The Nation 1876-04-06: Vol 22 Iss 562

Page 1

The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, APRIL 6, 1876. The Week. Gj ENERAL SCHENCK has appeared before the committee which J has in charge the Emma Mine investigation, and fully ex- plained his connection with the Company. He admits, of course, his secret contract with Park, dated November 1, 1871, by which he was guaranteed first two and then one and a half per cent. on his stock; that he paid no money for it, and that he had the right for a specified time, in case of any danger of loss, to make Park take the stock off his hands; but he says that this was a perfectly bond-fide agreement, which Park made because he was a “liberal” man and wanted to do the General a good turn. We have always thought, however, that the story of this contract and Schenck’s note for £10,000 given to Park was incomplete with- out details of the settlement between the parties, and we now find that the settlement was made in this way: Whenever any payments were made on account of the note, they were, as is usual between business men, endorsed on the back of it. There are endorsements for £500, for £1,897, and for £2,500—the first representing the value of shares which Schenck sold to ‘‘a friend” ; the second some “‘ stock speculations ” of Park’s, the details of which Schenck says he does not know ; the third (to the amount of £500) represented cash; the rest (£2,000), being put down to “ commissions” paid to and “refunded” by Albert Grant, making an actual payment of £500 out of endorsements to the extent of £4,897. In May, 1874. the transaction having meantime been subjected to some venal criticism by the licentious press, Park and Schenck settled their accounts, when Park told Schenck that there was a sum due General Schenck on account of some other “stock speculations” | sufficient to balance accounts. Here, it seems to us, Sechenek made his only mistake in the whole transaction; for, instead of taking this as a final settlement, he declared that he owed money to | Park, and insisted on transferring to him a quantity of stock, valued (by whom does not appear) at $32,000, and $1,700 cash, thus manifesting a total disbelief in Park’s statements, which is, to say the least, singular. At the same time, Schenck is to retain the income from this stock, and has the right to redeem it within three years. On being asked why, if Park said that he was Schenck’s debtor, the Jatter should have insisted on transferring his property to him, he said that this was on account of the publie criticism of his connection with the Mine. He also gave his note for 83,000, on which -ark will no doubt, indue course of time, make endorsements. At the same time he borrowed $15,000 more of Park and gave him the mort- gage of his house in Washington, of which we have heard so much before, and which, it now appears, was not given as security for his purchase of shares at all. It also appears that he received about $10,000 in dividends, and still holds 475 shares, worth about £2,500 more. So far as any cash transactions are concerned, therefore, the account stands as follows: Schenck’s receipts, $12,5€0; payments (£500 + $1,700), $4,200; Schenck’s profits, $8,300. General Schenck has also ful'y explained all the matters in dispute connected with his resignation. It will be recollected that he mailed his resignation to Washington on the 19th of February. On the 2d of March he begged that his resignation might not be accepted ; on the 3d, his request was refused ; on the 4th, the resig- nation was received; on the 6th, accepted; and on the 6th, the same day, the writ served on General Schenck was withdrawn, with an apology from the English lawyers, who said they had beet “under the impression ” that the General “ had resigned.” This explanation resembles, in one respeet, those of Professor Silliman ane r. Stewart. Mr. Silliman, aceording to Lyon, sent a Sill 1 Mr. St rt. Mr. Sil | to Ly t | despatch to England in 1872 to this effeet: ** Eight thousand tens dis- covered since last report; sample assay, two thousand dollars per ton.” This he indignantly denied, and declared that what he did telegraph was: “Sample assays twenty-eight per cent. lead and $2,000 silver. Reserves discovered since last report, over cight thou- sand tons.” Mr. Stewart was declared letter in which he spoke of the Enyna | This he indignantly denied, and says that he takes the grou that the phrase a ‘ worked-out” mine does i that the mine has been’ worked In the same General Schenck denies that there was any want of good fait his transactions with Park, and then, by way of proving this, makes the explanation we have just recapitulated. ‘The Committee are now engaged in cross-examining Lyon, the Emma partners be- by Lyon to have written a * worked-out ” mine as a out. ing desirous of showing that he is a bad character and uny belief. But nothing that is proved about Lyon can have any bear- ing on the fuets already proved by other evidence. Schenek’s expla | nation, aay business man or lawver can see, is a confession of frets which would in civil proceedings render him liable to the share holders, and which would make it necessary tor a grand jury to indict him for a conspiracy to defraud if he was within reach ot process. bv a vote of 31 to 17, the Senate has passed the resolution re ported by the Foreign Affairs Committee, * That the Senate does not advise and consent to the nomination of Richard H. Dana, jr., to be Minister to England.” An analysis of the vote shows that Mr. Dana’s support was entirely Republican, the Democrats either refusing to vote, pairing, absenting themselves, or voting against him. Of the 31 votes against the nomination, twenty were Demo- cratic, so that if the Democrats had really treated the matter, some of them affected to consider it, as a party question, with which they had nothing to do, there would have been a majority in Mr. Dana’s favor. as The House Judiciary Committee has reported on Mr. Pierrepont’s letters to the Western district-attorneys which he up, and Babeock got hold of and published, censuring him for his behavior. The Committee truly observes that ‘ the testimony of accomplices has been used against their associates from the early ages of our jurisprudence.” This is no more news to Mr. Pierrepont than it is to the public, or to Babcock. ence and necessity of the practice of using the testimony of accom- plices under promises of immunity, nor of the probable effect that the letter, even if sent privately, would have had on the minds of the prosecuting officers in Louis and When we find the President and the Attorney-General making arrange- ments to prevent the production of material evidence for the prosecution in Government cases, the only question is, ** What are we going to do about it?” Still further light promises to be thrown on Babeock’s case by the evidence of a man named Bell, who swears that he was employed by Babeock or his friends to steal evidence for him in the West. We of nothing in the character of the “ tarnished” man to render the siory improbable. ] ‘ arew The question is not as to the exist- St. elsewhere. know — The Senate has passed a law amendatory of the Bankrupt Act, to the effeet that bond-fide voluntary assignments made (without preferences) under State laws shall not be a bar toa discharge of | the debtor, if afterwards adjudged a bankrupt in involuntary pro-

Page 2

220 The ceedings. Besides this the Senate has done little of general in- terest, except with reference to the regular appropriation bills. Messrs. Boutwell and Bayard have had an encounter over Mr. Mor- ton’s resolution for a committee of investigation into the political affairs of Mississippi (subsequently passed), which went off, as we fancy most encounters with Mr. Boutwell would be likely to, rather tamely. In the House, the Belknap articles, based on the evidence of the Marshes, have been adopted, managers ap- pointed, and Belknap formally impeached before the Senate. The investigations are going on as usual, and early in the week it was reported that “‘ Robeson had been caught,” or, in other words, that the Secretary of the Navy had been detected in crimes and misdemeanors of some kind. But it is as yet too early to say positively what the precise nature of the transactions between the Government and Jay Cooke will turn out to be. The Real-Estate Pool witness, Kilbourne, is still inearcerated, and his ingenuity Nation. The old silver dollar was not demonetized until 1873, and was, therefore, part of the lawful coin money of the country up to that time. Should Congress, while the silver fever is on, restore that coin, there is nothing to prevent the establishment of the claim that the Treasury notes can be redeemed in silver as well as all the bonds of the United States issued since the outbreak of the war. Of course, silver with such an extended use for it would advance in price, but, nevertheless, the public creditors would be swindled out of a good part of what is due them. This, while the same kind of a fraud as that for which Mr. Pendleton was so great a stickler, could be committed in the name of ‘hard money.” It would be well, therefore, for senators and members of Congress who favor hard money to be on the lookout for such a scheme, and we also respectfully suggest to some of the newspaper writers who have approved of the House measure to be on the lookout for pitfalls. seems to be now devoted to the discovery of new and hitherto un- | dreamt of ways of “ getting even” with the Government. It seems that he is, while in prison, eating and drinking at the rate of from fifteen to twenty-five dollars a day, and, in fact, gives what may be called Bastile Banquets from day to day, to which he invites Boss Shepherd and the other gentlemen connected with the Pool. The | Democrats, who now begin to fear that investigation in this way may defeat its own ends, and, instead of benefiting the Govern- ment, lead to pecuniary loss, are going to look into these bills (they include, by the way, $3 a day for “ drayage,” this term being the political equivalent of restaurant carriage-hire), and if it cannot be stopped we trust they will release Kilbourne at once. The House of Representatives on Friday committed itself by a vote of 122 to 100 to the folly of substituting silver coins for frac- tional notes, and further to the enormity of making silver tokens a legal tender for $25, and “trade-dollars” a legal tender for $50. That the important principles involved were not understood by many who voted for the bill is evident from the weight which was given to Mr. Randall’s representations that it was simply a question of expense—that is, whether the Government should be burdened with a heavy charge in keeping up the fractional notes, or should save the public money by issuing silver. The falsity of this claim was thoroughly shown up by Mr. Hewitt, but apparently not to the satisfaction of the duller members of the House. The pretension put forward when the subject first came up, that the substitution of silver for fractional notes would be a step towards resump- tion in 1879, was abandoned, but no one showed that the bill would have the tendeney of driving California or rather the people of the Pacific coast into suspension and into the use of the paper legal tender with which the Atlantic States have been cursed since 1863. The only legal tender in use on the Pacifie coast is gold; and subsidiary silver coins, which can only be passed here as the fractional parts of the paper dollar (worth about 88 cents in gold), can be passed there as the fractional parts of the gold dollar. It will be strange therefore if, when the silver tokens appear, they are not gathered up and sent to California and gold obtained for them. This movement might continue until Cali- fornia had lost a good part of its gold. The third section of the Silver Bill, which makes the silver tokens a legal tender for $25, will of course aggravate this tendency, and the country may be prepared to hear very soon after their appearance that California and the Pacific States have, by the ‘‘step” which Congress has taken towards resumption, been carried or driven into suspension. The panic of last summer in San Francisco was indirectly caused by the executivn of the first section of the Sherman Bill; and if | another crisis should be precipitated the people of that section may well pray to be delivered from their friends—the Big Bonanza princes. There is another feature of this silver question which short- sighted advoeates of a sound currency will do well to consider. The Alabama Claims report will shortly come up in the House, and we trust that in the debate the attention of the members may be called to the opinion of the present court of Alabama Commission- ers, in the case of West v. The United States. This commission was created by the act of 1874, when the job had only gone so far as to involve a swindle of the insurance companies, and when nobody yet dreamed of carrying out the idea of which this was the germ to its logical consequences of a general “ grab.” The Court use the following significant language: ‘ Does not national courtesy and good faith require of us to suppose that Congress, in creating this Court, never intended we should distribute this fund other than for the purposes for which Great Britain supposed she was paying it? For instance, suppose Congress had chosen to keep half the fund and convert it into the Treasury of the nation, or had directed this Court to distribute it among those whose commercial interests had been injured by the terror and alarm caused by the insurgent cruisers, or among those who had suffered loss by the depredations of rebel cruisers other than the Alabama, Florida, and Shenandoah. In such cases, would not | Great Britain have had cause to complain that she had been misled, | overreached, deceived? Would our Government have been acting | in good faith in making such disposition of this fund ?” | The Connecticut election, on Monday, went, as it was generally expected to, in favor of the Democrats, but by a largely reduced majority. The total vote was less than that of last year, and the Republicans announced beforehand that they had little hope of carrying the State. Mr. D. A. Wells made a good canvass in the Third Congressional District, and drew off a heavy vote from the Republican candidate, who only won the day by a majority of a few hundred. There could not have been a better proof of the vastly greater importance the average voter attaches at the present time to character, ability, and reputation in a _ candidate than he does to any other considerations. The other po- litical news of the week chiefly consists of the meetings of Republican nominating conventions in Mississippi, Pennsylvania, Vermont, and Ohio. Mississippi is for Morton, Pennsylvania for their preferences. All the platforms are very much alike, and strongly in favor of reform, particularly that from Mississippi, where Governor Ames has just resigned to escape impeachment, as Cardozo, the State Superintendent of Education, did before him. Nothing but a new Force Bill will now save the State, and Mr. Mor- ton has given notice in the Senate of his intention to pass one which the Supreme Court will not be able to upset. ‘‘ Morton and Equal Rights” will be the ery from the Mississippi Valley to Cin- cinnati. The week has brought forth little of interest in Wall Street, except | the decline in the gold premium, the price as expressed in Treasury [Number 562 Hartranft, Ohio for Hayes, while the Vermonters have not declared , as lik in th ca co hi re ex cO be of M to of gr wi In da sit wl in, mi th Op th ad th fu be M

Page 3

Apr. 6. 1876] notes having fallen to 1123;a1127,. speculative, was due to the fact that the amount of gold in the New York banks is more than twice what was held a year ago, and that it will not be a long time before the May interest comes out of the Treasury. The London money market also continues very easy, and, as the Bank of England is steadily gaining gold, it is thought the official rate of the Bank w The small exports of gold from here show that few remittances are sent rather than that there is an abundance of sterling bills offering. The Stock Exchange, notwithstanding that the crisis in the contest between the Panama Railroad and the Pacific Mail Steamship Co. has come, has been very dull. ill be lowered this week. Complaints pour in from all parts of the country that trade is psor, and that the weather is such that transportation off the railroads is almost impossible. Of course more than fine weather is needed to make trade active, but, with a tendency towards dulness, bal weather becomes a serious matter. New York merehants complain of the absence of Western and Southern buyers, and say that except for the trade of which New York is the jobbing centre, they are doing almost nothing. The New York banks have stood the April drain of curreney without re- ducing their surplus reserve much below &10,000,000, which is nearly double what they he!ld a year ago. The value in gold of $100 greenbacks has the week between ranged during S87 62 and $83 59. In England, the prolonged debate on the bill providing for the assumption by the Queen of the title of ‘Empress of India” seems likely to end in the abandonment of the measure by the Ministry, in spite of the majority by which the second reading was carried in the House of Commons. A more puerile discussion than it has called forth has not taken place in England in modern times. The comic element in it has been heightened by Mr. Disraeli’s avowal of his desire to accommodate the people of India in the matter, whom he represented as largely desiring the assumption of a title of some kind different from ‘ Queen,” but what title he was unable to say exactly, nor did he produce any evidence of the desire. There has consequently been much discussion as to whether the Hindoos would be best satisfied by having her called *‘ Malikah,” or “Malik,” or “Sultana,” or ** Shahin-Shah,” or ‘“ Padishah,” or “ Maharani,” all of which are objected to on one ground or another. At this point Mr. Max Miiller appears on the scene, and cuts the knot in a letter to the Zimes, showing, by reference to the old Sanskrit of the Rig- Veda and the Atharva-Veda, that the right name for the sovereign of India is “ Adhiraja’’ or “‘Samraj,” but that there is “a still grander title” than this, viz., Rajadhiraja, which he “ feels certain would be understood, appreciated, and loved by every true son of India.” Naturally enough, the sober English people have been every day growing more and more disgusted with this stuff, and the oppo- sition to the bill out of doors been becoming stronger and more bitter. As the Queen could, by the exercise of her prerogative, give herself * tm] whatever title she pleased as ruler of India, the only object in pass- ing an act about it is to make the formal assumption of any title more solemn and impressive, and all the virtue of the act would, therefore, lie in the unanimity with which it passed. If bitterly opposed, as this is, it is generally felt it ought not to pass, and since the Opposition have resolved on the extreme measure of trying to address the Queen asking her not to take the title of ‘* Empress,” the Ministry doubtless feel that the scheme ought not to be pressed further. It has been thoroughly theatrical and ridiculous from the beginning, and touches English sentiment in a very tender place. Mr. Gladstone’s protest against it has been of his speeches. ablest one The Ministry has also been getting mto trouble about India through the action of Lord Salisbury, who seems to be too high and mighty a personage for our time, both in sending a very peremptory despatch to the Governor-General directing all proposed Indian legislation to be submitted to the Secretary for India at home betore being enacted, of which there is universal disapproval, and in di- The Nation. This decline, while ina measure recting the removal of the Indian duty on cotton goods at a certain fixed date—a measure avowedly projected in the interest « » Man chester manufacturers, and not in obedience to the principle of free-trads simply, because there are other portions of the Indian tariff whieh are much more objectionable on economie ground lle has defended this proceeding so fully in the House of Lord t coming so close on other mistakes, it helps to make the position of the Ministry almost preearious, and it would be decidedly prec ns if the Liberals had bold and enterprising leaders and some ed policy. The Freneh Ministry have read a * Declaration,” in the nature | of a presidential message, to the Chambers, containing a sort of out ' to him mM ah line of their policy. It reeognizes the legitimacy of a government based on universal sufirage ; profes-es fidelity to the * liberal econ servative spirit”; promises that the subordinate funetior s will make the Republic understood and appreciated by the people, by showing them how much more than any other form of government it rests on the general virtue and intelligence ; proacial L pede foreign policy; announces that, in renewing the commercial trea shortly to expire, the Government will persevere in * the wise policy of free trade,” problems of municipal government and university education. The correspondent of the London Times reports the comments of a mem- ber of the Cabinet on the Declaration, which means, he says, that and will shortly submit measures dealing with the ten or twelve of the present prefects, who have been pk rea tionary in their conduct, ought to be and will be dismissed ; but that, apart from this, everything will be done to give good men a teeling of security in their places; that the state of siege now maintained in four Departments will be brought to an end on the Ist of Ma that the Government will bring in a bill for the reform of the mu- nicipalities—that is, making the mayors elective, but will endeavor to provide that the elections will not take place within the year, to avoid the agitation they would cause; that last session, making university education tree, of whieh the Catholic clergy are so largely availing themselves, will be modi reserve to the Government the right of g the degrees. this is very promising, and it is made all the more so by the fact that Gambetta’s organ announees that the Ministry will, as tu Left is concerned, be judged by its acts. present the ot the ed so ranting as the Finance, made to the that Italy has turned rrocess of deliverance In the first place The statement of the Italian Minister of Chambers a fortnight ago, seems to indicate the corner in her finances, and that a steady | from her burdens may now be looked for. *, the unpaid arrears of taxes, whieh amounted in 1874 (the fiscal year in Italy is the solar year) to 840,000,000, amounted in 1875 to only $4,000,000, and all the items of the internal revenue had increased to such a degree that the deficit, which was wuthough The income expected to be $16,000,000, was only about 85,500,000, in this is included a vote of $3,000,000 for railroads. of 1875 was $277,500,000, and the outgo was 8$283,000,000. In taking up the estimates of i876, be said that, considering that they included considerable sums for railways and other internal improvements, he had at first set down a deficit of $3,000,000, but after seeing the results of 1875 he felt warranted in predict that not only would there be no deticit, but that there would be a surplus of $3,500,000. No wonder this announcement caused a “ sensation” in the Chamber. The law obliges the Minister, besides presenting the estimates for the current year in the month of March, to present also ** a provisional estimate ” for the year following, and accordingly Signor Minghetti set down bis surplus for 1877 at $5,000,000, which caused another and greater sensation. In taking this highly favor- able view of the future, he relied much on the working of the new he expected much advantage nye commercial treaties, through which for the treasury, while remaining faithful to the principles of free- trade introduced into Italy by Cavour, the furtherance of which was (Minghetti) a matter of pride.

Page 4

999 THE SENATE. to a that a feeling of great anxiety and appre ot likely to diminish, has been produced in tand up t men of all parties by the con- in the Dana case. We do not know at this i confirmed or rejected prob: bly th recurds the feeling of the country about the ces no difference which is done. The important that the affair has revealed a state of morals on the part of both Democratic and Republican sides of the Chamber which is us even of what remained of popular confidence in the Nor is the publie judgment about the contrast between Mr. Dana’s character and position as an American citizen and that of those senators who have sailed him, though it is painful enough and humiliating enough to respect for it. haped by the } nual bene ana The Nation | and the consulates. the national pride. This contrast was depicted in a powerful and | impressive article, entitled “ Tableaux,” in the 7ribune of last Wed- | nesday, which we wish every man and woman in the country could read and digest. Messrs. Cameron and Morton, is a matter of comparatively small What troubles people is that a body charged with such moment. high and weighty functions, and surrounded by so many guarantees | for its integrity and independence, should be capable of acting in vay towards any man, even if, instead of being a famous lawyer and literary man, and an honest gentleman, he were in unknown A or B. To hear and act on charges made secretly by personal enemies, themselves of bad or doubtful reputation, no matter who was the their attacks, were things fit to assist the President in administering the foreign affairs of a great nation. This, however, might have ccused on the ground of haste, and atoned for by a prompt retreat from an unfortunate situation; but the persistence in the original error, on the ground that the letter which this outrage object of unworthy of men 4 1c called forth from their victim was not sufficiently respectful, indi- cates a state of moral dilapidation in which, taken in connection with the recent revelations made about the condition of the civil For it must be remembered that the Senate is now the greater part of the Gov- ernment. It has an absolute veto on all legislation and, through appointing power and in the making of treaties, paramount influence on administration. In fact, it is now half the legislative and two-thirds of the executive branch, and exerts a vice, thoughtful men see reason for genuine alarm. its share in the strong intluence on the composition of the Supreme and subordinate Federal Courts. Moreover, it has more permanence than any other branch of the Government. It is the only portion of it which passes ha Presidential term without submitting itself to the popular judgment, and its permanence has been made the more striking of What Mr. Dana is, however, as compared to hy the growing evanescence of the various civil officers. fis character is, therefore, of enormous and increasing importance | to the e 'y Filled with pure, honorable, well-informed, and patriotie men, it is the made up even In great part of jobbers, adventurers, peculators, ogues, it becomes a political nuisance of the worst kind & pest-house the infection from which will eventually poison the tinesphere of the whole country. , ( Gemaye hat such powers as the Senate was armed with would beget first deliberative assembly in the world; | temptation to eneroach on the other departments of the | (rovernment was foreseen in the earliest days of the Republic. Madison, in discussing the chances of encroachment on the part of the Executive or the.Senate, said the danger lay with the latter, | but concluded that on the whole more danger lay with the House of Representatives than with either. thout foreseeing the enormous change which has since his day taken place in the constitution of the civil service, and there- machinery of government. Still less did he foresee the control Which the civil service would one day exercise over the expression of the popular will, both in the nomination and election of Presi- But Madison formed this judg- | power of the Senate over the Executive and the whole } [Number 462 dents and legislators. The Senate’s share in the appointing power Was a Comparatively trifling matter when the office-holders were a small body, of whom “few died and none resigned.” When they buinter 80,600, and there is a clean sweep every four years, this hare constitutes both an immense privilege and one of the most corrupting agencies to which any legislative body was ever exposed. That the Senat vill now deny. It is the very fountain-head of the great national disease Which is day by day filling us with shame and foreboding. When the Postmaster-General turns a postmaster out of office, he row formally requests rot the President, but cne of the senators to fill the vaeaney, and he fills it. The Custom-House and revenue offices and those of the Department of the Interior are filled in the same way, and, in fact, there may be said to be nothing left for the President but the diplomatic service If the appointing senator was supervised by his colleagues, the system might not be very bad, however ur- constitutional ; but he is not. Under what is called euphemistically “the courtesy of the Senate,” but which is in reality a sort of cor- rupt covenant for a proper division of the spoils, each Senator is protected by his colleagues in the arbitrary use of his patronage, without enquiry or hindrance, and the same phrase is made to sustain the arbitrary control of foreign appointments by the Com- mittee on Foreign Affairs. To complete the picture, we must recollect that nearly all appointments are made with a view to regu- lating the expression of public opinion in the nominating conven- tions and at the polls——or, in other words, to managing the electoral machinery, which is now of extraordinary complexity—and we then see how vast and far-reaching is the power, either direct or indirect, which the Senate has acquired over the Government through the appointing power. It has already filled the civil service with its creatures, and we are now witnessing an attempt to put its crea- ture in the White Howse. General Grant has notoriously been for some time in the hands of a kind of managing committee, which Harper's Weekly calls the “ Senatorial Group,” and the rejection of Dana is due far more to irritation at the President’s insubordination in sending in a name which was not on their “slate,” than to any- thing else. It is impossible in the limits of a singie article to describe the variety of influences which have combined to build up this remarka- ble system, but among them may be mentioned, besides the great in- crease in the number of Government officers since the war, the decline in the character of State legislatures which the past fifteen years has witnessed ; the increase in the size, complexity, and cost- liness of the political machine produced by the growth of popu- lation; the vast recent additions of ignorant and manageable voters ; the absence since 1860 of a respectable opposition ; and the injection into the Senate from the Southern and new Western States of a eonsiderable body of members without character or lawful calling, and without other qualification than recently-aequired wealth. The presence of even a small body of adventurers of this sort speedily lowers the tone of a legislative assembly otherwise re- spectable, through the necessity, which one party or the other experiences daily, of negotiating with them or conciliating them ; and for such persons ‘‘the courtesy of the Senate” of course only serves the purpose of the light overcoat which pickpockets carry gracefully on their arms when they enter a street-car in quest of purses and watches. Under all these circumstances, the management of the party ma- chinery falls naturally into the bands of the senators. They are more permanently in office and wield more power than any other members of the party, and bave not unfrequently reached their places by the practice of the very intrigues which they are called on to superintend on a larger scale when they go to Wash- ington. The loeal “managers” all work under the senator as their superior officer, and his failure or refusal to direct them actively is likely to cost him his place. Mr. Conkling, ate has succumbed, too, few who know it J { for instanee, relies or relied for his chanee of controlling the State delegation and getting the Presidential nomivation on the skill with ol p ae OF i re te r¢ B au

Page 5

Apr. 6,1 876] which the Government oltices had been used for pariisan under bis orders. This leads naturally to the last thing we have to say at present on a subject of no ordinary moment, and that is, that tl power of patronage, purposes is enormous and the use of patronage in withdrawing no- minations, and through them elections, from the control of publie opinion, naturally begets a contempt for non-official expressions of public opinion—that is, all expressions of it that do not reach the Senate through the regular channel of the district association, the “ pre-primary,” the county aud State conve tion, or the district- attormey, marshal, or collector, if there be one. The criticism, for instance, ef a hostile newspaper or of a hostile meeting is nearly as revolting or contemptible to a hard-working “ Administration sena- tor” as it is to a Prussian general of cavalry, though for less respectable reasons. The curious but incautious outburst of Mr. A. j B. Cornell against the Union League resolutions as * impudent,” was | an interesting revelation of a state of mind which is now that ofa large number of the senators, so much so that some of them already boast that they never read the newspapers. They bave acquired their power, and keep it, through machinery which is not affected either by popular opinion or passion. In fact, they have converted the “ship of state” imto a steamboat, in which we are all passengers, but are not allowed either to speak to the man at the wheel, enter the engine-room, or ask for the reckoning, though we see the officers throwgh the glass door playing poker and drinking champagne. their senses, and to reform abuses and prevent corruption and make elections free, we must leave them fewer oflices to fill. THE ALABAMA JOT. U NDER the award of the Geneva Court of Arbitration the United } States received the sum of $15,500,600 in gold for dam: caused through the negligence of the British Government in permit- ting the escape of Cenfederate cruisers during the Rebe!lion. The Treaty of Washington, drawn up in the spring of 1871, was very definite and precise in its provisions. 4 74 By the first article, reference was made to ‘differences ” between the two Governments “ grow- ing out of the by the several which have given rise to the claims generically known as the ‘ Alabama Claims,’” and agreeing that “all the said claims” “be referred to a Tribunal of Arbitration,” to be composed of five arbitrators. By the sixth article, the ‘Treaty provided three rules of interna- tional law with regard to the duties of neutrals, and, having laid down the law, proceeded to define its application in the seventh and tenth articles by the following very strict clauses : acts committed vessels, ‘¢The said Tribunal shall first determine as to each vessel sepa- rately whether Great Britain has, by any act or omission, failed to fulfil any of the duties set forih in the foregoing three rules, or recognized by the principles of international law not inconsistent with such rules, and shall certify such fact as to each of the said vessels. In case the Tribunal find that Great Britain has failed to fulfil any duty or duties as aforesaid, it may, if it think proper, pro- ceed to award a sum in gross to be paid by Great Britain to the United States for all the claims referred to it. “In case the Tribunal finds that Great Britain has failed to ful- fil any duty or duties as aforesaid, and does not award a sum in gross, the high contracting parties agree that a board of assessors shall be appointed, to ascertain and determine what claims are valid, and what amount or amounts shall be paid by Great Bri- tain to the United States on account of the liability arising from such failure, as to each vessel, according to the extent cf liability as decided by the arbitrators.” such By the final article, the Treaty provided that ‘the result of the 4 > rr... by ” e J ” proceedings of the Tribunal” or of the “ board of assessors” should be ‘‘a full, perfect, and final settlement of all the claims.” Under The moral of it all is, that to bring them to Why should they ? | The Nation. 223 transfer of the commercial marine to the British thag, er Ul 0) | gation and increased expense of the war. They also decided that the only cruisers for whose act Treaty the United States ecculd recover were the Algha Florida (with their tenders), and the Shena th Melbourne). Having thus determined the extent of ‘‘as to each vessel,” the only remaining ques ( whether the Tribunal would award a lump sum « case to assessors; and, second, whether they would alow inte: est, and if so, at what rate. As to the first, tl \ merely one of convenience. It has since been the “lump sum” was really a means of gi i rectly for claims which the Tribunal had in so \ directly ruled out. If this country had been represemted court by B. F. Butler, and Great Britain by Dr. Kenealy, t might, perhaps, be some ground for’ sueh a sus) > but much as the American and English representatives were Mr. Ad | and Sir A. Cockburn, it is no more than fair to sup] ey did not perjure themselves when they agreed to determi l ly, in accordance with certain rules laid down by the | amount of damages to be awarded, and did not stultity thre selves by first unanimously declaring that certain e| allowable by international law, and then admitting them by a contemptible quibble. There is certainly no trace of an) tention in the record of the proceedings. With regard to tl of interest, seven per cent. was claimed by our Government, and six per cent. was allowed by the Tribunal. Thus far, the reference of the Alabama Claims to the High Co wes | had produced the following results : The Tribunal had deeid Great Britain was liable for the acts of the three cruisers Mentioned above, and also expressly decided by separate votes that she y liable for the acts of the Georgia, Srmiter, Nashville, oy of t} otkers. It had also decided that the United States had no ce] i ‘“‘national losses,” nor for “indirect damages”: that the ‘1 re mium” men had no claim; that the totalamount of direct « caused by the three cruisers was, with interest, $15,500,000, round numbers, calling the time during which interest Was running twelve years, $13,500,000 principal, and $2,000,000 interest. Tl sum the Tribunal gave to the United S:ates as a * trust-fund,” to be distributed ** according to the tenor and spirit of the award ” (we quote the language of the counsel of the United States) ar 1 4 ants. It could Keep none of it itself. It had colle n agent, and must pay it over as anagent. These claimants were now reduced to three principal kinds—shippers, ship-owners, and - ers. As to the latter class, there was no dispute before the Tri ul that all underwriters who had paid as for a total loss stood shoes of the original owuers, and were, in the te of the law, ‘subrogated ” to their rights. Now, what has Congress done with this t ( ! vi two years after the decision of the Tribunal-—-namely, till the pa rh of the act of June, 1874—absolutely noth Whiate For nearly four years, during which time it has accumulated trom | 815,500,000 to more than $20,000,000, drawing interest at five pet | cent., it has remained in the Treasury. By the act itself ¢ i surers, Who had been from the first, by our Government and by all the arbitrators, decided to have the same rights to the money which the claimants themselves would have had, were depri ol half their rights; and anew Court of Alabama Claims was convened, directed not to allow any insurer’s claim unless he could s! that he sum ef his losses exceeded the sum of his premiun nd then to no greater extent than the difference between the two—or, in other words, was expressly directed not to to the insurers the these rules, the Tribunal, having the whole case left to them by | both Governments, decided, Ist, that Great Britain was liable for “direct losses ”’—i.e., losses of ships and cargoes, ete.; 2d, that she was not liable for any indirect losses, such as the enhanced rates of insurance eaused by the war; 3d, that the United States had no claim for what were known as “national losses,” such as the money which the Government had just collected in court tor then ! hould be this n that the elaimants the second place, the act provided entitled to interest at four per cent., the difference between rate and that of six per cent. awarded by the ‘Tribunal being kept back, on what ground nobody has yet had the assurance to state. This, however, was only q beginning. After all the payments that may be made under the act of 1874 there will be a large surplus, and it

Page 6

The Nation . . er . . | mains to be decided how it shall be distributed. The majority of | the House Committee have accordingly gravely recommended that the money be paid, first, to the claimants who lost by the vessels for ets the Tribunal « ressly decided Great Britain was not i] for whose acts she paid none of this money; second, to in claimants, whose claims were expressly ruled out ; there shall be any money left, to the insurers, who are of the three cl; s who have any valid claims at all. Meanwhile, the State Department, which collected the claims and lt ioney into the ‘Treasury, stands by as if it had nothing to do h the case. it lifiicult to say whether the case is made more or less mon- strous by the faet that the Committee is very evenly divided in its report, there being a bare majority in favor of the bill reported. Phis shows that the decision arrived at has been no hasty deter- mination, but is the result of discussion, arzument, and examina- | | | | (Number 562 THE BATTLE OF THE BOOKS. \| R, DANA may fairly be congratulated, from one point of view, on his : treatment by the Senate, for the o} portunity it has afforded him of making the public acquainted with the real nature of a transaction in which there was a vague impression in the minds of many people that he had been in some way to blame—an impression which was con- firmed or strengthened by the fact that in the controversy between him and Lawrence there had been a judicial decision against him, in which he had, to some extent at least, been held answerable for | an infringement of Lawrence’s copyright. The shape which the story | took in the minds of many people, to our own knowledge, was something tion of evidence ; so that it appears, taking this Lill and the former | act together, that the result of judicial discussion of private rights ina Committee of the House of Representatives is more likely on the whole, after due consideration, to be in favor of simple robbery than anvthing else. But the eileet of the disposition of this fund made by Congress } upon the rights of the particular claimants is a matter of compara- tively small concern. The disastrous part of the whole business is - the effeet upon the repwation and character of the Government and the nation. The A‘icame ‘Treaty and the subsequent proceedings have not been transacted on a narrow and provincial stage; we have called in the world to witness the nolle example set by the two foremost nations of modern times in substituting peaceful methods of settling quarrels for violence, blocdshed, and war. We not only virtually, but in express terms, oficred to show a benighted and barbarous generation our love of justice and law by submitting a grave international dispute to the decision of a court of justice. The submission of the Alabama Claims to a court was received the world over as a harbinger of the new gospel which was finally to do away with war altogether and put justice im its place. There is now no eseape for us. The result will be judged in the light of the promises; and the question that the pub- lic will ask will be, not simply has something been substituted fur violence, but what is presented to us in exchange? Can it be fraud? When we reeall the glowing language that was used six years ago about the “ principle of arbitration,” it is difficult to be- lieve that the management cf the business by the Government has not been from first to last a rearing farce, got up for the purpose of bringing arbitration into contempt. Certainly, if that had been the object, no means could have been better adapted to the end than the submission of a dispute by a trustee to a volcntary court of justice and to rules of law until judgment was rendered in the plaintil’s tavor, and then, walking off with the money out of the reach of the precess of the court, defying it to enfvice its decree for the distribution of the trust-fund, and proceeding to do what he pleases with the money. Bismarck and Moltke, when they hear of this queer triumph of justice over the barbarous instinets of human nature, may well doubt whether there are not some things that are even worse than war and blood- shed. Isolated as America is from the rest of the world both by position and circumstances, and exempted as we are by our immense material wealth from many of the consequences which bad government would naturally have brought in its train, we are always inelined to look on “the bright side” even of our worst But such mistakes as the Alabama business has thus far been have no bright sic It would have been a thousand times better than what has happened that all the meney we received from England should have been sunk in the sea, and that the High Court should never have met to illustrate the “ principle of arbitra- tion’ at all. errors. We should have been then, at least, spared the shame of seeing the Government submitting to rules of law to evade those of justice, and swindling its citizens at home to disgrace them abroad. of this sort: That Mr. Lawrence was a great master of international law, who had with much honor and authority annotated two editions of Wheaton at the request of and for the benefit of Wheaton’s family, but that his last edition gave dissatisfaction to the Republican party during the war, on account of its views on the right of secession and the rights and duties of neutrals ; ** Copperhead” ana ‘* rebel sympathizer,” and that, at the suggestion of Mr. Seward, Mr. Dana was induced to undertake a ‘‘loyal” edition of the work as a rival to Mr. Lawrence’s, with notes taking the Northern view of the various questions of public law raised by the Rebellion, and that Mr. Dana went to work and did bring out such an edition, but stole extensively from Mr. Lawrence’s notes on non-controverted points, and endeavored in a crafty and fraudulent manner to supersede Mr. Law- rence’s work in the market, and that on Mr. Lawrence’s suing him he (Dana) swore roundly that he had carefully abstained from any use whatever of Mr. Lawrence’s labors, but was speedily found out by the Court and exposed in a decision which the New York World and General Butler knew of, but nobody else, or nobody but Mr. Dana’s unscrupulous partisans, who of course tried to keep it secret. This was the story in its worst form ; as it spread it assumed among some of those more friendly to Mr. Dana the form of a charge that Mr. Dana had undertaken a rival edition of Wheaton, and had, being an honorable man, meant to abstain religiously from any use of Mr. Lawrence’s notes, but that, being very busy with his professional prac- tice, he had left the greater portion of the work to certain young lawyers, who had helped themselves freely to Lawrence’s accumulations, with resulting damage to Mr. Dana's reputation. Of course the great body of the public knew nothing about the matter and cared nothing, and, owing to its nature, probably no effort on Mr. Dana’s part would, under ordinary cir- cumstances, have been sufficient to obtain for him a fair and intelligent hearing of his ease. His nomination to the Senate would not have pro- cured it either, because outside the small circle who took any interest in his copyright quarrel his character stood too high to call for enquiry or hesita- tion of any kind. But Providence so ordered it that his two worst enemies, one of them notorious for the badness of his character and the other with atemper that would bear some improvement, rushed on to Washington, on hearing of his nomination, with charges which would have fallen stillborn if the Committee of the Senate had been a tribunal composed of honorable men, and Mr. Dana would thus again have lost the oppor- tunity of a vindication. It so happened, however, that the nomination was very distasteful to some of them, who had other ends in view, and ac- that Lawrence was, therefore, roundly abused as a | cordingly the appearance of Lawrence and Butler was very welcome and their charges very grateful, and they were promptly acted on and the President requested to withdraw Mr. Dana’s name. This at once aroused the attention and indignation of the country, and Mr. Dana has obtained a hearing which the public does not accord to a private controversy once in a century. It has now been brought out clearly that, whatever Butler said before the Senate Committee, the letter published by him in the New York 7ribune was the composition of a liar and a ruffian, and that Mr. Lawrence, in acquiescing in it, even tacitly, as a statement of the case against his opponent, rendered himself an accomplice in the lying ; that Mr. Dana was not a rival of Mr. Lawrence, but a successor—that is, that he was employed by the Wheaton family to do for them a piece of work which they had previously employed Mr. Lawrence to do, and in which there would have been no question of Mr. Daga’s right to use the results of his predecessor’s labors but for one thing, viz., en alleged agreement be- tween Mr. Lawrence and Mrs. Wheaton, the evidence of which was a ‘*memorandum ” signed by Miss Wheaton, her daughter, but not by Mr. Lawrence, binding Mrs. Wheaton in certain conditions not to make any use of Mr. Lawrence’s notes in a new edition without his written consent, and to give him the right to make any use he pleased of his own notes. This ‘*memorandum” never grew into a formal agreement, and was returned by Mr. Lawrence after much fruitless negotiation, rh owt oles CUtitiw* a ead

Page 7

The and its validity forms the principal point in the suit pend- | ing. Mr. Lawrence maintains that although he returned it and never signed it, it is a binding contract ; the Wheatons, that, if a contract at all, it was obtained by false and fraudulent representations. There is strong evidence in support of the latter view, that of Professor Parsons and Mr. Little, and the agreement of the Wheatons with Mr. Dana was made in the belief that they had no contract with Lawrence, but were the full posses- sors at law and in equity of the copyright of his notes, and that therefore Mr. Dana, acting for them, might make what use he pleased of them. The Court, however, held that the ‘‘memorandum” was a valid agreement. This was the first point in the case. Apr. 6 1876 | now The second was whether Mr. Dana had sufficient notice of the existence of the agreement to make him a participant in the infringement of the copyright—if any such infringement there was—and therefore a proper | defendant in the suit along with the Wheatons. The Court held that he | had no actu il notice of it. But then, he was intimate with the Wheatons ; he knew that they had a controversy with Mr. Lawrence, although, in order not to be mixed up in it, he declined to receive any communication from them about it or to read the correspondence, and declined, as a matter of propriety, to read a long letter from Lawrence to Professor Parsons, whio was the Wheatons’ adviser, which Parsons had not read himself, and which did contain an assertion of the Lawrence claim ; and therefore the Court decided that he (Dana) had constructive knowledge of it—that is to say, it decided that if he had heard things which he did not hear but might have heard, and read things which he did not read but might have read, he would have known that Lawrence claimed an interest in the notes. This is the link, and the only one, which connects him with the case. The third question was, did Mr. Dana, as a matter of fact, the foregoing points being settled against him, infringe Mr. Lawrence’s copyright ? Ofac- tual copying of Mr. Lawrence’s notes there was no proof, but Mr. Dana him- self acknowledged that he used the Lawrence edition as freely as, but no more freeiy than, he used other works on international law. In passing on this point, the Court followed the rule laid down in England with regard to the copyright of a map, guide-book, or directory, in these words : ‘* Express de- cision in Kelley agt. Morris is that in the case of a map, guide-book, or direc- tory, or the like, where there are certain common objects of information which must, if described correctly, be described in the same words, a subsequent compiler is bound to do for himself that which was done by the first compi- Jer ; that he is not enditled to take one word of the information published | without independently working out the matter for himself so as to arrive at the same result from common sources of information ; and that the only use he can make of a previous publication of that kind is to verify his own calcu- Jations and results when obtained.” (The italics here are ours.) One does not need to be a lawyer to see the extraordinary vexatiousness of a rule of this kind applied to a work on international law, in treating which the illus- trations used must needs be prominent historical events, and the literature of | which is small in volume and composed very largely of mere iteration of opinions. No man could undertake for a second time the annotation of a work like Wheaton’s and pass through a net as fine as this is, and there was, therefore, nothing wonderful in the finding of the Court that Mr. Dana had in some places trespassed on Mr. Lawrence’s rights. But it made no decree giving Mr. Lawrence the relief he sought ; it did not enjoin the sale of Mr. Dana’s edition ; it simply decided that under this rule there had been infringements, and directed a Master to report what they were. Whether such an application of the rule will stand, will be decided by the Supreme Court. Seven years have elapsed since then and no report has been made. The present position of the matter may be illustrated thus : Dana is building a house on land adjoining Lawrence’s, who asserts (1) | that the lot on which the house is going up is his ; (2) that, if not, Dana has agreed never to build on it ; and (3) that he has agreed not to build nearer than within one foot of the boundary-line, and sues him in equity. Dana claims the whole lot, denies having ever made any agreement about it, and maintains that, in any event, the house is not nearer to the line than one foot. To settle the matter, there has to be a prolonged examina- tion of old deeds, surveys, and correspondence, extending over many years, and the Court decides (1) that Lawrence has no claim to the lot, and that it belongs to Dana ; (2) that Dana never agreed not to build, (3) but that there was correspondence between them which did amount to’an agreement on Dana’s part not to build within a foot of the line ; (4) that the line is diffi- cult to determine accurately, but does lie from a to b and from 3 to ¢, and that, while no part of Dana’s house overruns it, it appears that parts of the out-offices do, and that his eaves overhang it ; but the Court is unable to examine the matter for itself, and refers it to a surveyor to report how it Nation. AO» 225 stands with regard to the line as thus laid down, and refuses Lawrence's prayer for an injunction or conveyance, and leaves him to awatt the result of the report. Dana then says he will appeal to the Supreme Court. In the meantime, three notorious faro-bankers and mock-auctioneers, named Butler, Cameron, and Morton, hearing of the affair, and learning that Dana has been appointed to a foreign mission by the President, collect in the street in front of his house, headed by Lawrence, and begin to shout ** Thief ! thief !” and protest against such a man’s representing the country abroad. Dana appears at the window and warns them off, and threatens that he will call the police, and then they go back to their business, telling everybody that they knew he was a bad fellow, for he had just lost his temper. In this bit of exegesis we have made no use whatever of presumptions derived from the reputation and history of the parties to the controversy, powerfully as these would tell in Mr. Dana’s favor. On this point, indeed, we are in- clined to think that all who know them both will concur heartily in the opinion expressed some time ago by a distinguished American scholar and diplomatist apropos of this matter, ‘that Richard TH. Dana would steal from no man, and no man would steal from William B. Lawrence.” We must in closing say one word about the letter of which the Senate Committee has made such ridiculous use to cover its retreat from the discreditable position it first assumed. In hearing Lawrence and Butler in secret, and on the strength of their ex-parfe statements rv sting the President to withdraw Mr. Dana’s name, it inflicted on him the grossest outrage, as far as our recollection goes, ever committed on an individual of goed character, and belonging to an honorable calling, by an official body of dignity or authority. The offer, unoflicialls indirectly made, after the insult had been inflicted and made to hear Mr. Dana in his own defence, not a reparation but an aggravation. If Mr. Dana had gone down to Washington and addressed the Committee under these circumstances, his been an answer, but an appeal ad misericord been degrading to any man of honor to make. As soon as he received an authoritative account of the Committee’s action, he wrote the letter to Mr. Boutwell which has been published, and which we are sure will be and and le public was address would net have am, Which it would have has been pronounced by men of character and intelligence on both sides of the Atlantic a perfectly proper letter under the circumstances, containing the right thing said in the right way. The irritation over it displayed by a portion of the Senate we believe to be for the most part feigned Everybody who knows anything of these gentlemen, and thei: social and political hist: ry, knows that the goodness of their temper and their calmness under harsh language is one of the conditions of their success. Sothat we are, we think, only doing them justice in treating their horror of Dana’s intemperate lan- gua ge as a sly caucus joke which they enjoy mightily among themselves THE ROYAL TITLES BILL. Lonpox, March 21, 1876. YUBLIC interest this week has been concentrated upon one subject—a most important one—the Roval Titles Bill. I have 1 n so much unpleasant feeling upon any subject for a good many years as has been exhibited upon this during the past ten days. I do not know that the feeling has yet had time to penetrate very deeply into the lower strata of society, or to take hold on the publie mind in the larger London. now heard the republican centres, in Newcastle, Sheflield, Manchester, and Birmingham, which may ty it ser towns outside But a moaning sound is even in be the prelude to a storm of indignation shortly to arise against the House, uiyt ou or may merely be the distant reverberation of the outburst which und edly is now going on in the metropolis. When it was first announced in the Queen's speech that the present was deemed a fitting opportunity for making a formal addition to the style and titles of the sovereign, the matter, as I wrote to you at the time, was con- sidered as another piece of manvaise plaisanterie o n the part of the Prime Minister—a vulg: ir joke this time, and smacking more than ever of Mr. Disraeli’s passion for the footlights and tinsel of the theatre. But peo- ple were interested in other things of graver moment, and if the Queen did not mind gratifying her Premier's fancies, and allowing him the satisfaction of mouthing big words about Oriental potentates and august dignities, it really did not much matter. Mr. Disraeli was getting old, and he had done some public service, and if it was a satisfaction to him to make a grandiose speech about the royal house and the Eastern Empire, and to bring in a bill to add India to the crown titles, the people would not grudge it to him. It was like giving an old circus-horse a sniff of the sawdust to remind him of the antics of his youth. It was, indeed, whis- pered that it was possible, but highly unlikely, that some members of the royal family were like-minded with Mr. Disraeli ; that they considered the

Page 8

The title of Ki r Queer 1 nol good enough for them; and that it would be a fir hing to be called Imperial Ilighness, and to take soc ial position in the courts of ign emperors along with their connections of imperial rank i } lor But this was hardly credited. We all the sons and daughters of Queen Victoria, and of Queen ! f, d we could not believe that any Ministry—even the Mr. Disraclimeould seriously propose that the addition to the | f the Crown was to imprint the brand of Linpe rialism upon i dominions. The first rumor of a suspicion of this proposal thot ie to my ears was a casual bit of gossip at a dinner-party that Mr. i s isly d:squieted on the subject. The popular instincts of the old tribune of the people were excited ; he feared that Mr. Disraeli micht ke such a proposal, and he would not answer for the consequences in the country if he did. On the first reading of the bill, the Prime Minister was interrogated upon the subject, but he declined to answer. He, as his manner is when he ‘ wishes to impress the Llouse with the solemnity of the occasion, raised him- self erect, and, in that style which Mr. Bright once happily characterized Nation. as a ‘‘ mixture of pompousness and servility,” dilated upon the impolicy of interfering with the royal prerogative. This solemnity was the reverse of tranquillizing. The Opposition were alarmed, and they plied him with questions as to what title the Ministry would recommend the Queen to take. But again and again he declined to answer, and he wrapped himself up ina mysterious mannerism that argued badly for his cause. It was not until a notice to reject the bill unless the House were told what the title was to be was put upon the Order-Book that Mr. Disraeli consented to come down from his pedestal, and broke his silence with the announcement that the Queen was henceforth to be known as the ‘‘ Empress of India.” ‘‘ For the future her title will run thus,” he said, and he rolled out the words with unction, ** Victoria, by the grace of God, of Great Britain and Ireland Queen, Defender of the Faith, and Empress of India”! How the old cir- cus-horse pranced and neighed as he uttered these ‘‘ august designations” ! But the House of Commons, the Ministerialists no less than the Opposition, did not participate in his prancings. They looked, on both sides of the House, and obviously felt, uncomfortable. The House of Commons, what- ever some few of the individual members may be, is, in its corporate feel- ing, a refined and cultivated body, It has no sympathy with the intellectual propensities of charlatanism. In its entirety it is a collection of high-spir- ited English gi of sycophancy or courtiership. The members felt on this occasion that they were most unnecessarily being dragged through the dirt by the fancies of the Prime Minister—the gilt and tinsel dirt of an inferior theatre ; and not they only, but the prestige, the honorable dignities, and the grand tradi- ntlemen, and it is not casily carried away by the emotions ° e e,° ‘ . + . | tions of the British Crown. ‘* Mr. Disraeli,” as one man said to me as the Prime Minister sat down with an air of ineffable self-satisfaction on his gen- | erally immovable countenance—** Mr. Disraeli, not being content with the | degradation of the Tory aristocracy, is now trying to degrade the Crown.” | This was no overcharged expression of opinion. It described tie prevailing | I I ] g fecling of discomfort and degradation, and that feeling of discomfort and | degradation has been growing ever since. ‘The metropolitan press, or at least unanimous il that portion of it which is independent of the Conservative party, has been condemning the proposal. Every man you meet in the street, and every sensible woman whom you meet in society, talks of the suggestion with wndissuised contempt. The cynically-minded in the clubs make pretty good fun of the thing, but their kindliest criticisms contain asting—a sting directed not against the Prime Minister or the Ministry alone, but against even more important personages. Only to-day I heard a lamentation that Thackeray was gone. It was thought he might have added an Imperial chapter to his ‘ Book of Snobs,’ Luist Wednesday it was announced that Lord Hartington, the leader of the Opposition, was to move a resolution the object of which was to run the title of Queen against that of Emperor ; and when this was known a sense of relief was felt by all independent men who take an interest in politics, The Ministry, it was thought, would now withdraw their bill, or drop their | fantastic preposal to foist this un-English exotic on the Crown, and rest content with the simple incorporation of the word India into the existing attributes of the Queen. But this was not to be. The Ministerialists came down in masses to the House, sick men and cripples even being brought out of their beds to vote, and they carried tl 2 bill into committee in spite of their opponents. Lord Hartington never spoke better, and he was well supperted by Mr, Forster and Sir William Harcourt. But it was all in vain. The Chancellor of the Exchequer and a young understrapper of the | Government called Lord George Llamilton, a son of one of Mr. Disraeli’s mushroom dukes, were put up to answer, and the Prime Minister was so [Number 562 assured of victory that he did not think it worth his while to speak. The division was taken at half-past one on Friday morning, and the Opposition were defeated by a crushing majority, larger than any they have had against them ona party fight in this Parliament. And why, you may ask, should this have been if the feeling outside Parliament is as strong as I have said? The reasons are not quite clear as yet, perhaps they never will be. The Ministerialists strained every nerve of party allegiance, and not one man among them voted with the popular side. The same cannot be said of the Opposition. The leaders and the Radicals were staunch enough; but in the miscellaneous cohorts which make up the followers of Lord Hartington there is a section who are hardly independent of the influence of the Court. They are a heterogeneous crowd, consisting of ex-lord-mayors and lord-mayors expectant, young noblemen connected by friendship or otherwise with the members of the reigning family, Home-Rulers looking for the release of the Fenian prisoners, and a few others who are drawn by temperament and disposition towards royalty like fiowers to the sun. All this section of the Liberal party voted with their natural political enemies on this occasion. Some have seen in this an indication that the whispers, spoken of at the beginning of this letter but discredited, had something in them, I express no opinion upon this point. The Republicans in London, however, have lost no time in drawing some such inference. They seem to think that they can make politicai capital out of the transaction. The following petition, relative to grants to mem- bers of the royal family, has been addressed to the House of Commons, and is being signed extensively throughout the metropolis : ‘*That no further grant or allowance may be made to any member of the royal family. That an account should be brought before the House, showing the total real and personal estate and income of each and every member of the royal family who may be ia receipt of any pension or allow- ance, and also showing all the positions and places of profit severally held by members of the said royal family ; also showing all pensions, if any, for- merly charged on any estate now held by any member or members of the royal family, and, if any such shall have been transferred, at what date such transfer took place ” and it cannot for a moment be disputed that the Republican party in the state—at present a very small one—is the one party that has got any good out of this untoward business. The moderate Liberals, who compose the Opposition, have gained nothing, neither have they lost anything. They represented moderation and conservatism by resisting a hateful innovation, and they sustained a crushing defeat. Their action in the matter will tell in the long run, but for the moment it has not apparently done so. The Ministerialists secured a party triumph, but it is no real victory. Already Mr. Disraeli has seen the serious mistake he made. Ile has damaged him- self and his Ministry in the opinion of his own supporters and of all sen- sible men both inside and outside the House of Commons; he has pleased no one ; and by his action last night he has apparently failed to ingratiate himself even with the Court. He made a statement to this effect : that under no circumstances would the Queen, by the advice of her Ministers, assume the title of Empress in Lngland, and that she would not under any circumstances be advised ‘‘ to confer a title upon her royal children and her agnates that would denote the Imperial connection.” This assurance is satisfactory so far as it goes, but it does not go far enough. If the Im- perial title is assumed anywhere in relation to British dominion, it will be only a question of time how long it will be confined to the limits assigned to it. There are always courtly and offtcial persons who will make it their interest and their pleasure to extend the designation ; and that is what ex- cites the suspicions of the country. Why did not Mr. Disraeli make this statement long ago, they ask, if this is what is really meant? ‘* Why,” rather, in the words of Lord Melbourne, ‘did he not let it alone from the beginning ?” The bill, however, is regarded as practically safe, and as very nearly suf- ficiently harmless. It is not likely that the House of Lords will raise any serious opposition to it, though they may press for the exclusion of the word Empress in the proclamation which will follow. Lord Granville will per- haps speak ont his mind, as he is understood to have been in close com- munication with Lord Hartington in the matter, and to have counselled him as to his course of action. Some of the young Liberal peers may also express the views which prevail among all men of sense and taste in the country. But the great majority of noble lords are too closely bound by social ties to the Court to say in public what many of them do not hesitate to say in private, and that is, that the proposal to assume the parvenu title of Emperor is vulgar and demeaning, and even the.,wish to assume it, if brought home to any member of the royal house, could not fail to slacken and almost to cast adrift the feelings of loyalty and affection with which that house has ever been regarded in this country and throughout the colonies. as ~ a— => «= Aq -A

Page 9

Apr. 6, 1876] The Nation. 997 we are doing exactly the same thing in Schleswig and in our Polish Pro- THE RUSSIFICATION OF TILE BALTIC PROVINCES. I Marc vinces ? JONDON, March 9, 1876. nv a . . eT : , non, Barn 9, 102 lhe first assertion is undeniably true. If the example of the German akens a feeling of sadness, even if the | Knights (Deufsehe Orden) in Prussia had been followed by their cousins, FUNERAL procession always ev | . deceased has been wholly indifferent or quite unknown to us in life. the Knights of the Sword (Schwertbriider). in the Baltic Provii ( i Ihnees, They Should it then be possible to pass the corpse of a body-politic quite un- would have conferred a blessing upon the vanquished natives and secured moved ? Perhaps its life was for a century or more only like a faintly- | their own existence. They did not do it for exactly the same reason that glimmering spark. Then its death will not strike us much. Perhaps it | jt was forbidden in yout S, uthern States to t te slaves how to read will even ineet with the fate of the Abbé Siey¢s, the announcement of whose | and write. And it wns wet Gren tedtiieenes co wadticnncn tek thn 1 death made quite a peculiar kind of sensation, because everybody thought | yot Germanize the natives. It was left undone with full cons ness. f he was dead long ago.. Yet the fact that a life is extinguished will never | to elevate them economically or mentally was to endanger t] hsolute fail to make an impression on those who are still living. sway of ¢he masters over them. When they at last | egan to be aware of It is a very curious coincidence that the political resurrection of Ger- | their fatal mistake, it was already too late ; for their eyes were only opened many is followed so soon by the agony of the only coiony proper ever | under the pressure of the first half-covert and stealthy attempts of Russia founded by Germany ; for, so far as my information goes, everybody is | to Russify as well the Germans as the natives. Russia has, of course, not agreed that the Imperial decree abolishing the governor-generalship over | been slow to answer all complaints with the question : Where is your right the three Baltic or German Provinces of Russia is meant to be their death- | to call the Provinces German, as only abeut one-tenth of your population warrant. When, about thirteen years ago, I left Livonia, half resolved | really is German ? And it was not possible to give a never again to return to this my native country, I incurred the severe blame | But this narrow-minded and short-sighted spirit has by no means, as all of most of my old schoolmates and university comrades, because they thought | the German papers seem to suppose, been confined to the landed feudal no one ought to leave the ship when everything indicated a storm infinitely | aristocracy, who have thus far, to the almost entire exelusion of all other: more dangerous than any she had ever had to weather before. My opinion | constituted the “ province” as a body politic. In the Livonian Diet n effective answer. was that she was doomed to inevitable destruction, and that a martyrdom | (Zandtag), in which every nobleman who is the owner of an estate (Gu), which can do no possible good is simple foolishness. This was, of course, | or who has charge of one, has a seat and a vote, Riga, to-day a city of more denounced as a threadbare veil with which I was trying to cover a inean | than one hundred thousand inhabitants, and with a tonnage larg r than egotism and a despicable lack of patriotism. that of Hamburg, has but two representatives ; and twice it has been due I should not have dared to tax the patience of your readers with what I | to the objections of Riga that the smaller cities did not get the representa- have thought or done if it had not been for the reason that I wanted to in- | tion which the nobility was willing to grant them. The peasantry had no troduce myself as one who knew scmething about those hapless provinces, | political rights whatever, and the cities had no connection either with the and who has something to support his pretension that he judges them and | nobility or with one another. In short, the whole province was a curiosity their sad fate correctly. Only two months ago I spent some weeks in Riga. | shop of relics from the Middle Ages. Nobody had as yet the faintest idea that such a blow was impending over And vet it is not true that Russia is now only doing what Germany does them. And yet the very men who had once judged me so harshly now | with regard to Schleswig and her Polish Provinces. No one will contend unanimously declared, heaving a deep sigh : ‘* If we had no family to care | that with these a necessary or likely effect of the Germanizing process will for we would at once emigrate to Germany ; here is no life ; we are barely | be a more or less considerable loss in their eeneral status of culture. This. allowed to vegetate.” You may judge what are their thoughts now—for | however, must be the inevitable effect of the Russifieation of the Balti they are confined to thinking ; speak so that the world may hear them they | Provinces, although it cannot be denied that. so far as the mere laws are cannot. When I complained of the absolute emptiness of the Rigaische | concerned, they have of late remained behind Russia in many and very Zeitung I was answered : The editors are not to be blamed ; they dare not, | important respects. In spite of that, taken as individuals, they are still, they cannot say anything, and they curse every hour the day on which they | morally and mentally, by far the superiors of the Russians in the average. turned journalists, for their work is more fruitless than that of the This the latter themselves acknowledge by ce nstantly com} laining that a Danaides. I venture to assert that now, in all the three Provinces, not a | really enormous percentage of all the offices of trust and responsibility is single sober-minded and reflecting man will be found who still believesthat | held by the Germans. And if it is admitted that, in the average, the the contest allows of any hope, that it isanything but a death-struggle. The | Germans are still morally and mentally the superiors of the Russians, then abolishing of the governor-generalship in itself can, of course, not have | also it must be acknowledged that the forcible Russification of the Baltic such an effect, though it is important enough. It is the old story of the | Provinces is a high-handed attempt against civilization, since, in this case, bundle of sticks which successfully resists every effort, while each stick, | nobody has dared to plead a paramount political necessity as with regard taken separately, is easily broken. The immediate effect of the Imperial | to ever-revolutionary Poland. If this be so, then just so far as Russia decree is just the separating of them, but nobody has as yet had the folly or | succeeds in her designs she will deprive herself of the best and most tried the impudence to suggest thet perhaps nothing more is intended. If there | levers for lifting her from the position of a semi-Asiatie power to a level could have been any doubt about the ultimate object for which this pre- | with the rest of the Western world ; for it is universally acknowledged that liminary measure is to pave the way, the Russian papers have taken good | the Russified German is not only not better but even much worse than the care to remove it. With the utmost directness, they declare that every- | Russian. And she wiil have to suffer the more from this most impolitie thing peculiar to the Baltic Provinces which distinguishes them from the | course because the struggle will be extremely stubborn, thongh it is utterly rest of the empire shall be levelled to the ground, and already they demand | hopeless for the Provinces. The Germans of those regions are an ex- with vehement impatience that the axe shall at once strike at the root of the | ceedingly tough race, as is abundantly proved by every chapter of tree by depriving the University of Dorpat of its German character. their history, and they have a shield against which many a strong shaft The German papers say as little as possible about the whole matter, | will be dashed to splinters ; they are Lutherans, and, upon the whole, not partly because they do not like to give offence to Russia, partly because we | only very orthodox Lutherans, but also Lutherans with the primitive faith are, in a political sense, a nation of yesterday. Heinrich von Treitschke, | of children, which they have remained in so many respects. As long as in one of his essays, remarks that the political age of a nation is indicated | they are not deprived of their Lutheranism—and, so far as one ean see by the time covered by its historical recollections—i.e., not as these are | now, neither force nor Craft will accomplish that—the mother will lull her laid down in the writings of the learned, but as they really live in the | child to sleep with a German song, and the dying father will bless his son people ; and he points out how short a time that is with us in comparison | in German words. And as long as this is so, the Ru with England or with France. Here is a proof of the truth of this asser- | complete. tion : the important part for a long time played by these Baltic provinces | = ’ *ye ~ Correspondence. is so entirely forgotten even by the higher educated classes that it happens quite frequently to a Livonian or Esthonian to be complimented on speak- A SHORT COMMENTARY ON PROFESSOR TIMOTHY DWIGIT. tion will not be ing German so fluently and correctly. So there is nothing astonishing in the fact that the sympathy now bestowed upon them resembles the sun ona ~ ; somewhat foggy day in December. Two or three saltless phrases of hardly To tHe Eprror or Tur Nation : lukewarm commiseration are followed by a long explanation of how the Srr : I beg a small space in your columns for a brief commentary on the Baltic Provinces are now oniy reaping what they have sown, and the whele is | Epistles of Timothy. I regret that the work of the Advisory Council so generally wound up with the exclamation, How can we blame Russia, while ' soon requires a defender, end that the defence requires so much artifice

Page 10

228 The Nation. As common fame attributes a very large share of the deliverances of the Council to the astuteness of the lively professor, he may naturally be ex- pected to speak of them with the affection we feel for our own offspring, whether of the body or brain. The Council was compurgator for Plymouth Church, and 11 sor Dwight is compurgator for the Council. It might be curious to enquire how far in an ascending series the process of compur- gation can be eflicaciously carried, Coleridge hinted at a difficulty attend- * The river Rhine it is well known Does wash your city of Cologne ; But tell me, nymphs ! what power divine Shall benceforth wash the river Rhine 7” The Jesuit fathers were famous experts in moral and theologieal casu- istry. The great Pascal, in the immortal ‘ Provincial Letters,’ exposed and ridiculed their adroit sophistries about ‘* proximate power” and “ sufficient grace.” ** Proxiznate power” was given to all men to keep the command- ments (incluling the seventh commandment, of course), but all men had not ‘*suflicient grace” to keep them. Those learned fathers also taught that a man might pay another for burning an offending neighbor’s barn, if he did it with the right motive ; and the motive wasright if the money was paid for the favor, ana not for the Sire. That precise case is put in the ** Kighth Provineial Letter” * A person asks a soldier to set fire to the barn of a man that has in- jured him. ‘The question is whether, in the absence of the soldier, the per- son whe employed him to commit the outrage is bound to make reparation out of his own pocket for the damage that has followed ? My opinion is that he is not. For none can be held bound to restitution where there has been no violation of justice ; aud is Justice violated by asking another to do usa favor ?” See how adroitly the proposition is changed from asking a man to burn another's barn to asking him ** to do usa favor”! Upon the same prin- ciple, the pious father would say that the wrongdoer is not bound to make restitution to Mr. Tilton for firing his premises, if the wrong was not done with intent to injure Mr. Tilton, duf from another motive ; for ‘* the inten- tion determines the quality of the action.” In another letter, Pascal quotes the casuist as saying that if a holy father is caught in a brothel, he may deny it, if his motive is to save the eredit of the church ; and in another place he adds that he may swear he was not guilty of fornication (interpo- lating in an undertone that he did not do it before he was born). By artfully changing the terms of propositions as the argument pro- ceeds, it can easily be proved, as no doubt it often was proved in that Yale College Debating Society the Profesor mentions, that a horse-chestnut is a chestnut horse. Was not the Professor himself a burning and a shining light in that debating society ? He evidently has given his days and his nights to the study of those Jesuit fathers, and in the practice of casuistry can give odds to his famous teachers. My task, now, is to expose some of his bold fallacies. Fatuacy No. 1.—That the proffer by the Andover Church of a mutual council to investigate a scandal seriously affecting the brotherhood of Con- gregational churches was invalid, because only a church can try a chureh- VLE te The fallacy isin the assumption that the Andover Church proposed a mutual council to try « church-member. Any procedure is to be defined, and to be characterized, by the effect it is legally competent to produce. The procedure of a church-irial is competent to the effect, first, of deter- mining the question of guilt ; second, of pronouncing sentence ; third, of ex cuting the sentence by excommunicating the convicted member ; but ne one pretends that a council can try, sentence, or excommunicate a member of achurch. The Andover letter does not hint at a proposal to try, sentence, or excommunicate anybody. The brotherhood of churches was interested to have a thorough investigation, and the Andover Church asked Plymouth Church to join it in calling a mutual council for that sole purpose. Its letter, as quoted by Professor Dwight, says: ‘ We therefore ask you to unite with us in calling an ecclesiastical council empowered to make a thorough investigation of this painful case.” If Plymouth Church had as- sented, and a thorough investigation had followed, the council could not have sentenced or excommunicated the member, but must have left the church to deal with him according to its own sense of right. If the church had then failed to do what it ought, a council might have been ealled to consider what further should be done to vindicate the brotherhood of churches, The Professor has the temerity to call such a procedure by a council a (rial of a chureh-member. That an investigation.is not a trial is shown by the scheme of a commission to investigate, for the Professor does not pretend that the commission can do anything more than investigate, and then leave it to the church to deal with the member. [Number 562 Fattacy No, 2.—That a council cannot lawfully investigate, but that a committee called a commission, constituted by a council, can, It is as true in law as in physics, that a stream cannot rise higher than its source. It certainly is true that if a council cannot investigate, it can- not confer a valid authority upon its creature to do so. If a council cannot try a church-member, its creature, whether called a committee or a com- mission, cannot try. him. Having affirmed that a council cannot investi- gate because it cannot try, the Advisory Council and the Professor turn a sharp corner and upset both their major and minor premiss by affirming that a council can, by its creature, investigate and so try a church-member. If they attempt (as I think they do) to escape this dilemma by saying that the commission can investigate if the church consents, I answer it must be equally true that a council can investigate if the church consents ; and that is what the Andover Church asked, and what the Council advised Plymouth Church not to consent to. The Professor must therefore give up his pro- position that an investigation is necessarily a trial, or give up his propo- sition that a council can constitute a committee to investigate ; and he must also give up his proposition that a consent of Plymouth Church to an investigation, as proposed by Andover, would not have been as valid as its consent to an investigation by a commission. Indeed, the Professor after- wards acknowledges that the local ministers’ association may, without the consent of Plymouth Church, investigate and expel the pastor from the association ; and that a council may finally investigate with a view to dis- fellowshipping Plymouth Church ; but is such an investigation any more or less a trial, or any more or less determinative of the sta/us in the church of the incriminated member, than the investigation proffered by Andover ? Fattacy No. 3.—The letter-missive having asked the Council to advise Plymouth Church whether the investigation by the pastor’s committee was proper and sufficient, and the Council having advised that it was, that therefore the Council had authority to advise upon matters the letter- missive did not submit, viz., (1) That Plymouth Church should reject the proffer of the Andover Church, (2) and institute and constitute an investi- gating commission, (3) and enact a sixty days’ statute of limitations, (4) and hedge the commission with conditions and limitations calculated to shut out more truth than they can Iet in. If, as all the church platforms affirm, the authority of a council lies within the four corners of its letter-missive, Jordan overflowed its banks in all the Council did towards further investigation. In advising that the in- vestigation by the pastor’s committee had been proper and sufficient, it fully answered the question submitted, and went to the verge of the letter- missive ; and in going further it stepped out into boundless space. The Professor affirms that it would be foolish to advise the church it had done enough, without telling it what more to do ; on the contrary, it was foolish and illogical to advise that it had done enough, and then say it should do more. He is fond of illustrating by supposititious cases assumed to be analogous, but in every case the supposed analogy fails. The validity of all analogical reasoning depends upon a true likeness of the instances. How absurd, the Professor says, when Jones, who has written to be advised whether he has done enough to compose a strife, comes to receive an answer to his enquiry, to refuse to tell him what more to do because he did not ask that in his letter. But Jones and his letter, taken together, are competent to ask any and every thing ; but Plymouth Church and its letter are competent to ask a council to answer only what is in the letter-missive —for the delegates were authorized by their constituent churches to answer nothing else. That the enquiry was not in Jones's letter was of no conse- quence to Jones and his friend when he came in person to enlarge his enquiry, but that the enquiry was not in the ietter-missive was of the most absolute consequence ; and when Plymouth Church asked the Councii a question not in the letter-missive, and which the constituent churches, therefore, had not authorized their delegates to answer, any answer to it was as void of validity as if made by a mob assembled at the door of the Council. So the Professor’s supposed analogy is specious but not sound. Fatiacy No. 4.—That because a party negotiating for the call of a mutual council may, for a good cause, object to a church or delegate nomi- nated by the other party, therefore it may, as matter of strict right, object, with or without cause, to any church or delegate so nominated, even after -having assented to the nomination. The specific case on which the Council was asked by the letter-missive to advise was, Whether Plymouth Church, after assenting to the nomina- tion and notification of the Church of the Pilgrims and the Clinton-Avenue Church, did right to object to them with the known and declared effect of its defeating the effort to convene a mutual council ? That question could have been answered in either of two ways, viz. : (1) By affirming the genc- ral proposition that each party had an unlimited right to object to any pe th as bi ar th

Page 11

N ‘legate nominated by the other ; or (2), by affirming the limited that such objection could be made only for good cause—i.c., Apr 6} The church or dk propositior the known partiality of such nominee. Affirming the general proposition, viz., the unlimited right to object in all cases, that would include every Affirming the limited proposition, the propriety of the objection to the two churches would de- pend upon whether they were in fact partial. If the Council had decided vould have been bound to en juire as to the fact of the alleged partiality, and to decide that question of fact but it is not pretended that it made any such enquiry, or pronounced upon any such alleged fact. case, and of course the case of the two churches. the case on the narrower proposition, it It was, therefore, not in a situation to alvise the objection to the two churches was proper unless it affirmed the large general proposition ; and it did explicitly aflirm it. Instead of supporting that general proposition against Dr. Storrs’s formidable assault. the Profes- sor goes off in a tangent about the right to compose the Council of impar- tial members, and to imagine extreme and exceptional cases of unfitness. Would the Professor, on his own principles, be a fit member of a council to which Plymouth Church or its pastor was a party ? But I will not press the argumentum ad hominem, and I will content myself with saying that he has failed to support the unqualified right to object ; that the Council did affirm that unqualified right ; and that the Council had no other basis for its advice that Plymouth Church acted properly in its negotiation with Mrs. Moulton ; for it will not be pretended that the Council aflirmed, or meant to affirm, that Dr. Storrs and Dr, Budington were by reason of partiality disqualified to be members of the mutual council asked for by Mrs. Moulton. Fatiacy No, 5.—The question the Professor was discussing when he uncaged his allegorical tiger was, Whether the Council properly advised that a member who had a@sented himself, and was also charged with a scandalous offence, could, in the exereise of a wise discretion, be dropped for his absence without taking notieé@ of his scandalous offence ? Hav- ing stated that question, the Professor introduces his royal Bengal tiger, and supposes himself to say to his neighbor : We can, in the exercise of a wise discretion, determine what animals we will turn loose in our court- yards with low palings. The Professor then triumphantly asks, Because I spoke of animals and discretion, is it to be inferred that IT meant I could properly turn a tiger loose in my court-yard ? My dear Professor, the question whether, in the exercise of a wise discretion, a tiger could be turned loose in the court-yard, was the very question in debate ; the ‘‘ scan- dalous ” member was the tiger. If you admit that he should not be turned loose, there is no dispute between us. It is the Council's he may be turned loose, without taking nctice that he is have taken the liberty to controvert. declaration that a tiger, that we merely provided for a selection of the tigers to be loosed ; the principle governing the selec- tion being the danger of holding on to the tigers, and not the danger of turning them loose. Finally, the Professor seems greatly agitated by his apprehensions that Andover will persist in calling a council, and that certain obnoxious per- sons named by him may be members of it. I am not authorized to say anything to increase or tranquillize his fears. With his knowledge of the extraordinary pains taken by Plymouth Church to exclude from the late Council all delegates who might be suspected of a bias in favor of that The Council’s rule church or its pastor, why should not that happy experience reassure him ? And as he believes that the action of that Council was inspired, and that its deliverances are stamped with infallibility, why should he not pray for and expect the like heavenly endowment of the next ? Whatever good or ill suecess has attended the nine-columned effort of the Professor to vindicate the deliverances of the late Council, he has certainly succeeded in making apparent to the public how distressingly anxious he will be to select as commissioners only such persons as will be eager to de- cide that the accused pastor is guilty. Josuua M, Van Corr, BRookuyyn, April 3, 1876. _ oe es Notes. J B. LIPPINCOTT & CO. publish in several languages the ‘ Visitors’ 7+ Guide to the Centennial Exhibition and Philadelphia.’ clear maps of the Exhibition grounds and buildings and of the southern half of the city, on which all the points and buildings of interest are desig- nated. The condensed text seems to contain all the information necessary to the tourist for getting about without loss of time and without imposition. A sentence on p. 24—‘‘ In population end commercial imporiance it {Phila- It has very iu 5 gr OR sae +10c0rFr29 ral delphia] is the first citv in the State o ennsvivania and the second in lelpl the first cits the State of P vl l th l a a ib. oe ation. United States °—stands in need either of revision or of division. Morris, Springfield, Mass., publishes in a tasteful 1 History of Springfield,’ delivered Oct dredth anniversary of th Morris. F. W. olume an address on th 16, IST), the wn | ‘Early on two-hun- e burning of the t y the Indians, by Henry The burning is the principal theme of this address, which is writ A steel J and autographic fac- ten with great simplicity and clearness, and is excellent of its kind. portrait of William Pynchon serves as a frontispiece settlers are given in th Which contains A.S. Barnes & ¢ announce a‘ Report of the Advisery Council held at Plymouth Church, similes of the earls pendix, number of original documents relating to Spring Brooklyn.’——Flihu Burritt will ue, through Brown & Hartford, a ‘Sanskrit Hand-book for the F “——Macmillan & Co. will publish ‘Notes of an Indian Journey,’ by Mrs. Grant Dutf The London Printing Times and Lithographer is now bringing out a * Biblio- graphy of Printing : an Alphabetical List of Books in all Languages re- lating to the History and Art of Printing (including Typography, Litho- graphy, Chalcography, ete.) ; with copious Biographical, Historical, and Critical Notes, and numerous I!lustrations..—— The Clarendon Press has lately added to the series of Italian texts begun two years ago by Mr. Cot- terill’s ‘Selections Dante’ the first shortly iss Gross, +9 reside, from two eantos of Tasso’s * Gerusa- lemme liberata,’ edited by the same gentleman, who has pretixed a life of Tasso end a grammatical introduction, and accom notes, historical as well as philologieal. Althoug! panied the text by copious so little of the is text giver, it can hardly fail to inspire students with a desire to read the whole work, an excellent, inexpensive edition of which for beginners is that edited by Domenico Carbone and published by Barber’ The ‘ Théatre Complet* of M. Emile Augier will short Lévy. in 1870,— y be published by } Auerbach, has of this city, for It will fill six volumes.——The Stuttgart pul honorably sent a compensation to * Edward Strahan,” using his novél, ‘The New Hyperion,” in a German edition just issued, We learn from Nature that ten unpublished letters of Gilbert White, ad- dressed to Robert Marsham, a Norfolk gentleman, have recently come to Norfolk and Norwich It is a pity they were not in time to be included in light, and are to appear in the Transactions of the Naturalists’ Socict y. the new edition of White’s Selborne ——For the purpose of preparing a series of articles on commercial and industrial co-operation in the United States and Great Britain, Mr. Charles Barnard has been sent abroad by the publishers of Scribner's Monthly. —We have before us a copy { f the Cal forn a Siar, Vol i” No. 13, for April 1, 1848—‘*a weekly journal, devoted to the liberties and interests of the people of California, and published in San Francisco.” The new terri- tory had just been annexed by treaty to the Union, and the American settlers were being rapidly reinforced by fresh arrivals from ** the States ” ; and this particular issue of the Star was prepared for the better information of ‘‘ our Eastern friends, or residents of any part of the globe.” The agri- cultural resources of the Territory are strongly insisted on (seven men breakfasted on a garden radish *tand found it well flavored”) and the future of San Francisco as a commercial port anticipated without exaggera- tion. Judicious prophecy also occurs in this paragraph : ** The gigantic project of Mr. Wilkes, of a railroad from the States to tl.ese shores, is rapidly gaining ground and favor in the United States—-a project which will ultimately be carried into execution, and needs no com- ments to show its influence over the destinies of the country. Besides, it appears that the American Government has resolved upon securing the right of establishing a ship-canal near the neck of land which divides the two Americas. If we are to judge from the highly interesting letter of Hon. G. M. Dallas, the Isthmus of Tehuantepec is already selected, and there is every reason to believe that this grand and beneficent project will be realized.” Pending the construction of the railroad, emigrants are earnestly reminded of *‘ the importance of keeping the well-defined ‘07d road’ to California,” and of avoiding short cuts, if they value their lives and property. ‘‘ The horrible sufferings of those who were overtaken by the winter snows on the California mountains in 1846 are enough to appall the stoutest heart.” The white population of San Francisco twenty-eight years ago consisted of adults —males, 575; females, 177 ; children, ‘‘of ages proper to attend school,” 60. ** Searcely eight months since, the total number of whites was 375.” This was still far behind the ‘Salt Lake Settlement,” from which the ad- vices were to December 24. ** Six hundred families are now located in the to maintain them until received information great valley, with a supply of provisions calculated The editor has ** from a re- liable souree thata large immigration from China may be expected here. We have already two or three the season of harvest.” of the ‘ Celestials’ among us, who have found ready employment. The mechanics, cooks, and other working-classes of 24

Page 12

230 China would be exece ingly useful here, and would undoubtedly find it to their advantage to emigrate. They would he espe ially invaluable for the introduction and manufacture of silk in this country.” The disadvantages of the Heathen Chir had not then been thought of. While we are on the subject ef California, and in contrast with the day of small things just reviewed, we may notice the report of the health officer of the city of Oakland for the calendar year 1875, which has just cometo hand. In June of that year Oakland had an esiimated population of 25,009 inhabitant in increase of 20 per cent, over the pre ding year. [ts health department was organized in 1868, but records were not begun till June, 1870. Judging from the report, the department is now well manned by intelligent officials, The health-officer, Dr. George E. Sherman, has illustrated his vital statistics by the graphic method devised by Mr. Wines and already effectively used by Gen. Walker in his ‘ Statistical Atlas | of the United States.’ In this particular the Oak!and report is in advance of any similar publication with which we are acquainted. Noticeable points in it are these: that the city has an excess of 2,640 males ; that a steady decrease in the birth-rate is apparent of about two in every thousand ; that ** while more children are born of foreign parentage, the aggregate number | of children with parents born in the United States who survive the first year is greater.” In the graphic chart of mortality, still-births are indi- eated. The percentage of mortality among females seems to be greater than among males. On the whole, the death-rate of Oakland is encouragingly Jow, and with so enlightened a board of health it ought not to get higher. In the number of ZL’ Aré for January 2 (New York: J. W. Bou- ton) are given two fine woodcuts and an etching as large as the origi- nal figure, from parts of Meissonier’s ‘‘ 1807.” The etching is a fine stuly by Monzies from the equestrian portrait of Maréchal Duroc, repre- sented by the painter at the Emperor’s right hand; and the cuts, al- most equally good, are large representations of the rider at the head of the column and the rider flourishing his clarion. The accompanying article by M. Ballu differs from some of the French criticisms which came out on the news that the picture was going to leave the country, in being frankly encomiastic. The purchaser even comes in for a share of the writer's eulogy, and his best friends cannot complain of a want of appreciation in the following little rhapsody : ‘*‘ 1807,’ its painter’s most important work in size, has been bought for 390,000 frances by Mr. Alexander T. Stewart. This royal art-lover, whom the magnificence of his New York establishments | has caused to be named the merchant-prince, possesses one of the largest picture-galleries in the world. It is fine to play thus the part of the Medici in the nineteenth century ; and, to sum up in the fashion of an apotheosis, I will say that I seem to see French art covered with gold by American in- dustry.” The Portfolio (same publisher) commenced in the February num- ber Mr. Hamerton’s important series of articles on Turner, and gives another instalment for March. We observe a rather ominous burnishing of weapons preparatory to a bout with Mr. Ruskin. Such an admission as that in the first chapter, that Turner never equalled hundreds of his prede- cessors in the use of oil-color and the handicraft of their common art, would have seemed treasonable to the ‘* Oxford Graduate,” and by him would never have been even introduced for consideration without some contradiction or qualification to deprive it of its force. Mr. Hamerton makes a good point in congratulating Turner in not having been born in a higher class of so- ciety—the respectability of 1775 having among its traits a contempt for the practice of art ‘‘as deadly to genius as an unbreathable gas is to the animal organism.” The illustrations of the Portfvlio have been quite up to the mark the present year, but we are not entirely reconciled to the cessation of Goupil’s fine photogravures, giving the identity of various fine paintings in all but the color. There are three etchings for March, two of them architectural, in which the robust sureness of M. Queyroy’s hand and the tentative delicacy of Mr. George's are the exponents of two art-schools ; and the third, botter than either, executed by Rajon from a fine portrait, self- painted, of Gerard Dow, where that master is represented as a Dutch exqui- site in velvet, with a pic-shaped cap adhering by special affinity to the right ear, and the hair in curls, —As a substitute, perhaps, for the too long discontinued literary and dramatic annual of M. Vaperetu, or perhaps as a mate to the ‘ Année Politique’ of M. Andr* Daniel, now in its second year, there has just been publishe L* Los Annales du Th “itre et de la Musique’ (Paris : Charpen- | tier & Cie., pp. xil.-533), elite lby MM Elouard Noel and Edmond Stoullig. To match M Daniel's book, the best title for this one would obviously have been ‘LL’ Ann‘e théitrale* had if mot basa pre-empted] by the volume of al- most worthless newspaper gossip of M. Georges Duval. The value of the volume before us is warranted by the writer of the preface, M. Francisque Sareey, whose name would never be lent to anything unworthy of careful The N

ation. [ Number 562

consideration. From his few words we learn that this is the first of a series to be annually continued, Although inferior in typographical beauty and pictorial embellishment to the dainty and delicate little ‘ Almanach des Spectacles’ which we reviewed upon its appearance last year, it is more am- content to give merely the facts and figures, bitious in scope, as it is not the names and statistics, of the French theatrical year, but subjoins criti- cisms as well. It even notes the novelties of the foreign stage—after a fashion. The sole entrance for these United States is : ** Philadelphic— ‘ Ostrolenka,’ op¢ra de Henri Bonewitz (janvier).” It also surpasses the ‘ Almanach’ in the attention it pays to music. Its bibliographical chapter is not as comprehensive as could be wished—no mention, for instance, is made of ‘ Foyers et Coulisses,’ a series of little histories of each of the Parisian theatres now issuing by Tresse. In the summary or review of the year a distinct trouble of the French stage of to-day is weil defined— that it is ‘‘ sterile without iosing its fecundity”; and, indeed, the only play of any poetic pretensions which achieved success during the year was the ‘‘ Fille de Roland.” Yet the gross receipts of the twenty-five metro- politan theatres exceeded twenty-five millions of frances, while the general curiosity to see the new opera-house is said to have paid its manager a profit of over a million, although as yet not a single new opera or ballet has been heard in the building. The grand staircase and M. Baudry’s pictures have rendered unnecessary any demand upon the muse of either M. Gounod or M. Thomas. Fortunately for the fate of French music, half a score of novelties, from which much may be expected, have been accepted by M. Vizentini, the director of the new Théatre Lyrique, shortly to be installed in the Théfitre de la Gaieté. ; —In Mr. Frederick Martin’s ‘Statesman’s Year-Book’ for 1876 (Mac- millan & Co.), the part devoted to the United States shows the usual marks of judicious revision and substitution, We observe, for example, statistics, heretofore unpublished in it, concerning churches and schools, commerce and railways, the national debt, ete., ete. Rather curiously, the compiler falls into an important misstatement about school attendance in the United States. Thus he correctly gives, from the last census, the total number of school children as ‘* 6,596,466, being upwards of one-sixth of the populs- tion.” But he adds that ‘‘out of this total 6,361,422 were children of natives of the United States, and only 235,044 children of foreigners, show- ing an extreme disproportion between school attendance and actus! num- bers of the existing native and foreign-born population.” There is a double error here. The 6,361,422 were natives (not ‘‘ children of natives”) of the United States ; the 235,044 were foreign-born (not * children of foreigners”). The total number of foreign-born children of school age (5 to 17 inclusive) was 546,317, so that the school attendance was 43 per cent. The total number of native children of corresponding age was 11,509,126, so that the school attendance for them was 57 per cent. This disparity is neither very great nor more than was to be expected. On the other hand, probably two millions of our school children were Americans of the first generation, if we include in that category all having a foreign-born father or mother. Mr. Martin’s ‘ Manual’ is so valuable and so generally trustworthy that a correction like this becomes of some consequence to those who resort to it. —The harvest of ethnolegical publications for the past year has been unusually rich in works of permanent value whose contents bear in an im- portant manner on the general progress of anthropological study. We desire to call attention to two works just issued. The venerable Midden- dorf, in the ‘ Transactions’ of the Imperial Academy of Sciences at St. Pe- tersburg, has opened his portfolios, closed thirty years ago, and given to students sixteen lithographic plates, representing line for line, without at- tempt at artistic remodelling, his original sketches from life of the people of Siberia. With this, under the caption of ‘Die Eingeborenen Sibirien,’ appear 220 quarto pages, plentifully illustrated by woodcuts and contain- ing his contribution to our knowledge of these singular nomads as a part of his yet unfinished ‘Sibirische Reise.’ That these sketches are faithful and characteristic is evident at a glance, and they are by no means lacking in expression. One plate is from photographs and represents Samoyeds of the Lower Yenisei. The strange forms of the head, of which these draw- ings offer a succession of examples, seem more misshapen and Caliban-like than those of any other people, mot even excepting Africans. <A singular want of uniformity in these misformations is very noticeable, the individual heads varying from cylindro-conie to truncate-pyramidal, but agreeing in receding forehead and deep, coarse, and massive rather than prognathous jaws. There is not that marked resemblance to Eskimo which some writers have fancied they could detect, nor yet any very decided Mongolian physiognomy. No summary appears in the paper of views in relation to the affinities of the various tribes. Indeed, it does not seem evident that A 7 th« ter ge th: otl Os ill ul fu Li th M lo aca = & & it.

Page 13

The the ethnic relations of the people were deeply studied or were specially in- teresting to the traveller. It is rather a generalized facts that he presents to us, Apr. 6, 1876] contribution of solid but net much tle remarks that the affinities of the Samoyeds are with the Finns on the one hand and the Mongols on the other, and that this opinion, expressed by him thirty years ago, has been } The work relates chi fly to the Ostiaks, Yuraks, and Yakuts ; illustrate implements, dwellings, or articles of dress. confirmed by philological investigations, Samoyeds, Tunguses, the woodcuts mainly For the ethnology of the eastern branches of the Ural-Altaic family it is indispensable and almost unique, ; —Another and nearly as important work is that of Dr. Georg Schwein- furth (« Artes Leipzig : F. A. Low & Co. 1875), which treats of the productions of the industrial arts of the tribes of Central Africa. It relates chiefly to the Dinka, Dyur, Bongo, Mittu, Niam-niam, Monbuttu, Sehre, and Golo tribes, of which it illus- trates implements, weapons, ornaments, utensils, and dwellings more or less fully. The writer divides Africa in regard to culture into three districts, corresponding to the movements of trade. Africane.’ srockhaus ; London : Sampson d ress, Across the northern half of the continent, which maintains a more or less direct commercial intercourse with Europe, we have the district of firearms. Further in the interior is a region supplied by intertribal traffic with European cotton stuffs, with which the inhabitants are chiefly clothed. Lastly, in the very heart of the continent spreads the territory almost free from any con- tact with Europeans, and where the natives are thrown upon their own scanty resources for clothing and utensils. Throughout Africa a change is progressing which is the reverse of that which would ordin- arily be supposed to follow contact with civilization. Tutercourse with the outer world, instead of promoting and stimulating, has everywhere had only a destructive influence native art. The greater the the path of external culture made by any African tribe in modern times, the greafer has become its dependence for all ob- jeets of refined cuiture on European industry, which, incessantly in- truding by the cheapness of its nanufactured articles and the high price it offers for indigenous raw material, everywhere excludes native competition and stifles the inventive impulse. on progress on This phenomenon, according to the author, is most marked in the negro states of the central Soudan, where, since their adoption of Islamism, a gradual retrogression of native cul- ture has resulted, and the last traces of native industry threaten shortly to disappear. Hence the fact that in the very heart of Africa, among the rudest, partly cannibal, most secluded tribes, where cotton stuffs and even glass beads are almost unknown, the indigenous mechanical instinct, the delight in the production of artistic work applied to the embellishment and refinement of daily life, the satisfaction in self-acquired property, are best preserved. The Kaffirs and Hottentots, not many decades ago, produced a variety of the neatest works of art, and now offer an almost barren field in this branch of ethnographic research, while their utensils and implements, like archeological objects, must be sought in the incomplete museums of Europe. ‘To this fact the great value and interest of the work under con- sideration are due, and it is to be hoped that others as competent may follow Dr. Schweinfurth’s example. Among the most interesting illustrations are the forms of sleeping-houses and granaries, ingeniously contrived to protect from the attacks of wild animals and termites ; also the incision of the lips for labrets and other ornaments, a custom which appears sporadically in Behring Strait, the Sitkan Archipelago, Mexico, Brazil, Borneo, and Africa. The work is neatly published, in parallel columns of German and English, making it available for any American student ; and the plates are of excellent execution. = — = LYTE’S HISTORY OF ETON COLLEGE.* - is true that public education came with Protestantism. But Protest- antism itself did not come suddenly and abruptly, though a critical point in its ascendancy and the fall of Catholicism is marked by the ap- pearance of Luther. Ever since the thirteenth century the foundation of colleges had been increasing, while that of monasteries had been de- creasing. Walter of Merton, who founded Merton College in the end of the thirteenth century, had marked a momentous antagonism, destined to be continually more developed, by excluding monks from his society. In Ox- ford and Cambridge the monastery school prevailed over the monastery itself, and expanded into a university. At length, in the reign of Henry VII., when Fox, Bishop of Winchester, Henry’s great ecclesiastical coun- cillor, was about to found a monastery, his friend Hugh Oldham, Bishop **A History of Eton College: 1440-1875. doa and New York: Macmillan & Co, By H. C. Maxwell Lyte, M.A.” Lop Nation. 231 of Exeter, advised him to ‘ound a college instead, warning him in words which, vivid as the handwriting on the wall of meditwvalisim then was, de- note remarkable prescience en the part of a bishop, that if he founded @ house of ** bussing (praying) monks,” his monks would be turned out of doors before the building was finished. Williain of Wykeham, ** the sole and munificent founder of the two St. Mary Winton Colleges,” to use the sonorous title which is appended to his name in University cxereises, was a zealous Catholic, specially addicted to the worship of the Virgin, and an opponent of the Wycliflites ; vet his figure as an artist and statesman-bishop belongs to the Renaissance, and his foundation does so still more decidedly. The Oxford branch of it might in those days be emphatically called ‘* New” College. As in its (the founder’s own creation) if the scak archits of beauty rough whic edivval art passed, so in its statutes it marks the com- tl gh which medieval art passed in if t marks t] Lule marks the close of mencement of classical education. It may be said also to herald the disso- lution of the monasteries, for its endowments were provided in part by the confiscation of alien priories. Wykeham’s foundation was double : sisted of a college at Winchester with a school attached to it, and a college at Oxford which received the boys trained in the school at Winchester and carried them through the university part of their education. Wykeham’s two colleges proved a great success, and were imitated by Henry VI. they were afterwards by Wolsey in his foundation of Ipswich and Christ- church ; though in the case of Wolsey Henry VILL broke in, and of the Car- dinal’s magnificent scheme one portion only, the Oxford College, was carried it con- in his foundation of Eton and King’s Colleges, Cambridge, as into effect, and even this on a reduced scale, while Ipswich perished with Wolsey ’s greatness, of Winches- ter, for it was under the influence of a group of Wykehamists that VI. conceived and executed his noble plan. The king seems in his 5 Bion may be regarded as a direct: offset Henry uth to have shown not only # good and religious disposition but intellectual sympathies, though there must always have been that weakness in his character and understanding which made him a puppet in the hands of his she-woif of a wife. The details of the foundation, including the negetia- tions with Rome for ecclesiastical privileges, are fully given by Mr. Lyte, and may be interesting to those who are specially connected with Lton. Perhaps the thing which most strikes the general reader is the commercial value attached to relics and indulgences in an age when religious faith was almost dead and Alexander Borgia became Viear of Christ amidst general approbation. Before it was completed, the foundation was overtaken by the civil war of the Roses, and, as the work of the Lancastrian King, narrowly The original design fer the buildings was shorn of its sumptuous proportions, and an escaped destruction at the hands of the triumphant Yorkists. architectural deformity in the arch of the east window of the chapel remairs a monument of the political tempest which had nearly levelled the whole with the ground. The cruel and unserupulous politicians of that day, how- ever, in England as well as in Italy, were often patrons of art and letters ; such was Tiptoft, Earl of Worcester, justly nicknamed the Butcher, and Edward IV. himself was a Nor were the authorities of the college wanting in practical wisdom. With no false deli- eacy, they threw a cloak over their Lancasirian origin, and removed the effigy of their ill-starred founder from their seal. The foundation at Eton consisted of a college of priests (a solenmn col- mau of the same character. lege of ten sad priests, as it is called in one of the documents), a school, and an almshouse. In this we see clearly the filiation of the new educational institution with the monastery ; only that the school, which, in the case of the monastery was quite subordinate, has become the important part of the institution, while the strictly monastic element is on the point of disappear- ance, the fellows of the eollege being secular priests. The eleemosynary element also has dwindled to small proportions. Thus the Darwinian finds his law of heredity and adaptation preserved ; and if he chooses to designate the intellectual influences under which the educational organ of the monas- tery was developed, while its religious, ascetic, and eleemosynary organs lost their importance, as mechanical, his case will he complete Eton College passed like other colleges through the religious \ icissitudes of the sixteenth century, the triumph of the anti-ecclesiastical element being marked by the appointment to the provostship of two eminent. lay- men, Sir Thomas Smith and Sir Henry Savile. During the provostship of Savile the college was visited by Elizabeth and James L., who were received with the usual fireworks of adulatory rhetoric in turgid Latin. Savile tried to give the college, as distinguished from the school, a real importance as a place of learning. He set up a press at Eton which brought out Greek books, and among them the splendid edition of Chrysostom with which his name will be always associated. Savile, in fact, was evidently a man of the Baconian type, and working for the fulfilment of the ideal of which the

Page 14

The t most elaborate exposition is the Nova Atlantis. Eton, however, was too mall for a Nora Atlantis, and the position which Savile had given it in the iMuropean world of lett lasted no longer than his provostship. After Sa vile’s death, B V in 1 weessful ndidate for the place esting ) i | \ ! aa) } mi } tO the eol- notin } t re ¢ ! ad.” Had he only been Provest of Kton or | a Vv plre f learni nd science inste ud of | ne man f the world without l worldly wisdom, what might he not have done what might he not have es ped ! In the middie of the sixteenth century the system of edueation is dis- closed to us in all its details by a consuvetudinarivm aseribed to Malim. then head-master. The curriculum is almost entirely Latin ; Greek, which had flourished as a study in the spring-tide of the Renaissance, having now temporarily declined. The curriculum is : In the first (lowest) form, Cato and Vives, In the second, Terence, Lucian’s * Dialogues’ (in Latin’, and ASsop’s * ables’ (in Latin). In the third, Terence, Aisop’s ‘Fables’ (in Latin), and selections by Sturmius from Cicero’s * Epistles, In the fourth, Terence, Ovid's ‘ Tristia,’ and the epigrems of Martial, Catullus, and Sir Thomas More In the fifth, Ovid’s ‘ Metamorphoses,’ Horace, Cicero’s ‘ Epistles,’ Valerius Maximus, Lucius Florus, Justin, and ‘ Sysembrotus,’ In the sixth and seventh, Cwsar’s ‘Commentaries,’ Cicero * De Officiis and * De Amicitia,’ Virgil, Lucan, and the Greek Grammar. N Latin versification, which afterwards assumed an almost portentous | importance at Eton, was at this time not so much a part of the curriculum as a holiday exercise. There seem to have been only two masters, the Magister Informator and the Ostiar-us, but the defect was partly supplied by the monitorial system, of which so much use was made at a later period, for the purpose of discipline, by Arnold. The discipline was pretty severe. The Eton scholars were awakened at five by one of the priepostors, who thundered ** Surgite.”. While dressing they chanted prayers. Each boy made his own bed, and among them they swept the room. They then went down two-and-two to wash at the pump, which must have been plea- sant in winter. Thence they went to the school-room, where the usher read prayers at six, after which hands and facés were examined by the Prepostor Immundanorum, and the unwashed were reported to the head- master, Who came in at seven. There was a pause at nine, and, we will At ten, one of the prepostors shouting Ad preces consurgite recalled the boys to school, where, tanding in order on either side of the room, they had to recite further prayers. At eleven came dinner, then school from twelve till three. The afternoon playtime ended at four, and was followed by another hour of lessons, At five the boys again left the school in procession, as Mr. Lyte hope, breakfast, though Malim does not mention it surmises, for supper. From six to eight they went to work again, not under the master and usher, but under the monitors. At seven there was a slight break for a slice of bread and a draught of beer. At eight the boys went to bed chanting prayers. The holidays were short, and not unvexed by Latin composition. A good deal of the ecclesiastical formal- ism and ‘rotatory calabash”’ praying of the Middle Ages had also been kept up in ecclesiastical places of education, though the mediaval faith was dead. It must have been one of the plagues of a schoolboy’s exist- ence, and have effectually implanted in the youthful breast a distaste for religion. Punishments and sports were alike barbarous. The pleasure of tormenting a cock or some other bird was the schoolboy’s privilege on Shrove Tuesday. In the strong, the system no doubt produced fortitude and industry, while many a weak child, cut off from his home and subjected to rough treatment, physical hardship, and a round of dreary labor, must have led « life of misery, if he did not entirely succumb. Sweet indeed to these hoys must have been the sound of Dulce domum pergere. The modern character of the school arises from the disproportionate development of an element which in the original design was quite subor- dinate, if it could be called a part of the original design at ail. This was the admission of pupils of the wealthier class, besides the boys on the elee- mosynary foundation, as commensales or oppidans, the representatives of the young noblemen and gentlemen received for education by monasteries. The term oppidans (oppidant), which is still applied te Etonians not on the forndation (these on the foundation bei that these pupils boarded in the town. The growth of this special element was due, no doubt, in part to the vicinity of the court at Windsor and to og ealled Collegers), denotes, however, | ation. [Number 562 the smiles of royalty. Eton thus became the great aristocratic school, Winchester and Westminster have the historic character of the English ‘public school” as well as Eton, but Eton alone has the aristocratic character. It is true that the aristocracy of Eton has been considerably mpered by the parvenu element since commercial wealth has learned to come there for a patent of gentility. The ebsurd educational conservatism of Eton, which, till a few years ago, confined e school in the nineteenth century to the curriculum of the sixteenth, besides keeping up a number of senseless and even barbarous rules and customs, may be traced to three causes : the endowments, the paralyzing pressure of the College on the School proper, and the connection with King’s College. Endowments place education beyond the sway of mere popular caprice or parental humor ; but it cannot be denied that they frequently have a benumbing influence, and that without some stimulating antidote in the shape of control and supervision, they are apt to lend color to the hard saying of Mr. Lowe, that the best thing to do with all the uni- versity endownients would be to throw them into the sea. The College had totally failed es a seat of learning—learning naturally tending, not to an isc- lated college at Eton, but to the great aggregation of colleges in the uni- versities. It had degenerated into a mere almshouse for superannuated masters of the Schcol. But the provost and fellows of the College were the governing body of the whole institution, which they paralyzed by their senile aversion to change. The connection with King’s College was perhaps even more fatal to improvement. The fellowships of King’s were all con- fined to boys on the foundation at Eton, who went off, not by examination or merit, but by seniority ; and the masterships of Eton, in turn, by a sel- fish custom for which no justification but habit could be found, were con- fined to the fellows of King’s. Thus Eton training revolved in an un- varying circle of self-complacent localism. To make the matter worse, King’s College, in the days of the founder, like New College at Oxford, had obtained an exemption from the university examinations for degrees, the intention of the founder being, of course, to subject his students to a stricter system of examination within his own walls. Thus the single col- lege from which the school could receive instructors was itself a paragon of torpor and isolation. No wonder if Eton education—which was the educa- tion of a large section of the governing class of England—degenerated into organized idleness, under pretence of exclusive devotion to classical culture. In the ease of clever boys rewards and praise were lavished, and perhaps genius gained in freedom of development part of that which mediocrity lost by the want of a better system. The brilliancy of Canning was a genuine and characteristic product of Eton. But the consequences, on the whole, were disastrous to English society and government. Of course, the school-life at Eton being very pleasant, and the place itself being beautiful and historic, Eton boys, as they always delighted to call themselves, loved their old school. Nor did the constant study of Ilomer, which was the great text-book, fail to impart something of a heroic tinge to aristocratic character. Mr. Arnold has somewhere given us an anecdote of an aristocratic statesman in the decline of life and health summoned to undertake a laborious embassy, and fortifying his sense of public duty by a quotation from Homer as a Puritan would by a quotation from the Bible. Perhaps the most graceful expression at once of attachment to Eton, and of the better side of its classical culture, is the epitaph composed for himself by the great Governor-General of India, Lord Wellesley, who, by his own desire, was buried at Eton : * Fortuna rerumque vagis exercitus undis, In gremium redeo serus, Etona, tuum, Magna sequi et sumine mirari culmina fam», Et purum antique lucis adire jubar, Auspice te didici puer atque in limine vitw ,,j Ingenuas verve laudis amare vias. Si qua meum vite decursu gloria nomen Auxerit, aut si quis nobilitarit honos, Muneris, Alma, tui est. Altrix da terra sepulchrum, Supremam lacrymam da memoremque mei.”’ There is nothing in these lines which, so far as our scholarship can dis- cern, might not have been written by a Roman poet. Nor is there any- thing in the sentiments they embody which might not have been inscribed on the tomb of a cultivated and generous heathen The Public School Commission and the opinion of a scientific age have expanded and liberalized the Eton system of education. Dr. Hornby, the present head-master, among other improvements, has recently introduced music, a softening and refining element of more value, as well as of more universal applicability, than Latin versification. The only special difficulty with which Eton educators have now to contend is the laziness of pupils brought up in wealthy and luxurious homes, and conscious that they will never have to work for their bread. A pe he li hi

Page 15

a] | Apr. 6, LS7¢ The N SCHERER’S LITERARY STUDIES.* TE have often wondered why M. Edmond Schérer, a critic whose privi- lege it sometimes is, by the acuteness of his insight or the felicity of \ his expression, to remind his readers of Saint-Beuve, has never undertaken a work of larger proportions than the short journalistic articles in which he has hitherto been content to record his opinions. Such an enterprise seems at present more remote than ever, for M. Schérer has for some time 1 ‘ past been devoting himself with increasing zeal to practical politics, and has lately been elected one of the seventy-five life members (on the Repub- lican side) of the new French Senate. Moreover, the present volume per- haps explains in a measure why the author has remained a desultory critic. Clever as he is, brilliant also, abundant in knowledge and excellent in style, he stops short at a certain point. He tends to fall within the limit that the reader has set for him. He often disappoints, he lacks imagination, and he is subject te odd lapses and perversities of taste. He is one of the very few French writers who give the reader a sense of any serious first- hand acquaintance with English literature ; and yet. we remember his speak- ing some time since of the remarkable faculty of the English people for agreeing at a given moment to get excited or infatuated over a nothing or a trifle, as the necessary explanation of the popularity of Thackeray, “a A literary critic who does not enjoy Thackeray has certainly a limp in his gait. This impediment in his own carriage however, M. Schérer manages on the whole very skilfully to conceal, and some of the best pages in the present volume are devoted to English authers. They contain, among other things, one of the best criticisms of Taine’s ‘ English Literature’ that we remember to have seen—that ex- traordinary work in which a superb energy has vainly done its best to con- ceal a fatal want of familiarity with the subject. M. Schérer resents this want of familiarity almost as roundly as a native Englishman, and has in particular some excellent remarks about the author's perverse magnifica- tion of Byron. There are indeed few things more singular than the way in which M. Taine steps over the heads of the whole literary group ushered in by the present century—Wordsworth, Shelley, Keats, Scott—and fastens himself upon Byron for the reason that he is more an ** Englishman” than the others—more a Viking, a Berserker, a product of north-winds and sea- fog! M. Schérer well observes that, with regard to Byron, M. Taine stands just where French criticism stood thirty yearsago. The author has a long, entertaining, and well-informed article upon Milton, whom he greatly ad- cold, ennuyevx writer.” mires, though perhaps the average English reader will wince at his sum- | ming-up of his judgment of ‘ Paradise Lost’ : ***Paradise Lost’ is a false, grotesque, tiresome poem ; not one reader in a hundred can go, without smiling, through the ninth and tenth books, or | without yawn/ng through the eleventh and twelfth. It does not hold together, it isa pyramid balancing on its point, the most frightful of problems resolved by the most puerile of means. And yet, nevertheless, ‘ Paradise Lost’ is im- mortal. famous. In opposition to Dante, whom we must read altogether if we wish really to possess his beauties, we must read Milton only in fragments But these fragments are part of the poetic patrimony of the human race.” In English we express the foregoing sentiments less trenchantly ; every one is waiting fer some one else to begin. been for some time tacitly admitted that with regard to ‘ Paradise Lost ’ some of the cargo must be thrown overboard to save the ship. But even among ourselves it has In an article on Bossuet and some of his recent editors, M. Schérer has some equally down- right remarks upon sermons in general. mon is a false style, and it is false in particular because it has grown old. It has so little human and general truth that it is difficult to interest one’s self in it even retrospectively. In vain we consent to place ourselves at the desired point of view, make allowance for time and change, take tradition into account. We must be very fond of eloquence to enjoy it when it is in the condition of pure form—that is to say, of empty form, of rhetoric.” On Bossuet in general M. Schérer makes some remarks which have a rather wholesome freshness as against the conventional, superstitious deference to their great classics which has so long prevailed ainong the French. **T conclude as I began : the ser- ‘‘The fact is that Bossuet has no stock (pas de fonds), or. what amounts to the same thing, that his stock doesn’t belong to him. He is neither a savant, a thinker, nor a moralist. He never has what we call views, still less audacities. He lacks invention, observation, intelligence. He has a great imagination, a consummate knowledge of the oratorical style, an abundant, magnificent movement of phrase, but he uses these things only to paraphrase the commonplaces of the ecclesiastical dogma and the eccle- siastical morality. His exposition, in spite of its amplitude of form, re- mains essentially scholastic.” Sixitme Série. -** Etudes Critiques de Littérature. Par Edmond Schérer. 1876. Paris: Michel Lévy ; New York: F. W. Christern. It lives in virtue of some episodes which will remain for ever | . ye ation. 25: slides iicenieiiaadiaiadeaiiaahiaiiaa The longest of M. Schérer’s papers, and the one we have found most interesting, is upon Goethe; its interest is the greater from the fact that it appeared after the Franco-Prussian war Better than anything else, however, it illustrates what we have called the author's limitations and in particular his want of imagination. He remarks upon the fact that since the war the French have begun to pay a good deal of attention to German literature, and he thinks it an excellent sign “The Germans,” to quote, ** have revived against us the right of con- quest ; they have aitached us with envious hatred and cowardly insult ; they have placed between us and themselves such offences as cannot be for given. But if it is just to detest Germany, it would be puerile on that account to seek to ignore her. It is at an end, we know: the charm that formerly drew us towards her is for ever broken ; we shall no longer expect from her a single one of the ideas that elevate, of the sentiments that en- noble. So be it, we shall be but better placed to judeze her. There had mingled itself with our inclination for German science and literature an enthusiasm which excluded discernment ; in future it will be easier to see things in their true proportions, . . If we are able to preserve ourselves from the other extreme—deliberate and intentional dispiragement —we shall have obtained the noblest of enjovinents : that of judging im partially those who themselves defy all justice.” If M. Sch¢rer has made an effort to be impartial, it is evident that it has cost him something. It may be said, too, t he deeid- edly exaggerates the ‘*charm” which the French publi> found, before the war, in German literature. If he speaks of a sina!l rie of highly cultivated men, his observations have a certain justice ; but French readers in general have certainly never given themselves the least troubl literature of the land of Gocthe. mans now, it is not that they ever loved them. ‘about the If they find good reason to The F for to be duped implies atten- but inating ate the Ger- } renen fave never been duped by the Germans or any one else ; tion and acquaintance, i] themselves. and excellent things, and his article is a very Vivid piece of portraiture ay They have never been duped by any peo} r I Upon Goethe M. Scherer says a great many dis But he is guilty of a strange dulness of vision when he declares that he can see nothing but dreariness in * Wilhelm Meister,” and, indeed, in all the author's literary works except the lyrics and * Faust.’ ‘* Goethe remains none the less,” he says in conclusion, ‘tone of the greatest among the sons ‘After all,” he said to one of his friends, there soine honest people who will be eniightened by my works, and whoever of men. *** there are here and reads them and takes the trouble to understand me will re ] ognize that he has gained by it a certain inward liberty.” I would write these words on f Goethe’s statue : one car the pedestal o deed, one can make of no man 1 give him no juster praise, and, in- We alluded just now to Sainte-Beuve, and it is in place to add thai we have ? a higher or more enviable eulogy.” often wished that he might have witnessed and survived the late war, if for no other purpose than to show us how he would have spoken of the Ger- mans. The situation would have been a most interesting test of that subtilized and almost etherealized faculty of impartiality which had de- veloped in him in his later years. It would have given play to all his finesse—to that strange mixture of fatal compliments and flattering blame. Unfortunately, Sainte-Beuve’s acquaintance with German literature was Ile had written he h ud evaded with characteristic skill any indication of whether he read them in transla- very limited ; one cannot know absolutely everything. ut about Goethe and two or three other German authors, | tions or in the original. The History of Landholding in England. By Joseph Fisher, F.R.ILS. (London : Longmans. 1876. 8vo, pp. 95.)—If Mr. Fisher had confined himself to the period of modern history, he would have produced a useful little book ; for in this period he is quite at home, and has collected a good For the early periods he is full of inaccuracies, store of valuable facts. Ile gives us (p. 18) three classes of the Anglo-Saxons (the upper, middle, and lower classes)—*‘ Earls, Thanes, and ‘*the Germanic mark system has no counterpart in the land system intro- duced into England by the Anglo-Saxons”: this in the face of Nasse, Stubbs, and even Freeman and Kemble! Folc-land and compared (p. 19) to freehold and copyhold respectively. the old exploded number of 60,215 knights’ fees for all England. The name but The This inaccuracy is ail unpardonable in one who undertakes to write upon this subject. Ceorls.”. He says on the same page that ? ”) c-land On p. 28 we have are villein is said (p. 46) to have come in after the Norman Conquest rillanus is frequently found, as equivalent to ceor/, before this epoch. ‘*King-maker” is called (p. 50) Guy of Warwick. the greater pity because Mr. Fisher has really a certain power of insight in his subject which only needs better knowledge to lead to valuable results ' The comparison, for instance, of freehold and copyhold to fole-land and hoe-

Page 16

The lun | has, after all, an idea at the bottom of it, and the distinction pointed out (p. 44) in the bearing of the statutes De donts conditionalibus and Quia emptoves, in their relation to feudal tenants and tenants in socage (didert homines, he is fond of calling them), is worth working out with more fulness than he has done As we have before remarked, the later portions are 1 h better, especially the Tudor period ; but even here, although we find much that is very good, we miss any clear statement of the causes which led to that most vital of all social revolutions which severed the English heusantry from the soil which had been their own, and resulted in the state i ° of things which has just come to light in the New Domesday Book. Mi moira of Eliphalet Nott, D.D., LL.D., for sixty-two years President of Union College. By C. Van Santvoord, D.D., with contribution and re- vision by Professor Tayler Lewis, of Union College. (New York : Sheldon & Co. 12mo0, pp. 399.)—The name of no American college president is more widely known than that of Dr. Nott, and about none has there been more controversy. In spite of all eriticism and ridicule, unmoved by the name of * Botany Bay” bestowed upon his college, he held to the methods of discipline which he adopted at the start, and had the satisfaction of liv- ing down much of the opposition before he died, conquering it by sheer success. Ilowever his policy may have worked in individual cases—and his most ardent admirers admit that no one but himself could have carried it Nation. out with equal suecess—he seems, at all events, entitled to the credit of | having been the leader in a great and salutary movement. His administra- tion of Union College was the first step away from the stereotyped routine | of these institutions—a movement which has since gone so far and’ in so healihy a direction. The eredit is claimed for him, for instance (p. 157), of having been the first to introduce a ‘* scientific” course by the side of the classical, Still more important was his departure from the stern and rigid method of discipline which everywhere prevailed before his time. His | policy was that of confidence, and reliance upon ‘‘ the elements of a true manhood ” which he recognized and relied upon in every young man. His treatment of ‘‘seeret societies ”"—one of the great problems of college disci- | p'ine at the present day-—is worth considering. ‘* Each society, as recog- nized, was required to have a regular or honorary member of the society in the existing faculty, and also a committee appointed by its president, whose duty it should be to consult and co-operate with the president of the col- lege in relation to any of its members who might be becoming remiss in study or irregular in conduct” (p. 32). The Black Tills. By Richard Irving Dodge, Lt.-Col. U.S.A. Tllus- trated, (New York: James Miller. 1876.)—Last summer the Interior Department sent a party into the Black Hills, under Mr. W. P. Jenney, geologist, to make a topographical and geological survey of the country, and to discover its real value in agricultural and mineral wealth, about which there had been so many conflicting reports. This party remained in and about the Hills for more than five months, and collected the materials for a good map, a comprehensive geological report, and a trustworthy esti- mate of the resources of the country. These results are not yet, however, in print. Col. Dodge accompanied this party in command of the escort, and being an officer of nearly thirty years’ service, more than half of which has been passed on the Plains, and being also quite without prejudice in the matter, he is capable of giving a judicious account of what he saw ; and this | he has done, in a very readable little book, composed without any attempt at literary finish, from which the general reader will readily obtain . ; p . ‘ : | all the information on the subject which he desires, The geological notes and sections, by one of Mr. Jenney’s assistants, are sufficient to give | x definite idea of the formation of the country, and this is supplemented by some fair lithographs and an excellent map—the most accurate up to this date. In addition, there are discussions of the climate and resources, the huniing, and the action of the miners who were expelled by military authority, considerable information of the guide-book sort, and a few very plain re- marks about the Indian question, from the standpoint of what might be called the educated frentiersman. Col. Dodge’s conclusions are these : The Black Hills constitute an oasis, about equal to the State of Connecticut in area, in the dreary waste of alka- line plains ; the climate and soil of the lower valleys are well suited to agriculture, and the upper valleys admirably adapted to stocik-raising. There is enough gold to pay for sluice and hydraulic mining, but not for simple panning ; ‘* gold enough to make many fortunes and tempt to the loss of many more.” The early settlement of the Hills is predicted some- What enthusiastically, bat not without the fear that the ‘ squaw men ” will first succeed in inciting the Sioux to war. [Number 562 Fine \rts. EXHIBITION OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF DESIGN. i "PILE display now on view at the Academy is very encouraging in quality. There is evidence of lively effort and of a Letter scholarship. The first is the cause of the almost total absence of slovenly work in the exhibition, and the second causes the artists to perceive more clearly what sloventiness really is, and that it may coexist with the most elaborate finish in the world, if the finish is languidly and unthinkingly applied. It is something rather new to see our artists really trying their strength in broad and strong effects, taking merit as effects. Mr. William Hart’s cattle-sketch (837), with a touch as palpable and pasty as a Constable, would hardly have been either offered or accepted a few years ago, yet it is a serious advance for him. His thinking has spent itself this time on the composition, on the fling and movable look of the figures, and on the grand scale of values throughout the work ; and his reward has come in the fact that this rude picture seems to pant and breathe with open-air life, and that it has a triumphant, luminous quality a thousand times more vivid than any of his ‘* window-gardening” pictures, in which, like a lady concentrating every sort of colored bloom into her jardiniére, he has aimed to bring in the whole solar spectrum, in close quarters and concentrated finish, within picture- frames of uncommon narrowness. Another artist who has dared to put his completeness into his plan and not into his pencilling is Mr. Eastman John- son, whose ‘*‘ Ilusking-Bee ” (285) is more vital than anything he has given us since the ** Stage-Coach,” and perhaps a little in advance of that. In such a scene as this, where a multitude of eager huskers, drawn up in two lines in battle array, are striving to outdo each other in amount of work, and carrying a tournament of effort over the whole sunny breadth of a corn- field, the sentiment of the scenery is what is paramount. The figures, very properly, are viewed as we view figures in a landscape, as parts of the general effect. It would be a greater fault if an old farmer or a pretty milk- maid reflected the light haltingly or made a false note in the general glitter than if an eye ora finger were imperfectly made out. The innumerable figures here accordingly present themselves, as they should, as attitudes ; and in the variety and racy invention of a hundred poses, we are allowed to distinguish the coquettishness of youth, the plodding industry of old age, the tense ambi- tion of the hard worker, winner of many shucking-matches, and the angu- lar motions of extreme senility, good for little more than corn-lhusking. The golden light on the maize-stalks is more precious than any elaboration of fig- ure could be ; the effacement of the distance, where the luncheon-tables are being laid, and the near-at hand flurry of eager cocks and hens, darting at the corn with the censciousness of a realized millennium, are touches that build up the seene in its completeness, and give us a picture realized in blurred colors—attitudes in landscape like’a fair pastoral a little blotted in the humid eye that sees and feels it. This artist, by the bye, who has two styles as distinct from each other as the baritone and falsetto of the man in the comic story, produces a second picture in his ‘‘ woolly” manner. It is a country father bringing in a milliner’s masterpiece to his favorite daughter. This is elaborated in the colored cobwebs Mr. Johnson paints in his less inspired moments. Occasionally he shows, with all the pride of a man who has several handwritings, a picture in which the figure is woolly and the accessories are broad, or otherwise, the distance in Berlin-wool meshes and the figure as firm as sculpture. An artist who sees ‘‘ breadth ” in quite another way from Mr. Johnson, Mr. D. R. Knight, has borrowed from its owner for this exhibition his Salon picture of last year, the ‘‘ French Washerwomen ” (176). Here the idyllic tranquillity aimed at permits a more individual examination of the fair models ; the washing-girls are accord- ingly treated in considerable detail, their beauty is elaborated, the twilight dwells lingeringly on their round arms and faces, the motion of the prettiest is arrested, and that of the others made rhythmic. A distinct poetic effort is admitted, and is not thrown away ; for the composition is a harmonious, elegant bas-relief, set with all unity into a low Poussinesque landscape, whose broad dignity envelopes and enhances the human beauty. A scholar-like intelligence, which we are very glad to see, is obvious in more than one contributor ; a betrayal of acquaintance with schools of art that have gone before, in place of the barbaric determination to leap soil- stained from the American earth and instruct the schools that have had the misfortune to exist in other countries. Thus Mr. Samuel Colman, finding himself in the Low Countries, depicts contemporary scenes with a recognition of the way in which the tranquil, delicious Dutch masters por- trayed their homes. The ‘‘ Boats of Antwerp at Low Tide” (449) and ‘On the Scheldt ” (227) are painted in the quaintest affectation of antique style,

Page 17

Apr. 6, 1876] just yielding in the proper place to a beaming modern touch of coler of which time has bereft the original examples. Here we have the gables notched like staircases, and crowded on each other’s shoulders, and the odd round trees appearing above them like chignons ; the lazy, unctuous lap of tideless water, the bat-like hovering of leathery sails, and then, in some happy focus, a glow of basking light in which the modern colorist exerts his freshest powers ; it is like the Van Kessels and Van der Heydens of the Museum, respectfully modernized with a dash wet from the palette of Clays. Mr. Miller, too, shows an intelligent study of past methods of art in his remarkably fine sunset view, ‘‘ New York from Newtown Creek ” (257). A good many Jacob Ruysdaels had been studied, we should say, before the painting of this effect, which respectably sustains comparisons with the best of them. The sky here is broadly intense, with a gradual dying away of light and color towards the zenith, where ranks of gossamer cloud are radiating in transient color-motives like the changeable lights of a pearl-shell. The composition, without being unpleasantly artificial, has a distinct focus and contrasting groups of forms. The narrow water and old rotting sails of stained boats give the scene a Dutch aspect ; and the whole picture has a strength, a reticence, a staying-power, an avoidance of clap-trap, suggestive of the sober poetry of Holland color at its best. Mr. Miller has several other pictures, in limpid gray effects, that are full of science and observation, and indicate a steady advance conquered through hard labor. “*A Woman Serving *(371), by M. R. Oakey, is large, striking, and am-

bitious. This lady has so often given indication of uncommon power in smaller works, and has promised so very much sometimes in her broad Velasquez-like charcoal sketches, that the exhibition of such a large picture is greeted with unusual interest. It is, however, obviously too heavy an undertaking. It is unmethodical, troubled, and anxious: we see the anxiety of the artist in drawing the hands and the mouth, and wish she could have been relieved of it ; the painting of the antique brocade is en- joyed as a relaxation from the more awful problems of design, and is en- joyed a little teo much. But the pose is good—(it is a dark-haired girl of the last century carrying a salver of fruits, such a type as one fancies ad- dressed in sinister tones by a Henry Esmond, with his ‘* Drop the charger, Herodias !”)—the flowing sense of a woman’s motion in carrying a graceful burden is perfectly given. It is solidly modelled and effectively relieved, and Cottier has framed it in a dull wooden splendor that admirably com- ports with its sentiment. For a female figure in life-scale, however, if we wish to go to one which easily overcomes everything else in the exhibition, whether portraits or invented characters, we must ay- proach Mr. Sartain’s simple head of a contadina (490). No other study of the life compares with it in the most distant way, and from the pint of view of its intentions and problems it may be called perfect work. It is a beautiful, plaintive Italian face, looking upward in prayer. The lifting of the brows over the forehead, the sockets of the black hollow eyes, the dark yet transparent olive of the cheek, and the flesh shadows 25 BOND STREET, NEW YORK. $2 50. RECENT AND FORTHCOMING BOOKS. | IN THE LEISURE-HOUR SERIES. SRSILIA. By the author of * My Little Lady.’ WRASER-TYTLER’S FONA THAN. REGIME [Next week. TAINE’S ANCIENT The N

tg | me Ip . . = flen vy flolt co t 0. . shaw ene PAA Ng Ay a ) Comparative Embryology. Copiously illustrated. 8vo, _

ation. 935 so deep, yet not opaque, show the great promise and present success of this pupil of M. Bonnat. The work has a Southern intensity so imposing as to make it hard to do justice to other efforts very admirable in their way, but emanating from a different condi- tion of feeling. Mrs. Loop’s portrait (389), will, however, bear almost any comparison, it is so winning, fresh, honest, and obvious, It is painted in the simplest planes and breadths possible, is like a seulptor’s bust just after the pointing-marks have been rubbed away. The expression is the bright and hardy look of a happy matron ; it is a picture we make friends with at once, and we can only congratulate the sitters whom Mrs, Loop will here- after interpret in such a genial andadmirable strain. Mr. Guy, who is now painting a good many life-sized figures, contributes another Italian girl, in carnival finery, and resting on a tambourine (207). The style is unrelent- ing, finished to the last polish of the epidermis, and completely superticial ; yet the wet globe of a gazing eye, the tough perfection of a healthy peasant’s hand, are given, from the outside, with a vigor and perseverance that lend them a kind of interest, as articles of ciselure or bij ulerie ; but the recent sight of a masterpiece like 490 has left the eye unprepared to appreciate a model treated as an object of virtt in the manner of M. Desgoff these life-sized studies, however, it is impossible to overlook the portrait by Mr. Page. It represents President Charles Eliot of Llarvard, and it is a Among crisp utterance that the most careless promenader cannot pass without notice. It is the pe ‘uliarity of Mr. Page, in all his better work, to give us pictures that we cannot regard without the deepest curiosity and interest, whatever we may think of his very individual handling. We must observe that he has made a study of the sitter’s character, and delivered a per- fectly clear report upon it. fused demi-tints, his modelling of muscles or osseous protuberances by strange litile clouds of reflected light that play around the temples and the jaws, we cannot but see that he works with intense conviction, and that he However we may like his flesh-tones, his suf- uses portraiture in the way of character-interpretation. Here, in a college president standing in his robes, a manuscript in his hand, and evidently addressing an audience, we have delineated the habit of mental command, an elegant self-possession, and that smile which a man’s friends take to indicate imperturbable urbanity, but which, in the ease of a lean New Eng le of the rize- Mr. Page exhibits another work, at once of portraiture and restoration, in the bronze land professor with close-shaved face, comes very near the smi fighter who accepts opposition and is ready to take as to give bust of Shakspere taken from the German death-mask. We have not space to-day to allude to it, except to say that it is a labor rather of archwol than sentiment, and as such worthy of the closest attention, Beside it, in a very limited exhibition of sculpture, is a dark bronze of Mr. d y farha' John A, Ken- nedy, by Mr. O’Donovan, in which the impasto of good painting is well represented, completely overcoming the stubborn tenacity of bronze surface ; and a little medallion by Mr. Warner, not much in itself, but irreproach- able, and the work of an artist who has exhibited several works showing great merit and the best education F. W. DEVOE & Co., Manufacturers ard Importers of Artists Alaterials. Wax-Flower Gocds, Varnishes, White iad, BRINTON’S THE RELIGIOUS | “442"'S HAND OF ETHELBERTA. French Zine and Colors. Sentiment. Its Source and Aim; a Contribution to the Science and Philosophy of Religion. Large 12mo, $2 50. | /RS. ALEXANDER’S HER DEAREST FOE. BRINTON’ S M V7HS OF THE VERS DE SOCIETE. 1 vol. New World. A Treatise on the Symbolism and Mytho- | G/FT’S PRETTY MISS BELLEW. logy of the Red Race of America. Second edition. Large 12mo, $2 50. MISS MOLLY. “* Justifies the belief that, in whatever Dr. Brinton may in MRS. OLIPHANT’S WHITELADIES. WALFORD'S MR. SMITH. future contribute to the literature of Comparative Mythology, he will continue to reflect credit upon himself and his coun- try.’ —North American Review, ALBEMARLE’S (Earl of) F/FTY (; INN Years of My Life. [Shortly WALKER'S (fF. A.) THE WAGES Question. [Nearly ready. HISTORY OF THE UNITED States, in Freeman’s Course. By J. A. Doyle. With Maps by F. A. Walker, Professor of History and Political Economy in Yale College, author of the * Statistical At- las of the United States.’ 16mo, $1 40. Thomsen—Retail, 40 « National Music Readers an Goodwin's Greek ties and Miscellanies. [SAh.rtly. ° Liddell & Scott's Lexicons > one , . SHROTHA ERS, rremont Place, Boston, PvuBLISH: Arnold’s English Literature, Amer. ed Hudson’s Pamphlet Edition jurns, Burke, Webster, Text-Books of Poetry and Prose School Shakespeares, separate Plays, Lectures. 4 | OUR WORLD Senies of Geo MAINE'S VILLAGE COMM UNT- ; Allen & Green ugh’s Latin Series. [Nearly ready. : 115 and 117 Fulton Street, New York,

_— . ) To Sedeitary Persons, Jo Luvalads. CUMULATIVE EXERCISE—that is, lifting gently, PISTER ely, and systematically, on the REACTIONARY IF TER—produces rest and rehabilitation in health. ‘Lo professional and sedentary persons it affords endurance, and to the invalid the energy which medicine cannot provoke. Ten minutes lifting a day is enough Those who try it for THREE months generally buy the Lifter, and continue their practice at home. A trial may be made at the Health-Lift Co.’s Rooms, 46 East Fourteenth Street, New York, where one may meet many distinguished men and women, and cannot well! avoid forming a favorable on of Cumulative Exercise, both from experience and observaticn. HEALTH-LIFT CO.

of Wordswortn, Coleridge, 7} Beattie, Bacon, Goldsmith, arts.

raphies.

Page 18

ee

-yN > > Reader / hie L EAMES. NO, OF Hiti-Treses or Western CuHIna ue British race ever and anon proves the excellence of rt t k by me new colonizi iw or ¢ xploring expedition that epeats, amid the altered circumstances of our day, the old s f a people born to traverse the globe—the suc- ce f Drake, Raleigh, and the colonists from whom we spring. No greater motive than that of trade is needful to call out the magnificent energy of this essentially aggressive race in its special virtue of quict application and patient re- moval of obstacles. The extension of commerce in the pre- ent age elicits those overcoming qualities which are always heroic and were once exclusively warlike. A large and intensely interesting volume by Dr. John An- derson reports a succession of expeditions from the eastern part of India to the western part of China, under the title of *Mandalay to Momien.’ The problem is to open a com- merce between China and India by trade-routes leading overland from the nei; hborhood of Calcutta, or, better, from Burma to points near the Yang-tse-kiang ; by such a con- duit the nch products of the Yunnan and Sz-chuen pro- vinces would be directed into British territory without the dangerous voyage by the Straits and Indian Archipelago, The overland route is across the neck of the peninsula of Siam, which is traversed by the two southward-flowing rivers of Irawady and Cambodia. Mandalay, on the Ira- wady, a royal city of Burma, was known to be the entrepdt of a valuable cotton-trade from China before 1867, at which date but four English freight-steamers had ever ascended to it. The route of the native caravans was reported to be over a distance of sixty miles among the hill countries of hiennee and Yunnan, with the crossing of about fifty mountains and thirty rivers, to Bhamo on the Chinese frontier The expeditions now narrated, in which the names of the intrepid explorers Major Sladen, Elias, Cooke, Margary, Gordon, and Colonel Horace Browne are rendered illustrious, penetrate into countrics hitherto almost entirely unknown, The hill tribe between Upper Burma and China, called Kak- hyen;, who worship twenty-one deities neither Mohammedan nor Buddhist; the Chinese Shans, living a little further east: and the Panthays, warlike Mohammedan Chinamen from the North (of whose conversion to the faith by means of a band of employed Ara) warriors or condottieri from See- yoogwet there isa sin rular native account), were the three particular tribes which the expedition of 1°63 was formed to investigate. The quarrels and rebellions of these hardy races had at that date temporanly stopped the cotton sup- ply in Burma. The enterprise of Major Sladen was at first successful A British resident was soon appointed and placed at Bhamo, on the Upper Irawady, near the Chinese frontier. In the four years between 1870 and 1874 the steam navigation on the Irawady developed into a fortnightly ser- vice, and cargoes worth about £200,000 were carried in one year through Bhamo. English travellers were well received at Momien, in China, the headquarters of the Mohammedan Panthay These Moslem Chinese however, rebelled again in 1873 and 1874, causing a suspension of traffic. This out- break having been quelled, the re-establ'shment of relations e made by similar means. At the head of the

| | wa izht to | expedition of 1865 was placed Mr. Margary, a clever young nsul. who was sent for from Hanghai. He came over- | la Momier i mplishing the four months’ overland i ifety, but w killed near there by Chinese trea ry | he author of this book, returning to Mandalay, Irawady in safety, and now gives a most spi- rite | and informing ac it of these important though abor- tive exy itions [Number 562

MANDALAY TO MOMIEN. A Narrative of the Two Expeditions to West- ern China of 1868 and 1875, under Col. E. B. Sladen and Col. Horace Browne. By John Anderson, M.B. Edinburgh, F.R.S.E. 8vo, with Maps and Illustrations, $7 50. MY CIRCULAR NOTES. from Journals, Letters sent Home, and Westward 1874, to July Campbell, Extracts Notes written while travelling round the World, from July 6, 6, 1875. By J. F. author of ‘Frost and Fire.’ 2 vols. crown Svo, with numerous Illustrations from Sketches by the author, $7 50. ALTON LOCKE: ‘Tailor and Poet. By. Charles Kingsley. New edition, with ‘Cheap Clothes and Nasty’ included, and a Prefatory Memoir by Thomas Hughes, Q.C. Crown 8vo, $1 75. é PREHISTORIC MAN. Researches into the Origin of Civilization in the Old World and the New World. By Daniei Wil- son, LL.D., Professor of History and English Literature in University College, Toronto. Third edition, enlarged and revised. With numerous Illustrations on Stone and Wood. 2 vols. Svo, $12. ANGOLA AND THE RIVER CON- go. By J.J. Monteiro. With sixteen full- page illustrations from Sketches taken on the spot, and a Map. 1vol. 12mo, cloth, 2 50. ** This book is somewhat of a rarity in African literature. It contains no hairbreadth escapes, no improbable hunting adventures, and it is written by a trained scientific observer, who has a distinct idea of the sort of information he desires to impart, and a very lucid method of imparting it.”—7’e Nation. FLORAL DECORATIONS FOR the Dwelling-House. <A _ Practical Guide to the Home Arrangement of Plants and Flowers. By Annie Hassard. Amer ican — revised. With many illustra- tions. Crown 8vo, cloth gilt, $1 50. “* The author of this delightful little volume is a lady who thoroughly understands her subject, both in its principles and its practical details. The relish with which she takes up, one after another, every form of the decorative use of flowers, and the ready clearness with which she illustrates it, commu- = ates something of her own enthusiasm to the reader.’ — . Y. Tribune. ** It contains well-considered and tasteful directions for the arrangement of flowers for decorative purposes in the dining- room, on the Christmas dinner-table, the breakfast-table, in vases for drawing-rooms, on mantelpieces, to be worn in the hair or button-hole ; also, for wreaths, crosses, for win- dow-gardening, the grouping of plants in rooms, and the like. A book which cannot fail to be useful to those who need advice on such subjects. It is thorou ghly practical, and comprehends all that one needs to know.”’—Athena@um., STATESMAN’S VEAR-BOOK, 1876. Statistical and Historical Annual of the States of the Civilized World. Hand- book for Politicians and Merchants. By Frederick Martin. Thirteenth annual pub- Revised after Official Returns. Crown 8vo, $3 50. lication. “* The volume is of such service to men of business and of letters that, onc: called into requisition, it will thereafter be regarded as an indispensable adjunct of the library and counting-room.’’—Chicago Tribune. MY YOUNG ALCIDES. A New Novel by Charlotte M. Yonge, author of ‘The Heir of Redclyffe.’ 1 vol. 12mo, cloth, $1 75. MEMOIRS OF GENERAL BUR- goyne. Political and Military Episodes from the Life and Correspondence of the Right Honorable John Burgoyne. By E. B. de Fonblanque. Comprising original letters from Lord Chatham, Charles Fox, Edmund Burke, Washington, and other distinguished statesmen. With Portraits. 8vo, cloth, $5. ‘““A highly interesting book.”—Saturday Review, Lon- don. THE ATTIC ORATORS. From Anti- phon to Isxos. By R. C. Jebb, Professor of Greek in the University of Glasgow, and Public Orator in the University of Cam- bridge. 2 vols. 8vo, $o. LIFE OF WILLIAM, EARL OF Shelburne, afterwards First Marquess of Lansdowne. With Extracts from his Papers and Correspondence. By Lord Edmond Fitzmaurice. Vols. I. and II. S8vo, cloth, each $4. SERMONS PREACHED IN THE College Chapel, Cheltenham, during the first year of his office, 1874-5. By Herbert Ky- naston, M.A. (formerly Snow). Crown 8vo, $2 2 22 THE GOSPELS IN THE SECOND Century. An Examination of the Critical Part of a work called ‘ Supernatural Religion.” By W. Sanday, M.A. Crown Svo, $3 75 SYZLABUS OF PLANE GEOME- try. Corresponding to Euclid, Books 1-6. By the Association for the Improvement of Geometrical Teaching. Crown 8vo, sewed, 50 cents. Macmillan & Co.’s Complete Catalogue, with Index, sent post-paid on receipt of six cents. MACMILLAN & CO., 21 Astor PLAcE, New York.

Page 19