The Nation 1870-12-01: Vol 11 Iss 283
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
NEW YORK, THURSDAY, DECEMBER 1, 1870. The Week. THINGS are appreaching a crisis on the Loire. The Prussians, un- der Prince Frederic Charles—who probably holds the chief command of the co-operating forces—on the left, Von der Tann in the centre, and the Grand-Duke of Mecklenburg on the right, press on the French army before Orléans and the troops covering Tours, in a semicircle ex- tending from the vicinity of Montargis, opposite Gien, to the vicinity of Vendéme, opposite Blois. Fighting, mostly on a small scale, has been going on for a number of days at various points along the front of the French army, the Prussians demonstrating in force, chiefly be- tween Montargis and Beaune, against the extended and exposed French right. The most important engagement thus far took place Novem- ber 28, near the latter place, the advantages of which are claimed by both sides, The wooded heights extending from Gien to Chevilly, in front of Orléans, seem to form the principal strength of the position occupied, and artificially fortified, by D’Aurelles de Paladines ; but the weakness of his left flank was betrayed by the abandonment of Chateau- dun, in consequence of the threatening concentration of Prussian forces on the opposite side. His communications with Tours can thus hardly be said to be secure. Norisit likely that the force lately commanded by Kératry, which, after the engagement at Dreux, was unable to oppose the advance of the Grand-Duke’s forces on the line of Chateauneuf and Nogent-le-Rotrou, towards La Chartre and Vendéme, will now be able to execute an effective diversion for the relief of the temporary capital. In the North, Picardy has been the theatre of active operations. Considerable bodies of troops of General Manteuffel’s command having joined the forces which had long but steadily been operating against Amiens, the offensive was more energetically resumed towards the close of last week. After some sharp fighting, with varying success, around Demuin, Moreuil, and Boves, a stubbornly contested engagement took place on Sunday, the 27th, east of the latter place, near Villers-Bretonneux, which lasted till late in the afternoon, when the French were compelled to field to the superior forces of the assailants. The struggle was continued at Boves, and further west at Dury, but finally the Army of the North was forced to abandon its last positions around Amiens, which was occupied on the 28th by a division of Man- teuffel’s army. The Prussians have thus, after repeated and ener- getically resisted attempts, become masters of that important city and of the rich valley of the Somme, a river which will now form a strong military line between the fortresses of Artois and Nord—the supporting points of the Army of the North—and the great commercial towns of Normandy—Dieppe, Rouen, and Havre. In which direction that army has retreated, whether towards Artois or towards Normandy, is not stated. South of Rouen, the Prussians have occupied Evreux in force. Almost simultaneously with Amiens, La Fére, after a very gallant resistance, surrendered to the Prussians. This conquest secures to the latter unbroken connections between Picardy and Isle de France and Champagne, and completes the separation of the strongly fortified north-eastern border of France from the rest of the country. It is not likely that the Prussians will attempt the reduction of any of the fort- resses on that border situated west of the Meuse, and there is no im- probability in the report of their having abandoned the inyestment even of Méziéres, on that river; but they continue their efforts to re- duce Montmédy and Longwy. Thionville has surrendered, after a ter- rible bombardment. An unsuccessful sortie is reported from Belfort. A severe fight in the vicinity of Dijon, between a considerable detach- ment or Garibaldians and some troops of General Von Werder’s com- mand, resulted in a disastrous rout of the former. The Prussians in ation. — that region, however, appear to have made no further advance towards Autun or Chalon-sur-Saéne, and their movements, as far as reported, are hardly sufficient to indicate the main object of their operations, Most of the communications received from Paris agree in represent- ing that capital as sorely tried by incipient famine, want of fuel, and in- creasing ravages of disease. According to some of those communications, the condition of the besieged two millions is such as to render a speedy capitulation not only desirable even to the patriotic, but a matter of utmost necessity, unless a successful sortie on the grandest scale puts an end to all the miseries of the siege —for the hope of a relief by the ‘Army of the Loire, or any other army in the field, is now cherished by few rational beings in the city, or out of it, To attempt such a sortie, however, without a simultaneous attack on the Prussian lines taking place from without, is something which only a criminal disregard for human life could suggest, and Trochu is hardly the man to venture upon an enterprise of this kind. It is, therefore, not surprising to hear that some of the Parisian journals, such as the Journal de Paris, the Gundlois, and the Figaro, have finally come out with protests against an indefi- nitely protracted defence of the city, and in favor of the conclusion of peace. Should this demand for peace become louder with growing famine, and the issue of the battle now imminent on the Loire be such as not to encourage hope, Trochu and his associates would have a pro- bably desired opportunity of yielding to the dictates of common sense, while pretending to yield to public pressure, In the meanwhile, how- ever, cannonading from the forts and demonstrations beyond them continue to take place from time to time against the russian positions, The whole of the news points in the direction of the catastrophe on the Loire which we ventured to foreshadow last week—the destrue- tion either by crushing defeat or wholesale capture of the army of D’Au- relles de Paladines, and the flight of the Tours Government further south, Paris would certainly not hold out after receiving the news of such a disaster, even if it does not fall sooner before the ravages of hunger and disease. There is something sad in the eagerness with which the French continue to buy arms, and the exultation with which they an- nounce the arrival of their purchases, as if they were suffering or had ever suffered from want of men or rifles. The things they need are things time oniy can supply—and time they cannot have. Their fall, as well as that of the Austrians in 1866, seems to prove pretty con- clusively that great disasters in the early part of a campaign will hereafter rarely be recovered from by the vanquished; the victor is able to follow his advantages up too rapidly in highly civilized coun- tries. The news of the Turco-Russian complication continues to be pacific. The exact position of the English Ministry in the matter is a little dif- ficult to make out. There are rumors that Earl Granville’s ground is too bold for his colleagues, and that they are disposed to repudiate him. On the other hand, the average public opinion seems to run in favor of war, while some of the more prominent Liberals, John Stuart Mill for instance, have come ont against war; but it is safe to say that the public will be ready enough to fight if the war seems likely to be naval only. But there is evidently no disposition on the part of Russia to force matters to a crisis; and while neither side will recede from its position, no overt act will be committed, and the affair will, it seems most likely, drift into a general Congress, summoned either to deal with that solely, or—if Paris falls soon—with the whole European situation, which is still full of danger. In the money markets dulness reigns supreme. Speculation in stocks seems a thing of the past. Government bonds continue firm, and have not varied materially throughout the excitement in the Lon-
Page 2
358 The Nation. [Number 283 = don and Frankfort markets. There is an animated discussion going on over Mr. Boutwell’s funding schemes, as foreshadowed in despatches from his friends in Washington, and over the probable fate of his efforts against the national banks and the Pacific railroads, in which he is likely to have the whole financial community against him, whiie all the rest of the country will be on his side. The uncertainty as to his action tends still further to diminish operations, The more peaceful tone of the latest European news has put down gold a trifle. Money, in the absence of all demand for business purposes, continues cheap and apparently abundant. The momentary uneasiness caused by last week's failures seems to be forgotten, and the only point to which any one looks for the least interruption to the present dead calm is real estate, which is getting into a rather precarious condition, from the al- most total absence of buyers. None of the varying reports of peace or war have been able to move our markets to any extent. Cotton has not varied more than one quar- ter of a cent per pound, in spite of various domestic influences tending to unsettle the price, while flour and wheat, under heavy receipts, have been lower. Groceries are somewhat lower, and fruits of every descrip- tion, both foreign and domestic, are unusually abundant, cheap, and of superior quality. A notable feature of business during the week has been the marked falling off in the Thanksgiving-day trade, which dealers report smaller and more unprofitable than for many years past, indicating anything but general prosperity, and foreshadowing 4 probable decline in many articles of food during the coming winter. The whiskey trade, an interest of great importance to farmers, continues disorganized, many distilleries preparing to stop work, owing to steady losses; corn, however, remains firm. Meats of all descriptions are lower, and altogether the prospects of consumers are somewhat im- proved, There has been a good deal of activity among the “ Revenue refor- mers” during the week. On the 22d ult, they held a private meeting in this city, which was attended by Mr. D. A. Wells, Mr. George Walker, Mr. Horace White, of the Chicago 7ribune, Mr. Bryant, Mr. Bowles, of the Springfield Republican, and others, and at which, after a good deal of talk, the conclusion was reached that things were look- ing very well; that the legislative debates of the coming winter wouid, under the influence of the late elections, probably do a great deal to educate the public and prepare the monopolists and jobbers for what is certainly coming; and that the question of civil service reform was closely connected with that of the reform of the revenue, and ought to be discussed and pushed with it; and it was resolved finally to charge a committee with the work of looking after the interests of both in a general way during the winter, with power to make arrange- ments for the calling of a national convention in the spring, in case the course of Congress proved unsatisfactory. The usual distribution of “ British gold” did not take place, it must be confessed to the regret of all present. Indeed, the desire for it, and for as much of it as possible, was avowed with the greatest effrontery. The open display of such feelings at a reform meeting was a curious sign of the times. Why the British should have cut off the supply was not explained, but we presume they were unable to withstand the repeated exposures in the Tribune, which have doubtless made Mr. Thornton wince a little. The feeling nevertheless gains ground, that if Mr. Wells is bribed by the British, so is Mr. Greeley, their fighting being what is termed atthe police courtsa “ put-up job ;” Mr. Greeley playing the part in the discussion which Sceptieas plays in the dialogue with Fidelis in the tracts which defend revealed religion. In these, it will be remembered, the argument is thrown into the form of a dialogue simply to make it more attractive to the frivolous, but Scepticus, almost from the first, behaves like an imbecile, and, after having opened the debate in the most bullying and insolent way, submits afterwards to a disgraceful de- feat with the most ludicrous equanimity. Of course nobody imagines Mr. Greeley will permit any such termination to the controversy as this; but people begin to wonder how long the present vehemence on his part will last. He has, during the past week, been rapidly repudi- ating “ British gold” as a key to any of the free-trade positions, and, we are bound to say, has grown much fairer in his treatment of the sub- ject than he used to be. The Tribune's full report of the proceedings at the Revenue Reform dinner is something which all friends of good journalism, whether they care anything about revenue reform or not, must admire. We make this personal reference to Mr. Greeley as synonymous with the New York 7ribune—in spite of his recent protest, and in spite of our fixed conviction that the newspaper etiquette which forbids such reference in treating of the editorial matter which appears in a paper is founded on the wisest expediency, and is a help no less to good morals than good manners—simply because he insists on protruding his personality into the editorial colamns of the Tribune. He frequent- ly signs its leading articles, and frequently fights out purely personal quarrels, and makes personal explanations, and follows up his personal enemies in them. Not long ago, he solemnly, in an editorial para- graph, contradicted a story that, having been unsuccessful in fishing, he had sworn so horribly that he had shocked and alarmed the boat- man, who put him ashore, and refused to take him out again. The Revenue Reform dinner had for its principal feature Mr. Wells's speech, which was a model of its kind, and told, in a very effective way, the story of his conversion, under the influence of his own investigations, from extreme protectionism to the position in which he now stands, which he says is that of a thorough believer in the free-trade theory, but who nevertheless believes indirect taxation best suited to this country, and the manufacturers who have invested capital under the protection- ist régime entitled to time and opportunity to extricate themselves. There is no doubt of the soundness of allthis. One of the most shame- less and injurious features in the present régime is the haste and reck- lessness with which duties are run up and down, and one of the most prominent features of anything purporting to be a reform should be slowness, and caution, and respect for vested interests. Industry can stand anything better than uncertainty, or rather needs certainty more than anything. e Additional election returns from the States of North Carolina, Ala- bama, and Arkansas point more de‘initely than to anything else to dan- gers ahead for the Administration, and for the Republican party, unless the party can change the Administration’s general policy and its own policy in regard to reconstruction. This latter, however, it is hardly worth any one’s while to consider any longer ; we imagine that it would be difficult to get a respectable minority of even a resuscitated Con- gressional Committee fon Impeachment who would not now condemn the President’s interference in the North Carolina troubles of last sum- mer and the Alabama troubles of to-day. All that is done and over, and the force of habit itself cannot make even back-country editors talk of it this fall with any seriousness. Apparently the President is of a different opinion. In Alabama, the Democrats having carried their State ticket, the Republican Governor and Treasurer, whom the vic- tory displaced, refuse to vacate their offices, on grounds which seem to them sufficient, but which are condemned as utterly inadequate by even the Republican members of the Senate, All but two of these offi- cials express indignation at Governor Smith’s conduct; but that func- tionary calls on the Federal commander in Montgomery for troops and has them supplied him. By these his rooms are now guarded, and bid fair to ygmain so till the case goes before the courts, when there is small doubt that he will be ousted, There is still less doubt that the people are heartily tired of seeing Southern Republican governors, considering what manner of men they are, making requisitions for United States soldiers, and making them when the Legislature is in session, or in the act of going into session. Meantime, a contest has been raging over the United States Senatorship ; a great deal of hostility to Warner, the present incumbent, being shown by many Republicans. These are very
Page 3
of ch er 1g it- al al ig >) t- —- State grows richer in spite of its plunderers; the colored politicians Dee. 1, 1870] The Nation. 359 bitter against him—for reasons not stated. Noone Southern Senator of the carpet-bag order has shown himself an ornament to the chamber: put of specified charges against Warner we know nothing. In North Carolina, the election to fill a vacancy in one of the | Congressional districts resulted in the election of a Democrat by a ma- jority greater than that which the Democracy obtained in August last. This result might have been less reasonably expected had Manning's competitor for the place not been the more notorious than celebrated Mr. Joseph Holden, a son of the Governor of the same name, but ap- parently not possessed of his father’s cleverness, if we may judge by his conduct of the Raleigh Standard, the family organ. In South Carolina, the Conservatives or Reformers, as they call themselves, are reported since the election as being in a state of apathetic despair as regards the political future of the State. Perhaps they have reason when it is the fact, for instance—as we know it to be, on testimony for which we can vouch—that some of the election inspectors unblush- ingly permitted such open frauds as the casting of ballots by the ne- gresses as well as by the men, and there will be plenty of proof of simi- lar irregularities when the seats are contested. But again, perhaps in these facts the white men of the State have reasons against despairing rather than in favor of it. The Whittemores and their like no doubt get some of their power over their ignorant constituents because it is yet too soon for the negro quite to trust the white man, even when planted on the best of platforms, and influenced, let us grant, by motives sin- cerely good, but some, at least, of their power is based on the mere ignorance of thcir constituents, and on their own as yet undetected rascality, and their prosperity has not the elements of stability. Its supports can in no long time be taken from under it by patient fair treatment of the negro population, and sincere co-operation with him for the common benefit in political labor and investigation. The must always be few in comparison with the colored laborers; and long before there is time or opportunity for the corruption of the latter by the example of the former, the laborer, if fairly treated, and if fully ac- cepted as a political co-worker, will have forsaken the corruptionist demagogues, or else have driven them to comparative decency. In the neighboring State of Florida, it may be very well doubted if the same thing is true for longer than the present year. The latest advices would appear to show that the Republican candidate for Con- gress has been successful by the bare skin of his teeth, having a dis- puted majority of about 200 over his Democratic opponent. There is said | to have been a good deal of intimidation of voters and some fighting, and, though news is scarce, this assertion is probably true; yet a Re- publican majority of about four thousand in a voting list of some thirty thousand, is not a Republican majority that looks as if it would stand the test of many years of Southern politics, as Southern politics go now—especially in States where men like Governor Reed are the exemplars of the party principles. In Arkansas, there is appearance of the Democrats having carried the State and caused the Congressional delegation to stand two to one in their favor instead of one Democrat to two Republicans as now. On the whole, the drift in the South is in the wrong direction, and there will have to be much heedful watching this winter. The expected lecture from General Butler on the political situa- tion has been delivered in Boston, and, as we remarked last week, the amount of attention it has received, and the amount of space that has been accorded to it in the papers, are enough to make one sad. The General has been in the employment of the Republican party for | about four years, and, apart from his services in the Impeachment case, the only work he has done above-ground has been an attack on the public credit, in the shape of a proposition to pay the bonds in paper, and another to reduce the interest by “a tax” on it; the advocacy of an unlimited issue of greenbacks, somewhat in the style of | Law’s Mississippi scheme ; and now he appears with a plan for getting up a war with England. Its principal features are a repudiation of the rules of international law in settling our disputes with her, and an open resort to the general ground of hostility, this to be followed by non-intercourse, or war at our pleasure. He says the expense of war could be paid by the increased stimulus given to manufactures. The most striking thing in most of the General's productions, after the rascality of them, is the gross and wild ignorance they display, and this is no exception to the rule. The plan is, on the whole, such a one as one might expect to issue from the brain of a fuddled bar keeper; . and when we consider that its author is now supposed to be high in General Grant’s confidence, and got between two or three thou- sand people to listen to his rubbish in Boston, one feels more than ever that it isnot“ caste” which is preying on our vitals. On the other hand, the lecture has been treated by the whole of the respectable press with thorough contempt, and has, we think, let the lecturer down a few steps more in his political decline, which will be very rapid, as long as he is unable to get up a row. Order and quiet suffocate him. We find the following in a letter from Mrs. Martha C. Wright to Mrs. Cady Stanton, in the last number of the Revolution, referring to our recent paragraph on the sapient despatch of Mrs. Emilie J. Meri- man to France as a “ peace advocate and commissioner ” “The Nation alludes, with its usual discrimination and amiability, to our convention, mistaking the mere reading of Mrs. Meriman’s letter for the decided action of the convention, and characterizes its members as ‘reformatory geese!’ ‘Be sure you're right, then go ahead,’ is not one of the Nution’s rules.” We are very sorry to be disagreeable to Mrs. Wright in any way, but, under the circumstances, it becomes our melancholy duty to quote the following from a very full report, the accuracy of which has never been questioned, of the proceedings of the convention in question by the New York Times of October 22: “Rev. Mrs. Olympia Brown then made a brief address, after which the resolutions were adopted. A letter was then read from Mrs. Emilie J. Meriman, who has just arrived from France, and who intends returning to that country, asking the sympathies ef American women in behalf of peace. After the reading of this letter, the following resolution was adopted : “ Resolved, That, having full faith in the potency of moral power in the problem of the world’s peace, we, in behalf of the women of America, do constitute and accredit our countrywoman, Mrs. Emilie J. Meriman, our peace advocate and commissioner, to proceed with all dispatch to France to present the gravity of considerations of peace to William, King of Prussia, and to Jules Favre, Minister of Foreign Affairs for France, and to intercede with them for peace.” The discussion about the annexation of Alsace and Lorraine in Ger- many is just now marked by a striking incident. A portion of the manufacturing interest of the Zollverein have come out with a protest against the annexation, on the ground that it will bring 870,000 spindles and 14,000 looms into competition with them. They therefore de- mand either that the annexation shall not take place, or that the cotton goods of Alsace and Lorraine shall be excluded from the territory of the Zollverein for at least a year, if not longer, in order to give the Germans time to prepare for them. This has called forth a storm of indignation from the political press, which says that whatever the national henor and safety require must be done, no matter what becomes of the cotton or woollen interest, and that, in any event, the interests of 40,000,000 of consumers are to be thought of before those of a small number of producers; and that, as the former will clearly be benefited by the opening of the frontier to Alsatian goods, the protectionist objection to the annexation is really an argument in its favor, They might add that the very least that Germany can do for the unfortunate people of the newly-acquired provinces, is not to shut them out from their very best market at the moment they most need a ready sale for the products of their industry. First to conquer, then annex them, and then, after having secured the exclusion of their goods from France, to exclude them also from Germany, would be the refinement of cruelty.
Page 4
The Nation. TO RUIN. THE “HIGH PRIORI ROAD” \RTES ron a course of philosophical speculation was to make a com- earance from his mind of all existing beliefs, so as to enter on his work in a state of universal doubt and interrogation. its success, and that is that the mind thus cleared be the mind of a philosopher; and as long as philosophers only resort to it, if it does no great good, it is pretty sure to do no harm. Unfortunately, how- ever, we are witnessing an attempt in France—and the present attempt is only the latest of many—on the part of “the ave- rage man” to apply this method to the work of practical poli- tics, and there is a strong disposition among the class of reformers to which we have taken the liberty of applying the term of “ Sen- timentalists” to try it to the extent of their power in all coun- tries. The process, as they all practise it, is very simple. The first thing done is to resolve that whatever is, is wrong; that the fact that a thing has existed raises a presumption against its utility; and that it is at any time open to any community to tear down all its institu- tions, and to build up new ones, on a philosophical basis, constructed out of the inner consciousness of its more voluble members. It con- sists, in other words, of the adoption of the Cartesian method by a great crowd of persons, the best of whom have little mental training of any kind, and the mass of whom are very ignorant, and in their total release from what is perhaps the strongest, and for political purposes will have to be the strongest, of the social forces, at least till the human race has entered on a stage of culture from which we are certainly still ages distant—viz., habit. It is perhaps fortunate for mankind that the French took upon themselves to try this experiment eighty years ago, before their bro- ther Sentimentalists in other countries were quite ready for it, and that we should now be witnessing the close of it before the delusion which prompted it had spread any further or gained more power. France was, at the first Revolution, made a tuhula rasa, and in the process an enormous amount of rubbish was unquestionably swept away. If the French nation, and especially the Parisian portion of it, had then been composed of philosophers of the first order, doubtless something very fine might have been built up on the cleared ground, They went to work as if they had been philosophers, however, and as if the com- munity were as wax in their hands, and as if they despised the past and could defy the future. Their mode of reconstruction was very simple —namely, to create out of their imagination a set of ideais, and treat them as actually existing powers, to which it was only necessary to | give full liberty of action in order to secure the happiness of the | nation, One—and, we need hardly say, the first in order of these— was The People, which was always spoken of, not simply as the aggregate of the human beings inhabiting the national territory, but as a moral person, not only of great strength, but of consummate wis- dom, purity, and goodness, which never erred, was never deceived, and, if let alone, was sure to do all things well, distribute justice, re- spect rights, and employ the proper agents of its will. How its will was to be got at never clearly appeared. A popular vote was never accepted as a satisfactory expression of it, as it was always said by those against whom the vote went that the essence known as the * People’s Will,” in passing through the gross medium of the ballot, became corrupted and distorted; and it generally turned out that if you wanted to get at the real thing, the proper course was to attend a lecture by a certain orator, on a certain evening, in a certain hall, where, for a small sum, you would have the genuine extract supplied This of course was only true as If you wanted to know the People’s Will as to who should fill a public office, you got it in a different way— namely, from a knot of gentlemen called a club or caucas, who “ thought it out” in a private room. This type travelled far and wide. It made its way to the United States, to England, and to Germany, and has to this day a powerful hold on the popular imagination in all ef them. In all of them, though in the United States, ever since Jefferson’s day, more than in the others, the People still sits apart, looking after to you on any subject of interest. regarded general questions, [Number 285 — laid it down that the first step to be taken by anybody | | things—a mysterious but terrible abstraction, before whom all tremble and adore—who selects not only the best governors and sheriffs but the best judges; but has to have the custom-house clerks changed about | once a year, and is made perfectly furious by talk of competitive exa- | minations ; and hates precedents and books, and political economy like Whatever may be the value of this expedient, there is one condition essential to | yo1sSON. The next type was The Republic. This was an ideal organization got up by The People for the banishment from the earth of poverty and crime, and the establishment of truth and justice. Its armies were invincible, and remain so to this day; its generals men of matchless skill and valor: its courts wise and incorruptible; and love its only law. It was the hold of this type on the popular imagination, and its complete separation in the popular mind from all experience, which led to the extravagant declarations which followed the overthrow of the Empire at Sedan. The New York Tribune called attention the other day to the folly of the Provisional Government in protracting the war by declaring, as soon as it took office, that it would not cede “an inch of territory or the stone of a fortress.” But this was preceded by a still greater folly, consisting in a declaration that the Republic would make no peace as long as a single Prussian remained on French soil; so that the very first proposition made by the Republic to the Prussians was that they should go back across the Rhine, and there treat. Now, this tone was undoubtedly taken, even by a man of such ability as Jules Fayre, under the influence of that sovereign faith in the mysterious power to control circumstances enjoyed by this abstract Republic, which, in the minds of Frenchmen of the democratic school, is not a political organization made up of Frenchmen as all the world knows them—that is, the Frenchmen of to-day, who have served two military tyrants within the present century with the greatest devotion —but a being of vast strength, raising great armies with the wave of a wand, and hurling them, under matchless leaders, on the helpless foe, and diffusing happiness and plenty through a smiling land on the return of peace. The wild exultation which followed the proclamation ot the Republic at Paris was really due to the secret belief that there was some magic in the name that would take the poison of eighteen years of servitude and profligacy from French veins, and enable demoralized ar- mies to recover in a day their discipline, and courage, and self-respect. The mania, too, as might have been expected, crossed the Atlantic, and found plenty of victims here. King William and Bismarck were savagely abused by some of our own Sentimentalists, because their earthy eyes did not also see the bright vision and bow before it; give his sword back to De Failly, because he was now a soldier of the Re- public ; and listen with awe to the utterances of Flourens and Roche- fort, who were two of the high-priests of the new deity. Another of these imaginary types rapidly growing up here among ourselves is Woman; not woman as we all see her and know her, and as the world has known her since the dawn of history, but a Woman of the mind, whose subordination to man, in the family and in society, and exclusion from politics, have been the great, if not the sole, cause why the People and the Republic have hitherto failed in putting a complete end to human misery. Woman it is, now, whose participa- tion in affairs is to bring our criminal jurisprudence to perfection, banish corruption from our politics, vice from our streets, inefficiency from our public service, and, in short, save modern society from all the evils which most afflict it. If you ask where this Woman is to be found, you find that she has never been embodied in the flesh; she is an ab- straction made up of the attributes of various remarkable women—of Miss Cobbe’s intellectual power, Mrs. Josephine Butler’s electioneering talent, Mrs. Cady Stanton’s dignity, Miss Susan Anthony’s activity, Mrs. Howe’s eloquence, Queen Victoria's domestic virtues, and the administrative ability of divers Hindoo princesses; and we are asked to believe that, when this combination is brought to bear on our affairs, we shall have a new earth. A_ striking illustration of the golden haze which surrounds her is to be found in the protest made by the Boston Woman's Rights advo- cates against the extreme ground which has been taken up by Mrs. Cady Stanton and the New Yorkers on the question of marriage and divorce. The former are resolutely opposed to all discussion of this subject now; but they promise that when Woman makes her appear-
Page 5
on re 285 its ld wo ive
ny er CDE SERA A, Dee. 1, 1870]
ance in the Legislature, and comes to debate marriage with Man on equal ground, something—they do not say what—will be done which will make marriage what it ought to be. Now, as there are only three things any human legislature can do about marriage—-(1) make divorcee | easy; (2) make it difficult; (8) or abolish marriage altogether—and as the two first plans have been in full operation in various parts of the world under male auspices, and as the last has been tried by various per- sons already without any legislative sanction ever since the creation, and not one of them has thus far seemed to hasten the millennium, the notion that when Woman takes the thing up husbands and wives will live together in lifelong peace, is evidently another form of the de- Jusion under which the unhappy Frenchmen are hurling defiance at | the Prussians. The condition of France ought to be, and we trust will be, a solemn warning against the whole process. No healthy national life and no sound political system can be built up on it. The basis of everything good in politics is character, and no character can be strong whose owners habitually live in dream-land, and treat their own fancies as forces capable of governing the world. Such people always shirk | the facts of life, and the more they shirk them, the harder it becomes to face them, They begin, therefore, by deceiving themselves; they end by deceiving others. The result is general mendacity and moral rotten- ness; and, finally, Sedan and Metz. The day is sure to come when valiant, self-reliant men are needed to stand in the breach or face the iron shower, and nothing is found but rhetoricians and poetasters and demagogues ; when naked, unadorned truth is needed to save the na- tion, and the air is filled with lies; when strong brains are needed in the council chamber, and the table is surrounded by hysterical de- claimers, wailing over the break-up of their own illusions, and telling a scornful world that if everything had gone differently, things would not be as they are.
MONOPOLIES AND THE FOURTEENTH AMENDMENT. Ir may be remembered by some of our readers that at the time of the passage of the Fourteenth Amendment certain politicians objected to incorporating it in the Constitution on the ground that, though only intended to establish the civil rights of negroes, its terms were so far-reaching that it might possibly be construed by the courts into something much more dangerous. A curious case has recently arisen in Louisiana which will probably result in a determination of this question by the Supreme Court at Washington. The facts of the case were these: For a long time back the health of the inhabitants of New Orleans is said to have been endangered by the presence of innumer- able slaughter-houses, scattered through the city with less regard for its sanitary condition than for the convenience of the butchers. With the ostensible design of improving the health of the city, the Legisla- | ture of Louisiana, in 1869, passed an act, the practical effect of which | was to incorporate the Crescent City Live Stock Landing and Slaughter- | house Company, and to give it a monopoly of the business for twenty- five years, within a certain district. The act directed the discontinu- ance of all other yards, slaughter-houses, and stock landings. The new | company were to be entitled to levy tolls on all cattle slaughtered at their shambles. The avowed object of the act was to localize a business | which the hot climate rendered dangerous to the health of the inhabi- | tants during certain portions of the year—in other words, it was enacted as a police regulation. Whether the minds of the legislators who passed the bill were in reality influenced by sanitary or by pecuniary | considerations, we have of course no means of knowing. It is enough for us to know that its passage caused great dissatisfaction among the | butchers of New Orleans, who found their business sadly interfered with, and at once applied to the courts for relief. The Supreme Court | of Louisiana sustained the monopoly, and the contestants thereupon | went into the courts of the United States. The suits brought were in- | numerable; but the case which has recently been decided by Judges Bradley and Woods in the Circuit Court is the most important. The Court (Mr. Justice Bradley delivering the opinion) held, in substance, | that the monopoly in question was unconstitutional under the Four- teenth Amendment, which declares that all persons born or naturalized | in the United States, and subject to its jurisdiction, are citizens of the
The Nation. 361 / United States and of the State wherein they reside, and that no State . ? 22° _ °7 : shall make or enforce any law whic? shall abri: de the rit irileges Of TAMi f acat ~~ - ? , r os aon oy lise, liberty, or property tilhout dite } €88 0} 3 r deni ' y | person within ts) irisdiction the equat protection of tik we, The rea- | soning by which the court reaches this conclusion is this: Although the privileges belonging to citizens of the United States, which the Amendment secures, and which a State cannot by its laws abridge, may be diflicult to define, “we may safely say that it is one of the privileges of every American citizen to adopt and follow such lawful and industrial pursuit, not injurious to the community, as he may see fit, without unreasonable regulation or molestation, and without being restricted by any of those unjust, oppressive, and odious monopolies or exclusive privileges which have been condemned by all free govern- ments.” ‘ There is no more sacred right of citizenship than the right to pursue unmolested a lawful employment in a lawful manner. It is nothing more nor less than the SACRED RIGUT OF LABOR.” As the act incorporating the company in effect prevented the butchers and live- stock men of New Orleans from pursuing their lawful calling, it inter fered with this right, and was unconstitutional. Such is the reasoning of the court. The case will probably come before the Supreme Court, and will there receive full consideration, Meanwhile, we desire to call attention to the decision, for its scope is, as we believe, very broad, and strikes not merely a blow at a New Orleans slaughter-house com pany, but at the existence of almost every franchise in the United States. Every patent, every railroad franchise, every canal, turnpike, and ferry company in the world is a monopoly. They are all cases of ex- clusive rights, vested in a small number of private persons. A railroad franchise, for example, confers an exclusive right of carrying: passengers and freight between two designated points; it is absolutely exclusive of all the world, since any one who attempts to conduct this business within the established limits—or, in other words, over the company’s tracks—renders himself liable to an action. In the same way, a patent confers an exclusive right to manufacture and sell a particular article for a certain length of time, and unquestionably infringes the sacred right of labor, if anything of the kind does. To these arguments Judge Bradley replies in the following way: He says that the right to labor is not infringed by the issue of patents, because * society only gives to” the patentee * the temporary exclusive use of that which, without him, it would not have had the benefit of, as a consideration of that benetit and to encourage others to make use of their powers.” As to franchises, his argument is that the legislature does not interfere with the “ sacred right of labor” by conferring them, because, in the first place, the employment made legal by them could not in the absence of legislative provisions be pursued by private indi- viduals at all; and, in the second place, because “ society obtains a consideration for the grant of these franchises in the investment of large amounts of capital in public improvements which are required for ' the development of the country and its resources.” We are unable to follow these distinctions. In the case of the pat- ' entee, as in the case of the railroad, the ostensible object of the grant is a public benefit; the immediate effect is an exclusive privilege. This is precisely the case of the slaughter-house company. We can sce no essential distinction between such objects as the public health and the public wealth ; still less do we follow the argument as to railroad and other like franchises, that as they confer rights to do what the legisla- ture alone can authorize to be done, and which ao private citizen has a right to do without such authority, they are, therefore, different from | monopolies which interfere with previously established occupations. It is true that the public advantages claimed for railroads cannot be obtained without legislative interference ; but it is equally true that the public advantages claimed as the result of concentrating an unhealthy business in a particular locality cannot be obtained without the same in- terference. It is true that legislative interference in the one case does not seem to interfere with any previously established pursuit; but this is only an apparent distinction, The introduction of railroads broke up the old lines of stage-coaches, just as the slaughter-house act in New Orleans interferes with the business of the butchers; and the old stage-
Page 6
osc 302 coach required no act of the legislature to enable it to run, any more than butchers do to enable them to slaughter animals. So it may be said of a ferry franchise that it interferes with the “sacred right of labor” in exactly the same way. Did not the old-fashioned ferryman, who had enjoyed for a lifetime the sacred right of carrying pas- sengers and freight across the stream on the banks of which he lived, regard as an odious monopoly the charter which took away from him his livelihood? We are driven to the conclusion that all these exclu- sive privileges belong to the same category ; their ostensible object isa benefit to the public; their immediate effect the pecuniary emolument of private individuals. But Judge Bradley says that the act of the Louisiana legislature, so far as it is a police regulation—in other words, so far as it inures to the public advantage—is valid, but that the claim that it was no- thing more than a police regulation was “too bald for a moment’s con- sideration.” How this is shown does not appear. It may be that the judge means that the act is so grossly and palpably a “job,” so obvi- ously passed for the benefit of a ring, that the avowed object of the legislature is of no avail. There is a principle in the law of taxation which makes it necessary that a tax shall be laid for a public pur- pose; and any tax which is grossly and obviously laid for private benefit is set aside by the courts as unconstitutional. But the case must be such an extreme one as to appear on the face of it a swindle. It may be that Judge Bradley, having this principle in mind, thought an analogy might be drawn between the case of a tax and the case of a monopoly. But will any one say that the Louisiana act is on the face of it aswindle? The declared public object is at least a reason- able one. But this is a technical legal point with wliich we have no- thing to do. Our object in the present article has been to show, as we have endeavored to do, that the reasoning of the court as to monopo- lies in general will apply to patents, railroads, and other private fran- chises, quite as well as to the privileges conferred upon the New Orleans Slaughter-House Company. If the decision is sustained, every moneyed corporation in the country is in danger of destruction. When- ever a court can be satisfied that the exclusive privilege granted by the State or the United States inures rather to private than to public advantage, the franchise will be set aside as in violation of the Four- teenth Amendment. Very few corporations will be able to stand this test. It seems hardly possible that the Supreme Court will sustain Judge Bradley ; but, if they do, the consequences which we have endea- vored to indicate appear not improbable. MR. BOUTWELL AND THE OIVIL SERVICE. OnE result of the recent trouble between Mr. Cox and the Presi- dent, which, though perhaps not very important, is not wholly without value, is the sudden development of zeal on the part of divers high functionaries for the purity and efficiency of the civil service. There appears, if we may judge from what we hear and read, an anxiety pervading our political circles that the Government offices should be filled by “ honest and competent men” which would have done credit to the best days of the Republic. They do not pro- pose, of course, to adopt any such new-fangled tests of fitness as are proposed by Cox and Jenckes and Schurz; “the people” would not stand it. They have little contrivances of their own, which do the work without inconvenience to the party. The best and latest of these is that of Mr. Boutwell. This gentleman is opposed to civil service re- form, as the term is generally used. He hasagain and again expressed his belief that the party could only be “run” by making the offices the reward of party service, and dismissal the penalty of “ unsoundness,” and, we may add, holds that opinion at present. As soon as Mr, Cox took office, he began to introduce the system, not of examination only, but of competitive examination, into the Patent Office and Census Bureaux, but failed in obtaining the slightest sym- pathy orsupport from Mr. Boutwell, whose department contains a larger number of employees than any other, and was, therefore, the seat of the principal scandals connected with the ofiice-seeking business, In fact, the latter has always avoided any sign of departure from the party tra- ditions on this subject. There is an act of Congress, of 1853, which pro- The Nation. [Number 283 vided for the examination of Government clerks, and to which we re- ferred a fortnight ago, but we believe it is correct to say that the exami- nations held under it were, down to 1869, rather practical jokes than tests of efficiency. In fact, the law was a dead-letter till June of that year, when an order was issued, signed by the Assistant Secretary of the Treasury, and directing the examinations to be held in a bon@-jide manner; and this the Boston Advertiser published a week ago, as proof that the charge brought against Secretary Boutwell of indifference to civil service reform was unfounded. Enquiry, however, now elicits from the Treasury Department itself the confession, which we knew was sure to come, that the examinations held under this order were a farce, and remained a farce for a whole year. It was not till September last that any serious attempt was made to enforce the law, and this only under pressure of the growing public feeling on this subject and the example set by Mr. Cox in the Department of the Interior. The character of this attempt at reform is worth study. It consists of an order and an “examination schedule,” which we reprint in full. “ TREASURY DEPARTMENT, July 29, 1870. “Tt is ordered that from and after this date the Board of Examiners provided for by the third section of the act of Congress, approved March 8, 1853, will be constituted as follows : “The chief of the bureau to which the clerk is assigned, the chief clerk of the department, and E. B. Elliott, Esq., of the office of the Secretary of the Treasury. “ Examinations will be in writing, and must show the process by which the conclusions or solutions are reached. All the papers to be submitted with the report of the Board of Examiners, and filed with the appointment division of this office. GEORGE S. BOUTWELL.” TREASURY DEPARTMENT EXAMINATION SCHEDULE. Outline of a schedule to serve as a guide in the examination of applicants for clerkships in the Treasury Department, suggested by the permanent ‘members of the Board of Examiners. 1. Name. 2. Residence. 3. Place and date of birth. 4. Elementary education—Mathematics, book-keeping, languages, etc. 5. Special acquaintance with business, art, or science. 6. Clerical experience generally. 7. Clerical experience (if any) in the service of the Government. 8. Example illustrating the class of accounts, computations, or work in which lately engaged. 9. Questions in notation. 10. Questions in numeration. 11. Questions in the addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division of whole numbers. 12. Questions in the addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division of fractions, decimal. 13. Questions in the addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division of fractions, common. 14. Questions in interest and discount, simple and compound. 15. Questions pertaining to the conversion of domestic and foreign cur- rencies. 16. Questions pertaining to United States weights and measures, com- mon. 17. Questions pertaining to United States weights and measures, met- rical. 18. Questions pertaining to book-keeping. 19. Practical applications of the above. 20. Questions pertaining to grammar and orthography. 21. Geographical questions. 22. Historical questions. 23. Questions pertaining to government and law. 24. Correspondence. 25. Miscellaneous questions, tending either to further test familiarity with the subjects above specified, or to elicit acquaintance with other and more special branches. (3 In the solution of numerical examples, it is desirable that the work be proved, and the process of solution and proof stated. Washington, D. C., September, 1870. It would be difficult, we suppose, to hit upon a better contrivance than the above for throwing dust in the public eyes. In the first place, let us remark, an “ examination schedule” by itself means absolutely nothing. If Mr. Boutwell wants to convince people of his good faith in this matter, he must publish a batch of the examination papers— that is, of the questions drawn up and put under the schedule, and of the answers returned by the persons appointed. To judge whether this new process is or is not, like its predecessor, a farce, we want to know what the examining board asked the candidates, and what the candidates said in reply. Everything depends on this, and, after what has happened, it is absurd for Mr. Boutwell to ask the country to trust iy MEIN Bey Tete * aided ns
Page 7
TS rk of ch ad nt [Ss at Ba IN gee Dee. 1, 1870] his simple assertion, or that of his subordinates, in this matter. The examination papers are, we presume, on file; let us have a sample of them along with the monthly accounts of the Treasury. Write two hundred and forty, is a question in notation. Add 2, 7, and 4; substract 20 from 40, and multiply 7 by 5, are questions in addition, subtraction, and multiplication. How many pints in a quart? is “: question pertaining to United States weights and measures.” On what river does Washington stand? is “a geographical question.” And, What year was Richmond taken? is “a_ historical ques- tion.” In fact, an examination which is held in secret, and the results of which are not published, and which is conducted by men who are opposed to the principle of examinations altogether, is almost an insult to the public intelligence. No reform of the civil service can be anything but a mockery, a delusion, and a snare which (1) does not consist in the examination of candidates by persons unconnected with the departments, and, above all, unconnected with the party in power. The board must be thoroughly independent. The present board consists of Mr. Boutwell’s appointees, whom he can dismiss at pleasure, and who are as much interested as he in “ running the machine ;” that is, in seeing that the useful party hacks get places, and that members of Congress obtain their fair quota of the offices for their hangers-on. (2) The examination must be open to every Ameri- can citizen, high and low, rich and poor. Every man has a right to have a chance to enter the public service if he shows himself qualified. Neither Mr. Boutwell nor any Congressman has any right to shut him out. (3) It must, as a guarantee of fairness and of efficiency both, be competitive (that is, if there are many candidates for one place, the person who passes the best exami- nation must be held entitled to the place), and it must be public (that is, be either conducted with open doors or have the results published) ; and (4) the tenure of office must either be during good behavior or for a fixed term. Anybody who rests satisfied with the device which Mr. Boutwell is now working at Washington may feel assured that he has given the Forneys and Chandlers the best possible cover for their operations, ENGLAND.—MR. GLADSTONE ON THE WAR, Lonpbon, Nov. 11, 1870. WE are wel! into November; and no American travellers who may have visited London at this period can complain of not having seen the genuine fog of the British islands. The air is yellow, heavy, and thick, and our spirits are perhaps somewhat influenced by the simultaneous oppressiveness of the physical and the political atmosphere. We look into the street at noonday and see, instead of the sun, the feeble glimmering of gas-lamps ; and, if we turn t ward the political horizon, the prospect is not much more cheering. The war weighs like a nightmare upon our spirits, and I presume that in that respect at least you will sympathize with us. French refugees throng our streets ; the neat white-capped bonnes are to be seen in our dismal London squares, wondering how John Bull supports the burden of existence ; Regent Street, as presenting, I suppose, the nearest approach to a boulevard—nearest, but with an enormous interval—is full of foreigners, and one hears French spoken there almost as frequently as English. Judging from external appearances, one would say that our guests manage to keep up their spirits better than could be expected. Probably the less cheerful exiles do not exhibit themselves so freely ; and, to say the truth, I doubt whether any large number of the poorer classes have really taken refuge on our shores. The relief societies seem to have some trouble in discovering a sufficient number of deserving objects for their benevolence, and it is amusing to observe how the English impostor is hastening to take advantage of the position. An old acquaintance in that line has just presented himself in a new dress. In former times his dis. tresses were of the average type; he wanted five shillings to secure a per- manent employment of great value; he had been reduced to the verge of starvation by a complicated series of terrible diseases ; now, it seems that he had lately obtained an excellent situation in Paris, and was forced to fly from it by the advance of the Prussian armies. The ill-luck which in. duces this unfortunate being to place himself in the way of any catastrophe that is taking place at the time is truly lamentable. However, there is distress enough of a more genuine character, and it is painful to look for- ward to the winter and all it may bring. | | } | Government to bring about an armistice. The Nation. 363 Our attention has been lately fixed upon the praiseworthy effort of ovr I call it praiseworthy, for it was, doubtless, undertaken from the very best of motives. But it is very hard to see what prospect of success it could ever have offered. It is plain enough that the French and Prussian Governments are still too far from tak- ing the same view of the state of affairs to allow of anything short of a de. cided intervention producing the slightest effect ; and it would have been as well to ascertain that their wishes were approximating before undertak- ing such a hopeless bit of peacemaking. The case was, I rather imagine, that our Government had been so vigorously entreated to do something, that they were willing to make some proposals, even though the too certain result should be to demonstrate the futility of any advances at the present moment. Some light is thrown upon their temper by a very remarkable article which recently appeared in the Edinburgh. That venerable peri- odical has of recent years been declining into a decided state of fogyism. What its circulation may have been, I have no means of knowing ; but it led an innocent and inoffensive existence, curiously contrasting with ite early vitality, and few people condescended to enquire of so sleepy an oracle. The present number, however, has gone through more than one edition, and excited a very lively sensation. The cause of this phenomenon is an article attributed to Mr. Gladstone, and called Germany, France, an} England. The authorship has not been openly avowed, and I have even heard a rather evasive contradiction given to the report on apparently good authority. I think, however, that I may say positively that Mr. Gladstone is really the author. Besides private information, which appears to me to be above all doubt, the simple fact that the Dat/y Neos published the statement, and that other papers have criticised the article on assump. tion of its authenticity, without any contradiction having ever been pub- lished, is apparently conclusive. and, as far as internal evidence goes, there is no reason to doubt the accuracy of the report. In such matters, silence ‘gives consent ; Mr. Gladstone, then—if, as I have no doubt, it is Mr. Gladstone—writes with his usual eloquence, and speaks with remarkable freedom upon the general questions involved. His statements are those which, I may say, are generally popular at the present moment amongst educated men. He throws the blame of the original quarrel upon France, and condemns the Emperor and the Ministers in no measured terms. Of the French policy which led to the war, he says that “ for fault and folly taken together, it is almost without parallel in the history of nations.” “The Mexican ex- pedition,” he says again, “and the whole scheme of ideas with which it was connected, constituted such a huge mass of blunders, like a huge agglom- erated iceberg rising high to heaven and sinking far into the deep, that it might have been deemed incapable of adoption even by an ordinary human being if it had not captivated what was then considered the astuteness of the Emperor.” The French people, indeed, cannot be relieved from responsi- bility ; but the’system of the Empire was detestable and eriminal. On the other hand, the Prussians by no means escape from this energetic censor, The piety of the King and the policy of his Chancellor, “which, whatever else it may have been, was not pharisaical,” come in for some sharp sneers. The plan of annexing Algace and Lorraine is brutal and retrograde. If Count Bismarck has not been misrepresented, or does not misrepresent his countrymen, “ Germany will yet have to prove her civilization by some other means than by boasting that six or six hundred letters have been written in good Sanskrit by the soldiers of her army to their friends at home.” Turning from the contemplation of these wicked Continental races, Mr. Gladstone exclaims, “ Happy England!” and becomes eloquent about “the streak of silver sea,” which, though ‘t does not cut us off “from the duties and the honors,” yet does exempt us “ partly from the dangers and wholly from the temptations which attend upon the local neighborhood cf the Continental nations.” He proceeds to give his view of our position and prospects, which are painted in the most glowing colors. We are freer than ever, lie thinks, from all danger of invasion. We have finally abandoned the lust of conquest, which misleads all other nations. We may be blamed for our neutrality by hot-headed people, but we occupy a position of un- equalled dignity. England is the “ appropriate object of the general con- fidence, as the sole comparatively unsuspected power. In every quarrel, in every difficulty, it is her aid that is most courted ; it is by her agency that parties, if they seek a mediation, prefer to come together ; it is under her leadership that neutrals must desire to move.” Blessed are the peace- makers: and if we show ourselves worthy of our high calling, that is the position which we shall be called upon tooccupy. A new law of nations, a new value for peace and respect for the independence of others, is gradually taking hold of the world. We, owing to our fortunate freedom from temp-
Page 8
The _ ———————————— |) 54. S18) tation, are in a position to take the lead inadvancing this desirable consum- mation, the which come We have already satistied our colonies, pacified Ireland, withdrawn from “ feverish contest for influence,” content to accept the moral power ‘from good character, and purpose to move forwards quickly and steadily in the path of progress. “The foremost among the nations will be that one which, by its conduct, shall gradually engender in the minds of others a fixed belief that it is just. In the competition for this prize, the bounty of Providence has given us a place of vantage, and nothing save our own fault or folly can wrest it from our grasp.” i need not dwell upon the value of the opinions thus expressed, of which your readers can form their own estimate without my help. I will merely say that with many of them I thoroughly agree, and, though I fear that the picture of England is just a little sanguine, I admit that the as- pirations are generous, and really wish there was a better chance of their being fulfilled. But from another point of view, the manifesto is more re- markable. Mr. Gladstone rather shocked the nerves of steady old Consti- taking the stump in Lancashire—a proceeding held to be “Interviewing ” is a pro- cess which has not yet become entirely naturalized with us. But if Mr. Gladstone had desired to find some mode of expressing his views of tutionalists by derogatory in a leading Minister of the Crown. European polities, he might surely, it is said, have found some more dignified method than that of contributing an anonymous article to a re- view. It is rather a singular position for a Prime Minister of England to be telling the world at large that the rulers of the two principal European powers are utter knaves and fools, that the King of Prussia is a hypocrite, Count Bismarck a cynical tyrant, the French Republican rulers a set of impracticable enthusiasts, whilst England alone stands mounted on a moral pedestal above the rest of Europe. This, at least, is rather an awk- ward expression of sentiment for one who is about to attempt a mediation between the victims of his satire. The restless and impulsive spirit which leads him to express himself in so unguarded a fashion explains the thoughtlessness with which he has rushed into the recent negotiations. Mr. Gladstone is incapable of judicious reticence, and has a great dislike to see any business going on without taking a more or less active part in it. He has many virtues, and a degree of talent which falls not far short of genius. But his nervous and eager temperament is always leading to superfluous displays of energy, whether in philosophizing about Homer or putting to rights the politics of Europe. l'o swear by all Mr. Gladstone's doings is part of the creed of a large With every respect for his intentions, for his remarkable talent and ceaseless energy, I have never been able to work lie has not the simplicity and manliness of mind which one desires in a statesman of the first class. section of the Liberal pariy. myself up to the proper pitch of enthusiasm. Still it is impossible not to admire him very sincerely, and I the more re- gret an act of indiscretion which will certainly do him little service in the general opinion. However, the meritorious nature of silence is little under- stood at this day, in spite of Mr. Carlyle and his preachings, and perhaps this performance will not be so much resented as his enemies desire. And perhaps, on the whole, Mr. Gladstone’s expression of opinions will contrast pretty favorably with the recent utterances of his great rival—Mr. Disraeli. You have doubtless seen the recently published preface to our late premier’s novels, and will have been much amused by his conception of the political and religious movements of the time. Mr. Gladstone has, at any rate, least of the charlatan, if he has also least originality. THE MUNICIPAL REFORM IN RUSSIA. Sr. PeTerssune, Nov. 1. THe epoch of which Peter the Great was the exponent, though he neither began it nor ended it, was eminently ene of centralization : the Most of the reforms of the reign of the been absolute reversals or entire remodi- present of decentralization. Emperor Alexander have fications of measures instituted by Peter, or at least conceived in his spirit. What was then judged useful and an incentive to progress The ultra-Slavophilists assert that the reforms and innovations of Peter have kept Russia back has now become an obstacle and a hindrance. insiead of making it advance, because they were imposed from without, instead of being developed from the germs which already existed in the nation. It would be difficult to admit the truth of such a sweeping r judgment, but certainly the reforms of Peter excited such a discontent and opposition among his people that many had to be soon given up, and some others which remained in force prevented many reforms which would naturally have come of themselves. The abolition of serfdom, Nation. | which Peter did so much to strengthen, has brought in its wake the almost complete abolition of class distinctions, for the nobles have only two privileges left—freedom from recruiting and from the poll-tax—bot); of which will soon go, and the clerical caste was last year destroyed. The passport system, which gave rise to several rebellions, and is a great obstacle to the material progress of the country, has just been radically modified. While by the emancipation act the villages were allowed their old custom of free assemblies and an elective government, by the creation of provincial diets and by the judicial reform, the governors of the pro- vinces were reduced from autocrats almost to clerks; and the same prin- ciple of representative assemblies was extended from the village to the province, embracing all classes. Slight as these privileges were, and they are unfortunately partly paralyzed by an imperfect publicity of proceed. ings, they are more than have been enjoyed since the parliament held by the first Romanoff. The cities alone were left out of these reforms, and remained entirely in the hands of the central power. Novgorod, Pskov,and Viatka, and their colonies, were once free towns, and enjoyed the utmost liberty, even to excess, of popular government. The reign of Ivan the Terrible put an end at once to their freedom and their prosperity. Moscow, Vladimir, and the towns of the South had always been under the immediate eye and rule of the grand-dukes, and had borne the Tartar yoke, but even in Peter's time they had some rem- nants of self-government. It was Catharine the Second, however, who reduced all Russian towns to one model, in the hope of creating a middle or bourgeois class, which had almost entirely disappeared—all Russia being then divided into nobles and peasants. She founded numerous cities—and the flourishing state of most of them now does credit to her good judgment as to site—and introduced the “ City Regulation,” which has been, with little change, in force to the present day. Each of the six classes into which the city inhabitants (excluding nobles and serfs) were divided elected a member of the city council, and the mayor was ap- pointed by the crown, till 1861. The council bad extremely limited powers, and was entirely controlled by the governor. The Emperor Nicholas gave a more liberal government to St. Petersburg and Moscow, allowing the nobles and officials some share in the administration ; and, four years ago, really liberal charters were granted to St. Petersburg, Moscow, and Odessa, with a council chosen by a system of double-election and an elective mayor, with large powers of self-government, and almost perfect freedom from outside pressure. The new institutious have worked so well, except in part in Odessa, where the representatives of the most numerous and lowest constituency have proved factious, demagogical, and corrupt, that a general law has just been signed by the Emperor, which confers self-government, on a still broader scale, on every city and town in European Russia, except the Western and the Baltic Pro- vinces, for which special provisions are necessary. Much more than a year was spent in the preparation of this law, which was devised by a special commission of jurists and persons versed in municipal matters, under the presidency of Prince Urussoff, after conference with many dele- gations, and free and minute discussion in the press. The importance of the reform itself, and the curious experiments contained in it, will justify me, perhaps, in commenting on some of its chief features. In general, the city government has the same powers and to the same extent as with you, except over the local police, which is an affair of the state, though the city is represented by delegates in the police board. No citizen can be taxed except as allowed by this law, by the law regu- lating the provincial diets, and by the corporative guilds, unless by a law of the Empire; and the city is bound to support the complaint of her citizen thus wronged, At the same time, the city is responsible for every excess of power or illegal act, and the governor is directed to lay all com- plaints before a special commission in each province, composed of the vice-governor, the treasurer, the district-attorney, the president of the justices of the peace, the president of the provincial regency, and the mayor of the chief city of the province—the last three being elected by the people, the first three appointed by the crown. If the city govern- ment does not collect the Imperial taxes—a duty imposed on it—the governor will collect them at the city’s expense. The city is governed by a city council (duma) and a city regency (up rava). Every inhabitant of the city is a voter, provided he is a Russian subject, twenty-five years old, has taxable real estate in the city, or is pro- prietor of a commercial or manufacturing establishment, with a mer- chant’s certificate ; or if he has lived in the city two years and has paid excise duty as a retail trader or clerk of the first class, and is not in arrears for taxes. An elector is deprived of his vote if he has been condemned or
Page 9
r 283 ke the re only —both 1. The LTeat lically l their eation e pro- > prin. to the | they ceed. ld by 3, and Wns, nent. band had : and rem- who ddle issia rous her hich SIX vere ap- ited ror ow, ind, rg, ion ost ced ost al, or, ity ro- ORE IRR TRE Se soy Sto a ER eo epeTRS Dec. 1, 1870] is under trial for a crime; if he has been expelled the public service for a crime or misdemeanor ; if he is a fraudulent bankrupt, or is in bank- ruptcy with affairs still unsettled ; or has been expelled from the clergy, the nobility, or some guild, for fault. The governor, the members of the special commissions for cities, and of the provincial regency and of the local police, cannot vote while they hold office. Women, absent voters, and persons of legal age (twenty-one) but not twenty-five, can vote by proxy, duly legalized. The proxy of a woman may be one of her rela- tives. Minors owning real estate have a vote in the persons of their guardians. Institutions, companies, societies, churches, and monasteries which own taxable real estate vote by their president ; but nm person can have more than two votes—one for himself and one as a proxy. A list of voters is prepared, with the amount of taxes paid by each, and is then divided into three parts. Those paying the first third of the taxes form an electoral assembly, and elect one-third of the city council ; those who pay the second third of the taxes elect another third of the council ; and the rest elect the remainder. Elections are by an absolute majority of votes; the voting by ballot. Every elector is eligible to office, but service is not obligatory. The elections are held once in four years. This complex system is intended to secure a vote for every person and institution interested in the welfare of the city, and for whose protection the city is instituted. It gives at the same time a preponderance of votes to a preponderance of wealth. How well it will work when reduced to practice remains to be seen. That economy in the administration of the city revenues and the minimum of taxation would follow seems almost certain. Asa city government passes no general laws, a vote for the pro- tection of the individual is by no means necessary. The imposition of a tax on lodgings and the admission of their hirers to vote—‘ household suffrage ’’—is to be considered by each city, and to be settled in a year by general law. The number of members in the city council varies with the number of electors. Where the electors age three hundred or less, there are thirty in the council, and for every one hundred electors beyond that six mem- bers are added, till the number reaches seventy-two. The council is pre- sided over by the mayor, and in certain affairs has a vote. As the city council represents the whole community, it acts in its name, and has full powers, among which is that of fixing the salaries of all city officers, and that of voting and revising the budgets. The council examines and takes action, on the initiative of the mayor or one of its members, on the propo- sition of the city regency or the government authorities, or on the demand or complaint of private persons. One third of the members forms a quorum, and a simple majority passes a measure, except that the purchase or sale of real estate, action on loans or guarantees, conversion of service in kind (paving and cleaning are done at present) to a money-tax, and removals and impeachments, which require a two-thirds vote, and where half the members must be present. The city regency or executive board corresponds to your elected or ap- pointed city officers, and is, as it were, the cabinet of the mayor. The num- ber of the members is fixed by the council, but there must be at least two besides the mayor, its president, though in very small towns the mayor has also the duties of the regency. It has the immediate charge of the execu- tive administration of the city interests, and on its proposition the council can appoint commissions or individuals to take measures necessitated by extraordinary circumstances, or to have the immediate direction of cer- tain branches of the city economy and administration, who need not be members of the council, but must have one of the members of the regency as president. The members of the regency have seats in the council, but not votes, unless members. The mayor, the regency, and the city secre- tary are elected by the council, and any elector can be chosen; but the mayor cannot be a Jew, and the secretary need not be an elector. The mayor holds office for four years, and the members of the regency go out half every two years. Substitutes are elected to fill their places in case of absence or disability. There are two or three other disabilities. Father and son, father-in-law and son-in law, and brothers, cannot be members of the regency at the same time ; and ecclesiastics, judges, government attor- neys, and officers of the treasury cannot hold a city office. The council appoints also all officers now appointed by the mayor or council, such as representatives in the police boards, and takes charge of whatever duties are now imposed on the city governments, the collection of Imperial taxes, the recruiting duties, etc. The revenues of the city come from a tax on real estate, which cannot exceed ten per cent. of its income or one per cent. of its appraised value ; The Nation. 3 } —_——— oe | and are now becoming in comparison almost clerks. | shrug of pettish resignation, beckon their especial cavaliers to a conti | various licenses for manufactures, trade, distilleries, etc., licenses for rea taurants, hotels, etc.; a tax on hacks and carts, a tax on private horses and carriages, a tax on dogs ; tance, which have always been paid to the city. and a few excise duties of very slight impor- The tax on lodgings will probably be granted also, but no other tax of any kind can be laid without a special Jaw of the Empire, Strict accounts must be kept and budgets regularly prepared, but the city expenditures are not subjected to the investigation of the Imperial control. It was strong)y urged by one party to give the city government power to make loans and give guaran- tees to works of public utility, such as banks and railways; but this per mission was, I think wisely, refused by the Government. There is one blot on this liberal measure. No Hebrew can be mayor, and not more than one-third of the city council or of the regeney can be non-Christians. In cities like Kazan and Orenburg, where at least half the population is Tartar, this seems hard; and there are many towns in the southwest where nine-tenths, or even more, of the population are Jers. There is one peculiarity about Russian reforms. What the Govern ment gives with one hand, it seems itching to take back with the other weing The necessity.of the mayor's election being there is so often some provision which hinders the measure from perfectly liberal. So here, confirmed by the Government ; the power given to the governor of gene ral supervision of the city government, though he is unable to interfere, except when he can allege a contravention of law or of the charter ; the right of the regency to disobey a command of the council which they be lieve to be illegal, and their reference of the dispute to the wovernor—all detract from the complete independence of the municipality. Granted, however, the necessity of the central government retaining some control the establishment of the special board for cities in each provinee, com posed half of elected, half of crown officers, seems the fairest and best way possible for settling the disputes of the two jurisdictions The reason of these hindrances can easily be seen. Here, for instance, are some sixty governors of provinces, who were formerly petty autocrata, Unless they are ex traordinarily enlightened and patriotic men, they will dislike every attempt to limit their powers, and as they are in constant communication with the central government, they will show in their reports the faults and weak spots of all the new measures, and what they say will naturally have its influence. Another new reform, which is now being worked out in a comi- | mission, treats directly of the powers of the governors and of the adminis tration in the provinces. It will be a sharp fight. Let us hope that i will end rightly, and that the provincial diets may set in earnest, as some have already begun, at the work of popular education, and then, when these new, self-governing institutions have taken root, we may expect the by a representative parliament and a respon When that “crowning of the edifice ” sible ministry, which will be the abdication of autocracy. will be depends doubtless in great measure on the action and fate of the new French Republic. There is always danger of reaction, M. FAVARGER'S FRENCH READINGS. THE conventional announcement, in the midst of a crowded salon, t! “Mr, —— or Miss will now favor the company with a little reading,” usually occasions a sensation more vivid and general than agreeable. ear ia int The gentlemen whose happy stars have placed them at that instant n the door slip off to the smoking-room, while the young ladies, wit! guous sofa behind the welcome shelter of curtains or a piano, and lighten the weary moments with a flirtation of glances if not of words. The feel ing is natural enough, and does less discredit to our social culture than might at first appear. In such amateur efforts, the imprisoned speciator must usually resign himself to a choice—alliterative but aggravating —- among prosiness, platitude, pretension ; and may esteem himself happy if he is not bored with all these. Setting aside the consideration of the original and innate taste and feeling possessed by most parlor-readers, it is safe to say that not one in three has the technical training indispensalle to their illustration. Good reading, quite as much as good acting, is a mat- ter of delicate mechanism, and should be the result of thorough and, at least, quasi-professional drill in the technicalities of the art. But this, as a very cursory glance over the ranks of our amateurs will show, very few possess, and the judicious critic will hardly sit through an average parlor. reading without having his taste, if not his common sense, offended, and his nerves uakindly tried by a glaring lack of the simplest and most ee
Page 10
r« ww —* (5 The Nation. [Number 283 - EE a ee mentary principles of technizue. The professional reader, on the other hand, js apt to sin in the opposite direction. Occupied as he has been with the details of his art, with inspiration and respiration, with whisper and or¢ ‘otundo, with aceent and inflexion, he is sadly apt to present an instance of technicality run mad. Ilis enthusiastic study of means and methods has led him unconsciously to exaggerate their importance, and, sinking the poet inthe professor, he not unfrequently treats the company to a bril liant and elaborate but unrefreshing fantasia on his own lungs and larynx. His effi- Were he working with the dry light of the pure understanding, nine-tenths of the spectators would prefer to take the book from his hands and retire to Ilis appeal, like the actor's, is far less to their brains than to their sentiments, their passions, or their imaginations. But for this he Scenery, music, costume, artificial light—all fade and dwindle to a little table,a handkerchief, a glass of Unaided by the varied personality and magnetic impulse of other actors, he must “in his time play many parts,” he must be himself the be-all and the end-all of his mimic scene. Little or no freedom, even of motion and gesture, is allowed him, and constraint of position is usually added to his other limitations. Then the scrutiny to His auditors have him at short focal range, both for eye and ear. When attentive—and what reader ?—they Jend him an attention which seems to be concentrated in inverse ratio to the size of the audience. Like Brutus, he finds Even the best of readers is in a somewhat trying position. ciency is, in strictness, picturesque and dramatic, not intellectual. digest it at leisure. lacks the actor’s accessories. water, and a pair of candles. which he is subjected is embarrassing. would wish them otherwise ** All his faults observed, Set in a note-book, learned and conned by rote.” In him an awkward movement or expression, harsh tone, or false inflexion, which in the more distracting atmosphere of the theatre might have escaped notice, is magnified under the microscopic examination of the parlor or music-room. Add to this that even the willing listener is often haunted with an anxiety that he is to be bored, and, expecting it, can hardly forgive the reader for disappointing him. This curious form of uneasiness is apt to retard the hearer’s pleasure or modify it, and not a few auditors at a really good reading, if they analyzed closely, would find mingling with their satisfaction a spice of resentment for having been interested as it were against their will. Yet these entertainments have some marked advantages. The reading of a well-selected programme by a skilful artist may be, and often is, an occasion of very refined and profound enjoyment. Such an interpretation is to the more glaring representation of the theatre as a predella of An- gelico or acabinet gem by Frére to a piece of Michael Angelo or an altar- piece by Rubens. Ondisturbed by the broad picturesqueness of the stage, the attention of the hearer is free to concentrate upon the more intellec- tual traits of the work—in grace of expression and subtle underlying chain of thought or feeling. The imagination and the emotions, too, may gain rather than lose by the close magnetic relation into which the reader is brought with his audience. Many a pathetic or passionate thrill of the voice or quiver of the feature, many a comical twinkle of the eye or sig- nificant twitch of the fingers, which would have been lost before the foot- lights, gets home to its mark, and will interest in the almost confidential relation of the reading circle. . To the careful student of belles-lettres, it is almost superfluous to remark that French literature offers an unsurpassed field for such enter- tainments. The subtle, almost impalpable, grace and wit of the best modern French work ; the exquisite fitness and proportion of its treat- ment; and the singular electric energy and dramatic fire which pervade French literature, as it does, or did, French life and character—all these qualities render the works of their really able authors, whether dramatic or lyric, especially fit for the use under discussion. De Musset, Delavigne, Hugo, Béranger, Nodier, and a host of others, offer a field for the selection of a programme, or of many programmes, which, in this view, it might be hard to parallel in any other language. With the exception of Robert Browning, probably no poet on our shelves so combines the dramatic and emotional with lyric grace and picturesqueness as Béranger or Victor Hugo, as exemplified in the “ Ballades” of the one or the “ Orientales” of the _ other. Both of these brilliant poets, with others as good, have frequent and honored place in the programme of the professor whose name heads our article, and on whose admirable interpretations these few remarks are but a form of comment. The cultivated public stand greatly in his debt, not only for the enterprise which has led him to organize the course, but for the fire, grace, and humor of his elocution and acting; for what Frenchman could read without acting? For his taste and feeling he has, of course, Nature to thank; his uncommon technical skill comes from careful training at the Paris Conservatoire. That his readings should be widely known or enjoyed, no one in his senses expects. Spite of geologic eternities (all individual experiences being sammed up), of boarding-house labor, of Noel and Chapsal, and Fleming and Tibbins, and Ollendorfi— spite of all the oceans of tears shed and all the peine forte et dure suffered “for talking English in class hours”—the sad, inexplicable fact still remains that not one young person in five really understands, or heartily enjoys, the reading of poem, tale, or play in real French. The satire of our italics will be appreciated by those who, armed with a com- petent knowledge of that nondescript and utterly imaginary dialect yclept boarding-school French, have taken a plunge into the bewildering practi- calities of the Boulevards or the Champs Elysées. An old German proverb says, “ As the old birds sing, so twitter the young ;” but the saying does not admit of conversion. The faint Gallic twitter of the collegian or the belle just out rarely deepens and swells into the full song of mature knowledge, but more frequently, alas! in the course of business cares or home duties, dies away into the inaudible. And thus it happens that the appreciative little audience which looks forward with such pleasure to M. Favarger’s Tuesday afternoons at the Union League theatre, is painfully select ; but they are heartily obliged to him for all that. Correspondence. SIR HENRY STORKS AND HIS FEMALE ASSAILANTS. To tne EpIToR OF THE NATION: Sir: It strikes me that a moral unsuspected by the writer lies in Mr. Webb's letter to you boasting that Sir Henry Storks lost his election at Colchester through the efforts of a lady who, no doubt as the emissary of her party, went down and plunged into the electioneering campaign against him because he was a supporter of the Contagious Diseases Act. Sir Henry Storks, as Mr. Webb truly says, is no ordinary man. He is one of the ablest and most upright of the public servants of England ; he has been the successful governor of more than one dependency in trying times; he combines in a singular degree humanity and liberality of senti- ment with military force of character ; and his appointment to the tempo- rary governorship of Jamaica after the disturbances was welcomed by the friends of a humane policy. His capacity and experience asa military administrator are at the present time greatly needed in the House of Commons. But he, it seems, is deprived of his seat in Parliament, and the country of his services, because he will not submit to thedictation of a party of ladies on a special question about which they have worked themselves up into a state of wholly disproportionate excitement. I have not the slightest prepossession in favor of the special provisions of the Contagious Diseases Act; but every one who knows the British Parliament must know that if the Act can be shown by trustworthy evidence and rational argu- ments to be injurious, it will be readily repealed, and that the frenzies of crusading fanaticism are absurdly out of place. It appears that the language of Sir Henry Storks, who is probably a greater master of things than of words, was infamously perverted by his opponents ; and any one who is familiar with British constituencies of the Colchester type can well imagine what a tempest of prurient hypocrisy would be raised by this slanderous appeal. But no sane woman, however excited about the Contagious Diseases Act, can pretend to believe that the intentions of such a man as Sir Henry Storks in supporting the Act were otherwise than moral. No doubt he holds that, in questions relating to the prevention of disease and the alleviation of human suffering, the dictates of medical science are the dictates of morality. As a military man, he knows the ravages which disease made in the army before the adoption of sanitary precautions, and the extent to which hereditary mala- dies were transmitted to the children of the soldiers who married after passing the years of early manhood in garrison towns. His high charac- ter and his professional responsibility forbid him to suppress for election- ecring purposes his convictions on a subject of so much importance to his profession. The other principles and interests represented in the candidature of Sir Henry Storks were of course left entirely out of sight ; nor, I presume, Ct wae SSM ee BPP wy on
Page 11
lls yf one Be SN OD @ y 4
SPLOT ORE
CPT ert
Dec. 1, 1870]
—— did the ladies pause to reflect that by procuring his rejection they were securing the election of a Tory, who will vote with his party for standing armies, which, whether the ladies will it or not, do universally and inevi- tably bring prostitution in their train. When we are acting on “ princi- ple,” to consider the real tendencies of our actions is treason to the cause. If the ladies personally engaged in this affair were eminent among their sex for talent and virtue, this only strengthens the moral to which | their conduct points. AN ENGLISIMAN. November 26, 1870. [Exactly ; this last sentence expresses what is passing in the minds of thousands who are watching the performances of the ladies who have entered the political arena. We let Mr. Webb's letter pass, too, without recalling Mrs. Josephine Butler’s outrageous attack on a gen- tleman of high standing, at the last meeting of the British Social Science Association, accusing him of indecency because he had visited hospitals ofa certain class in Algeria. He was absent when the charge was made; but went into the room in which she had performed this exploit, and pointed out to her the impropriety of her conduct, and informed her, what she apparently did not know, and had not taken the trouble to find out, that he was a physician of thirty years’ standing, and had visited the hospitals for scientific purposes. The reproof and expo- sure, however, did not elicit from her one word of apology or atone- ment of any kind, It may be said that men do these things to each ether; but then, men are still able to find in their homes the society of those who do not do them, and who, in having neither lot nor part in them, seem to do at least as much to “purify and elevate politics” as the new female politicians have given us any reason thus far to expect from female suffrage. And, as our correspondent says, seeing What these distinguished ladies who are now on the stump are capable of, people begin to ask what the state of things will be when the female Tweeds, Sweenys, and Fisks begin to come to the surface and “ manage” things.—Ep. Nation. } REAL UNIVERSAL SUFFRAGE AT LAST, To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: When in my last letter I intimated an intention of not again trespassing on your columns for the present, I little expected so soon to | g I have an occasion to revise my cecision. The reformer is, however, abroad, and the flippant article entitled “* The Feud in the Woman’s Rights Camp ” in your last issue calls in my mind for an antidote. It shall be no fault of mine if the readers of the ation are wholly mystified as to the best re- | sults of our most advanced thought. One point, and one point only, has for some time now troubled the advocates of female suffrage. It has been evident to us that the posture of political affairs was rapidly passing from bad to worse. That this was due to the vicious limitations confining the ballot to one sex only was indisputable ; for the stream will always rise to a level with its source, and if it fails to rise high it simply proves that the source is low. The enfranchisement of women promised much, but, as hitherto proposed, left much to be desired. To women, we believe, we must look for those pure, elevating, unimpassioned infiuences which shall lift politics out of the slums in which men have dragged them. Such grave questions as temperance, “ the social evil,” divorce, and that “ gen- eral cussidness,” if I may use the expression, which now make jails, re- formatories, and wars necessary or periodical, can only be vigorously dealt with through the introduction of women. Though this is or soon will be universally conceded, yet it was difficult to see how the suffrage as hitherto demanded would secure the desired reforms. To put the result beyond a doubt, a female preponderance seemed necessary—the women must, if necessary, be abie to vote down the men. I am rejoiced to see at last that even this final difficulty is solved. I need not add that this solution came from a woman; the clear, calm, men- tal vision of the sex at a glance saw that which the coarser masculine in- tellect had puzzled over in vain. In her speech, replete with mystic wis- dom of which Emerson must be proud, at the Women’s Peace Meeting in Boston on the 25th inst.—the day after your article appeared, and, as it were, in dignified response to it—Mrs. Julia Ward Howe made this notable ecntribution to the science of politics: “ Let the men vote and let the | women vote, and let every child a woman has given to the state give her an additional vote.” Much as I admired Mrs. Howe, I confess I was not The Nation. 367 , ———~——- —-- —- = = a ~ Se —-—-—- == <
prepared for the nice knowledge of legal principles indicated by this re markable utterance. That by the instinct of intuitive genius she should solve the whole suffrage question need surprise no one familiar with her mind ; that she should do it in absolute accordance with legal maxims is astonishing. All lawyers are constantly citing the rule, partus sequitur ventrem. Why, L ask, was it reserved for a woman (to make this nice ap- plication of it? This principle conceded, and the suiTrage question may be considered settled; the ballot will belong to all, even to the babe unborn. This simple, quiet solution of a question which has leng perplexed men called profound opens a sure way to those reforms which wholly de pend on female supremacy. ‘“ Let the men vote "—can we in justice de mand more ?——‘‘and let the women vote ’—can we in justice grant less? —and then partus sequitur ventrem—our own rule, mark you !—all children under age cast their ballots through their mothers. Others more familiar with the subject than I may correct me, but I venture to hazard the asser- tion that this application of a familiar principle is no less novel than startling, and that Mrs. Howe may new claim to be recorded among the rare minds who have contributed ideas absolutely new to political science After this, can even you assert that women have not the legal instinct ? A SENTIMENTALIST, Boston, Nov. 27, 1870. [We clearly foreshadowed this reform some time ago in an article on “Baby Suffrage,” which “ A Sentimentalist ” evidently wishes people to believe he has not seen, and in which we boldly claimed the sufrage for young children, on the grounds with which the Woman Suffray
’ t controversy has made the world so familiar, Of course, our demand was received with jeers and abuse; but this did not move us. We knew we had sown the seed, and we now begin to see the fruit. The proposal of the women to have the children counted in the basis of representation, and have votes cast for them by thcir mammas, as * trustees,” just as the slavcholders were said to be “trustees” for the negroes, and the English oligarchs for the unenfranchised masses, and as the male voters for the women, is but the first step in a movement which will eventually put the ballot where it belongs, in the child's own hands, and then we shall have an end to infanticide, and, better than ail, a final solution of the corporal-punishment question, the pro-
| per settlement of which can never be expected from adult parents and school-trustees. The world is sick of trusts and trustees; they are both | mediwval devices in aid of human bondage. In the new era nobody will “ trust ” anybody else; everybody wil! paddle his own canoe, take sare of No, 1, and carry his property about with him on his person, The first step toward this is the abolition of the present degrading | dependence of babies on their weak and tyrannical mothers and nurses. —Ep. Narion.] Notes.
LITERARY. Messrs. SHeipon & Co. will shortly republish Victor Hugo’s “Na. poleon the Little,” as being a prophecy worth reading now. They have oo also in press a selection of the best minor poems in the English language, | entitled “ Our Poetical Favorites,” by Professor A. C, Kendrick, of Rochester University ; and a new story by Mrs. Jane G. Austin: “ The Shadow of Messrs. Roberts Brothers announce for next week Gq. W. Carleton will publish immediately a posthumous work on Italy by Mrs, Anna Cora Ritchie, entitled “ Italian Life and Legends,” with illustrations of Italian scenery. Moloch Mountain.” “ Brevia: Short Essays and Aphorisms,” by Arthur Helps.
| —Messrs. Hurd & Houghton have completed the American edition of | that truly grand performance, Dr. William Smith’s “ Dictionary of the Bible, comprising its Antiquitiea, Biography, Geography, and Natural History ;"’ and, now that the task is finished, we cannot refrain from | repeating the eulogy with which, three years ago, we greeted the incipient | enterprise. The American editors, Prof. Hackett and Dr. Ezra Abbot, | have deserved well of the literary world and the Bible-studying public in general by the excellent revision they have bestowed upon the work, as well as by the numerous additions with which they have enhanced its value. As it now is, it may justly be said to represent the best acknow]-
Page 12
yea) 36) = = SS —- — The Nation. [Number 283 edged biblical scholarship of both England and America—though cer- | a gentleman who was very fond of the University. So long had he dene | its printing that he had acquired by prescription a right to be so em. | ployed ; he had honored the institution by naming his press after it; he ' had come to love it so mach-that he had put it down in his will for a large | sum of money, and would, says the story-teller, have very likely, if he had tainly not the most advanced criticism of the age—and in technical exe- cution to rival the finest publications of a similar character. Among the original contributors—about threescore and ten—we find Dean Alford, Canon Blakesley, Emanuel Deutsch, Bishop Ellicott, Farrar, Bayard, Lightfoot, Oppert, E. H. Plumptre, J. L. Porter, George Rawlinson, Dean | Stanley, and a number of other distinguished writers, to whom the list of writers for the American edition adds the names of Prof. Bartlett, Dr. Conant, Prof. Day, Prof. Fisher, Prof. Gardiner, ete. The latter edition consists of four volumes, of about nine hundred closely printed octavo pages cach. It is still sold by subscription. ' see it go elsewhere. ; another printer. —A heavy loss has befallen Nassau Street in the death on Sunday of | Mr. William Gowans, who for forty years had been par excellence the an- tiquarian bookseller and publisher of New York. He was born in the parish of Lismahagow, county of Lanark, Scotland, on the 29th of March, 1805, and removed with his parents to this country in June, 1821, landing at Philadelphia in July of that year, and immediately removing with them to Crawford County, Indiana. In September, 1830, he commenced business in this city as a bookseller at No. 121 Chatham Street, near Pearl. From this small beginning he became at last the leading antiqua- rian bookseller in the country, with a bibliographical knowledge unsur- passed, and with a sound and sure taste in publishing. His first venture was Plato’s “ Phedon,” in 1833. His last, to our knowledge, was the “ Bibliotheca Americana,” which a year ago had reached its fifth volume with the reprint of Alsop’s “ Character of the Province of Maryland,” no- ticed at the time in the Nation. Mr. Gowans was naturally of a very amiable and kindly disposition, and if he at times had the appearance of crabbedness it was due partly to his native frankness and partly, no doubt, to a constitutional headache which never forsook him. His death will excite universal regret in literary circles. —We have already mentioned the fact that Mr. John Langdon Sibley, the chief librarian at Harvard College, has in preparation a biographical record of the first two hundred and twenty-five men who were graduated at Cambridge. ‘The work is, indeed, in the printer’s hand, and will appear as soon as there shall be obtained the number of subscribers requisite to cover the expense of publication. It will be sold to subscribers only, will not be stereotyped, will be excellent as a specimen of typography, and will for these reasons, apart from its biographical and historical value, be very well worth the attention of even such book-buyers as may not take in it the interest which it will have for those whose kinsmen by blood, or by the aflinity of having a common Alma Mater, are commemorated in its pages. Its historical and biographical value will, however, be not incon- siderable, Mr. Sibley being already known as a worker in the field of Massachusetts local history ; and his painstaking labor in the making of this book having covered a long term of years, and been expended in care- ful and minute research, some of the matter which he has discovered is curious and interesting, but most of what he has to present is, of course, material of the sort which, however it may serve as the basis of the pictorial writings in which some future romancer or historian or essayist shall reconstruct colonial history, is in itself certainly not picturesque. How valuable it is the best pictorial writer best knows. “I myself,” says, in substance, Arthur Clough, in speaking of a new volume of Macaulay's “History,” “ have as yet discovered but one blunder, and that a small one, but it is characteristic. ‘The oaks of Magdalen,’ he says. They are not oaks at all, they are elms; but the temptation to be particular was irresis- tible.” To be particular, and to be at the same time exactly truthful, it is the business of such books as this of Mr. Sibley’s to make possible—books unwisely scoffed at by many who should know better, and by some who do know better. We had not intended to say so much about the work in question ; no harm is done, however, if our mention of it shall help to bring up the list of subscribers, Harvard men or others, to the necessary number. Some sixty or more new names are, we believe, wanted, and, of course, as soon as may be. We may add that the volume will be an octavo, and the paper will be of the best quality, the same as that of Up- ham’a “ Witeheraft,” while the work will be done at the press of Welch & Bigelow. The mention of this press reminds us of a little story, as Mr. Lin- coln used to say. It is a little story with a moral; and it was invented for the benefit of a “certain University, whose name begins with an H and ends with a D,” and which is situated at “Charlésbridge ;” and it first saw the light in the columns of a certain Boston evening paper, the name of which we think we shall not give. The fable of which we speak asserts that the university at “ Charlesbridge ” for many years employed as its printer | poor catalogue than it paid before for an admirable catalogue. been asked to do so, printed the college catalogue for nothing, rather than The university, however, in a recent fit of small economy, forgets the honor this gentleman had done it by naming his press after it, and, being ignorant that it is down in his will for a large sum of money, overrides his prescriptive right, and gives its printing to A lawyer is now sent for, the will in question is altered, the bequest to the university being stricken out, and the upshot of the matter is that the foolish institution of learning loses twenty-five thousand dollars in cash, and will probably, this year, pay more money for a very Pretty obviously one would say, all this is nobody’s business but the printer's and the university authorities’; and it is as decidedly his and their private business as the tailor’s bills of those gentlemen. But, now that it is made matter of public comment, a remark or two is here in place. It is need- less to point out the cleverness of the argument that the college should have been influenced by its knowledge of the bequest of which it was ig- norant, and of which in this ignorance it is said to have deprived itself. This peculiar sort of cleverness is common to the whole class of writers | and talkers who devote themselves to the making or spreading of such tales as the one we have summarized ; the snake described by medieval naturalists as the amphisbena—which is provided with a venomous head at each extremity, each of which is capable of despatching the other—might very well be taken as their crest by the entire tribe of them. A true but unpractised brother of the guild was he of whom it is somewhere related that he once wrote to his friend a scurrilous “ anonymous letter,” denounc- ing the friend’s intended wife—a lady who had been a cook, he said, and was given to intemperance—and then inadvertently signed his full name to it. Happily it was in duelling days, and the other gentleman fought him, and prevailed against him, and stopped iis writing of anonymous letters. Our fabulist’s prediction as to the probable quality of the new printer’s workmanship is another pleasant and characteristic stroke, this contingent belying and detracting being another stick with which all of this flock are tarred. Doubtless the probability is that the university has given reasonable attention to securing the kind of work it wants, and at the price it thought good. As for the prescriptive right above-mentioned we do not see how it could be established. There would seem to be no reason why So-and-so should do my work at rates, say ten per cent. or two per cent. or twenty per cent. higher than those at which another man will do the same work equally well. Universities especially, which, in this country at least, are all very poor, are bound to make their money go as far as they possibly can. As for the honor and benefit conferred upon the “ Charlesbridge” university by the naming of the press, we should say that any member of the university who should maintain that there was honor and benefit conferred upon as well as by the printing establish- ment, might have good hope of making out his case. But it was not our purpose, nor bave we the necessary knowledge, to go into the details of the story. It is no affair of ours; and it comes without proofs of its statements, and comes in a way so suspiciously like a malicious invention or perversion of facts, that it should be disregarded both by the friends of the highly respectable man, now dead, after an honorable life of hard work, who is made to appear in it, and by the friends of the university. Oar purpose was to ask for renewed attention to one of the disgraces of journalism. ~-In view of such disgraces, it might be worth while to introduce into this country the use of the postal cards which have been found so ser- viceable to the French and German soldiers, and which the English, too, have adopted. Possibly they might do something towards abolishing the scurrilous editor, who certainly flourishes about as rankly now as ever before in the history of our journalism, though we suppose he is more clearly known for a rascal and a pest than formerly he was, and suppose, too, that the proportion of the decent men to the indecent in journalism is now greater than ever. The “high-toned” editor of the good old times was pretty often an unscrupulous party hack ; and pretty generally he was an ill-informed old braggart, too, whose “eloquent editorials ” would have had not much left in them (except some traditionary bits of good sense from “ The Federalist ” and the Constitution), if, for instance, they had all been treated as Webster treated President Harrison’s annual message. He had just done a good morning’s work, he told a friend of RRR No ¥ sate
Page 13
— Ve eee ES 6 ommeaews sev es oO ahd, REE IRR TERE ty AE eal Dee. 1, 1870] his; he had been with the President, and had succeeded in getting we forget how many “ Roman proconsuls out of the message,” and much other similar Greek and Roman matter. To-day there is room for improve- ment, of course; but we imagine that there is more sense, wit, knowl. edge, and honesty in our journals than even a gentleman of the old school would be able to discover in files of the journals of the immortal Mr. Daniel of Richmond, or General Jackson’s Mr. Blair, or Mr. Prentiss. Our existing scurrilous papers are, however, villanously bad, no doubt ; for impudent handling of the affairs of private life, for malicious attacks on private character, for political dishonesty and greed, for cynical devo- tion to money-getting, for downright hard lying, for their indifference to common decency, not to say their preference for sensational indecency, for their frivolous personalities, we suppose they have never been excelled. The famous “stout oak stick” on which Dr. Johnson immediately laid out a sixpence when he had information that it was Mr. Sam Foote’s in- tention to portray him at one of that gentleman’s divertisements, is really about the only instrument of criticism which it is proper to employ in commenting on the performances of certain gentlemen of our daily and weekly press. The doctor never otherwise so well earned his title of the Great Moralist—if indeed the title was not purchased there and then when the stick changed hands. Some stories that we hear are false, or itis a fact that something recently very like this Johnsonian method of criticism has been efficaciously applied to certain editors who might be mentioned. —Our notion in regard to the postal cards was suggested by what is told of the English use of them. They are meant to be used for the transmission of short messages, as to which the sender and the receiver are indifferent whether or not all the world reads them. It has been found, however, in these first days of the trial of them, that they furnish what seems to many people an irresistible temptation to send to objects of their displeasure opprobrious and insulting messages. For instance, a lady desirous of fo- menting domestic discord may write a postal card to the husband of the family whose peace it is desired to disturb, and cause it to be delivered when he is absent and his wife is not. This card, the assumption is, the wife will of course read, and that the consequence will be “ incompatibil- ity ” of greater or less duration and savageness. Or a discontented trades- man may successfully impart to all a man’s servants that he thinks he “has waited about long enough,” with the result of bringing upon the debtor the contumelious regards of the kitchen girl who receives the missive, and also of importing deeper bitterness into the remarks of the cook when she is discharged for peculation. So of all other weaknesses and crimes. . They may, by means of the postal card system, be so im- puted toa man that some members at least, and very likely all, of the circle immediately about him, and whose good opinion is of most impor- tance to him, shall distinctly know that he stands so indicted. It is in this particular that the postal card writer has the advantage over the writer for scurrilous newspapers. The latter cannot be sure that a man’s wife, for example, will read the next morning’s—National Intelligencer, let us say for safety’s sake. Ile may fling as much mud as his talents permit, and with the best will, and yet it may all fall innocuous. For pur- poses of general defamation of public persons the newspaper would no doubt still be used; but we may fancy that some of the libellers of private men would feel it better to employ their abilities in the devising of postal card messages than in putting their rascality into print. Another advantage would be that there would probably be some, though a small, opportunity for retaliation upon the libeller ; slender and delicate persons might properly prefer the retaliatory postal card to the stout oak stick above-mentioned or the revolver—instruments that now afford nearly the only resource open to the public. —The Proceedings of the Massachusetts Historical Society for June to September, inclusive, contain a clear and interesting account by the President, Hon. Robert C. Winthrop, of a singular suit which the Legis. lature of Massachusetts has directed the Attorney-General to bring against the Society, to recover certain original documents known as “ The Hutchinson Papers.” It appears from this statement that in 1819 and 1820 the Secretary of the Commonwealth presented the Society with sun- dry letters and papers “ saved,” as he described them to the Legislature in the following year, “from the riot at Gov. Hutchinson’s house—some of them of a private nature, and some of them public documents collected by him probably as materials for his History of Massachusetts and a volume of State Papers which he had published.” These he did not re- gard ‘‘as belonging to the Government, or as any part of the records of the Commonwealth, or ancient colony or province,” and accordingly, with the then Governor's permission, he deposited a part of them, “ valuable The N ation. 369 chiefly for their antiquity,” with the Historical Society, as already men tioned. In 1846, and again in 1847, Dr. Palfrey, the historian, then Sec retary, sought to reclaim the decuments for the Commonwealth, but the Society adopted the report of a special committee that the State had not the shadow of a claim to them,and that the statute of limitations might properly be invoked against any such claim. In 1867, the Legislature re- opened the controversy, and has ended by ordering a prosecution of the Society. It seems quite unlikely that the court should dispossess the de- fendants, who mean to contest. They will do so for the principle in volved rather than for the sake of keeping the letters, which have either been copied or printed, and are no longer indispensable. —Very interesting memorial notices of the late Hon. John P. Kennedy and Rev. Dr. N. L. Frothingham are contained in these same Proceed ings. A letter from Rev. R. C. Waterston, written from San Francisco, men tions a national service of the Jate Mr. Stanton which is far from being generally known. One may now examine in San Francisco a collection of about one thousand volumes, mostly manuscript, constituting the body of Spanish and Mexican archives which fell into the hands of the United States Government when it took possession of California. They were concealed at first at Los Angeles, but finally brought to Monterey. To 1851, Government placed them in charge of the surveyor-general—a very proper disposition, since six hundred of the volumes relate to grants of land. “In 1858,” continues Mr. Waterston, “the Hon. Edwin M. Stanton came officially to this place, and found the papers disarranged, and more than one-half (now in this collection) were still in other parts of the coun try. By his influence and under his oversight, they were brought to gether, systematically arranged, and substantially bound.” In addition to royal decrees, official orders and correspondence of the Mexican Vice- roys, correspondence of the Governors of the Province from 1775 to 1844, records and correspondence relating to missions, presidios, and pueblos, and civil, military, ecclesiastical, legislative, and judicial reeords, there are miscellaneous records of current domestic history, and, what is especially valuable, “correspondence by navigators of different nations, in as many as ten languages—documents dating as far back as 1767,” and containing a history of the coast from Cape Horn to Columbia River, for a hundred years. “ Here are manuscripts relating to Vancouver (dated 1795); also to the celebrated voyage of Captain Cook, together with accounts of Prussian admirals, Eaglish captains, and French ex plorers.” —Among the clever pictures which the [talian correspondent referred to a fortnight ago gives of Paris under siege, is one of the club called the “ Folies Bergéres,” question whether, seeing that the Prussians impressed the peasants to work on their fortifications, the Prussian prisoners should, in return, be made to work on the defences of the city. The generosity of the French character and republican fraternity made the negative prevail ; and it was very well so, inasmuch as at that date (September 25) there were no Prus- sian prisoners in Paris. The same club in its debates was in the habit of referring to the provinces as if they were Patagonia, and their inhabit- ants as if they were South Sea savages—ignorant, stupid, imbruted, des- titute of patriotism. All this, in hearing of the mablots or Gardes Mobiles from the same provinces. How to “civilize” these wretched inhabitants of France? “ Persuade them,” says one, “ that their interest requires them to rise en masse, or else the Prussians will burn their houses and drive off their cattle.” “ Not so,” says another; “we must go among them with an iron hand and unlimited powers, inspire them with fear, and compel them to be republicans, and obey Paris.” The club does a more sensible thing when it asks /igaro by what means it obtained its pretended report (made, of course, out of whole cloth) of a council of war at the Prussian headquarters, what it paid for it, and how the editor manages to keep up direct communication with the enemy. Quite different is the club at the Théatre Porte St. Martin, whose leading spirits and orators are Yung and Ratisbonne, of the Débats, Pressens¢é, and Cocquerel—a club which, if times were not changed, might seem to revive that of the Girondists, especially as it is one of the few at which one may address his andience 2s “ Messieurs ” without being hissed. Crowds attend, and an admission fee of twenty-five centimes is collected. “guardians of the peace” which, he says, discussed for an hour one night the The correspondent tells of the whom Ké¢ratry substituted for the gendarmes, taking away their arms, and disguising them as much as possible. He made them shave their moustaches and imperials, and wear their hair combed down over their foreheads; from this circumstance, and because of the great hood which they wore on their coats, the populace dubbed them capuchins. They were instructed to walk three by three, soberly,
Page 14
and with downcast eyes. The result was that they had to be saved by the National Guard from the attacks of malefactors. By night one meets the vs de nuit—five men, carrying a lanthorn on a pole, and charged gruel to look out against fires—the watchmen of the Middle Ages. —As for news, says this correspondent, in his diary for October 25, the eagerness for it is so great that when German newspapers fall into the hands of the Parisians, they are immediately reproduced, and, to add to their value, are imitated in form and makeup. Such a paper, found on the body of some Prussian victim of a sortie or reconnoissance, is carried as a prize to the office of some one of the Paris journals, which makes a great parade in announcing it. English papers excite a still greater sen- sation. On one memorable occasion, at Bagneux, a cutlet was found wrapped in a piece of the Morgen-Post—a double treat (due regali in uno). 300k literature has not perished utterly, for Victor Hugo had printed the first French edition of his “ Chatiments,” preceded by a beautiful poem hitherto unpublished, entitled “ Le Retour.” The profits were destined to swell the subscriptions for cannon. The siege has seemed, too, a good opportunity in which to bring out of its obscurity the statue of Voltaire, aud set it in a more commanding position—in that previously occupied by the statue of Eugéne Beauharnais, in the Place formerly of the same name, but henceforth to be called, along with the boulevard, after the new incumbent. With so much more serious business clamoring for the best energies of every citizen, this renaming of streets, tearing down of odious insignia, and casting and melting of statues, in which Paris has been indulging since the 4th of September, is one of the most striking evidences of incapacity to face the situation. The logic of it would seem to be that the Republic could not be carried on in sight, say, of the Avenue de l' Impératrice, or that if Boulevard Haussmann becomes Boule- vard Victor IIugo the Republic will be assured—and Paris impregnable. HARTT’S BRAZIL.* In this volume, of over 600 pages, we have one of the results of that expedition to Brazil which, by the generosity of Mr. Nathaniel Thayer, of Boston, was undertaken by Prof. Louis Agassiz and his companions in 1865-66. The director of the expedition has already in his pleasant nar- rative given us a general account of the journey and many of its results, but it was reserved for future publications to give the completed studies of the various branches of natural history whose investigation was in- cluded in the labors of the party. Fortunately for science, the task of thus investigating the geology and physical geography of Brazil was by Prof. Agassiz assigned to his companion and former pupil, Mr. Charles Frederick Hartt, now professor of these sciences at Cornell University, who, to prepare himself more fully for his work, returned to Brazil in 1867, and there spent several months. The results of his completed studies are given in the volume before us. The author has, as he tells us, examined more or less critically the works of the principal investigators who had preceded him in this field, so that his book, instead of being a simple report of Prof. Hartt’s own observations, has grown into a general work, “in which have been incorporated the best results of others who have written on the geology and physical geography of Brazil.” For this critical labor, and for the numerous citations and references showing the extent of our author’s acquaintance with the literature of his subject, the student cannot be too grateful, the more so as many of the works citéd are rare. It is no easy task, in the short space of our columns, to give an adequate notion of the varied and important information with which this work is filled; but we propose to call attention to some of the points which have specially attracted us in the perusal of it. As regards the name of the country, which is that of a red dye-wood, known to Europeans before the discovery of this continent, and then brought from the East Indies, our author is apparently in doubt both as to the etymology of the word and the reason for applying it to the eastern coast of South America. A reference to Webster's Dictionary, however, gives a seemingly satisfactory solution of the deuble problem. We are there told that the name of Brazil, from the Portuguese braza, a glowing coal or fire, given to this bright, and then highly prized, red dye-wood, was by King Emanuel applied to this newly-discovered land because it abounded in what, under the name of Brazil-wood, is still an object of commerce from th ut country. * “Scientific Results of a Journey in Brazil. By Ch. Fred. Hartt.” Fields, Ca sood & Co. 1870. The Nation. [Number 283 For the better understanding of the book a photo-lithographed sketch- map, on a considerable scale, compiled by Prof. Hartt from the best sources, is prefixed to the volume. The data for an accurate geographical delinea- tion of the country are still wanting. Several sma!l maps and sections and numerous wood-engravings, chiefly from drawings by Prof. Hartt, serve to illustrate the work; many of them are of considerable artistic merit. Our author takes up, one after another, the description of the several provinces to which his studies extended, and gives details of their geological character, including notes on the altitude of the rocks, their mineralogy and their lithology; while, in the case of the fossi- liferous strata, their organic remains are carefully noted, and in many eases descriptions of new species are given, constituting important con- tributions to paleontology. The studies in the recent zodlogy of Brazil, which are scattered throughout this book, are also very valuable, and have been furnished partly by the author himself and in part by several American naturalists, whose aid is acknowledged in the preface, among them Messrs. Marsh, Hyatt, and Verrill. Prof. Agassiz, we regret to learn, has by illness been prevented from giving with this volume his descrip- tions of the great collections of fishes made during the expedition. The botany has not been neglected, and lists of the most characteristic and valuable plants are given in describing the various regions. The geographical features of the country are described at length, and our author, inspired by the beauties of the natural scenery, sometimes for- gets his concise and scientific style, and records his impressions in lan- guage which betrays the poet. Of the view from the summit of the Corcovado, near Rio, he says: “If the geologist has any soul, any love for the beautiful, there is no scene which, with all his cold analysis of topo- graphical and geological elements, is more likely to impress him as an artist's work.” This is followed by a fine piece of description, which, did space permit, we would gladly copy (pages 11 and 12). Nor are economic considerations overlooked ; we have valuable information as regards soil, timber, and the cultivation of the most important crops, while the coal-mines of the southern provinces are described in much de- tail, and shown to be of great richness. In chapter xviii. will be found a careful account of the gold mines of the empire, considered both from a geological and an economic point of view. To this last chapter succeeds a summary of the results to which our author has arrived with regard to the geology of Brazil. From the facts observed by himself, and by those who have preceded him in the same field, he has been enabled to give a general notion of the geognostical structure of the country, and to establish certain very instructive compari- sons between it and the eastern parts of North America. We can only here call attention to two or three points of interest. The weathering, or the softening and disintegration of hard crystal- line rocks under the influence of the elements is well known to observers as a process which goes on in some regions with great rapidity. In our latitude, however, it is very slow, and the granite-like rocks of the North- ern United States, where protected by a thin layer of soil, still bear un- effaced on their surfaces the ice-markings of the glacial period ; while even the naked summits of the White Hills, after ages of exposure to the changes of the seasons, are but very slightly and superficially dis- integrated. As we go southward, however, these conditions are greatly changed ; in our Southern States the crystalline stratified rocks are found to be softened and altered to such depths from the surface as to sur- prise Northern geologists, and this condition of things is still more marked in parts of Brazil. In the province of Rio de Janeiro, the great mountain belt of the Serro do Mar consists of a crystalline gneiss, often granitic, and probably, as supposed by Williamson and by Hartt, of Lau- rentian age—that is to say, belonging to the same system of rocks as the Highlands of the Hudson. Beneath a layer of unstratified drift and gravel, which generally mantles around these hills in the province of Rio, the gneiss is found te be softened and decomposed to depths of from a few inches to one hundred feet. The feldspar has been turned into clay from the loss of a part of its constituents by solution, yet the crum- bling products of decay still retain their original positions, as shown by the lines of stratification and by the intersecting veins of quartz. The causes which have produced this singular alteration of the rocks have been a subject of much speculation. Darwin, who studied the phenom- enon in Brazil, supposed the change to have taken place beneath the sea—a conclusion which to the chemist is scarcely admissible. There is no doubt that the view advocated by Prof. Hartt, and by most chemical geologists, is in the main the true one, and that the process of alteration is dependent upon the action of warm rain-waters holding in solution, besides
Page 15
iis MAE OD we Dec. 1, 1870] carbonic acid from the air, nitrate of ammonia, and perhaps nitric acid, which are frequent products of thunder-showers in tropical regions. Prof. | Hartt, moreover, suggests that the organic matters, more or less acid in their nature, resulting from the decay of vegetation, may have aided the solvent action of the waters, and notes that this remarkable decomposition has only taken place in regions anciently or at present covered with forest. Inasmuch, however, as it is only in rainy districts which support an abun- dant vegetation, it would not seem by this relation alone to be established that the products of vegetable decay were in any way instrumental in effecting the alteration of the rocks, although the suggestion has chemical considerations in its favor. In any view, this softening of the rocks is a subject upon which we look for further light. It is well known that cer- tain granitic rocks, even in England, are subject to this change; while others, apparently similar, have great power of resistance. In the present state of our knowledge, there is something mysterious in this softening of hard felspathic rocks by a process which is, to a certain extent, analo- gous with the mouldering of wood, and is not to be confounded with the mechanical crumbling down of certain brittle rocks by the action of the weather, in which frost plays an important part. The great wasting and wearing away of crystalline rocks in former geological periods, of which we have abundant evidence, is less difficult to be understood when we learn that rocks as hard as those of our New York Highlands become, even in our own time, under certain conditions, so softened as to offer little more resistance to the eroding action of a torrent than an ordinary gravel- bed. Closely connected with this phenomenon in Brazil is that of the glacial drift. When Prof. Agassiz, on his return from Brazil, told us of evidences of the action of ice beneath the tropics, and as near the equator as latitude 8° south, the statement was so surprising that, notwithstanding his great | authority, it was received by many with doubts. On his second visit to Brazil, however, Prof. Hartt gave especial attention to this question, and he gives us good reasons for maintaining that the unstratified, coarsely- ground detritus which overlies alike the disintegrated gneisses and the more recent deposits, and is found both on the mainland and on the islands off the coast, is in all respects similar in its character and mode of occurrence to the so-called glacial drift of our northern regions. He be- lieves that at the time of its production the country stood at a much higher level than at present, and was covered by a general glacier, which, in its passage over the previously decomposed rocks, ground up the superficial layer, spreading it as a paste over the surface, where it was left after the melting of the glacier. We confess that the scepticism which we shared with many others as to the glacial drift of Brazil, is overcome by the evi. dence furnished by Prof. Hartt. This unstratified layer, however, in many parts of the country, reposes not upon the gneiss, but upon stratified clays and sands, which were by Prof. Agassiz supposed to belong to the drift, and thus contributed to swell greatly the extent of the drift forma- tion as defined by him, but are supposed by Prof. Hartt to be really older deposits, and of tertiary age. It thus appears that while fully sus- taining the discovery of glacial drift in tropical Brazil, our author ex- cludes from it much of the material which Prof. Agassiz had referred to that period. The comparisons between the geology of Brazil and that of the great Appalachian region of North America are very instructive, showing cer- tain homologies between the northern and southern divisions of our con- tinent. We have already noticed the Laurentian age of the Serro do Mar ; The Nation. ee and the greenish, micaceous, and chloritic schists, with diorites, horn- | blende rocks, and crystalline iron ores of the interior of Bahia, suggest the Huronian system (p. 298). The great mass of mica schists, however, in their general characters approached those cf the White Mountains of New England ; while the gold-bearing strata of Brazil, according to Professor Hartt, bear striking resemblances to those of Nova Scotia. These litho- | logical similarities appear to be confirmed by the stratigraphical relations, showing how widely spread were the conditions which presided over the rock formations at these early periods of the world’s history, and opening new vistas of study in comparative geology, as pointed out in the note by Dr. Sterry Hunt on page 550. We must not conclude our notice of this instructive volume without again mentioning the fact, already noticed in our columns, that Professor Hartt, together with the professor of botany from Cornell and a large party of students, has spent the last few months in Brazil. The return of the party may soon be expected, and they will, doubtless, bring a rich har vest of materials for the further elucidation of the natural history of Brazil. i 1 ww -~| BELL'S TRAVELS IN NORTH AMERICA.* Ir is not always the oldest or the most familiar proverbs which carry the most complete conviction. Occasionally, the very disgust produced in the mind by the wearisome repetition of a popular saying tends to blunt its effect on the imagination. It has been so often dinned into our ears that ‘* Westward the star of empire takes its way,” and we have not infre- quently found so much of crudeness or vulgarity in the people most fond of urging the assertion, or in the methods of its enforcement, that one might almost be pardoned for regarding this well-worn apothegm with callousness, if not with resentful distrust. It may be perfectly true that the sceptre is passing westward ; but the cultivated denizen of the Fast- ern slopes finds it hard to believe, and certainly very unpalatable when demonstrated. The Lowell manufacturer among his mills, the Broad. way or Church Street importer going to his business through miles of commercial palaces, the Yale or Harvard professor sauntering through the venerable grounds of his beloved university, or the Fitth Avenue dandy fluttering his idle hour at Newport and Saratoga—each and all of these will naturally struggle against the disagreeable conviction that his wealth, his enterprise, his learning, or his fashionable splendor may. iu an assignable period, be utterly thrown into the shade by the glories of some nascent metropolis in Arizona, Oregon, or California. Perhaps the main value of such a book as Dr. Bell’s to the general reader is the brisk stirring up of our ideas on this subject which it cannot fail to produce, and the renewed confirmation it lends to a truth which we would gladly overlook if we could. Though it may not convince us that New York and Philadelphia, Chicago and Cincinnati, are in immediate danger of becoming subsidiary to Santa Fé, or Denver, or Sacramento, it will greatly aid in clearing our notions about the great wave of West ern progress, and furnish us with invaluable details for computing its scope and impetus. The author, a cultivated English physician and man of science, was appointed in 1867 to the position—nothing better offer. ing—of photographer on the surveying expedition sent out by the Kansas Pacific Railway Company, “to determine upon the best route for a south ern railway to the Pacific coast through Kansas, Colorado, New Mexico, Arizona, and the southern part of California.” A vacancy in the corps shortly after its departure enabled him to take the more congenial position of physician to the expedition, which turned out to be a mere sinecure, / and allowed him leisure for the extended and minute observations on physical geography, botany, geology, and mineralogy, with still farther comments on habits and social condition of the races met in his journey, which he has embodied in the bulky volume before us. His photographie tastes, also, when once contracted, did not desert him, and the book is en- riched with very good illustrations from views taken with his own hands. The work is a combination of the book of travels and the scientific report, and,as such, not altogether satisfactory reading for the general student. Dr. Holmes’s witty criticism on a similar work, that, like the mermaid, it was impossible to tell where the fish ended and the lady began, is here applicable. Probably, the ditliculty must be regarded as inseparable from the nature of such books; certainly the present volume has so inex- tricably mingled the statistical, the adventurous, and the picturesque that almost any one class of readers will have to take it with great allowance ; the would-be speculator, miner, or contractor will grumble at the space wasted on Indian fights and sketches of scenery; the after-dinner reader, ar tious only for pleasant excitement, will often get inextricably strayed in the mazes of Western geography, or hopelessly bewildered with the details of Rocky Mountain metals, products, and flora. Of its two merits—interest and information—the latter must be considered as pre- dominant. Wild and adventurous as such a journey must needs be, the relation of stirring or thrilling incident, or the painting of picturesque scenes, is kept subsidiary to the main object of the book as of the expedition—the furnishing detailed and exact information about the coun- try in every regard which could affect the location of the proposed railway. In all these matters the author seems to have been worthy of the highest praise, as indefatigable in the collection of his facts, at whatever risk and trouble to himself, as simple and concise in his statement. In an enter | prise where personal observation is of the highest importance, where the ipse vidi of the writer would bear a value higher than Cwsar’s, he miplit be excused if his narrative were plentifully sprinkled with capital I's. Bat the doctor is one of the modest and reticent type so common among his countrymen. Though he seems to have smelled powder more thin once, and though his scalp must occasionally have felt an unpleasant * “ New Tracks in North America. By Wm. A. Beil.” London: Chapman & [all. New York: G. P. Putnam & Sons. 1870. ‘anes :
Page 16
6) = OT: The Na creeping at the near prospect of Soiadlio ain knives, he tells his story simply and almost barely, with a quiet stoicism which the red | man, his assailant, might envy. After certain very terrible and pathetic scenes, Where most writers would have been profusely lachrymose or im- with brief comment and little or no sentiment. For purposes of interest we could wish him less reserved, and in view of the rich material under lis hands for picturesque description or thrilling narrative, we could par- don a little more of that fascinating, if untrustworthy, imagination which enlivens the pages of Dixon or Ludlow. Principal elements of difficulty in the problem of running a railroad across the continent are heights, cations, and lack of water and fuel. To all these points our author's observations were directly addressed. It would be impossible in our brief review to resume in any satisfactory way the manifold results of his enquiries; bat the most ungeological reader may be interested in his preliminary chapters on the physical geography of the great central plateaus of the continent, with his clear bringing out of the one prominent feature in their conformation—the mesas and cafions. Briefly stated, the lesson of this chapter is that a large portion of the coun- try between the Rocky Mountains and the Sierra Nevada is made up of high tablelands, or mesas, to give them their Spanish name, themselves the product of water-deposit from some vast superincumbent ocean in re- note geologic periods, cut in every direction, through the process known as erosion, by streams from the mountains, which have gradually worn their beds deeper and deeper through the varied strata, and produced the curious and picturesque chasms known as cajions. Thus, instead of the gracefully swelling hills and glades, the sloping meadows, and placid lakes of our own Atlantic landscape, the traveller on the Plains sees for hundreds of miles only a succession of table-lands and perpendicular cliffs, intersected and sliced down, like pound cake cut up for tea, by these singu- lar gullies, whose very existence he is frequently unaware of till he stands upon the verge of the chasm In the cafions, if by choice or acci- dent he descends into their beds, he finds himself hemmed in a precipitous gorge, of varying width, but in many cases, especially the so-called Grand Cafion of the Colorado, far exceeding in height and savage grandeur the well-known gorges of the Tamina and Trient in Switzerland. ‘his won. derful gorge was explored involuntarily, in 1867, by James Baker, a “ pros. pector,”’ swept down on an improvised raft in his attempt to ‘escape from Indians. His account is one of the most wonderful stories in the book ; but is confirmed in all essentials by the report of Major J. W. Powell, who explored it with a party in 1869. A glance at the lithograph of the Colo- rado Plateau, in the introduction, does more for the imagination than pages of description, and impresses the reader with the impossibility of carrying a railroad through such a country. The only remedy would seem to be to “turn” the ravines, or avoid entirely the tract of country in which they are found; and to do this is a main object of the proposed “32d parallel route” in which our author was engaged. The actua! surveying work of the expedition commenced at Fort Wal- lace, on Smoky Hill Fork, in Western Kansas. At Fort Lyon, just over the Colorado frontier, they struck the Purgatoire River, and, following its course upward through the Big Cajon, crossed the Raton mountains and came down on the head-waters of Red and Canadian Rivers. From Fort Union, on the eastern slope of the Spanish range, they struck south-west- ward through the Placer Mountains by the Caion Blanco, and came down on the Rio Grande del Norte at Albuquerque, with an intervening trip to Santa lé. Thence. moving due south down the Rio Grande, and passing Forts Craig and McKay, they turned westward through the dangerous Apache country, over the Peloncello and Pina Lefio Ranges, and through the pic- turesque Aravaypa Cajon to Fort Grant. Here, leaving the rest of the party to pursue their way towards the west and the head of the Gulf, Dr. Bell struck southward, with a guide, through Sonora, to investigate the feasibility of a branch road to Guaymas. From Guaymas by steamer, doubling the extremity of Lower California, he reached San Francisco, from which, by the then only partially completed Central Pacific, he got back by Austin and Denver to his starting-point at Fort Wallace. Weare greatly tempted to insert in full his description of the pueblo, or fortified village, at Zui, on the head-waters of the Gila, and greatly interested in his sketch of the peaceful, industrious, and half-civilized Pueblo Indians at Jarge throughout the States of Arizona and New Mexico. Very pleasant, too, is his account of the lazy simplicity and cool greenery of the quaint old Mexican town of Albuquerque, as, later, of that of Hermosillo. His bit of description of manners at the Santa Fé baile (dance) is very lively, and his comparison between the neatness of the Mexican peon and the [Number 283 =———2 tion. Irish emigrant of the Eastern States very suggestive—especially to the latter. Very worthy of attention, too, is his recommendation to German | or other emigrants of the Mesilla Valley, with its yet undeveloped possi- bilities of grape culture ; and his calculation of potential thousands or mil- pressive, he, with true British phlegm, drops the chapter and the reader | lions of bottles which may yet pass over the South Pacific line makes one } | thirsty to read it. HOLIDAY BOOKS FOR ‘THE YOUNG,.—IL* Ir “ genial” criticism is ever in place, it would seem to be in the case of that sort of literature with which we are concerned in this article. We are accordingly disposed to err as much on this side as is customary, but, being especially jealous in behalf of the infants, we sometimes lose sight of our purpose to judge lightly where judge we must. We can illustrate this with the two books first named below, whose exteriors prepared us for something out of the ordinary, and which, so far as the pictures go, might still be recommended, even if these were more crudely executed than they are. The “ Little Red Riding-Hood Picture-Book ” is one of the handsome quartos of the season, with showy, high-colored illustrations and large print. It is intended to amuse children in the divided syllable stage of reading, and reads like a publication of the Society for the Pro- motion of Cowardice and Cruelty. It opens with the popular classic which gives it its title, and the remembrance of which is, to say the least, not reassuring in the dark. This is followed by the “ Three Bears,” but not the amiable three of our childhood—and, we are inclined to believe, the original three also—when we used to envy Silverhair her visit to them. Whoever edited the present version seems to have judged the other maw- kish and feeble, for he makes his bears as frightful as possible, and a warn- ing to all bold, meddlesome girls who go peeping into strange places. This, we suppose, is what is called fitting a story with a moral, and it has been done by degrading the character of all the actors, both beast and human. Next follow six short stories of animals, every one of which offers some spectacle of blood-thirstiness for the innocent little mind to dwell upon. Last of all comes the story of the “ Three Little Kittens,” who lost their mittens, and it is the only one that seems to have crept in by acci- dent as not likely to scare the timid or quicken the germ of cruelty in the strong. Of similar appearance, and, in its leading tale, fully as objection- able, is “ The Snow-White and Rose-Red Picture-Book,” which, however, has as a set-off Hans Andersen’s “ Ugly Duckling,” for those who can ap- preciate it, and, with several illustrations to the page, “Cock Robin,” “ Cinderella,” the “ Three Bears” again, “Jack and the Beanstalk,” etc The book is a made-up one, and all the last-mentioned stories are so patched, clipped, or otherwise altered as to be of little value except as ex- planations of the colored prints. Very good books to keep from the young are the “Rollo and Lucy Books of Poetry,” in three graded volumes, prepared, of course, by the author of the Rollo and Lucy series of story-books, which was useful and respectable in its day—the day of canal and stage-coach locomotion, and somewhat later. Mr. Abbott’s capacity for his present task is manifestly small indeed, whether one considers his selections or the “original” dog- gerel interspersed among them. In fact, taking account of his preface, one is forced to believe that the best poetry for youth is highly objection- able, since “the compiler has taken pains to exclude carefully from this collection everything that seemed to him to inculcate anything false, whether in matters of fact, in morals, in sentiment, or in philosophy.” Or else his criterion for poetry is the aid which any given piece can be made to render to family and school discipline. Here is a choice specimen of versification from the first book : ‘* A mother was sitting one night at her table, And rocking her baby, that lay in the cradle. As she rocked him, the rocking grew slower and slower, Till the cradie at last did not move any more.’ In the third book, among the “ pieces not before published,” or else the “The Little Red Riding-Hood Picture-Book. Containing Little Red Riding- Hood. The Three Bears, Dash and the Ducklings,” etc. With 24 pages of illustrations. New York: Geo. Routledge & Sons. 1870. “The Snow-White and Rose-Red Picture-Book. Containing Little Snow-White, The Ugly Duckling, Nursery Tales, Mother Hubbard, and Cock Robin.” With 24 pages of illustrations. ew York: Geo. Routledge & Sons. 18:0. * The Rollo and Lucy Books of Poetry. First, Second, and Third. Original and Selected. By Jacob Abbott.” With original engravings. ‘New York: Dodd & Mead. 8 vols. 1870. ‘* Our Feathered Companions; or, Conversations of a Father with his Children about Sea- birds, Song-birds, and Other Feathered Tribes that Live in or Visit the British Isles, their Habits, etc. By the Rev. Thomas Jackson, M.A.” New York: Geo. Routledge & Sons. 1870. ** National Nursery Rhymes and Nursery Songs. Set to Music by J. W. Elliott.” With illustrations engraved by the Brothers Dalziel. New York: Geo. Routledge & Sons. 1870. * Ranald Bannerman’s eer By George aes, LL.D.” With numerous illustrations. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott & Co. 1871 “The Holiday Camp ; or, Three Days’ Picnic. A ‘Story for Boys and Girls. By Robert St. John Corbet.”” New York: Geo. Routledge and Sons. ORY é & & é 5 ‘ be 2 RPS OP me RN fe peg, a SRT ONE, sites Plat 5%
Page 17
ee Sean s-shamiin aa POOP REC EE Dec. 1, 1870] The Nation. 573 ee — — = ‘many anonymous articles, gathered from various sources,” there are verses entitled “A Valentine,” which we shall not quote, but the intro- ductory note to which shows very well to what sort of a yoke Mr. Abbott is inclined to hitch Pegasus. It runs thus: “ The following valentine was sent to a bachelor, accompanied by a little parcel. On opening the parcel, the gentleman found a ri) of a very small animal, completely en- veloped with white satin ribbon, ornamented with a true-lover’s knot at each end, and another in the middle.” “ Our Feathered Companions” is a book in all respects worthy of the holidays, and which has for its leading motive the preservation of birds by showing what a valuable part they play in human economy, and also how much more interesting they should be as objects of study than as victims of the fowler. This end is sought to be reached by a supposed conversa- tion between a father and his children, in which, however contrary to the common experience, the latter seem to know as much about ornithology as the former. The result is a dialogue only in form, and one in which it would make no great difference if Charlotte’s remarks were labelled 7Tom’s, or Freddie's Edith’s, or Mary’s Papa’s. The respective ages of the chil_ dren are, we need not add, scarcely distinguishable ; bat the first remarks of Jom, which are introduced as if not above the heads of his brothers and sisters, would, we opine, be quite impossible in an American family in similar circumstances. Papa has just opened the conversation by welcom- ing the exchange of the city for “ the shore of the ever-sounding sea,” and Tom takes up the parable in this wise : “T think that phrase, ‘the shore of the ever.sounding sea,’ pronounced slowly, echoes the sense of the words as delicately as Homer's celebrated line ending with ‘TloAvgzccBowo Yaracons.’” The illustrations of this book are numerous and well-drawn, though the figures are not to be compared, for their action, with Michelet’s “ Birds,” nor of course for fidelity of form and plumage with Bewick’s masterly de- sigos; and, as we have said, there is here an excellent vift for Christmas or New Year’s. In all that pertains to the manufacture, we cannot speak too eulogisti- cally of “ National Nursery Rhymes.” It is an admirable sample of the art of book-making, in binding, paper, and typography. Mr. Elliott has selected upwards of fifty rhymes, from Mother Goose chfefly, prefixing to each a capital design illustrating it, and set the whole to music. The pictures alone are worth the price of the book. We will even go farther, and say that the head-piece on page 10, “ Nineteen Birds,” is worth the price; while there are a score of others which have, perhaps, as good a right to be mentioned—say, “I had a little doggy,” on page 12, which for sentiment and drawing it would be difficult to surpass. Mr. Elliott was attempting a very great task when he set about composing over fifty melodies, which needed to be not only “ within the capacity of children’s execution and the compass of children’s voices,” but of that catching originality and swing which should at once ally itself to the verse, never to be separated from it. To make to order six tunes worthy of the immortality of Mother Gcose would have been a feat; so that we shall not be thought to praise too little when we say that the composer has got through his stint like a gentleman and aschular. The tunes are simple and graceful, and harmonized in good memory of classic models. It would have lightened Mr. Elliott's task and not made the result less valuable, we think, if he had preserved a few of the old tunes that, in one way or another, have attached them- selves to certain of the nursery rhymes. “Zampa,” nor the Hutchinson’s excellent “Spider and the Fly,” we cannot dismiss for a new tune, however elaborate; or our “ Twinkle, twinkle, little star ;” or the old, very old, “ Margery Daw ;” bit of music, wherever it came from, “ The north winds do blow”’—we wish we could transcribe it here. been singing to us “The old woman that lived in a shoe” to pretty Polly Hopkins ;” able and acceptable, for so long that it becomes difficult to detach them and take on the new and delicate but somewhat characterless motifs of Mr. Elliott. “Ranald Bannerman’s Boyhood” is likely to prove interesting to both boys and girls not under twelve, in spite of its formal language, and its tolerably frequent wanderings into the realms of sentimental reminiscence, so dear to old people and so worthless to children. The interest is in the episodes of the story, which read like real occurrences, and are very lively and entertaining. We are at a loss “ Pretty, | | Herbert (George), Poetical Works, illustrated o | Taylor (B.), Jose ph and his Friends............ Possibly, though, the English | . 3.). | Other P ved public never had heard “ Baa, baa, black sheep” sung to the “ Prayer” in | Whittier (J. G.), Miriam, and Other Poems..... which | or that perfect | Also, the English opera bouffe has | and other rhymes to other tunes equally vener- | to understand why Mr. MacDonald feels it necessary to keep to such strict English, and apologize so overmuch for the few passages of Seotch dialect that he must introduce. To put the elegant language, with due care for the subjunctive, into the mouths of his Scotch peasants, makes them absurd. There may be somewhat too much of Seotch in the dialogue of a story, as every one knows who has had to seek a glossary to make the sense ; but a modified Scotch is not only pleasant to read, but desirable for a boy to understand who has Scott’s novels before him. However, we had no intention of going into any artistic considerations in noticing this little story, for its merits end with its morality and its readable anecdotes. As a mere narrative, “ The Holiday Camp” has merit, and the incidents are ail probable enough. A bevy of boys and girls camp out for several days, under proper restrictions, in the woods of an English gentleman's estate, near a brook and lake, which give them fine opportunities for fishing and boat-racing. There is a rebellion in the boys’ end of the dor- mitory, which is quelled by a vigorous use of the slipper in the hands of the head-boy, but the principal sensation is the capture, conflict, of three burglars, caught prowling about the premises at night. The author insists a great deal, after the manner of his countrymen, that fair-play is an English virtue; and of the pluck and beefiness of Old England there is quite as much as is necessary in the slang discourse of the regattas. Except these, and some minor drawbacks, due to the scene of the story, we find nothing objectionable, and much that is likely to in- terest, in the story. We note with some satisfaction that the author has heard of Mark Twain’s “ Jumping Frog,” and introduces on page 10, after a severe him in a simile, a - =] *,* Publishers will confer a favor by always marking the price of their books wpon ihe wrapper. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Authors.— Titles. Publishers.—Pricea Attwell (H.), A Book of Golden Thoughts (Macmillan & Co.) Blunt (Rev. JM. ), A Plain Account of the Eng lish Bible (EK. P. Dutton & Co.) Dictionary of Doctrinal and Historical Theology. : Bryant (W.C.}, Library of Poetry and Song... .. ; (i. B. Ford & Co.) $5 00 (J. B. Lippincott & Co.) Butler (T. B.), The Atmospheric System, and the Elements of Prognostication (Ivison, Blakeman & Co.) Bryant (W. C.), The Song of the Sower. 42 illustrations. .. (D. Appleton & Co.) , Bryce (Prof. J.), The Holy Roman Empire, 3d ed.. (Macmillan & Cx Collins (W.), The Dead Secret, swd.. ..(T. B. Peterson & hoa » Oso Colange (L.), Zell's ome Encyclopedia, No. 49, sw. cv oe Zell) 025 Cope (Prof. E. D.), The Hypothesis of Evolution, swd. (Cc Chatfleld) 0 80 Curious Facts for Little P eople about Animals... (E. P. Dutton A Co ) Charlesworth (M. L.), Letters to a Friend under Affliction... - Corbet (R. St. d.), The Holiday Camp..... (Geo, Routledge & Sons) . Elliott (J. W.), National Nursery Rhymes ‘and Nurse ry Songs ” Every Day: a Tale.. a -.....(Noyes, Holmes & Co.) Greene (Hon, Mrs.). The School- Boy Baronet. ... ‘ ....(E. P. Dutton & Co.) Hallowell (R. P.), The Quakers in New England, swd.... ....(Philadelphia) Hlowitt (W.), Jack of the Mill..... (Geo. Routledge & Sons) Helps (A.), Essays written in the Intervals of Business... ..(Roberts Bros.) 1 50 day (W. M. L.), Shiloh: a Tale. a ee. i Ee (BE. P. Dutten & Co.) John W hopper. the Newsboy... ; ...(Roberts Bros.) 0 75 Jackson (Rey. T.), Our Feathered C ompanions. (Geo, Routledge & Sons) Keeler (RD), V agabond Adventures... eae ecnccesseee- (Pields, Osgood & Co.) 1 50 Little Red Riding- Hood Picture Book... .........sccssees (Geo. Routledge & Sons) game ), Stephen Scudamore, the Younger Mi o> cheats 2 " o Lever (C. A Rent in a Cloud............ ‘ wees. eee. B, Peterson & Bros.) 0 50 Major oa ss Courtship. swd........... ae 8 " 0 75 Milton's Ode on the Morning of Christ's Nativity, jliustrated (E. P. Dutton & Co } Mackenzie (Rev. W. B.), Handbook for the Sick. > he » nag Radenhausen (C.), Isis: der Mensch und die Welt, I. Heft... swd..(L. W. Schmidt) 0 23 Snow-White and Rose-Red Picture Book. . (Geo, Routledge & Sons) Shand (A. I1.), Against Time: a Tale, swd. i: tah bk beck (Littell & Gay) 0 75 Theed (Marion F.), What She Did with her Life. * (Geo. Routledge & Sonsy AG. P. Patns um & Sons) Steiger) 0 50 The W orkshop. No. 9, swa. fe I. 2 (Fields, Oss good A Co.) 1 50 € Warner (C. D.), My Summer ina Garden...... . Work for All, and Other Tales, 5th ed Fine Arts MR. LINCOLN’S STATUE IN UNION SQUARE. THE statue of Mr. Lincoln in Union Square, freed from its wrapper of planks, appears now united to its pedestal. A general objection to the (E. P. Dutton & Co.) | statue itself, expressed when it alone could be seen, was rather a pleasant thing to notice. A dozen years ago, a better or worse work of art would have troubled fewer people. There is, naturally enough, a toleration of statues in the open air. A mass of metal and stone must needs exert itself somewhat, through art, to be offensive under the genial influences of light and atmosphere. There is no doubt that, separately, the statue was called a failure ; and in its seeming to be a simulacrum of Mr. Lincoln, even to his clothing, realism appeared to be at fault. The baldness of a
Page 18
ar oO ( + literal copy of nature accounted for all defects, until the evidence of failure by accumulation of mistakes made the statue interesting as a lesson of what not to do. As each little misapprehension of the | point came up, one recognized a certain general character of error, ac- | counting for the respectful dislike of statues which most people ob- scurely feel, i Certainly, given a portrait of Abraham Lincoln in his usual clothing, nochance is left for the usual attempts at beauty through elegance or proportion. By so much, then, is the task simplified. Mr. Lincoln was neither graceful nor majestic in person or in gesture, but his typical ugli- ness, not devoid of dignity, gives to the artist a figure logical in its very defects, and seen to advantage in certain definite positions only, any of which could be exactly ascertained. These difficulties have this further advantage, that if frankly accepted they ensure character, the ideal of realism, and avoid compromise, the curse of art. Art in itself is compro- mise enough ; so much has to be given up in its use that all remaining truths need to be reinforced, exaggerated sometimes, to recall the settled purpose in the nature we dare to imitate. Here, then, the straitened conditions of his subject should force the artist into realism, for which his metallic material gives him peculiar facilities. The clothes to be imitated are flimsy, and make sharp folds; they can be perfectly realized in the tenacity of bronze, and by so doing—by breaking folds as vigorously as on the real, by accentuating the projection of edges—the shining flatness of the metal can be broken up and the eye be directed to the main points of attention, and the particular truth becomes subservient to the general meaning. All the more, too, that such imitation of the thinness of the | covering can help by contrast the great merit and power of sculpture, the | assertion of the body’s structure under drapery—a very distinct character | of the bony frame of our hero. JUST PUBLISHED BY PORTER & COATES, 822 CHESTNUT STREET, PHILADELPHIA. Longfellow’s Eocets and Poetry of urope. —- A New and Revised Edition, just completed, by H. W. | Longfellow, with the addition of 150 pages of entirely | the moet elegant and complete works extant. With | Introduction, Biographical Notices, and Translations, from the earliest period to the present time. By Prof. Henry Wadsworth Longfellow. Lllustrated with en- gravings on steel and engraved title. Imp. Svo, cloth, pany, London. The Nation. ATHENS. j P The undersigned will publish for the author an Afbum new matter never before published, making it one of | of photographic views, entitled “The Acropolis of Athens, Picturesquely and Architecturally Illustrated, by W. J. Stillman,” printed in carbon by the Autotype Com- [Number 283 This is what might be: let us see what hesitation will produce. A memory of the sculptured toga or pallium shall persuade to the copying of a coat no longer of cloth but of clay or stone, made, it is true, according to the cut of Mr. Lincoln’s, but padded out with the comfortable wadding of | some other man’s body; and, remembering Mr. Story’s statue in Boston, shall we say that of Mr. Everett? The trowsers, also, in their ponderous slope, shall be made to look as if they carried the mass above without the help of any interior legs. Above, where the thin shoulders characterized the man, and by their drooping gave importance and a certain sad sentiment to the head, all shall be hidden with a heavy cloak whose classical folds shall call attention to the meanness of our present costume. The marked features whose lines and wrinkles the bossy and edged metal might have paralleled, shall be smoothed and flattened out, and shine with a brazen polish. ‘To end it all, the anatomical improbability of a gesture and atti- tude suited to any other man shall help to add another monotonous statue to the list already published in metal and in stone. For, unfortunately, this tale of a statue is the story of many others, and therefore is told here. All such contradictions have been carried out even against difficulties, rather than to follow a programme without com- promise. It has been observed by some critic. perhaps in exaggeration, that whereas most pictures by fairly good painters are signed in their very execution, most statues need a catalogue of authors, and of modern por- trait statues that they could scarcely be known apart were their heads but taken off. Fortunately it is not so in nature: she is as fresh to-day as when centuries ago hundreds of sculptors, not born with greater talent than those of our time, filled Italy with lifelike and poetic works. But they disliked compromise in art, and recognized in realism the safeguard | of the ideal. Not of them could we say that they made the statues of other statues. THE GREAT ENGLISH AND SCOTCH QUARTERLIES AND BLACKWOOD’S MACAZINE. x) VIEWS OF THE ACROPOLIS. Bs NOW READY. The Westminster Review for October, Contents.—The Land Question in England. American Literature. Partial Remedy for the Pressure of Local Taxation. John Wesley's Cosmogony. Ancient Japanese Poetry. The Scottish Poor-Law. The Laws of War. Gunpowder. The New York Gold Conspiracy. The Bal- lot. Contemporary Literature. extra gilt top, bevelled boards, $6; sheep, marble edges, library style, $7 50; half-calf, gilt, $9; Turkey morocco, $12. “This valuable work contains selections from about four hundred authors, translated from ten languages. Mr. Longfellow himself gives us translations from all these languages but two,"’—Allibone’s Dict. of Authors. * This edition has been revised and enlarged by the author, and contains his last touches and additions to his labors..’—The Age, Philadelphia, Nov. 3, 1870. * It is now a better book than ever, the Professor hav- ing added an Appendix and a Supplement, the latter dated 1870, containing a very precious list of newer poetical translations. . .. The supplement is very choice and interesting, and absolutely rejuvenates the work. Here we have specimens from Bayard Taylor's translation of * Faust,’ not yet received in complete book-form, ctc., | etc.”’-—Evening Bulletin, Philadelphia, Nov. 5, 1870. Hedgoe’s Prose Writers of Cermany. A NEW AND KEVISED EDITION, With Introduction, Biographical Notices, and Transla- tions. By Freperic H. Heper, D.D. With Six Por- | traits on Steel and Engraved Title. Imperial 8vo, cloth extra, gilt top, bevelled boards, $5; sheep, marbled edges, library style, $6; half-calf, gilt, $7 50; Turkey morocco, $10. | “There is no book accessible to the English or Ameri- ean reader which can furnish so comprehensive and sym- | metrical a view of German literature to the uninitiated ; and those already conversant with some of the German | classics will find here valuable and edifying extracts from works to which very few in this country can gain access.”’ | ~Prof. A. P. Peabody, in North American Review. “A new and beautiful edition of a work of sterling merit."’—The Age, Philadelphia, Oct. 29, 1870. ' It is a photograph such as is very much needed at this juncture for instant study.”"—N. A. and U. 8. Gazette, Philadelphia, Oct. 27, 1870. * Universally recognized as one of the best collections | of specimens of German literature in the English lan- g tage.’’—New York Tribune, Oct. 28, 1870. | ** Its merits and value are wellknown. In this enlarged edition it will be sure to find renewed favor.’""-—Bosion | Post, Nov. 3, 1870. ee eee GRISWOLD'S PROSE WRITERS OF AMERL- CA. New edition, revised and brought down to the | present time. | AMERICAN ORNITHOLOGY. By Alex. | Wilson. With Bonaparte’s Continuation. Colored plates *,* pent by mail, postage paid, upon receipt of price. For sale by all Booksellers. | views show the Acropolis from five exterior points of These indestructible photographs are from 8x10 inch negatives, taken by Mr. Stillman during the winter and spring of 1869, and include all the views which are neces- sary to give the most complete idea of the existing ruins on the Acropolis, and their relation one to the other. They were taken with architectural lenses correcting the perspective distortions, and so that the proportions of the buildings may be measured as to scale, on any given plane; and most of them by Dallmeyer’s wide-angle rec- | tilinear lens, by the aid of which views never before suc- cessfully photographed have been rendered. Of the twenty-five subjects, sixteen have not been taken by any other photographer, and the negatives used are | selected from not less than 300 taken. The picturesque view, and the architectural show those characteristics of Greek architecture which contribute to its unexplained as unapproached perfection—the curves of the horizontal lines, pitch of the columns, etc. They are mounted on board about 13x22, with a page containing description opposed to each print; the whole bound in substantial and elegant style. Asa holiday gift | this Album is unsurpassed by any publication of the | year. Price, delivered at the Nation office, 8 Park Place, New York, $25. Subscriptions, for a limited number of copies, will be received by E. L. CODKIN & CO., Office of the Vation, New York. CHEAPEST BOOK-STORE IN THE WORLD. 11672 Magnificent English Books | AT OUR PRICE, 86725 Children’s Books AT YOUR PRICE, 45672 Miscellaneous Books AT ANY PRICE. Catalogues Nos, 23, 24, 26, free. Send stamp. LECCAT BROTHERS, No. 3 Beekman, between Nassau and Park Row. Dec. 1, 1870. The Edinburgh Review for October. Contents.—Baron Hubner’s Sixtus V. Cox's Aryan | Mythology. Memoirs of a Russian Dekabrist. Dr. New- man’s Grammar of Assent. Ernst Moritz Arndt. Sir John Lubbock’s Prehistoric Times. The Campaign of August, 1870. Earl Stanhope’s Reign of Queen Anne. Germany, France, and England. The London Quarterly Review for October. Contents.—The War between France and Germany. Sir Henry Bulwer's Life of Lord Palmerston. Prévost-Paradol and Napoleon III. Mismanagement of the British Navy. The French and German Armies and the Campaign fn | France. Von Sybel’s History of the Revolutionary Epoch. German Patriotic Songs. Inefficiency of the British Army. Terms of Peace. Blackwood’s Magazine for November. Contents.—Nuremberg; or, How to Build Houses. A Very Strange Correspondent. The Poetry and Humour of the Scottish Language. Earl's Dene, Part XU1I. New Books. Professor Porter on the Human Intellect. The Great Collapse. IN PRESS. | The North British Review for October. Contents.—The Moabite Inscription. The Poems of Shelley. The Growth of a Trades-Union. Philosophy, oar and Metaphysics. The Russian Church and Clergy. Uses and Requirements of English Diplomacy. | The Vatican Council. Contemporary Literature. Tenms.—Blackwood or any one Review, $4 a year; Blackwood and any one Review, $7; Blackwood and two Reviews, $10; Blackwood and three Reviews, $13; any | three Reviews. $10; the four Reviews, $12; Blackwood and four Reviews, $15. Single number of a Review, $1; of Blackwood, 35 cents. The Leonard Scott Publishing Co., 140 Fulton Street, New York. English Newspapers, Maga- zines, and Periodicals Supplied regularly to subscribers in any part of the United States. Send for our new Descriptive List, with prices of over 600 English Publications. WILLMER & ROGERS NEWS CO., 47 Nassau Street, New York. So OOS gageae Me Rowen
Page 19
es ci ane Augeit A ESE eRe NE THe RSENS gee RESHMA MIMI Ry ateeles esscapebeiy carr NAIR) Dec. 1, 1870] The Nation. a ————_—— MACMILLAN & CO.'S NEW PUBLICATIONS. BRYCE. THE HOLY ‘ROMAN EMPIRE. + Fee Bryce, D.C.L, Third edition, revised, New Volume of ‘The Globe Library”: COWPER’S POETICAL WORKS. Edited, with Notes and Biographical Introduction, by Rev. William Benham, M.A. §1 75. “ Mr. Benham’s edition of Cowper is one of permanent value.”’"—Saturday Review. New Volume of “ The Golden Treasury Series " : A BOOK OF GOLDEN THOUGHTS. By Henry Attwell. $1 25. FLOWER. AN INTRODUCTION TO THE OSTEOLOGY OF THE MAMMALIA. Being the sub- stance of the Course of Lectures delivered at the Royal College of Surgeons of England in 1870. By W. G. Flower, F.R.S. With numerous Llustrations. 2. ni fi. work is one eminently adapted for professional students: butit also suits a much more extensive class, namely, all who are interested in anatomy or surgery or godlogy. We cordially recommend the work to all classes of our readers."’—British Medical Journal. POOLE. PICTURES OF COTTAGE LIFE IN THE WEST OF ENGLAND. By Margaret E. Poole. Crown 8vo, cloth, $2. JEVONS. ELEMENTARY LESSONS IN LOGIC: Deductive and Inductive, with Copions Questions and Examples, and a Vocabulary of Logi- cal Terms. By W. Stanley Jevons, M.A. $1 25. (Forming the new volume of Macmillan’s College Class-Books.) Recent Volumes of the Clarendon Press Series: ENGLISH CLASSICS. CHAUCER. The Prologue to the Canterbury Tales; The Knight's Tale; The Nonne Prest his Tale. Edited by R. Morris. $1. SPENSER’S FAERY QUEEN. Books 1 and 2. With Introduction, Notes, and Glossary. By G. W. Kitchin, M.A. Each #1. SHAKESPEARE’S SELECT PLAYS. Edited by W. J. Clarke, M.A., and W. Aldis W right, M.A. 1, The Merchant of Venice. 40 ceuts. 2. Richard the Second. 60 cents. 3. Macbeth. 60 cents. MILTON’S ENGLISH POEMS. Edited, with Life, Introduction, and Selected Notes, by R. C. Browne, M.A. 2 vols.. $2. PIERS THE PLOWMAN. Edited by Rev. Walter W. Skeat, M.A. §1. POPE’S ESSAY ON MAN. With Introduc- tion and Notes by Mark Pattison, B.D. 50 cents. HOOKER’S ECCLESIASTICAL POLITY. Book I. Edited by R. W. Church, M.A. 175 cents. MENTAL AND MORAL PHILOSOPHY. THE ELEMENTS OF DEDUCTIVE LOGIC, designed mainly for the Use of Junior Students in the Universities. By T. Fowler, M.A. $1. THE ELEMENTS OF INDUCTIV E LOGIC, designed mainly for the Use of Students i in the Uni- versities. By IT’. Fowler, M.A. $150. A MANUAL OF POLITICAL ECONOMY * for the Use of Colleges and Schools. By J. E. Tho- rold Rogers, M.A. $1 25. HISTORY. A MANUAL OF ANCIENT HISTORY. By George Rawlinson, M.A., Camden Professor of An- cient History in the University of Oxford. 8vo, $2. FRENCH LANGUAGE AND LITERATURE. BRACHET’S HISTORICAL GRAMMAR OF THE FRENCH LANGUAGE, Translated into Eng- lish by G. W. Kitchin, M.A. $1. MASSON’S FRENCH CLASSICS. Vols. I. to V. Each #1. Vol. 1. Corneille’s Cinna, and Moliére’s Les Femmes Sa- vantes. Vol. 2. Racine’s Andromaqne, and Corneille’s Le Menteur Vol. 3. — Les Fourberies de Scapin, and Racine’s thaile, Vol, 4. Belec tions from the Correspondence of Madame de Sévigné. Intended more especially for Ladies’ Schools. Vol. 5. Voyage autour de ma Chambre, by Xavier de aisire, etc., etc. Catalogues of the Clarendon Press Series till be ready shortly. MACMILLAN & CO., 63 BLEECKER STREET, New York. Rare and Valuable BOOKS, IN BVERY DEPARTMENT OF LITERATURE, SUIT- ABLE FOR Public Institutions and Gentiemen’s Private Libraries, Offered for Sale, at very Low Prices, for Cash. Our Stock is various, comprising the Best and Rarest Editions of Works IN ALL LANGUAGES, including illustrated Works, Voyages and Travels, Poetry and the Drama, Biography and Memoirs, Secret Histories, French and Italian Works, Latin and Creek Classics— English and Foreign. Early Fathers in Theology, ix their Original Tongues, with Translations, etc. Together with a Rich Variety of STANDARD WORKS IN BBST LIBRARY CONDITION, Reviews, Encyclopzdias, Magazines, Etc., now offered at Aute-War Prices, THE OLDEST AND CHEAPEST IMPORTING HOUSE. EsTaBLisHeD 1840. IMPORTATIONS BY WEEKLY STEAMERS. CATALOGUE No. 59 now ready, and sent gratis on application. A. L. LUYSTER, Lond6n, & 133 Fulton St., Now York. Ready Sanita 1. JEAN INCELOW’S NEW POEMS. THE MONITIONS OF THE UNSEEN AND POEMS OF LOVE AND CHILDHOOD, With 12 Superb Illustra- tions. Cloth, neatly gilt, $1 50. PAUL KONEWKA’S SILHOUETTE. ILLUSTRATIONS TO GOETHE'S FAUST. The Eng- lish text from Bayard Taylor's new translation. One elegant quarto, bound in levant cloth, ueatly gilt, bevelled boards, price $4. DEBORAH'S DRAWER. BY ELEANOR GRACE O'REILLY, Author of “ Daisy's Companions." With Fine Ilustra- tions, and neatly bound in black and gold. Square $2mo, price $150. (English edition limited.) ROBERTS BROTHERS, Publishers, BOSTON. Just Publis hed. TAINE’S ART IN THE NETHERLANDS. 16mo, $1 25. “One feels at moments as if before this writer there bad been no critics, no travellers, observers, or wsthetic in- | quisitors."’—Nation. EPISODES AND LYRICAL PIECES. BY ROBERT KELLEY WEEKS. lémo, $1 50. “Shon!d Mr. Weeks never write another line, his claim te an houerable mention among American poets would be secure.""—Springfield Republican, LEYPOLDT & HOLT, 25 Bond Street, New York. S15 VAN. NOSTRAND’ S Eclectic Engineering Magazine. Vol. 3. No. G. For December, NOW READY. CONTENTS : Solar Heat (Minetrated).—Determination of the Unit of Oblique Pressure (Ilustrated).—The Gauge for the Rail- ways of the Future.—-The Solar Engine (Ilustrated).— Pneumatic Transmission through Tunnels and Pipes. — On the Separation of Phoaphoric Acid from Iron Ores and Iron Cinders. — Rolling Loads.—On Liquid or Coneen- trated Fucl.—Sea Walls and Foreshores.—On the Duty of Cornish and other Pumping Engines.—On the Mode of Working Coal and the Mechanical Appliances in the Mid- land Coal Fields.—Explosive Power of Nitro-Glycerine,— Working Load of Iron Structures.—Fireproof Structures ~—Rail Mending.—The Application of Hot Blast to Blow- pipe Purpose, and the Proposed Substitution of Heated Air for Oxygen in Producing certain Thermal and Hiumi- nating Effects.—Tractive Power of Locomotives.— The Sewage of the Air.—Electrolytic Insulation.-- Ferro Man- ganese,—The Utility of Railways for War Puarposes.— Mobility of Field Artillery.—-War and Education.—Cen- tralizing Motive Power.—On a Steam-Power Meter (Iilas- trated).—Ransome Stone.--On the Application of the Centre Rail System in Brazil, ete —The History of Mill- tary Fire-arms.--Iron Arches (Llustrated).—Dust Foch — The Uses of the Bessemer Metal.--Lecture on Stream Lines and Waves in Connection with Naval Architec- ture, Paraoraras.—Railway Notee.—Iron and Steel Notes. —Ordnance and Naval Notes.—Eagineering Structares.— New Books. —Miscellaneous. Terms: Published Monthly Numbers, 50 cents. D. VAN NOSTRAND, Publisher, 23 Murray Street and 27 Warren Street, New York, “RAILROAD GAZETTE The Railroad ‘Man’ s — ng ine erin sa wg Weekly s Quarto Jonrnal, 2i Pages, Advertising | Reporte } Manav re ment, A. N. REL LOG AN Pablishe ¥: Tenus: $3 per Annum.) 101 Washington St., Chicago. CB Will be Four Dollars after January 1,137. et at $5 per annum; Single $=» * A set of books that contains what may be called the cream of reading and research from the times of Dr, John- son to our own.” WIDDLETON’S CHOICE LIBRARY EDITION oF THE ELDER DISRAELI’S WORKS. Authorized and Complete. Edited, with Notes, by his Son, the Right Hon. B. Disraeli, ex-Premier of Great Britain. In 9 vols. crown 8vo, large, clear type, on fine toned paper, bound in handsome library style, in extra cloth, comprising: THE CURIOSITIES OF LITERATURE. 4 vols., $7. THE AMENITIES OF LITERATURE, 2 vola., $3 50. THE CALAMITIES AND QUARRELS OF AUTHORS. 2 vola,, $5 3 50. THE LITERARY CHARACTER. 1 — $2 35. Any of the Works sold separately, as above, or the en- tire set of 9 vola., in acase, for $15 ; haif-calf, $30. *,* For sale at the principal Book-stores thronghont the country; and sent by mail or expreas, on receipt of price, by W. J. WIDDLETON, Publisher, 7 HOWARD STREET, NEW YORK. Many other choice impreseions of Standard Worke of value for the Library will be found in our Catalogue, Mailed free upon application,
Page 20
O76 OPINIONS RESPECTING First Steps in English Literature.” The Publishers of Gruman’s “ Finst Steps in ENGLISH Lirenature take the opportunity afforded by a new edition of this successful hand-book to bring together some of the very favorable jadgments passed upon it by teachers and editors. From Joseru G. Coeswett, LL D., Recently Librarian of the Astor Library. * I know of no work in the English language from which eo much on the subject can be learned in so small a com- pass as from this, As an outline for beginners, it is all that can be desired, and an excellent preparation for a more extended course. I miss a few names from the list of American writers which I think ought to be there, and no doubt will be in a future edition.” From Cyrus Nortruror, Professor of English Literature in Yale College. *“Tts clearness and conciseness, the interesting histori- cal facts introduced as closely related to our literature or the history of eur language, the judicious selection of an- thors, and the bold rejection of o:hers by which your work is kept within the proper limits of such an undertaking, are some of the points which have specially impressed me."’ From Homer B. Srracver, Principal of Adelphi Academy, Brooklyn, N. Y. ‘Mr. Gilman has prepared a valuable work. Tdo not know where an equal amount of valuable literary in- formation, combined with judicious criticism, can be found in so brief a space.” $ From the Curtst1An Unton, Henry Ward Beecher, rditor. “Within the limits of a pocket volume Mr. Gilman has contrived to take a marvellously comprehensive and thorough survey of English literature from its dawn to our own day. From the Hartrorp Counant. “*Pirst Steps in English Literature’ is a little hand- book that we desire most heartily to commend. It is the most concise, comprehensive, intelligent, and the best ar- ranged outline of English literature that bas ever been printed, so far as we know. *,* Gilman's ‘First Steps” is a 16mo volume of 231 pp.. with three charts, valuable indexes, and bibliogra- yny ; bound in flexible cloth, price $1.00, For sale by all p *ksellers, and sent prepaid on receipt of price by the Publishers, HURD & HOUCHTON, 13 ASTOR PLACE, NEW YORK. RIVERSIDE PRESS, CAMBRIDGE, “We strongly recommend this book as one of the most entertaining volumes of travel that has appeared for some years.”—London A thenwum. Tent Life in Siberia. BY GEORGE KENNAN. 12mo, cloth. $2. c. P. PUTNAM & SONS, New York. To Collectors of Choice Books The undersigned begs to invite attention to his extensive assortment of Sranpanrp, ILLvs- TRATED, and Frine-Art Works, embracing the largest and best-selected stock of Im- ported Books in the country, all of which are offered at reasonable prices. J. W. BOUTON, IMPORTER AND BooKsELLER, 706 Broadway, Catalogues sent to any address upon receipt of a stamp New York. to pay postage. | Lee, Shepard & Dillingham, The Nation. [Number 283 Publishers and Booksellers, 47 AND 49 GREENE STREET (Old Stand of Messrs. Ivison, Blakeman, Taylor & Co.), NEW YORK. Up-Town Agency for MESSRS. HARPER & BROTHERS’ PUBLICATIONS. All New Books received as soon as issued, and orders for EVERYTHING in our line exe- cuted promptly and at the lowest rates. American Journal of Science and Arts, Founded by Professor Silliman in 1818, and now numbering 100 volumes, in two series of 50 volumes each. EDITORS AND PROPRIETORS, PROFESSORS SILLIMAN AND DANA, Associate Eprrors, PROFESSORS GRAY and GIBBS, of Cambridge, and NEWTON, JOHNSON, BRUSH, and VERRILL, of Yale. Devoted to Chemistry, Physics, Geology, Mineralogy, Natural History, Astronomy, Meteorology, etc. A Tuikp Sexes in MONTHLY Numbers, making two volumes a year of about 450 pages each, from January, 1871. Subscription price, $6 a year, or 50 cents a number. A few Complete Sets on sale of the First and Second Serics. Address SILLIMAN & DANA, NEW HAVEN, CT. PUBLISHED BY JAMES MILLER, 647 Broadway, N. Y. THE ILLUSTRATED RED-LINE EDITION OF ELIZABETH B4aRRETT BROWNING’'S PORTI- CAL WORKS. Uniform with the Red-Line Edition of Tennyson and Longfellow. With original illustrations by Sol. Eytinge, Jr, Hennessey, Thwaites, and Bush, Beautiful tinted paper. 1 vol. small 4to, cloth, gilt ex. $4 50; half-calf, $6; full calf or morocco, $8, THE DIAMOND EDITION OF ELIZABETH BARRETT BROWNING’S POETICAL WORKS. Com- plete in 1 vol. 16mo, cloth, $1.50. SLOVENLY KATE, AND OTHER STORIES. Translated from the German, With numerous illustra- tions, colored. A companion volume to the famous and popular ** Laughter Book.” 4to, cloth, $2. BOOK OF NONSENSE. Full of Funny Pie- tures, drawn by Edward Lear. 1 vol. oblong, cloth, $2. DORE’'S POPULAR FAIRY TALES. With full-page illustrations, by Gustave Doré, Handsomely bound. 1 vol. 4to, cloth, $2.50. JAMES MILLER, Publisher, 647 Broadway, New York. GLAVE SONGS OF THE UNITED STATES. A Unique Collection of Original Melodies—words and music—obtained among the negroes of the South ; preceded by an account of these Songs. and an Essay on the Negro Dialect, as observed at Port Royal, by Prof. W. F. Allen, of the University of Wisconsin. Cloth. 8vo, price $1 50. Sent post-paid on receipt of price. Address PUBLISHER OF THE * NATION,” Box 6732, New York City, ——— London 'Bocks. CATALOGUE NO. 23, Containing Prices and Descriptions of many SCARCE, CurRIOUS, AND STANDARD ENCLISH AND FOREICN BOOKS, In press, and will be sent free of charge to any address. A. DENHAM & CO., IMPORTERS OF ENGLISH AND FOREIGN BOOKS, {7 Murray Street, New York. New Publications THE BIRTH AND CHILDHOOD OF OUR LORD JESUS CHRIST. Meditations selected from the works of Augustine, Chrysostom, Bishop Cosin, Bishop Hall, and other writers. With Twelve Photo- qepes, after Leonardo da Vinci, Raffaelle, Murillo, wuido, Delaroche. Ary Scheffer, and other masters. Small 4to, cloth, illuminated and gold cover, $6. HOLIDAY PLEASURES. With an Introduc- tion by the author of * Harry Lawton’s Adventures.” With Twelve Full-page Etchings. By Rudolf Geiss- ler. 4to, cloth, extra, $3. CHATTERBOX. Volume for 1870. Edited by J. Erskine Clarke, M.A. Small 4to, boards. Mlus- trated with a Colored Frontispiece and upwards of 280 fine Wood-cuts, many of which are full-page Ex- gravings. $1 50. POTT & AMERY, COOPER UNION, FOURTH AVENUE, New York. AN IMPORTANT FACT FOR THE PUBLIC. The following letter is one of hundreds received of like tenor. Kerosene has become a household terror, owing to the daily accidents that oceur from its careless use. Pratt's Astral Oil may be relied upon as the safest, purest, and best illuminating oil in the marKet. It burns in the ordinary kerosene lainps, is free from offensive odor, and gives a clear, uniform, and brilliant light: ‘* Troy, N. Y., August 22, 1870. ** Mr, CHaRLEs Pratr: “ Sur: We have a short story to tell you abont ‘ Astral Oil.’ In the rear of our store, about three years since, we had a warehouse built, with gravel roof, for storing Paints, Oils, Glass, Acids, Kerosene Oil, etc., ete. Unfortunately for us, it was set on fire early Saturday morning, and en- tirely consumed. The 100 cases of Astra) Oil bought from you a few days since were in the warehouse, and. strange to say, came out of the fire almost unharmed; they were piled up two and three tiers higk; the wood casea, of course, were burned off. and several of the top cans unsol- dered on top ; but there was no explosion, and the oil in the open cans did not burn. The rear of our store was very badly damaged. The Astral Oi] was within six or eight feet from the store, and, of course, in a hot place. Had the eo taken place, nothing could have saved the store. We had several barrels of Aerosene in the ware- house, which burned lively. To say the least. the Oi! has stood a very severe test, and we think it is all you claim itto be. This morning, before anything was disturbed, we had a picture taken of the ruins, showing the Oil as it remained after the fire was put out. ** Yours respectfully, “Sropparp & Burton.” The picture above-mentioned, and original letter, may be seen at our Office; also several of the damaged cans, as they came out of the fire. Send for Circulars. OIL HOUSE OF CHAS. PRATT, EsTaBiisHep 1770, MANUFACTURERS, PACKERS, AND DEALERS IN STRICTLY PURE OILS, 103 Fulton Street, New York.