The Nation 1877-03-08: Vol 24 Iss 610
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
The NEW YORK, THURSDAY, MARCH 8, 1877. rh r = The Week. i Democratic filibusters kept up their fight against the Electoral count till the end, although it was known a week ago that their efforts would be unavailing. When the State of Vermont was reached, an attempt was made to introduce a paper purporting to be a second return and so get the State referred to the Commis- sion, but this, of course, failed. They then determined to object to Virginia and West Virginia, but no Senator would sign the objee- tions. Finally, after scenes of great excitement, the proceedings were closed by the counting of the vote of Wisconsin and the an- nouncement, at 4.10 A.M. on Friday, by Mr. Ferry, that Hayes and Wheeler had received 185 votes, and were consequently elected. President Hayes’s inaugural address is in the main an amplifieca- tion of his letter of acceptance, and must thus have had the charm of novelty for the Republican managers, as none of them during the canvass seemed to have any recollection of the letter or its con- tents. He opens by dwelling on the supreme importance of the pacification of the South, and as a means to this end mentions ‘“*honest and peaceful local self-government,” recognizing and maintaining inviolate the rights of both races in hearty and loyal submission all parties for their co-operation in the work of restoring the South. He does not indicate clearly what course he intends to pursue in the matter, but any vagueness there may be in his utterances is of the less consequence as he will be called on for imme- diate action on this question. Of the necessity of civil- service reform he speaks in the strongest way, and what he means by the term he makes perfectly clear—appointment for competency, and tenure during good behavior—and recommends an amendment to the Constitution extending the Presidential term to six years and forbidding re-election. As to foreign rela- tions he expresses, with some simplicity, his reliance on arbitration as a means of evading all differences, and, touching lightly on the Presidential contest, endeavors to console the vanquished by the reflection that it was decided by the best tribunal that could be created for the purpose, and that if the result was net satisfactory it must be remembered that “ buman judgment is never unerring, and is rarely regarded as otherwise than wrong by the unsuecessful party.” He concludes by praying, in the noble English of the Epis- copal liturgy, ‘ that all things may be so ordered and settled upon the best and surest foundation, that peace and happiness, truth and justice, religion and piety may be established among us for all cenerations.” The address is a clear, modest, and sensible docu- ment, which promises nothing which reasonable men may not hope to see performed, and leaves nothing untouched of which was desirable. nention The Cabinet at this writing is considered half formed. Of Mr. Evarts’s accession to the State Department, in case of the Repul lican success, there has never been any doubt, so plainly was he marked out for it by his talents, services, and character. tie has literally no competitor in the party. Mr. Sherman’s appointment to the Treasury, on the other hand, coupled with the probability that be will be the ruling spirit of the new Administration, will cause more or less apprehension among the friends of reform—not enough certainly to make them withhold their support from the new Administration, but enough to make them a little watchful and un- easy. If Mr. Sherman has, during his long service in the been in favor of civil-service reform in hostile to the ordinary methods of political mar voneealed it with a Senate, any shape whatever, or igement, he has hy success whieh mak ene fear that In
to the Constitution and the laws, and calls on men of |
Nation. very timid man. Then the triends of sound eney ¢ forget that though he has been on Whole in fa t return to specie payments, he has dodged about so and hee on such good terms with the intlationis hat nobody Knew where to find him at any particular junetur Phe pperters of tl public eredit, too, will remember with bitterness that when i 1-67, those two demagogues, 1 try by advocating the payment of the bonds in greenbacks Sherman strengthened their influence by 1 conversion of the five-twenties into a five per eent. bond, and ad vising the bondholders, in an elaborate speech, to aceept the re duction of interest without t] of being paid off, lest the 1 Option followers of Butler and Morton should beeome unce nal a worse thing happen them. Those who believe, as we do, that Haves’s title to the Presidency is as good as a ( have ‘ the circumstances ina government by law, w eve 3 St With regret in the present condition of the public mind th ance at the head of his Cabinet of one of the ** Visiting Statesme Whose presence encouraged the Louisiana Retur r Board int iniquity, and who afterwards whitewashed them in a most disi genuous report. Mr. Hayes’s best friends will be those least dis- posed to condone that most disereditable feature in the late eonuthet The remaining appointments, Messrs. Schurz, Met Key, will be received, we are sure, with hearty satistaction, and as a strong indication of the sincerity of Mr. Havyes's pr sions. That he has put Mr. Schurz in the ¢ net speaks highly for his courage, and we have no doubt illustrates his gratituc also, for Schurz is the one man who took an active part in the late canvass whose labors did not help to destroy the Repub lican majority. No man has, therefore, on the lowest party ground, a better claim to honor and reward than he, and there is no man whose presence in the Cabinet will furnish the publie better guarantee that Mr. Haves’s Administration is expected of it by those who voted for him. doing the But we have no doubt work that the fight with the politicians will begin over Mr. Sehurz, and that Mr. Haves’s ability to keep him will show whether he is the man for whom an afflicted people has for eight vears been praying. If he has confidence in the public, the greatest fame of the century except Lincoln’s is within his reach; but if this fails him, and he cries aloud in the perilous places for the managers to take him by the hand, he will be the greatest failure in American history. Grant had at least his military career bebind him. Congress adjourned at noon on Sunday after a session of nearly twenty-four hours. <All the appropriation bills went through, with the exception of the Army and the River and Harbor bills. The failure of the latter is of no particular moment, but as money will be needed for the support of the army by the end of May, a special session in the course of a few months is deemed unavoidable. The Forty-fourth Congress passed few general laws of mueh importance, gy and noticeable one. No bills to compromise the Par railroads; to extend the time for but the list of the bills that failed is a lon } progress has been made with the difficulties between the Government and the Bankrupt Act is still unrepealed; the bill Northern Pacifie The House bills for a further distribution of the Geneva award; for the resto- ration of the silver for the equalization of bounties; and for the transfer of Indian affairs to the War Department, all failed. The Texas and Pacific subsidy scheme got no further than a com- mittee’s favorable report could carry it, though it will, no doubt, be senate ifie the completing the road did not pass, Sta o GQowar s St as Congress comes together again, when the heard from as soon Pacific and Brazilian Mail subsidies, which also failed, may be re- vived. Ane th s whieh Mr. D. D. Field's me the meas failed were mo-rarranto Wil which received onls inthe House ule TINEA mm vote i
Page 2
The Nation. | I eK ( of the Senate began on Monday with the re eles { Mr. ke a lent pro tem. ind the swearing in the ewly-eleeted Senat nineteen in number, eleven Democrats and eight Republicans. A resolution was adopted that all disputed | redentials should lie over till the next day, consequently the eases f Lo (Ke 2), Mississippi (Morgan and Lamar), and South ( olina wre Corbin and Builer are contestants for the single ‘ al tcome upt 1‘ uesday, when spencer, of Ala- 1 to get a couple of votes to exelude Mr. Lamar. Mr. Lamar s defended by Mr. Blaine as prima-fucie elect, but erely as acover for securing the admission of Kellogg without dis- With the airs imported from the House be declaimed about the election of Hayes resting on identically the same basis as that Packard, and challenged the Administration torecognize Nicholls Mr. Blaine’s account of what the Commission had decided in regard to the Louisiana Returning Board was contradicted by Mr. Thur- man, and was contrary to the knowledge of every Senator, includ- g¢ Mr. Blaine himself. Au exchange of incivilities between Blaine ind Morton e1 the debate. of t appear on Monday to claim his s livened Governor Grover, Oregon, ot al aid me issued an address to ** the The Aine! the House have cinning with “a Democrats of review of the events which ‘lection of Rutherford B. Haves.” Two facts, tood out prominently in the eanvass—first, that the Re- publican party sought to unify the North against “the solid South,” d at the ican people,” te ‘resulted in the « ihey Sav, was busily sume time the South; second, that troops were sent to States in which “ there ‘ neither invasion nor insurrection to require them.” This is true, but the conelusion drawn that “in depositing their ballots they enjoyed only such liberty as the army permitted ” is ridiculous. They wlege that 196 Tilden electors were chosen, and that he got more than **one million majority of the Caucasian race”; that on the day after the election the Chairman of the Republican Na- tional Committee announced, ‘‘ although nothing had been learned of the election except the vote actually cast,” that 184 Tilden and 185 Hayes electors had been chosen. The conclusion they draw that an announcement could only have been made in pursuance from this is such un arrangement to change the vote shown to been by What they ought to have said was that “such an announcement justified the suspicion, ete.,” which, we think, no eandid man ean deny. They then charge cer- tain Florida and Louisiana Republicans with a conspiracy to cheat Democrats out of the Presidency (at which, they say, leading Republicans connived), and J. Madison Wells with having actually ol have given the per ple.” the engaged in dividing the votes of } | sold the decision of the Returning Board to the Republicans ifter having offered it for $200,000 to the Democrats. The latter of these accusations is, we believe, sufficiently proved, of the former there is no proof whatever. They recite the bis- tory of the Electoral Commission, maintain that its duty was | to ascertain whether the election in the disputed States had been fair, and that the public expected it to do so; assert vigorously that fraud vitiates everything; draw a mournful picture the probable consequences of the decision of the Commission ; that Hayes has been ‘ fraudulently elected” and is a dec are "and call on the people not to acquiesce, and to take Ol *usurper, every opportunity of * expressing their horror of the outrage.” address Massachusetts, Singleton of Mississippi, and Lynde of Wisconsin. deal of truth in the document, and less than the but the account of the Com- There is a great amount of extravagant language; and its proceedings is bighly evasive and unsatisfactory, discourse of much of the weight to which on other ustlal mission and deprives the grounds it would be entitled. The | is signed by Hurd of Ohio, Gibson of Louisiana, Abbott of The Democratic papers have, since the announcement of the re- | sult of the count, devoted themselves chiefly to denunciation of the frauds and perjuries of the Republicans, to wails over the state to | [Number 610 Usurper will now proceed to ruin himself. A week or two of this kind of thing nobody has any right to find fault with, but we trust it will not be kept up too long. If the Democrats mean to make an effective opposition they ought not to dream for a moment that Haves’s ‘‘ usurpation” will serve their turn for four years, or that they will be able to carry a majority of the States in 1880 because the eleetion of 1876 was carried with the help of the Returning Boards. Nine-tenths of the people throughout the country are heartily tired of the dispute that has been going on for the Jast four months, and are disposed to judge of the new Administration, what ever they may think of the character of its title, by what it actually does. If the Democrats wish to retain as much of the public con- fidence as they have undoubtedly gained by their behavior during the winter, they must do it by accepting the situation, and proving that their late professions of a desire fur reform sprang from a well-defined policy, which, whether in power or in oppo- ition, they mean try to carry They must insist on civil-service reform and revenue reform, and show themselves better reformers than the Republicans they oppose. They will not be afraid either, if they really have reform at heart, of alliances with nen of the opposite party which tend to further reform, any more than the Southern leaders have been afraid of acting with the Re- publicans to secure a settlement of the Presidential dispute. They may rely upon it that they can now do nothing more pleasing to the Republicans than to employ themselves in denouncing the ‘usurper,” because it distracts them from their proper business of watching carefully what the ‘‘usurper” is doing, and thus enables the latter’s *‘ wicked partners ” (a long and heated campaign always increases the membership of the firm enormously) to cook the to out. accounts, to make private contracts, to give themselves fat berths, and to reorganize the management of the concern in their own way. The Silver Commission has made a majority and minority re- port, the former signed by Messrs. Bland, Groesbeck, Jones, Bogy, and Willard, the latter by Messrs. Boutwell and Gibson and Pro- fessor Bowen. The testimony taken is probably, for those who are interested in the question, a good deal more valuable than the re- ports, though it ought to be said that the accounts in circulation of the manner in which it was taken are not very favorable, inas- much as they go to show that the majority went into the enquiry in search of a foregone conclusion, argued with the persons examined, and conducted the enquiry in the style of a lawyer trying a cause. The majority report maintains that the recent fall in the price of silver was not due to excessive production, as commonly supposed, but to the demonetization of silver by Germany and the United States and other countries, the diminution in the Asiatic demand x for it, and the spread of exaggerated reports as to the yield of the Nevada mines; attributes to this demonetization the prevailing busi- ness depression all over the civilized world, denounces gold as a poor and variable standard, the supply of which is diminishing, and recommends the free coinage of both metals as legal-tender to any amount; but the signers are unable to agree upon the relation in whieh gold aud silver should stand to each other, some proposing 155 and the others 15,4° The majority likewise allege that we cannot resume specie payments in gold alone, because there is not gold enough available for the purpose, and they reconmend the use of silver also, for reasons which are ap- parently not intended to be humorous. One that both ‘¢metals are fourd under our own flag,” and because as soon as we made silver a legal tender we should be flooded with the demonetized silver of Europe, which some people think very dread- ful, but which this majority think very desirable, for what is silver ‘(but money and one of the precious metals?” In other words, the more silver we bave the better, whatever may be its purchasing power; and they hold, moreover, that the fact that so many nations are adopting the gold standard is a reason why we should avoid it, as we could not sueceed “in the disastrous race” against them for gold—which leads us to wish that they had defined what they mean is which they have brought the country, and to predictions of how the | py ‘ standard.”
Page 3
Mar. 8, 1877 The minority report that the double standard, even if adopted, could not be maintained, inasmuch as the laws of trade, which govern the value of gold and silver like other commodities, would prevent it, and that it never has been maintained ; and show easily, by a simple reference to the market quotations of bullion, that if we made silver a legal tender side by side with gold the gold would at vice be exported, and we should be left to trade on silver alone, which, ** demonetized and discarded ” in other countries, would flow in on us from every quarter to play the part of a depreciated cur- reney. They declare also that the effect on the credit of the coun- try would be mischievous, inasmuch as when the act of 1862 was passed, setting aside the customs duties in coin for certain purposes, the standard of value wns practically gold, and the word * coin” was understood by the public creditor to mean gold. Moreover, if the duties were based on fluctuating silver, the importers would suffer all the inconvenience they now suffer from fluetuating paper, und we should be placed at a great disadvantage in our dealings with London, the great financial centre of the world, where the gold standard only is maintained The Louisiana case appears to remain in the same condition as last week. Last ‘Thursday the President sent a despatch to Pack- urd informing bim that troops could no longer be employed to up- hold either claimant, and on Saturday he announced that he had cancelled all orders for the preservation of the status quo ; that the people of Louisiana were henceforth ‘(as free in their affairs trom Federal interference as the people of Connecticut”; that if the Nicholls government should take possession of the offices ‘ without mob violence” there would be no military interference; and that a posse executing the process of a Nicholls court would be interfered With ‘*no more than in any other State.” The despatch to Pack- ard caused great consternation among his supporters in New Or- leaus and Washington, and led to a good deal of telegraphing back- ward and forward, the result of which is that the Nicholls party have very wisely postponed all action against Kellogg until the Louisiana ease can be finally acted on by the new Administration. Tbe position of affairs in South Carolina has been advanced one stage further by the decision of the Supreme Court of the Chamber- lain-lIlampton contest. ‘lhe matter came before the Court on ap- plication of a convict numed Tilda Norris, pardoned by Hampton, for her release from the penitentiary. It now appears that on the 27th of last month an order was entered in the case discharging the pri-oner. Judge Wright, the only negro on the bench, mani- tested hesitation in agreeing to the decision, but finally signed the order, begging at the same time for delay in the announcement of the decision, on account of his fears as to his personal safety. For the next two days and nights Wright was threatened, cajoled, argued with, brow-beaten, prayed to, and otherwise ** bulldozed.” This treatment had the desired effect, and he relented aud tried to get possessicn of the order for the purpose of erasing his signature Failing in this, he entered an order of his own withdrawing his signa- ture and substituting a dissenting opinion. On this the court came together, but the Chief-justice, Moses, being paralyzed, could not be present. Wright did not appear at all, and the sheriff had to be sent after him; but his return being “not found,” the opinion of the court was delivered by Judge Willard, who announced that the tinal order was entered on the 27th, that Judge Wright’s subse- quent order was of no effect, and that Hampton, having been duly elected, was governor of the State; that his pardon is consequently valid, and that the prisoner must be discharged. Tilda Norris was at once released. Almost every judge in South Carolina has now recognized, in one way or another, the Hampton government. The U. S. Treasury during the week notified the holders of $20,000,000 more 5-20 6 per cent. bonds that they would be re- deemed ninety days from the respective days of notification. This wakes a total of $100,000,000 5-20 6 per cent. bonds notified for re- demption since the furmation of the present Syadicate, all of which The N | have been replaced with 4's per cent. | ation. {+41 bonds. The main advar secured by the advance in the public credit to the point at 4's per cent. bond can be sold at or above par in gold is the redu tion of L's per cent. in the interest account of a considerable part of the public debt, no use having yet been made of this high ered to prepare for resumption. ‘The Wall Street markets were but lit tle affected by the political pews of the week; the crusade against railroad stocks was checked, and prices recovered part of the de cline of the preceding week. ‘The settlement of the Presidential contest was regarded by all classes as the harbinger of better times for every material interest. The gold value of the U.S. legal tender note for one dollar ranged during the week between S0.850% and x0.952:3. There is no very marked change in the Eastern situation. In so far as any change at a!l is perceptible, it is in the growth of an opinion that Russia does not wish to fight, and will not if it can be made easy for her to withdraw from her present position. Accord- ingly, there are schewes on foot for getting Turkey to offer some guarantee for her reforms that will satisfy Russian pride - such, fo instance, as a pledge, addressed to the Powers collectively, that the promised reforms will be carried out within a vear, of course on pain of military execution if default is again made. indeed, is that Russia is disposed to be satistied with something of this kind. The other and less hopeful view, and we are inelined to believe a more likely one, is that Russia is whiling away the mudd) season in notes and memoranda, kuowing full well that the mere delay is, in the present™ condition of Turkey, doing the work of a disastrous campaign, and so that it is within the bounds of proba bility that by May 1 there will be no need to tight. The Ottomar army on the Danube is now enormous, poorly equipped in ever) thing but arms, badly drilled and clothed and doctored, very sickly ot paid at all, and largely composed of levies who have left their fields untilled in Asia Minor, and know that their families run the risk of peiishing of famine next summer dissensions in the official class at Constantinople deep and _ bitter, and rumors o; the present Sultan’s folly and extravagance bezin to spread. In short, Turkey is bleeding at every pore, and there pay any day be a convulsion that will break up t the Mussulmans back on that old-fashioned ly, latanct “wan ’ The latest rumer, The treasury, too, is empty, the he govervment, throw plan of salvation, “a general massacre,” and compel the Powers to intervene, if for noth ing else, for proper division of the spoil. The elections to the new Turkish Parliament are going on, and there is by the constitution to be one deputy for every 50,000 in habitants; but in the absence of an electoral law regulating the manner of holding the elections, which the first Parliament is to yass, the members are on this occasion to be elected by the Pro- rincial Councils, which are composed mainly of Mussulmans, and the Christians they are sending up are said to be nunentities. Still it is doubtful whether they have much choice in the matter, as few Christians of any prominence have the courage to serve. Consul Holmes, who has lived thirty years in Turkey, has presented an in- teresting report to the British Government, giving his reasons foi thinking that all mixed representative bodies in Turkey must be farees and hindrances to good government. He says that the Christians who serve in such assemblies in the provinces are, if they venture to open their mouths at all, afraid to differ from their Mus sulman colleagues, and when, under instructions from his Minister he made efforts in Bosnia to get Christians of local prominence to enter them, he found they would not think of it, through fear ot ‘‘ getting into trouble.” Outrages continue to be reported from Bul A Turkish zaptieh, or gen 1 v garia. One of the latest is amusing. darme, being annoved by a Christian village mayor, saddled and bridled him, rede him up and down the village street, had hii groomed and fed with hay, and then tied him to a post in public, from which nobody ventured to release him until the zaptieh, atter some hours, relented.
Page 4
SINCE THE ELECTION. Vig j ( 1 ?t the ¢ | il , ol ‘ ‘ Conor the Re can ( it eer re ana als 1 | ‘ { ( duratio \ that of the Lf e few how iwi »reports ( hive believed. The disjointed ‘ ol tive ‘ i to fT ra utteranes Wel rad d had they been continued might have had a esome effect. They were checked, however, with great sud- denne oon as the discov wos made that there was vet some ehanee of the party’s continuance in power, and many zealous vial ould now be glad to blot out from newspaper files readers’ memories all record of those unhappy is understood that sackeloth and ashes had been donned too hastily, an entirely different attitude was taken and kept until the meeting of the Electoral College, or until the final decision of the Returning Boards of the “disputed” States. A typical ilustration of the bearing of the party during this period was furnished by the visiting Republicans who hastened to New In their letters to the nd in their subsequent report to the President the intentions of the party were set forth as plainly almost as Orieans the week following the election, Visiting Democrats a though declared in explicit language: These disputed electoral votes are bow Within our reach or may yet-be placed where we can grasp them, and although you Democrats now stand in the way and embarrass us somewhat, nevertheless, if we can manage to get areund you, we intend to have them. - The attitude assumed irre- sistibly suggested that of a dog Which, Gisecvering a joint of meat carelessly hung where he believes he ean reach it, would at once dash toward and seize it, but, observing a watcher, ebecks his in- tended course and assumes an appearance of innocence, without in the least givin soon as he can do so with safety. deings of the Republican party at.this time. It exhibited precisely such characteristics as, manifested under analogous circumstances by any single man, would inevitably cause him to be deseribed as a sneak. } the profits of criminal action on the part of others. Its prominent POLITICAL PARTIES | Nation [| Number 610 Honorable men were, of course, deeply grieved by this equivocal or scandalous position of their party, and afew managed to make them- selves heard in protest but were powerless to effect anything to the and *‘ managers” contr ‘Too many of the prominent ‘* workers ” had made up their minds that the desired vctes should be theirs, and their determination was either openly abetted or, at least, silently aequiesced in by an overwhelming majority of the party followers and party organs. What we have said with especial re- ference to Louisiana is equally applicable, with some necessary cor- rections, of course, and with somewhat less force, to South Carolina and Florida. The last attitude of the party, from the meeting of the Electoral College to the Ist of March, was that of Sullen detianee. The dog had got his joint and meant to keep it. The votes were tightly ; clutched, and any feeling of shame with reference to the manner of | rup his purpose of carrying off the coveted joint as | It is impossible to gloss over the } Though net guilty of positive crime, it was willing to reap | men beeame suddenly unable to perceive anything raseally in the | character ol not recollect that Sheridan, Grant, investigating committees, and Congress itself had, in different ways, formally pronounced judg- ment against the men for whose favorable decision they were now pleading. One very important fact should not be lost sight of here. If the men who composed the Returning Board of Louisiana bad been of well-tried and acknowledged probity, Republicans could not have been too anxious, even then, to throw the strongest light of These men, thus suddenly pushed | publicity upon all their actions. uch persons as Wells and his associates, and could into the position of judges over vast interests, were political bro- | thers and allies of the Republicans, or, at least, their creatures | and servants. The least appearance of wished-for concealment, | therefore, Was certain to beget suspicion of fraud or collusion. sensitive man would dread to have a case In private life any + decided in his faver by persons to whom he held similar rela- tions. When, therefore, this intimate relation between the lead- ers of the party and the members of the Returning Boards is considered in connection with the notoriously bad eharacter of some of the latter, and with the additional fact that many of them (more especially. however, in South Carolina and Florida) were in the position of bribed judges, inasmuch as they were can- didates for offices which might be acquired or lost by their own de- cisions, no candid man eau beli ized the attitude of the R whic h publicans during the dreary weeks in we waited for the decision from the “ doubtful” States. that we have unjustly charaeter- | their acquisition was suppressed by the intensity of the determina- tion that not one should be given up until safely counted. But how could the votes be safely counted with any show of legal justifica- tion? Not, certainly, by any law or precedent adopted or estab- lished by the Republicans during their sixteen years’ control of the Government. The Twenty-second Joint Rule, enacted by them- selves to meet the exigencies of former counts, if now followed, would defeat them; so would their own precedent with reference to Louisiana. The principles of Morton's Electoral Bill, which many | of them had earnestly favored less than a year before, if now adopted would bring the same result. Something new was needed, | ie et , : ‘ |} and was accordingly invented, for only as an invention can we de- seribe the project that the President of the Senate should count whatever votes commended themselves to his judgment as valid. A scheme, accepted because a certain chair was oceupied by a Re- publican, which would not have been thought of if a Democrat had been seated in the same place, does not require rational considera- tion. In favor of this scheme, nevertheless, many of the party leaders defiantly stood firm for at least six weeks, or until the fears of Democratic violence, the opinion of the decent men of the party, and an outraged public sentiment required its relinquishment. But they did not willingly abandon it even then. Fifty-four Republican memters of Congress voted, indeed, for the establishment of the Electoral Commission, but eighty-four Republican members voted against it, and to the Democrats, therefore, must be accorded the credit of the passage of the measure which saved the country from possible anarehy and enabled the Republicans to convey their chosen President “unchallenged to bis chair.” The selection of Morton as a member of the Electoral Commission, an outrageous impropriety from almost any point of view—as great, for instance, as would have been our putting Ben. Butler on the Geneva Tribu- nal—was, nevertheless, fully in keeping with other party practices from the beginning of the unfortunate controversy. There is a great deal, undoubtedly, in the words and actions of individual Republicans which contrasts sharply with the above unpleasant exhibition, but in the course of the party as a party there is almost nothing in the history of the past four months which any member, good or bad, would not be glad to have forgotten. If, now, we cousider the course of the Demoeratie party during the same period and in connection with the same events, we have coneessions to make with which the country has been lung un- familiar. The invitation sent by the visiting Democrats at New Orleans to the Republicans to meet in conference, “ in order to exert influence in favor of an honest count and true return of the votes,” was reasonable and commendable from any point of view save that of a designing Republican ; and the report of the same Democrats, subsequently made, was certainly a more complete document than that of the Republicans, and, in its admission of “ irregularities ” and “the evidence of intimidation and violence on both sides,” a more eandid one also. Of all the dismal investigations subsequent to the election, moreover, the only unpartisan report we now recall wis that made by a Democratic committee which declared that South Carolina had voted for Hayes. ‘The position of the more ex- reme Democrats with referenee to the counting of the votes—that
Page 5
Mar. 8, 1877] The N the House bad exclusive power—-was certainly as violent as that of the Republicans, but it never had the support of the better mem- bers of the party, and was adopted by others rather as an offset to the scheme of the Republicans than because of any real belief that it could be sustained. We have already conceded to the Democrats the chief share of credit in the establishment of the Electoral Commission ; and in the acceptance of its decisions, in spite of severe temptation to the contrary, all credit, of course, belongs to them. It must not be for- gotten here that the Democrats had tenfold more cause to be dis- satisfied with the decision of the Commission than the Republicans would have had if the decision had been reversed. The Democrats fully believed (whatever the fact) that Tilden was fairly elected, and had perfect confidence, moreover, that the Commission would so decide. Thiscontidence, indeed, was fully shared by Sherman, Blaine Morton, Garfield, Hale, and other Republicans, and furnished them with a sufficient reason for opposing the Commission’s formation. Very many leading Democrats, moreover, undoubtedly believed that the Republiean party, first, by conniving with rascally Return- ing Boards, and, second, by partisan decisions in the Electoral Commission, was fraudulently depriving them cf the fruits of hard-fought and fairly-won battle. That they were willing, under the circumstances, to stand by their agreement, and to abide by the decisions of the Commission, may have been nothing more than they ought to have done, but was, nevertheless, a sign of political Virtue such as the best Republicans may be thankful they were not called upon to exhibit. That some of their number indulged in Vigorous and indignant protestations is a faet which an honest Republican must judge by putting himself in their place. That there was not more excitement under the circumstances is some - thing to be wondered at. The conduct of the “filibustering ” Democrats was bad enough, but was more than counterbalanced by that of the more reputable members of the party; for, at the last, the peaceful inauguration of Hayes was made _ possible only by the firmness of Randall, the Speaker—a man who has never been suspected of saintliness or of excessive love for the animating principles of *‘ the party of moral ideas.” The misconduct of the Democrats during the crisis has, in facet, consisted almost wholly in intemperance of language. Their sole recourse to legal fraud was in the Oregon affair, and would that we could say the Florida and Louisiana juggles had received as little countenance or support from the Republican chiefs as the Oregon juggle did from the Democrats! The appearance of the terrible David Dudley Field in the last session of Congress was damaging to them mainly because of his prominence as an investigator ; as a simple “statesman” they would have suffered but little from him. In faet, as far as their course taken altogether during the elee- toral crisis is concerned, it is impossible to deny that they have gained in credit and the Republicans have lost, and if the Demo- cratic party were not apparently doomed to fatuous leadership it would give the country during the coming Presidential term what it has so long and so sorely needed—a strong opposition pos- sessing some moral weight with the best portion of the people. The address just issued by the House Demucrats, however, does not encourage much hope on this seore, for it ends with a scream- ing recommendation to follow the course most sure to disgust the public, and again close the political future to the party, namely, the pursuit of Hayes with a factious hostility, on the ground that he is not lawfully elected. It is extraordinary that politicians of the smallest experience and sagacity bce 1 fail to see that Hayes is now the President of the United tes, and the only one there is or can be, and that popular ceniillena a support will inevitably be gathered to him, therefore, in view cof the fact that, good or bad. he represents the nation to the world. All impugning of his title, and all heaping of insults on him now on the score of “fraud,” will very soon touch the national pride, and cover those engaged in it with an odium which nobody who remembers how much national pride has to do with the success of free government will be sorry to witness. ation. 145 THE GRANGER DECISIONS. i. Supreme Court has decided the various cases kno Granger Cases,’ and arising out of the ** Granger Movement ” of three years ago, between the States of Hlinois, Wiseonsin, low and Minnesota, and the proorietors of ( il tod railroad companies in those States, touching the power of the State Leg tures to regulate the charges made for the storage of g transportation of freight and passengers. The decision is, in su stance, that the commen-law power of the State governm culate ferries, common carriers, hackinen, bakers, millers, what gers, innkeepers, ete., applies to railroads and that it has in no way been diminished and res ad by t C stitution of the United States, and that the State | lature the right to decide by statute, if they rates ” of transportation. Two yvears ago thi have created a good deal of excitement, and probably ve | ] } serious effeet on the market value of railroad property ~ from which the appeals were taken. Since then railroads, in which the legislation fixing rates ot appeared, and the Granger movement itself, political fore collapsed, so that the haee mis not now likely to have y marked immediate influence. Some of its indirect and remete consequ S are, however, worth the attention of investors, and we may be p doned for repeating on this subject some of the Harks wa on it three years ago, When the Granger fury was at its heig! grave and sensible men were found recdy to aceept the ideas wh ic lay behind the * Potter Law,” as if they we hereaiter part of the order of nature. The decision of the Supreme Court leaves the raviroads ot country in precisely the same position towards the Government as { railroads of all civilized countries. In all of them the state h power of regulation and control, and no one doulits the reasona ness and expedieney of its exercising that power, nor does its doing se in any way diminish the value of the property. There is a Railre Commission now sitting in England which has powers of interference with the working of railroads such as no body in existence in t] COUNLTY possesses, pie such as have never been claimed tor agent of the state, and it exercises those powers nearly every we It prevents unfair discrimination in trains or location of stations, and in ftaet exercises on the cor of persons aggrieved a supervision of the relations of the railroad | corporations to the country such as the Grangers in their hottest days never asked for: and this is true, with modifieations, of Government supervision of railroads on the Continent. Whe we go the state meddles with the railroads and treats them as eom mon carriers; but nowhere except in the Western States of the Union does such interference, or the threat of it. excite alarm and ce preciate the property ot the stoekholders. The reason of this is that in no other civilized states is corporate property, or any property, in any way devoted to public use, ex posed as is in the — m States to damage or depreciation through gusts of popular passion. It is one thing to have rates regulated in a ealm at oy idicial spirit by persons equally careful for the rights of railroad proprietors and those of the public, and desi ig for the 2 and another to have it do ne at the demand of an excited multitude road proprietors as public enemies, and rous of providit eneral comfort without alarming capital, } by agents who regard | celebrate victories ove! them in the courts as great political triumphs with firing of guns, as the governor of Wisconsin did three vears ago. Nobody likes to hold property which it is in the vainst whom there is no power of a hot-headed, passionate man, a appeal, to injure or destroy, and the feeling of security is net Te sened by his being sorry for the mischief he has done when his furs In over. Now, this is very much the condition of raiiroad property in cer- tain States of the West. They are exposed, as the Granger move as shown, to wild bursts of hostility in which reason and expe- rience are laid aside, and which result in Jegislation which, as usual
Page 6
nt have the largest share in framing. of faet, that nobody in the Wisconsin Legis- lature out railroads than the Mr. Potter who drew the Potter N the disappearance of the Granger movement suf- { ( Speculators or very rich men may not ed with contiseation and having the value of ds lowered for two vears at atime, but the bulk of tl s form the greater part of the capital invested ( ey enough nor nerve enough for such l eek, above all things, security for their pro- ( for their minds. They are ill-prepared, at be ‘ ecast the effeet on their fortunes of the ordinary and leit te thuctuations of business ; they are not prepared at all to ie turns and twists of State polities or find out what are the the people ” with regard to ‘¢the bloated corporations ” they form a part, and even two years of alarm and anxiety ( h to sieken and disgust most of them. What is to be feared now from the decision of the Supreme ( ( iV immediate attack of the State legislatures on rail- erty, but a strong stimulus to threatening legislation here- fter, or, in other words, the practice known as “striking,” on the part of the tribe of impecunious politicians who form the noisier and re active element in State legislatures, and the consequent deep- ening of the corruption whieh already marks the relations of the reat railroad companies with these bodies. Nothing could well be more unfortunate for the best interests of the West than that the establishment of the State supremacy over the roads, beyond fur- ther question or appeal, should result in the surrender of the roads by the people to even fitful extortion at the hands of the politicians. All that the West most needs and most values must come from the well-settled faith of the people all over the world who have money to lend or invest that its State legislation is, in all that relates to property, stable and sober-minded, and that nobody who lets his money get within the jurisdiction of the State government has to fear the imposition of unforeseen or onerous or unfair conditions on his enjoyinent of it. Nothing in this involves the exemption of railroads from proper control, and there is no doubt they have got nte lax notions of their duty to the public and their owners on various important matters; but nothing can be more certain than that, in the long run, no machinery any American State can create vill be half as likely as these managers themselves to regulate rates in a manner to promote the best interests of the public. In r, in other to tempt as large a body of the people as possible to fixing his rates every manager is ‘* seeking for business,” « words, trying employ him, and for his sagacity and self-interest in this matter there is in our society no possible substitute. He may make mis- takes, but he cannot make them long without being discovered by the laws of trade and punished with a thoroughness and vigor which no political administration ean equal or even approach. {t has to be remembered, too, that the common-law doctrines with regard to the regulation of various callings which the Supreme Court has applied to the railroads took their rise at a period when minute regulation was looked on as the great function of govern- ment and little was left to popular sagacity in the choice or wode of anv business whatever. It was not the business of common carriers only which the state overlooked, but that of nearly evers \ kind of laborer and manufacturer. ‘The folly of most of this legis- iF rh cen made fully manifest; but that a portion of it. still has its uses, and that there is no absolute rule to oppose to it Iso undoubtedly true. It does not follow that because it was unwise to fix the price of corn or bread, or the charges of millers, it is now unwise to fix or regulate hacks, or put limits to the prices which practical monopolies like railroads put on their services. But in settling this matter, like all other politico- commercial or politico-tinancial matters, Wwe have to be guided by the common sense and business principles which we use in the management of our private affairs. It is not rational to tear one’s hair or fly into a furious passion in considering how to protect one’s elf awainst railroad extortion or abuses, any more than to go down The Nation. | } | | | [Number 610 to one’s store determined to knock down the first man who offers less than a fair price for one’s goods. A common carrier is not ex vi termini a Common rogue; he is a man performing a very useful function, prone, like other people, to consider his own advantage more than that of those whom he serves, but nevertheless to be restrained like other people by careful and well-considered weans, formed not with the view of getting the apparent worth of our Inoney out of him to-morrow or the next day, but with the view of promoting bis move distant usefulness, encouraging competition in his business, and spreading the reputation of the State as a body whose credit is good, whose promises are trustworthy, and whom it is profitable to serve faithfully. THE NEW SEVIGNE CORRESPONDENCE Paris, February 9. HARDLY know any title for a book which could be more interesting | than this: ‘Inedited Letters from Madame de Sévigné to Madsine de Grignan,’ and here are actually two volumes, which are to form the supple- ment to Hachette’s great edition of Madame de S¢évigné. I confess my partiality for the oldest editions of every work. Few people are happy enough to possess the first collection of the letters of Madame de Sévigné, printed in 1725 at Troyes. This small volume, made up of ** choice letters,” is hardly to be found. The edition which, even among the bibliophiles, long passed for the first was printed a year afterwards, in 1726. In its two volumes you have not only an exact text of the letters but you have also what I may eall the fower of that most amiable, charming, and delightful Whoever will read and re-read these two volumes will know her Then came the edi- woman. well, and not only her but her little court of friends | tion of 1735-37, in six volumes, published ‘by the care of the Chevaiier | tened the unruly locks ; Rollin. He was devoted to the memory of Madame de Sévigné, but, alas ! he thought he could improve her style ; he corrected her letters, as a pedan- tic schoolmaster would correct the letter of a young child. This conscien- tious and learned iconoclast rubbed the bloom off the peach of Madaine de her incorrectness alarmed him ; he combed her, he flat he thought he could make her presentable to pos- Sévigne’s style; terity. Our time, which has many defects, has at least one quality : we look everywhere in literature for the real text, we try to see the work of art exactly as it came out of the creative mind. This is the reason why such ¢ extravagant prices are given for the original edilions of our great clas ‘The edition of Madame de Sévigné which we owe to the consecien- sics | tious M. Régnier is a monument of care and exactitude ; but epistolary literature has this characteristic, that it can hardly ever give anything definitive. Just at the moment when the great edition of Hachette was ended, M. Charles Capmas, professor at the law school of Dijon, made an extraordinary discovery. It was known that some manuscript copies of Madame de Sévigné’s letters had been made in old times. There was one copy in a chateau in Burgundy, which was not far distant from Bourbilly, | one of the seats of the Rabutins. J/abent sua fata libelli. 1 will not at | tempt to explain how this precious manuscript was for sale in January, 1872, with the furniture of a house, after the death of an inhabitant of A woman who sells old furniture and bric-d-brae in she bought a part of the furniture, and, Semur-en-Auxois. Dijon was present at the sale ; | accidentally, the manuscript ; this poor manuscript remained for fifteen months in her shop at Dijon, sometimes exposed to the rain. If any passer- by glanced over it he threw the manuscript away with contempt. M. Capmas bought in March, 1873, for eighteen francs, the six volumes in 4to, each of more than 400 pages. He took the pains to study these volumes, and found, to his great joy, that they contained three hundred and twenty letters which were unknown ; all these letters are addressed to Madame de Grignan. The Dijon manuscript nearly doubles, therefore, the correspon- dence of the marchioness with her daughter, as there were only about three hundred letters to Madame de Grignan known to this day. Of this maternal correspondence we can only say what Madame de Sévigné says herself ; ** I give you with pleasure the flower of all the baskets (la fleur de tous les paniers)—that is to say, the flower of my Spirit, of my head, of my eyes, of my pen, of my inkstand ; the rest goes as it can, I amuse myself with you while I plough with the others.” M. Capmas has thought himself obliged to tell the story of his discovery in the most minute details, and he has entered into a very long comparison of his manuscript with another manuscript which was written at the begin- ning of the eighteenth century, and which is commonly called the Gros-
Page 7
————n The Mar. 8, 1877] bois, as it was a part of the rich library of the Chateau of Grosbois in | Burgundy. This manuscript, a heavy folio of 1,052 pages, had been placed | at the disposition of M. de Monmerqué, who spoke of it in 1827, and who really began the great edition of Hachette which was only ended a few years ago. The Grosbois manuscript is now in the possession of the D'Har court family, and M. Capmas was allowed to see it and to make an ela- | borate comparison between it and his own manuscript. I confess that | the professor of Dijon has been unsparing in the uccount of his long analysis of these two copies, It is even a pity that so light a venlus as Madame de Sévigné should become the subject of ponderous criticism The scholiasts of the Middle Ages and of the Renaissance were not half so There should be some fit- ness in things. We ought to be thankful to M. Capmas for all the trouble prolix as the new lover of Madame de Sévigné. he has taken ; but why does he wish to make us suffer ourselves ¢ His in troduction of 240 pages is really terrible M. Capmas had first the idea of publishing himself a complete edition | of Madame de Sévigné, and of inserting among the letters already known the new letters to Madame de Grignan which he had found in the Dijon manuscript. He changed his mind and took a middle course ; be has pub- lished not only the inedited letters, but also those which were inc omplete in the Grosbois manuscript or the ancient editions of Madame de Sévigné. In all the former editions the correspondence of the Marquise with Madame de Grignan, which began in 1671, ends in 1690; in reality it continued four years longer. In 1690 Madame de Sévigné went from Brittany, across France, to Grignan, a journey which at that time lasted twenty days. She remained fourteen months in Provence, and returned to Paris in the last days of December, 1691, in company with Madame de Grignan ; they re- mained together till 1694 ; but Madame de Grignan was then obliged to go back to Provence, and her mother could not follow her immediately We have, therefore, in this correspondence of the year 1694, inedited till now the novissima verva of the charming woman, the last rays of her esprit; and, curiously enough, there is no trace of sadness or of melancholy in this part of the correspondence. While Madame de Grignan was in the first bloom of youth and beauty, the friendship of Madame de Sévigne, as we know by her letters, had sometimes to suffer ; her affection was perhaps too morbid, too inquisitive, too nervous ; and the * plus jolie fille du monde ” could hardly understand the full value of her admirable mother. Time and separation did something for Madame de Grignan ; and it may well be imagined that towards 1694 she valued her mother more than towards 1670 ; she did not love her more perhaps, but her love became more in- telligent. Madame de Sévigné had a seconde jeunesse in this increase of devotion on the part of her daughter ; and this may, perhaps, explain why this inedited part of her correspondence bears hardly any trace of the effect of age Can anything, for instance, in the correspondence of the former vears be better than this letter of the 19th April, 1694 ? To-day ends the long magnificence of the marriage of Mile. de Louvois. For two months the presents have been exhibited ; lL wonder that they have not been plundered. Monsieur de Reims gave, besides many louis (which accompanied those of Madame la Chanceli¢re and of Madame de Bois-Dauphin, and those of one of the corners of the jewel-box of the Maré- chale de Villeroi), two earrings which you used to see and admire at the late Mademoiselle’s, which were valued at 12,000 ées ; he got them for 13,000 francs, and throws them to the two or the four or six ears which I wish his niece might have. Well! this poor creature, burdened like Midas with the gold which she carries, is now with her grandmother, the Chanceliére, with all her noble company, where they will read and sign the contract. At eight o’clock, the company goes to Madame de Louvois’s, where M. de Langl‘e, to help her, takes care of the supper—five tables of twenty persons each, served as at Psyche. Six hundred pistoles have been thrown away for to-night’s clean little repast. M.de la Rochefoucauld alone, with a little hardness and inhumanity, refuses the honor of his presence to this great feast, where all the Dukes, the Estrées, the Armagnacs, the Brissaes, and others take pleasure in showing themselves.” ' When Madame de Sévigné wrote these lines she was already sixty-eight years old ; in former days she had narrated the marriage of the eldest daughter of Louvois ; now she was speaking of the marriage of the second The last page of M. Capmas’s book might in truth be called a literary relic The day before Madame de Sévigné left for Grignan, where death was await- ing her, she wrote to her daughter (10th May, 1694) : ** Indeed, it isa strange thing to start and to leave one’s place as we do ; one pities one’s self ; one has nothing more left ; the furniture is sold. But 1 am too happy to go and see you, and embrace you, and to leave a place where ev rybody will soon die. ’’ She was to die first ; the incomparable mother's days were already counted. She preserved her gaiety to the end, that gaiety which was, so to speak, the vestment of purity and of virtue. Sévigné was, in fact. a true philosopher. and she was all the more admirable in that she bad a tenderness of heart which is not always found in the breasts of phi- Nation. 145 ~ k SO} hers. It is delightful to find in these inedited letters new irks f untiring affection for her light-hearted son, the Marquis de Seévigne ; { good Abbé de Coulanges, whom she called the ** bien bon”; for all her w known friends and relations—Emmanuel de Coulanges, Madam: { £ , langes, the Chevalier de Grignan, for ( he was paying a heavy penalty for the faults of his pen at bridled imagination. Every year he wrote abject letters to the ku would not allow him to leave his splendid exil Bussv wi a al best generals of his time, and he was condemned 1 ive in the countrs adorning his gardens and his chateau. He had been indelicate ev his charming cousin ; still, we will forgive him something, as he was tl first man who admired and felt the great genius that Was in her let ‘ be classed first in the list of those who have ven the Nighest nk Madame de Sévigné among the classies of the seventee enturs WAGNER'S ONLY COMIC OPERA Mesicn, February #187 i ies romantic whims and eccentricities of the present Wing of B have given rise to much unfavorable and sarea: ment iS after all, it seems better that a king should spend his leisure re and surplus money in having operas performed for his sole be {, at structing greenhouses with artificial full moot lt roof of | than that he should resort to war and the other fashionable amusem the monarchs of bygone ages. If political history will say little of 1 l1., his name will be the more prominent in the history of art. Evervbody knows what he has done for Wagner, and that but for his material assist ance the Bavreuth stage festival would not vet Ve | Thanks, also, to his genuine taste for art, Munich, though containing t 180,000 souls, has a dramatic and operatic stage in many respects the fh in Europe. This winter all the dramas of Schiller are being produced | g in all parts and a br in succession, with a perfection of actin scenic outfit which they have never received on any other stage. In M a German version of the ** Frogs” of Aristophanes will be brought out stage modelled after the Greek ; and other works ate produced here wt are seldom seen on any other stage, such as Byron's ** Manfre Sehumann’s music, and Goethe’s ** Egmont” with Beethoven's cor music. But, in particular, to attend the performance of a Wagner in this city is quite a different thing from hearing the same work as per formed in Vienna, or even in Berlin. In the latter city, and still more in Vienna, these operas are given with a number of red-pencil marks ‘euts” and other traditional operatic licenses, which render them rather unsatisfactory to one Whose musical intelligence is sufficiently advances appreciate the organie unity of the musie drama Here. however, n | proc eedings are { lerate 1, and the works ire rendered as ] Seiya it in accordance with the intention and spirit of the composer. Considerable excitement has prevailed here of late in the circles of tl musical liberals, owing to the performances of the ** Meistersinger,” had not been heard in this city for three vears, and for the ¢ ment which the brilliant suecess of the ** Nibelung” performances at Bayreuth had sharpened the appetites of all. The ‘* Meistersinger ’ is one of Wag ner’s must mature works, having been composed even after ‘* Tristan und Isolde,” which he himself regards as the nearest approach to his ideal of i the art-work of the future, and which itself followed ** Rheingold” and the ** Walkiire,” the first two dramas of the trilogy. The plot of the ‘* Mei tersinger,”’ however, belongs to a much earlier period, having been con ceived before that of ‘** Lohengrin.” Immediately after completing the score of ** Tannhiiuser,” the composer visited one of the Bobemian summer resorts, and there, partly urged by some friends, who desired him to essay his powers in some other than the tragic field, originated the idea of writ ing a comie opera, to follow ** Tannhiauser,” just as among the Greeks a Sutyrspt. 7 was wont to f llow the performance of a tragedy In the XIIth and XIIIth centuries poetry and song were entirely in thy hands of the troubadours in Provence and the Minnesingers in Germany They were chiefly knights and other noblemen, kings and princes even being found among their numbers. But gradually the higher classes lost their interest in such pursuits, and the cultivation of song and poetry wa transferred to the artisans in the towns—to the tailors, shoemakers, wea vers, and other Meister, who formed societies and fostered the Meise gesang. in accordance with a large number of fixed, conventional rules of amazing complexity and artificiality. One of the chief seats of these Meistersingers was Niirnberg, which at the time of the ins mortal **Hans Sachs. cobbler.” in the middl f the XVIth_ centu had more than two hundred and fifty of them into this circle
Page 8
144 i { ‘ 1, | in 1 , J V \ i T i for th I ] mich } } mV « | . | | 1h \ ‘ VJ I \ t spirited and wonderfully n heard on concert l ! " the in- , i nerecat nl fen nel ‘cel t} ist | which « t | tt Middle A In i tier rr re thie | nv t ne knight. Walther von ir de whos mi o re As the neregation ind to confess h ove, but i ly betrothed To-morrow. she \I \ ly the yn t the festival { it that, happen what will, 1 leaves with her purse ne the preparations which are ! ersinge! Pending their arrival Ifans Sachs, endeavors to initiate i nd ru if the musical code or tabulature \ { they appear, coming in im groups of two | 1 Pogner then announces to his colleagues wd from Eva. The knight now steps forward lin e worthv s ind to be allowed to to the disgust of one of their number, neeited, and disagreeable character, who \ 1 Ss v rival, s all the other JMhisters are | lo proy his fitness for the desired e is required to sing a song, in which, if he de- nine time from the rules of the = tabulature, Americans would say, is ** plaved out.” A chair is while Beckmesser takes his stand behind a r marker, in order to note down on a blackboard every of the tabulature. Walther’s song is only half-ended Who has all the time been scratching away audibly, nd holds up the board, all covered with marks. Most with him as to the complete fieseo of the knight ; his all traditional! forms and usages—no cadences and wliishments, and **of melody not atrace.” But Hans sfavor. Ile finds the sons ** new vet not confused,” to measure by their own rules that of which they Ll the rules. But, in spite of this, the masters unan- lat h s/ Of the inevitable three dramatically and musically, the least interesting int and ever-varying instrumentation, parts of it jut it should be remembered that instrumentation, ‘tone-colors,” is Just as important an element in my, and rhythin, and that its gradual development ' tius as that of those other elements. Re- it t act contains most of the theme-buds which are unfolded into full blessom. By means of the ! the paris of a Wagnerian music-drama, as in a per- uta, correlated and intimately united. One feels ul am I com- ntel bird’s eve view of the whole before he And i y miracteristic of a real work of art, | ruisties the new music-drama from the patch- oO ' h its unconnected string of ** thematically j s lone *Gotterdiimmerung.” The per- t six and ends at eleven. At Bayreuth an intermis- n two acts of each drama was alwavs made for | nstunces and aims unfortunately do not allow lin an evening performance in a modern Ger { ifteen minutes for refreshments” and a short irtain rises on the second act, showing one of those ts in old Niirnberg, smelling of feudal times the humble house of Hans Sachs, to the Pogner We see and hear first a score Ly ! {f David, who has been discovered to s through the latter that Wal- The knight appears, and, after pas t! le - of the Meistersingers, the twe t 1 But their plan is frustrated. That small Ger- Mil \ves (still surviving in some Natiogn. | Number 610 man towns), the night-watchman, comes up the street with his lantern, and tha loud sing- song voice that the clock hasstruck ten. The lovers behind the bushes in front of Pogner’s house. This danger ous one presents itself. Around the corner of the house thes yre is heard. Beckmesser is about to sing a serenade to Eva. But t nite disgust Sachs, who has an eye on the fugitive lovers, at this moment carries out his work-bench in front of the house, and begins to hammer away and to sing in a loud voice some coarse shoemaker songs Becks r entreats, commands him to stop, several times beginning his serenade, but in vain. The details of the whole scene are exceedingly ( The altereation and noise finally reach such a pitch that t] indignant neighbors are aroused from their slumbers. David Magdalena looking out of the window to which Beckmesser’s song is directed, he attacks the unhappy musician seeing and, and heats him most unmercifully, The street is soon filled with appren- An infernal cene of terrible confusion ensue, comparable only to the mob- the the women, Who are looking out of all the windows on the scene below. Sud- tices and workmen of all trades, who take sides in the quarrel. scene in Schiller’s ** Fiesco.” The noise is inereased by cries of denly the horn of the watchman is heard, not far off, and in a second the crowd has dispersed. The sudden contrast is most amusing, as the wateh- man slowly comes down the street, blowing his immense cow-horn and solemnly proclaiming the eleventh hour. The curtain drops on act the second, which, from beginning to end, abounds in genuine humor, gro- tesque effects, and well-seasoned sarcasm ; and is in these respects equal to the third, the longest and the best of the acts. With the exception of ** Rienzi” all the stage-works of Wagner are divided into three acts, and, moreover, he seems to show a remarkable partiality for introductions to his third acts. So those in ‘* Siegfried,” Tristan,” ** Lohengrin,” ‘* Walkiire,” and ‘ Meistersinger” are among the very finest efforts of his genius, and go some way towards disproving his own dogma, that pure instrumental music had reached its highest de- velopment before his time. A deeply meditative spirit pervades the intro- duction to the last act of the ‘ Meistersinger.” It is exactly what one might imagine an ideal introduction to the first scene of Goethe’s * Faust ” Hlans Sachs sits in his room reading in a large folio, and engaged in pessimistic reflec- to be, and reveals the hand of the composer of ** Tristan.” tions on the scenes of the last day and night, and the weaknesses and fol- lies of mankind in general. He is interrupted by David, who comes to congratulate him on his birthday, sings his apprentice-song about St. John on the banks of the Jordan, advises his master to marry again, and leaves, glad that he is not taken to task for bis pugnacious conduct of last night. Walther now enters and tells Sachs a wonderful dream which he Sachs carefully Thus, from an unexpected quarter, is the knight equipped for the coming contest. After they have gone to pre- had during the night—Walther’s well-known prize-song. notes it down on a slip of paper. pare for the festival, Beckmesser enters, finds the paper lying on the table, There is time Sachis and quickly puts it in his pocket. A new song by Sachs ! left for him to learn it, and with it he must surely win the prize returns, discovers the theft, but tells Beckmesser he may keep the poem and The latter rushes out, wild with joy. One of her shoes does not quite fit. use it. Eva enters, richly dressed in While Sachs makes it right, Walther returns, and, dazzled by the beauty of his expected bride, addresses white. to hera verse of his song. David and Magdalena also appear, and, mirabie dictu, the scene ends in a quintette—a genuine and most delightful quin- tette, by Richard Wagner of Bayreuth, in one of his latest works! It is said, though with what degree of truth I know not, that Wagner wanted to remove this relic of operatic barbarism from his work, but, on the soli- And it surely would It would be out-Wagnering Wagner not to permit for once in five hours an interruption of the dramatic action for-the And now wide citation of some friends, was induced to leave it. have been a pity to remove it. sake of such an inspiring and sublime piece of absolute music. follows the grandest part of the opera. The meadow, with a most imposing view of the whole city of Niirnberg in the Floral decorations, men, women, and children in festive A chorus of shoemakers sing the praises scene changes to a background, attire, singing and dancing. of St. ¢ rispin, who stole the leather from the rich to make shoes for the tailors tell of the patriotic feats of one of their number who was sewed up mn a goat-skin, and, by frisking about on the city The bakers The whole scene is poetically and musically of a the poor ; wall, induced the enemy to raise the siege in despair. also have their song. nost exuberant humor, and one wave after another of half-suppressed the house. At last the sounds of that glorious march which has the same laughter Meistersinger come march- crosses the ing aiong to ——
Page 9
Mar. 8, 1S77 | | inspiring effect on the hearer that ** God save the Queen” has on a London audience, or “* Die Wacht am Rhein” on a band of German soldiers. On an eminence quickly constructed with pieces of turf Beckmesser now takes his stand, confused and trembling : but his ill gotten song is too much for him. His memory fails him, and he is obliged (to use a college phrase) to | ‘erib” several times from his manuscript. Of the text he makes the most Judicrous nonsense, and his melody is a capital parody of the Italian aria, with all its bombastic vocal embellishments. The people interrupt him seve ral times with exclamations of surprise, and finally his song is drowned by their laughter and cries of derision. Enraged, he throws the manuscript on the ground, and exclaims it is not his—Hans Sachs is the author. Sachs explains that the poem is good, only it must be properly rendered. It is ‘an sing its proper melody shall receive the prize Walter steps forward, fulfils these conditions, and wins the bride. A jubi agreed that he who lant outburst of fall orchestra and chorus, with swinging of hats and hand- } kerchiefs, follows, and the curtain drops on this most realistic and lively ? ¢ exfest, Which must arouse the enthusiasm of representation of a German Vo he most pronounced music-Puritan and conservative. It would be interesting, if space allowed, to examine how far the ‘* Meistersinger ” deserves the name of ** opera,” and how far it belongs to the species of music-dramas. A few of iis points of agreement and dif- ference with the ‘* Ring des Nibelungen” and ** Tristan” may be briefly mentioned. It differs from the representative works mentioned in having a historical instead of the orthodox mythical sbject ; in returning from alliterative verse to rhyme: in containing a quintette, and giving considerable prominence to the choruses, of which the whole trilogy contains only two, and “Tristan” not one. The points of resem- blance, however, are more significant—a “national”? subject; the full symphonic orchestra, adding to all the modern resourees of color- ing some revived from the Middle Ages, and never degraded to perform the function of a guitar, accompanying a vocal solo ; the em- ployment and skilful contrapuntal interweaving of leading motives or themes characterizing persons and situations, so useful in the drama for combining past with present impressions ; and, finally, the conscientious avoidance of threadbare phrases and cadences. Wagner's musical sty} bears some resemblance to the literary styie of Tacitus, is always concise and suggestive, and abhors the Ciceronian music-rhetoric of a Mendelssohn— elegant language with meagre contents. His melodies are always short and rich. They float in the ever-changing and turbulent sea of harmonies, as rose-buds peep out of their surrounding leaves shaken by the wind. There are just enough of them. Too many would spoil the scene. Apart from its purely poetic and musical elements, the ‘* Meistersinger” is chieily inte- resting as being a satire on the critics of the composer. It belongs to the same category as Schiller and Goethe's ‘ Xenien,’ Byron’s § English Bards,’ Pope’s * Dunciad,’ and Mr. Browning's recent ‘ Pacchiarotto.” It is easy to see that Walther represents for his age the artist of the future, and Jeckmesser the firm of ** Hanslick, Lindau & Co.”: while Hans Sachs is the antagonist of their musical philistinism, or, as Matthew Arnold defines the word, ‘‘ inaccessibility to new ideas” and impressions. Of course all thi ** Beckmesser critics,” as they are now called in Germany, have been unani- mous in their condemnation of the opera as a “musical monstrosity,” and one of them naively confesses that it has the same effect on him as unripe gooseberries ! Local critics assert, what one can easily believe, that thi recent performances were not so good as those during the régime of Wag- ner and Hans von Biilow. The greatest defect here is that Munich has not yet, like Dresden, Weimar, and Magdeburg, followed Bayreuth in making the orchestra invisible, and hence the brass is sometimes too prominent, and the gallery the best place from which to hear. It is to be hoped that at one of the coming stage-festivals ‘* Meistersingers of Niirnberg ” will be given by the ** Wagner-singers of Bayreuth.” The opera will be produced in London next season by Mr. Carl Rosa, and it is rumored that it) will then also be heard in America, given by the same troup Correspondence. THE SUPREME COURT JUDGES ON THE ELECTORAL CoOM- MISSION, To tue Eprror or THe NATION : Sm: In the Nation of February 22, in your article on ** The Decisi of the Commission,” you say : **To say now that because both sides \ ie di \ s some one man must have been dishonest, rd as the posit ft impeachers of Andrew Johnson who hi any Repul Sena The N ution. 1147 who did n vote cuiltv on som t " ¥ rrupt his seen { l the posit \ ag \ quentiv t expres that the sel s PXET( 1} ! inl fume 1 ss \ jured had he not Loa ‘ dence demanded, Irrespectiy \ \ desirableness or undesirabieness 1 Turning to your number of the | \ Florida Decision,” Tread : * It is. of course. to be regretted that } i { _ the Commission should have been d decision : that one or two of the Demoet fit, when the majority was certain, to vet judgm nt of the Commission greate Wo? \ tw to prevent even the slight loss of prestige W tion that the opinions of the judges have bee ! by t I Tam not aware of anything in the pos noof the ¢ quired iis members to exercise Judicial function members of the High Court of Impeachment. If not wight innocently decide according to his jud ! some effeet to follow and flow out of = 4 l member of the forme: ndos W you please to exp » the appa \ j | New Haven, Conn., February vs [In the first place, we believe it is the practic all State courts of high standing to make ¢ ‘ the sake of the dignity and intluence of the tribunal, as « approach to unanimity as possible, and that ino many cases, wl the judgment is settled ard it is desirable that it sheuld have possible weight, the minority do not hesitate to by concealing their dissent from it. Whr of his brethren differing frem him ona point of law, li very proud or very self-contident not to tind his own ¢ shaken, and not to find the surrender or suppression of it an « matter, particularly as the decision is the decision of the eourt, | not hisown. A judge who holds a casting vote is d ated. He virtually has it in his power to decide the case, and bound to express and vote in aceordance with his opinion, just he sat alone. In the Senate, in Andre J s reason why the Republican minority were asked to vote some article or other was that they were needed to make up the thirds necessary to a eonviction. If they had voted guilty « article they would, therefore. have changed the result from: acquitt to econvietion, something which they were bound by t 0 to do. But apart from this altogethy he Ss , in it different situation from law dees Pheir « prin cipally legislative: they only meet as a court: very rarely, and even when they do eannot put the character of representa- tives. They vote as Senators, not as members of a tribunal, and the country has a right to know how they vote and what they think We believe that the disposition which has shown itself with locreas- ing strength among the Supreme Court judg f late years to give prominence to their individual opinions, and make them of greatest importance than the corporate opinion of the Court, is viewed with considerable regret by the best portion «el the bar but we must add that the matter is one on Which we do not mean to saya judge’ dutv is atallelear. There are two or three diflerent views of th position of the Supreme Court judzes on the Electoral Commission 1 of wv 1 there something to be said It v had agrecd it the outset to consult apart and east solidly the vote of ¢ mit rit of the t ( s the vote of the hole fh e, the vould have done we Ul ik. lawt | ‘ nd CT u eful th eu Wy Voun oe © a3 id 1 } \ ] ( thev @) | 1very ditt rent tong Whi h \ regre ut ck te th for doing. —Ep. NATIO Pui AMERICAN MINISTER TO i i ) To Turk Eprror or Tit Nation Sir: The f ving article appears in the London Wor/d of Pebruary
Page 10
The 14 i na t and irge circulation amongst thi Great Brit ‘ir M ( t asked Colonel Diver, ‘Is smartness American for { int mel and editor of the Rowdy Journal re : | | \) an for a good many things that you call But you can’t help yourself in Europe. We can.’ I was and characteristic question and answer when I vas said during an interview between some Eng- United States Minister. The former were anxious t cl had in getting a bill relating to an international igh Congress, With the candor of Colonel Diver, V wat Oni ecossary to bribe heavily in order to tasked if he really meant that bribery was a concomitant n the great Republic, he corrected himself, and said that it tial to use much ‘influence.’ What newspaper ‘ enterprise ” St means the English public are aware. They now know } tral the rd ‘ influence’ * \\ her i Statement as is here imputed to the United States Min illy made or not, yet that such an allegation should be emed credible, and, as such, should find its place in a respectable journal, ficient indication of the excessive loss of dignity which the position of epresentative of the Umited States at Great Britain has sustained Che frivolity and silly publie utterances of Mr. Pierrepont, united to t} ndal mnection of his predecessor with mining speculations, have ted degrading in the minds of the British public the oifice and vhich they have so unfitly represented, and give frequent occasion for mortification on the part of every American resident here It is perhaps too much to hope that any official notice should be taken f the charge so distinctly made against our representative ; but it may in terest some of your readers to be informed of the esteem in which our min- is is suid to hold his own Government A New- Yorker, LONDON, February 18 It would certainly not be improper for the American Minister World to produce the person who says he held this inter- view with bim, and we eould readily understand his attention being Ep. NATION. } t ‘ the it ist. LLit called to it by the State Department. Notes. sACE’S * Russia’ will be publis! ALI ‘ \\ Henry Holt & Co wed during the present month by Directions for coloring the maps have been late in arriving and have delayed the work.——A.S. Barnes & Co. will issue iinmediately ‘Memoirs of P. P. Bliss,’ by Major D. W. Whittle, with an introduction by D. L. Moody.——Architects and builders who wish to ex- ° tend their acquaintance with the principles involved in the graphical method of ascertaining the stresses in the different parts of framed struc- tures will be interested in a little volume of sixty-four pages by Professor | f+ le, OL Ft cc. f Roof Trusses Greet he University of Michigan, entitled * Graphical Analysis Geo. H. Frost). The book is a reprint of a from Engineering News. The subject is treated clearly * (Chicago : irticies series OL ind concisely, and in such terms as to be easily understood by any one who has a slight knowledge of geometry and elementary mechanics. ——A bib- rraphy of the game of billiards is now in course of publication in Notes (Juertes The Library Table, published in this city by Henry L. Hinton & Co. during the past year as a monthly, is to become a weekly th the April number, under the editorial management of Mr. Porter C. Bliss. ——Mr. Steiger sends us the sixth revised edition of Kiepert’s ‘ Atlas | \ntiquus "—*' twelve maps of the ancient world for schools and colleges” | Berlin : Dietrich Reimer). The title-page is in English, and we suppose this really help the salein the English and American markets. Dr. Kiepert’s t of course, the highest. The maps are large enough to include e of It for example) without greatly diminishing the scale. IL is a broad esentation of the northern provinces of Rome from brit the mouth of the Danube In comparison with maps drawn on pper, these, being lithographed, have a somewhat woolly appearance Memorial of the late Dr. Francis Gardner has been published by the Public Latin School Association of Boston ——A Summer si projected by the Butler University of Indiana. The scientific fr will head an exploring expedition in the interest of geology and natural histor: With espechu reference to collections, leaving Indianapolis about June 20. Dallas, Texas, will be the centre of operations. ‘‘ Lady be received if five or more make application.” should be addressed to Prof. John A. Myers, Irvington, Ind Enquiries Nation. | Number 610 -Of Messrs. L. M. week as **two of our artists” exhibiting etchings at the present Water Yale and A. M. Warren, to whom we referred last Color Exhibition, a correspondent writes: ‘* Permit me to say that, as to the former gentleman, he is an amateur, a physician in good practice, and professor in one of the schools of medicine here, his etchings wholly the and as to the latter, he polis, and has been d-ad a twelvemonth.” product of leisure hours ; as a professor at Anna —The Atlantic for March has made quite a stir in journalistic circles by the publication of an article by Mr. E. S. Nadal on ‘* Newspaper Lite rary Criticism.” There are two theories of the function of the newspaper, widely opposed to each other, one of which is held or advanced by the journalist when in his more exalted and sacerdotal moods, the other being put forward by him when he is on the lower plane of carnal worldliness. When he looks at the modern times, and upon himself as a member of the new priesthood that newspaper as the great progressive influence of keeps alive and ever infuses new vigor into this influence, he generally thinks of the function of the newspaper critic—be he literary, artistic, educational, or musical critic—as in a measure that of final judge in the various fields over which he presides, and as being a reverent and awful personage to whom this nineteenth century looks up as former cen- turies have to priests and divinely-anointed rulers pressed by care, and the difficulty of reconciling this view of his profession with the actual condition of the paper trade and the labor market, the weary journalist chews the bitter cud of reflection, and meditates upon the real as distinguished from the ideal in journalism, he generally comes to the conclusion that the lofty view of the critic as a judge is a mistake; that for such work he is underpaid ; well for the rich and prosperous, who have nothing todo but to think about other people’s duties ; but that the poor, half-fed journalist, if he wishes to | earn his bread and butter, had better not at any time be too Rhadaman- | thine, but think twice before he makes enemies among authors and publish- | ers, when it is just as easy to make friends, With the sort of temptations | that beset the critic when in this world Mr. Nadal seems to be tolerably | When, however, op- that these elevated standards may be all very familiar. He says : ‘‘ A silent pressure is brought to bear upon the critic to be continually coquetting with the advertisers, to reward those who do advertise, to punish those who do not, and to invite those who are expected to. Isay the pressure is a silent one ; the reviewer is not told, or at any rate not frequentiy told, to do such and such things. On the contrary, he is said to have a curte blanehe. But there are two sorts of curte blunche,a verbal and a moral eurte blanche. The carts blanche I refer to says to the reviewer, * You may do as you like, but’—and there is an ominous reser- vation which he prudently construes to mean that it will be well for him to whether Mr, Nadal really, ‘‘ comprehends the slanderous and insulting sig- So far does its indignation carry it that, dropping the anonymous, the ‘‘ present writer” brings himself forward editorially to refute Mr. Nadal by making affidavit that he *‘ has reviewed several thou of books, *‘ good and bad” together, in his time, and among them were many ‘‘ whose authors were his acquaintances and friends” ; “ but he does not remember that he ever yet consciously wrote an untruth concern- ing any of the books, or that he ever had greater hesitation in saying that his friend’s book was not a good one than he would have in criticising his friend’s pigs or poultry. His friendship may have perverted his judgment in some cases ; he may have attributed some part of his friend’s personal excellence to his friend’s literary performance, but he has not knowingly sacrificed truth upon the altar of friendship, if for no other reason, because as a man with a living to earn he could not afford to do anything of the We have no space to go into the merits of this controversy, but we must call the attention of the Post to the fact that it somewhat weakens the effect of its manly denunciation of Mr. Nadal by an attempt to give its own idea of what the true function of a newspaper literary critic is. | It is perfectly intelligible, but we have never met with it before in print | It says : ‘‘ The work of the critic is not so much criticism as description. It is | in the nature of news and comment upon news, and the newspaper reviewer rightly omits much in the way of adverse criticism which he would include if he were writing literary criticism in the stricter sense of the term.” We must take the Post’s word for it that it is the critic whose duties it is de- fining, for the functionary to whom we should have supposed the description applied is not so much the critic as that humble but useful satellite of the literary system—the composer of advertisements, who, under the guise of | criticism, but omitting to say much that is ‘‘ adverse,” strives to excite in lixe to do what proprietors wish to have done.” | r . . . . . ~This suggestion of the influence of low and sordid motives has, we re | ° . 1 , = | gret to see, caused some feeling in the Heoning Post, which wishes to know | nificance of his words.”’ sands ” sort.”
Page 11
Mar. 8, 1877] The Nation. 149
— —e See =x the publie that intellectual craving for knowledge without which there can | that one sometimes meets such characters among the lower orders, artisans he no true prosperity among the manufacturers of books. ete., she is unquestior ably thinking « f him whom Frederie the Great somewhere ‘un gargon charpentier juif Deronda resembles | —Washington’s birthday was celebrated at the Johns Hopkins Univer- | in freedom from sin, ability to resist temptation, and in a great dea sity by public addresses from President Gilman and Professors Gildersieeve jut he is still more like the Jesus of M. Renan than him of the Ey - . P : . gelista, for he has a special power over the female heart. Poor Gwend and Sylvester, and by the recital of Lowell’s Ode to Washington by the poet pe Vegghoce A a >stantinalg “pl saa Sh: ; ee ‘ wns. plays the part of the Magdalene ; she looks at him as at a shrine; himself. Prof. Sylvester, who occupies the chair of Mathematics, and isan | the single guiding star for her deserted, aberrant soul. Every word w acquisition from Cambridge, England, spoke partly of himself and his satis- | he bestows upon her is a law. From him she expects absolution faction with his new relations, and partly of his work and proposed courses of | PePance, forgiveness and benediction. The magic power which he ser A : : possess we first appreciate when we know his model. Deronda is g instruction, and indulged in some general remarks of a very interesting | |, a i rai ‘ ) 3 , : itself ; he is all tenderness, ail consideration. There is no « To character. He maintained with much force ‘* the position that the two | ing of which he was not, even asa boy, capable. He has early aceustom functions of teaching and working in science should never be divorced,” | himself in imagination to take part in others’ expenences. He regards | . . . . . if } ‘ 10 as whiliar ( yeolf } P s for th} - *y . ~ illustrating from his own experience the advantage of their conjunction, | life and action not as peculiar to himself, but always fo en P He discovered early in his prof ‘ship on the other side the principle now others. From his thirteenth vear he has striven to understand those who fie aise ere Ci Ss protessorshil Oo ne ¢ er side e pring 1e no 7 : . | ‘ie Be oie t | feel differently from himself. He makes his mother no reproaches, is oppress known in the text books as the *‘ Dialytie Method of Elimination,” in the | only by a growing sadness. His deepest sympathy is excited by those wl act of teaching a private pupil the simpler parts of algebra ; and but re- | have done something wrong and are unhappy. Sir Hugo says t cently, at the University in Baltimore, the persistence of a student in | eis ts 1 porapetionad en. 20 who are pi met) i think »y ‘ . ‘ ; : | easily be led to go arm in-arm with a lunat espe llv if he want his desire stu » N lvebri i ) Y Pe) ste ** a re- ’ - . his desire to study the New A seora or led Prof. ylvester into i re fending ee eyes and look have wonderful ou a | search of fascinating interest ” from which he hopes for great results. He | are of a dark and gentle inwardness, which seems to express an es has reason, he told his audience, ‘* to think that the taste for mathematical | terest in the person with whom he is spe: - > Whoeve i ; - | é > pros Le S [or é ie : . SS ee ee eee tee ee | of color in his face which makes one nervous when he throws : matical journal of a high character, to be published under the auspices of | clance, and this glance is terrifying when he disappro. the University, appears to have met with encouraging responses. Prof. | bear to bring up new points of resemblance bet i «in - A i pn . ) ese meselves 1DpON eve reader's ¢ + Sylvester spoke at considerable length and rage feeling on theestrange- | COPY + they press themselves upon every reader's atten
ment between the two great branches of the Anglo-Saxon race caused by —It might be expected that the historical literature of I876 would hay the exclusive, ecclesiastical policy of the English Universities in former | especial reference to those countries of the East which have bee vears. ‘* Their work it is that a separation deeper and a chasm more diffi- | object of attention this year. Most of the books on this subjeet hay ) cult to fill up has been created between the two most free and powerful ever, been either hastily prepared or ephemeral in t nature —< nations in the world—England and America—than any due to political | tions and books of travel rather than histories. Asa selid eont it causes, present or past.” Why is it, he enquired, that the flower of Ame- | historical science, the first place is undoubtedly taken by Jirecek's * G ican youth do not resort for their mental impulse and higher education to | schichte der Bulgaren,’ a book that bas long been in preparati Oxford and Cambridge, instead of to Berlin, Leipzig, Jena, or Heidelberg ? | just now published. Of books of travel in the seat of war, BE ‘It is because there they are welcomed, to whatever religious commu- | ‘Through Bosnia and Herzegovina’ is distinguished by va ipt nion they are attached or unattached, without question and without dis- | of an historical character. Bukharoff’s ‘La Russie et la Tun , tinction. It is because there they can rest on the bosom of a common } good sketch of the relations of these two countries in the two last e« ; mother, who shows kindness to all and favorto none. . . . Ihave been aoc Soa ie Shane gt ere struck, almost from the first hour of my landing on these shores, by the | S¢hmeidler’s ‘Geschichte des osmanischen Reiches im letzten J manifestations I have everywhere witnessed of the close intellectual sym- | is a timely work, although it is pronounced not fully ad ite, O pathy which exists between America and Germany. It is German books | books relating to Eastern Eur pe the most noteworthy are K s that are read, it is German euihors who are quoted, German opinion on all | . Deux Chanceliers’ and Riépell's * Polen in Sitin Aae matters of science ~ learning that is appealed to; and as regards com- we lh i a ae Rd a ee i ee oe munity of work and iniellectual ties, I do not think it at all extravagant to Jahrhunderts’ ; the eminent historian of Poland has depicted the causes assert that Germany and America belong to one hemisphere, and we in | of the downfall of the nation with great vigor and truthfulness. Here may England to another.” also be mentioned Howorth’s * History of the Mongols,’ and here, too, the On this subject of the alienation of intellectual sympathy Prof. Sylvester has death of Franz Palacky, the venerable historiographer of Bohemia, whose perhaps not done full justice to his countrymen. If educational opportu- | great work had reached its fifth volume, at the onion of Bohemia with nities were equal, and if the accumulations of German science were asacces | Austria. sible as those of England, there would still be a clear advantage in acquiring —There is a good deal in the field of ancient history. For Eevpt. the ) another language in the country where it is spoken, and in coming in con- | grt yolume of Maspéro’s * Histoire ancienne des peut se die Water tact with a different order of mind, however little superior. The disparity | noynced a work of the highest merit ; the eek enhané at i Bias of attendance ought not to be so enormous hereafter, certainly ; but we d'Egypte,’ by the eminent Egyptologist Brugsch-Bey, comes down to the believe Germany will always, from natural causes, prove more attractive | eng of the Hyesos period. Lenormant, attracted Scum his cid Geld be than England. Schliemann’s discoveries, has published ‘ Les antiquités de la Troade, vt les —In spite of the innumerable reviews of ‘Daniel Deronda’ which have | antiquités primitives de la Greece.’ In classie hi y there 1s a voit appeared in English, a German critic (Mr. Wilhelm Scherer, in the Deutsche | from each of Clason and Ihne in their respective histories of Rome ( Rundschan for February 7) is probably the first to discover that Daniel was | son’s posthumous volume brings his continuation of Schwegler’s encvel intended to represent no less a person than the hero of ‘Joshua Davidson, pedic work down to the year B.c. 828, so that this great work is sti Communist,’ a novel whose alleged flippancy and irreverence attracted con- | finished. We have before mentioned the general histories of Greece and siderable attention a few years ago. After suggesting that the title of the Rome by Cox and Merivale The fifth volume of Duruy’s ‘ Histoire « book, to convey an idea of its character, should have run : ‘Selfishness | Romains’ completes the work. Ernst Curtius has published a volume of and Self-sacrifice,’ or ‘Love of Self and Sympathy,’ or ‘Self interest and — and addresses under the title ‘ Alterthum und Gezenwar Not a Disinterestedness,’ and remarking that, while the Jews were taken as repre- | classical history, but covering a classical period, is the third volume of sentatives of self-sacrifice and unselfishness, it cannot have been the au- | Stanley's ‘ History of the Jewish Church,’ reaching from the Captivity te thor’s intention to put forward her characters as types of Judaism, he pro- | the Christian Era ceeds as follows : —For the Middle Age we have some very important works of eruditio: chief among them the JaArbiicher; of Louis the Pious, by Simson (Vol Il.), of Otto the Great, by Diimmler, and of Henry II., by Hirsch. Pott- hast’s ‘ Regesta’ of the popes is also finished, covering the thirteenth cen- ‘We have in mind the evening when Deronda, rowing on the Thames, =) found Mirab. The author describes his hands while rowing : ‘They are not small and dimpled, with tapering fingers that seem to rox * nly a deprecating touch : they are long, flexible, firmly grasping hands, such as Titian t . The creat collection of chr ‘les of rm: ‘iti . has painted in a picture where he wanted to show the combination of refinement ury. The great collection of chronicles of German cities goes on, embra with force. And there is something of a likeness, too, between the faces belonging | ing now Nuremberg (five volumes), Augsburg (two), Strassburg to the hands—in both, the uniform pale brown skin, the perpendicular brow, the | : — i tic : calmly penetrating eyes. Not seraphic any longer: thoroughly terrestrial and Brunswick (one), Magdeb yurg (one), and Cologne (two). This vear and the manly ; but still of a kind to raise belief ina human dignity whic h can afford to | jact have seen three volumes of Waitz’s great ‘ Verfassungs-Geschichte.’ In ackuowledge poor relations veld of aes : é . ' — ree er ; the field of constitutional law we have the first volume of Fustel de ‘‘ Now, I can recollect no picture of Titian’s, except the ‘Christ with | 7, "age a. aa tending the Tribute Money,’ in which the hands fasten the observer's attention as | Coulanges’s * Histoire des institutions politiques de l’ancienne . rance perhaps those of no other picture. And when the author goes ontosay America has also contributed a valuable work in ‘ Essays on Anglo Saxon
Page 12
150 The Nation. | i md students. JLefele’s +4 ici ‘ nl a revised edition of the ‘ i] ~ ended with the councils of the fifteenth not vet rendy for writing a his i 1 s, bv tl Wii In prepara- { ~ id edition of whose * Unge- ! | Werner's * Bonifacius* we hav | | i ned du G ( “by Simeon ut To { important is perhaps the completion of n Conqu or the same period we have Skene’s of Ay ent Alban,’ the first volume of which treats of the liste ry phy tothe death of Alexander IIL. (12285). Mary, Queen of Scots, li in Chantelauze (‘ Marie Stuart’) and Gauthier (* His- f Marie Stuart’) Mr. Brewer's ‘Calendar of State Papers’ under Het VIIL has another valuable volume: it was feared that the editor's eof a living In the country would interfere with its continuation, bout inderstand that satisfactory engagements have been made for it by Thomas [Lardy There is another volume, too, of Mrs. Green’s ‘ Calen- for tl } riod of the Commonwealth. Reumont’s ‘ Geschichte Tos- nas’ has found an English translator. The fifth volume of Carlson’s Ciescl te Schwedens’ comes down to the death of Charles XI., pro- i period of decay, although the decay was first clearly visible under hi n, Konrad Maurer’s ‘Island’ is a work of the highest scientifie value \ new history of Austria by Krones has reached its eighth number ul the fourteenth century. J. G. Droysen’s ‘Geschichte der preussischen Politik’ (Vol. \ Part 2) covers the period between the treaties of Breslau (1742) and Dresden (1745).
Of more general nature are Richard Rothe’s lectures on Church His- tory, edited by Weingarten; Lorenz’s * Drei Biicher Geschichte und Poli- tik,’ a collection of essays chiefly upon the XIIth and XIVth cen- turies ; Lindsay's ‘ History of Merchant Shipping’ (four volumes), which Stephens’s * History of Thought in the Kighteenth Cen- turv’: andthe translation of Comte’s Of historical bio- besides this, there the lives of Macaulay and Ticknor, Martin's ‘ Life of the Prinee Con- xl Morse’s * Life of Hamilton.’ ‘Social Dynamics,’ ‘most important is that of Lord Shelburne ; The republication of Fortescue’s ‘De Laudibus Lecum Anglix,’ by Robert Clarke of Cincinnati, deserves mention. The several * Epochs’ series have idditions, Menke’ received new and valuable Atlas * has reached its sixteenth number. <A slight disagreement is understood to have arisen be- *Spruner’s Historical tween the editor (Dr. Menke) and the publisher (Perthes), who seems unduly A new Ilistorical Atlas by Wolff, eneral public, is to contain nineteen maps in four num- that it be speedily completed. lesigned for the s imbers have already been issued. ‘HE EFARL OF ALBEMARLE.* \ PLEASANT life is that of the excellent nobleman who has given us 4 it in the comely volume described below. ste ud of ** fifty yea s”’ of his life, Li “as some of the most interesting circumstances which he narrates happened as long ago as 1806. It was about that time that he—then But, in- rd Albemarle might have better said a '- ~—= t boy of seven vears old—and his brother played trap-ball in the garden fst Anne’s Hill with Charles James Fox. The great orator was then un- ik from dropsy, and, consequently, always had the ‘innings "— which he enjoved but for brief intervals in his political career—while the ther children (for he was the youngest of them all) did the bowling and fa rout. And it was not much later that he became the play fellow d dof the Princess Charlotte, when he had the honor of receiving facers ’ from the little fists of the royal hoyden in her sparring fancies, and her riding-whip across his shoulders when he had brought a scolding T } r one of her pranks. But then she made amends by presents of wat nd pony and pocket money out of her slender allowance, to- ether with good advice, such as became the maturity of twelve years when addressing nine Altogether, the glimpse he gives us of the childhood of the poor little princess, who had small comfort of her short life, is a plea- and shows qualities which would have stood ‘*the Daughter of the Isles” in good stead had she lived to be their queen. | The childish intimacy between Lord Albemarle and the princess was owing to his grandmother, Lady De Clifford, being the governess of her Roval Highness. TT post she resigned because the Prince Regent broke *: Fifty Years of my Life Dy (seorge Thomas. Karl of Albemarl New York: Henry Halt & ¢ Ih.
| Number 610 his promise of secrecy as to some confidential communication of hers. g asked by him the reason of her leaving Bein his service on such short notice, the old lady replied, ** Because your Royal Highness has taught me the distinction between the word of honor of a prince and a gentleman !” juel was equally characteristic of the ** First Gentleman in Europe.” e sent her a special royal command toa party al Carlton House, which we believe makes attendance all but cbligatory. She was doubtful as to what she should do under the circumstances, but was induced to go. The prince showed why he had invited her by turning his back upon her osten- tatiously before the whole company. Lord Albemarle tells interesting stories of another most famous lady whom George IV. treated worse yet, and whom Horne Tooke called in print Her Royal Highness the Princess of Wales—Mrs. Fitzherbert, to wit. love which that royal profligate This was, perhaps, the one honorable He risked the loss of his crown by marrying her in defiance of the Royal Marriege Act and of the Act of Settlement, she being a Catholic ; ver had. and he was buried with her miniature round his neck, which it appeared that he had always worn since their separation, nearly forty years before. Young Keppel, like most of his rank, was passed through the fire of the Moloch of a publie school edueation, which has been so strange a | endured, with perhaps some mitigation, unto this day. | story, and is never tedious in the telling. superstition of the English higher classes for centuries. That the belief in the virtue of the brutalities of masters and of the elder boys, the floggings by the one and the exaction of menial service by savage cruelty of the other, to make little boys manly, should have endured so long, is one of the anomalies of English human nature. More than a century and a half ago the Spe ctutor denounced the barbarities of the public schools as more apt to break than to strengthen the spirit of the boys. But they have From school, young Keppel took the next step in life usual for youthful sprigs of nobility not intended for the university, and received his commission as ensign in the Fourteenth Foot before he was sixteen. Ile served but one campaign, but that one was the complement and the quintessence of many ethers—that of Waterloo, itself, and of the oecupation of Paris and its humors, remind one of Thackeray in * Vanity Fair. His account of the scenes previous to the battle, of the battle * Though he does not mention Becky Sharp and Rawdon Crawley, there is not the least doubt that they were there. Returned to London, he had his last sight of the Princess Charlotte at the Chapel Royal, on an occasion just before her marriage. Her quick eyes, under her hands joined over them in edifying devotivn, soon spied her old playfellow out, and made telegraphic signals at him as in the old days of childhood; and after service, as he stood looking for her at the corner of the street, she kissed and waved her hand to him as long as she was in sight. The opportunities which young Keppel had of seeing the world and the amount of it which he did see was astonishing in those days before univer- From Pauland Virginia’s Isle of France he went to India, thence overland by Persia, visiting Bagdad and Babylon, returning through Russia home. sal travel, and remarkable even in these. Of this journey he published an account entitled an ‘Overland Journey from India,’ which gave him ad- mission to literary circles not before open to him. Afterwards he made a tour through Turkey in Europe, with an excursion into Asia Minor, which Thus the excellent au- ihor lived on in various activities, coming into his title at past fifty, but having enjoyed it for more than a quarterofacentury. He is not, happily for himself and for us,a great man, but he is a very pleasant teller of his Ile has known celebrities of all ranks and conditions—military, political, literary, and fashionable—and likes to tell what he has known of them. The days of the Regency and of George LV. were not virtuous days, nor will we affirm that these are much better than those ; but there were more lively scandals and more gossipping anecdotes afloat then, that have had specific levity enough to keep on the he published as his ‘Journey across the Balkan.’ surface of talk for fifty years, than these more decorous Victorian times are likely to provide for posterity. London has grown too great for social Brummel would be an There are now exclusive circles enough, but there is no one exclusive society like that of which Lady Jersey held the key, and to which high birth did not command admission and from which low birth did not necessarily exclude. The fantastic, indefinable, but despotic power of fashion has no longer the sway in the sense or in the degree that it held fifty or sixty years ago. Crowds have smothered it. celebrities, good and bad, such as flourished then. impossibility now, and so is Almack’s. Those were times when men fought duels, and ran away with oue another's wives, and ruined themselves at Crockford’s. There were dandies in those days, and they lounged in Bond Street, now as deso- late as Baker Street or Tadmor in the Wilderness, as far as fashion is con-
emer:
Page 13
Mir. 8, S77] The Nation. cerned, The dandies are no more, and the swells have not made their place good. The Marquis of Steyne himself has been gone for five-and- thirty vears, and it is to be hoped that the Thackeray of the next age will le puzzled to find his successor. We do not Say that the late days are better or worse than the former ones. It is likely that substantially they are much alike. But the former were the racier of the two. and amuse us as we doubt whether our successors will he amused by the latter, As thi innkeeper said to Yorick on another occasion, there may not be any great difference as to the sins, but there will be all the difference in the world as to the scandals, Lord Albemarle is much more entertaining than Mr. Greville, without the malignity and brutality of that writer, His readers will not find themselves entrapped into moral, political, or philosophical reflec- tions, or into the slightest attempt to make them wiser or better: with which commendation—the highest that we know of in such a case—we dis- miss his book with the advice to all and singular to buy and read it. Herzegovina and the Late Uprising. By W. 3. Stillmen. (Lendon : Longmans, Green & Co.)—Mr. Stillman was correspondent of the London Jimes in Ierzegovina and Montenegro in the fall of 1875 and the follow- ing winter, bringing to his work the experience of irregular warfare and of Turkish character and methods of administration acquired while Amer- ican consul in Crete during the insurrection in that island in 1866-8. His book is made up partly of his letters and partly of memoranda of matters which came to his knowledge under a seal of temporary confidence, or which, for other reasons, it would have been at the time improper to com- municate to a newspaper. Ie spent his time partly in Montenegro and partly in the insurrectionary districts, either with the insurgents or the Turks, observing closely, and evidently, in spite of his strong sympathy with the rebels, quite ready to give the Turks any credit that was due to them—which, to tell the truth, was not much. Ile saw but little fighting because there was very little to see, and, indeed, his book is rather a description of a state of things than a narrative of events. The rising was begun, in the usual way, by refugees from Turkish violence, and it lasted with varying fortune, mainly owing to Turkish incompetency, until, first, Russian sympathy and support were assured, and then the attention of Europe was attracted and the diplomatists began to interfere. It consisted in the main of skirmishes, which were always bloody in proportion to the force engaged, in plunderings, burnings, and murders; the Turks, on the it in the armed encounters, but getting their whole, getting the worst of revenge in devastation. In fact, as a military operation, the Herzegovina insurrection amounted to nothing ; as a disturbance, however, it amounted toa great deal, for by drawing Servia and Montenegro into the field, it brought Europe once more face to face with the most serious question of modern international polities, Mr. Stillman’s opinions about the Turks are well known. Ile believes them as rulers irredeemably cruel, vicious, inefficient, and dishonest, through whom no reform can possibly be carried out, whose promises are not to be believed, and to whom it is a burning shame that any Christian population should be left in subjection, He therefore proposes that, if anything is to be done for the salvation of the poor Christians in Herze- govina, it should be done through Christian administrators—the Austrians, for instance, who have been accustomed to command on the Military Frontier, or Anglo-Indian officers, who have had just the kind of experi- ence Turkey needs. He thinks a mixed representative government, half Turk, half Christian, would be useless, because the Turks would have it all their own way, and would enforce ‘‘ the previous question ” in debate by strangling their brother legislators ; and the ‘t autonomy ” of the newly- emancipated rayahs, he thinks, would be simply a species of Carpet-baggery —that is, the rule of an ignorant mass by a parcel of imported demagogues. The reason why he does not believe the Turk will improve is that, in so far as he is bad, he is bad not as a Turk but as a Mussulman: or, in other words, he is bad in virtue of what he regards as his highest good—in all of which we cordially agree with Mr. Stillman. His illustrations of Turkish incapacity for reform, or rather of Turkish ‘‘ reform within the party,” are amusing but horrid. Judicial pursuits into crime seldom go farther than HBpeial + Lewis, TO a ‘‘report,” and ‘to make a report ”’ is, in the eves of Turkish of do sufficient justice. Mr. Stillman had more than once the novel, but always exciting, experience of hearing discussions about the fitness and pleasurableness of cutting off his head. Anciint Streets and Homesteads of England. By Alfred Rimmer. With 150 illustrations from drawings by the author. (London and New York: Macmillan & Co. 18% — ~ —s duction to this work after qu ting 1 ie i | the Nati concerning Chester, re k | ' Mr. Rimmer’s book verv mu east y ti ] h readers are ke ¥ to tan t! Wal ences of historv in which the rv ft land s ix Whatever mav | ( this point We sul tha \ cially we are inclined t! t I keep an American audien dill \ 1 | rye have been to improve the volume « \\ them, for example, he does not think it t! particularly the location of some the] \ readers he might have employed a sketch map showing the s, fa and obscure. This would have had an add ! \ fact that Mr. Rimmer, though contriving to 1 le nearly ery England, has failed to observe a strict ge } cress. In faet, the way in which he skips about wit \ . exasperating even to an English reader. One-third of nt a book as this lost if the an quilt a \ proper place on the map, and we defy any M Rimmer with a distinet notion of county p Mr. Rimmer’s course, so far he can | Chester and proceeds through the western west eastwardiy, thence northeasterly a/ Berks is reserved for another serik Cambrid will be given to gateways and their history, “This be hoped that the author, who is evidently 1 ib ¢ k “\ time accept friendly advice as to his literary st () ous defects is referring to what has not gone bef tioned ; another, not a little annoying, is | Thus, on p. 149, he tells us that ** the ey Oxford t is per most beloved to the attempts which James II. mad forme i that os @ A ” \ ‘ rights.” , . more important criticism relates t »is fr On p. 195 we are In Ol n its sturdy resistance tectural prin detail or mo main we rat le by Englishmen is r that his feeling 1 il thought out. His illustration } +} : } nf chosen Tor scuin s iw! De 3 ! \ I Irdnere pl { iresquenhess tiquity has not governed t r select i \ \ value for architects and bu sand we mev ins in Warwick, pictured on p. 254 planation of ‘the avay in whict I ! contain rectangular rooms an upper stor I" \ way ing it imav be seen in Rose Str it vo wi f are paral] each other and 1 to t t.s is Stowed away between these « rs wit ttle s l s deal of useful information. especially in illus n of Shaks s histor eal play We learn of Derbyshire (p. 240) t 1 I f Derby is not derived from any part of t . but from the hundred of West Derby. 1 Livery \ ( 2277), { ¢ rs D gave the nal The i ‘ . *was at onet e surrounded by lakes ‘ byt verfl ny of the Humber, and its name is said t lerived mB - t one time these animals were very al n this part ’ t Me r or forest ¢ s the 1 \ - suffix -] As ‘*the making of cakes f s quite an industry a if the natives of Pontefract,” it is fair to suppose (what is the truth) that this is the popu lar pronunciation of the name place, Which has been literally r tained in our 1% et (C On p. 290 we read that in Carlisle is still n eable the ty} oe | tings colonized there by William Rufus: and again The singular wav in which a type of feature is preserved from genera tion to generation is certainly exhibited in Chester, in the Roman character of manv of the features of the country per ple near the « ity This has never been noticed, as far as 1 know, and it was only in iooking over a collection of Roman ¢ to be noticed in the coins of I man nose, and str ney marked features ; indeed, nobodv can 0 rT i 1rou | types of fe | women.” ins that } Lt the Chester marke ture without being it occurred to me. These characteristics are especially Hadrian, or Claudius, or Agricola—a_ ful] t on a Saturday and observe the various struck with these peculiarities in the Cheshire
Page 14
p I Lise C're ! f { ! el { f , Yr)? f f + } I I they are ‘ 5 i ed. ¢ 2 W we Lv the personal element in history, an element | the driest and most tedious of school druc ‘ est f ‘* tendencies nd evolution nd how- | better adapted than geometry to feed and stimulate t P I l al the itest men are blind instruments of I forces, t r car and achievements are after all the best | site faculty, is alone set to work. ‘ ex x interest and inculcating the lessons of history try ’ before us is Herbert Spencer's father. | ; f Montfort and the Black Prince are well and attractively W n the judgment which takes the Black Prince as a typi- wter, sa hero to be placed before the young He was, no doubt, | sections P ive rior of that age,” but we cannot call that commander ‘a fu eneral ” who placed himself in a situation from which he could | are too long y by the desperate victory of Poitiers, and who allowed x” no sufficient cause, into the unwarrantable | for a single lesson. So with his personal character He had marked vir- | out the less ns witl e of his own class ; but we protest against any book assigned to us, | ssacre of Limoges, on the oft-repeated ground that he | tainty that the good results would be perma , lity of his dav.” The model knight should The ‘Short Geography’ seems to be mer be e the average morality of his day; but even this average mo- | memorizing of elementary map-questions by judi ‘- urt lemned this massacre The maps are | face is as sensible as it is distinct : ! } \ t I 1 t late vear TI it in tl life f the Blac k is the ( hief é nd of rer graphy The way to ! volume the map of England is fair, that | at a time, and that thoroughly. The way f unsat Ac ne is en as if it were a province learn all you can from one map before quitting it for another. ( e ( ! \ ! to extend st to the Vistula and, this little work “one map Lo one book,” ete, f , mpr Denmark as well; Florence is given The ‘ Algebra Self-Taught’ is adapted to an ideal student nv. and Southern Italy in this period is reckoned | not know where to look for him. Py Lou | t hod f thew k (p. 69), Gascony Is said to be * the only f nenta ess f Henrv IL. which still remained BOOKS OF THE 1 t f , | Gascony was only a province of zremnge 4 | . man | N Oo | 1 of | n | | iF | \\ - ( »- | ! I \\ } | Lan Olt IVES, | nd Publishers, | / 7 1o- | Archite All new books s The Nation. fional Geometry. (New By W. G York: D Spe Spe neer °
Kirby (W.), Le Chien d'Or: a Tale WIDDLETON’S Special Notice to k:ditions of Standard Works.| — ousrerty revies ment in 2op to 1
HENRY HALLAWMS WORKS " icaieienacae \ ice Library | ple i inabridged, in loth $1 are : the »wlement A a a Birds of Amer \ crow ri h. $1 half-calf, Com- virion Dy one FOno ' sails | ires ol 1 » all i The vate: 2 ; Plates and text, half-} The are or “rope Henry R School Const ‘ ry of Enela Ss 25, | History. Condition, and lay , History of Englana vols., 3 the United States. Illu Ma ation of Hallam—down to 1860.) vols. gto, cloth, $ \ 1a I g editor f works suit le for the For sale wns ( ¢ i
W. |. WIDDLETON, Prputsues 27H i Street war treet, New York Rare -ngravings Fan) dS and Etchings. GREAT RI
Connoisseurs and all Art-lovers are invited to call and ex- ; A ’ : . n of Rare Engravings and Etch- € ek, gr ss. eae mol ngs undersigned has returned from Cruden s Con nip he Eur _ “a mae n the Historical Book iro est collection ever W | ; N brought thi ludes many of the master- ith grr etn Maps, I pieces of t reate irer, Rembrandt, a mass of useful inform Ede k, Strange, yschi, and Mandel Foolscap 8vo, Turk I he et ] . Sy I Ss Ww al é on T, . k | r any informatio Turkey moroc “W i
FREDERICK KEPPEL, 66 Bee BAGSTER'’S OC nan Street, New York. = P N.I A high-class, Rare Engraving 1 a very appropriate Large print 8vo, Tt print Svo, cal Large |
Albert Levy, IMPORTER OF ARCHITEC DECORATIVE Imported and for sale TURAL WORKS. ctural Photogr aphs f United 77 UNIVERSITY PLACE gues sent on AND *,* Catalogue grati f States and - NEW YORK W. Catal ay plic ition, i Europe. } | LOCK WOOD, BROOKS & WW" ITE to ‘Kk 4 CO., Boston, for any bcok ; you want | nt, post-patd, ata verlised prices. ‘* Topography, Importers and B neer, igeries, ghton, pp. 230. (Lendon A Short Geography. First Part : The Hemispheres Ss make f we | delphia : Claxton, Remsen & Haffelfinger. 1876 now in course of publica- | Zanght. By W. P. Higgs. (London and New Y nterest felt in historical | 1876. Pp. 104.)—We ultivated The lives an- | ble usefulness. They have f Raleigh, Cromwell, | ness. The first is ar Appleton & Co. 1877. 1 elaborate and desperate attempt to rescue
[Number 610 with a prefatory note by rar pp V7 j— (Phila tre Sel AN F. N. Spon By E. Roth. 52 \— Alive rk: E. have named these books in the order of their proba nothing in common except brevity and direct- Lhe study of geometry from the treadmill of routine which has degraded it into being No study is inherently he inventive faculty ° ut, as now taught, instead of arousing inventiveness, memory, the oppo- The author of the * Inventional Geom He has collected nearly five nent. and run the risk of excessive lessons, hundred problems or questions, extending from the simplest observation, as ‘Show how many faces a cube has,” to mechanical applications of coni This is a very steep ascent to be achieved in one hundred pag and it must be confessed that the steps are unequal, and that some of them Many of the single questions would constitute a lesson apie and we wish we could be certain that some of them are not even too long Still, a sympathetic teacher would know how to giv: ms, and, if we were school-boys, we should wish to have this with the cer- ely an attempt to facilitate the learn to le WEEK. Lovell, Adam, Werson & Co ‘ious grouping. Its pre or a knowledge of m:ps, well is to learn one thing arn geography well is to Motto of We should 40 50 Estes & Lauriat EF. Steiger Lovell, Adam, Wesson & Co 2 0 “DUC and 400 of the Old fw » aid the ition ¢ ev moeroce TA VO Librarians. et, from its commence- Ss 1 ls., half-calf, ghth editi vols. gt dition. Il- ntaini 4 Vv > t Informat s f the Indi ir f y Capt. S. Eastman, voksellers, PION BAGSTER S TEACHERS glish Ver calf-lined, pre n ' SIEMON & BROTHER, Fort Wayne, Inc Bagster & Sons bibles, IN PRICE. BIBLE. n of the P lyglot Ser . th Answers, 1 New Testaments ight u Teacher
BIBLE /} » CA NOTES. irkey mor f-lined, T by JOHN WILEY & SONS, 1 ? } 00 rkey moroe I Astor Place, N. Y. CHRISTERN, FOREIGN BOOKSELLER AND IMPORTER, | 77 UNIVERSITY PLACE, NEW YORK, | _ Large assortments of the publications of Charpentier, Didier, Didot, Hachette, Lévy Fréres, etc., on hand ; also complete lists of Tauchnitz’s Collection of Briatish Authors, and Teubner’s Greek and Roman Classics. periodicals received weekly in parcels, All European
actice «
Page 15
Vy E> fn leat yp reer wre } d