The Athenaeum 1904-03-26: Iss 3987
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
Hl
THE ATHENZ Journal of English and Foreign Literature, Srtence, the Fine Artd, Hisic and the Brame, No. 3987.
SATURDAY,
MARCH 26, 1904. ERPENCE ” THREE EPENCE REGISTERED AS A NEWSPAPER
UEEN’S HALL.—SUNDAY AFTERNOON CONCERTS.—SUN DAY NEXT, at 330. Queen’s Hall Orchestra. Conductor—Mr. HENRY J. WOOD. Tickets, ls. to 5s. ; admissi free, at Hall, and R. Newan, Manager, 320, Regent Street. gE tesees ASSOCIATION. The NEXT PROFESSIONAL EXAMINATION will be held at various Centres, on MAY 4 to 6, 1904. The Examinations Syllabus has been recently revised. Copies may be had on application to the Hon. Secretary of the Education Com- mittee, from whom full particulars may be obtained, and to whom intending Candidates must send their names not later than SATUR- DAY, April 2, 1904, the date having been extended for this year. HENR Y D. ROBERTS, Hon. Sec. of the Education Committee. 44s, Sainwent Bridge Road, London, 8.E., March 1, 1904. teres DRAWINGS To THE OLD TESTAMENT. NOW FIRST EXHIBITED IN LONDON AT HENRY SOTHERAN & COS, 37, PICCADILLY, W. ADMISSION, with CATALOGUE, Is. RAzLY BRITISH MASTERS.—SHEPHERD'S SPRING EXHIBITION contains choice Portraits and Land- et Reynolds Richard Wilson J. 8. Cotman T. Gainsborough John — ee bl Vincent John ng nd John ter Lely, &c. SHEPHERD'S GALLERY? 27, 7, King Streets Bt James’ 8 Square.
HE FINE-ART SOCIETY’S EXHIBITIONS.— 300 Engravings of London in the Eighteenth Century. The City andthe West-End. NOW OPEN at 148, NEW BOND STREET. XHIBITION of PEWTER- PLATE. — SUBSCRIPTIONS for ~ ILLUSTRATED CATALOGUE, 25s., a be sent at once to H. J. L. J. Mass£, Clifford's Inn, Fleet Street,
N EW BOND STREET, EXHIBITION of PICTURES in. — MESSRS. DICKINSONS’ newly decorated RUSKIN ROOM is available for the above and — purposes.—For terms and vacant dates apply 114, New Bond Street. S'- MARY’S HOSPITAL MEDICAL SCHOOL, PADDINGTON, The SUMMER SESSION will COMMBNOR on MAY 2. The Medical School provides complete Courses of Instruction for the Medical Degrees of the Universities of London, Oxford, Cambridge, and Durham; for the Diplomas of the Royal Colle ot of Physicians and Surgeons; and for the Government Medical Servic: SIX ENTRANCE SCHOLARSHIPS in NATURAL ‘SCIENCE, value 1451. to 521. 10s., competed for in SEPTEMBER. Students entering in May are eligible Handbook of Curriculum on application to the Dean. St THOMAS’S BHOSPITA &, ALBERT EMBANKMENT, 8.E. A School of the University of London. ‘Ihe SUMMER SESSION will COMMENCE on APRIL £1, except for those taking Prelim. Science Classes ; for these the SESSION begins on AY 1.
The — occupies one of the finest sites in London, and contains 602 beds. T wenty-six Entrance and other Scholarships and eee of the value of more than 500/., are offered for competition each Upwards of 60 resident and other appointments are open to students after qualification. A Students’ Club forms part of the Medical School buildings ; and the athletic ground, nine acres in ereerer situated at Chiswick, can be es in 40 minutes from the hospita! A Prospectus, containing full a may be obtained from the Medical Secretary, Mr. G. Renp_e H. G. TURNEY, M.A. M.D.Oxon., Dean. NIVERSITY of LONDON. ‘Whe SENATE invite applications for the post of SECRETARY to the ACADEMIC REGISTRAR. Salary 2001. Particulars may be had on application. ARTHUR Pyke RUCKER, Principal. University of London, South Kensington, 8 March 21, 1904.
City of LtV a 2.F OO sk, WALKER ART GALLERY. The LIBRARY, MUSEUM, and ARTS COMMITTEE of the COUNCIL of the CITY of LIVERPOOL are prepared to receive applications <j ALKER ART GALLER
the appointment of CURATOR of the WA The salary will be 400/. per annum, subject to a contribution of 3 4.4 cent. to the Corporation Superannuation Fund, and to a condition that the person appointed will effect an insurance on his life to an amount the premium on which shall be equal to 2 per cent. of his salary. The official will be required to devote the whole ef his time to the service of the Corporation, Particulars of duties may be had on application to the Town Clerk. Applications, stating age. qualifications, and pre- vious by copies of Testimonials, endorsed “Curator of the Walker Art Gallery.” and addressed to rei oe Clerk. Municipal Offices, Liverpool, must be delivered at Clerk’s Office, not later than 12 o'clock at noon on THURSDAY. ‘Zou Vt
Canvassing Members of Lg os Council will be a disqualification. DWARD R. PICKMERE, Town Clerk. Town Clerk’s Office. c, Liverpool, March 17, 1904.
METROPOLITAN BOROUGH of WOOLWICH. LIBRARY ASSISTANTS. The COUNCIL - the METROPOLITAN BUROUGH of WOOLWICH require the services of : (a) An ASSISTANT LIBRARIAN. annual increments of 51. to 1501. (b) A SENIOR ASSISTANT. Salary commencing at 90/. per annum. licants, in both cases. must sere: had previous experience in Putiie ¢ Library Work. Appli in own handwriting, enclosing copies of three recent Testimontale, to be sent to —s at the ‘Town Hall, Woolwich, not later than WEDNESDAY, April 6, 1 Ap) lications for (a) are to be endorsed “ Assistant ptbeny and for (6) “ Senior Assistant.” Candidates will be required to devote the whole of their time to the duties of their appointment. Canvassing members of the Council rel - yes Selected Candidates only will be en the appointment when made. ARTHUR 7 BRYCESON, Town Clerk. Town Hall, Woolwich, March 22, 1904. ANTED, YOUNG WRITER, having some experience in Sensational Fiction. —Address communications to M. L., Athenzum Press, Bream’s Buildings, Chancery Lane, E.C. TUITION by CORRESPONDENCE. — For Matriculation, B.A. Scholarships, and Prof 1 Prelimi ies.
Salary 1201. per annum, with
NOTICE. —FRIDAY NEXT being GOOD FRIDAY, the ATHENEUM will. be spub- lished on THURSDAY, at Ten o’clock.— ADVERTISEMENTS should be at the Office not later than 10 o’clock on WEDNESDAY Morning.
Yearly Subscription, free by post, Inland 15s. 3d.; Foreign, 18s. Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Class matter. RE FRANK KARSLAKE (carrying on business as “The Guild of Women Binders” and ‘The Hampstead eo y of 61, Charing Cross Road, and 14, Southill Park, Hampstead. E IS HEREBY GIVEN, ‘That the WHOLE of the STUCK of BINDINGS produced by ‘The Guild of Women Binders” and “ The Hampstead Kindery,” comprising unique, artistic, and valuable speci- mens of the Bookbinder’s art. is TO BE SOLD at greatly reduced prices, in many instances at half the original cost. A number 0 valuable Prints and Engravings, and rare and scarce Books, includin; numerous First Editions, will also be offered for Sale. Such 8 will be on view at 6l, Charing Cross Road, London, W., as from = 12th March, 1904, and daily thereafter (except Sundays), from 10 a.m of “ The Guild
till5 ep... All the of Women Binders,” “The Hampstead ‘Bindery,” Karslake & Co., and Frank Karslake, to be addressed to the undersigned. Dated this 10th day of March, 1904.
OSCAR BERRY (Of the tirm of Geer Berry & Co.). Monument House, Monument Square, London, E.C. And at Brighton. TT XPE- -WRITING.—AUTHORS’ MSS. accurately COPIED, from 10d. 1,000 words. Mail orders receive immediate attention. Carbon Copies half-price —W. List, Haymarket Type- writing Office, 11, Haymarket, 8.W. (First Floor). TYPE-W. -WRITING. — AUTHORS’ MSS. 8d. per rds. Accuracy and dispatch.—Miss Rispox, Norbu Cobham mond, Kingston-on-Thames. o citi mae (THE AUTHOR’S AGENCY.—Established 1879, The interests of Authors capably represented. Agreements for Publishing arranged. MSS. placed with Publishers.—Terms and Tes! monials on application to Mr. A. M. Burcuegs, 34, Paternoster Row.
Tuition in any Subject : a Greek, egg va German, Italian, Mathe- matics, yehology, ‘Logie, Political Economy, Book- Salen The Staff inehades Graduates of Oxford, Cambridge, London, and Royal Universities. gay rioving Mr. J. CHARLEs- ton, B.A., Burlington Correspondence College, 8, Crescent Grove, Clapham Common, S.W. M USICAL CRITIC requires ADDITIONAL ENGAGEMENT. Highest references. Twenty years’ experi- ence on leading Papers. Weekly or Monthly preferred. Terms moderate.—Address E. G., Atheneum Press, Bream’s Buildings, E.C.
GENTLEWOMAN of UNIVERSITY EDUCATION desires a POST as SECRETARY or AUTHOR'S AMANUENSIS. Shorthand and Typewriting. Experience in Col- rings Plaga a Literary Man.—Address L, 91, Lamb’s Conduit treet, W.C. T° PUBLISHERS.—Shortly disengaged, LADY, late Secretary to well-known Critic. reaper nn Indexer, Correspondent. ‘Translates German. Good Jud Experienced Reviewer, and well up in Literary Matters Helped “foundation of important Keference Work. Could Edit Publishers’ Periodical with success. oT Moderate payment.—Address L. U., Willing’s, 162, Piccadilly, W
ADY SECRETARY, AMANUENSIS, or B.M. TRANSCRIBING —WORK WANTED. Knowledge of French, German, Latin, Shorthand, Type-writing. Good references.— Miss Squire, 32, Kennett Road, Maida Hill.
[NDEXING, Translations, Research Work (Eng- and Abroad), Shorthand, Type-writing. Pupils trained as Private Secretaries.—Miss PerurroripcE (Nat. Sci. Tripos), Secretarial Bureau, 52a, Conduit Street, Bond Street, W.
UBLISHING.—A LONDON PUBLISHER of High-Class Books is willing to consider the introduction of further Capital up to 5,000. for Extension of his Business.—Write Z , 44, Chancery Lane, W.C.
PHEDFORD COLLEGE for (University of London), YORK PLACE, BAKER STREET, W. The LECTURESHIP in LATIN will be Mae Pet the END of this SESSION.—Applications must be sent by MAY 1 the Secretary of the College, from whom all information may be F4A H. WALTON, Secretary. PV IELASTON SCHOOL, NANTWICH. (An Unsectarian Pablic School). NEXT TERM OPENS MAY 5, 1904. ADMISSION EXAMINATION, MARCH 29. For particulars, apply Heap Master. QO‘ the CHOICE of SCHOOLS and TUTORS. HIRTY YEARS’ EXPERIENCE. SCHOOLS for Bors (Public, Preparatory, Engin GIRLS, In Bngland or Abroad, and TU and General Education, Englich. or C (gratis), from personal knowledge acquired by an experience of thirty years, by GABBITAS, THRING & CO., Soma Agents, 36, Sackville Street, w. State ap details of each case, 80 that. ° imited and satisfactory may be WOMEN
eering. &c.) or for ‘TORS for ae ‘universities,
Interviews from 10 till 4.
YPE-WRITING.—The WEST KENSINGTON OFFICES. Authors’ MSS., Translations, &c. Legal and General Copying. Circulars, &c., Duplicate ted. Usual terms. References. Established eleven years a & Sixes, 13, Wolverton Gardens, and 229, Hammersmith Road, W UTHORS’ MSS., SERMONS, PLAYS CIRCULARS, TESTIMONIALS, &c., carefully TYPED at home (Remington), 10d. per 1,000. Orders promptly executed.—M. L. L., 7, Vernon Road, Clapham, 8. w. Te See MS6&., SERMONS, ARTICLES TYPE-WRITTEN Strictly private. New Machine, best work. Seven years’ experience. References if necessary. Lowest terms on application.—Asusy (Mr.), St. John’s Cottage, Frome. y , ‘a MANU SCRIPTS promptly andaccurately TY PED, I 1,000 words. Dictation in Shorthand, English, French, or Italian. Translations of same. Good references. —Apply, M. Mackay 23, Mount Carmel Chambers, Kensington.
C. MITCHELL & CO., Agents for the Sale and Purchase of Newspaper Properties, undertake Valuations for Probate or Purchase, Investigations, and Audit of Accounts, &c. of Terms on application Mitchell House, 1 and 2, Snow Hill, Holborn Viaduct, E.C.
Catalogues, HE INTERNATIONAL BOOK CIRCULARY Notes on New and Forthcoming Publications, and Classified Lists of Books, is issued by Wicttams & Norcare, Book Importers, 14, Hen- rietta Street, Covent Garden, London, W.C.— Specimen Copies gratis.
LELIGHTON’S ATALOGUE of EARLY PRINTED and other INTERESTING BOOKS, MANUSCRIPTS, and BINDINGS. Part VI. N—Q, 170 Illustrations, price 2s. READY NEXT WEEK. Parts I.—VI., containing A—Q, with 890 Illustrations in Facsimile. Price 15s. the 6 Parts. J. & J. LEIGHTON, 40, Brewer Street, Golden Square, W. CATALOGUE No. 39.—Etchings by Whistler— / Turner's Liber Studiorum, and other Engravings—Engravings by Hogarth, &c.— Drawings of the Early English Schoo!—Iliustrated ks —Works by John Kuskin. Post free, Sixpence.—Wx. Warp, 2, Church Terrace, Richmond, Surrey. ANTED, TURNER’S LIBER STUDIORUM, in fine states only.—Wx. Wasp, 2, Church Terrace, Richmond,
Surrey.
JUST READY. ROBSTHAIN’S ORIKNTAL CATALOGUE, No. IV. The FAR EAST (China, Japan, Tibet). 1,076 Numbers. ROBSTHAIN’S ORIENTAL CATALOGUE, No. III. INDIA. 2,088 Numbers Proustn itn & Co., Oriental Booksellers, 14, Bury Street, W.C. Pp U BLISHERS REMAINDERS. MARCH LIST NOW READY, Inclading all Latest Purchases offered at greatly reduced prices. WILLIAM GLAISHER, Remainder and Discount Bookseller, 25, HIGH HOLBORN, LONDON Also CATALOGUE of POPULAR CURRENT LITERATURE and LIST of FRENCH NOVELS. CLASSICS, &c.
ESSRS. HENRY YOUNG & SONS possess one of the LARGEST STOCKS of OLD and NEW BOOKS in GREAT BRITAIN, and they will be glad to hear from any one in search of Books out of print, as they can in many cases supply them from their large stock. ILLUSTRATED CATALOGUES MONTHLY. Price Gd. 12, South Castle Street, Liverpool.
YPE-WRITING undertaken by highly educated Women of Literary experience (Classical Tripos; Cambridge Higher Local; thorough acquaintance with Modern Languages) Research, Revision, Translation. References to Authors.—Tue Cam- BRIDGE TiPe-Writine AcEncr, 10, Duke Street, Adelphi, WC.
M. MURPAY’S CATALOGUE of SECOND- e HAND BROOKS (No. 96) NOW READY, including Travels, Biography, History, Philosophy, &c. Port free on application. Full value given for Small or large Quantities of Books —79, Renshaw Street. Liverpool.
Page 2
386 THE ATHENZUM N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904
THE AUTOTYPE COMPANY, 74, NEW OXFORD STREET, LONDON, W.C, PERMANENT PHOTOGRAPHIC COPIES OF FAMOUS WORKS OF ART BY THE AUTOTYPE (CARBON) PROCESS. AUTOTYPES of the OLD MASTERS in the GREAT CONTINENTAL GALLERIES. AUTOTYPES of MODERN BRITISH ART. AUTOTYPES of WORKS by ARTISTSof the PRE-RAPHAELITE SCHOOL. AUTOTYPES of PICTURES in the NATIONAL GALLERY. AUTOTYPES of DRAWINGS by OLD MASTERS. AUTOTYPES of SELECTED WORKS from the PAsIS SALONS, The AUTOTYPE FINE-ART CATA- LOGUE. Now ready, NEW EDITION, with upwards of 150 Miniature Photographs of Notable Autotypes and 23 Tint Block Illustra- tions. For convenience of reference the Pub- lications are Arranged Alphabetically under Artists’ Names. Post free, One Shilling.
A Visit of Inspection is invited to the AUTOTYPE FINE-ART GALLERY, 74, NEW OXFORD STREET, LONDON, W.C.
ARUNDEL CHROMOS, Large Number in Stock. Many rare ones. Send Stamp for THIS MONTH'S PRINTED LIST. St. Jude’s Depot, Birmingham. LA MORE PRESS PUBLICATIONS will be found advertised on p. 412.
[Hs DE
WNERS of GENUINE SPKCIMENS of OLD ENGLISH FURNITURE, OLD PICTURES, OL!) CHINA, OLD SILVER, &c., who desire to DISPOSE of same PRIVY. ATELY, are invited to send particu'ars to HAMPION & SONS, Pall Mall East, Who are always prepared to give full value for interesting Examples. WANTED TO PURCHASE, WATER-COLOUR VIEWS in AUSTRALIA, by Skinner, Prout, Martens, or 83, High Street, Marylebone,
Oswald Rrierley.—Francis Epwarps, London, W '‘PYPISTS OFFICE.—TWO ROOMS, partly Furnished. First Floor. Some Work ob ble in same Brreac, 5, Henrietta Street,
—Inquire INTERNATIONAL PUBLISHING Covent Garden. THE GREATER PART of an_ old-fashioned HOUSE, looking over Ravenscourt Park, TO LET. Three minutes from District Line. Electric Light shady Garden with a mulberry tree. Cycle House. Inciu-ive rent, 80/.a year.—Apply, by letter, to D., care of Street's, 8, Serie Street, W.C.
Sales bp Auction. Engravings. N ESSRS. SOTHEBY, WILKINSON & HODGE will SELL et AUCTION. at their House, No. 13, Wellington Street, Strand. W.C.. NDAY, March 28. and Two Following Days, at 1 o'clock sreaheale. mENGRAY INGS, Framed and in the Portfolio, eye Mezzotint Portraits of Ladies, rs y mith af fterG Remney. Lady Hamilton as Fmma, by J. Jones, p83 os same. &c—Fancy Subjects of the English school, after F. Wheatley. A. Kauffman, H. Kunbury, G_ Moriano, W R. Bigg, and others, some printed in Colours—Piates from J. M. W. Turner's Lider Studio: um - Naval Aquatints in Colours—Engravings after Old Masters --Drawings, &c May be viewed. Catalogues may be had.
Important Sale of British Birds’ Eggs, and some fine Clutches of rare Foreign Eggs. TUESDAY, March 29, at half-past 12 o'clock, R. J. C. STEVENS wil! OFFER, at his Rooms, 38, King Street Covent Garden, W C., the COLLECTION of BRITISH BIRDS’ EGGS formed by Mr. JOH" A. BUCKNILL. Author of ‘The Birds of Surrey,’ containing many fine varieties, with full + gg-+—fine Clutches of rare data ; also other fine Lots of British Rirds’ INDIAN Species ano Varieties taken in Nova Zembia, with full data. BLRD»s’ BGGS a valuable Collection in Lets to suit ail buvers. of over 600 British and other Bird skins, with full data to each specimen— tine Fgg Cabinets—also a tine Co!lection of British Lepiduptera. On view day prior, 10 to 5, and morning of Sale Catalogues on app'ication. Photographic Cameras and Lenses, Microscopes and Microscopic Slides, Scientific Instruments and Apparatus. - THURSDAY, March 31, at half-past 12 o'clock. B J. yd STEVENS will OFFs BR at bis Rooms, Street. Covent Garden, W.C., many fine PHOTO- GRaruié CAMERAS. Hand and Studio, by Best Makers, also Lenses and Fieid Telescopes—Surveying Instru- ee Levels and Drawing Instruments—Microscopes for Dissecting, Histological, and Gene h, for Students’ and Advanced Work —Electrical Inatruments and Apparatus—and many Lots of valuabie Miscellaneous Property. ig of Sale. Wea a On view W Miscellaneous Books in ali Classes of Literature. ESSRS. HODGSON & CO. will SELL by AUCTION, at their Rooms, 115, Chancery ey Ww.c., 28. and Two Following Days, at o'clock, US BOOKS, comprising Lyly’s Euphues, 1508, and a few others in Old English’ Literature — ch Lliustrated Hooks — Baskerville’s Prayer Book, with Landscape Painting on the fore edge —Stevenson's cee ‘and other First Editions—the Oxford Fae- simile Shakespeare — Standard Historical Works, some in morocco bindings—Hentham’s Works. by Bowring. 11 vols —Sowerby’s Botany, 13 vols., and other Books on Natural History—Proceedings of the Soeiety of Antiquaries of Scotland, 1871-1902, 31 vols.—Encyclopedia tannica, Tenth Edition, 35 vols. —a jarxe Collection of "Books in General L ; also a C of Autograph Letters. Catalogues on prem.
2to5and
Rare and valuable Books, including a Library from an old Country House, the Property of a Gentleman. ESSRS. HODGSON & CO. will SELL by AUCTION, at their Rooms, 115, a Lane, W.C SHORTLY AFren EASTER, RARE and VALUABLE O0KS, com ris: ing Buck's Antiquities in England and Wales, Original Iseue, 3 vols.— Lipsco; History of Buekinghamshire, 7 vols.—the Fourth Folio Shakespeare— Books in Elizabethan Literature—Blake's Visions of the Daughters of Albion, Original Coloured Copy—Hayley’ 8 Life of Romney. Presentation Copy—fine Copies of Surtees’s Jorrocks’s Jaunts, and Apperley’s Life of Mytton, with Alken’s Illustrations— handsomely bound Sets of the Edition de Luxe Thackeray and Dicsens, &c. Catalogues are preparing.
Valuable Books. including a Portion of the Library of the late ALFRED SALOMONS, Esq.,0f Manchester, and the Dupli- cate Coilectwon of Works relating to Eton, formed by the late Dr, MANLEY SIMS, ESSRS. PUTTICK & SIMPSON will SELL by AUCTION at their Galleries, 47, Leicester Square, W.C., on WEDNESDAY, April 13, and Two Following Days, atten minutes stl — precisely, valuable BUOKS, i roperties.
ig the above
Ex-Libris. ESSRS. PUTTICK & SIMPSON will SELL by AUCTION, at their Galleries, 47, Leicester Square, WC., EARLY m APRIL, an important COLLECTION. et BOOK-PLATES (Ex-Libris), including many rare and va!uable specimens. — CHRISTIE, MANSON & WOODS ctfully give notice that they will hold the following SALES by AUCTION at their Great Rooms, King Street, St. James’s Square, the Sales commencing at | o'clock precisely :— Tw-DAY (SATURDAY), March 26,and MONDAY, _ 28, PICTURES and DRAWINGS of the late C. H. T. HAWKINS, sq On MONDAY, March 28, and TUESDAY, March 29, OLD ENGLISH FURNITURE, PORCELAIN, and OBJECTS of AKT, the Property of a LADY, and from various Private Sources. On TUESDAY, March 29, the COLLEVTION of BOOKS, ENGRAVINGS, and OLD DRAWINGS of the late C. H. T. HAWKINS, Esq. TUESDAY, WEDNESDAY, and THURSDAY, April 12, 13, 14. THORN YCROFT, RHOS-ON-SEA (near Colwyn Bay). ME: F. A. DEW is favoured with instructions to SELL by AUCTION, as above, THE WHOLE OF THE VERY CHOICE AND VALUABLE MODERN AND ANTIQUE HOUSEHOLD APPUINTMENTS,
E of Chi dal,
including some very valuable and other Furniture—Uil Paintings and Water-C a Drawings by many of the best-known Artists—Proof Engravings—Rockingham, Spode. Crown Derby, Copeland, Old Willow. Oriental. Worcester. Old Stafford. Old Delft, Wedgwood, Chelsea, and other China—fine (ld English Cut Glass— Modern and Antique services of Silver and Electro Plate—and the Complete Appointments of over a Dozen Bedrooms, Six or Seven Reception Kooms—Bed and Table Linen—Blankets—and thoroughly well-furnished Domestic Offices. Sale at 1 rp... prompt each day. On view (with Catalogues only, price 6d. each, can be obtained of the Avctionerr, Llewelyn Chambers, Colwyn Bay, and Castle Street, Conway) on Sa’urday, a 9, from 10 A.M. till 1 p.M., and on Monday, April 11, from 10 4 M. til) 4
THE JORTNIGHTLY REVIEW. Contents. APRIL, 1904. RUSSIA and the WAR. By (idipus. FROM HARBIN to MUKDEN. By Col. De la Poer Beresford. COWLEY’S LAST TESTAMENT. By H.C. Minchin. The NEW CAPE PREMIER: Dr. Jameson. By Edward Dicey, C.B. The FUTURE of GERMANY. By Dr. Fmil Reich. OF the TRUE GREATNESS of THACKERAY. By H. H. Statham. SPAIN : Yesterday and To-day. By L. Higgin. The LOST ART of GOVERNMENT. By H. Hamilton Fyfe. MR. BODLEY on the CROWN. By Justin McCarthy. PORT ARTHUR: its Strategic Value. By Angus Hamilton, F R.G.S. Baa -OCEANIC CANAL: Nicaragua or Panama? By Octave zanne. VOX CLAMANTIS. A Sonnet. NAVAL CONCENTRATION—and a MORAL. By Archibald S. Hard. WAYNE WOOD. By Ethel Clifford. D’'ANNUNZI10’S NEW PLAY. By May Bateman. The “LEONAINIE” PROSLEM. By Alfred R. Wallace. LETTERS on the DRAMA:~—1. By Madame Navarro. Cra‘gie. ‘lhird List of Signatures. THEOPHANO. Chaps. 15 6,and17. By Frederic Harrison. London : Chapman & Hall, Ltd. 2. By Mrs.
———— ONGMAN’S MAG ZINB APRIL, 1904. Price SIXPENCE. NATURE’S COMEDIAN. By W. E. Norris. Chaps. 19, 20, MODDER RIVER. Il. By Capt. A. O. Vaughan. IN ARCADY. By Ben Bolt. A METAPHYSICAL PROBLEM. By P. Littlewood. A REBEL at the COURT of LOUIS XIV.: the ee Of Charlotte Elizabeth, Duchess of Orleans. By Dora M. Jone MADAME FELICIE. By M. EB. Francis. FEATHERED FORAGERS. By Alexander Innes Shand. AT the SIGN of the SHIP. By Andrew Lang. London : Longmans, Green & Co. SUGGESTION fora MONUMENTAL HALL ang TOWER at WESTMINSTER (two Views and Pian) ; Christchureb: Harbour ; — and the — Main Drainage; The Institute of rehes (Studeat’s Column); House in Sena Stress: Design fora ure: place Modernity in Decoration, &e, —See the BUILDEK of March 26 (4d; by post, 4}d.). Through any Newsagest; or direct from the Publisher of the Builder, Catherine Street, ‘London, Ww.c.
JUST PUBLISHED. THE DEMOTIC MAGICAL PAPYRUS of LONDON and LEIDEN. Edited by F. LL. GRIFFITH, M.A., and HERBERT THOMPSON. 210 pp. royal 8vo, cloth, 10s. 6d. net. The MS., dating from the third century 4p, which is here editeg for the first time in a single whole, has long been known to scholars, Its subject-matter— magic and di is closely with the Greek magical papyri from Egypt of the same period. London : H. Grevel & Co., 33, King Street, Covent Garden, WC.
JUST READY. 8vo, cloth, gilt top, 12s. net. [SE RISE of BRITISH WEST AFRICA, Comprising the Early History of the Colony of Sierra Leone, the Gambia, Lagos, Gold Coast, &c. With brief Account of Climate, Growth of Education, Commerce, and Religion. Also a Comprehensive History of the Bananas and Bance Islands, and Sketches of the Constitution. By CLAUDE GEORGE, Of the Colonial Secretary’s Office, Sierra Leone. London: Houlston & Sons, Paternoster Square. J.M. DENT & CO.’S LIST. oe BEST BOOKS FOR EASTER. JUST PUBLISHED. ROBERT BROWNING. By EDWARD DOWDEN, LL.D. D.C.L. Crown vo, 4s. 6d, net. DAILY CHRONICLE.— ‘The criticism, from start to finish, is a Avoiding every sort of temptation—eschewing windy para phrase P it moves straight to the heart of the ‘poerry. probing its intention and sifting its performance with great exactitude and no little subtlety of appreciation. [tis in short, true literary criticism of the highest order, making no attempt to bao! its | own cleverness by paradox or violence, but simply setting about its busi ina like way, and performing its proper task with high ethciency and yechasatinoranin no means without eloquence.” SIENA. By Edmund Gardner. With numerous Illustrations from Reproductions and yg er Drawings by HELEN M. JAMKS. Feap. 8vo, 4s. td. net, leather. DAILY CHRONICER All the makers of Siena pass through Mr. pe agen pages. It is a guide-book, and something more. A guide k in its re and comer. Something more in it» ical insig Symp
THIRD EDITION JUST PUBLISHED. VENICE: and its Story. By T. OKEY. 1l. 1s. net. With 112 Illustrations, 60 being in Colours. DAILY CHRONICLE.—“ Authors, illustrators, and publishers are alike to be congratulated on the production of this beautiful book.’ CAMBRIDGE: and its Story. By the DEAN of ELY. A beautiful Volume, with 24 Tinted Lithographs and other Lilustrations by HERBERT RAILTON,. li. 1s. aa CITIES. By Arthur Symons. With 8 Photogravures. 7s. 6d. net SATURDAY REVIEW.—* The entire book will be a delight to the cultured traveller, to whom we here commend it with sincere applause.’ LAMB’S WORKS. Edited by W. MACDONALD. With 465 Illustrations, Reproduced from the Original Editions, from Portraits, and from: Drawings by Modern Artists. 12 vols. long feap. 2/. 2s. net, or 3s. 6d. net each vol. 29 and 80, Bedford Street, Lo: don, W.C.
By duct we C may scier and skal Wor yea scie it, < waj upo and ene phy of : wo! it h Ccivi the inte
Page 3
Pil Otte ted rs. he TT we we, eS N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 THE ATHENAUM 387 ——— = SWAN SONNENSCHEIN & CO. NEW ADDITIONS TO THE PARALLEL GRAMMAR SERIES. ADVANCED FRENCH COMPOSITION. By H. E. BERTHON, Hon. M.A., and C. T, ONIONS, M.A. (Lond.). 106 pages, 2s. 6d. AN ADVANCED &E NGLISH SYNTAX. By C. T, ONIONS, M.A. (Lond.). 166 pages, 28, 6d. REWRITTEN EDITION OF DR. A. RUSSEL WALLACE’S THE WONDERFUL CENTURY In the Age of New Ideas in Science and Invention. By ALFRED RUSSEL WALLACE, Author of ‘Island Life,’ &c. Entirely Revised, and now first illustrated with 107 Pictures. 540 pp. 7s. 6d. net. ‘*The second edition of Mr. Wallace’s book is really a remarkable pro- | duction. It is an extremely comprehensive epitome of modern science, and | we can quite envy any educated though unscientific person who in its pages may for the first time be introduced to scientific facts. All the most interesting scientific advances are described therein......and all are described in a simple and telling fashion..... This latest book is one to have and to hold, and we skall be pleased if this review would induce many to add to their library ‘ The Wonderful Gentury.’”—British Medical Journal. THE SCIENTIFIC BASIS OF MORALITY. By G. GORE, LL.D. F.B.S, Author of ‘ The Scientific Basis of National Progress,’ &c. Pp. viii-600, 10s. 6d. net. This important work, on which the author has been engaged for many years, is the outcome and expression of the thoughts of a lifetime spent in scientific work. The chief subject of the book and the main idea pervading it, are expressed in the title. ‘The leading objects are to show, in a general way, that the entire conduct of man—physical, mental, and moral—is based upon a scientific foundation : to make clear the truth that the great powers and laws of science are the chief guides of life; to show that universal energy, acting according to law, is the true “divine” power governing physical, mora!, social, and religious conduct ; and to illustrate the influence of science upon the material, mental, and moral progress of mankind. The work also seeks to show that all human progress is due to natural ciuses ; that it has its origin in new knowledge; that maintenance of the existing state of civilization is due to education and the constant diffusion of knowledge ; that the rate of progress is regulated by the continual conflict of ignorance and intelligence, and that this conflict is itself due to natural causes. The BIBLE from the STANDPOINT OF THE HIGHER CRITICISM. By RAMSDEN BALMFORTH, Author of ‘The New Reformation,’ &c. 3s. 6d. ESSAYS IN FURY. By ARTHUR D. LEWIS. 2s. 6d. ~*A hostile criticism of Christianity, not without literary ability.”— Times. GOD and the AGNOSTICS; or, the End of the Age of Faith, By AN ENGLISHMAN. Large crown 8vo, 6s. ** A book of some originality. The work is largely critical of leading philosophers and divines, and the consideration of a rational social ideal leads bim into the field of — ‘imes. ‘* Much vigorous writing and nota little stimulating thought. The book is in many ways refreshing, and points are made which deserve to be considered.”—Sheffield Telegraph. AMONG the FIFE MINERS. By Kellogg DURLAND. 2s. 6d. ** An interesting and instructive sociological study.”—Scotsman. : he experiences of one who ‘went to see’ what it was like in the pits and in the JESPERSEN (0.).—HOW to TEACH a FOREIGN LANGUAGE. By OTTO JESPERSEN, Professor of English in the University of Copenhagen. Translated from the Danish Original by SOPHIA GHLEN-OLSEN BERTELSEN, M.A. Crown 8vo, 3s. 6d, The CRITICS of HERBARTIANISM, and other Matter contributive to the Study of the Herbartian Question. By F. H HAYWARD, D.Lit. M.A. B.Sc. (Lond.), B.A. (Cantab.), assisted by M. E. THOMAS (Battersea Polytechnic). 4s. 6d. The SECRET of HERBART. By F. H. Hayward, D, Lit. M.A. B.Sc. B.A, [ Shortly, GEOMETRY for KINDERGARTEN STUDENTS. Specially adapted to meet the Requirements of the Examinations of the National Froebel Union. By the late ADELINE PULLAR, Second Edition. Crown 8vo. 1903. 38. ** Deserves a wide circulation in our nurseries and in the lower forms of our preparatory schools.”— Guardian. **A successful attempt to state and explain clearly the various problems and facts of geometry which are required by the syllabus of the National Froebel Union.” Practical Teacher. PRO PATRIA: a New Latin Story. By Prof. SONNENSCHEIN, D.Lit. (Oxon.), M.A. Illustrated. 2s. 6d. Being a continuation of the same author’s ‘ Ora Maritima,’ which has had such a remarkable success since its first publication about a year ago. FROM ADAM'S PEAK to ELEPHANTA (Ceylon and India) By EDWARD CARPENTER. New and Cheaper Edition in crown 8vo, with the Original Illustrations, 4s. 6d. The FOURTH DIMENSION. By C. H. Hinton. With Diagrams. [Shortly. FAMOUS SAYINGS and their AUTHORS. By EDWARD LATHAM. [Shortly. NEW NOVELS. TO BE ISSUED SHORTLY. FRED SEAGOOD. By Edward Roper. With numerous Illustrations by the AUTHOR. 6s. | SPINDRIFT. By Ella Fordyce, Author of ‘Had I but Known.’ Illustrated. |The WIGHT THAT WAILED, and other Tales. By ERNEST MANFRED, Author of ‘ Peelah.’ SWAN SONNENSCHEIN & CO., Limtr:p, London.
Page 4
388 N° 3987, Marcx 26, 1904 THE ATHENAUM SMITH, ELDER & CO’S NEW BOOKS. NEW NOVEL BY GRAHAM HOPE. JUST PUBLISHED, crown 8vo, 6s. THE GAGE OF RED AND WHITE. By GRAHAM HOPE, Author of ‘A Cardinal and his Conscience,’ ‘ The Triumph of Count Ostermann,’ &c. OUTLVUOK.—“A stirrirg romance of the six- teenth century. Perhaps as good as anything Mr, Stanley Weyman has done.” NEW VOLUME BY THE AUTHOR OF ‘DOWNY V. GREEN.’ PUBLISHED TO-DAY, crown 8vo, 3s. 6d. DWALA: a Romance. By GEORGE CALDERON, Author of ‘The Adventures of Downy V. Green, Rhodes Scholar at Oxford.’ WITH A PREFACE BY MRS. HUMPHRY WARD. Demy 8vo, 16s. AN INTRODUCTION TO THE NEW TESTAMENT. By Prof. A. JULICHER. Translated by JANET PENROSE WARD. GLASGOW HERALD. —‘“‘A real boon has been conferred upon English readers by this admirable translation...... Mrs. Humphry Ward has frequently shown her deep interest in such subjects as Jiilicher discusses here, and she has written a well-informed and very sjmpathetic prefatory note.” A NATURALIST IN THE GUIANAS. By EUGENE ANDRE, F.R.G.S. M.S.A. F.ZS. With a Preface by Dr. J. SCOTT KELTIE, Secre- tary of the Royal Geographical Society. With 2 Coloured Plates, 32 Illustrations, including 2 Por- traits of the Author, and a Sketch Mav. Demy 8vo, 14s. net. OUTLOOK.—‘‘A volume of intense interest. Mr. André has eyes for many things besides the immediate object of his pursuit.” PUNCH.—“A notable addition not only to geographical knowledge and incidents of personal adventure, but to rare information of hitherto unknown birds that swarm in the pathless forests of Venezuela.” THE CORNHILL MAGAZINE For APRIL. Price ONE SHILLING. Contents. SIR LESLIB STEPHEN. By Frederic ey by. TRUANTS. Chaps 10-12. By A W. Mason wa ~ 4 of MAGNIFICENT DISTANCES. By ieacy w. HISTORICAL MYSTERIES. Daniel Dunglas Home _ By Andrew Lang. The by ye TORPEDO. By Lieut. G. BE. Arm- stron MEMONLES of of the T/MES. By Alex. Innes Shand. The BEGINNING in the FAR EAST.” By Dana ti e n the FAR EAST. By Davi ICARUS. By Arthur F Wallis. denim OLD TIME NEWFOUNDLAND. By Judge Prowse, K.C. TRODD’S CORNER. By Horace Annesley Vachell. ** Messrs. SMITH, FLDER & CO. wiil be happy to forward @ copy of their CATALOGUE post free on pan be nt Ps IV. The Strange Case of London : MR. WM. HEINEMANN’S NEW BOOKS. THE TOPIC OF THE DAY. K O R E A. By ANGUS HAMILTON, Third Impression. With Map and Illustrations. Demy 8vo, 15s. net. PALL MALL GAZETTE,.—“ This extremely es and delightful volume will retain its values long after the present crisis has passed away. The standard work on Korea ALL THE RUSSIAS. Travels and Studies of Contemporary Conditions and Problems in European Russia, Finland, Siberia, the Caucasus, and Central Asia. By HENRY NORMAN, M.P. A New Edition, with many Illustrations and Maps. THE WORLD'S HISTORY. Edited by Dr. H. F. HELMOLT. With an Introduction by the Right Hon. JAMES BRYCE, D.C.L. LL.D. F.B.S. Superbly illustrated with Maps and Plates. To be completed in 8 royal 8vo vols, 15s. net each in cloth, or 21s. net each in half-morocco. VOL, II. OCEANIA, EASTERN ASIA, AND THE INDIAN OCEAN. ENGLISH LITERATURE. AN ILLUSTRATED RECORD. By RICHARD GARNETT, C.B. LL.D., and EDMUND GOSSE, M.A. LL.D. In 4 vols. small imperial 8vo, fully illustrated. Price, in cloth, 3/. net; or in half-leather, 4/. 4s. net the Set. Volumes in cloth may be had separately at 16s. net each until on and after May 1, when these Volumes will be supplied in Sets only. TIMES.—“ The story of our early literature has never been popularized to such good purpose...... We cannot think of any living writer who would have achieved the task better than Dr. Garnett.’ A beautifully illustrated Booklet post free on application. REAL CONVERSATIONS. Recorded by WILLIAM ARCHER. With Portraits. 6s. net. DAILY NEWS.—“ Mr. Archer has hit upon a contrivance which has produced a book exceedingly readable and suggestive.” Demy 8vo, 18s. net. THREE GOOD NOVELS TO READ. THE MAGNETIC NORTH. By ELIZABETH ROBINS (C. E. Raimond), Author of ‘The Open Question.’ 6s. STANDARD.—“ A work of genius. This a large word, but nothing short of genius would bring such unfamiliar matter home to the inexperienced imagination. It is not quite like any other book...... We must go a long way to match it.” THE INTERLOPER. By VIOLET JACOB, Author of ‘The Sheepstealers.’ 6s. SPECTA TOR,.—" Mrs. Jacob is to be doubly congratulated on ‘ The Interloper ’—first, on having written a singular! Vv interesting and attractive story; and, second, on having maintained a high standard of excellence achieved in ‘The Sheepstealers.’’ JUST PUBLISHED. URIAH THE HITTITE. By DOLF WYLLARDE. 6s. Dolf Wyllarde will be remembered as the author of ‘The Story of Eden,’ a book which had a great vogue when it first appeared, and has continued in steady demand ever since. SIX SHILLINGS EACH. THE LION OF GERSAU. THE LAW OF LIFE. “ SIRRAH.” | ANNA McC. SHOLL. (Just published. we ‘THE MONEY GOD. UNTO EACH MAN HIS OWN. BASS BLAKE. samugL Gorpon., THE ISLAND PHARISEES. | JOHN GALSWORTHY. LOVE THE FIDDLER. ‘THE WEB. LLOYD CSBOURNE. F, TREVOR HILL. SMITH, ELDER & CO. 15, Waterloo Place, &.W. London: WM. HEINEMANN, 21, Bedford Street, W.C. B] TI Tr JE
Page 5
N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 THE ATHENZXUM 389 - MESSRS. ARCHIBALD CONSTABLE & CO.’S LIST. REMINISCENCES of the (AMERI- CAN) CIVIL WAR. By General JOHN B. GORDON, Illustrated with Portraits. Demy 8vo, 474 and xii. pp. 16s. net. “ Fascinating reading.”— Morning Post. * Thrilling descriptions of his experiences.” Manchester Guardian. ‘* A story at first hand, and therefore of first- rate importance, which gives a true insight into the origin, the conduct, and the circumstances of a campaign unprecedented in the history of the world.”—New Liberal Review. STUDIES in SHAKESPEARE. By J. CHURTON COLLINS, Author of ‘Ephemera Critica,’&c. Extra crown 8vo, 7s. 6d. ‘Full of solid information, and the fruits of that erudition which is a feature of Mr. Collins’s criticism.”—Atheneum. “Mr. Collins has done real service to students of these two great poets, alike by his researches and by his appreciation.”— Times, ‘*A book we have found exceptionally interesting and suggestive, and of high credit to English scholarship.” — Manchester Guardian. “It is instinct from first to last with that vigour of mind in which, among living critics, Mr. Collins bas no superior.” WILLIAM ARCHER in the Daily Chronicle. “Tt is a pleasure to come across a book as scholarly, vigorous, and independent in its judg- ments as ‘ Studies in Shakespeare.’ ”—Standard. The COMMON SENSE of MUNI- CIPAL TRADING. By BERNARD SHAW, Author of ‘Man and Superman,’ &c. Crown 8vo, 2s. 6d, “ A refreshing example for economical writers— that is to say, writers on economical matters.” Morning Post. ‘“‘Mr, Shaw at his best.”— Daily News. READY IMMEDIATELY, The MEMOIRS of HENRY VIL- LARD, Journalist and Financier, 1835-1900. 2 vols. demy 8vo, with Portraits and Maps, 21s. net. An autobiographical record of the varied and romantic career of the war journalist who sub- pletion. Full of incident and valuable for its reminiscences of Lincoln and other prominent men of the time, as well as for its descriptions of important battles of the Civil War. The AGAMEMNON. Rendered into English Verse by the late Rev. EDWARD THRING, Head Master of Uppingham School: Demy 8vo, 10s. 6d. net. ELECTRICITY and MATTER. By Prof. J. J. THOMSON, D.Sc., Author of ‘The Discharge of Electricity through Gases,’ &c, Extra crown 8vo, 5s. net. The SECOND AFGHAN WAR, 1878-80. Vol. II. Its Causes, its Conduct, and its Consequences. By Col. H. B. HANNA. Demy 8vo, with Maps and Plans, 15s. net. ELIZABETHAN SONNETS. With an Introduction by SIDNEY LEE. 2 vols. 8s. net. [An English Garner. The CHURCH of ST. MARY the VIRGIN, OXFORD, in its Relation to some Famous Events in English History. By the Rev. HENRY L. THOMPSON. Crown 8vo. With Frontispiece. 3s. 6d. net. “Mr. Thompson’s book is marked by a rare ‘historic’ charm A beautiful little volume.” Bookman. POEMS. By St. John Lucas. Crown 8vo, 5s. net. BEATTIE and HIS FRIENDS. By MARGARET FORBES. Demy 8yvo. With a Frontispiece. 15s. net. AMERICAN TARIFF CONTRO- VERSIES in the NINETEENTH CENTURY. By EDWARD STANWOOD. 2 vols. demy 8yvo, about 400 pp. each, 18s. net. NEW 6s. NOVELS. The DELIVERANCE. By Ellen GLASGOW, Author of ‘The Battle Ground,’ ‘The Voice of the People,’ &c. With IIlus- trations in Colour by FRANK SCHOONOVER. BINDWEED. By Nellie K. Blissett, Author of ‘ The Concert Director,’ &c, The LADDER of TEARS. By G. COLMORE, Author of ‘The Strange Story of Hester Wynne,’ &c. The TUTOR’S LOVE STORY. By ae ae FRITH, Author of ‘In Search of JEWEL. By Clara Louise Burnham, Author of ‘A Right Princess,’ &c. SIX-SHILLING NOVELS. READY SHORTLY. BELCHAMBER. By Howard OVERING STURGIS, Author of ‘Tim,’ ‘ All that was Possible.’ AGNES AND EGERTON CASTLE’S NEW BOOK. INCOMPARABLE BELLAIRS. Illustrated by FRED PEGRAM. Crown 8vo, 63. The IMPERIALIST. By Sara JEANNETTE DUNCAN (Mrs, Everard Cotes), Author of ‘ Those Delightful Americans,’ &c. PEASE, Author of ‘ Borderland Studies,’ &c. MRS. PEEL'S NEW HOUSEHOLD BOOK. The SINGLE-HANDED COOK. More Recipes, Menus, &c. By the Author of ‘Ten Shillings a Head for Housebooks,’ &c. 3s. 6d. HISTORY of YORKSHIRE COUNTY CRICKET, 1833-1903. By the Rev. R. 8. HOLMES. Demy 8vo, 5s. net. MAGNUS SINCLAIR. By Howard Demy 8yo, 400 pp. with 54 Illustrations and a Map, 16s, net. CANADA IN THE _ TWENTIETH CENTURY. An Account of its People, Industries, Urban and Rural Life, its Scenery, Society, and Sport, in the Old Provinces, French and English, and in the New West—from Quebec to Vancouver. By A. G. BRADLEY, Author of ‘The Fight with France for North America,’ ‘ Wolfe,’ &c. sequently became a power in the financial world, and carried the Northern Pacific Railroad to com- | The only comprehensive book on Canada written by an author familiar with the country Of particular interest alike to the intending set: ler or traveller, the politician, business man, or g.neral reader. SOME PRESS OPINIONS. ‘Mr. Bradley’s excellent book should be widely | read. It should be placed in every public library as soon as possible.”—Daily Chronicle. ‘If I could [ would put this volume in the hands of every public man in the Empire, of every merchant and manufacturer, of every intending settler.”"—Sir GILBERT PARKER in Academy and Literature. “A readable and instructive book, written in vleasant style—have no hesitation in recommendiny to all persons interested in Canada.”—Field. ‘* Everywhere one finds the same comprehensive view of the country he is describing, the same | accuracy and the same understanding of the genius of the Canadian people.”—Toronto Globe. “Exceedingly pleasant reading—a book from which one might select an interesting passage quoted at random from any page-—can hardly fail to be consulted by those who have need to refer to | a good general work 01 Canada.”—Daily Telegraph, ‘A book I have fo :nd extremely interesting and it will be found sti.oulating and serviceable to people about to visit Canada.” — WestminsterGazette. “A well-written volume—deserves a welcome from every one interested inthe subject.”—Scotsizan. “ A more comprehensive view of Canada and its | affairs it would be difficult to present.” Daily Mail. ‘*The reader who does not obtain from it enter- tainment and information must be an exceptional person.” — Globe. ‘A deeply interesting description of Canada and the Canadians written by one who is thoroughly familiar with that country and its people.” Trish Times. “ A clear and attractive style. Has planned and carried out the work with discretion and judgment —fascinating and comprehensive,.”— Yorkshire Post. ‘‘He has something interesting to say about every part of the country...... Beautifully illustrated. ....seHe leaves no part of Canadian life untouched, and we may say without hesitation that he has produced a book which will provide Englishmen with the best picture of Canadian life that can be devised.”— Manchester Guardian. ARCHIBALD CONSTABLE & CO., Luomirep, 2, Whitehall Gardens, Westminster.
Page 6
THE ATHENZUM N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 390 MACMILLAN & CO.’S LIST VOLS. I. AND II, NOW READY. A HISTORY OF MODERN ENGLAND. By HERBERT PAUL, In 5 vols. 8vo, Vols. I. and II. 8s. 6d. net each. WORLD.—« Mr. Paul's fine volumes are admirable examples of the way in which history should be written....Will certainly be the standard work on the period.” FISHING HOLIDAYS. By STEPHEN GWYNN. Extra crown 8vo, 7s. 6d. net. NEW BOOK BY THE AUTHOR OF ‘ELIZABETH AND HER GERMAN GARDEN.’ THE ADVENTURES OF ELIZABETH IN RUEGEN. With Map. Crown $vo, 6s. CLASSICAL LIBRARY.—New Vol, The HOMERIC HYMNS. Edited, with Preface, Apparatus Criticus, Notes, and Appendices, by Thomas W. ALLEN, M.A., Fellow and Tutor of — College, Oxford, and E. E. SIKES, M.A., : omg | -_ Tutor of St. John’s College, Cambridge. 8vo, s. 6d. net. The MAKING of ENGLISH. By HENRY BRADLEY, Hon. M.A.Oxon., Hon. Ph.D. Heidelberg, sometime President of the Philological Society. Globe 8vo, 4s. 6d. METHODS of SOCIAL ADVANCE. Short Studies in Social Practice by Various Authors. Edited = C. S. LOCH, B.A., Secretary of the London —e rganization Society. Extra crown 8vo, 3s. 6d. net. The OPENING of the MISSISSIPPI: a Struggle for Supremacy in the American Interior. 2 AUSTIN OGG. Extra crown 8vo, s. 6d. net. SEEKING the KINGDOM. A Study. By ERNEST KE. DAY. Crown 8vo, 6s. 6d. net. EASTER TOURS. MACMILLAN’S GUIDE-BOOKS. GUIDE to ITALY. Fourth Edition. With 51 Maps and Plans. 10s. net. The EASTERN MEDITERRANEAN, including GREECE and the GREEK ISLANDS, CONSTANTINOPLE, SMYRNA, EPHESUS, &c. Second Edition. With 27 Maps and Plans. 9s. net. The WESTERN MEDITERRANEAN, including SICILY. With 21 Maps and Plans. 9s. net. ANCIENT ATHENS. By Ernest ARTHUR GARDNER. With Illustrations, Maps, and Plaus. 8vo, 21s net. TIMES.—“ Splendidly illustrated....Prof. Gardner's descriptions of extant me are 1) ...On all imp points we find Prof. Gardoer eminently sane and sensible.” APRIL NUMBERS READY ON TUKSDAY. MACMILLAN’S MAGAZINE. Price ls. Annual Subscription, post free, 12s. THE CENTURY MAGAZINE. Illustrated. Price 1s. 4d. Annual Subscription, post free, 16s. The APRIL Number contains :— VILLAS near ROME. By Edith Wharton SINCERITY and LOVE By Maurice Maeterlinck. The YOUTH of WASHINGTON. ‘Told in the Form of an Auto- erp y. y S. Weir Mitchell, M.D. LANDMA RKS of POE in RICHMOND By Charles M. Graves. 1 se Iv. By JACK LONDON, Author of ‘The Call of the And numerous other Stories and Articles of General Interest. ILLUSTRATED MAGAZINE FOR CHILDREN, ST. NICHOLAS. Price ls. Annual Subscription, post free, 12s. The APRIL Number contains :— The AUTHOR of ‘ROBINSON CRUSOE.’ By W. B. Northrop. R BINSON CRUSOE'S ISLAND (200 oO 0. J : (2 ears later). B: Collins. Illustrated. “ > nS. A JAPANESE “ MIDDY” By Teiichi Yamagata. NATURE and SCIENCE for YOUNG FOLKS. Illustrated. And numerous other Stories for the Young. MACMILLAN & CO., LimITED, London, HURST & BLACKETT’S NEW PUBLICATIONS. —_—o——. NOW READY, 1 vol. demy 8vo, 7s. 6d, net. A STUDY of BRITISH GENIUS. By HAVELOCK ELLIS, Author of ‘The New Spirit,’ ‘The Nineteenth Cen- tury,’ &c, ‘*A book of very great interest and value, not merely for the general reader, but for students of sociology, psychology, and anthropology.”—Manchester Guardian. NEW AND CHEAPER EDITION, 1 vol. large crown, 6s. net, The HEARTS of MEN. By H. FIELDING, Author of ‘ The Soul of a People,’ &e. [ Ready shortly. SECOND EDITION. 1 vol. 6s. The MAN from DOWNING STREET. By WILLIAM LE QUEUX, Author of ‘The Tickencote Treasure,’ ‘ Secrets of the Foreign Office,’ &c. ‘The story of his adventures makes as good a tale of mystery and intrigue as any reasonable lover of such tales could desire. It is one of the best Mr. Le Queux has ever told.”—Scotsman, ‘*Mr. Le Queux gives us adequate sensation without straining verisimilitude in too violent or vulgar a fashion. ‘The Man from Downing Street’ will be enjoyed to the full.”"—Pall Mall Gazette. “This strikes us as being out and away the best thing Mr. Le Queux has yet given us.”—/rish Times. **One of the best books of its kind I have read for a long time past.”— Pelican. NOW READY. 1 vol. 3s. 6d. TALLY. By Mrs. Finnemore, Author of ‘A King of Shreds and Patches,’ ‘A Man’s Mirror,’ &c. “The plot is unusual and natural. The conflict of love and law is always interesting......a book that deserves to be read as being fiction that is not journalism but artistry.” Morning Post. A SENSATIONAL STORY. 1 vol. 6s. The TURNSTILE of NIGHT. By Mrs, C. N. WILLIAMSON, Author of ‘The Silent Battle,’ &c. “ There can be no doubt that the work is a good one of its own sensational kind.”—Glasgow Herald. “Mrs. Williamson’s wonderful imagination has served her well.”—Dundee Advertiser. “The author has so cleverly worked up the excitement that one cannot lay down the book until the end is known.” Morning Post, NOW IN DEMAND. 1 vol. 6s. AN INARTICULATE GENIUS. By W. R. H. TROWBRIDGE, Author of ‘The Situations of Lady Patricia,’ ‘A Girl of the Multitude,’ &c., “The novel shows promise, and is not without its dramatic moments, especially at the end, the climax turning on the emotional hero’s love for his elder — ‘mes, “ Full of cleverness and real thought.’”’— Atheneum. ‘* All. the characters are drawn with refreshing vitality, especially the children.”— Morning Post. **The fiction is one of literary distinction, and its problem and the human materials used to demonstrate it are singu- larly interesting.” — Dundee Advertiser. A LOVE STORY. 1 vol. 6s. The KINGDOMS of this WORLD. By STEPHEN HARDING. “An amusing story with some serious moments, and anyhow it makes capital reading.” —Daily Mail. “ Just a love story beautifully told and not without some really dramatic situations.”—Ziterary World. ** We have read this book with great enjoyment.” Ladies’ Field, A NEW NOVEL, READY MARCH 29, 1 vol. 6s. A GOD of CLAY. By Bertrand WAUGH. THE SIXPENNY EDITION OF JOHN HALIFAX, GENTLE- MAN, by Mrs. CRAIK, has been reprinted and is now ready. HURST & BLACKETT, LIMITED, 13, Great Marlborough Street, London, W. MESSRS. METHUEN’S NEW LIST. The MICROCOSM of LONDON; or, London in Miniature. With 104 Illustrations in Colour by PUGIN aud ROWLANDSON. In 3 vols. small 4to, 3 Guineas net. This is one of the finest and most popular of old coloured books, and is an invaluable description of London a century ago. The plates are unusually interesting, being the result of a collaboration between a distinguished architect and a no less distinguished artist. It is reproduced on a reduced scale from the original edition published by R. Ackermann, The LIFE and LETTERS of OLIVER CROMWELL. By THOMAS CARLYLE. With an Introduction by C. H. FIRTH, M.A., and Notes and Appendices by Mrs. S. C. LOMAS. 3 vols. demy 8yo, 18s. net. This edition is brought up to the standard of modern scholarship by the addition of numerous new letters of Cromwell, and by the correction of many errors which recent research has discovered. DISRAELI. A Study in Personality and Ideas. By WALTER SICHEL. With a Frontis- piece. Demy 8vo, 12s. 6d. net. THINGS SEEN in MOROCCO. Being a Bundle of Jottings, Notes, Impressions, Tales, and Tributes. By A. J. DAWSON. With many Illus- trations. Demy 8vo, 10s. 6d. net. A MODERN BCOTIA. By Deborah PRIMROSE. Crown 8vo, 6s. SLINGSBY and SLINGSBY oe eee eS A SHORT HISTORY of ENGLISH ARCHITECTURE. By T. D. ATKINSON. With numerous Illustrations by the Author. Feap. 8vo, 3s. 6d. net. BEACONSFIELD. By W. Sichel. With 12 Illustrations. Feap. 8vo, 3s. 6d.; leather, 4s, net. [Little Biographies. TITUS ANDRONICUS. Edited by H. B. BAILDON. Demy 8vo, 3s. 6d. [Arden Shakespeare, SHELLEY at OXFORD. By Thomas JEFFERSON HOGG. With an Introduction by R. A. STREATFEILD. Fcap. 8vo, 2s. net. The LIFE of EDWARD, LORD HERSERT of CHERBURY. Written by Himself. From the Edition printed at Strawberry Hill in the year 1745. Leather, 2s. net. The VISIONS of DOM FRANCISCO DE QUEVEDO VILLEGAS, Knight of the Order of St. James. Made English by R.L. From the Edition printed for H. Herringman, 1668. Leather, 2s. net. LITTLE BOOKS ON ART. With 30-50 Illustrations. Demy 16mo, 2s. 6d. net. GREUZE and BOUCHER. By Eliza F. POLLARD. VELASQUEZ. By Wilfrid Wilber- FORCE. THE LITTLE LIBRARY. Small pott 8vo, each volume, cloth, 1s. 6d. net ; leather, 2s. éd. net. SELECTIONS from the ANTI- JACOBIN. With GEORGE CANNING’S Additional Poems. Edited by LLOYD SANDERS. The POEMS of ANDREW MARVELL. Edited by EDWARD WRIGHT. The ESSAYS of ABRAHAM COWLEY. Edited by H.C. MINCHIN. The POEMS of HENRY VAUGHAN. Edited by EDWARD HUTTON. THE LITTLE GUIDES. Small pott 8vo, cloth, 3s.; leather, 3s. 6d. net. ROME. ByC.G.Ellaby. Illustrated by B. C. BOULTER. HAMPSHIRE. By C. J. Cox, LL.D. Illustrated by M. E. PURSER. METHUEN & CO. 36, Essex Street, W.C. es hw mm eG cna N En Ir 80 the list am lite tra’ of que and the Fro pro woU far of ples in | enjc und ease worl at t] to tl ** the coars and | the c toler: devel tures whic read have Coll d Step toric mod¢ obse
Page 7
N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 a THE ATHENAUM 391 —_—_ SATURDAY, MARCH 26, 1904. CONTENTS. Pace Sir LESLIE STEPHEN ON THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY 391 JeREMY TAYLOR... pon eee eee oes aes oo. 392 THE ISLAND PHARISEES see eee ove oe wwe 394 IntsH GODS AND FIGHTING MEN .,.. eco eee ow. 304 HIGHWAYS AND Byways In SusSEX ° ooo ooo New NovsEts (The Vineyard; The Red Leaguers; The Story of Tonty; The Watcher on the Tower; The Vulgar Truth; A Comedy of Conscience; His Emicence; The Law of Life; The Despoilers) 395—397 CiassIcaL Books én ‘one ine eco oe 397 Our Liprary TABLE (Disraeli, a Study in Personality and Ideas; India in the Victorian Age; The Mag- netic North; Friends of Yesterday; The Grant and Validity of British Patents; Dr. Airy on Charles II.; An English Tauchnitz; Reprints; * Daily Mail’ Military Map of Korea) 398-—400 List OF New Books .... e nibs w. 400 Nores FROM OXFORD; LONDON RESIDENCES OF SHAK- SPEARE; ‘THE PsaLMS IN HuMAN LIFE’; THE SPRING PUBLISHING SEASON; SALE ... 401—403 LITERARY GoOssIP ose ose eee +. 403 ScIENCE—THE OLDEST MAP NAMING AMERICA; RE- SEARCH NOTES; SoOcIETIES; MEETINGS NExT WEEK ; GossIP nse one ° 404—407 Fink ARTS—PEWTER PLATE; ENGLISH RENAISSANCE ARCHITECTURE; Messrs. SHEPHERD’S GALLERY; Tue FINE-ART SOCIETY; SALES; Gossip ... 407—410 Music—MLLE. TREMELLI’s DEBUT; Lapy HALLE AND Mr. PLUNKET GREENE’S RECITAL; MADAME MarR- CHESI AND MR. O’SULLIVAN’sS RECITAL; PoPULAR Concert ; M. RIVaRDE'S VIOLIN RECITAL; GossIP; PERFORMANCES NEXT WEEK .,.. ° 410—411 Drama— Love's CARNIVAL’; GossIP 411—412 LITERATURE —o— English Literature and Society in the Eighteenth Century. By Leslie Stephen. (Duckworth & Co.) Ir was with a work dealing with the philo- sophical ideas of the eighteenth century that Leslie Stephen thirty years ago estab- lished once for all his name and rank amongst the foremost critics of English literature. Since then his busy pen has travelled far afield, ranging from the poetry of Shakspeare and Milton to the burning questions of yesterday—to the nimble genius and delicate craftsmanship of Stevenson, the daring methods and brilliant art of Froude, the titanic industry and gladiatorial prowess of Huxley. Yet now and then he would turn aside from the altitudes of the far past, or the thronged and dusty levels of the present, to tarry awhile on the pleasant tablelands of the middle-distance, in the genial company of men who could enjoy the leisure they possessea—men who understood the art of living, and were at ease and satisfied with themselves and the world around them. And now once more, at the close of a strenuous career, he reverts to the seculum rationalisticum— ‘the century, as its enemies used to say, of coarse utilitarian aims, of religious indifference and political corruption ; or, as I prefer to say, the century of sound common sense and growing toleration, and of steady social and industrial development.” The volume before us consists of six lec- tures (here rearranged in five chapters) which, owing to the author’s illness, were read on his behalf at Oxford last year, and have since been seen through the press, by his nephew, Mr. Herbert Fisher, of New College. In the opening chapter Sir Leslie Stephen expounds and vindicates the his- torical attitude and inductive methods of modern criticism. In former days, he observes, critics conceived of their office as judicial ; they held that their business was to try the pretender by the laws formulated for all time by Aristotle, to decide whether he had observed or broken these laws, and to give sentence accordingly. Now under- neath this misconception there lurked an element of truth; for, unquestionably, there are in literature certain fundamental prin- ciples of universal force, from which may be deduced corresponding laws applicable to all modes of human expression. The error of the early critics lay in assuming that the literary forms known to themselves were the only legitimate exposition of those principles—an assumption which betrayed Voltaire (for example) into his barren judg- ments of Dante and Shakspeare. Nowadays the critic has grown liberal enough to recognize a variety of forms, and to own that ‘‘each has its own rules, right under certain conditions, and appropriate within the given sphere.” Moreover, he has come to see that his true relation to these various forms is that of an interpreter; that his rightful function is not judicial, but explanatory ; that his duty is to inquire, “first, what pleased men, and then, why it pleased them; not to decide dogmatically that it ought to have pleased or displeased on the simple ground that it is or is not congenial to himself.” Assuming, then, that from time to time many different literary forms and schools appear, all equally legitimate under their respective conditions, the critic has to account for their rise, continuance, and decay. That in every period the literary no less than the philosophical movement is powerfully affected by the social and political—that, in short, the literary forms and fashions of an age are in themselves determined in great measure by the social position—is Sir Leslie Stephen’s conten- tion :— ‘* Bagehot treats the question in his ‘ Physics and Politics.’ Why, he asks, did there arise a special literary school in the reign of Queen Anne—‘ a marked variety of human expression, producing what was then written and peculiar to it’? Some eminent writer, he replies, gets a start by a style congenial to the minds around him. Steele, a rough, vigorous, forward man, struck out the periodical essay; Addison, a wise, meditative man, improved and carried it to perfection. An unconscious mimicry is always producing countless echoes of an _ original writer.” It will be seen that this version of the matter postulates the emergence, ‘jump at the right hour,’’ of the ‘‘ eminent writer.” Here we are at once confronted with a fac- tor in the question which defies scientific inquiry. No one can pretend to account for the apparition of individual genius. The critic must be content to recognize that it is an element beyond explanation. But if the arrival of the ‘‘eminent writer’’ is deter- mined by the play of forces beyond our ken, the differentia of the school to which he belongs may be seized and registered. And to the province of the critic it belongs to seize and register them; for it is on the correspondence of these special character- istics with the main contemporary intel- lectual characteristics—it is on the fidelity and power with which the literary forms of the school reflect and embody the leading political impulses and the strongest social aspirations of the time—that the vitality and the prosperity of that school and those forms will be found to depend. The birth of a new literary form usually coincides with a sudden expansion of the philosophical horizon. On the counter- influences which retard it Stephen has some weighty observations, the force of which might be illustrated by the story of Wordsworth’s early experiments in search of a suitable medium of expression. In the ‘Descriptive Sketches’ of 1793 there is an attempt to clothe revolutionary ideas in the conventional garb of the period. The poet is in touch with the new social and political movements, but his dic- tion and imagery are still traditional, his machinery obsolescent, his style modelled on that of Erasmus Darwin’s ‘ Loves of the Plants’ (1789). The form, as distinguished from the substance, of the poem is mani- festly contrived, not inspired; it is hope- lessly artificial, and strikes us as, at best, a mere display of technical skill. In the ‘Lyrical Ballads’ (1798), on the other hand, Wordsworth has said good-bye once for all to the traditional conventions and symbols of the eighteenth century; he has come to see the ‘‘inadequacy of the traditional form ’”’—nay, to hold it as ‘‘a gross super- stition.’’ He will presently upbraid the very writers whom but a few years ago he had been fain to imitate for their ‘‘ adulter sted phraseology” and their ‘‘ motley masquerade of tricks, quaintnesses, hieroglyphic, and enigmas.” Yet though he has defi: itively broken away from the old form, he has not yet succeeded in finding one to replace it; that ‘‘ has still to be worked out by a series of tentative experiments.” He has, indeed, in his solitary walks over the Quantocks, thought out the true principles of the matter —principles which, in the famous ‘ Preface’ of 1800, he will endeavour, with indifferent success, to expound; but in the practical application of those principles he is still raw and unripe, and for years to come he will falter, and halt, and stumble into awkward pitfalls, and be forced into humi- liating compromise or disastrous retreat. If, indeed, we may believe certain of his critics, the poet never wholly succeeded in his attempt to strike out a new path and persevere in it: ‘* Wordsworth,” says Matthew Arnold, ‘has no assured poetic style of his own, like Milton.” Certain it is that in after years he reverted now and then to the cold and lifeless conventionalism of the eighteenth century—the very manner which, in the years of his first revolutionary ardour (1798-1805), he had been at such pains to deride. Zante molis erat to create a literary form that should be really original and new. In his subsequent lectures Stephen pro- ceeds to apply to the literary movement of the eighteenth century the inductive critical principles laid down in the opeuing chapter. His object and methods are best described in his own words :— ‘*The literary history, as I conceive it, is an account of one strand, so to speak, in a very complex tissue: it is connected with the intel- lectual and social development ; it represents movements of thought which may sometimes check and be sometimes propitious to the existing forms of art; it is the utterance of a class which may represent, or fail to represent, the main national movement; it is affected more or less directly by a!l manrer of religious,
Page 8
392 THE ATHENAUM N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904
political, social, and economical changes ; and it is dependent on the occurrence of individual genius for which we cannot even profess to account, I propose to take the history of English literature in the eighteenth century. I do not aim at originality. I take for granted the ordinary critical judgments upon the great writers of whom so much has been said by judges certainly more competent than myself, and shall recall the same facts both of ordinary history and of the history of thought. What I hope is that by bringing familiar facts together I may be able to bring out the nature of the connexion between them ; and...... to illustrate one point of view, which, as I believe, it is desirable that literary histories should take into account more distinctly than they have generally done.” Of the abundant merits displayed in the performance thus modestly introduced to our notice—of the philosophic breadth of view, the wide and accurate knowledge, the just sense of economy and proportion, the spontaneous yet thinly-sown felicities of epithet and phrase—it would be difficult to speak in terms of excessive praise. Here, as we read, the panorama of a century unfolds itself to our eyes, while with prompt and unerring finger our guide points to the shifting features, social and political, intellectual and literary, of the passing view, and, in language that by its apt brevity stamps itself on the memory, catches and fixes them, before they disappear, in their mutual connexion and interdependence. As we travel down these pages, closely packed, but never overcrowded, confused, or obscure, we recall the courtly compliment of Cicero—no idle flattery here, but a tribute of just and well-earned praise: ‘Quis te fuit unquam in partiundis rebus, in defini- endis, in explanandis pressior?’’ It would be impossible within our limits to resurvey, however rapidly, the ground traversed ; one salient point in this critical pilgrim’s pro- gress may, however, be noted. The journey is accomplished in four stages. Of these the first takes us to the death of Queen Anne (1714); the second to the Declaration of War with Spain (1739); the third to the close of the Seven Years’ War (1763); and the last to the year of the Regency Bill (1788). Amongst the promi- nent features of the earliest stage is the rapid declension of the Restoration drama, which reaches its nadir under Colley Cibber, Mrs, Centlivre, and (later) Henry Fielding. The matter is handled here in a fashion which strikingly illustrates the dependence of literary form upon national movement. The birth of the Elizabethan drama (to go back to the beginning of the story) synchro- nized with a sudden outburst of national energy in every department. The blossom- ing time of that literary movement was brief, commencing with ‘Tamburlaine’ (1587) on the eve of the Armada, and reaching its highest point some fifteen years later. After 1603 its native strength began to show signs of waning; conscious endeavour after effect began to replace the old spontaneous bravery. With the death of Fletcher in 1625 the period of decline set rapidly in. Thus within the space of a generation came the rise, the culmination, and the decay of a great literary movement. How was this ? The rapid decline of the drama is com- monly (as, ¢.g., by. Matthew Arnold) laid
to the charge of the Puritans, who assailed the players and closed the playhouses. But “it is plain that the decay had begun when the Puritan was the victim instead of the inflictor of persecution.” A glance at the course of political events reveals the truth. With the accession of James I. (1603) there comes a rift in the body politic—a cleavage between the Court and the nation at large. Loyalty is no longer the main current of popular sentiment; the hearts of the great middle class are estranged. Now the stage was an essen- tially aristocratic institution; it existed by and for the pleasure of the sovereign and the great nobles. While, then, as in Elizabeth’s time, the Court which maintained the stage kept also the fealty of the nation, the drama could embody and reflect a powerful popular sentiment; but when there came a split, and the tide of political feeling turned against the Court and its adherents, then the drama, still clinging to its patrons, came to be identified with a tone and a tendency which, instead of leading, became more and more out of sympathy with the main body of the more progressive classes of society. In a word, the stage ceased to be the organ of the nation, and became transformed by degrees into the organ of a corrupt and servile class of courtiers, a class standing absolutely aloof from the mass of the nation in general. And with its trans- — came its inevitable decline and fall. Again, when the playhouses, closed by ordinance of the Lords and Commons in 1648, had been reopened by Charles II., what is often termed ‘‘a reaction” fol- lowed ; in the words of Mr. Austin Dobson, ‘‘the drama, lawless with freedom, began to run shamelessly its riotous and disreputable course.’ And this development also is commonly laid at the Puritans’ door; the deterioration, according to Macaulay, was ‘‘the effect of the prevalence of Puritanism under the Commonwealth.” But “in what sense, in the first place, was there a reaction at all? The Puritans had suppressed the stage when it was already far gone in decay, because it no longer satisfied the great bulk of the nation. The reaction does not imply that the drama regained its old position. When the rule of the saints was broken down, the stage did not become again a national organ. A very small minority of the people can ever have seen a performance. [There were but two ill-sup- ported theatres under Charles, both dependent on the Court.] From the theatre, therefore, we can only argue directly to the small circle of the rowdy debauchees who gathered round the new king. It may certainly be true, but it was not proved from their behaviour, that the national morality deteriorated...... The Restoration comedy was in one sense thoroughly ‘ realistic ’ ; and I am inclined to say that in that lay its chief merit. There is some value in any truthful representation even of vice and brutality...... [But] though realistic in one sense, we may grant to Lamb that such comedy becomes < arti- ficial ’...... because it supposes a state of things -— as happily was abnormal except in a small e. ge of the stage was not confined to the Puritans: Bossuet denounced it ; and Jeremy Oollier and William Law (who also attacked it) were Tories and High Churchmen. The result of Collier’s denun- ciations was that
**the theatre was left more and more to a sec. tion of the ‘town,’ and to the section which was not too particular about decency...... Comedy did not become decent...... The evolution took the form of degeneration...... When Congreve retired, and Vanbrugh took to architecture, and Farquhar died...... the production of comedies was left to inferior writers......[who] were forced by the disfavour into which their art had fallen to become less forcible rather than more refined.” Thus we see how the drama, when once it had divorced itself from the strongest senti- ments and aspirations of the nation, fell into gradual decay. It had come to represent the ideas and tastes of a class composed of the seamy side of the ‘‘town’’; and the nation, unable to modify it in the direction of decency, relinquished it to the rakes, the fribbles, and the inériguantes of the metro- polis. With the death of Farquhar it passed into a mere literary ‘‘survival,” a condition in which it remained till the days of Goldsmith and Sheridan. The composition of these lectures was an extraordinary feat for one already in the toils of a mortal illness. The buoyant and energetic style never flags, holding the reader to the close. We have here the quintessence of our eighteenth-century lite- rature — the rich cream of criticism — the last skimming (to quote the quaint figure of Bacon) of an opulent brain. The Ford Lec- tures for 1903 fitly conclude the life-work of a nobly serious and impartial judge of books and men—a critic whose least merit, perhaps, was his admirably lucid and ungarnished style —stilus sanus et vere Atticus, utpote pressus et tenuis, et qui minimum ab usu quotidiano recedat.
Jeremy Taylor. By Edmund Gosse. ‘English Men of Letters.”’ (Macmillan & Co.) Mr. Gosse is always at home in the seven- teenth century; and—partly, no doubt, because of his literary sympathy with his subject—this biography of Jeremy Taylor is amongst his best work. It is not from any plenitude of material ; for, as he says, Taylor was biographically neglected after his death, and later ages have had to glean such material as they might, with the one contemporaneous support of Rust’s invalu- able funeral sermon on him. Since then biographers have had to reckon with only two principal publications: Heber’s ‘Life of Jeremy Taylor,’ and Eden’s elabo- rate revision of that ‘ Life,’ which (as Mr. Gosse remarks) has not received the recog- nition due to its value. To these has since accrued supplementary matter, bearing specially on the Irish phase of Taylor’s career (this from Ulster church antiquaries), which makes a completer biography possible. Mr. Gosse has treated Taylor with his most practised literary skill, with a pro- portion, an eye for pictorial and allusive detail, a critical sureness and discrimination, which hold the reader’s interest and make for a more permanent value than is always the case in monographs written for @ series. Mr. Gosse is never dull, and he has added to our knowledge of Taylor’s life. In particular he has eliminated a small cloud of untrustworthy witness, by arriving at the conclusion that Lady Wray’s epistolary account of Taylor is 4 forgery, or at best a mere compilation
had shi] Oxi cral arts cen ima it Lav & SC Spo: mit writ him cast dev: at | nati han fria alsc
Page 9
8 B 8 = Yee ™Ns NS Oe oe wee ww tt @ « ViIM N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 THE ATHENAZUM 393 so carelessly ignorant as to be of no value or authority. This is the alleged grand- daughter of Taylor, whose letter was among the papers of William Todd Jones of Homra, used by Heber in his ‘ Life.’ Mr. Gosse’s volume would have importance from this detection alone. The gradual development of the great divine’s genius is brought out by Mr. Gosse with a peculiar clearness that has never been attempted before. This arises largely from his treating Taylor’s books as what they are—the chief portion and feature of his life. Jeremy Taylor was no divine who sometimes published books; he was a writer whose energies took the water-bed of the Church. In this respect—to borrow a parallel from modern times and another communion—he was a Newman rather than a Manning. The son of a barber, he yet from his earliest schooldays displayed both his precocity and his purely intellectual trend. Mr. Gosse upsets more than one pious belief in regard to his ancestry, such as that he was descended from Dr. Nathaniel Taylor, burnt at the stake by Bonner; but himself suggests an assumption not less gratuitous, that Jeremy may have been con- nected with Dr. Thomas Taylor, teacher of Hebrew at Christ’s College during the young Jeremy’s boyhood, and “a brazen wall against Popery.” So hardly shall a biographer avoid the delights of speculative theory! Born at Cambridge, Jeremy slipped easily and naturally into the University, where he lived the typical life of a recluse scholar, passing from scholarship to degree and fellowship with marvellous rapidity, distinguished already by that attractive sweetness which was no less eminent in him than intellectual brilliance, but not gre- garious. As Mr. Gosse remarks, he had for fellows at the University Milton, Crashaw, Herbert, Fuller, and Henry More, yet with none of them did he come into relation. For that matter, it is scarcely less remarkable that none of these great writers to be came into relation with each other. The accident of a schoolfellow getting him to preach for him at St. Paul’s brought reputation and the notice of Laud in his twenty-second year. Laud was delighted, but Taylor was too purely a preacher, too little of a divine, for the aggressive purposes of Laud, who had come to send a sword upon the earth. He transferred Jeremy to a _ fellow- ship in his chosen college of All Souls, Oxford. There for two years he remained, cramming the Fathers and acquiring the arts and learning necessary for seventeenth- century controversy. No doubt Taylor was by nature wholly imaginative and deficient in solidity. Yet it may be doubted whether we should thank Laud for endeavouring to convert him into a school divine. It was this training which spoilt the earlier, and appeared inter- mittently with evil effect in the later, writings of Jeremy Taylor. It did not make him an acute controversialist, a sound casuist, a deep theologian; but it did for a time retard, and afterwards alloy, the development of a splendid rhetorician. Yet at Oxford he did much to broaden his naturally quick sympathies. On the one hand, he was allied with the Franciscan friar Franciscus 4 Sancta Clara, the friend also of his patron Laud ; on the other, with the sceptical and subtle-witted Chilling- | worth, who amicably blamed his one-sided controversial methods. From all this he emerged at last what we should now call a broad-minded High Churchman, who could win the respect even of so fierce a Puritan as Milton, as one whose life, learning, faith, and pure intent Would have been held in high esteem with Paul. In his early publications, the ‘Sermon on the Gunpowder Plot’ and ‘ Episcopacy Asserted,’ there is no token of the Jeremy Taylor who was to be a glory of English prose. His imagination, his opulent fancy, are not even foreshadowed ; they were over- laid and choked by masses of dry learning accumulated at Oxford. The style in the ‘Sermon’ is cramped and uneasy; in the ‘Episcopacy Asserted’ it has become clear and direct, but is still bare and arid. The copious variety of his best work could not be suspected from these efforts. His best friend was misfortune—the rebellion which, depriving him first of Laud and then of his next patron, Lord Hatton of Kirby, cooped him in the obscurity of a South Wales parish as chaplain to Lord Carbery and his lady at their house Golden Grove. It cast out the Laudian train- ing; it removed him from books and pedantry. He could no longer crowd his writings with casuistic and _ patristic learning, with bristling Latin and Greek quotations. Forced back on itself, his native genius began to find out its way. Above all, it set him preaching to a small, sympathetic, and cultured audience of the resident gentry, which—under these bene- ficent conditions—drew forth his rhetorical powers in their highest form. The cast of his genius had an essential kinship with that of the poet, in its profuse imagery, its luxuriant fancy, and—like the poet’s—needed for its development that his mind should be stored by suffering and experience. Family no less than public calamity contributed to this result at Golden Grove, and still further humanized, moreover, his naturally sweet and sym- pathetic character. To this Welsh exile, this enforced retirement, which he looked on as a misfortune, belongs his greatest work — all the work by which he is immortal. The change came with no burst, but gradually, throughout a series of books conceived during his earlier period, when he was rector of Uppingham or accom- panying the army of Charles I. An ‘Apology for Liturgy,’ the ‘Liberty of Prophesying,’ show a style steadily clari- fying itself; his religious romance (as it may almost be called) ‘The Great Exem- plar’ shows also the unfolding of his fancy. The ‘Holy Living,’ his first book entirely conceived at Golden Grove, Mr. Gosse has the independence to pronounce over-valued as a literary work; and we are at one with him. It lacks the imaginative power which makes its successor, the ‘ Holy Dying,’ the first of Taylor’s great books. But it was with the two volumes of sermons preached at Golden Grove, the publication of which we owe to the instigation of his friend and patroness the first Lady Car- bery (who died before their appearance), that his genius culminated. There is Jeremy in all his glory, especially in the first section, later published, though first in time. In order to judge Taylor one need not go further. He has more various power and richness than any of the great seventeenth-century masters of prose. That quality of sweet- ness which endeared him to his friends and made him a popular director humanizes also his writings, and it is wedded with a playful humour, a quality which only Fuller, in different fashion, possessed. Even in the labyrinthine ‘Ductor Dubi- tantium’ comes a description of Chilling- worth, who ‘‘when he read the Roman doctors was very much of their opinion, and as much against them when he read their adversaries ; but kept himself to the religion of his country, con- cerning which at all times he remembered that there were rare arguments and answers respectively, though he could not then think on them.” In the sweet and bantering pleasantry of this there is something akin to lovable Dick Steele. But while these traits humanize Taylor’s magnificent rhetoric, bring it nearer than the remote and lonely splendour of his great rival, Sir Thomas Browne, its master quality is, by general consent, the prodigious activity of his fancy, lavishing itself in endless imagery. He seizes on all natural objects and phenomena, and converts them to radiant illustration, with a universal chemistry scarce paralleled outside Shakspeare. This delighted and delighting profusion is echoed in his style, which, at such times, heaps up its clauses and its ‘‘ands”’ with a breathless and zest- ful prodigality. Let us confess it runs riot to the extent of lacking structural firmness and completion; yet its copiousness has a generous glory, fountaining forth like an organ in blast from all its pipes. And (as Mr. Gosse points out) he can mingle these flocks of clauses with succinct, shapely, and quite modern sentences. Mr. Gosse, too, happily observes his sensitiveness to all images drawn from light. We might say all radiant things, from rosebuds to young children, appeal to his own radiance of power. Tender beauty and sublimity are equally at his command. But beyond his province of rhetoric Taylor was weak; in pure intellect he did not excel, and no study could make him a controversialist or a great divine. Thus, when years quieted the ferment of fancy, he declined. From the time he left Wales he put forth no more great work, and his Irish episcopate saw a fine genius pass away in dreary ecclesiastical brawls. His maturing was slow, his decay quick ; some three years out of fifty cover his greatness. But those years at Golden Grove were golden years, and have left to all time some of the most golden prose in literature. Beyond this, and his gentle and zealous life, Jeremy Taylor has the glory that (in the ‘Liberty of Prophesying’) he was first to preach the principles of toleration. It was a sad irony which doomed his latest years to the forcible suppression of the Ulster Presbyterians.
Page 10
394 THE ATHENZUM N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 The Island Pharisees. (Heinemann. ) Tue oddness of this book is not its least striking feature. Not that its oddness is too obvious, for it comes rather from a certain unfamiliarity of thought and matter than mere eccentricity of manner or method. We doubt if the majority of good islanders will be gratified, edified, or greatly enlightened by this critical survey of themselves and their complacent attitude towards some of their own institutions and leading characteristics. This satire makes one think perhaps a little too ‘‘furiously”” even for more observant and critical folks. It takes a light and narrative form ; it is subtle, for though the real intention is always manifest, it is not always over-emphasized. The indictment is sincere and severe, keen and quiet, and not over kind—and there is something in it, though not, perhaps, so much as the author supposes. The number of uncommon objects in life—even novels—is, in spite of advertisements, limited. ‘A Man of Devon,’ from the same pen, may be there- fore remembered by some people. ‘The Island Pharisees’ is still more notable. The characters in it are cleverly turned into concrete human beings, yet each stands in some sort for an idea, a thought—in some instances a determined absence of thought. The author’s notion is that one idiosyncrasy of the islanders is a settled distrust and dis- like of all mental processes likely to result in criticism of the thing that is—at any rate in their own island. They wish not only to ignore their deeper longings and feelings, if they have any, but also to turn from the thought of the sorrows and soreg that writhe beneath the surface of their smiling prosperity and grave respectability. Want of insight and sympathy, not lack of prac- tical aid, is the chief arraignment. The author has used a young foreigner, an alien onlooker, to illustrate and deepen his, or rather Richard Shelton’s, views. The foreigner, a very talented impersonation, will not be agreeable to all readers. His luminous reflections, spoken or merely suggested, react on the already impression- able temperament of the hero, and make a species of chorus to his own thoughts and observations throughout the story. Hero and story are not, however, the words to use in connexion with this sufficiently well-born, well-bred, well-off young man and his peculiar experiences. He returns to his native shores after a period of foreign travel. Absence has sharpened his senses to what is at first a merely pleasurable feel- ing of contrast between what he has left and what greets him at Dover Station—the manners, speech, and tone around him. He has hardly seated himself in the train (for no particular reason he has chosen a third- class compartment) before he feels his casual observations ane and strengthening. The presence of the young foreigner already mentioned is partly responsible for the dropping of scales from his eyes. He begins to see his chance companions and country- men of both sexes as it were through another man’s eyes. This process does not cease till the last page in the book, and culminates in an upheaval of his own outward life as well as inward thought. The actual episodes and general trend of the action need not be By John Galsworthy. indicated here, though there are humour and strength in parts. Several of the men and women, gentle and simple, and especially a girl of good family, are not to be overlooked. They are—if we admit the premises and the position—excellently imagined and realized. Without being the ‘ill bird” of the proverb, we may recom- mend this book to our fellow-islanders. Gods and Fighting Men: the Story of the Tuatha de Danaan and of the Fianna of Ireland. Arranged and put into English by Lady Gregory. (Murray.) Tue ‘ Forus feasa ar Eirinn’ (‘ Foundation of Knowledge on Ireland’) of Geoffrey Keating, finished in 1629, and read and transcribed in every Irish-speaking part of Ireland during the two succeeding centuries, is the latest literary summary in Irish of the historical tales, traces of which are to be found in Irish books for many previous centuries. Leabhar na Huidhri, an exist- ing manuscript written about the year 1100, shows that many of these tales were preva- lent beforethatdate. The glossary of Cormac, the composition of which may be attributed to the tenth century, is evidence that in the year 900 they were part of literature. The Irish manuscript numbered 1395 in the library of St. Gall carries them back to the eighth century, and as they were then part of common knowledge, it is easy to believe that they were well known two or three centuries earlier. It is, therefore, a justifi- able hypothesis that they were in existence at the time of the introduction of writing into Ireland from Italy. Had they, when first met with, been attributed to any one great author, it is probable that some indication of this attribution would have survived. Such is the nature of the evidence which justifies the belief that these historical tales of the early history of Ireland are older than the fifth century and the introduc- tion of writing into the island. How much older they are is unknown, but the remote period to which they can be traced, and the study of their development and elaboration, lead to the conclusion that they were the foundation of Irish lite- rature. They present considerable varia- tions in detail, but are constant in certain particulars. Thus, three races in the same order—the Firbolg, the Tuatha Dé Danann, and the Gaedhel—are always represented as the successive rulers of Ireland, each asso- ciated with particular topographical features and particular names of illustrious men. That all this, whatever its origin, is to be regarded in its existing form rather as lite- rature than as historical narrative, is shown by the fact that it is difficult to trace in the accounts of these races any distinctive lin- guistic or social characteristics. They have tribes and kings and administrators of laws and hereditary artificers, resembling those of the Irish of the early Middle Ages, and nota single sentence of any speech but Irish is put into their mouths. When the Gaedhel, or, as they are often called, the race of Miledh, are established in the land, there are further developments of historical tales. A great series, of which the centre is the famous Tain Bo Cuailgne, relate to the times of King Ailill and Queen Medhb, the exploits of Cuchulainn and his friends and foes. The heroes, the character of the adventures, and the general style of these tales are uniform. Another series deal with events in the days of a later king, Cormac Mac Airt, and of heroines and heroes of his time—Graine, and Finn, Oisin, Osgar, and Caeilte, They too have their proper characteristic epithets, and are associated also with topographical features. In all their ad- ventures these heroes never fall in with those of the time of Ailill and Medhb, and their histories are related in a totally different style from those of Cuchulainn and his contemporaries. Both series are joined on to the period of the introduction of Christianity into Ireland, but in different ways, for the survivors of the Court of Cormac Mac Airt are represented as talking on earth with St. Patrick in the Agallamh na Senorach, while in the Siabhar Carpait Cachulainn is called up from Hades by St. Patrick to prove the power of the saint, and thus help to overcome the doubts of the pagan king Laeghaire. The stories of the heroes of King Cormac Mac Airt’s day are of a higher degree of literary ability, and show more true poetry and less mere marvel, than those which tell of the reign of Ailill and Medhb, and they are more closely connected with later Irish literature. Such is the scope of the tales of Lady Gregory’s book. They are all interesting, and most readers will agree with what Dr. Butcher is quoted as saying about a story of Cuchulainn: ‘‘ It opened up a great world of beautiful legend, which, though accounting myself an Irishman, I had never known at all.” Many of the tales are taken from the ‘Silva Gadelica’ of Mr. Standish Hayes O’Grady. It is a pity that some of the other contributing translators, and Lady Gregory herself, have not followed his example of translating good Irish into equally good English. It is a harmless affectation of Dr. Douglas Hyde to make believe not to know enough English to translate Irish, and to prove his Irish patriotism by writing broken English. Prof. Kuno Meyer appears to think that obsolete English words express the mean- ing of simple Irish better than everyday modern words, and thus his heroes fare instead of going, and reach their steads, instead of their homes, and employ a wright to work for them, instead of a carpenter. An Eastern proverb says, ‘‘The words of kings are kings of words,” but Lady Gregory prefers to use an intentionally illiterate method of expression at the Court of the King of Tara, because in a cottage at Kiltartan she heard a sad story of the death of kings so told. But the cottager meant to tell the tale in the choicest lan- guage he had, and he would like to hear a story in English such as Goldsmith’s rather than in this artificial language. A graver faultisthat, to support an untenable historical hypothesis, Lady Gregory has tampered with the text of some of the tales, and left out such great names as those of Cormac and of Art. But these are critical objections to a book which is not meant to be critical and which will do good service by encourag- ing the reading world to make the acquaint- ance of Irish literature. Ee ae ee ee Oe lll
Page 11
N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 THE ATHENZUM 395 Highways and Byways in Sussex. By E. V. Lucas. With Illustrations by Frederick L. Griggs. (Macmillan & Co.) Sussex has recently found its laureate in Mr. Kipling, whose poem in ‘The Five Nations’ will become the inevitable quotation for the use of all writers on this county. We had the curiosity to wonder whether Mr. Lucas had made use of it, and came pat upon the opening stanza, slightly mis- quoted, on the second page of the book, and a further five stanzas later. Mr. Kipling has summarized the essential physical features of Sussex in a way which must rejoice the hearts of all true lovers of their county from Selsey to Rye. Mr. Lucas has summarized the geography, the history, and the personal associations of Sussex in a volume of 400 pages. He must have found it a pleasant task when he set about preparing this book as an addition to the engaging ‘Highways and Byways” Series, for he has intimate knowledge of his subject, con- siderable literary ability, and the necessary enthusiastic appreciation of the beauties of breezy, invigorating downs, rich parks, and retired woodlands. If I see well, I’m king of what I see, says Mr. Meredith in one of his illuminative poems, and the truth thus crisply put is one that is becoming ever more widely recog- nized. Hence the publication of various series of books which are taking the place of the dry, old-fashioned ‘‘ guides,” con- noting a widening interest in the beauties of scenery and in matters of personal and historical associations. Mr. Lucas, with a proper enthusiasm for his district, shows how we may take to the open road in Sussex—he provided us some years since with a delightful pocket companion for such occasions—and with deviations down lanes, through footpaths, and over pathless downs, may find pleasures inexhaustible. His method, so far as he can be said to employ one, is pleasant. He does not mark out definite ‘‘ tours” to be followed by his readers, but, taking various places as centres of interesting country, zigzags across Sussex from the north-west, about Midhurst, to the border country of the north-east in the neighbourhood of Tun- bridge Wells, thus providing hints as to those places at which one may best stop to study a particular district, for most districts will bear study if only the student is equipped with a proper love of the country. If we but walk, or ride, or drive from point to point, we miss more than half of the eauty and interest of the country through which we are travelling. We want time for digressions up every hill, down every promising byway, along every promising footpath, and all such are promising wherever a tantalizing bend, dip in the land, or over- hanging bough cuts off the view. That Mr. Lucas, with pen in hand, is himself a master of the art of divagation, he shows amply in the course of this volume. Per- haps we should not quarrel with him greatly on that account if only his work had been provided with a fuller index. In history Sussex has its chief import- ance as providing the battle-ground on which Harold and William of Normandy fought for the English crown, and the inci- dent here receives adequate treatment in the light of modern research. In the story of our literature the county has no great association beyond being the birthplace of Shelley ; but Shelley, though born and brought up at Field Place, passed his short, active life away from his native county, which played virtually no part in his poetry. Mr. Lucas is, however, able to point to many notable authors, characters, and other celebrities who were natives of or sojourners in Sussex. Brighton, of course, since the Prince Regent made it fashionable, has known almost every- body; but, apart from those who have visited Thackeray’s ‘‘ Dr. Brighton,” there are other memorable literary associations. Coleridge introducing himself, in 1817, to Cary on the beach at Littlehampton, while the translator of Dante was reading Homer to his son, seems a subject made to the hand of some painter of pictures. It was at Felpham, about half a dozen miles west of Littlehampton, that William Blake saw a fairies’ funeral—Felpham which the poet-painter declared to be ‘*a sweet place for study, because it is more spiritual than London. Heaven opens here on all sides its golden gates; the windows are not obstructed by vapours ; voices of celestial inhabitants are more distinctly heard, their forms more distinctly seen ; and my cottage is also a shadow of their houses.” At Felpham, too, Hayley, a Sussex man, lived, greatly honoured by the readers of his time, died, was buried, and lies unre- membered by readers of to-day. Cowper visited Sussex, but was unable to write there, so made but a brief stay before returning to his loved Weston. Lamb, whom Mr. Lucas felicitously describes as ‘‘fastidiously urban,” visited Brighton, and wrote afterwards in the very abandonment of whimsicality of one of the smallest of Sussex churches. Of Brighton Mr. Lucas writes with particular success, indicating at once its history and characteristics within the sufficient space of a single chapter. A full-page quotation from ‘Dombey and Son’ appears to us to be redundant. If Dickens, why not Thackeray? If Dr. Blim- ber’s, why not Miss Honeyman’s, or that memorable interview at the Pier in ‘ Philip’? But such extracts from novels are really not wanted in a book of this character; a reference to them should be sufficient for those educated readers to whom such a book is likely to appeal. Later, when dealing with Winchelsea, Mr. Lucas quotes more fittingly a couple of pages from ‘ Denis Duval’—more fittingly because Thackeray was dealing with the actual history of the town. Shak- speare is made to contribute three pages on the flimsiest excuse; but when mentioning Bates’s Oak in Perham Park, and referring to Bates as an archer at Agincourt, Mr. Lucas misses the opportunity of pointing out that he is one of the three soldiers who have a straight talk with the king on the eve of the battlein ‘Henry V.’ In this matter of quotation Mr. Lucas evinces a courageous freedom, drawing not only upon older writers on the county and its worthies —Taylor the Water Poet, Fuller, and Cobbett —but also on such recent ones as Richard Jefferies, the retiring author of ‘Idle- hurst,’ and various living bards. He might have recalled that Mr. A. J. OC. Hare gave us a ‘Sussex’ about ten years ago. While writing as one who sees well, and suggesting a sense of the restfulness of the great parks of Sussex, of the invigoration of her lanes and woodlands, Mr. Lucas does not neglect the human interest in which his county is rich and varied, ranging from Jack Cade to Mr. Kipling, from William Blake to Thomas Paine; and on the subject of the national game of cricket he waxes enthusiastic again and again as he touches upon the towns and villages associated with Newland, Nyren, Noah Mann, and other heroes of the cricket-field. He is repeatedly—and with justice—indignant at the way in which village churches are kept locked, and only to be seen as ‘‘show”’ places after hunting up the holders of the keys. The frequent happiness of the author’s style is notable, though occasionally we find indications of haste in production, and of affectation. We have referred to Lamb’s being described as ‘‘ fastidiously urban’’; happy, too, is this of Verdley Castle, “ Utilitarianism was too much for it, and its stones fell to Mac- adam.”’ A writer of Mr. Lucas’s ability should not spoil a passage telling of the lark’s song on the downs by closing with a packing of the sublime and the ridiculous into two such words as ‘‘cosmic twitter”; and he should not apply the word ‘‘ miscreant ’’ to a notable public man; it is tasteless, if not libellous. Of Hawker of Morwenstow we are told ‘‘he was not him- self a smuggler, but his parishioners were”’; and of the well-woman at the Tunbridge Wells spring, ‘‘ Those visitors that descend her steps are impelled rather by curiosity than ritual, and many never return”— which is ambiguous. The book is so good that we must not end with dispraise. It makes a reader already at home in Sussex desirous of going off again to its grand downs, while Mr. Griggs’s excellent drawings render admirably many things we know and strengthen our wish to visit those parts of the county as yet unfamiliar. NEW NOVELS. The Vineyard. By John Oliver Hobbes. (Fisher Unwin.) Tur scene of Mrs. Craigie’s new novel is provincial, the characters are provincial, but the atmosphere is literary. Jennie Sussex, Gerald Federan, Rachel Tredegar, Helmyng, and Harlowe are not simple with the simplicity of country folk who accept the conventions. They are infected with the modern disease of self-conscious- ness; they are always pulling their souls up by the roots in order to see how they grow. In fine, every character is a projection of ‘‘ John Oliver Hobbes.” It is true that each character is clearly drawn, but behind all the differentiating traits we find the same temper, the same spirit, a bitter wistfulness, a pitiful irony, an acid compassion. The spiritual analysis is carried on not only by the characters, but also by their creator. Indeed, Mrs. Craigie’s method may be compared to that of the vivisector. Her creatures are alive; they respond to her stimulus, and as they respond she explains the response. | This method sacrifices the life of the emotions to
Page 12
396 THE ATHENAUM N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 the life of the mind. Mrs. Craigie is not interested in the physical side of love. She does not greatly care whether Federan marries Jennie or Rachel. What she cares for is the drama of mental moods, spiritual postures, and imaginative attitudes. Hers is a subtle, shadowy realm, and its denizens lack the beef and the blood of the characters in less sophisticated and more popular fiction. But life and love have grown too complicated for bold, broad, slapdash treat- ment, and the dim recesses of the modern mind must be explored by new paths. The charm of Mrs. Craigie’s extremely delicate art is its equipoise between realism and romance. Jennie, for example, is sheer romance shot with sheer realism. Her imagination is romantic, while her brain is cool reason. She is a fine and by no means rare type of modern woman, the woman in whom the dualism of passion and perception sets up a perpetual interplay of the senses. Rachel is not so vivid, but her maid Tagg is a perfect miniature. Indeed, all Mrs. Craigie’s women are sharply cha- racterized. Her men are not so sure and salient. Federan is curiously un-English. He is a French lover; and to us Mrs. Craigie’s men are all tinged with Gallicism. Another Gallic quality is the intellectual cruelty of her method. Her bitterness seems to grow keener. Towards women she is peculiarly remorseless, though her most cutting strokes are often followed by a restrained sigh. Here are some epigrams. Mrs. Puddifant’s figure was ** not all it had been in some respects, and very much more than it had been in others,” ‘* Nothing is utterly false. A sham jewel is genuine paste.” ‘*The young of both sexes often take the still happiness of being loved for love itself.” ‘**Humour is the refuge of the disappointed wise: the disappointed unwise take to religion.” The book is disfigured by misprints. It is really time to ask publishers or authors to make a stand against the growing laxity in this respect. The Red Leaguers. (Methuen & Co.) Tue scene is here laid in the district which formed the background of the admirable ‘Squireen,’ and one or two characters from that story are again brought before us; but the present novel is more artistic in execution, and far wider in scope than its predecessor. It is the history of an ima- ginary Celtic insurrection, supposed to take place in the near future, and purports to be written by one of the rebel leaders, who, as has often happened in real cases of this sort, belongs to the Protestant section of the com- munity. In spite of a determined resist- ance on the part of the loyal minority, the rebellion is at first successful; but the national spirit of Jaisses faire and lack of staying power lead in the end to a hopeless and most humorously depicted collapse. The chronicle of these vicissitudes shows a power of lucid and picturesque narration and a minute accuracy in detail unsurpassed amongst Irish novelists of the present day. We cannot help thinking that the author, while obviously striving after impartiality, has done a little more than justice to the By Shan F. Bullock. his belief that the deadly religious animosity which is Ireland’s chief curse still smoulders fiercely as ever on both sides, under much apparent courtesy and kindness of inter- = is, we fear, only too well grounded in fact. The Story of Tonty. By Mary Hartwell Catherwood. (Grant Richards.) ‘‘TuHEe romancer,” says Mrs. Catherwood, ‘ig covered with the dust of old books, modern books, great books, and out of them all brings in a condensing hand these pic- tures of two men whose lives were as large as their continent.” The two men are La Salle and his friend and companion Henri de Tonty, who in the seventeenth century explored the western parts of North America. The author’s object has pro- fessedly been to write Tonty’s story rather than that of the better-known La Salle, but the narrative is intimately concerned with both. It is obvious that out of La Salle’s schemes and expeditions sufficient material for a full novel could not be obtained, save by a master hand. Stevenson would have loved to write of those wild journeys. But Mrs. Catherwood has thought to supplement her interest by furbishing up two love stories. La Salle is provided with an affair of the heart, the object of his affections being Jeanne de Ber, a young dévote; and Tonty, not to be out in the cold, is supplied with a sweetheart, Barbe, who is represented as La Salle’s niece. It is to be doubted if even these strands are adequate to give the tale unity. The action straggles; the narra- tive is divided into three parts, to which the dates 1678, 1683, and 1687 are severally affixed; and we feel no very great interest in the explorer’s success or in his love- making. ‘The story is carried to the tragic death of La Salle in the wilderness, and the union of Barbe and Tonty. We fear that the author has unduly hampered herself by her choice of a subject; for she shows much skill in her characterization and an unusual tenderness in her writing, which are reasons for regret that she should have been tempted to use these properties on an unprofitable theme. The Watcher on the Tower. (Fisher Unwin.) Tuts is a tale of London political and society life at the period of the Napoleonic wars, with a strong Russian and Jewish interest. Mr. Hales has a very good idea of the construc- tion of a rattling sensational narrative, but his method of treatment appears to be that of a newspaper correspondent, who wishes to turn out a picturesque column of material in haste for telegraphic dispatch. He maps out a number of situations, and converts them into what American journalists call ‘* good stories.” He is perhaps at his best in describing a fight, between men or game- cocks. Cock-fighting he handles with special and affectionate enthusiasm. Israelites who have made any study of the history of their own people, and of the human race, will be more amused than flattered by his generali- zations regarding the Jews of his story, effusively eulogistic as these are. His notion appears to be that all Jews are the lineal descendants of kings, and men whose By A. G. Hales. good qualities of the Ulster Protestant; but “pedigree” was ancient and honourable before the ancestors of any of the other peoples in the world had been heard of. Here and elsewhere he is crude and lacks insight. The Vulgar Truth. By L. Lockhart Lang. (Arnold. ) Tus is a brightly written story of modern society life. One hardly knows why it is called ‘The Vulgar Truth,’ unless because a number of its characters, put forward as types of what are called “smart sets,” are very vulgar. Oa the other hand, its three principal characters, a doctor, his wife, and his niece, are very decent and agree- able people. The unfortunate husband of the worst of the ‘‘ smart’? women, Lady Flavia, is also a likable person, despite his peculiarities ; and their doings are depicted with all the brightness and glitter of drawing-room comedy. In fact, there is a good deal in the story that suggests the theatre. It is amusing, not badly written, and could be read easily upon the laziest of holidays, without the exercise of any thought. A certain cleverness is requisite for the production of this sort of thing, and we find both cleverness and deftness in ‘ The Vulgar Truth,’ as well as elements of farce and exaggeration. A Comedy of Conscience. By 8. Weir Mitchell. (Edinburgh, Douglas.) Mr. Davin Doveras was the pioneer of American books in this country; he in- troduced to us originally almost all those of Mr. Howells ; and his latest issue is this story by a popular writer across the Atlantic. The theme is of the slightest, but it is handled agreeably and with a sense of humour. It depends merely upon an acci- dent in a tram-car. Serena Vernon sat next to a gentlemanly person, who made off with her purse, but involuntarily left behind hima valuable ring, worth eight hundred dollars. The problem, therefore, is simply—since this man stole my property, can I appro- priate his? Of course, this is complicated by the possibility that the ring may have been annexed from some one else. She therefore consults her conscience, and finds no help there. The parson argues that she cannot claim the ring, but suggests that she should devote the proceeds of its sale to church work! Other worldly friends have no scruple in laughing at her scruples, and her attentive and wealthy cousin John Winterbourne is not sorry to see her drift- ing into a perplexed condition in which she must seek his assistance. Ultimately, Miss Vernon advertises, and becomes a celebrity. Apparently the ring belongs to thousands of people. But with Mr. Winterbourne’s aid she identifies the thief, and secures peace—also a husband. It is a pretty piece of comedy, and suggests a delicate touch. One can almost see it making into a one-act curtain-raiser. Perhaps that will be its fate. As an airy trifle, light as whipped cream, it suffices in its present form. By Lady Helen Forbes. His Eminence. (Nash.) Tus is a well-told story of the eighteenth century which keeps the attention and interest on the gui vive. Lady Helen Forbes has got well into the atmosphere of the = time and reve gitu: The pers Oar¢ rege dom and stan Rev abro cour gene Mon to s€ too, are t crats scar wide love heed time amb’ ‘6 for Duel and natu ticul betw to se of tl look the I Littl 80 al the | Prin ever) with appa vivid the s colou
Page 13
N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 THE ATHENZUM 397 time and place chosen. Strife of tongues and intrigues of various sorts hold high revel inthe ancient town called Montechiari, situated in the fastnesses of Northern Italy. The most carefully wrought and important ersonage in the coil is his Eminence the ardinal d’Este, who from small beginnings —in spite of his great name—comes to be part regent and part ruler of the ancient duke- dom which has survived many changes, and in the closing years of the century still stands as in medizval times. The great Revolution has just taken place in France, and the spirits of unrest and misrule are abroad in Europe as well as in the mimic court of Montechiari. The young Corsican general is about to invade Italy, while the Montechiarians are busy settling or refusing to settle their small disputes. Mutterings, too, from the wretched folk in the low town are to be heard directed against the aristo- crats in the high town. Their complaining scarcely reaches the palace where the young widow-duchess and regent dances and makes love to a handsome captain of the Guard, heedless of these and other signs of the times. The enthusiasm is all for the ambitious Cardinal, not for the fair “foreign woman,” as they call the Duchess. The drawing of these people and others shows some knowledge of human nature in general, as well as of the par- ticular period. The struggle for power between the Cardinal and the lady is made to seem very real. So is the strange dotage of the aged archbishop, who can and does look back on the Court of more than one of the Louises, not always too discreetly. The Little Sister of the Poor is prettily drawn, so are the ducal children. Once or twice the Duchess reminds one of Stevenson’s Princess Serafina, though the former is in every sense inferior. The book is written with taste and some strength, though the apparition of Napoleon is not particularly vivid. It closes in an atmosphere of gloom, the sombre hue of real life rather than the colours of romance. The Law of Life. (Heinemann. ) To play faithfully the part one has chosen —that is the simple rule of conduct to which the imposing title of the law of life is given in this story. A charming young lady is married to a middle-aged professor of mathematics at an American university, so busily engaged in the writing of learned treatises that he neglects all his domestic and social duties. At the same home of learning is a younger professor, more con- scious of the claims of beauty, upon whom Mrs. Penfold learns to look more tenderly than upon her industrious husband. This brings her perilously near the verge of divorce, but she contrives to keep an affec- tionate respect for the scholarly and absent- minded being to whose life she has linked her own, and, actuated alone by a desire not to hurt his feelings, resists the temptation to leave him. If the outlines of the story are familiar, the treatment is original and clever. Mrs. Penfold and Richard Waring are hoth drawn with a skilful hand. Their love scenes, in which a strong note of pas- sion is sometimes struck, are written with a fine sense of delicacy and restraint. Some By Anna McClure Sholl. of the minor characters in the story talk overmuch in epigrams, but the dialogue as a whole is bright and interesting. A want of simplicity is the chief defect of the author’s style. The Despoilers. By Edmund Mitchell. (Cassell & Co.) Tus ‘‘story of a missing will” is not so commonplace as the central device would indicate, for the action takes place mainly in Tenerife and Brazil, and the local colour- ing is dexterously managed. But four unscrupulous lawyers are surely too many for one novel! England is responsible for two out of the number, and we vaguely wonder what becomes of the London practice of such gentlemen while they are careering all over the world to spite a legatee, with a deceased client’s will in a brown kit bag, and indulging in similar eccen- tricities. The author's knowledge of the methods of the “ pettifogging” profession is not commensurate with his hatred; for instance, he represents a draft will as written on parchment. The book is alto- gether too melodramatic, but a strong situation occurs here and there, in spite of manifold improbabilities. CLASSICAL BOOKS. The Annals of Tacitus. Books I.-VI. An English Translation, with Introduction, Notes, and Maps, by G. G. Ramsay, Professor of Humanity in the University of Glasgow. (Murray.)—There are signs of a widespread and growing interest in classical authors. There was the same thirst, but stronger, in the sixteenth and seventeenth cen- turies, which we have to thank for that series of incomparable translations which, whatever their merit as ‘‘ cribs,’’ must always rank high amongst the treasures of English literature. But the demand and the supply have not been so well matched since. Translations there have been in plenty during the last two centuries, from the prolific Thomas Taylor to Bentley and Bohn; but almost all lack the virtues of style which alone can give permanent value to this class of book, and secure for it a place in literature. The trans- lation has been regarded too much as a crutch for the weak, and its possibilities as a literary work neglected. Of late there has been a change in this respect, but the translations have gone to the other extreme, and become affected. Prof. Ramsay has done a distinct service to letters by his introduction, which we regard as the most important part of his book. It is an essay of eighty pages on the translations of Tacitus in several European languages, which touches new ground, and is interesting as a critical study. He draws attention to the merits of the Italian and French ren- derings, of which he gives specimens. In M. Panckoucke’s list of translations, he says, ‘we find that France stands at the top with 153; next comes Germany with 142; Italy can boast of 63, England of only 35......standing at the bottom of the list in point of number, and as a whole, it must be admitted, in quality also.” We do not agree with the last statement, and Dr. Ramsay admits himself that “German scholarship is more celebrated for its learning than for its style; and I soon found that a German translation, however good, could afford no guidance for a translation into English.” For conciseness and force he gives the palm to Davanzati’s version in the ‘“ volgare Fiorentino,” first published in 1596, which seems to combine with terseness a command of racy idiom reminding us cf the Eliza- bethans. The French translators, Lemaistre, D’Ablancourt, De la Bléterie, and De la Malle, are remarkable, as we should expect, for brilliancy, and excel in rendering the epigram. One example may be quoted from Dr. Ramsay’s pages. The sentence (i. 75, 2) sed dum veri- tati conseditur, libertas corrumpebatur, is rendered by M. de la Bléterie, ‘‘ La Justice y gagnait, mais du dépens de la liberté.’’ ‘* With this,’’ says Dr. Ramsay, “we may well compare that of Grenewey, who, as often elsewhere, goes to the point with a homely phrase: ‘ but whilst he laboured for justice, liberty went to wracke.’”’ This brings us to the English translators, of whom Dr. Ramsay has so poor an opinion. It is true he makes an exceptionof Grenewey, but he is unjust to Sir Henry Savile, about whom, by the way, he is oddly mistaken. He assigns Savile’s work (p. xxxviii) to 1698, and states that it is based on M. Amelot de la Houssaie’s translation, with ‘ Réflexions Poli- tiques ’’ (1690). But Savile’s ‘Ende of Nero and Beginning of Galba, Fower Bookes of the Histories of Cornelius Tacitus,’ with the ‘Life of Agricola,’ came out in 1591. It has the vigour and strength of the writers of the great age, and although not so pithy as Davanzati, nor so rich as Holland and North, is worthy of its place amongst the Eliza- bethans. Of Grenewey’s version of the‘ Annals,’ after- wards published along with Savile’s, we need not speak, as Dr, Ramsay has recognized its merits; but we should put it higher than he does; and we do not think that the English- men need shirk comparison with the French and Italians in point of dignity. Coming now to Dr. Ramsay’s own transla- tion, we have first to notice that he accom- panies it with a series of useful explanatory notes. These are intended in the first instance for those who are not scholars, and therefore they contain a good deal of elementary infor- mation as to history and antiquities ; but they contain more than that, and their lucidity and good sense will make them valuable to the more serious student. The translation is idiomatic, and commendably free from the stilted inversions which are the besetting fault of translators from the Latin. In point of accuracy nothing need be said; Dr. Ramsay’s fine scholarship is known, and in style he is superior toChurch and Brodripp. He is more readable, and will appeal to the educated man who enjoys his Macaulay and his Gibbon, as well as to the student in search of knowledge. It may be that the definitive translation of Tacitus has yet to be written. Nevertheless, Dr. Ramsay has achieved no mean feat in this age of vulgar verbosity by his strength, clear- ness, and dignity of style. The Gdipus Coloneus of Sophocles. Witha Commentary abridged from the Large Edition of Sir R. C. Jebb by E. S. Shuckburgh. (Cambridge, University Press.)—Prof. Jebb’s incomparable editions of the extant works of Sophocles ought to be in the hands of as many students as possible, so that we welcome an abridgment which gives his text, almost all his splendid commentary, a liberal percent- age of the introductory matter, and a selection of his critical foot-notes with English in place of Latin. Of course, by all except students who are learning by practice how to turn Greek into passable English, the absence of the translation given in the unabridged edi- tion of the ‘(£dipus Coloneus’ must be regretted. Dr. Shuckburgh has performed his task of curtailment and arrangement con- scientiously, but he has occasionally forgotten that with a translation some notes would be superfluous which without it are required. For instance, he has incorporated ‘“‘ feathered choir’ by the interpretation of ruxvdmrepor (dnSdves), V. 17; but there is no note on oy, y. 23, the translation giving “now” in
Page 14
398 THE ATHENAZUM N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 “* Canst tell me, now?’’ or on yévno?e, v. 86, ‘* show yourselves ”’ ; or as to the rendering of Stiodpovos arys, ‘* the doom of a dark soul.” Among the few illustrations added by the new editor might have been included the criticism of Euripides, ‘Phcen.’ 538, ov x Gmravta TH yHpe Kaka mpdoertt, ON yHpas...... iva mporavra | kaka Kax@v £vvorxel (1237 f.) ; and from v. 1276, aAAa==*‘ at least,’ a refer- ence back to v. 241, and Euripides’s reminis- cence, ‘ Electra,’ 432 ff., vdes... | réumovoas opovs peta Nypifdwv, of vv. 717 ff., tAdra... "Nino Suv akdAovOos, if there had been any necessity to add to Prof. Jebb’s judiciously selected wealth of annotation. Demosthenes on the Crown. Edited by W. W. Goodwin. (Cambridge, University Press.)—We offer Prof. Goodwin’s abridged edition as cordial a welcome as we gave his large edition of the ‘ Crown’ some three years ago. Our eulogy need not be repeated, but we must reiterate that the order rods eis tiv moAw avOpmrovs adixopévovs, § 201, and the gnomic futures éGeAjce, yyjoerat, § 205, should have been noticed. We venture to suggest that ‘‘the real meaning’”’ of éi... érexeipouv...€ritysnoeé por (§ 206. 1-3), is, “ if I were (now) undertaking to tell you this,’ .Bv dv €mityszjowv pot, rather than ‘the result would be (jv dv) that all would justly censure me.’’ It is satisfactory that the valuable essays and historical sketch have been retained, though shortened, while more elementary points than before have been noticed in the admirable commentary. If all school-books issued by the University presses were as thorough and as scholarly as the exceptional specimen before us, no one could object to their multiplication. A. Persii Flacci Satire. Edidit G. Némethy. (Budapest.) — We have not hitherto met with any of this Hungarian series of texts, but if we may judge from this specimen it is likely to be really useful to students. The Persius is not, we must admit, adequate on the critical side, but the commentary is both full and judicious, and has the great merit of quoting in full all important illustrations. We lay stress on the last point, because the good old habit has fallen too much into disregard. It is true that we have the advantage, which early scholars had not, of texts cheap and easily accessible ; on the other hand, time is more precious now because so much more has to be done in it, and an editor who saves us the mechanical task of opening books has earned our sincere grati- tude. The book is also excellently well printed in large clear type, and altogether is well suited to the student. The text is virtually that of Biicheler’s third edition of Jahn (1893). In the pre- face a list of the present editor’s variations from that text is given, and fills four pages ; but there is no account of the MSS. nor any attempt at an apparatus criticus. Thus the book is not one which will suffice for the critical scholar, but it contains enough to meet the wants of the university student, who appears to be in view of the editor. In this country it cannot take the place of Coning- ton’s book, with selected readings and his spirited translation; but its commentary makes it a useful companion to that work. Where the two commentators have points in common, M. Némethy often has the advantage (as in i. 1) of exact quotation, where Conington is content to allude, Bat Conington’s judgment is superior; as when he rejects est (i. 8), keeps auriculis (i. 23), writes Calliroe (i. 134), and interprets turbida (i. 5) as ‘muddle - headed,’ while M. Némethy says, without point, ‘*inquieta, quales magnze urbes esse solent.’? The syntax of pede liber (i. 13), and the case of patricius (i. 61), mens (vi. 41), deserve a note; the explanation of subplantat (i. 35) is not clear; an apt illustration of i. 43 could be got from Juvenal. Something more than a summary enumeration might be expected in matters of principle, which might lead to interesting results. Thus on i. 90 and iii. 21 the cognate accusative is illustrated by a number of examples collected without classi- fication ; and on i. 123 and iii. 28 Persius’s peculiar affectation of the vocative for nomi- native is in question. We shall deal more briefly with the other satires, where, as in the first, a general approbation is tempered by some regret in the absence of an apt illustration, or sometimes a lack of point. Horace was Persius’s great exemplar, hence we are surprised that ii. 18 is not illustrated by ‘‘est ut viro vir latius ordinet arbusta sulcis’’; the suggestion that the phrase means ‘ est causa ut ”’ is hardly correct. The subject of the satire might well be compared with Lucian’s brilliant ‘Tcaromenippus.’ The physical sense of vitium, ‘‘a flaw,’’ should be explained on iii. 21. M. Némethy cannot be expected to know Thackeray, but it is odd that no Eng- lish commentator has thought of illustrating iii. 30 by the famous caricature of Ludovicus Rex. Rem populi (iv. 1) seems to be taken for granted by all commentators, but it is a strange phrase, and at least regis opus might be cited. The plural noctes in v. 42 might be further illustrated both from Latin and Greek; for example, by the phrase so generally misunderstood in the first line of the ‘Clouds,’ 7d ypyua Tov vuKToV dcov, ‘how interminable the night is!’’ Velina in v. 73 is ablative of origin, like the Greek deme- adverbs in -fev, not locative, as the editor seems to think. We must not conclude without adding that M. Némethy has added considerably to the illustrations of his author, and that the notes as a whole are very helpful. In particular we call attention to a foot-note on p. 278, where Horace, ‘Sat.’ ii. 3, 186, is referred to the fable of the Lion and the Fox, No. 41 in Halm’s edition of Hsop. Lastly, a great boon is the ‘Index Verborum.’ Would that all editors would supply similar lists! Compositions and Translations by the late Henry O. F. Mason, edited by H. H. West (Clay & Sons), well deserved to be collected and made accessible in a single volume. Mr. Mason was, as the memoir of him prefixed by Mr. R. C. Gilson shows, excellent both as scholar and schoolmaster, giving to Hailey- bury the best part of his short life after his academic career, a life and example bright to friends and many boys. His composition was usually done without book, pen, or paper, and exhibits remarkable powers of idiom and vocabulary. Graceful always, at times it seems to us a thought too elaborate, lacking the easy flow which a writer unhampered by an original would or might attain. Several pieces are done which have been already ren- dered by well-known experts, so that readers can judge for themselves how Mr. Mason comes off against them. We certainly recom- mend all lovers of classical composition to acquire his book. Here and there revision might have been of advantage. In ‘‘the Nereid maids in days of yore,’’ which Calverley has done too, ‘‘ the youngest of the train’’ is difficult to put well in Latin, since there is no single word for ‘‘ youngest’ ; but ‘‘ ex illa quee florentissima turba’’ will hardly do, suggest- ing the most buxom, rather than the most juvenile. There is an admirable rendering of Mr. Kipling’s ‘ Recessional,’ and also of some humorous pieces. OUR LIBRARY TABLE. Messrs. METHUEN & Co. publish Disraeli: a Study in Personality and Ideas, by Mr. Walter Sichel, who says :— “TI have not drawn on Mr. Meynell’s delightful ‘Disraeliana’ (the pleasure of reading which I pur- ge] stponed), because I wished this i Soak Gen end tie aied to he chet ete We have no reason to doubt Mr. Sichel’s statement, and although his book is, like Mr. Meynell’s, an unconventional biography, largely in Disraeli’s own words, yet there is no trace of plagiarism. Mr. Sichel has a good deal of sound literary criticism in his. chapter on literature, and we agree with him in the following remarks :— “I have mentioned Disraeli’s early tendency towards ‘Ha!’ and ‘Pah!’ For this there werg several reasons besides his own temper and that of the time. When we speak of an ‘artificial’ style we mean one unnatural to the author. Disraeli’s = was perfectly natural to him, and it altered ittie, When we cometo politics we think Mr. Siche} off his ground. He assumes, for example, from his knowledge of Disraeli, that he would have withstood Mr. Chamberlain’s proposals as being hazardous and designed in the interest of plutocracy. Possibly! But there is no sort of establishment of this position such as. to carry conviction to any reader who is dis- posed to think the contrary. Mr. Sichel, however, has a happy quotation from ‘Endymion’ which has not, we think, been worn threadbare in the recent controversy, It tells rather against Mr. Sichel’s opinion of Disraeli’s probable view in 1904 of ‘‘ fiscal reform.’’ Mr. Sichel is inclined to exalt his hero’s foresight. He thinks that ‘‘had he lived, he would never have left the problem of the housing of the poor to private experi- ment, or merely municipal omniscience.” But in 1874 Disraeli was Prime Minister, and the Bill promoted by his Government, and now known as Lord Cross’s Act, was a ‘‘merely municipal’’ measure. Like all who, sympathizing with the policy of the days which began in 1877, write of Disraeli’s opinions, Mr. Sichel defends his imperialism as fairly consistent throughout life. This claim cannot for one moment be maintained by any historical observer. From 1878 to his death Disraeli had returned for ever to the language of his novels, but the enormously long period of his middle career is full of declarations in the diametrically opposite direction, such as now would be called Little Englandism in its most revolting form. The fact is that Disraeli was above all an Opposition leader, bent, with great public aims, on obtaining political power; and that he was as unscrupulous as to temporary means as 1s usually the case. His opposition to Palmerston and the dominant Whigs, who were Jingoes, as we should say, forced him into alliance with Cobden and Bright, and during the many years of that alliance Disraeli’s language was that of Cobden, with the absence of Cobden’s sincerity. Mr. Sichel’s excursus into politics involves him in a defence of the wisdom of the still-born Asia Minor Convention. But to strategists and students of the real power of the British Empire it has always seemed incredible that Disraeli could have believed that Asia Minor was the best position for conflict with Russia. Neither does Mr. Sichel please us when he writes upon the royal pre- rogative. There is nothing more interesting in Disraeli’s career than the way in which he foresaw the utility of refurbishing the monarchy in the interest of the empire. But Mr. Sichet mixes together things which have nothing to do with one another: ‘‘ Prerogative,’ which merely means the power of the Prime Minister or of the Cabinet, and royal influence, which is a very different thing, usually exercised, if at all, against the Prime Minister and Cabinet. Mr. Sichel writes ignorantly :— “There is the prerogative of disapproving the choice of Speaker, which will probably cease. There is that for proposing grants of public money, and there is the salutary initiative of Royal Com- mission which paves the way for social reform. On these personal rights I need not dwell.” There is nothing of a ‘‘ personal ’’ right of the } bp — ‘Kin; king whit ocel of 4 Viet Clas corr Que with mem same cour enti tion: of hi Afri: are auth in “é it V mem fiftie 1854 beca revel §* swe their times who with the | sprul hair back the a in the of th early in on! peare but h son. ear-ti mome Disra himse wond Gove are i offer stone applic time, before opinic @ goo haste is no book reade ME Victor distin tive | Indiar volum the te the ay been : late P see its handle incline that t which fall of which reacti« to 18 behave liberal their 1 and wi passed Workii Act, a
Page 15
on ’g tt. he ry) yn he: N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 THE ATHEN ZUM 399 King about any of these things, in which kings rarely, if ever, interfere. The one case which might be quoted of intervention of the occupant of the office of king in the granting of a Royal Commission was that of Queen Victoria and the Housing of the Working Class. But then, as we know from the royal correspondence which has been published, the Queen interfered, by way of healthy influence, with the action of both Houses through members of the Opposition; that is, in the game way in which any great lady in the country might have interfered. All this is entirely different from what Mr. Sichel men- tions in the same paragraph—the influence of his present Majesty on the peace in South Africa. There are smaller pointson which we are inclined to differ from our interesting author. He says that the ‘‘swells’’ appeared in ‘the seventies.”” We should have thought it well established, by Punch if not by memory, that the ‘‘ swells’’ date from the fifties, and that while the type was altered in 1854 by the Crimean beard, as soon as it became fashionable to shave the beard it reverted to the type of 1852. We have many ‘swells’? among us, although in most cases their appearance has changed with the times. But there are those still living who can remember Sir William Harcourt with the whiskers of the period. In the seventies a wholly different type had sprung up, and it was the fashion to wear the hair long, cut out at the back, and brushed back in a style which is still recalled to us by the appearance of the present Duke of Argyll, inthose days Lord Lorne. The photographs of the present King in the late sixties and early seventies show this style, which came in only after the ‘‘swell’’ had virtually disap- peared. Mr. Sichel does not tell many stories, but he spoils that of Disraeli and Mr. Thomas- son. The latter used to move about, with his ear-trumpet, to sit near the speaker of the moment; and it was in this way that Mr. Disraeli came to murmur, ‘‘ He seeks to deprive himself of his natural advantages.’’ We wonder what Raphael purchased by Disraeli’s Government is alluded to on p. 30. We are inclined to think that it is to the later offer of a Raphael, purchased by Glad- stone’s second Administration, that the story applies. The picture was for sale for a long time, and Lord Beaconsfield undoubtedly before his death had been asked to express an opinion with regard to it. We have noted a good many repetitions, due, we suppose, to haste or to imperfect revision ; and the index is not sufficiently full; but Mr. Sichel’s book is to be commended to the general reader. Messrs. KeGAN PAu publish India in the Victorian Age, by Mr. Romesh Dutt, a most distinguished former member of the Legisla- tive Council of Bombay, now Lecturer in Indian History at University College. His volume is, as may be expected, an answer to the teaching on fiscal and other questions of the apologists of British rule as it is and has been: a book which would have pleased the late Prof. Fawcett if he could have lived to see its issue. There is one interesting topic handled in three passages, on which we are inclined to differ from Mr. Dutt. He thinks that the modern Imperialism of this country, which he deplores, began in 1874 with the fall of Gladstone’s first Administration, from which moment he dates the ‘ Conservative reaction in Great Britain.’’ Now from 1874 to 1877 the Conservative Administration behaved as a Whig Administration, or more liberally. Itgavethetrade unionsthecharterof their liberties, which the Liberals had refused and which the Courts have now upset. It passed Cross’s Act for the Housing of the Working Class, Northcote’s Friendly Societies Act, and a number of other measures, during Gladstone’s retirement from the House, and with the steady support of the Radicals. No doubt the policy of 1878 was that of Disraeli’s early novels, and constituted a complete change; but it had notat that time the support of the constituencies, which in the opinion of Disraeli’s own advisers would have given a large Liberal majority at any moment had he dissolved, and in 1880 that policy was swept from the board. Mr. Dutt thinks that this was a personal success of Gladstone, who stemmed ‘‘ the tide of Imperialism for a time,”’ and forced on ‘‘a short Liberal reaction.’’ He understates the period during which Glad- stone maintained himself, and writes of ‘‘ the four years of his second Administration,’’ the fact being that that Administration lasted five and a quarter years. It is often thought now that Imperialism definitely asserted itself in consequence of the disgust felt at the Majuba surrender, but no one who remembers the period can agree in this view. Majuba was denounced by some Conservatives, the most violent of whom afterwards reversed their Opinion ; it was undoubtedly the Soudan dis- asters and the death of Gordon which, rightly or wrongly, caused the popular change. Another point on which we differ from Mr. Dutt is his censure of Sir Robert Sandeman, the expression of which contains, by the way, 2 most unusual slip in the perfection of his literary style: the use of ‘‘unique’’ for ‘“sole’’—a French idiom. Mr. Dutt writes of “Sir Robert Sandeman, whose unique aim was to extend the zone of influence beyond the frontier, and whose method was to participate in tribal dis- sensiong, and to benefit by them...... In pursuance of this restless and ambitious policy, Lord Lansdowne took some action in regard to the State of Kashmir, which created alarm in India, and brought on a discussion in the House of Commons.” Sandeman was by no means a strong expan- sionist, and he and his policy and his friends were not concerned in the occupation of Gilgit to which Mr. Dutt’s second passage refers. Sandeman’s aim was to govern cheaply and without war the frontier tribes, by a system of recognizing the chiefs and paying for a tribal militia. He held the enormous stretch of territory whichis knownas Khelat, Baluchi- stan, Lus Beyla, and so forth, right away to the Persian frontier, without troops and without war; and the expenditure was small compared with that wasted in a Punjab frontier war by the disciples of the sealed frontier. The defence of Sandeman’s policy, as against the Punjab policy, from the point of view of economy and efficiency, is complete, and it has always been a pity that able repre- sentatives of the Congress school have failed to recognize this fact. The Magnetic North. By Elizabeth Robins. (Heinemann.)—It is surely a feat for a lady novelist to step into other people’s shoes— especially snow-shoes—and to keep them on, as it were, for seventeen hundred miles of toil- some Northern travel, at the wrong season! This is what Miss Robins has done in this book, and so well that the reader almost believes she must have gone over the ground in person. The worst of a bad route lies between the island of St. Michael, at the mouth of the Yukon, and embraces the river’s ice-bound windings to Minook, a mining camp on the way to Dawson and the Klondyke. Gold is the object of an expedition undertaken by five men of different sorts from different parts of the Western continent. It is a long journey, and the record of it is also long, yet we hardly wish it shorter. The gold fever which raged in the nineties is at its height, and the men have, for different reasons, taken it badly. The month is September, the idea is to make for the gold without delay. This, of course, soon proves impossible at the season. The eager five find it necessary to construct as best they may a winter camp. Miss Robins makes her readers feel quite excited over the details and division of the work. Afterwards the mono- tony of close companionship sets in, telling on the tempers and the morals of some of the campers. There is malingering over the wood supply ; the whisky and even the syrup vanish oddly. The most innocent and unavoid- able idiosyncrasies—the shape of a jaw, a trick of manner—become unbearable. All this is vivid and veracious, one would say, and very true to human nature. Rare visits from Esquimaux, passing travellers, or the Fathers from Holy Cross are at first blessed inter- ludes, but the weather ends them, Fish and game are scarce, the supplies are not like the widow's cruse. The best of the five is but human and full of frailty. If this truth is too much insisted on throughout the story, it is all the same an essential verdict. The two best men of the bunch (and the principal adventurers) are Southerners, ‘‘ the Colonel ’’ and ‘‘ the Boy ’’ as they are constantly called. As the rations decline dangerously and the tempers rise, these two, for the sake of the majority and in their own longing to break camp and push on, decide to make for Minook in spite of everything. Their struggles and ultimate success make capital, if at times pain- ful reading. It is not altogether a case of conquering man in his heroic aspect, but of man unadorned and unvarnished and in sore straits. In spite of all ordeals and dangers the men never wholly lose the soul of good, toil- somely acquired through the ages, though they come near to it at times. The Boy’s gaiety, the Colonel’s grand manner, are much obscured, and under the weather frequently sub- merged indeed; but to their credit they manage to remain men—and, what is more, friends—inspite of theterrible strain. Physical dangers of every sort, hunger, thirst, fatigue, with death a constant onlooker, are all met and conquered. It seems as though the author had herself experienced them. Merely to read them is to feel like shivering and starving with the frost-bitten, snow-blinded men as the food grows scantier and the thermometer lower, to fall with them in their log-like speechless weariness at the bitter close of a day’s march, to share in the animal enjoyment over the feeble flicker of green wood and the draught of Bovril before they too give out. There is all the time latent a strange and stirring sense of exhilaration in the fight with nature, and the passion for wild, free existence. If only as a series of bleak travel-pictures and out-of-the-way scenes and people, the book is to be commended. Probably fewer details, less minute incidents, that read like instan- taneous photography, would have helped the sense of artistic completeness and originality. But as a means of making plain and living the life of undaunted and ever-recurring effort pitted against the most blighting circumstances it is all that can be wished. Every step in the right direction (and how often they take the wrong and lose the trail!) is won by battle. It is this terrible intensity that makes every- thing else rather pale—even the charm of the Jesuit fathers, and the character of the fierce yet delightful dogs whose services are secured none too soon for the travellers. Friends of Yesterday, by A. M. Wilson (Bullen), consists of some sketches of folks gentle and simple in a village where the lan- guage has a touch of the Midlands as well as East Anglian affinities. The fast disappear- ing rusties of older times are admirably por- trayed, with delightful touches of dialect, yet without that literary affectation which spoils much work of this kind. The village clerk, the decayed gentlewoman, and more than one obstinate old couple stand before us, vividly hit off, even if they were not excellently figured in the illustrations for the sake of which we can forget the heavy, shiny paper. The book, in fact, might be selected as 2 typical delineation of the old rustic in Eng-
Page 16
400 THE ATHENZUM N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 land. Modern delights and inventions play but little part in such districts; but here isa paragraph concerning the event of this Satur- day. The postmaster has only once “ broken his official rule of silence where telegraphic messages are concerned, On the afternoon of the Universities’ Boat Race there are usually anxious inquirers from among the youth of the neighbour- hood. It has long been the recognized custom at Much Gaping to purchase a pencil, the postmaster, with a finger on his lips, supplying either a light or a dark blue one, according to circumstances. It is remembered that on one occasion his garrulity got the better of his official secrecy, and that he imparted the remarkable intelligence that ‘Oxford and Cambridge are dead beat !’” The Grant and Validity of British Patents for Inventions is the title of a large volume, written by Mr. James Roberts and published by Mr. Murray. It is dedicated by permission to the Lord Chief Justice, and is worthy of his patronage. A great lawyer like Lord St. Leonards may succeed in compiling a book which the professional man and the layman can read with equal interest and benefit, yet it is very seldom that a law- book is of any use outside the circle of legal practitioners. This work is an excep- tion to that rule. Patent law is a subject of general interest in these days, and inventors who desire or intend to become patentees have not had, till now, any work which gives them the help and the information which they require. The members of the Bar whose practice is chiefly confined to patents, and the solicitors who instruct them, will also find in Mr. Roberts’s pages what they desire to learn and cannot easily get elsewhere. Mr. Roberts has added illustrations to a law- book, an innovation which does him credit. The diagrams enable every reader of it to understand the cases. Quite as useful, though less novel, are the printed illustrations of the points involved in the exposition of the con- ditions under which patents are granted. Clearness, which is the one thing needful here, has been attained by Mr. Roberts. Use- ful information is given as to the character of the changes in granting patents which will soon take place. Mr. Roberts sticks closely to his text, yet he might have made a reference to a class of patents which betray a form of ignorance that is alike gross and lamentable. Many patents have been granted for ‘‘improvements in obtaining motive power,’’ and each is a plausible mode of per- forming what is impossible, that is obtaining perpetual motion. He might also, if he had chosen, have written a few paragraphs on the patent law of this country as compared with that of others, and might fairly have shown how superior the system of the United States is to that of all other countries. However, as we have already said, he has adhered closely to the subject of his book, which is bot the latest and the most practical on the law of patents and its application. Every one interested may confidently be advised to consult it, WE may call special attention to Dr. Airy’s monograph on Charles II. (Longmans). It is a reprint of the fine monograph published by Messrs. Goupil in 1901. The wonderful quality of the pictures in that volume should not obscure, as it might, the value of the text, which is both authoritative and of high interest, As we said in our long review of the book, ‘‘ the author is to be congratulated alike on his opportrrity and his performance,” a praise that can be rarely awarded. Mr. Naso has begun a ‘Collection of Popular Novels,’’ the first three of which are The Herb Moon, Almayer’s Folly, and A Mil- lionaire’s Daughter, in a style copied from the Tauchnitz volumes. We believe, as we have often said, that there is a future for books in paper bindings, and these shilling novels, well printed on good paper, are likely to be a great success. It might be worth while not only to take the tourist’s shilling, but also a little more from the book-lover, by a decent binding at a higher price. WHEN we have said that Coridon’s Song, and other Verses (Macmillan), is illustrated by Mr. Hugh Thomson and introduced by Mr. Austin Dobson we need add nothing by way of commendation, except that the text is good old-fashioned poetry. Messrs. CAssELL have just published The Black Arrow and The Master of Ballantrae in their admirable ‘‘ Pocket Edition ’’ of Steven- son. Messrs. CHAPMAN & HALL have issued David Copperfield in a ‘‘Student’s Edition,’’ which is cheap at a shilling. The print is very small, but students cannot afford luxurious type, and they will find here useful aids to the study of the book, including Mr. Waugh’s biographical introduction, some sensible notes, and an analytical list of characters. AN interesting sign of the times is the pub- lication of Corn-Law Rhymes, and other Verses, by Ebenezer Elliott, in paper at twopence, by Mr. Fisher Unwin. WE notice the appearance of the ‘ Daily Mail’ Military Map of Korea, by George Philip & Son. This shows the heights, and is therefore a useful index to the points at which, if they succeed in clearing the peninsula of Russians, the Japanese are likely to entrench themselves to await attack, There is in the north of Korea, as a completion of the line of the Yalu, towards the right, or east, a fairly continuous chain of heights over 5,000 ft., all but reaching the sea near Kilju. At another point where the Japanese may need to entrench there are heights of from 3,300 to 3,900ft., on the railway south of Niuchwang, and about half way between Niuchwang and the neck of the Port Arthur peninsula. WE have on our table Elements of French Pronunciation and Diction, by B. Dumville (Dent),—Gautier’s Voyage en Italie, with Intro- duction and Notes by De V. Payen-Payne (Cambridge, University Press),— The First Part of Henry the Fourth, edited by F. W. Moorman (Blackie), — Twelfth Night, with Introduction by Fanny Johnson (Blackwood), —A School Geometry, Parts I. to V., by H. S. Hall and F. H. Stevens (Macmillan),—Ele- mentary Geometry, Part I., by Cecil Hawkins (Blackie),—Elements of Inorganic Chemistry, by H. C. Jones (Macmillan),—The Land of Silence, by G. B. Burgin (Nash),—The Lady Cake-Maker, by L. T. Meade (Hodder & Stoughton),—An Act of Impulse, by Helen Bayliss (Greening),—The Sword in the Air, by A. C. Gunter (Ward & Lock),—The Duties of the Heart, by Rabbi Bachye, translated by E. Collins (The Orient Press), — New Light on the Life of Jesus, by C. A. Briggs (Edinburgh, Clark),—The Discipline of Faith, Sermons, by D. Stone (Brown & Lang- ham),—Verses, by Ruth Young (Longmans),— Apollo and Keats on Browning, a Fantasy, and other Poems, by C. Lanier (Brown & Lang- ham),—Unseen Kings, by Eva Gore-Booth (Longmans), — Indian Summer, and other Poems, by J. C. Challiss (Brown & Langham), —Glow-Worm Flames, by Agnese Laurie- Walker (Paisley, Gardner),— Dr. Otto Weininger tiber die Letzten Dinge (Leipsic, Braumiiller),—and Pistoia nelle sue Opere d’ Arte, by O. H. Giglioli (Florence, Lumachi). Also the following Pamphlets: The Classics and Popular Education, Address delivered at the Second Annual Meeting of the Scottish Classical Association, December 5th, 1903, by G. G. Ramsay (Glasgow, MacLehose),—The Teaching of the Dutch Language in South Africa, by Dr. Brill (Longmans),—and The Junior Book-Keeping Examiner, 1904, by J. and F. O. Thornton (Macmillan), ha LIST OF NEW BOOKS. ENGLISH. Theology. Lester (J. H.), The Destiny of Man, cr. 8vo, 3/ net. Rice (W. N.), Christian Faith in an Age of Science, 6/ Fine Art and Archaology. Budge (E. A. W.), The Rosetta Stone, 3 vols. 3/6 net each, Harper (R. F.), The Code of Hammurabi, King of Babylon about 2250 B.c., 8vo, 18/ net. Hayden (A.), Chats on English China, 8vo, 5/ net, Watts (G. F.), by G. K. Chesterton, 12mo, 2/ net. Poetry and the Drama. Catullus, Poems, with English Translation by F. W, Cornish, 4to, 7/6 net. Lucas (St. J.), Poems, cr. 8vo, boards, 5/ net. Payne (J.), Songs of Consolation, 8vo, 5/ net. Selections from the Anti-Jacobin, together with some later Poems by George Canning, edited by L. Sanders, 12mo, 1/6 net. Pl Works, 4 vo s. cr. 8vo, in box, 21/ net. Yeats (W. B.), The Hour-Glass, Cathleen Ni Houlihan, The Pot of Broth; The King’s Threshold, and On Baile’s Strand, cr. 8vo, 3/6 net each. Philosophy. Iverach (J.), Descartes, Spinoza, and the New Philosophy, cr. 8vo, 3, Political Economy. Giffen (Sir R.), Economic Enquiries and Studies, 2 vols, 8vo, 21/ net. History and Biography. Acton (Lord), Letters to Mary, Daughter of the Rt. Hon, W. E. Gladstone, edited by H. Paul, 8vo, 15/ net. Arnold (Matthew), by G. W. EK. Russell, cr. 8vo, 3/6 Cowper (W.), Correspondence, arranged and edited by T, Wright, 4 vols. 8vo, 63/ net. Disraeli, by W. Sichel, 8vo, 12/6 net. Farrar (F. W.), The Life of, by R. Farrar, er. 8vo, 6/ net. Forbes (M.), Beattie and his Friends, 8vo, 15; net. Gould (R. F.). A Concise History of Freemasonry, 10/6 net. Reresby (Sir J.), Memoirs and Travels, cr. 8vo, 3/6 net. Scherger (G. L.), The Evolution of Modern Liberty, 5/ net. Stone (J. M.), Reformation and Renaissance, 16/ net. Geography and Travel. Hogarth (D. G.), The Penetration of Arabia, roy. 8vo, 7/6 Kidd (D.), The Essential Kafir, 8vo, 18/ net. Mitchell (C.), The Commission of H.M.S. Renown, 1900-4, Mediterranean Station, er. 8vo, 4/ net. Pauli (G ), Venice, trans. by P. G. Konody, roy. 8vo, 4/ net. Wyon (R.), The Balkans from Within, 8vo, 15/ net. Sports and Pastimes. Beldam (G. W.), Great Golfers, roy. 8vo, 12/6 net. Hoffmann (Prof.), Later Magic, 8vo, 7/6 2 Mighty Mahseer, and other Fish, by Skene-Dhu, 8vo, 5/ net, Philology. Jespersen (O.), How to Teach a Foreign Language, trans- lated from the Danish, cr. 8vo, 3/6 Science. Holms (A. C.), Practical Shipbuilding, 8vo, 48/ net. , Nuttall (G. H. F.), Blood Immunity and Blood Relation- ship, roy. 8vo, 15/ net. General Literature. Austin (M. W.), Veronica, cr. 8vo, 6/ Boyd (M. S.), The Man in the Wood, cr. 8vo, 6/ Burdett (Sir H.), Hospitals and Charities, 1904, 5/ net. Colmore (G.), A Ladder of Tears, cr. 8vo, 6/ De La Mare (W. J.), Henry Brocken, cr. 8vo, 6/ Findlater (J. H.), Stones from a Glass House, cr. 8vo, 6, Finnemore (H. P.), Tally, cr. 8vo, 3/6 Her Great Reward, and Twenty-four other Stories, 5/ Heroes in the Fight, and Twenty-four other Stories, 5/ Hobbes (J. O.), The Vineyard, cr. 8vo, 6/ Hope (G.), The Gage of Red and White, cr. 8vo, 6/ Hunt (V.), Phe Celebrity at Home, cr, 8vo, 6/ Le Queux (W.), As We Forgive Them, cr. 8vo, 6/ Linden (A.), A Woman of Sentiment, cr. 8vo, 6/ Lion of Gersau, by Sirrah, cr. 8vo, 6/ ae Merriman (C. E.), Letters from a Son to his ‘Self-Made Father, cr. 8vo, 6, Natal Almanac, Directory, &c., 1904, 8vo, 10/6 net. Pugh (E.), The Fruit of the Vine, er. 8vo, 6/ Rhys (G.), The Prince of Lisnover, cr. 8vo, 6/ Sell’s Dictionary of the World’s Press, roy. 8vo, 7/6 Shafer (S. A.), The Day before Yesterday, cr. 8vo,6/ Souttar (R.), Alcohol: its Place and Power in Legislation, er. 8vo, 3/6 Warden (Florence), What ought She to Do ? cr. 8vo, 6/ Watts-Dunton (T.), Aylwin, 12mo, 1/ net; leather, 2/ net. Young (F. E.), A Dangerous Quest, cr. 8vo, 6/ FOREIGN. Fine Art and Archaology. Daremberg (C.), Saglio (E.), et Pottier (E.), Dictionnaire des Antiquités Grecques et Romaines, Vol. 3, Part 2, 40fr. Millet (G.), Pargoire (J.), et Petit (L.), Recueil des, Inscrip- tions Chrétiennes de l’Athos, Part 1, 15fr. Wessely (C.), Studien zur Paliographie u. Papyruskunde, Part 3, 12m. History and Biography. Lavisse (B.), Histoire de France, Vol. 5, Part 2, 6fr. Roches (L.), Dix Ans 4 travers l'Islam, 1834-44, 5fr. Rodocanachi (B.), Le Capitole Romain Antique et Moderne, 12fr. Roulx (J. D. Le), Les Hospitaliers en Terre Sainte et 4 Chypre, 1l5fr. F ‘ Te Sorel (A.), L’Europe et la Révolution Frangaise, Part 7, Sfr. Stenger (G.), La Société Francaise pendant_le Consulat, Series 2, 5fr. Geography and Travel. Barbier (L. le), Dans la Haute-Guinée, 2fr. 50. Jacot-Guillarmod (Dr.), Six Mois dans l’Himalays, le Karakorum, et l'Hindu-Kush, 15fr. , Education. Duruy (G.), L’Officier Educateur, 3fr, 50, -_ Li tt Bien tee te ee en eee ee em ee ek Ue oe 6h ae oe 2 Ok ee ee ae
Page 17
ig ter 10, le’e by, ‘Is, on. dé Dy ey fr. ity asbaaa N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 THE ATHENAUM 401 Philology. Morgan (J. de), Mission Scientifique en Perse: Vol. 5, Etudes Linguistiques, 40fr. Science. Bouglé (C.), La Démocratie devant Ia Science, 6fr. Quinton (R.), L’Eau de Mer Milieu Organique, 15fr. General Literature. Delpit (B.), Joseline, 3fr. 50. Essertier, Les Apparences, 3fr. 50. Guillaumin (E.), La Vie d’un Simple, 3fr. 50. Haussonville (Comte a’), Varia, 3fr. 50. Lorris (C.), La Pente, 3fr. 50. Mirbeau (O.), Farces et Moralités, 3fr. 50. Pouvillon (&.), Jep, 3fr. 50. Valdagne (P.), Mon Fils, sa Femme, et mon Amie, 3fr. 50. NOTES FROM OXFORD. THE most notable event of the term was the vote on the Greek question. The scene in the Sheldonian was decidedly imposing, Congrega- tion filling the body of the theatre to over- flowing, whilst youth and beauty lined the galleries. The oratory was, on the whole, worthy of the occasion, a wise moderation of tone being its distinguishing feature. And well might the orators bestir themselves. As it turned out, had but a single ‘‘ emancipationist ” been won over to the cause of compulsory Greek, a tie would have ensued ; and it is no secret that the casting vote of the Vice-Chancellor, himself a distinguished classic, would in that case have turned the scale in favour of the ‘‘pro- tection’ of the old classical tongue. The two parties will have another opportunity of trying their strength next term, when the House will be asked to pass the preamble of the statute now in course of preparation. If, as seems not unlikely, a slightly increased majority declare itself in favour of optional Greek for science men and mathematicians, Convocation must in the next place be consulted. The country parsons, it is generally assumed, will side with the conservatives, the schoolmasters, on the other hand, and the miscellaneous ‘friends of science””—no negligible quantity — with the reformers. Meanwhile the march of events at Cambridge will assuredly exert a considerable influence on our decisions, just as our doings will doubtless not fail to have an effect on Cam- bridge. Altogether the future of Greek at Oxford offers a magnificent theme to the “ sport- ing prophet.” As a curious incident of the poll it may be mentioned that the non-placets took far more time to record their votes than did the placets. Gossip has it that this was due to the greater difficulty experienced by the tellers on the dissentient side in identifying the voters as members of Congregation. Be this as it may, the need of a drastic reform of Congregation is never made more manifest than on the occasion of a big muster such as that we have recently seen. The House purports to be a body of educational experts. Actually, however, those engaged in university teaching constitute no more than, say, two-thirds of the whole assembly, it being counted amongst the ‘“‘ resi- dential advantages ” of modern Oxford—and they are many, to judge from the steady inflow of settlers—that the casual graduate may inter- vene in the intimate deliberations of our teach- ing body just as his prejudices—and these are for the most part reactionary—and the party whips dictate. Truly the hand of Pusey—if he be rightly credited with having contrived the existing system in the interest of the resident cleric—lies heavy upon us, Meanwhile, another matter of no little intrinsic interest and importance has agitated Congregation, and threatens to provide non- resident members of Convocation with an excuse for a second visit to Oxford during the Summer Term. The proposal to admit lay- men to be examiners in theology sounds inno- cent enough, but behind it there lies the whole question whether our Theological School is to remain denominational—that is, Anglican—or not. By 123 votes to 73 the House decided to do away with what is surely a mere ‘sur- vival,” namely, that a University, unsectarian ’ and free of all ‘‘ tests,” should continue to exercise, or even to seem to exercise, the func- tions of a Theological Training College. As a matter of fact, thanks to the tolerant and broadminded conduct of the school at the hands of the scholars who preside over Oxford theo- logy, it has long been in practice, if not in the theory of its constitution, a school of historical Christianity, an opportunity for acquiring learning and a liberal education rather than for obtaining professional instruction preparatory to the taking of Holy Orders. Once the school can declare itself to be in principle what it has for many years been in fact, it will have the confidence of all, save perhaps of those ex- tremists who are at present heard to declare that they cannot conscientiously entrust their pupils to examiners who have not defined their position by submitting to a ‘‘ test.” After all, those who have the cause of religious liberty and, what is perhaps more immediately to the point, impartial science at heart are not much moved by the threat that in the course of the next few years some theological students of the baser sort are likely to transfer their patronage to the Pass Schools, or, it may be, even to Durham. Whether it follows that, ifthe Arts degree be granted to learning and not to orthodoxy, argal the higher degree of Doctor of Divinity should be awarded on similar lines, is a debatable point. There is no doubt something to be said for the German plan of allowing a plurality of Faculties, each prescribing its peculiar confes- sional test, to put their several hall-marks on their own leading divines, The German system, however, well as it may work, is designed to meet aset of conditions fundamentally different from those that prevail in England. Moreover, it is difficult to see what a free and unsectarian university has do do with forms of sectarian hall-marking at all. Meanwhile, the fact on which there seems to be special need to insist at the present juncture is that the ‘‘ libera- tion ” of the Theology School and the ‘‘libera- tion ” of the D.D. degree are not one question, but two. The newly published regulations and scheme of papers for the Honour School of Modern Lan- guages are causing searchings of heart,not merely to certain would-be candidates, but likewise to many of those maturer and more dis- interested persons who voted for the establish- ment of the school in the hope—nay, on the express understanding—that literature was to be given an equal chance with pure phonetics. A suspicious flavour of medizvalism attaches to much of the literature prescribed for special study, and it is feared that attention to linguistic form will, on the whole, be encouraged at the expense of attention to manner or matter, the former being in any case notoriously easier to test by means of an examination. Doubtless, however, the Board of Studies, called upon to satisfy the conflict- ing interests of two groups of specialists, had no easy task before it; and these are early days in which to prophesy concerning the actual working of the school. It rests largely with the examiners to make or mar it. If they would make it, that is, start it as a going concern, let them see that it is, in the words of a recent critic, no mere ‘‘ school of medizval linguistics,” but one ‘‘of the intellectually stimulating and broadening character of our old Litere Humaniores,” From topics redolent of odiwm theologicum, or that even more dismal thing, odiwm philo- logicum, one turns with relief to Mr. Warde Fowler’s little book of some hundred pages, entitled ‘An Oxford Correspondence of 1903’ (Oxford, B. H. Blackwell). Here all is mild wisdom, humour, and a style that is perfect, both otherwise and because it is the man. The correspondence is between a College tutor and his pupil, who first of all misses his “‘ First in Greats,” and later on fails in the I.C.S. examination. The tutor characterizes these examinations as ‘‘ elephantine ”—apt to trample- out the fine quality there is in a man—though the latter is ‘‘of a far more exasperating and degrading type” :— “Exams there must be of cone kind or another ; but the less we have of exams that do not positively help us in education, the better we shall be as a nation. I would lay it down as a first principle that all exams should contribute to the education both of examiner and examinee, and that when they are obviously only used as a test, as in the competitive exams of Government, they should (if no other way can be found of selecting the best men for the purpose you have in view) be constantly scrutinized by a committee of educators of the highest reputa- tion, and reduced to a minimum in regard to subjects- and duration. We in England have become so com- pletely salted, soused, and pickled in these exams,. that we no longer use our natural intelligence in judging of them. We take them for granted, and never or rarely inquire into their effect on the human mind.” Are we then to abolish Greats? The pupil is bidden to read Prof. Gardner’s ‘Oxford at the Cross Roads’: ‘‘Prof. Gardner is the Gracchus of Oxford ; he wishes (so they say) to destroy the constitution of Greats.” Yet the tutor on the whole sympathizes with the demand for less “rhetoric” and more “first-hand work” (though he carps, somewhat wickedly perhaps, at both these phrases) :— ‘Weare so many kettles that never quite get to the boiling-point...... Yes, the tea that we make is generally weak—made with water out of kettles that have never got beyond a gentle singing on the hob. Now do you understand what Gardner wants?” And so he reaches his conclusion :— * At the present moment all I have to say is this: don’t commit yourself all in a hurry to a Gracchan policy with regard to Greats, but keep the essential principle of it, and adjust it as you can or will to new needs, and find a way somehow to give @ man a chance of getting his kettie really on the boil.” And so say all of us, who regard our school of Litere Humaniores, with all its faults, as the best thing of its kind in existence. Only the fundamental principle of the examination must not be lost sight of—and there is a real danger lest this happen, since, in the absence of advanced students to whom he may unbosom himself, every specialist is tempted to press his most recondite lore upon the undergraduate— that the highest honours go, not to the man who. memorizes, but to the man who thinks for him- self, M. LONDON RESIDENCES OF SHAKSPEARE. Iv is, of course, extremely probable that Shakspeare lived for some years at least near the chief theatre with which he was connected, that is, near the Globe on Bankside, and many handbooks have been sufliciently inspired to tell us the exact site of his house. Unfortu- nately they do not all hit on one spot, but perhaps we are to suppose that Shakspeare changed his address now and then, which is not impossible or indeed improbable. Butifwe ask for evidence instead of what are vaguely called ‘‘traditions’’—traditions that cannot be shown to be of any longevity—there is none whatever forthcoming except a statement of Malone’s in his ‘ Inquiry into the Authenticity of the Shakspeare Papers, 1796.’ Such is the respect paid, and justly paid, to Malone’s conscientiousness and accuracy that this statement has considerable value, although the documents referred to in it are no longer extant so far as is known. But even those who are fully disposed to trust Malone may be glad to have some confirmation of a fact that at present rests on his entirely unsup- ported authority; and this I think is to be had. Briefly, in Pipe Roll 41 Eliz. on membrane ‘Residuum Sussex,’ where the name William Shakspeare occurs in the margin in a cursive contemporary hand, are the words ‘‘ Episcopo- Wintonensi,’’ and the obvious interpretation is that the person concerned was then living in the Clink—in the Bishop of Winchester’s
Page 18
402 THE ATHENZXUM N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904
liberty — where the sheriff's writ would not run, and so it was necessary to refer the aatter to the bishop. I must say at once, before this discovery is made clearer, that it has been communicated ‘to me by my friend Mr. Montague 8S. Giuseppi, of the Record Office, who informs me that he mainly owes it to the kindness of Mr. R. E. G. Kirk and his son, Mr. E. F. Kirk. The only credit I can claim is asking Mr. Giuseppi a question as to a certain Subsidy Roll, which question resulted in the ascertainment of some not hitherto published facts most kindly placed by him at my disposal, though I am -sure he or Messrs. Kirk could have set them forth much better than I can hope to do. Perhaps it will be well first to quote the statement of Malone above mentioned :— “From a paper now before me, which formerly belonged to Edward Alleyn, the player, our poet appears to have lived in Southwark, near the Bear Garden, in 1596. Another curious document in my possession, which will be produced in the history of his life,* affords the strongest presumptive evidence that he continued to reside in Southwark to the year 1608...... ; nor is. there any ground for sup- posing that he ceased to reside there till he quitted the stage entirely.” Now many years ago, in 1845, Joseph Hunter called attention to the occurrence of the name of William Shakspeare in a Sub- sidy Roll, dated October, 1598, containing items that relate to the parish of St. Helen’s, Bishopsgate, as to the first of three subsidies granted to Queen Elizabeth in 1597, and had no hesitation in identifying this Shakspeare with the dramatist—rightly, as what has lately been noted proves, I think. He was rated 13s. 4d. on goods valued at 51. But prefixed to his name appears * Affid.,’’ which means that, for some reason or other, he objected to any such demand upon him, the most probable reason being that he no longer resided in that neighbourhood. It may be mentioned in passing that many other names in the list—some twenty out of seventy-two—show the same ‘‘ Affid.’’ attached to them. To Hunter’s valuable discovery may now be added that even at an earlier date Shakspeare had been assessed as an inhabitant of St. Helen’s parish. This earlier assessment amounts to only 5s., though the specified value of the property on which the assessment is made remains the same, viz., 5/., and this also ‘was unpaid, presumably for the same reason as is suggested above. It is only 5s. because the subsidy due in 1595 was levied in two items, viz., ls. 8d. in 1595-6 and Is. in 1596-7. It is ‘‘ the second payment of the last sub- sydye of the three entire subsydyes latelye graunted unto her Majestye by her Highnes laye subjects by Acte of Parliament holden at Westminster, in ye XXXVth yere of her Majesties raigne’’ (November 17th, 1592, to November 16th, 1593) ; and the Commissioners report that the ““* petty collectors of the sayde second payment of the sayde last subsidye within the warde of Byshopsgate, London,’ have appeared and ‘come personallie’ before them, and ‘ upon their corporall othes upon the holye Evangelists of Allmightye God then and there solempnelye taken and made, dyd saye and affirme that the persons hereunder named are all ether dead, departed, and gone out of the sayde warde or their goodes soe eloigned or <onveyd out of the same or in suche a pryvate or coverte manner kept, whereby the severall sommes of money on them severallye taxed and assessed towards the sayde secound payment of the sayde
* Malone did not live to complete his ‘Life of Shake- speare’; see section xvi. of it, p. 449 of vol. ii. of his edition. “*It is with deep regret, in which the reader, I have no doubt, will participate,” says James Boswell, son of the Johnsonian Boswell, who edited the unfinished work, “that here that portion of the ‘Life of Shakespeare’ which Mr. Malone had prepared for the press is brought to a close; and consequently it has devolved upon me to arrange as well as I am able those particulars which I wage = - Ao gy — his papers,” &c. Amongst e ngs collec y Boswell, the documen' promises fe not to be found, , —
last subsydye nether mighte nor coulde by anye meanes by them the sayde petty collectors, or ether of them, be levyed of them, or anye of them, to her Majestys use.’ And amongst the defaulters in ‘St. Eliens parishe’ that are named occurs ‘ William Shackspere V/i—Vs.’ ” It must, of course, be borne in mind that Shakspeare must have been perpetually absent from his “‘ local habitation,’’ house, or inn, or whatever may be its right description—the company of players to which he belonged ‘strolling ’’ in various parts of the country ; and the collector may, probably enough, have seldom, if ever, found him at home. His was a nomad life, though he may have preferred to have a settlement somewhere, however seldom or for however short a time he could stay there. The exact date of the document is Novem- ber 15th, 1597. The assessment was made in October, 1596, and the payment was due on or before February, 1597. So some time, certainly, before the beginning of 1597, if not sooner, Shakspeare had, it would seem, ceased to reside in St. Helen’s parish. But evidently, as the document quoted by Hunter shows, he was still believed to be resident there—he was not known to have ‘moved ’’—for application was made, pretty certainly early in 1598, at the house or premises he had occupied, for payment of his assessed contribution to the “first whole subsidy of three whole subsidies granted ”’’ in the thirty-ninth year of the queen (November 17th, 1596, to November 16th, 1597); but the collectors could get nothing for their pains. William Shakspeare is mentioned amongst “divers persons......ia the ward of Bushopsgate in the parish of St. Helen......{[who] have no goods or chattels, lands or tenements, within the limits of this collection by which the aforesaid collector may be able to distrain for the like subsidy, as is certified to the Court by divers Commissioners of the lady the Queen there upon the oath of the aforesaid col- lector and in the bag of particulars of this account remaining, Certain persons are made _ responsible (‘ought to answer’’) for the deficit — it totalled 288/. 12s., Shakspeare’s amount being, as we have seen, 13s. 4d.—‘‘ and they answer in the great roll [of the Pipe] of the 40th year in Residuum London,’’ 1598. In the part of this Residuum accompt that concerns us is found this entry :— ‘“‘William Shakspeare in the parish of St. Helen’s in Bishopsgate Ward owes 13/4 of the subsidy ; and he answers ia the following roll [i.e., for the following year] in Residuum Sussex.” Now, to quote a letter from Mr. Giuseppi, “as Sussex and Surrey had one sheriff between them at this time, the Sussex roll includes the Surrey entries. In Pipe Roll 41 Eliz.. on membrane Residuum Sussex as stated, is this entry: ‘William Shakspeare in the parish of St. Helen 13/4 of the whole subsidy aforesaid granted in the said 39th year. Which is required upon the same roll there, «.e., referring to the previous entry, which relates to another person also charged in the previous year under London. Against this entry is written in the margin ‘O.N.,’ the conventional contraction for the phrase ‘oneratur nisi,’ he is charged unless (he show cause for exemption or the like). But also in the margin, in acursive contem- porary hand, are the words ‘ Episcopo Wintonensi.’’ Also in the margin at the same place is “*¢”’ (=tot), a letter set against all such forms, rents, and other debts as the sheriff charged himself with the collection of. Now, as I have said, the Liberty of the Clink, Bankside, belonged to the Bishop of Win- chester. Possibly amongst the records of that diocese may be discovered some day some further par- ticulars of this matter; but I am informed that no such discovery seems probable, as amongst the inventory of the Court Rolls there seems to be none for Southwark of the reign of Elizabeth. But Mr. Giuseppi writes that he is ‘‘ convinced that the debt was,’’ in 42 Eliz., “settled, and the money recovered in some way. Shakspeare’s name does not appear in this roll—at
least, ia connexion with this particular debt. On the other hand, the Bishop of Winchester accounts for a sum of money ‘of the issues of divers persons’ which had been referred to him by the Sheriff of Sussex and Surrey. If these issues be picked out of the preceding roll and added together they make this sum, except that there is a 4d. either too much or too little. (It is not quite clear in the roll whether an 8d. is to be included in the total or not.) Moreover, those entries in the roll of the preceding year which are accounted for by the sheriff (either by himself or his assiga) in the year following are marked, as stated by him, with a T (=tot), and against the Shakspeare entry in 41 Eliz. is this T, the significance of which I had not at first grasped.” All these things considered together, and also in connexion with Malone’s statement, ean there be any reasonable doubt that the William Shakspeare mentioned was the great dramatist, and that he lived for a time in or near Bishopsgate, and then for some years on Bankside ? Joun W. HALEs.
‘THE PSALMS IN HUMAN LIFE,’ I am obliged to your critic for a kindly notice of ‘The Psalms in Human Life.’ I cheerfully recognize his right to disagree with my conclusions, But he definitely joins issue with me on two points, which are matters not of opinion, but of fact. As inaccuracy destroys the value of such a book as mine, I should be obliged if you will allow me space to defend my statements. In one of the two points I think that your critic is wrong ; in the other, that we are both right. The first point is, whether Episcopacy con- tinued to exist in Scotland after Knox’s ‘ Book of Discipline ’ (1561) and before Melville's ‘ Book of Discipline’ (1581). Your critic says that it had ceased to exist; I say that it continued. Possibly your critic has forgotten the convention of Leith (1572). The facts are shortly stated in the ‘ Dictionary of National Biography,’ s.v. Andrew Melville or Melvill :— * Melvill’s attack was directed against the remaining forms of episcopacy. The first ‘book of discipline’ (1551) had permitted a quasi-episco- pacy in the shape of ‘superintendents.’ The con- vention of Leith (1572) had re-established the hierarchy, though with limited powers.” The second point is the event which led directly to the signature of the National Covenant in 1638. I wrote :— ‘‘ When, in 1637, Charies I. attempted tointroduce a book of Canonsand a Liturgy framed on the English model .....a wave of excitement swept over Scot- land.” Your critic’s mind and mine were working on different lines. I emphasize the fact that the Prayer Book did not reach Scotland till May, 1637, and that it was to be first used on July 23rd, 1637, at St. Giles’s in Edinburgh. Your critic objects that the Book of Canons was pub- lished in 1636, and, if it will help him, I may add that it was in October, 1636, that Charles commanded the use of the Prayer Book. But the action which brought the excitement to a head was the introduction of the Prayer Book into St. Giles’s in July, 1637. Rowtanp E. ProruHero. Leghorn, March 18th, 1904. Ir is somewhat strange, surely, that Mr. R. E. Prothero, desirous of knowing St. Francis’s attitude to the Psalter, should go to a late com- pilation like the ‘Speculum Perfectionis,’ when we have the saint’s own views on the subject in a document written by him. And the same may be said of your able reviewer, who in his notice of ‘The Psalms in Human Life’ (Atheneum, March 12th) seeks to correct a misstatement on the part of Mr. Prothero by likewise drawing upon this very puddled source. In chap. iv. of the ‘Speculum’ St. Francis is made to refuse a novice the use or possession—it is not clear which—of a Psalter. Possession would, of course, have been refused to the Minister-
es" S Oil a ~m wi ws Se DO Ae A A eR OH 4 8 eS es
Page 19
N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 THE ATHENAUM 403 General himself, for no Friar Minor might own anything ; but the wse of a Psalter would not have been denied even toa lay brother. Hear St. Francis himself in cap. iii. of the Rule of 1221 :-— ‘‘The clerics shall say Office...... according to the use of the clergy...... And they may have the books which are necessary to saying Office ; and even lay brothers who can read the Psalter may have it.” This is not the language of one who would forbid a novice the use of a Psalter, and so the ‘Speculum’ is here convicted out of the mouth of St. Francis as being not only fantastic and erroneous, but obviously tainted with the fanaticism of the extreme spirituali. The chapter can contain but the merest echo of the original incident. Thomas of Celano, in his curt account of the matter (‘Vita Altera,’ iii. 124), speaks of a ‘‘frater laicus,” not a ‘‘frater novitius,” as desiring the Psalter, and it seems to me possible that St. Francis’s reproof was really addressed to a lay brother, unable to read, or scarcely able to read, who desired the use of a Psalter from motives of vainglory. This chapter of the ‘Speculum’ gets even more fantastic as it proceeds. St. Francis is made to reiterate, in horror, ‘‘Ego breviarium! ego breviarium !” And yet, as we have seen, he enjoined its possession ad usum, and his own favourite breviary is preserved to this day in the Poor Clare Nunnery at Assisi. Friar Leo, his secretary, whom Mr. Prothero regards as the author of cap. iv. of the ‘Speculum,’ has authenticated it with a priceless inscription : “*Beatus Franciscus acquisivit hoc breviarium sociis suis fratri Angelo et fratri Leoni,” &c. The rest of the pious annotation may be read in a variety of works, among them the ‘Spec. Perf.,’ p. 175; my abridgment is due to regard for your space. Surely it is time that scholars like Mr. Prothero and your very able reviewer should shake off the fascination due to the brilliant ability with which a clever writer has presented a formless tardy omnium gatherum as the early homogeneous work of the saint’s confessor. The ‘Speculum’ will have its uses, and pos- sibly even great uses, when a proper endeavour has been made to ascertain by the light of scientific criticism how much of it is early and genuine, and how much late and legendary. But the complacent reception of its every page as the genuine and unadulterated work of Friar Leo cannot advance— indeed, has done much to retard—that true knowledge of St. Francis and his first disciples which is so eagerly being sought among all classes of men. MonTGoMERY CARMICHAEL, THE SPRING PUBLISHING SEASON, MESSRS. CASSELL & CO. announce The Story of the Britannia Training Ship for Naval Cadets, by Commander E. P. Statham,— English Earthenware and Stoneware, by William Burton (edition limited to 1,450 copies),—The Kiss of the Enemy, by Headon Hill,—a third impression of Wild Nature’s Ways, by R. Kearton,—a popular edition of Mr. Foster Fraser’s The Real Siberia and America at Work,—Fact ~. Fiction, the Cobden Club’s Reply to Mr. Chamberlain,—The Water- Colour Drawings of Turner in the National Gallery, text by Theodore A. Cook, a limited edition,—Cas- sell’s Illustrated History of the Boer War,—Pictorial Practical Chrysanthemum Culture, edited by W. P. Wright,—Profitable Hume Farming, by Yeoman,— Cassell’s Art Postcards,—in the “ Work” Handbooks. edited by P. N. Hasluck, volumes on Upholstery, Saddlery, and Harness-making,—Joseph’s Letters upon Egypt,—The Khedive’s Country, the Nile Valley and its Products, edited by G. M. Fenn,— Koreans at Home, by C. J. D. Tayler,—Notes on Alternate Currents for Students, by H. H.Simmons,— ocket editions of Stevenson’s Black Arrow and aster of Ballantrae,—sixpenny editions of The Lord Protector and Nebo the Nailer,—in “ Cassell’s National Library”: The Rivals and the School for Scandal; The Pilgrim’s Progress; Much Ado about Nothing; Selections from Walpole’s Letters and Hazlitt’s Essays ; Sartor Resartus ; Burns's Poems ; Goldsmith’s Plays,—Cassell’s Guide to London for 1904,—The Therapeutics of Mineral Springs and Climates, by I. Burney Yeo,—and The Student's Handbook of Surgical Operations, by Sir F. Treves and J. Hutchinson. MESSRS, T. C. & E. C. JACK are publishing: In the Century Bible: Genesis, by Prof. W. H. Bennett; Judges and Ruth, by the Rev. G. W. Thatcher; 1 and 2 Samuel, by Prof. A. R. S. Kennedy ; Job, by Prof. A. S. Peake ; 1 and 2 Kings, by Prof. Skinner; Psalms, 2 vols., by Prof. Davison ; Isaiah (chaps. i—xxxix.), by Principal Whitehouse ; Minor Prophets: Hosea, Joel, Amos, Obadiah, Jonah, Micah, by the Rev. R. F. Horton ; and Nahum, Habakkuk, Zephaniah, Haggai, Zecha- riah, Malachi, by Canon Driver,—The Jacobite Peerage, Baronetage, Knightage, and Grants of Honour, by the Marquis of Ruvigny and Raineval, limited to 250 copies ; and The Plantagenet Roll, by the same. : MESSRS. BEMROSE’S new books include: Daylight for Japan, by Frances Awdry,—The Registers of the Parish of Askham Westmoreland) from 1566 to 1812, copied by M. E. oble,—Memorials of Old Devonshire, edited by F. J. Snell,—Black Jacks and Leather Bottles, by Oliver Baker,—new editions of Railway Maximum Rates and Charges, by M. B. Cotsworth; Heller’s Annotated Edition of the Code for 1904-5, revised by R. Holland; and T. B. B.,—and A Glossary of the Technical Terms employed in connexion with Church Bells, their Furniture and Fittings, and in the Science and Art of Change-Ringing, by the late Rev. H. E. Bulwer. SALE. MEssrs. SOTHEBY, WILKINSON & HODGE sold on the 21st and 22nd inst. the following books from the library of agentleman : Alken’s Sporting Repository, 1822, 307. Analysis of the Hunting Field, 1846, 167. 10s. Annals of Sporting and Fancy Gazette, 1822-8, 201. Apperley’s Life of a Sportsman, 1842, 291. Boxiana, 5 vols., 1812-29, 287. Brough’s Life of Falstaff, presentation copy from Cruikshank, 121.5s. Carey’s Life in Paris, large paper, original numbers, 1822, 587. 10s. Combe’s Tours of Dr. Syntax, first editions, 3 vols., 1812-20-21, 347. Life of Napoleon, 1815. 137. Dance of Death and Dance of Life, 3 vols., 1815-17, 197. 15s. The Humourist, with coloured plates by Cruikshank, first edition, 4 vols., 1819-20, 302. Cruikshank’s Comic Almanack, 19 vols., as issued, 1835-53, 147. Dickens’s Sketches by Boz, first edition, 3 vols., 1836-7, 237.; The Strange Gentle- map, a burletta, first edition, 1837, 1417. ; Speech at the Meeting of the Administrative Reform Associa- tion, June 27th, 1855, original proof, 317, Egan’s Life of an Actor, original picture boards, uncut, 207. British Volunteers, 6 numbers, coloured plates, 151. 15s. Naval and Martial Achievements, coloured plates, 2 vols, 1815-17, 277. 5s. Ackermann’s Microcosm of London, 3 vols., uncut, 22/, Alken’s National Sports, 1821, 607.; Humorous and Sporting Designs, 318 plates, 81/.; Sport- ing Notions, 1832, 40/.; Ideas accidental to Hunting, n.d., 402. Caricature Magazine, by Wood- ward, 500 caricatures, 75/. Egan’s Finish to the Adventures of Tom, Jerry, and Logic, 1830, 207, 10s, Grimm’s Popular Stories, 2 vols., 1823-6, 25/. 10s, Ireland’s Life of Napoleon, 4 vols., 1823-8, 347. 10s, Moore’s Annals of Gallantry, 3 vols., 1814-15, 17/7. 15s. Vicar of Wakefield, illustrated by Rowlandson, boards, uncut, 1817, 26/7. 10s. Scrope’s Deer- Stalking and Salmon Fishing, 2 vols., 1838-43, 227. Shelley’s Queen Mab, first edition, 1813, 897. Surtees’s Jorrocks’s Jaunts, Alken’s plates, 1843, 277.; Sporting Novels (5), first edi- tions, 1853-65, 244. Poems by Two Brothers (the Tennysons), first edition, uncut, 1827, 327. Vanity Fair, first edition, in original parts, 1847- 8, 1027. The English Spy, 2 vols., original boards, uncut, 1825-6, 557. Pyne’s Royal Residences, 3 vols., 1819, 197. 15s. Reid’s Cruikshank Catalogue, 1871, 127, 10s. Natural History of Selborne, first edi- tion, uncut, 1789, 277. 10s. Harding’s Portraits of the Royal Family (22), printed in colours, 1806, 437.10s. Kit Cat Club Portraits, original im- pressions, 1735, 247. Orme’s British Field Sports, 1807, 752. Rowlandson’s Loyal London Volunteers, 1799, 277. 10s, Hiterary Gossip. Mr. Henry Frowve will issue next week a double section of the ‘New English Dictionary,’ containing the first portion of the letter P. In the introductory article Dr. Murray notes that, while initial P had a very limited use in Old English or Anglo- Saxon—in which it was by far the smallest native initial, comprising about a hundred and eighth part of the vocabulary — in modern English it has grown to be one of the “three gigantic letters” (S, C, P) which between them occupy nearly one-third of the modern dictionary. In illustration of this the striking fact is mentioned that out of 2,454 main words included in this section, only one, viz. “pan,” can claim to be a native word in Anglo-Saxon. Messrs. Surrn, Exper & Co. will publish on April 12th a volume by Mr. Edward George Harman, entitled ‘Studies from Attic Drama,’ containing ‘The House of Atreus’ and the ‘ Alcestis.’ ‘The House of Atreus’ isa translation of the‘ Agamemnon’ of ischylus, specially marked, from the metrical point of view, by the use of blank verse for the choruses. The ‘ Alcestis’ is, in the main, a translation of Euripides, but with one or two dramatic variations adapted from M. Georges Rivollet’s ‘ Alkestis, Drame Antique d’aprés Euripide,’ as acted in Paris. THE great success of Mr. Harry Furniss’s ‘ Confessions of a Caricaturist’ has led him to write another book of experiences. It will be entitled ‘Harry Furniss at Home,’ will be illustrated with many characteristic drawings, and published by Mr. Fisher Unwin. Among other things Mr. Furniss deals with Mr. Chamberlain’s fiscal policy and the construction of a political lampoon. There is a humorous account of experiences during the Coronation year, and of the difficulties which surround those who cater for the public amusement. A chapter is devoted to the author’s late friend Max O’Rell, and there are also reminiscences of Corney Grain and other celebrities. Tue Monthly Review for April will contain articles on ‘The German Staff on the Boer War’; ‘Russia’s Financial Staying-Power,’ by Mr. M. A.Gerothwohl; and ‘The Cavalry and its Principal Arm,’ by Eques. ‘The Eastern Mind’ is discussed by Mr. D. G. Hogarth ; ‘Ancient and Modern Farming in the Roman Campagna,’ by Prof. Lan- ciani; ‘Edward FitzGerald,’ by the late Whitwell Elwin; and ‘The True Story of the Stratford Bust,’ illustrated, by Mrs. Stopes. Tue April Blackwood opens with a sketch by Lady Ourrie entitled ‘The Feast of Kebobs: a Reminiscence,’ in which she describes a fantastic dinner-party, given by her father, at which the guests were clad in Eastern costumes, and the dish of the even- ing was the Turkish delicacy kebobs, followed by hasheesh. In ‘A Friend of Warren Hastings’ Sydney C. Grier throws light upon the private character of the great proconsul. The number also includes ‘The Wandering Population of the West High- lands,’ by L. M.M.; ‘The Prisoner,’ a story by Mr. Ernest Dawson ; ‘Musings without Method’ (which treat of Whig and Tory, Lord Acton’s letters, the Scientific Historian in Theory and Practice, and Tacitus and his Translators); and a new estimate of Sir John Moore. Messrs. Macuiiian & Co. will shortly publish a new volume of sermons by the late Master of the Temple, and also a volume of his occasional Jectures on Shak- speare, Chaucer, Cowper, and other literary subjects. Both volumes will be edited by Canon Beeching.
Page 20
404 THE ATHENAUM N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 Mr. Lavrence Hvrron is busy with another volume of his ‘‘ Landmarks Series ’’; this time it is ‘Literary Landmarks of Scottish Universities.’ Just as we go to press on Thursday afternoon, we hear with great regret of the death of Sir Edwin Arnold. A new edition of Sir Robert Douglas’s *Peerage of Scotland’ is at present in pre- aration, under the editorship of Sir James Balfour Paul, Lyon King of Arms, who has, along with a staff of contributors, been working at it for some time. The last edition, by J. P. Wood, was published in 1813, in two volumes folio, and has till now been the standard work of reference on the subject. So much correction has been required, however, in consequence of the amount of fresh material published within the last century, that it has been found necessary virtually to rewrite the whole book. It is to be named ‘The Scots Peerage,’ and is expected to occupy six volumes. The first volume is ready, and will be published next month by Mr. David Douglas, of Edinburgh. There will be a Jarge number of heraldic illustrations by Mr. Graham Johnston. Tue Scottish Law Times, which published a biographical sketch of the late Dr. T. G. Law, will also print a bibliography of his books and scattered historical articles, which should be of interest. Tux Annual Report of the Selden Society shows that the numbers are well maintained. The publication for 1904 will be a first volumeof ‘Select Borough Custumals,’ edited by Miss Mary Bateson, which is already well advanced. Provisional arrangements have been made for the following publica- tions : in 1905, ‘ Year-Books of Edward II.,’ Vol. II., edited by Prof. Maitland, whose brilliant work in the first volume has been widely appreciated; in 1906, ‘Borough Custumals,’ Vol. II., or ‘Star Chamber,’ Vol. If.; and in 1907, ‘ Year-Books of Edward II.,’ Vol. III. Tue first volume of the long-expected Variorum Edition of the Works of Beau- mont and Fletcher is now nearly ready. The edition, which has been planned under the general direction of Mr. A. H. Bullen, assisted by several scholars, includes a full list of various readings, besides the usual annotations. The first volume contains “The Maid’s Tragedy’ and ‘ Philaster,’ edited by Mr. P. A. Daniel, and ‘A King and No King,’ ‘The Scornful Lady,’ and ‘The Custom of the Country,’ edited by Mr. R. Warwick Bond. The work will be completed in twelve volumes, the last con- taining memoirs, &c., by the general editor, and will be published jointly by Mr. Bullen and Messrs. Bell & Sons. Mr. Fisner Unwin will publish before long a work by Mr. Arthur Davenport, entitled ‘China from Within: a Study of Opium Fallacies and Missionary Mistakes.’ The purpose of the book is, firstly, to refute the assertion that England “has forced opium on China,” and, secondly, to suggest @ total change from the present methods of missionary propaganda, which are, the author believes, entirely unsuited to the Chinese character, and a perpetual menace to the peace of the country. Temple Bar for April contains, amongst other features, a biographical paper on Mlle. de Montpensier by Miss Eleanor C. Price; ‘On Browsing in a Library,’ by the Rev. Archie F. Webling; ‘Here and There in West Hertfordshire, by Miss Etta Courtney ; and‘A Windy Garden,’ describing floricultural experiments in Ireland, by Mrs. Dorothea Townshend. Tue April number of Macmillan’s Maga- sine includes a paper on Alfred Ainger by the Master of -Peterhouse; ‘ Harrow Revisited,’ after an interval of fifty years, by Sir Charles Bruce; ‘Thirty Years Ago in Japan,’ by Mr. H. F. Abell; ‘The Boer War through German Glasses,’ by ‘“‘ Par- ticeps’”?; and an article on ‘Contraband of War,’ by Mr. F. Baty; while the discovery of radium and other scientific wonders are discussed in ‘ Paracelsus Redivivus.’ A potiTicaL satire, in rhymed couplets, entitled ‘Cleon in the Palace of Truth; or, the Art of Statecraft,’ is shortly to be pub- lished by Mr. Brimley Johnson. The name of the ostensible author, Lucian Lambert, is said to conceal the identity of a well- known writer. An International Exhibition of Printing, Stationery, and Allied Trades will be held at the Agricultural Hall, Islington, from April 30th to May 14th inclusive. Sir Henry Bemrose is president of the scheme, and a strong list of patrons is already announced. The exhibits will include all sorts of fine printing, art illustrations, picture posters and postcards, illuminated addresses, cloth and “ extra ’’ bookbindings, and technical handbooks. Medals and certificates will be awarded. Tue Angus Lectures, delivered last year at Regent’s Park College by Dr. T. Vincent Tymms, on ‘The Christian Idea of Atone- ment,’ are to be issued next month by Messrs. Macmillan & Co. Several of the lectures are historical, reviewing the prin- cipal theories which have at different times prevailed in the Church ; but they are also largely constructive, stating the author’s own position. Tue Ridley Lectures, also recently de- livered at Regent’s Park College by the Rev. William Brock, on ‘The Church’s Relation to Children,’ will shortly be pub- lished by the Kingsgate Press (Baptist Union). A sPECIAL edition, with a brief introduc- tion by Mrs. Stevenson, of Stevenson’s ‘Prayers written at Vailima,’ will be published before long by Messrs. Scribner. Tue Readers’ Dinner last Saturday was universally regarded as a great success. Attendance and speeches were alike excel- lent. Lord Goschen was both wise and witty, speaking of his hereditary gifts as a proof-reader. Mr. Teignmouth Shore made an interesting plea for the recognition of present-day literature and criticism; Mr. Pett Ridge and Mr. Max Beerbohm were humorous, and everybody more than equal to the occasion. We are glad to hear that the subscriptions towards the Jubilee Pension have reached 440/. Tue Hon. Oliver A. Borthwick will pre- side at the Sixty-fifth Annual Festival of the Newsvendors’ Benevolent and Provi- dent Institution, which will be held at De Keyser’s Royal Hotel on Wednesday, June Ist, next. Tue Ninth Annual Meeting of the Book- sellers’ Seaside Holiday Home was held last Thursday. We regret to see from the Report that the receipts were not equal to those of the previous year, and, in consequence of the wet season, there was a falling-off in the number of visitors to this pleasant institution, which boasts among its attrac- tions an excellent library. Tue Bibliothéque Nationale closed for its annual overhauling on Saturday last, and will not be opened again until April 4th. Ir is proposed to celebrate the forth- coming centenary of Jules Janin by erecting at Saint-Etienne, his birthplace, a plaque, bust, or monument. His collected essays, published under the title of ‘Le Livre,’ form a very pleasant ‘‘ bookish” book. Although not now much read, Jules Janin did good work in his day. Tue letters of Henrik Ibsen are being collected, with his sanction, for publication in the near future. Tue Parliamentary Papers likely to be of most interest to our readers this week are Report from the Ecclesiastical Commis- sioners for England, with Appendix (6d.); Education, Scotland, Training of Teachers, Report, Statistics, &c. (5d.); Return show- ing Expenditure from Grant for Public Education in Scotland, List of Day Schools, Scotland, &c. (10d.); Report on the Edin- burgh Museum of Science and Art, 1903 (13d.); Statutes made by the Governing Bodies of New and All Souls’ Colleges, Oxford (1d. and 3d.); Annual Statistical Report of the University of Aberdeen (13d.); Queen’s College, Belfast, Staff and Equipment, Resolutions, &c. (2d.); and Yorkshire College, Leeds, Application for Establishment of a University in Leeds, Report, &c. (23d.). SCIENCE —o— The Oldest Map with the Name America, of the Year 1507, and the Carta Marina of the Year 1516. By M. Waldseemiiller. Edited by Prof. J. Fischer, 8.J., and F. R. von Wieser. (Innsbruck, Wagner ; London, Henry Stevens.) In the year 1507 there was published at the town of St. Dié in Lorraine a small book containing a short ‘Cosmography’ followed by a Latin version of the ‘ Four Voyages of Amerigo Vespucci.’ This little book has become historically interesting because its author, Martin Waldseemiiller, rashly sug- gested in it that the then lately discovered fourth part of the world should be called ‘«‘ America because Americus | Amerigo | had discovered it.” He refers in this book to two “ descriptions” of the world, tam in solido, quam plano, that is to say, by means of a globe and an ordinary map. The globe, a very small affair, was discovered by Varnhagen in 1872, and has since been published and definitely ascribed to Waldseemiiller by Prof. L. Gallois. The map, however, though an edition of one thousand copies of it was printed, remained absolutely unknown until 1901, when Prof. J. Fischer, when searching the library of Prince Waldburg at Castle Wolfegg for
Page 21
N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 THE ATHENAUM 405 materials for a work on the discoveries of the Norsemen in America, since published, quite unexpectedly came across an old volume which had formerly belonged to Johann Schéner, and which not only con- tained the map of 1507, but likewise an equally gigantic twelve-sheet ‘ Carta Marina’ by the same author, dated 1516, and hitherto absolutely unknown. It is these two maps which are now presented to the geographical world in excellent facsimiles, together with a valuable com- mentary, the joint work of Prof. Fischer, the discoverer of them, and Prof. R. von Wieser, the well-known student of the history of geography. Most of the sheets of the two maps have been divided up in red ink into small squares, and the errata enumerated by the author have been corrected. The editors conclude from this that ‘‘the maps of the Wolfegg volume were proof-sheets ”’ revised with a view to a second edition. We are, however, unable to accept this explanation. No small squares are needed in order to revise a proof, and the correc- tion of errata would have extended beyond the few instances pointed out in a legend, for the author must have been perfectly aware that there were many other “‘ corup- tele” which, very unfairly, he charges upon the ‘‘negligence” of the wood engraver. We believe, on the contrary, that Schéner, the owner of the maps, first corrected the errata, and then inserted the red lines at intervals of a degree, the usual method when it is intended to make a copy of a map. Asa matter of fact, he freely utilized Waldseemiiller’s maps when designing his globes in 1515 and in 1520. We are con- firmed in this view by a marginal MS. legend placed close to the ‘‘Insule 7 delle Pulzelle,” beginning ‘‘Insule S. Martini ibi?’’ and ending with a reference to “‘algalia,” which can only have been taken from Behaim’s globe at Niirnberg, freely accessible to Schéner, but not to Waldsee- miiller. The MS. of one of the sheets of the ‘Carta Marina,’ bound up in the Wolfegg volume, is certainly not a ‘‘tracing”’ (Pause), but either the original design for the map or a copy of it upon paper of the same make as that used for the printed maps. The paper of an impression of this sheet lying loose in the volume bears a different water-mark from all other sheets, and was, therefore, printed separately. It is not, however, a second revised edition, for the errata already referred to have not been corrected, and there are many others, suchas papapagulli instead of “‘ papagalli,” habudatia instead of “ abundantia,’”’ sapodes instead of “‘sciopodes,” and others. Such obvious mis- takes would hardly have escaped the eye of a competent corrector. More remark- able still, a long legend referring to the discovery of 8. Thome, which is to be found on the original, has been absolutely for- gotten by the engraver. The ‘Sources of Waldseemiiller’ are not dealt with by the editors so thoroughly as we should have desired. The editors prove, indeed, that he made extensive use of Canerio’s chart, and of other charts recording the discoveries of the Portu- guese; they refer to Ptolemy, Marco Polo, and other authorities quoted by the author himself, but they throw no light whatever upon the sources whence he de- rived his delineation of the Asiatic Archi- pelago or of the interior of Africa. With reference to the latter they are content to refer to ‘“‘a most remarkable transfer of data of Abyssinian topography to South Africa.” It is, indeed, easy to identify such names as Goia (Gojam), Gafat, Adra (Adiha), Ago (Angot), and Vabi (Webi), but the origin of the bulk of the names has not been traced. Reference might, for instance, have been made to a description of the Nile sources by an unknown author first published in Hudson’s ‘ Geographi Greeci Minores,’ of which Waldseemiiller made full use, or to the fact that all the places which the Ritter von Harff claims to have passed in the course of his apo- cryphal journey down the Nile are to be found on the map of 1507. This boastful knight returned to Germany in 1499, and although his narrative was only first printed in 1860, Waldseemiiller may have seen a MS. copy, or—and this seems more likely— both the knight and the cartographer may have obtained their information from a map not hitherto identified. The editors say of Waldseemiiller that ‘“‘he was not the man to copy anything without criticism, but utilized and worked up his sources quite independently.” We regret that after the publication of these two monumental maps we are unable to subscribe to this favourable estimate. We should rather say that he was an indis- criminate copyist. In 1507 the peninsular shape of India could no longer be doubted ; indeed, it would have revealed itself to any cartographer who took the trouble to plot Marco Polo’s route. Yet Waldseemiiller rejects the results of actual observations and blindly follows the lead of Ptolemy. In 1516 Ptolemy is unceremoniously thrown overboard, and Canerio’s authority is accepted, notwithstanding the palpable error of that cartographer in the trend given to the Red Sea. Still, in these respects Waldseemii ler was not inferior to most of his contemporaries, and we are certainly grateful for the publication of these historically interesting maps, for they exercised a paramount in- fluence upon the cartography of his age, and were copied wholly or in part until far into the seventeenth century. The translation is by the Rev. G. Pickel, S.J., possibly a descendant of the famous poet and geographer Conrad Pickel or Celtes, who was a contemporary of Waldseemiiller. RESEARCH NOTES. Tue centre of interest in the world of physical science continues to be the N rays discovered by M. Blondlot, and (literally) no week has passed since the beginning of the year in which some fresh discovery concerning them has not been announced to the Académie des Sciences. Meanwhile their existence outside the imagina- tion of the Nancy professors has been denied — more Germanorum— by Dr. Lummer; but this attack has been promptly countered by the photographic proof produced by their first dis- coverer. There can now be little doubt that these rays have a shorter wave-length than any radiations hitherto known, and extend well beyond the ultra-violet. They are produced by the sun, Crookes’s tube, the Nernst electric lamp, and the Auer-Welsbach gas mantle, and, as it now appears, by the bodies of living animals, growing plants, the vibrations of sound, the magnetic field, and all substances in a state of strain, such as tempered steel, crystal- lized sulphur, compressed wood and _ india- rubber, Prince Rupert’s drops, liquid carbonic acid heated to a temperature of not more than 40°C., liquid air, and ozone. They pass unchecked through most polished substances, but are arrested by water and certain metallic oxides, are stored up within substances like quartz, fluor-spar, glass, and saline solutions, and can be conducted by means of polished wires of silver or copper, or rods of glass, which conduc- tion is said to be a phenomenon of reflection. Finally, they increase the phosphorescence of faintly luminous substances, which proves, so far, the easiest method of exhibiting them. It is, however, in the direction of their phy- siological effects and the results of them that discovery has proceeded most rapidly of late. As was said in the Athenewm of January 23rd (No. 3978), M. Blondlot’s colleague, Dr. Char- pentier, has established that the rays emitted by the nerves and muscles of the human body differ in character from each other. This has been now extended until he claims to be able to recognize by the increase of light upon a phosphorescent screen the phenomena of diges- tion and the process of thought not followed by action, or, as he puts it, cerebral work unaccompanied by exterior expression. Revers- ing the method of procedure, he has shown that the action of the N rays increases the sensitiveness of the eye to light, of the olfactory nerves to odours, and of the auditory nerves to sounds ; while he conjectures that the excitement of both nerve and muscle that they produce may possibly be utilized in the future as a mode of treatment. Dr. Richet has gone further, and, observing that the living cells in action are a source of N rays, has tried the effect of luminous screens upon sensitive living cells, with the result that he claims to have been able to increase the speed of lactic fermentation. It should also be said that most of the Nancy experimenters are agreed that the sources of N rays produce also an intervening series, which they call the N', and which appears to have the reversed effect of decreasing instead of increasing the light of the phosphorescent screen. It is possible that this is connected with the fact that the increase of light is not observed, unless it strikes the eye of the observer almost at right angles, and that if it be looked at obliquely the N rays appear to diminish its light. It is doubtless this phenomenon which has caused the failure of some of our English men of science to repeat M. Blondlot’s experiments. Facts seem to be accumulating in support of Prof. Metchnikoff's theory that appendicitis is mainly caused by the infection of parasites from the lower animals. Dr. Chauvel, in a late report to the Académie de Médecine, declares that it is unknown among the Mohammedan populations of Algeria and Tunis, who live on a vegetable diet, and this is confirmed by Dr. Schneider, the Shah’s doctor at Teheran, who says that the only cases of appendicitis he has met with among the Persians have occurred with those travellers who have brought back with them from Europe the habit of eating meat. Perhaps there is no country in the world where the disease is more prevalent than in the Eastern States of America, including New York, where the consumption of meat per head is said to be far greater than even in England. This also accounts for its late appearance among the agricultural classes of European nations, to whom meat, other than bacon, was until late years a luxury. ; Another disease, even more terrible and more mysterious than the last-named, has also had some light cast upon its origin by the researches of the German Dr. Donath. Following up the conclusions of other specialists as to the exist- ence of some toxic substance in the blood
Page 22
406 THE ATHENAUM N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 of epileptics, he is now able to prove that the cerebro-spinal fluid in fifteen out of twenty- one cases of epilepsy that he was able to examine showed the presence of choline, a tri-methyl- oxethyl-ammonium hydrate which enters into the composition of the nervous tissue in man and other animals. On applying this to the cerebral cortex of a dog, he found it to pro- duce convulsions of extreme violence, but the same result did not follow from the cerebro- spinal fluid of hysterical patients. Although r. Donath seems to consider proved the theory that the symptoms of epilepsy are really caused by the toxin in question, it is not yet shown that this is the only determining factor of the attack. Ata time when the high-priests of science were wont todogmatize more fiercely than they now ven- ture to do, it used to be said that all solutions could be divided into crystalloids, such as solu- tions of salts, and colloids, or glue-like sub- stances. However this may be, there is no doubt that all organic liquids contain colloids, and that all membranes through which absorp- tion and secretion take place are composed of them. Ina communication lately made to the Société Francaise de Physique, MM. Victor Huni and Ascher Mayer assert that all colloids are of one of two kinds, one category contain- ing those which are displaceable in an electric field in the direction of the current, which they propose to call positive colloids, and the other those which are displaced in a direction con- trary to the current, or negative ones. Whether this has any connexion with the phenomena of osmosis remains to be seen, but it shows how large a part the knowledge of electricity is coming to play in physiology as in other branches of science. F. L. SOCIETIES, ASTRONOMICAL.— March 11.—Prof. H. H. Turner, President, in the chair.—The Secretary gave an account of a paper by Mr. Nevill, of the Natal Observatory, on the comparison between the purely theoretical and observed places of the moon. A short account was also given of a paper by Prof. E. W. Brown on the degree of accuracy of the new lunar theory, and on the final values of the mean motions of the perigee and node.—The President read a paper on the instrumental errors affecting observations of the moon, his conclusion being that it seems probable that meridian instruments may give very different values for the parailactic in- equality, so that the results which Mr. Cowell had sup- plied must for the present be received with caution. —Mr. P. H. Cowell read a paper on methods of analysis of the moon’s errors, with some results.-- he Astronomer Royal read a note on the determi- nation of positions and magnitudes of stars inthe Greenwich Astrographic Catalogue, now in course of publication, discussing the probable errors of photographic star-places as compared with those obtained from meridian observations.—Mr. Furner read a paper, by himself and Mr. Storey, on the absolute proper motions of certain double stars having large relative motion.—Mr. Maunder read a paper, by himself and Mrs. Maunder, on the date of the passage of the vernal equinox from Taurus into Aries.—Many other papers were taken as read. GEOLOGICAL.—March 9.—Dr. J. E. Marr, Presi- dent, in the chair.—Mr. G. Barrow exhibited and commented on a small striated boulder which was found a little above high water on White Island, one of the northern projections of the Scilly Isles. It was firmly embedded in the ground, and there- fore the striations which occur on both faces could not have been produced in situ by the grinding action of boulders or stones moved by powerful waves.—The following communications were read : ‘On the Probable Occurrence of an Eocene Outlier off the Cornish Coast,’ by Mr. Clement Reid,—and ‘The Valley of the Teign,’ by Mr. A. J. Jukes- Browne. SOCIETY OF ANTIQUARIES. — March Viscount Dillon, President, in the chair.—Mr. O,. M. Dalton read a paper on the ‘Crystal of Lothair in the British Museum,’ giving a summary of research relating to the jewel, and an abstract of its remarkable history as dis- covered by Mr. W. H. J. Weale in the chronicle of the Abbey of Waulsort, near Namur. Mr. Dalton also 10. — read notes on early cloisonné enamelled brooches in the British Museum sometimes attributed to Anglo- Saxon jewellers, He pointed out that the most massive of these, formerly in the Castellani col- lection and found in Italy, was probably made in Lombard territory in pre-Carlovingian times. It was probably earlier than the ninth century, and therefore a most important document in the history of enamelling in Europe. Of two other early enamelled brooches in the Museum, that with a floriated cross of very fine execution, and said to have been found in Scotland, could best be compared with work preserved on the Continent, and having no connexion with England; the second, with an admirable portrait of aking, found in Thames Street, might indeed have been made, like the Alfred Jewel, in these islands, though even in this case there was no conclusive evidence. Mr. Dalton further drew attention to a curious similarity (possibly no more than a coincidence) between the representation of certain busts upon Coptic textiles bearing wands over the shoulders, and that of the figure upon the Alfred Jewel.—The Bishop of Bristol suggested that the figure might represent Alfred himself, holding a twin sceptre or pair of sceptres for his kingdoms of Mercia and Wessex.—Mr. Philip Norman, Treasurer, exhibited a sculptured head found on the site of Newgate Prison, which he suggested might have formed part of one of the figures that were set up on Newgate when it was rebuilt in 1672.— Mr. E, P. Warren exhibited a number of pewter and base-metal spoons and other objects discovered at Westminster, including part of one of the Purbeck marble twisted shafts that are missing from the tomb ef Henry III, in the abbey church. The fragment discovered is to be refixed in its place.—Mr. W. W. Portal exhibited a cutlass with the Solingen mark, probably of the nineteenth century, found during the operations now in progress for the enlargement of Waterloo railway station. March 17.—Viscount Dillon, President, in the chair.—The President referred in suitable terms to the loss which the nation and the Society had sus- tained by the death of H.R.H. the Duke of Cam- bridge, and proposed the following resolution, which was seconded by the Treasurer, and carried unani- mously: ‘That in consequence of the lamented death of H.R.H. George, Duke of Cambridge, a Royal Fellow of this Society, the meeting this evening be restricted to the formal business of the Society.”—At the conclusion of the formal business the meeting was adjourned, BRITISH ARCH ZOLOGICAL ASSOCIATION.— March 16.—Dr. W. de Gray Birch, Treasurer, in the chair.— The Rev. H. J. Dukinfield Astley exhibited a photo- graph of a Neolithic fireplace, discovered in 1903, at Shawalton, N.B., by Mr. T. Downes. Numerous arrowheads, spearheads, and celts were included in the find. The fireplace, perfect when discovered, was in the shape of a basin, and filled with burnt wood and bones. This discovery is the more in- teresting from being in the neighbourhood made famous by the much-debated finds of Messrs. Bruce and Donnelly at Dumbuck and Dunbuie. — Mr. Astley also exhibited a large photograph of the six coffins (¢ach containing an almost perfect skeleton) discovered during the recent excavations on the site of the great abbey church at Bury St. Edmunds. One of the skeletons has been identified as that of Abbot Samson, who died in 1211, and has been immortalized by Carlyle in his commentary on the Chronicle of Brakelond in ‘ Past and Present.’ Some photographs of the ancient Saxon church at Bradford-on-Avon were also exhibited by Mr. Astley, one being of the exterior as it now appears after the removal of all the surrounding cottages. Canon Jones, who first brought it to light, identified it with the ecclesiola mentioned by William of Malmes- bury as having been built by Aldhelm, first Bishop of Sherborne, at the close of the eighth century, but recent study of the architectural details, as exhibited by the pilaster strips and the porticus on the north side, has shown that it is later than the time of Aldhelm, probably about 975. A photo- graph of the interior showed the east wall of the nave with the little chancel arch, hardly larger than a doorway, and considered to be the smallest in England. A view of the Bridge Chapel was also given. It is hoped that a visit to Bradford- on-Avon will be included in the programme of the Congress at Bath in August.—A paper was read by Mr. Andrew Oliver dealing with the ancient appearance of Whitehall and the Thames, and the history of the numerous stately buildings which once lined the ancient thoroughfare of the Strand. The paper was profusely illustrated by old evgrav- ings, maps (including Ralph Aggas’s and that of Hoefnage), 1560), and plans and views of Whitehall at various dates. These comprised Inigo Joues’s design for rebuilding the Royal Palace, of which the _— Banqueting House (now the United Service useum) was the only part carried out.— Mr. Patrick read a paper by Mr. C. Lynam upon the remarkable Saxon doorway in the west of the north wall of the ancient church at Laughton- en-le-Morthen, Yorkshire, which was visited by the Association during the Congress last year. ~ The paper was illustrated by sketches made on the spot and by geometrical drawings to scale.—A discussion followed, in which Mr. I. C. Gould, Mr. Astley, Mr, Compton, Mr. Patrick, and others took part. RoyaAt NuMISMATIC.— March 17.— Sir H, H Howorth, V.P., in the chair.—It was announced that letters patent under the Great Seal had been issued, granting a charter of incorporation to the Society under the title of the Royal Numismatic Society, by which title the Society will henceforth be known: and also that His Majesty the King had consenteq to be the Patron of the Society.—Mr. J. H, Fitz. henry exhibited a specimen in bronze of the gold medal by the artist Jacques Gauvain, which was presented to Queen Eleanore, wife of Francis I. of France, and to Antoine Duprat, Cardinal Legate and Chancellor, on the occasion of their visit to Lyons in May, 1533. The original medals in gold are lost, and there only remain two replicas in bronze.—Sir Augustus Prevost showed a medal of Louis XIV., struck in 1672, and commemorating his visit to Utrecht, on which occasion the church of St. Martin, the cathedral of that city, was handed over to the Roman Catholics. The medal is the work of Giovanni Hamerani, by whom it wag executed under the order of Pope Clement X.—Sir Augustus Prevost also exhibited a medal com. memorating the “Escalade” of Geneva, Decem- ber 12th, 1602. On one face is seen a soldier of Geneva hurling down a Savoyard from the battle. ments, and on the other the arms of Geneva,-—Mr, F. A. Walters showed two York half-crowns of the heavy and light coinages of Henry VI.; and Mr. T, Bliss two dies made by Becker, the forger, for striking false Hungarian coins, These dies were prepared by Becker when staying at Buda-Pesth.— Dr. Julius Cahn communicated a paper on some German Renaissance medals in the British Museum, amongst which he recognized some unpublished works of the German medalists Friedrich Hagenauer, a native of Strasburg ; of Peter Flotner, of Nuremberg; of Hans Reimer, of Munich; of Valentin Maler, also of Nuremberg ; and others. All the medals described by Dr, Cahn are portrait medals, ZOOLOGICAL.— March 15.— Dr. H. Woodward, V.P., in the chair.—The Secretary read a report on the additions to the menagerie during February, and called special attention to two male Asiatic wapiti, presented by the President on February 23rd, and to a male kiang (Hqguus hemionus) obtained by purchase on February 26th.—Mr. Frank Slade exhibited and make remarks upon a living bantam hen which had on each of her wings a well- developed thumb and claw.—Dr. C. J. Forsyth Major exhibited and made remarks upon some dental peculiarities in a rodent of the genus Hystrix, a springbok antelope, and a Tertiary shrew.—Mr, G. A. Boulenger exhibited and made remarks upon an anterior paddle of a new species of ichthyosaur from the Lias (?) of Somersetshire.—Mr. A. E. Pratt exhibited a series of skins of paradise-birds which he had recently collected in the Owen Stanley range, British New Guinea; also a series of photo- graphs taken by his son during a two years’ resi- dence amongst the natives near the frontier of German New Guinea.—Mr. R. Lydekker read a paper on the skull and markings of the quagga, in which he drew attention to vestiges of the face- gland of Hipparion in the skull, and expressed his belief that certain alleged differences in the colour and markings of various specimens of the quagga were due to feeding or to the manner in which such markings came out in photographs.—Mr. Lydekker also read a paper on the wild ass of Mongolia, of which an example is in possession of the President at Woburn Abbey, and stated his opinion that it was the true Lguus hemionus of Pallas, and distinct from the ass of Tibet and Ladak. ‘Lhe latter he roposed should bear the name Hguus hemionus iang.—Mr. R. I. Pocock described a new series of spot-nosed monkey, of the genus Cercopithecus, from Benin.—Mr. I. E. Beddard read the first of a series of papers entitled ‘Contributions to the Avatomy of the Lacertilia.’ It dealt with the venous' system of Jguana tuberculata, Tiliqua scincoidcs, and Varanus griseus.—Mr. P. I. Lathy contributed; a paper dealing with a collection of butterflies from Dominica, West Indies, of which three were described as new and thirteen had hitherto not been recorded from the island. ENTOMOLOGICAL.— March 2.—Prof. E. B. Poul4 ton, President, in the chair.—Mr. L. C. H. Young was elected a Fellow.—Cotamander J. J. Walker exhibited Hecatesia fenestrata, Bdv., an interesting Australian moth, the male possessed of a very marked power of stridulation (stridulating organ on longi- they air be would humic air is: patter thenr in wh descri cloud. Soc Bloun course Electr furnac large | 'of car furnac certait Moisss Mar paper was re Emmo Sir Hs Sir He
Page 23
trait ward, rt on ruary, siatic ruary onus) ‘rank living well- rsyth some ‘strix, — Mr, upon ovaur Pratt which anley yhoto- ' resi- er of pad 2& za, in face- d his olour uagga 1 such ekker lia, of ident hat it stinct er he LiOnUS ies of 1ecus, | of a 9 the enous | ides, buted from were > not ‘alker esting arked longi-+ Poul ou ae on ‘ Cotton-Growing N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 THE ATHENZUM 407 tudinal transparent bar on fore-wing), known in New South Wales as the “ whistling moth”; Dodonidia helmsi, Butler, a@ rare Satyrid butterfly from New Zealaud ; and a gigantic species of the Thysanurid genus Japyx, found at Picton, New Zealand.—-Mr. G. C. Champion exhibited specimens of the two species of Dorcadion found during his recent journey in Spain: D. almarzense, Esc. ?, from the summit of Montcayo, and D. neilense, Esc., from the Sierra de Logrofio. He also exhibited numerous examples of Pyropsyche moncaunella, Chapm., found by Dr. Chapman and himself on Montcayo.— Mr. A. J. Chitty, Mr. Jennings, and other Fellows exhibited specimens of the genus Tropiphorus to determine if possible whether 7’. tomentosus and 7. obtusus were in reality one and the same species. —The President exhibited a specimen of a beetle, Glenea pulchella, Thoms. (one of three individuals of the species taken in the Nilgiris by Mr. Leslie Andrewes), which clearly mimics a large ichneumon fly, at present not identified —Mr. L. B. Prout exhi- bited, on behalf of Mr. A. Bacot, long bred series of Triphena comes, Hb., the result of breeding for two generations from a wild female of the curtisii form, taken near Forres. Inthe first generation rather more than half the te age followed, to a certain extent, the parent female, though varying from rich deep red to almost black. Pairings of these dark specimens resulted in a brood in which the percentage of ab. curtisit was slightly increased, although the type forms were still well represented ; but it was notice- able that in every specimen the orbicular stigma was filled up with the darker or melanic colour.— Dr. F. A. Dixey read a note on the so-called “Bugong”’ moth, which is much appreciated as food by some of the Australian natives. He said it was not a Euplcea at all, as supposed by Mr. Kirby in his ‘ Bridgewater Treatise,’ but a Euxoa, and not a butterfly, as also stated by the late Prof. West- wood.—Mr, A. M. Lea communicated ‘Notes on Australian and Tasmanian Cryptocephalides, with Descriptions of New Species.’—Mr. Gilbert J. Arrow communicated ‘ A Revision of the Subfamily Pelid- notinz of the Coleopterous Family Rutelide, with Descriptions of New Genera and Species,’ by the late Frederick Bates.—Col. C. Swinhoe read a paper ‘On some New Species of Eastern Australian and African Moths in the British Museum.’—Mr. G. C. Champion read a paper on ‘An Entomological Excursion to Montcayo, Spain, with some Remarks on the Habits of Xyleborus dispar., Fabr., by Dr. Thomas Algernon Chapman.’—Mr. Kenneth J. Morton communicated ‘Further Notes on Hydro- ptilide belonging to the European Fauoa, with Descriptions of New Species.’—Mr. R. W. C. Shel- ford communicated ‘ A Note on H/ymnias borniensis, Wallace.’"—A discussion followed on ‘What is a Species ?’ METEOROLOGICAL.— March 16.—Capt. D. Wilson- Barker, President, in the chair.—Mr. R, H. Curtis delivered a lecture on ‘Water-Vapour,’ which he illustrated by experiments and lantern-slides. After explaining that water-vapour is water in the state of a gas, he proceeded to speak of the processes of evaporation and condensation, and showed that the capacity of the air for moisture varies according to the temperature, The amount of vapour in the air has a great deal to do with our personal comfort. A dry cold air is not so unpleasant and does not feel so cold asa damp air, although the temperature of the damp air, as shown by the thermometer, may be higher than that of the drier one. But our sensa- tions are often at variance with the thermometer, and this generally so because of the way in which they are affected by the vapour of the air. If the air be dry a degree of heat can be enjoyed which would be simply unendurable if it occurred with a humid atmosphere. The amount of vapour in the air is ascertained by means of a hygrometer, various patterns of which were shown by the lecturer. He then referred to some phenomena of the atmosphere in which water-vapour plays a leading part, and described the formation of dew, hoarfrost, fog cloud, halos, rain, snow, and hail. a. Society OF ARTS. — March 21.—Mr. Bertram | Blount delivered the concluding lecture of his course of Cantor Lectures on ‘Recent Ad i Electro-Chemistry.’ The subject was pgp furnace, and practical illustrations were given ona large scale in the lecture-room of the preparation of carbide of calcium and carborundum in separate ont ag — 4 the reduction of chromium and certain other metallic com ee ae pounds by means of the March 22.—Sir Edward Grey in the chair.—A I in the Briti ire’ was read before the Colonial Section ena "Alfred Emmott,—A very full discus-ion followed, in which Sir Harry Johnston, the Hon. W. Pell, Lord Reay, Sir Horace Tozer, Sir George Birdwood, Sir M. M took part. March 23.—Lord Belhaven and Stenton in the chair.—A paper on ‘The Rural Housing Question’ was read by Mr. T. Brice Phillips,—A discussion followed. HISTORICAL.—March 17.—Dr. G. W. Prothero, President, in the chair.—The following were elected Fellows: Sir G. O. Trevelyan, Mr. G. W. Forrest, Dr. Norman Moore, and Mr. Herbert W. Paul.—A paper by Mr. A. Denton Cheney on ‘The Holy Nuo of Kent’ was read.—A discussion followed, in which Mr. Frederic Harrison, Mr, Leadam, Dr, James Gairdner, and Mr. Hovenden took part. PHysicAL.—March 11.—Dr. R. T. Glazebrook, President, in the chair.—A paper on ‘The Whirling and Transverse Vibrations of Shafts’ was read by Dr. Chree.—A paper entitled ‘ Notes on Non-homo- centric Pencils, and the Shadows produced by Them: Part I]. Shadows produced by Axially Symmetrical Pencils possessing Spherical Aberration,’ was read by Mr. W. Bennett.—Messrs. W. G. Pye & Co., of Cambridge, exhibited a large quantity of apparatus manufactured at their works. MEETINGS NEXT WEEK. . Institute of Actuaries, 5.—‘The Valuation of Whole-Life In- dustrial Assurances, with Allowance for Lapses,’ Messrs, T. G. Ackland and J. Bacon. Surveyors’ Institution, 7.—Junior Meeting. Institution of Civil Engineers, 8.—‘ Lowering the Sill of the Kamsden Dock, Barrow-in-Furness,’ Mr. L. H. Savile; ‘ Burntisland Harbour: Construction of the East Dock,’ Mr. R. Henderson. Tvss. Science Gossip, Last Monday, at a meeting of the Society for Psychical Research, Dr. Albert Wilson read an interesting paper with new views and deduc- tions on ‘ Multiple Personality.’ Tue fifth volume of the ‘ Annales de l’Obser- vatoire Astronomique, Magnétique et Météoro- logique de Toulouse,’ recently published by M. B. Baillaud, the director, contains a résumé of the climatic observations from 1863 to 1900, in continuation of that by M. F. Petit, the first director of the present observatory, which appeared in the first of those years. The previous observatory at Toulouse was founded by Darquier, the pro- prietor, who died in 1802. The present was established by the Municipal Council in 1839, and reorganized in 1873, under the superin- tendence of the late M. Tisserand, afterwards director of the Paris Observatory. From the month of May, 1881, the meteorological obser- vations have been made every third hour from six o’clock in the morning until midnight ; but the extended hours have not been used in the volume before us, in order to render the study of the climate of Toulouse homogeneous with that contained in the earlier publication of M, Petit, who describes himself as ‘‘obligé de suffire lui-méme 4 tous les détails.” We had occasion recently, in speaking of the death of M. Perrotin, to refer to the astronomical obser- vations obtained in late years at Toulouse. But the present volume is wholly occupied with those relating to meteorology. WE have received the second number of vol. xxxiii. of the Memorie della Societa degli Spettroscopisti Italiani, containing another paper by Dr. Bemporad on atmospheric extinction, a note by Prof, Riccd on the solar spots and their connexion with terrestrial magnetism, and a second letter from Prof. Hale respecting details on the suggested co - operation in solar spectroscopy. SEVERAL portions have appeared lately of the Algiers section of the photographic chart of the heavens, with an introduction by M. Trépied, the director. This great work is now approach- ing completion. Bhownaggree, Sir White Ridley, and the Chairman FINE ARTS —+— Pewter Plate: an Historical and Descriptive Handbook, By H.J.L. J. Massé. (Bell & Sons.) A REMARKABLE interest in old pewter has recently been shown both in this country and America. In the last two or three years its price has risen fully a hun- dred per cent. One consequence of this interest is a considerable production of modern “ art pewter”’ so called. Mr. Massé’s book, which is certain to be appreciated as it deserves by connoisseurs, does good service in strongly reprobating both the material and design of much of this modern stuff, which chiefly reaches England from Germany. The alloy used is too hard and brittle for genuine pewter, and feebly hankers after the appearance of silver :— ‘* The designs for the most part are such that no self-respecting pewterer and no real silver- smith of bygone days would have demeaned himself to work. The motif of most of this trumpery is the treatment of animal and vegetable life in such a way that all their naturally beautiful curves are reduced into a common denominator of meaningless squirms.” Such ware as this is hard and repulsive to the touch, and differs in every respect from genuine pewter. Though Mr. Massé avowedly writes as an enthusiast, there is much truth in his contention as to the attractions of well-kept true pewter. It has a quiet decorative effect, particularly when it stands out against a background of panelled oak :— ‘*Perhaps the greatest charm in pewter is the colour. Compare the effect of a dresser full of pewter—dishes as a background, tankards, mugs, beakers, and flagons in the front—with a similar array of silver or silver parcel-gilt, and the sesthetic sense of colour will be more satis- fied with the gris de perle of the pewter than with the whiter colour of the silver. Silver will always look a little harder than the humbler pewter. Gilt plate somehow or other generally suggests brass, and there is an element of dis- traction in its frequently ornate richness.” The author, however, realizes that pewter cannot again take a regular place in the daily service of our own days such as it at one time occupied. Britannia metal and cheap enamelled ironware have made that an impossibility; but there is no reason whatever why there should not be an artistic revival ; in fact, there are clear signs that such a revival has set in, and is being to some extent already met by the one old- established firm of pewterers that has never died out. All such vessels should be made with the idea of being used for the purpose intended, if desired, and not as mere decorative pieces. Otherwise simplicity of design is sure to be lost amid that over- elaboration of ornament which degrades pewter more than any other metal. Lovers of pewter will well remember Mr. Welch’s two volumes giving the history of the Pewterers’ Company, published in 1902. This volume forms a most useful and attrac- tive supplement to that work, and is remarkably well illustrated. With such a wealth of illustrations before us, it is perhaps scarcely fair to grumble at omis- sions, but we miss certain fine and interest- ing forms of old foreign pewter, such as some of those shown by Mr. Cahn in the
Page 24
408 THE ATHENAUM N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 exhibition at Clifford’s Inn. It is some- what curious that Mr. Cahn’s remarkable collection is nowhere named in this volume. Among the more excellent of the simple but effective designs shown in these pages are two English candlesticks (p. 69), a Flemish almsdish (p. 127) from Mr. Massé’s own collection, and a wall candle-box (p. 140) belonging to Mr. Frampton, R.A. The volume is comprehensive in scope, for it deals with the history and composition of pewter, with the method of manufacture, with its domestic and ecclesiastical use, with its ornamentation, with pewter marks English and foreign, and with the articles exhibited in various museums. The bibliography of the subject in the appendix has been drawn up with some carelessness. There are notable omissions and several slips, such as R. G. Hope for R. C. Hope, the writer on the church late of Rutland, or the turning of the late . J. E. Nightingale, the author of church plate of Dorset and of Wilts, into a clergy- man. These things are, perhaps, scarcely worth mention; but if this list in the first genuine book on pewter was worth making at all, a little more trouble should have been taken to make it complete. References are lacking to the following works on church plate, all of which contain accounts of pewter plate: Scott Robertson’s ‘Kent Plate’; Freshfield’s ‘ Plate of the City,’ ‘ London,’ ‘Middlesex,’ and ‘Essex’ (first part); Hasle- wood’s ‘Suffolk Plate’ (1897); Halliday’s ‘Landaff Diocese Plate’ (1901); and the recent fine volume on Hereford plate. Mr. Halliday mentions, among the fifty or sixty cases in that small diocese where old pewter remains, a flagon at Trelleck dated 1620, and one at Llansoy, 1694. Mr. Hasle- wood also showed that there is a consider- able amount remaining in Suffolk, includ- ing a 1671 flagon at Linstead Parva, and early examples at Trimley St. Mary and elsewhere; in the deanery of Hadleigh, which comprises but eighteen parishes, there are no fewer than five pewter flagons and three ‘‘ decent basons.’”’ Pewter com- munion vessels, through poverty, are still in use in two parishes of the Llandaff diocese. What Mr. Massé means in his biblio- graphy by ‘‘Morley, ‘Church Plate of Leicestershire,’ ’’ wecannottell ; Mr. Trollope wrote on the plate of that county, and is duly entered ; we cannot identify any Leicester- shire writer of the name of Morley, and Mr. Trollope did his work exhaustively. We suppose Mr. Redman’s unpretentious but useful little book on pewter and pewter marks was issued too recently to find the place that it deserves in this bibliography. It would be easy to extend and improve the quotations from old inventories, and particu- larly from account rolls, as to the form, price, date, and material of old English pewter. In this respect the book is somewhat meagre, and there is not sufficient information as to the different terms for pewter in early use. The two sorts of pewter chiefly in use in old days were the fine and the ordinary, the former an alloy of tin and copper, and the latter of tin and lead. In monastic and manorial accounts it is somewhat difficult occasionally to recognize what was genuine pewter and what was latten or metal wherein copper predominated. The earlier rolls for the most part use the actual word “pewter” in various more or less clumsily Latinized forms ; but at a later date it was usually termed ¢lectrum, though that word was also undoubtedly used for other mixtures of metal. The Durham Account Rolls—not cited by Mr. Massé—are full of interest with regard to pewter and its price. In 1376 mention is made of a ‘‘dozen de peudervessell,” whilst in 1415-6 it is termed ‘‘ peudre.” A reference to certain vessels ‘‘ de stanno” in 1471 almost certainly implies pewter. In 1468 the monks bought 1} garnish of pewter (vasor’ electr’) for 22s, 3d., ready for the feast of St. Cuthbert. ‘‘Garnish” was the term for a dozen each of dishes, platters, and saucers. In 1507-8 1} garnish were bought for 26s. for the Whitsuntide feast, weighing 75 lb., at 4d. a pound; for St. Cuthbert’s September feast in the same year another garnish cost 14s., weighing 42lb. at 4d. The same year the pewterer of Richmond was paid at Christmas 14s. for half a garnish—we suppose of unusually large size, for it also weighed 42 1b.—whilst two more garnishes for St. Cuthbert’s March feast weighed 90 1b. and cost 30s. In 1511- 1512, 13 square plates, 18 round ones, 13 salts, and 2 chargers of pewter (e/ectrinis) cost 25s. 7d.—namely, 43 1b. at 4d. and 271b. at 5d. An inventory of the greatkitchentaken in 1480-1 enumerates 51 square plates, 36 round ones, 38 salts, and 9 chargers. This shows that pewter plates, or platters, were in use among the more dignified of the monks or their guests. For ordinary use wooden trenchers were employed; the Durham kitchen at this date contained 260 square and 218 round plates of this material. Mr. Massé’s book tells us far more than any other work in English as to the art and history of the pewterer’s craft. We hope that the first edition will be speedily exhausted, for future issues will doubtless be improved, as was the case with the work of the late Mr. Cripps on old English plate. ENGLISH RENAISSANCE ARCHITECTURE, Early Renaissance Architecture in England. By J. Alfred Gotch, F.S.A. (Batsford.)—This handbook covers much the same period as Mr. Gotch’s larger work on the ‘ Architecture of the Renaissance in England,’ but with the addition of the first half of the sixteenth century. The earlier work, however, was almost entirely con- fined to the illustration and description of a series of examples, and contained only a brief historical introduction, In the present work Mr. Gotch gives ‘‘a historical and descriptive account of the Tudor, Elizabethan, and Jacobean periods, 1500-1625,” and endeavours ‘‘ to trace in a systematic manner the development of style from the close of the Gothic period down to the advent of Inigo Jones.” The book is excellently illustrated with plans and other geometrical drawings, photographs, and sketches of details, to the number of over 300 in all. Mr. Gotch is an acknowledged master of his subject, and he writes pleasantly and clearly, without being too technical for the general reader. In his first two chapters he relates the history of the invasion of the foreign style, which manifested itself chiefly in ornamental details and in minor structures such as tombs and screens, but did not greatly influence the general design, which still followed the English tradition. The ornament was usually inspired by Italian models—sometimes filtered through French sources—and was frequently the work of Italian artists. In much of this earlier work the Italian and English influences are so curiously mixed) as to give the impression that it was executed by Englishmen with Italian proclivities, rather than by Italians under English orders. After the death of Henry VIII. details of pronounced Italian or French character tend to disappear, and are replaced by ornament inspired from Dutch or German sources. Both are ‘‘ strongly infused with English feeling,” but, says Mr, Gotch, “whereas the earlier phase ended abruptly, no merging of it into the latter being traceable, the second phase can be followed step by step into the pronounced Italian of Inigo Jones’s mature manner, neti The style of Burghley House glidesimperceptibly into that of the Banqueting Hall at Whitehall.” It is, of course, true that this second phase becomes marked by a striving after symmetry and unity of design which does, to a certain extent, lead up to the style of the later Renaissance, but it appears to us that the work of Inigo Jones was much more of an archi- tectural revolution than the mere substitution of Dutch or German influence for Italian in the ornament of the middle of the sixteenth century. After these first two chapters, Mr. Gotch abandons the chronological treatment of his subject for an analysis of the architecture of the next three-quarters of a century. Although the eight chapters devoted to this analysis tell us much of the history of the architectural movement of the time, we are inclined to think that the book would have gained in value if Mr. Gotch had continued his general historical sketch to the end of his period. So far, however, as house-plan is concerned, the third chapter contains an excellent account of its development, illustrated by the plans of some thirteen houses drawn to a uniform scale. Mr. Gotch shows that the plans of houses followed the old lines long after the superficial decoration had taken on itself the foreign fashion. The essential idea of the English house-plan—the hall in the centre, with the kitchen at one end and the parlour at the other—continues to govern the more or less elaborate plans of the houses of Elizabeth’s time. The builders of these houses aimed not so much at comfort and economy as at magnificence and display, and they endea- voured to obtain these qualities by symmetry of the larger features. Mr. Gotch traces the gradual development of the idea of symmetry in plans of different types, the courtyard plan, the H plan, the E plan, and plans with small central courts. The number of the family apartments is increased, and as a consequence the hall loses its character as the centre of family life, and ultimately becomes merely an entrance, Three chapters are devoted to the design of exterior features, beginning with the general lay-out, and three more to that of interior fea- tures, These latter are prefaced by some valu- able remarks on the effect of royal progresses and large retinues on the plans of the larger Elizabethan and Jacobean houses. Chimney- pieces, plaster ceilings, and staircases are among the subjects which Mr. Gotch treats in a very interesting manner, and illustrates with many well-chosen examples. Another chapter deals with street-houses, schools, market-houses, tombs, &c. Attention is rightly directed to the smaller buildings, for such simple works as the Swan Inn at Lechlade the almshouses and market-house at Chipping Campden, and the school at Burton Latimer possess a charm which we fail to find in many of the more preten- tiously designed mansions of the time. In his chapter on the collection of drawings in the Soane Museum known as John Thorpe’s, Mr. Gotch does not pursue the controversy to which these drawings have given rise, though he believes that by far the larger number of them, if not all, were executed by John Thorpe, father or son. Accepting them as surveys of existing buildings, as designs for new ones, or as exercises in planning, drawn during the closing years of the sixteenth or opening years of the ae ee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee ae ee ee ee a aS a a a he mL ee) a eS a a ae ee a ae a | SS a ee
Page 25
all Is YIIM N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 THE ATHENZUM 409 seventeenth century, Mr. Gotch analyzes them as showing the ideas of the time as to what such houses were or ought to be. The draughtsman had evidently studied Italian, French, and Dutch books on architecture ; French influence can be traced in some of the plans, though it was not strong, so far as we know, in the works which were actually carried out. Dutch in- fluence is very marked in the ‘‘ uprights” or elevations, especially in the strap-work gables, which fortunately do not appear in the same proportion in actual buildings which have sur- vived. In the concluding chapter, which deals with the architectural designers of the sixteenth century, Mr. Gotch shows that the architect, in the modern sense, did not exist ; the buildings were either designed entirely by the workmen in each trade, acting on the general instruc- tions of the proprietor, or a sketch made by a surveyor, the workmen devising the details for themselves. Mr. Gotch may be congratu- Jated on a work which cannot fail to be of great interest and value to the student of the archi- tecture of this fascinating period. A Short History of Renaissance Architecture in England, 1500-1800. By Reginald Blomfield. (Bell & Sons.)—This is an abridged edition of Mr. Blomfield’s work in two volumes, which we reviewed at the time of its publication in 1897. That part of the fourth chapter of the larger book which deals with the architectural treatises of the sixteenth century is omitted, and the chapter on the architectural literature of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries is entirely omitted. With these exceptions, the short his- tory follows the original text with only slight abridgment. The illustrations are only half as numerous, and are necessarily smaller in scale. Mr. Blomfield’s book is one of the most scholarly works which have been written on the history of English architecture, and we welcome its appearance in a shorter form, which should bring it within the reach of all students. Clearly he who desires to obtain ‘‘a clear grasp of the historical development of the movement,” which is reasserting its influence on present-day architecture, cannot do better than study this history. Where so much is excellent, it would be ungracious to emphasize small errors, but Mr. Blomfield’s reference to the Chapter-house of Ely, when he means the Lady Chapel, should be corrected in a new edition. MESSRS. SHEPHERD'S GALLERY. Messrs. SHEPHERD’s collections are always interesting to the student of English painting. Nowhere else are so many of the forgotten or scarcely remembered artists of a century ago to be found. From this point of view, the value of the exhibition is greatly enhanced by the care taken in the matter of attributions. Owing to this, many minor but by no means despicable artists come by their own instead of yielding up their works, as is so often the case, to more celebrated names. Probably to most people the name of Mark Anthony conveys no ideas connected with landscape painting, and yet the picture by him in this show, The Village Church (No. 110), proves him to have had a talent which deserved recognition. Indeed, there is something pathetic in the thought that such an artist should have been so completely overlooked, while landscape painters like Mr. Vicat Cole, Mr. Leader, and Mr. MacWhirter were hailed with enthusiasm. For here is a land- scape of a kind that might well have been popular, The sentiment is fairly obvious—of akind, indeed, that has inspired a great deal of modern land- scape: a saffron evening sky, silhouetted trees, and an old church tower ; all that seems against it is that the obvious sentiment is finely expressed with a certain scholarly reserve and with a real appreciation of the correct usages of .paint. Mark Anthony had clearly learnt much from Corot and the French Romanticists, but this paint has a firmness and his touch a crisp- ness which betray his descent from the old English tradition, from Crome and Constable. Here, at least, is one master who will claim some posthumous glory whenever we begin a careful estimate of what English art has pro- duced, A less individual artist, whose works we have seen passing under Wilson’s name, is Rathbone, by whom there is here a typical landscape (84). The composition, the drawing, and the liquid brush stroke are all as near as may be to Wilson, but Rathbone betrays himself by a certain commonness of colour, a liking for coppery hues and violets, which seem a foretaste of the colouring of Barret and his contemporaries. George Vincent, whose works sometimes pass as those of his master Crome, may be seen here in two pieces, one a severe and stately composi- tion, Fish Auction on the Beach (112), entirely in Crome’s manner; the other, a landscape (113), in which he has found his own aggres- sively clever and drawing-masterly style, is much less commendable. The greater masters are also represented at Messrs, Shepherd’s Gallery. There are two Wilsons, both very unusual and instructive. One, the Landscape with Mill (108), would scarcely be taken for his at a first glance. The composition is rather closely filled with incident, and the masses are cut with intricate, almost petty, details of foliage, It shows throughout a close study of Claude, and is, indeed, scarcely more than an imitation of his manner, though already there is something of Wilson’s personal feeling for colour and his more fluent touch. The other landscape, Cader Idris (109), belongs to his later years in Wales, when he felt the beauties of nature with a purity and freshness which were new in English landscape art. We feel here none the less what a strict training in classical composition under- lies this apparently simple vision. Nemi and the pure classical outlines of the Roman hills are implied in this rendering of a little Welsh tarn. Only an artist trained in that school could have seen it so largely, with such a sense of the universal, with so strict an elimination of what is peculiar and accidental. Only a classical landscape painter could have given to the spare and rugged mountain side so deep a serenity, or painted an atmosphere so luminous and suave. And yet it is no mere Italianizing of a Welsh scene; the pearly, colourless sky, the pale dead greys of the distance, and the delicious cool browns of the hillside are new notes in landscape, notes that Claude and Salvator Rosa never struck. It shows as few pictures do how great, how original, and, in a good sense, how modern a landscape painter Wilson was. Gainsborough, intense as his personality was, never got quite so far from his chosen models in landscape as Wilson. In the large landscape by him at this gallery (86) he is seen pitting himself against Both. His free design and easy vigorous brushwork give to the composition a life and movement which the Dutchman never attained ; but his less methodical technique has prevented him from getting quite so intense a luminosity in the sky, or quite so pervading a glow in the half tones and shadows. Neither of the pictures attributed to Cotman is quite first rate. The coast scene (101) seems to us scarcely worthy of the master, but the Yarmouth Beach (102) is a fine design with heavy masses of dark sails and roofs cutting upon aluminous, grey, cloudy sky. The handling is certainly unusual, more agitated and less deliberate than we asso- ciate with Cotman, but the depth and simplicity of the chiaroscuro make us think the attribu- tion a possible one. Close by this hangs the work of another almost unknown painter whom Mr. Shepherd has been able to identify. On the River Bank (114) is a brilliant plagiarism of Cuyp by James Burnet, an artist who died young, but who shows here the promise of unusual power. Dearman, again, is a minor artist who, if we may judge by the small landscape (120) shown here, deserves to be remembered. He worked in a manner not —_ Nasmyth’s, and not so very far behind im. The miniature Romney—a portrait of his wife (124)—deserves mention for its singularity. It is an early work, sensitive, precise, and with a dainty colouring which almost reminds one of the French art of the period. It is in many respects a great deal better than his more ambitious and dashing pictures. Among the still earlier masters we noticed a good, though not remarkable, Lely of the Harl of Rochester (82), and two Knellers, one of Ernest Augustus, Elector of Hanover, being unusually fine and strongly characterized. The lower gallery is hung with the works of recent artists of the British School. This, however, includes nothing, if we except two really meritorious Sidney Coopers, which calls for serious criticism. But among the older masters there is a great deal which we omit to mention only for want of space. It is, on the whole, a remarkably interesting, well-chosen collection, THE FINE-ART SOCIETY. Ar this Gallery there is on view Mr. Holman Hunt’s recently finished replica of the Light of the World. There is something odd—almost uncanny—about this resurrection of a motive which belongs to a long-forgotten past, a motive, too, which owed its inspiration so directly to the spiritual conditions of the time. The new version bears, indeed, many traces of the division between the time of its conception and of its execution. There is here none of that scrupulous minuteness and precision of tech- nique, none of that passionate investigation of the details of natural form, which inspired Mr. Holman Hunt fifty years ago. The picture shows the more relaxed and facile manner of to-day, and the technique is of that loose and casual kind to which the painting of the last three decades has accustomed us. It is vain, therefore, to look here for any rich luminosity of colour— any of that transparency and glow of which Mr. Holman Hunt once knew the secret. Still, in rehandling his theme Mr. Hunt has not failed to make some decided improvements. The poise of the figure is more definitely ascertained, the lines of the drapery are more thought out, and the figure has gained in sim- plicity and mass. The face, too, has been altered: the expression is nobler, more serene, but also, we think, less intense and less significant. But, in any case, it is no small feat, and one on which the artist deserves con- gratulation, to have succeeded so far in recall- ing the ideas and feelings of his youth, and giving them such adequate expression. SALES. THE collection of engravings formed about the middle of the last century by Mr. J. H. Anderdon, and recently belongiug to the late Mr. A. Ander- don Weston, was dispersed by Messrs. Christie, Manson & Woods on the 15th and 16th inst. The engravings after Reynolds occupied the whole of the 15th, and comprised the following: Mrs. Abington, by Elizabeth Judkins, 96/7. ; Mrs. Bonfoy, by J. McArdell, 73/.; Duchess of Devonshire and Daughter, by G. Keating, 102/.; Lady Gertrude Fitzpatrick as Collina, 527.; Miss Greenway, by J. Watson, 617.; Lady Jane Halliday, by V. Green, 47l.; Mrs. Harding, by T. Watson, 947. ; Hon, Miss Frances Harris, by J. Grozer, 397.; Warren Hastings, by T. Watson, 987. ; Mrs. Williams Hope, by C. Hodges, 40. ; Miss Mary Horneck (The Jessamy Bride), by R. Dankarton, 63/. ; Lady Louisa Manners, by V. Green, 601. ; Miss Meyer as Hebe, by J. Jacobé, 997.; The Ladies Elizabeth and Henrietta Montagu, by H. Meyer, 527.; Miss Theophila Palmer, by J. R. Smith, 54/.; Lady Caroline Price, by J. Jones, 1942. ; Madame Schindierin, by J. R. Smith, 46/7. ; Lavinia, Countess Spencer, by C. Hodges, 52/. On the 16th three other engravings after Reynolds fetched good prices : Lady Taylor, by W. Dickinson, 194/,; The Ladies Amabel and Mary Yorke, by E. Fisher, 37/.; The Strawberry Girl, by T. Watson, 810.
Page 26
410 THE ATHENAUM N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 Mr. Anderdon Weston’s collection also included the following. After Lawrence: Lady Harriet Clive, by S. Cousins, 58/7. After Cotes: Lady Susan O'Brien, by J. Watson, 517. After W. Owen: Miss Elizabeth ura Russell, by H. Meyer, 587. After Read: Maria, Countess of Suffolk, by J. Watson, 524. An Album containing 98 Portraits, chiefly mezzotint, 1300. The sale of the remaining portion of the collection of the late Mr. C. F. Huth on the 19th inst. was noteworthy for the high prices realized by pictures by Reynolds. Gainsborough, and Old Crome, the 1,995/. id for On the Yare, Norwich, above the New Mills, oe the largest sum ever given for a work by the last-named master. On the Yare, Moonlight, also by him, brought !,207/. Revnolds’s Portrait of a Lady (a member of the Ducie family), in green dress and white cloak lined with ermine, produced the highest price of the day—3,255/. The Gainsboroughs were: A Pastoral Landscape, with Figures, 3,045/. ; William Pitt, 2,415/.; Frederick, Duke of York, 2,625/. Constable, An Undershot Mill at Gilling- ham, 178/. Etty, Love's Angling, 252/, J. Holland, A Canal in Venice, 2672. ely, Duchess of Portsmouth, 1207. Morland, The Traveller’s Repast, 346/.; Louisa, 346/.; The Traveller’s Halt, 136/.; A Shepherd Reposing, 2207. R. Wilson, The Destruction of Niobe’s Children, 1057. The drawings belonging to Mr. Huth included: Gainsborough, Duchess of Devonshire, 525/. ; Head of a Lady, 105/.; A Woody Landscape, with a peasant, and two cows in a pool, 577. J. Holland, Venice, 1107. ; Genoa, 632. Prout, Buildings on a Canal, Venice, 50/. F. de Wint, Stacking Hay, 86/7. P. de Wint, An Extensive Landscape, with sheep, 50/. The pictures from other collections sold on the same afternoon included Gainsborough, Mrs. Richards, 12002. Early English, Two Young Girls (daughters of Lady Boynton), in white dresses and straw hats with blue ribbons, 2207.; Mary Boynton, wife of Sir David Boynton, 162/. Portrait of a Lady, in dark dress, with black hat and feathers, 1057. P. Mercier, Catherine Goddard, wife of Henry D'Arcy, 1651, Sir W. Beechey, Portrait of a Lady, in white dress with lace, 1997. A. Cuyp, A Shepherd, with ewes, lambs, and cow, 147/. A. Ostade, The Itine- rant Musician, 756/. G. Vincent, A Road Scene, with cottage and figures, 120/, Zoffany, Scene from the Opera ‘The Decoy,’ 1057. J. Wynants, A Woody Landscape, with figures on a road, 220/. Rembrandt, Portrait of a Gentleman, in dark dress, with red vel- vet cap, 1687. A. Canaletto, The Courtyard of the Doge’s Palace, Venice, 105/. J. Downman’s drawing of the Duchess of Devonshire fetched 199/., and J. Russell's pastel of Anna Taylor 54, Fine-Art Gossip, Mr. H. Forses Wiruersy is holding at the Modern Gallery, 175, Bond Street, an exhibi- tion of landscapes in oil and water colour, ‘ At Home and Abroad.’ The private view takes place to-day. THE receiving day for pictures intended for the forthcoming exhibition of the New English Art Club at the Dudley Gallery, Piccadilly, is fixed for Tuesday, April 5th. The names of the jury are as follows: Francis Bate, P. W. Steer, Prof. Brown, Henry Tonks, W. Rothen- stein, W. Orpen, A. E. John, D. S. MacColl, D. Muirhead, J. L. Henry, A. A.McEvoy, R. E. Fry, and A. W. Rich. It will be necessary for non-members of the Club to procure the written invitation of two members to submit not more than two works to the jury. Tue Exhibition of the International Society of Sculptors, Painters, and Gravers will close next Tuesday. The next will open in the New Gallery in January, 1905. This has been the most successful of all those held by the Society. Up to Saturday last nearly 21,000 paying admissions had been recorded. The sale of pictures in the Black-and- White Room has also been very good. At the Whitechapel Art Gallery the Dutch Exhibition will open on Wednesday next, and will be on view till May 10th. Tue Oxford Exhibition of Historical Portraits, to which we have already referred, will open on April 12th, at the University Examination Schools, High Street. Mr. Wepmore’s health this winter has inter- fered with his completion of a long-announced book for the collector of Constables, but he has been able to finish an important article on Whistler for the new Nineteenth Century. Last week the following painters were elected to the rank of Associates of the Royal Scottish Academy :—Mr. David Young Cameron, Mr. Robert Brough, and Mr. J. Campbell Mitchell. Mr. Cameron has long been known as a talented member of the so-called ‘‘Glasgow School,” and his name is also familiar as an etcher. Mr. Brough is an Aberdeen man, and, like Sir George Reid, began life as a lithographer with Messrs. Keith & Gibb. He is known chiefly as a portrait painter. Mr. Campbell Mitchell has devoted himself mainly to landscape painting. One of his pictures, ‘A Scottish Moorland,’ exhibited in Munich, was recently purchased by the Bavarian Government for their permanent collection. WE regret to announce the death at Edin- burgh on Friday last week of Mr. D. W. Stevenson, a well-known sculptor. Mr. Stevenson’s work was largely of a popular character. He did ‘Highland Mary’ for Dunoon, the statue of Tannahill for Paisley, two colossal statues of Burns—one for Toronto, the other for Leith— and the figure of Wallace, 12 ft. in height, which stands in a niche of the National Memorial to the Scottish hero on the Abbey Craig. For the Scott Monument he modelled several of the figures, notably Queen Mary and James VI. ; and he also assisted in the sculp- tural decoration of the Scottish National Portrait Gallery. Last Saturday a collection of about eighty old portraits which belonged to the late Mr. J. N. Durrant-Steuart, of Dalguise, was sold in Edinburgh. The collection included a portrait, 38} in. by 47in., by Raeburn, believed to be Miss Stewart, of Ballechin, wife of Mr. Charles Steuart, of Dalguise. This, after a keen com- petition, was sold for 2,887/. 10s. to Messrs. Lawrie & Co. The collection also included numerous specimens of the work of Sir John Watson Gordon, three of whose pictures reached three figures. Mr. Ruvotr Drrcks, the Librarian of the Royal Institute of British Architects, has just written a little hook on Rodin. It is to be included in the ‘*Langham Series of Art Monographs,” now in course of publication by Mr. A. Siegle, under the general editorship of Mr. Selwyn Brinton. Mr. Dircks’s volume will appear almost immediately. Tue death, in his sixty - fourth year, is announced from Monza of the well - known painter Moses Bianchi, Director of the Academy of Fine Arts in Verona. We hear from Florence that, since his appointment as Director of the Florence Galleries, Cavaliere Corrado Ricci has carried out a much-needed rearrangement of many of the masterpieces in the Pitti Collection. The best effects of light have been carefully studied, and some of the pictures changed accordingly. Further space has been obtained by relegating three very large pictures, not of primary import- ance, to the vestibule. While bringing forward some of the finer paintings into better positions, the Director has taken the opportunity to examine anew several works, and in some cases to alter the traditional ascriptions. Tue death is announced of M. Félix Soults, the sculptor, at Gers, where he was born forty- seven years ago. He studied under Jouffroy and Falguiére, and won the second Prix de Rome in 1887. He obtained a Second, First, and Silver Medal respectively at the Salons of 1889, 1892, and 1900. To the last of these exhibitions he sent ‘ Enlévement d’Iphigénie’ and ‘Bacchus & la Chévre,’ which now belong to the State. He was one of the artists employed in the decoration of the Grand Palais. A BAKER’s shovel (pala), such as is still in use for putting bread into the oven, was dis- covered at the bottom of a recently excavated Roman well in the Saalburg. Similar instru. ments are represented on Roman frescoes, but this is the first one that has been found. It is. of beechwood, and is made in one piece. A silver coin of Antoninus Pius, a bronze coin of the Empress Faustina, and a well-preserved leather shoe were among the further contents of the well. A NOTABLE series of twenty lots of drawings, in colour, pen-and-ink, and pencil, by Thackeray, will be sold by Messrs. Sotheby on April 21st, It includes some of his earliest schoolboy efforts, from the collection of the late J. F. Boyes, his schoolfellow and lifelong friend. MUSIC THE WEEK. #ouran Hart —Mlle. Tremelli’s Debut. CrystaL Pavace.—Recital by Lady Hallé and Mr, Plunket Greene. St. James’s Hatu.—Recital by Madame Blanche Marches? and Mr. Denis O'Sullivan. Popular Concert. M. Rivarde’s Violin Recital. Miz. TREMELLI, a niece of the formerly well known operatic vocalist Madame Tre- melli, made a successful first appearance in London at the Molian Hall on the evening of Friday of last week. She had only recently completed a course of study with Madame Marchesi in Paris. Mlle. Tremelli has a voice of unusual range and mezzo- soprano quality. It is flexible and well under control. The new artist was heard in the air ‘ Voce di Donna” from ‘ Gioconda,’ of which she gave an effective rendering, the dramatic features of the music being well represented. Lady Hallé and Mr. Plunket Greene were associated in .a recital at the Crystal Palace last Saturday afternoon. The vio- linist was in excellent form, and her play- ing of Friedrich Wilhelm Rust’s Suite in D minor, which contains five well-wrought and interesting movements, gave complete satisfaction to critical ears. She also in- cluded in her list of pieces the well-known ‘Ballade-Polonaise’ by Vieuxtemps, and the ‘Hush Song’ and ‘Reel’ from Sir Charles Stanford’s ‘Irish Fantasia,’ the dance being given with rare sparkle and animation. Mr. Plunket Greene selected fourteen songs, including examples of Bach, Scarlatti, Schubert, Schumann, Brahms, Stanford, and Parry. Apart from occasional lapses in the matter of intonation, he was heard to advantage, the Schumann and Brahms songs being interpreted with special fervour. At the recital given by Madame Blanche Marchesi and Mr. Denis O’Sullivan at St. James’s Hall last Tuesday afternoon the baritone vocalist introduced Edward German’s six songs from Mr. Rudyard Kip- ling’s ‘Just-So Stories.’ In setting the poems to music the composer displays his gift of melody as well as much quiet and unobtrusive musicianship. He has, perhaps, been most successful in his treatment of ‘The Uninhabited Island,’ wherein he employs Eastern tints with graceful effect, and ‘The First Friend,’ which shows both expression and humour. There is a particularly merry setting of ‘ Rolling Down to Rio,’ but that of ‘Kangaroo and Dingo’ is not convincing. All the songs were interpreted by Mr. O’Sullivan with vocal skill and due appreciation of the requirements of the music. Madame Marchesi sang a group of songs from Scandinavian sources, her renderings of N°? ————— be entitle ‘Love Amon keep 46 Mas Mr. 5 miD Broac the c Satur prove that 1 close The fi Anda that | The Final featu of tl exact maste brevi recité eveni Rich: trans and L furth accor score omiss for it rema ing, | attra chief and Strat work had sion ment on tl at th birth have Char previ and ¢ Thea excel Mile subst comr oper: Reev the | Hart duri Wall duce nine! succes by J Loui Fran 1892 70. Harr Dari was! yest He 1
Page 27
gs, ay, Ist. rts, his N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 THE ATHENZUM 411 a beautiful example by Sigurd Lie, entitled ‘The Snow,’ and of Kjerulf’s ‘Love’s Message’ proving specially attractive. Among the duets selected was ‘‘I prithee keep my sheep,” by Nicholas Laniere, first ‘‘ Master of the Musicke.”’ Mr. Cyril Scott’s Pianoforte Quartet in g minor, which has already been heard at a Broadwood Concert, was performed, with the composer at the pianoforte, at the last Saturday Popular Concert. The work im- proves on acquaintance. It seems a pity that Mr. Scott ‘‘ purposely”? avoided a full close during the course of each movement. The first movement suffers thereby, but the Andante is so well worked up to a climax that the method seems to suit the music. The Allegretto is delightful, but in the Finale there is a falling off. One excellent feature of the Quartet is the brevity of each of the sections. Few composers know exactly when to stop; even the greatest masters forget at times the advantages of brevity. M. Rivarde, who gave his third violin recital at St. James’s Hall on Tuesday evening, professed to play as a novelty Richard Strauss’s Violin Concerto. He transposed the first two movements (Ajlegro and Lento), and omitted the final Rondo; and further he played the music with pianoforte accompaniment, whereas the latter has been scored for orchestra by the composer. The omission of the Finale was no great loss, for it is a kind of Saltarello, not in any way remarkable. The slow movement is pleas- ing, and with orchestra would be still more attractive. The first movement proper is chiefly interesting in so far as it shows, and very clearly, the composers by whom Strauss was influenced when he wrote the work over twenty years ago. If M. Rivarde had the authority of Strauss for the omis- sion of the Finale and reversing of move- ments, it certainly ought to have been stated on the programme. Riusical Gossip, Lovisa Fanny Pyne passed away last Sunday at the ripe age of seventy-six ; the date of her birth—given in dictionaries as 1832—is said to have been 1828. She sang in Macfarren’s ‘ King Charles the Second’ in October, 1849, but had previously appeared as Zerlina in ‘Don Juan’ and as Amina in ‘Sonnambula’ at the Princess’s Theatre, and of her performances there are excellent accounts in the Athenewm. In 1851, Mile. Zerr being indisposed, she appeared as her substitute in ‘The Magic Flute.’ In 1856 a committee was formed for the revival of English opera—Balfe, Beale, Bishop, Chorley, Sims Reeves, and others being members. This was the commencement of the famous Pyne and Harrison company, which lasted for six years, during which period operas by Balfe, Benedict, Wallace, and other British composers were pro- duced. The scheme was not new ; early in the nineteenth century a long, though not finally successful attempt of a similar kind was made by Arnold at the Lyceum Theatre. In 1868 Louisa Pyne retired from the stage, and married Frank Bodda, a baritone vocalist, who died in 1892. In 1896 she received an allowance of 70/1. per annum from the Civil List. ANOTHER prominent member of the Pyne- Harrison company has passed away. Charles Durand, the baritone and actor, whose name } waslong known throughout the kingdom, died yesterday week at the ripe age of seventy-seven. ‘He was excellent both as singer and actor. As manager he will be remembered in connexion with the earliest performances of Gounod’s ‘Faust’ in the provinces, Tue Alma Mater Male Choir gave a concert at Bechstein Hall on the evening of Thursday of last week. Most of the twenty-eight members are either past or present students of the Royal Academy of Music. The voices were of robust quality, and the tone rich and full. A steady and effective performance was given of Saint- Saéns’s ‘Les Soldats de Gédéon,’ written for double chorus. In style the music is somewhat old-fashioned, but it is melodious, and in one of the sections the composer employs the bouche fermée device in skilful manner. Other com- positions well rendered by the choir included Max Bruch’s ‘The Lay of the Norsemen,’ Liszt’s arrangement of Schubert’s ‘Die All- macht,’ and Sullivan’s ‘The Beleaguered.’ Miss Minnie Tracey sang several songs in artistic style, and Miss Dorothy Bridson was successful with her violin solos, THE first of the two extra Broadwood Con- certs on March 10th was of great interest. The Moscow Trio (Messrs. D. Shor, D. Krein, and R. Erlich), who visited London last season, played three pianoforte trios—Mozart in E, Schubert in B flat, and Tschaikowsky in a minor —and by admirable ensemble, refinement, and skill created a most favourable impression. It was indeed a treat to listen to such artistic playing.—The Kneisel Quartet (Messrs. F. Kneisel, J. von Theodorowicz, L. Svecenski, and A. Schroeder), from Boston, appeared at the eleventh concert of the series (March 18th), and performed Beethoven’s E minor Quartet, Op. 59, No, 2, and Dvorik’s Quartet in F, Op. 96. The rendering of these works was exceedingly good as regards tone, technique, and reading of the music. There was, in fact, no fault to find, only we could have wished for a little less restraint. Miss Adela Verne was the pianist. Miss Hitt Rivineton (Mrs. C. J. Holmes) gave a violin recital at the Bechstein Hall on Wednesday evening, her programme including Brahms’s fine Sonata in a, Op. 100, for piano and violin, in which Mr. Herbert Fryer took part. Miss Rivington played Mendelssohn’s Concerto, but was evidently suffering from nervousness, and we therefore hope for another opportunity of judging her merits. Mr. G. Ferrari was the accompanist. PERFORMANCES, under the direction of Mr. Edgardo Lévi, were given by members of the operatic class of the Royal Academy of Music on March 11th and 12th. The programme included ‘Il Piccolo Haydn,’ by A. Cipollini, a short pleasing work in which young Haydn, by supplying a missing aria, enables Porpora to deliver the score of his opera according to con- tract ; alsothe third actof‘ Der Freischiitz.’ These performances reflected credit on both teachers and pupils. The selection of a novelty and of an act from an opera which is rarely heard deserves praise.—This week at the Guildhall School of Music three representations have been given of Auber’s ‘Le Domino Noir,’ one of the French composer’s brightest operas. It was produced in Paris in 1837, and the first performance in English of any note in London was in 1861, with H. F. Chorley’s version, the réle of Angéle being taken by the late Miss Louisa Pyne. The rendering at the Guildhall on Wednesday, the first night, was not sans peur et reproche, and unfortunately Miss Kathleen Dumayne had almost lost her voice ; but the selection of the work, which is now never given in London, deserves all commendation, Mr. Georges Jacobi conducted. THE programme of the pianoforte and vocal recital given by Miss Fanny Davies and Mr. Ffrangcon Davies at St. James’s Hall on March 10th deserves note. It was of quite uncommon character. Miss Davies played some interesting pieces by old Netherlandish masters, and with all skill and earnestness Brahms’s F minor Sonata ; while Mr. Davies was heard in Bach’s cantata ‘Amore Traditore,’ and in some old Welsh melodies. PuRcELL’s music for the funeral of Queen Mary, in 1694, and Chopin’s Funeral March were performed at the funeral service of the late Duke of Cambridge at Westminster Abbey—a striking juxtaposition of old and new. Purcell’s music was recently discovered at Oriel College, Oxford, by Mr. J. W. Taphouse, and published and described by Mr. William Barclay Squire in the Sammelband (January to March, 1903) of the International Musical Society. It consists of a March, which in 1694 was ‘‘sounded ” by trumpets or trombones before the Queen’s chariot, and a Canzona played after the anthem. The March was adapted by Purcell from a pas- sage in the music which he wrote for Shadwell’s ‘Libertine.’ It occurs in the fifth act of that play. The use of the brass, as noticed by Mr. Squire, is a remarkable anticipation of Mozart. THREE extra Symphony Concerts are announced at the Queen’s Hall for April 28th, May 10th, and June 2nd, under the direction of Mr. Henry J. Wood. A CONCERT is to be held on June 11th next in commemoration of the fiftieth anniversary of the opening of the Crystal Palace, and the services of the London contingent of the Handel Festival choir and orchestra have been secured. Miss Agnes Nicholls and Mr. Ben Davies will appear, and engagements with other dis- tinguished artists are pending. THE programme of the first Joachim Concert, on Apri! 23rd, will be devoted to Haydn, Mozart, and Beethoven. PERFORMANCES NEXT WEEE. Sun. Sunday Society Concert, 3.30, Queen's Hall. — Sunday League, 7, Queen's Hail. Mon. Popular Concert, 8, St James's Hall. . Broadwood Concert. 8.30, st. James's Hall. Concert, 3, Queen’s Hall. a Royal Choral Society, 7, Albert Hall _ Grand Sacred Concert, 7 30 Queen's Hall. — Annual Sacred Concert, 7 40, St. James's Hall. = Two Grand Sacred Concerts, 3.30 and 8, Crystal Palace. THE WEEK. Sr. James’s.—‘ Love’s Carnival,’ an English Version, in Five Acts, by Rudolf Bleichmann, of Otto Erich Hart- leben’s Play ‘ Rosenmontag.’ Tsat Mr. Alexander’s second incursion into German drama is less prosperous than the first is attributable to many causes. In details as well as in conception ‘Love’s Car- nival’ is un-English ; its fatal termination, though inevitable, constitutes a serious draw- back with anignorant public, and thespectacle of endless potations is unedifying and in the end depressing. In conception the play is powerful, and the influence it exercised upon a German world to which the problem it presented seems real is easily under- stood. The treatment, however, is inept, the author having sacrificed the dramatic to the theatrical. Conceding, as we are bound, the postulate that the German code of military honour is that exhibited, we can accept the joint suicide of the hero and heroine. That they should, however, spend the hours immediately preceding death in the wild excesses of the Carnival, deprives them of all sympathy, and casts upon the play an air of extreme artificiality. In the case of a piece of this class it was indispensable to keep the German frame- work. The wisdom may be doubted, how- ever, of adhering rigidly to proceedings which to an English public are unmeaning or distasteful. Herr Hartleben seems to have dreamed of assigning the whole a
Page 28
412 THE ATHENZUM N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 species of admixture of the tragic and the rotesque such as characterizes Webster. 8 far as regards an English public he has missed his mark. The chorus in ‘Samson Agonistes’ congratulates the son Manoah upon his immunity from that Desire of wine and all delicious drinks Which many a famous warrior overturns. It is, however, humiliating to listen to the utterances of a lot of silly lads who through five acts are rarely, if ever, sober. Nothing in the work or the performance prophesied a reversal of the unfavourable verdict passed by the first night’s audience, and Mr. Alexander is probably judicious in with- drawing the piece, for which on Tuesday was submitted a revival of ‘Old Heidel- berg.’ Mr. Alexander himself acted in his best style, but his get-up was ineffective, the hair, which he wore long, to indicate presumably the poet and the dreamer, being unbecoming. Miss Lilian Braithwaite as Gertrude, who for some reason is named Else, Mr. E. Lyall Swete as Ferdinand von Grobitzsch, and Mr. Ernest Leicester as Hofmann proved acceptable. The general cast was in no respect noteworthy. Dramatic Gossip, On his return to England, Sir Henry Irving will begin on April 25th a country tour which will last ten weeks. Tue illness of Miss Mabel Terry Lewis, fol- lowing upon other calamities, has compelled Sir Charles Wyndham to substitute temporarily at the New Theatre ‘ Mrs. Gorringe’s Necklace’ for ‘My Lady of Rosedale,’ the run of which will, however, be resumed at Easter. During Holy Week the theatre will remain closed. Tue Orestean trilogy of A®schylus, in the translation of Mr. E. D. A. Morshead, will be given at the close of next month at the Strat- ford-on-Avon festival by the Benson Company. *‘Lirtte Mary’ has been withdrawn from Wyndham’s Theatre after a run which, though considerable, seems less than might have been anticipated. At Easter Mr. Beerbohm Tree will reappear as Zakkuri in ‘The Darling of the Gods.’ The actor must be credited with a knowledge of his own business, but the disappearance from a none success of the protagonist is always a risky experiment. During the week preceding Easter His Majesty’s will be closed. In consequence of the action of the Censor, to which we last week referred, the proposed series of French plays at the Avenue has been indefinitely postponed. THE promised performance by the Mermaid Society at the Court Theatre of Congreve’s * Way of the World’ has been postponed until April 17th, 18th, and 19th. Hatr a dozen afternoon representations of Mr. Bernard Shaw's ‘Candida’ are promised at the Court Theatre. ‘THE next novelty at the St. James’s Theatre will consist of a comedy by Mr. Frederick Man- ville Fenn and Mr. Pryce, the production of which may be anticipated with no long delay. To CoRRESPONDENTS.—M. @.—G. G. S.—J. H.—H. J. B. —received. C. BE. L. W.—Not contemplated at present. I. M. P.—No vaeancy here. No notice can be taken of anonymous communieations. MESSRS. LONGMANS & CO.'S LIST. —_—_— THE HISTORY OF TWENTY-FIVE YEARS (1856-188). By Sir SPENCER WALPOLE, K.C.B,, Author of ‘A History of England from 1815-58.’ Vols. I. and II. (1856-70). S8vo, 24s. net, SCOTSMAN.—“ With this book when completed, and Mr. Morley’s ‘ Gladst *—consulted with discretion—the young politician will be in a better position than he has ever been in before to understand the great men and events of our recent past...... This is the first instalment of a his- torical work of more than ordinary interest and value.” DUCHESS SARAH: Being the Social History of the Times of Sarah Jennings, Duchess of Marlborough. With Glimpses of her Life, and Anecdotes of her Contemporaries in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries, Compiled and Arranged by One of her Descendants, Mrs, ARTHUR COLVILLE. With 10 Photogravure Plates and 2 other I]lustra- tions. 8vo, 18s. net. Mr. St. Jonny Lucas in the WORLD.—“ Mrs. Artbur Colville has given us an interesting picture of an interesting character, and has evidently studied the records of her period with great diligence.” ENGLAND IN THE MEDITERRANEAN. A Study of the Rise and Influence of British Power within the Straits, 1603-1713. By JULIAN 8S. CORBETT, Author of ‘ Drake and the Tudor Navy,’ kc. 2 vols. 8vo, 248, net. SPECTATOR.—‘' We have not space to deal with the many interesting matters in Mr. Corbett’s book, but to all who want a lucid and picturesque account of a vital epoch in our national history we heartily recommend it......We may note as one of the points in which Mr. Corbett seems to us to have made a real contribution to knowledge, the new picture which he has drawn us of Marlborough as a naval strategist.” NEW LAND: Four Years in the Arctic Regions. By OTTO SVERDRUP. Translated from the Norwegian by ETHEL HARRIET HEARN, With Maps and numerous I]lustrations, 2 vols. 8vo, 36s. net. [On Thursday next, VISITATION CHARGES delivered to the CLERGY and CHURCHWARDENS of the DIOCESES of CHESTER and OXFORD. LIAM STUBBS, D.D. Kdited by E. Honorary Canon of Christ Church and Vicar of Sonning, formerly Domestic Chaplain to the Bishop of Oxford. 8vo, 7s. 6d. net. (On Thursday next. The OLD RIDDLE and the NEWEST ANSWER. By JOHN GERARD, S.J. F.L.S. Crown 8vo, 5s. net. [On Thursday next, *.* This is an inquiry as to how far modern science has altered the aspect of the problem of the Universe. The DREAD INFERNO: Notes for Beginners in the Study of Dante. By M. ALICE WXLD. With Frontispieee. Fcap. 8vo, 2s, 6d. net. LONGMANS, GREEN & CO. 39, Paternoster Row, London, E.C. ; New York and Bombay. THE DE LA MORE PRESS. —~—— NEW VOLUMES OF THE KING’S CLASSICS. EIKON BASILIKE ; or, the King’s Book. With Engraved Portrait of Kirg Charles I, Edited by EDWARD ALMACK, F.S.A. This Edition is the first inexpensive one in which the Original Spelling of the First Edition is preserved. 28. 6d. net; quarter-bound vellum, 3s. 6d. net. KINGS’ LETTERS. Letters of the Kings of England, from Alfred to the Coming of the Tudors. Newly Edited from the Ori- ginals by ROBERT STEELE, F.8.A. Witha Portrait of Henry V. as Frontispiece. 2s. 6d, net ; quarter-bound vellum, 3s. 6d. net. “Mr. Steele has done his work very capably.” Saturday Review, BY PROF. SKEAT. CHAUCER FOR MODERN READERS. CHAUCER'S KNIGHT'S TALE; or, Palamon and Arcite. Tone into Modern English by the Rev. Prof. SKEAT, Litt.v, With Frontispiece. 1s. net; quarter-bound vellum, 2s. 6d. net. “ Professor Skeat has accomplished a difficult feat. He has succeeded in modernizing the language without de- parting from either the form or substance of the original.” Scotsman, JUST PUBLISHED. ALL ABOUT SHIPS and SHIPPING. A Popular Handbook of Nautical Information. By FRANCIS MILTOUN. With 6 Coloured Plates and many Illustrations in the Text, specially designed attractive Cover, stamped in Colours, 5s. net. ‘In every way this is one of the most complete little manuals of the sea and the sea services we have seen.” Lloyd’s Weekly. RECENTLY PUBLISHED. STEVENSON’S SHRINE: the Record of a Pilgrimage. By LAURA STUBBS. With many Illustrations and a Map. Part J. Auckland to Tonga. Part II, Vavau to Samoa. Part III. Vailima and the Shrine. Fcap. 4to, handsomely printed on Hand-made Paper, and bound, with Cover Design, in grey boards, 5s. net ; cloth gilt, 7s. 6d. net. ‘*Miss Stubbs has completed a book that will delight thousands of Stevenson devotees.” —St. James’s Gazette. THE KING'S POETS. The Volumes of the Series named “The King's Poets” are uniform in size, type, paper, and bind- ing with those of ‘‘ The King’s Classics,” of whicl: “ The King’s Poets ” is a section. The object of “ The King’s Poets” is to present a series of poetic texts of commanding interest in a literary background which will exhibit the full significance of each Work. THE FIRST VOLUME NOW READY. WORDSWORTH’S PRELUDE. With Introduction, Notes, &c., by W. BASIL WORSFOLD, M.A. The Volume is furnished with a Reproduction of the Portrait of Words- worth by H. W. Pickersgill, R.A., in the National Gallery, and a Map of the Lake District. 33. 6d. net; quarter-bound vellum, 5s. net. THE KING’S SHAKESPEARE. Uniform with “The King’s Classics” in size, plan, and general arrangement. The Plays and Poems in separate Volumes, 1s. 6d, net each. Sold separately. THE FIRST VOLUME NOW READY. The SONNETS. Edited by OC. C. STOPES, with Introduction and Notes, and Portrait of the Earl of Southampton. ALEXANDER MORING, LIMITED, 298, Regent Street, W. last repri ® Cat: C! Witl
Page 29
sd, an, ed he ike B. Z€; nd ch. nd N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 THE ATHENAUM 413 CASSELL & COMPANY’S ANNOUNCEMENTS. NEW FINE-ART WORK, uniform with ‘English Porcelain’ and ‘The Old French Faience.’ READY SHORTLY, price 30s. net. ENGLISH EARTHENWARE AND STONEWARE. By WILLIAM BURTON, Author of ‘ English Porcelain,’ &c. Containing 24 Plates in Colours, and 54 Black-and-White Plates , With numerous Reproductions of the various Marks, __ This | Edition i is limited to 1,4 50 numbered copies. POCKET EDITIONS OF WORKS BY R. L. STEVENSON. NEW VOLUMES NOW READY. THE BLACK ARROW. Cloth, price 2s. net; leather, 3s. net, THE MASTER OF BALLANTRAE. Cloth, price 2s. net; leather, 3s. net, *,* The Pocket Editions of KIDNAPPED and CATRIONA, published last Autumn, achieved an immediate popularity, and have already been | reprinted to meet the large demand. ‘* Messrs. Cassell’s pocket editions of Stevenson’s ‘Kidnapped’ and ‘Catriona’ are delightful, the form being both choice and convenient.” Atheneum, POPULAR EDITION, READY SHORTLY, 3s. 6d. AMERICA AT WORK. By JOHN FOSTER FRASER, With 36 Full-Page Plates from Special Photographs. [Tenth impression. NOW READY, POPULAR EDITION, 3s. 6d. THE NEW FAR EAST. By ARTHUR DIOSY, F.R.G.S., Chairman of the Council of the Japan Society. Illustrated. With upwards of 500 Illustrations from vinnie and acne Drawings, NOW READY, complete in 2 vols. price 21s. CASSELL’S ILLUSTRATED HISTORY OF THE BOER WAR. NOW READY, price 5s, THE “DEATH OR GLORY BOYS.” The Story of the 17th Lancers. By D. H. PARRY. New Edition, Greatly enna with 8 Illustrations, NOW READY, price 3s. 6d. THE BLACK WATCH. The Record of an Historic Regiment. By ARCHIBALD FORBES, LL.D. New Edition, with 8 Iustrations., NEW SIX- ‘SHILLING NOVELS. SECOND LARGE IMPRESSION NOW READY. RED MORN. By Max Pemberton. ‘*Max Pemberton’s masterpiece.”— British Weekly. ** Far above the ordinary run of modern novels.”—Punch, _ ANGELS, and DEVILS, and MAN. By Winifred Grahaur. = A very iednenien story...... The novel is one of the cleverest we have read this season.” —Ladies’ Field, -TO-MORROW’S TANGLE. By Geraldine Bonner. ‘* This is a dashing novel, and breathes the very breath of Californian freedom.” Morning Pest. The DESPOILERS. By Edmund Mitchell. ** Plots, bold schemes, the passions of love and of gain, and ceaseless incidents fill @ sensational and vehement book.” —Daily News. a READY NEXT WEEK, BURNS'S POEMS. (A Selection.) With Introduction by NEIL MUNRO. BEING ONE OF THE NEW VOLUMES OF THE IMPROVED ISSUE OF CASSELL’S NATIONAL LIBRARY. VOLUMES ALREADY PUBLISHED. Vol. 1. SILAS MARNER. By George Eliot. With Intro- duction by STUART J. REID. » 2 A SENTIMENTAL JOURNEY. By Laurence STERNE. With Introduction by L. AUSTIN. » & RICHARD II. By Eodkanaaase. » 4 BROWNING’ s POEMS. (A Selection.) With: Introduction by A. D. INN ~ we ON HEROES and HERO. WORSHIP. By Thomas. » 6 A CHRISTMAS CAROL and The CHIMES. By CHARLES DICKENS » 7% The VICAR of WAKEFIELD. By Oliver Gold- SMITH. With Introduction by Sir HENRY IRVING. » 8. MACBETH. By Shakespeare. » 9. EVELYN’S DIARY. (The Reign of Charles II.) With Introduction by AUSTIN DOBSO , 10. JOHNSON’S RASSELAS. » ll. The FOUR GEORGES. By W. M. Thackeray. With Introduction by L. AUSTIN ,» 12. JULIUS CAESAR. By Shakespeare. , 13. TENNYSON’S POEMS. (A Selection.) With Introduction by A. T. QUILLER-COUCH » 14. The MERCHANT of VENICE. By Shakespeare. ,» 15.EDGAR ALLAN POE’S TALES. (A Selection.}- With Introduction by TIGHE HOPKINS. ,» 16. The LADY of the LAKE. By Sir Walter Scott. 17. EMERSON’S ESSAYS. (A Selection.) With Intro-- 4 duction by ©. LEWIS HIN ,» 18. HAMLET. By ‘9 » 19. GOLDSMITH’S PLAYS. Each Book contains an Introduction, Where not otherwise stated it is by Prof. HENRY MORLEY NEW SIXPENNY EDITIONS. ' The LORD PROTECTOR. By S. Levett-Yeats. (wow reasy. | NEBO the NAILER. _ By S. Baring-Gould. (Early in Apri. READY SHORTLY, price 12s. 6d. net. THE STORY OF THE “BRITANNIA” TRAINING SHIP FOR NAVAL CADETS. With some Account of Previous Methods of Naval Education, and of the New Scheme established in 1903.. By Commander E. P. STATHAM, R.N. With numerous I]lustrations, CASSELL & COMPANY, Lnurep, London; and all Booksellets.
Page 30
414 THE ATHENZUM
BLACKIE & SON'S LIST. JUST PUBLISHED. THE LITERATURE OF THE HIGHLANDS. By MAGNUS MACLEAN, M.A. D.8c., Author of ‘ The Literature of the Celts.’ Demy 8vo, cloth extra, price 7s. 6d. net. Contents. — Highland Literature — Alexander Macdonald and the Jacobite Bards—Duncan Ban Macintyre and the Poets of Nature—Macpherson and his ‘ Ossian’—Rob Donn and the Elegiac, Amatory, and Satiric Poets—Dugald Bu- chanan and the Religious Poets and Hymn Writers—Gaelic Proverbs—English Renderings of Gaelic Poetry and their Authbors--The Gaelic Bards of the Nineteenth Century— The Literature of Travel and of History—Index of Names. ‘The LITERATURE of the HIGHLANDS’ forms a com- anion volume to the author's ‘LITKRATURE of the ELTS,’ which recently met with such a favourable re- >; St James’s Branch: 26, Charles Street ; LONDON OFFICES [55 ‘piccadilly, W.; 81, Edgware Road, W. l 1, Victoria Street, 8.W. Claims Pald .......ccccccccscccces £17,270,000 Applications for Agencies invited. DINNEFORD'S MAGNESIA. ‘The best remedy for ACIDITY of the S1OMACH, HEARTBURN, HEADACHE, GOUT, And INDIGESTION, . And Safest Aperient for Delicate Constitutions, Ladies, Children, and Infants.
London: SIMPKIN MARSHALL & CO., LIMITED. DINNEFURD’S MAGNESIA,
SSS SS
we es
=
a a ee
_ -..)
Page 31
N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 THE ATHENAUM 415 me FROM WELLS GARDNER, DARTON & CO.’S NEW AND RECENT BOOKS. A NEW AND IMPORTANT WORK.—JUST PUBLISHED. The DESTINY of MAN. By the Rev. J. H. Lester, M.A., Rector of Lexden, Colchester, Prebendary of Lichfield Cathedral. Crown 8vo, cloth boards, 3s. net. BY CANON EVAN DANIEL. MOST SUITABLE FOR CONFIRMATION CANDIDATES.—JUST PUBLISHED. NEARER to GOD: a Manual of Devotions for the Young; together with the Order of Confirmation and the Order of Holy Communion. By the Rev. EVAN DANIEL, M.A., Vicar of Horsham, Hon. Canon of Rochester. 128 pp. royal 32mo, cloth, 6d. net. This little book of devotions is intended to help the young in their daily communion with God, and in the great crises of their spiritual life—Confirmation and First Communion. READY NEXT WEEK. The HEAVENLY FEAST. A Companion to the Altar with Devotions for the Communion of the Sick. By the Rev. EVAN DANIEL, M.A. Royal 32mo, cloth. TWENTIETH EDITION.—This Revised Edition contains an Appendix on the Articles, and considerably Enlarged Notes on the Occasional Offices and the Ordinal. By the The PRAYER BOOK: its History, Language, and Contents. Rev. Canon EVAN DANIEL, M.A. Extra large crown 8vo, 700 pp., cloth boards, 6s. BY THE REV. W. S. SWAYNE. The PSALM of the SAINTS, and the SUFFERINGS of JESUS CHRIST. oo Sem tee, ae a j= Poon Rev. W. S. SWAYNE, M.A., Vicar of St. Peter's, Cranley Gardens, BY CHANCELLOR P. V. SMITH. The LAW of CHURCHWARDENS and SIDESMEN in the TWENTIETH CENTURY. By P.V.SMITH, LL.D., Barrister-at-Law, Chancellor of the Dioceses of Manchester and Durham. Cloth boards, 2s. net. [Second Edition, “ Altogether an admirable production.’—Guardian. BY THE BISHOP OF LONDON. WORK in GREAT CITIES, Six Lectures on Pastoral Theology, delivered in the Divinity School, Cambridge. By the Right Rev. A. F. WINNINGTON-INGRAM, D.D., Bishop of London, Crown 8vo, cloth boards, 3s. 6d. (Third Edition, ‘* We unhesitatingly tell all young workers, lay and clerical, that whether their work lies in poor districts or ‘ well-to- do,’ amongst men or lads, be it social or didactic, they are doing themselves and the work great injustice so long as they remain unacquainted with Dr. Ingram’s epigrammatic, sensible, experienced talk.” —Church Times. The MEN who CRUCIFY CHRIST. Crown 8vo, cloth boards, 1s. 6d. [Fourth Edition. FRIENDS of the MASTER. A Sequel to ‘ The Men who Crucify Christ.’ BY CANON LESTER. Crown 8vo, cloth boards, 1s. 6d. {Fifth Edition, BANNERS of the CHRISTIAN FAITH. Crown 8vo, cloth boards, 3s. 6d. [Second Edition. The AFTERGLOW of a GREAT REIGN. 18mo, cloth boards, 1s. 6d. ** One of the best and truest of the many appreciations of the late Queen’s character.”’— Times. [Fifth Editicn, UNDER the DOME. A Volume of Selected Sermons on Special Occasions. Crown 8vo, cloth boards, 3s, ¢d. [Third Edition, BY THE BISHOP OF ST. ANDREWS. FOR QUIET MOMENTS. Devotional Readings from the Published and Unpub- lished Writings of the Right Rev. G. H. WILKINSON, D.D., Bishop of St. Andrews. Crown 8vo, cloth boards, 2s. éd. HOLY WEEK and EASTER. Fcap. 8vo, cloth boards, 1s.; leather, 1s. 6d. [Twenty-fourth Thousand, BY F. J. ROWBOTHAM. STORY LIVES of GREAT AUTHORS. By F. J. Rowsornam. cloth boards, 3s. 6d. Each Life is accompanied by a Portrait and several Illustrations. “A work of literary quality, persuasively interesting helpfully exemplified by portraits and illustrations.” Dundee Advertiser, BY THE REV. THE HON. JAMES ADDERLEY. PRAYER BOOK TEACHING. By the Rev. the Hon. James AppERLEY, M.A., Vicar of St. Mark’s, Marylebone Road. Feap. 8vo, Is. net. [Just ready. An attempt to construct a positive statement of Church of England Doctrine and Practice from the Words of the Book of Common Prayer. BY ELIZABETH WORDSWORTH. ONLY a FEATHER : Wayside Thoughts. 0' ards, ls. net. BY THE REV. W. H. HUTION. Crown 8yo, By ELizaBETH WoRrDSWORTH. THE BAMPTON LECTURES FOR 1903. The INFLUENCE of CHRISTIANITY upon NATIONAL CHARACTER ILLUSTRATED by the LIVES and LEGENDS of the ENGLISH SAINTS. By the Rev. W. H. HUTTON, B.D., Fellow, Tutor, and Precentor of St. John’s College, Oxford. Demy 8vo, cloth boards, giit top, 12s 6d. net. ** Readers will not find this in any sense a dull book. The subject is a strictly original one, full of suggestiveness, and worked out in a picturesque and interesting style, which exhibits also consideravle research, the fruits of which are summarised in e'aborate and valuable notes.”"—Church Times. ‘* This book may d» for the motern generation of English Churchmen what Newman hoped to do with the ‘ Lives of the English Saints’ in 1843.”—Pall Mall Gazerte. THE LATE CANON BRIGHT. SELECTED LETTERS of WILLIAM BRIGHT, D.D., Canon of Christ Church, Oxford ; Regius Professor of Ecclesiastical History. Edited by the Rev. B. J. KIDD, D.D., Keble College ; Tutor of Non-Collegiate Students, and Lecturer in Theology at Pembroke College, Oxford. With an Introauctory Memoir by the Rev. P. G@. MEDD, M.A., formerly Fellow and Tutor of University College, Oxford. Demy 8vo, cloth boards, 10s. 6d net. “In his own subject he was unrivalled These letters have a special interest, for they touch on various subjects of the present-day controversy, and they are the work of a typical man.”—Spectator. The LAW of FAITH. By the late Rev. Witt1am Bricut, D.D., Canon of Christ Church, Oxford, Regius Professor of Ecclesiastical History. Crown 8vo, cloth boards, 6s. [Second Edition, London: 3, PATERNOSTER BUILDINGS, E.C., and 44, VICTORIA STREET, §,W.; And of all Booksellers. WILLIAM BLACKWOOD & SONS. —_—~— CHINESE LABOUR. The Question of the Hour in South Africa. AN IMPORTANT CONTRIBUTION TO THE DISCUSSION OF THIS QUESTION IS CONTAINED IN Mr, JOHN BUCHAN’S THE AFRICAN COLONY: Studies in the Reconstruction. Price 15s. net. NEW NOVEL. 6s. ONE LONDON SEASON. By CAROLINE FISHER, 6s. 5s. NEW NOVEL. THE DISAPPEARANCE OF DICK. By WALTER B. HARRIS, With 17 Illustrations, NEW NOVEL. 6s. THE KING'S FOOL. By MICHAEL BARRINGTON. 6s. OUR INTERESTS IN THE EAST. ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT RECENT SURVEYS OF THIS SUBJKCT IS TO BE FOUND IN The ENGLISHMAN in CHINA. (With a Section on Japan.) By ALEXANDER MICHIE. 2 vols. 38s. net. GEORGE ELIOT'S COMPLETE WORKS. Of which Messrs. Blackwood are the only Publishers; LIBRARY EDITION. 10 vols. cloth, each 10s. 6d. net. With Photogravure Frontispieces by MAURICE GREIFFENHAGEN, W. HATHERRKLI,. E. J. SULLIVAN, BYAM SHAW, MAX COWPKR, and others. WARWICK EDITION, WORKS and LIFE.. 14 vols. printed on Special Thin Bible Paper. Cloth, gilt. top, each 2s. net. Limp leather, gilt top, each 2s. 6d. net. Leather, gilt top, each 3s. net. Half-vellum, gilt top, each 3s. 6d. net. POPULAR EDITION. 8 vols. each 3s. 6d. STANDARD EDITION. 21 vols. each 2¢. 6d. SIXPENNY EDITION. ADAM BEDE, MILL. on the FLOSS, ROMOLA, SILAS MARNER, SCENES from CLERICAL LIFH. THE ETHICS OF WORK AND WEALTH. BY D. C. BANKS. A NEW IMPRESSION OF BON GAULTIER’S BOOK of BALLADS. By sir THEODOKE MARTIN, K.c.B. A NEW KDITION, with Auto- biographical Introduction. With Illustrations. by Doyle, Leech, and Crowquill, 5s. net. WILLIAM BLACKWOOD & SONS, Edinburgh and London.
Page 32
416 THE ATHENZUM N° 3987, Marcu 26, 1904 MESSRS. BELL'S NEW AND FORTHCOMING WORKS. NEW LIST POST FREE ON APPLICATION. DEDICATED BY SPECIAL PERMISSION TO H.M. QUEEN ALEXANDRA. The HISTORY of PORTRAIT MINIATURES from the Time of Holbein, 1531, to that of Sir William Ross, 1860, with a Chapter on Modern Work. By GEORGE C. WILLIAMSON, Litt.D. 2 vols. imperial 4to, with upwards of 700 Illustrations. Edition, limited to 510 Copies, 107. 10s. net. Special Edition of 50 Copies, with 34 Hand-Painted Plates, 52/. 10s. net. This work is by far the most comprehensive and authoritative that has ever been written on the subject, as the author has been able to examine all the great collections in this al and Imperial collections on the Continent, which have hitherto been inaccessible to the student, The seven hundred miniatures, which are illustrated, form a superb series of portraits—mostly quite unknown—of practically every one of importance in English history since the days of Hlizabeth, besides very many foreign celebrities. The EDITION DE LUXE will haveasa frontispiece a new miniature of the Queen, painted at the Author's request, and by her Majesty’s gracious permission, by Mr. Alyn Williams, country and also the Roy: Hand-made Paper [Ready shortly, VARIORUM EDITION OF BEAUMONT AND FLETCHER. The WORKS of FRANCIS BEAUMONT and JOHN FLETCHER. Variorum Edition. Edited by A. H. BULLEN. Vol. I. containing The MAID’S TRAGEDY and PHILASTER. Edited by P. A. DANIEL.—A KING and NO KING, A SCORNFUL LADY, and The CUSTOM of the COUNTRY. Edited by R. WARWICK BOND. 8vo, with Portrait of Beaumont from the Painting at Knole Park, and Facsimilies of Early Title-pages. *,* This Edition is to be completed in twelve volumes, and the last volume will contain Memoirs, Excursuses, &c., by Mr. A. H. Bullen, under whose general direction the edition has ‘been planned. To each play are prefixed list of original editions, notes on the date of compositien, notes on the state of the text, the argument, the source of the plot and theatrical history, Imperial 8vo, 21s. net. PEWTER PLATE. A Historical and Descriptive Handbook. By H. J. L. J. MASSE, M.A. With 100 Illustrations. FOURTH THOUSAND, post 8vo, 5s. net. HOW to IDENTIFY OLD CHINA. A Handbook for Collectors of English Pottery and Porcelain. By Mrs. WILLOUGHBY HODGSON. With 40 Plates and numerous Reproductions of Marks. ** Of its kind this is quite a model handbook.”—Daily Telegraph. VOLS. I. and II. NOW RBADY. VOL. III. APRIL 15. BRYAN’S DICTIONARY of PAINTERS and ENGRAVERS. A New Edition, Revised and Enlarged, under the Supervision of @.C. WILLIAMSON, Litt.D., Assisted by a Staff of Specialists. With about 450 Illustrations. In 5 vols. 21s. net each; or in half-morocco, 3ls. 6d. net each. To be published at intervals of Three Months. “‘ The new Bryan reflects the greatest credit on the editor and publishers, The book, long -since recognized as a classic, will be more than ever indispensable.’’—Magazine of Art. 3 2 SECOND EDITION, REVISED, small 4to, 10s. 6d. net. | The ART of JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER. By T. R. WAY and G. RAVENSCROFT DENNIS. With 50 Reproductions in Half-Tone and | 5 Facsimiles in Colour. “If anything were needed to give the world a just view of one whom it so entirely mis- understood in life, it is supplied by the admirably complete, sympathetic, and richly illus- trated study of Messrs. Way and Dennis.”—Mr. A. G. GARDINER in Daily News. | SECOND and CHEAPER EDITION, 6s. net. JAPANESE ILLUSTRATION. Being a History and Description of the Arts of Pictorial Woodcutting and Colour ——, in Japan. By | EDWARD STRANGE, M.J.S. With 8 Coloured and 80 Black-and-White | Illustrations. Crown 8vo, 6s. net. The ART of the PITTI PALACE. With a Short History of the Building and its Owners. By JULIA DE W. ADDISON. With numerous Illustrations. *,* Uniform with ‘The ART of the VATICAN,’ by Mary Knight Potter. n 2 vols. demy 8vo, 21s. net. I ECONOMIC INQUIRIES and STUDIES. By Sir Robert GIFFEN, K.C.B. | ! *,* Several of the essays included in these volumes formed part of Sir Robert Giffen’s ‘ Essays in Finance,’ which have been out of print for some years. The bulk of the essays shave not, however, been published before in a collected form, and one, on ‘The Present | _— Conditions and Outlook for the United Kingdom,’ is now published for the first | ime, Large post 8vo, 5s. net. The FOUNDATIONS of MODERN EUROPE. Twelve Lectures delivered in the University of London by Dr. EMIL REICH, Doctor Juris, | Author of ‘ A New Student’s Atlas of English History,’ ‘Greco-Roman Institutions,’ * History of Civilisation,’ &c. THE CHISWICK LIBRARY A Series of finely printed Books, printed at the Chiswick Press in fcap. folio (13} in. by 8} in.). ‘The GOLDEN ASS of APULEIUS. Translated from the | Latin by WILLIAM ADLINGTON. Reprinted from the First Edition (1536). With | Decorated Frontispiece and Title-Page by W. L. BRUCKMAN. 2, 2s. net. [ Shortly. OF NOBLE WRITERS. WALTON’S LIVES of DONNE, WOTTON, HOOKER, HERBERT, and SANDERSON. KEdited from the Edition of 1675 by GEORGE SAMPSON. With a Series of Initial Letters and a Title-Page designed by D. CLAYTON CALTHROP, and 6 magnificent Portraits in Photograyure. 200 Copies for sale in Great Britain. 3J. 3s. net. {Jn the press, POCKET-BOOK CLASSICS. Printed on thin paper, small imperial 32mo. Price, with Pocket-Book and Diary, 4s. 6d. and 5s. 6d. net. The Volumes are also sold separately, bound in limp leather, with gilt edges, 2s. net. NEW VOLUMES. ‘CALVERLEY’S VERSES, TRANSLATIONS, and FLY- LEAVES. [/mmediately. The SATIRES and EPISTLES of HORACE. Latin Text with Conington’s Translation on opposite pages. [Jn the press, ‘SSHAKESPEARE’S HAMLET. [Jn the press. NEW VOLUME OF THE CLUB SERIES. BRIDGE. By “Templar.” Small post 8vo,1s. Also in limp leather, 2s. net. THE ALL-ENGLAND SERIES. NEW VOLUMES. Small post 8vo, illustrated, 1s, each. CRICKET. By Fred C. Holland, Surrey C.C. With 32 Illustrations. | WRESTLING. By Walter Armstrong. New Edition. With Chapters on Japanese and Russian Wrestling, &c. /-ROWING and SCULLING. By Guy Rixon. THE YORK LIBRARY. A NEW SERIES OF REPRINTS ON THIN PAPER. Messrs. Bell have pleasure in announcing the issue, under the above title, of a new series of reprints of the classics of all languages. ‘texts, which will in all cases be printed complete and unabridged. The volumes will be printed in a handy size (6jin. by 43in.), on thin bound. A special cover and end-papers have been designed by Mr. A. A. Martin, and title-pages by Mr. D. Clayton Calthrop. PRICE 2s. NET PER VOL. IN CLOTH attractivel -and 3s. NET PER VOL. IN LEATHER. The Volumes will be issued Fortnightly, beginning with the following :— ‘COLERIDGE’S AIDS to REFLECTION, and the Con- fessions of an Inquiring Spirit. (Ready. BURNEY’S EVELINA. Edited, with an Introduction and Notes, by ANNIE RAINE ELLIS. (Ready. Care will be taken to obtain the best possibli but opaque paper, and will be simply if MOTLEY’S RISE of the DUTCH REPUBLIC. With @ Biographical Introduction by MONCURE D. CONWAY. 3vols. [Vol. J, April 11. EMERSON’S WORKS. A New Edition in 4 vols. contain# ing all the Essays, Lectures, and Poems, and a Number of Miscellaneous Pieces. London: GEORGE BELL & SONS, York Street, Covent Garden. Editorial Communications should be addressed to ‘The Editor”—Advertisements and Business Letters to ‘‘The Publisher”—at the Office, Bream’s Buildings, Chancery Lane, E.C. Published Weekly by Joun C. Francis at Bream’s Buildings, Chancery Lane, E.C., and Printed by Jonny Epwarp Francis, Atheneum Press, Bream’s Buildings, Chancery Lane, E.C. Agents for Scortanp, Messrs. Bell & Bradfute and Mr. John Menzies, Edinburgh.—Saturday, March 26, 1904. Me