects that we owe, nowadays, the few, the very few, buildings on which our eyes can look with pleasure,” and he adds that ‘‘ the work of the professional builders is always in these days an eye-sore.” It is easier to follow Mr. Cook when he does not generalize, and when he tells us what he thinks of particular buildings. He has surveyed the field, and has found very little that is good in it. For instance, there are ‘‘ the churches on the Back Bay lands ” in Boston—one ‘‘ with the foolish frieze of sculp- ture encircling the lofty, awkward tower, and wholly unintelligible from below,” another with “*the completest Saratoga trunk” on top of it ; for what purpose placed there Mr. Cook does not know, and the Art Museum, “‘so finikin fine, with its heads of great men, looking out of portholes in the most shipwrecked fashion.” The same extravagance we find repeated in the Sanders Theatre at Cambridge and in the Historical Society’s building in Brooklyn. The Boston Art Museum and the Memorial Hall at Cambridge are, it seems, “examples of what comes of building getting into the hands of literary, critical men, art students, with their heads crammed full of remembered bits of Old-World architecture, and their portfolios stuffed with photographs of more and more bits.” As for the Vanderbilt houses, the two built by Herter and

Page 16

) q ty fi vj) e/ 160 the third built by Mr. Richard Hunt—what are they? The art of architecture, it seems, ‘‘ has not received many worse blows in this coun- try” than have been given her by these three houses. Of Mr. Hunt, Mr. Cook says he ‘‘has certainly loaded earth with some of the most ungainly among all the ungainly structures that make our streets such a misery to any one who cares for good building.” He “spoiled quiet Beacon Street ” by the erection of what Mr. Cook cautiously says he ‘‘ believes” to be “the ugliest house that has ever been built this side the At- lantic”; and he built the Lenox Library, too, ‘‘with its silly pediments and blank monotony of wall.” No wonder such a man as this should have built the third Vanderbilt house, ‘a patchwork made up of bits.” This is cer- tainly a gloomy picture; and the worst of it is that there seems to be no chance for anything better, for reform must come either from build- ers or architects or students of art, and for all three classes Mr. Cook has the profoundest con- tempt. After reading the article we can only say, Alas! alas! there is no hope. Other readable articles are ‘“‘ Tornadoes and their Causes,” by T. B. Maury, and ‘ Earth-Burial and Cremation,” by Augustus G. Cobb. Mr. Cobb quotes an eye- witness as giving the following pleasant account of the spectacular effect of crematory funeral: ‘* When, in obedience to his own dying request, I saw the door of the cinerator taken down, its rosy light shine forth, and his peaceful form, en- robed in white, laid there at rest amid a loveli- ness that was simply fascinating to the eye, and without a glimpse of flames or fire or coals or smoke, I said, and say so still, this method, be- yond all methods I have seen, is the most pleas- ing to the senses, the most charming to the imagi- nation, and the most grateful to the memory.” —The Norwegian Edmund Neupert, now on his way to America for the purpose of giving concerts in our larger cities, is a pianist of the first rank and a composer of considerable merit. He is in the prime of life, having been born on the first of April, 1842, He received his first lessons in music from his father, Hermann Neupert, a music-dealer and teacher of the pianoforte in Christiania, Norway. He played in public con- certs at the age of seven with marked success, and in 1858 he was sent to Berlin, where he re- ceived further instruction from Professor Kul- lak. Here he soon became a favorite in the best musical circles, and at the age of twenty-two he appeared in the ‘“‘Singakademie,” and was re- ceived with favor. By invitation of Gade he became a teacher in the Copenhagen Conserva- tory of Music in 1868. He has repeatedly given concerts in the largest cities of Germany and Scandinavia. In 1880 Neupert was called to a position in the Musical Academy of Moscow, Russia, where he was greeted with great ap- plause. After the death of Nicholas Rubinstein, at whose request Neupert had gone to Moscow, he returned to Christiania, where he has estab- lished a music school. If we except Erika Lie, who isa famous interpreter of Beethoven, Neu- pert is unquestionably the most brilliant piano virtuoso the Scandinavian countries have pro- duced. Among his compositions his six ‘ Im- provisations” on Norse themes are perhaps the best known and most popular. His ‘“ Etudes” are also frequently found on concert pro- grammes. —In an interesting essay on the connection be- tween Arthur Schopenhauer’s philosophy and personality, in the July Rundschau, Professor Paulsen certainly proves that Schopenhauer’s peculiar philosophy was the direct outcome of his private convictions, and that theoretically as well as practically he was the pessimist pur 4 [ Number 895 ‘The Nation. excellence. He was the most distrustful of hu- man beings. ‘*He believed in no man’s honesty, not even the commonest, every-day sort. Just as he fear- ed that his own mother and sister wanted to take advantage of him, so he did in the case of all his friends. A friend of his youth, a French- man, who had shown sincere devotion for him, was asked by Schopenhauer for advice concern- ing a projected investment in a French life-in- surance company. His friend dissuaded him, and offered to invest part of the capital in his own business. Schopenhauer never answered the letter, but wrote on the margin: ‘Do you smell a rat ? (merskt Du was). For a similar reason he received an extremely painful rebuke from his publisher, Brockhaus. After baving sent him the manuscript of the first edition of ‘Die Welt als Wille und Vorstellung,’ he could not shake off the suspicion that Brockhaus want- ed to defraud him of his payment. He accord- ingly wrote him a tolerably impudent letter, adding that he understood the firm to be general- y unreliable as far as payment was concerned. rockhaus asked him to name a single instance in which he had failed to meet his obliga- tions, saying that otherwise he could no longer consider him a man of honor. Schopenhauer had to swallow the reproach, and Brockhaus broke off all further connection with him.” —His valuables were so carefully hidden that in spite of the Latin direction contained in his will it was difficult to discover them. After his second journey in Italy he kept his account-book in English, and important business notes he wrote in Latin and Greek. In order to be safe from thieves he wrote deceptive labels, calling bonds arcana medica, keeping coupons in old letters and among sheets of music, and gold coins un- der the inkstand in his writing-desk. Altogeth- er, Schopenhauer knew well how to take care of hisown. A large part of his money, as well as that of his mother and sister, was invested with a commercial house in Dantzic, which in 1819 be- came insolvent. All the creditors lost seventy per cent. of their claims ; Schopenhauer alone, by skilful threatening and bullying which would have done credit to any lawyer, managed ina few years to recover his capital with interest added. Schopenhauer, like most eminent men, seems to have inherited a fair share of his tem- per from his mother, one of the prosiest of novel- writers, who exchanged with her son such ge- nial epistles as the following: ‘‘ You may dine with me on my reception evenings provided you can abstain from your troublesome disputing, which always puts me out of humor, as well as from all lamentations over the stupid world and human misery, which never fail to give me bad dreams, and you know I like to sleep well.” LECKY’S HISTORY OF ENGLAND IN THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY. —ILI. A History of England in the Eighteenth Cen- tury. By William Edward Hartpole Lecky. Vols, III. andIV. London: Longmans ; New York : Appletons. 1882. THE key to Mr. Lecky’s theory of our Revolu- tionary struggle may be found on page 1138 of vol. iv. : ““The American people, though in general un- bounded believers in progress, are accustomed, through a kind of curious modesty, to do them- selves a [toy injustice by the extravagant man- ner in which they idealize their past. It has al- most become a _———— that the great nation which in our own day has shown such an admirable combination of courage, devotion and humanity in its gigantic Civil War, an which since that time has so signally falsified the predictions of its enemies, and put to shame all the nations of Europe by its un eled efforts in paying off its national debt, is of a far lower moral than its ancestors at the time of the War of Independence. This belief appears to me essentially false.” While, therefore, Mr. Lecky sympathizes, on the whole, with the results of the Revolution, and pays a hearty tribute to the character of some of its leaders, the general tone of his book is that of depreciation at once of the American people of that day, and of the acts of aggression which led to the Revolution. Nothing is easier than to make a plausible showing on at least the first of these. In any popular movement the good and the bad are so intermixed that it depends entirely upon what eyes we look with, whether we approve or con- demn. The reader of Macaulay wonders how a revolution carried through with such venality and half-heartedness as that of 1688 can have been a ‘‘ glorious” revolution, What meanness and hypocrisy one meets at every turn in the revolution of 1640. Mr. Lecky eulogizes the spirit and character of the American people in the time of the Civil War ; but the noble army of contractors, the chronic grumblers, and the venomous Copperhead, gave occasion to lamenta- tions and discouragement quite equal to any that he quotes from the correspondence of Washing- ton and Adams. Times of revolution bring out all the heroism of a people, but they also place its low and evil traits in a glaring light. When we pass to the other question, the pro- vocations to the Revolution, and its justification, it is certainly true that the oppression exercised by England was not of the kind that drives men to madness. But is not this fact, in view of the almost unanimous feeling that existed at first against separation, even on the part of those whom Mr. Lecky calls ‘“‘ demagogues ” (Otis, the Adamses, etc.), the clearest evidence of the lofti- ness of spirit with which the colonists entered into the struggle? It was only the assurance that they were contending, not for threepence a pound on tea, but for the principle which lay at the foundation of English liberties, that could. have inspired them to a resistance which seemed so desperate. The American Revolution finds its fullest justification in the present policy of the British Government in dealing with its colonies—a policy forced, we may say, upon the mother country by the success of the American Revolution. Excellent as is Mr. Lecky’s analysis of the causes of the Revolution, he wholly fails to ap- preciate, or at least to bring into due prominence, its relation to the colonial system. This subject it is, we believe, Mr. Bancroft’s merit to have first elaborated, but, after all, Colonel Barré’s speech, familiar to every schoolboy, contained the gist of it. It was urged, and Mr. Lecky urges, that the contributions called for from the American colonies were far from being their fair proportion of the expenses incurred by the war from which the colonies had so largely profited. And this is very true, if we could con- sider the colonies as really forming part of the British Empire, and the war as waged in their behalf. But it is manifest that this was not the case ; that the colonies were planted and ad- ministered as pure dependencies, for the sole profit of the mother country. Of course all prosperity which fell to the lot of the mother country could not fail to redound in some degree to the benefit of the colonies ; but this was no part of the plan. From the passage of the Navi- gation Act of Charles II. (that of Cromwell was conceived in a different spirit, and treated the colonists as Englishmen of equal rights), the colonies were systematically forced to make their industry subservient to the interests, not of England, but of English manufacturers and merchants. Mr. Lecky says (vol. iii., p. 372) that the restrictions upon manufactures were “of no great consequence to a country where agriculture, fisheries, and commerce were natu- rally the most lucrative forms of enterprise” ; but nothing is more certain than that, except for these restrictions, the natural inventiveness and enterprise of the New Englanders would i»

Page 17

Aug. 24, 1882] The Nation. 161 have made manufactures a “lucrative form of enterprise” long before the Revolution. With good reason, the Americans felt that it was an impertinence to require them to contribute to the expenses of the Government when they not only were unrepresented in its counsels, but were treated by it as only a source of profit. Moreover, if it was right that the colonies should be taxed for the benefit of the Empire, it was right that they should be made an integral part of the Empire ; and this step should have come first. No doubt it would have been a matter of great difficulty to arrange the details of such a union —perhaps it would have been impossible. The first great attempt, Franklin’s scheme of union, in 1754, failed ; but, at any rate, wise statesman- ship would have made fresh efforts, and would have been willing to wait indefinitely, rather than insist upon raising money by taxation from a community which stood in no organic relation to the British Empire except that of subjection. Compared with the injustice of the colonial system, the legal argument as to the right of the Crown or of Parliament in the colonies is of very secondary importance. No doubt, the colonists did shift their position from time to time, as the inherent injustice of the system became more strongly impressed upon their minds. It was at first only internal taxation that they resisted ; then external taxation ; then the right of legis- lation. This was inconsistent, perhaps ; but, after all, they proceeded by logical steps. No- thing would have satisfied them in the long run —and nothing ought to have satisfied them—ex- cept either an integral union with the British Empire or such complete administrative inde- pendence as is now enjoyed by Canada and Aus tralia. As, therefore, they understood the in- justice of their economical relations as clearly as Adam Smith and Turgot, so they, by a pro- phetic instinct, led the way to the present colo- nial policy of Great Britain. We are told that even at that time the British colonial policy was far more liberal and just than any other. No doubt; and no wonder the routine British states- men could not comprehend the attitude of the colonists. So much the more must we honor their clearness of view and their readiness to devote themselves for a principle which is now recognized and unquestioned. Mr. Lecky’s failure to appreciate the impor- tance of the colonial system as a cause of the Revolution gives to his whole discussion a cer- tain one-sidedness in tone. He believes that the Americans were right, and that their triumph was the triumph of constitutional liberty. He- sees this clearly now, in the light of events ; but he cannot understand how the American leaders could see it a hundred and twenty years ago. The English statesmen—except Burke and a few others—thought it clear that the colonies should contribute to the burdens of the war; and it seems to him strange that the colonists should have thought differently. The result is a curious inconsistency: the opinions are generally favor- able to the American cause, the tone generally unfavorable. The Boston Massacre affords a very good illustration of this. After an account at considerable length of the unreasonableness and imsubordination of the people of the colo- nies, and especially of Massachusetts (vol. iii., p. 397), the so-called massacre is described, and its effects dwelt upon, in exciting the passions of the people and alienating them still further from the mother country. The impression given is almost that of a reign of terror ; and when we read directly after of the trial of the soldiers, their defence by Adams and Quincy, their ac- quittal, and the complete acquiescence in this acquittal by the American people (including the election of Adams as representative for Boston), one cannot but feel that the previous account was somewhat exaggerated, or, at any rate, that the author fails to understand the real sentiment of the community. And when he proceeds to ascribe this result solely to the ‘humanity ” of the American people, we feel that he totally mis- apprehends the situation. It was a far nobler thing than sentimental unwillingness to shed blood : it was a sense of justice—a readiness to understand the requirements of the law and to acquiesce in them. We have pointed out what seems to us the principal defect in Mr. Lecky’s view of the Ame- rican struggle, in his failure to go behind the mere question of law and to comprehend the position of the Americans asa people. In his account of the War he has brought out with great fulness—possibly with some exaggeration —the weakness of the American cause, the strength of the loyalists, the lukewarmness of the majority of the inhabitants, the shortcom- ings of the administration. It would almost seem as if he wished to show, as M. Taine has shown for the French Revolution, that the movement was pushed through by a resolute and unscrupulous minority. But an essentially democratic country like America, in which local self - government was carried to its furthest point, cannot be compared with a centralized despotism like France. No doubt, as Mr. Sabine and others have shown, the strength and respec- tability of the loyalist element were much un- derrated in the first years of the Republic ; but we think it certain that in most of the colonies a large majority was in sympathy with the Revo- lution. The military history, as might be expected in a work of this character, is the least complete part of the history of the Revolution. On the other hand, the political and financial portions are very well handled ; the sketch of the powers of the Continental Congress (vol. iv., p. 55) is especially good. We find on page 12 of vol. iv. the strange statement that. in 1776 ‘‘ Congress, without absolutely superseding [Schuyler], gave the supreme command to Gates, who was by birth a New Englander.” Schuyler offered to resign at this time, but his resignation was not accepted by Congress ; it was a year later that he was superseded by Gates, who was au Eng- lishman by birth. Again, on page 63, it is said that Carleton was, in 1777, superseded by Bur- goyne. Here, too, Carleton had offered to re- sign, but was left in his original command in Canada, while Burgoyne advanced to the South. Charlestown, near Boston, is regularly called **Charleston,” and Dickinson is spelt ‘‘ Dicken- son.” BOOKS ABOUT THE STAGE. Mrs. Duff. By Joseph N. Ireland. With [lus- trations. [American Actor Series.] Boston: James R. Osgood & Co, 1882. 12mo, pp. 188, Great Artists of the American Stage: a Por- trait Gallery of the leading Actors and Ac- tresses of America, with Critical Biographies. By Alfred Trumble. New York: Richard K, Fox. Part I. 8vo, pp. 73. Un Dossier: “La Fiammina ” contre *‘ Odette.” Par Mario Uchard. 1882. Paris: Dentu; New York: F. W. Christern. Mémoirs de Samson, de la Comédie-Francaise, avec un portrait dessiné par G. Jacquet. 1882. Paris: Ollendorff; New York: F. W. Chris tern. 12mo, pp. xxi.-338. L’Odéon: histoire administrative, anecdotique et littéraire du Second Thédtre-Frangais. Par Paul Porel et Georges Monval. Paris: Lemerre; New York: F. W. Christern. Vol. I. (1782-1818). Pp. 355.—Vol. II. (1818-1853). Pp. 397. 1876, 1882. Vor den Coulissen. Original Blitter von , Cele- britaten des Theaters und der Musik. Heraus- gegeben von Josef Lewinsky. Zweiter Band. Berlin: A. Hofmann & Co.; New York: B. Westermann & Co. 1882. Mr. JOSEPH N. IRELAND is honored by all stu- dents of the history of the theatre in these United States as the author of the admirable ‘ Records of the New York Stage,’ the two ample and accurate volumes of which come down to the end of 1860; and they cannot but wish that Mr. Ire- land had preferred rather to give them a third volume, covering the score of years and all the changes between 1860 and 1880, than to tell anew and at length the story of the life of a single actress, even though she were as great an artist as Mary Duff. Itis a curious commentary on the prevailing ignorance of the highly honorable history of the earlier American stage that the general reader, however fond he may be of the theatre, probably never heard of Mrs. Duff before. Hence Mr. Ireland’s assertion that she was a great actress, the equal of Fanny Kemble and Charlotte Cushman, and unsurpassed by any who have come later, excepting only Rachel and Ristori, will take most persons by surprise, No one, however, who is versed in American histri onic memoirs can doubt that this assertion is well founded. Mrs. Duff was a great actress As a woman she beld on our stage a position like that held by Cooper asa man, But Cooper was aman, and with careless strength held his own to the end of his life; so it happens that some memory of him survives, though his biography is still unwritten. Mrs. Dutf, was a woman lack- ing in self-assertion, and with a large family, and at the height of her powers she left the stage and hid herself in religious seclusion; so that recol- lection of her artistic powers naturally faded away. Itis well that Mr, Ireland has taken such great pains to trace her career. His investiga- tion has been thorough and his narrative is simple and straightforward. There is in it none of that convenient omission and ignoring of dates which make many theatrical biographies most exasperating. There are lists of parts acted by both Mr. and Mrs. Duff; there are two por- traits of each; there is a facsimile of Mrs, Duff's autograph, and there is a view of the Federal Street Theatre, Boston, in which Mrs. Duff had many of her greatest triumphs. It may interest some not specially interested in the stage and in stage folk to be told that she was the elder sister of the Miss Elizabeth Dyke whom Tom Moore married, and that Mr. Ireland thinks it was Mrs. Duff, then Miss Mary Dyke, to whom the poet was first attracted, and to whom he addressed the well-known lines; “ Mary, I believed thee true.” A word of special praise is due to the very full and unusually accurate index provided by the editor of the series. , Mr. Trumble’s pamphlet contains brief biogra- phies of thirty actors and actresses seen of late years on the New York stage, accompanied by wood-cut portraits engraved from photographs: and it is apparently a reprint from some weekly paper. The photographs have been well chosen generally, and they are engraved boldly, if not delicately: most of them are good likenesses, though there are a few hopeless caricatures. The biographical sketches are not ill done, though they contain little that is new, In the main they are fairly accurate, but we observe a few unfortunate slips, like that on page 19, where Miss Clara Morris is said to have made a hit in the “‘ Geneva Cross,” in which the chief part was acted in reality by Miss Rose Eytinge. Misprints are also more frequent than they need be. ‘‘ Coleman” for Colman, and “ Monte Chris- to” for Cristo (both on p. 21), ‘‘ John Hollinshed ”

Page 18

bi 162 for Hollingshead (p. 34), ‘‘ Sangarelli” for San- valli, and *‘ Woolcroft” for Moorcroft (p. 47), ete. We believe that the assertion (p. 60) that Mr. Bret Harte derived his play ‘‘ Two Men of Sandy Bar” from his novel ‘Gabriel Conroy’ is wholly unfounded. But altogether Mr. Trumble’s work is better than might be expected from its rather glaring and gaudy appearance. M. Uchard’s pamphlet is an accusation of plagiarism in due form. In it M. Sardou is charged with having taken the vital situations of “Odette” from ‘‘La Fiammina,” and M. Uchard remarks that various critics have de- clared that ‘“ Divorcons ” was inspired by “ Bru- tus ldche César”—an old play known to the English stage in Charles Dance’s very skilful adaptation called “ Delicate Ground.” M. Sardou has filed a plea of confession and avoidance: “Odette” is like ‘‘La Fiammina,” but ‘ La Fiammina ” was like earlier plays, and he who seeks equity must come with clean hands. It is the same defence he has made when accused of borrowing the fundamental situation of other of his chief plays. But, in anticipation of this, M. Uchard brings forward a new battery. M. Sar- dou, he says, is ever complaining of English ‘‘adapters”; now, what is he but an adapter himself ? And this, in fact, is just what Sardou is—an adapter, a contriver, an arranger, a maker-over of old coats; but so skilful is he and so brilliant is his new gilt embroidery that it takes a keen eye to detect the trick. Although he was one of the most artistic and consummate comedians of the French stage, Samson is perhaps best remembered now as the trainer of Rachel. It was he who planned Ra- chel’s best work; hers was but the unequalled execution. It is therefore with not a little dis- appointment that we find that Samson’s memoirs break off abruptly just after Rachel came with- in his circle, and just as he was about to set forth in detail his relations with her and his opinion of her character and genius. We learn more of the way in which they toiled together over a part from M. Legouvé’s lecture on ‘‘Samson et ses Elves” than from these pages. But if we get little new light on the workings of one of the greatest histrionic geniuses of this century, we have none the less an interesting picture of the early struggles of Samson himself, both pecuni- ary and artistic. He was very slow in makiug his way, but he was sure. Not only had he no great natural advantages, but he had positive defects to overcome by force of will and by dint of hard work. Worse than all, he was timid— distrustful of his own powers and terribly af- flicted with stage-fright. Yet he began in a small provincial theatre, and he ended the first comedian of the Thé&tre-Francais, a teacher at the Conservatory, and the instructor of Rachel, Mme. Allan, Mme. Plessy, the Brohans, and of many others who now hold a foremost rank on the French stage. Such a life was worth living, and the story of such a life is well worth reading. The Odéon, one of the most important and one of the honorable theatres in Paris, is fortu- nate in its historians. M. Porel is an actor of marked ability, and he has for many years been attached to the theatre whose annals he now publishes ; while M. Monval, who was also an actor at the Odéon when this book was planned and when the first volume was published in 1876, is now the archivist of the Comédie-Francaise and the founder and editor of Le Moliériste. When the third and final volume appears, the Odéon will have a history worthy of its reputa- tion, for the work before us is exactly what a book of this sort should be. It does for one theatre of Paris what Mr. Ireland in his ‘ Re- cords’ did for all the theatres of New York; and the French book is very like the Ameri- can in its method and in its merits. For The Nation. some years after the erection of the building, the Odéon was occupied by the Comédie- Francaise, which there gave the famous and long-deferred first performance of the ** Mariage de Figaro” of Beaumarchais, on Tuesday, April 27, 1784. At the Odéon, again, in 1824 and 1825, Weber’s ‘‘Freischiitz” and * Preciosa,” fear- fully mangled, were first presented to the Pari- sian public; and in 1827, the English actors, head- ed by Charles Kemble and Miss Smitbson, began tointroduce English tragedy to the French and to lend the mighty aid of Shakspere to the then slowly-gathering Romantic movement. The next year, Victor Hugo’s first acted play was performed there and damned out of hand. It was an “ Amy Robsart” imitated from Scott, and produced as though it were the work of M. Paul Foucher, the poet’s brother-in-law. In 1843 and 1844 began, still at the Odéon, the reaction against the Romanticists by the so-called Schoo} of Common Sense, with the ** Lucréce” of Pon- sard and the ‘*Cigué” of M. Augier; and here, finally, the first play of Alfred de Musset met with a noisy reception, and the first play of M. Octave Feuillet met with one scarcely less boisterous. There are many humorous incidents narrated with due effect in the course of the history, but none is so comic, perhaps, as a little slip of the author’s in printing the name of Mrs. Cowley’s comedy as the “ Bell’s Stratagem,” and in trans- lating it accordingly—“ Le Stratagime de la Cloche”! This is almost equal to the famous rendering of Cibber’s ‘‘ Love’s Last Shift” as the ** Derniére Chemise de l Amour”! It remains to be added that this mistake is almost the only one we have noticed in the two volumes, and we can also report that each volume has an excellent in- dex. ‘Vor den Coulissen’ is a collection of some forty articles, written by as many theatrical and musical celebrities. It is a second venture, the first volume consisting chiefly of sketches and essays by actors, while in the present issue musical artists and composers predominate. While it is creditable to the theatrical profession that so many of its members should give evi- dence of a considerable degree of literary cul- ture, it must be confessed that, on the whole, the book is a disappointment, and does not keep the brilliant promise of its table of contents. One naturally expects much enjoyment from “ Re- collections of Schubert and Beethoven,” by Franz Lachner; from ‘‘ Reminiscences of My Life,” by Flotow; from ‘‘ A Meeting with Heine,” by Friedrich Kiicken; from “ Jenny Lind,” by Sir Julius Benedict; but the principal benefit to be derived from reading these tempting produc- tions is an abiding conviction of the truthfulness of Sydney Smith’s new beatitude. They all give evidence of having been made to order, and are correspondingly flat and bald. In the four arti- cles just mentioned there is but a single passage worth quoting—a letter of Heine to Kiicken, en- closing some new poems which the composer was to set to music. It may be necessary to mention that Kiicken is a playful North German expres- sion for chicken. The letter is as follows: **My Dear Kiicken: ‘Here are some eggs for you to hatch; don’t eackle over them too long, and let me hear from you soon. Yours, H. HEINE.” Kiicken asked Heine why he did not write his articles in the French periodicals in French (of which he was a perfect master), instead of writ- ing them in German and having them translated by Alexander Weil, the well-known author of Jewish village tales. Heine answered: ‘It is said that I write a good German style, and I should hate to spoil it. Weil does the business well, and I pay accordingly.” One of the most serious contributions is Rubin- | Number 895 stein’s proposal for the establishment of sacred opera, which may be defined to be a dramatic oratorio, or an operatic miracle-play. The dis- tinguished pianist considers the entire species of the oratorio objectionable, and is greatly disturb- ed to see the grand personages of the Bible repre- sented by gentlemen in dress-coats and white cravats, and ladies in extravagant evening dress. He would have such themes represented dramatically, with all the accessories of cos- tume and scenery. While he rejects the popu- lar notion that there is any sacrilege in produc- ing sacred subjects on the stage, he would make such a concession to a widespread prejudice as to have a theatre specially devoted to this new kind of entertainment. This project has been his hobby for a quarter of a ceutury, and he has made numerous efforts to carry it into execution, applying for aid in divers quarters, but always in vain. The Grand Duke of Wei- mar, to whom he suggested the idea, was of opinion that it could only be carried out in a large city; Miihler, the Prussian Minister of Public Worship, thought it might be applicable to subjects taken from the Old Testament, but not the New, and did not consider that the state should concern itself with such an undertaking; Dean Stanley advised that it be tried as a popu- lar entertainment in a booth at a fair. The nearest approach to success was in this country, the chief obstacle being the lack of the musical talent to produce the entertainment. Undaunt- ed by all his failures, Rubinstein has composed two sacred operas—‘‘ Paradise Lost” and ** The Tower of Babel”; and is writing four more— ‘*Cain and Abel,” ‘‘ Moses,” ‘‘The Song of Songs,” and ‘‘ Christ.” There are some amusing passages in a descrip- tion of a concert tour in the Caucasus in the win- ter of 1879-80, undertaken b. Désirée Artét, her husband, Mariano de Padilla, and the pianist Sternberg. In Kizliar, Mme. Artét, who relates the story, was terrified when she stepped upon the stage and beheld the audience, clad, some in furs and some in immense shcwls, wearing high bearskin caps on their heads, girt about with broad belts which bad a big knife and a brace of pistols stuck in them, and holding lances in their hands. This audience manifested its applause by bellowing like wild beasts. Although pro- grammes had been distributed, not a soul stir- red when the concert was over. The artists were frightened. Mme. Art6l sang a few more airs. Still the audience remained seated. Her hushand sang a few more airs. The audience howled with delight, but made no motion to go home. Then M. Sternberg sat down at the piano, and played without inter- ruption till three in the morning. In another place, a half-savage fellow boaght a ticket for five rubles. After the second number of the programme he walked out with tears in his eyes, went to the ticket-office and laid down a fifty- ruble note. ‘“‘What is that for?” asked the manager. “‘ For my ticket.” ‘‘ But you paid for your ticket.” ‘‘Oh, no, sir,” shaking his head; ‘‘T should be ashamed of myself to hear such great people for only five rubles.” An Amsterdam manager, A. van Lier, tells a good story of Marie Seebach, who played a star engagement at his theatre in 1855. On the way from Amsterdam to Leyden the actress lost her jewel case, containing valuables to the amount of 20,000 thalers. Her despair may be imagined, and it was with the greatest difficulty that she could be prevailed upon to go upon the stage that evening. The manager succeeded in re- covering the lost treasure, and in doing so in- curred an expense of thirty-eight guilders.- When pay-day came he desired to deduct this amount from what was coming to Seebach. ‘‘See here, my friend,” she said, ‘our agreement was to go

Page 19

Aug. 24, 1882] The Nation. halves on this trip; Pll pay nineteen guilders, and you can pay the other ha'f.” The longest article is a lecture delivered in Florence by Salvini, and treats of Hamlet, Macbeth, and Othello. Salvini’s views of Shakspere are uot unknown to American readers, and it is not necessary to examine them here ; but itis curious to note what a singular blunder so clever a man may commit. He gives several reasons, none adequate, for the innovation he introduces, in the final scene of ‘‘ Othello,” of cutting his throat, instead of stabbing himself, as other actors do. One of the reasons is this speech of Othello : “TI took by the throat the circumciséd dog, And smote him—thus.” Heargues from this that Shakspere intended that Othello should cut his throat. Now, leaving out of view the stage direction, ‘‘ Stabs himself,” which may be an unauthorized interpolation, and admitting that the word “smote” may be am- biguously translated in the Italian version, it would be interesting to have it explained how it is possible to cut the throat of a man whom one is holding by the throat. It would be, to say the least of it, an awkward and complicated opera- tion, while to plunge a dagger into the breast of a man so held would be a natural and impulsive action. it will indicate the cosmopolitan character of the book to mention that besides Salvini’s con- tribution, it contains a lecture delivered at Edin- burgh in November last by Henry Irving, on “The Stage as It Is,” and a sketch of the Ger- man stage in New York, by Adolf Neuendorff, the manager of the Germania Theatre, who does not even mention the rival establishment, the Thalia Theatre—more successful, if not more im- portant, than his own. The sad fortunes of the German opera in New York are briefly narrated by Mr. Max Goldstein, formerly the editor of a musical journal in this city, but now living in Berlin. Guide to Moosehead Lake and Northern Maine. By Lucius L. Hubbard. 3d ed. Boston: A. Williams & Co, 1882. Paddle and Portage. By G. W. Steele. Boston: Estes & Lauriat. 1882. IT is an odd fact that the art of getting away for a little from the complexities of modern life has more than kept pace with the development of those complexities. We have Horace’s word for it that in his day Care scaled the brazen-prowed trireme; while every sportsman nowadays knows that Care never yet ventured to put foot. in a birch canoe. It is much to be feared, how- ever, that she will go with the crowd the mo- ment the birch canoe becomes fashionable, and for that reason there are many people who are sorry that it ever occurred to Mr. Hubbard to write the guide book whose title we give above. The thing being done, however, the jealous lovers of the Maine woods must reconcile them- selves to the fact, and are at least bound in honor to admit that if their secrets must be re- vealed, it could not be by a more faithful hand. Mr. Hubbard’s third edition shows unwearying work. A considerable amount of new matter has been added, dealing in particular with the extreme northern and northeastern parts of the State, and an additional map has been made which covers the headwaters of the St. John and Aroostook Rivers. The two beautifully printed maps now included in the Guide represent a prodigious amount of the most careful labor. A slighter addition, but one which will be welcome to amateurs, is to be found in the two pages of illustrations of the foliage and bark of the six most familiar evergreen trees. A feature which we shall hope to see further developed in later editions is the explanation of the meaning of In- dian proper names, in which northern Maine is very rich. Of quite a different character is Mr. Steele's ‘Paddle and Portage,’ the alliterative successor of his ‘Canoe and Camera.’ The new book purports to be a narrative of adventures on the trip from Moosehead Lake, Me., to the Aroostook River. These adventures are made to do service to their utmost capacity, the most effective of all being a moose-hunt in which no moose was seen, and the inflation by the guides of the rubber beds of the luxurious tourists. The narrative serves, however, as a thread upon which to string unnumbered stories and jests, of which material the writer appears to have so large a supply that one cannot help regretting that he should have found it necessary to repeat upon page 50 and illustrate over again by the engraver’s art his jest upon the ‘“ wet and dry process of photography,” from page 77 of ‘Canoe and Camera.’ Mr, Steele’s nimble fancy should have been kept under some control for the sake of people who know the things he is writing about. He himself is, of course, perfect- ly well aware that his Indian guide, Thomas Nicholas, does not talk Indian English in real life as he does in Mr. Steele’s book. He probably knows that no guide would draw up a canoe into such a place as one is seen to occupy in the illus- trations upon pages 52 and 101, unless it were for the especial purpose of making a falsely effective foreground for a picture. He cannot believe in his own heart that even a party of novices with- out a guide would arrange for a carry as is shown in the monstrous illustration on page 45, where one may see a canoe placed upon a sled, another laid directly above that, with no other support, and two men seated, in absolute in- difference to consequences, upon the upper canoe. And at any rate, whatever may be the impres sion which Mr. Steele is willing to convey in re- gard to his own knowledge of wood-lore, he ought not to represent his “comrade adven- turer,” Colonel G., who has a sportsman’s repu- tation, as jerking a trout “ which weighed above two pounds” high into air with a rod that bent “like a whip-jash.” A map prepared toaccompany this book would naturally be a careful presentation of the coun- try through which the trip was made. Instead of this, we find a map of all northern Maine from Moosehead Lake up. The region of the author's trip is given with much less detail than in Mr. Hubbard’s new map, while the rest of the map abounds with errors. Towns and houses are placed on the wrong bank of rivers, or are re- moved miles from their true situation (see on the St. John River Savage's, Baker’s Mills, Fort Kent, Edmundston, and the Edmundston block- house). Even for Moosehead Lake, the map is grossly wrong. Deer Island is placed far from its real position, and two islands are put down to the southwest of it which have no existence. Mount Kineo itself is twisted out of shape, and even the Kineo House is placed where it is not. Thesimple secret of all these errors is the fact that Mr. Steele copied his map, with scarcely a change, from the very inaccurate and now anti- quated State map. The style of the book is in admirable keeping with the illustrations and the map. The author tinds it well to use italics thrice in a single page of preface; to use the word stimulate in place of the word produce; to speak of horses’ snouts, etc., ete. A ‘single sentence will illustrate the pecu- liar glow of his manner. Its meaning, as ap- pears later, is that the Colonel and Mr. Steele took their guns and went off to shoot a partridge or two for their first supper. But Mr. Steele uses no such commonplace language. Under his pen this simple occurrence becomes: “ And the Colonel and I, seizing our rifles, sauntered forth 163 with sanguinary strides to decroase the popula tion of the forest game in the interest of our first meal.” Notes Preparatory to a Biography of Richard Hayes McDonald, of San Francisco, Cal. Com piled and edited by his Eldest Child, Frank V. McDonald.-. Vol. I. Honour thy Father and thy Mother.—Ex. xx. 12. Cambridge : Uni- versity Press. 4to, pp. xvii.-119. THE enormous size of the vegetable products of the Pacific Coast would appear, €rom this sump- tuous volume, to have an analogy in the cultiva- tion of the domestic virtues in that favored section. Mr. F. V. McDonald has already pub lished three genealogical works on his father’s family, and one on his mother’s, and will have another quarto volume of ‘ Notes Preparatory ’ before arriving at his ultimate task of a Biogra phy of his father, all the main incidents of whose life and a large number of the petty are related in the work before us. But why do we say ulti mate? Dr. R. H. McDonald is still living, and it is not intimated that the Biography will be postponed till his death, When that event occurs, filial piety will certainly prompt another tome or tomes in memoriam. A small library will thus take the place of the modest memoi: which, east of the Rocky Mountains, usually discharges a man’s obligation to honor his father and his mother, even when they have been per sons of eminence. Dr. McDonald's distinction consists in his having been the pioneer druggist in California, and in his being now the President of the Pacific Bank. From his predecessor in that office, ex-Governor Burnett, we have lately had some very interesting autobiographical * Recollections’ ; and if his example has become a tradition and regulation of the bank, it is clear that that institution must be reckoned among the more important literary agencies of the land of gold. Governor Burnett, however, was content with 448 pages duodecimo, and candor corpels us to say that had Dr. McDonald written about him- self in the first person, not only would the story have been much more valuable, but it would have occupied, it is safe to infer, scarcely one- quarter of the space allotted to it by his son. This defect of second hand is perhaps nowhere felt more than in the chapter relating to Dr. McDonald’s practice among the Mormons at Nauvoo at the time of their expulsion. The editor, on his part, has taken considerable pains with this episode, whose relative importance in any rational biography of his father he has tacitly signified by giving in an appendix forty pages of extracts from various works on tlie Mormons. But still he has not succeeded in making a real contribution to the subject as his father might have made, and as Governor Bur- nett did make in recording his experience with the sect during its earlier lodgment in Missouri. The hardships of the overland journey in 1849, Dr. McDonald's first partnership in the business of dealing in emigrants’ outfits, and squatter and gambling lawlessness, furnish occasion for graphic descriptions, and this has been well im. proved. We can also praise the interesting foot-note on page 84, which explains why Sacra- mento fell behind in the race with San Francisco. The editor is old enough to speak from personal recollection of the time when the American River had not begun to be filled up with silt from the mining sluices ; and this incident in the development of California is worthy of a place in the late Mr. Marsh's ‘ Man and Nature.’ To a foreign reader Dr. McDonald’s career will probably appear more eventful than to an American. He wasa native of Kentucky, and his early years were passed in that State and in two adjoining, until the gold fever caused him

Page 20

164 to embark, with a thousand other dissatisfied, invalid, or ambitious spirits, in the quest for laborious ease. He did not perish by the way, nor in the struggle for existence at the end, and his face shows him to be a typical American of the Western variety. We should hardly have supposed another volume necessary for the ‘preparatory notes” on his ‘ family relations,” his ‘‘life as husband and father” and as a “‘ man among men” in the State of bis adoption. But there can be no Jimit to filial reverence, and the means to gratify it in print seem in this case to be also illimitable. The numerous family por- traits, on wood and steel, and the singularly chosen illustrations, of which ‘‘ Indian Summer ” may be taken as a specimen, leave no doubt as to the pecuniary backing of this unusual enter- prise. As to the genealogical part, this line is doubtless traced from Brian McDonald who settled in New Castle County, Del., and died in 1707. It is here stated that he was from Wick- low, Ireland, had been one of the supporters of The Nation. James IT., and, above all, that he was descended from the Mac Donnells of Leinster, a branch of the Lords of the Isles. Pedigrees are prover- bially problematical, but we never feel sure that the Irishmen believe in their own pretended records. Lists of names without evidences of any description, without a single point on which to fix a distinguishing mark, are as | Hospitalier, E., and Maier, J. worthless as the columus of a herd-book. But | as we have not yet read the fuller genealogy also issued by Mr. MacDonald, perhaps we do him less than justice. We cheerfully comply with the editor’s re- quest to mention that the work has been placed in the leading libraries of the country and in the British Museum. BOOKS OF THE WEFK. A Tight Squeeze ; or, The Adventures of a Gentleman as a Professional Tramp. Boston : Lee & es $1. Cook, B. F.. History of the Twe!fth Massachusetts Vol- unteers (Webster Regiment). Boston: Twelfth Regi- ment Association. Craik, Georgiana M. Fortune’s Marriage. Franklin a Library. 20 cents, Harper’s | §mith. M. W. oes 895 | DeBeer, T. H., and Irving, Flisabeth J. The Literary Reader. Part 2 2, Nineteenth Century. 2d ed. Kuiler- burg: Blom & Olivierse. Delbriick, B. Introduction to the Study of Language. Leipzig : Breitkopf & Hartel; New York: B. Wester- mann & Co. Freeman, A.C. The American Decisions. Vol. xxxvi. San Francisco: A. L. Bancroft & Co. Hollyday, Mrs. R.C. Domestic Economy : A New Cook- ery Book. Baltimore John Murphy & Co. The Modern "applic ations of E lectricity. Tilustrated. D. Appleton & Co. $4 50. Jevons, W. S. The State in Relation to Labor. Mae millan & C oO. Kern, Prof. H. Der Buddhismus und seine Geschichte in Indien. Webersetzung von Prof. H. Jacobi. Vol. i., Part 1. Leipzig: Otto Schulze. Knortz, K. Shakespeare in Amerika. Berlin: Thos. Hofmann ; New York : B. Westermann & Co. M. Tulli Ciceronis Cato Maior de Senectute, Lelius de Amicitia. With Introduction and Notes by James 8. Reid, M.A. American edition, revised by F. W. Kelsey. Boston: John Allyn, $1 10, Riley, H. H. The Puddleford Papers; or, Humors of the West. Boston: Lee & Shepard. Robinson, S. W. Railroad Economics. D. Van Nostrand. 50 cents, Robinson, 8S. W._ Strength of Wrought-Iron Bridge Mem rs. D. Van Nostrand. 50 cents. Studies in English Literature. Cincin nati: Van Antwerp, Bragg & ¢ aigeiee. F.H. The Queer, the yuaint, the Quizzical: a Cabinet for the Curious. P iladelphia : Robert A. Tripple ; New York : Dodd, Mead & Co, $2 50, Sweetser, F. M. King’s Hand- k of Boston Harbor. Cambridze, Mass. : Moses King. $1. Wentworth, G. A., and Hill, : A Prac tica] Arithmetic. Boston : Ginn, Heath & Co. | $1 10.

Look Balon: Vou Lenk By Mrs. Alexander, author of ‘The Wooing O't,’ ete. 16mo (Leisure-Hour Series), $1, Kinley Hollow By G. H. Hollister. $1, l6mo (Leisure-Hour Series), ** Ttis quite above the line of the ordinary novel, To the merits upon which we have specially re- marked, the skilful and effective delineation of a past and gone society, the Sashions of thought, and the faithful represen- tation of types of character which had much to do with making New England what it is—it adds the further excellences of vivacious dia- logue, which serves really to illustrate the speak- ers, and a strong feeling for the beauties of nature.”-—-NeEwWw YORK TRIBUNE. ; HENRY ILOLT & CO., /mportant New Text-Books. FRENCH SYNTAX. Onthe Basis of Fdouard Matzner. By James A. Harrison, Profes- sor of Modern Languages in Washington and le e University, Author of a ‘ History of Spain,’ and Edi- tor of Beowulf, Selec . ons from Heine, etc., etc., ete. i2mo, cloth extra, $2 THE SCIENCE iad ART of ELO- cution; or, How to Read and Speak. A Series of Exercises for Ge sture, Calisthenics, and the Cultiva- tion of the Voice; and a Collection of nearly One Hundred and Fifty Literary Gems for Reading and Speaking. New and enlarged edition. By Frank H. Fenno, of the National School of Oratory. 12mo, cloth extra, #1 25 THE ARTIST and his MISSION. A Study in Saetes, Designe?) for the use of Schools and Colle By Rev. William M. Reilly, Ph.D., Professor © Pane ient Languages, Palatinate College. 12mo, cloth extra, $1 60. 4A MANUAL of the GERMAN Language. By Augustin Knoflach, Teacher of Lan- suaces. 12mo, cloth extra, $1. AN INTRODUCTION TO THE Study of English Literature and Literary Criticism. Designed for the use of Schools, Seminaries, Col- leges, and Universities. Vol. I. POETRY. By Prof. James Baldwin, Syvo, cloth extra, $2 50, New York.

*,* For sale by all booksellers, or copies sent, post- paid, on receipt of price. JOHN E. POTTER & CO., PHILADELPHIA, Fohus Hopkins University, BALTIMORE, MARYLAND. Publishers, Programmes of the courses offered to Univer- sity students for the next academic year may be obtained on application, realization of old |

C Pp. Putnam’s Sons, 27 and 29 W, Twenty-third St., New York, PUBLISH New and Standard Works on Astronomy. SCHOOL ATLAS OF ASTRONM- omy, comprising, in 21 plates, a complete series of illustrations of the Heavenly Bodies. PB Alex. Keith Johnston. 1 vol. royal 8vo, ; O,, ~occo, $4 50. ‘pb, EAS. “Nie,, > LESSONS. trated . 2, Proctor. u.%¢ HALF-HOU Lasgin ITH THE Telescope. Being a pe. dlar Guide to the Use of the Telescope. With illustrations on wood and stone. By R. A. Proctor. 12mo, cloth, $1 25 HALF-HOURS WITH THE Stars. <A plain and easy Guide to the Know- ledge of the Constellations. With 12 maps. By R. A. Proctor. Demy 4to, cloth, $2 50, A NEW STAR ATLAS. For the Library, School, and Observatory. In 12 circular maps, with two index-plates, letter- press illustrated by woodcuts. By R. A. Proctor. 8vo, cloth, $2 50. LARGER STAR ATLAS. Show- ing 6,000 Stars and 1,500 objects of interest in 12 circular maps, with two colored index- plates, and letterpress introduction. By R. A. Proctor. Folio, cloth extra, $7. Illus- ~and 36 cuts. By R. A WW » ‘oth, $250. Educational Lists sent on application, and New General Catalogue (nearly ready) sent on rec receipt of stamp. “THE OPEN- BOOK ‘RE ES r i \—Holds open, adjusts. revolves, and inclines to suit eight large volumes. Eminently endorsed by ministers, editors, lenges etc. Send stamp for fine photos, price-list, ete. C. K. Swartz & DANIEL, Gettysburg, Pa. The Portable Bookcase h weATHVainut, or Ash. Solid and In Ebony, Che ac alnu 8 Permanent. Mo oma where Books are used complete ” Forde ~- ipti ircular and price oy address the ate or descriptive circula -list, mokers, Tocswoon, Prooks & Co., 381 Washington S Boston.

The Publishers’ Account of Sales to the Author is the Fatrest Basis from which to Judge the Popu- | larity of a Book. ENGLISH LITERATURE. Our most eminent Shakespearians consider HUD SON'S HARVARD EDITION OF SHAKESPEARE the best_for Americans. AUDSON’S SCHOOL SHAKESPEARE has had a copyright sale of over 100,000 copies. LATIN ALLEN & GREENOUGH’S SERIES continues to grow in favor. and can indisputably claim to be the leading series. It has been introduced into 19 colleges and 150 high-schools the past year. It is now used in 177 colleges and over 1,000 prepara- tory and high-schools. GREEK. Fifteen colleges and 106 high-schools have intro- duced GOODWIN’S GREEK GRAMMAR the past yose. It is now used in 240 colleges and 660 high schools, MATHEMATICS. During the four years since the publication of WENTWORTH’S GEOMETRY it aS had a copy richt sale of 21,944 copies, of which 1,157 were soid during the first year and 10,784 the fourth year. During this first year WENTWORTH’S ALGEBRA has had a copyright sale of 5,780 copies. LANGUAGE LESSONS. WHITNEY & KNOX’S LANGUAGE LESSONS have been endorsed hy leading educators in every part of the country, and the enthusiasm of teachers using it is unprecedented. “It harmonizes and utilizes most, if not all, of the practical peventon o | for conflicting theories.” — Dr. Sta Met,

GINN, HEATH & CO., Publishers, 13 Tremont Place, Boston; 4 Bond Street, New York ; 180 Wabash Avenue, Chicago. A General Index to the Ni ation, From July, 1865, to September, 1880, Net price (no trade discount), $250. Purchasers will please remit with order. address Publisher of ~ Na- tion, Pox 100, Bow Samm, or Q. P. INDEX, Bangor. Mi aine. I] adsworth B ros. & Howland, TERS AND DEALERS I AR TISTS’ MA TERIALS And ese 7 ew Supplies of escri 8t WASHING ON STE = ‘BOSTON. 2 Catalogues free on application: UNMOUNTED PHO TOGRAPHS Of ANCIENT and MODERN WORKS .# ART, Set ames reproductions of farnous original pa sculpture, architecture, etc. Price, cabinet sie ‘1 bo eek per aon bend 6-cent mame for catalogue and suppl lement of 5,700 sun- jects. S0U PH RAPH . (successors to John a P. Soule). Pubitsbers. : Rae WwW senington St. Boston. Mans, HE HYGEIA HOTEL, Old Point ae- fort, Va., situated 100 Ah yenme from Fort Mon Open all the year. ual to hotel in the United States as a Summer Kesort or Cold Weather Sanitarium Send for cirewar describing hygienic ¢ advantages, ete, UICK AS A WINK.”—Rockwood’s In- stantaneous Photograovhs, 17 Union Square, N. Y,

Page 21