The Nation 1882-08-17: Vol 35 Iss 894
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, AUGUST 17, 1882. The Week. THERE is no very good reason to suppose that Mr. 8. W. Dorsey ever sent to President Gar- field the remarkable letter which was pub- lished on Sunday, or that it was ever written during President Garfield’s lifetime. There are some reasons for entertaining a contrary opinion. The letter is dated February 7, 1881. At that time Mr. Dorsey was accredited with an earnest desire to secure the appointment of Mr. ‘‘Clint” Wheeler as First Assistant Postmaster-General, and the famous Dorsey dinner, which was given on the 11th of Feb- ruary, four days later than the date of the al- leged letter, was really a demonstration in- tended to help on that project. What Mr. Dorsey’s reasons were for desiring to have a friend in that particular office are now tolera- bly well known. Moreover, as Dorsey knew all the facts (which have been slowly dragged into the light) of the Star-route robberies and his own connection therewith, he had par- ticular reasons for wishing to be on friendly terms with the new President. But the letter now printed is impudent and insulting, and calculated to excite the ire of any self-re- specting man holding the high responsibilities of the Presidential office. It tells him that he owes his election to ‘‘ Conkling and Arthur.” These, says Dorsey, are ‘“‘the two men who elected you, with the aid of Grant.” Not to follow their advice, he adds, is to ‘‘drive the last nail in your political coffin.” Even coarser language is used. The rumors about MacVeagh and James going into the Cabi- net are dismissed as ‘‘ blathering talk” and ‘detestable rot.” Is it probable that a man who had an important end to gain, and who was actually about to start for Mentor to carry his point—the newspapers of the day mention the fact that he did go there directly after the dinner—would have written a letter which would in all probability have closed the door against him? President Garfield was a high-spirited man, who could have had no illusions as to Dorsey. They had served in Congress together, and had lived not far from each other before Dorsey ‘‘ car- pet-bagged” from Ohio to Arkansas. To suppose that Dorsey would, under such cir- cumstances, take on the airs of a baggage- smasher toward the newly-elected President, from whom he had favors to ask and punish- sident Garfield’s death. Whether such a letter was really sent at the time it purports to have been written or not, its publication is plainly an appeal to the Stalwarts, including President Arthur, to save an old friend of the name of Dorsey, who fought valiantly and bled other people freely in a memorable crisis of the past. There ap- pears to be nothing stirring the public mind just now upon which the alleged letter has any ; | teller, and Mr. ‘‘ Barney” Biglin ‘‘ ment to fear, requires better evidence than the | , 4 a : ee ublicati fa lett ; fter Pre. | dozen clerks. How many business men would on of a letter n y aye , = ee ; ‘ ; ; P ee oe | hd perfectly comfortable in doing business bearing or significance, except the trial ot Dorsey himself and his ‘‘ pards” in the Star- route business The Washington newspaper which publishes this precious missive, and vouches for its genuineness, hints that 1t has more of the same sort, or perhaps of a worse sort, which may be forthcoming hereafter. Will not President Arthur take the hint? The way in which the appointment of new clerks has been going in the departments at Washington reminds one of the most ‘‘ haleyon and vociferous” days of the spoils system. It is reported from Washington that Senator Don Cameron “ gets” eighteen clerks, Senator Logan seven, Representative White, from Ken- tucky, as many as twenty-one, and that the Stalwarts among the Senators and Representa- tives generally ‘‘ get” a large majority of the whole lot. Of course there has been no ex- amination of the new clerks by the Govern- ment at all. They have been taken simply upon the recommendation of their political backers, and there is, therefore, a good deal of appropriateness in using the expression that Senator Don Cameron ‘got’ eighteen new clerks in the Pension Office. It must be as- sumed that Mr. Cameron has satisfied him- self of the qualifications of ‘‘ his” Govern- ment clerks. It is not probable that he put them through a competitive examination as to spelling, syntax, arithmetic, letter and ab- stract-writing and the like; but, as he is at present engaged in a rather doubtful political fight in Pennsylvania, he has undoubtedly se- lected ‘‘ his” eighteen clerks very carefully, with a view to the good the favor bestowed upon them and their families within the circle of their influence will do him in this contest. We have no doubt he has been quite consci- entious in that respect, and the Commissioner of Pensions may then see how he can get along with the eighteen new men. He may be sure that if one or more of them turn out badly, Senator Cameron will be promptly on hand to protect them against removal, on the conclusive ground that it would hurt him in his State ; and so all round. To illustrate this method of appointment, suppose one of | our great New York banks had a number of new officers and clerks to appoint, and it be- | came known that Mr. ‘‘ Clint” Wheeler ‘‘ got” the chief bookkeeper, Mr. ex-Insurance Su- perintendent Smyth ‘got’ the cashier, Mr. “‘Johnny” O’Brien “ got” the paying teller, Mr. ‘‘Jake” Patterson *‘ got” the receiving got” halfa | with that bank? ; | The refusal of Secretaries Lincoln and Tel- ler to appoint women to any of the clerk- ships recently provided for by Congress has caused a good deal of excitement among the female applicants for places, and we hear of indignation meetings, resolutions, and the like. The Secretaries are reported to have answered that for the places just filled, or to be filled, women were generally not well | be excelled. fitted. The larger question whether ap- pointments of any class are henceforth to be given to women in those two depart ments seems to have been left open. It is probable that if the opinions of all the department, bureau, and division chiefs were polled, they would be found to be very far from being unanimous. Some of these func- tionaries would insist that, on the whole, men are more reliable and steady workers than women; that the women are kept away from their desks by indisposition much more fre- quently, and, therefore, give a lower average of time to the Government; that they are usually fitted only for certain kinds of duties and will fail in the discharge of others; that it is more difficult to keep them in good discipline; that they are more frequently, more persistently, and more unreasonably asking for favors and indulgences; that many of them are apt incessantly to trouble their superior offi- cers by bringing down upon them men of influence, such as Congressmen and promi nent politicians, to urge their applications for favors or to protect them against the conse- quences of their neglect of duty or other short comings; and, finally, that the presence of so many women in the departments has given occasion to much intrigue and scandal. A searching and impartial investigation of the matter would probably show that there is some truth in all these objections, but it would show also that there is much to be said on the other side. The original reason for the employment of womenin the Government service no longer exists: there are no wives or daughters to be provided for on the ground that their husbands or fathers are in the war, and the number of real soldiers’ widows and orphans who are fit for oftice-work and who are not otherwise pro- vided for, 1s small, But taking a larger view of the matter, it is certain that we should open to women all fields of useful activity which they can efticiently and properly fill; and it will not be denied that there are many things in the Government departments which women can do as well as men, and some which they can do even better. It would be difficult to find better copyists than they are, and, unless we misinformed, it believed in the Treasury that counters and.assorters of paper currency they cannot In the discharge of those higher are is as | duties which require a certain degree of legal knowledge or mathematical faculty, or the ex- ercise of accurate judgment and reasoning power, men are found in the departments to show on an average more fitness than women. But some women—although their number is not large—have proved very efficient as ac- countants, examiners of claims, keepers of books and records, and so on; and if a proper system of examination and probation be introduced which gives women an equal chance with men, it will not be Gifficult to pick out those of superior merit, and to assign them to corresponding duties. It is certainly true that there have been some
Page 2
122 scandals which would not have happened bad employed in the public offices; but it is also true that the number of these scandals has been comparatively small, and that they might altogether have been avoid- ed had a proper method of appointment been no women be eu followed. Appointment by favor, and _par- ticularly by favor to those who recommended women for places, has been the source of the evil, Dr. James McCosh, President of Princeton College, has written a short but forcible letter to the 7imes civil-service reform. He discusses the movement, not merely from a theoretical, but also from a practical point of view. Ile lived in Great Britain when the reform ‘‘was discussed and carried there.” He was a member of a commission ‘‘ appoint- ed by the crown to organize the system ” on its first application to the Indian administration. Before he quit Great Britain he “ saw the good effects that followed immediately and visibly ” upon the adoption of the measure. The ques- tion, therefore, does not present itself to him as a speculative one. He looks wt it as an ex- periment already made with great success on the other side, and likely to prove as success- ful here. Dr. McCosh urges the continued agitation of the subject by thinking and edu- cated men. While he does not favor the dis- cussion of such questions in the pulpit, he be- lieves that ministers as citizens may profitably consider it, and that ‘‘colleges should speak out loudly and openly both by their officers and students.” on The testimony hitherto taken by the Tariff Commission is that of interested witnesses, but it will go far to inform the Commissioners of the abuses and absurdities of the existing system, if they wish to inform themselves. The frequent contradiction of one witness by another helps to establish the truth. For ex- ample, last Thursday a representative of the manufacturers of saddlery hardware said that the investment of millions of dollars in the business had been made under the present tariff; that if it were reduced by even 5 per cent. the country would be flooded with for- eign hardware, and that the duty ot 35 per cent. was not equal to the difference be- tween the of labor here and its cost abroad. If we accept this statement of the case as true, we must believe that, in conse- quence of the higher rate of wages, it costs at least 35 per cent. more to make the hard- ware in this country than in Europe;, that the tariff, by raising the price of the articles 35 per cent., enables the home manufacturer to compete with the foreign, and that even a slight reduction would make such competition impossible. But another representative of the same interest told a different story. He said that the tariff had not increased the price of the goods. Clearly, then, the tariff is of no use as a protective measure. This witness said the effect of the tariff had been ac- tually to lower the price. Why not repeal it then and send the price up? The wit- ness further made short work of the wages argument. He said that saddlery hardware was never so cheap before, not because of for- eign competition aided by pauper labor, but cost | on | | | | proved machinery.” The Nation. [ Number 894 account of “home competition and im- This is a demonstration of the failure of the protective tariff to pro- tect. The manufacturer must in some way find ‘‘ protection” against his American com- petitor. With all his concern for his highly- paid workmen, he does not hesitate to cut down the aggregate of their wages by using improved machinery to take the place of la- bor—as, indeed, there is no reason why he should hesitate. Another advantage of the English manufacturer mentioned by this wit- ness is that he can get copper cheaper; and the well-known fact was referred to that American copper is sold to English manufacturers for five cents a pound less than the price in this country. It is understood that a condition attached to the sale is that the copper shall return to this country only in a manufactured form. This is the way in which the American copper pro- ducer protects himself, and illustrates the folly of the high-tariff system. The Navy Department vindicated its dig- nity and traditional reputation recently by re- lieving Capt. J. K. Miller of the command of the frigate Tennessee. His offence was a curi- ous one, and consisted in the employment of one Henry Burnett, a Sandy Hook pilot, to bring the ship into New York harbor. Such employment is inconsistent with a rule which requires every commander in the service to be his own pilot, at least upon entering home ports. This rule originated in the times when we really had a navy and when it was proud of its seamanship. The suggestion that any naval officer could be taught anything by a sailor in the merchant service would then have been repelled with scorn. For a captain of a vessel-of-war in those days to ask a pilot to show him the way from the lightship to the Brooklyn Navy-yard would have been as un- dignified a proceeding as to ask the crew of a trading bark to reef his topsails or to ex- ecute any other nautical mancuvre. Times, however, have changed, and Captain Miller believed it to be not unbecoming to seek as- sistance in avoiding the dangerous shoals and deceptive currents of the bay. Mr. Burnett agrees with the captain that it would not have been safe for him to do anything else ; and their views are confirmed by the fact that the Tennessee afterward, in trying to go into Boston harbor without a pilot, ran aground. Senator Sherman has delivered a speech at Mansfield, Ohio, in which he defended the large river and harbor appropriations, as he probably would not have done had he still been Secretary of the Treasury, and in which he is reported to have said that the Sunday and the liquor questions are ‘‘an irrepressible conflict which must be met.” We do not know whether Mr. Sherman is correctly re- ported, but, if he is, he will upon reflection satisfy himself that these questions do not rep- resent any ‘irrepressible conflict” at all; that they cannot be ‘‘ met” and finally settled by le- gislative enactments, whatever attempts in that direction may be made; that they are really under the control of a public sentiment which gradually modifies the ways of thinking and habits of society in a manner which will make a law designed to overrule it a dead letter; that this public sentiment has its fits and starts, but finally always develops itself in the way of tolerance; and that these questions are most apt to push themselves forward on the political stage and to agitate the nerves of the politicians at times when there are no other issues strongly engaging the popular mind. The ‘‘irrepressible conflict ” in Ohio will sub- side again in due season. The agreement between the United States and the Republic of Mexico, by which the troops of the two parties are reciprocally authorized to cross the boundary line of the two countries in close pursuit of hostile Indians whenever it may be necessary, is undoubt- edly calculated to satisfy a long-felt want on that frontier. The territory of Mexico has al- ways served as a refuge for Indian desperadoes escaped from the United States, who used their asylum as a basis of operations for hostile incursions, This circumstance has, in a great measure, made Indian ‘“‘ wars ” in that region so frequent and interminable. Our troops have sometimes crossed the Mexican line without authority, but this always led to remonstrances on the part of the Mexican Government. The present agreement will, in a great measure, do away with these embar- rassments, although we are not sure that, in spite of the careful regulations it contains, it will not in the course of time prove a prolific source of ‘‘ claims.” The drainage of summer “‘resorts”’ is so fre- quently bad that the public at large have a good deal of interest in the typhoid cases which have caused so much trouble at the Bellevue Hotel, at Seabright. The admitted facts are that two of the guests, one of them a woman, were suddenly taken ill with typhoid fever, which, according to their side of the case, came from improper drainage. What- ever it came from, it caused a panic in the hotel, and great loss of business. The hotel pro- prietor, Mr. Corey, who has a lease of the premises, recouped himself to the extent of $5,000 by informing the friends of the pa- tients that unless that amount of money was immediately paid they would be turned out of the hotel. As the exposure was almost certain to be fatal to them, the money was paid, and they were allowed to remain. The friends of the patients now threaten to ‘“‘ make it hot” for Mr. Corey, and we trust they will succeed in doing so, if, as they maintain, he is responsible for the fever. There is no principle of law or justice which allows a hotel-keeper to extort money in this way for a fever contracted in consequence of the bad drainage of his premises, and generally it does come from bad drainage. People do not contract typhoid fever wilfully, and as they usually know little or nothing of the drain- age of the places they go to in summer, they are very much at the landlord’s mercy. If he can, the moment a disease of this kind breaks out, threaten those attacked with death by exposure, a new terror is added to summer seaside life. The ‘‘ Ford boys,” who killed Jesse James, have, it seems, been suffering in public
Page 3
Aug. 17, 1882] The Nation. 123 estimation through the misrepresentations of the press. A story had got about that they had been “ riotirg” in Richmond, Mis- sourl, which they deny emphatically, and say that they have not been in Richmond lately. They say that the fact is, a couple of low fellows, knowing their fame and posi- tion in society, ‘‘ went through” the town, ‘* claiming to be the Ford boys.” The real boys have therefore given notice of the fraud through the press, and desire that the two ruflians may be treated as they deserve. The boys have, it 1s said, like so many other distinguished characters, taken to the stage, and we regret to learn that they have lowered themselves somewhat by appearing in some sort of show in ‘‘a State Street dive.” They say, how- ever, that they had no idea of the character of the place, and had to ‘fill their contracts.” As to future plans, they propose to “star,” and hope to obtain engagements 1n first-class theatres. This frank statement of their in- tentions ought to remove the misunderstand- ing created by the behavior of their fraudu- lent rivals. It has been a dull and uneventful week in Wall Street. The New York banks added $1,147,875 to their surplus reserve, and the rates for demand loans ruled at 3@ 4 per cent. Foreign exchange was firm, but below the gold-exporting point. The merchandise ex- ports are increasing, but to a large extent the bills against them were engaged by bank- ers in July. The movement of securities be- tween New York and the foreign markets has been against New York to a moderate extent. The prices of railroad stocks were variable during the week, but in most instances higher figures were established. The general outlook for trade is encouraging, as the large crops are a solid basis for a full year of prosperity, seeing that the foreign demand for our food products promises to be larger than of late. In an English libel suit brought by a sculp- tor named Belt against Vanity Fair, the Judge, Baron [fuddleston, was reported to have said he would allow the plaintiff to make a bust of himself in the presence of the jury, in order to show what sort of a sculptor he was. This seems to have been taken as an intimation that the Judge was willing to allow ocular demonstration of all sorts, and, accordingly, a plaintiff in a recent suit for personal inju- ries against a railway company, in order to prove how lame he was, offered to walk across the court-room. Baron Huddleston however. refused to permit it, and said that he had been entirely misrepresented by the press, and had never said that Mr. Belt might make a bust of him. The general introduc- tion of tests of this sort would be productive of great inconvenience. We should have plaintiffs in libel suits not only modelling, but painting, singing, declaiming, acting, in order to show how unfair any criticism of their performances was. Moreover, if some paper should say, for instance, of Mr. Booth that he ranted, or of Nicolini that he could sing no more than a cat, no fair test would be possible in court, and there would be nothing for it but to take the jury to the theatre or opera on several successive nights to let them see and hear for themselves. This would involve a great deal of time and ex- pense, and the result would probably in most cases be a disagreement. Mr. Freeman, the historian, has been record- ing in the Fortnightly Review his impressions of America, derived from the tour which he made here last year, and he declares that the thing which principally struck him was the great similarity between England and the United States. Where he expected differences he finds resemblances. England and Ame- rica he discovered to be more alike than England and Scotland. The great American cities are very like Manchester and Liverpool. He thinks that the ideal after which the two branches of the race should strive, is for both to feel ‘‘at least as close a tie to one another as was felt of old by all members of the scattered Hellenic folk”; but for this purpose we ought all to have a com- mon name. Mr. Freeman, who confesses himself somewhat of a pedant on this sub- ject, will not hear of ‘‘ Anglo-Saxon,” because he does not think it historically or philo- logically correct. Nor will ‘‘ Briton ” do, be- cause it “‘is not the natural name by which an Englishman speaks of himself; it is used either in a half-laughing vein or because it is thought to be fine, or else of set purpose to find some name which shall take in all the people of Great Britain. The only alternative would seem to be the grotesque and rather ug.y form ‘ Britisher.’ And I always told my American friends,” he says, ‘‘ that I had rather be called a Britisher than an English- man, if by calling me an Englishman they meant to imply that they were not Englishmen themselves.” It may be that if all the mem- bers of our great and wise race were sud- denly to adopt the practice of calling them- selves ‘‘Britishers,” it would help on the cause of international amity, but there would of course be a difference between the use of such a term and that of ‘‘ Hellene” among the Greeks, who did not agree to call themselves Hellenes for the purpose of establishing a good understanding among themselves. They called themselves so because they could not help it, and it must be confessed that their common historic name did not prevent the different branches of the race from waging the most bloody and destructive wars with one another. It seems to be the tendency of English opi- pion at present to exaggerate the similarity be- tween the two countries, just as a generation ago it was the custom to exaggerate the differ- ences. Of course, within that period there have been enormous changes in the United States, while all parts of the world have grown more alike, owing to the increase of the facili- ties of communication. Sull, comparing the tour and observations of Mr. Freeman and other recent visitors with those of Dickens and his contemporaries, it is impossible to attribute the changed tone altogether to a changed condition of society at home and abroad. A generationago when an English- man inspected us, he did it with the expecta- tion of finding a new and totally distinct species from himself, and he invariably found one. Now, he comes with the expectation of finding similarity, and he findsthat. Formerly he was almost surprised to hear his own lan- guage spoken, and now he wants to have the whole race adopt a common name. _ This obviously may be pushed too far. As a na- tion, we have grown too prosperous and strong to care any longer very acutely about hostile foreign criticism ; but it ought to be un- derstood that there is one thing that we do in- sist upon, and that 1s, having peculiarities of our own. It is certainly possible to meet with Americans who are unduly vain of their coun- try, but the class of Americans who like to be mistaken for ‘‘ Britishers” is a smail one, and is eyed with some jealousy and distrust by their fellow-citizens. The ground is now fully cleared for the im- pending trial of arms in Egypt. The Porte, in its fashion, has proclaimed Arabi a rebel ; Russia has professed satisfaction with Eng- land’s explanation of the occupancy of Suez ; England and France have agreed, with re- serves, to Italy’s proposal, in the Conference, of a European police of the Canal; and Sir Garnet Wolseley has arrived at Alexandria, and for the moment finds himself unembar- rassed by the presence of Turkish troops. A few days will show what part Ismaflia may serve as one of the bases of his campaign. On the other side, if we may trust reports, Arabi is retorting on the Sultan by deposing him and doing his best to propagate a reli- gious war. The only significant political ut- terance of the week has been Mr. Glads.one’s speech at the Lord Mayor's banquet, with re- ference to England's disinterested undertaking to protect the interests of the civilized world in the Suez Canal. The ‘‘ Mussulman jurists” whom the cable despatches report to have given a legal opi- nion on the status of Arabi before the law, must not be imagined to be what we call “jurists” in this country. Law in Turkey, especially public law, is not discriminated from religion, and both are ascertained by a construction of the texts of the Koran, Ori- ental jurists, not being familiar with the prin- ciple of stare decisis, decide each case as it arises without reference to whether it is 1n con- flict or accordance with previous decisions, and consequently no two decisions are necessarily alike. They have in giving their replies only one fundamental guide, and that is to satisfy the Sultan. Knowing this, the Sultan wisely frames his questions in such a way that the jurists may know what the answer vught to be. In the present case the cable despatch only gives the answer, but we can give the question. It was as follows: ‘*O jurists,1s Arabi Pasha, in so far as he has disobeyed the Caliph, a rebel, and may he be unceremoniously treated as such ; but in so far as he has been a defender of a Mohammedan country aguinst the aggressive designs of Christians, has he merely ful- filled the duties of a good Mussulman’? May the Sultan punish Arabi Pasha, if some act of rebellion 1s proved against him, while dis- sociating himself from those who wish to crush Arabi Pasha as the defender of Islam ?” A jurist who could not tell how to answer this would be immediately dismissed from the force,
Page 4
SUMMARY OF THE WEEK’S NEWS. {WeEDSESDAY, August 9, to Tvespay, August 15, 1882, inclusive.) DOMESTIC. WASHINGTON was immediately deserted, after the adjournment of Congress, by the politi- cians and offce-holders. In several of the Gov- ernment departments, however, there 1s con- siderable activity. In the State Department the laws recently passed ure being deposited and recorded. ‘The Treasury is occupied with the transfer of bonds. The office of the Super- vising Architect is busily engaged in preparing plans for the new public buildings ordered by Congress. The Navy Department is interest- ed in beginning a new fleet of vessels. In the War and Interior Departments pension claims are occupying a number of new clerks. A list of 422 appointments to clerkships in the Pen- sion Office was announced on Thursday, the first of the 800 provided for in the Legislative Bill. The appointments were all made b political recommendation, and not by a civil- service examination. Stalwart Senators got a large share. Of the entire list only about a half-dozen are women. The reason announced is that the duties of the positions are not suited to their sex. The disappointed women held an indignation meeting in Washington on Thursday night. During the last hours of Congress, Senator Windom presented a report on the whiskey investigation. The report asserts that no cor- rupt action had been proved in regard to the passage of the Bonded Spirits Bill. It finds that an association of distillers in Kentucky raised $5,000 to pay a lawyer for pushing the measure, but that nothing was done by him inconsistent with the character of an honor- able attorney. The imputations cast on honor- able journalists were not supported by evi- dence. President Arthur left Washington on Thurs- day afternoon, on the steamer Despatch, for New York. He will remain in this city for about ten days, and then make a short visit to Newport. The Secretary of the Navy has approved a flag of navy-blue bunting, with the American coat of arms in the centre, as the President’s flag. It will fly from the mainmast of every vessel when the President is on board. The closing arguments in the Star-route trial have been in progress in Washington in the Crimmal Court during the week. On Wed- nesday morning it was announced tbat the fol- lowing order of speaking had been agreed upon by counsel: Mr. Ker to open for the Government, to be followed by two replies from the defence. Colonel Bliss will then de- liver his address, to which the defence will be allowed three replies. The Attorney-General or Mr. Merrick will next speak, followed by three replies from the other side, and then the At- torney-General or Mr. Merrick will close the argument. Mr. Ker then began his argument. It was an analysis aud restatement oi the evi- dence in regard to each of the routes, with a running commentary of sarcasm and invective. Mr. Ker closed his speech on Friday. Mr. Carpenter, counsel for the Dorseys, opened the argument for the defence in the Star-route trial on Monday. He reviewed Mr. Ker’s argument, and attempted to show the necessity for ‘‘expedition.” His speech was continued on Tuesday. A letter was published in a Washington Sunday newspaper, on August 13, from ex- Senator 8. W. Dorsey to President Garfield, dated February 7, 1881. The editor of the newspaper professed to have found the animus of the Star-route prosecution in the letter. It is, in short, an impudent Ictter of instructions to the President, who was soon to be inaugu- rated, not to take advice in regard to his Cabi- net appointments in New York from Col. George Bliss or Mr. Knox, or other men of that liberal class, but to send for ‘‘ Conkling or Arthur, the two men who elected you, with the aid of Grant.” Mr. Dorsey also remarks, , rT The Nation “‘T am tired of this blathering talk about McVeagh to go into the Cabinet from Pennsy]l- vania, and James from New York. Such de- testable rot should be smoked out at once, and you ought to do it in some public way. As Il have repeatedly urged upon you, there is but one appointment you ought to make from New York, and that is Chief Judge Folger to be Secretary of the Treasury.” General Garfield was further kindly informed that “all that Mr. Conkling wants, and all that General Arthur desires, is a fair show and an honest deal. These two men, with their friends, represent the intelligence, the progressive and the ag- gressive elements of New York Republican- ism.” The fall campaign was opened at Mansfield, Ohio, on Saturday night, by Senator Sherman. He defended large appropriations for rivers and harbors and public buildings. On State questions he declared the Sunday and liquor questions to be an irrepressible conflict, which must be met. He was in favor of the observ- ance of the Sabbath. The Republicans of Indiana, in Convention, on Wednesday, nominated Emanuel R. Hawn for Secretary of State, Roswell 8. Hill for Treasurer, and other minor officers. The plat- torm demands that the pendivg prohibition amendments to the Constitution of the State shall be submitted to the people, the fountain of power, by the next Legislature, for decision thereon ; that there be such a reduction in taxa- tion that no unnecessary burdens may be in- flicted upon the consumers of i:mported articles, nor upon our domestic industries ; and that Congress adopt laws to secure a thorough re- form of the civil service. The National and State Administrations are warmly approved. The Kansas Republican State Convention on Thursday renominated Governor St. John by a very large majority. The platform de- clares unqualifiedly in favor of prohibition ; demands the enactment of laws regulating railroads ; and requests the next Legislature to submit a woman-suffrage amendment to the Constitution. The Illinois Prohibition Convention met at Bloomington on Wednesday. It adopted a strict prohibition platform, and nominated Judge J. G. Irwin, of Madison, for State Trea- surer, and Professor Andrews, of Galesburg, for Superintendent of Public Instruction. Senator John Stewart, the Independent Re- publican candidate for Governor in Pennsyl- vania, has forwarded a letter to General Bea- ver, the Stalwart nominee, proposing a joint discussion of political differences in the State. The Republican Executive Committee of South Carolina have decided to hold a State Convention on September 12, but to endorse the nominations ot the Greenbackers. At Saratoga, the American Bar Association was in session for several days during the week. Mr. Francis Kernan delivered the an- nual address, giving a review of recent legisla- tion in various States. Many valuable legal papers were read during the session. After a long discussion, a resolution was adopted ap- proving a bill for the relief of the Supreme Court of the United States, which was ad- vocated by ex-Secretary Evarts. The Photograpbers’ Association of America held its annual Convention wn Indianapolis last week. More than 500 delegates were pre- sent. At Long Branch the Tariff Commission heard the pleas of representatives of a number of industries during the week. On Friday they paid a visit to the Trenton potteries. In secret session at Chicago, the Amalga- mated Iron and Steel Association adopted a new constitution, and laid the basis of a better understanding with the manufacturers. It is said they guaranteed the manufacturers not to ask an advance on the rolling and puddling scale prices for five years. In the Pittsburgh, Pa., iron region, more mills are resuming work, with non-union men [ Number 894 as operatives. The Philadelphia grain-hand- lers’ strike was ended by the men returning to work at the old rates, Heavy rains have fallen throughout the West and Northwest within the past week, and in some sections great damage has been done by them to the crops. In many places in north- ern Ohio the hay crop will be a total loss. Wheat in stacks and shocks is beginning to sprout. The oat crop is also injured. In the Northwest the damage done was trifling, and the wheat crop just harvested is said to be the finest ever raised there. There was frost in Wisconsin on Thursday morning, and a snow- squall on Lake Michigan. An agreement has been entered into by this country and Mexico, providing for the recipro- cal crossing of the international boundary-line by troops of either country in pursuit of hos- tile Indians. Gen. J. Rufino Barrios, President of Guate- mala, sailed for Liverpool from this city on Saturday. It is said that before sailing a con- vention was signed which will end the dispute about the Guatemala-Mexico frontier. The convention, it is reported, contains the follow- ing provisions : The high contracting Powers agree to submit their differences to arbitration by the President of the United States. Guate- mala abandons her claims to Soconusco, and recognizes it as now belonging to Mexico. A boundary commission is to be appointed b both of the contracting Powers to run a divid- ing line between them. The British Government has been searching the foreign mails for seditious matter, Clip- pings from an American newspaper which were transmitted in a registered letter have been intercepted. The Post-office Department of the United States acknowledges the per- missibility of the proceedings under the inter- national postal treaty. There have been sixty-two cases and twelve ceaths from yellow fever at Brownsville, Texas. It has also appeared at New Orleans. It is epidemic at Matamoras, Mexico. A virulent disease has +t among cat- tle in Pennsylvania, West Virginia, Alabama, and North Carolina. Judge Donohue, in the Supreme Court Chambers in this city, rendered a decision on Thursday, in a suit brought against Dr. Ste- phen H. Tyng, jr., by Edward L. Owen, his partner in stock speculations. The latter claimed more than $5,000 as the balance due him after all credits were allowed. The Judge decided that he thought the plaintiff honestly intended to give a bill of particulars, but it was too general, and should be made more definite before payment could be enforced. A brakeman on the Elevated Railroad, in this city, on Friday, was thrown from his platform to the street below in a scuffle which he had with a bar-tender, named Reddington, who tried to board the train at Bleecker Street after the gates were closed. He was fatally injured. A woman was run over on the same day at the Fiftieth Street station, on the Sixth Avenue road. She died at midnight. Commodore Shufeldt, who negotiated the Corean treaty, is ill at the Naval Hospital in Mare Island, Cal. He has just returned from China. Gen. G. K. Warren was buried on Saturday from All Saints’ Chapel, Newport. Ex-United States Senator George R. Dennis, of Maryland, died on Sunday. He served in the Senate from 1873 to 1879. Mr. Jesse Hoyt, for many years one of the most prominent business men of this city, died on Monday morning, at the age of sixty- seven. He was engaged in the grain commis- sion business until 1881. He had large rail- way interests in the West. FOREIGN. At the seat of the war in Egypt the week has been marked by preparation, and by a few skirmishes. The armored train, on its usual night patrol on Wednesday evening,
Page 5
Aug. 17, 1882] exchanged a few shots with Arabi’s second line of intrenchments near Mahalla Junction. It is asserted that the rebels are fortifying Nefersa Junction, where the Suez, Ismailia, and Cairo lines of railroad meet. The enemy have evacuated the works immediately oppo- site the Ramleh position, and there will be no attack at present ; but Arabi is having con- structed, within three miles of Ramleh, a for- midable redan and embankment, thirty feet high. The British ship Svperd fired shell at the works on Friday. On that day Captain Ewart made a-plucky reconnoissance from Fort Meks. He started at 1 o'clock in the morning with an interpreter, and by daybreak had ridden ten miles into the country. He ascertained that there was no truth in the re- port of large bodies of the enemy in the direc- tion in which he rode. A council of leading British military au- thorities has been investigating the effects of the bombardment of the forts at Alexandria, and the general tenor of the evidence is that masonry 1S useless against modern guns, but that earthworks turn every shot. A skirmish took place on Sunday to the westward of Alexandria, beyond the Meks forts. The sailors and marines stationed there drove the Arabs back with the fire of a small field-piece. There was no loss on the British side. Great activity has prevailed in England in the preparation of troops for Egypt. Daily several transports have started with regiments on board. In India there has been similar activity. On Wednesday, five transports with troops left for Egypt from Bombay. General Wolseley arrived at Alexandria on Tuesday, and took command of the Army. The Berlin organ of Prince Bismarck, in an article friendly in tone toward England, de- nies the rumors of an intention of placing the Suez Canal permanently under the control of a mixed commission similar to that on the Danube. As the British traffic on the Canal immensely preponderates, the Powers, it re- marks, cannot expect England to subordinate such vast interests to the decision of a non- English majority. At a meeting of the Conference in Con- stantinople on Thursday, the Sultan submitted the following proclamation: ‘‘ Arabi Pasha, having a second time transgressed the law by taking authority which does not belong to him, and having presumed to menace the vessels belonging to an old and tried friend an! ally of Turkey, is, for these misdeeds, proclaimed arebel, together with his adherents. Be it known to all that obedience is due solely to the Khedive, who is the representative of the Sultan.” Lord Dufferin, the English representa- tive, then announced the assent of England to the proposal of the Italian Ambassador for tem- porary international protection of the Suez Canal. It is understood that he did not insist that England should have supreme command of the troops in Egypt. England's assent to Italy’s proposal is coupled with a reservation that if international police are sent to guard the Canal, they shall not interfere with mili- tary operations. The Russian representative asked why England had occupied Suez. Lord Dufferin replied that the step was taken on account of military necessity, and in order to save the town from pillage. Lord Dufferin insists that, in order to secure harmony of ac- tion, no movements of the Turkish troops, when they are in Egypt, shall take place with- out the preliminary consent of General W olse- ley. The Sultan has ordered that an addition be made to the proclamation against Arabi, declaring him a rebel, because, in resisting, he acts contrary to the principles ot the Koran. Importance is attached to this men- tion of the Mohammedan Bib!e. No Turkish troops will be landed in Egypt until the arri- val of the Turkish Special! Commissioners. France has accepted, under certain reserva- tions, the proposal for collective protection of the Suez Canal. It is reported that Arabi called a meeting of The Nation. the Ulemas on Sunday, and obtained from them a decree deposing the Sultan and naming the Shenf of Mecca as Caliph. On Tues- day Arabi was ordered by the Sultan peremp- torily to lay down his arms. If he refuses, the Sultan will leave him to be dealt with by the English. At Constantinople, on Monday, the Con- ference finally agreed to the Italian proposal in regard to collective police supervision of the Suez Canal. The proclamation against Arabi will not be onal until the convention is signed. At the Lord Mayor’s banquet in London, on Wednesday evening, to the British Minis- ters, Mr. Gladstone, in response to a toast, said with reference to the Egyptian question: ‘* It is of vital importance that the position of Eng- land should not be misunderstood. Forces have gone to Egypt in prosecution of great interests of the empire. Unless those interests exist it would not have been possible for us to find a justification for intervention. But let it be known and proclaimed from this spot that those interests are not ours alone, but interests we have in common with every state in Eu- rope—nay, with the whole civilized world.” In regard to the Suez Canal, he said that the utmost they had in view was to keep that gate open, and the country in which it is situated peaceable. ‘This was a work which every country in Europe should perform. In con- clusion, he said : ‘* Wedo not go to war with the Egyptian people, but to rescue them from the oppression of military tyranny ; nor do we make war upon the Mohammedan religion, as Eng- lishmen respect the convictions of believers in every other faith. We do not want to repress the growth of liberty in Egypt, but desire that she be prosperous. England goes to Egypt with clean hands, and with no secret intention to conceal from other nations.” In the House of Commons on Thursday, Mr. Gladstone said that an indefinite occupation of Egypt was not contemplated. The ultimate condi- tion of Egypt could not be settled by any one Power. A meeting of Conservative Peers was held at the residence of Lord Salisbury, in London, on Thursday. Lord Salisbury adhered to his original view in regard to pressing the Lords’ amendments to the Arrears Bill, but he was overruled by a large majority of those present. The matter came up in the House of Lords later in the day. Lord Salisbury then de- clared that he thought the bill was a public blunder, but as he found himself in a hopeless minority he would not challenge a division. The Lords then acquiesced in the rejection of the first amendment by the House of Com- mons, and agreed to all the reamendments. It is said that Lord Salisbury thinks of declin- ing the Tory leadership, in view of this re- buff. The Duke of Richmond took the lead in urging the concessions upon the Conserva- tives. Mr. Gladstone has announced that Parlia- ment will adjourn next Friday until the 24th or 26th of October. The threatened strike of the Irish constabu- lary has been averted, or at least postponed, by the tact of the Government. On Wednes- day the Limerick police, as a consequence of an interview between the County Inspector and the Clonmel deputation, in which the for- mer acknowledged that their claims were justifiable, telegraphed all over Ireland that they were resolved to suspend the agitation for the present, pending the action of the Govern- ment. The Cork police took similar action, and repudiated the charge that they were in collusion with the Fenians. Earl Spencer ad- dressed the constabulary in Dublin, and an- nounced that $900,000 would be immediately distributed, and any grievance inquired into. Thomas Walsh, who was arrested at the time of the seizure of arms at Clerkenwell, Ireland, and convicted of treason-felony, has been sentenced to seven years’ penal servitude. Henry George, the American political econo- mist, was arrested in Loughrea, Ireland, on 125 Wednesday, under the Curfew section of the Crime Act, and kept in custody until he could give a satisfactory account of himself. He was rearrested on Thursday, at Athenry, and accused of associating with suspects, but was liberated on Friday. Stephen J. Meany, the correspondent of a New York newspaper, was arrested on Thursday night, in County Clare, Ireland, charged with being a dangerous cha racter. He was subsequently released on giv ing bail for his good behavior for six months. At a special meeting of the Ladies’ Land League, in Dublin, on Thursday, the League was dissolved, and a recommendation was passed that leagues be established throughout the country to teach the rising generation the national history. ‘ Theannual Convention of the Irish Land League of Great Britain was held in Manches ter, England, on Saturday, Three hundred delegates were present. Resolutions were _— relative to the death of Miss Fanny ?arpell. A report presented asserted that the Highlands of Scotland were ripe for land agi tation. A resolution making peasant propri tary one of the objects of the League was olen ed by a large majority. An amendment em bodying Mr. Davitt’s land-nationalization scheme was rejected. The justice of aiding the laborers was recommended to Irish farmers Westgate, the self-confessed assassin of Lord Frederick Cavendish and Mr. Burke, in Dublin, has arrived at the Island of Jamaica, A de spatch from there says that the evidence im plicating him in the crime is strong The Dublin Exhibition was opei 3, and the O’Connell statue was unveiled in that city, on Tuesday, with great ceremonies. The North German Lloyd's steamer ose’, from Bremen for New York, went aground off Lizard Point, England, at 8:30 o'clock on Wednesday morning. The accident happened during a dense fog. There were about 700 passengers on board, but there was no panic among them when the vessel struck. They were all safely landed at Penzance. The mails and specie were also landed, and part of the cargo was taken off. The Mosel has a big hole through her bow, and the bottom from stem to stern was broken. An effort is making to raise the vessel. A meeting of English gentlemen interested in rowing was held in London on Friday eve ning, and resolutions were passed expressing sympathy with the Hillsdale, Mich., crew, and protesting against the action of the self-elect ed Rowing Association in excluding them from amateur races. William Stanley Jevons, Professor of Politi- al Economy in the University of London, was drowned while bathing at Bexhill, Eng land, on Tuesday. He was forty-seven years of age. His best known work is ‘The Prin ciples of Science.’ The condition of Tripoli is alarming to Eu- ropeans. The natives talk of a massacre of Christians. A holy war is being preached throughout Morocco against Christians. A great anti-Christian demonstration has oc- curred at the funeral, in Beirut, Syria, of a Moslem who, it was reported, was murdered by the Christians. Many tled to the moun- tains. A score were arrested, and one was killed. A decree has been promulgated in France, giving duly authorized American joint-stock companies a legal status in that country. A decree closing the session was read in both the French Chambers un Wednesday. Professor Esmarch, the eminent German surgeon, has published an essay on the treat- ment of General Gartield’s wound, in which he holds that the late President might have lived had it not been for the treatment he re ceived. The vessel conveying Lieutenant Bove and the members of the Italian Antarctic expedt- tion has been wrecked off Cape Horn. All on board were saved.
Page 6
126 THE STAR-ROUTE DEFENCE. NovTHING in the Star-route trials has attracted attention than the tone of defiance adopted both by the defendants and by their leading counsel from the beginning. Mr. Car- penter’s address to the jury on Monday was one of the most impudent harangues ever de- livered in a court of justice. He denounced the Attorney-General for appearing in the more case, and denied that it was possible that the President should have instructed him to prose- cute. The reason that he assigned for this asser- tion was that ‘ Chester A. Arthur was a man,” and therefore it was incredible that he should have decided to proceed against “his friend, his familiar, his acquaintance, one with whom he was on terms of kindness and hospitality, one with whom he had associated in political life for years, and one for whom, about a month his to the Vice- Presidency, he had borne testimony as a capa- ble and honest man.” The Attorney-General had said that he was ‘“ the mouth of this Gov- ernment to urge that this case be heard and determined.’ If he spoke for the President, this amounted, according to Mr. Carpenter, to say- ing that the President ‘‘ was in a conspiracy, contrary to justice and humanity, to crush the defendants arrayed in this court.” He was yoing on to prove still further how unlikely it was that the President should have taken any part in the conspiracy to ruin Brady and Dor- sey, by a reference to the Delmonico dinner of last year, but was stopped by a reminder from the Court that there was no evidence re- lating to that dinner in the case. The whole drift of his speech was that some wicked and designing men had conspired to ruin his cli- ents, and that they were hiding behind the President and the Attorney-General. This is all of a piece with the conduct of the defence from the first. The principal rea- son why the defendants’ guilt has generally been assumed is that their behavior has been that of guilty men. After first insisting on a trial for purposes of a vindication, they inter- posed every technical defence they could in- vent to prevent the case going to the jury. Finally, being obliged to go to trial on the facts, they opened fire on Court and witnesses through newspapers controlled and owned by one of the defendants, and when this de- fendant had an opportunity of going on the stand, and testifying in his own favor, he declined to do so and remained dumb, with testimony in the case nearly con- clusive as to his guilt, if believed. Finally, while the case is being summed up, a letter purporting to be written by this defendant is published in his interest, the object of which is, if anything, to show that he is the victim of a conspiracy, but which in reality consists of nothing but foul-mouthed insolence and abuse, and reveals nothing except the low cha- racter of the person who says he wrote it. It must be remembered that in discussing the ‘‘ guilt” of the Star-route defendants, the jury which is trying the indictments for con- spiracy is considering a different question from that in which the public at large are interested. There is nothing more technical than an indictment for conspiracy; no criminal offence is harder for the prosecution to make , before accession The Nation. { Number 89 out satisfactorily, and none in which the de- fence has so many loopholes of escape. No- body can possibly say in the present position of the case any more than the Court has it- self said—that there is sufticient evidence of guilt to require that the jury shall pass upon it. But the question of *‘ guilt,” par- ticularly in the case of Brady, in which the public are interested, is not simply the ques- tion of liability under this indictment for As alleged by Mr. Carpenter, it may be that if Walsh’s testimony is true— that Brady told him he taxed all the contrac- tors twenty per cent. on *‘ expedition ”—this would technically be extortion, and not con- spiracy to extort; and a verdict of not guilty would leave it entirely uncertain whether Brady’s escape was not owing to some such technical distinction as this. All that the pub- lic care about, however, is to know whether Brady defrauded the Government and betrayed his official trust. Now, in arriving at a conclusion as to this matter, Brady’s behavior and that of his counsel are important elements in the case. If they had from the first set about to produce a general certainty of their guilt, they could not have done the work better. The behavior of the ring has been very much like that of the Tweed ring here. When Tweed’s frauds were detected, the material proof (consisting in the inflation of contracts) resembled a good deal the material proof in the Star- route cases, and the technical difficulties in the way of legal proof were quite as great; indeed, it seemed almost impossible for a long time to get any legal redress of any kind. But as some of the ring ran away and others con- fessed, and those who stayed brazened it out, much as Brady and Dorsey are brazening it out now, the only question of guilt in which the public had any interest was settled long be- fore any of the rascals were brought to justice. It must be considered fortunate for society on the whole that this is so. If the legal presumption of innocence that we always hear so much about from the defenders of men like these, meant that nobody must form any opinion about their characters and acts except under the technical rules of law applicable to an indictment, society would hardly be able to protect itself with much success against rascality. Ifon the acquittal of such a man as Brady, the public had immediately to treat him as an honest man, it is hard to see why he should not be restored topublic favor, and again be put in possession of public funds. Dorsey, who is involved with Brady, actually does take very much this ground, and has refused to resign from the Republican committee, because, he says, until he has been tried by a jury, it is impossible to say whether he is a criminal or a good and pure man who is amply qualified for party leadership. This was the ground that Tweed took, and he actually got himself elected to office by a popular vote after his crimes had been fully exposed. But it 1s to be hoped that the notion that nothing short of a conviction for felony will disqualify a man for politics, or put him beyond the reach of ‘‘vindication,” is suffi- ciently on the wane to make Dorsey's position untenable, and the repetition of such defences as that of Brady impossible. conspiracy. THE SALVATION ARMY AND THE CHURCH. THE rise and progress of the revival caused by ‘‘ General” Booth by means of the Salva- tion Army in England, is attracting more and more attention from the regular churches. Unlike many revivals, the Army acts in a cer- tain sense in hostility to the Church of Eng- land as at present organized. In the current number of the Contemporary Review, ‘‘General ” Booth gives an account of his work, and the Rev. Randall T. Davidson criticises its opera- tions with great acuteness. The ‘‘ General” de- clares that for his purposes the ordinary sys- tems of church government are of no use, and that an absolute military despotism is the only thing that will produce ‘‘ unbroken peace and harmony.” He has been engaged in his task for some seventeen years, and has expe- rimented with other systems, but finds nothing but army discipline of any avail. His Army is really an autocracy, which recalls that of the Jesuits, and isin many respects similar to the Mormon system. The ‘General’ is sole trustee of the property of the Army, which now yields an annual income of $350,000; he is empowered to nominate his successor in the trust; he can dismiss any of his ‘‘ captains” at pleasure. It seems to be understood that “General” Booth is to be succeeded in com- mand by his eldest son. There is nothing new about the doctrines of the Army, which are those of what ‘‘ General ” Booth calls the ‘‘ old-fashioned Gospel ”’—the Gospel of ‘‘a crucified Saviour, who shed real blood to save men from a real guilt and a real danger of a real hell.” The Gospel is preached —and this is an essential part of the system— in the streets, wherever a crowd can be col- lected, and this, of course, is easiest in the worst quarters of large cities. In very low neighborhoods the Army gets possession of notorious places of amusement, which it con- verts into Army headquarters, and in many instances, to judge by testimony cited by Dr. Davidson, has made neighborhoods of this sort, formerly given over to vice and crime, quiet and respectable. Of course, such work as this cannot be done without risk of mob hostility and violence, and there has been much trouble in the streets, though mob persecution of the Army has only helped on the cause, as per- secution in the long run must. : In the Church of England the success of the movement is watched with great and increas- ing interest, among other reasons because, as Dr. Davidson insists, one of the main agencies in the work is the recognition of the power of ‘‘testimony ” in converting sinners, something ‘*almost unknown in the Church of England.” We are familiar enough with it in this coun- try, but Dr. Davidson mentions with surprise that he has seen people ‘‘sit agape for half an hour listening to the same ‘testimony,’ re- peated almost in the same words, by man after man, woman after woman, when they would not have listened to it attentively for ten min- utes had it been quoted second-hand by an ed- ucated teacher.” But ‘‘ General” Booth and his wife, whose influence in the movement seems to be almost as great as her husband’s, have greatly intensified this revival agency in the present movement. They endeavor to
Page 7
Aug. 17, 1882]
make use not merely of the contagious effects of ‘‘testimony,” but they rely greatly for aid on the universal modern passion for publicity and notoriety. Privacy of any kind, even in prayer, is almost unknown, if not forbid- den. Sensationalism of every kind is encou- raged. The Army has a press of its own, which has a large and increasing circulation, both among young and old. The War Cry, with a circulation of 300,000 a week, is mainly devoted not to appeal or exhortation, but to encouraging the reader, by means of accounts of the increasing success of the movement, to believe that it isa ‘‘live movement,” a “‘ big thing,” which he had better join if he wants to keep up with the times. The book of ‘* Doctrines of Discipline ” contains the follow- ing advice, which it will be seen woulll do credit to an accomplished advertising agent : ‘‘ Make your bills and posters striking in what you say on them, and the method of printing, the color of the paper or ink, the way they are stuck up, given away,and thelike. Theycan be carried about on an umbrella, on a man’s hat; round his person like a church-bell, with his head out at the top, and his feet at the bottom; on a monster box, pushed bya man or drawn by a donkey, or in ten thou- sand different forms. Invent for yourselves.” Confession and penance are all made public, and even children are encouraged to publish letters giving accounts not only of their own spiritual condition, but of that of their parents. Thus we find one precocious correspondent of the Little Soldier, aged eight, writing: ‘‘I am still trusting in Jesus. I mean to fight unto the end, and give all my days to Jesus. My father and mother are not saved yet”; while another, two years older, says: ‘‘Thank God, I am saved and on my way to heaven. My two brothers, George and Ted- dy, are saved, and baby May. I am sorry that father and mother are not saved yet, but hope they will soon. Mother is very fond of reading novels to father in bed at night.” Dr. Davidson objects to all this, and says that it is not only not Christianity, but is directly opposed to the teachings of Christ. ““No body of Christians, I believe, has ever before striven thus to live their whole life in the full glare of day.” A system of discipline which compels young girls to stand forward upon an open platform and confess their sins to a mob, and which encourages little children to boast of their ‘‘ getting ahead” of their parents in being saved, he thinks immoral; but, curi- ously enough, he sees no reason why these ‘“‘extravagances” should not be given up without the movement's losing its attrac- tions. But obviously the secret of its suc- cess lies in these extravagances. There is no doubt that for large masses of people there is a far greater satisfaction to be derived from making their conversion notorious and public than from any sort of secret repentance; and the Army’s use of the press stimulates this passion. The Church of England is, of all existing Churches, the one which has hitherto most discountenanced this craving, and now it finds itself confronted by a revival which, in prose- lyting work, outbids it by reversing the command, ‘‘ Thou, when thou prayest, enter into thy closet, and when thou hast shut thy door, pray to thy Father which is in se-
The Nation. cret,” making it read, ‘‘Thou, when thou prayest, go into the street, and when thou hast collected a crowd, pray as loudly as possible, and before many days thou shalt see thy name in print.” Add to this that the movement is a temper- ance movement conducted among the classes which suffer most directly and visibly from the effects of drink, and the reasons for its succeeding where the Church of England has confessedly failed become plainer still. Cu- riously enough, an attempt is now being made to adopt its methods within the Church. A clergyman in Surrey has been doing this for eighteen months, and he declares that he has found the processions, testimony meetings, and public penance work like a charm. ‘All our other efforts at evangelizing have failed to gather in the lowest classes. But since we have adopted the present methods the worst characters have been brought within the sound of the Gospel, and most encouraging instances of real conversion to God have been the result.” This shows that it is really the methods which produce the effect. The Sal- vation Army, which goes forth even to the antipodes, has begun work in this country also, and it is, of course, impossible to pre- dict that it may not have a considerable suc- cess here. But there is in the United States no established Church which can feel that its proper province is being invaded by the re- vival, and the Salvation Army will, if success- ful, be merely one more religious organization on a ground which is very fruitful of them. How long the converts will remain banded together in their new Church is another ques- tion. COMMON SCHOOLS IN THE TWO CAPI- TALS OF RUSSIA. ENovuGH has been said lately in newspapers and periodicals of the literary ability of Count Tol- stoi, Minister of Public Instruction during the reign of Alexander II., and now Minister of the Interior, and of his zeal in founding universities and colleges (gymnasiums); but not enough of his narrow-mindedness and his infatuation with his own schemes. He founded new universities and professorships, and made laws to suppress the independence of science; he increased con- siderably the number of classical gymnasiums, and decreased the number of Real and commer- cial schools: Latin and Greek alone were to save Russia. For elementary instruction Count Tol- stoi did less than nothing. Of the truth of this assertion, an essay entitled ‘‘ The Common Schools in Moscow and St. Petersburg,” by Baron N. A. Korf, in the June number of the Huropean Messenger, furnishes abundant proof: “If Russia had,” so he begins, ‘‘only the hundredth part of all the excellent institutions decreed by legislation, she would be one of the happiest countries on earth; but it is well known that she has not: the law is one thing, the reality quite another. It would be useless to enumerate the laws which are not carried out, and more useless still to recite those which are entirely un- accomplishable.” Russia had a school-law as early as 1763 (France had none until 1794). Catherine, in the year 1775, ordered “schools to be established in all cities, towns, and larger villages of the em- pire,” and at her own expense opened a public school in St. Petersburg (1781); but, unfortu- nately, she did not find as many imitators in this action as in her vices. The number of pub- lic schools in the first capital of Russia was in the year 1802 but thirteen, Then the Ministry of
127 Public Instruction was established, and great progress was expected. After three-quarters of a century (1877), St. Petersburg had sixteen pub- lic schools! The communities repeatediy a» xed the Ministry's permission to establish schools on their own account (for instance, St. Petersburg in 1867), but the answer was always a refusal. Large numbers of children not being able to find room in the few schools of St. Petersburg, the city proposed to satisfy their desire for learning by temporarily introducing so called after-dinner- schools. The very same Ministry which con- stantly overburdened the young students of the gymnasiums to an alarming degree, rejected the city’s proposal, because after-dinner-schools were “contrary to the laws of modern pedagogics and hygiene.” Another city offered the public schools a collection of books; they were not ac cepted, because their titles were not in the cata logue of useful books published by a committee of the Ministry of Public Instruction. Even now, when the cities have finally got to a certain extent the right of self-government tn these matters, granted years before te the provinces and districts, the Ministry seems to be a constant hindrance. In 1878 the city of Moscow wanted to establish a higher school for girls under the name of “Alexander School.” The permission of the Ministry was solicited, and, after a delay of fully ten months, the Minister (Count Tolstoi) deigned to reply that he could not agree to the name of the new school. The Duma (Board of Aldermen) of the city of Moscow wisely decided to give up the project altogether. The number of pupils taught (which is more important than the number of schools) is now increasing in both the capitals—in Moscow, where there has always been more interest in public affairs, steadily ; in St. Petersburg, where the public schools up to 1877 were unpardonably neglected, rapidly. In addition to the increase of schools and of pupils taught, we notice a far greater increase still in the number of children turned away for want of room. During the last four years not less than 6,945 children, all eager to learn at least to read and to write, could not be admitted to the public schools of St. Petersburg and Moscow, as the following tables will show : Moscow. St. Petersburg. : 3 x « 12 2 3 3 2 s $18 = z : 3 5 -» << s = 2 3 o F £ 2 F a a 1870 6 350 ‘ Ste 1875 23 1,950 ian seen nie aa 1878 33 3,506 877 23 ave 326 1879 = 38 3,862 917 dl 1,890 763 1880 ao 4,138 1,147 53 2,362 600 1881 438 4,691 1,516 88 4,074 700 The age at which pupils enter the schools varies very much. In the capitals and other larger cities children from four to five years of age often apply for admission, and at St. Peters- burg 91 per cent. of all pupils are under twelv: years, In the country, children seldom enter school before their ninth year Moreover, in th country they are without all preparation what ever, while in the cities one-half generally know at least the rudiments of reading and writing (they are, asthe Russians say, gramotniye—i. e. knowing the ypdéuuara). In Moscow there ars among the new scholars only 51 per cent. ignoran! of the rudiments, or “‘ negramotniye ” (47.6 per cent. boys, 55.3 percent. girls). The school year consists of 200 days in Mos cow and St. Petersburg, of four hours a day (800 hours); of 120 days, six hours a day (720 hours), in the country. Notwithstanding this fact, the results are considerably better in the
Page 8
aes ~ oo bee. 128 provinces than in the capitals. Here the chil- dren are too young and leave school too early, eager to earn a living for themselves. The Mos- cow schools have in the highest of the three grgdes only 15 per cent. of all the pupils; in the district of Mariupol, Province of Yekaterinoslav (which, by the way, has only one-sixth of the populati m of Moscow, but quite one-half as many pupils in the public schools), 21 per cent. of all the pupils are in the third division. The average attendance in Moscow is 4 per cent. The educa- tion of women, considered a luxury among the lower classes in Russia until recently, is becom- ing more and more common. Out of the 4,691 pupils in Moscow, 2,284 are girls; in St. Peters- burg, out of 4,074, there are only 1,368 girls. A great obstacle, in the cities as well as in the country, is the poverty of the parents. Hun- dreds of poor children cannot attend any school in the winter-time because they have no shoes. One sees often in schools, as a part of the furni- ture, from six to a dozen pairs of shoes of dif- ferent sizes, to be lent to the freezing pupils until their own are mended. In Moscow, the teachers distribute to the children brown bread and salt, for which entertainment the city spends 11,000 rubles a year. Another serious drawback is that the children have to pay for their instruction. The annual fee in St. Petersburg is two rubles, and two rubles fifty kopecks for slates,text-books, and stationery; in Moscow a pupil pays, alto- gether, three rubles a year (about $1 80; St. Petersburg, $2 70). The male teachers come generally from theo- logical seminaries, where, for one reason or another, they have not been able to pass the ex- amination for entrance into the priesthood ; the lady teachers (more than one-third of the total number) are graduates of the female colleges (gymnasiums), or of some of the higher private institutions. The remuneration is exceedingly low, From 1802 to 1877, a teacher in one of the thirteen or sixteen public schools of St. Peters- burg got 171 rubles 59 kop. a year ($103) ; now the pay is much better, but still bad enough. In St. Petersburg, a teacher (male or female indifferently) receives 600 rubles ($360) a year, and lodgings; in Moscow, the first male teacher of a boys’ school, 500 rubles ($300) : the first lady teacher of a girls’ school, 400 rubles ($240); the assistant teachers (nearly all ladies), 300 rubles ($180). This salary increases in Mos- cow every three years (a system not known at St. Petersburg), until the following maxima are reached: for a first male teacher, 750 rubles ($450); for a first lady teacher, 600 rubles ($360). In St. Petersburg every teacher has fifty pupils in his class-room, and these belong to the three different grades. Moscow has, in this respect, truly model schools, from which our own cities could learn much. There one teacher teaches scholar¢ of only one grade; in the firstand second grades the maximum number in a class is 35; in the third grade the maximum is 30, the mini- mun 8, the average 20 pupils. It is, therefore, not surprising that the schools of Moscow are far ahead of thosein St. Petersburg. In the latter city the children are taught only reading, writ- ing, arithmetic, and composition; in the former they acquire, besides, a certain proficiency in freehand, linear, and perspective drawing. The elements of the natural sciences are taught no- where, whether because the Russians have great talent for them, or because the Church tries to keep the human mind away from science. In both the capitals the schools are provided with sufficient, sometimes even luxurious, furni-- ture and apparatus; but neither St. Petersburg nor Moscow owns a public-school building—obvi- ously a very serious deficiency. Moscow, how- ever, is about to erect a commodious school-house for 400 children, at a cost of 120,000 rubles, Class- rooms are hired in private houses; yards or gar- dens are rare. The authorities of St. Petersburg, at all events, enforce strictly the law providing 100 cubic feet for each pupil; in Moscow this number descends to 73 (in one house even to 66) cubic feet a pupil. In both cities the Duma (Board of Aldermen) has control of the common schools. There exists, however, in Moscow a Board of Education, con- stituted in the best possible way. Ladies and gentlemen who take an interest in public educa- tion send their names to the Duma; this body selects the necessary number, and invests them with the necessary rights and powers. It is easy to comprehend that a board like this is much more useful and more apt to have new and better ideas concerning the improvement of the schools than a board the large majority of which has no understanding of school business whatever, and of which too many members feel no interest at all in their office except in so far as it may ad- vance them in their political aspirations. The Duma of St. Petersburg appoints a physician for every school, who has to visit the class-rooms regularly, and upon whose certificate a pupil must be received in the city hospitals at once and without charge. A private society for the aid of poor school-children has recently been founded, the members of which not only furnish clothing, food, and, if necessary, lodging for the indigent, but will insure the most promising higher professional education. It is, of course, a great encouragement for poor children to be under the protection of this society, and as the members, at least so long as there is no com- pulsory education, attend only to the children enrolled in public schools, these schools have a new attraction for the poor and needy. The annual cost of each pupil in the schools of Moscow is 40 rubles, 50 kopecks ($24 30), in St. Petersburg, 37 rubles, 20 kopecks ($22 32) ; but though the expense is nearly the same in the two. cities, Moscow accomplishes much more. Here the expense for common schools is 3.84 per cent. of the whole budget; in St. Petersburg, merely 1.33 per cent. There are only two towns which spend comparatively so little for educa- tional purposes as the first capital of the Russian Empire. In thirty provinces together, in 1868, 5.1 per cent. of all revenues were spent for popu- lar education. Some of the larger Russian universities are excellent, and many of the professors of the younger generation would be an ornament even to a German or an English university, but the universities are the ‘ couronnement de Pédifice,” and a reasonable architect begins with a solid foundation; the public schools are this foundation. In the few years of partial self- government, Zemstvos and Dumas have accom- plished comparatively much. If undisturbed, they will build a strong fortification against Nibilism and thoughtless revolution, as well as against despotism. THE DEBATE ON THE EGYPTIAN QUES- TION. LONDON, July 29, 1882. LIKE a stone pushed down the side of a moun- tain, which at first rolls slowly, then, gathering momentum, flies along by leaps and bounds till it thunders into the valley, this Egyptian crisis, which in its earlier phases was so tedious, has latterly advanced with a speed that hardly leaves us time to apprehend and judge the situation into which England has come, before we find ourselves ina new one. In my last letter I described to you the sentiments excited by and views ex- pressed regarding the bombardment of Alexan- dria, which ushered in a new act of the drama. This was followed by the negotiations intended The Nation. {Number 804 to bring about a Turkish intervention—negotia- tions conducted by the Conference of Ambassa- dors of the six Powers at Constantinople. I do not intend to describe the action of that Confer- ence, which, ss you may remember, the Sultan refused to enter, and did not even formally re- cognize. It—or rather the several Powers repre- sented in it—invited the Turkish Government to intervene by arms in Egypt, and the Sultan delayed so long and shuffled in so irritating and obviously dishonest a way that the patience of England was exhausted. Between the danger of appearing to attack a Mohammedan leader who was resisting a Christian Power in a Mohamme- dan country, and the other danger of seeing that Christian Power take the matter into its own hands and thereby weaken the hold of Turkey over her dependency, the Turks could not make up their minds what course to follow, and con- tinued, in their usual fashion, to interpose delays, hoping that Fate would somehow solve the prob- lem for them, and no doubt encouraged by the caution and apparent hesitation with which Eng- land and France had hitherto acted. After the bombardment, however, England could no longer afford to move so deliberately. The position had become for her a most difficult one. Alexandria was inruins. She had tokeep order there and defend herself against the at- tacks of the army of Arabi, which held the country. The navigation of the Suez Canal was imperilled. What was practically astate of war existed, and yet she was not technically at war, and could not well proceed to invade the country. Besides, everybody in England itself was calling out for something to be done, some resolution taken ; and the Ministry were bad- gered five days a week with questions in Parlia- ment about everything they did or left undone. Accordingly they suddenly determined to waitno longer either for the Powers, or for France, or for Turkey, but to act alone, on their own responsi- bility, and intervene in Egypt for the purpose of restoring order there by expelling Arabi, breaking the power of the Army, and reéstab- lishing the Khedive at Cairo. The constitu- tional way of taking such action is, of course, to obtain a vote of money for the pur- pose from Parliament, and this has just been done. They announced on Saturday, the 22d, that they would ask for £2,500,000 for the pur- posing of strengthening the Queen’s forces in the Mediterranean ; they moved for this vote on the 25th, and obtained it on the 27th, after a de- bate of three nights. As regards the other Powers of Europe, they intimated that since something must be done, since Turkey had not undertaken to do it, since it did not appear that the Powers collectively desired to take action for the purpose, since England had always taken a leading part in the affairs of Egypt, and had special interests there, she proposed to act alone, not adversely to them or any one else, but simply in default of steps being taken by any one else. France was, of course, imvited to join; but France declared that her action would be limit- ed to the protection of the Canal, and it is now (while I write) doubtful whether she will under- take even so much as that. Neither she nor the other Powers are, however, entitled to complain, for England has consulted them at every step, has given them the opportunity of joining, and cannot be expected, where she feels her own duties or interests involved, to hold back mere- ly because they will not go forward. It is toward Turkey, however, that the game has been most intricate and most entertaining to the lookers-on. When it was announced that England was going to proceed alone by landing anarmy in Egypt, the Sultan screwed himself up to the point of saying that he would enter the Conference. When news reached him that Eng-
Page 9
Aug. 17, 1882] lish preparations were being rapidly pushed for- ward, he declared he would himself intervene, but that the conditions which the Conference had laid down were inadmissible and must be re- vised. When he perceived that this declaration did not arrest Mr. Gladstone’s movements—for that statesman, on being asked in Parliament what his Government would do in consequence of the change in Turkish policy, answered that it would go on just as before—he threw all his hesitations and procrastinations aside, and proclaimed that a Turkish force would be forthwith despatched to Egypt. This is the last move we have yet heard of. It has been met by an expression of the willingness of England to receive Turkish troops to codpe- rate, provided that the Sultan takes the pre- liminary step of proclaiming Arabi a rebel, and exerting his moral influence against him and his associates. Before this letter reaches you, you will know how the Sultan faces this fresh diffi- culty. It will not be very easy even for him to denounce a chief upon whom he conferred a high decoration a few weeks ago, and who is re- garded by zealous Mussulmans at Constantinople as a champion of the faith; and probably several further moves may have been played in the game, which it would be no use trying to predict. It is the feeling in England itself that I wish to endeavor to convey to you. There was nothing that we expected less three months ago, and certainly nothing that we de- sired less, than to send a fleet and army to guard and occupy Egypt. We were entirely occupied with domestic difficulties. The Egyptian ques- tion had never laid hold of the national mind. It was so extremely complicated that even pro- fessional politicians shrank from mastering it, while the general public left it altogether on one side. Even now hardly anybody outside the relatively small circle of members of Parlia- mentand journalists professes to understand it. The vast majority of the Liberal party were so much disgusted by the foreign policy of Lord Beaconsfield’s Government, and still more by the cynical grounds on which it was advocated, as to have become vpposed to almost any kind of inter- vention abroad. Two principles had become to them axioms: one, that war was so great an evil that scarcely anything but the necessity of repel- ling an attack would justify it ; the other, that the engagements and responsibilities of Britain in every part of the world are so numerous and heavy that they ought not to be increased, and least of all by the acquisition of fresh territory. Hence the idea of occupying, perhaps after a serious struggle, a country like Egypt, as to which other European Powers are very sensitive, and where we may have to stay longer than we like, had a great deal of reluctance and dislike to overcome in the mind of the ordinary intelli- gent Liberal—the sort of man who, as the chair- man of the committee of a local Liberal asso- ciation, or as a Nonconformist minister, or a speaker at workingmen’s meetings, or the editor of a provincial newspaper, forms, as well as represents, the opinions of those voters who placed the present Government in power. An expedition to Egypt, and the suppression of what has been represented as the National party there, looked suspiciously like a repetition of Lord Beaconsfield’s conduct in Afghanistan, or his snatching of Cyprus. And, in fact, the Tory party, while approving the determination of the Government to intervene in Egypt. could not ab- stain from taunting them with being mere imi- tators of their predecessors, and following the very course in office which they had denounced in opposition. There are caricatures in the shop windows which represent the present Prime Minister trying to “‘make himself up” so as to look like the last one. | The Nation. 129 These things being so, why has the action of the Government met with so little opposition (and I do not speak merely of Parliamentary opposition, but of hostility from the organs of public opinion throughout the country)? Two reasons may be assigned. The first is the extent to which the interests of British commerce are involved in Egypt, and still more in the naviga- tion of the Suez Canal. A good deal of the finer qualities of cotton comes to us from the delta of the Nile, and many English houses have become, in one way or another, so connected with the Alexandrian trade that anarchy in Egypt would mean serious loss to them and to those whom they employ. People outside that special circle, but either dependent in some way upon the pros- perity of our commerce or connected with India, think that the destruction of the Canal, or even its temporary stoppage, would be a national mis- fortune, and are therefore ready to justify mea- sures that seem required for its protection. To their fears it is replied that the Canal is not se- riously threatened ; that whoever reigned in Egypt would willingly see it open; that it can be protected without conquering the whole coun- try. But these arguments do not make much impression against the deeply-rooted belief that somehow or other this international highway must be secured, and that we are more con- cerned than any other nation to have it secured. As this consideration has much weight with the commercial and moneyed sections of the Liberal party, so the other sections, and particu- larly the Nonconformists and the working classes, are swayed by another, possibly even more important. This is personal confidence in Mr. Gladstone, a belief in his honesty, his fidel- ity to bis principles, his aversion to war and ag- gression. ‘‘If he has gone into this enterprise,” say his admirers, who are the rea! strength of the party, ‘‘it is because he has felt it unavoida- ble. He must dislike itas much as we do. He knows better what the dangers are than we do: if he thinks these strong remedies required, he is more likely to be right than we are; and we must follow him.” So strong is this feeling that even the retirement from the Ministry of Mr. Bright has not sensibly weakened it. Much as he is personally respected and trusted, the great orator of the Radical party has never been a fighting leader, never awakened the same per- sonal enthusiasm that Mr. Gladstone has done and still does; and though he is younger in years, he belongs more distinctly to a past generation, and is supposed, at least, to be less in sympathy with the new turn and color which Liberalism has of late years taken. Owing to this genera: disposition of the Lib- erals to support Mr. Gladstone, and owing also to the fact that the Conservatives could not, con- sistently with their own principles of foreign policy, oppose armed intervention in Egypt, the debate in the House of Commons on the vote of £3,200,000 was somewhat spiritless. The opposition to it, which ended in being supported by nineteen members only, came from those fol- lowers of Mr. Parnell—not more than half his party—who have remained till this late period of the session, and from a small group of Eng- lish Liberals who condemn all foreign interven- tion, and indeed all war that is not purely de- fensive. Few in number, these members are respectable from their consistent zeal and the purity of their motives; nor is it to be denied that they represent a considerable body of opinion among the working classes. Some others, though not going so far as to vote against the grant of money, refused to vote for it; and a good many thought, though they left it to the Conservative Opposition to say, that the Gov- ernment had not managed things in the best way, but ought to have foreseen the approaching dangers, and either sooner invoked Eurcpe to deal with them, or else itself nipped them in the bud. The Opposition, however, is not oratori- cally strong, and inflicted little damage on the Government; so that the chief net resuit of the debate has been, while not seriously weakening them, te enlighten the country on the question geuerally. Two remarkable speeches were de livered. In one of them Mr. Thomas Bruce, brother of the late Lord Elgin and of Lady Au- gusta Stanley (Dean Stanley’s wife), a Conserva tive of advanced age and moderate views, gave a singularly lucid and instructive account of the state and changes of Egypt during recent years, showing how interwoven she had be- come with Western interests, and how much the difficulties of England and France there had been increased by the action of France in Tunis and the passions which she had roused among the whole Mussulman popula tion of Africa. The House of Commons is very intolerant of disquisitions, but very ready to listen toa man who possesses special know ledge and rarely obtrudes it ; and as Mr. Bruce has been for many years connected, as the head of the Ottoman Bank, with Eastern financial affairs, his approval of the general policy which the Government had pursued was felt to be weighty. Still more important was the autho rity of Mr. Goschen. Having been concerned in the establishment of the Financial Contro! in Egypt in 1876, and having served as Ambassador at Constantinople in 1880, he has more direct knowledge of Eastern topics than any other statesman of nearly equal rank and ability... He pointed out with great force that England's position, not only toward Turkey, but toward the Christian subjects of Turkey, foreed her to interfere; condemned in weighty terms the du plicity of the Sultan’s Government: explained, while regretting, the hesitations and timidity of France; and made in some respects a better case for the Government than diplomatic reticence permitted them to make for themselves. Although, however, the general result of the discussion bas been in favor of Mr. Gladstone’s policy and Ministry, its position is still a very delicate one. Any serious misfortune in Egypt, any misunderstanding with France or the other European Powers, might imperil it. Yet even then it would have the advantage of being able to ask the country whether a Conservative Government, headed by Lord Salisbury, would be hkely to do any better. ES (From another Correspondent.) LONDON, July 20, 1882. THE debates in the Houses of Lords and of Commons previous to entering upon direct hos tilities in Egypt have done much to clear up the situation and explain the present policy of the Government. Lord Granville, Mr. Gladstone, Sir Charles Dilke, and Mr. Chamberlain have expounded the difficulties which have had to be encountered by the Government, and the modes in which, both in theory and in practice, they have been surmounted. Lord Salisbury, Sir Stafford Northcote, Colonel Stanley, and sup- dry Opposition sharpshooters, have done their utmost to criticise without exactly obstructing, and have had their say. Sir Wilfrid Lawson and Mr. Richard have stated in the fullest form the arguments, of all kinds, in favor of peace everywhere and always, and most of all in favor of peace with Egypt at the present moment. The subject has, undoubtedly, been thoroughly threshed out from all points of view, and, as it is inherently a difficult one, the conspicuous ad- vantage of parliamentary institutions in the way of educating the popular mind has been seen to the full.
Page 10
130 The first thing to be noticed is, that the de- fenders of the ‘‘ National party ” as represented by Arabi Pasha have cut a very poor figure, or rather evanesced altogether. Even those who, like Mr. Chamberlain, have admitted that there muy bein Egypt some indenendent movement of 2 patriotic sort directed against European in- tervention, have strongly and decisively resent- ed the notion ot Arabi representing anv such movement Speaker after speaker on the Gov- ernment side pointed out how every step in Arabi’s advance was directed to his own promo- tion and enrichment : how the Chamber of No- tables, illegally summoned by himself without the Khedive’s consent, repudiated him and co- operated to promote his expulsion from the country ; how, in destroying Alexandria, he committed (as one speaker said) one of the greatest crimes of this century ; how, by dis- obeying both the S..ltan and the Khedive, whom he professed to ovey, he brought about the bom- bardment ; and how, from first to last, every- thing he had done had been productive of nothing but ruin to his country. Mr. Glad- stone, indeed, generalized on the necessarily pernicious character of every military despot- ism, even when the despot had some personal qualities to recommend him, and he took the in- stances of Cromwell and the Napoleons. These reigns, said Mr. Gladstone, did not advance pub- lic liberty, but retarded it; and the constitutions of England and of France only began to progress when the military despotism in each country came to an end. Sir Charles Dilke explained with the greatest exactness and elaboratencss the intervention of England in Egypt, as justified by the Govern- ment. He said this intervention was to be de- fended by necessity, right, and duty. He based the special claims of England to intervene on the treaty for the pacification of the Levant of 1840, by which Mohammed Ali was recognized as the supreme ruler of Egypt, and his dynasty established, subject to his conforming to certain conditio 1s, which he conformed to a year after. Sir Charles Dilke, in one part of his speech, more especially addressed members on his own side of the House. Ue submitted to them that a policy of absolute non-intervention had never been part of the Liberal, or even of the Rafiical, creed. He justified the bombardment by point- ing out that if the fleet was at Alexandria for an undoubtedly legitimate purpose, it was surely necessary to protect it. The Government had no right to expose their men to a daily increas ing danger. He could not perceive anything contrary to Liberal or Radical principles in striking hard when British representatives were threatened. Sir Charles Dilke defended the Government against the imputation that they ought to have had a large landing force ready, by saying that, in the then political cir- cumstances, it was impossible to have a large landing force. ‘It was one thing to act in self- defence, and another to undertake what they had undertaken not to undertake—namely, iso- lated action.” Mr. Chamberlain made a most effective speech by dwelling on the extraordinary amount of the interests which England had in Egypt, in which he especially included the number of persons who had been induced to trade in the country by the promise of security. While he admitted that those who speculate in foreign countries must take the consequences of the risks they en- counter, he at the same time resented the notion that all persons who lend money to foreign states were unworthy of the least consideration. His words were a little vague about the future of the bondholders: he hinted that hereafter they must make their own arrangements for themselves. This might refer only to future The Nation. creditors of Egypt, or it might mean that Eng- land would not trouble herself any more to carry out the existing arrangements for the liquida- tion of the debt. From other assertions of Mr. Gladstone, it would seem that the last is not the meaning. It is probable that the Conservative party will not encourage Egyptian repudiation, and a large party among the Liberals will join to resist any change in the working of a scheme of liquidation which has once been deliberately settled by the British Government, and round which complicated vested interests have grown up. The main controversy between the Govern- ment and the Opposition has turned upon how far the present troubles in Egypt and the resist tance to European influence bave sprung from the institution of the dual Control, and to what extent this Control owes its recent character to the acts of a Conservative or of a Liberal Gov- ernment in England. It is argued by the Con- servatives that the most they did in instituting the original Control in 1876 was to help the Khedive Ismail in arranging with his creditors aud preparing his accounts according to Euro- pean methods; and for this purpose skilled European financiers were attached to the Egyp- tian Cabinet, to be permanently at hand as supervisors of all liabilities and expenditures incurred from time to time. The Liberals reply that mere clerks with financial experience would have served so much of this purpose as was not unjustifiable intervention on the part of Eng- land and of France; and that there was con- tained in the original dual Control the proba- bility and, indeed, the necessity of political aggression. To this some (but not all) of the Conservative speakers reply, that neither the original Control of 1876 nor the revived and amended Control of 1879 contained the necessary elements of political aggressiveness, but that the careless diplomacy of Mr. Gladstone’s Govern- ment, and their ill-fated attempts to codperate with France, and withal to conciliate Turkey, brought about a state of things which Jeft Egy pt defenceless before the first shock of revolution. Loru Salisbury pointed out that there is al- ways much in diplomacy, and in the printed records of diplomacy, which does not meet the eye ; and this argument—which was introduced for a different purpose—may be used for the defence no less than for the defamation of the Government. There is no doubt that the ditti- culties which the English Government have en- countered in conciliating and codperating with the French in Egypt have been greater than will ever be told. It hus been seldom that a French Consul-General, Commissioner, Controller, or Administrator has been of one mind with his English colleague, or indeed has not been silently and secretly counter-plotting him. At the last, it was transparent that the attitudes of the Eng- lish and the French officials in Egypt were quite opposed on the critical question of the day, the French being disposed to compromise with Arabi, and the Euglish consistently viewing his preten- sions with uncompromising opposition. The speeches of Mr. Goschen, Mr. Bourke (Under-Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs in the last Conservative Government), and Sir A. Wolff, on the third day of the debate, brought out into clearer relief some historical aspects of the question, as affecting the responsibilities of the Conservative and the Liberal Governments for the present state of thmgs. Mr. Coschen’s speech has been more commended on all sides than any other single speech in the course of the debate. His personal experiences as adviser of the Egyptian Government at the time that the British Government first lent its services to Ismail to hberate him from his insolvent condi- tion, rendered him an authority of the highest [Number 894 kind at this crisis. He assured ‘‘ those who took an interest in such matters as the slave-trade, tbe better government of Eastern Rumelia, and the position of the Christian population in Armenia, that those objects would not only be compro- mised, but in all probability frustrated for ever, if England were to allow herself, by the terror- ism of massacre, to be driven out of Egypt.” Mr. Goschen, also, was strongly of opinion that, as far as military and naval operations went, the Government should act alone. He derided the notion of any value attaching to the “ moral support ” of Turkey, and pointed out that France would be hampered in her action in Ezypt by the possible enemies on her borders, and by the weakness of her successive Governments, which prevented a continuity of policy being insured. Mr. Bourke imputed to the Government that they had not been firm enough with the French, but had tacitly accepted all their policy through- out, including that by which, when the insurrec- tion began, the French set themselves decisively against all physical or moral intervention. ‘“Her Majesty’s Government ought,” he said, ‘to have told France fairly and broadly that they could not follow the policy she had marked out.” Mr. Gladstone, in summing up the debate on the fourth day, mainly rested the whole defence of the Government policy on the inherent diffi- culties of the position created by the dual Con- trol. He admitted that when the Control was first inaugurated it was not intended directly to intervene in the government of Egypt. but he held that the revived Control, as recognized by Lord Salisbury in 1879, at the outset of the pre- sent Khedive’s reign, involved by its nature political interference. It was the Controller who had come into direct conflict with the Chamber of Notables, and who had called upon the Bri- tish and French Governments to part company with it at a moment before Arabi had acquired complete domination over it, and identified the wilitary with so much as existed of a national party. Finally, Mr. Gladstone insisted strongly on the value of the efforts his Government had made througbout to obtain and retain the co- operation of France, even at the risk of making considerable coucessions, such as those which re- lated to inviting tbe aid of Turkey. He was of opinion that but for conciliating France through- out, a general European war might have resulted. The vote of credit was agreed to by 275 against 19. The minority was composed, in a large measure, of Irish members, followers of Mr. Parnell, besides Sir Wilfrid Lawson and Mr. Richard. It will be seen that all sides of the House are, with rare unanimity, agreed on the substantial facts of the case, and eager to support the Gov- ernment policy, the main point of disagreement having relation to the history of the Control and the advisability of deferring so constantly to France and the other European Powers. A. THE RESTORED CASTLE OF CHANTILLY. PaRIs, July 20, 1882. THE restoration of the Chateau of Chantilly was undertaken by the Duc d’Aumale as soon as he returned from his long exile in England, after the war of 1870. It showed no small confidence in the country, which had just got through the horrors of the Commune ; but if anybody had the duty of giving to France such a mark of confidence, it was the descendant of the old royal family which had ruled over it for cen- turies. The ChAteau of Chantilly was originally a little stronghold, built on a sort of rock, sur- rounded on all parts by marshes and by the braaches of a little river which is called the Nonette. This little fortress played a part in
Page 11
Aug. 17, 1882] the long wars between France and England at the time when the river Oise formed the disputed boundary between the French and the English. The first proprietor of the Chateau was Bouteil- ler of Senlis ; it passed afterward into the hands of the Montmorencys, v ho kept Chantilly for a very long time—the great Constable Montmo- rency chose it for bis favorite residence. It came into the Condé family when the last Mont- morency was beheaded for treason, by order of Richelieu ; Louis XIII. confiscated the estate, and gave it to Montmorency’s widow, who was a Princess of Condé, The estate remained in the hands of the Condés during the seventeenth, the eighteenth, and the beginning of the nine- teenth centuries. The last Duc de Bourbon, who bad no children, left it by will to the Duc d’Aumale. The Chateau bad many vicissitudes, in an artistic as well as in an historical sense. It was once a castle of the Middle Ages ; it was rebuilt in the fifteenth and the sixteenth cen- turies, and you will find in Du Cerceau’s great architectural work excellent drawings of it as it was built by the famous Jean Bullant. The Duc d’Auwale has in his archives some accounts of Jean Bullant, in which he modestly styles himself mason, not architect. There remains a part of Jean Bullant’s work completely intact—namely, the little castle, or lower castle, called the ChAtelet. There were always two castles, a low one and a higher one, separated by a moat and connected by a draw- bridge. The Chatelet is admitted by all archi- tects to be a model of the architecture of the French Renaissance; they admire the originality and simplicity of its lines, the beautiful propor- tion between the pleins and the vides—that is to say, between the openings (windows or doors) and the solid parts or walls, the forms of the roofs and chimneys, the sobriety and elegance of the whole building. The moat which sepa- rated the Chatelet from the Chateau no longer exists, and the Chatelet is attached directly to the Chateau. This last building was not always the gigantic pile which you see in Du Cerceau. Built on a polygonal basis formed by the rock itself, this substructure, with its vaults and galleries, has never been changed, but the castle which was standing on it wascompletely altered: it had become, at the end of the eighteenth cen- tury, a sort of immense and ugly barrack, limited by four towers at its corners. After the French Revolution this was completely demolished to the level of the substructure, and there was no- thing left over the kitchens, vaults, and under- ground gaileries but a large polygonal terrace. — It is on this terrace that the Duc d’Aumale has built the new Castle, which he has opened re- cently to the public. The general, I might say the universal, impression has been very favora- ble to this reconstruction. The new Castle is in the style of the French Renaissance ; it is in- spired in all its details by the admirable Chatelet of Jean Bullant. You approach it by a road which leads to a great terrace, in the middle of which is the model of the equestrian statue of the Constable of Montmorency, which is mm pre- paration in the atelier of Dubois, so famous al- ready for his admirable tomb of Lamoriciére. The Duke chose Dubois for this work though he had never made a horse ; but Dubois is intelli- gent, he knows the best models, he has wurked very hard on the anatomy of the horse, and we may be sure that his definitive work will be fine. The figure of the Constaple, as it is now, is fine : the old warrior carries the sword of Constable in his hand, and he seems to stop his horse before the door of his castle. He stands directly op- posite the great entrance, which reminds one a little of the famous cour du baptistére of Fon- tainebleau. A bridge connects the terrace of the Constable with the high inner court, and the The Nation. court has in front a high and open portico. The great central door is adorned with two excellent copies of the “Slaves” of Michael Angelo. The Duc d’Aumale remembered that the original ‘*Slaves” (which were destined for the tomb of a Pope) had been presented to the Constable of Montmorency by a Strozzi, who had been obliged to exile himself from Florence, and who had taken service in the French army. These two statues had been afterward left by the last Montmorency to Richelieu, who gave them to the King ; and they are now in the Museum of the Louvre. When you enter the cour dhon- neur, as it is called, you find in the left corner of the court the Chapel, which is not yet finished inside. Itis a little jewel of architecture, adorned on the outside by a statue of Saint Louis, who carries in his hands a crown of thorns. The glass-windows come from the Chateau d’Ecouen, which belonged to the Montmorencys; they rep- resent the Constable and his wife at prayer with their numerous children. The altar comes also from Ecouen ; it is a very fine work of the Renaissance, of which the centre-piece is the sacrifice of the son of Abraham. The wood- work which will cover the walls is of great beauty, but is still in preparation. Let us leave the Chapel and enter into the first hall. This hall is at the head of a beautiful elliptical staircase, which now connects the lower building, or Ch&telet, with the higher building. The staircase and the hall are con- sidered very original by all architects. The decoration is severe : it is made with old pieces of faience, with bronze and marble busts, with old tapestry ; but the bare stone predominates, and gives a noble and palatial look to the whole. This hall leads on one side to the upper story of the old Chatelet, of which I will not speak at present ; and on the other side to the interior of the new building. First comes the dining-room. There is nothing finer in Fontainebleau than this gigantic hall, adorned with magnificent tapes- tries of enormous size, representing the various episodes of a stag-hunt. These tapestries, which are called the tapestries of the Guises, received new borders at the time of the Comte de Provence ; they were made in Flanders, and their coloring is remarkably well preserved. The roof, which is all in compartments (caissons), shows the arms of all the various proprietors of Chantilly ; the cornice is adorned with a series of stag-horns. The head of a white stag (a variety now extinct, once imported from Lithu- ania), comes out from the well and makes a fine effect. Over the huge chimney, Baudry has painted the miracle of Saint Hubert. The saint, who was a Merovingian warrior, has dismounted; a page holds the head of his horse. He climbs the rocks, surrounded by his dogs, and sees be- fore him the white stag, with a brilliant cross between his two horns, Baudry has given to the Saint the likeness of the Duc de Chartres, and the young page resembles exactly the Duc d’Orleans, the son of the Comte de Paris. The windows of this huge hall are replaced at night by mirrors ; windows and mirrors are movable, like doors which run on wheels ; they can retire into the wall or come out at will. The effect at night is very fine when all these mirrors reflect the light of the bronze torches, copied from Venetian models. Over the door there is a great balcony, large enough to receive a band of musicians, who play during the gala-repasts. The table can receive eighty guests ; but it can be so subdivided that any inferior number of people can be accommodated. The banqueting-room opens on the great pic- ture-gallery, which deserves a long description by itself. The collection is chiefly composed of that once owned by the Prince of Salerno, who was the Duc d’Aumale’s father-in-law. The 1381 Duke bought it when the Prince died. The pic tures are perfectly authentic, have suffered no indiscreet restoration, and were for a very long time in the hands of the royal famnly of Naples. There are some fine pictures by Carracci, by Titian, by Poussiu, by Morone. The other pic tures noticeable in this gallery are, the view of Scheveningen by Ruysdaal, some fine Vande veldes, a great number of Decampses, a Meisso nier, some Horace Vernets, Philippe de Cham pagnes, Ary Scheffers, a great number of por traits of the last century. At the end of the gallery there is a tmbune of a circular shape, which is in one of the towers of the ChAteau. It is devoted to Prudhon, and completely covered by his admirable drawings. From the windows of the tribune of Prudhon one sees the mag nificent gardens designed by Lendtre, the par terres with their marble statues, their basins, their water-works. This French garden extends as far as the great moat, which was the work of the Grand Condé. A long gallery runs along one of the faces of the Castle. It shows the vitrauex of Ecouen, representing the history of Psyche, from the drawings of Raphael, These windows are a monument of art. They were made in the six teenth century, and are extremely interesting on account of their origin and of the singular beauty of the drawings of Raphael. The wall which runs opposite the windows showing the history of Psyche is quite covered with a collec tion of historical portraits by Clouet and his school, You can see there the most authentic portraits of the Prince of Orange, of Colign) and his brothers, of the first Condés, of the Valois, their wives and their children. From this gallery you go into the Tribune, another tower witha circular room, Here are the gems of the Duke's collection, of which [ re serve a description for another letter. The Tri bune leads back by a small passage into the great banqueting-ball. The surface of the Cas tle’s polygon being very irregular, the archi- tect was obliged everywhere to adapt his ‘plans to this irregularity. He has united the towers by galleries, This want of symmetry is pleas ing: it gives origmality to the whole work, and from the windows the view is ever chang ing. M. Daumet, who made this restoration, has been recompensed for his labors by a high prize of the Institute. * PARSIFAL” AT BAYREUTH. THE FIRST PERFORMANCE, BAYREUTH, July 26, 1882. AT ten minutes past 4 yesterday the first per- formance began. The introduction to * Parsifal,” which unites some of the most charming motives in the drama, is a symphonic prelude of wonder- ful beauty, destined soon to become a favorite in concert halls. Before its last notes have died away the curtain parts in the middle and shows the spectator a shadowy but not gloomy land- scape in the neighborhood of the Castle Mon- salvat in northern Spain, the Grailsburg, which was built by King Titurel and his knights as a sanctuary for the holy grail that was brought to them by angels. The grail has the same qualities that the earth has for Anteus, or Freia for the gods in Walhalla—it rejuvenates and invigorates the holy knights who are pri- vileged to behold it whenever the King un- covers it, and it thus enables them to per- form their duties, which consist in punishing misdeeds and defending innocence among mor- tals, as we see in the case of Lohengrin, in Wag- ner’s drama, who goes forth on his swan-boat to protect Elsa from her unjust accusers. When Titurel found the end of his allotied life ap-
Page 12
132 The Nation. [ Number 894 proaching, his son Amfortas was crowned king of the brotherhood. But King Amfortas suc- a temptation which had already brought misfortune to many of his knights. cumbed to Not far from Monsalvat is the castle of Kling- sor, the wizard. Alingsor, the representative of heathen sensuality, had once endeavored to se- cure admission to the holy brotherhood. But he lacked the requisite purity of heart and con- duct, and freedom from worldly desires, to ob- tain which he resorted to self-mutilation. Re- pulsed froin the Grailsburg, he swore vengeance on the knights, and in his magic castle he now holds many of them as captives to the charms of his lovely maidens. King Amfortas, when he went forth to annihilate the sorcerer and bis castle, fell a victim to the wiles of Kundry, the most beautiful of the unhappy females en- slaved by Alingsor. Kundry is a sort of female wandering Jew, the Herodias of German le- who laughed at the Saviour when he For this she was condemned to “‘cursed laughter,” and to wander about the earth until she could again find a saviour to re- lease her from her curse by his love. Klingsor had gained control over her through his magic arts, and now compels her to aid him in reducing the number of faithful knights, so that be may ultimately satisfy his desire of gaining possession of the grail. While King Am/fortas is ensnared by Kundry’s charms, Klingsor snatches from him his holy spear—the spear with which Lon- ginus had pierced the Saviour’s side, and which Titurel had received with the grail. With this spear he inflicts on Am/fortas a painful wound, which henceforth forever exposes him to the most woful torments. These events, which precede the drama proper, are made known tothe audience in an epic or episodic form during the first act, which also contains some of the most stirring dramatic incidents in the play. When the curtain is drawn, Gurnemanz, a robust and hale old knight, and two young pages are seen asleep under a tree. Gurnemanz awakes at thesounds of invisible trombones blowing a morning call in the direction of the Grailsburg. He rouses his companions, and bids them go tothe lake and prepare the wounded King’s morning bath. As they retire toward the lake, which is seen in the background, they suddenly behold a horse, with a female rider, dashing wildly along, almost flying. Itis Kundry, who in hours of freedom always endeavors to atone by some good service for the harm she does the knights while under the influence of Klingsor’s spell. She is arrayed in a short dress, held together by a girdle of snakeskins; her black hair flows in disorder over her shoulders; her ccmplexion is dark brown, and her eyes piercingly black, now wild in expression and anon fixed in a dead stare. In ber hand she bas a small flask, which she gives to Gurnemanz, and then throws her- self on the ground, exhausted. The King’s approach is now heard. He is con- veyed in a litter, accompanied by knights and esquires. From Gurnemanz he receives the flask, and hears that Kundvy has brought it as balm for his wound from Arabia. He expresses his gratitude, but has no hope in the remedy, for he knows he can only expect a cure through one whom the grail has announced to him as his saviour. ‘ By pity enlightened, a guileless fool; Wait for him, my chosen tool”—these were the words that once appeared in magic letters on the rim of the holy vessel while he lay before it in fervent prayer. The procession now moves on toward the lake, while the esquires remain taunting the mysterious Kundry, when sud- denly the whiz of an arrow, imitated in a strikingly realistic manner by the orchestra, followed by weird, swap-motive harmonies from gend, bore his cross, ‘* Lohengrin,” isheard. A wounded swan slowly flies across the lake, and then falls down dying. The Parsifal motive announces the appearance of the culprit who has thus ruthlessly killed one of the animals sacred in these precincts. In an affecting passage, in which words and music are alike beautiful, Gurnemanz reproaches Parsifal, who at first boasts of his skillin having killed the bird ‘on the wing,” but, after listening to the old knight, follows a sudden impulse and breaks his bow in pieces. The question who he is and where from he professes to be unable to answer, when Kundry interrupts the dialogue and announces that he is the son of Gamuret, who gave birth to him after the death of his father, who fell in battle. To save her son frum a similar fate she reared bim in a deep forest, ignorant of the world and his parentage. Parsifal now remembers that one day he saw some armed horsemen, with beautiful horses, whom he endeavored to follow. Soon he lost sight of them, and, with self-constructed weapons, fought his way through the various dangers that beset him. Kundry replies that his mother is dead—that his departure broke her heart; whereupon Pursifal is seized by such sudden regret and horror that he threatens violence to the unhappy messenger of these tidings; but Gurnemanz protects her from his fury. A sud- den trembling and fatigue now overcome Kun- dry, who retires into the forest to sleep. The magic motive of Klingsor in the orchestra ex- plains that it is his spell which calls her thus to his castle. Gurnemanz suspects that Parsifal may be the “‘guileless fool” who is chosen to relieve the King, and accordingly invites him to follow him to the Grailsburg. As they seem to walk from left to right, the scene gradually changes; the forest disappears, and wild rock takes its place; a door opens amidst walls of stone, which they enter. Sounds of bells and trom- bones are heard coming nearerand nearer. At last they arrive in a large hall, ending above in a vaulted dome, through which alone light is admitted. A door opens on each side, through one of which the Knights of the Grail enter in procession, singing a solemn _ chorus. While they take places at two long tables their voices are joined by those of youths in the mid- height of the dome, and boys’ voices at the sum- mit. Through the opposite door another proces- sion enters bearing Am/fortas in his litter. It is the King’s duty to uncover the grail, to reju- venate his knights ; but he longs to be relieved of this duty, as it gives him, too, renewed vitality and prolongs the agony of his existence. The voice of Titurel, however, urges him on, and he at last uncovers the grail. Darkness has mean- while spread over the hall so that the grail is distinctly seen gradually glowing with a purple lustre. Am/fortas raises it and gently swings it about on all sides—the whole act being accom- panied by music of the most super-terrestrial, ethereal character, like a haloof sound. Gurne- manz invites Parsifal to take part in the supper, but Parsifal remains standing lost in mute astonishment at these proceedings. After the knights have again departed, the disappointed Gurnemanz shakes Parsifal by the arm and bids him depart : “Leave thou our swans in future alone, And seek thyself, gander, a goose.”” The first is by far the longest of the three acts ; its duration being over an hour and a half, while the others are somewhat over an hour each. It con- tains situations as fine as any Wagner has ever conceived, the most affecting scene being the un- covering of the grail, followed by the triple chorus of knights, youths, and boys at different altitudes above the stage—the effect of which can be ap- proximately judged of from the wonderful beauty of the trio of Rhine daughters from an elevated position, as heard at the late musical festival in New York. The idea is similar to that which Wagner, early in his career, used in his cantata “Das Liebesmahl der Apostel ”; and as thus transplanted it is eminently dramatic— that is, in harmony with the character of the situation. The gradual glowing of the grail is effected by means of a current of electricity with which it is supplied by means of a thin wire. The effect is exceedingly impressive. The flight of the swan, like that of the spear which remains suspended over Pursiful’s head in the second act, and of the dove which hovers over him at the close of the third, is also managed in a clever and thoroughly artistic manner. The contents of the second and third acts may be summed up in fewer words, After an agitated introduction by the orchestra the spectator finds himself transferred to Klingsor’s magic castle— at first in the inside of a tower open at its top. Magic implements are scattered about every- where. Klingsor summons Kundry by lighting a bluish flame in the background of the stage. When Kundry appears he commands her, in spite of her pitiful protests, to use her beauty and persuasiveness to ruin Parsifal, who is already seen by him approaching the castle. He calls out to the knights to defend them- selves, but Parsifal soon puts them all to flight. The tower now slowly sinks out of sight, and its place is taken by a magic garden full of tropical vegetation and the most luxuriant large flowers. Anumber of beautiful damsels in light attire rush on the stage and bewail the loss of their playmates until they behold Parsifal. While some flirt about him, others disappear in an arbor, whence they soon return arrayed in flowers, looking like living flowers themselves. Parsifal regards the spectacle unmoved and un- yielding, when presently Kundry’s vuvice is heard calling out his name, “ Parsifal, re- main!” The flower-girls reluctantly retire, not without a parting fling at the ‘‘ guileless fool,” who is now at the mercy of Kundry’s charms. With true feminine art she wins his confidence by telling of the last moments of his mother. Parsifal, overcome with grief, sinks down at her feet, when she raises his head and gives him his mother’s last greeting and the first long kiss of Jove. Withan expression of consternation Parsifal jumps to his feet, and pushes Kundry away. Her kiss, like a sudden pang, gives him a presentiment of Am/fortus’s sufferings, and at once the whole situation dawns on him. Hitherto he has only been the “‘ guileless fool”; now he is also, ‘‘ through pity, enlightened.” Kundry re fuses to listen to his explanation that to grant her his love would condemn her to a new lease of her cursed existence. She invokes a curse on him—a curse which shall compel him to go about the world searching in vain for King Amfortas. Her cries summon Klingsor to the castle wall, whence he hurls Am/fortas’s holy spear at him. The spear remains suspended over the head of Parsifal, who seizes it and de- scribes the shape of a cross. Instantaneously, as through an earthquake, the castle vanishes, the garden is transformed into a desert, and the maidens lie as withered flowers on the ground. The suddenness of this transformation is one of the greatest of modern scenic marvels, and, like some of the other effects, it shows that the machinist, Fritz Brandt, is determined to emulate the fame of his father, Carl Brandt, who con- structed the Nibelung machinery, and planned some of the contrivances to be used in ‘“ Parsi- fal” before death took him away, about a year ago. The third act contains so few incidents that it will be pronounced undramatic by those who hold that the essence of the drama consists in rapid and varied action. But in a higher sense
Page 13
Aug. 17, 1882] ‘The of the word—that in which ‘‘ Tristan and Isolde” is Wagner’s most dramatic work—the third act of ‘* Parsifal” is also highly dramatic, for in it the development and conflict of emotions are intensely and vividly portrayed. At the begin- ning of the third act, after a weird and sad in- troduction of great beauty, we see a smiling meadow at the borders of a forest; in the back- ground, a simple hermit’s hut. It belongs to Gurnemanz, who now appears as a very old man. Strange, mournful sounds, proceeding from behind a bush, induce him to search for their cause. It is Kundry, now again the sim- ple, homely servant of the grail, and no longer the fascinating queen of Klingsor’s flower garden. She is disinclined to speak, but goes into the hut to work. Looking about him, Gur- nemanz espies a knight in full armor approach- ing. He bids him respect the laws of this holy place, which forbid any one on Good Friday to bear arms. Pursifal complies, and Gurnemanz now recognizes him, as well as the holy spear, at sight of which he breaks forth in joyous ex- clamations, heralding the King’s release from his torments—for only then can his wounds be closed when they are touched by the ‘‘guileless fool” with the same spear that in- “flicted them. Gurnemanz relates how, since Parsifal’s departure, the knights have been de- prived of the blessing of the grail, since the King refuses to uncover it—hoping thus to starve out his life even as Titurel’s came to an end after long privation. Once more on this day, how- ever, the grail is to be uncovered. The scene changes back to that which closes the first act, in the Grailsburg. Two processions of knights again appear, one with Am/fortas on his litter, the other with Titurel’s bier, accompanied by the strains of a majestic funeral march. Am- fortas refuses to perform his task—to be once more brought back to painful life from the brink of death. He tears open his bandages and begs his companions to kill him, when Parsifal ap- pears and touches the wounds with his spear. He then takes the grail in his hand while a halo of light is shed over all. A dove descends and hovers over the head of the new King, Parsifal. Kundry sinks slowly to the ground, lifeless, while Amfortas and Gurnemanz do homage on their knees to Pursifal. It isa magnificent final tableau. As time is short and art-criticism at Bayreuth long, I must defer some general esthetic remarks on the poem, and the music, and the relations of *Parsifal” to Wagner’s other dramas, until after the second or third performance. The reception of the new drama last evening was very enthusiastic. After the first act there was prolonged applause for Wagner, the spectators all facing round toward his box, as it was under- stood that the artists had agreed not to appear before the curtain so as not to interrupt the illu- sion, After the second act the applause was so demonstrative that Wagner was obliged to come forward and explain that the refusal to appear before the curtain was not stubbornness on any one’s part, but a desire that the artists should only be seen within the frame of the art work. This was interpreted by the audience as a desire on his part that there should be no applause, and accordingly the third act, the grandest of all, was received in silence—a curious illustration of the absolute subjection of the Wagnerites to their master’s command. But Wagner again came forward toexplain that he had been misun- derstood; at the end of the performance he was the first to applaud the artists for their admira- ble work. A perfect tornado of applause and calls of ‘ Artists,” and “Bravo” now burst out; but the artists were already busy with their wardrobe and could not appear. This was a pity, for they deserved the most un- Nation. 138 qualified approval of the audience. The cast, down to the smallest details, was as perfect as it can only be at Bayreuth. To prove this I need only state that the parts of Kundry, Gurnemanz, Parsifal and Amfortas were taken respectively by Frau Materna and Herr Scaria, of Vienna, Herr Winkelmann, of Hamburg, and Herr Reichmann, of Munich. The choruses of knights, youths, and boys were beautifully sung, as well as the flower-girls’ chorus, which was very effec- tive and stirring. All the vocalists pronounced their words with a distinctness which if emulated elsewhere would soon make obsolete the read- ing of text-books during a performance; and most wonderful of all was the perfect accord- ance in time and tune between the various musi- cal factors, invisible to one another—the orches- tra, the choruses, the vocalists, and the brass- band and bells on the stage. To those who had not been at Bayreuth before, last night’s per- formance must have been a revelation. BISMARCK AFTER THE CRIMEAN WAR.—IT. BERLIN, July 12. AFTER having shown that a most intimate alli- ance between France and Russia will be a natu- ral result of the Paris peace, Bismarck discusses the chances of other possible alliances among the great European Powers. ‘ Austria,” he continues, ‘‘ will have to share the dangers created for Europe by the connection between Russia and France, and must avert them by timely sacrifices, by either making con- cessions in Italy for advantages to be ob- tained in Germany, or else strengthening her- self against attacks by treaties with other Powers. I believe that she will choose the first alternative, and that she will try to gain Russia's confidence by a personal change of her Ministry. Austria will only in case of the utmost neces- sity avail herself of our or of English support. If she should endeavor to make us guarantee her foreign possessions by new treaties, I do not be- lieve she would use such a treaty for any other pur than to parade it on the diplo- matic field to her advantage and to our injury. Even supposing that arrogance and hatred should allow the Vienna Cabinet to ask for English assistance, or to have the hereditary im- rial provinces protected by Prussia, Austria is, on the other hand—even if strengthened by an alliance with us and with England—too cau- tious to engage in a serious struggle against France and Russia, if it can be avoided per fas et nefas. She will consider the party of the Teutonic nations (Germanen) too weak for ber to join, and in my opinion she will be right in this respect. “If it could be expected that in such a war Prussia, Austria, the German Confederation, and England would codperate sincerely, intimately, and confidently with their full power, it would be cowardice to doubt a victory. But that is not the actual situation of affairs. Suppose that England should resolutely stick to us, and that in spite of the French, Russian, and perhaps the American, Danish, and even Dutch fleets, she should succeed in keeping off an invasion, in victoriously maintaining herself on the sea, and in protecting the German shores and in occasion- ally harassing the French coasts with 10,000 to 20,000 men. Such an energetic way of acting would surpass my expectations, but nevertheless the Continental war against the armies of Russia and France would chiefly rest on the shoulders of Germany. The four last army corps of the German Confederation have not the military efficiency of those of a great Power, and how many of them would fight on ourside would only be proved by success. Su ported by an alliance of Russia, Austria, and Prussia, the Confedera- tion would fairly hold tegether so long as it believed in the final victory of those Powers, be it with or without the participation of the Middle States. In such a doubtful case, however, as a war against East and West the princes au fur eta mesure would secure themselves by neutra- lity treaties if they did not oppose us in the field. “In any real danger, as in face of a French, Russian, and Austrian alhance, the old Federal treaties will not hold out. Last year I was told over and over again by the leading ministers of Bavaria, Wiirtemberg, Baden, Darmstadt, and Nassau, that they considered it their honest duty to give up the Confederation if the interest of their respective countries, or the personal security of their respective princes, would be endangered by their sticking to the said Confederation mae Backed by a million soldiers of the Holy Alliance, it may eee pretty durable. As matters stand now, I am fully convinced that a real danger from without does not exist. There is no need either of enlightening the foreign Powers by the pilgrimages of the Beusts, Pford tens, Dalwigks, and other small fry to Paris, nor does it require an extraordivary seduction to draw the rats out of the house when it is threat ening to falldown. The foreign ministers here listen with a sarcastic politeness when we occa sionally speak of a Confederate war in grand style. The seriousness of the Roman augurs of the old school is necessary to the Diet in order to revive thorougbly the military constitution of the Confederacy. ‘* It would not have been different if the Holy Alliance had gone to pieces sooner, but we owe it tothe Austrian policy of the last two years, which reached its culminating point m the treaty of December and in the note of January i4, that the inner rottenness of the Confederacy has become so apparent and generally known at home and abroad. The Confederation could hold itself free from any of the wars of the two great Powers without breaking its constitution, if one-third of its votes (such as Frankfort, Nassau, Luxemburg, Hesse-Darmstadt, Baden, Wirtemberg, and Bavaria) refused consent to the declaration of war. They, however, do not dare so to do ; they rather vote and leave us in the cold. Shall we be able to defend ourselves in alliance with Austria against East and West, if Sardinia, probably the Belgian army, and a part of the German Confederation be united with the latter: If everything were as it ought to be, I would not despair ; but the Eva peror Francis Joseph is not m the same degree master of his provinces and of his subjects as our King. Austria on the offensive is an enemy not to be trifled with. She can employ more than 200,000 good soldiers beyond her bounda- ries, and besides keep euovgh of them at home to watch over her Italians, Magyars, and Slavs. On the defensive, bowever, and attacked within her own boundaries from East and West, the present Austria seems to me to be rather weak, as at the first successful shock of the invader the whole artificial structure of Bach’s and Buol’s regiment of clerks (Schreiberregiment) will tumble down like a house of cards.” ‘** Besides this danger I see a still greater one in the fact that even in the greatest common peri! a Prussian and Austrian alliance would be just the reverse of what a sincere alliance ought to be. Mutual political distrust, political ana mili tary suspicion on the part of the one lest the other might, by special treaties with the enemy, prevent the aggrandizement of the other when successful, but secure its own salvation when un suecessful—all these considerations would in this case be even stronger and more paralyzing than inany ill-arranged alliauce of the past. The generals would grudge a victory to each other until it would be too late. In our own history we have the records of the treaties of Vossem and St. Germain, the recollection of our defeat at the Vienna Congress, which justify us in dis- trusting the results of an Austrian coalition; and the politics of the last two years proves that Macchiavellian practices bave not been dis- carded. Austria would perhaps propose to give us guarantees by a change of her responsible men after Buol bad lost credit and confidence with all cabinets ; but the traditional policy of Austria toward us would not be set aside by such a policy, and I would trust the old fox in a new pelt as little as the old one when shedding his summer hair. According to Vienna politics, Germany is too small for bota of us. As long.as we have not arrived at and executed a fair set- tlement as to the influence of each of us in Ger- many, so long we shall both plough the same acre and so long will Austria remain the only state by which we can suffer lasting losses, and from which we can gain lasting advantages,” ‘** By the Concordat and its consequences this historical and necessary friction has recently been increased, and the understanding has been aggravated. We have, however, besides these difficulties, a large number of conflicting interests, which neither of us can give | without resign- ing the mission in which each of us believes, and these cannot be disentangled by diplomatic and peaceful correspondence. Even the heaviest pressure from without, the most urgent danger threatening the existence of both of us, could not, either in 1813 or in 1849, forge the iron. The German dualism for a thousand years occasion- ally, and since Charles V. in every century, has regulated its relations by a thorough internal
Page 14
184 war, and in this century also no other means than war can set the clock of its development at the right hour. By thus reasoning I do not pro- pose to arrive at the conclusion that under the most tavorable circumstances we should direct our policy toward effecting the decision between Austria and ourselves. I only wish to express my conviction that in not too long a time we shall bave to fight for our own existence against Austria, and that it is not in our power to pre vent such a war, because the march of events in Germany offers no other outlet.” “If this, my opinion, be correct, which of course is more a question of personal belief than of proof, it will be impossible for Prussia to carry her self-abnegation so far as to jeopardize her own existence in order to protect the integri- ty of Austria, and that in a conflict which in my eyes will be hopeless. Among the many difficul- ties with which our side would be saddied in such a struggle, [ have not mentioned those which lie in the peculiar state of English affairs. Since the Reform Bill the hereditary wisdom of for- mer days has not been able to clear the passions of an inordinate party feeling pected mgr mi It is impossible for me to gain confidence where a newspaper article is of more importance than the considerations of a statesman. On account of her insular security it is very easy for Eng- land to support or drop a Continental ally ac- cording to her wants, and a change in the Minis- try is sufficient for effecting and justifying a revirement, as Prussia experienced in the Seven Years’ War. The mutual aversion and the commensurate arrogance of Austria and England, and the political and religious contrast between them, will in many ways loosen and cripple an alliance of the two; and if we really remain victorious against a Franco-Russian alli- ance, what have we, after all, fought for? For the preservation of the Austrian preponderance in Germany, and the miserable constitution of the Confederation. For such ends we cannot possibly stake the last remnant of our strength and jeopardize our existence. If, however, in compapy with Austria, we should try to carry out changes in our favor, we should fare as in 1815. At the right moment Austria would con- clude new treaties of Ried and Fulda, and, in the long run, by treaties with the enemy, place ber- self in a favorable position to mete out to us, as at that time, the price of our vic- tories.* As formerly, she avails herself of every means to prevent Prussia from arriv- ing at a higher position in Germany, and to keep us in our awkward geographical boun- daries, and under the unfavorable constitu- tion of the Confederacy. “In delineating what may appear to you eventualities and phantasms which may never be realized, I only justify my assertion that Aus- tria will not even accept the chances of a Ger- man-Prussian-English alliance against Russia and France, apprehending that they are too weak and uncertain. If, therefore, it be true that Austria has already urged at Munich trea- ties for the guarantee of her Italian possessions, and that she intends similar steps in Berlin, that Count Buol has already visited Hanover and Dresden for the same purpose, Ido not believe that these plans are prompted by the idea of col- lecting Germany under her flag, and of braving a world in arms. The Vienna Cabinet, on the contrary, intends to make diplomatic use of our or the other Governments’ assurances in order to secure for herself better conditions at our ex- pense for an understanding with Russia, and, if possible, with France. She will play Don Gio- vanni, at all courts, if she can misuse as robust a Leporello as Prussia; and in keeping with this rOle she will always be ready to draw herself out of the scrape and to leave usin it. If peace con- tinues, she will thank us for our friendly feelings toward the solidarity of German interests by trying to draw the Zollverein out of our hands {as she did in 1862); if war breaks out, she will, in spite of all the treaties in her pockets, not be prevented from obtruding with as much dexterity as safety on that side which offers her the best prospects of supremacy in Germany, which, in consequence of her centralizing Ger- man tendencies, is at present more necessary to her than ever before. * It was in October, 1813 (not in 1815), that the Austrian Government concluded special treaties with Bavaria, Wiirtemberg, and Baden, at Kied and Fulda, by which these kingdoms and grand duchy of Napoleon's grace obtained full indemnity for the st and the acknow- ledgment of their sovereignty and territorial extent, so that, as the peers of the great Powers, they made’ war against Napoleon. The Prussian patriot Stein wanted to have the porey kings of the above-named countries outlawed. Glorious old Bliicher, when asked how he wuvuld like to have them dealt with, answered, “I pre- fer them cold.” Metternich, however, carried his plans, and, to the detriment of Prussia, gained strong support- ers tor his future federal policy. The Nation. ‘‘T cannot believe that we or Bavaria should lend ourselves to such a one-sided business at a moment when the situation is not yet clear, when no danger appears, and no new political group is yetformed. By binding ourselves to Austria we should only tie ourselves to an incalculable and malevolent passenger on our voyage into the un- known sea of the future. In the year 1851, es- pecially at its beginning, the danger of the revo- lution spreading beyond the limits of France and Italy was much nearer, and the monarchical Governments had a joint interest, as against this danger, which quite naturally created our treaty of May. Asimilar situation would recur after the French Empire had been overthrown. As longas it stands, however, the repulse of democrats is out of the question, and the cabinets have only to agree on a common policy, in which our and the Austrian interests do not coincide A treaty like that proposed by Austria for the protection of her Italian meme would only prema- turely provoke France, and cause a cooling of Russia toward us. Such consequences would be in the interest of Austria, and she would take care that the fact did not remain un- known in Petersburg and Paris; and, besides that, the culpability of the indiscretion would be thrown on our shoulders. However, in all and everything that Austria would like and be able to do witnout us, she would not feel herself con- founded by the best Prussian or German treaties of guarantee. She used the treaty of April 20, 1854 (neutral guarantee of Austria and Prussia of the former’s non-German provinces], for no other purpose than to make it sparkle in her own interest, to treat us badly, and to carry on a policy as double-tongued as unwise. On the other hand, our guarantee did not prevent her clandestinely entering into the treaty of m- ber following, and acting with others as her inte- rest dictated. If the calculations of Count Buol had not been defeated by the deatb of the Czar Nicholas and the unexpected yielding of the Emperor Alexander, we should not have become acquainted with Austria’s thanks otherwise than by ber secret opposition to our admission to the conferences. ‘*In my opinion, our situation, being that of a desired ally, isa very favorable one, as long as the new political groups are not too sharply de- lineated, as long as their activity remains diplo- matic, and as long as a good understanding with one does not involve a rupture with the other, If, however, a Franco-Russian alliance with war- lke purposes should be realized, we could and should not be among its adversaries, because we should very likely succumb, or perhaps tri- umphantly bleed to death—pour les beaux yeux de VAutriche et dela Diéte. To keep open every chance, nothing seems to me at present required but a little more inexpensive friendship toward Louis Napoleon, and the refusal of each attempt to bind us, gratuitement and beforehand, to the heels of another power.” So far Bismarck. Three years later the Italian war was brought about by Louis Napoleon against Austria. The Prince of Prussia, then regent of the kingdom, went so far in contra- diction to his future Chancellor's views as to in- tervene in Austria’s behalf. Several Prussian army corps were under marching orders; but the Emperor of Austria concluded the sudden peace of Villafranca, preferring to sacrifice his best Italian provinces rather than that the Prince of Prussia should be chief commander of the united German-Austrian forces. Rather an ignominious defeat than an energetic war, the possible vic- tories of which he would have had to share with the hated German rival! Seven years later the inborn animosity led to a new outbreak of hos- tilities, but this time King and Chancellor were guided by the same aspirations and tendencies. Koniggratz settled the old dispute of supremacy. Austria was put out of the Confederation, which was dissolved forever by Bismarck. The new German Empire rose from the ashes of a de- tested and contemptible political nondescript. Germany is herself again, Austria, too, is better off, and both countries live side by side in a state of friendship which, in the absence of colliding interests, is growing more intimate from day to day. oe [ Number 894 Correspondence. MR. HAMERTON ON TRUTH TO NATURE. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION : Str: It is not generally worth while to take notice of misrepresentations in reviews, but as the reviewer of ‘The Graphic Arts’ in the Nation has touched upon a doctrine of mine which I con- sider of especial importance, perhaps you will kindly allow me space to state what the doctrine really is. It refers to truth in art. Your re- viewer says of me: ‘In an early part of the book Mr. Hamerton reiterates the doctrine, which he has for some time held and ay ae Peo | it most dis- tinctly and fully im his ‘ Life of Turner’—that the business of an artist is to give ssthetic plea- sure without necessary regard for truth to na- ture. He teaches that an artist may utterly violate all laws of truth with impunity. We hold this to be a very mistaken view of the mat- ter. Weagree with the ————- that it is an artist’s business to give wsthetic pleasure ; and we go so far, also, as to hold that if he does not give esthetic pleasure, a man is not entitled to rank as an artist at all. But we entirely dissent from the doctrine that any esthetic pleasure which does violence to nature can be worthy pleasure, or that any form of representative art which is not truthful can be good art, The lim- itations, or conventions, to which all art is more or less subject, are by no means of the nature of untruths. Against the idea that art should con- cern itself simply with physical facts, Mr. Ham- erton has very justly contended ; but we think he has been led too far, and that his present doc- trine is calculated to cut the arts adrift from their proper moorings quite as effectually as ever the narrowest pre-Raphaelite doctrines did.” No doubt your contributor quite expresses the popular sentiment as his own, and it would only be natural if the great majority of your readers sided with him against me ; but I should at least desire that they might be made acquainted with the real nature of my doctrine on this subject. Careful observation of what has been actually done in the fine arts by the most famous men has fully convinced me that the exact delinea- tion of nature and the exact imitation of natural color have not been the ultimate goal to which their different orders of genius have tended. We must remember always that severely truth- ful naturalism in art would be something very nearly resembling accurately - colored photo- graphy (not quite resembling it, for reasons which every reader acquainted with these mat- ters will know). It would be like a camera- obscura image with inferior light. But, in fact, what do we see in the works of celebrated artists? We see, in the first place, that their paintings do not resemble the colored image in the camera obscura (which is the natural pic- ture), and we see, again, that the paintings of different men do not resemble each other. On further and more minute investigation, we dis- cover that these differences are occasioned by divergences from the positive truth ; and when once we understand what the positive truth really is, and what a rigid, unaccommodating thing it is, we soon become able to measure the divergencies occasioned by individual prefer- ences and feelings. Perfectly accurate art would be entirely devoid of passion: the ex- pression of passion in art (which is highly desir- able) is always obtained by some kind of accent or emphasis which destroys the balance of the real truth. An absolutely truthful painter would be keenly observant, yet without pas- sion; and he would probably be most uninte- resting. Now, with reference to the degree of liberty enjoyed by the artist : can he violate all natural truth with impunity? The answer to this question is, that an artist misses his purpose when he attracts attention to questions of truth
Page 15
Aug. 17, at all, because discussions about truth are fata to the perfect enjoyment of his work, which’ is the delight in its beauty or the sense of its im- pressiveness. Now, my theory is, that the real object of an artist, so far as truth is concerned, should be to escape discussions about it ; but te escape these, I think it is obvious that there must.be a con- siderable amount of truth in his work, and a very great amount of knowledge in his own mind. To give an example, I may say that an artist who made a drawing for me omitted the mouth in one of his faces. I said that omissions were often very permissible, and even necessary, in art ; but that, as all human beings I had seen possessed mouths, it seemed desirable that the feature should not be omitted in the drawing. The reason for my criticism was not the falsity of a face without a mouth, but that the peculi- arity attracted attention. There were other less obvious omissions in the same design that I did not complain of. Here, then, was a case (of a very elementary nature) in which a truth was essential, and thousands of other truths are essential in the same way, so that there is a vast amount of essential truth in art simply because the artist cannot afford to attract attention by its absence. And now let me pass to the intro- duction of falsities. Here is an example : I was in the studio of a very famous English artist, when he showed me a picture in progress. ‘1 have been obliged, as you see,” he said, *‘ to put the architecture in my background in false per- spective, because the true perspective looked wrong.” I could only say that he acted wisely, and that a great master in similar circumstances would have done the same. A landscape-painter will sometimes introduce a false light—I mean a light which, under similar conditions, would not be possible in nature—and he will do it with clear knowledge that it is not natural, yet it may look more natural than the light calculated at its true angle. Things are often put in pro- portions which are intentionally false: the small size of the fishing-boats in Raphael’s “Calling of Peter ” is a well-known example. To be of any use as fishing-boats, they required to be at least three times that size; but, then, what would have become of the composition? It would have been a study of boats. The discrepancy between the boats and their work is of very little conse- quence, as few remark it, and those who do at once understand the reason for it. In color, as in light and shade, arrangements are very frequently made for artistic reasons when they have very little reference to nature ; and the higher the rank of the colorist, the stronger the color-faculty in him, the more will he be tempted to the employments of a kind of color which is to nature what the poems of Ten- nyson or Rossetti are to every-day conversation. Of course the work of a colorist has some foun- dation in nature: it is suggested by natural color, but it is really the product of human genius. Even when colorists suppose that they imitate nature (as by a facile illusion they some- times do), they will tell you frankly that much of natural coloring is unsuitable for the purposes of art. One very good colorist told me that all the cold coloring of nature was unavailable ex- cept occasionally for contrast, yet there is a great deal of cold coloring in nature. Your reviewer seems to be apprehensive that if my doctrines were generally admitted, they would be dangerous to art. Let me at once re- assure him on this point. A candid and com- plete statement of the true state of the case can sutely do no harm to art, while it may be of great benefit to criticism. It cannot be injurious to art, because, if the artist is not to draw atten- tion to questions about truth at all, he must cer- tainly have a great knowledge of truth. I have The Nation. 185 always maintained the necessity for knowledge, and always frankly expressed admiration for the knowledge displayed by great artists whose deviations from truth are frequent. Conse- quently, ny teaching cannot have the effect of relaxing the industry of students. With regard to criticism, the effect of it can but be beneficial. What I dislike most in the common criticism of the day is its unfair application of the truth test. Contemporary artists, especially when they are young, are often rudely condemned for devia tions from truth which are as nothing in com- parison with the far bolder deviations of great masters. If Mr. Briton Riviére were to draw lions as little like natural lions as those of Ru- bens, he would be treated with contemptuous severity ; yet it has been the fashion among critics to extol Rubens as an animal-painter. “One of the greatest powers,” says Kugler, ‘* wielded by this almost universal genius is that of animal-painting. Horses, dogs, stags, wild boars, and especially ravenous animals, such as lions, tigers, panthers, wolves, and foxes, he renders alike with inconceivable mastery.” No doubt Rubens cou/d have painted lions truth- fully if he had taken the trouble to study them ; but, in fact, he only painted them with sufficient truth to satisfy the criticism of his own time ; and so hisanimal-painting fulfilled the necessary condition of not attracting attention to truth, but it is quite unjust to modern artists to extol his work as if it were absolutely true. may be said of Rubens as a landscape-painter ; he gave truth enough for his time, but he did not give absolute truth, or anything approaching to it. if my doctrines were so dangerous as your re- viewer imagines, I should not be so much en- couraged in my work by the approval of artists. It is well known that, as a general rule, artists dislike writers on art, the reason being that writers on art so often positively prefer to re- main ignorant of technical matters, whereas artists rightly consider that sound and thorough technical knowledge is the very foundation of art criticism. It has been said of me that I am the only writer on ait whom artists read. This, of course, is an exaggeration ; but it is quite true that I am supported by the opinion of artists to a remarkable degree. When I offered myself as a candidate for the Watson-Gordon professor- ship in the University of Edinburgh, my can- didature was supported in very strong and de- cided terms by twelve Royal Academicians, including the President, besides several associ- ates, and by ten Scottish Academicians. It was also supported by several foreign artists of emi- nence, who had some acquaintance with my work ; and it has often happened to me to receive hearty encouragement from artists outside the Academy. This is very easily explained. Men whose lives have been devoted to these studies are naturally gratified to see that there is at least one writer on art who will take the trouble to ascertain the true nature of the difficulties against which artists have to contend—a writer who does not expect incompatible qualities ; a writer who has himself studied nature as well as art, and who knows in what they differ. It has been my special work to demanstrate the impor- tance of technical conditions in the expression of mental qualities ; to show the inexorable nature of these conditions, and their enormous influence on performance—an influence comparable two that of the chosen instrument in music. The same musician may play on the violin, the piano, and the drum, but he can never make the violin give the harmonies of the piano, nor obtain from the piano the sustained notes of the violin, nor from the drum its range. No power of genius Phe same can get over the limits of the instrument. So it is in the graphic arts. They are, it is true, no- thing more than instruments for the expression of that artistic genius which lies behind all of them; but the genius itself is affected as it passes through them. Some part of it may be kept back. The Titian of the pen-drawings is not the Titian of the paintings, but only a part of hin. The Direr of the woodcuts is not the Diirer of the intaglio engravings, but only a part of hin I certaialy do not undervalue that general art faculty which lies behind these instruments, and uses them as means, but I say that if you try to estimate artists without being at the pains | learn what are the conditions— the material eu - ditions—of their work, you are little hkely to do justice either to their artistic abilities or to such critical faculty as you may yourself pcsser Sincerely yours, P. G. HAMERTON AuruN, July 18, 1882 {We agree with Mr. Hamerton that ‘tle exact delineation of nature and the exact imu tation of natural color” have never been, and can never be, the object of a great painter Mr. Hamerton seems to us to write confused) \ and to criticise erroneously, Owing to his limi tation of the term ‘truth to nature.” Ther is a higher and a lower truth to nature. Mrs Jarley’s wax-works exhibit the lower, Micha! Angelo’s ‘‘ Fates” the higher. The higher truth to nature is truth, not to her appearance to the outward eye, but truth to her aspect to the eye of the imagination—truth to her essential meaning as interpreted by the poetic spitit in the soul of man. *' The visionand the faculty divine” see and represent the higher truth not the literal, visual fact, but that literal and visual fact according to the terms of art. In each art these terms differ. No man speaks in verse continuously in real life, but the characters of Shakspere are true to patur in doing so. But this truth to the imagina tive vision and inward passion of the artis’ rests indissolubly in the exact, minute, and absolute knowledge of the truths of externa! nature. Our doctrine is as old as Aristotle, and we regret that Mr. Hamerton should mis take our meaning, and much more that hi should use his justly-acquired influence in diffusing what we believe to be confused and mistaken teaching.—Ep. NATION. } ever Notes. JAMES R. Oscoop & Co.'s fall announcements include * Jewish History and Home-Life in the Bible,’ by Henrietta Lee Palmer ; ‘ Bible Narra- tive,’ in three volumes: Cruden’s ‘ Concordance,’ enlarged by the Rev. J. B. R. Walker; ‘ The His- torical, Political, and Diplomatic Works of Nix cold Machiavelli,’ translated by C. E. Detmold, in four volumes octavo; ‘ The Correspondence of Thomas Carlyle and Ralph Waldo Emerson, 1834-1872,’ edited by Prof. C. E. Norton, in two volumes; ‘ The Life and Letters of Francis Lic- ber,’ edited by Thomas Sergeant Perry ; ‘The Life of Dr. William Rimmer,’ the sculptor, hy T. H. Bartlett, with numerous illustrations from his works in statuary, painting, and drawing : Memoirs of John A. Dahlgren,’ by his widow : ‘Charles Albert Fechter,’ by Kate Field, in the American Actor Series: ‘The Works of James Abram Garfield,’ edited by President Hinsdale; Lieut. Danenhower’s ‘Narrative of the Jeun- nette’; ‘The Old Masters of Belgium and Hol- land,’ by Mrs. Mary C. Robbins, illustrated ; ‘Parisian Art and Artists,’ by Henry Bacon, illustrated : a translation of Gonse’s ‘ Eugéne Fromentin >; Howells’s latest serial, ‘A Modern
Page 16
136 Instance’; a posthumous tale by Nathaniel Haw- thorne, only recently discovered, ‘ Doctor Grim- shawe’s Secret’; Poole and Fletcher's ‘Index to Periodical Literature’ (in December); ‘ Poems,’ by Margaret E. Sangster, and ‘Poems of Love and Nature,’ by Mary Clemmer; ‘Old Love Let- written by persons eminent in English literature and history, and edited by Mrs. Abby Sage Richardson; ‘Short Sayings of Famous Men,’ with historical and ex- planatory notes, by S. Arthur Bent; ‘ Nantucket Mrs. Jane G. Austin; *‘ Spiritual Creation, by Henry ‘Chimes and Rhymes for Holiday Times,’ edited by Almira L. Hayward; ‘Heavy Ordnance, Siege and Naval Guns, Light Artillery,’ as invented and improved in the United States, edited by Gen. C. B. Norton; and a quite new edition of Scott's Lady of the Lake,’ with 120 special illustrations by American artisis, the scenes of the poem having been freshly sketched upon the spot bv Mr. A. V.S. Anthony. The same house will also publish by subscription ‘A Memorial His- tory of the County of Hartford, Conn., its Towns and Cities, 1651-1881,’ edited by Dr. J. Hammond Trumbull; and Bishop Perry’s ‘Centennial His- tory of the American Episcopal Church.’ J. B. Lippincott & Co. have in press ‘A Land lubber’s Log of his Voyage around Cape Horn,’ being a journal kept during a four-months’ voy age on an American merchantman, bound from Philadelphia to San Francisco, by Morton Mc- Michael, 3d Macmillan & Co. have in press a cheap but not inelegant American edition of Butcher and Lang’s translation of the ‘Odyssey,’ which ap- peared two years ago in England. The ‘Clarendon Press Series” (Macmillan) has added to its list of classical text-books the ‘Helena’ of Euripides, edited by Mr. C. 8S. Jer- ram. When Mr. Jerram’s edition of the ‘Tabula Cebetis’ was published in the same series we ex- pressed a very favorable opinion of the ability and scholarship with which the work was exe- cuted. The present edition of the ‘Helena’ ap- pears to be better adapted for the use of students in a class than any with which we are ac- quainted. We would, however, suggest one or two changes, either for a second edition or for future editions of other plays. Mr. Jerram had previously edited, for the some series, the ‘ Al- cestis’ of Eurmpides. He seems to take it for granted that all readers of his edition of the ‘Helena’ will have at hand his edition of the ‘ Alcestis,’ an assumption by no means true in It would have been better to make the one more independent of the other, even at the risk of a little repetition. Again, Mr. Jerram has placed his explanatory and his critical notes in different parts of the volume, though it would have been conducive both to convenience and clearness to put all the notes on a given passage in one place. G. P. Putnam’s Sons have ‘Transatlantic Novels’ a Halévy’s ‘Abbé Constantine, in these columns. B. Westermann & Co. have received from Justus Perthes, Gotha, the much-needed map of the seat of war in the East, for lack of which the daily reports of operations have been very im- perfectly intelligible. It consists of (a) a general map embracing Crete, Cyprus, Palestine, and Egypt as far south as Edfu; (b) a small side-map of what might be called ‘“ British interests,” ex- tending from the British Channel to Beacons- field’s “‘ scientific ” Indian frontier, and giving at one glance all southern Europe, all northern Africa, and all of Islam as far as Kandahar; and (c) another side-map, on a scale of 1: 1,500,000, showing the Nile delta in detail, and the Suez Canal, with Cairo and Suez for the southern ters, or Letters of Sentiment Scraps,’ by James; all cases. added to their translation of already noticed ’ limits. This chart has the well-known excel- lence of the Gotha work, and is well worth its moderate price. After the success of M. Francisque Sarcey’s series of critical and biographical sketches of contemporary actors and actresses, M, Jouaust was encouraged to start a similar series devoted to the artists, and written by M. Jules Claretie, under the title of ‘Peintres et Sculpteurs’ (Paris: Jouaust; New York: F. W. Christern), of which eight parts have now appeared. The work is divided into two sections: in the first, comprising the artists who died between 1870 and 1881, M. Claretie has considered Henri Regnault, Tassaért, Hamon, Millet, and Corot; in the second, which includes only artists now living, he has noticed MM. Meissonier, Baudry, and Géréme. Eachessay has a portrait etched by L. Massard. The plates of Part 7 of Reiss and Stiibel’s ‘Necropolis of Ancon in Peru’ (Dodd, Mead & Co.) present a great variety of specimens of Peruvian art, all admirable. The woven stuffs are, as usual, remarkable for their coloring, and for the ingenuity of their geometric and animal patterns. Especially noteworthy are the highly- decorative raised braids and rosettes of Plate 60, designated by the French term passementerie. Delicately mnde slings are shown to have been used also as fillets, in the handy fashion still to be witnessed in Bolivia. Another plate depicts sundry small domestic and toilet articles like spoons, spools, combs, dye-tubes, needles, brushes, and an elegant little workbag—a net for holding balls of cotton thread. The mummies of children yield very curious wooden dolls, one represeut- ing a child in its cradle, whose fez-like cap, anx- ious face, and clasped hands suggest Abdul- Hamid pondering England’s requirements to- ward Arabi; and some quilted and clay toy figures of the lama. A few excellent pieces of earthenware conclude this instalment. Three more will finish the work. Bulletin No. 62 (July) of the Boston Public Library contains the titles of a large number of books on Egypt, Assyria, etc., mostly purchased from the library of the late F. J. Chabas. Our readers may remember that the Société Bibliographique Belge offered a prize for the best historical bibliography of Belgium. The results are said to have been very satisfactory. Two memoirs have received prizes, by M. La- haye and M. Potter, and are both to be pub- lished. The Government gives 2,000 francs in aid of the publication. —The late Mr. George P. Marsh’s interest in everything relating to the forest lasted to the very end of his life. Four days before his death, on the 20th of July, he sent a long letter to the writer of this note describing his impressions of the forest school of Vallambrosa, where he died on the 24th. ‘*Even at this height, the deciduous trees,” he wrote, ‘‘ which in Milton’s day strewed the rare brooks so thickly with their autumnal leaves, thrive luxuriantly, though the monks apparently slanted few, if any, other than evergreen trees. t would be difficult to exaggerate the pictu- resqueness of the scenery here, or the beauty of the vast outlook over the Tuscan hills, but Ihave been disappointed at not seeing a single compat- riot among the forest growths of these woods, al- though there is every reason to believe that most of our native trees might be advantageously ropagated here. There is, very near the Old Monesery, a row of maples, stated to be less than thirty years from the seed, in which many of the trees have attained a diameter of fifteen inches—a rate of growth much greater than that of the sugar-maple in Vermont. I am told that in a part of the forest I have not yet seen there are many beeches above a metre in diameter. I have met with no instance of Ueberwallung (renewal of the bark on the cut surface of a treejin these woods, though there are good specimens of this rare phenomenon in the museum of the In- [ Number 894 stitute. . Iam more than ever impressed with the superiority of the artificial forest, both in quantity and quality, as compared with that of the natural and spontaneous growth. The fir woods here, though so thickly planted as to leave room for scarcely any laterai ramification, are of surprising rapidity as well as regularity of growth, and I think the famous ridge-pole of a barn in Waterbury, Vermont, which squares six inches with a length of sixty-five feet, might readily be-matched here.” Mr. Marsh’s knowledge of the literature of the forest and of forestry was unequalled even by that of the few specialists who devote themselves exclusively to the study of this subject. The in- fluence which ‘Man and Nature’ has exerted in directing attention to the importance of a better understanding of the principles which underlie the theory of forest preservation, is hardly ap preciated. It must long remain the best text- book for those who desire to understand the fo- rest in its most important relations to man. —The Public School System of the City of New York is the subject of aGerman lecture by Dr. Hartwig Gercke, a veteran pedagogue who for many years followed his vocation in this city (‘ Vortraege herausgegeben vom Deutschen Ge- sellig-Wissenschaftlichen Vereine von New York. No. 5’; New York: E. Steiger & Co., 1882), Dr. Gercke finds that during the last thirty years there bas been much improvement in the public schools, and that some of their most glar- ing defects have been more or less remedied. His severest criticism is directed against the marking system, and against the excessive prac- tice of examination, and especially of examina- tion by others than those who do the teaching. On the former point, the majority of competent judges will probably agree with him; bat on the latter there is plenty of room for difference of opinion. Too much examining is, no doubt, a bad thing, especially if it causes the time and energy that should be devoted to teaching pro- per to be diverted to preparing for examina- tions—in other words, to cramming. On the other hand, it is indispensable to have some ready method of testing the efficiency and con- scientiousness with which our three thousand teachers discharge their important duties. Com- ing to details, Dr. Gercke is of the opinion that there has been much progress in the teaching of reading, spelling, and definition, inasmuch as the parrot-like spelling-lessons and the learning of definitions by rote which were once so much in vogue have fallen into discredit and given way to more rational methods. In the teaching of grammar, however, much remains to be wished, in spite of recent improvements. In arithmetic there is still too much adhesion to an- tiquated methods, not enough attention being given to mental arithmetic, which is so valuable in inducing mental readiness and flexibility. Geography is better taught than formerly, and with better results, but not enough attention is given to map-drawing. History of the United States shares in the improvement, but all other history is still utterly neglected. The department of physical culture continues in a very unsatis- factory condition. Of course, Dr. Gercke is an ardent advocate of the teaching of German asa regular and compulsory branch in all the schools. This vexed question is one that should be decid- ed entirely on practical grounds. The point is, whether the attainable results are proportionate to the time spent in attaining them ; and per- haps the only way of settling this is by actual experiment, as bas been done for some years past. The prospect now is that, whether cor- rectly or not, the controversy will be ultimately decided in favor of German. —Dr. Gercke isa warm admirer of the Nor- mal College, which he considers on the whole, and in spite of various faults, a well-organized
Page 17
oy epeatnpeeee 1 SRP Pg iene Aug. 17, 1882] The Nation. 137 and useful establishment. disposed toward the College of the City of New York, and, so far from agreeing with those who from time to time engage in futile attempts to abolish it, he would rather develop the school system in the direction of high schools, consider- ing that no system of public instruction can be called complete which confines itself to the lower branches. He considers it strange that while the cost of the city college is so often urged against it, the much greater comparative expensiveness of the Nautical School, $249 per pupil, is never mentioned. One feature of our system meets with bis unqualified approval: not only does the city furnish its school-children with all the text-books and stationery they need, but it does soat the remarkably low average cost of 90 cents per annum per pupil, the entire expendi- ture for this purpose in 1881 having been only $119,161. In summing up the results of his ob- servations, Dr. Gercke concludes{that while our city school system has reached so mature a state of development that all attempts to introduce radical innovations must prove abortive, on the other hand it shows much aptitude for re- form and improvement, for which there is still a great deal of room, and that its principal dan- ger lies in an excessive straining after unifor- mity. Fortunately, it has been keptentirely free from sectarianism, and it has demonstrated its capacity for producing secondary or higher schools. The general management is character- ized by economy and honesty. The chief defect, aside from those already adverted to, is the lack of a body of trained teachers. Nine-tenths of the instructors are women, who only teach till they marry, and, even of the men, many take up teaching only as an ad-interim occupation while they are preparing for some better-paid and more-considered profession. There is only one way of obviating this trouble, and that is by raising salaries. This will necessitate an increase of expenditure, while the current cry is for econ- omy. Proper economy is a good thing. Itisa good thing to insist on getting one’s money’s worth, and to object to being cheated ; but it is foolish economy, when you have made up your mind that you must bave a thing, to refuse to pay a just price for a good article. —Something more detailed than the account given by the biographical dictionaries of the architect Du Cerceau, who is referred to by our Paris correspondent in connection with the Ch&teau of Chantilly, will be found in the cur- rent quarterly issue of L’Art (J. W. Bouton), to- gether with views of certain buildings in Orléans attributed to him. Champfleury, who had al- ready paid homage in Le Livre to the pencil of Tony Johannot, returns to the subject and to his brother Alfred, and adds further facsimiles of their works. Delacroix is the theme of M. E. Chesneau, in several chapters, and a portrait of him is annexed, but there is a great distance between his sketch of a lioness overpowering a man and most of his other pen-drawings repro- duced here. Far more interesting we have found the outline landscapes of Aligny, remark- able for their breadth, firmness, and proportion. Several of them depict the environs of Naples, with more than one masterly sketch of Ve- suvius. This artist was not much of a colorist, we are told by M. René Ménard; at least, his sense of form was supreme. But he had one curious distinction: ‘‘ Never, in the history of the prix de Rome, since France has sent her laureates to the Villa Medici, has a single one of them been struck with the magnifi- cences of the Roman Campagna. To comprehend and interpret these required a man alien to the Ecole, and having, in the presence of nature, no other guide than his personal feeling. This man was Aligny.” Full-page etchings abound in this as in the previous volume of L’Art, but for us none of them surpass in interest the portraits of Corot and Courbet, or are technically more note- worthy than, say, the varied wood-cutting of M. Puyplat. The face and the works of G. F. Watts, the English painter, are celebrated in these pages, where also much may be read and seen concerning the late Hamilton Palace collec- tions, as well as the Salon of 1882. —An interesting relic has been found in the Public Library of Besancon, a manuscript which formerly belonged to the librairie of the Louvre. (The early French employed this word “‘ bookery” as we use library, though now they have con- fined it, as did the Romans—the writers at least —to a bookseller’s shop, and have substituted the Greek and Latin bibliotheca, which has a more learned sound, though it be, after all, only ‘“bookplace.”) It contains, as says an inventory of 1873, ‘le gouvernement des roys et princes, le livre de Moralitez, Botce de Consolation des Philosophes, lEstablissement de Sainte-Eglise, le Miroer de la Messe, Ysopet et la Misére de YOmme.” And on the last page of the volume, so carefully erased that only a photograph was able to render the words at all legible, was the inscription, in the autograph of Charles V., founder of the librairie du Louvre, ‘‘ En ce livre Roman sont conteneus pluseurs notables et bons livres et est & nous Charles le Ve de notre nom Roy de France et le fimes escrire et parfere l’an M-CCC-LXXII Charles.” The book disappeared from the Louvre between 1418 and 1424, and after various fortunes, in the course of which it was valued, in 1607, at 6 francs (it would now fetch 10,000), it was bequeathed to the Public Library of Besancon in 1694. —In the new complete and ne varietur edi- tion of Victor Hugo’s works now publishing in Paris, and to be complete in some forty-five or fifty portly volumes, the latest issue is the third volume of the dramas, containing ‘‘ Lucréce Borgia,” ‘“ Angelo,” and ‘Marie Tudor.” In this volume appears for the first time a mass of new passages now printed from the original manuscript. Among these passages are many of minor importance omitted here and there from ‘‘ Lucréce Borgia,” and one whole act hith- erto left out of “Angelo.” It is now announced in Paris that ‘‘ Le Roi s’amuse,” produced origi- nally at the ThéAtre-Francais in 1832, and for- bidden by royal mandate after the first perform- ance, is to be acted for the second time at the Théatre-Francais, just fifty years since it was seen there for the first time. M. Got is to play the jester Triboulet, known in opera as Rigo- letto and in English drama as Bertuccio. The Literary World’s recent attempt at a Hugo bib- liography, by the way, being apparently almost wholly derived from M. Barbou's biography, was very far from exact or adequate. —The Jesuits of the House of the Holy Virgin at Laach have recently issued the sixth volume of the ‘Collectio Lacensis Sacrorum Concilio- rum Recentiorum’ (Freiburg: Herder), which ought to complete the work ; but we find that the Vatican Council is reserved for a seventh and concluding volume. This undertaking sup- plements and completes the great collections of the last century by Hardouin and Labbe, Coleti and Mansi, and places within reach of the stu- dent a vast mass of material illustrating the development of Catholicism in both hemispheres, which it would be almost impossible for him to obtain in any other form. So long as religion is one of the most powerful factors in human affairs, no one can form a correct conception of secular history without paying close attention to ecclesiastical movements, and this is espe- cially the case with Catholicism, whose preten- sions bring it constantly into contact, and fre- quently into collision, with the state. For the periods prior to the present century, the older collections of councils afford substantially all! the assistance in this direction to be looked for from the authentic exposition of the wishes and aspirations of the Church in its synodical gather ings ; for during the eighteenth century these almost ceased to be held, The renewed activity of the Church in recent times has, however, ex pressed itself largely in a revival of these assem- blies, and the student has long felt the need of such an authorized collection of their ‘‘ Acta et Decreta” as the industry of the Jesuit Fathers has here supplied. —Such of our readers as are interested in that branch of medieval literature which goes under the title of ‘‘ Visions and Wanderings © will be gratified to learn of the following publication : ‘ Visio Tnugdali, lateinisch und Altdeutseh,’ pub lished by Albrecht Wagner (Erlangen: Deichert, 1882, pp. Ixxii.-186). The editor vives a Latin version in prose, another in verse, fragments of a poem in Lower-Rhenish, and the Mitfedhoeh deutsch poem of one Alber. The editing is based upon a careful collation of numerous manu scripts, especially for the Latin. ‘ Visions and Wanderings ” are chiefly interesting to us because of their relations to Dante. Ever since the pub lication of Labitte’s essay, 1842, and the more comprehensive works of Ozanam and ‘Toomas Wright, it has been well known to Dante scholars that the great Italian poet did not in vent the framework of his ‘Commedia,’ Medi- zeval literature offers a whole cycle of legends in which hell, purgatory, and paradise are described in the form of a vision—i.e., as if visited by a human being ina state of trance. Thus, there is the Vision of Alberic, the Purgatory of St. Patrick, Paul’s Journey to Hell, ete., ete. One of the earliest and best known is that of Fur- seus, given by Bede in his ‘Historia.’ The editor goes too far, perhaps, when he asserts (p. vii.) that a continuous chain of such Jegends can be traced back “ bis zum Beginn des Chris tentums.” There are a good many gaps, and we doubt if any one legend can be placed as early as the first, or even second, century with perfect conclusiveness. Irish monks appear to have had a large, if not the largest, share in shaping these legends, and giving them currency. Thus the writer of the present ‘ Visio Tnugdali is undoubtedly an Irishman (see p. xxiii.) ; but we need not, therefore, conclude that visiou literature is of Irish, or even of Christian, inven tion. The descriptions of the nether world in the ‘ Aneid’ and in the ‘ Odyssey,’ not to speak of similar passages in classic literature, may very well have prompted the movement. And when weconnect ‘‘ visions ” with ‘‘ wanderings’ —e.g., the voyages of Brandan and Maeldan— and consider what a part was played in later Greek literature by such ethnographic fables as the Argonautic expedition, the travels of Pytheas (part of which are genuine), Ktesias, Megas thenes, the marvels and wonders in the Alex- ander fable (Pseudo - Kallisthenes), we shall scarcely err in assigning to all medieval tales of the kind a Greek-Oriental origin. Perhaps we may even trace them back to that great literary beehive, the fables of Brahmanism and Bud dhism. Perhaps we may go back still further, and recognize their prototype in the popular story-telling of Old Egypt. See the story of the “‘Naufragé ” in Maspero’s ‘Contes’ and the Lon- don Academy, July 8, p. 24.
Page 18
138 MAJOR DI CESNOLA’S SALAMINIA. Salaminia (Cyprus). The History, Treasures, and Antiquities of Salamis in the Island of Cyprus. By Alexander Palma di Cesnola, F.S.A. With an Introduction by Samuel Birch, Esq., D.C. Ig, LL.D., F.S.A. ; and with upward of 700 illustrations, and map of Ancient Triibner & Co, SVO, pp. Cyprus. London : xl viii. -350. MaJor pi CESNOLA, the writer of this volume, describes himself as a soldier by profession, and “an enthusiastic digger-up of antiquities” by position. He is not to be confounded with his brother, the better-known explorer of Cypriote antiquity, General Luigi Palma di Cesnola, the Director of the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York. His book justifies the modesty of his claims as an archeologist, but its full title is a little misleading. The ‘‘ History” of Sala- mis promised by it, and for which students of the past would naturally look with the hope that new discoveries had thrown light upon the sub- ject, is a compilation from old and familiar authorities which occupies but two or three pages. The author tells us in his text that the city of Salamis is situated in the middle of the eastern coast of Cyprus, and is careful to warn his readers by a note that ‘‘ this site must not be confounded with the island of Salamis off the west coast of Attica,” etc., etc. But, if the ‘*History” of Salamis is thus slighted, the ‘Treasures and Antiquities” are not much better treated. There is ne topographic sketch of the site, no general description of the ground and of the character of the remains, whether those of tombs or temples ; there is no attempt to give any connected account of discoveries, or to study the field from the point of view of archeology proper. Even the 700 illustrations announced in the title shrink into more mode- rate proportions when we find that 375 of them are obtained by enumerating the small objects grouped upon twenty full-page plates. And the ‘“‘map of Ancient Cyprus” turns out to be not made up from original investigations, but merely a reproduction of the map published by Ortelius in 1581—exceedingly creditable for that time, but far beneath the level of modern knowledge. The book is, in truth, little more than an il- lustrated catalogue of a considerable collection of antiquities dug up, not at Salamis only, but at other sites as well, and which does not contain any objects of the first order of interest, while it affords few specimens that exhibit features novel to the student of Cypriote antiquity, or add essentially to the knowledge of it. As a catalogue of such vases, terra-cotta figures, lamps, and other minor articles as form the staple of any large collection of antiquities from Cyprus, and of those rarer objects of more pre- cious material—ornaments of gold and silver, engraved gems, works in alabaster, crystal, and ivory, of which there is such a rich display in the New York Museum—the volumeof Major di Cesnola has its value. Like the collection it describes, it contributes little to the increase of real knowledge, but it makes very considerable additions to the stock of familiar facts ; and, in view of his ignorance of archeology, the book is creditable to its author in its general freedom from additions to the stock of familiar errors. Its pages are, indeed, not free from loose state- ments, of which the Preface affords one rather striking example. On p. xx. Major di Cesnola tells us that he arrived *‘in Cyprus at the end of July, 1876,” and ‘“‘in the month of August was ready to resume researches,” while on p. xxi. he states, somewhat to the surprise of the attentive reader, that ‘‘ from the end of June until October, The Nation. 1876, I was obliged to suspend work.” There is no reconciliation of these statements. The introduction, by Dr. Birch, points out the objects of chief interest in the collection, and contains some critical remarks upon them. Dr. sirch has a reputation as a scholar, but, whether from his devotion to Egyptian hieroglyphics or from some more recondite cause, his English style is often of worse than Egyptian obscurity. The introductions he has furnished to successive volumes of the translations of Egyptian and As- syrian texts published by the Society of Biblical Archeology may have prepared the reader in a degree for what he finds here; but it is not with- out a fresh sensation of wonder that he comes upon sentences like the following : ** A class of objects, also of Phoenician fabric, are the scarabei made of hard stones. These scarabeei were made on the island as well as im- ported. The earlier engraved were followed by the usual Greek intaglios, and many of the pe riod of Greek and Roman dominion are in the collection. These are principally of the later period of art, and probably made in Cyprus, as under the Ptolemies there was a mine in the island.” What mine was in the island at one time that was not there at another is not obvious, and what the existence of a mine has to do with the local carving of gems is a puzzle. Again, he says: “Silver contemporaneous with the ear- liest period does not retain its preservation so well as gold "—preservation being a quality not hitherto, so far as we know, attributed to either metal. He informs us that many specimens of ancient glass ‘* exhibit a rare iridescence of col- ors,” not satisfying the natural curiosity as to what other iridescence they might be expected to exhibit. But perhaps his most remarkable statement (the choice is large) is that “the great peculiarity of early Cypriote art is the employment of birds in its earliest develop- ment.” We are tempted to give longer speci- mens of Dr. Birch’s peculiar employment of words, but these are enough to show its nature ; and they would be simply amusing were it not for the regret that they awaken that a scholar should write in so slovenly a style, and that often, instead of elucidating, he should darken the subject which he treats. Dr. Birch’s reputa- tion will hardly be able to stand his own attacks upon it. This book will do nothing to alter the judg- ment already formed by students of Cypriote art as to its general character. The antiquities found in the island present a curious and in- structive medley of Egyptian, Assyrian, Phoeni- cian, and Greek works. Cyprus imported the greater part of her art. What her native art- ists produced was affected by the influence of foreign methods, both in technical quality and in the forms of expression. Such originality as her artists exhibit gives evidence of a low order of eivilization, as compared with that of Egypt on the one hand and of Greece on the other. A refined sense of beauty is seldom manifest in any of the higher forms of her art, and there is no display in them of the poetic imagination. Cyprus never embodied a lofty type of ideal loveliness, never expressed a deep sentiment by strokes of vigorous realism. No building noble from its harmonies of proportion ever stood upon her soil. Her sculptors lacked the discipline of marble, and, though bronze was at their command, they preferred to work out their conceptions in soft stone or softer clay. The exquisiteness which their work sometimes exhibits is an exquisiteness purely external—of hair, of garlands, of ornaments. The faces they have preserved for us are of men and women who lived soft lives, and pleased themselves with sensual more than with intellectual delights. Cyprus never produced a great artist ; the ser- [ Number 89 vice of the Cyprian goddess forbade. Aphrodite and Athene are the divinities of different breeds of men. LUBBOCK’S ANTS, BEES, AND WASPS. Ants, Bees, and Wasps. A Record of Observa- tions on the Habits of the Social Hymenoptera. By Sir John Lubbock, Bart., M.P., F.R.S., etc. [International Scientific Series, Vol. xlii.] D. Appleton & Co. 1882. THE author remarks in his Preface : “*This volume contains the record of various experiments made with ants, bees, and wasps during the past ten years. My object has not been so much to describe the usual habits of these insects as to test their mental condition and powers of sense. The prin- cipal point in which my mode of experimenting has differed from that of previous observers has been that I have carefully marked and watched particular insects ; and, secondly, that I have had nests under observation for long periods— even for seven years.” The work embraces eleven chapters and a somewhat extended Appendix, containing the detailed records of some experiments and de- scriptions of a few species. There are also five excellent colored lithographic plates, thirty-one figures in the text, a full index, and a list of nearly seventy books and papers referred to. Of the single short chapter devoted to wasps, the most interesting portion describes the life and pathetic death of a Polistes gallica, which the author kept for no less than nine months, ‘ dur- ing several of which I never saw her sting.” Perhaps now some one wil] undertake to tame an American hornet. A second, somewhat longer, chapter is given to bees, upon which the au- thor had intended to make most of his observa- tions; ‘‘but I soon found that ants were more convenient for experimental purposes, and I think they have also more power and flexibility of mind. They are certainly calmer and less excitable.” The introductory chapter gives a condensed but clear account of the life-history of ants. These insects form three families, and more than a thousand species are known, of which rather more than thirty inhabit England. The author has kept in captivity about balf of the British species, as well as a considerable num- ber of foreign forms, and for the past few years has generally had from thirty to forty commu- nities under observation. The remaining chap- ters deal with ‘‘ The Formation and Maintenance of Nests and the Division of Labor,” ‘The Rela- tion of Ants to Plants,” ‘‘ The Relations of Ants to other Animals,” ‘“‘ Behavior to Relations,” ** Recognition of Friends,” ‘* Powers of Commu- nication,” and ‘: The Senses of Ants.” In treating all these subjects, our author deals fully and fairly with what has been written thereon by others. The chapter on ‘“‘ The Relations of Ants to other Animals” contains an account of the remarkable institution of slavery among ants, first discov- ered by Huber. It is now known that several species enslave other species, and becorue more or less dependent upon them, and Lubbock cha- racterizes the several degrees as follows : ‘“‘ These four genera offer us every gradation, from lawless violence to contemptible para- sitism. Formica sanguinea, which may be as- sumed to have comparatively recently taken to slave-making, has not as yet been materially af- It is predatory, but can do for itself, and, if necessary, carry on a nest without slaves. ‘* Polyergus, on the contrary, already illus- trates the lowering tendency of slavery. They have lost their knowledge of art, their natural affection for their young, and even their instinct of feeding! They are, however, bold and pow- erful marauders. ae: “In Strongylognathus, the enervating influ- ence of slavery bas gone further, and even told on the bodily strength. They are no longer able to capture their slaves in fair and open war- fare.
Page 19
Aug. 17, 1882] The Nation. “In Anergates, finally, we come to the last scene of this sad history. They are weak in body and mind, few in numbers, and appa- rently nearly extinct, the miserable representa- tives of [presumably] far superior ancestors, maintaining a precarious existence as contempt- ible parasites of their former slaves.” That some ants assume the charge of large numbers of plant-lice (Aphides), and actually ‘‘milk ” from them the sweetish juice which they exude, has been long known ; in addition, there have been found in ants’ nests a few other insects under circumstances indicating “that some of them may be kept as pets.” The peculiar value of the present work rests in the fulness and accuracy of the record of the author’s personal observations and experiments. Extending as they did over days and weeks for a single insect or community, it was fortunate that efficient aid could be rendered by his two daughters and their governess. In some in- stances an entry was made every two or three minutes for at least twelve hours respecting the doings of a single ant. The individuals under observation were ingeniously distinguished by painting their backs with different colors. Few naturalists have manifested the patience to con- duct such experiments, and fewer still, perhaps, the power of so arranging the numerical records that their true significance may readily appear. And yet Sir John Lubbock is likewise a leading banker and an active member of Parliament. Very interesting and instructive are the ex- periments with intowicuted ants, in order to ascertain how far a discrimination was made between friends and strangers, such as would show a recognition of the former notwithstand- ing their abnormal condition : “The general results were that the ants re- moved forty-one friends and fifty-two strangers. Of the friends, thirty-two were carried to the nest, and nine were thrown into the water. Of the strangers, on the contrary, forty-three were thrown into the water ; only nine were taken into the nest, and seven of these were shortly afterward brought out again and thrown away. Indeed, I fully believe that the other two were treated in the same manner. It seems clear, then, that even in a condition of insensi- bility these ants were recognized by their friends. . « «. The sober ants seemed somewhat puzzled at finding their fellow-creatures in such a dis- graceful condition, took them up, and carried them about for some time in a somewhat aim- less manner.” The following statements certainly merit the attention of many human families and com- munities : “So far as I can observe, ants of the same nest never quarrel, I have never seen the slightest evidence of ill-temper in any of my nests ; all is harmony. Nor areinstances of active assistance at all rare.” For example, an ant lacking the antenne lost its way, was set upon by ants of anotber species, and left wounded and helpless on the ground. An ant from its own nest found it, ‘‘ examined it carefully, then picked her up carefully and carried her away into the nest.” ““While the utmost harmony reigns between those belonging to the same community, . . . if a stranger is introduced, she is atonce attacked. This implies that all in one community have the power of recognizing one another, a most sur- peting fact when we consider the shortness of heir life and their immense numbers. In the large communities of Formica pratensis there are probably from 400,000 to 500,000 ants.” Our author concludes that “the recognition is not personal or individual, . . . yet that the fact that they recognize their friends, even when intoxicated, and that they know the young born in their own nest, even when they have been brought out of the chrysalis by strangers, seems to indicate that the recognition is not effected by means of any sign or password.” What, then, is the means of communication ? Notwithstand- ing the somewhat vague assertions of previous writers, Lubbock concludes, from his own care- ful experiments, that ‘‘when an ant has dis- covered a store of food, and others flock to it, they are guided in some cases by sight, while in others they track one another by scent.” In other experiments, the food—a fly or spider —was so pinned to a board as to prevent the ant which first fouad it from carrying it to the nest, and the fact that the ant returned with several companions apparently to aid in securing the prey, disposes our author to accredit to ants “something approaching to language.” But even here the protracted efforts to move the prey may have caused its scent to adhere to the ant. Certainly, any other means of communi- cation must have been very imperfect, for none of the ants summoned went directly to the prey, or even followed the guide, and some never found the former at al). In some cases, too, they ‘“‘had all the appearance of baving come out reluctantly, or as if they had been asleep, or were only half-awake,” as if the harmony so strongly dwelt upon were of a passive rather than an active character. Indeed, our author relates several cases of almost wanton neglect of members of the same community, which show that ‘‘tenderness is not invariably the rule ; that there are individual differences among ants—Priests and Levites and Good Sa- maritans—as among men” (p. 101). The most conclusive experiments respecting the power of communication are described on pages 172-175: ‘‘During fifty-two hours, the ants which had access to a glass containing nu- merous larve brought 304 friends; while, during fifty-nine hours, those which were visiting a glass with only two or three larve brought only 104 to their assistance.” It is difficult to see how information as to the greater number of objects to be moved could be given excepting by some kind of language. What the ant’s language consists in is still undetermined. To all sounds producible by human instruments, Lubbock con- cludes that ants, like bees and wasps, are insen- sitive ; but he is disposed to think that they may perceive sounds which we cannot hear (p. 233). As to the other senses, ‘“‘there can be no doubt whatever that in ants the sense of smell is highly developed”; moreover, ants have two kinds of eyes, simple (ocelli) and compound, and it is clear that they see therewith, but the precise mechan- ism is ‘‘ difficult to understand.” From a series of ingenious experiments with variously-colored media, our author concludes that ants are not sensitive to the ultra-red rays, but perceive the ultra-violet rays, and that the colors of objects and the general aspect of nature presents to them a very different appearance from what it does to us (Dp. 220). From the most general point of view, the pre- sent work has three aspects—(1) as a record of personal observation ; (2) as a digest of these ob- servations in combination with those of other writers; and (3) as a discussion of the ulti- mate significance of the facts and considera- tions so attained. Upon the first two points | nearly unqualified praise is due to the author's | ingenuity, care, patience, and candor. The fol- | lowing paragraph well illustrates also his anxiety | to avoid an error of proximate interpretation : ‘‘ Every one knows that if an ant or a bee in the course of her rambles has found a supply of food, a pumber of others will soon make their way to the store. This, however, does not neces- sarily imply any power of describing localities, A very simple sign would suffice, and very little intelligence is implied if the other ants merely accompany their friend to the treasure which sbe has discovered. On the other hand, if the ant or bee can describe the locality and send her friends to that food, the case is very different” (p. 160). 1839 When, however, our author passes from facts and their immediate significance to a discussion of their broader psychological aspect, his re- | marks are less satisfactory, as may be judged from the following passages : ‘*In the face of such facts as these, it is im possible not to ask ourselves, How far are ants mere exquisite automatons ; how far are they conscious beings? When we see an ant hill, tenanted by thousands of industrious inhabi- tants, each one fulfilling its duties in dustriously and without confusion, it is difficult altogether to deny to them the gift of reason ; and the preceding observations tend to contirm the opinion that their mental powers differ from those of men not so much in kind as in degree” (p. 181). “The Anthropoid apes no doubt approach nearer to man in bodily structure than do any other animals ; but when we consider the habits of Ants—their social organization, their large communities and elaborate habitations, their roadways, their possession of domestic animals, and even, in some cases, of slaves—it must be ad- mitted that they have a fair claim to rank next fo man in the scale of intelligence” (p. 1), The concluding portions of these two extracts are italicized, because they will impress most readers not only as unsubstantiated by what is related in the first seven chapters of the work, but as absolutely refuted by some of the experi- ments described in chapter ix. The author found that ants would carry larve at least thir teen feet up and down nearly vertical sticks rather than fall about two-fifths of an inch. In another experiment, ‘they tried in vain to stretch up from the earth to the glass, which was just out of their reach, though they could touch it with their antenne; but it did not occur to them to heap up the earth a little, though if they had moved only half-a-dozen particles they would have secured direct access to the food. I was the more surprised at their want of ingenuity in constructing bridges on account of the ingenuity with which they avail themselves of earth for constructing their nests” (pp. 248, 249). Without insisting unduly upon metaphysical distinctions, do not the fore- going facts illustrate the commonly-accepted difference between instinct and intelligence, be- tween an inherited skill in the performance of certain acts and a capacity for adaptation. to new conditions ? Unless, however, the passages above quoted are to be regarded as the insuf- ficiently revised expressions of a very nutural enthusiasm respecting the special and almost peculiar objects of his study, the author, a President of the British Association for the Ad- vancement of Science, believes that no animal other than man would venture to drop a distance little greater than its own length, and easily spanned by its limbs, rather than perform a really toilsome journey. Upon the whole, it is to be wished that Sir Jobn had either omitted these passages altogether or devoted an entire chapter to the compara- tive psychology of his favorites, The space for such a chapter might well have been gained by condensing the typographical arrangement of some of the numerical records—as, e.g., those upon pages 162, 163, 297, 301, 367-570, ete.—and by omitting the technical descriptions of new species. RUGE'’S HISTORY OF OUR TIMES. | Geschichte unsrer Zeit, von den Freiheitskriegen bis zum Ausbruche des deutsch-franzisischen Krieges. Von Arnold Ruge. Leipzig and Heidelberg. ARNOLD RuGE—whose long life, embracing suc- cessive periods of participation in the Burschen- schajt, imprisonment, professional activity, edi- torial work, revolutionary agitation in the Fatherland, conspiracy in exile, and quiet au- thorship, came to a close in England on the last
Page 20
140 day of 1880—could justly boast of having gone | through the events of his time not merely as a spectator, but as one who had a part, though a pars minima, perhaps, in shaping them. And as a thinker, observer, and actor, familiar with men and things and theories, he had a right to bequeath to us, as he has done, a history of the age. In composing it, however, the ardent Neo- Hegelian theorist and revolutionist was less bent on telling what he had witnessed and observed, learned and unlearned, in the course of his checkered career at home and abroad, than on proving to his readers that his Neo-Hegelian views of civilization and progress, of reason and the spirit of the age, of self-government and equality, of the futility of political reaction, of the irrepressible advance of science and the doom of religion, are fully justified and bril- liantly illustrated by the struggles and vicissi~ tudes of the century. He narrates little, illumines the salient points of the history with fugitive rays, and abstracts from this light a dogmatic vindication of his extreme historical optimism: The civilized world is triumphantly marching ahead toward material felicity, self-rule, ethical elevation, and freedom from caste and belief. Napoleons, Bourbons, Metternichs, Jesuits, pope- dom, the slave power, the Church, can form only temporary obstacles in the path of the free spirit ; they are all doomed to be successively crushed by it ; they even serve it, unconsciously and unwillingly, and help to destroy each other. The Hallesche Jahrbiicher of 1838-40, the Deutsche Jahrbiicher of 1840-43, the Reform of 1848 were right ; their editor has unlearned no- thing. Leipzig, the barricades of 1830 and 1848, Solferino, Appomattox Court-House, Sadowa, Sedan have righted many a thing ; Vildgos has been, and Warsaw will be, avenged. The repub- lican philosopher and poet whom the renovated German Empire pensioned at the close of his life dies happy in his faith, He is far from re- canting anything. Hear his introductory retro- spect, for instance : ‘The German reformers of the sixteenth cen- tury rebelled, not against superstition, but only against the commonwealth of superstition, the hierarchy and its president, the Pope. In lieu of the spiritual hierarchy they set up spirityal an- archy—a sound principle, for the spirit has no master—but they did it in the name ef supersti- tion, and they were, indeed, greater believers than the Pope and the Cardinals ; they made the story-book of the Jews and Christians the norm of thought and source of truth ; they re- placed the authority of the hierarchy by the au- thority of the ‘holy writ ’; and, though they re- cognized no otber but the ‘invisible’ Church, they never thought of banishing the medizval spirit, Christianity : the more absurd a story sounded, the more edifying it wastothem. They made no serious attempts to discover the sense of the dogmas and myths, or to realize morality ; the old conflict between heaven and earth re- mained. . Still less did the Reformation attack the social and — al institutions of the Middle Age, feudalism and despotism. . . . The French in the eighteenth century were the first to take this step, setting up science in lieu of religion, in lieu of feudalism the right of the individual, and in lieu of despotism or ab- | solutism the free state, the republic. ; torians who even nowadays close the Middle Age with the advent of the Reformation call The his- | neither the Middle Age nor its opposite by the | right name: they stiJl cherish a fondness for its | spiritual slavery, the Christian faith, and for its external slavery, the feudalexploitation of man and despotic rule.” The same uncompromising spirit pervades the whole book, and its tone is aggressive through- out. It is history written, or rather discussed, by a combatant ; there is plenty of invective, of piquant sallies, and animated protests, amid which the facts are often largely, and the details entirely, skipped over. The philosophy of the history is the main point ; the work is to bea prose epopee of the modern idea ; even the men who carry the victorious banner are treated The Nation. { Number 894 with neglect. The author surely does not forget his revolutionary associates, Kossuth, Mazzini, or Ledru-Rollin, nor does he forget himself ; but he wastes very little praise on any man—Canning is perhaps the only exception—and his egotism is of a very mild kind, and not unamiable. Adulation he is entirely free from, and the adoration of the German spirit and virtues which disfigures so many German writings, is equally alien to him. In fact, he has preserved unimpaired his enthusiastic admiration of the great journées of revolutionary France. The 14th of July and 4th of August, 1789; the last days of July, 1830 ; the 24th of February, 1848 ; and the 4th of September, 1870, are still to him the sacred dates in the calendar of self-emanci- pating humanity. The massacre and guillotine days of 1792, 1793, 1794, and 1871, fortunately, do not fall within the scope of his sketch. Nor is he inclined to expatiate on crimes or errors com- mitted on the revolutionary side in a contest. Thus he faithfully records the atrocities com- mitted by the Turks on the Greeks in 1821, but makes no allusion to the horrors of Tripolitza, where—after a partial capitulation and surrender —ten thousand Turkish men, women, and chil- dren perished in a three days’ uninterrupted butchery, followed by equally horrible massacres in the surroundings. ‘‘Colocotronis took Tripo- litza by storm "—this is all our author says about the affair, forgetting that Colocotronis boasted that his horse, stepping over piles of the massa- cred, nowhere touched the ground between the walls and the palaces, and that he reckoned the number of the butchered at 32,000, ‘* By honest victories did the Greek avenge cowardly massa- cres and atrocious desolation,” says our author. But in discussing history deductively, and pleading for an historical dogma, one must not be too precise in stating facts. ; It is a pity that there is also some uninten- tional looseness in the author’s way of stating facts : a looseness of diction which often distorts the statements. When, for instance, he says, ‘Karl Albert riickte vor, ging am 8. April tiber den Mincio und die Etsch,” he means to state that the King of Sardinia crossed the Min- cio on the 8th, and the Adige weeks later. When he says, ‘‘Pio nono wurde am 11, De- cember als weltliches Oberhaupt abgesetzt und fliichtete nach Gaeta,” he reverses the order of events, for Pius LX. fled to Gaéta on November 24. In the phrase “Gérgei, Perezel, Klapka und Bem schlugen die Croaten” the word Croats is used figuratively for all the various defenders of the Austrian cause in Hungary. When our author says, ‘‘Am 12. Juni, 1864, setzte Louis Napoleon auch wirklich seinen Kaiser in Mexico ein ; aber dies war gerade das Jahr, in dem General Grant Rich- mond nahm und Jefferson Davis gefangen gefiihrt wurde,” his statement, if not originating in a slip of the memory, can be excused only on the assumption that ‘‘das Jahr” does not refer to the year 1864, but toa twelvemonth embrac- ing both June, 1864, and the spring (April and May) of 1865. Unfortunately the book is also disfigured by a large number of absolutely false dates, some owing to defective revision and proof-reading (the publication is posthumovs) | and some to the use of untrustworthy materials. Among those we have noticed are the dates of the evacuation of the citadel of Milan by Radetzky (March 20 for March 22), of the procla- mation of the republiz of Venice (March 20 for March 23), of the battle of Custozza in 1884 (July 24 for July 25), of the capture of Buda by Gérgei (May 26 for May 21), of the battle of the Alma (Sept. 26 for Sept. 20), of the naval duel at Hampton Roads (March 7 for March 9), of Mac- Clellan’s fight before Richmond (July 1-5 for June 26-July 1), of the battle of Chancellorsville (May 1-2 for May 2-4), of the battle of Gettys- burg (July 31 for July 1-3), of Grant’s advance in 1864 (June 5 for May 4), of the battle of Spottsylvania Court-House (June 11 for May 10-12), and of the evacuation of Richmond (April 5 for April 2). In spite of its various shortcomings, however, we can recommend this ‘History of Our Times’ as not only readable, but instructive. It is as suggestive as it is one- sided. ‘es 7 y.. Camps in the Rockies. By W. A. Baillie- Grobman. Chas. Scribner’s Sons. AMONG the legion of books on the Far West in its varivus aspects which have appeared since King’s ‘Mountaineering in the Sierra Nevada,’ we have found none so fresh, so full of the breath of its Alpine woods and peaks, and giving withal so fair and representative a view of frontier life as Baillie-Grohman’s ‘Camps in the Rockies.’ His sketches, like those of Mr. King, are founded on personal explorations involving hard- ships and dangers of no trivial nature; and though, from a literary point of view, Mr. Groh- man’s style wants the ease, fluency, and grace of the former, and he writes rather from the stand- point of the sportsman than the scientist, yet his language is clear and concise, and his experi- ences and observations are given with a frank- ness and modesty, free from all attempt at fine writing, which carry the reader with him, and leave no trace of a feeling that he has been ro- mancing or drawing the long-bow. Mr. Grohman is essentially an Englishman, al- though his father was an Austrian of high stand- ing at the Imperial Court, and he himself was brought up among the Tyrolese Alps, where he gained his first taste for hunting at an early age in pursuit of the chamois, and later earned laurels asa member of the Alpine Club in peak-climb- ing. His first literary venture was a little book on ‘ Tyrol and the Tyrolese,’ founded on his ex- periences among the mountains and peculiar people of whose life we get such charming glimpses in Tautphceus’s novels. An enthusiastic sportsman and mountaineer, and an earnest student of na- ture, Mr. Grohman came to this country some three or four years since, to shoot some of its big game and compare its people and their moun- tains with those among which he had spent his youth. His first season’s experience was mainly useful in familiarizing him with the ways of the West, and teaching him “how not to do it.” In succeeding excursions, therefore, instead of providing a large and expensive outfit, after the manner of the ‘‘ top-shelfer,” he associated him- self on equal terms with a little band of hunters and trappers, with whom he spent several sea- sons among the mountains, suffering many per- sonal discomforts, and obtaining an intimate knowledge of the country and of his companions that could hardly have been got in any other way. In hisselection of hunting-ground Mr.Groh- man was also exceptionally fortunate. Owing to the fierceness of the Indian tribes to whose reservation it belonged, the wild and mountain- ous region of northwest Wyoming had sel- dom been visited, even by the hardy trap- pers. With the discovery of the wonders of the Yellowstone Park on its northern bor- der, and its subsequent exploration by vari- ous Government expeditions, that portion has become comparatively well known; but the region lying to the south, between it and the Green River basin, comprising the mountain groups of the Wind River and the Sierra Sho- shone, is still practically a terra incognita, Here our author found in abundance the game he sought—the grizzly bear, mule-deer, big-horn, and wapiti (commonly, though erroneously from a zodlogical point of view, known as the elk). The white mountain goat, which he was particu-
Page 21
1 Ne Rae Aug. 17, 1882] larly anxious to bag, as being the nearest repre- sentative of the chamois in this country, must, he found, be sought in more northern latitudes. The chapters on the experiences of the sports- man and his three trapper companions contain many good descriptions of the characteristic scenery, and remarks on the habits of its game which will be of interest to the scientist as well as the general reader. Mr. Grohman’s German blood shows itself in his close observation and accurate statement of fact. His own experiences, though wanting the blood-curdling episodes of most books on hunting, are yet full of interest because of the frank truthfulness of their narra- tion, and the un-English capability on the part of the author of appreciating a joke, even when it is against himself. His solitary bear story may serve as an illustration: “T was out on my usual preliminary bug- stalk; and going along with bent form, now hitting, then again missing my plump game, my whole attention being fixed upon my occu- — I reached a clump of dense service-berry ushes. I had just delivered a successful throw, and was about to stoop to gather in the prize, when out of the bushes, as if growing from the earth, there rose—a grizzly. Rearing up on bis hind legs, as they invariably do when surprised, le stood, his head and half-opened jaws a foot and a half or two feet over my six feet of hu- manity, and hardly more than a yard between gi antic him and pigmy me. The reader will xelieve me when I say he looked the biggest grizzly I ever saw, or want to see, so close. It would be difficalt to say who was the more astonished of the two, but I know very well who was the most frightened. My heart seemed all of a sudden to be in two places; for had I not felt a big lump of it in my throat, I could have sworn it was leaking out at a big rent in the toes of my moccasins. ‘* Now, grizzly-shooting is a fine healthy sport —I know none I[ ain fonder of ; but there ought to be neighboring trees to facilitate centraliza- tion to the rear ; and above all, I must be hand- ling my old ‘trail-stopper’ ;and that moment I was here on a treeless barren en face with one I ‘ was not looking for’ or ‘ had not lost,’ and yonder, 100 yards off, lay that famous old rifle—Boreas {the horse], in the distance, putting some spare und between him and that noxious intruder. ortunately, the old Uncle of the Rockies had more than probably never had anything to do with human beings, for I saw very plainly that he was more puzzied as to my identity than I was regarding his. His small pig eyes were not very ferocious-looking, and first one, then the other, ear would move, expressing, as I inter- preted it, more impatience than ill-feeling. Ido not a who first moved, but I do recollect that on looking back over my shoulder, I saw the old gentleman actually running away from me! On regaining possession of my rifle, which on this quite exceptional occasion 1 had allowed to get beyond my reach, as it interfered with my ‘buggings,’ I felt considerably braver, and spent the rest of the day in a vain endeavor to resume our acquaintanceship on more satis- factory terms. But the old gentleman evidently thought he had frightened me sufficiently, and so kept out of my way.” Mr. Grohman had a great desire to see the most characteristic of all the wonders of the West, the cafions of Colorado. The fitting out of a boat expedition, however, being somewhat above the means of a private individual, be con" ceived the rather novel idea of exploring them in midwinter on the ice. This somewhat hazard- ous undertaking was successfully carried out by the aid of the officers of Fort Bridger, and forms the subject of his ‘‘Camps and Cafions on the Colorado River.” In ‘‘ Camps in Cowboy-land,” he gives a graphic picture of the life of the cat- tle-raiser of the plains of the West, which is as free from exaggeration as the nature of the sub- ject will allow of. No inconsiderable portion of the book is de- voted to the characteristic features of West- ern life and people, of whom Mr. Grohman is a hearty admirer; and, as a natural consequence, it abounds in Western stories, in which, however, Mr. Grohman hasendeavored to avoid the rock on which so many English travellers have split—of The Nation. swallowing whole the yarns with which the Westerner delights to regale the gullible tourist. To his English friends he gives a very practical piece of advice in regard to the necessity of carrying a revolver. Most travellers’ books teach them that it is an absolute necessity, and, that when once they have crossed the Missouri River, ‘‘a man for breakfast ” will be the order of the day. He reasons that it isnot only un- necessary, but a disadvantage. In the first place, if they avoid disreputable places they will probably see or hear of no shooting. In the second place, if they do frequent such places, and get into an altercation with a Westerner “‘on the shoot,” his practised fingers will have discharged the contents of his revolver before they can be quick enough to have drawn theirs. And, thirdly, such action on his part would be considered justifiable homicide if it was found that they carried a revolver on their persons. The scenery of the West Mr. Grohman regards as in keeping with the character of its people, and possessing an essentially American charac- ter. It abounds in elements of sublimity and grandeur ; but, as contrasted with the verdure- clad slopes and soft, hazy atmosphere of the Alps, the bare, rocky surfaces and the brilliant, garish atmosphere of the Rocky Mountains give an eifect of crudity and newness, wanting the mellowing touch of time. Of the Western peo- ple he says, after briefly describing their promi- nent characteristics : “If we look at the result of all this twenty years of experimentalizing,we see the unfinished, rough sketch of a country vast and great as few ever were, and as none other now is; peopled, as it would seem to me, not with a strange med- ley of race and temperament, as is so often re- marked, but rather by a community about which there is a singular unanimity of purpose anda startling uniformity of character.’ A Flight to Mexico. By J. J. Aubertin. With seven illustrations. London: Kegan Paul, Trench & Co. 1882. 8vo, pp. 325. REGARDED merely as a book of travels, ‘ A Flight to Mexico’ cannot take a very high rank, chiefly from the great freedom of digression which the author allows himself. At first it is rather amus- ing to have Mr. Aubertin thinking aloud, as it were, for our benefit, but it soon becomes weari- some and at times positively irritating. He jumps, for instance, in a single sentence from a reference to Brazil and its chief products to Mexico, and from thence, by the slender link of a Latin quotation, to Eton, endivg with some trite remarks on ‘‘the ever-changing human brain.” In another place he gives a long and dull account of a visit to the grotto of Adels- berg, in Austria, his excuse being that he did not see a somewhat similar cave in Mexico. These digressions, it should be said, are the most numerous and the most tiresome when Mr. Au- bertin bas the least to tell us, but they cease when we come to the important parts of his nar- rative. He landed at Vera Cruz June 26, 1881, at a time when the yellow fever was raging with such violence that the captain of the English mail steamer “ issued strict orders against any of the officers or crew going on shore for the few days the vessel was to stay there.” The miserable sanitary condition of the chief port of Mexico, which ‘‘is, in some months, a mere pest- house,” is naturally one of the chief obstacles to the growth of commerce, and to this fact the native press seems at length to be thoroughly awake, The mere traveller, however, is never compelled to passa night in the port, but can take a mid-day train for the interior, which the railway company ‘always puton as far as Ori- zaba for passengers arriving by the packets,” The inefficiency of the Custom-house officials is 141 also the subject of Mr. Aubertin’s criticism. French silks, he assures us, ‘‘can be bought cheaper in Mexico city than in New York, though the Mexican duty is double that of the American, and though the freight to Vera Cruz is higher than that to New York ; not counting the freight on 265 miles by railway after the goods are lended.” And he adds, with a certain air of incredulity, as if making a statement which he cannot expect his readers to credit, ‘* Not only, it is said, are Custom-house positions given to indi viduals merely because they are poor, but some times to political agitators, merely to keep them quiet.” Of the railway connecting the port with the city of Mexico, built and managed by an English company, Mr. Aubertin speaks in terms of the highest praise, both in regard to the ex- cellence of its works and the beauty of the sce nery. We have no space, however, to dwell upon this, nor upon the skill with which the en gineers overcame the difficulties presented by the Sierra Madre in an ascent of 8,150 feet—dif ficulties so great that at Atoyac “the workmen were hung over the rocks by ropes to complete the cutting out of the line.” The city of Mexico proved a disappointment. The scenery was not equal in grandeur to our traveller's expectations, the hotel was poor, the food bad, and the air pes tilential. Though he found the city duli, yet it speaks well for the Mexicans that ‘* bull tights are forbidden within the federal or capital dis trict,” and that the sport is ** denounced in more than one of the newspapers, the Monifor Repub licano at their head, by whom it was coupled with gambling.” The principal silver mines which Mr. Auber tin visited were those of the Real del Monte Company at Pachuca, and the Santa Gertrudes. At one of the former the ore was still crushed and reduced in the most primitive fashion. Near the “treading-ground” of Regla was a “ vast perpendicular wall of tall compact basattie co lumns,” similar to those found at Staffa and the Giant's Causeway, though far surpassing these latter, “‘as regards masses.” Pieces cut from these columns “are rudely tied by a cord, and are run round and round in a broad trough of water and ore.” After the requisite fineness is produced, ‘‘ quicksilver and sulphate of copper are mixed with it, and horses are driven to and fro over the mess as we have seen them being driven round and round to thresh corn. Men, also, were at work after the same fashion, under roofing, recalling, but by violent antithesis, the treading of the wine-press! Men and horses of course suffer by this ugly and incomplete pro- cess; their feet and legs become gradually para- lyzed, and the men are subjected at last to great trembling of the nerves, and thousands of ingots escape reduction and are lost.” Ata hacienda near by there had been set up some ‘elaborate machinery for extracting silver ore. . . . But it unhappily came to pass that on its being for the first time set to work, it was committed to incompetent and uninstructed hands, and in consequence of this some boiler or boilers: had burst, by means whereof the whole affair had been thrown out of order and had been left in that abject condition ever since. Now, this isa fair sample of what is going on in the not-doing style in Mexico.” At Las Animas, near Orizaba, was a large cof- fee plantation, from which Mr. Aubertin brought home ‘two sacks, one of the double-bean, and one of the perola, or single-bean coffee.” These were tested in London by a Rio coffee shipper, who pronounced them both to be ‘“‘ first-class cof- fees. As regards the perola, indeed, he ranked it with the best Java that he is in the habit of drinking. Mexico, with fitting population, could produce an unlimited quantity of coffee. She has coffee grounds in all parts, and coffee trees
Page 22
142 in comparatively very few. This is a question of overwhelming importance to her, considering what a large market for coffee exists among her Northern neighbors, And all who have an in- terest in Mexico have a right to augur the most promising results from an extended cultivation of this plant.” At another hacienda, Jasmine, not far distant, sugar was the chief production. But of this Mr. Aubertin does not speak so par- ticularly, though he refers to the “‘ vast planta- tions ” of the sugar-cane through which he passed, and to the excellent machinery, including the centrifugal pans, which had been set up in the sugar-house of the estate. Having been instru- mental in introducing the culture of cotton into the Brazilian province of San Paulo during our Civil War, it was natural that he should be in. terested in the attempts to introduce the growth and manufacture of cotton into Mexico. The only factory which he visited was the ‘* Hercules,” at Querétaro, the largest at that time in the coun- try. It employed 1,200 hands, all of whom are ‘* Indians, steady, attentive, and obedient.” Their working-hours, the year round, are from five o’clock in the morning till half-past nine at night, with two intermissions, if he correctly informs us, for breakfast and dinner, aggregating an hour and a half. ‘The short staple cotton in use comes from the State of Vera Cruz; the long staple from the Pacific Coast; and rather more than half the raw quality employed is imported from the States.” It may be said here that while Mr. Aubertin is confident that a time of great prosperity is in store for Mexico, in which her rich natural resources will be greatly developed, he is no less certain that the United States must furnish both the capital and the men who shall accomplish this peaceful revolution. By a rare good fortune, one of the three com- panions of our author in the diligence on his journey to Querétaro was ‘‘ the Government As- sessor at the court-martial which sat in judgment on Maximilian and his two Generals”; and the second was a Colonel who ‘‘commanded a regi- ment at the execution.” His host in the city, the owner of the “ Hercules” factory, had en- tertained Maximilian in his house ‘‘ when he made his imperial visit to the city in the early days of his aspiring to found a throne,” and ‘‘supported him later, and more sadly, while he lay for five weeks an invalided prisoner in the convent of the Capuchinas.” By the aid of this latter gentleman Mr. Aubertin obtained an in- terview with the priest who attended the unfor- tunate monarch in his last moments. From these various witnesses was received a detailed and presumably accurate account of the tragedy on the Cerro de las Campanas. It isasad and touching story, in which treachery combined with a fatal weakness of character brought a brave man toan untimely end. Two incidents of the closing scenes of his life seem to us to show in a striking manner both the weakness and the nobility of Maximilian’s character. ‘Just as they were leaving the Capuchinas Convent for the Cerro,” said the Canon Soria, his confessor, ‘* Maximilian pulled himself together, and strik- ing his hand over his breast, said: ‘I have doubled eight handkerchiefs over here to prevent iny blood from soiling my uniform.’” On reach- ing the place of execution he said to General Miramon, ‘on the latter passing to the left in order to leave the centre for Maximilian, ‘ Gene- ral,a brave man must be respected, even by sovereigns; permit me, then, on dying, to con- cede to you the post of honor.’” Oppressed with the failure of all his hopes, worn out with sick- ness, and believing his wife, the scarcely less miserable Carlotta, to be dead, there can be little doubt that he went willingly to his fate. “‘ He said he always wished to die on a fine day,” his confessor told Mr. Aubertin, “and was well con- - The Nation. tent to do so on that morning.” As they rode together in a carriage to the fatal spot, “‘ he re- marked upon the view of the city, and said, ‘Whata beautiful view, and what a beautiful day to die on!’” Here it may be well to call attention to an in- accurate statement in Sir Theodore Martin’s fourth volume of his ‘Life of the Prince Con- sort’ in regard to this event. He represents Maximilian as, ‘‘ just before he was shot,” giv- ing a message for his wife to the attending priest. But Mr. Aubertin makes it evident that he died in the firm belief in his wife’s death. The false report which was brought to him, but three or four days before his execution, by Mejia, the Indian general who suffered with him, was ‘*generally supposed to have been invented by Mejia to pacify the mind of the Emperor, who had been more afflicted by the idea of leaving her in misery than by any other considera- tion.” Though our author stayed in Mexico but nine weeks, he made such good use of his time and opportunities, and he was so thoroughly pre- pared by his life in Brazil to understand and ap- preciate what he saw, that his book is more than a mere sketch. To all appearances it is, as far as it goes, a faithful picture of the present condi- tion and prospects of the country. Essays at Home and Elsewhere. By E. 8S. Nadal. London and New York: Macmillan & Co, 1882. THESE essays are partly critical and partly so- cial ; and, at the risk of using a very hackneyed phrase, we can think of no word that so aptly characterizes their general drift as ‘“sugges- tive.’ Mr. Nadal’s English is simple and straightforward, and no one can read the whole book without meeting with a good many trains of thought or suggestions that will make him feel that his time has not been thrown away. In the essay on Byron, which is the best in the book, Mr. Nadal has some interesting remarks on the fighting passion as it appears in Byron’s poems. Byron’s combatants, as he says, fight like tigers ; they are filled with a deadly enmity. Sir Wal- ter Scott's are apt to display a magnanimity in battle which reminds us of “‘ highly honor- able head-boys at Rugby.” On the other band, ‘“‘the combatants of Byron have for one another a really feline hate. His imagination carries us into the midst of dark and impla- cable passions. He describes a character of man to whom an insult incompletely avenged is as irremediable a calamity as the loss of her vir- tue toa womaa.” Mr. Nadal adds: ** Such states of mind, although they exist, are very much the exception at present. It is, in- deed, surprising, considering what the possibili- ties of those passions are, and their history, to see how little force Se Bye in most people’s minds. It is evident that they are gradually, but surely, growing weaker. This is being ac- complished by the delicate and universal in- fluence of democracy upon the individual cha- racter. This power works not through the moral sense of men, but through their self-interest. It does not repress the thought, but represses its manifestation. People cannot go on nursing thoughts which they are not permitted to ex- ress or exercise. Hence the passions themselves Awindle like those organs of the animal creation which disappear by disuse.” The idea which lies at the bottom of these passages, that the passions of hate and revenge in modern life are not what they once were, bas no doubt a good deal of truth in it; and their intensity in Byron’s poetry was the intensity of the antique, anti-democratic world—the world in which love-making and war were felt to be the only proper occupation for a gentleman, But the connection between the change and democracy Mr. Nadal does not make at all clear. | Number 894 It is probably the commercial spirit that every year tends to produce a type of character in which hate plays a very unimportant part. Displays of hate and anger, moral considerations apart, are discountenanced universally in this country, not because it is governed by universal suffrage, but because the country is devoted to business ; and nothing is more dangerous to suc- cess in business than a sensitive and uncertain temper, or indulgence in feelings of animosity, as such. In a commercial country the man will get on best who is most universally good-natured and considerate of the feelings of others, and who allows his intellect to be least clouded by passion of any kind. A man who is frequently losing his temper, or easily insulted, is at a dis- advantage in the struggle for opportunities of profit. Consequently, most Americans are ac- customed to look upon temper of any kind as a vice, and even to confound a perfectly natural and just indignation with it. In a country in which most people are always trying to sell each other something, bad temper interferes with success in life ; and, on the principle of natural selection, those will succeed best who have the best tempers, and thus amiability will itself be- come, as it has become in the United States, a marked national trait, and the Byronic passions will only be found among the uncommercial classes—the cutthroats and ruffians who figure in the police reports. Mr. Nadal makes up for his occasional sug- gestiveness by writing a vast amount of rubbish, which there can be no excuse for printing unless the fact that the author really does not know the difference between the important and the trivial in literature. He has an essay on Arte- mus Ward which would probably have made that eminent showman laugh loudly if he could have read it. Mr. Browne was, after all, hardly a serious literary character, and an analysis of the sources and meaning of his humor is a task full of peril. A Comprehensive Commentary on the Qurdn: Comprising Sale’s Translation and Preliminary Discourse, with Additional Notes and Emenda- tions. By the Rev. E. M. Wherry, M.A. Vol. I. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co, 1882, WE have here the twenty-ninth volume of ‘‘ The English and Foreign Philosophical Library,” the constituent members of which have been of va- rious degrees of excellence, and, taken alto- gether, rather a motley assemblage. For a moment our temptation is to say that the novel- ty of spelling which substitutes Quran for Ko- ran, is the only new thing about the book. Of 390 pages, more than 280 are taken up with Sale’s preliminary discourse on the Koran, and much of the remainder of the book with his transla- tion. This appeared in 1734, and has stood the winnowing of time remarkably well: The ‘Preliminary Discourse” also has suffered less than almost any other study in comparative re- ligion of an equalage. Sale brought to his work of translation and exposition a remarkable sobriety and diligence, and a spirit quite uncom- mon 150 years ago. Luther’s “Oh, fie, for shame, you horrid devil—you damned Mahomet!” was not then two centuries old, this being a note on a translation of the Koran, a miserable one in Latin, that he came upon in 1540. From Luther to Sale there was but little change, if any. The talk of Behemoths, and beasts, and korahs, and six hundred and sixty-sixes, and the Little Horn of Daniel, had shown hardly any sign of improvement when Sale attained by a magnificent leap to well-nigh the appreciation of Goethe and Carlyle. Mohammed was at least for him no miserable impostor, but a sincere re- former of religion, deserving of a name high and revered among the great religious founders
Page 23
17, 1882 | Au oC, 5 of the world. At points were the ‘ Prelimi- nary Discourse ” of Sale has obviously been cor- rected by more recent studies Mr. Wherry has made the necessary corrections. The translation of Sale, as well as his prelimi- nary discourse, was a remarkable production for the time when it appeared, quite worthy of the generous commendation of Voltaire, though his opinion in the premises was of small account. Its arrangement of the Suras is the orthodox arrangement, whereas the recent translation of Rodwell attempts a chronological order. Both arrangements have their advantages. Mr. Wherry, preparivg a commentary for the use of the missionaries, naturally preferred the or- thodox arrangement. Rodwell’s translation is more exact and has more of verbal felicity, but Mr. Wherry has used it so freely in checking Sale that not much is lost upon this side. Fora translation that gives a better idea than either Sale’s or Rodwell’s of the Koran’s real force and beauty we must betake ourselves to Lane’s ‘ Se- lections.’ Mr. Wherry is a Christian missionary, and has worked with missionary aims, but he is one of the broader-minded of his class. He has been at considerable pains to draw out the testimony of the Koran to the genuineness and credibility of uhe Christian Scriptures; to insist upon the fabricated character of the Koran in con- trast with its claim to supernatural inspi- ration ; to indicate Mobammed’s denial of the doctrines of the ‘‘ Former Scriptures ” while attesting their divinity; and to reprobate his appeals to Heaven in sanction of his personal immorality. There is something over * vigo- rous and rigorous” in Mr. Wherry’s putting of these things; but, on the other hand, he is careful to correct many of the grosser misrepresentations and misapprehensions of the Christian world concerning Mohammed and his religion, Many of his own notes are a real addition to those of Sale, but the value of bis commentary depends less on these than on his citations from the best Moslem com- mentators and the ablest European scholars in elucidation of the text. The notes from Muir and Néldeke are always able and instructive. Mr. R. Bosworth Smith’s ‘Mohammed and Mo- hammedanism’ is quoted in a manner more re- spectful than its trivial and bumptious character would seem to warrant. Another volume will be necessary for the completion of the transla- tion and the commentary. William Penn (1644-1718). By R. J. Burdette: {Lives of American Worthies.] Henry Holt & Co. 1882, THE work: before us marks a very decided de- parture from the ordinary methods of biogra- phical and historical criticism. It 1s a difficult task for any but the most rigidly conscientious writer to execute a comic biography which shal} do adequate justice to the merits of the character he designs to present, so easy is it, under the disguise of a joke, to portray the most disin- terested and high-minded actions in such a man- ner as sorely to mislead the uninformed. Mr, Burdette appears to have been particularly sedu- lous to avoid this danger. He has endeavored, as far as possible, to be perfectiy fair, and fre- quently at the close of some humorous or exag- gerated account of events he has a serious para- graph by way of rectification. His closing eulogy of Penn is flattering enough to satisfy the great Quaker’s most ardent admirer : “Tp an age of bitter persecution and unbridled wickedness he never wronged his conscience. A favored member of a court where statesmanship was intrigue and trickery, where the highest morality was corruption, and whose austerity was venality, he never stained his hands with a bribe, Living under a Government at war with 4 The Nation. the people, and educated in a school that taught the doctrine of passive obedience, his life-long dream was of popular government, of a state where the people ruled.” But Mr. Burdette has by no means wholly escaped the quicksands of comic biography. The effort to present in a humorous guise Penn’s final reception of his religious faith, his diplo- matic mission to Holland, his prolonged resi- dence in England, his assumed tenacity of self- interest, and his anxiety for “* quit rents,” has resulted, as such efforts are very likely to result, in somewhat distorting the real facts of the case. At one place the author says of Penn: ‘‘ His faculty of self-interest was well developed,” but forgets at the same time to give due prominence to the fact that Penn refused the offer of the Assembly of 1683 to grant him “an impost on certain imports and exports”; and also that, in after-life, when oppressed with financial burdens and despoiled of many of his rights by his de- linquent colonists, he steadfastly declined to consider his manifest advantage, by selling the province to the Crown, without the strongest guarantees that the liberties he had granted to the people of Pennsylvania should be preserved intact. Our author also attributes the attitude of the early Pennsylvanians regarding ‘ quit- rents ” to the fact that their proprietor stood to them in the relation of a feudal lord. It is possible that such was the true cause, but it seems hardly likely when we inquire what ground they had for withholding supplies, and allowing the Proprietary to maintain, at his private ex- pense, the Government by which they profited somuch. The early settlers not only never paid Penn his ‘“ quit-rents,” but the Assembly only voted supplies on one or two occasions. They even refused a grant to defray his expenses to England, when he was obliged to return to the mother country to represent their interests be- fore the House of Lords. Logan’s view of the case, that their conduct was due to an excess of freedom, is the more probable one. In a letter to Penn, the Secretary says: ‘‘ There are few that think it apy sin to haul what they can from thee.” Mr. Burdette has, upon the whole, displayed fidelity to bistorical facts. He has drawn his materials largely from the works of Dixon and Janney. His aim has not been to add anything substantially new to our knowledge of the sub- ject, but simply to set forth in a comical way the somewhat prosaic items of history. His sketch of the pamphleteering energies of religious controversialists of the seventeenth century is very amusing. American Game-Bird Shooting. By John Mor- timer Murphy. Illustrated. Orange J udd Co. A PARAGRAPH of the publishers’ circular which accompanies Mr. Murphy’s work claims preémi- nence for him as a sportsman on the following grounds : “* Having served in the artillery, when only a mere lad, during the War, and subse- quently acted as Assistant Adjutant-General of the State of Oregon, he has a complete know- ledge of ordnance, and this and his varied expe- riences in field sports have made him a clever ‘all-round sportsman.’” It would be most de- sirable if the majority of those who use a sport- ing gun were made to go through a similar course of training. What with the casualties of war and the dangers attendant on an Assistant Adjutant-Generalship of Oregon and the care of its ordnance, the chances of the survival of even an ‘all-round sportsman” would be pleasantly slim. Mr. Murphy has not emerged from so bitter an apprenticeship entirely unscathed, as is demonstrated by the fact that he has written a book on ‘ American Game-Bird Shooting.’ it is but just to concede that to one class of 143 readers this book cannot fail to prove attractive. Those youths about to become the possessors of, or who already own, their first shotgun, will ac cord it a warm and gracious welcome. To them the facts the author gives will prove both in- structive and entertaining ; to the sportsman he imparts no information which has not been al ready given much more agreeably over and over again. What the effect of Mr. Murphy's success as an author will be,in the way of encourage ment, upon his successors to the Assistant Adju- tant-Generalship of Oregon and the “all-round sportsmen ” of that State, is a question to which the boldest man will shrink from hazarding a reply. Essays on the Floating-Matter of the Air, in relation to Putrefaction and Infection. By John Tyndall, F.R.S. D. Appleton & Co. 1882, As all the essays contained in this volume have already been before the public for several years, it is only necessary to call attention to their publication in book form. No better book can be placed in the bands of a student about to en gage in the study of the question of spontaneous generation and the germ theory of disease. The care and ingenuity displayed in peforming the experiments, and the power of close reasoning shown in the discussion of their results, entitle the book to be regarded as a model of its class. Now that the recent researches of Koch upon tubercu losis have justified the hope that we are upon the threshold of important discoveries in regard to the connection of low organisms with the pro duction of disease, it is of vital importance that the minds of all who are engaged in the research should be imbued with the spirit of fairness and the love of truth which are so conspicuous in the writings of Dr. Tyndall. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. 13th ed, Brockhaus’ Conversations-Lexikon. Parts 28 30. New York: L. W. Schmidt. Collot’s French Dialogues and Phrases.—Interlinear French Reader.—French Anecdotes and Questions, Levizac’s French Grammar and Exercises.—Pronowne ing French Reader. Five volumes. Philadelphia: T. Ellwood Zell. Daugé, H. A Fair Philosopher. Co. > Encyclopedia Britannica. Vols. 1.-xiv. edition. Charles Scribner's Sons. Gereke, Dr. H. Das Sffentliche Schulwesen der Stadt. New York: E. Steiger. 30 cents. Griswold, W. M. Autoren- und Sachregister der Deufsch en Rundschau (vols, .-xxix). Bangor, Me. : Q. P. Index. Hackettg¥. W. The Geneva Award Acts, with Notes, and References to Decisions of the Court of Commis sioners of Alabama Claims. Boston: Little, Brown George W. Harlan & Subscription & Co. Hennell, Sara S. Comparative Ethics. I. Moral Stand point. London: Triibner & Co. - Hollister, G. H. Kinley Hollow. Henry Holt & Co. 8&1. Hubbard’s Guide to Moosehead Lake and Northern Maine. Boston: A. Williams & Co. $1 50 Locke, D. R. Nasby in Exile; or, Six Months ef Travel in England. Ireland, etc. Illustrated. Toledo: Lock: Publishing Co. ; New York: C. T. Dillingham. $3 50). Lombard, J. K. Gleanings. G. P. Putnam's Sons, 50c. Longley, F. Eclectic Manual of Phonography. Cincin nati: Kobert Clarke & Co. 75 cents. : Miller, J. B. Das englische Recht und das romische Kecht. New York: E. Steiger. 50 cents. Murphy, J. M. American Game Bird Shooting. Orange Judd Co. 2. Reiss, W., and Stiibel, A. Necropolis of Ancon, in Peru. Dodd, Mead & Co. 87 00. é Russell, W. C. My Watch Below ; or, Yarns Spun when Off Duty. Harper's Franklin Square Library. 20 cts. Short, J.T. Ohio: a Sketch of Industrial Progress. Columbus: A. H. Smythe, Stebbins, Sarah Bridges. The Annals of a Baby. Phila delphia: T. B. Peterson & Bros. $1 Stirling, M.C. The Minister’s Son. square Library. 20 cents. z : Treat, Mary. Injurious Insects of the Farm and Garden. Orange Judd Co, 4 Vaihinger, Prof. H. Keinen Vernunft. "Harper's Franklin Commentar zu Kant’s Kritik der Vol. i, Part 2. Stuttgart : W. Spe- mann. ‘ Walcott, C. F. History of the Twenty-first Regiment Massachusetts Volunteers, 1861-65. Boston: Hough ton, MiMliin & Co. $4. Westcott, B. F., and Hort, F.J. A. The New Testament in the Original Greek. Introduction by Dr. Schaff. arper & Bros. ; Whitehead, Celia B. What's the Matter? W. B. Smith & Co. % cents. Whitman, W. Leaves of Grass. Philadelpbia: Rees, Welsh & Co. $2. e . Yonge, Charlotte M. Unknown to History. Harper's Franklin Square Library. 20 cents. . at: Young Disciple: a Novel. W. B. Smith & Co. $1 25. Zi Prof. O. Handbuch der theologischen Wissca- ay Vol. i, Past 1. Nérdlingen: C. H. Beck ; New York: B. Westermann & Co. Zola, E. The Mysteries of Marseilles. Philadelphia: T. B. Peterson & Bros. 75 cents.
Page 24
144 “Kinley [lollow 7 F yuile above the line of t inary novel. lo the merits upon which x | specially re- marked, the skilful and effecti delineation of 1 past and gone socicty, the 4 ation of old fashions of thou fp At, nia thi fail i ful veprest ie fation of types of character 7 ) had much to : ith making N E-neland what it is—tt dds the further ex Ne of vacious dia- weuc, which serves really to illustrate the speak- , and a strong feeling for ¢ beauties of nature.”-—-TRIBUNE. l6mo (Leisure-Hour Series), $1. » > RECEN1 LEISt RE-Hot R Books. l6mo, $1. THE REVOLT OF MAN. By Walter Besant. DEMOCRACY. THE FRERES. Al .
‘k, make a specialty of fu dwellings 4 churches with G FIXTURES adapted . style and finish to the architecture and inte- ior decoration.
“T*“HE HYGEIA HOTEL, Old Point Com- fort, Va., situated 100 yards from Fort Monroe. Open all the year. Equal to hotel in the United States as a Summer Kesort or Cold Weather Sanitarium. Send for cirewar rlescribing hygienic advantages, etc. UMMER BOARD at Amenia Seminary. Grounds of unsurpassed beauty. New manage- ment. No malaria. Fine drives. Bena for circular to, or ad SECRETARY OF AMENIA SEMINARY, Amenia, Dutchess Co., N. Y. “ QUICK AS A WINK.”—Rockwood’s In- stantaneous Photographs, 17 Union Square, N. Y.