The Nation 1880-11-04: Vol 31 Iss 801
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
The THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 4, The Week. B Raesneconniefn election, so far as the result is known at the present writing, gives General Garfield 21 o’7 dS 1880 VORA, NEW 9 electoral votes and General Han- cock the remaining 150, a majority sufficiently decisive, of course, to re- move any anxiety about the official count. This estimate gives Han- cock, besides the 138 votes of the Southern States, the 9 of New Jersey and the 3 of Nevada. With these exceptions the line is exactly drawn between North and South, and Nevada is not yet conceded by the Republicans. In New Jersey, too, the Democratic majority is but a fraction of that in 1876, and the Republicans claim the Governor and State ticket, and joint ballot. New York is the surprise of the day, the Republican majority undoubtedly have a substantial legislative majority on being about 25,000, apparently, and due not to the State so much as to Democratic losses in this and in Kings County, Hancock's majority in them being some 20,000 below Tilden’s. The majority in Ohio is largely increased over that of October. Indiana remains about the same, and Maine has been “redeemed.” New Hampshire was comparatively close, and for a time Oregon was doubtful. The Democratic majority in Delaware was but 1,000 odd. In Virginia the Readjusters are badly beaten, and have either lost their negro allies or “ traded ’’ Hancock for Congressmen. In Tennessee, where the situation was somewhat simi- lar, a Republican governor is probably elected ; and the Hancock elec- toral ticket seems to have had a close shave in North Carolina. estimates for the next Congress are various. The The Republicans certainly have the House, however, and gain Senators from Indiana, New Jersey, Connecticut, New York, and Pennsylvania; if they retain the disputed seat from Nevada they will, with General,Arthur’s vote, have a ma- The de- feat of Mr. Chittenden, in Brooklyn, is noteworthy and a misfortune. jority, though at present Fair seems to have the best chance. Mr. Hewitt has a very large, and Mr. Morton a sufficient, majority in the Tenth and Eleventh New York districts respectively. Grace is elect- ed mayor of New York, but by a significantly small margin, and Truax is defeated for Justice of the Superior Court. The result is, apart from its effect on the policy of the Government, gratifying in several ways. It promises to make the White House, during the next four years, as during the past four, the resort of good company—that is, of reputable and intelligent men—and to keep it clear of the class to which the Shepherds, Macdonalds, Joyces, Babcocks, and the like belonged. It proves, too, that there is no need strong at the head of the that equipped lawyer can carry as many States as are necessary to oI “a man” Government, and well- give him the Presidency without dispute, and that the best way of preventing the Democrats from making a fraudulent count is to put up a man who will get large majorities, and not a man who will make a close run and then offer to fight anybody who doubts his election. We see our esteemed and sorrowful and great- ly-mistaken contemporary, the Wor/d, thinks Garfield in 1880 means Grant in 1884. General Garfield’s edection certainly means nothing of the kind. Whether his Administration will prepare the way for Grant in 1884 depends very much on the part the select body known as “the Grant crowd ” plays in it. If it should be a pure and efficient Ad- ministration, and receive as such the steady support of “the crowd ” in question, and they should successfully conceal their natural propen- sities for four years, it would undoubtedly strengthen them greatly, for the country is very indulgent and oblivious towards them. Should they dominate the Administration, however, with such ease as to make self- restraint and disguise seem unnecessary, the country will be just as sick of them in 1884 as it was in 1876 and 1880, and will show it in the same way. If General Garfield will consider carefully the causes of the Republican defeats between 1870 and 1876, and Tilden’s Northern Nation. } +} ] hhh ' P 2 c 4 ) mf ) }, “ Y y +! nf position of the Administration in 1876, when the Secretary of the Inte- e : . - ] ae hye y } rior Was chairman Of a party committec ind was bus\ hent ge tne devil with fire,” and the President was backing up the Southern carpet- baggers with “troops” and snapping his fingers at the State courts, and generally seeing to it that the wicked Democrats got the worst of it. The fact is, that now that our elections are getting to be very close, and that disputed counts are becoming common, it is very desirable that both the chief executive officer of the Government and his le | adviser, the Attorney-General, should keep out of the fray, so ut, if there should be a quarrel over the returns, they can exert whatever au- thority in the matter constitutionally belongs to them rather as by- standers than as participants. The solid business men have held several meetings in Wall Street during the week, but the Republican rally Thursday was undoubtedly the most imposing as well as of the most unquestioned commercial cha- The orator of the day was Col. Ingersoll, who made a most The and serious contingent racter. itness of his selection to address eftiective speech after his kind. the sober-minded has bec n criticised in Demo- serve ; but it is <a Hi ; : : cratic quarters with customary fiippancy, we ol plain, of course, that it is not such persons who need conversion to sound prin- ciples, and that the Colonel is admirably adapted to cheer and animate A more noteworthy consideration is, ty for h oking of these on those who are already with him. perhaps, the toleration shown by pillars of soci is abandoned the ologic il views, or possibly we should Say the overlk We should not have to go b ick many years to find a state of feeling far more alive account of his eminent services. very to the interests of theology than to the success of political parties, and insisting on the close connection between the two. As it is, only the HW’or/d is sensitive enough on this score to display the intolerance indicated in its remark that “the only financier who addressed the otherwise highly respect- able, if not very intelligent, Garfield business meeting in Wall Street yesterday was Col. Bob Ingersoll.” This Mr. Beecher, we notice, does not feel in this way, and is the cynicism of Bour- bon orthodoxy.
Page 2
endorses I for the « 1 } only perhaps, but cordiall Ina \ 1) ecept ul tation to preside at ( t cleat t between occasions ( ( ! Tl IS He me, he Ss, to t n reed. “If it would promote the ( e, I\ ide at twenty meetings with twenty Robert Inger- to speal he sures the ex-sheriff, and concludes: ‘“ Do what 1 think best about it, and I will be obedient.” Accordingly, the two oke together in Brooklyn Friday night, but whether they will be in ch close sympathy again until the next Presidential canvass it is a ate matter to predict. Che judicial enquiry into the genuineness of the so-called “‘ Chinese letter’ of General Garfield to “H. L. Morey” has occupied the week past without being concluded, so far as the guilt of the person accused } he letter and its of concocting it is concerned; but the pro luction of t envelope in court betrayed at once the tampering to which the latter had been subjected, and settled the character of this disgraceful politi- cal manceuvre. The alleged forger is an English Bohemian who writes for the “ story-papers,”” and who confessedly wrote the editorial articles defending the genuineness of the letter in the underground journal which first published it. No account has been offered of the source from which the precious document was obtained, nor any explanation of Morey’s” inaccessibility; while the most respectable testimony has been given to show that he is a myth, along with the “ Employers’ Union” of Lynn. The extensive use made of the forgery has, perhaps, justified the Republican managers in attaching so much importance to Idition to General Garfield’s repudiation of it; but it its disproof in ad was highly unfortunate that the last hours of a canvass not remarkable n for the clash of principles should be taken up with so contemptible a incident. Moreover, the cunning of the parties implicated enabled them to entrap Mr. Jewell, who very unwisely sought to get a retraction from them, into actually bespeaking of Mr. Garfield a political reward for the lawyer who served as the medium of communication, and was made to appear to have been successful in his mission. Mr. John M. Forbes, whose address to young voters we noticed last week, says in party as to the use by the Administration of the money and services of : } it that “there is a division among the Republican office-holders,” while there is no such division among the Democrats. It would, perhaps, be more correct to say that the proportion of Repub- licans opposed to such use is greater than the proportion of Democrats, because there are undoubtedly a large number of the best Democrats opposed to it. But when Mr. Forbes goes on to say that only “a cer- tain small use of both” has been made by the Republicans in this cam- paign, we are sure he greatly underestimate We believe as much use has been made of both as the Democrats could or would make were they in power. As much money certainly has been asked of the oth the agg fully e We have whos ce-holders, wh sa laries Mr. Forbes estimates at $24,000,000 in regate. If they paid what they have been asked for, it has jualled in amount their direct taxation, both State and Federal. seen a printed circular demanding $17 from a poor letter-car- s only $800, and another since the Indiana election ! rier, salary wa demanding one per cent. of salary from everybox We do not believe t the ever, because one result of Mr. Hayes’s attempt at reform has been to managers have got nearly as much money as they demanded, how- infuse a little courage into the poor clerks. It is a shameful business The reco; i one party, and that the income of the Government employees, which is throughout nition it involves that the revenue belongs to unquestionably the property of poor and hardworked men, is taxable by arty committees at discretion, is a national disgrace—a disgrace to our politics, our morals, and our religion, and a greater disgrace to the Repu! ins, for obvious reasons, than it would be to the Democrats. \ir. Forbes complains that we did him injustice in our remarks on last week in ascribing to him the opinion that the Treasury | Number 80 1 a thousand way Mr. would be used, in case the South got into power, “it Forbe S'S eX “ There thousand ways in which the Tre isury can be used for their [the Sout] for the exclusive benefit of the Southern States. words were (we did not profess to quote him textually): ern States’| benefit, after throwir ount the danger of ve 2 out of act tious and unjust taxes.” The construction we put on this was that Mr Forbes did not mean partial taxation ; he must have meant direct votes of money to be spent in some way at the South, or, in other words roughly speaking, for the exclusive benefit of the South, although, of course, strictly speaking, what benefits one part of the country in som g, degree benefits all parts of the country. But if money spent in th: South benefited other parts of the country much or directly, the advent If, on the other hand, it only benefited the North slightly or indirectly, as it of the South to power would not on this score be at all dangerous. would benefit Canada or England, it seems hardly too strong to describe But Mr. Forbes explains that he meant simply to express his belief that “ the Southern oligarchy the benefit to the South as exclusive benefit. would get more than their share of the public-improvement fund, and, what is worse, would throw their weight in favor of a system of public im- provements by the nation [which he considers a dangerous and injudi- cious system], and thus involve us in large national expenditure ever) where, of which the South, needing outside help, would get more th its share, while paying less than its share of the taxes.” To this we repiy, first, that the West and every part of the country in which capital Every Congressman tries to get mon he least is scarce do this very thing. out of the Treasury every year for his “ deestrict,” without t reference to its share of the taxes. Secondly, that we do not see h Mr. Forbes reconciles the doctrine that the National Government should into account the amount of revenue col- } Ke in making improvements ta lected at the Jocus zx gio with the doctrine There is in this, it seems to us,a strong flavor of State sovereignty. A nation measures the public bounty by the need calities, and not by the amount it gets out of them. If this is a nation, the poverty of the South constitutes the strongest possible claim for If a confederacy, grants ought only to be made in propor- tion to receipts. ; that this is a Vad/ona Government. s of assistance. Mr. Edward Atkinson, of Boston, made a speech at Atlanta, G a fortnight ago, in the Senate chamber, the most prominent Stat officials being present. After giving the audience a most dismal plain-spoken sketch of their own condition under slavery, he among other things, that his own observations told him that “the pro- gress of the colored people of the Atlantic States is one of the mat This, however, cannot be true, if we are to be- of economic history.” lieve Mr. Sherman’s and Mr. Dawes’s account of the negro in th States, neither of whom, it must be admitted, has made any observatio1 on the matter at all. Mr. Atkinson also put in a good or a bad word for the carpet-baggers by alleging that the majority of the white men in th: carpet-bag legislatures which piled up the large State debts after the war, were natives. This, however, is not saying much for them, for, if we remember rightly, there were at one time only six whites in the South Carolina Legislature. The worst carpet-baggers were not in the legis- latures, but devoted themselves to “manipulating,” “ mind-poisoning, Mr. Atkinson, whose ad and bond-peddling outside. dress was main! devoted to the methods of cotton culture and manufacture, also enforced ‘ in some very vigorous language the necessity to material prosperity o! letting every man who came amongst them say his say without let 01 hindrance, and invited them, if they wanted to “ jaw back,” to come up to New England and “ search out its weak places.” The hardened an: diabolical crowd, instead of precipitating themselves on the speaker with pistols and bludgeons, according to their nature as described by “stati correspondents,” only laughed and cheered. He told a good story of an old colored man at Columbia, S. C., who accounted for the over- throw of the Chamberlain Government by saying that the reason was “dat you can’t put ig’nance ober intelligence and make it stay.” The 7%mes has not learned caution since its hasty adoption, through its Washington correspondent, of Marshal Fitzsimmons’s account of the
Page 3
Nov. 4, 1880] cause of his “ persecution” in Georgia. On Saturday it devoted the better part of a column to a despatch from the same quarter on behalf of “a persecuted freedman,” by name Samuel Perry, who a year ago was a prominent leader in the negro exodus from North Carolina to In- diana. Extradition papers were served on Perry last week in the Dis- trict to answer a charge of forging a school certificate in his native State, and Judge Cartter declined to go behind them, after ascertaining their regularity. Perry was accordingly remanded, but Judge Wylie here interposed by a writ of habeas corpus, and the case comes up for decision to-morrow. In the meantime the attempt to excite Northern sympathy is made by alleging that the real object of the “ kidnapping” is to punish Perry for his part in the exodus, and the 77mes lends its columns for that purpose, as well, perhaps, as for campaign effect. Now, it clearly appeared from the testimony last winter before the Voorhees Committee that Perry, with one or two associates, “‘ worked up’ the emigration ” (we quote the 77zmes’s report of January 25) on business principles, receiving a drawback of one dollar per adult passenger over the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad, and tifty cents for each child or half- fare, and that his choice of Indiana over Kansas, the original destination, He admitted on the stand that the circulars which he distributed were extravagant, and was determined by the profits of this arrangement. he gave the impression of being entirely open to mercenary motives. It was shown that he had suddenly left North Carolina in October on account of this charge of forgery, and he has stayed away ever since. In short, there is no reason for suspecting that he is the object of perse- cution, or for proclaiming in advance of his trial that he is innocent of the alleged offence. The three weeks’ session of the Episcopal General Convention in this city was remarkable for the complete disappearance of the vexed questions of ritual, liturgy, and doctrine that have agitated the discus- sions of its recent predecessors. The High-Church faction made no trouble, being probably perfectly content to be let alone, and the tena- city with which it clings to its beliefs and practices has become so noto- rious that the other parties have undoubtedly come to the conclusion that there is nothing to be gained by stirring it up. The Low-Church- men as such had very little to say, and since the secession of the “ Cheneyites ” it is perhaps noticeable that they have not. The with- drawal of the Reformers, indeed, may be said to have had an amelior- ating effect in several ways upon the general body. ‘Their success, ex- cept in attaining the rewards of conscience, has not been brilliant enough to attract large accessions from the Low-Church party, and yet it has probably made ecclesiastical trials such as that of the Rev. Dr. Tyng, jr., more unlikely than ever. It is clear that the councils of the Church are dominated now mainly by those who call themselves “ con- servative churchmen,” and by those who sympathize nearly with the English Broad-Church spirit, the number of whom-is evidently increas- ing every year. As to liturgy, the changes proposed in the Convention were very mild compared with the dogmatic changes formerly dis- cussed ; they concerned modifying the Lectionary, adding a phrase to the Litany, and a petition for extempore prayers from the pulpit on cer- tain occasions and under specified conditions. ried, The first only was car- On the other hand, distinctly moral and religious matters were debated with fervor, and various measures taken to forward the strictly evangelical work of the Church. If this has fallen behind that of other denominations heretofore it has perhaps been due to the subordination of the characteristics of the Convention just closed to what the laic mind is apt to regard as technical questions. ~ Colonel Higginson has answered, in the Iieman's Fournal, our re- quest that he would discuss Gail Hamilton’s defence of the “ Ladies’ Deposit” swindle in Boston in its bearing on the expectation that the entrance of women into the political arena would exert a purifying in- fluence on politics. The answer is that the purifying influence argu- ment “has now been so generally abandoned or subordinated that we need no further sins or follies of women to point the moral.” It was Theodore Parker, he says, who started it, “but the whole tendency of later years has been to abandon it and rest the movement on firmer The Nation. 31'7 grounds.” The object of the woman's suffrage movement now, it ap- pears, is not “to purify politics, but to establish justice.” This may be the doctrine preached on Colonel Higginson’s side of the I ortan’s Journal, but we fear he cannot read the writings of the other contri- butors with care or he would meet frequent insiances of the use by them of the In the very number in which his alter pointing out that the Nason purification argument. article appears, “ H. B. B.,” i ‘has been betrayed by its prejudices into a still lower depth of idiocy” than the Cengregatfonalist, maintains that Gail Hamilton's performance does not shake the purification argument, because she is an opponent of female suffrage and stands alone in defending the swindle, while fifty-seven other women, eminent in literature and journalism, advocate He also calls attention to the fact that the great majority of criminals are men, and that only five woman suffrage and deplore the swindle. per cent. of the convicts for swindling are women. It seems, there- fore, that the purification argument is not so completely abandoned as Colonel Higginson supposes. “H. B. B.” does not seem to understand fully Gail Hamilt tion. Ons Posi- Whether she advocates woman suffrage ge or not has nothing to do with her attitude towards the swindle. She is at any rate a prominent female political writer, and she has done what we maintain no male writer of any prominence has ever dared do, in publicly defending a swin- dle by which she was profiting, and asking the person who had exposed it This did it, or when to give his note of hand for the amoumt she lost by the exposure. } mie makes her position unique. Nobody, the week before s she was abusing the civil-service reformers in the newspapers and writ- ing books on woman's domestic wrongs, suspected for a moment that her mind worked in this way. Her performance, therefore, has spread alarm through the community about the other female lecturers and es- sayists. Men are asking whether any of the female contributors to the Woman's Fournal may not any day advocate something which would break up the framework of society. But Hamilton seemed as sound about swindles as any of them. one short month ago Gail In fact, men’s great objection to the entrance of the female mind into politics is drawn from a suspicion of its unsteadiness on matters fn which the feelings could by any possibility be enlisted, and this objection draws support from a flagrant example of unsteadiness and obtuseness on the part not of an ordinary woman but a prominent “ woman of intellect.” It may be that it is unjust to keep women out of politics because they are unsteady, but to a great many men this consideration is a very powerful one; they prefer safety to abstract justice. They maintain that states were not built up and are not maintained by absolute equality of rights and duties, but by shrewdness and patience and good sense; and, in fact, talk about the whole thing in a most provoking and idiotic way. It was for the benefit of these absurd creatures that we desired to have the subject discussed. The foreign specie imports during the week amounted to $3,404,089, 753355 The rates for foreign exchange at the close of the week did not warrant further imports. The New York banks, notwithstand- ing the heavy receipts of foreign coin and the Treasury disbursements, barely mainta making the total receipts of the year $49,944,917, against $59, last year, ined their surplus reserve of something over $3,500,000. At the Stock Exchange prices continued to advance in anticipation of General Gar- field’s election. Business in all departments was dull during the week. The purchase of railroad securities since the October elections, on the theory that they decided the Presidential contest, ad- vanced during October the prices of the active stocks at the Stock Exchange from 5! 3 to 23 points, the percentage in some stocks being nearly 50 per | Whether General Garfield’s election has been * discounted ” remains to be seen. In London, British consols have ad- cent. United States bonds there have been steady, but American railroad securities The price of silver bullion in London has dropped to 5124. to §1’gd@. per ounce; and the bullion value here of 1as fallen to less than 8615 cents. vanced to 99% and 99°%,, the highest price for a long time. have generally advanced. the “ buzzard dollar" } aad
Page 4
‘The WHA iit OUTH HAD BETTI DO OVW > 3 I t | ( i ( t ( port e€ bot ritsell and for try If Hancock be ¢ ted it will be largely due to the t the North Ss not elle d Repul ican predictior of t ( cy of the South in Democratic council If, in « f his ‘ there is n that the Sout! is disposed to use the Govern- nent its own especial benefit, the reaction at the North against the Democrats will btedly ( itself in a very marked way at the ext r } el on, and General Hancock will ss his term as on al In a hope s contest with a hostile Cong 5 It is un- ubtedly t disgust d alarm inspired by the absorption of the De- mocratic majority dul r the last four vears in | slation (whether ] tifiabl or not) for the Southern benefit which has been gradually irittering that mayority away, ind ¢i ing the Republicans once more the power the | under General Grant, and has enabled the old to out of their retirement and swagger once more in the t ol If, on the other h 7. |e Id be elected nd the South nm ats il ce with the Democrats, it will, of « e, mean th ( | exclusion of all Southern whites of character and ability from al hare in the administration of the G rnment d the exclusion of Southern opinion from all influence on public policy. The South- ern y about finance, taxation, foreign affairs, Indian affairs, civil- vice reform, and a host of other matters which are sure to come to th front before long, will count for as little during the next four years as it has during the past fifteen. In other words, the Government will be carried on still longer with an almost cultivated indifference to the opinions of three-fourths of the population of sixteen States, inc luding the bulk of the property-holders. This is a most unfortunate situation, not Is there no remedy for it? for the South only but for the whole country. like our correspondent in Memphis, Tenn., whose letter we print elsewhere, Many Southerners—perhaps we should say most Southerners— seem disposed to give way to despair, and to treat Northern hatred of the South not onlv as fact, but as one of the forces of American i I the removal or modification of permanent politics, against whi politics, again 1 there is no use in struggling, and ust be left to Providence. The in the New York 7rzhune ; ‘storation to influence of Logan, Conkling, and Blaine, which m sale of the Tourgee books; the chang whose South ; inion of any man of the charge that he sympa- composed exclusively of hatred of the re taken by General Hancock's supporters i under Southern influence, t Northern di Now, we cdo not rat he would if chosen President be en proofs, tl like of the South need to disclaim on the part of the Na¢zon any sympathy with the attitude of the extreme or stalwart Re | ublicans towards the South We have on this point eX- pressed ourselves with sufficient explicitness during the past ten years. We believe the division between the North and South to be in large part due to the efforts of Republican, politicians to maintain at the South a black party for the sake of the aid it would or might give them ‘ederal politic 3, and without the sl ohte st re eard to the mischief it Chis policy has now, in our opinion, been delil 1865, and has, of course, had to be supported by vituperation of the Southern whites, and “stories,” some true and some false, and might work in State politics. pursued with more or less eration ever since some distorted and exaggerated, of their turbulence and cruelty. But after granting this, and granting too all the assertions made in our correspondent’s letter, there remains for tl South the exce eding| practic il question: What is to be done out it? It is foolish to maintain, even if Northern hatred of the All that we said last character of political motives and conditions is just as true of the North as of the the mass of the Northern people to maintain indefinitely towards the South of 1870, than it is for the South to rds the North. In fact, the South exists, that it is universal and ineradicable. week of the changeable South. It is no more possible for the temper of 1861 or maintain iis temper of those years tow North is a far more mobile ind changeful society than the South; it has far less time for hatred, or revenge, or malice, or for brooding over N ation.
[ Number 80; The Northern air is too full of hone to indulge in much reflection on the rascality of enemi \ rt So that while it is undoubtedly tru larg f Ne n voters, especially of the older generati carried on t r, cheri distrust of the South asa sort of duty 1d approaches outra tories with a reverence and credy tULY t ‘i a vCl Ce al The requ 1 } : ee oo. | 1} } on : | > } } which might almost be called religious, it 1S also true thatal rge increasing body, especially of the younger generation, is thoroug the Southern question in all its aspects, and sick of the | which Republican politicians have put it. This was sho very distinctly by the overthrow of the n Grant school of politician 4 and 1876, by the declining S 87 I / , } influence of the “bloody shirt ” in elec- tions, ind by the defeat of the third-term sch« me, which rested laree ly the assumption that the South was still a public enemy. Now, the problem before the South of dealing with this Northern re- sentment and prejudice and of overcoming it, and of securing a share in the conduct of the Government, was a thoroug! ly practi al « It was made clear very soon after the war was over that-the Democ: party at the North was too weak both in numbers, in intelligence, in 1 press an | in wealth, to make it possible for the South to secure rest: Pie tion tl rough alli nce with it. It, moreover, ve ry soon became app i vy as early as 1872—that the Democratic party was too much dis- credited by its connection with slavery and secession to make it possi- ble for it even to “turn over a new leaf,” by taking up with strange can- and new-fangled doctrines. It has been shown again and ag didate that when the North was fairly roused it would not submit to Demy cratic rule, and that the enable the party to overcome this repugnance. Southern alliance was not strong enough to l nder the Be 4 ire - stances, putting all sentiment aside and looking at the situation wit the eye of the practical politician who seeks place and power solely, it
It might have sought to profit by the dissensions which as early as 1870 beg seems to us as if the course of the South was plain enough. to show themselves in the Republican party. It ought to have held to the younger generation of Republicans, who remembered little of t! war and were every year taking a more active part in affairs, some induce- ment to break loose from the party yoke and attempt some new political combination. It ought to have actively furnished those Republi who were tired of the “ bloody shirt ” with arguments in support of position that the Southern men were occupied with better things cheating negroes out of their votes, and that their co-operation w: be valuable in the settlement of the economical and administra questions which, since 1873, have had so much importance for whole country. It ought to have held out a hand, in short, to t! Republican civil-service reformers, tariff reformers, railroad reforn ‘ and others who were seriously interested in questions affecting the enti! 7 er than any one part of it. In nation rat! this way it would ha and the forma- take part promoted the disintegration of the Republican party, tion of some new organization in which the South could without loss of self-respect, and find some relief from that contemp! tion of “old unhappy far-off things ” into which men whose hopes h: been crushed are so apt to fall, but which is sure ruin for any school of politicians. Unhappily, the South did not see fit to follow this course or a1 thing like it. It has been prominent and influential in Congress sinc 1876, and used its prominence and influence, with curious obtusen Democrats to engage in legislation intended, as every in helping the one knew, for the benefit of the South exclusively, which was su revive Northern irritability, and which dealt with grievances nothing but Northern irritability kept alive. It offered no help or en- couragement to those Republicans, like ourselves, who were trying to Noth came from any Southern politician calculated to quicken the pulses ol the younger Republicans with any fresh or generous emotion, 0! When the time came, too, abate Northern prejudice and hopelessness about the South. any expectation of a better political day. for the friends of civil and constitutional government at the Nort to make a fight against the coarse and shabby Czsarism which was concealed under the third-term scheme, and against the permanent lodgment of military ideas and methods in American polity, there cam« from the South no word of encouragement or sympathy that we hav« ever heard of. On the contrary, as soon as the Republican Convention
Page 5
Nov. 4, 1880] bad nominated a man who, whatever his faults, was an experienced civilian, the Southerners joined the Democrats in setting up for the hiehest office in the Government a mere soldier, who owed a// his fame his success in killing Southerners in a civil war. It must be admit- { that this is a somewhat disheartening story. We can tell it with the better grace because we are among the number of those who be- lieve in the reality of Southern grievances, and also in the reality of Southern progress. But there is certainly nothing in the course of the South in Federal politics since es war to remind us of the skill with which Southern politicians for so many years ruled the North in defence of slavery. They fear and hate the Republican party, but do not see that it is at any time in their power to convert the Republican party into something very different from what it is, and to compel the Logans, Blaines, and Conklings either to give up abuse of the South, or go into ODs¢ urity. THE “OUTRAGES” IN THE IRISH TROUBLI present agitation in Ireland, horrible as of its features FINI are, has not been in vain. sequence of it received through the English press a more thorough dis- some The Irish land question has in con- cussion than ever before, and there are, apparently, few if any Liberals ho d now that it differs from the English who deny land question, and that the ideas of the great bulk of the Irish people about land tenures are entitled to recognition in legislation, even if they seem strange and re- pulsive to the English mind. It seems to have been at last made clear to that (in Irish matters, at least) not very receptive organ that the ct that the English landlord makes all the improvements on a farm § | before letting it, and keeps the fences and buildings in repair, while the Irish landlord does nothing but furnish the land, constitutes a very marked difference between the land systems of the two countries. It established by all but conclusive evidence that it is cus- their manner has also been for Irish landlords to raise rents on account of improvements made by the tenant, in a tomary, or at all events very common, which amounts to confiscation of the tenant’s property; also that in all those districts and on those estates in which the tenant’s property in his improvements is recognized as a salable interest, under the name of “tenant right utmost content and good feeling be- tween landlord and tenant prevail, and there is now no disturbance. Also that the arbitrary ” or good-will, the government of estates by rules which aim at controlling the tenant’s way of living, and keeping him in social subjec- tion to the landlord er his agent, which has been in vogue over most ol Ireland for two hundred years, no matter what justification, or seeming justification, may be found for it in the faults of the tenantry, is no The isolation of Ireland from the rest of the world, which so long helped to maintain this system, has passed away. longer possible in our time and must be given up. The influence of the Irish in this coun- try on manners and ideas at home has become very great, and it is, of course, hostile in the highest degree to the social system which the existing land tenure supports. The opinion of the whole of too, may be said to be running strongly Europe, against the deduction from contract of any relation but a commercial one, and to make the mainte- nance of any feudal view of the landowner’s function increasingly difti- cult. Lord Lymington has written an interesting article in the last number of the Nineteenth Century, giving an account of the system in- troduced by his grandfather, Lord Portsmouth, of Wexford sixty years ago, and still in force, in which the absolute in- dependence of the tenant as long as he pays his rent is a leading feature. on estates in the county He may farm well or ill, just as he pleases, and live and labor in all respects according to his own ideas, and if he wishes to dispose of his interest in the farm, which is always a thirty-one years’ lease, he is welcome to do so, to the highest bidder. The practical result of this system is that, on the whole, the tenants, feeling that they are working for themselves, farm well, even if not up to the landlord’s standard. But he is abundantly repaid for the surrender of his right of interference by the peace, content, and prosperity which reign on his estates, An ejectment for non-payment of rent hardly ever occurs, and even when it does occur the tenant is allowed to sell his same, but what he receives of course goes to pay his debts, the arrears of rent among the number, interest all the The Nation. 319 Undoubtedly this discussi not | useful to the Ministry Parliament when they attempt to t e land question next ye as it would have been if there had been no outrages; but, on the ot hand, there is much reason to fear that without the outrages the dis sion would not have been so thoroug! One of the great difficulties with which England has had to contend of late years in the govert nt f Ireland lies in tien different rhetorical standards of the two countries The Englishman of to-day distrusts everybody who uses extravagant language, and pays no attention to him. The Irishman, on the othe hand, feels that high coloring is necessary to make ary impression all, but has had abundant experience of the failure of his eloquence to bring Englishmen to any adequate sense of his wrong Phe result is a constant temptation to supplement the speeches with crime, and - fortunately this does undoubtedly impress the Eng | Chey are not moved by the hyperboles and picturesque s \ cn Irish grievances are usually dressed up, but murder son t understand and are roused by. There was much n y trut Mr. Gladstone’s admission, which made so much uproar last vear, t it was the attempt to blow up the Clerkenwell prison which led in rectly to the passage of the Land Act of 1870 and t of the Irish Church. It was a truth, too, of which there are several other trations, ¢ tholic Emancipation was not accorded until the « try Was on verge of civil war, and the same thing mav be said of 1 lition of the tithes. O'Connell sternly repressed “ outrages dl « ‘ violence during the Repeal agitation, but he accomplishe is not wonderful that with these examples befor é e ] should believe that the only way to obtain a settlement of question, which in one form or another has now been px Y nearly two hundred years, is to strike terror. Turbulence and viol have led to the righting of some Irish wrongs Such is the lesson with which the history « S ¢ trv { ( century has furnished the Irish peasant, anc is not surpt that he acts on it. Even in the days before the Catholics peared « { scene at all, the Protestant colonists were obliged to seek theit sla- tive independence by embodying a large armed force, and threat the Engiish Government when it had both a French and an Ameri war on its hands. This unfortunate state of things has been aget vated by the prevailing English ignorance of Iris ory. Irish his- tory is by no means attractive reac \ more sm din m ys repulsive, history no country of the western I to sl It describes no contribution whatever to the stream of European pro- gress. Whatever Irishmen have done for the world either in arts or ims has been done either through England or some other foreign country. The consequence is that the history of the country has had no place in any system of education or cultur As occasionally repro- duced in a form to suit English tastes, by men like Froude, it has presented the Irish people in the guise of a vicious and turbulent trib whom it was the mission of England to thrash into civilization—a view which, ever since the conquest of India made the *imierior races S50 prominent In BNgushn poutics, has cen a peculiarly grateful view which even the most philanthropic and religious Englishmen onl put away from them by a hard struggl It came into play in Irish politics at a most unfortunate period, when the earlier Cromwel- lian theory, that the Irish were a parcel of Popish cut-throats, was fast dying out, and when they were just beginning to display in the freer ai of the present century that remarkable political tenacity which now makes them so troublesome and has raised the Irish There our time than this te to the English legislator, question into the first rank of state problems. is no more strik- No race in stage of deg s, they ing political phenomenon of nacity. Europe has been reduced by conquest to a lower i than the Irish Celts. Nevertheles and conquering people. On the radation poverty have not died out before the contrary, the y’have multi- pi lied enormous ly. Nor have the \ become me rgea Wil th their conquerors or accepted their ideas. On the contrary, they have, generation after generation, opposed a fanatical | resistance to every attempt to absorb them into the British Empire. They have emigrated by millions, and have carried with them everywhere an almost furious sentiment of nationality, although they have never formed Bb a nation, arid a singularly interest in politics, such as has perhaps nowhere been witnessed active
Page 6
among people who have had so little political training, even such as local self rmment gives, and whose reliance on leaders in politics has been » great. If this interest could be in any way made to inure to the benetit of the British I mpire it cannot be denied that it ould prove a new and valuable source of strength. Mr. Gladstone has done more towards this consummation than any other English states- man. If he can make it sure, it will be the greatest achievement of re- 6 cent British history. fie STATE OF PARTIES IN FRANCE. Paris, October 17, 1880. i ine parliamentary session will begin in a few days, and will be a par- ticularly important one, for it is the last of the present Legislature, whose term expires next October at the latest, and very lkely the general elections will take place before that tin Everything will give way to this great preoccupation, for it is impossible to conceal the influence which the future Chamber will have on the destiny of the Republic, and the formation of it gives much uneasine Permit me to undertake a slight sketch of the state of parties on the eve of the opening of Parliament, before the renewal of those ardent struggles which will not fail to break out in a few days. the Besides great divisions between the Right and Left many secondary may be remarked, whose importance ought not to be but by the judged by the echo they obtain in the country. Katl efine their real groups noise they make, ier than tod characterize them in a general way I prefer influence at the present time. Concerning the Right we shall be brief, for that party has but little weight in the Chamber's deliberations. The first reason of this powerlessness is that for the time being, August for the Councils-General, they have I especially since the elections in st all consideration in the coun- They have not recovered from the defeat of the attempt they made 16th of May, The Legitimists, who have just try. on the 1877. Besides this, the Right is greatly divided. celebrated the féte of their king by numerous banquets, at which the Government allowed them free scope, well know- ing their insignificance, cannot pardon the Orleanists, who still sit in the Chamber of Deputies, for having refused to accept the white flag. More- over, the monarchical party have just experienced a great annoyance: of the few generals who belong to them, one, General de Cissey, former president of the ¢ Minister of War in moral order, has just been disgraced in the famous trial about the alleged tbinet Council and 874, in the palmy days of information sent to The entirely exonerated, and it has been proved that General de Cissey took ad- Prussia respecting our plans of military reorganiza- tion, accused was a young Republican officer, but he has been vantage of his position to gratify a shameful passion, not to betray France, but to heap iniquitous favors on a miserable woman who, we have every reason to suppose, was a paid spy. ‘These revelations have produced con- siderable excitement, more particularly as the unfortunate general had ren- dered himself conspicuous by his devoutness. I need not revert to the in- curable divisions of the Bonapartist faction ; they are more and more evident every day. On Sunday, October 17, M. Paul de Cassagnac presided at a large meeting directed against Prince Napoleon. The Right have, however, one chance in their favor—the irritation produced in some parts of the coun- try by those unlucky decrees which are thorns in the side of the Republi They may also become dangerous in Parliament by voting for all the extreme motions of the radical Left, in order to put a spoke in the wheel of the Re- They do all they can to disturb the water in the hope government. publican of making a miraculous haul. The Extreme Left will not be any stronger at the next session, for they They en- by noise, and it may be taken for have made no recruits in the partial elections during the vacation. deavor to compensate for their weakness granted they will make more than ever. They do not speak in the Chamber, but appeal to the country, or rather to the radical masses of our large towns ; Unhappily, the Municipal Council of Paris £ their support is entirely in these. belongs wholly to the Extreme Left, and if it evinces a certain aptitude in dealing with the pecuniary affairs of our large city, it is decidedly intempe- rate in politics and takes pleasure in the most extravagant things, espe- cially in what concerns religion, which it pursues with hatred. It amuses itself by constantly changing the names of the Paris streets, striking out all those which recall old France and its glories or some religious reminiscence, and replacing them by names either obscure, ridiculous, or revolutionary, to the great annoyance of the inhabitants. It has just commenced another of these changes which upset all one’s habits. -The greatest injury to the Ex- treme Left comes from their outside allies, who push extravagance to its utmost limits. I have spoken enough about Rochefort. For the time being he is qui eclipsed by Felix Pyat, one of the proscribed brothers of the Commune, who files down and polishes his writings like an ornamental dagger. This comparison is inevitable, ior he unceasingly preaches assassination in his journal, Za Commune. He has opened a subscription to present a fancy
The The Nation.
{| Number 8o ving attempted to assassinate 1867. The dagger to Berezovski, now a convict, for h: the Czar at the Universal this Exhibition of Government has d cided to prose ute shameless def ndet of regi ide. While acknow. ledging that Felix Pyat far surpasses the party designated as the Ex. treme Left, we can but observe that the Extreme Left have too mu affinity with the advanced radical parties, as seen by the excuses for t} Commune published in their newspapers. The Left, properly speaking, is divided into Left Centre, Left ‘‘ sazs phrases,” and the ‘* Union Reépubli- caine,” the group long directed by M. Gambetta, who is the axis of the ma- jority. The old Thiersists have united themselves with the Left, and are kk remarked than the Republican Union, which is, upon the whole, moderate in everything concerning social questions, opposed to socialistic chimeras, but very ardent in the contest against clericalism. On this point it is not possib! to effect a compromise with them. At the present time no influence equals M. Gambetta’s with the Republican Union. One of the reasons, however, which prevent him from at once taking office is that this majority is not easy to discipline, and Gambetta does not think he should have sufficient supp rt from them to be able to give a firm, well-prosecuted direction to politics. He attributes this instability or incoherence to the manner of recruiting the Chamber, which is elected by district ballot, thus making the deputies sub- ject to local influences on which their fate depends. The important side in poli- Gam- betta earnestly desires to have all the deputies of a department voted { He hopes that a Ch ber so constituted would better obey the inspirations of a leader and would tics being often effaced by the petty preoccupations of class prejudices on a general ticket in place of the district ballot. You know tl een introduced in the Chamber. conform more easily to a grand, united political programme, a proposition of this kind has already | The most serious discussions of the coming session will be on this subj Gambetta has against him all the Extreme Left, who fear nothing so mu to means. see his influence increase, and they desire to ruin him by every po Iie has against him the electoral interests of the present deputic who would find it very convenient to preserve their districts. They have made their beds with great care and would like to lie down in them instea of being exposed to the risk of a larger election, which would make them lose the advantages of their local influence, maintained with so much labo: Gambetta will have to descend from the presidential chair and throw the weight of his eloquence into the scale. I do not doubt that he would be victorious, for he would employ all his tact, skill, and energy to win this great political game, on which, according to him, all his future depends. No doubt, if he succeeds, he will not hesitaté to take office at the opening of 1) new Parliament, and then will be the time for him to show what he is statesman in power, whether he can contain factions at home and reassure Europe in his foreign policy. It would be very desirable for the present Ministry to remain in office until the next elections, It is favorably regarded in Europe. Its chief, M. Jules Ferry, is a clever, energetic, eloquent man. It cannot be denied, however, that this minister, like his predecessors, will at the mercy of a defeat from the majority in a Chamber, both unstable ar Let us hope he will avoid these dangers and be able to preside over the formation of a new impassioned, where he is not recognized as the veritable leader. Chamber. With respect to the Senate, we may be sure they will support the present Ministry., The attempt which was made to suppress it met with no response in the country. When you receive this letter the last session of the existing Chamber will be about to commence, and we shall soon learn whether my surmises will be realized. i. THE ‘ DEMONSTRATION” AGAINST TURKEY. PARIS, October 14, 1880. . i doors of the temple of Janus have been half opened, but they are suddenly shut again. ‘The demonstration made against Dulcigno ended in a total failure. ‘The Montenegrins were not willing to attack the little fortified town, defended as it was by the Albanians and by the regulars o! Riza Pasha. ‘The ‘‘ Prince of the Mountain,” as Prince Nicholas of Monte- negro is called, had often said that every one of his mountaineers, that the children even, and the women, were ready to fight at all times against th Turk; but when the allied fleet was before Dulcigno the mountaincer showed as much prudence and discretion as if they had been born in th flattest plains. Prince Nicholas asked Admiral Seymour to land some trooj and to give the signal of attack against Dulcigno. The signal was not give and could not be given. <A landing of troops was not in the programme o! Meanwhile the weather became bad on the coast oi ‘ the Adriatic, and the fleet had to return to the Bocche di Cattaro. Not a shot had been fired on the Albanian coast, and the demonstration h: the ‘‘ demonstration.” demonstrated nothing except the impotence of the allied Powers. The Porte had sent a note to the great Powers, in which she explained that she would only give up Dulcigno if all idea of an armed demonstration She pronounced herself ready in that case to make proposi tions concerning the new Greek frontier and the reforms in Armenia, in the was abandoned. Nation. [Number &. + ORS EATERS HE wth; SE SSS
Page 7
ae a eae a “poh Nov. 4, 1880] course of time. This note was considered as insolent in the last degree, especially as the last Conference at Berlin ha tlement of the Greek frontier. I of veosraphers and oflicers of the staff, had drawn a line to the north of ly said that she could nly adopt 1 had no other object than the : All the western diplomats, with the help | i Land Metsovo, and the Porte now quiet o the south of these two cities. In fact, this note of the Sultan’s, in iunction with the resistance of Dulcigno, seemed like a gauntlet flung boldly down to the western Powers. War became almost imminent, and the u idenness of the peril caused great consternation in all Europe. People began to ask themselves who could be the inspirer of the Sultan, for they could not believe that, left to himself, he would have been so imprudent 1 as to defy all Europe. The advantage of a sudden crisis consists in dispel- ling in an instant the diplomatic fogs which at first surround every ques- It soon became apparent that the common understanding, and the common action which had begun with the demonstration against Dulcigno, really covered two opinions, two policies—I might almost say two virtual lliances. On one side stood Prussia and Austria, on the other England, ance, and Russia. By a strange combination of circumstances, England, I ; LR By trang I f t England ia in the East, who had fought for the integrity of the Ottoman Empire, was now in the front of the battle, more who had always opposed the plans of Ru ardent than Russia against the Turks. She seemed to resent the insult of Dul lied fleet. An English admiral had commanded the igno more than anybody else. g Mr. Gla termined to execute the will of Europe, to give that shock to the glass of istone, who had taken the place of the Tories, was de- the Ottoman Empire which must bring about a fracture on the line which had been marked by the diplomatic diamond at Berlin. ‘ There is not much dot t that at the outset England prepared herself for mergency. Many measures were discussed which were of a very vio- lent character; but could England enter alone upon the terrible future— No, she was morally sure of the sympathies of Russia if once she began war against Tur- ‘‘dans le sombre avenir,” to use the words of an old poet? key ; she knew that the frontier between Bulgaria and Rumelia, which was of her own making, was merely artificial ; she knew that the Russian armies would easily cross again the Danube and the Balkans. But she was more anxious to have French co-operation than Russian, ‘The English Govern- ment, or at least some members of this Government, entertained the hope that France, after ten years of rest, with magnificent finances, with a large army, would like, perhaps, to try her growing strength, and to try it with a sufficient degree of safety, with the powerful alliance of England and Russia, The temptation was undoubtedly great for a French statesman; he would 70 that in 1880 have been a bold prophet who should have predicted in 18 France could again take the lead in Europe, and would have on her side the moral and material forces not only of England but of Russia. Mr. Glad- Forster, Sir Charles Dilke, and others thought that if Napole III. had found it to his advantage to enter into a close alliance with Englan stone, Mr. yn the young French Republic would perhaps promise herself the benefits which the second French Empire reaped from this alliance. There have been un- doubtedly some men in France in high places who, moved by the most patri- otic motives, have hesitated, have thought that they had better not reject the The words of the Cherbourg speech had not been without an echo in many hearts, in the army forces which Providence placed at the disposal of France. and out of the army. the desires, the designs, the aspirations of the most active minds to be satis- But the general state of public opinion has not allowed fied. France had been carefully taught by the press for ten years that she must ‘‘se recueillir,” remain alone, shut up in a determined policy of peace and of non-intervention ; she had been taught to mistrust @// foreign powers ; she had been told repeatedly that England and Russia and Italy had no pity for her misfortunes, that her blood was no longer to be shed ‘for an idea,” ‘ that there was no “ question” for her except the question of Alsace-Lorraine. The lessons had gone all the deeper into all hearts because the memories of the late war were still vivid, and because the sufferings of the invasion were remembered in every village, in every city, in every household. France did not much mind the congresses and conferences to which her ambassadors were sent, as it were, ‘ ‘en parade”; she did not believe that anything serious could come of it. As soon as Eastern affairs seemed to involve our responsi- bility there was a universal protest ; the papers of all shades, of all opinions “e became pacific ‘‘ with a vengeance.” There was but one important paper, the République Frangaise—which is supposed to be inspired by the President of the Chamber of Deputies—that advocated the continuance of a common action with England ; and even this paper dared not show distinctly whither this common action might lead the country. The English Government exercised a strong pressure upon those whom it supposed capable of affecting the public mind in France; the incense which was once burnt for Napoleon III., when he could lead with one word the armies of France, was all ready to burn for those who should help England strike a heavy blow in the East. England would not believe that it was not in the power of the Presi- dent of the French Republic to declare war in the absence of the Chambers ; the French diplomats in vain assured her that there was an Article g in one ak , —- — we | a The Nation. 33°21 of our constitutional laws which said that the President can only declare war with the formal assent of the two Chambers. Tlie English ministers wished to see the text of the Constitution ; and, strangely « gh, the English bassador in Paris could not procure it Che fact t] it d not exist i the form of a book or a little pamphlet ; there were a few copies of the « stitutional laws printed for the National. Assembly at Versailles in 1875, a1 they were only given to the deputies. Since that time no bookseller had ; y§ | the idea of reprinting the collection of laws which form our Cor u f the use of the public. There were, only a few days ago, still two « ents in the} ent ¢ € : : a few of its members, who receive more directly the inspirations of the Pre dent of the Chamber of Deputies, would probably not have been unwi try a policy of intervention in the East; but the majority of the ¢ drawing their inspiration from public opinion at large, took such a ] f titude that it soon became evident that all idea of an active policy must abandoned. ‘The French ambassador in on informed Mr. Gladstone's Government last Saturday that France w 1 in no der occupation in the East, either at Smyrna or elsewhere Phis step seemed almost natural, as the news had just arrived that the Sultan, havir uccess- fully resisted the armed menaces of Europe, was now willing to surt Dulcigno to the Montenegrins. Whoever advised the t ( stance gate him very good advice. By surrendering Dulcigno after the de. parture of the allied fleet the Sultan shows some deferens for tl Will of europe, and at a small price places himself in a ] tion which will « him to be much more free with regard to the pretensions of the Greek It unties the two Montenegrin and Greek questions ; the first may | ww « sidered as solved; and Europe has not cut such a good figure in her last ‘*demonstration ”’ that she will be very anxious to ** demonstrate in for the Greeks. Europe was brought face to face with the fearful w! were hidden under the ‘‘common action”; the goddess Bellona showed het profile only, and it was found that nobody was very willing to follow he: I‘rance will sink again into a policy of non-intervention, but she will be still more careful not to tie her hands even diplomatically. Ra 1 will have learned that she has not much to expect from distant western es, and she will fall back on the old policy which led to the partition of Poland, Ger- many, without moving, without effort, has been the real arbiter in the late events ; she has taken the Sultan under her dangerous protection, she has ol tained from him the surrender of Dulcigno, and she will probably be called upon to fix the new frontier of Greece, by a sort of arbitration which nobody in Europe will be willing « le to d Correspondence. THE ‘* RESTORATION” OF ST. MARK’S 70 THE Epiror oF THE NATION Sik: In response to the appeal in your columns for the St. Mark's Pre- servation Society, I should like to say that owing to the agitation made over the so-called demolition last winter I went to Venice and carefully examined with the architect the plans and the work done and to be done, and can as- sure your readers and the ad s of the great Basilica that they may save their money for better uses, as nothing has been done or is contemplated to be 1 4) done at Venice which the ruinous state of the h does not make impera- : 1] *? ) net a} ¢ , , , ‘ . ‘ tive, if the walls are not to fail into \ most of the agitate rs seem to fancy With one to be the proper state of an old church—viz., a picturesque ruin, single modification, in which a return was made from a sixteenth-century vul- garism to the original plan, the original design has been carefully retained in every detail, and as far as possible the al stone put back into the origi- e , : : ie nal position, but in some cases the marble veneer has been absolutely dissolved away by the elements or decomposed into chalky rubbish. In every case } where a stone, column or slab, cornice or casing could be returned to its place it, it has f and of carved work of none has been lost. Some parts of the facade brick-work underneath so split and disintegrated, that the facing is only kept 1 : been cone, even by turn any kind almost are now so decayed, and the in its place by timbers and iron bars, which disfigure the church more than , and unless the foundations are strengthened the west facade men- ig and falling apart. It may not be realized by the ‘‘ pre rvers t a > of St. Mark’s that the whole edifice is slowly sinking into the mud on which it is built, but sinking unequally, so that in one case a pier has gone down twenty-two centimetres, owing to the entirely inadequate foundation on which the church was built originally. One door-way is now, but for the struts and bars that keep it up, in utter ruin and must be taken down soon er it will fall of itself, and other parts will be taken down and reconstructed on new bricl work as soon as necessity arises, but no sooner The whole body of the building is brick-work, and the brick very poor and soft, while in the laying of it sticks were put in to strengthen temporarily the work, bufggeg@imese are now only ashes and dust they leave the masonry very weak - wwe
Page 8
‘The Pail not } ve er h « } t cases 1 uite crut I y I l ‘ hich re erence i pal - t i ! ‘ | ! ! t Nn itain the | ill | but that it will not (to please painters ' ! Id architecture, the mtore decaved the better, to restored) ed t ( lire ] ture uc t the ex] e of its architectural keep- ba d pr ! 1 whol The great outcry had its origin in total ( I tw pro] ( to be « me, of what needed to be done, and t had al ly done- foolish scare by some one who had een the crumbling to pieces, and, like Henny Penny, on whose tail the sky f went about alarming the world with cries that the cathedral was being demolished. A more senseless and gratuitous excitement was never got up by e, and lo he church is under the care of the present architect, Meduna, we need have no fear that harm will be done for want of reverence of it or wanton reconstructio1 Yours truly, W. J. STILLMAN. Fi t E, October 18 MATTERS IN VIRGINIA. fo THE Epiror oF THE NATION: ° Sir: The conflict in Virginia between the old *‘ Conservative” party and the new party under General Mahone must be peculiarly interesting to a student of history. He sees a phase of affairs which has occurred many times in the past, and recognizes an epoch in the progress of ideas, limited though it may seem in comparison with some others. It is, however, far from insignificant, and means nothing less than that revolution which had to come in the South as fulfilment of the work done in the war. t means the downfall of leaders who have not entered into the spirit of modern advance- ments, and have supported them only in so far as they were compelled. It “he means new men and more liberal ideas. ‘The true issue in this, as in all revo- lutions, is almost hidden in talk of temporary questions ; but there are men who see it very clearly, and that the people have a feeling beyond taxes is shown in frequent county resolutions, and in the constant use of the term ‘‘Bourbonism.” But a question so intangible as that implied in this word can- not move the masses, upon whom revolutions depend. The great leaders in the world have not accomplished their work by discussing with their followers inner questions involved wl Mass- leading requires something more definite ; and the pity is that in Virginia, ich could not have been comprehended, just at this time when the masses needed to be led, the requisite definiteness has presented itself in a form so unworthy as the forcible readjustment of the Many do not believe, however, that the creditors of Virginia This can hardly be hoped ; but it is likely that in the with the liberal party in power (as will surely be the case whatever the debt. will be really affected. public Crata tate, result in the present national contest), there will be rapid improvement, ma- terial as well as intellectual, and that whatever readjusting may be done will not be to the extent that the leaders of the old party would have the world believe. Even these, though they cannot understand the real issue, feel that They generally attribute the whole hate as heartily the debt question is not at the bottom. movement to the selfishness of General Mahone, whom they as the Cavaliers did Cromwell. This hatred is more than political: it is the hatred of a party aristocratical in its notions, full of sentimental fogyism, and blind to liberality of thought and speech. Said a Funder the other day to another who jokingly asserted himself a Readjuster: ‘* You for that.” He did not too much of a gentleman for underscore the word, but he could not have expressed more innocently and are briefly the sentiment of his party and the true secret of the whole matter. This is an old war which is going on now in Virginia. D. OCTOBER 30, 188 DO THE NORTHERN PEOPLE HATE’ THE SOUTHERN? fo tHe Epiror oF THE NATION: Sir: The last number of the \a¢ion quotes an extract from Mr. Schurz’s recent speech at the Cooper Union, and recommends it to the careful con- ideration of every Southern voter and politician. The whole force of his utterance depends upon the truth of the assumption that ‘‘the people of the North cherish no ill-will towards them”—7.¢., the Southern people. If the people of the North do cherish ill-will towards them, then Mr. Schurz does not call upon the South to lay aside all sense of grievance which springs from that fact. The people of the North, it is true, may cherish no ill-will to- wards the South, but I affirm, without fear of serious contradiction, that there » not one hundred Southern white men in each Southern State who believe this; and the number I select is not merely for the sake of the conventional comparison. These are a few of the causes which produce this belief : 1 publican party is a representative of Northern principles and inte- In spite of the s its long lease of power to Northern suppori. Nation. {Number 80; fact that a systematic disregard of Southern rights was one of its main fea. t nd in spite of the fact that during eight years, at least, they managed th ff of the Government so inefficiently and dishonestly as to caus these eight years to be a term of reproach in the Nation's vocabulary of poli- es, they finally lost control of power only by an almost impotent majority In spite, also, of the disreputable procedure of the Republican eturning boards and visiting statesmen during the Presidential contest of 1876, they are apparently on the eve of a more overwhelming victory than he war. might be attributed to the ordi. All of this ults of political forces when brought into play. they have gained since t Other points will not admit of this interpretation. The two | 00ks of which more copies have been sold than any others ever The effect of *‘ Uncle Tom’s Cabin’ was but natural, coming as it did at a time whe: known to American booksellers were both directed against the South, The people of the South having finally been brought to a recognition of the hor- the evils it described were still in existence and still needed reform. rors of slavery mainly through the agency of the Republican party, being also thankful that it no longer exists, look upon ‘ Uncle Tom’s Cabin’ as legitimate factor in a beneficent movement. If the prejudice and positiv: the peculiar cause of its origin disappeared, the ‘ Fool’s Errand’ would have been ill-will entertained by the North towards the South had become extinct as read as we now read Longfellow’s tragedy of ‘Giles Corey,’ and certainly } not more widely. But the ‘ Fool’s Errand’ is a book written by an author of wonderful power, and teaching the old lesson of Southern pride, arrogance, brutality, cruelty to the negro, intolerance of free discussion, and hatred ¢ { the North in a manner more artful than it has ever been taught before. Northern dislike of the South, therefore, finds its most exquisite gratification ‘Fool’s Errand’ was writté It is to this fact and expression in the ‘ Fool’s Errand,’ and the fifteen ye that the South attributes the success of the ‘ Fool's Errand.’ Mr. ars after the evils it described had passed away. Schurz says the demonstration of ill-will towards the South on tl! part of Northern politicians is merely stage-thunder. Now, newspapers do not depend for their subscriptions upon Republican politicians. Tix popularity in the main is owing to the fact that they reflect the opinions and The New York 77idune was at on The New York Tribune's position towards the South to-day is too well known to need de- advocate the interests of their readers. time a paper liberal in its treatment of sectional questions, The intensity of its hostile feeling towards the South defies th The Cincin- scription, characterization of the most powerfully descriptive adjectives, nati Gazette is its Western reflection. You say in one of your editorials that politicians like Senators Conkling and Blaine ‘‘manage conventions dextrously, but they do not manage a party so as to give it success at the polls.” The four men who sin the war have been most distinguished for their passionate abuse of the South have been all Senators—Morton, Chandler, Conkling, and Blaine. Two died in office and the other two are universally admitted to b the leaders of the Republican party. These men were elected, not by the people at the polls, amid the excitement and restless turmoil that ever attend a popular election, but by those from whom, if from any body of men, liberality of sentiment was mosi naturally to be expected. Their stage- thunder appears to the South to be more popular than the genuine lightnin, and rain. It cannot be answered that the election of these men was brow about by other causes. They are and were nothing if not vituperative. The Northern press and Northern orators always speak of the advent of Southerners to office as a grandson of Noah might have alluded to anothe: An insinuation by a political opponent that they are ‘‘ playing into As an offset to your quotation from Mr. Schurz’s speech, allow me to offer one from a speech deluge. the hands of Southern rebels” is met with indignant denial. by General Sherman, made a few months ago, in reply to an allegation that ‘* What nonsense !” he exclaimed, ‘*nothing can be more absurd! Why, General Schofield, Colonel Lascelle, and the other heads of the Academy are all Northern men, thoroughly im- West Point was under Southern influence. bued with Northern sentiments, views, and ideas. This charge is like the rest, purely fictitious, and existing only in the fertile imagination of the news- paper writers.” To a Southerner it does not appear that Southern influence at West Point would be a very lamentable national calamity. The South either has or it has not an equal right to take part in the ad- ministration Federal affairs. ‘The North says it has not, and the South attributes this denial to the continued vitality of Northern hatred engendered We have expressly said we accept cheerfully and gladly the ol by the war. freedom of the negro. The right of secession has but one living advocate in the South, named Robert Toombs. Notwithstanding this, we are still rebels, and the most liberal mind in the North cannot contemplate without secret dismay the possibility of the administration of Federal affairs passing into Southern hands. Even those who know the absurdity of the usual charges against thé South regard us as too illiterate to be able to carry on the Govern- ment in a respectable manner. Every Federal office in the South is occupied by a Republican, and in nearly every instance by a Northern Republican.
Page 9
Nov. 4. 1880] udicial positions are invariably filled by Republicans. There is no reason Judicial posi ) b I why Democrats should be selected, but certainly none why Republicans as u h should be, except that Northern sentiment demands and sustains it. The people of the North are sincere in their conviction that these are things | i with which the South has no legitimate concern, 1 You quote from the Suz, a Democratic paper, but less Democratic than Northern. It says—in your extract—that Hancock’s Administration ‘* will be as free from the rule of the rebels as from the rule of the Czar of all the sias. You congratulate the country on the fact that Southern outrag« Rus and the Solid South have been finally consigned to the lumber-room of worn-out political tools. There is surely ground for congratulation, but the satisfac- tion of the South is somewhat dampened by the reflection that the war closed in 1864, virtually, and that this is the year 1880, In addition to this we are not yet prepared to believe that the millennium of political tolerance has come. So sure are Southern Republicans of Northern readiness to believe ill of the South that their speeches are all directed to the one’end of calling forth some expression of indignation, in order to become famous at the North as an ad- ditional martyr in the cause of Southern regeneration. The manifestations of dissatisfaction which appeared throughout the North at the census reports of the increase of Southern population and prosperity were certainly neither noble nor magnanimous. These are only a few of the points which suggest themselves as proof that It would the North does cherish ill-will towards the South. not be diffi- cult for the South to find a philosophical explanation of this hatred—an ex- planation which would please Buckle himself. But the explanation would not lessen the reality of the fact that the North hates the South. The ex- implies a great deal, but not too much when treating of s pression ‘‘ hate ” Northern sentiment towards the South. Mr. Schurz’s statement does very well, as such , but the object of the remark is only to influence Southern ac- tion, and Southern action can only be influenced by conclusive proof that his statement is true. If history proves anything, the history of the last fifteen years proves that the North wishes the negro to rule the South. The negro is the only element of Southern society which would act in unison with the North in those matters where Northern and Southern interests are antago- nistic. ‘There has been no period during the last nineteen years when North- ern troops have not been in Southern States, when the Government has been in the hands of Republicans. This was natural during four years of that time ; it was very unnatural for the following ten. As soon as the Demo- crats came into power the troops were withdrawn, Mr. Hayes withdrew them, but the Democratic party was the cause. They were not withdrawn until a belated Northern sentiment had been partially aroused to the iniquity of Re- publican misrule. ‘Those who had been most disreputabie of all in the States where they had been upheld by the troops immediately went North, and were lionized or were provided with comfortable salaries everywhere except in the North. does not mean a return The South has no assurance that a return of Republicans to power of Northern troops to some Southern States ; at least the two ideas are associated in the mind of the South, in spite of the pooh- poohs of those who send Mr. Hoar, Mr. Conkling, and Mr. Blaine to Wash- ington as Senators. The grievances of the South may be imaginary but the nanimity of belief in the South that they are not imaginary is astounding. The Solid South is an evil, no doubt, as the South is most ready to admit, but the Solid South will end when there has ceased to be what Henry Wat- terson called the Stolid North. as much as the fact is to be regretted, his statement quoted above is an ex- The South can only say to Mr. Schurz that, pression solely of his own generous liberality of mind, and is not an expres- sion of Northern sentiment. MEMPHIS, TENN., Oct. 23, 1880. J—s P—n. EXPLANATION OF J HAD RATHER IDIOMS. GO AND SIMILAR To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: At least five and twenty years have elapsed since I worked out, though with the help of much less evidence than I now possess, the historico- grammatical justification of the expressions referred to; and, in the mean- time, I have looked about me diligently to see whether any one had forestalled me in what I have to say in their defence. done so. I have by me, and intend shortly to print, a brief essay on the phrases in question, the collocations ‘‘ I had rather go,” ‘‘ they had rather be fined than punished,” etc., or, more distinctly, collocations in whigh rather comes between Aad and an infinitive. Besides rather, circumstanced as above, and so circumstanced by rights or otherwise, we find “efer, liefest, as lief, as good, like, better, best, as well, as Soot. Expressions such as ‘‘I have liefer go,” ‘‘ I had liefer go,” are the oldest As far as I am aware, no one has From that essay I here give a few extracts, exclusively relating to ~~ — —_—_— EE - members of the group to which they belong. ‘Their precursors were liefer ‘*me was liefer go,” ‘‘ me were liefer go.” In all these case liefer is an adjective, meanir g ‘‘ preferable’; and me, where it occurs,.1s a dative. Exactly parallel to ‘* I had liefer go” ts ‘1 had rather go.” An elucida- tion of the latter therefore dispenses me from dwelling on the former. In certain constructions, éyéry (in post-classical use), Aadere, avere, haber avoir, and haden, signify ‘‘deem,” ‘‘rate,” “hold,” ‘* re gard,” onside ‘*account,” or the like. In other words, these verbs, « riginally possessive have come to be factitive. To them we are to add our fave. Sir John Fas- tolf wrote, about 1449: ‘‘If the place that is beside Walsyngham stand cleyr, I have hit lever t} en tem I hold it to ] e more de sirable tl} | the te ther. ’ Paston Letters (ed. 1872-1875), vol. i., p. 04. "To be Aad in reverence” and ‘‘ fad in honor” we are familiar with from the Bible; a: uch modes of speech, though slightly quaint, are by no means yet obsolete. Had, as equivalent to ‘‘should have,” ‘** would have,"’ emerged in our language as far back, at least, as the eleventh century. Rather, the c mparative of rathe, ** speedy,” hasty,” ‘‘ early etc., at first had the significations to be expected from those of its positive = speedic e ‘* hastier,”’ *‘ earlier,” ‘* prior,” ‘* former,” “ older That this adjective must, at some time, have denoted ‘‘ preferable,” might almost certainly have been inferred from the adverb rafher, in phraseology such as ‘‘I would have this veather than that,” #.¢., I would have this fre- ferably to that.” And it actually once was a synonym of freferad/e, notwith- standing the silence, on this point, of lexicographers and grammarians. Proofs are subjoined, The first that I shall adduce occurs in an anonymou poem, supposed to date before 1430, found at pp. 86, 87, of A/ymns to the Virgin and Chrisé, etc, (1507): “Tt is rathir to bileeve the wageringe wiinde han the chaungeable world that makith men so blinde.' The second is from Bishop Pecock’s Aefresser, written about 1456 ‘* And, certis, in such aventure, it were va/er to truste to the conscience and discrecion of him which is in state of a reuler, than to the conscience of hem Vol. ii., p. 393. rt to be reulid,” of the welth [7.¢ whiche ben in the state of hem that ben Ihe third is from Lord Berners’s time of Henry VIII.: *‘ For I had that hath maryed my doughter, than of hym that never dyd nothyng for me ¥Ol, be 1812). translation Froissart, executed in the ralhe? -» Welfare] of hym though I have maryed his suster.” $1 (ed. In the anonymous 7 %ersvies, which appeared a few years after Lord Berners’s death in 1532, is the verse : “1 thincke thou haddest rather alyve to be flavne Even in the days of James I., the consciousness that rather meant * pre- ferable”’ lingered on. ‘This signification of the word is pretty plainly recog- ‘* Had tl r s nized by Edward Brerewood (d. 1613), who writes : 1e Apostles rather a man should perish of famine than be releived of his owne? 1 Second Treatise of the Sabbath (1632), p. 17. Had is, with some probability, a strict preterite here ; the sense then being: ‘‘ Did the Aposiles hold it to be better,’ etc ‘*T had rather go,” to be construed ‘‘ I should deem going more eligible,” is, therefore, simply a way that obtained, in older English, of expressing ‘I should think it better that I went,” or ‘* I somewhat prefer to go.” Your obedient servant, FITZEDWARD HALL. MARLESF@RD, Sept. 1, 188 1 on the roth of last June, I quoted, for the In my letter which you printe: intransitive verb claim, nearly two hundred years earlier, wrote : that... this i Ae Ni fi ¢sser vi | a book published in 1648. 7“; But Bishop Pecock, ertis, nO man mai ¢/, schulde needis bitokene 140, word ap graved ymage, CIVIL-SERVICE REFORM PUBLICATION SOCIETY. ITOR THE NATION: As a single one of many cheering signs that, notwithstanding the con- THE E SIR: O} g } Hace aign } > treated civil-ese e refar i the campaign have treated civil-service reform, tempt with which both parties in the importance of the subject is being more and more recognized by earnest and thoughtful people of all classes, will you allow me to mention the fact that at the Michigan State Conference of Unitarian Churches, held in Detroit last week, a paper on civil-service reform was read by Rev. C. G. Howland, of 1 bject—and Kalamazoo—long an earnest advocate of the sul in the subsequent discussion of the paper it came to light that every minister of the Conference was an active friend of the reform. Accordingly the Conference took action Howland to give the paper (which was regarded } (1) to open the way for Mr. as a very able presentation of the subject) as a lecture in as many towns of the State as possible within the next few weeks, and then (2) to publish the same in large quantities for free general distribution as a “a religious tract,”
Page 10
*>.) H i i | . ‘» | 1 : oo Riggs,
gerous missionary field, and will have a certain degree of attraction for the ligious world for its display of Christian faith and courage, especially on re the part of the deceased Mary, the wife of the author. It does not give, o: pretend to give, such a view of the special characteristics of the Indians, and of the considerations bearing on the question of their permanent civilization, as would make the book have any special significance in the discussion of the great Indian question. ‘The Englishman and the Scandinavian,’ by Frederick Metcalfe, M.A. (London: Triibner & Co.), is an attempt to give lively and popular account of the customs, notions, language, and literature
of the Anglo-Saxons and Scandinavians by picking out all the good things If it were intended for scholars, fault might be found with it as not using the latest authorities on various mattgs ; but it is sufficiently accurate and learned fo: its purpose, and may very well be a success. from the original books in both languages and weaving them together. It is disfigured, however, by an unreasonable insistence on the superiority of the Scandinavians, and also by the use of polite slang by way of garnish, as we find it in the mouths of cha- racters in English novels, not heretofore in the historical works of the fellows of Oxford. Dr. A. Rambeau has printed in a separate pamphlet his paper in the Englische Studien on the relation of Chaucer's
‘ House of Fame’ t Dante's ‘ Divina Commedia.’ He has gathered all the parallel passages aml expressions with true German thoroughness; but they do not amount much, after all. However, Dr. Rambeau brings in much general exposition Dr. John Koch, in his ‘ Ausgewahlte kleinere Dichtungen Chaucer's’ (Leipzig : W. Friedrich,
and criticism, and has made an interesting paper of it. “Ral a $s mm . Sa oe
Page 11
Nov. 4, 880] Chaucer’s minor poems, which he thinks are most interesting and suggestive connection with the poet’s character and life. The longest and liveliest is the ‘ Parlament of Foules,” of which Professor Lounsbury lately gave us an excellent edition. The translations are good, The notesare brief and few. (he Introduction, however, contains some interesting attempts to fix the dates other circumstances of the poems.——J. W. Bouton is agent f new Revue des Arts Décoratifs, of which Quantin is the Paris pul s Beaux-Arts. and illustrate the recent exhibition of the The opening numbers lat e The photogravures are admi- in relations with the Union Centrale de criticise it works of the Viollet- le-Duc, among other matters of much interest. Musicians will be delighted to hear that "Breitkopf & Hiir- Liszt’s French and rably executed. tel, of Leipzig, are preparing and letters on musical topics, hitherto scattered throu; sh various a complete edition of Franz articles German periodicals. The first volume, comprising the monograph on Chopin, translated by ‘‘ La Mara,’ other ——Parts 21 of Westermann) conclude the history of the rs are to follow (New or Kugler, and The reproduc- "has just appeared, and four and 22 Oncken’s ‘ Allgemeine Geschichte’ York : Crusades, by Profess begin the history of the Roman Empire, by Professor Hertzberg. illus- trations relating to the siege of Rhodes by the Turks are quaint tions ; those concerning the Roman Empire are fine wood-engravings of well- known scenes and masterpieces of art, introduced by two fragments from the Ath sculptured gigantomachy of the Pergamus altar, showing Athena and Hecate secpectionty | in combat with the giants. thirtieth volume, readers who had eserved the files of the paper urged us to make a comprehensive index to but the task —Long before the Nation reached its pre them. Editorial convenience powerfully seconded this appeal, and meantime the asso- ‘Poole’s Index’ had included the ation up to the present year, giving subject-references to grew more and more formidable while we hesitated, ciated libraries which have undertaken the continuation of select editorial articles and book reviews, and occasionally to the other de- partments of the paper, and affixing, where known, the names of the writers. Che probable date of completion of this international enterprise we cannot indicate, and we should further state that the Na¢ion index will not stand by i.self, but will be confounded topically with that of the several periodicals We have been lately ‘A General Index to the embraced in the scheme. surprised and gratified by re- ceiving advance-sheets of ‘ation—V ols. i.—xxx., July, 1865-Sept., our contributors, who we can only hope will find his account in it beyond the 1880,’ compiled entirely without our knowledge by one of satisfaction which he takes in making our files accessible for those who value them as he does. —This Index will fill about 40 pp. 8vo, in three columns, containing refe- rences not only to articles, but parts of articles, and having this general plan : ‘(1) To place under the name of each author the volume and page on which each of his books has been reviewed ; (2) to place under each subject and sub- We cannot speak of the execution as a whole, having only seen a portion of the subject the volume and page of articles, notes, or reviews relating to it.” press-proofs, but there is clearly no attempt to reach the standard of the ad- vanced index-making of the present day, and cross-references will often have to be imagined by the searcher. For example, under Credit-Aobilier, the references are to the original scandal, and not to the revival of it during the past few months, for which Garfield will probably haye to be consulted. In- consistencies like Aishkulos Athens Crété and C; occur in the of Biografy, Elefants, and Filosofy show the compiler’s predilection for the new orthography, the old. the Index will soon get accustomed to and make allowance for, while divi- sions like America—U. S., Art, Bible, Boston, Catholic Church, China, Copyright, Dante, Education, Houschold, International Law, Politics, Politi- cal Economy, Social Subjects, Trade, etc., reveal the real utility of the work. Without endorsing it, therefore, as the best that could have been done, can heartily recommend it as worth far more than it costs, to nothing of its being the only actual Index, with no great probability of ever having a rival, and Alexander, and prus, treatment Greek names. and Chymistry for But these caprices are the ‘‘ personal equation” which the user of we say Our next issue will probably contain the compiler’s advertisement. und Mr. of Cincinnati, is welcome not only in and for itself but as adding another American publisher to the list of American authors. East- ern examples of sucha conjunction are, if not so numerous as might be desired, still not rare ; and in Cincinnati Mr. scholarship and research and literary aptitude are compatible with success in the manufacture and sale of books. The Ohio pr! Historical Series, which he inspired and supported as long as he was able, is fitly supplemented by Mr. Thomson’s Bibliography, an elegant royal octavo volume of 436 pp., printed on heavy paper, with broad margins and rubrics, in unexceptionable taste. It contains some 1,400 titles, from which the ordinary public docu- ments have been excluded, but among which are recorded all the publications of the State geological surveys and the laws of the Northwestern T —The ‘ Bibliography of the State of Ohio,’ issued by Peter G. Thomson, prepared ; Robert Clarke had already shown that erritories. It ranks ninth in the order of State bibliographies, for only Maine, New | ' The Nation. Hampshire, Vermont, Massachusetts, Rhe de Island, Marvland, and Wisconsin can point to similar undertakings ; in all other respects i perhaps second to none. Mr. Thomson has personally examined nearly eve work on his list, and in the case of the rarer ones he indicat the libra in which they may be found. He appends, wh r \ ] Otes, explanatory a .d critical, and not seldom ‘gossipy, ending with an exhibit of the prices which the work in hand has brought at \ s | l dock literature, with Washington’s Journal; Harrisoniana, which embraces no less than thirteen campaign lives (with Caleb Cushing and Richard Hil h among the writers of them) and nine campaign song-boo besides « sermons, eulogies, etc. ; American, German, and French editions of Hee! welder’s ‘ History, etc., of the Indian Nat s’: the liter re of Svm theory ” of the inner constitution of the globe, which enables Mr. Thomson in a note to describe the theory and sketch the life of its eccent ventor | the ‘ Book of Mormon,’ of which the second edition w lished in Cir nati, are perhaps the salient features of the B phy. Clas like I net’s and Dodd ridk s ‘ Notes, Finley ] if among th l s Cc) Frederick Post’s ‘Second Journal,’ and even Ashe’'s bogus ‘ Travel \ rica’ and Josiah Priest’s ‘American Antiquities,’ of course, are | among the eminent names not already cited we meet with J. Q. Adar Ly. man Beecher, T. Corwin, Michaux and Ratinesque, Paine 1 Volney 1, of an earlier generation, Governor Thomas Pownall. Anappendix of « ! titles, a subject-index, and a list of sales conclu ul con . worthy performance. —We find in the London Athena@um of O 16 a fulle ‘ it we were able to make a fortnight ago, from the Messrs. Harper , concerning the English edition of their J/on¢/ It will | p . this how significant a step towards international copyright, wit! P P vention of any treaty, has been undertaken by this house *“*A European edition of Has S Vagazine isto] ru i r by Messrs. Sampson Low & Co, it he s been through well-know zine, in the course of its sixty volumes, that a of the leading vels of Bulwer, Dickens, Thackeray, George Eliot, and other English writers have been introduced to American readers, and the use of such copyright material has hitherto prevented its sale here. This difficulty it is proposed to obviate by securing the right of serial publication both for Europe 1 America, and Mr. ‘Thomas Hardy is now engaged upon a novel which, with illust iby Mr Du Maurier, will appear exclusively in //arfer’s. It is noteworth t whil English newspapers greatly surpass American in average circulat the D> t > i American illustrated cazines have, on the contrary, larger sales, , ser’ reaching about 140,000, and its younger rival rs, Which has already gained a footing here, about 100,000 monthly, eat outlay on illustra. tions, reaching sometimes a hundred ina num! 1 incur, would evidently be impossible did they not tion The European edition will be partly printed here, the 1 de partments being partially replaced by English.” —We have received a circular from the ‘t Rochester Astronomical So- ciety,” with permission ‘‘to use-in any way most desirable Upon second thoughts, and upon seeing it appear expat ded and with a cut in the idine columns of such papers as the A England urnad Education and the Illustrated Christian Weekly, it “ as seemed that some brief notice would he such ause. It chronicles the facts, among others, that ‘‘the new Warner O} servatory which is being erected at Rochester, N. Y., is tracting much attention in social and liter: as well as scientific circles,’ and that it “has been heavily endowed by My. H. H. Warner, proprietor of the Kidney and Liver Cure and other remedies.”” It is also to be ‘‘the finest private ob- servatory in the world,” and as it is to be ‘‘ specially devoted to discoveries there are good reasons to expect very many scientific revelations in the near Professors Watson and Swift, the intra- future.” latter of whom is to have charge of it, have already ‘*discovered three mercurial planets,” which, con- sidering the endower's ownership of remedies that are safe, suggests nomasia that is execrable, to be sure, but how otherwise to account connection between astronomy and patent medicines it is diificull to see. Does the science of concocting kidney and liver cures depend in some occult way upon astrology, and is it possible that astrology can have been developed anew by the ‘‘ discoveries” of Professor Swift? In any event, it is easy to perceive that Mr. Warner has hit upon an ingenious device in advertising his astronomical appliances instead of his chemical compounds. Notori- ously the ordinary means of familiarizing the public with the virtues of safe stale and monotonous, and such a novelty as thtis can- Whether scientific societies and individuals who de- sire to make use of the discoveries al will be GIsCOVeEeTICsS al cate by taking packages of the patron’s remedies for general distribution and kidney cures have grown not fail to be admired. out to occur obliged to re ipro- personal consumption, does not appear. Possibly the general impression that wn uh finest private observatory in the 1} At any rate, the conjunction aforesaid is odd enough to make a man who is unselfish enough to build the world in the interests of science cannot manufacture deleterious nostrums, is that is sought. us think that educat do so in their advertising columns or make more fuss about it in the interests ional and religious journals which parade it should either of novelty.
Page 12
The Nation. {Number 80; nt meeting of th a rican Oriental Society in this city (Oct. | tragedy, A’erdran has finally determined to break off his engagement with Lu- Il. ‘ Y ty ‘ 4 . > > ’ ,Y YT oe | t , . wer De om 4 } o.° e esp lly inter ng by the presence of Dr. Martin, president | céenze and m ury A/rxe, so that the discovery of her wretched position comes for instruction of Chinese young men in European languages | at what was apparently going to be a happy turn in the tide for her. At one d knowledg t Peking. Dr. Martin made two communications: one on | stroke her whole life is ruined. She discovers that she is illegitimate, that the Chinese worship of ancestors, of which he took a much more favorable | her mother is a faithless wife, and that she is the sister of the woman who ’ han that of most missionaries, asserting that it had done much to save | lover she is taking from her. Such a play could have only one climax—the - aCe lll MiSs . { : ——— si 4 +} on ‘ : . : : es China from idolatry and hierarchical despotism, and that any objectionable | death of the victim; and as emotional drama is nothing if not heartrending element in it might be left to melt out under the influence of an accepted | we are feasted in the fourth act with a sight of the corpse itself. She h Christianity instead of being made by positive attack the strongest obstacle in | drowned herself, and the play fittingly ends with the scene in which her bod the way of Christianity ; and another on new forms of Buddhism in Japan ! is brought into the house of the marquis. The range of emotion in the part | China, in which, especially in the former country, is seen a notable | of Adixe is, of course, very great, and Miss Morris is an actress of such assimilation to Christian doctrine. Prof. 5, Wells Williams, of Yale College, | marked natural powers that she brings out many of the strongest points in read an article on /w-sang, held by many to be a western America known | the play with striking effect. She is, howeyer, to our mind, much better to the Chinese ; he showed by the circumstances of the origin of its description, | fitted for parts requiring stormy and passionate acting than for pathetic scenes and by the surroundings of the latter, that the notion was destitute of any shade | It is difficult to imagine anybody acting A/ixe perfectly. Certainly no Eng. of plausibility. The veteran Egyptologist, Professor Seyflarth, discussed the | lish or American actress could do so, for the whole conception of the cha Miss Morris origin and date of the obelisk now in process of erection on Central Park. He pointed out that its first set u , i inscribed by racter, and one at least of the situations, is pre-eminently Gallic, current connection with Cleopatra is purely fanciful, | is at her best in the scene in which she discovers her mother’s guilt. H efore | bewilderment and horror over this are a good example of her acting at The acting of Mrs. J. J. Prior, who takes the part of Madame Val- The part is one full of difficulties, which Mrs. Prior d regarded it as » by Thothmes III., nearly 1,900 years b Christ, and further Rameses I]., 200 years later, Interesting | best. contributions to Biblical exegesis and Eastern ceremonial were made from the | ey also deserves notice. by Prof. Isaac H. Hall, of Philadelphia. Prof. Whitney, of New I[aven, discussed the methods of transliteration of Sanskrit in use amoung > Syria overcomes with marked ability. Indeed, she makes it almost the principal part of the play. sc lars rit * sign ) ‘on rj ing > ific i hei 5 | ah . : . P . . cholars, with ~ de 1g" of cor tributing —— the unification of their pre- | —The most interesting event of last week’s Italian opera was the repro- sent variety, Mr. Perry, of Columbia College, read extracts from an ex- | duction of ‘‘ Rigoletto,” with Madame Gerster in the cast, who, for the first haustive discussion of the god [ndra as he appears in the Rig-Veda. Further Short and Whitney, time in this country, assumed the part of Gi/da, one of the most interesti Never before h Madame Gerster so fully displayed her splendid dramatic qualities as she did papers were offered by Drs. Ward and Hitbsch, Professors Mr. Rockhill, and others. and effective characters on the Italian operatic stage. —The institution over which Dr. Martin presides is called the Tungwen | © this occasion. Her girlish simplicity in the first act was charming, and College. It issued last year its first printed calendar in Chinese and English. the awaking of her love was beautifully rendered in the famous aria, ‘‘ Caro From this we learn thet, founded in 1861, it now numbers over a hundred | nome,” which she decorated with a wealth of florid ornamentation that was students, with eight European professors, of various nationalities, and one | at times bewildering, while the broader passages were rendered with intense Chinese, besides an auxiliary corps of native instructors. The full course of | fervor and dramatic force. A delightful effect was produced by the artist as instruction is eight years; three are devoted wholly to the acquisition of | she slowly ascended the staircase to her bedroom ; she ended her long scen with a high, sustained note of remarkable clearness and power, which faintly European languages, the remainder to scientific and general studies, followed In the great duo through the medium of those languages, but chiefly of English, for which | died away long after she was out of sight of the audience. alone at present the course is completely organized. The successful students with the baritone in the second act she was equally effective ; but she had re- are placed in the line of official promotion and put to use as interpreters, served the full strength of her dramatic and vocal powers for the famous translators, attaches to legations, and the like. They are supported by Goy- | quartet in the third act, perhaps Verdi’s best piece of work, which wa the crowning point of the evening’s performance. It is needless to speak Rigoletto is one of the most powerful parts of this admirable art- The new tenor, Ravelli, sang the part of the Yue with great brilliancy and animation, and ** Favorita,” with the same cast as last year, with Campanini and Miss Cary in the leading ernment from the start, and begin soon to receive a monthly stipend, which is gradually increased according to progress made. There is a foreign library | of Galassi. of 1,350 volumes, besides text-books and Chinese books, and a printing-office | ist, and he infused it with all his habitual grace and skill. forms part of the establishment. A list is given of works turned into Chinese from western tongues for the use of the college, mostly by its instructors. Mile. Belocca looked exceedingly pretty in her gipsy costume. he institution was founded and is maintained under the enlightened patron- 7 _ . . ° . , a. ' . ha G. . inee aye of Prince Kung, uncle of the boy-emperor. It is, of course, impossible | roles, was given at the Saturday matinée. —The ‘ Proceedings and Transactions of the Manchester Conference of the Library Association of the United Kingdom’ has at last appeared, nearly to tell to what it will lead ; but it is likely to prove an important agency in helping to break down the thick wall of Chinese exclusiveness. a year after the meeting and just in time for the Edinburgh meeting. Ameri- | can librarians had received a foretaste of the contents through an abstract in the fourth volume of the Library Fournal, prepared by Mr. Tedder, who seems to have a special gift in the art of précis writing. The volume is but seems to us to be of less prac- —Miss Clara Morris is, we believe, the only American actress who has After an interval of some years, she is now playing at the Park Theatre several of ever attempted with any success the modern French emotional drama. her best-known parts, including that of Adixe, a role in which she made some sumptuously printed, like its predecessors ; tical interest, a large part of the space being devoted to historical and de- scriptive sketches of the libraries of Lancashire, Cheshire, and Yorkshire. Mr. Parr’s paper on the card-ledger, in which he has re-invented an Ameri- of her earliest successes. The play is one which presents opportunities for Alixe, brought up extraordinarily fine and also extraordinarily bad acting. in the household of the Afarguis de Césaranne, a happy and amiable girl, knowing nothing about her origin except that she is the daughter of Afadame | it a “ , . | can device, Mr. Cotgreave’s on his indicator, and Mr. Walford’s on library- fires are worthy of attention. The paper on the employment of young women shows some advance in English opinion on this subject since the London conference. Mr. Wilson’s ‘ Classification (meaning classed catalogues) in Libraries’ contains many just remarks. The gist of it is that a system of classification shou!d be made to fit the books, and not the books crowded into a preconceived artificial classification. ut the author does not notice that a scheme can be made out beforehand from the books now in the world, as Valory, is in reality the illegitimate child of that lady, who is really the wife of the Count de Somerive. The countess had deserted her husband for the father of Alixe years before, and the husband and wife have never met since. The daughter sees and loves //enri de Kerdran, who is unfortunately be- Lucienne, trothed to Lucienne, the legitimate child of the count and countess. however, knows no more of the previous history of AZadame Vadlory than does The Duc de Mirandol, A/ixe, and imagines her mother dead. a rich man, gifted with a great deal of good feeling, but also afflicted with a considerable share of folly, is in love with Adixe. The Marguis de | ascertained by a careful study of the innumerable catalogues published, and Césaranne and wife, married and happy, are figures in the back- | then applied to any library. Such a scheme, if it contains within itself pro- vision for modification as science progresses, will probably be not only more logical, but more consistent, and therefore more convenient, than one built up day by day, as the author recommends, by the addition of new subjects a ground of the play, serving to lighten its general gloom and _ tragedy. In fact, and it is a curious fact, if these characters and the duke were omitted, as they easily might be, the play, thoroughly modern as it is in feeling, would be almost classical in form: the unities of time, place, and action are | "&W books come into the library. It is obvi- | preserved throughout to an extent very rare in modern tragedy. ous that with such materials as the characters and situation present, abund- ant opportunity for tragedy exists. First, we have the revelation of the mu- tual love of //enri de Aerdran and Alixe, followed closely by the discovery that he is engaged to be married to Laucienne. Upon the heels of this comes the unexpected appearance of the Count de Somerive and the discovery, grad- ual but certain, by déxe of her real history. Meanwhile, to deepen the rmrAnpr —Additional announcements of forthcoming English works include the following books of travel : ‘The Expiring Continent: a Narrative of Travel in Senegambia,’ by A. W. Mitchinson ; ‘Seven Years in South Africa,’ by Dr. Emil Holub ; ‘A Trip up the Niger and Benueh,’ by A. Burdo ; ‘ Inci- dents of a Journey Through Nubia to Darfur,’ by Sidney Ensor, C.F. ; ‘Tent Work in Palestine,’ by Lieut. C. R. Conder ; ‘ Pathways of Palestine,’ by the Rev. H. B. Tristram ; ‘ A Pilgrimage to Nejd,’ by Lady Anne Blunt ; NRT a tian. panne eee oe °
Page 13
Nov. 4, 1880] ‘India in 1880,’ by Sir R. Temple ; ‘ The Irrigation Works of India and their Financial Results,’ by R. B. Buckley; ‘Sketches from Nipal, Histori- cal ‘Voyage of the Vega,’ by A. E. Nordenskidld; ‘Siberia in Europe,’ a naturalist’s visit to the valley of the Petchora, by H. ‘The Gardens of the Sun’ Borneo and the Sulu Archipelago, by I. W. Burbidge ; ‘ New Guinea,’ by L. M. d’Albertis ; ‘ Across Patagonia,’ by Lady Florence Dixie; ‘A Lady’s Tour in Corsica,’ by Gertrude Forde ; | nknown Hungary,’ by Victor ’ * Holland,’ cis; ‘Round about Norway,’ by C. W. Wood; and ‘ Rambles among the and Descriptive es Seebohm ; ‘ Ilios,’ by Dr. H. Schliemann ; mountains, swamps, and forests of
‘issot ; by Edmondo de Ami- Hills in the Peak of Derbyshire,’ by L. J. Jennings. Kindred works to the foregoing are ‘ Coral Lands of the Pacific,’ by H. Stonehewer Cooper ; ‘ In Zululand with the British, throughout the War of 1879,’ by C. L. Norris- Newman ; ‘ With the Kurrum Valley Force in the Cabul Campaign of 1878- =o,’ by Maj. J. A. S. Colquhoun ; ‘ Colonel Gordon in Central Africa, 1874- 79," with a portrait and maps, edited by G. B. Hill; and ‘ Voyages of the Elizabethan Seamen ’—selections from Hakluyt by E. J. Payne. —In biography we observe ‘A Diary Kept while in Office, 1828-30,’ by nd Letters of Lord Chancellor Hardcastle ; ‘ The Personal Life of David Livingstone, from his Unpublished Journals and Correspondence,’ by W. G. Blaikie; ‘ Letters of the late Dr. Thirlwall,’ edited by Deans Stanley and Perowne ; ‘ Memoirs of the Duke of Saldanha’; ‘ Mme. de Staél,’ by A. ‘Jane Austen and her Works,’ by Sarah Tytler; ‘Samuel Pepys and the World he Lived in,’ by Henry B. Wheatley ; ‘ Life of Sir Rowland Hill,’ with a portrait by Paul Rajon ; ‘ Life and Letters of John T. Dela late editor of the 7?mes,’ by Sir G. W. Dasent ; and ‘ Life of Sir Anthony the third and last volume of Col. G. B. Malleson’s admirable ‘ History of the Indian Mutiny
Edward Law, Earl of Ellenborough ; ‘ Life < Campbell,’ edited by his daughter, Mrs. Steven Ne, Panizzi,’ by Louis Fagan. Histories are not numerous : of 1857-59,’ for which, by the way, an analytical index, embracing also Sir J. Kaye’s ‘ History of the Sepoy War,’ has been prepared by F. Pincoit ; a ‘History of Penny Postage,’ by the late Sir R. Hill and his nephew, G. B. Hill; and an ‘ Enquiry into the Origin, Character, and Reform of the Eng- lish Land System,’ by Sir George C. Brodrick. In connection with this last should be mentioned a treatise, by Prof. Richey of the University of Dublin, on the existing legal relations of landlord and tenant in Ireland and the pecu- liar [rish legislation concerning them; and the concluding volumes of the ‘Contemporary History of Affairs in Ireland from 1641 to 1652,’ which in- clude hitherto unpublished letters of Oliver Cromwell. ‘Studies in English Art,’ a second series, by F. Wedmore ; the third edition of Chatto & Jackson’s Arts,’ ‘ Horace’s ( des,’ select English translations, edited by W. —We conclude with some miscellaneous titles : ‘ Treatise on Wood Engraving, Historical and Practical’; ‘ Japanese
by C. Dresser. F. Cooper ; ‘ Studies in Song,’ by A. C. Swinburne ; ‘Songs and Poems from 181g to 1879,’ by J. a ‘Selection of English Sonnets by Living Writers,’ edited by 5. Wadding- R. Planché, edited by his daughter, Mrs. Mackarness ; ’ < » ton; a translation of the ‘ Lusiads’ of Camoéns, by Capt. Richard Burton ; ‘The Lyrical Drama,’ by H. S. Edwards. ‘ The Plants,’ by Charles Darwin, Darwin ; ‘ Prehistoric Eu- by James Geikie ; a ‘ Dictionary of Ethnological and Philological Power of Movement in
assisted by Francis rope,’ Geography,’ by R. G. Latham ; ‘ Factors of the Unsound Mind, with spe- cial reference to the Plea of Insanity in Criminal Cases and the Amendment of the Law,’ by W. A. Guy.——‘ Our Old Country Towns,’ by A. Rimmer, illustrated ; ‘Edinburgh in the Olden Time,’
63 original drawings, 1796- 1828, collected by the Rev. John Sime.——‘ The Letter H, Past, Present, and Future,’ by Alfred Leach. —Curious as the estimate of American literary work by English writers often is, it must yet be admitted that in this respect the palm is rathew due the Germans, with whom it is a common notion that the only living American His works more than fifteen volumes of Reclam’s cheap edition of German and _ for- author of note and originality is Bret Harie. are in all libraries, eign books being devoted to translations of his sketches and novels, while enterprising newspapers, such as the Berlin 7ageddett, make great efforts to secure a new sketch from his pen, which is then announced weeks ahead in large type. Even the great Johannes Scherr, in the brief chapter on Ameri- can writers appended to his admirable ‘ Geschichte der Englischen Literatur, follows the taste of the crowd in so far as to devote almost a page of praise to Cooper, while Hawthorne is no more than mentioned by name, in con- nection with Neal, Kennedy, Willis, and Bird. As Germany has never produced any novelists that compare with the greatest French and Eng it can hardly be expected that the average German should show better taste in matters of fiction than the average Englishman does, say, in musical matters,
But it is somewhat surprising to see the attitude assumed by Spielha- gen, who is by many regarded as the leading German novelist, in the October number of Westermann’s Monatshefte, of which he is an editor, or at least a regular contributor. Under the heading ‘‘ Ein lustiges Buch” he gives a very favorable review of Mark Twain's ‘Tramp Abroad,’ with a tr: ns- ‘The Nation. ‘ lation of the episode of the bluejay. It c icterizes Spielhagen’s se
of humor that he should give the first place ¢ Mark Twain's works to this, his latest, production, which has cert c ributed little to his fame in this country, and of which the second volume is simply wretched, o1 at least silly. Spielhagen says that, with the best intentions, he cannot modify his views of American literature as expressed ten ye wo in th preface to one of his works. An American drama is still a thing of the fu ture ; the lyric poets, Longfellow, Bryant, Stoddard, Taylor, et , paint after European models, and the specific American elements—a tendency to mora and indulge in descriptions—are, according to German esthetic notions, a defect rather than a poetic merit. In our novels all is imitation ex epting a
Of first-rate placed by the side of the first German, E few touches of local color. authors his line, who might be ‘lish, and French He isa there is not on Hawthorne is very much overestimated. ll imitation an
and style is altogether out of the question in his « Pox LW { fiction, of course fares no better. The only greet nch on tl ree American fiction—and that only of the short, sketch bears the 1 of Mark Twain and Bret Harte. Of Howells, Ald 1 W: r Sy hagen appears never to have heard, and Henry James, jr., he probably for an Englishman. All this is certainly very discouraging to hopeful An cans. Apropos of Spielhagen, we may add that his admirers will find ; trait and sketch of him in ord und Sid for October. The mam { the sketch got lost on the way and had to be replaced by ther, w shows that even the well-organized German postal sy n has its short ings. FURNESS’S ‘KING LEAR.'*® have now an admirable hand-book for the thorough study of ‘* King \WF one, Lear.” Mr. Furness gives us the substance of a hundred volumes in It contains a critical text, with all the various readings and interpreta. , g pret tions and explanatory notes from the beginning to the present time, with the
criticisms and comments of all kinds, lexical, grammatical, wsthetical, and the rest. Mr. Furness works with more ease and expresses his own opinions more freely than in his former volumes, and this is a gain In an appendix there are discussions of the date of composition, the sources of the plot, the actors, the costume ; extended passages of English, German, and French eri- ticism ; a good bibliography, and an index. In all there are §03 close-packed pages, and it is a piece of work which Mr. Furness and his collaborators n ay well be glad to have done. There is no book to be compared with it ; it is indispensable to every student of Shakspere. An examination of it shows that this, sometimes reckoned hended. the greatest of all the study of it both in the text and t Shakspere’s works, is still imperfectly compre
a great many difficulties remain unsolve 1e interpreta- } tion. In ‘t Hamlet” the verbal difficulties seldom or never extend to the throwe ing of doubt on the meaning of a sentence ; the coherence and familiarity of But in the brok 7 e clauses is often doubt t-
the matter enable us to follow the sense with cont en and exalted utterances of this play the sense of whi ful. ! originals are al fron ridged. Mr. Furness’s greatest labor must have been with his text. The printed re so different
ridgments, and they : as to suggest that the copy
which the folio was abridged had been after Mr. Furness follows the folio, but with many laps too mat rewritten the quarto was corrections ; per- tudents — +f make } non . mn thanat } ways, if 1t makes sense and metre, even though some other
It would be simpler and more satisfactory to most to have the folio al rea ling seems to be more perspicuous, or } etical, or Shak peri in, kK Se pere is not always at his best, nor are we ; we may see the dark passage in new light to-morrow. Thus in I. i, 226, when /vance suggests that Cor- delia must have done something monstrous and unnatural to make her father so curse her, she beseeches him to make know: * It is no vicious blot, murder, or f .
For this Mr. Furness reads : “It is no vicious blot or other foulness
e admitted that the new reading is at best rather an improve- Indeed, if ‘ ment than a necessity. murder” is something too monstrous for Cordelia, the other is too tame for Zear’s curses and charges. Mr. Furness might have taken warning from Mr. Richard Grant White, who at first ac- cepted the new rea
at last rejects it. The example may stand for one class of objectionable corrections ; iv. 4), bec class. reading durdocks for hardokes \1V. ause the botanists cannot identify Aarvdokes, is an example of another Mr. Furness is more and more disposed to adhere to the exact forms of words used by Shakspere. ‘‘Why should Shakespeare’s text be modern- ized?” he says; ‘‘we do not so treat Spenser. Is Shakespeare’s text less for more, vilde for vile, and the like; and he regrets that he has not printed the ‘‘ then” of the folio for sacred ?”’ So he has retained 7¢ for 7ts, woe * *A New Variorum Edition of Shakespeare. Edited by Horace Howard Furness, Ph.D., LL.D., Honorary Member of the “ Deutsche Shakespeare-Cesellschaft '' of Weimar.’ Vol. V., King Lear Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott & Co. 1880
Page 14
3285 O | it to publish a cheap reprint in t li WO It i pel Cl- I ctv l alr p! iti I ; \ carry | dhe 1 t i I ( vith d Ne | { { he | ! | 1, cr , t ls banisht, voucht, d the like to ( : t : honor'd to honour, honou | rt t | ! sive to have retained Jountie, Libertic, yu cood old endi gr te hould not have yielded to the pen- i for final y. So dn for éeen might well stand to testify for \1 n pronun n \nd why should such a truthful word as horson ej tymology pr ia id ised by heading and padding it | | > Mr. Furn } 1 1 that particl metimes wholly disappear through rption » adjace ‘ | he keeps a sharp lookout for them, and indicates | rophe. Thus, in I. i. 275 he read Ir r us our q } } to | been absor lL by the Zof wef; and in II. it. 116 he 1 1 } : if } t n 7/ is absorbed ¢. But in neither passage is there any such orpll na he ] Ores, In the cri | y of ‘‘ Lear” a great difficulty arises from the point of view We ¢ ly ept the view in ‘‘ Romeo and Juliet,” where everything ippea it does to the cye of youth; Fediet, thirteen years old, is old enoug!l In ‘‘ Hamlet,” too, we see the world as it appears to one just en- tering t battle of life. The father of our Cphelta is still a superfluous old Poloniu But, as Shakspere grows older, he passes beyond the experience of great 1 rs of | reade In ‘* Macbeth” and ‘‘ Othello” the point of view is that of middle age, and in ‘‘ King Lear” the world is seen as it ppears to an infirm old man. We must take the truthfulness of the present- never have been old men: we do \ ¢ } never have had ment with a large measure of faith, not know how they feel; we thankless daughters; we never have been insane ; we do not even know by observation how the insane act nd talk. the story, w to entertain in their families the old king and his hundred knights. difficulty of bringing us to this point of view is increased by The hich turns upon the doings of the young married couples who have It is very easy to take the point of view of the young folks when they say : ‘‘___vour all-licensed fool, And other of your insolent ret Pe lo hourly carp and quarrel Our « rt crows like a riot Fifty of these followers Change the sex of Zeav. Literature has hardly a point of view more familiar or more easily taken than the married man’s view of the worrying mother-in- Shakspere Iie shows us the king in his law. does not disguise the facts. unreason, his passion, his worrying, his domineering. How, then, does he bring us to accept his point of view ? ‘The most obvious source of this power is the perfect utterancy of the king, the ease and copiousness with which he gives intense expression to his feelings. He is regal withal, every inch a king; and in the first scene, as we hear him dispensing kingdoms and curses so grandly and so strangely, we give the reins to imagination and bid farewell to the regions of common sense, as though rhe difficulty of keep- ing us in sympathy with the old king afterwards is partly met by showing we were listening to the heroes or gods of .ischylus. the young folk committing crimes against each other abhorrent to human so that no one tl At the crisis of the play, at the tempest, the whirlwind inks of questioning the justice of their father’s re- nature, proaches and curses. 1 of his passion, when conversation with other men must needs be pitiful or laughable, the powers of nature—night, and storm, and darkness—fill the stage ; rain, wind, thunder become the old king’s interlocutors in place of thankless daughters. gods killing men for sport as wanton boys kill flies. We see the heavens taking part against us, and the It is a matter of course that he who could carry us with the king to such heights of frantic passion at the wounds offered to his imagination and kingly pride, should be able to keep us with him in his truly human woe at the death of the daughter he loves. The tears shed over Cordelia need no explanation. But Zear’s per- fect utterancy in gentleness is as noticeable as that in passion. Perhaps no other character.in fiction or history has been set forth with such minuteness and eloquent elaboration, on the hint of so few recorded traits, as Cordelia. But the commentators treat her mainly as she appears in the final scenes. With her tears and smiles for her poor father, and her im- mortal voice—ever soft, gentle, and low—she seems the incarnation of filial piety. When her father appeals to her in the first scene. to say how much she loves him, she might be expected, if she could not speak, at least to look But she defends her- She also her love, and tenderly deplore her want of utterancy. ends her want as a virtue. self sharply in her silence, and comm The Nation. [Number 8o1 roundly declares that she expects to love her husband, if she shall have one l that will t 1 to be wholly devoted to her father. Some of t ' exp lt she ¢ that Cordelia had a pi e of her fatl tempel It does not 1 to} urred to any that she has al- ready looked with love on one of her suitors; but that would explain mux on r grounds than t t g | LUCA SIGNORELLI AND THE ITALIAN RENAISSANCE.*® } | ERR VIS¢ HIER seems to foresee in his preface that few readers who are not unusual not unusually gifted with patience and perseverance will foilow him through the maze of his historical, topographical, and biographical rambles, Ife does not, however, warn us that he means io dissect and discuss al] themes, including such as the nature of the Deity, the Antichrist, and the Evi] One ; that he will touch on different philosophical systems of thought, includ. ing those of Hegel, Schopenhauer, and many others; nor that he means to quote largely from the book on esthetics of Herr Fr. Vischer, whose flights of fancy are truly bewildering. He promises to spare us details on Rome, llorence, Lorenzo the Magnificent, and the popes, making sure that we ar } well informed on these subjects, and this generous consideration on his part gives rise to speculation as to how much more tedious the book might have been had he not given us credit for some previous knowledge and dwelt at } length on these themes also. We have under our author’s guidance the op- portunity of considering Luca Signorelli, his work, and his relation to the [Italian Renaissance from every point of view. To use his own words: ‘‘ We secret door into his studio, we will understand him at his work, we will listen to his monologue, we will look will open the into his very heart ; we will not ny form of psychological or phjlosophical research” ; and ire our elves though the data of Signorelli’s life are too slight and leave too many gaps for let any very detailed biography, Herr Vischer has, by a close study of the work of this great master, done all that patient investigation and a warm sympathy for the personality of Luca Signorelli can do towards giving us the story of his life and work. Ile made three journeys to Italy in order to see and study afresh Our author has spared himself no trouble in this labor of love. Signorelli’s frescoes ; other journeys he made to the art galleries of Alten- burg, Dresden, and Berlin. One cannot but be impressed by the earnestness and conscientiousness of the biographer, though one may deplore his not havy- ing given his work a more readable form. "7 1 I i he first part of the book is taken up with local history—z.¢., detailed accounts of the history and government of Cortona, Signorelli’s birthplace ; of Arezzo, Fiorence, Loreto, Perugia, Rome, Citta di Castello, Urbino, Siena, and Orvieto during the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, the master having executed works in all these towns. Then comes the biography of Signorelli’s teachers and predecessors in art; for example, Lazzaro Vasari, who took him as a boy and introduced him to Piero della Francesca of Borgo San Sepolcro, whose assistant and disciple Luca remained for many years. A chapter is devoted to Verrocchio and Pollaiuolo, Herr Vischer having come to the conclusion that Signorelli during his stay at Florence came directly under their influence as a pupil, on account of a certain similarity in the type of some bearded saints to the works of both those masters ; he also recognizes Verrocchio’s mannered style of bending up the little finger in hands in movement, in Signorelli’s drawings after his acquaintance and apprentice- ship in the Florentine school, of which Verrocchio and Pollaiuolo are regarded as the Realists. Another chapter is devoted to the Idealists and Romanti- cists. Of these, Fra Filippo Lippi, Sandro Botticelli, Luca della Robbia, Ghirlandaio, and Benedetto da Maiano are most important, not forgetting Benozzo Gozzoli, who, according to Herr Vischer, is the only one of his countrymen gifted with gladsomeness, The great Leonardo is placed mid- way Detween the Romantics and the Realists, taking the highest place in either camp. Perugino’s ‘‘angels of upturned looks and pious glances” seem to have infiuenced Signorelli, as also Pinturicchio, whose style i similar. After this long preamble follows the life of Luca Signorelli, taken chiefly from Vasari and Manni. The former is a warm admirer of the master’s work and speaks of him in these terms : ‘* Although there is great blame to those who, through the mere desire and pride of surpassing others rather than from a wish of usefulness or benefi- cence, do good work, this reproach cannot be given to Luca of Cortona, who always loved his art and was always kindly to whoever desired to learn, and wherever he could be of use to his profession. And the goodness of his nature was such that he never stooped to anything that was not just and holy, for which reason heaven, recognizing him as a truly good man, was very generous in the blessings showered on him. Luca Signorelli was an ex- cellent painter, and his works were in such great esteem that none were more so at any time.” The name of Signorelli appears in the books of communal deliberations * ‘Luca Sign orelli und die Italienische Renaissance. Eine Kunsthistorische Monographie von Robert Vischer.’ 79 cipzig. 12
Page 15
Signorelli. il Ile is ; family was one cidio di maestro Ventura de’ hives of hi the ar¢ native town, and he was elected nine times to the P st of supreme ignori Priori.” At the age of 1 he went to Arezzo to h Lazzaro Vasari (1451), who, dying the following year, left hima 1 of Piero della Fr ca (degli Franceschi), ‘The usual term of appren- ti hip was then thirteen years, according to Cennini (in his ‘ Libro dell’ Arte’ of 1437); but this term was in some cases curtailed to seven, and Herr Vischer concludes this must have been the case with Signorelli, though he may afterwards have remained with Piero as an assistant in his work at Borgo San What became of Signorelli after Herr Vischeris ed that he then studied in Florence, and sees every evidence of this in his work cemies Sepolcro and other places where he painted. his years of apprenticeship re mains a question, ;convin ollaiuoli than to that of for carries him quite o much more affinity to that of Verrocchio and the I his master Piero della F uses in which the This evidence is scare there natural bent of the in a different track from the one followed by his master. chapel of Sta. Barbara in St. painting a Madonna with St. this work has been dest rancesea, ely convincing, are many cx artist Signorelli is the Lorenzo of his a di ¢ The first work of at Arezzo. In 1474 we hear Hieronymus a Paul in Citt TI sa gap of four years, during which time he cc lk yssal nd St. ‘astello ; royed, is supposed to have en ensue at Florence, where he was recognized as a great master in his knowledge for \ , and how ‘asari tells how Lorenzo the asked } for » human form, Magnificent im fora sample of his art ‘“‘he painted him some naked gods ! ] | g which brought him much fame.” From the year 1479 up to that of his death t the age of cighty-two we have very exact information as to his work and very few details of his family life. There is one episode showing hana on his return to Cortona he found a beloved son killed by some sudden death, Vas was always attired in silk, and was held in high ears he ari also relates and how without t splendidly, esteem by all the great personages of his time. drew his figure most carefully. that he lived We further hear of his being at Rome in 1513 when Giovanni Medici became Pope under the title of Leo X. The most imposing ceremonies took the Medicean Pope. for a letter from Michael z describes how Messer Luca had come to him to borrow money in order to re- Herr Vischer is much exercised by this letter, and cannot believe it possible that so honorable a place on this occasion honor of Signorelli seems to have made a long and unprofitable stay there, Angelo to the ** Capitano ” of Cortona turn to his native place and had never thought to repay it. man as Signorelli should have behaved so discreditably ; he cannot reconcile himself to the thought of this standing against Signorelli’s character for ever, and entreats us to believe some mistake must have occurred in returning the money. Greater familiarity with the artistic temperament might go far to persuade Herr Vischer that the occurrence is possible and quite probable. After the comparatively short sketch of his life comes a chapter on the art In this far to form the the circumstance of his being and fantasy of Signorelli with relation to the Italian Renaissance. Herr Vischer seeks to show us the influences which went so art of this m the literature of his time ; an Umbrian ; the wild and continually disturbed state of the country around ; the orders he received from religious bodies for church decorations, on which, by the way, he seems to have bestowed less serious work than on the commis- sions from noble Florentine houses ; the study and revival of ancient Greek art, which led to the more frequent use of the human form in pictures, and a thorough knowledge of anatomy, derived from the Florentine school. The tranquil life of Signorelli seems in contradiction to his art, which derived its color from the troublous times in which he lived, and suggestec 1 continual struggle and active movement. We have next a description of Signorelli’s greatest work, the frescoes in the chapel of the Madonna di San Brizio, at Or- he ) so dec P- mm of the Last Juc leave every margin for a vivid imagination to vieto, representing the history of the Antichrist, the Resurrection, and t Last Judgment, which is supposed to have impressed Michael Angel ly that it did much to inspire him with his own des The subjects in themselves lgment. have full play. In the forms of his demons, so varied and full of inven- tion, in the beauty of the figures of the seraphim, Signorelli shows an un- rivalled power of expression. There is also a series of subjects from classical history, beneath which are medallion portraits of the great Italian poets, scenes from the ‘ Divina Commedia,’ At Monte Oliveto, near Siena, representing e] the life of St. powerful, though less impressive than the great epic at Vasari's, used in different senses, furnishes the lessly discursive and is another mytho- of very of and need- series logical subjects. frescoes, yisodes from Benedict, also Orvieto. A term text of a very long Vasari speaks often of work as ‘‘ terrible,” 1 ing sometimes awe-inspiring and sometimes merely lifelike and striking ; whereupon Herr Vischer is very eloquent, and takes the ¢erridilitd as chapter. ean- one of the striking qualities of the quattrocentist painters, and especially of Luca Signorelli, and here it is impossible for us not to lose the thread of hi arg ment. He tries to explain what seems very simple and at once ‘unde rsto vod, therefore not needing much explanation, or else conething that is inexplic The second part of the book contains a complete list of Signo orelli’ $s paint- ‘The Nation. ‘ ings, with their dates and histories, explaining through what hands they have assed ; also a second description of the work at Orvieto, with diagrams of chapel. This will make book a ble work of reference. Sul joined is a list of painters who have all directly or indirectly ced by Signorelli’s w Michael Angelo, 1 even Albert ire among these, and Herr Vischer explains his reasons for eac! e on his list though his grounds for usin it to such a length seem to us frequently in- ufficient. The portrait of Signorelli is a fac-simile reproduction of a drawin by Charles Fairfax Murray from Luca's portrait of himself in one the fres coes at Orvieto. fourth Report of the Record Commis (Bostor 1880,)—Th volume embraces ‘‘all the records contained in the first \ f the Re- cords of the Town of Dorchester,” now incorporated with ] Ihe earliest entry is in 1632, the last if not the 1 n the ck (which follow ne jumble of the original) is in 1691. In 163( It ‘ i that Mr Duncan shall haue tos payd him by the Towne for to t1 ‘ hese orders into a new booke in a fayre legible han I th esent ( bably final transcript the Boston authorities appropriated $1,000 The stern physiognomy of this Puritan comm y relaxes, 1 t renial influence of Time, almost ’ Phe Penn 1 pointed in 1634 ‘‘to order all fayr Plant , to ce { one yeere, & to meete m methly, nd who after ve wavt = men, were bound by the agreement that ‘‘ whosoever is chosen in t \ office for the good of Plantation, he sh bide by it, « mit t is the company shall thinke meete to impose.” Moreover If anv of these shall be absent without good cause, allowed by the rest, fhe] sh; pay for his so fayleing 5 shillings, any that shall com ter the hour of 8 of clock to pay I2 pence, and after g to pay 2 shillings,” « ] 1642 out eneral towne meetinge ” had become very disorderly, ‘* by reason that men haue used their libertye to p’pound theere matters to the Plantation w any fore knoledge of the seauen men, and theere 1 se lowed that diuerse things haue beene spoken of and ee issued by reason that new matters haue beene vp ner hath beene in heeringe and so much tyme spent and lytle work done wherefore it is ordered that the seven men have ‘fore knoledge ” of ything ‘‘to be gitated.”” The rules for ‘the Schoole of Dorchester” contirmed in 1644 enjoined the schoolmaster that ‘gly efiery second day in the weeke he shall call his tweene 12 and one of the ¢ loc k to examin them wha the saboath day p*ceding at which tyme also he shall demeanor or disorder that any of his skollers shall saboath to the end that at somme convenient tyme Correction may bee a¢ dmistred 2 him according as the the offence shall requir ~. & ** sly hee shall equ: ‘liy and imp sent and Comitted to him . ¢ refacine a } rich not refusing any v receiue, a . whither thei i Interest in the Schoole.’ eral} artially for th * haue Rig Cl vho “oly And becat » Rodd of Cor re ner is ce of ¢ sary sometymes to “stig Manne *d vnto children as may abused by oitimuch seititic and rigour on ‘the one hand, or by o@ mu ! gence and lenitye on the other. It is therefore ordered and agreed that the schoolemaster for the tyme beeing shall haue full ‘power to minister Correction to all or any of his schollers without respect of p’sons,” ete. The standing terror of the Puritan polity was the er who might be- come a burden upon the town. In 1658, ‘It is ordered therefore by the select men of this towne that if any maner of p’son ore a in this towne shall intertaine any soiornour ore inmate into his or ther house ore habitation aboue one weeke without lisence from the clectmen ore the n | tc f them first had and obtained, shall for- feit fiue shillings, and r every weekes continuan three shillings foure pence. Hence in 1671 Francis Bale was taken to task ‘‘for Entertaining his Brother in law phillip Searle 1 his famely in his 1 e without licence” ; and Richard Butt for enterta g his father-in-law Stephen Hoppen, ‘‘whos answer was that he did not entertaine him, . . . but for to turne him out of dceares, he could not Considering the relation that is between them, but he would willingly be ridd of him if he could”; and ‘tthe wife of Henery Merrifield” ‘‘for entertaining of their daugh- ter Funnell, Contrary to towne order, whose answer was, that she was their daughter and Could not turne her out of doars this winter time but she would willingly returne to her husband as soone as a passadg prsents.’ ’ So, too, in 1079, John J ackson had to file his bond ‘‘ to secur the towne from damedg" by reason of the further entertainment of ‘ Op’tunitie Lane his daughter in law Contrary to towne order”; and the year before, the luckless ‘‘ John Brown appeared and thought that he might Come into town to be inhabetant becaus born in the town and that he might be an help to his father and mother, the Select men did Respit the full determination at that time to know the towns mind therein and in the meane time his warning out of town to continue in force.” here r2- corded is the followi: But perhaps the most stubborn case Y 672) ng (I Djal.
Page 16
e > 4 $5 >( ) ‘* The Select men haueing sent for John plum and his daughter Mercy, ind finding that ] id daughter being marryed to Th ymas Chub of Beuer le nd bei ilsoe neere the time of her delivery is not p’vided for by het } i, nor taken home to him, but continues heer with her father, y to good ord nd to the hazarding of a chat vpon the towne, doe { ordet d requier that the said Merey Chub doe spedily within Six it days leaue thi ywwne, and betake herself to her said husband. And also warne and order the said John Plum that he noe longer entertaine ni iid daughter, but hasten her to her husband as afor¢ said,” etc. Instead of this the husband rather hastened to his wife (1673), bringing his father-in-law into fresh trouble, and in 1674 the worthy Plum was for th third time summoned to ‘‘ Cleer the towne of them.” For a final glimpse of the interference with domestic relations let us notice that Francis Bale reap- pears in 1679 to answer the selectmen’s enquiries ‘‘ Concerning his outward Estate,” of which he seems to have had none too much, for they ‘‘ aduised him to dispose of two of his Children, his answer was that his wife was not willing the Select men p’swaded him to p’swad his wife to it.” 9 } srl hi Our space warns us to pass over other marked passages of equal humor with the foregoing. We cannot forbear remarking that the Record Commis- ioners had proposed to reprint only the land records of this volume, but that a protest having been raised by very respectable citizens of Dorchester, a of the Common Council reported in favor of a complete reproduc- One looks for a Puritan signature ‘Hugh committee tion, on historical and patriotic grounds. to such a. report, and it is an agreeable surprise to find it signed O'Brien, Chairman.” The Worst Boy in Town. By the author of ‘ Helen’s Babies.’ (New York : G. P. Putnam’s Sons. 1880.)—This book belongs to the new dispensation of books about boys ; we were about to say of Sunday-schools books, but possi- bly we have yet to wait for Sunday schools sufficiently advanced to have rea- sonable hopes of catching up with it. It is written in the now familiar and perhaps hackneyed vein of protest against the old order of pietistic juvenile literature, and is a defiant departure from former classic models in the direc- tion of ‘* The author is felt to be a kind of Baudelaire, except for the fact that he is a little tardy with his ‘‘ Fleurs du Mal,” and as wroth with the false and affected academic notions of Miss Edgeworth and the naturalism. Misses Warner as the early romanticists were with canons of adult literature then prevailing. He must be charged, however, with ignoring an important element the ie manufactured with a deft touch to be entirely acceptable. ‘The New Sanford and Merton,’ and more recently Mark Twain, under- in construction naturalist’ moral tales. They must be The author of stood this better, and accordingly their works of this sort have a distinctly humorous quality, or at least a comic flavor, whereas, though it would be unjust to say that ‘The Worst Boy in Town’ can be read without a smile, it is perfectly true that the proportion of depression to mirth that it con- tains is dejectingly preponderant. Few things of the kind are more laugh- able, for instance, than the description of the strategy with which Master Tom Sawyer contrived to get his task of whitewashing a fence performed ; it may be remembered that Tom was averse to labor but a thorough child of this world, and when given this distasteful job as a punishment compassed it by to representing a comrade that it was a very delicate zsthetic performance, and declining for a brief time on that ground to allow him to touch the brush. The author of ‘ The Worst Boy in Town’ lays violent hands on this incident, and devotes a chapter to an account of how his boy got his comrades to chop the wood he had himself been set to chop for misconduct ; and we are bound vo confess we have rarely read twelve more dreary pages, and this not because chopping wood is naturally less humorous than whitewashing, nor wholly be- ca the humorous possibilities of the situation had already been exhausted by Mark Twain, but because of what housewives call the ‘‘ heavy-handed- ness” that the author betrays. Again, nothing is more requisite than a light and tricksy treatment when one is describing the absurdities of prayer-meet- ings, and the rollicking fun which pit-balls ” at, and peppering with torpedoes the boys who are not milksops may have by sticking pins into, throwing ‘ enthusiasts who take part in them. This sort of style will never do : ‘* Under the single slat which formed the back of the bench and directly in front of him Jack beheld the broad and well-patched trousers-seat of Nuder- kopf Trinkelspiel, and Satan, who long ago became noted for putting in an appearance when the sons of God were in council (see Job, chap. i.), sug- gested to Jack that through.such a mass of patches a bent pin might work its way for quite a distance without doing any serious damage to the wearer. Jack broke an anticipatory laugh square in two and closed his eyes in prayer to be delivered from temptation, but,” etc., etc. This must be described as irrelevantly labored, and before we get to the event we lose our interest in seeing the meeting break up in disorder. We must add that another fatal defeet of the book is its lack of verisimilitude, and the danger it thus illustrates of falling into the opposite extreme to that of the old order of moral tales. ‘* The worst boy in town” transformed into a mere puppet can have no more influence for good than impossible ‘‘ Little Episco- It is to be feared that the writer not only fails to treat his subject palian The Nation. [Number 801 flippantly enough, but fails to conceive it seriously enough ; and the latter, we need not point out, is as grave a defect under the circumstances as the other, and one we never expected to find in the author of ‘ Helen’s Babies.’ Di ‘isch Zopf. Eine Studie von Emil Naumann, Prof. Dr. ii rchen-Musikdirector. (Berlin: Robert Oppenheim ) —Emil Naumann’s musical study gives us an insight into the present musical ndition of Germany. We see how intense is the party spirit, how bitter the fecling among the worshippers of Wagner and Brahms towards the dis. ciples of the classical school. The author is one of the neutrals whose num- ber is very limited in Germany, and who, standing on a higher plane than the contending parties, should be able to give an impartial criticism. He is pained to see how many musicians have not the slightest perception of organic unity in the laws which govern music, and are wholly ignorant of the history of music. When the representatives of the classical school are in their most generous mood they assert that with Beethoven the history of music ends; while, on the other hand, the modern Romanticists regard Beethoven as only the beginning of the higher development, and some of them are willing to concede eve 2 this honor only to the Beethoven of the Ninth Symphony and the later string quartettes. Naumann, though he is ready enough to make concessions to not of the opinion that any one has the right to make The fact that Beethoven omits a repetition of the first part of the allegro in his Ninth ter ters, 1S ma *s in the scores of the great composers of former times. living change Symphony, at once emboldens the newest of our new musicians to do away Beetho- ven’s last sonata for the pianoin C minor, Op. 111, and his string quartette in with all tradition and omit the da capo in symphonies and sonatas. B major, Op. 130—both works belonging to the same period as the Ninth Symphony—have an express direction for the da capo, and prove clearly that Beethoven himself could not have understood an omission of it in the light of areform. Naumann thinks it equally unjustifiable when famous quariette- players spoil Haydn’s lovely music, in itself so grand and simple, by, an amount of false sentimentality and a number of pianissimos, fortissimos, crescendos, diminuendos, and sforzandos, that would make poor papa Haydn turn in his grave should he hear them. Beethoven, Mozart, Haydn, he thinks, certainly stand in no need of having their taste corrected by these modern apostles. ‘‘ Away with these dusty traditions !” they cry, ‘‘ which impede your flight, and you will soar sunward like eagles.” ‘away with the sonata! that most threadbare of the antiquated Therefore, es- pecially, garments of the past.” Jean Jacques Rousseau’s ‘‘ Que me veux-tu, Sonate ?” might be excused on the ground that the best of them with which he was ac- quainted were the compositions of Samartini (1700-1775) and Sacchini (1735- 1786). Had he been so fortunate as to hear Haydn’s, Mozart's, and Beetho- ven’s symphonies and sonatas he would have changed his mind as readily after becoming acquainted with Gluck, he retracted what he had said in his ‘Dictionnaire de Musique’ about the superiority of the Italian opera. With Gluck and Mozart the musical drama reaches its climax. Gluck pre-eminently is the master who in his own productions designates the exact boundary be- tween music as an independent art and music as the mere reinforcement of diction. Ie who aspires to go beyond the great master in this direction can produce at best but a musical mongrel, which is neither genuine poetry nor genuine music. The so-called leading-motive (Zeztmotiv) is not original with the musicians of ‘‘ the future’; only the immense abuse of it is the spe- cial property of this party. The Zettmotiv existed two hundred years ago, but not as the mere mannerism which it has now become. Mozart’s ‘‘ Don Giovanni” When the theme in the introduction of the overture to resounds again in the mouth of the Commendatore at the finale of the opera, or when the trumpet-signal in Beethoven’s great overture to ‘‘ Leonora” is heard again later on in the prison scene, the two themes, considered as musical prologues, are like an awful foreboding, and intensely powerful in their effect. The last chapter of the little volume is mainly devoted to Wagner. After a brief sketch of the renaissance in Italy, and of the condition of music in Germany in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, we are told that the epoch of German musical genius begins with Johann Sebastian Bach and ends with Beethoven. Between this great beginning and this great end come in chronological order Haendel, Gluck, Haydn, and Mozart, equally great in their several ways. Composers of the later period like Franz Schubert, Weber, Spohr, Marschner, Berlioz, Chopin, Schumann, Mendelssohn, and contemporaries like Wagner, Liszt, and Brahms are characterized as men of great talent, All of them except Mendelssohn (and the exception is made only in favor of his oratorios, psalms, and church music) represent in greater or less degree the new Romantic school. ‘‘The predominating tendency of Wagner’s dramas,” we are told, ‘‘ man- ifests itself in the portrayal of the Germano-Christian world of the middle ages, in the idealization of woman (originating in medizval Mariolatry) into the redeeming angel of man, who is lost in a world of diabolism and sin, such as she appears in Sevfa in the ‘ Flying Dutchman,’ and in L&zadez/ in ‘’Tannhauser’ ; or again in an attempted glorification of free love, in the spirit of medizval chivalry, as a mysterious celestial power which overrides all
Page 17
Nov. 4, 1880] The Nation. 8331 ventional restraints, as in ‘ Tristan und Isolde’; or, finally, in a revival | meditated symbolic and parabolic teaching of most sublime doctrines, of { the ‘ Minne’ and ‘ Meister’ songs of the medizval and succeeding periods, which the first originators of those portions of the Talmud had not tl exhibited in the * Meistersinger.’ ” motest idea. But is this allegorical method of explaini g the Tal In his love for themes from German mythology Wagner shows himself a | Agadah any better than the method of the Mohammedan clergy in Per lisciple of the Romantic school, though his Nibelungen dramas are | who symbolize the lyric outbursts of Hafiz, the rer of Shiraz, and wh hat of a departure from his general tendency ; yet in the last of them, | find, for instance, in the wine whosc | is sung by | rsymbol of fait! ‘ Gotterdimmerung,” he hints clearly enough at a speedy return, for the | in intoxication caused by wine-drinking, a symbol of the religious ecstasy of of IVetan and Walhalla would seem to indicate that the old Teutonic | the soul ; in the beloved maiden, th ! t of th munity of the 1 not brought the fulfilment of things, and that something higher | faithful; in the friend with whom t poet s] ls | happy and be expected. In ‘ Parcival” we have, as he himself says, the key- | hours, a mystic representation of the Deity?) This method, however, ts by of all his creations. In this drama he emphasizes even more intensely | means restricted to the scholars of Persia and to the commentators of | ionately the Germano-Christian tendency with which he started, and | Talmud. The theological literature of other denominati too, offers vhich is the basis of his earliest musical productions. Naumann remarks | parallels without numbe1 t modes of thought which were perfectly natural, healthy, and justified in Admitting that the Talmud, like every othe dante’s or Wolfram von Eschenbach’s time, or in the time of the Crusades, | contains elements which no artificial ology ¢ elevate int bs to-day morbid and affected, because there is nothing in contemporary eternal wisdom, it must also | needed that it is exceedingly rich t tory to furnish a background for them. poetry, lofty and sublime, and in sayings breathing the purest : \ Franz Liszt, the second eminent ‘‘talent” in the new school, shows a | Mr. Sekles’s work, we have to say that, in tl of any e resemblance to Wagner in his symphonic poems ‘‘ Tasso,” ‘* Dante,” glish languag re t ugl x1 1 sch ' ‘Hamlet,” in his oratorio of ‘* Christus,” and in some of his songs and | recommended as one which gives to the general reader a fair ide f the A nds. The events of his life more even than his works are proofs of this dah. In special ch ipters it speaks of for liturgical ity. The great virtuoso, celebrated and applauded by the world, the | of wedding celebrations, funeral o1 », fabl rtist who had spent more than half of a long life in brilliant gaieties and | forth, and the examples and illustrations the author gives will undoubtedly ements, after a fantastic existence makes a pilgrimage to Rome, like | appear to many to be interesting. In making h knight of the middle ages, there exchanges the coat of the layman for the | dant materials the author must have had rabl tt y. Very tly robe, retires to the Dominican convent on Monte Mario and soon be- | noying is the slovenly d uneven mann in which t Hebrew v the favorite of Pio Nono, who calls him his faithful son, his ‘* Pales- | are transliterated. Sometimes the Dagesh t rina.” Another great ‘‘ talent,” though not so closely related to Wagner, is | consonant, but in innumerable cases this has not been d And thus we fohannes Brahms. Robert Schumann stood godfather to his first produc- find the unorthographic spellings Shamai, Kama, \ ui, Nida, ehila tions, and before he died gave Brahms a kind of prophetic blessing. Yet | Tana, etc. Nissim (instead of mesi-"tm, p. 7), s (instead of shalom Wagner’s influence upon him and his productions is easily traceable, no mat- | 12), sufdanim (instead of sappedanim, p. 12) instead of dccur how much his disciples may try to deny it. They are, as a party, even | p. 19), an 1 similar other grammati ind y ln trosities greatly more one-sided and conceited than the Wagnerites, and form as great a | disfigure the book. A little more schol xact . little more quicker mutual admiration society as these. Who was it that announced the first | ing of the philological consci , a littl car ; these things are ymphonic work of Brahms as the ‘* Tenth Symphony”? Not the worship- greatly to be desired, not only in our aut it in very many others who ap- pers of Wagner, but Brahminical idolaters. ‘The essentially lyrical talent of | pear before the public as write1 Jewis! 1 Hebrew t Brahms ought never to have been compared with Beethoven, to whose unap- pro chable greatness Wagner comes at any rate somewhat nearer than The Procress of the | Py iy \: \r lture, ( merce, M Brahms, who is by nature tender and delicately strung, whilst the former | factures, Instruction, Railways, i Wealtl the Beg puts the stamp of his powerful personality upon all his productions, Nau- | of the Nineteenth ( ry. By Michael G. Mulhall, F.s.S. (1 mann closes his volume with the hope that by his frank and impartial criti- | Edward Stanford. 1880 I2mo, p] Vill.—869 Mi Mulhall’s be cism he has earned the approval and s¥mpathy of all those who share his though not annour lf as at nt pu t : best described by opinions in silence without daring to express them openly. The future will | comparing it with Martin's well-known * States ’s Year-Book.’ Vr show how far he is right. latter is intended to show, primarily, how the world is governed, M Mulhall’s work how it crowing The two v Lhe Poetry of the Talmud. By S. Sekles. (New York. 1880.)—To one equal amount of infor t bout the leading states of the civil i wo f the component elements of the Talmud the author of this book has fur- | 2nd some part of tl ta are similar in the two, as, for instance, the sta nished an introduction which is not lacking in interest and in merit. Such | tistics of population, , and trafin But the space that Mr. Martin giv introductions are indispensable aids to any student of the vast Talmudic lite- | to reigning families SOV gns is taken up in Mr. Mulhall’s book witl rature. They have been felt to be a necessity since Samuel ibn Nagdilah, in | statistical accounts of the vital 1 industrial development of the different the eleventh century, wrote his ‘ Introduction to the Talmud,’ and large is | peoples. In the first | > grouped, t way that comparison may the number of such keys and guides which have appeared since then, For | be made at a glanc W the different nations, the statistics of capita the Talmudic literature treats of the most diversified subjects, is almost all- income, accumulations, « neree, | property, manufactures, imstruc- embracing, and reflects all the various aspects of the mental life of the Jews tion, charities, etc. These e givel suy round numbers ; they form during the seven centuries following the Maccabean war of independence, in | ® More servic conspectus Of West rld’s economic condition the second century before Christ. The rich contents of the Talmud, embar- than we have elsewhere s “ th ne compass. Part II. gives in rassing Jer se, become still more perplexing and appear still more entangled fuller detail the leading stat it British Empire, and Part TIT, m and chaotic in consequence of the lack of order and systematic treatment. briefly those of foreign « tries, the latest sources of information bein; Even the specialist who devotes all his time to the study of the Talmud will used. Mr. Mulhall has done his work with great care and intelligence find it difficult, without the help of good and reliable guides, not to become | he has found room for imber of the curiosities of statistics, vital and othe lost in this pathless labyrinth. The one great element of the Talmud, known lhe book is well indexed under the name Halakhah, and treating of the legal life of Judaism, has been ; , systematized, codified, commented upon by numberless post-Talmudical I Shepard) $1 scholars, Another large part of the Talmudic literature—and, in the wider .s r'sS 4 sense of the word, the Midrashim, etc., are also included in this term—is ' ; f called the Agadah, and comprises the didactic, narrative, and poetically oe fanciful utterances of the Rabbis in the period indicated above. The , ee gen BB Agadah, too, has been the subject of a considerable number of books of (Econ has. Scribner's Sons diverse value. There exist Agadic chrestomathies and anthologies, more Di : ee ; or less complete ; there exist learned writings on the nature, and contents, at foal. a, , es pea Chicago) 2 25 and origin, and meaning of these peculiar products of Eastern fancy. A nie J G Linpineed & Co. 1 ; few modern writers on this subject may be characterized as being unbiassed ao oe | and truly scholarly, while others still pursue the old apologetic and unscien- . Bike being, oe og . tific tendencies, and, by applying a totally unhistoric method, still allegor- s Co Part 9, swd.......(F. WE be —_ : ize even the grossest superstitions prevalent in those ancient times, and | raw... G. P. Putnam's Sons) 2 the grossest Miinchhausenisms of a Rabbi Bar bar ‘Hanah and others. By aie ee: Oe Shepends : ie such perverted hermeneutics they succeed in finding in the Agadahs a pre- | ahy oe ee TR Ocmmda Coy * :
Page 18
The Nation. Robert Clz irke & Co., cri CINC]
OLD PARTS
[Number 801 ibner & Welford’s BOOKS. NEW AND
LItt ed. ‘ ( i : ( LRCOAL DRAWING ( M \ | lreat j . , 77 4 LP eater : ie i 2 I I ing in Char , h I i Studies 1. SAMUEL PEP YS, Hillebvand'sGerman lhought se. By Karl Robert. 7 iby E. H. Apy World he! By Henry B. Wheatley, F.S.A ' “7 t pt j nate. treceun rate! CONTENTS : Pepys before the Diary—Pepys in the Diary—Pey y ’ ° P ritt I I , fter tl I y I 1 le s Be I cx ' oe “ — Lord Raglan, Ma | By A. W. Ki pe for th lest student t “AT | Theo! siti A Volume 6. ‘ Winter T: ! her clear ar . GLIMPSES OF BIRD LIFE Hard Por Ninth 1 1 Ll) ONLY BY SUBSCRIPTION Portrayed by Pen and Pencil. Twenty colored plates of boards 4 for pr most I ; drawn 2's ert, al described — 1 . J.F ted i highest le of Parisian art GEBBIE & CO the Lemercier et ¢ Fo! cloth, « Sent by mail, prepaid, re pt S Street, Pl Iphia gilt, $18 eee ee UR I LY TL E ONES | 8 WOMAN OUTSIDE OF CHRIS- Cin »U ( 4 \ / ( d aS hn ¥ — I i by Cl 1dom An xposition ¢ t if ence xerted by rist ALL WH NGAGI . AT IN SCHOOL: anity on the S ul P : H iess otf Women. By J ‘ P , ow , , M les & lot e> Be 1 P ln Lliustrated Slag nN r Little People. a 7 - svi: seacla eso dadatih briprleing -canphioscnagl 9. PICTURES from the GERMAN Wi “r leasure i t I s il y trat yuse of the AMATEUI SS MINIATURE RILA tI ich nut As] Fatherland. Dri I Pencil. By the Rev. Samuc! ed), wi ’ les tl mic J it \ SCTS Wé l G. ¢ n, D.D. With num s ill by English s a the pr r M 1 $1 a year November ‘ fe al i Cuy auce " : I wsdealer RUSSELL PUBLISHIN( Foreign Artists. §vo, cloth \ nall sizes: t . st s wy \ ,t Mas can Pictures,’ ‘ Er » Pix ,” etc., et $35 12 i liameter and 8 he I 7 [ Many artists who are using STANDA gs = SERIES, | 10. THE“ DRUID” SPORTING LI ’ = z . . . a little ex aay ! 1. Post and Paddock.—2. Saddle and Sirloin.—3. Sil ng able to adapt N LIF Sa, SPURGEON. tt I ' German Books. | ior India-paper proofs. Folio, v« sarts of Eur ype Each . a Fren i German V s received as soon nity p ct ( i i new French, German, and ‘ Sy , = j INI. are 3 x —_w JOHN PENINGTON & SON, rs, | The Dras wings have been 3 : , Vex I 127 South Seventh Str ect. Philadel elphia. bound in vellum, and subscribers way of Venice —— paniseeiaeiadtindiadammianens bner & Welford, who h Plates IV. and V. will follow shortly, as Sy ]/ oy - s t ica. SIULLLVA ; 201 Plate IV Florence from near S Min ¢ van Bros TL tbbie ’ NEARLY READY “ Yn tl af V nice _ " 7 in ~ - rr . . ¢ fe a Fa 4 . | lpr AUCTIONEERS, THE STORY OF THE DIAMOND The series may be had as fast as issued on appl : ' : Necklace. Told in detail for the first time, by the aid of Con- OSCAR F. ALLEN, Salesroom No. 2 Beacon Street, Boston. temporary Memoirs, O ] Letters, and Official and cther Cambridge SavingsBask, Cambridge, Mass — Documents, and compri a sketch of the life of the Countess Proofs before letters : i de La Motte, pretended confidante of Marie-Antoinette, with Plain prints — » oon en Ae i ns of private particulars of the career of the other actors in this remarkab! HS, COMBS, Pain Sy . - 1 . e . 4 , ITS TRPN as , , etc. drama. By Henry Vizetelly. Illustrated with an exact repre- I W » 4 H RIS I ERN, 3/ W uyers gratis. sentation of the Diamond Necklace and a Portrait of the ? Y j? } Countess de la Motte, engraved on steel, Crown 8vo, cloth, Aepertoiwr: vd Sara ) RHATAL,. ROPE FOR $22 j Paris tion of t I tels and travelli = i | ( I d n can 1a party co “OP TPNY : — " . a Zz > ‘ i cI rope n expe I “* i O. B € SL RIBNI & W ELFORD, y 4 Rrociiva. N.Y. ee ee es No. 745 Broadway, New York. E