The Nation 1882-06-08: Vol 34 Iss 884

Page 1

The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JUNE 8, 1882. The Week. Mr. FRELINGHUYSEN has taken up the task of abrogating the Clayton-Bulwer treaty, but much more deftly and effectively than Mr. Blaine. The solid and substantial reason which Mr. Frelioghuysen advances for tear- ing up the treaty is that the agreement was made thirty years ago with reference to the construction of a canal by the Nicaragua route; that from that time to this no such canal has ever been built; that consequently the engagements of the treaty cannot be con- sidered of binding force on either party. No such treaty can be expected to remain in force forever unexecuted. After thirty years’ talk about a canal when there is no canal, the con- tinuance of negotiations for a joint or univer- sal protectorate of it seems idle, and a treaty for the purpose gets to be obsolete. Mr. Fre- linghuysen might have made this part of his letter stronger by dwelling less upon the par- ticular route designated by the Clayton-Bul- wer treaty, and more upon the failure to con- struct a canal by anyroute. The article of the treaty which evidently gave him most trouble was the eighth, which declares that the Gov- ernments of the United Siates and Great Bri- tain, ‘‘ having not only desired, in entering into this convention, to accomplish a particular object” (to wit, the Nicaragua canal), but also to establish a gencral principle (that of an international protectorate), ‘‘ hereby agree to extend their protection by treaty stipulations to any other practicable communication, whether by canal or railway, across the isthmus.” It is this provision of the treaty, Mr. Fre- linghuysen says, ‘‘ which has occasioned this correspondence.” It is this provision, at any rate, Which has occasioned the main difficulty in carrying it on. It does undoubtedly show that in 1850 what we meant to do was to secure the canal, by whatever route it might run, by a general guarantee of the maritime powers. But here, again, there is no canal, and no general guarantee by means of addi- tional ‘‘ treaty stipulations ” has been obtained, although Mr. Fish, only five years ago, made an attempt to carry out this branch of the treaty. The more Mr. Frelinghuysen’s despatch is examined the more clearly will it appear that the gist of his objections to the treaty is that it is a dead letter, owing to the fact that nothing has been done under it, and might as well be treated as such by both Governments. The various other arguments advanced by him do not strengthen his position, but give an opportunity for ingenious counter-arguments, which of course will be beside the point, but for which there was no necessity for making an opening. He says, for instance, that the treaty is ‘‘of course voidable at the pl of the United States,” because Great Britain has been violating it by extending her “‘sovereignty” in Central America. He says that ‘‘ the impression prevails that since the conclusion of the treaty of 1850 the English inhabitants of that district have spread into the territory of the neighboring republics, and now occupy a large area of land which, under the convention, belongs to one or the other of the two republics, but over which the Government of Her Majesty assumes to exercise control. Such dominion seems to be inconsistent with that provision of the treaty which prohibits the exercise of dominion by Great Britain over any part of Central Ameri- ca.” This is a strong point, although not abso- lutely necessary to the argument. If Great Britain is actually doing anything of the kind, she is not merely violating the Clayton-Bulwer treaty, but she is violating the Monroe doc- trine, which, according to Mr. Frelinghuysen’s own definition of it, ‘‘at least opposes any intervention by European nations in the poli- tical affairs of American republics.” But, as we have already said, the gist of his objections is that the treaty is obsolete. If we desire to withdraw from it, there is no rea- son why we should not, and Mr. Frelinghuy- sen’s despatch extricates the Government from the awkward position in which Mr. Blaine placed it perhaps as well as could be expected. We have been hoping for some days to see, in the columns of the Herald and Sun, something in the nature of a handsome apolo- gy to Mr. Lowell for the reproaches they have been heaping upon him for what they were pleased to term his ‘‘ignorance”’ in asking his Government for instructions as to the length of residence in his native country necessary to exhaust the American citizenship of a natu- ralized citizen. A correspondent of the Nation showed last week, in a very neat way, that the rumpus over this was all due to the ignorance of Mr. Lowell’s assailants of the his- tory of the expatriation question here, and thus the apology to him became at once due—that is to say, on Friday last. The Sun does not make this apology to Mr. Lowell, but tries to excuse itself by saying that what our correspon- dent showed the other day was simply that the several members of General Grant’s Cabinet had expressed the opinion ‘‘ that a renewal of residence by a naturalized citizen in his mother country should effect a renunciation of his ac- quired citizenship here.” ‘‘ But our Govern- ment,” adds the Swn, ‘in its treaties with Great Britain, has never recognized any such view, and this Mr. Lowell ought to have known with- out making any inquiry of the Secretary of State on the subject.” Error and injustice again, Es- teemed Contemporary. The question on which the members of Grant’s Cabinet expressed opinions was not whether the renewal of resi- dence, etc., should ‘‘ effect a renunciation of citizenship,” but whether it should not be considered by this Government a release from the duty of giving its protection through the Army and Navy, and this question does not need a treaty for its decision. Great Britain bas nothing to do with its decision. It lies wholly within the discretion of this Govern- ment; and when Mr. Lowell asked what view this Government was now taking of its duty in the matter, he made a perfectly proper and sen- sible inquiry. and did not fall into the error ot supposing, like our contemporary, that we bind ourselves by treaty with foreign powers to give a certain amount or kind of protection to our citizens. Wedo nothing of the kind. On the contrary, by such treaty we simply bind foreign powers to respect certain claims of ours, if we choose to make them. So that the apology to Mr. Lowell is still due on this head, and we recommend at the same time au apology also for abusing him for asking for the release of the suspects, on condition that they would come home, this also being perfectly justified by our own precedents. The Western case against Mr. Lowell crows darker every day. He is not only a scholar, a gentleman, and a man of civil demeanor in the transaction of business, who wears his trowsers outside his boots, but he has, accord ing to the Dubuque J/erald, become “liable to severe punishment, under Section 200 of the United States Revised Statutes,” which provides that naturalized citizens shall re- ceive the same protection as native-born citi- zens, and ‘“‘ provides for the punishment of any man guilty of collusion with a foreign government.” ‘‘ The statute,” says the Du- buque publicist, ‘‘renders Lowell liable under this charge to a tine of $5,000 and imprison- ment for three years,” which, it justly observes, ‘‘is not a very agreeable thing to face.” It only remains now, apparently, for the East to ask that in bringing him home for trial proper re- gard be paid to his age and to the position he has occupied in the United States service, and that he be allowed a cabin to himself, and be spared the indigmity of irons, and that the goodness of his clothes, and general neatness of appearance, and his familiarity with Eng- lish literature, be not used to prejudice his case under the statute. Many of the qualities, it must be remembered, which most damage him in Western eyes are congenital, and it would, therefore, be very un-American to pun- ish him for them, or allow them to aggravate his punishment, in case he is found guilty of a violation of Section 200. During the week the specie movement be- tween the United States and foreign countries was unimportant, but at the close the indica- tions were that some gold might be shipped for Italian account, particularly as under the recent law the Treasury will pay out fine gold bars on even terms for gold coin, and these bars are in London worth more than the coin. The crops have been the uppermost subject in Wall Strect and mercantile cir- cles, as on them to a large extent depend the profits of the railroads and the condition of business for the coming year. The weather has thus far not been favorable for corn, The winter-wheat crop, however, is well assured, and it is not venturesome to say that in quan- tity and quality it-will exceed that of last year. It now looks as if the spring-wheat crop would be no larger than last year. The cxtensive strikes in the ‘ron trade, the causes of which ; ee ox! on Fi ae | 4 AO on sbi wn Ris Ea — conte cee tren apne escrito ~ Fite y hah, Pe See ee st cs Ty ots ss

Page 2

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 3

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 4

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 5

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 6

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 7

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 8

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 9

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 10

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 11

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 12

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 13

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 14

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 15

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 16

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 17

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 18

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 19

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 20

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 21

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.