The Nation 1876-03-16: Vol 22 Iss 559
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
The Nation.
NEW YORK, THURSDAY, MARCH 16, 1876. The Week. R. ORVIL GRANT, the President’s brother, who has been fre- \ quently mentioned by the licentious and unbridled press during the last two or three years as a nomadic gentleman whese occupa- tion would not bear examination, appeared on Thursday before the Committee on the War Department, and told his own story of his jobs as an Indian trader in a simple, artless way that would be di- verting if it were not for the picture it presents of the views enter- tained by the Presidential family on “ the science of polities.” Mr. Grant appears to be an unsuccessful man, who, when all else failed, tried to get a living in some easy way out of the Government, and accordingly applied to his brother to license him as an Indian trader. The reply was very characteristic of the ‘‘ simple-minded, sagacious man” at the White House. He did not say that it would be im- proper, or inexpedient, or likely to causé scandal to put one of bis own family in such a position; nor did he even say that a certain post was vacant which Orvil might have, and in which he hoped he would earn an honest living. He told him of fexr posts at which the traders were going to be removed, and Orvil accordingly applied for licenses not for one, but for four, and obtained them. This was in 1874, and he at once put “partners” of his in all the vacancies, who were to pay bima heavy share of the profits; but in one only, in January of this year, did he invest any capital, and in this only $2,000. Of course, the traders in paying him profits paid him simply for his influence with his brother, the President, at Washington, and Orvil confessed to the committee in the plainest manner that what was regrettable in his eyes in the whole affair was, not his use of his “influence,” but the smallness of the amount he made out of the traderships. The transaction differs from the Belknap affair, as far as the President is concerned, simply in this, that while Belknap allowed his wife to sell traderships and apply the money to his household expenses, the President allowed his brother to sell them and keep the money himself. We are not surprised to hear that General Grant is very much annoyed by these investigations, and says they are carried on for “partisan purposes.” Orvil appeared before the committee to be a man entirely devoid of what is called a sense of honor in matters pertaining to public funds, and is well worth study as a product of recent popular education, andas an illustration of the moral tone of ‘‘ Administration circles.” A correspondent of the St. Louis Republican calls attention <0 a@ singular statement in President Grant’s deposition in the Babeock case, with regard to his system of appointments, which seems deserving of more than a passing notice. He was asked what was done on the death of Ford, the St. Louis collector, as to the appointment of his successor. He replied that inasmuch as Ford had died “suddenly and away from home,” | he told Babcock that he ‘*should be guided largely in selecting his successor” by ‘the recommendations or wishes of bis bonds- men”; and in reply to another question, he stated that he could not say ‘‘on whose recommendation exclusively” the successor was actually appointed, but that he was ‘well recommended and satisfactory to the bondsmen of Mr. Ford.” This was all stated in a matter-of-course way, as if all appointments had been made in this fashion ever since the formation of the Govern- ment, and it is proper to enquire what it means. Now, the only interest the bondsmen of a collector have in the appointment of a successor is, to get a man put in who will cover up any frauds or is strong just in proportion to the probability of fraud. Their interest is therefore directly hostile to the Government, and they are the very people whom the Government ought most carefully to avoid consulting. So much for the abstract principle. The result of actually applying it in Ford’s case was this: Babeock tele- graphed at once to Joyce, who was applying for the office, to get the approval of Ford’s bondsmen. Ford's bondsmen were the Whiskey Ring, and they agreed with Jovee to recommend one Constantine Maguire for the place. He was immediately appointed. It is hardly necessary to say that Maguire is one of the leading whiskey thieves found out by Bristow, and now, we believe, awaiting sentence of court. bach will be here soon. We hope Offen- More damaging facts in Mr. Pierrepont’s case have come out in connection with the Babeoek military court. When this court was called together Mr. Pierrepont immediately wrote to Dyer, the District Attorney in St. Louis. to send to the Judge-Advoeate at Chicago “any documentary evidence bearing upon the ease, and the names and residence of any witnesses whose testimony you [Dyer] judge important to make the investigation thorough”; and ended by reminding Mr. Dyer of what he (Pierrepont) had “ often said,” that no “dl, and no guilty one to escape.” The reply which Dyer sent to this letter has not been published, but there is reason to believe that he at once wrote to Mr. Pierrepont asking whether he in earnest, reminding him that it is not customary in this country in time of peace for civil courts to be the hands of army; declaring that he refused the order, that, even if he were willing to court would allow such a proceeding. This would unquestionably have been the proper reply to It will noticed that the view Mr. Pierrepont takes of his duties is, not that he is bound to pro- secute anybody whom he ean find primd-facie evidence against, but that he is a kind of wise and loving judge, whose business it is to prevent the innocent from being punished quite as mueh as to secure the conviction of the guilty. In facet, throughout the case we see Mr. Pierrepont in what, in a’ profession closely allied to politics, would be called his “‘ Protean feat” of appearing at one and the same time in the three roles of prosecuting officer, counsel for the defence, and judge. We strongly recommend him to read the fable of the Innocent Dog recently published in the World. so ‘“we wish innocent man punish: Was put into to so, the and hot ' abe) do the send. be The Republicans in the Senate, not to be beaten at investiga- tions, have passed a bill to investigate insects injurious to vegeta- tion —the locust, the chinch-bug, the army-worm, the Hessian fly, and the potato-bug. The bill provides for an investigator-in-chief at a salary of $4,000 a year, the herculean labors of the head of the Agricultural Bureau preventing that official from giving the neees- sary time toit. The act, should it pass the House—which seems
dcubtful—will be a new application of the great principle of division | of labor, for in future the Agricultural Commissioner will seatter the seed broadcast over the land, while the national entomologist will follow closely on his trail and exterminate the various bugs that may attack the ripening grain. We only want now another Com- missioner to harvest the crops, and another to see that they get to deep water, and the husbandman will be entirely relieved from grinding toil. The Senate has also disposed of the case of Mr. P. B. 8S. Pinehback, refusing him his seat by a vote of 32 to 29; has had a debate on the excise service, which we have dis-
cussed elsewhere ; has passed a bill to admit New Mexico; and has debated Mr. Morton’s bill as to the counting of the Presi- | dential vote. The House has refused to turn over the documents | in the Belknap case to the District Courts, after an exciting de- irregularities their principal may have committed, and their interest | bate; has brought before the bar a Mr. Wolff, formerly a book-keeper
Page 2
170 for a firm of navy contractors and claim agents, who refused to tell the Naval Committee whether he knew of money being corruptly used by the firm. On being brought up, he fell down in a fit, and Mr. Whitthorne, the chairman of the committee, explained that he had already answered the question, and he was discharged. The precise facts disclosed by him to the committee yet remain a seeret. The House has passed a bill for the protection of witnesses, exempt- ing all witnesses who testify under protest before either House, or any committee, or the Senate sitting as a court of impeachment, from all criminal liability except impeachment, and providing, at the same time, that absconding witnesses shall be punishable by fine or imprisonment; the Legislative and Executive bill has been re- ported, with estimates cut down to the extent of $8,000,000; and the Hawaiian Treaty has again been discussed, and the conference re- port on the District of Columbia 3.65 bonds adopted. The expected report of the Senate Committee against the con- firmation of Mr. Dana, to the body which has just confirmed Bil- lings in the judgeship at New Orleans, would be a wretched piece of business. We believe the agents who have contributed to this result are Mr. W. Bb. Lawrence, who accuses Mr. Dana of hav- ing pirated the notes of his edition of Wheaton, and Mr. B. F. Butler, who accuses him of having “ bolted the regular ticket” on certain occasions, and being generally obnoxious to himself. As re- gards Butler’s hostility, we had hoped that the Senate had learned enough to be indifferent to it. As regards Mr. Lawrence’s charges, we shall only say that the matter is still before the courts, having been re- ferred some time ago toa master to report on the rival editions. He has made no report because, we venture to assert, there is nothing to report that would not be almost ridiculous as a charge against Mr. Dana. We made a careful collation of the two books ourselves in 1866, and published the result in No. 66 of the Nation. The only basis for Mr. Lawrence’s charges worth notice was that Mr. Dana’s translations from foreign languages occasionally were textually like his own, to which nobody who has ever translated from mo- dern languages will attach any importance in the case of a man like Mr. Dana, who was himself a master of internaticnal law and a leading practitioner in Admiralty cases when he undertook the work. As to identity in the illustrations cited of certain rules, since the illustrations were prominent events of modern history, it is almost absurd to base on them an accusation of bad faith offered to educated men. There is one case of literal copying of a quotation of four lines of Lawrence’s from Blackstone, with the typographical error which it contained—-over which Mr. Lawrence has been childisbly exultant, but there is no doubt that this was due to an oversight of the printer, to whom, improperly as we think, Mr. Dana had left the task of striking out all of Lawrence’s notes. That this error was not detected by him in the proof-sheets was natural enough. In facet, to attack Mr. Dana’s character in this matter in ever so slight a degree is to give proof of a perverse and malignant temper, and if the Senate Committee is influenced by such attacks in making its report, without giving him a hearing, it will be guilty of a gross offence against justice and decency. in his testimony before the House Foreign Affairs Committee James E. Lyon testified that, in 1872, a despatch was sent to England by Professor Silliman, Brydges Willyams, and Hussey, who had made an examination of the Emma Mine, to the effect that there were “ eight thousand tons discovered since last report; sample assay, two thousand dollars per ton.” Professor Silliman could not remember that be had signed such a despatch, and on go- ing home he searched the files of the English mining journals, and came upon the following, which he admits he did send and wishes to have included in his testimony given under oath, and on which he relies for his professional vindication : ‘“ Very great improvements since last report. On seventh floor drifted 120 feet, and tenth fleor 40 feet, all in ore; at the bottom winze, 70 feet below old workings, drifted 40 feet, all in ore. Sample The N | yun ; , an assays 28 per cent. lead and $2,000 silver. Reserves discovered [Number dd9 ation. since last report over 8,000 tons. Everything connected with the mine is highly satisfactory. Mailed supplementary report. Canyon road still bad. Shall forward 1,000 tons first-elass ore forthwith, Have 65 tons bullion, worth £20,000 ; propose selling here. Arranged all other matters here. Will report fully on return. ‘“¢WILLYAMS, SILLIMAN, AND HUSSEY.” We have examined this despatch carefully, and eannet see what the difference is between the statement actually sent and that given by Lyon; though Professor Silliman says in a letter to Mr. Hewitt, the chairman of the committee, that “there is rothing in this despatch to justify the monstrous statement made in the garbled extract from it that those 8,600 tons of ore had an assay value of $2,000, or that the despatch above quoted gives to the reserves any specific value whatever.” If the despatch did not mean that there were 8,000 tons worth $2,000 per ton, we cannot understand what it did mean, unless Mr. Silliman uses lan- guage in a way totally different from that in which other people use it. In fact, it seems to us that the meaning of the despatch was clearly just what Lyon represented it to be, and that it was intended to effect just the object he said it was intended to cfiect. Another point in the case not cleared up is as to the expert’s pay- ment for services. He was paid $5,000, he says, at the outset, and promised more afterwards. After the mine was floated, he got $20,000 more. He was employed by the vendees of the mine, he has always maintained, and yet the man who actually appeared as his employer was, he now says, General Baxter, one of Park’s ‘‘ pals” in the sale. As to the $20,000 additional which he got, he says it was in part paid for work on other mining property of Park’s. Now the question arises, what was tbis other property, and what was the work, and did the Emma Mine pay for work done on other and disconnected mines? This witness evidently needs a good deal more vigorous cross-examination than he has yet been subjected to. The Texas and Pacific Railway Pill has not yet been reported to the House, and the impression is daily gaining strength that its friends believe it unwise to urge it at the present time when its advocates would be intimidated by the approaching Presiden- tial election. If the bill is one which, either from want of merit or through the means used to secure its passage, will not bear the daylight of an election year, it is difficult to see on what ground it ought to pass in any other year, while the character of the bill, so far as known, shows that the period of delay has also been a pericd of growth, and that the scheme has obtained a size during gestation which will probably strangle it in its birth. The ‘Texas and Pacific Railway proper is 1,500 miles long, of which 1,300 only remain to be built, and there would seem to be no propriety in asking a subsidy for anything more than this 1,300 miles; but the bill, as reported from the sub-committee, would most properly be termed a * Bill providing for the construction of a Railway System in the Southwestern States.” In addition to the main line it provides for a branch, at least 300 miles long, from Shreveport to New Orlears ; for a branch, nearly 200 miles long, from the same point to Vicks- burg; for a third branch, 300 miles long, from Jefferson, Texas, to Memphis; and for a fourth, 400 miles long, from a point in Western Texas to the present terminus of the Atlantic and Pacific Rail- road in the northeastern part of the Indian Territcry, forming with that line a route to St. Louis. The total length of these branches is fully 1,200 miles, nearly as long as the unbuilt main line, and none of them are demanded to accommodate business. The railway already has rail communication with the Texas ports and steamboat communication with New Orleans. Vicksburg is a point of no impertance,while both Memphis and St. Louis are reached from its eastern terminus over the St. Louis, Iron Mountain, and Southern Railway, and its connections, by lines now in operation, nearly or quite as direct as the shortest which can be found. It is un- derstood that the promoters of the railway have no desire to build these branches, but that they are accepted to secure the support of Congressmen. The bill in its proposed form finds a
Page 3
oN Tf, } ie Mar. 16, 1876] parallel only in the story told early in the war of the young man who, on asking fora lieutenant’s commission, Was answered that his request could not be granted, but that he might, if he really eared about it, be made a brigadier-general. r9 — ek > ’ Any moral authority the late Advisory Couneil in | might have had may be safely said te have been destroyed by the address of Dr. Storrs to his church on Sunday evening las’, and by the subsequent action of the church with regard to it. Dr. Storrs’s arraignment of the Council follows the same line as Professor E. C. siastical defects of its action, but his exposure of the arrange- ment it made for the further trial ef the charges against Mr. Beecher is still more damaging. He declares that under its rulings “ no priest or minister in any other body of Christians ever known on earth was so entirely shielded from enquiry as to his character as is the pastor of a Congregational church, according to the state- ment of this assembly, so long as he succeeds in keeping his hold on his circle of local hearers.” We cannot help thinking that this, if true, is due in some degree to the nature of the Congregational system itself, but we do not know what answer can be made to Dr. Storrs’s account of the extraordinary machinery which the Council invented for a final and decisive enquiry into Mr. Beecher’s case. In the first place, the Council had, under the letter missive, no au- thority to suggest or create any such machinery; in the second, the organization of the proposed tribunal was committed to three gentlemen whose confidence in Mr. Beecher is “express and com- plete”; in the third, the list of twenty persons from whom the tri- bunal can be chosen contains several names of those who believe in Mr. Beecher’s innocence already and are eager for his vindication ; in the fourth, if five of them cannot be got to serve, any three can make up the full number out of the denomination at large ; so that, in short, the composition of the court would be unknown to the aeeuser up to the last moment, and it might he strongly hostile to him; in the fifth, the charges must be presented within sixty days, and to the church, who are to forward it to the commission; in the sixth, it is in the power of the commission to decide that the charges presented have been sufficiently tried already (i.c.. by Mr. Beecher’s investigating committee), and dismiss the complaint; inthe seventh, the commission can only act at the request of Plymouth Church, and if at the end of the sixty days no charges have been presented, the chureh may offer fresh ex-parte evidence, and ask on it a further vindication of Mr. Beecher. substantially Acting on Dr. Storrs’s address, his church on Monday evening passed resolutions repudiating the decisions of the Advisory Coun- cil and refusing to bold Congregational fellowship with any church which adheres to the principles laid down by it ; and declaring that whatever concerns the collective brotherhood of the churches may be judged by the brotherhood in a properly constituted council, and that whenever any church refuses to rid itself of a scandal, by appropriate ecclesiastical procedure, either instituted by itself or proffered by sister churches, it may be the duty of the brotherhood of the churches to institute enquiry cn its own account, in order to rid itself of such scandal or of such church. On this, steps will probably be taken to bring about some thorough investigation of “the main question,” or to expel Plymouth Church from fellowship | if it refuses to submit to it. The Stock Exchange was enlivened during the week by a “bull” speculation in Erie and a “bear” speculation in Pacific Mail. Each of these stocks has for years been a favorite {ootball for speculators. It appears that Erie, encumbered as it is with financial embarrassments, has been fortunate enough to attract, for ultimate purposes of their own, the attention of capitalists connected with the Delaware, Lackawanna, and Western and the Delaware and Hudson Companies. They, through the Lackawanna Iron and Coal Company and the Cambria Iron Company, both of which are con- trolled by the interest nathed, have agreed to lay « third rail en the rooklyn | Smyth’s as regards the eccle- | v i 1 uge from Jersey City to Waverley, ~ ne m 61") ) Hill ( rf act Erie, making it a narrow- station a few miles beyond Elmira. The Lehigh Valley, in the e | interest, has agreed to continue this third rail from Waverley to Buffilo. The advantages ef a narrow-gauge to the eoal reads named are important, but the remote ol was to benetit ihe Michigan Central, whieh is owned in good port by the ¢ who control the Delaware, Leek. wanna, and Western Railroed In the case of Pacific Mail, a month ago, when the stock was ie at 40 or thereabouts, the Company was reported to be in exeeilent condition, with a small floating debt and with an encouraging busi- ness. It is now by the same speculators, and they directors, repre- sented to be wholly insolvent, with an alarming tloating debt, with a poor business, and that soon to be divided with a rival Ii To | gages. show the desperate condition of the finances of the Company the directors have authorized the issue of $2,000,000) bonds, which needed, they say, to pay the floating debt. the stoek has fallen to about 12. are Onsuch representations The suspension of the Bank of the State of New York was direetly due to tie action of the Clearing-House Association, whieh, on netiti cation from the Bank Examiner, ascertained that the bank was un sound, and accordingly excluded it from the privileges of the Associa- tion. This bank was organized in 1835, has a eapital of $2,000,000, and has stood respectabiy, its steck last week having sold at 106.) On investigation it was found that the capital was impaired about one- half—that is, that it could pay depositors and all other credi- tors in full, and have remaining about s1,000,.000Q. The difficulties of the bank were.in no way chargeable to the times, but entirely to bad management. | Ss t Lt A circumstance whieh strong] was the appearance in the “cash” of an individual check of Vice-President for $20,000. In addition to these bad eggs in the basket was $224,000 protested paper, among which was $70,000 of Vv charaeterizes this th Lilie e Dunean, Sherman & Co. It is but just to assume that such man agement is not customary in New York banking. Of course, Wail when first Spec . Money ad- veneral calling in of When the exact facts were known, and it was seen that Street was ablaze with excitement the suspension was announced. Gold advanced to 115, but fell back to 114 ulative stocks fell from 1 to 5 per cent., but soon rallied. vanced to 1-16 per day, there having been a loans. ho creditor of the bank would lose, comparative tranquillity was restored. The exposure of the bank was due to the vigilance of the Bank Examiner; its bad debts were of The gold price of $100 greenbacks ranged during the week between S86 94 and $87 43. recent ereation. The reports of the New York savings- banks for the vear [875 have appeared. There were at the close of the vear forty of these institutions, one having since failed—the Security small concern. These banks report total deposits of $124, 188,216, against £1°0,010,703 in 174, and S170,00¢,706 in Is73. The total resources from which to pay depositors were, in 1875, 3205,415,447 ; in 1274 they were $195,325,104 ; and in 1873, 3184,414,895. The amount of deposits, including interest credits, which were made during [875 was $80,000,863, while the amount of deposits withdrawn was $75,026,606; in 12874 these posits, 8¢°0,506,502, and withdrawals, $77,541,208 ; posits, $91,540,649, and withdrawals, $90,715,320. $205,415,447 resources in 1875, $46,184,8=7 States 7 i Which was a items were: de- in73, de- of the consisted of United of bonds and mort- It would speak better for the management of these cor- porations if the investments in United States bonds were larger, as these securities excel all others not enly in point of safety but of availability. The number of open accounts in 1875 was 468,562, against 494,026 in 1874, and 479,102 in 1873. This is not strange, considering that five banks, no one of them important except the Third Avenue, failed during the year, and that these failed banks hed 19,000 open accounts in Out while 865,328,83 bonds, consisted The statement shows a smaller decrease in the amount of deposits than was expected, considering the hare “times and the extent to which labor has been unemployed,
Page 4
172 The Nation. [Number 55) “THE ECONOMY AND SIMPLICTTY OF OUR FOREFATHERS.” MGLE fall of Mr. Belknap is generally ascribed, and with considerable appearance of truth, to bis wife’s desire, and doubtless also his own, to live handsomely. She was what is called a ‘leader of fashion ” in that remarkable portion of human society called “ Ad- ministration circles,” and required considerably more money than ] | her husband’s income to reach the standard of gentility in the mat- | ter of meat, drink, clothing, and carriages set up by the people among and she got it out of the sutlers, and they out of the soldiers and settlers on the Plains, Whether this is an accurate statement of the case or not, it is the one generally accepted by the public, and the moral drawn from it, by a somewhat sweep- ing generalization, is that extravagance in living isthe main source of our political corruption, and that if we would reform the Govern- ment we must go back to the simplicity of food and attire and the accompanying personal integrity supposed to have been common in the year 1776 or thereabouts. We confess there is to us something almost as depressing in this kind of talk as in the practice in which many of our newspapers indulge, of drawing consolation for the present corruption of this Republie from the reflection that the corruption of the English monarchy one hundred and fifty years ago was just as great; because both one and the other have a ten- deney to turn people’s minds away from real remedies and throw them back on quackery. There is, in the first place, always something childish in calling out in times of publie danger and distress for things which are clearly whom she sought to shine ; unattainable, and nothing is more clearly unattainable than a | return to the manners and customs of another age. This would be true even if it were certain that there was any necessary connec- tion between the plain living of the early Americans and their good morals. There is no such connection. No man or woman is kept from knavery by wearing homespun and living on pork and molasses. If we had only to change men’s clothes and put them on short commons in order to make them good, we might dispense with religion and law, and the saints of every community would be found in the penitentiary. It may be said, too, with confidence that the people of every age have lived about as well as they could afford. The men and women of the last century wore plainer clothes than we do, «ud ate plainer fare, because fine clothes and rich diet were harder to get, because, in short, they had less to offer in exchange for them. The steam-engine and the power-loom and the spinning-jenny bad not been invented, and nearly everybody had to trust to the produce of his farm for a livelihood, and the difficulties of travel and the absence of periodical literature kept his imagina- tion ina state of virtuous quiescence. He wore homespun, then, not because he was good, but because he could not help it. ‘ Plain liv- ing and high thinking” even in our time often go together, but the thinking is not high because the living is plain; more generally the living is plain beeause the thinking is high. In order to go back to the manners of 1776, we should have to get rid of all the material progress which separates this year from that—that is, all the in- dustry, art, and means of locomotion which the discoveries and inventions of the last century have placed at our disposal. In order to get very much advantage from living like the forefathers, we should have to reduce the number and power of our temptations to the level of theirs. If we dressed all our modern legislators in serge, and fed them on grits and hominy, it would profit us nothing as long as we allowed Jay Gould to assail them with thousand- dollar bills or railroad stock or bonds. There are, however, some characteristics of the men of the last century which we can imitate and restore, and which in our present plight may do us much politieal service. First and foremost among these is their thorough practicalness, and freedom from the kinder- garten tendeney to shape in your own mind the way you would like things to be, and then to make your arrangements as if that was the way they would be. ‘The Rousseau whey had not made its way into their veins. If we look through their speeches, debates, political treatises, and constitutions, we find that the animal they are thinking about and working for is man as they know him and see him, and not man as they would like to see him and as it would be convenient to have him. Jefferson had some of the true Red dreams about the probable effect on human nature of certain poli- tical contrivances or material conditions, but on the whole his contemporaries were politicians of the true Anglo-Saxon type, who saw no Visions, and did not expect from human nature any extraordi- nary displays of self-denial in the ordinary work of life. If we run through the volume which is perhaps on the whole the best ex- ample of the political thinking of that day, the ‘ Federalist,’ we find the writers occupied anxiously from first to last in the construc- tion of a government which should put the least possible strain on human nature, and offer it fewest temptations, and take most account of its weaknesses. They tried to set up, not something to which truly good men would do well to adapt themselves, but some- | thing which the average man—a being who is neither saint nor devil—would find it easy to live under. For instance, when they were fixing the salaries of the high officers of the Government, they did not, as we do now, evolve from their own moral consciousness the sum which an ideal President ought to need annually. On the contrary, they found out what the Presidents of Congress under the old Confederation had spent in the year, and they made such addi- tions to it as they thought the new President would require to enable him to live with ease and dignity. In like manner, when they came to fix the salaries of the judges of the Supreme Court, they did not thrust one hand under their coat-tails, and run the other through their hair, and pour forth a stream of blatherskite about the way an ideal judge ought to live, and about the smallness of the sum for which good lawyers of their own acquaintance could be got to fill the place. They said: ‘‘'The Supreme Court ought to contain the best lawyers in the country, and in choosing che judges for it we ought not to be restricted to men of accumulated fortunes. Therefore, to get the best lawyers we must pay as much annually a the leading lawyers actually earn in the centres of the largest prac- tice.” Having ascertained that this was about $3,000, they fixed the salary of the Chief-Justice at $4,000 a year, and that of the associate Justices at $3,500. They followed a similar course with regard to all the other offices of the Government. They offered, in short, such salaries as would in the market of that day command the best labor of the kind the public service required, and made absolutely no extraordinary demand on the virtue of the candidates. They no more thought of treating the public service as a monastery, and exacting a vow of poverty from those entering it, than private bankers thought of it. They knew that men would serve the Government from ordinary motives; that good men would need good pay, and security, and the chance of living in the same style as the people with whom they naturally associated in other callings, and they acted accordingly. Since that period Congress has raised the pay of the Supreme Court judges only one hundred and fifty per cent., although the remuneration of leading lawyers in active practice has increased five or six hundred per cent.; and the very same policy (we have no space for illustrative details) bas been pursued through all branches of the service. The rate of pay has been kept far below the market rate, and the result .is that in most of them we get the refuse of the market for Government work—that is, the helpless, the dis- solute, the sickly, the lazy, the incompetent, and the knavish, and when they steal and cheat we implore them “to return to the economy and simplicity of their forefathers”; and when they refuse, we begin tu weep and wail, and ask what is going to become of the country, and what would Washington say if he could see Belknap. There could probably be no better illustration of the darkened state of the public mind about the causes of our present political disease than the approbation with which the present rage for cutting down the salaries of public officers is regarded, as a measure of economy. Far from being a measure of economy, it is one more step in the process by which a middle wall of partition has been erected be- tween the honesty, capacity, and energy of the American people and the Government which it dearly loves and would fain be proud of. on at er ot SR ot 44
Page 5
Mar. 16, 1876] Apply all this t» the case of the unhappy Belknap, and what do we find? The office of Secretary of War, putting as de altogether its dignity and its moral responsibility as regards the discipline of the army, is one of enormous commercial importance. ‘The ineum- bent is charged with the proper disbursement of about $32,000,000 annually. He ought, therefore, to be sought in the ranks of that body of men who are called in this country to take charge of the greatest railroads or manufacturing or mining companies, or, in other words, ought to be the kind of man who finds no difficulty in obtaining from $20,000 to $30,000 a year for his services, and he ought to be one of the very best ef them, because while the president of a railroad or manufacturing company has his conduct submitted every year to the sharp test of money dividends, and is kept up to his work by the watchful eyes of self-interest, the Secretary of War has, for the greater part of his work, no other auditor or supervi- sor than his own conscience. In Belknap’s case he was, however, The N 175 ation. replied to by a leading Republican senator, and the reply consisted of these three heads: Ist, a eulogy of the Republican party; Yd, a statement of a report that the Georgia election was carried by bribery and corruption; 3d, an enquiry why, if Mr. Gordon wished to imitate the English, he did not * monarehy.” In the Belknap impeachment case, the House h ing the question as to the status of an impeachment pending at the same time with an indictment. In the course of the discussion Mr. Lamar of Mississippi spoke of impeachment as a process in- tended for “punishment,” on which a leading Republican, himself a lawyer, immediately proceeded to debate the point with him, maintaining that impeachment was “ protective” and not tive.” Now, the peculiarity of the debate was that there was 1 to debate about. Mr. Lamar immediately produced the constitu come out at once In favor of a d been diseu * Pe peu " lothing | tional provision for total disqualification for office in cases of im- chosen in the person of an humble and obscure revenue collector | in a Western town, where he earned about $3,000 a year, and he was suddenly charged with these enormous responsibilities, | . ’ with a salary of $8,000, and in a position so conspicuous and surrounded by such social conditions that the temptation to live | at the rate of $30,000 a year was trethendous. If he had been a man of Roman virtue, of incorruptible patriotism, of lofty aspira- tion, of refined tastes, of thrifty habits, and had had a monkish scorn for the good things of this life, and his wife had been like him, they would have returned to ‘the economy and simplicity of their forefathers,” and have saved money out of their salary. reason had we to suppose that he was that kind of man? Why should we expect $8,000 a year to fill our Cabinet with saints and sages ? how this calamity overtook us. smiling sadly at our simplicity in expecting anything better. TWO “FAVORITE SONS.” But what | Let us not flatter ourselves that Washington is wondering | On the contrary, he is probably HE past fortnight has witnessed two events in Congress of more | than ordinary importance—one in the Senate and the other in | the House. In the Senate, the occasion was the delivery of an able speech by Mr. Gordon, of Georgia, on the excise service ; in the House, the discussion of the Belknap impeachment. About a month ago Mr. Gordon introduced some resolutions instructing the Committee on Finance to ascertain what amendments to the laws are necessary to secure economy and certainty in the collection of internal revenue, and to prevent frauds in its collection. He desired to have the committee instructed especially to enquire whether it is advisable to “‘ create a corps of excise to hold office indefinitely, removable only for incapacity or malfeasance in office.” Mr. Gordon, in his speech, showed that Great Britain, whose excise system is always put forward as the model of our own, collected a tax of £2 in gold on every gallon of whiskey made, while we could not collect twenty cents per gallon in greenbacks, and when we attempted to col- 1ect $2 a gallon the whole was lost. He quoted from Mr. Fessenden’s | report, made in 1864, to the effect that the annual product of our dis- tilleries was, even then, $100,000,000 ; and proved from Mr. Pratt’s report of 1870 that, notwithstanding the increase of population and development of business since, a tax upon only $77,500,000 was paid in that year; or, in other words, $22,500,000, at the very lowest estimate, eseaped taxation altogether. He asked why it is that one government ean collect $2 in gold and the other cannot collect twenty | cents, and insisted, what everybody knows to be the case, that the | explanation is that the English system of appointments is a pre- mium on honesty and fidelity, while our system of appointment for short terms, for reasons having no bearing whatever on fitness for office, combined with rapid rotation, is a premium on dishonesty and inefficiency. The speech was entirely non-partisan in its tone, and contained just the recommendations which any reflection on the whiskey-fraud exposures and the cases of Joyce, McDonald, McKee, and the rest, would be likely to suggest to the mind of nine out of ten honest and intelligent men. He was immediately | | ! peachment, and a decision of the Supreme Court in which disqu fication for office in case of conviction on impeachment is referred to in so many words as “ punishment;” on which the Republican leader was silenced. It may seem to the reader that we have & rake up the rubbish of the Congressiona’ R this monstrous repivy to Mr. Gordon’s sensible speech in the Senate, and this flimsy trifling with important subjects but the reason we have done so is that the reply to Mr. Gordon in the in the House, did out of our way te me wd in reproducing in the House, not come from obscure and harmless Congressional tledglings, but from two of the leading representatives of the party now in posses- sion of the Government—one of them the ** leader” of the House and the other the head man in the Senate. and most prominent candidates for the Presidential mean, of course, Mr. Morton and Mr. Blaine We have selected these two * incidents” because thes fairly enough what has been going on in Congress beginning of the session, and illustrate better than mons could one of the worst effects of the present political life. We do for a2 moment to Mr. Morton and Mr. Blaine in other respects. Blaine is a man of reputable standing outside of politics, a man of education, and, we believe, right intentions, while Mr. Morton is an unscrupulous demagogue and turncoat. But in one respect they are they are both candidates for the Presidency, and it is important for them to put themselves before the country during the present session in the best possible light, and to lay up as much eapital as possible against the autumn. This is quite right and natural, and we have not a word to say against it. It is for the of country no less than the candidates that we should know much about them we ean, and first and all sort of men they are, and what sort of propose for our consideration and approval. It fact that both being amony th Succession : we } represent ince the imes of ever os voh ser- debasement of not mean compare Mr. alike the Interest as as above whit they HNeasures ingular IB a 8 these two leading candidates, taken from the opposite extremes of the party, should have thus far offered the country abso- lutely nothing. Mr. Blaine did, indeed, bring forward at the opening of Congress a constitutional amendment directed against the Catholies. but the anti-Catholic every one knows now, a mere flurry; and all that Mr. Blaine means to do or can do with his amendment is, not to pass it, but to use it in the campaign to catch anti-Catholic His next appear- ance was in the Amnesty debate, in which he showed that Jefferson Davis was a traitor and a bad man, and suceeeded, by the usual parliamentary tricks, in making a mess of the Democratic Amnesty Bill. exeitement was, as votes. Last year, when the Republicans had possession of the House , they voted, almost if not quite unanimously, ter a bill almost identically the same, without any indication from Mr. Blaine that he was offended by the proposal to pardon Davis. Since then he has made a speech on the curreney question, in which he has neither brought rv even suggested a plan to deal with the only question of importance connected with the sub- and he has new been dis forward 1 ject — the resumption of specie payments :
Page 6
174 The a tinguishing himselfin the impeachment proceedings— to involve perhaps the ruin of his party-——by putting forward, views as to the process which have no rity as to harass the Democrat foundation in law or reason, and would be recognized as a quibble by a We take choolboy it that there has never been a time in the history of the Nation country when there was more deep discontent with the condition of | the Government, nor a greater longing for the appearance on the scene of a new order of men in publie life, capable not merely of expression to this discontent—for this has been pretty well but ef taking part in the actus] government of the giving done already country and bringing some decent order out of tae present confusion. | The day of the fire-eater and of the abolitionist and of the “ war- horse ” it has gone uy, and the question is who are to take their places. It which it is very difficult to avswer, fer it is one of the dry-rot which is eating out the life of our system that no new generation of politicians is coming to the surfaee capable of dealing with the questions which must be dealt and very too, if we are not to give up the attempt at self-government as a failure. The present dearth of new men in political life in France is one of the most noticeable results of the political decline in that country during the last thirty years, but the French never took the means we have taken to drive honest and intelligent men out of political life. They never made a practice of turning a man out of office because he was a faithful public servant and refused to devote his time to other objects than his official duty. ” is a question of the siens with, soon That is exactly what “ rotation’ and the “ wheel-horse ” has gone by, and everybody knows | means, and that is what we have made the corner-stone of our Government. The result has been that the honest, industrious, | respectable classes have been for more than a generation warned | away from public life, and the management of affairs has fallen into the hands of the peculiar people that we now see in Washington. The theory of “rotation” is that it brings up new politica! men * fresh from the people,” but it really does just the opposite. Every year the divorce between public cpinion and the political class has been becoming greater and greater, just as it did for many years in this city between the Tammany politicians and the public, until finally a point is reached—and it looks very much as if we had reached such a one now—at which nothing short of a ‘clean sweep,” or, in other words, a passionate movement for the rotation of all the rascals out of office at once, is the only resource or hope of good government left. In the failure of Mr. Blaine to hold his own during the | of such solem- | [Number 559 TIE PROGRESS iT) OF THE EXHIBITION, PHILADELPHIA, March 10, 1876. ‘ie REE months ago a visit to the Centennial was easy and pleasant. The buildings were comparatively few in number and easily distinguished, | and the ground was in good condition and unencumbered with building materials. But at the present day the visitor speedily discovers that he has hard work before him. The multiplicity of buildings begins already to be perplexing, the ground is softened by the outcoming frost, cut up here and there with excavations, and dotted with piles of boards, laths, shingles, bricks, and unremoved débris. Fiverything betokens the last travail before the installation of goods. Not that I wish the reader to infer from these remarks that the Centennial is backward and the managers hastening to make up lost time. On the contrary, the work of preparation is far | advanced, and we have the best reasons for expecting the 10th of May to be the opening day in fact as wel) as in form. But, as every one knows, the last stages in making ready a great enterprise always wear the mien of distraction. It is difficult for the inexperienced to detect the real order beneath all this seeming confusion. The very forwardness of the Centen- nial looks like the opposite because there are so many buildings rapidly approaching completion about the same time. Let me run briefly over the principal features cf the Centennial in order. The Main Building is done and awaiting its contents. Some boxes and cases from South America, Sweden, and Norway are already placed in position, but the contents not unpacked. The spaces and sub-spaces for all the exhibits are marked off by red lines on the floor. The Machinery Building was finished long ago, and also spaced off. The shafting is well under way and can be finished easily in four weeks, In the centre the huge Corliss engine (1,500horse-power) which is to supply all the motive-power is rapidly approaching completion. The bed is laid, the upright cylinders erected, and also the two walking-beams. The foundations of other heavy pieces of machinery throughout the building are laid. Back of the Machin- ery Hall is a new structure, 314 feet by 160, with galleries, to be ready on the 15th. This Shoe and Leather Annex is the work of private subscription, and will contain the most complete display ever made of articles of leather. The importance of the department is manifest when we consider that the aggregate annual business is computed at $230,000,000 (of which $90,000,000 belongs to Massachusetts alone). The annex will | contain specimens of every kind of shoe and boot manufactured, every kind present session we see a curious effect of this wide divergence | | The plastering is done, except some ornamental work around the base cf between public opinion and that of the political class. He is a shrewd manager, and as a shrewd manager he has for years been oceupied, not in studying the condition of the country, or considering what quesiions demand solution, or what questions “the people” are thinking about, but in watching the ‘‘machine.” He has mastered it completely.- He can “spar” in the House, he can expose a Democrat, he can force him into a false position, he can make him introduce a bill that he does not want to introduce, and he can prevent him from introducing a bill that he does want to introduce——and this is all. He betrays no signs of thinking or caring for anything else, and acts as if there really were no questions to care for or solve, but as if we were all simply playing a game in which it was agreed that one side should be calle’ Democrats and the other Republicans, and the side that “scored” the most exposures and the most successful parliamentary dodges should win the game and carry off the “ pool.” The differ- ence between him and bis playmate, Morton, is that he plays the game fairly, while Morton cheats. Politicians are merely the gauges of party sentiment and atility, and Mr. Blaine’s failure is simply the failure of the Republican * machine,” or, in other words, the failare to produce men equal to the demands of the time. It is no answer to this to say that the Demoerats are equally incapable. They must be produced, if not by Democrats oar Republicans, then by somebody else, of leather prepared, and every machine used in the country. Horticultural Hall was finished some time ago. There is a little painting to be done inside, and the potting proceeds slowly, as it requires a good deal of care. But in generai I should say that this hall, like the main building, is only awaiting its contents. Agricultural Hall, the most backward of all the large buildings, has made astonishingly rapid strides. The arches are up ; the roofing is laid, except around the central cupola and over a part of one of the wings ; and the greater part of the flooring is down. In all probability the building will be delivered by the contractor at the end of the presenti month. The art building (Memorial Hall) is likewise in the last stages. the rotunda, the wood-work is done, and the tiles in some of the rooms are laid. A delay in the delivery of the tiles from Connecticut has thrown the workmen back a week or more, but, notwithstanding, the building will be in readiness by the beginning of April. One hundred feet in the rear is a detached structure, altogether new—the Art Annex. This annex, which is even larger in superficial area than Memorial Iall, is not of a permanent nature, but intended to contain the overflow, as it is called, of pictures and statues. Even with this extra room at their command, the managers fear that they will be unable to gratify all the demands for space. Being pro- jected suddenly to meet an unexpected want, the annex is of course behindhand. But it is being pushed with great energy, and will doubtless be ready in season. The outer walls are of brick; the framework is wood. In appearance it is rather squat and ungainly, especially if compared with the handsome fagade of Memorial Hail, and will be found, I fear, to be hot in summer weather. However, it will be no worse than the Exposition des Amateurs at Vienne. Near by is the Annex for Wagons and Carriages, also beckward. Piles of lumber and the constant buzz of a circular saw reveal the process of con- struction. It is little more than a temporary frame building, which will not be inelegant when finished, but which at present shows its ribs and joints too plainly. The U. 8. Government Building was completed more than a month ago. The Women’s Pavilion was handed over last week. The Southern Restaurant and the New Jersey State Building are finished. But it will not be necessary for me to enumerate more of the fifty or Suffice it to state that all sixty buildings now seattered over the grounds. ~~ =- -—-— —- & -— oF a ai af mie
Page 7
The the principal ones are now ready, or so nearly ready as to be practically dis- posed of, and that the buildings incomplete or not yet begun are of a kind that admits of very rapid work. The managers will probably issue an order in a few days to the effect that all building material must be deliv- ered and tn situ before the 1st of April. The object of this is to reserve the railroad tracks and roads in the grounds for the conveyance of go is, By the middle of the present month Belmont Avenue, a large public drive Mar 16, 1876} which intersects the grounds, wili be closed to travel, and the enclosure | fence will be completed. From the 1st of April, most probably, the pub- lic will be excluded rigorously from the grounds, and the work of installation begun in earnest. The more I compare the state of things at Vienna with the condition of the Centennial, the more I am convinced that the mana- gers of the present enterprise have it perfectly in hand. In fact, there seems to be but one source from which to apprehend delay, and that is tardiness on the part of exhibitors in forwarding their goods. If manufac- turers could be induced to begin at once the shipment of at least their heavier and bulkier articles, the Director-General and his hard-working associates would, I know, feel much relieved. They would then see their way rid of every shadow of a doubt. Circulars and messages have already been sent out urging haste. I feel it to be only my duty, therefore, to do what little Ican in the cause, and to beg every exhibitor whom these words may reach to ** hurry up.” It may seem inconsistent with the opening remarks of this letter to add that the grounds are already in excellent order.” What I mean is this—that, although the grass and some of the walks are soft under foot, the frost is entirely out, and a fortmght of dry wind will remove all traces of damp- ness. Even now the main walks and drives leave little to be desired, and there is no real discomfort except when one tries to save time by short cuts over the grass. The artificial lake in front of the Machinery Hall has an almost finished look; the masonry is in perfect order, and the ground, hav- ing been highly manured, will soon begin to put forth a bright green. A swan or two on the lake would do away with the appearance of newness. The terrace around the Memorial Hall is in great part graded, and the stone steps leading up to it on the south side are laid. The statues to right and left of the steps are also in position. There is a good deal of work still to be done in this vicinity in the way of sodding, gravelling, laying-out walks, and removing unsightly débris. But assuming the labor of construction to be over by April 1, the six weeks to May 10 will be an ample allow- ance of time for the finishing touches. Around Lauber’s Restaurant, Hor- ticultural Hall, and Agricultural Hall scarcely anything more is required than the removal of some boards and the laying down of a few walks. If the present mild weather continues, the trees and vegetation here will be in a remarkably advanced condition by the opening day. The State Build- ings near the United States Buildings are backward, but, on the other hand, the offices of the English Commission are almost ready for occupancy, and the Japanese have their house and bazaar far under way. In general, it is evident that the builders have been highly favored by the weather, and have worked very steadily, ‘‘ without haste and without rest.” A Department of Public Security, as it may be called, has been organ- ized, and will be placed in charge of Col. Starr as marshal. This depart- ment comprises the police (and detective) force, more immediately under Col. Starr’s supervision ; the fire brigade, under Mr. Atwood Smith ; tele- graphs, under Mr. Phillips ; and medical attendance, under Dr. Pepper. Concerning the Department of Education, which is doubtless of special interest to the readers of the Nation, I may add that the State of Pennsyl- vania will exhibit in a separate building, 100 feet by 100 feet ; Maine, New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Rhode Island, New Jersey, Ohio, Michigan, Indiana, Tlinois, Iowa, Missouri, Kentucky, Tennessee, ang Wisconsin will exhibit in the main building, chiefly in the gallery, 350 feet by 24, which has been laid out in sections of 25 feet. It is also possible that Massachusetts may decide to erect a separate building. It may not be safe or fair to give an opinion of the Centennial in its ensemble at this early day. The next two months will probably develop a great many novel features of beauty and merit, and give the exhibition an air of finish which it does not yet possess Nevertheless, I venture to say this much in advance of the season : The Centennial will not afford any one view so imposing as that of the Rotunda at Vienna from the southern en- tranee. It will not have any one building so unique as the Khedive’s Palace—any one private exhibition so complete and artistically arranged as those of Prince Schwarzenberg and the Duke of Coburg. Neither will there be any one part of the grounds so perfectly attractive as the Mozart Circle and the upper ead of Elizabeth Avenue. Yet the Centennial grounds, as a whole, will probably prove much more picturesque and less wearisore to Nation. | |
1795 the eye and foot, and the buildings will !.e more convenient of access, and will display their contents to better advantace. I take the liberty of calling attention to one point of great practical im- portance. There will not be restaurants enough, I fear, for the large num- bers of visitors confidently expected. On the map of the Vienna Exhibition are laid down eighteen restaurants, without: counting soda-water stands, My impression is that there were three or Some of these restaurants were small, buffets, and lunch-counters. four more, not entered on the map, and some did not have a very profitable business. Others, again (notably the Liesinger Brewery), were larger than any at Philadelphia, and were un- comfortably crowded. The latest plan of the Centennial grounds enumct ates only eight restaurants. These would not have sufliced for the daily at tendance at Vienna. How they are to be made to accommodate the much greater attendance expected here is more than Tecan see. Besides, largest are rather close together in that part of the grounds near Agricultu ral Iall—in other words, remote from the chief centre of attraction. There seems to be a decided necessity for three or four good-sized restaurants, one or two at the eastern end of the Main Building, one at the western end of Machinery Hall, and one near the United States Building. The programme for the opening day has not yet been settled in all its details, but will probably be as follows : The exercises are to be held in the open air and to be short and simple in their nature. There will be an ode by Mr. Bayard Taylor, a cantata by Mr. Sidney Lanier, some other musie, instrumental and vocal, a very brief address of welcome to President Grant, the three In conclusion, a formal tour of inspection When they reach the centre of Machinery The reader cxn judge how and an equally brief response. by the Presilent and suite. Hall the Corliss engine is to be set in motion, far we areahead of Vienna in point of time when I add that the Machinery Hall there was not in running order before June, The time occupied in music and speaking will probably not exceed three-quarters of an hour. Altogether, the exercises will be plain, | might say democratic, and quits unlike the dress-coat and kid-glove affair of Vienna, which was a sort of court-reception. MR. DISRAELI'S SURPRISES. Lonpon, February 22. 1876 \* DISRAELI prepared with some ingenuity a couple of surprises in ‘ the Queen’s Speech, the one to dazzle the Philistines on whose active sympathy he confidently calculates, the other to get himself and his Ad- ministration out of a serious difficulty. The solemn announcement that the Queen deemed the present a fitting opportunity for making a formal addi- tion to her style and titles in respect that the direct government of India had been transferred to the Crown some twenty years ago, has been received with acclamation by all the retired shopkeepers and villa-occupiers in Eng- land, and with regret by everybody else. Any trifle regarding royalty, even an unveracious scrap of news picked up by fashionable prints through the servants’ hall, is read with interest by many well-to-do Englishmen and Englishwomen. <A morsel of gossip about the precedency of the Duchess of Edinburgh, or the domestic doings of the Marquis of Lorne and the Princess Louise, is greedily devoured by these people. This sort of thing delights them and engrosses them more than the gravest piece of political intelligence. No one knows this better than Mr. Disraeli. Whether it be due to the insight of genius or to some obscurer cause, 1 do not know, but it is an undoubted fact that the creator of Mr. and Mrs. Putney Giles has a keener appreciation than most people of what will take with that numeri- cally not insignificant class of Britons to which Mr. Thackeray has assigned the name of Snob. Years ago. when the present Prime Minister of Eng- land was a clerk in a solicitor’s office, he displayed this peculiarity of his He used to come down to his office, the story goes, day after day, genius. He had no turn and sit there listlessly reading Spenser's * Faery Queen.’ for parchment deeds and musty documents, and, but for regard for his family, the héad of the firm would have parted with him before his appren- ticeship was over. But there came a turn in the tide of his fortunes. The firm was called upon to draw up prospectuses for companies, and by good luck it fell to the listless student of the * Faery Queen’ to try his hand on these. He acquitted himseif to perfection. He turned the sentences and threw out the baits to catch the British Philistine of the day with an adroit- ness that charmed and amazed the head of the firm, who, no doubt, good man, was caught himself. And from that day to this, during a full half- century of time, Mr. Disraeli has been drawing prospectuses with an expe- rienced hand, and dazzling Philistines with increased success. Just consider the various incidents with which Mr. Disraeli’s name has been prominently associated during the last five or six years—the coining of the phrase, “‘ Sanitas
Page 8
176 sanitatum omnia sanitas” ; of Malacca” in his address to the ofa‘ bill to put down Messrs. Rothse! addition to the stvle and titl Buckinghamshire electors ; the support Ritualism ” ; the telegram announcing that the formal What are these but so many ** road to India” ; and now the > of the Queen. ld had bought the paragraphs or marks of exclamation in Mr. Disraeli’s political prospectuses ? Analyze these emotional interjections, or analyze the whcle of Mr. Dis- racli’s political life, and you will find it all of a piece—all tinsel, and spangles, Analyze bis novels, and you will find the same in- Ile is well aware that this artificial glitter, when applied to polities, acts upon the half-educated Briton who vegetates in a villa like a The salmon cannot and theatrical effects, gredients. gaudy fly thrown over a sluggish salmon in a pool. resist it, neither can the Briton. with amazement, not unmixed with something like contempt, discussions in Parliament, like that of last Thursday, on the propriety of the Queen ealling herself by this title or by that. The whole proceeding must have an air of unreality, almost of servility, about it in the eyes of your hard- headed, practical people. When the paragraph in the Queen’s Speech upon The Nation. | Sensible people in America must read | the subject was read in solemn silence at one of the official dinners the | night before Parliament opened, whether at the Duke of Richmona’s or at Lord Granville’s Ido not know, a young peer was overheard to say in a loud whisper ** Queen of England and Begum of India,” amid the inextin- guishable laughter of the assembled magnates. That light-hearted sally represents, not unfairly, the feeling of the majority of sensible people whom you meet. Mr. Disraeli, they say, having created three dukes, which is one more than any other prime minister ever managed, is insatiable. He now wishes to create an empress before he dies, and accordingly has taken the opportunity of making royalty ridiculous. The matter was un- consciously brought to its proper proportions in the discussion when Sir | George Campbell suggested that the Queen should be regarded as the Great Mogul, and the Iridian princes as the Great Maccallum. an error has been made in mooting the point at all, an error in taste which it is difficult to put right. for the certainty that the private feelings of a lady whom we all, as loyal subjects, love and respect must be hurt by the proceedings. But it is, to say the least of it, unfortunate that the Prime Minister should have been People feel that | | cies. The whole thing would be too silly if it were not | induced to initiate a discussion in which the name and dignities of | the Queen could be held up to ridicule, both in the House of Com- mons and in the press—unintended ridicule, I do not doubt, but none the less anpleasing. And this manceuvre of the Prime Minister's is the more distasteful at the present time when we have, within a few days’ sail of us, one of the greatest nations in the world glorying in its untitled grandeur ; when our gigantic dependencies are flourishing without a shadow of these unmeaning formalities ; and when, across the Channel, that nation which has identified imperialism with suppression of liberty, with profligate pub- lie expenditure, and with bloody and unsuccessful war, is struggling to | emancipate itself from the dead weight of sham splendor which an empire imposed upon it. We all love our Queen. We respect our Queen’s hereditary | titles, which are associated with most that is great in British history, and | we desire that these titles should be respected by foreign powers and foreign peoples ; but we do not desire that she should add to these titles for no pos- sible object but to gratify a whim, or please the vanity of one whom, with all his ability, we can never regard as a true-born Englishman. The second surprise which Mr. Disraeli prepared for us was the an- | nouncement that a Royal Commission was to be issued to enquire into mat- ters of international law on the question of slavery, which one would have supposed ought to have been within the cognizance of the Government of the day. I have hitherto refrained from mentioning those unfortunate | certain want of reality in all our political manifestations. slave cireulars in my letters, because I have found myself at variance with most people about them. The motives which prompted the issue of some kind of instructions for the guidance of naval officers in the territorial waters of slaveholding states are intelligible enough. It is out of the ques- tion to suppose that British ships-of-war are to lie in friendly ports and act the part of cities of refuge for the reception of any natives who disapprove of the law of the land in which they unfortunately live. With all our na- tional anxiety to set all men free, we have found ourselves compelled to bear with the institution of domestic slavery in certain states with which we have entered into treaty. How can we, with one hand, sign a treaty recognizing this institution, and with the other provide the means for ships as slave-escapes? This country The constituencies here got its destruction, and employ our - } view of th» matter. accepting slavery, and giving up the battle different has taken a it into their heads that we ar for which many good men at the end of the last and at the beginning Agitators and popularity-hynting mem- of this century struggle l nobly. “to these circulars cannot be too strongly censured. | Number 559 the Bath letter ; the reference to tlhe ** Straits | bers of Parliament and well-meaning philanthropists have fanned the popu- lar excitement on the subject, and the Government have pusillanimously thrown over their law-officers and their under-secretaries and fled before They learned that the borough members who sit on their side of the House were alarmed, and were unable to give them their the public wrath. wonted support ; and hence the appointment of this Commission, which will give the Government an avenue of escape. Punch—which, by the way, has of late been singularly happy in its political eartoons—has neatly delineated the situation. Mr. Disraeli appears as a mountebank con- jurer—not the first time he has been represented as a mountebank—doing the ** Extinguisher Trick.” ‘+ Here,” he observes, ‘‘ you perceive ‘ Fugitive Slave Circular’ number two, number one having disappeared already. [ now take this cone into my hand. It resembles an extinguisher, and is called a ‘ Royal Commission.’ I place it over the ‘ Cireular,’ and—hey, presto !—on raising it again ‘ Circular’ number two will have disappeared.” Can you imagine Mr. Gladstone, or that fine old Englishman, Lord Palm- erston, whose last twenty years of political life have just been published, acting the craven in this manner? I cannot, and I do not know the man who can. But be that as it may, the appointment of the Commission will stave off immediate disaster. The members have been named, and they are undoubtedly well selected. Their report will be looked for with much in- terest, especially by those who are out cf harmony with the popular feeling But the vacillating conduct of the Government in regard Mr. Whitbread, the member for Bedford, and a man of great weight with the Liberal pariy, lias given notice of something very like a vote of censure, which comes on for discussion to-morrow night, and will lead to a protracted debate of several ” on the subject. days. There will be some hard hitting on both sides and some powerful speaking. There will also be a good deal both of cant and rant. The Govern- ment will ride off on the Commission, and win a House-of-Commons victory with the half of their majority. But the debate will tell in the constituen- It will not be difficult to show that the Government acted carelessly or ignorantly in issuing the first Circular ; calpably in issuing the second, when their attention had been emphatically directed to the feeling of the country, to which they have now succumbed ; and pusillanimously in shrinking from their own action, and shirking responsibility when they found that their supporters were as timid as themselves. So much for Mr. Disraeli’s two ‘‘ surprises.” Perhaps it would have been better for the sta- bility of his Administration if he had satisfied his soul with commonplace. THE FRENCH REPUBLIC BEGUN. Parts, February 25, 1876. "OU must not expect me to speak to-day of Dumas’s new play, ‘* L’Etran- gére,” or of the rew American drama called the ‘‘ Chevaliers de la patrie,” in which I saw an Abraham Lincoln very differeut from the Lincoln whom I had seen in Washington. The new elections are the all- absorbing topic, and their importance for the future of France is such that it is impossible to think long of anything else. Last night, while the various tableaux of the new American drama were unfolded before me, while I heard the pompous speeches of Abraham Lin- coln receiving his visitors, I could not help thinking that the American Republic was as different from our new Republic as this actor Lincoln from the actual Lincoln. The actor may be some day a member of a ‘* Comité central de la Commune,” as many of his comrades were in 1871 ; he would only continue to play on another stage. There always seems to me to be a During the two weeks which preceded the elections in Paris there were all sorts of public theetings. ‘The men who appeared in them, were they not actors ? Their bombastic eloquence did not seem to cover any deep feelings. You saw everywhere the same actors and the same people who wanted a little excite- ment and amusement. There was no platform to explain or to defend ; all the candidates were republican, and the Republic has not yet lived long enough that there should be two parties equally ready to govern but with different and definite views. The last Assembly voted a republican con- stitution ; it could hardly be discussed now in its details—the revision of the constitution can only take place after a certain time. There was, there- fore, hardly anything to taik about, yet such a flood of turbid eloquence never rolled over the capital. In order to stir their audience, the popular orators had no need of promoting views of administration and of govern- ment ; they all struck the same chord—the amnesty chord. The people whom they addressed were the very men who had cheered the Commune in i871, and who, if they did not fight om the ramparts at Neuilly, received the pay of fédérés during the whole reign of the Commune, Amnesty in
Page 9
The their eyes is not an act of generosity and of pardon, it is the glorification of the Commune. be applauded if he only abused the Versailles Assemblv. It was always easy for a speaker at these public meetings to Though the As- sembly founded the Republic, it was always called clerical, reactionary, etc.; the real reason of its unpopularity lies in the fact that the \ Assembly vanquished the Commune. ersailles This is also the real danger for Marshal MacMahon ; he is now receiving the official marks of respect of those who must bow before the President of the Republic. But he is the man who reorganized the poor prisoners coming from Germany, who formed them into regiments again, who would not lend himself to the timid counsels of the men of the 4th of September, who | re-entered Paris by force, and crushed the Commune with his strong hand. Can he like this word amnesty ? He lost eight thousand of his) men— good, honest French soldiers—in the long siege of Paris. Will they be amnestied ? L was always of opinion that too much severity was exercised towards the foolish and ignorant in- struments of the Commune, and too much leniency shown to the wicked men who were its chiefs and instigators. I can quite conceive that the Minister of the Navy, who has supreme authority over New Caledonia, should pardon as many unfortunate insurgents as possible ; but individual eases of pardon are not what Victor Hugo, ‘what our Radicals ask for. They want a general amnesty, an unconditional surrender of the Gevern- ment and of MacMahon before the survivors of the Commune ; they want Rochefort to be seen in Paris and to carry his Lanferne on the boulevards. Under this word amnesty lies a very deep question, which is only one of the formulas of the problem of the day. Will the Republic be conservative, or will it be radical, socialistic, communistic ? The problem is all the more formidable inasmuch as these words are themselves vague and elastic. Every man is always a radical for one anda moderate for another. What is going on beneath this war of words is a dangerous war of instincts—what Mr. Darwin would call the struggle for life. It is the eternal war of the Revolu- tion against the past. It seemed as if there was nothing more in France for the Revolution to destroy. It has destroyed the traditional monarchy ; it has destroyed the old aristocracy ; it has destroyed the influence of the ehurch ; it has destroyed, by the articles of the Civil Code, and sometimes by confiscation, the ‘‘ grande propri¢té ” ; it has established the most abso- Will the hostages be amnestied ? Nation. . . . . q lute equality that the world ever saw anywhere ; it has, finally, given the political power to direct universal suffrage ; but it seems as if all this was not enough. The fields of the country are cut up and divided in every generation ; but there are still large fields and small fields. The socialistic ideas which have long pervaded the towns have, it seems, made some headway in the rural districts. Some of the men who made this last electoral campaign tell me that it is surprising to find what the one-sou papers have done in the country. They have been astonished to find that the poorest servants on the farms now take an interest in politics ; the peasant who has increased his small piece of land with borrowed money is jealous of the peasant who owns a few more hectares. My friends tell me that there is much jealousy in the smallest village between those who have more land and those who have less ; and that by some natural instinct of mankind all the malcon- tents vote the Republican ticket. Now, if this be so, it will be always, and even under the most favorable circumstances, very difficult for a republican leader to form and constitute a conservative party. If adhesion to the Republican party has ever been the outward expression of discontent, disappointment, and envy, so soon as the Republican party shall be thought to have a quiet tenure of power the mal- contents will be ready to give earto some new tempter. And the danger of the future lies in the fact that this tempter exists. There is a party which professes as much love as even the Republicans do for the people, for uni- versal suffrage ; which professes contempt for the so-called privileged classes, for the old nobility, for the egotistical bourgeoisie : it is the Bonapartist party. The Bonapartist deputies will in the Senate as well as in the Lower Chamber assume the position which was held in the National Assembly by the Right ; and they will besides speak as the friends of the people, the re- presentatives of the democracy. Their minority will be the focus of the Conservative party. This result is much to be regretted, for the Bona- partists have so far found no favor at all with Marshal MacMahon. He said to one of the Bonapartist leaders some time ago : ‘* You reproach me with “my indifference to your cause, but | know only my duty. I am mounting guard for order. All the traditions of my family, all my own personal in- clinations, drew me towards the cause of the legitimate monarchy. , at the very moment when the cause of the Comte de Chambord seemed on the point of triumphing, when the legitimate king had but one werd to say to be proclaimed the sovereign of this country. I remained perfectly quiet a There are still some poor among us, and still some rich. Still nad neutral. I did not discomage, but I did not encourage, the fusion. IT did nothing for the Comte de Chambord. How ean you expect me to de ‘ thing for the Prince Imperial ? Can I forget Sedan, if everybo should ?” Marshal MacMahon may not be a brilliant political genius, but he is an honest and patriotic man. What will he do if he finds himself unable to } stop the tide of demagogy ; if all the conservative laws passed by the late Assembly are repealed ; if amnesty is proclaimed ? Atthe present moment he is perfectly wiiling to try the Moderate Republicans and to give them fair It M. Buffet, history will judge more leniently than the irat which a chance. was the last advice given him by whom combined against him. M. Buffet, if L am wel) informed, said to him: **Go as far Left as you can conscientiously do ; IT am done for ; | have n parties t be en under- stood ; call the men who have represented me in the eves of the people as ive ahd to the enemy of the constitution which I was the first to orga protect, and tell them to govern after their own fashion. If they ean find a majority in the Chambers, if they can make a respectable government, | shall be happier than anybody, and from my retirement L will send them my best wishes.” The Marshal has appointed M. Dufaure to take the pla AY UU } of M. Buffet, and the administration of M. Dufaure will soon be at work lt is said that Gambetta meant at first to support it : he say venly in his paper that he has no intention of upsetting Marshal MacMahon He may be himself now in a moderate mood, and half afraid of bis own triump! but will he be capable of enforcing a moderate policy on his own party will he be able to satisfy the rancor of M. Thiers, who wishes before dies to take his revenge for the 24th of May ? Time will soon answer these questions. One thing is certain: the fair trial of the true Republic has now begun, and it will be for the Repubhiean to show that thev are capable of conducting the affairs of the country They will find no obstacle in the Legitimist party—the Logitimists are now t of the field ; nor in the Orleanists—they have taken refuge in silence ot have swollen the ranks of the Constitutional party. Their only open eng mies will be the Bonapartists ; and universal suffrage, which has always been the hope of the Bonapartes, has just loudly proclaimed its verdict against them. Whatever may be said of the government which France has had during the past two years, it must be admitted th which was Jately personified in M. Buffet, has increased the prosperi ‘yan has revived, and her the country and maintained material order. | finances have never been so prosperous. The army has been reorganized with a wonderful activity, and would now be much readier for new struggles than it was in 1870. It can also be said that liberty ha 1 the whole, been respected ; the lite elections were as free as any elections which ever took place in France. The state of siege had, to be sure, been maintained since the Commune in Paris, Lyons, and Marseilles, but the press was completely free, and the triumph of the Radicals in these great towns shows that they have been crushed nowhere and that they have been left xt liberty to keep up a pacific agitation. C sist |] npRAa JOYVeSpOnadence. CAN NOTHING BE DONE ? To tHe Eprror or THe Nation : Sm: The recent scandals at Washington are deplorable enough, but they will be still more deplorable if their only result proves to be the revival of the prospects of Democratic success, justly forfeited by the admitted in- competency, in Congress and elsewhere, of that party under its present leadership. For several years each party has based its claims to power not on its en- deavors to deserve public confidence, but on its ‘s to prove that its antagonist is more dangerous than itself, and popular majorities have fluc- tuated not from conviction of the merits of the organization, but from well-founded dread of the other voter has felt that he had but which seemed at the moment to be the least. Sho 1¢ temporarily successful very e has chosen the one intelligent a choice of evils, and | hould quires no prophet to foretell the result in the near future. this continue, it re- The average voter is rapidly becoming independent to a degree unex- ampled in the experience of the present generation, and the demand for I I purity of administration is taking in his mind the place of the ordinary par- ts-—to be followed flagrant —will intensify this demand enormously, and will present an opportanity which it would be insane to throw The no doubt by others equally tisan war-cries. Sabeock and Belknap developmen Away.
Page 10
The gravest public question of the moment is, What use will be made of it ? The fiasco of the Cincinnati Convention showed sufficiently, I think, the futility of an effort to construct a third party. At the same time, to do no- thing is to invite the Democracy to offer some old * war-horse” for the sulfrage of the disgusted Republican. Cannot, however, some movement be started to organize the independent voters of both parties into a body strong enough to turn the scale either way, which shall say emphaticaliy to the Republican and Democratic managers alike that the only prospect of success lies in presenting candidates worthy of confidence ? I throw this out as a suggestion of what seems to me the only mode of binging to bear decisively the healthy public opinion which unquestionably exisis at present. Both parties just now would respect such a movement, and would exert themselves to secure its support or to avert its opposition. Very respectfully, Henry C, Lea. PHiLADSLPHIA, March 6, 1876 RESIGNATION AND IMPEACHMENT. To tue Eprror or Tur Nation: Sin: The Constitution of the United States provides in article 1 tion 2, clause 5, that the House of Representatives ‘shall have the sole power of impeachment,” and in section 3 as follows : , see- ‘6. The Senate shall have the sole power to try all impeachments. When sitting for that purpose, they shall be on oath or affirmation. When the President of the United States is tried, the Chief-Justice shall preside. And no person shall be convicted without the concurrence of two-thirds of the members present. ** 7. Judgment in cases of impeachment shall not extend farther than to removal from oflice, and disqualification to hold and enjoy any office of honor, trust, or- profit under the United States ; but the party convicted shall nevertheless be liable and subject to indictment, trial, judgment, and punishment according to law.” And the Constitution contains in article 2, section 4, this additional pro- vision : 7 ‘“‘The President, Vice-President, and all civil officers of the United States shall be removed from office on impeachment for, and conviction of, treason, bribery, or other high crimes om misdemeanors.” Before and at the time of the convention that framed the Constitution, an impeachment before the Lords by the Commons, in Great Britain, in Parliament, was a prosecution of known and established law, and had been frequently put in practice against persons who had ceased to hold office. Before and during all the time that convention was sitting the prosecution was pending against Warren Hastings, although he had resigned his office. His resignation was in February, 1785. In the House of Commons, on the 4th of April, 1786, charges were exhibited against him. The resignation of his office did not prevent the House of Commons from impeaching him, nor prevent the House of Lords from trying the issue of guilty or not guilty. When Mr. Justice Story, in his commentaries on the Constitution, alluded to that case in Vol. IL, sec. 795, he had not seen how it was mentioned in the convention, those commentaries having been published several vears before the publication of the Madison, papers. These papers show that on the 8th of September, 1787, when the con- vention had before it the clause providing for the President’s removal from oflice on impeachment and conviction of treason and bribery, Col. Mason said ; ‘Why is the provision restrained to treason and bribery only ? Treason as defined in the Constitution will not reach many great and dangerous offences. Llastings is not guilty of treason ” (Elliot’s ‘ Madison Papers,” p. 528) This reference to the case of Hastings being followed by an amendment embracing ‘‘other high crimes and misdemeanors” (besides treason and bribery). it is difficult to suppose that with that case present to their minds, and made the grounds of action, the framers of the Constitution intended that a civil officer of the United States should by resigning his office take away from one house the power to impeach, or from the other house the power to try impeachments, when-the resignation of Hastings had no such effect. Such a supposition is the more difficult in view of the fact that those framers introduced safeguards and limitations when they saw occasion for them—safegrunrds prescribing that when the Senate sit for the purpose, they shall be on oath or affirmation, that when the President is tried, the Chief-Justice shall preside, and that there shall be no conviction without the concurrence of two-thirds of the members present ; and upon the judg- ment this important (imitation, that it ‘‘ shall not extend farther than to 178 The Nation. {Number 559 removal from office, and disqualification to hold and enjoy any office of honor, trust, or profit under the United States.” Though resignation of office should be regarded as attaining all that could be attained by a judgment of ‘removal from office,” yet it does not attain all that could be attained by a judgment of ** disqualification to hold and enjoy any office of honor, trust, or profit under the United States.” Though the party is ‘‘.iable and subject to indictment, trial, judgment, and punishment according to law,” yet the effect of such indictment and proceedings therein might be less than the effect of judgment in case of impeachment : the President has ‘‘ power to grant reprieves and pardons for offences against the United States, except in cases of impeachment.” C. R. March 7, 1876. S. BARNES & CO. have assumed the publication, by subscription * only, of Mrs. Martha J. Lamb’s new ‘History of the City of New York,’ in 2 vols.——James Miller will republish in this country ‘ Letters from Elizabeth Barrett Browning and the Author of ‘Orion’,’ with recol- lections of contemporaries, by R. H. Horne. ——J. B. Lippincott & Co. have in press ‘Elementary Physical Geography’ and ‘Elementary Astronomy,’ by Richard A. Proctor ; and ‘ America Discovered by the Welsh, in 1170 A.D.,” by Rev. Benj. F. Bowen.——F. B. Patterson, 32 Cedar Street, will shortly publish *‘ How to Steady our Dollar,’ by Dr. James C, Hallock, jr. —— Following the example of J/arper’s, with its fifty-volume index. we are promised a ten-volume index of Seribner’s by the publishers of the latter magazine. ‘A History of my Life and Times,’ by the veteran George Cruikshank, is announced as in preparation, and will be eagerly looked for on both sides of the Atlantic. Geo. P. Rowell & Co., the well-known ac- vertising agents, have undertaken to ensure ‘‘a full and complete exhibi- tion of American newspapers” at the Centennial, at an estimated cost of $20,000 for the building and its equipment, salaries, and a catalogue of 300 pages in solid nonpareil type, which will serve both as a directory to the various files, and as a gazetteer, showing the importance of our towns and cities as gauged by the newspapers they sustain. The enterprise is as praiseworthy as it is bold, and will rank among the greatest novelties of this or any international exposition.——The lately published ‘ Proceedings of the American Antiquarian Society’ at its annual meeting last October is made valuable by Dr. Charles Deane’s account of the fortunate filling of a lacuna in the ‘ Records of the Council for New England’ (June 28, 29, 1623), and by what we may call a memorandum on the criminal laws of Massachusetts, by Judge Aldrich. The aim of the latter paper is to show the amelioration of the penal code of the State, and to defend the present time against charges of unprecedented corruption anc of a growing insecurity of life and property. This is so ably sketched that one is led to hope the author may find time to elaborate the subject ——Still another summer school is open to the student naturalist—a school of biology at the Peabody Academy, Salem, Mass. ‘ Especial attention will ke given to ‘arine botany and zodlogy, as the advantages for dredging and shore collecting are most excellent.” Only fifteen students can be admitted. Dr. A. S, Pack- ard, jr., editor of the American Natural’st, will direct the school, and in particular the zodlogical instruction ——The Rev. Isaac Taylor’s paper on the Etruscan Language has been reprinted from the Transactions of the Philosophical Society of Great Britain. Now that Corssen is generally acknowledged to have broken down with his Aryan hypothesis, Mr. Taylor speaks with the authority of a presumed “fittest survivor.” Perhaps his argument savors something too much of authority and dogmatic assertion, but it is very ingenious, and one at least of his wood-cut illustrations—that of a Samoyed-like Etruscan warrior—lends weighty support to his view.—— With the new year began the eleventh series (Heft 241) of Virchow and Holtzendorff’s ‘Sammlung gemeinverstiindlicher wissenschaftlicher Vor- triige,’ and the fifth of Holtzendorff and Oncken’s ‘ Deutsche Zeit- und Streit- Fragen’ (Berlin : Carl Habel). These two publications are among the most remarkable of the day. We have frequently had occasion to call attention to them, and we wish we could think that like selections from the best cur- rent writing—political, literary, and scientific—of our own country would: find a popular acceptance, No heulthier or less repulsive form of tract could be devised. —It is announced that examinations for admission to Harvard College will hereafter be held in Cincinnati simultaneously with those in Cam ridge. The advantage which this will give the college in attracting studen‘s, and
Page 11
Mar. ‘6. 1876 The the great economy and convenience of it for candidates living west of the Alleghanies, are patent. But it will be perceived, we think, on reflection, that the proposed step has a much wider importance than a mere move in the competition of our colleges. Not only will Harvard, for example, become and be felt as a near instead of a distant rival of Oberlin and Antioch, but her examinations (which are published, together with the number of rejected as well as of successful applicants) will contra-t with theirs in a manner which will inevitably set either their officers or the public, and probably both, to thinking. We apprehend, however, that these and other Western colleges will not be the first institutions affected by the inno- vation. A great and rather sudden change for the better may be looked for among the preparatory classical schools, of whatever name ; and what has been observed in Michigan in this respect under the influence of the Uni- versity at Ann Arbor, is certain to come about over a much wider area when a still higher standard is set up by Harvard. Parents will insist that their sons be fitted to pass her examinations, and the test of a good school or a good teacher will shortly be the percentage of pupils who do so pass. That the colleges will long lag behind the academies we do not think likely, and the level of education and scholarship throughout the West wiil thus be raised—insensibly it may be, but surely—by the simple attendance once or | twice a year at Cincinnati of Harvard’s examiners. —If any one is sceptical of the results we have foreshadowed, we com- mend to him the perusal of a little pamphlet on ‘The Influence of the Older English Universities on National Education,’ by the Hon. George C. Brodrick, Fellow of Merton College, Oxford. read before the Social Science Congress at Brighton, last October. The author begins by offering some statistics to show that Matthew Arnold was in error when in 1868 he alleged that in England there was ‘* but one ma- triculated student for every 5,800 of population,” against one for every 2,600 in all Germany, while ‘* Prussia alone numbered 6,362 students in its eight universities.” Mr. Brodrick increases the ratio for England and Wales to 1 : 4500, exclusive of the students of academical age of theological naval and military, engineering, and other colleges. He proceeds to argue that the practical influence of the older universities is not to be measured merely by the number of their students. Even when their number ** was much smaller than it is at present, Oxford and Cambridge virtually governed the whole course of higher education throughout England. . . . Every school of reputation professed, above all, to prepare boys for the Universi- ties, and, notwithstanding that only a small minority of boys actually pro- ceeded thither, the instruction of all the rest was limited and fettered by University requirements "—a remark which has an obvious bearing on the probable working of Harvard’s examinations at the West. Now that the Universities have begun to broaden their curriculum and have undertaken ‘* the office of Examining Boards on a very large scale, they have strength- ened to an extraordinary degree their former hold on secondary education. . .. It is not too much to say that by forming this widespread network of examinations and occupying the centre of it, the Universities of Oxford and Cambridge have virtually made themselves arbiters of learning over the great mass of schools above the elementary grade, and assumed some of the most important functions exercised by the Ministry of Education in other countries.” Mr. Brodrick further points out that the Universities supply the leading public schools with trained masters; that ‘the great body of clergymen and of barristers, all the bishops, and nearly two-thirds of the judges, are alumni of English or Irish universities.” Even more than in this country, and ex-officio, the clergy educated at the Universities ‘‘ are the sole representatives of learning in most country parishes,” and manage the great majority of parochial schools not under school boards. The Education Office is almost wholly manned from Oxford and Cam- bridge ; ‘‘ out of 123 school-inspectors for Great Britain, all but two or three are university men.” They predominate on the staff of the Civil- Service Commission, and in the ‘‘ whole administrative and political ser- vice of the state we find graduates of the older Universities filling high positions in a ratio out of all proportion to their numbers.” More than a third of the present House of Commons were educated at Oxford and Cam- bridge alone, as were ten out of Mr. Gladstone's original Cabinet of fifteen, and are ten out of Mr. Disracli’s twelve—he being the only minister who has not received a university education. What the press owes to Oxford and Cambridge men for its characteristics may be guessed but cannot be exactly determined. —Mr. Brodrick next considers the nature and tendency of the influence of the Universities on national education. ‘‘ So long,” he says, ** as Oxford and Cambridge were treated as clerical seminaries rather than as national seats of learning and education, it was not to be expected that any kind of attain- It is a reprint of a paper | Nation. 17) ment would be effectively encouraged within them except such as might conduee to success in the clerical profession.” Consequently, as the schools the country was dwarfed and stunted by the dogmatic immobility of instita- followed the lead of the Universities, ‘* the whole educational growth of tions which ought to have been foremost in every advance of knowledge The spell of ecclesiastical ascendency has, within the present generation, been markedly weakened, but there is yet a ** want of what the Germans call freedom in learning and freedom in teaching.” ** Students "—tl reads like an extract from one of President Eliot's reports—** might be left at liberty to pursue a special line of study from their first entrance to the University, and yet be subjected to as much control, both intellectual and moral, as may be thought desirable without foreing their various tastes and abilities into conformity with any Procrustean model. In a word there may be a common basis of university training with an inexhaustible variety of university teaching ; a certain family likeness and freemasonry amony university men, with the greatest possible individuality of thought We are again reminded of Harvard that without effective extrance examination to exclude those who have not mastered even the rudiments of a liberal education, and to defeat of bad schoolmasters with bad college tutors, neither University can discharge its proper functions.” We can do no more than allude to Mr. Brodrick’s plan of enhancing the influence of the older Universities ** by affiliating existing local institutions, by founding local University Colleges, or by otherwise colonizing the provinces from Oxford and Cambridge.” His views are not without interest and instruction for us, but their application is still remote, and multiplicity of accomplishments.” when we read: ** It is admitted on all hands an the « onspiracy rather *—Anything is of general interest that casts light on the way of working of so famous a scholar and critic as Max Mfiller ; and this is especially t] case at the present time, when his threat to abandon England and move back his ‘* German workshop ” to its native soil is drawing out the renewed and heightened adulation of the English press. A recent incident, now, Miller has r to the great Sanskrit lexicon, completed last year, the charge that they are ** mutual-admiration society.” illustrates in a rather striking manner his eritical method peatedly made and urged against the ‘editors and « intributors ” In order probably to help correct the ev'l effects of their mutual flattery, he breaks out, in the preface to his last ‘ Rig- Veda’ terms volume, with the following reproach : ** Why are not such technical as gitin, strahkampin, ete., given in the Petersburg Di tionary To this the editors reply, in their concluding preface : ‘*In our dictionary a great deal is wanting, but these particular words are not wanting. They are in their proper place, properly explained, and each referred to the only known place of its occurrence. We might therefore ask on our part, How can any one find fault so wantonly ?” In a late number of the Academy (February 12) Miller explains himself, and sive editors with confusion London vers the unsubmis- ‘“netty made. Ile is sure that, if they had only studied carefully his eriticism, they would have seen that nothing was farther from his thotghts than to intimate that gifin and sirakkampin were not to be found in their work. All the point of his ob- jection lay in the * ete.,” which was intended to inculcate three things—1, Ife styles their answer a remark,” which they will hereafter sorely regret having That certain other compounds oceurring in the same treatise with the words mentioned ought, **though everybody would understand their general meaning,” to be noted in any future possible editionfof the lexicon ; 2, That such words ought to be given more distinctly the aspect of technical terms ; and, 3, That they ought to be invariably referred to the treatise in which they orizinally occur, instead of in part to an intermediate source. a wonderful abbreviation, this ** ete.” ! Truly There are few living writers who can use the English language with such pregnant significance. Perhaps there is nothing in universal literature to be compared to it, except the Hindu awn, in the three letters of which the devout whole of divine truth to be wrapped up. Brahman believes the Only, to avoid such misapprehen- sions as this of which the editors of the lexicon have been guilty, Miiller should, like sor ritative comment, pointing out that when he seems to say one thing he really ne of the Hindu authors, accompany his text with an autho- means several other and very different things. —A recent work on the ‘ Genuineness of the Moabite Antiquities,’ by Pro- fessors Kautzsch and Socin, of Base], has moved a writer in the Afhenmui of Feb, 26 to commiserate to the length of a column and more the simpli- city of the unfortunate individuals and government who have been duped by +} > vese ‘‘ antiquities,” and especially of the two writers named. He would speak unkindly of their work, but at the same time he has “‘ rarely met with so remarkable an instance of misapplied labor.” The pity he bestows upon not
Page 12
180 The them is somewhit misplacel. The work in question is not a defence but a most overwhelming attack, which seems likely to give the finishing stroke to a reputation which was always poor. The writers have thoroughly sifted—with needless thoroughness, many will think— Prof. Socin the external evidence, the circumstances, of the alleged dis- covery; and Prof. Kautzsch the internal evidence, arising from the sup- posed religious use, the paleographie and archeological character, of these ‘‘abominations of Moab,” as they have been termed (see also Ps, lx. 8). The conelusion at which they arrive amounts to this : on the one hand the external evidence is so suspicious that only the most undoubted internal on the other, their internal character is so bad that even the best of external evidence would hardly suffice to proofs of genuineness can save them ; prove them innocent. Their case, we fear, must be given over. Prof. Kautzsch has had the rare fortune to gain admission to the collection which is so closely and sacredly guarded in Berlin. first ‘* unbeliever” to whom it has been opened. We suspect he is the It is possible that the writer in the Atheneum read the book, as papers are sometimes read before and barely that, for the full title, ‘ Die Achtheit der moabitischen Alterthiimer geprift,’ should have put him on his guard. It is more than likely that his slender knowledge of German learned societies, +? iy title,” led him to translate gepriift ** proved.” Ile is now doubtless receiving back in contributions from his friends the pity he so foolishly squandered on Professors Kautzsch and Socin, who “ have evidently no acquaintance with even the rudiments of archwology.’ —The supplementary catalogue of the great Berlin circulating library Nation. has just been issued, and, taken together with the last complete catalogue | (published in 1874), affords curious statistics in more than one branch of literature. We have found it especially curious as a list of the relative faine and worth of American authors. ‘To appreciate the value of the test, it must be borne in mind that in Germany libraries for the general public do not exist, and that circulating libraries are very few and are the better patronized on that account. The catalogue is divided into the de- partments of *‘ Belletristik” and ‘* Wissenschaftliche Werke,” and pro- fesses to embrace ‘‘die neuesten Erscheinungen und das Beste aus allen Zweigen der Literatur.” The following is the American contingent in Belles-lettres : T. B. Aldrich, two works ; H. W. Beecher, one (‘ Norwood’); Emerson Bennett, five ; Brockden Brown, two ; Alice Cary, one ; Sylvanus Cobb, two; J. Esten Cooke, three ; Cooper, thirty-one ; Miss Cummins, four ; Emerson, one (‘Die Fiihrung des Lebens’); ‘‘ Fanny Fern,” one ; Bret Harte, three; Hawthorne, two (‘ Blithedale,’ ‘Das Sieben Giebel- Haus’ [sie]) ; Holmes, one (* Elsie Venner’) ; Longfellow, three ; Irving, one ; Poe, two ; Miss Sedgwick, one ; Mrs. Southworth, twelve (51 vols.) ; Mrs. A. 8. Stephens, eight (26 vols.); Mrs. Stowe, five; Bayard Taylor, two (*‘ Hannah Thurston,’ ‘ Kennett’); Miss Warner, eight ; N. P. Willis, one (* Komische Geschichten’) ; Theodore Winthrop, one. As representing all other branches of literature, we encounter: Bancroft, three volumes of his history ; Samuel Bowles, one ; J. Ross Browne, one ; H. C. Carey, one; J. W. Draper, two; Irving, two (‘ Granada’ and ‘ Washington’); Dr. Kane, one ; Prescott, one ; Bayard Taylor, two. The library does not include works on natural science, but one wonders whether as regards the rest of our literature the German public is fulfilling the office of posterity. And again, are we to suppose that the German writers now so popular with the American public—the Marlitts and Werners and Ilillerns, are held in the same estimation at home as the Cobbs and Southworths and Stephenses are here ? —Having recently spoken somewhat slightingly of the first two volumes of Reinwald’s ‘ Bibliothéque des Sciences Contemporaines,’ it is proper not to be silent when a volume appears which merits commendation. Such a one is the ‘ Anthropologie’ of Dr. P. Topinard, which forms the third of the series (New York: F. W. Christern). The natural history of man from the physical point of view has made such immense strides in the last few vears, and in ene way or another its garbled results have become | matters of such popular allusion (if not comprehension), that a compendium which shall accurately present the zodlogical, ethnological, and archwologi- eal facts and results, but which shall at the same time not be unwieldy, We think M. Topinard’s duodecimo fills this lacuna very well. All the important matters seem to be there, will prove a true public benefaction. ed so concisely, and at the same time so conscientiously, that we are i reminded of a piece of German labor. Any one who reads this book will be able to see the bearings of nearly any special. investigation on the subjeci. It is pleasant to notice how already in France the lessons of the war are beginning to show themselves in the intellectual field. Ther L distinetly new tendency to stick to matter and facts in | Number 558 scientific writing, even if general phrases have to suffer. Even the bugbear of appearing pedantic has lost its horrors, and we see polyglot bibliographic references starting up on every side in French writings which a few years ago would have scandalized the worshippers of classic form, preferred, even if they remembered perfectly, to say, ‘‘ Je ne Of course this is, considering all the cireum- who always sais quel auteur a dit,” ete. stances, an exceedingly healthy tendency, and one which we can cheer on its way with a good conscience ; for we need not fear that in France it will ever run to pernicious extremes, as in some respects it has done across the Rhine. SIDGWICK’S METHODS OF ETHICS.* ll. \ R. SIDGWICK’S ‘system ” (to use aterm he probably will repudiate) ‘ consists in maintaining that the utilitarian doctrine that it is reason- able to pursue as an end the greatest happiness of mankind, is in effect equivalent to the fundamental moral axioms propounded as_ intuitive truths by Clarke and Kant. The subtlety and skill with which this result is worked out and the utilitarian dogma is, so to speak, shifted on to an intuitional basis, can be appreciated only by those who have studied Mr. Sidgwick’s work. It is apparent, however, at a glance that the position he occupies has some great advantages. It enables him to do ample justice to the strongest and practically the most important of the doctrines of Ben- thamism, viz., that the tendency to produce happiness is the test of virtuous action. The amount of cumulative proof which can be produced in favor of this dogma, and the invalidity of the apparent objections to it, are ex- hibited by Mr. Sidgwick with a fulness and force which may more than satisfy the wishes of ardent utilitarians. Its importance consists in its leading to the result that when moral sentiments conflict, as they certainly will do from time to time, with views of general utility, it is the dictate of duty, no less than of reason, to train our moral feelings into harmony with our views of utility. Another advantage of Mr. Sidgwick’s position is that he ean give to utilitarianism all the support derived from the idea of duty and obedience toa moral law. The opposition, in fact, between Benthamism (as Mr. Sidgwick conceives of it) and intuitionalism vanishes away under his treatment, and the really fundamental opposition in ethics becomes that between ‘* egoism,” or the theory that it is rational for an individual to seek his own happiness, and the theory that-the-only course of action which approves itself to reason is that which aims at the happiness of mankind. On this point, which is to him a vital one, Mr. Sidgwick writes with unaccustomed indecision. ‘‘ Against any identification or blending of Egoistic and Universalistic Hedonism, and even against any representa- tion of their differences as secondary or subordinate, it seems very impor- tant to protest. . . The contrast between Egoism and Altruism is at any rate one of the most fundamental that morality exhibits.” In one point of view this is a self-evident truth. No two rules of action, considered as advice for the conduct of an individual, can be more different than the rule ‘* seek your own happiness ” and the rule ‘‘ seek the happiness of mankind”; and it does not need half Mr. Sidgwick’s dialectical power to bring this fundamental contrast into a clear light. It is, however, im- possible not to feel a misgiving that this central point of Mr. Sidgwick’s position, which involves this opposition of ‘‘ Egoism ” and ‘ Utilitarianism,” may be liable to damaging attack at the hands of professed utilitarians who are prepared to maintain what may be termed the orthodox utilitarian doctrine, that every one seeks and must seek his own happiness. One fact is clear: utilitarians in general have not attempted to dissever the ‘‘ egoistic” and the ‘‘universalistic” view of utilitarianism. Mr. Sidgwick’s own complaint is that they have identified or blended the two methods. It is of course possible that the teachers of the utilitarian school have mistaken their own positions ; still, that they should have done so is prima facie improbable, and the necessity that Mr. Sidgwick is under, so to speak, of breaking with his natural allies, suggests the idea that he may have to fight hard for his position. No man is more capable of maintaining his ground against all comers. His diffidence of expression, his studied fairness, his persistent maintenance of the attitude of a mere enquirer, conceal from careless critics his amazing aptitude for logical fence, and his extraordinary power of analysis, and above all his boundless argumentative resource and fertility. It is scarcely an exaggeration to say that if you will approach ethical problems from Mr. Sidgwick’s point of view, you will find that scarcely a single train of reasoning which bears upon his topie has escaped The enormous number of arguments which crowd his pages Of no writer is it more true his attention. in fact considerably injures the general effect. *-The Methods of Ethies By Henry Sidgwick, M.A., Lecturer and late Fellow of Trinity College, Cambridge.’ New York: Macmillan & Co.
Page 13
Mar. 16, 1876] that the “half” of his work would have been ‘‘ more than the whole.” | The argument is constantly concealed by the mass of arguments. You There is there- fore not the least danger that he should not make a good fight for the ground he has taken up, and none but a very rash critic would venture to pronounce Mr. Sidgwick’s position untenable. cannot, as the saying goes, ‘* see the wood for the trees.” We, at any rate, have no wish to pronounce any decision on the subject ; our object is simply to point out one of the lines of attack to which he seems to be exposed. Let us suppose for a moment that a Benthamite who, like Austin, repre- sented the narrowest but certainly the most consistent form of utilitarian doctrine, were to criticise Mr. Sidgwick’s attempt to sever ** Egoism ” from Utilitarianism. His argument would, we conceive, take something of the following form : The opposition (he would urge) on which you dwell be- tween the fundamental maxim of Egoism and the fundamental maxim of Utilitarianism arises from your treating the latter precept as if it were ad- dressed primarily to an individual. It is in reality a maxim for the guid- ance of that mass of individuals which we call the state. Admit this, and there is no opposition between the two rules. ‘* Seek your own happiness ” is the rule which reason imperatively impresses on the individual. ‘** Seek the greatest happiness for the greatest number ” is equally the rule which reason suggests to a mass of individuals acting together. Reason suggests it just because each individual desires his own happiness ; since there is no other course which secures to the mass of individuals an equal chance of securing the greatest lot of pleasure or happiness for each. Examples best exhibit what is meant. A hundred shareholders have equal shares in a joint-stock company. Each of them would like to get the greatest possible profit for himself ; but just because of this the only rule for their collective action is to secure the greatest amount of profits for the company, @e., for all of them. A ship catches fire. Each member of the crew wishes to save his life. The captain shouts, Keep order and all or most of you will es- cape. The captain’s advice is clearly the best which can be given, and based upon, not opposed to, each individual's private desire for life. Mani- festly in each case the interest of individuals may conflict with that of the mass. The manager of the company tries to cheat the other shareholders, The Nation. or a hulking blackguard attempts to force his way to the boats, crushing | down his weaker companions. It were vain to call this conduct ‘ irra- tional.” The interest of the mass can only be protected by forcing indivi- duals to conform to it. The manager is threatened with prosecution. The captain adds force to his utilitarian advice by giving notice that he will shoot any one through the head who breaks the ranks. what on a Benthamite view is done by the state. The main object of legis- lation is by direct and still more by indirect means—which, it may be added, are infinitely more powerful than is generally conceived—to force indivi- duals to pursue the general interest. This is precisely the general interest is that as far as the majority of men are concerned, the only mode of attaining the largest amount of individual happiness is to aim at the greatest happiness of the greatest number. Of course no one would dream of putting forward these obvious con- siderations as thoughts which have escaped Mr. Sidgwick ; they lie on the surface of the matter with which he deals. But they require attention be- cause they suggest that, in order to effect a reconciliation between utili- tarianism and intuitionalism, he has in fact altered the whole character of the utilitarian dogmas. A rational maxim of self-interest addressed to the state is transformed by him into a precept of self-sacrifice addressed to the individual. Unfortunately, what the maxim gains in moral elevation it loses in rational stability. Mr. Sidgwick, rejecting the support of ‘*egoism,” | finds an admitted difficulty in pointing out to any one who does not admit the validity of a somewhat doubtful intuition the reasonable ground on which an individual is to pursue the precepts of philosophical utilitarianism. The last words of his book are ‘‘ inevitable failure,” and in its closing sen- tences he warns his readers—with a grandiloquence of which not a single other specimen is to be found in the ‘ Methods of Ethics ’—of the peril that, if an unverifiable hypothesis be rejected, the ‘Cosmos of Duty” may be ‘reduced to a ‘Chaos.’”” This language recalls the tone in which certain political theorists announce that if their scheme of society be rejected we shall fall into the horrors of ‘‘ anarchy.” Anarchy, as represented by the unphilosophie prosperity of England or the United States, is a bearable condition of existence, and a hope suggests itself that the moral ‘+ chaos” which arises from the want of an absolutely coherent system of ethics may not greatly affect the moral prosperity either of mankind or of philosophers. There are, moreover, many steps between perfect order and chaos, and those who are not turned aside from the study of Mr. Sidgwick’s work by the gloomy knell with which he quite unnecessarily gives melancholy to its close, will find that they obtain from it, if p«t a complete system, yet great sut the ultimate motive for pursuing | Q 1s1 help towards arranging their ethical ideas, and the still greater advantage which is always derived from the teaching of an author who sifts to the bot- tom a host of current notions, and devotes the whole power of a singularly original and subtle intellect, not to the maintenance of dogmas or para- doxes, but to the impartial pursuit of truth. Par Charles Nuitter. Le Nouvel Opéra. With 59 woodcuts and 4 plans. 1875. (Paris: Librairie Hachette et Cie. Pp. 255.)—Les Treize Salles de (Opéra. Par Albert de la Salle. 1875. (Paris: Librairie Sar- torius, Pp. 315 )—Jlistotre del Opéra. Par Alphonse Rover. With 12 etch- ings. 1875. (Paris: Bachelin-Deflorenne ; New York: F. W. Christern. Pp. vi.-228.)}—The completion of an important national monument like the opera-house opened in Paris a year ago has naturally given oceasion for the publication of entertaining monographs drawn from the annals of French musical drama, works can be their titles. The first, by M. Charles Nuitter, who is now and has been fcr many years the archivist of the Opera, is a full account of the new building, The scope of these different seen in from its inception to its completion, and may almost be considered official. The advocates of the paternal theory of government will be delighted to find it recorded in M. Nuitter’s pages that the parental care of the tive went so far as to appoint a state commission to d M. de la Salle describes the in which the musical theatre of France has been permanently or tempo- rarily housed. The third volume, by the late Alphonse Rover, the Opera from 1856 to 1862, the } It is a history of the men and women who have succeeded each ot! exect- iscuss the best method of seene-shifting. thirteen hones manager of is perhaps the most ambitious of three. er upon the stage of the Opera ; with an appendix containing lists of the managers and of the chefs d’orchestre. It is disfigured by etched portraits badly drawn, and printed upon thin, harsh paper, in marked contrast to the ex- cellent woodcuts which illustrate M. Nuitter’s text According to Voltaire, France owes her comedy and her opera to two t cardinals, The assertion is not absolutely accurate, for while Richelieu was of material assistance to the earlier dramatists, credit is due to Mazarin only for suggestion. The success of a company of Italian singers imported by the cardinal to please Anne of Austria incited the Abbe Perrin to pre- duce, in 1659, ‘La Pastorale d’Issy,’ with musie by Cambert. Mazarin was disposed to encourage the new enterprise, but he died in 1661, and it was not until 1669 that Perrin received a royal patent according him a monopoly of the opera. This was soon revoked in ‘favor of Lalli, the wily Italian, who is popularly believed to be the omginator of French opera. Lulli, who had first attracted the attention of the king in one of Moliére’s pieces for which he had composed the music, opened the 1672, with a pastoral into which he had woven his musical interludes from Opera in May, ‘Le Bourgeois Gentilhomme’ and * Georges Dandin.”. The next year Mo- his more com- li¢re died, and by royal command Lulli took possession o modious theatre, thus supplanting Moliére’s company, as he had previously superseded Perrin, Lulli was versatile and industrious, and when he died, in 1687, he left behind him nineteen operas (not counting ballets and in- terludes) and six hundred and thirty thousand golden livres During the next hundred years there is but little of interest, excepting only the often-described quarrel between the partisans of Gliick and of Piccini. But in 1781 there occurred an instance of roval generosity well worthy of record. The theatre in the Palais Royal, in whicl been established for ninety years, was burnt, and, under the patronage of Marie Antoinette, the architect, Lenoir, by working day and night, built a new opera-house at the Porte St. Martin in eighty-six days. began to circulate at court that it was unsafe—that such hot haste could not have been carefully constructed. The intimidated authorities therefore decided that, in order to test the strength of the new opera-house before permitting the Queen to enter it, a performance should The honored 1 the Opera had Rumors at once a building erected in beams having been thus tested the Opera with their be given gratis to the people of Paris. by the common herd, their majesties presence. In 1791, for the first time, the names of the singers appeared in the bill of the play. Previously it had been understood that the best singers ap- peared on Fridays only. Three years later, when the Opera was transferred to the building confiscated by chicane from Mlle. Montansier, the specta- tors in the pit were at last provided with seats. The year before this, under the Terror, on March 20, 1793, Mozart’s ‘‘ Marriage of Figaro” was per- formed for the first time. The vacillating Louis XVI., after absolutely in- terdicting Beaumarchais’s piece, at length authorized its performance, and finally acted in it himself with his queen. Louis XTV., had danced in ballets, and his suecessor, Louis XVITI., when Comte de Provence, His predecessor, was the anonymous author of more than one opera-libretto, notably of the
Page 14
182 The ‘Caravane du Caire,” set by Grétry. This compuser did not long retain his royalist tastes. In the archives stored away in the capacious galleries of w building are the scores of many revolutionary operas by Grétry, Mehul, and Rouet de Isle, in which representatives of the people, muni- ‘ ieers girt with their tricclored scarfs, or sans-culettes curates replace ‘ ) ‘ ls of Olympus the det ex machind. } w-born Goce In these curious works we find less Of Reason dancing the Carmagnole or singing the 1, a revolutionary song of particular interest to Americans, fer it was cnuegested by a remark of Franklin’s. the bookseller Memoro. The Goddess of Reason was the wife The Goddess of Liberty was the beautiful Mile. Maillard of the Opera, who had so often played the part in the Offrande ala Liberté” that at last it became incarnated in her. The in } netress from the goddess, e, giving a leeal habitation to their ideal, no longer distinguished the In spite of her unconcealed royalist sympathies, he was constrained to personate Liberty in all the civie celebrations, and even to be adored in the ‘* Temple of Reason” (formerly ‘* Notre Dame”), together with Mme. Ducamp and Mlle. Florigny, also of the Opera, as Equality and Fraternity. During the whole Revolution the stage of the Opera was prompt to reflect the shifting scenes of blood and iron ; every victory over the foreign foe was at once set to music and represented before the footlights. Indeed, the Opera had a direct connection with the first great event of the Revolu- tion : its property-room had been sacked of its sabres to assist in arming the populace for the assault on the Bastile. It was, perhaps, in return for this timely loan that, upon the spoliation of the churches, the Opera was presented witha chime of bells, unfortunately destroyed in the fire of 1873. M. Nuitter mentions a tradition, impossible to verify, that one of these bells came from the Church of St. Germain-l’Auxerrois, and after having been nsed to give the signal for the real massacre of St. Bartholomew, it had again tolled the alarm during the five hundred performances of Meyerbeer’s ‘* Huguenots.” Like everything else, the Opera felt the beneficent effect of paper-money issued by the people for the people. With the unlimited issue of assignats, the price of tickets was rapidly raised until a seat in the boxes cost 9,000 On the 18th Prairial an TV. the receipts of the Opera were 1,071,350 livres! The real value of this million of livres was a little over two hun- dred dollars. livr Livres Under the Empire and the Restoration the Opera prospered. In 1822 it spent 188,260 franes upon the mounting of one piece, ‘‘ Aladin, ou la jampe merveilleuse.”. In February, 1820, as the Due de Berri was handing his wife into her carriage he was assassinated. In consequence, the Govern- meut razed the building and gave the ground to the publie as the Place Louvois. A temporary home was found for the Opera in the rue Le Pele- tier, and there it remained for more than fifty vears, until the night of Oct. 28, 1873, when the building caught fire. Within a few hours it was burnt to the ground. As M. de la Salle walked home from the fire he saw by the early dawn the wet and just posted bill of the Opera announcing the ‘* 100th performance of ‘ Hamlet’ for this evening at 71¢ o’clock.” 7. Lngland, Literary and Social, from a German Point of View. By (London : Richard Bentley & Son. 1875.)}—Herr Rodenberg’s book, though entertaining and worth printing, is rather disappointing. Julius Rodenberg. It is not, as its title seems to indicate, a study of contem- porary manners, and it contains very little psychology. Neither is it in any especial sense written from the ‘‘German point of view.” It is a col- lection of four long antiquarian essays by a man who knows and likes Eng- land so well that it is only to be divined from an occasional Teutonism of style that he is not an Englishman. It must be said, however, that the abundance of research and the paucity of personal observation are suffi- ciently characteristic of the author’s nationality, and that only a German, probably, collecting impressions of a foreign country on the spot, would have looked for them almost exclusively in books. Herr Rodenberg knows his England perhaps better than M. Taine ; but there is more of vivid por- traiture—of the essence of the matter—in a single page of Taine’s ‘ Notes’ than in one of this author’s long chapters. Herr Rodenberg writes upon ** Kent and the Canterbury Tales,” ** Shakspeare’s London,” the ‘‘ Coffee- liewres and Clubs of London,” and the ‘Jews in England.” To these lightly historie studies he affixes two chapters of inferior value, entitled ‘ Pictures of English High-roads ” and ** Autumn on the English Lakes.” These essays contain a great many curious reminders and allusions, and not : little unfamiliar information, presented in an easy, agreeable style, in which the ** geniality ” alone, perhaps, is a trifle overdone. Herr Roden- berg evidently knows English history and English literature with great ex- Nation. | |
fNumber 559 —~ actness, and his manner of entering into them, the peculiar degree of his relish for the objects, persons, and places associated with them, are very re« markable in a foreigner. Beyond a certain point, generally, such facts be- come too minute for a foreigner’s care : he is content to admire more in the gross. But Herr Rodenberg seems to feel a sort of intellectual birthright in the English past, and his intimate acquaintance with it may serve as an average, least acquainted with their own history and their own classics, For instance, it strikes us with a kind of respect for the thoroughness of a foreign observer that he should quote, apparently off-hand, some flat lines from the poet Akenside about Chaucer. How much must he have gone through, we reflect, before he arrived in the due course of things at drowsy Akenside ! Herr Rodenberg, taking for his text the Kentish landscape and the streets of Canterbury, gossips very agreeably and eruditely upon Chau- cer’s life, and weighs one hypothesis against another as to certain contested points in it. The author’s long prose synopsis of the contents of several of the Canterbury Tales might, however, have been profitably omitted from the work. The article on ‘*Shakspeare’s London” contains a good deal of entertaining archeology and topography, and many curious details about the arrangement of the primitive English theatre. It is to be in- ferred, however, that the author's knowledge of the past is more exact than it occasionally appears to be of the present. After the play, in Shakspere’s day, he says, the troupe of actors stood forth in a semicircle and di:- missed the audience by a prayer to the qucen—‘‘a custom which is maintained to the present day in England, where no play, opera, or concert is left before the National Anthem has been sung.” But Herr Rodenberg’s most entertaining pages are those upon the London coffee- houses and clubs, into which he compresses the savor of the whole literature of the subject. He calls attention, properly, to the singular anomaly of the fact that though coffee-houses began to flourish about 1650, the coffee of England is still the worst in Europe, having usually a strange, barbarous, experimental flavor. It is also very odd that in a country where coffee is made with the least appreciation of its merits and has always re- mained a decidedly exotic beverage, the dining-room at hotels should inve- riably be dubbed the coffee-room. This often seems to the breakfastless foreigner like a wanton addition of insult to injury. ‘‘It is remarkable,” says Herr Rodenberg in a note, ‘‘ that the smell of coffee seems so unplea- sant to the true Briton. Each of the above-quoted pamphlets [broadsides and satires of the seventeenth century] calls it a ‘stink.’”” We must thank the author for reminding us of one of the most characteristic and amusing instances of Dr. Johnson’s conversational brutality. Garrick had been pro- posed for election into the Literary Club, and Johnson, who was supposed to be his very good friend, protested against the nomination. “Sir,” he said, ‘‘I love my little David heartily, more than all, or many, of his flatterers do; but surely in such a society as ours one should not sit elbowed by players, pimps, and mimes!” Almost the only pages of con temporaneous allusion in Herr Rodenberg’s volume are his descriptions of the great clubs in Pall Mall, ‘‘the almost overpowering splendor ” of the Reform, and “those deep, handsome basins, in which it is a delight to bathe one’s face and hands.” We have mentioned the paper on the history of the Jews in England, which traces their varying fortunes up to their present highly comfortable condition, and is written, if we mistake not, from the ‘Semitic consciousness.” We must add an extract from the chapter on the “English High-roads”: ‘‘A universal shout <f revolt went through the British nation when, at the beginning of the last century, the improvement of the roads began and_post- chaises came into use. Some declared that the national courage would be destroyed if a man who had been in the habit of riding on horseback through the country, and of maintaining at any rate a struggle with a high- way robber, shou now allow himself to sneak along in coaches.” These objectors, if they had been prophetic, might have held their peace ; they would have foreseen a system of locomotion which was to be, in some of its ultimate developments, quite as effective a test of the national courage as the danger of meeting Dick Turpin and Claude Duval. example to the English themselves, who certainly of all nations are, in the Tales and Traditions of the Eskimo, with a sketch of their habits, religion, language, and other peculiarities. By Dr. Henry Rink. Trans- lated from the Danish by the author. Edited by Dr. Robert Brown. With numerous cuts drawn and engraved by Eskimo. (London : Blackwood & 1875.)—In this new form Dr. Rink’s classical work beeomes available to many students who may hitherto have been deterred frem at- tempting to master it in the original Danish. Sons. S8vo. What is here cffered us i M: not am mo Dr. pre ing of ma mi Gr cor det car pr rel lan sal lis! me ex wh ot Ks dif Ne hi: jo: fet afl nH ~— - -— -— it Pa ae a ae
Page 15
The N not merely a translation but a complete revision, in some parts slightly | amplified and in others condensed from the original, As the foremost | modern authority on the habits and traditions of the Greenland Eskimo, Mar. 16, 18 76) io Dr. Rink’s reputation has been long established, and the contents of the present volume can only extend still further, without in any way diminish- ing, this reputation. The most valuable portion of the work is its summary of the vths, distribution, and habits of the Eskimo, in which many ) zh lanzuage, I old but stil manner which leaves nothing to be desired. 1 current errors are exposed in a quiet and scholarly As a matter of course the Greenlanders, as the best known and most studied of the groups of Eskimo, i } I come in for the largest share of description, but in many particulars the details are also applicable to the whole Orarian stock, Were an equally careful study applied to the Western Eskimo, including the Aleuts, it is probable that many striking contrasts in habits and community-law, if not religious myths, would be brought out. Some remarkable coincidences in language and traditions between these widely separated branches of the same stock have been already made known, and we are aware of unpub- lished material which would largely increase the number. It may be mentioned that the Aleuts, the most specialized group of Eskimo people in existence, have certain traditions in regard to mythical ‘‘ inland” people which are almost paraphrased by some of Dr. Rink’s tales. The abzence of other than family, housefellow, or communal ties in the different groups of Eskimo holds as good in the west as in the east. Their habits, of course, differ with their environment. The well-fed and warmly-housed Eskimo of Norton Sound, with his comparatively long and actually warm summer, his abundance of game and ignorance of glaciers and bergs, is a more joyous and keener-witted fellow than his cousin of Greenland. This dif- ference extends to his myths and his temper. Many of his tales show close affinity to those of Greenland, but some of the fabulous animals seem to be wanting, and there is less of bloodshed, spite, enmity, and frostiness than in the legends from the east. Special modifications, induced by the environment, are noticeable in many of the western tales ; and in not a few the sentiment of the lover, almost wholly wanting in the Greenland stories, lends an interest and a charm to legends otherwise rather bald and tame. The translation is excellent, and the book will be a revelation to many of a strange and novel phase of human life, unlike anything afforded us by the Arctic voyages. The style is sufficiently attractive and clear to make it equally interesting to the school-boy and the philologist, and the illus- trations seem as characteristic as they are quaint. The erotic element of the tales has been almost entirely expunged, so that they have not for stu- dents quite the value that they would have possessed if untouched by the scissors. This gives them, however, all the more value for miscellane- ous reading, and does not detract from the incisive manner in which the other phases of Eskimo character are illustrated. A very brief summary of the author’s views in regard to the origin of the Eskimo is given. This is the enly specimen of really philosophical treatment of the subject which has come under our notice, and for that reason it is,all too short. But the ground where this part of the problem must be worked out is on the northwest coast of America ; and in the absence of exhaustive data the author's caution is praiseworthy. The book is edited by Dr. Brown, himself an eminent au- thority on Greenland, and printed in a neat and attractive manner. Elements of English Grammar. By S. W. Whitney, A.M. (New York ; J. W. Schermerhorn & Co, 1875.}—We are much in the habit of despising books of merely moderate size, and on this account the grammar before us will probably not meet with the reception which it deserves ; yet the author gives sound reasons for shortening and simplifying his text- book. In the preface he says : ‘Grammar is but one department of the science of language, that which treats of the structure of speech. Some, from a misconception of its true province, have attempted to teach, under the name of grammar, subjects as foreign to its real nature as geometry and conic sections are to arithmetic.” ‘ Grammar is usually divided into four parts—namely, Orthography, Etymology, Syntax, and Prosody ; but, troperly speaking, it embraces only Etymology and Syntax. Orthography treats of spellir Prosody treats of pronunciation and _ versification. These are taught in spelling-books, dictionaries, and rhetorical treatises.” The 160 pages of which Mr. Whitney’s Grammar consists are then divided equally between Etymology and Syntax. The former is subdivided into classification and inflection, to cach of which 40 pages is devoted. 1g ; We are particularly pleased with the neat and logical statements in which the parts of | speech are defined and their subdivisions bounded. We wish we could quote and illustrate the seven and six classes into which nouns and pro- 1 nouns are respectively divided. One class of adjectives compels notice : : ation. } ** A Pronominal Adjective is any adjective used as a pronoun s lwo of the boys went,” in contrast with ‘* two boys,” where fire would | limit- ing adjective. Under this class are ranked many words which are usually mistakenly termed pronouns. In fact, our author’s is the first g¢ cal text-book we have ever seen which satisfactorily distinguished a tives from pronouns, Our author boldly rejects the passive voi and defends his position as follows : ** Take the two sentences J yl nd Ll tise fed. In the latter, satisfied would generally and unhesitatingly be coupled with am and calied ‘a passive verb,’” while g/ad is considered a moditier of I. * Why not be consistent and regard glad” and saftisfed as construed alike ? f the verb am. Hence a new rule of syntax: ‘* An adjective or a participle either modifies some noun or pronoun expressed or implied, or is the plement of some verb.” The abstruse matter of the classificatior ordinate clauses is condensed into the threefold division of such clauses into ** pronominal, adjective, and adverbial,” accordin pplements Neither of them modifies the subject ; each of them su rof sub- gas tl ev act the part o prcnouns, adjectives, or adverbs ; as, Thai foriune by; i} fuvors ft i} } cheering ; I venerate the man whose heart is warm «nd re; pt go, | meet the same story. Besides ample illustrations, the author has introduced frequent exercives by which a pupil’s understanding of the text may be tested. The only points which seem deserving of censure are the omission of because and therefore from the list of conjunctions or conjunctive adverbs, the repetition of the familiar absurdity of calling the and an a different part of speech from this and one, and the hasty introduction of a tenth part of speech to- tally unealled-for, including the three words yes, ne, and amen, which our author terms ‘‘ responsives”; we might ask wherein the word n , Th n ry ole to a question differs grammatically from nv serrcely, perhaps, ete. sponse cr, da . ; and wherein yes differs from ¢ quite, indced, and a score of other adverbs of aflirmat on Presbyterians and the Revolution. By the Rev. W. P. Breed, D.D.— Historical Sketch of the Synod of Philadelphia. By WR. M. N Patterson Pastor of the South Presbyterian Church, Philadelphia ; and Biegraphteal Sketches of Distinguished Members of the Synod of Philadelphia, By the Rev. Rcbert Davidson, D.D. (Philadelphia: Presbyterian Board of Pub- lication.)—Presbyter‘anism and Calvinism can with full right assert for themselves the honor claimed by Dr. Breed of having been foremost in the. le for liberty, from the days of Coligny and William of Orange Revolution, rooe rugy great st to our own As representative of the denomination in this of Dr. ation of Inde pen- It was the Scoteh- lrish Presbyterians again that have the credit of the Westmoreland County Resolutions and the Mecklenburg Declaration of Independ Dr. Breed wholly ignores the disproval of the latter document: but, in truth, the credit of a series of patriotic resolutions was even greater than would have county The ynod of Philadelphia deserves the special commemoration given to it by Dr. Patterson, from the fact that it at one time comprised the entire Pres- byterian organization of America ; this was its original seat in this coun- try. ic and eul a) Witherspoon, the only clergyman who signed the Declar dence, and in all respects a leading statesman of his day latter struggle, his book is largely devoted to a li ence i been that of the hot-headed secession of a single inland g An interesting note is found, p. 33, appended to the assertion ‘* that it represents the largest and strongest religious denomination in the terri- tory which it occupies.” The note, in support of this assertion, examines the statistics of the Roman Catholic Church in the same territ ry, whose numbers, Dr. Patterson believes, are not so great as its adherents assert ; they ‘‘ seek,” he says, *‘ by the persistent array of the wildest claims, to earry by storm politicians who always want to be on the strong side.” The Presbyterian organization in this district, he has told us, counts ‘356 ministers, 288 churches, and 45,737 communicants (p. 28).” Now, the Catholic ** priests are largely clubbed together, two, three, and even more in a parish. , They report ‘ churches,’ The chapels are generally apartments in the churches, which are reported as such, and are thus included twice in the returns, or little places of wor- ship in their schools, academies, and theological seminaries ; stations : ‘chapels,’ and ‘stations,’ while the e spots also really connected with the churches, and visited by the priests in some cases (I quote the reports) ‘ monthly,’ in others ‘every The figures in our bounds are two hundred and sixty priests, regular and secular, and two hundred and forty churches.” No doubt, however, the Catholie churches will average more members than those of any Protestant 1 tI six weeks,’ ‘every second month,’ ‘four times a year,’ ‘ occasionally.’ denomination.
Page 16
Fine Arts. THE THEATRES. f 1875-6 is said to be principally distinguished for ENT ’ : pos antes i ison its pecuniary suec Last year there was a great deal of noticeable this year there has been little or none, but at no less than three of the theatres the managers have brought out plays which have hit the public tiste on the opening night, and have now been running each some three or four months. Last year we had in tragedy Ristori, in Shakspere (it is difficult to know how to classify ** Henry V.” except by the old term ‘ Iis- ) Rignold, in low comedy Toole, Col. Mulberry Sellers, and Bouci- cault, to say nothing of almost continuous ope ra-bouffe at the Lyceum, { ry ” reduplicated in German bouffe at the Germania. at the Fifth Square, and This year we have had three **Rose Michel” for at the Booth’s, The Lyceum has been occupied for a short time by a very good French * Pique” for months Avenue, three months Union ‘Julius Cesar” at company (after a few nights of bouffe), but has been a great part of the time closed. The Park Theatre has experienced the vicissitudes of fortune, now making a success, as in the case of the ‘* Mighty Dollar,” and now a dead failure, as in the case of Mr, Oakey Hall ; now collapsing altogether and closing its doors, and again suddenly reappearing with a broad comedy— distinguishable from a farce chiefly by its length—called ‘‘ Brass,” and appa- With the exception of Mr. and Mrs. Florence in the ** Mighty Dollar,” and Mr. Honey in his inimitable part of Old Eceles in ** Caste,” there can hardly be said to have been any actors of rently destined to have a long run. real note at the native theatres, and, nevertheless, the theatres have on the whole found the season a profitable one, and that is tantamount to saying that the audiences have not found much to grumble at. The key to success in the management of a theatre in the present condi- tion of the drama is the discovery (and in this term must be included not only translation and adaptation, but even writing) of a play which will run so great a number of nights as to reimburse the management for the enormous outlay «# telling play now involves. When we say the present condition of the drama, we mean of the Anglo-Saxon drama. The amount of money required for the production of a pageant like ‘* Julius Cesar,” as it is now given at Booth’s, is so great that playing it for a short time must ruin the managers, and the same thing may be said of plays like the ‘Shau- ghraun,” ** Rose Michel,” the ‘‘ Two Orphans,” or ‘* Pique.” The public taste demands fine dresses, gorgeous upholstery, absolute ‘realism ” in the This is suf- ficiently proved by the fact that the plays which have these peculiarities, properties, and scenery constructed without regard to expense. and yet have nothing else in common, succeed. be debased and material, and so undoubtedly it is ; but the fact cannot be the he who takes the most intel- Instead of trying to make his theatre attrac- of bill, tablish ” a play as he might a daily newspaper ora railroad. judicious is it. variety gainsaid, and manager ligent advantage of tive by continual and change he sets to work to ‘es- He is confident that if he only spends money enough on the ‘ plant,” acting that would otherwise be barely endurable will pass for excellent. If the candid theatre- goer, who has enjoyed—as we have ourselves enjoyed—the absurdities of ‘* Pique,” or the pageantry of ‘‘ Julius Cesar,” or the ‘‘ sensations ” of ‘‘ Rose Michel,” will ask himself what the plays would have been without the acces- The Nation. The taste may be said to | sories, the scenery, the dresses, the properties, he will, we believe, come to | The the conclusion that not one of the three would have run a fortnight. true test of good playing is bare walls, cheap clothes, and the minimum of | The red and blue lights, practicable fireplaces, or other accessories. actor who can create an illusion without anything more is a real actor; the more he needs to make the public believe he is acting, the less of an actor he is. These are rank heresies, but we will undertake to prove them truths to any one who, with even a very moderate equipment of German, will go to the Germania Theatre in Fourteenth Street and see ” or, on Tuesday night, There we are in a ‘* Posse mit Gesang,” or a ‘‘Sechwank mit Gesang, a classical play, given by the company now playing there. a different country from that which has the ‘* Union Square” and Daly’s for its capitals ; a country into which few Americans, for obviovs reasons, intrude, and which keeps its traditions and canons of taste unchanged. There the which the theatre iscarried on is that of perpetual variety. great law regarding the *‘ plant” is unknown, and the plan on An admirable stock-company and a long répertoire of amusing and more than amusing plays are the German substitute for upholstery and tinsel, and we must iv the substitute is a good one. The theatre, stage and all, is smaller than in ordinary New England town-hall, and has little to adorn its native, by ugliness ; the stage is extremely small, and the scenery, so far as we have observed it, of the simplest. But the acting is capital, and the com- , {Number 559 ————SSS—— > pany well drilled in every kind of playing. Looking, not at individual actors, who excel in particular parts—in this the native theatres make now and then as good a show as could be asked—but at whole plays, there has been better acting at this little theatre and the Lyceum, this winter, than at all the native theatres in the city put together. Fechter is an actor who belongs to three countries, and his reappearance at the Lyceum was an event which was of almost as much interest to the American as to the French population of New York. But he has sadly fallen off within the last few years, and it has become almost painful to see him with such good-will and ardor attack the parts in which he won his fame, and in which he seems now determined to bury it. He is no longer suited in appearance to young parts, but this is a trifling matter which many an old actor has triumphed over ; for some reason or other he has ceased to be interesting, and we are almost forced to ask ourselves whether his former success in this country was not a mistake, and whether the trumpet-blast from Dickens heralding his approach did not really overawe our theatrical provincialism and prevent us from exercising our own minds on the subject. The rest of the company made ample amends for Fechter’s shortcomings, and while they were here fairly held their own with the Franzosenfresser beyond Fourth Avenue. The ‘** Mighty Dollar” deserves to be singled out from the plays of the winter as an exceptional success. Mr. and Mrs. Florence, always good actors, fairly outdid themselves, and the former in the character of an unsuccessfully corrupt Congressman, and the latter in the rdle of what we suppose we may call the Franco-American matron of the period, were capital low-comic characters. Perhaps they ought to be called burlesque, but as there are no less than two, if not three, living women of whom Mrs. Florence in this part is said to be a lifelike reproduction, this may not be a fair word for it. The Honorable Bardwell Slote is a real creation, not so delicately done as Col. Mulberry Sellers, but, like him, drawn from real life, and we regret to say containing a touch of nature that goes straight to the heart of an audience in New York ; how it would be in the Puritan at- mosphere of Massachusetts we cannot undertake to say. Wallack’s still continues to be the only theatre in the city which makes a point of keeping alive the traditions of English comedy, and for the most part strenuously resists the surging tide of sensational melodrama, of plays of ‘* society,” and of ‘‘ contemporaneous human interest ” which has carried everything before it in the other theatres. There is no stage in the city ex- cept Wallack’s, probably, where the manager would dream of giving Mrs. Centlivre’s ‘* Wonder,” now nearly two centuries old. Whether the attempt will prove a success or not remains to be seen. The play itself is a lively and entertaining comedy of a bygone school, and derives its interest now in part from the fact of its having held the stage so long. But a play must have intrinsic attractions to do this, and what these attractions are it is easy enough to see. The ‘‘ Wonder” is a play of ‘‘ situations,” and the situa- tions are very laughable. The jealousy of a lover, suggesting to him a sus- picion of his mistress, and fed through four acts with all sorts of damning circumstantial proofs, which the audience meanwhile is allowed to see are no proofs at all, but derive their suspicious character from the fact that the lover’s sister (escaped from the parental custody) is concealed in the house, while honor forbids any explanation, are the materials which furnish the play its life. It has something the effect of a practical joke played upon the chief actor with the connivance of the audience, and it is excel- lently carried out. The two principal parts, Violante and Don Felix, afford room for acting of a high order, and it is easy enough to imagine that Gar- rick may have found the latter well suited to him. The play is besides very well balanced, there being two “ heavy fathers,” two pairs of lovers in high life, and one pair in domestic service. The lover of Violante is the brother of the lady whom Captain Briton loves, and the servant of Don Felix is of course in love with Violante’s maid. A Scotch retainer of Captain Briton’s performs the necessary part of marplot, and the wit of his part is greatly heightened by a broad Scotch accent, and vigorous kicks adminis- tered by those in authority. The dialogue is rapid and bright, though without any distinct marks of originality, and the play is enriched here and there by one or two of those jokes which seem so very improper when made by the wicked Gaul, but when occurring in a standard English play fill us with delight, not unmixed with respect for the manly frankness of our sturdy ancestors of both sexes, who could make and laugh at them without blushing. The play requires better acting, or at any rate a very different kind of acting, from that which the market here affords, and though it may very likely succeed now, it is impossible to see it without feeling that the types it introduces are so obsolete that ordinary actors do not naturally take to them, and have to be forced into them, almost as the men and women of our day would have to be forged into the armor and dresses of medieval time;
Page 17
fi if “ Fes