The Athenaeum 1891-03-21: Iss 3308

Page 1

XUM THE ATHENZAUM ~~. Journal of English and Foreign Literature, Science, the Fine Arts, Music and the Brawma. Zi No. 3308. SATURDAY, MARCH 21, 1891. PRICE jj = THREEBPENCE (| > REGISTERED AS A NEWSPAPER» OYAL SOCIETY of LITERATURE, 20, Hanover-square, » WEDNESDAY, March 25, 8 P.m., Paper by C. H. E. CAR- MICHAEL, M.A. F.R.S.L., on ‘ Folk-lore.’ HE INSTITUTE of ACTUARIES. Founded 1848. Incorporated by Royal Charter, 1884. NOTICE is HEREBY GIVEN, that the ANNUAL EXAMINATION will be held on FRIDAY, 24th day of April, and SATURDAY, 25th day of April, 1891, at the Rooms of the Institute, Staple Inn Hall, Holborn, W.C. ; and at the Offices of the Scottish Life Assurance Company, 77, Geo! 4 Edinburgh ; and at the Offices of the National Assurance Company of Treland, 3, College Green, Dublin. Candidates who | parane themsel ves for Examination on April 24th Meeti and 25th next will be required to att end as under :— Frivay. SaturpDay. Candidates for :— a — PART I. ee 10-1 oe 3-6 PART II. oo 2-5 10—1 PART III. eo 2-6 ee 10—2 Candidates must give fourteen days’ notice in writing, add d to yr - THE INSTITUTE of JOURNALISTS.—News- Li, oR prietors, Editors, Managers, and Agents, home or abroad are inv ted to apply for rticulars of the new PROFESSIONAL EM- PLOYMENT GIS TION, established under wers of the — eo Institute. No fees.—Central Office, 78, Fleet-street, ondon, ERMAN and ENGLISH TRANSLATION.— WORK WANTED, and tice aaa easy Presswork.—Fr. A. Hvco, 18, Bernard-street, Russell- -square, W.C. RITISH MUSEUM.—RESEARCHES conducted by OXFORD GRADUATE, with special knowledge of Modern History. Advertiser also desires permanent Secretarial or Tutorial Work. Good references.—Oxon., 33, Charlotte-street, Portland-place, W. NIVERSITY MAN desires MODERN LAN- GUAGE APPOINTMENT. Speaks fluent French and German, NOTICE.—FRIDAY, March 27th, GOOD FRIDAY, the ATHENZZUM rit be published on THURSDAY NEXT, at2a’clock. —ADVERTISEMENTS should be “the Office not later than 10 o’clock on WE NES- DAY Morning. ARIS.—The ATHENZUM can be obtainad Gx SATURDAY at the GALIGNANI LIBRARY, 224, trae do Bhat f 9 WITZERLAND.—A French Lady, somewhat Literary, is anxious to receive EN PENSION in her family ONE or TWO YOUNG LADIES wishing change of air, or to study. ‘Unusual opportunities for French and Painting. Excellent references in Scot- land.—Address Madame Wu tizmoz, 4, Rue Thalberg, Geneva. and has had great experience with Pupils for Woolwich, Sandh and Stat — Highest Testimonials.—M. P. 8., 27, Northbrook-road, » the Honorary Secretaries, of their intention to present themselves for Examination, specifying the particular Examination for which they intend to present themselves, and must at the same time remit the Examination Fee of One Guinea. All Candidates must have ‘paid their current Subscriptions to the Institute prior to = 31st March. By wher of the peta c. paew? NE, THOS. H C00 i} Hon. Secs. Staple Inn Hall, Holborn, W.C., March, 1 “BLACK AND WHITE.” R. HENRY BLACKBURN’S STUDIO. uence of the demand for Book and Newspaper I!lustrations, the yCOU E of INSTRUCTION in DRAWING for the PRESS will be continued four days a week. Students have an 0) (acterae of seeing and handling the various me erp ory wood-' use for the New —A e SECRETARY OF "Academy — 123, Victoria-street, Westminster, 8. Ww. PUBLIC LECTURES as u: R. R. 8. SMYTHE, the only recognized Aus- t Manager of First - Class Entertainments other than “Theatrical, will arrive in London on March 23rd. Lit on ae directed the Colonial Tours of Madame Arabella Goddard, Proctor the Astronomer, Mr. Archibald Forbes the War Corterponaent, Mr. G.A. , Miss Von Finkelstein, Mr. Charles Santle: r. W. 'T. Best, - many other Celebrities.—Address Weat Cent ’ Hotel, London} LATE RESIDENT PARIS CORRESPONDENT to the Lancet would be glad to undertake Seereies of French works re Fiction, Science, Religion, Politics, &c.—Apply to F. = Cc. 8., Messrs. Francis & Co., 4, Took’s-court, Cursitor-street, ndon, E.C. DITOR WANTED.—The Proprietors of a popular Journal for Amateur Mechanics uire the services of a Gentleman as EDITOR.—Apply by letter, stating qualifications, to No. 1121, Sell’s Advertising Offices, London. DITORIAL WORK.—The Literary Adviser of a gar Publishing House in London has leisure to undertake the above. y years’ experience. Excellent references.—Address W., care of C, B. Ward, Esq., Solicitor, 35, Bedford-row, W.C. ADVERTISER, experienced in Newspaper Work ‘Publishing, Advertising, and Reporting—is OPEN to an EN- Moderate salary. GAGEMENT in Town or Countr + Lowe references. —T., 3, Clayton-terrace, Balham, 5 M R. CHARLES F. RIDEAL has a VACANCY fora PUPIL, to whom he could e personal supervision for six or twelve months in PRACTICAL OURNALISM, as well as in Editorial Routine. cation. must be intelligent, not afraid of work, and of — ‘ood social position. Moderate premium.—Address 3, Victoria: street, Westminster, 5. W. UTHOR of a SENSATIONAL STORY, already ope in Volume form (good Press Notices), is OPEN to OFF tor REPU BLICATION in Country Newspaper. co very moderate.—Address Autor, 30, Gibson-square, Islington, N fraActs HUNTED UP, Registers Searched, Wills Found, Pedi Traced, in the British Museum, Record O and Local Registries. Books and Papers Copied and Translated oa aay Language from Manuscript or wae .—Pracock & Peacock, Antiquarian Genealogists, 41, Wych-street, W. YOUNG LADY, Shorthand Writer and quick operator on the Remin eS -writer, with three years’ ex- negra DESIRES RE-ENGAGEME. Can offer highest references. —E. M. D., 7, Richmond-crescent, Barnsbury, N O AUTHORS.—-MS. TYPE-WRITTEN at 1s. per 1,000. Duplicate Copies, 6d. per 1,000 (for over 10,000 words) ; Plays from bs. yi Shorthand Writersand Ty: ype riters sent out to Hotels &e. e Metropolitan School of Shorthand, Limited, =f Chancery- -lane. Feeghuns No. 2,801. Telegrams “Shorthand,” Londo’ ‘| YPE-WRITER. .—AUTHORS’ MSS., Plays, Re- YRANSLATIONS in FRENCH, ITALIAN, and GERMAN ee ee — also LESSONS, by an EXPERI- ENCED INSTRUCTOR. Pupil Pp for Military, and other Examinations.—Ad i t., ‘4, New Oxted street. EAD MISTRESS WANTED for WITHING- Hgeceote See MANCHESTER, after Summer V: tion. The ‘salary 8 1501. per annum and Capitation Fees, with House and Pe oar Fda with, copies of testimonials, should be sent immediately to bem Hon. SecrErary oF THE Councit, Withington Girls’ School, Mancheste: OLSTON’S GIRLS’ DAY SCHOOL, CHELTENHAM-ROAD, BRISTOL. WANTED, early in May, Two ASSISTANT MISTRESSES, one to teach English Subjects and Part Sy pecs and os Cress to teach English Subjects and Model and Freehan: Lg Re th must be thoroughly competent. A knowledge of French would be a recommendation in each case. Applications, stating salary required, and accompanied by copies of Testimonials, which will not be returned, to Le sent tothe Heap Mis. Tress at the School not later than the 15th April. UNIVERSITY TRAINING COLLEGE, LIVERPOOL. The Committee are about to oe a WARDEN of the HOSTEL con- oe with this College, who shall discharge aa the — of Normal Masi Salary, 30Ul. per annum, with d | ing. Applications must tbe received on or before April 1lth.—Further information can be obtained from Professor Carry, University College, Liverpool. Letters should be endorsed on the envelope, “* Application, Warden.” _ ART SCHOOL and TECHNICAL COLLEGE COMMITTEES. WANTED, an ART HEAD MASTERSHIP in a la SCHOOL of ARTS or TECHNICAL COLLEGE by a thoroug experienced HEAD ART MASTER, holding Four Art Master's en! Cer- — Medallist in Seven ste Branches of Art, including Besides ordinary Art Wo teaches Modelling in yer Ete Z on Copper and Clay, and Copper-Plate Printing. His centage in annual successes of Pupils in Art Examinations is mask greater than in the majority of Art Schools, the Department of Science and Art havin; os agen him two premiums for such successes. class testimo’ tending over twenty years, and up to the present time. Is desirous of moving to a dry, bracing, manufacturing neigh- bourhood. Satisfactory reasons given for his desire to move. Apply, in first instance, to A. KR. T., School of Art, Princess-square, Plymouth. ESTMINSTER SCHOOL, An EXAMINATION to FILL UP VACANCIES on the FOUNDA- TION and EXHIBITIONS will BEGIN on JULY 7th.—For particulars apply to the Heap Master, Dean’s-yard, Westminster. S'. PAUL’S SCHOOL.—An EXAMINATION for filling up about THREE VACANCIES on the Foundation will be held on the 8th APRIL NEXT.—For information apply to the Bursar, St. Paul’s School, West Kensington. Pista COLLEGE, SHEFFIELD. ROYAL COMMISSIONERS: (1851) At 1851) SCHOLARSHIP OF 1507. plications for this Schol: must be sent to the Recisrrar, int College, on or before rei 15. Candidates ye have been — students in Firth College for at least three years, and must in te high promise of ca: ity for advancing Science or its applica- soma The Scholarship — “on to Physics, Mechanics, or Chemistry, and is tenable for Two Yea: A FORMER STUDENT of Somerville Hall (Honour Schools of Modern ENGAG Higher 1 Cam. certifi- cate) wishes for a TRAVELLING ENGA EMENT, - ny Teaching in ee privately or in a school.—R. , Elmhurst, Manor-road, N ISS CONSTANCE I. MARKS, B.A. (Lond.), BE ge PRIVATE and CLASS LESSONS "in MATHEMATICS. ggg for Examinations and Boys for Public Schools. > required. —Address 40, Fitzroy-square, W. or — ge COPIED with licate Copies. .—Address E. Trcar, 1884. and despatch. Terms moderate. ibe 23, Maitland Park-villas, Snvenaech 1, N.W. ['YPE- -WRITING, in best style, at 1d. per folio. Shorthand Notes taken. References to Authors.—Miss GLappINa, 1, Loughborough -road, Brixton, 8. W. C MITCHELL & CO. are instructed to negotiate e for the SALE or arrange a PARTNERSHIP in a well-known County Paper. Plant. 'y reasons for sale. MITCHELL & CO., Agents for the Sale and e Purchase of Hewsperet. Properties, undertake Valuations for Frotate or Fusehece, In vestigations, and Audit of Accounts, &c. Card of Terms on 3 2 and i 13, Red Lion-court, Fleet-street, E.C. Classics Ba Engl., M LONDON has MORNINGS DISEN- «tie GAGED.—Address 16, Eccleston-road, Ealing. prs SCILLA, LAUSANNE. —Miss WILLS, late Head Mistress of the Norwich Hi r sister, Madame ¥, WORMS, have a very comforta able EDU EDUCATIONAL HOME for GIRLS. l-sized Tennis Court. Numbers limited. Bacort trom I ra By april 7th. ANOVER.-HIGH-CLASS LADIES’ COLLEGE. Excellent Education under the best Professors and Governesses. Pupils mix with young German Ladies gh pager aa to over can always be arranged.— f application to Mrs. GiLzeRr, 33, 8t. George’s-road, Kilburn, or to the cipal, Friulein von Locuavsen, Hanover. RESDEN. —Frau SCHMALZ, Liittichau Strasse, offers a ita HOME to yl ferences pe i Boyd, 5, e Lawn, Se, Leonards-on-Sea ; J. Duncan, M.A., the Schools, “snrewsbary son, M.A., . Paul's School, West Kensington ; A. C. Treedgo ot ae Bath College. MERSHAM HALL SCHOOL, near READING. Head Master—A. 8. WEST, M.A. Camb. and Lond., late of Trin. Coll., Camb., Fellow of Univ. Coil., Lond. Lt 181 Bo ve the London Matric. direct from School, 62 of them in Honours, with 14 Prizes or Exhibitions. 23 Entrance Scholar- ships gained by Pupils on leaving School. HE LINTON SCHOOL ART STUDIO for LADIES. Under the personal direction of Sir James D. Linton. For Prospectuses appl: hep dlrs 8u) tendent and Secretary, Miss enate 5, Cromwell-place, 80 in, 8.W. — ‘HE NEW STUDIO for LADIES.—StTupgEnts y PREPARED for the SCHOOLS of the ROYAL ACADE Y by Mr. HAROLD COPPING and Mr. PERCY SHORT. FIVE of their Pupils admitted at poe last Examination, January, 1891. Leigh Studio, 38, Great Guneabanaa Bloomsbury, W.C. } OYAL INDIAN ENGINEERING COLLEGE, oe ve ’s-hill, Staines.—The Course of Study is arranged to fi Enginee r Employment in in Rae India, or the Colonies. prin fifty Students will be ad: SEPTEMBER. MBER, 1891. For a the Cecretary of State all ro Ten Ap tments in the Indian Public Works Department, and Two in the I Telegraph Department. For particulars apply to the Szcrerary, at the NIVERSITY COLLEGE, FACULTY OF MEDICINE. The CLASSES RE-COMMENCE on MAY Ist, andare so asto afford a convenient opportunity for Students to begin their Medical Course. Full information des be obtained from the Office of the College, Gower-street, 7 WILLIAMS, M.D., Dean. . HORSBURGH, M.A., Secretary. UNIVERSITY COLLEGE, LONDON. The General Course t cannes and Practical Instruction in Prof. F. IL Botany, by ee a The Lectures (50) are given dutiy, 2 pe Saturdays, at LONDON. The Practical Classes (30) meet Three Days a o Weck (Mornings ©: Afternoons). The Course is gy asd to meet the requirements : of the pea Univ. Prelim. and Int. Scien in aly. The Course - open to all Students, whether taking other Classes 2 i e ber or no’ For further Solermmation apply to . M. HORSBURGH, M.A., Secretary. THs UNIVERSITY of ST. ANDREWS grants the DIPLOMA and TITLE of L.L.A. to WOMEN. The Subjects of Examination may be selected from any seven —— twenty-nine different subjects, the standard the sam the M. 4 e centres of Examination are 8t. Wereets Aber- deen, Bedford, Belfast, Birmingham, Bristol, Cardiff, nham, Cork, Dublin, Dumfries, Bélnbargh Inverness, Leicester, Liverpool, ndon, I ‘Tyne, and ley. For Pros ectus, &e., , apply to the Secuerany, L.L.A. Scheme, the University, St. Andrews, HE GIRTON GOVERNESS and SCHOOL AGENCY.—Madame AUBERT Meo ENGLISH and FUREIGN bate gael DAILY, and VISITIN GOVERNESSES J r, Nursery), Art and Music Com ons, [HE SOCIETY of ARTS PRACTICAL EXAM- INATION in VOCAL and INSTRUMENTAL MUSIC will this year be aR in London during the week commencing MONDAY, the ist of Jan The Society’ s BRONZE MEDAL will be given to any Candidate ob- A iteited de rr the Societ SILVER Late as will be — umber of the Society's - a First Examiner to hee Candida: taking a it Class) whom the certify as ae reds themselves best My the Honours cuten of of The Lists will 1 be oe on Iaeripend en Full particulars ma; obtained on a) . HENRY YT UEMAN WOOD, Secretary. Society's House, John-street, Adelphi, London, W.C. a Hosnekeepe:s, Matrons. Schools and Educational Homes re- commended.—27, Regent-street, Piccadilly-cireus, 8. W. TO : AUTHORS.—Old-Established Publisher is prepared to ADVISE Authors as to es gr pa of ot ent Address, in ps 4d, 4 yoo Guaweltess. 3 og Re Mi SormwooD and BOOK PRINTING ware. —SOUTHWOOD, SMITH & King- reet, my = Tieamengur iene ee BY Fetter- = aa Lenten, I A

Page 2

362 THE ATHENAUM

N° 3308, Marcu 21,’91

N R. A. M. BURGHES, AUTHORS’ AGENT, AC- \COUNTANT, and VALUER. Advice given as to the best mode of F m behalf of Authors. ‘Transfer of Literary aroma — conducted. Safe Opinions obtained. Twenty years’ gy reriphest free.—la. Paternoster-row, E.C. T.O AUTHORS.—DIGBY & LONG (Publishers of The AUTHORS’ MANUAL, by PERCY RUSSELL: a Guide to all Branches of Literature, a 5s.; postage, 44d.; Fourth Edition, Pabieati s free) are pre undertake on favourable oe the blication of ‘all approved Works Correspondence invited.—Miss E. Brapvon writes of ‘The AUTHORS’ MANUAL’: “ Your a a both to the Journalist and the Imaginative Writer is full of wisdom.” Dicsy & Lone, 18, Bouverie-street, Fleet-street, London. A BTISsTs’ ADDRESSES WANTED. DAVIES, who Painted ‘The Meet of Lord ——’s Hounds.’ KOHLER, who Painted ‘In his Father's Footsteps. These Artists will much aot “aed sending their addresses to H., 8, Union-court, Old Broad-street, ‘ Q WEAL ENGRAVING, SEALS, SIGNET RINGS, WO STONES, &c.—Mr. THOMAS MORING begs to announce that his ILLUSTRATED CATALOGUE dealing with the above is now r and will be forwarded (post free) Ry receipt of 1s. ld.—First ‘Avenns Hotel-buildings, High Holborn, W

| OND ON LIBRARY, j 8ST. JAMES’-SQUA | President LORD TENNYSON. | _ Viee-Presidents—Rt. Hon. W. E. Gladstone, M.P., The Very Rev. the Dean of Liandaff, —* H. prey # Bart., Sir Henry Barkly, K.C.B. ‘Trustees—Right Hon. Farl of Lytton, Right Hon. sir John Lubbock, Rart., Right Hon. Earl of Rosebery. | _ The Library —— 130,000 Volumes of Ancient and Modern Lite- ture, in variou guages. Subscription, 3/. a year iggy | Entrance-fee, or 2. with Entrance-fee of 6l.; Life Membership, 30 Fifteen Volumes are allowed to Country and ‘Ten to Town Members. eading-Room open from Ten to half-past Six. Catalogue, Fifth Edition, 2 vols. royal 8vo. price 21s. ; to Members, 16s. Prospectus on @ plication. ROBERT HARRISON, Secretary and Librarian.

ie: CREST HOLDER S&. COMMUNICATIONS and full PARTICULARS of CRESTS and EMBLAZONINGS used are REQUESTED by the undersigned, who is engaged in preparing an entirely New Edition of Fairbairn’s Standard Book of Groen Proofs of entry and sketches will be submitted for approval on application.—Prospectus on application. A. C. Fox-Davies, 20, John-street, Adelphi, London, W.C. To be published by T. C. & E. C. Jack, London and "Edinburgh.

Catalogues. FOREIGN BOOKS and PERIODICALS prompts ALOGUES on moderate terms. ert eo a lication. DULAU & CO. 37,

YIXHE REPARATION of PAINTINGS, or any WORK necessary to their PRESERVATION, effected with every regard to the safest and most cautious treatment, by M. R. THOMPSON, Studio, 41, George-street, Portman-square, W.

Peete egsa VY CES TO PUBLISHERS, AUTHORS, ARTISTS, AND FINE-ART OLLECTORS. Messrs. ANNAN & SWAN are prepared to estimate for Reproductions in PI ee of Paintings, wee 8 Photographs, Engravings, and any other object that can be pRosoere: _ ‘They will be pleased to show mensof their Engravings to any one interested in the peeraiaaion 3 Works of Art. Annan she Swix, 7, Vevonshire-road, South Lambeth, London, S.W. r ‘HE AUTOTYPE FINE-ART GALLERY, 74, NEW OXFORD-STREET, LONDON, W.C. (Twenty Doors West of Mudie’s Library.)

The GREAT MASTERS. Represented by choice Examples from the most celebrated Galleries of Europe. The NATIONAL GALLERY, LON DON. Two Hundred and Seventy Paintings reproduced in Autotype ; also Selections from the Royal Galleries of Windsor and Bucking nam Palace. AUTOTYPE REPRODUCTIONS of MODERN PAINTINGS from the Salon, the Luxembourg, the Royal Academy, &c., including choice Examples after Benner, Breton, Cabanel, Carolus- Duran, Chaplin, Chardin, Corot, Henner, Lefebvre, Meissonier, Millet, &c. The LIBER STUDIORUM. Facsimiled in Autotype from tine states lent by the Kev. Stopford Breoke, M.A. The GOOD SHEPHERD; CHRIST and PETER; The ANGEL GUARDIAN; The RES URRECTION MORNING. From Drawings and Paintings by Frederic Shields. Fine EXAMPLES of the ART of D. G. ROSSETTI, BURNE JONES, HOLMAN HUNT, and G. F. WATTS, ANCIENT ATHENS. Twenty-five p lorge Autotypes from Siege by W. J. Stillman, Esq., by authority of the Hellenic Society. Also 8 Autotypes from Greek Temples in Sicily by the Same Author, and Nine Athenian Subjects from Negatives by Mr. Walter Leaf. Prospectus on application. The ty A ne AL Ants of PEACE and WAR. <Autotypes f he Cartoons for the Frescoes in South Kensington Museum by SIk- FREDERIC LEIGHTON, P.R.A . = a The AUTOTYPE PROCESS adapted to Photographic Engraving on Copper. Copies of Paintings by Gainsboro, Holman Hunt, Herbert Schmalz; of Portraits by Holl, R.A.; Ouless, R.A.; Pettie, R.A.; Prinsep, A.R.A. ; of the Fresco in Guy’s Hospital; ‘Spring,’ by Herbert Draper, &c.; Auto-Gravure Reproductions of Photographs from Art Objects and from Nature, can be seen at the Autotype Gallery. 2° O=sG ££ A VY U RSE. Estimates and particulars on application. The AUTOTYPE COMPANY, 74, New Oxford-street, W.C. N UDIE’S

SELECT LIBRARY. SUBSCRIPTIONS from ONE GUINEA per Annum.

MUDIE’S SELECT LIBRARY. Books can be a at the residences of Subscribers in London by the Library Messengers. SUBSCRIPTIONS from TWO GUINEAS per Annum.

MUDIE’S SELECT LIBRARY. COUNTRY SUBSCRIPTIONS from TWO GULNEAS per Annum.

A large number of Copies of the Best and expel Popular Books of the Season are now in circulation at Mupre’s Linrar All Works of general interest are freely added immediately on publication. Library Catalogue for 1891, a5 6d. Pro pectuses and Clearance Lists ef Books on Sale, postage fre:

MUDIES SELECT LIBRARY, LIMITED, 30 to 34, New Oxford-street, London. Eranch Off ces : O-SQUARE. . y m Fst EDITIONS of MODERN AUTHORS, ey reed Dickens, Thackeray, Lever, Ainsworth; Books illus- trated by G. R. Cruikshank, Phiz, Rowlandson, &e. The largest and choicest *Collection offered for Sale in the World. Catalogues issued Monthly and sent post free on Hs cinema —Watrer T. Spencer, 27, New Oxford-street, London, W.C. ee ee ee ae BLvVe Y, Dealers in Old and Rare Books NEW CATALOGUE, 71, Now Ready, post free six stamps. 29, NEW BOND-STREET, LONDON, W. TI.0 BOOK SOCIETIES, Free Libraries, &c.— Special cheap CATALOGUE now ready, containing an extensive variety of Modern Travels, Historical Works, Biographies, Anecdote, Drama, Poets, Illustrated Books, Cheap Sets, Art, &c.; many in new bindings, and all at reduced prices.—Gratis and post free on application to A cers Bookseller, 38, New Oxford-street (next Mudie’s Library), London. ] OOKS—Rare, Curious, and Scarce—from the Library of Edward Hailstone. Romances, Antiquarian, Old Plays, &c.—CATALOGUE one stamp, of A. Reaper, Orange-street, Red Lion-square, W.C.

TT.O BOOKBUYERS.— JAMES: TH RPE has just published his EIGHTY-THIRD CATALOGUE of Standard, Useful, and Rare SECON D-HAND BOOKS, in ail Branches of Literature, at low Prices. To be had, post free, at 53, Ship-street, brighton 0 ein te KEN NN A RD, t-street, Leamington § will send his CATALOGUE of Misc ELEANEOU S$ SECOND-HAND BOOKS free by post to any address on application. | OOKS (SECOND-HAND, MISCELLANEOUS), —C. HERBERT, English and Foreign Bookseller, 319, Goswell- E.C. CATALOGUE (over 2,000 items) free on receipt of Libraries Paraaael, or Valued for Probate.

road, London, two stamps.

[NTERESTING HISTORICAL DOCUMENTS, Manuscripts, and Autograph Letters of (not living) Celebrities PURCHASED by 8. J. Davey, Archivist Oftice, 47, Great Russell-street. ([SAnecairtT of the STATIONERS’ REGISTER, 1554-1640, by Arber, fine copy, 4 vols. 4to. cloth, 1875-77, privately er only 130 copies issued, of which this is No. 50, price 121. or offer.

James Connisu & Sons, 297, High Holborn, W.C. PDE Bait Edition, “LODGE’S: PORTRAITS, 12° vols. proof on India Paper, 181. The Abbotsford Edition of the WAVERLEY NOVELS, 12 vols. fine lates, 10/ Z The —— the TURF, and ROAD, “Nimrod,” plates by Alken, 1837, 2 AitABIAN NIGHTS’ ENTERTAINMENT, with Notes, E. W. Lane, T 3 vols. , Three Guineas. AR OTLE, LOGICA ARISTOTELIS EX TERTIA RECOGNI- TIONE ORDINANTE. J. F. Stapulensi, Woodcut Title in red and black, original stamped leather boards, 1520, 31. Grorcr Atzerr Suir, St. Ives, ee ‘RECIAN ANTIQUITIES, TERRA-COT TAS, IX BRONZES, VASES. &c., and some Early Christian Embroideries, are ON SALE by PRIVATE C ;ONTRACT.—For particulars apply to H. ack, L eadenhall Chambers, St. Mary Axe. TWO HOUSES, with good Sculptor and Painter's Studios, TO BE SOLD, 33 and 37, Ovington-square.—Inquire there or Write Besnarp, 17, Rue Guillaume Tell, Paris. (TONBRIDGE WELLs.— BOARD and RESI- DENCE offered in a Private Family. Position cheerful and central, three minutes’ walk from 8.E. Rly. Station.—R. G., Roxwell, Guildford-road, Grove Hill-road, Tunbridge Wells. ym . . YO LET, in St. Peter’s-square, West-end, Hammersmith, a SEMI-DETACHED HOUSE, with large Garde en, Vinery, Conservatory, and Summer-house ; looking on to the enclosed Square and its fine trees. ‘T'wo upper stories : five good Ked-rooms, one 25 ft. by Il ft.; Bath-room and Dressing-room. Ground-tioor: Drawing- room, 25 ft. by 16 ft., 10 ft. Gin. high, opening to Conservatory and Gar- wie ; Dining-room, ‘16 ft. by 11 ft. 3in., 10ft. 5in. high; Smoking-room ; Hall; Stone Stairs ; and w.c. Basement : handsome M orning-room ; Kiphen, Seulleries, Still-rooms, and other excellent Othices. Tradesmen’s Entrance; Front Garden; Recessed Porch. In complete order for occupation ; gas and blinds throughout. Extremely quiet and close to tram and trains. Rent, for a term, Sixty Guineas.—Address 0., 10, Hammersmith-terrace, W.

YHISLEHURST (near the Railway Station, and ) ge gree situated opposite Bickley Park) —TO BE LET, Tor the residue Lease (six years unexpired), a SUPERIOR RESIDE er with spacious rot lofty Reception and Billiard Rooms, Nine Bed and Dressing Rooms, Stabling, Lodge Entrance, Glass Houses, &c., and all the adjuncts of a Gentleman's trst-class establishment, surrounded by 14} acres of perfectly charming (though inexpensive) Pleasure Grounds, Gardens, Wilderness, and Pasture. Original rent, 36v/. per annum No remium.— Detailed particulars, &c., may be had’ at Inglewood, Chisle- ‘oO PRESS EN and others. — Comfortable Resident. uarters in Central oe close to Fleet-stree midway between City and West-End. lofty bed-sitting pone tor | lobby entrance, 15s. ] charges for attendance, a; Pay 8 - pair by Sp age sede tal § per week inclusive. Electri r rter, ——u..:mhlCme 1 Collector's Office, 63, Chancery-lane, W.C pply Maxson, N EMORY.—A. LOISETTE’S SYSTEM.—« Phy- siological, scientific.”—Dr. Andrew Wilson (April, '83). “ | cecssamend the’ system.”—Dr. Wilson (Jan., . 2Gre rent svestee ee | ames a “2 aid to weak one.”—Dr. Buckley.

““Invalu. al age , Law Lect., King’ ‘8 Coll., Lon: Leann “ post or voice. pectus free. Write or call at 37, New Ox ford-st., lend

Sales by Anction Valuable Musical Property. ESSRS. PUTTICK & SIMPSON will SELL by AUCTION, at their House, 47, Leicester-square, W.C., TUESDAY, March %, at half-past 12 o'clock precisely, an ASSEMBLAGE. of valuable MUSICAL PROP RTY, inleding full-compass Pianofortes by Broadwood & Sons, Erard, R. Cocks, Blankenstein, Kuhse, and other manufacturers—several fine American s of the Estey, Monr roe, Prince, and other Companies—la size Harmoniums—Musical Boxes— several valuable Collections of Italian and other Violins, ‘Tenors, Vio- loncellos, and re le Basses, spooler a number of desirable examples just d from the ¢ acquired by a Connoisseur— bows ~_Cases—Fittings— Military Band Instr uments—Guitars—Mandolines— Music and Music Paper, &c. Catalogues on receipt of two stamps.

Collection of Books in various Branches of Literature. pr ESSRS. PUTTICK & SIMPSON will SELL by AUCTION, at their House, 47, Leicester-square, W.C., on THURSDAY, April 2, and Following Da: y, atten minutes past 1 o'clock recisely, a COLLECTIUN of BOOKS (Englishand Foreign), comprising Works on the Colonies, India, America, Australia, New South Wal ales, New Zealand, &c.—best Editions of the Classics and Translations— various Voyages and ‘Travels—Books of Prints and Cpe oe —Science—Poetry and Fiction, &c.—Pine'’s Horace— ntaine Contes —Angas's South Australia—HKarrington’s New South Wales Whites Voyage to New South Wales—Phillips’s Botany Kay—Wakefield’s New Zealand—Brees's Pictorial Llustrations of New Zealand—Daniell and Ayton’s Great Britain—Lope de Vega’s Works, 21 vols. 1776—Hamilton’ : Hedaya—Hodges’s Views in India—Cooper" s Cattle Groups—Dug St. Paul’s, by Ellis—Hargreaves’s State Trials, 11 vols. —Reskin's Modern Painters, &c.—Grose’s Antiquities, 12 vols.—Walpole’s Anec- dotes, portraits—Nicolson and Burn’s Cumberland—Heriot’s Canadas— First Editions of Dickens, &c. Catalogues on receipt of two stamps.

Library of M. J. RHODES, Esq., removed from Abergavenny, ESSRS. PUTTICK & SIMPSON will SELL by UCTION, at their ee nae — icester - Bg hone W.C., on WEDNESDAY, April 15, and Tw ig Days, at ten minutes past 1 o'clock precisely, the THEOLOGICAL TIBRABY ‘of M. J. RHODES, Esq. (Author of ‘The Visible Unity of the Church ’), comprising valuable Works in Roman Catholic Theology, Writings of the Fathers and School men—The Acta Sanctorum of the Bollandists—a yee of Early Editions of Dante, and numerous Works relating to him, Catalogues in preparation.

Autograph Letters and Historical Documents, Johnsoniana, §c., of LIONEL OLIVER, Esq., of King’s Lynn. ESSRS. PUTTICK & SIMPSON will SELL by AUCTION, at their aes m, Leicester-square, W.C., DURING Bao MONTH of APRIL, an ortant COLLECTION of AUTOGRAPH LETTERS and HISTORIC AL OCUMENTS, rages Iq Series of ‘inverestin ng Letters by and relating to Dr. Johnson and ies—Cor of Messrs. Cadell and Davies, Mr

Straten’ —also Historical Documents addressed to Sir Richard a anes a small collection of Vellum Documents of French Royalty and Nobility—Napoleonic Relics, & a in the press, and will ‘be forwarded on receipt of three stamp:

A Library of Books on Natural History, the Property of a Collector (deceased), removed from Norfolk, and a Library of Modern French Historical Works, in neat bindings. .|N ESSRS. HODGSON will SELL by AUCTION, I at their Rooms. 115, Chancery-lane, W.C. op MONDAY, March 23, and Two Following Days, at 1 o'clock, MISCELLANEOUS. BOOKS, te a the above Libraries, comprising Houbraken's Heads, Large Paper—By res and Howard’s Caverns of Tarquinia—Hamerton's The Portfolio, &c., 8 yols. —Harleian Miscellany, 10 vols. —Encyclopedia Britannica, 22 ols. —Staffordshire Historica! ‘Collections, 12 vols.— Scrope’s Deer-Stalking—Transactions of the Linnean and Ray Socioties —Botanical Writings of Aiton, Relhan, eyes Martyn, Bolton, Thunberg, Tournefort, &c. —Sowerby’ 8 Fung ls.—Turner’s Fuci, 2 vols.—Gmelin, Historia Fucorum—Schefier, Icones Fungorum, 5 vols. — Bulliard, Champignons, 5 vols.—(Eder, Flora Danica, 12 vols.—Stac house’s Nereis Britannica—Turner’s Herbal, Parkinson’s Herbal, and Paradisi in Sole—Matthiolus de Plantis—Wafer's Isthmus of America, 1699—D'Acuyna’s South America, 1698—Venega’s California, 1759—and other interesting Rooks of Travel. Also a Library of Modern French Historical Works in neat bindings—Mahogany and other Bookcases, &c. To be viewed, and Catalogues had.

THE LAKELANDS LIBRARY. N ESSRS. SOTHEBY, WILKINSON & HODGE will SELL by AU CTION, at their House, No. 13, Wellington- street, Strand, wef C., THIS anes (SATURDAY), March 21, and Three Fol- lowing Days, atlo "clock prec! rs the important and valuable LIBRARY of the late W. iL CRAWFORD, sq., of elands, coe. Cork. May be viewed. Catalogues may be had, price 3s. 6d. each,

Coins and Medals, the Fes gi of the late F. H. DUTTON, Esq., and others. N ESSRS. SOTHEBY, WILKINSON & HODGE will SELL by AUCTION, at their House, No. 13, Weningson- street, Strand, W.C., on MONDAY, March 23, and Two Following I A at 1 o'clock ‘precisely, the valuable COLLECTIONS of ENGLIS H, SCOTTISH, FOREIGN, GREEK and ROMAN COINS and MEDALS, the Pr Ap esky of ee late F. H. DU TTON, Esq., a PRIVATE GENTLE- MAN, deceased, and others; com rising In Gotp: British Staters— Nobles of Edward IIl., Richard Henry V. and VI.—Angels of Edward IV. and Henry VIII. pe of Henry VIII —Fine Sove- reign of Elizabeth—Rose Ryal of James I.—Oxford Three Pound Piece of Charles I.—Five Guinea Pieces of Charles I1., William II1., and Anne —Two Guinea Pieces of Anne and George I.—Pattern Two Guineas of George Il —Pattern Two Pound Piece of William A, . In SILVER: Pennies of Bu Ered, ere os Alfred, Eadred, r, Eadmund, Acthelstan, Harold II., &.—Crowns of Edward vie livabeth, and James I.—Exeter uae ns and Oxford Half-pound Piece of Charles Se _ Newark Half-Crown—Ormond Crown—Pattern Crown and Shillin Cromwell. Scorrisu: Testoons of gees and Francis and Mary— of Henry and Mary and James VI., &c. Also several interesting series of Greek and Roman Coins, in gold, silver, and copper—the Numismatic Library ofa og Nobleman and that of an Othcer—and some well- made Coin Cabinets.

urst, Kent; or from Mr. Davin J. CHArTELL, of 29a (corner of), Lincoln's

#41, Brompton-road; and 2, King-street, Cheapside

Inn-tields and Chislehurst, who strongly recommends the property.

May be viewed we days prior, Catalogues may be had; if by post on recept of four stamps,

in oh ii os th M 2 f Pe Ol

Page 3

we = ~ Qa ee "| ew rT Ie ee eee N° 3308, Marcu 21, 91 THE ATHENAUM 363 The Library 0 _ late Sir LOUIS JACKSON, 0, id ft ‘adleigh Hall, Suffolk. w ESSRS. SOTHEBY, WILKINSON & HODGE N will SELL by pages at their vip No. 13, Wellington- street, KET Bohs m THURSDAY, April 2, ree Fuulewis 4, at lo i precise! ly, the LIBRARY “of t the late Sir LOU Dare GON, 0! on Maadlet h Hall, Suffolk, comprising Standard English, French, German, @ and Italian Works, including numerous Publications on India (ineluding Law) and relating to the East—County Histories (especially of Suffolk)—Voyages and Travels in various Countries— Works of — and Fore! gn Dramatists and Novelists—Transactions of Learned Societies—Selby’s splendid Illustrations of British Orni- thology—Jardine’s Naturalist’s Library—Blake’s Marri of Heaven and Hell—Harris’s Portraits of African Game and Wild Animals—and other Books of Prints. May be viewed two day prior. Catalogues may be had ; if by post, on receipt of four stamps. A valuable Collection of Coins and Medals, the Property A the late Hon. GEORGE WOOD, M.L.C., of Graham's Town, Cape of Good Hope. MESSES. SOTHEBY, WILKINSON & HODGE will SELL by AUCTION, * their House, No. 13, Wellington- oma. Strand, W.C.,on MONDAY ril 6, and Two Followin Days, at l o'clock precisely, a valuable COLLE ‘CTION of ENGLISH, FOREIGN, GREEK, and ROMAN COINS and Bhopaenans the Pro avg of the late Hon. GEORGE WOOD, M.L.C., of Graham's Town, to og Good Hope, comprisin; Sag Pe gal °Nobles of Edward and IV., Richard II., and V. and VI.—Angels from Henry VIL to Eliza- beth—James L. lamvele and Half Laurels—Charles I. Oxford Three Pound and One Pound Pieces — Pattern Broads of Cromwell and Charles II.— Five Guinea Pieces of Charles II. and William III.— George III. Pattern Two Guineas, by Tanner, and Seven Shillings, by Yeo. Scottish: James IIT Unicorn—James V. Bonnet Piece—Mary Lion and Testoon—James VI. Hat Piece, &c. Strver: Pennies of Edgar and Edred—Crowns of Edward VI. to James I.—Oxford Half Pound Piece—Exeter Crown-— Bristol and Oxford Half-Crowns of Charles I. ; also Mint Sets of 1831 and 1839—an interesting Series of a Gold Coins and Roman Aurei; also an enroneene Collection of Foreign Orders and Decorations, Cabinets, May be viewed two days prior. nies may be had; if by post, on on receipt of four ‘stamps. The Library of the -_ CHARLES ROACH SMITH, Esq., F.S.A. N ESSRS. SOTHEBY, WILKINSON & HODGE i will SELL b by A N, at jhelr House, No. 13, Wellington- street, Strand, W.C, + DAY, April 7, at 1 'o clock lager dh ae LIBRARY of the iste (CHARLES Si Ng SMITH, Esq., F. by order of Col. CHAS. JOLLIF R.M.A., and GEORGE ROBINSON. Esq., the Executors), anaeien: ot Works on wraps Prehistoric Remains, British, Roman, and Anglo-Saxon Antiquitie of Archeological Societies, both English and Continental—Numismata, various Works written by the late C. R_ Smith, Esq., his own Collec- tions and Note-Books—also the whole of the remainder of his Collec- tanea Antiqua, including the Copper-Plates and Woodcuts of that and other Works written by him. May be viewed two days prior. Catalogues may be had of the Avcrionrens; or from Grorce Roxtnson, Esq., Solicitor, Strood; if by post, 0 on receipt of two stamps. An important and valuable Collection of Autograph Letters and Manuscripts. ‘ , \ ESSRS SOTHEBY, WILKINSON & HODGE will SELL by AUCTION, at their House, No. 13, Wellington- street, Strand, W.C.; on WEDNESDAY, April 8, ‘and Following Day, at 1 o'clock precisely, an important and valuable COLLECTION of AUTO- GRAPH LETTERS and MANUSCRIPTS, from various Private Sources, comprising Interesting Letters of James Boswell, Robert Burns, eck cg ott Carlyle, Charles Dickens, P. B. Shelley, Dr. Johnson, L. Sterne, George Eliot, Dr. Swift, A. Pope, Thackeray, Benjamin Franklin, C. Lamb, Lord Strafford, Mrs. Browning, Byron, Coleridge, J. J. Rous- seau, D. Hume—Albums of Autographs. May be viewed two days prior. Catalogues may be had; if by post, on receipt of four stamps. The Collection of — ed Stones ~~ "eas of the Rev. W. F. SHORT, " \ ESSRS. SOTHEBY, WIL KINSON & HODGE will rye! by AUCTION. at their House, No. 13, Wellington- Strand, , on THURSDAY, April 9, at 1 o'clock precisely, the TION t's "ENGRAV ED STONES and ANTIQUITIES of the F. SHORT, M.A., &c, comprising Babylonian and Assyrian ¢ siinarical Seals— Egy ptian and Etruscan Scarabei—Greek and Roman Intagli anil Camei—a large number of Gnostic Talismans, &c. The Miscellaneous qos comprise a most important Gold Pendant Ornament, with oh ennai an i Bags ergo and other Objects in Glass. Glazed Ware, Bro: &e Antiquities, Gems, Cylin- ders, &c., of the late Rev. Dr. CHU ROHILL ‘BABINGT ‘ON. May be viewed two days prior. Catalogues may be had. Porcelain, Oljects of Art, and Decorative Furniture of G. FARNHAM, Esq., and others; Tapestry, §c. ~ Tr N ESSRS. CHRISTIE, MANSON & WOODS respectfully give notice that they will SELL by AUCTION, at their pe Rooms, King-street, St. James’s-square, on MONDAY, March 23, at 1 o'clock precisely, a COLLECTION of PORCELAIN and DECORATIVE OLJECTS, the Property of G. FARNHAM, Esq., re- moved from his Residence, Quorndon House, Loughborough, com- rising Old Nankin, enamelled Chinese, and Old Japan Porcelain, Sévres, dresden, and other European Porcelain— Worcester and Derby Services —Bronzes—Clocks—and a few pieces of Jecorative Furniture—also Porcelain—Decorative Objects—Old French and English Furniture— Old French and Flemish Tapestry, &c., from various Private Sources. May be viewed, and Catalogues had. The Collection of Pictures of the ate W. RENDALL, Esq. ESSRS. CHRISTIE, MANSON & WOODS respectfully give notice that they will SELL by AUCTION, at their Great Rooms, Kin: roth St. James’s-square, on TUESDAY, March 24, at 1 o'clock y (by order of the Executors), the COL. LECTION of ANC MENT 1 my MODERN PICTURES of WILLIAM RENDALL, Esq , deceased, and others from different Private Collec- tions, comprising Works of B. Blake R. Elsheimer A. Storck G. Barret A. Hondius J. Vernet J. Both Van der Heyden M. de Vos Breughel F. Hals R. Wilson L. Backhuyzen J. C. Ibbotson Wynants A. Everdingen P. Mignard Cc. May be viewed, and Catalogues had. The Library of the late G. ROOTS, Esq., F.S.A. ESSRS. CHRISTIE, MANSON & WOODS respectfully give notice that they will SELL by AUCTION, at er Great Rooms, King-street, St. James’s-square, on ‘WEDNESDAY, March 25, at 1 o'clock precisely (by order of the rds og the L IBRARY of GEORGE ROOTS, Esq,, F.S.A., late of Ashley-place, 8. W., deceased, cemains County Histories— Works on Archxology— - historic Remain: sritish h, Ro oman, and 73 nglo-Saxon Antiquities— Heraldry and G f &c.—a few Engrayings ¢ ‘and ‘anne and A selection of Books from other Collections. May be viewed two days preceding, and Catalogues had. Modern Etchings and Engravings. ESSRS. CHRISTIE, MANSON & WOODS respectfully give notice that they will SELL by AUCTION, at their Great Rooms, King-street, St. James’s-square, on WEDNESD. March 25, at 1 o'clock precisely, Choice Modern EICHIN GS and EN: GRAV. Sones = ior Works of A. H. Haig, ue Debaines, R. W. Macbeth, A. Law, C. Aygo by 8. Cousins, and cat after Sir E. Landseer, R.A., Sir r hton, P R.A., Sir J! E. Millias, R.A. Also Mezzotints after Bir J. Reynolds, T. Gains borough, R.A., G. Morland, works of F. Bartolozzi and others of the Early English School. May be viewed two days preceding, and Catalogues hat had. THURSDAY NEXT-- —Photographic A pparatus, §e. R. J. C. STEVENS will SELL by AUCTION, at nes Crees t Rooms, 38, King-street, Covent-garden, on THURS- DAY NEXT, March 26, at half-past 12 o'clock prec aay PHOTOGRA- PHIC APPARATUS, comprising Cameras and Lenses by good makers, Tripod and Studio Stands, Dry Plates, Photographs, Sp tor and Race Glasses—Microscopes and Slides — Telescopes — Electrical and Galvanic Accessories— ¢ Lanterns and Slides—Furniture, Books, Pictures, and Miscellaneous Property. . = view day prior from 2 till 5 and morning of Sale, and Catalogues ad. A DIAMOND of 39 CARATS, a finely proportioned Brilliant-cut stone, of great lustre and free from marks—a NECKLACE with THREE PENDANTS, set with upwards of FORTY FINE PINK PEARLS— a HALF-HOOP BRACELET, consisting of Thirteen Brilliants, weigh- ing 16 Carats—a Pair of choice old Brilliant Top and Drop Earrings— a large Assemblage of DIAMOND ORNAMENTS—some ANCIENT PLATE—100 LOTS of GOLD and SILVER WALTHAM WATCHES, &e. | EBENHAM, STORR & SONS will SELL as above, at their Great Mart, 26, King-street, Covent-garden, on Ww EDNESDAY NEXT, March 25, at 12 o'clock. On view from Saturday. Catalogues post free. The QUARTERLY SALE of Miscellaneous Works of Art, Paintings, Books. China, Musical, Surgical, Mathematical, and other Instruments, Opera Glasses, Intaglios, Carvings, &c. On MONDAY, APRIL 6, Miscellanies, as above. On TUESDAY, APRIL 7, many Thousand Volumes of Books, in all Classes of Literature, &c. On WEDNESDAY, APRIL 8, acontinuation of the Qarterly Sale of Miscellanies. On THURSDAY, APRIL 9, 80 Pianofortes, in Walnut, Rosewood, and Mahogany Cases, and including some fine Instruments by Broadwood Sons, Erard, and others; various Musical, Optical, and Surgical Instruments, Bronzes, Mic: croscepes, Telescopes, Old China, Books, Paintings, Marble Busts and Statuettes, &c. On FRIDAY and SATURDAY, APRIL 10 and 11, Gallery and Cabinet Paintings by and after esteemed Masters, Prints, Drawings, Etchings, and Miscellanies. On MONDAY, APRIL 13 and during the week, similar Sales. D) ie store 8A STORR & SONS beg to announce the above SALES. 26, King-street, Covent-garden. Commence daily at 12 o'clock. To Bankers, Solicitors, Trustees, Executors, and others.— Jewels, Watches, Plate, Clocks, Dressing-cases, and other Valuable Effects disposed of publicly Three or Four Days in each week at ] EBENHAM, STORR & SONS’ AUCTION MART, 26, King-street, Covent-garden, London, Three or Four Days in each week. and full market value realized. ‘Terms and Catalogues on application. At 72, RENFIELD-STREET, GLASGOW, on MONDAY, March 23, and Five Following Days, commencing at 12 o'clock each day. PUBLIC SALE of the extensive and valuable LIBRARY of the late PETER FORBES, Esq., Writer, Glasgow, comprising Works on Scottish History and Antiquities—Fine Arts—Club Books—Private Printed Publications—large and interesting Collections of Books on Glasgow—best Library Editions of the Standard Authors —and Works in all Classes of Literature, many of them in fine Bindings. Also a valuable LAW LIBRARY. \ JALTER J. BUCHANAN will SELL by PUBLIC AUCTION as above. Catalogues, price 1s., to be had on application to the AucrioneEn. 72, Renfield-street, Glasgow, March 14, 1891. Finely Illustrated Works—Egyptological Book re Rare Antique Furniture, China, PYCROFT HOUSE, CHERTSEY, Seven ait Chertsey Station (on L. and S.W.R.). ESSRS. WATERER & SONS are instructed by the BARON DE CO8SON to SELL by AUCTION, on the Premises, oa MONDAY, March 23, at half-past 11 o’clock prompt, the CONTE) of the RESIDENCE, including usual Furniture—Seven Octave de by Pleyel— —Ornamental thina—Objets d’Art—rare Antique Furniture—old Flemish Oak Cabinet, 2ft. 3in —Achromatic and Reflecting ent peat Seventy Engravings (all framed and glazed) by Bartolozzi, 8. W. Reynolds, Edelinck, Hollar, Thos. Land- seer, and others. The Books include Pyne’s Royal Residences—The Copper-plate Magazine—Hone’s Every -day and other Books, Original Editions—Brookshaw’s eee Britannica—Owen Jones’s Alhambra— Rooks on Costumes—Hand- Books on China and the Chinese— Helman's Engravings to Les Cc ‘onquétes de l’Empéreur de la Chine— Ruskin’s Modern Painters -- Art Books — Cassini’s Map of France— (Euvres de Gessner, and other Books—Gillray’s Caricatures—several Egyptological Books from the Library of the late J BONOMI, Esq., ant many others Catalogue of the Avcrionrgrs, at either of their Offices at Chertsey, Weybridge Station, and Walton-on-Thames. PEACHERS’ SCRIPTURAL LIBRARY OF SHILLING BOOKS. By W. T. LYNN, B.A.,F.R.AS. 1. BIBLE CHRONOLOGY and DICTIONARY; or, the Principal Events recorded in the Ho! re es tures, arranged under their probable respective ——_ with a D Greta giving an account of the places named, an Appendix on English Trans- lations of the Bible, and Six Maps. 2. BRIEF LESSONS on the PARABLES and MIRACLES of OUR LORD. The First Part contains short expo- sitions of the Parables, arranged according to Date ; in the Second, the Miracles are treated under the heads ofthe Regions in which they were wrought. With Two Lilustrations. 8. EMINENT SCRIPTURE CHARACTERS: a Series of Biographical Studies in the Old and New Testaments. yar written for the popular monthly periodical Youth and e, these short ex tory Essaysare now collected intoa volume, i ustrated by six views of Biblical Scenes, which will, it is hoped, be found useful to all who are interested in the study of the Holy Scriptures. Published by George Stoneman, 21, Warwick-lane, Paternoster-row, E.C. Now ready, Price One Shilling, YHE TEMPLE BAR MAGAZINE, Contents for APRIL, 1891. MR. CHAINE'S SONS. Chaps. 13-16. The BARD of OLNEY. WHIST. THOSE WESTERTON GIRLS. Chaps. 1-4. WHY WE LOVE a MAN-OF-WAR. GEOLOGICAL BEMINISCENCES. “La BELLA.” Part I. APOLOGIA MEA. RECOLLECTIONS of an OCTOGENARIAN CIVIL SERVANT. (Conclusion.) LOVE or MONEY. Chaps. 14-17. Richard Bentley & Son, New Burlington-street. 39 Er Moo fo rm S Now ready, price One Shilling, GS CRIBNER'S MAGAZINE. APRIL, 1891. Contents. — = of the VOYAGE. Frontispiece. Drawn by Charles Brough- outst PASSENGER TRAVEL. John H. so (Being the first Paper of a series upon Ocean ) ith Ill A KANGAROO HUNT. Birge Harrison. “ml i from P is by the Author. HORACE, BOOK I., ODE XXI.—In HONOR of DIANA and APOLLO. = hg Francis’s Translation, 1831.) The Illustration by J. R. Yeguelin. GASPAR NUNEZ de ARCE. RolloOgden. With Portrait. The MEANING of the DAKOTA OUTBREAK. Herbert Welsh. With a Map of the Sioux Indian Reservation. SPRING SONG. Graham R. Tomson. The PHENIX. Bliss Perry. WHAT is RIGHT-HANDEDNESS? Thomas Dwight, M.D., Professor of Anatomy in the Harvard Medical School. ith numerous Illus trations prepared under the direction of the Author. WHERE the ICE NEVER MELTS—The CRUISE of the U.S. STEAMER ‘““THETIS” in 1889 Robert Gordon Butler. [Illustrations from Drawings by W. L. Metcalf and W. L. Taylor. JERRY. Part Third, Chapters 13, 14. (To be concluded in May.) The RELIEF of CAPTAIN NELSON. A. J. Mounteney Jephson, of the Emin Pasha Relief Expedition. Illustrated by eric Villiers. NIGHT. Archibald Lampman. The STORY of the FRESH AIR FUND. Willard Parsons. The POINT of VIEW: Cloistral Criticism—As to the Long-Engaged— The Investigation of Crime. Frederick Warne & Co. bes Bedford-street, Strand. Price einsin, Monthly. 7 H E L A D D E R for APRIL will be published on TUESDAY NEXT, Containing— The PROGRESS of the EMPIRE. The COMING CENSUS. LEADERS of the PEOPLE. SMALL HOLDINGS. A HINT to the CHANCELLOR of the EXCHEQUER. FIRESIDE READINGS. LITERARY and SCIENTIFIC ARTICLES. CONTEMPORARY THOUGHT, HOME and FOREIGN. STANDARD :—‘The third number deserves all the encomiums we bestowed on the first. There is not a trivial page in it from beginning to end.” ATHEN ZUM :—“ Most useful.” SPECTATOR :—“ None deserves more encouragement. ”’ ST. JAMES’S GAZETTE :—“ Popular but thoughtful articles.” MANCHESTER COURIER:—“ An admirable production. . and interesting.” EXPOSITORY TIMES:—“* Thoroughly deserving....Will most as- suredly prove a great force in education. SCOTTISH LEADER :—“A varied and admirable programme.” MANCHESTER EXAMINER:—“ Has been received with unstinted praise by all the reviewers.” LIVERPOOL POST:—‘ Great amount of rare ability,” &c. An EXTENSION STUDENT writes :—‘‘I am taking out the Ladder, and am exactly suited with it.” Marshall Bros., London. At all leading B . Brilliant 3’ and B NOTES and QUERIES. (SEVENTH SERIES.) THIS WEEK'S NUMBER contains— NOTES :—she Old Cemetery at Ostend—A Remarkable Pedigree — ‘Thomas Hood’s Monument—Anonymous Works—N. Breton: Blay- ing — Modern Phases of English Words — Funerals in London— Boyne’s Trade Tokens—To Inone—The Hol oe ulchre—Pheenicians in Devonshire—Saying for a Wet Day—Sir chardson—Lines by Sydney Smith — Tennis Court in te ano Heine and Justin Mevarthy. QUERIES :— The Bloodie Banquet '"—Seguidillas—‘‘ The Princes Armes” —Portrait of Lord Tennyson—‘ Lillibullero’—Cologne Cathedral— Anglo-Saxon Personal Names— Holy-water Clerk—sir H. Bishop— R. Whittington—The ‘Fall "—Scottish ‘kook of Common Order '— Elisabetta Sirani—A Challenge to Tieck— Burns's Sonnets—Lady Hewley’s Charity—Sir W. Cosiipai ee Hon. Mrs. Ward—Silver Quill Pens—8. Garbett—Grace before Meat—Shakspearian Con- cordance—‘‘ Ones "—Bowman—R. Hover—Abbess Alice St. Botolph Register—Author Wanted. REPLIES :—Hoods— Memoria Technica— Newton an Aseassin—Lord W. Bentinck’s Minutes—Nursery Rhymes—Riot—O'Shaughnesey— Assassination of Perceval—Carmichael Family—Quarr Abbey J— ‘Wax Models—FEgerton—A Long Lease—Charlotte Braeme—Swaatika —Tiers — William Lea age —Crucifix in Banana—Old Proverb— Title ‘‘Sir”—Warin: De la Warenne—Names of Oxen—Grayson— Rove—W. Howley—Gold th in Peckha at Sand- gate—Origin of Garis Forgorie_—Kavote—Mise Sumi tameee Family — Precedence 0 Restoring Engravings— Riddio: “A headless man”—Gin Palaces. TES on BOOKS: — Rhys’s ‘Studies in the Arthurian Legend’ — = Fara Memorials of Southwell Minster’—‘ Bygones relating to Wales. Notices to Correspondents, &c. Published by John C. Francis, 22, Took’s-court, Cursitor-street, Chancery-lane, E.C. Now ready, price 6d. (THE ADHESIVE POSTAGE STAMP; Removal of Official Documents from H.M. Treasury by Sir Rowland Hull; Discovery of Contents pate Title of James Cnatmers, with ace from Mr. Rowland Hill. Mr. Wallace, P., Mr. Joseph Hume, M and others. By PATRICK CHALMERS, Fellow of the ae Histo Society. London: Effingham Wilson & Co. Royal Exchan

Page 4

364 THE ATHENAUM N° 3308, Manon 21, °91 SPENCER BLACKETT’S NEW BOOKS. —~>—_ Now ready, crown 8vo. cloth extra, price 2s. 6d., postage 3d, CARD-SHARPERS: their Tricks Exposed ; or, the Art of always Winning. By ROBERT HOUDIN. With Explanatory Diagrams. NEW NOVEL BY LADY FAIRLIE CUNINGHAME. At all Booksellers’ and Libraries, crown 8vo. cloth, price 6s. The SLAVE of HIS WILL. By Lady FAIRLIE CUNINGHAME. NEW AND CHEAPER EDITION OF H. RIDER HAGGARD'S NOVEL. At all Booksellers’ and Bookstalls, uniform with ‘Dawn,’ crown 8vo. cloth extra, price 3s. 6d. with 16 Full-Page Illustrations by Charles Kerr, The WITCH’S HEAD. By H. Rider ae Author of ‘Allan’s Wife,’ ‘Mr. Meeson’s POPULAR EDITION OF L. B. WALFORD’S NOVELS. Now ready, at all Booksellers’ and Bookstalls, cloth extra, price 2s. 6d., with Frontispiece engraved in Paris from drawings by Laslet J. Pott, A STIFF-NECKED GENERATION. =. B. WALFORD. Uniform with ‘Pauline,’ ‘ Cousins,’ r. Smith,’ &c. NEW NOVEL BY BRANDON ROY. At all Libraries, in 3 vols. GUY MERVYN. By Brandon Roy. London : SPENCER BLACKETT, 35, St. Bride-street, E.C. Demy 8vo. cloth, 5s. SAFE STUDIES. By the Hon. Mr, and Mrs, LIONEL A. TOLLEMACHE. Contents. HISTORICAL PREDICTION. Sir G@. C. LEWIS and LONGEVITY. LITERARY EGOTISM RECOLLECTIONS of Mr. GROTE and Mr. BABBAGE. Mr. rae ane ° nore PHILOSOPHY. CHARLES AUSTI PHYSICAL and MORAL COURAGE. The UPPER ENGADINE NOTES and RECOLLECTIONS of Sir CHARLES WHEAT- STONE, DEAN STANLEY, and CANON KINGSLEY. The EPICURIST’S LAMENT. TRANSLATIONS and POEMS. Demy 8vo. cloth, 2s. 6d. STONES of STUMBLING. By the Hon. LIONEL A. TOLLEMACHE. Contents. The CURE for INCURABLES. The FEAR of Hay FEARLESS DEATHS. DIVINE ECONOMY of TRUTH. Appendices. *RECOLLECTIONS of ae Mr. ROMANKS’S CATECHISM NEOCHRISTIANITY and NEOCATHOLICISM : a Sequel. * This is also published separately, demy 8vo. cloth, 1s. earn Tollemache’s essays seem to us to possess literary merit of a and Len order. e is not peso reef anecdotic, he is , and appreciative, and many of "these" ae are also exhib -y his more speculative and less perso papers. His recollections of Grote, Charles Austin, and Pattison are full of interestin; mage anecdote and suggestive co comment, while those of Bab’ ies Wheatstone, tanley, and Canon ley belo’ one to yay order. We can best enforce oa favourable judgment of these denne dacs pe yea wed by quotin, from a letter received from Pattison, m be h sent the privately- ee edition, which, of course, aid 3 pA the paper on Pattison himself :—‘I should gay oy the papers on the Whole show viz., a cuit, 4 ever com 8u is here sod al pointra of your argu- range of as ment must be matter of wonder. ‘t ee a if you could draw at pleasure upon ali lit — from the classics down to Robert Mont- gomery Swinburne.’ this judgment we cordially concur.” Times, March 5, 1891. London; WILLIAM RICE, 86, Fleet-street, E.C. ie ART of WEAVING by HAND and POWER. ATSON. Price 8s.—The ART sp SPINNING and THRESD MAEING By JOHN WATSON. ice rge Watson & Son, 162, Imgram-street, Glasgow. Simpkin Marshall & Co. London. HATTERTON and the VICAR of TEMPLE CHURCH, BRISTOL. By W. GEORGE. Folding Facsimile of the Poet’s Account of the ‘ Knightes Templaries Chyrche’ and 3 other Illustrations. 8vo. 16 pp. wrapper, 1s. 6d. post free. Bristol, 1 “We would commend it to collectors of Chattertonians.”—Academ y. NEW FACTS relating to the CHATTERTON FAMILY, from Manuscript Entries in ~ History of the Bible’ and from Parish Registers. 8vo. 16 pp. 1s. post free. Bristol, 1883 “Will be wel to the coll of Ch jana. The editor’s annotated index is a marvel of exhaustiveness.”—Times and Mirror. William George's Sons, Park-street, Bristol. ¥ & Tf. CLARK’S 2.8 2. e oe DECLARATIONS and LETTERS on the VATICAN DECREES, 1869-1887. By J.J I. VON DOLLINGER. Authorized ‘Translation. Just published, crown 8vo. 3s. 6d. “Indispensable to every one who would have an intelligent grasp of the Infallibility question.”—Dr. Alfred Plummer. MESSIANIC PROPHECY: its Origin, Historical Growth, and Relation to New Testament Fulfilment. By Dr. EDWARD RIEHM. Translated by the Rev. L. A. MUIRHEAD, M.A., with an Introduction by Professor A. B. DAV IDSON, Edin- burgh. Post 8vo. 7s. 6d. PRE-ORGANIC EVOLUTION and the BIBLICAL IDEA of GOD. An Exposition and a Criticism. By C. CHAPMAN, LL.D., Principal of Western College, Plymouth. Crown 8vo. 6s. MESSIANIC PROPHECIES in HISTORICAL SUCCESSION. By Professor FRANZ DELITZSCH, D.D., Leipzig. Just published, in crown 8vo. 5s. Note.—This was Professor Delitzsch’s final literary work. ‘The last printed sheet was laid on his bed the day before he died. PHILOSOPHY and THEOLOGY: being the First Edinburgh Seed Gifford Lectures. By J. HUTCHISON STIRLING, LL.D. Post 8vo. 9s. “We feel that Dr. Stirling has done splendid service, both to the history of philosophy and theology and to these great sciences them- selves.”—Professor Ivenacn in the: ritish Weekly. DELITZSCH'S ‘ISAIAH.’ Now ready, 8vo. 21s. Authorized Translation of the Fourth Edition. Note.—In his Preface the Author states that this Fourth Edition con- tains the fruit of his continued labour, and that a thorough revisal of the whole has been made since the Third Edition was published many years ago. Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark, 38, George-street; to be had from all Booksellers. in 2 vols, Orn COTTAGE and DOMESTIC ARCHITEC. "enol Wie, tent bone te Fame Now os the Author, Rolls Chambers, 89, Chancery-lane, W.C. Published this day, New Novel, 1s L OVE: THE KEY. By Curosi, Dodd, Eyton & Co. 65 and 66, Chancery-lane, London, W.C. MR. HERBERT SPENCER'S ESSAYS. LIBRARY EDITION. ES884y¥s SCIENTIFIC, POLITICAL, ane SPECULATIVE. By HERBERT * SPENCER Library Edition, 3 vols. 8vo. (each 10s. } with minor additions and Seven more Essays. Ss. M® HERBERT SPENCER’S WORKS. THE DOCTRINE OF EVOLUTION. FIRST PRINCIPLES. 8th Thousand. 16s. PRINCIPLES of BIOLOGY. 4th Thousand. 2 vols, PRINCIPLES of PSYCHOLOGY. 5th Thousand. 2 vols. 36s PRINCIPLES of SOCIOLOGY. Vol. I. Third Edition, 21s. The Same. Vol. II. (Ceremonial and Political Institutions), 2nd Thousand. 18s. POLITICAL INSTITUTIONS (separately). 2nd Thousand, 12s. ECCLESIASTICAL INSTITUTIONS. 2nd Thou- sand. 8yo. cloth, 5s. The DATA of ETHICS. 6th Thousand, 8z. OTHER WORKS. The STUDY of SOCIOLOGY. Library Edition (the 9th). 8vo. 10s. 6d. EDUCATION. 6th Thousand. 6s. Also Cheap Edition, 25th Thousand, 2s. 6d. The MAN versus The STATE. In cloth, 8th Thou- sand, 2s.6d. Also Cheap Edition, 11th Thousand, 1s. The FACTORS of ORGANIC EVOLUTION. 8vo. cloth, 2s. 67, Williams & Norgate, London and Edinburgh. A PUBLISHER AND HIS FRIENDS. NEXT WEEK, with Portraits, 2 vols. 8vo. 32s. MEMOIR AND CORRESPONDENCE OF THE LATE JOHN MURRAY, WITH AN ACCOUNT OF THE ORIGIN AND PROGRESS OF THE HOUSE, 1768-1843 By SAMUEL SMILES, LL.D. JOHN Murray, Albemarle-street. NEW NOVEL BY THE AUTHOR OF ‘THE STORY OF PHILIP METHUEN.’ At all Libraries, 3 vols. crown 8vo. cloth, 31s. 6d. STEPHEN ELLICOTTS DAUGHTER. By Mrs. NEEDELL, Author of ‘Julian Karslake’s Secret,’ ‘ Philip Methuen,’ &c. ‘‘ Rarely, indeed, are lovers of real life indulged with so interesting a heroine and hero as those of Mrs. Needell’s admir- able novel, ‘ Stephen Ellicott’s Daughter.’ novels of this or many seasons. The book is full of able things in diction and in thought. Refined and thoughtful from end to end, yet vigorously alive with human interest, a very It is one of the best excellent piece of work, and one that must not be missed.”—Court Journal, ‘* Like all the previous works of this accomplished author, it is distinguished by loftiness of aim, grace of diction, and purity of treatment. conceived and brilliantly carried out.”— Scotsman. At the same time it is not lacking in emotional or sensational incidents. The plot has been boldly ‘‘Mrs. Needell has written nothing more absorbing or more skilfully constructed than this romance of English country life. If less concentrated than the ‘ Philip Methuen’ of the same author, it is brighter reading, and shows a greater mastery in the delineation of character and in the natural flow of the dialogue. Mrs. Needell excels, in fact, in the fidelity with which she depicts mental endowments and idiosyncrasies, the result being that she places before her readers not so many puppets disguised for this or that impersonation, but with that rare art in which art is concealed, her creations have all the strong and weak attributes of our common humanity, be the social scale high or low.”—Leeds Mercury. ‘“«*Stephen Ellicott’s Daughter’ is the best story which Mrs. Needell has written, and one of the best which has been published this season. forth in action the distinctive characters of the actors in the drama. The plot is probable, coherent, well constructed, carefully developed, and admirably serves to set The novel is much more one of character than of incident, and Mrs. Needell has shown great skill in analyzing and setting forth the mind-workings of her leading personages under stress of the various trials and temptations to which it is exposed.”—Nottingham Daily Guardian. ‘‘The plot of the story is good and the characters are capitally developed. Full of interesting problems, with many well-drawn characters, the novel repays perusal, and Mrs, Needell has to be congratulated on her treatment of the story.” Preston Guardian, “* Stephen Ellicott’s Daughter’ is much to be commended. It is a good story carefully told, and involving in its course some very interesting problems.”—Manchester Guardian. “While Mrs. Needell endows all her characters with the requisite amount of individuality, her gentlemen are gentlemen and her women are well-bred ladies. this novel. Ellicott’s Daughter.’”—Chester Courant. It is as a literary performance, however, that we wish more particularly to commend The writer knows how to write gracefully, and this rare accomplishment is apsarent on every page of ‘ Stephen London: FREDERICK WARNE & Co, Bedford-street, Strand.

Page 5

Ne 3308, Marcx 21, 91 THE ATHENEUM

365

MESSRS. LONGMANS & CO.’S LIST. SIR EDWIN ARNOLD’S NEW POEM. THE LIGHT OF THE WORLD; Or, THE GREAT CONSUMMATION. A POEM. By Sir EDWIN ARNOLD, K.C.LE. Author of ‘ The Light of Asia,’ &c. Crown 8vo, 7s, 6d, net. DAILY NEWS.—‘‘The multitude of readers who were delighted and instructed by ‘ The Light of Asia’ will turn to this new volume with lively expectation......The whole burden of the poem is to set forth the joyful aspect of the Christain faith as compared with that of Buddha.” CHRISTIAN WORLD.—“ The poet's real task is to compare Christ’s character and teaching with the character and doctrine of Buddha, and in this task he has accomplished signal success...... The Spirit is reverent and devout, nor does the verse fail in nobility of thought or beauty of form.” ARCHDEACON FARRAR in LONGMAN’S MAGAZINE.—“ The author of this book has little to fear from com- rison with any other poet of our time, and the intrinsic merit of his poems will secure them a permanent place in English literature......For myself I can only say that I have read it with delight and with keen interest. It seems to me to be a very beautiful poem, rich in noble thoughts. I venture to prophesy for it a wide and loving appreciation wherever the English language is spoken. I believe that it will be even more popular than ‘ The Light of Asia.’’ VOL. II, OF GARDINER’S STUDENT'S HISTORY OF ENGLAND. A STUDENTS HISTORY of ENGLAND. From the Earliest Times to 1885. By SAMUEL RAWSON GARDINER, M.A. LL.D., Fellow of All Souls’ College, Oxford, &. (Three Volumes.) Vol. I. B.c. 55-a.p. 1509. With 173 Illustrations. Crown 8vo. 4s. (ready). Vol. II, 1509-1689. With 96 Illustrations. Crown 8vo. 4s. (just published). Vol. III. (in preparation). “A work distinguished by accuracy and clearness of statement, sobriety of judgment, and a due sense of historical proportion...... The story is told in a bright and pleasing manner; the style is easy and simple; and the illustrations with which the book is abundantly supplied are excellently chosen and executed, and throw much light on the history ef the times to which they belong...... Prof. Gardiner will lead his students to think—a thing most necessary for students, especially perhaps, students of history.”— Atheneum. NEW BOOK BY HENRY DUNNING MACLEOD. The THEORY of CREDIT. By Henry Dunnine Macteop, M.A., of Trinity College, Cambridge, and the Inner Temple, Barrister-at-Law. 8vo. Vol. II. Part I. 4s. 6d. (ready). Vol. II. Part II. 10s. 6d, Gust published). “Mr. Macleod does not exaggerate the importance or the novelty of an English book on the subject which he has undertaken. Noman understands better than an Englishman of business the practical side of credit, and few men under- stand so little as Englishmen how to formulate their ideas on the subject. This defect Mr. Macleod proposes to supply, and few Englishmen are better qualified than he to supply it.”—Law Journal. The SEAL of FATE. A Novel. By Watrer H. Pottock and Lady POLLOCK. 1 vol. crown 8vo. 6s. [Next week. FAMOUS GOLF LINKS. Horace HuvrtTCHINSON, ANDREW LANG, H. S. C. EVERARD, T. RUTHERFORD CLARK, &c. With numerous Illustrations by F. P. Hopkins, T. Hodges, H. S. King, and from Photographs. Crown 8vo. 6s. RHYMELETS. By Epwarp Locke Tomurn. Crown 8vo.

THEOLOGICAL LIST. The ORACLES of GOD: Nine Lectures on the Nature and Extent of Biblical Inspiration and the Special Significance of the Old Testament Scriptures at the Present Time. By W. SANDAY, M.A. D.D. LL.D., Dean Ireland’s Professor of Exegesis. Crown 8vo, 4s. MAXIMS and GLEANINGS from the WRITINGS of H. P. LIDDON, D.D. Selected and Arranged by C. M.S. Crown 16mo. 2s. The CHILDREN’S YEAR: Verses for the Sundays and Holy Days throughout the Year. By C. H. WOODRUFF, B.C.L. With an Introduction by the Right Reverend the Bishop of SOUTHWELL. Feap. 8vo. 3s. 6d. With A LADDER of HEAVEN: an Allegory in Verse. Preface by the Right Reverend the Bishop of LINCOLN. Crown 8vo. 3s. 6d. of OUR LORD'S An INQUIRY into the NATURE KNOWLEDGE as MAN. By W. S. SWAYNE, M.A. Oxon., Clerk in Holy Orders, Taeological Lecturer and Diocesan Preacher in the Diocese of Lichfield. With a Preface by the Bishop of SALISBURY. Crown 8vo. 2s, PEACE and its HINDRANCES. By the Right Rev. Bishop ASHTON OXENDEN, formerly Bishop of Montreal. Crown 8vo. 1s. paper cover. (In a few days.

On March 24, price Sixpence, LONGMAN’S MAGAZINEW—No. APRIL. The MISCHIEF of MONICA. By L. B. Walford. Chaps. 16-18. UPON A DAY. By Aubyn Battye. The PUPIL. Part II. By Henry James. SARK. By C. W. Kennedy. SALLY. By Mrs. Parr. An ITALIAN COUNTRY HOUSE, 4.p. 1490-1500. By Sebastian Evans, LL.D. At the SIGN ofthe SHIP. By Andrew Lang. London: LONGMANS, GREEN & CO. CII.

HUTCHINSON’S A ——$—$— By Mrs. RIDDELL. AUSTIN FRIARS. TOO MUCH ALONE. The RICH HUSBAND. MAXWELL DREWITT FAR ABOVE RUBIES. A LIFE’S ASSIZE. The WORLD in the CHURCH. HOME, SWEET HOME. PHEMIE KELLER. The RACE for WEALTH. The EARL’S PROMISE. MORTOMLEY’S ESTATE. FRANK SINCLAIR'S WIFE. The RULING PASSION. MY FIRST and MY LAST LOVE. CITY and SUBURB. ABOVE SUSPICION. JOY AFTER SORROW. By FLORENCE MARRYAT. MOUNT EDEN. GERALD ESTCOURT. LOVE’S CONFLICT. TOO GOOD for HIM. WOMAN AGAINST WOMAN. FOR EVER and EVER. NELLY BROOKE. VERONIQUE. HER LORD and MASTER. The PREY of the GODS. The GIRLS of FEVERSHAM. MAD DUMARESQ. NO INTENTIONS. PETRONEL. By ANNIE THOMAS. ON GUARD. WALTER GORING. By JOSEPH HATTON. CLYTIE. The TALLANTS of BARTON. IN the LAP of FORTUNE. VALLEY of POPPIES. NOT in SOCIETY. CHRISTOPHER KENRICK. CRUEL LONDON. The QUEEN of BOHEMIA. BITTER SWEETS. By J. SHERIDAN LEFANU. CHECKMATE. ALL in the DARK. GUY DEVERELL. The ROSE and the KEY. TENANTS of MALLORY. WILLING to DIE. WYLDER’S HAND. By M. BETHAM EDWARDS. LOVE and MIRAGE. By F. W. ROBINSON. CHRISTIE'S FAITH. CARRY’S CONFESSION. UNDER the SPELL. The HOUSE of ELMORE. MILLY’S HERO. Mr. STEWART’S INTENTIONS. NO MAN’S FRIEND. WILD FLOWERS. POOR HUMANITY. OWEN, a WAIF. WOODLEIGH. A WOMAN’S RANSOM. MATTIE, a STRAY. SLAVES of the RING. ONE and TWENTY. SALA. QUITE ALONE. By G. A. By SIDNEY S. HARRIS. The SUTHERLANDS. RUTLEDGE. CHRISTINE. By JOHN COLEMAN. The WHITE LADYE of ROSEMOUNT. By Sir JULIUS VOGEL, K.C.M.G. A.D. 2000; or, WOMAN’S DESTINY.

London: HutcHiInson & Co, 25, Paternoster-square, E.C,

Page 6

366 THE ATHENAUM N° 3308, Marcy 21, ’91 RICHARD BENTLEY & SON’S LIST. —_.———— THOSE WESTERTON GIRLS Will make their first appearance In the APRIL Number of TEMPLE BAR. Price ONE SHILLING. Published March 24. *,* See also page 363. NEW WORKS. —_—~— NOW READY, The LETTERS of HORACE WALPOLE, Fourth Earl of Orford. Edited by PETER CUNNINGHAM, F.S.A. New Edition, with additional Portraits, 9 vols. demy 8vo. 5I. 5s. MR. AND MRS. BANCROFT ON AND OFF THE STAGE. A New and Cheaper Edition, being the Eighth. In 1 vol. crown 8vo. paper cover, 1s. NEW NOVELS AT ALL LIBRARIES. —_——~o—- BY THE AUTHOR OF ‘YOUNG MISTLEY.’ PRISONERS and CAPTIVES. By H. S. MERRIMAN. In 3 vols. crown 8vo. “There is nothing trite or commonplace about Mr. Merriman’s romance. It is a tragedy as fully and completely as ‘Hamlet ’was; for when we read the last page there are as few of the characters left alive, yet there is not one word from beginning to end that could be counted hysterical. Alto- gether Mr. Merriman has written a remarkable book, and it is a relief to find an author who can draw characters who act from principle and behave like ladies and gentlemen.” Saturday Review. BY THE AUTHOR OF ‘LADY GRIZEL.’ THE MAID OF HONOUR. 3y the HON. LEWIS WINGFIELD. In 3 vols. crown 8vo. * Always readable and often thrilling.” National Observer. BY THE AUTHOR OF ‘MAYGROVE.’ AN AMERICAN DUCHESS: A Pendant to ‘ Miss Bayle’s Romance.’ By W. FRASER RAE, In 3 vols. crown 8yvo. NOW READY. TO SAVE HIMSELF. By CAPTAIN CLAUDE BRAY. In 2 vols. crown 8vo. BY THE AUTHOR OF ‘A LOST ESTATE.’ A WINTER'S TALE. By MARY E. MANN. In 2 vols. crown 8vo. A NEW EDITION. THE PARTING of the WAYS. 3y M. BETHAM-EDWARDS, In 1 vol. crown 8vo. 6s. RICHARD BENTLEY & Son, New Burlington-street, Publishers in Ordinary to Her Majesty the Queen, HURST & BLACKETT’S PUBLICATIONS. —@~—— UNDER THE ESPECIAL PATRONAGE OF HER MAJESTY. Now ready, Sixtieth Edition, 1 vol. royal 8vo. with the Arms beautifully engraved, 31s. 6d. bound, gilt edges, and LODGE’ S PEERAGE BARONETAGE for 1891. Corrected by the Nobility. THIRD AND CHEAPER EDITION. Now ready, in 1 vol. crown 8vo. 6s. BENCH AND BAR: Reminiscences of One of the Last of an Ancient Race. By Mr. Serjeant ROBINSON. With Appendix and Portrait of the Author. NEW NOVELS. NOW READY AT ALL THE LIBRARIES. KINSFOLK. By Mary Deane, Author of ‘St. Briavels,’ ‘Quatrefoil,’ &c. 3 vols, The PHILADELPHIAN. By Louis JOHN JENNINGS, M.P., Author of ‘The Millionaire,’ ‘Rambles among the Hills,’ &c. 3 vols. A BITTER BIRTHRIGHT. By DORA RUSSELL, Author of ‘Footprints in the Snow,’ ‘The gs Seal,’ &e. ‘3 vols. “The story is written with the delightful ee and vigour that characterize all Dora Russell's novels.”—Scotsm JANET. By Mrs. Oliphant, Author of ‘It was a Lover and his Lass,’ ‘Agnes,’ &c. 3 vols. ‘ One of the ablest of the author’s recent novels; perhaps the ablest “ea of the kind that she has produced since the Carlingford Series.” Manchester Examiner. HER LOVE and HIS LIFE. By F. W. ROBINSON, Author of ‘Grandmother's Money,’ ‘The Youngest Miss Green,’ &c. 3 vols. ‘The author has for once contrived to givean arrangement of the osiane in his familiar kaleidoscope which is at once entirely new and extremely interesting.”—Atheneum. RUPERT ALISON; or, Broken Lights. By GERTRUDE FORDE, Author of ‘In the Old Palazzo,’ ‘Driven before the Storm,’ &e. 3 vols. “‘A pleasant, wholesome story, at once restful and interesting.” Literary World. ON TRUST. By Thomas Cobb, Author ot ‘Brownie’s Plot,’ ‘For Value Received,’ &c. 3 vols. ‘There is in these three volumes a tale of considerable ingenuity, and one which shows that the author is possessed of much constructive power and other important qualifications.” Exan A LIFE SENTENCE. By Adeline SERGEANT, Author of ‘Little Miss Colwyn,’ ‘Jacobi's Wife,’ &c. 3 vols. NEW SERIES OF CHEAP NOVELS. Now ready, at all Booksellers’, in 1 vol. crown 8vo. 3s. 6d. The AWAKENING of MARY FENWICK. By BEATRICE WHITBY, Author of ‘Part of the Property.’ TWO ENGLISH GIRLS. By Mabel NOVELS BY EDNA LYALL. Uniform. Each in 1 vol. crown 8vo. 6s. A HARDY NORSEMAN. WE TWO. IN THE GOLDEN DAYS. KNIGHT ERRANT. WON BY WAITING, DONOVAN: a Modern Englishman. A SELECTION FROM HURST & BLACKETT’S STANDARD LIBRARY. EACH IN A SINGLE VOLUME, PRICE 5s. BY THE AUTHOR OF ‘JOHN HALIFAX,’ JOHN HALIFAX, GENTLE-|CHRISTIAN’S MISTAKE, a WOMAN'S THOUGHTS tn Se HANNAH. a tie te ta mE. The UNKIND WORD. NOTHING NEW. A BRAVE LADY. MISTRESS and MAID. STUDIES from LIFE. The WOMAN’S KINGDOM. | YOUNG MRS. JARDINE. BY THE AUTHOR OF ‘SAM SLICK’ NATURE AND HUMAN The OLD JUDGE; or, Life NATURE, in a Colony. WISE SAWS and MODERN |7 ZALTS of AMERICAN INSTANCES, The AMERICANS at HOME. BY DR. GEORGE MAC DONALD, DAVID ELGINBROD. ALEC FORBES. ROBERT FALCONER. SIR GIBBIE, BY MRS. OLIPHANT. ADAM GRAEME, LIFE of IRVING. LAIRD of NORLAW. A ROSE in JUNE. AGNES PHBE, JUNIOR. ‘IT WAS A LOVER AND HIS LASS. London: Hurst & BLACKETT, LIMITED, An Atlas of Unexampled Complete- ness, Accuracy, and Cheapness, within the reach of all. In Monthly Parts, price One Shilling, THE UNIVERSAL ATLAS, | A NEW AND COMPLETE GENERAL ATLAS OF THE WORLD, CONTAINING 117 Pages of Maps, handsomely printed in Colours, and a Complete Index to over 100,000 Names. Part 1 ready March 24, price ONE SHILLING. To be completed in 28 Parts. EXTRACT FROM PROSPECTUS. The UNIVERSAL ATLAS consists of an Edi- tion, prepared expressly for the English-speaking world, of Dr. ANDREE’S famous ‘Handatlas,’ which was originally produced at a cost of One Million Marks. NEW MAPS. A large number of New Maps have been prepared specially for The Universal Atlas, Among these are included— A Magnificent Four-Page Mapo England, A Double-Page Map of Scotland, Maps of Canada, Australia, and of the Indian Frontier, The Trade of the British Empire, together with others scarcely less important. COMPARATIVE SIZE OF COUNTRIES. In many Maps a small Inset Map, representing an English County, the Principality of Wales, or England, has been introduced, on the same scale as the principal Map—a plan which affords an admir- able means of appreciating the vast area of such countries as Australia, South Africa, Borneo, &c. AFRICA. The Maps of Africa will no doubt be regarded by many as the most important in the Atlas. These Maps, which comprise eleven pages of the work, are the first to embody the most recent results of African exploration and of European diplomacy. SIZE AND PRICE. The Universal Atlas will consist of no less than 117 Pages of Maps (size 11 in. by 17 in.). The Publishers believe that no such work as The Universal Atlas has ever been offered to the public at so low a price. They do not, however, base the claims of the Work upon the low cost at which it is offered, but they invite most careful scientific comparison of each Map with correspond- ing Maps in any of the Atlases now in the market and offered at prices of from 3 to 12 guineas, For the first time it will now be possible for every household and for every reader to possess a complete and perfect Atlas of the World, prepared according to the best scientific method, issued in the most attractive and complete form, and obtain- able at a price hitherto unheard of. *.* A full Prospectus, including a List of the Maps, may be obtained at the principal Booksellers’ and Railway Bookstalls, where a SPECIMEN MAP may also now be seen, CASSELL & CoMPANY, LIMITED, Ludgate-hill, London, = ex co dit ing hi we ney the the cha saic it | slig Spo: a de that to } her- prof is 01 best he di up a some agai seem men, while Oppo: quen is o polen YUM

Page 7

N° 3308, Marcu 21, ’91 THE ATHENAUM 367

SATURDAY, MARCH 21, 1891,

CONTENTS. PAGE Toe TRACTARIAN MOVEMENT ese . 367 Mason CLARKE ON FORTIFICATION 368 eS eee ae ae . 369 {ue LIGHT OF THE WORLD ... bes 370 Tue TEXT OF ARISTOTLE’S ETHICS 371 NovELS OF THE WEEK ae ane aie an 372 Tue LITERATURE OF THE NEW TESTAMENT ... 373 Our Lisrary TABLE—LIsT OF NEW Books ... . 374 THE CALENDAR OF ANCIENT DEEDS; M. DE BANVILLE; SALE; WILLIAM HUNNIS, GENTLEMAN OF THE CHAPEL RoyaL; THE Harris Papyri; THE SPRING PUBLISHING SEASON; THE AMERICAN INTERNATIONAL COPYRIGHT ACT 375—377 LITERARY GOSSIP es is aa oh ae ww. 378 ScleENCE— THF RIVERSIDE NATURALIST; SIR W. Rowan HAMILTON; GEOGRAPHICAL Nores; So- CIETIES; MEETINGS; GossIP ... sas «. 379—383 Fine ARTS—ANNALS OF THE ARTISTS OF SPAIN; INSTITUTE OF PAINTERS IN WATER COLOURS; THE PORTRAIT OF CHATTERTON; THE COLLAR AND JEWEL OF THE LORD Mayor or Lonpon; SaLEs ; GossIP <a aa ane a «» 883—385 Musio—THE WEEK; THE RoyaL ITALIAN OPERA; Gossip ; ConcerTs, &C., NEXT WEEK 386—387 DraAMA—THE WEEK; GOSSIP X 387—388

LITERATURE se The Early History of the late Cardinal New- man. By F. W. Newman. (Kegan Paul & Co.) The Oxford Movement— Twelve Years, 1833-45. By the late Dean Church. (Macmillan & Co.) Tacitus, in one of those flashes of insight that make his pages so often terrible read- ing, speaks somewhere of enemies that hated one another plus quam fraterno odio. It is greatly to be regretted that Prof. Newman should have chosen at his advanced age to make such an exhibition of fraternum odium against the late Cardinal. No doubt it is the odium theologicum that inspires the pro- fessor’s belittling pages. But even that explanation is scarcely a sufficient excuse for his present publication. Prof. Newman could have put on record his theological differences from his brother without imply- ing at every turn what a bad Christian the Cardinal’s particular form of belief caused him to become. When Keats’s letters to Fanny Brawne were published, Matthew Arnold said they never ought to have been published. But, he continued, as they have been put before the world we cannot avoid making use of | them for any light they may throw upon his character. Much the same thing may be said of Prof. Newman’s “ revelations.” But it has to be added that they are extremely slight. That the Cardinal did not care for sports in his boyhood ; that he early showed a desire for mastery; that he tried, but failed, to dictate to his mother and sisters in religion ; that he could not convert Prof. Newman to his views; that he plotted against the English Church while professing to defend her—these are the kind of charges that the professor thinks worth while printing. There 1s one point on which the professor on the best authority corrects previous impressions :

he denies that the Newmans were brought | up as Calvinists. The professor puts with | some cogency the extreme Protestant position | against the Anglican contentions; but there | seems no valid reason why he, above all other | men, should be called upon to state this, | while at the same time implying that the opposite opinions involve some moral delin- | quency in those who hold them, including his own brother. polemics Prof, Newman does more harm to | Merely as a matter of ,

his own position by the want of charity he betrays than any he inflicts on Tractarian- ism. The whole business is pitiable in the extreme. We turn with the more satisfaction to Dr. Church’s long-expected volume on the Oxford Movement. The high reputation of the Dean for style and taste, for deep feeling and wide knowledge, has naturally aroused expectation in a considerable degree. To some extent this expectation will be satisfied, but not altogether. Dean Church’s volume is written with much of his characteristic charm and skill. It is the first attempt that has been made to distinguish the men from the movement, and yet to connect them. It contains many vignettes of the less-known actors in the movement, and one or two rather elaborate portraits. Considerable skill is shown in disentangling the permanent and important elements from the temporary and unessential, and throughout evidence is given of wide and thorough personal acquaintance both with the chief actors and the main events of the Oxford Movement. Yet with all these merits the volume does not altogether answer to the expectations that have been raised with respect to it. It does not profess to be a critical history of the movement. He did not pretend, the Dean wrote to Lord Acton, ‘‘ to write a his- tory of the movement, or to account for it or adequately to judge it and put it in its due place in relation to the religious and philosophical history of the time.” But as a matter of fact he gives hints, and most suggestive hints, on most of these points. Yet on the whole it remains true that the book is a book about the Movers rather than about the Movement, which still awaits its philosophic historian. Let it be added in all fairness that the said historian, when he comes, will find nothing of more value for his purpose than the late Dean’s clear-cut sketches of the main actors and the chief phases of the movement. The Dean gives full portraits of some of the chief leaders—Keble, Hugh Rose, Wil- liam Palmer, Hurrell Froude, and W. G. Ward—and of persons less known, but equally interesting, such as W. J. Copeland, Isaac Williams, and Charles Marriott. The account of Marriott, with his solid qualities and uncouth exterior, is a masterly piece of work. He has much to say, though scarcely in full sympathy, about Arnold, about Whately, and about Dr. Hampden. There is, however, no attempt to delineate Pusey; and above all the central figure of Newman is left un- drawn and unjudged. This was doubtless due to the fact that the Cardinal was still alive when the book was composed, most of it having been in type since 1887. This absence of the sun of the Tractarian system is the main weakness of the volume, re- garded as a gallery of portraits. But the Dean’s unerring taste doubtless caused him to refrain both from the attempt at a por- traiture of a living personality and from competition with the magnificent self-por- traiture of the ‘ Apologia.’ It is difficult to praise too highly the literary skill shown in this gallery of por- traits. We sce the men in their inmost being, with their temperaments and special qualifications to take part in the movement. The Dean was not blind to the weaknesses of his sitters, but these form only the

shadows of his pictures. So far as it is possible for the pen to make us know men as they really are, the Dean has achieved — the task. Unfortunately these portraits are on too large a scale to admit of quotation. Nearly one-third of the book is taken up by these character sketches, and they form the most valuable part of it. It would have been as well, we think, if it had been made clear what were the exact materials on which the Dean based his judgments. In the case of Isaac Williams and Marriott he quotes MS. memoirs by relations, but from the tone of the preface we are left to assume that it was mainly from personal knowledge that the Dean was speaking, and this, if the case, lends additional weight to his words, and should have been more explicitly stated. In two cases the Dean adds an appendix to his chapters—on Hurrell Froude, and on the St. Mary’s sermons of Newman. Are we to assume that he was unacquainted with the former and did not hear any of the latter? In the second case this is scarcely possible. It is with regard to Newman’s sermons at St. Mary’s that the Dean makes one of his most striking and suggestive points. His account of their influence may be quoted as a specimen of his style, and at the same time as an estimate of their importance :— ‘* But the Tracts were not the most powerful instruments in drawing sympathy to the move- ment. None but those who remember them can adequately estimate the effect of Mr. New- man’s four o’clock sermons at St. Mary’s. The world knows them, has heard a great deal about them, has passed its various judgments on them. But it hardly realizes that without those sermons the movement might never have gone on, certainly would never have been what it was. Even people who heard them continually, and felt them to be different from any other sermons, hardly estimated their real power, or knew at the time the influence which the sermons were having upon them. Plain, direct, unornamented, clothed in English that was only pure and lucid, free from any faults of taste, strong in their flexibility and perfect command both of language and thought, they were the expression of a piercing and large insight into character and conscience and motives, of a sympathy at once most tender and most stern with the tempted and the wavering, of an abso- lute and burning faith in God and His counsels, in His love, in His judgments, in the awful glory of His generosity and His magnificence. They made men think of the things which the preacher spoke of, and not of the sermon or the preacher.” It is, indeed, in dealing with the influence of the Oxford Movement on the souls of men that the Dean shows himself to greatest advantage. No one hitherto has given the 00s of the movement with more sympathy or more subtlety. He points out in par- ticular two directions in which it made for fundamental change in the Church attitude. It made Gospel teaching really deserve that name by directing attention in Bible read- ing to the Evangelists rather than to the epistles. Leaving St. Paul to the Evan- gelicals, it concentrated attention on the personality of Christ, and thus made more effective the force of the Great Exemplar. The other feature of the movement may be best given in the Dean’s own words : ‘‘The other feature was the increased and practical sense of the necessity of self-discipline, of taking real trouble with one’s self to keep thoughts and wishes in order, to lay the founda-

Page 8

368 THE ATHENZUM N° 3308, Marcu 21,91 tion of habits, to acquire the power of self- control. Deeply fixed in the mind of the teachers, this serious governance of life, this direction and purification of its aims, laid strong hold on the consciences of those who accepted their teaching. This training was not showy; it was sometimes austere, even ex- travagantly austere ; but it was true, and en- during, and it issued often in a steady and unconscious elevation of the religious character. How this character was fed and nurtured and encouraged—how, too, it was frankly warned of its dangers, may be seen in those ‘ Parochial Sermons’ at St. Mary's, under whose inspiration it was developed, and which will always be the best commentary on the character thus formed. Even among those who ultimately parted from the movement, with judgment more or less unfavourable to its theology and general line, it left, as if uneffaceable, this moral stamp ; this value for sincerity and simplicity of feeling and life, this keen sense of the awfulness of things unseen. There was something sui generis, in the profoundly serious, profoundly reverent tone, about everything that touched religion in all who had ever come strongly under its in- fluence.” It is in passages like this that the merit of the Dean’s treatment comes out in fullest force. Otherwise he has to tell a twice-told tale, and can scarcely have hoped to rival the ‘Apologia’ on its own ground. Be- ginning with an account of the sleep of the Church in the pre-Reform days, when she reached her nadir, the book tells how the Reform Bill roused her adherents to the sense of her danger from the new forces brought into public life by that measure, and roughly known as Liberalism. How this sense of danger was borne in upon Keble by Hurrell Froude’s impetuosity, and from Keble it was passed on to Newman by Froude, is told in the next chapter. The three that follow deal with Newman’s entourage, Froude, Williams, Marriott, and we then enter upon the movement. Here we have given the First Tract with its powerful call to arms. A general chapter on the Tractarian spirit follows, contain- ing the passage quoted above. We then have three chapters on the success of the movement in opposing the admission of Dissenters to the University and in re- sisting the appointment of Dr. Hampden as Divinity Professor. The dividing line comes in 1840, and in an interesting chapter Dean Church shows how the Roman question came to the fore. Briefly the position of the Tractarians towards Rome had been to allow its Catholicity—and therein they were both just and generous, though thereby arousing Protestant ire—but to deny its Apostolicity. So for Anglicanism they allowed a want of Catholicity, but claimed a full measure of Apostolicity. When Newman began to doubt on the latter point, the crisis was reached. The “Apostolical”’ movement could not stand if its Apostolicity was doubtful. On the other hand, the doctrine of develop- ment would account with equal force for Romish development and for Anglican changes. Here the Dean interpolates a chapter on “what might have been” if the leaders of the Church had not lost their heads and if they had made a few concessions. Then in three chapters he deals with ‘Tract No. 90’ and its effects in the episodes of the Poetry Professorship, the Macmullen contest, and Pusey’s condem- nation by the Heads. After this we have the final act, in which W. G. Ward plays protagonist. As it was the fiery energy of Hurrell Froude that initiated the movement, so it was the Philistine persistency of Ward that precipitated it. The Dean describes, with a subtle sense of humour, the worrying persistence of Ward in forcing Newman into extreme positions. For a leader Newman was certainly exceedingly susceptible to out- ward influences. The end of the Oxford Movement, pro- perly so called, came when Father Dominic received Newman into the fold of Rome. But as the Dean points out in a few weighty words at the end, its influence was only then beginning. The 460s of the movement kept spreading, and has touched the higher life of England at a hundred points, with the effect that the English Church is more in touch at the present moment with the higher life of the nation than at any time in the century and a half that elapsed between 1688 and 1838. The Dean was himself one of the most striking outcomes of its influence, and was, therefore, a most suitable person to describe it. He was of the faithful few who did not despair of the Church at its darkest hour, when Rome seemed trium- phant. He was, in other words, rather a Puseyite than a Newmanite. To a certain extent this produces an advocate’s tone in some parts of this book, from which New- man, when outside Anglicanism, became free in the ‘ Apologia.’ But there was room for a sympathetic defence of the men and the spirit of the Oxford Movement from the standpoint of the Movers, and that Dean Church has given in this book with all the charm that distinguished his style and his own character. Fortification: its Past Achievements, Recent Development, and Future Progress. By Major G. Sydenham Clarke, C.M.G., Royal Engineers. (Murray.) An undue attachment to theory, an adherence to old forms, and a tendency to make a mystery of their art are reproaches generally levelled at the Royal Engineers, and with a certain amount of justice. Such accusations cannot, however, be brought against Major Clarke. He is eminently a practical man, he is a foe to dogma, he bases all his conclusions on experience, and proclaims boldly that fortification is a matter of common sense. In fact,in the book before us he never ceases to attack the Chatham school of military engineers, and to deride the doctrines of the Drawing-Office. In an introduction, which in this case is by no means surplusage, the author com- plains of the poverty of military engineering literature in the English language :— ‘*Tt results that there is no school of thought in regard to Fortification; that elementary principles are still floating in solution ; and that no approach to a consensus of matured opinion is ever attained. Of mere text-books there are enough ; but such works are apt to be swamped in the dreary morass of technicality. Principles are lost in details, and criticism can have no place where dogma must necessarily reign supreme.” A detailed review of such a book as this is practically impossible. Some of the six- teen chapters, therefore, into which the work is divided, must necessarily be passed ! The conclusions over with little criticism. of the author are that **no science is so delightfully empirical ag that of Fortification. The test of experiment cannot satisfactorily be applied to it; that of practical experience is uniformly ambiguous, No fad is so unimportant that an instance cannot be found which affects to illustrate its utility ; no office-table theory so unpractical, that evidence of some sort cannot be produced for its support. For the data are never scientifically complete, and each successful or unsuccessful attack or defence may generally be traced to any one of a dozen causes in accord- ance with the personal predilections of the writer.” In the second chapter the author passes rapidly in review the sieges of Marlborough and Eugene, the sieges of the Peninsula, and the lines of Torres Vedras. It is note- worthy that the average duration of the sieges of Marlborough and Eugene was under thirty-four days, ‘‘ a period actually less than that of the resistance offered in some cases, by almost identical fortifications, to the Ger- man artillery in 1870-71.” In these sieges the author is of opinion that in most cases “the requirements of details and trace” exercised no influence over the result. In the twenty-nine sieges — Turin and Toulon, not having been taken, are excluded from consideration—only in one case was an assault awaited. In the Peninsula, on the other hand, there were twelve assaults of breaches, of which five were successful. Again, there were twelve attempts at escalade, of which six succeeded. In chap. iii. the author, taking the sieges of Tarragona, Saragossa, Danzig, and Mayence for his text, asserts that these sieges and others at the same time were long or short according to ‘the spirit of the troops, the genius and readiness of resource of their commanders, the available supply of food and ammunition, and not because the fortress was laid out on simple or complex lines.” Major Clarke is by no means a blind idolater of Vauban, and styles Cormontaigne “that mediocre artist.” He entertains, however, much admiration for Montalembert, who condemned the bastion trace. Carnot he describes as a man of “originality and independence of judgment,” and he reminds us that Carnot was ‘one of the first to claim an all-important place for high angle fire on the part of the defence.” The birth of the German system of fortifi- cation is casually referred to, chiefly for the purpose of condemning the large caponier. Attention is called to the towers surrounding Linz as the germ of the modern entrenched camp. The campaigns in Turkey of 1828-29 tell very much against the scientific engineer. There were four important sieges during the war, viz., those of Schumla, Silistria, Braila, and Varna. Schumla, although only defended by simple fieldworks, held out till the signature of peace. The per- manent fortification of the other three for- tresses was of the simplest and most incom- plete nature, and the deficiencies in the works were not compensated by any advan- tage of position. Yet although the siege was in each instance carried out by an ade- quate army and a powerful train of artillery, and the operations executed in due form, Braila held out for thirty-seven days, Silis- tria for forty-four, and Varna for sixty-eight.

Page 9

————- COGS ee YT OCU ww CS XUM N° 3308, Marca 21,’91 THE ATHENAUM 369 ‘‘What deduction can be drawn from the above facts except that, within broad limits, the nature of the defence matters little, and that sieges, like battles, are decided by general tactical considerations ? ” In the Russo-Turkish war of 1853 the Russians, after a siege (supplemented by a bombardment) of thirty-eight days, with- drew from Silistria with heavy losses. The success of the defence, mainly due to Captains Nasmyth and Butler, ‘‘iJlustrates the difference between the teaching of theory and that of war. A town subject to bombardment throughout the siege; six de- tached forts of simple design unconnected by trenches; one advanced work (Arab Tabia) open at the gorge and having a ditch six feet nine inches deep, not palisaded ; a motley garri- son of about 12,000 men, subsequently re- inforced by some Bashi-Bazoucs—these were the conditions under which an army of 60,000 men was completely repulsed, and the wave of Russian invasion completely broken.” The reflections on the sieges of Sebastopol and Kars are pithy and interesting. The upshot of Major Clarke’s criticism is that the simple, extemporized earthworks of the defenders were quite as effective as elaborate, costly, permanent works would have been. Of course, at Sebastopol the necessity of constructing works under fire and the absence of sufficient shell-proof shelter cost an enor- mous number of lives. With the fall of Kars the reign of smooth-bore artillery and small arms came to an end. There are no important lessons in forti- fication to be learnt from the American Civil War, but it confirms the experience of Sebastopol that it is difficult to injure earthworks. The Danish war in 1864 showed the superiority of guns mounted on high car- riages, firing over the parapet, to guns fired through embrasures. Among the deduc- tions from the Franco-Prussian War, 1870- 1871, the following are the most important : the power of the rifle in defence, the use- lessness of réduits, the advantage of low command and comparative invisibility. Of Plevna Major Clarke says :— ‘*Plevna, like Sebastopol, supplies no argu- ment against permanent works built in peace time ; but in common with all the experience of war, it distinctly proves that the fortifica- tion which has been arrived at in defiance of the law of the survival of the fittest, may be safely relegated to the domain of abstract specula- tion.” By this the author, to judge from the con- text, evidently means that at Plevna the Turks took into consideration the nature of the ground, tactical requirements, and the dictates of common sense, instead of fol- lowing the pedantic rules and complicated tracing of mere theory. So much for the experience of the past. As to the future, the accomplished author writes on it with great force and clearness, and the nine chapters devoted to this branch of the subject merit thoughtful perusal. The moral of his book may be given in his own words: “It is necessary to withdraw fortification from the dim realms of occultism into the light of common sense ; to fling mere theory to the winds, and to seek a basis in the teaching of war alone. Then will the science emerge from the clouds of uncertainty which have too long obscured it.” Gypsy Sorcery and Fortune-telling. By Charles Godfrey Leland. (Fisher Unwin.) Journal of the Gypsy Lore Society. Vols. I. and II. (Hdinburgh, Constable.) In the far Highlands there is a village, say travellers, whose inhabitants eke out a pre- carious livelihood by taking in one another’s washing. The ever-increasing literature on the gipsies is somehow suggestive of that Highland village. For the books are so many, the readers must be so few. The Gypsy Lore Society was founded, it seems, three years ago, but it counts only some seventy members, and nearly half of these aredwellers beyond seas—in Hungary, India, America, and elsewhere. Yet the two hand- some volumes of its quarterly Journal con- tain much curious matter that should be interesting not only to the Romany Rye, or amateur gipsy, but to philologists, ethnolo- gists, and folk-lorists generally. Nothing certain was known till the other day of Brazilian gipsies: here one may read how their ancestors were banished from Portugal in 1718; how in the New World they turned from horse-dealing to the slave trade ; and how gipsy blood now flows in the veins of Brazilian nobles. Nothing at all was known of gipsies roaming in the country south of Mount Atlas—gipsies speak- ing the selfsame language as their Euro- pean kinsfolk, and like them fortune-tellers and workers in metal. Who knew before that the Lithuanian gipsies possess, like those of Alsace, a legend of the founder of their race having stolen one of the four nails with which Christ was to be crucified ? Of ‘‘Shelta,” indeed, the tinkers’ talk, Mr. Leland published some specimens as far back as 1880; but it was reserved for Prof. Kuno Meyer to show that it is ‘‘an Irish secret language of great antiquity, that in Irish MSS. we have mention and record of it under various names, and that, though now confined to tinkers, its knowledge was once possessed by Irish poets and scholars, who, pro- bably, were its original framers.” Much ink has been spilt over the ques- tion whether John Bunyan was or was not of gipsy birth. Mr. James Simson, of New York, is the chief upholder of the former view, and the Rev. John Brown, of Bedford, of the latter; but neither of them was aware thatat Launceston on March 4th, 1586, ‘‘ was christened Nicholas, sonne of James Bownian, an Egiptian rogue.” This, if not conclusive, is certainly in Mr. Simson’s favour; whilst against Mr. Brown’s main contention, that there had been Bedfordshire ‘‘ Bonyons” since the twelfth century, it may be urged that Bosvile is an old and honourable Yorkshire name; and yet Charles Bosvile, buried near Doncaster in 1709, was beyond doubt a gipsy potentate. So, too, was Matthew Baillie, grand-uncle to Mrs. Car- lyle’s maternal grandmother, though the Baillies are one of the chief Lanarkshire houses. The above form the subject of notes or at most of short articles. Of longer articles the most important is by M. Paul Bataillard, the doyen of gipsiologists. An English expansion of a French monograph pub- lished nearly fifty years since, it deals in a masterly and exhaustive fashion with the immigration of the gipsies into Western Europe in the fifteenth century. It traces their wanderings backwards and forwards through Germany, Switzerland, Italy, France, and the Low Countries, and furnishes in- numerable extracts from municipal archives and contemporary chronicles, such as those which tell how at Tournai in 1422 the magis- trates gave twelve gold pieces and bread and beer to ‘“‘ Sir Miquiel, prince of Lating- hem in Egypt”; how the women of his company told fortunes, and the children cut purses ; and how ‘*the men were sufficiently well dressed, the greater number of whom occupied themselves with the buying and selling of horses, and they were such skilful horsemen that a horse appeared very much better under them than under other men. And thus, by deceiving, they often got a better horse than their own, and money into the bargain. And some of these men, when they bought merchandise, gave a florin in pay- ment, and in receiving their change, were so skilful with their hand, confusing and cheating the people, or asking for other money than that which was given them, that none escaped with- out loss. And often, when they had stolen what they could, they would not take the mer- chandise, pretending not to know the money that had been given them in exchange.” Then there are valuable articles by Mr. H. T. Crofton on ‘Early Annals of the Gypsies in England’; by Mr. David Mac Ritchie (the founder of the society) on ‘Scottish Gypsies under the Stewarts,’ and on ‘Callot’s Bohemians,’ with admirable reproductions of the four famous etchings ; by Mr. John Sampson on ‘ English Gypsy Rhymes’; by Dr. Wlislocki, Mr. Groome, and Prof. Kopernicki on gipsy folk-lore and folk-tales; and by Prof. von Sowa on the dialect of the Slovak gipsies. And articles which, could one accept them implicitly, would be worth all the rest put together, are ‘ Kounavine’s Materials for the Study of the Gypsies,’ by Dr. A. Elysseeff. Accord- ing to these, Michael Ivanovitch Kounavine was born in 1820, studied medicine at Mos- cow, and then for thirty-five years (1841- 1876) wandered from gipsy camp to camp in Europe, Northern Africa, and Asia. Eight of those years were spent amongst the gipsies of Germany, Austria, Southern France, Italy, England, and Spain; twelve amongst. those of Asia Minor, Armenia, Mesopotamia, Kurdistan, Iran, Hindustan, and the Deccan; ten amongst Russian gipsies; and then from the Caucasus ‘*the indefatigable traveller followed the transi- tion of the European Gypsies into those of Kurdistan, and all along the Ural Mountains into those of Central Asia and Turan, on this occasion revisiting India and the ranges of Tian- Shan and the Himalayas.” Meanwhile he collected an ‘‘immense store of materials, consisting of 123 tales, 80 traditions and legends, 62 ritual songs, and 120 smaller products of Gypsy poetry...... In the ancient legends the mythological elements assert themselves most strongly, and the cha- racteristic features of the Hindu mythology are there so evident that even the names in these tales recall the analogous divinities of the Hindu theogony. These are Baramy, the proto- divinity, Jandra, the sun-god, Laki, Matta, Anromori, and others, in which one cannot fail to recognise the Hindu Brama, Indra, Lakshmi, Mata (Prithik, earth-mother), as well as the Zendic name of Arimai...... In the tra- ditions and historical narratives one meets with classic names of towns known to the Greek geographers, such as Batalo, Pourini, Espadi, Rikoi, Bikin, and Babili—in which it is not

Page 10

370 THE ATHENAUM Ne 3308, Marcx 21, 91 difficult to recognise the ancient towns Pattala, Poura, Aspadana (Ispahan), Rhage, Beikind, and Babylon, cited by Arrian and other his- torians and geographers.” These are the merest pickings from Dr. Kounavine’s “colossal” eollections, which perished, alas! with him somewhere in Siberia in 1881, and are known to us only through an abstract drawn up three years before his death by Dr. Elysseeff. First printed in the Zransactions of the Russian Geographical Society (1882), that abstract now, thanks to Prof. Kopernicki, of Cracow, appears in English in the Gypsy Lore Jour- nal, where it occupies twenty-five pages. The society has done well to publish it, and yet we cannot feel absolutely certain that there ever was any Dr. Kounavine at all; if there was, we are certain that three- fourths of the discoveries claimed for him are the merest moonshine. To maintain that the gipsies of North-Eastern Europe arrived at their present habitat by way of the Ural Mountains, and those of Western Europe by way of Sicily and Calabria from the coasts of Africa, is to evince an utter ignorance of the gipsy language. For the possession of the selfsame Greek and Slavonic loan-words by the gipsy dialects of both Spain and Scandinavia proves that the ancestors of the present Spanish and Scandinavian gipsies must at one time have dwelt together in Greek- and Slav-speaking lands. Equally false is it that “every Gypsy dialect contains a large number of words of non-Aryan origin : Aramaic, Semi- tie [sic], and even Mongol words form 25 per cent. of the Gypsy vocabulary, taken in its largest sense.” Again, what of the sketch-map, according to which Dr. Kou- navine seems to have found “fragmentary and confused traces of a primitive mytho- logy”? somewhere about Newtown in North Walesand round the Cambridgeshire Wash? Newtown is a Welsh gipsy centre (it was shown to be such in an English book pub- lished in 1880); but surely its gipsies would retain some recollection of a visit from a mysterious gipsy-speaking foreigner, even after the lapse of close on half a century. Meanwhile we have kept the society’s president waiting. ‘Gypsy Sorcery’ is Mr. Leland’s fourth work on the gipsies. It appeals perhaps more to the general reader, and less to the gipsiologist, than any of its predecessors. There is little in it of that personal element which lent such a charm to ‘The Gypsies’ (1882), where we read how “‘ Hans Breitmann”’ detected a gipsy in the pious washerwoman, went to Hampton races and to Cobham fair, and listened to gipsy singers at Moscow, at Paris to gipsy fiddlers from Hungary, always learning the while so much that was novel and curious. Instead, this book is a serious contribution to the Philosophy of the Unknown—a book to be read by all students of theo- sophy, oneirology, clairvoyance, occultism generally, withal by the whole body of folk-lorists. These last, with scarcely an exception, have strangely ignored the gipsies, though to the gipsies folk-lore pro- bably owes more than to any other one race. “‘ Gypsies,” says Mr. Leland, “have been the colporteurs of witchcraft”; a hundred confirmations might be adduced of the say- ing. It is fifty years now since old Mrs. Petuléngro travelled Norfolk with her sparrow that told her all manner of secrets ; to-day her descendants are camping in Scotland, Ireland, America, and New Zea- land. Wherever they have wandered they have carried with them both gipsy and East Anglian superstitions; so that you still find them counselling a Clydesdale beekeeper who has just lost his wife to ‘‘ tell” the bees and put crape upon his hives, practising their own strange methods of ordeal and tabu, or plucking out the heart from a live white pigeon at midnight, and casting it on a clear fire, as a gipsy girl did five years since to put a spell upon her false lover. For gipsies both borrow and lend; if they gull, they are gullible, and the Gentile ‘wise man’’ has no more credulous victims. Found as they were in Finland in 1580, in Shetland in 1612, and roaming as they do from Poland to China, from Hungary to Algeria, the gipsies are a most disturbing factor in the problems of folk-lore. How much they have done towards the diffusion of magic and folk-tales it were hard to estimate; that they may have done very much is at least possible. Their tales present all the familiar features (of swan maidens, for- bidden chambers, the grateful dead, and so forth) ; their superstitions in Eastern Europe are often identical with those of our Eng- lish peasantry—e.g., Transylvanian gipsies seek out a drowned body with a loaf having quicksilver in it. And only last summer a member of the Gypsy Lore Society dis- covered in Argyllshire a band of boat- dwelling ‘‘tinklers ”’ speaking good Romany. They got it from their grandfather, and he was John M‘Donald, Campbell of Islay’s principal informant. The question at once arises, Were John’s stories Gaelic or gipsy ? Mr. Leland is our first English guide in this untrodden bypath of folk-lore, and a right pleasant and capable. guide he proves himself, if sometimes he seems to trip, some- times even to wander astray. The Rou- manians are not Slavs (p. 130); and King David is not the patron saint of Wales. “Thrice” nowhere occurs in the Romany couplet on p. 120; and in the spell on p. 56 there is no equivalent for the seventh line of the English version. rghtment (rather lightmans) in Harman means “day,” not “theft”; and manzin is surely the Anglo- Romany form of manghin, “ riches,’’ in the Turkish dialect. ‘ You shall get a manzin, you shall,” is a frequent reproach to a greedy gipsy brat. Kidnapping, we think, has never been brought home to the tents of Egypt; and the boots of the murdered Laurie were buried simply to keep his ghost from walking. Fault-finding, however, is in this case a specially thankless task, for “‘ the critics,” says Mr. Leland, ‘‘ we have, like the poor, always with us, and a century hence we shall doubtless have far better ones than those in whom we now rejoice—or sorrow.” So, first expressing our admira- tion of the splendid grotesques with which Mr. Leland has himself adorned the cover, initials, and tailpieces of his fine quarto, we conclude by quoting this story :— ‘* A peasant of Petersdorf returned one day from Bistritz with 200 florins, which he had received for oxen. Being very tipsy, he lay down to sleep, having first hidden his money in a hole in the kitchen wall. When he awoke, he missed his coin, and having quite forgotten what he had done with it believed it had been stolen. So he went to a Gypsy, and ordered him to put a spell upon the thief. But as he himself had the money, the spell worked against him, and he grew weaker and weaker and pined away till he died.” The Inght of the World; or, the Great Consummation. By Sir Edwin Arnold, K.C.LE., C.8.I. (Longmans & Co.) Ir may fairly be doubted whether Sir Edwin Arnold’s recent volume will have the success which attended his earlier attempt at versify- ing theology. The story of thelife and adven- tures of Buddha, as set forth in ‘The Light of Asia,’ possessed for the great majority of English readers that magnificence with which we are apt to credit the unknown; and the Oriental imagery and phraseology of the poem undoubtedly contributed to the result achieved on that occasion. The author ap- peared in the guise, as it were, of a hiero- phant, endowed with strange tongues, and discoursing to the uninitiated of hidden mysteries. But in the remarkable work with which he has just presented the world he is dealing with a more familiar theme, and is deprived of the advantages he pre- viously enjoyed. We have all of us—even the most emancipated—at one time or another read or listened to the tale of Christ’s ministry on earth as related by the four Evangelists; and while our interest in a fresh recital of the well-known events is thus to some extent discounted, our criticism of such a venture is likely to be jealous and unsparing.. Sir Edwin may display his usual erudition as much as he chooses, in the hope of investing the New Testament with a novel and unsuspected charm ; but those who have been moved by the story of the raising of Lazarus, as told in all its divine simplicity by St. John, will not be moved the more by finding the dead man’s name trans- mogrified into El Azar. They know what is in the book before they open it: how Jesus was born at Bethlehem, wrought as a car- penter at Nazareth, preached and performed numerous miracles, was crucified, died, was buried, and rose again; and the insertion of a number of Oriental phrases, and de- scriptions of scenery that savour of a guide- book to the Holy Land, can add no dignity to the sacred theme. Still, there is no ac- counting for tastes. Archdeacon Farrar’s ‘Life of Christ’ (as a recent unedifying controversy revealed to us) has proved a thoroughly successful commercial specula- tion for its promoters; and Sir Edwin Ar- nold’s competitive epic may conceivably have a similar vogue. But in any case its acceptance, as we shall attempt to show, will not be due mainly, if at all, to its literary qualities. To begin with, the framework of the poem is by no means happily contrived. After an introductory section dealing with the Nativity, which is written, like the inter- polated passage on Tyre in the latter part of the book, in rhyming heroics, the re- mainder of the action—if action it can be called—passes in the house of Mary Mag- dalene, and the story evolves itself in the form of an interminable dialogue, in which ‘the Lady Miriam” and Pontius Pilate, and afterwards one of the Magi, are the prin- cipal speakers. It is possible that such a scheme, in the hands of a great poet, might be made attractive and interesting, though

Page 11

N° 3308, Marcu 21,91 THE ATHENAUM 371 even Milton’s conversations between our Lord and Satan in ‘ Paradise Regained,’ for all their subtlety and strength, have scarcely succeeded in retaining the ear of English readers; but as employed by Sir Edwin Arnold we have no hesitation in saying that it is intolerably clumsy and portentously dull. The loquacity of the Magdalene and the Magus, their long disquisitions de omnibus rebus et quibusdam aliis, his trivial questions and her tiresome answers, form a most exhausting combination. The steady flow of talk is scarcely broken, except where (as above mentioned) a sort of Newdigate prize-poem upon the glories and infamies of Tyre is dragged in by the head and shoulders to serve as a digression, or a commonplace lyric in small capitals recurs with irritating insistence. Here and there the words of Scripture are employed with- out alteration; at other times they are tor- tured into poetry, and cut up into the regu- lation lengths, thus losing their own beauty without gaining anything in its place. Sir Edwin Arnold’s blank verse is not exactly bad, but it is utterly without dis- tinction. It runs on, like the strains of a piano-organ, with maddening ease and monotony. Loosely constructed and lax in expression, its sentences trip each other up, and jostle along confusedly to no certain close. Gorgeous they often are, decked out with purple and gold; but their splendour is meretricious and unreal, and soon palls upon the reader. One looks in vain for the felicitous use of epithets, the charm of those ‘*Jonely words ” which the Laureate ascribes to Virgil, and of which he is himself so admirable a manipulator. The following description of the gathering of the congre- gation which listened to the Sermon on the Mount is a fair and characteristic specimen of the quality of Sir Edwin Arnold’s work : And a multitude Followed Him to the Mountain, gathering By troops and companies, on bank and mead, Heedless of all things save His gracious words, Till all the grass was blotted with great bands Of gladsome people, clad for holiday, Like divers-coloured flowers ; and, all around, Dark eager faces of ten thousand folk— Men, women, children—made a sunlit throng So thick, so talk-full, on the asphodel, The frightened eagles fled their crags—the snake Slid to his hole, the wolf and panther hid Ashamed of blood. But gentle things of Earth,— a crowned lark, and the dove, and mountain- are,— "Ware of some new good word thro’ man to them— Listened in thickets, There is nothing in the whole passage to arrest attention, except the one phrase “blotted with great bands of gladsome people,” and that is a failure, for blots are usually black, while this assembly was “‘ clad for holiday, like divers-coloured flowers.” Anybody, in fact, might have written the lines, and, having done so, he would have no particular reason to be proud of the achievement. The author’s grammar is not always above suspicion, though some of the errors may be charitably ascribed to his printers. What is to be made of the fol- lowing ?— Nimbly ran, On this, the people of their caravan And fetch the gold, and—laid on gold—the spice, — or of this ?— And lift thee to those heights of Love unseen And who shall unravel the complexity of the relative sentences (to mention no other difficulties) in this extraordinary passage ?— Saying our sweet Lord taught Dark tangled schemes of sad salvation ; God Making Earth ill; which went awry ; was lost For sin; was forfeit to the wrath of Heaven ; Which—for it must exact a victim !—slew The Son of Heaven Himself, willing and free ; And by His blood, self-shed and innocent, Washes Earth’s sins away, propitiates That hungry anger of the offended Law, The second relative must, we imagine, de- pend upon the word “‘ Heaven,” which itself awkwardly stands as a synonym for ‘‘ God’; but the narrative stress of the passage at first sight would make it seem, like its pre- decessor, to refer to ‘“‘Earth.” These ex- tracts also require some explanation :— The Morning dawned [? donned] Amice of summer gold—her loveliest— To meet His holy footsteps on the Hill. The woes begone [? undergone] of Earth Unsuccoured ; while Pilate’s impetuous ery,— Mehercle ! I would give much sesterces To buy that ill time back, — leaves something to be desired in point of expression. Again, what does Sir Edwin mean by calling the birds ‘small almoners of Heaven”? We had always believed the word to imply not a receiver, but a dispenser of alms; and the use of its co-derivative ‘“‘almonry ” elsewhere in the poem,— If grass on the lone mountain-side Grows unforgotten, garlanded so rich From Heaven’s full almonry,— seems to bear out that interpretation. But worse than these slips of language are the faults of taste with which the book abounds. We can cite only a few examples, but they are sufficient to justify the statement we have made. We read of the Lake of Chin- nereth, how fisher-boats Drove Pearl-furromws in the sapphire of its sleep, a specimen of natural jewellery which he who will may admire. A butterfly is de- scribed as Burning and blossoming, all gold and blue. With regard to the kiss of betrayal we have this singular couplet :— For as the sin so is the suffering, And Judas needs must ache with Jesus’ cheek. But the height of infelicitous absurdity is probably reached in the astounding line, A red paludamentum-laticlave, which is Sir Edwin Arnold’s pedantic and tasteless substitution for the plain ‘ purple robe” of the Authorized Version. Akin to the last-mentioned instance of the author’s habit of advertising his attainments are the Orientalisms which bestud, like so many sham diamonds, the loose garments of his verse. The rock which encloses ‘‘ El’ Azar’s”’ remains is ‘“‘a great stone gold/.” The spikenard which Mary Magdalene poured upon her Lord’s head comes from the “ Sum- bul tree, the ‘jatamansi.’” She puts off the rich robes of her days of harlotry and dons ‘‘the mitpachath rddid and tsaiph,’”’ which articles of attire are supplemented (in the case of ‘“‘Shélomith”) by ‘an abnét wove in gold and white” and a ‘‘tsaniph tied with pearls.” The Magus, for his part, is not to be outdone. ‘‘Om, Amitaya!” he ex- claims on one occasion, on another (in large —and here we heartily agree with him—he is found asserting, Yet is the Parabrahm unspeakable ! We have felt constrained to point out some of the many defects observable in ‘ The Light of the World,’ because an attempt so ambitious by an author so well known necessarily challenges a severer criticism than is employed upon the exposition of humbler themes by less distinguished per- sonages. At the same time its fervour and fluency will undoubtedly delight a certain order of readers, and we may perhaps be excused if we leave them to find out for themselves such beauties as it possesses. Aristotelis Ethica Nicomachea. Recognovit I. Bywater. (Oxford, Clarendon Press.) Sryce the publication of Susemihl’s text of the ‘ Nicomachean Ethics’ no pressing need for a new edition has been generally felt by students whose desires are limited to a sound text with such critical help as may enable them to form their own opinion of the most probable reading in a particular passage. Susemihl’s care in recording the important variants of the best authorities and the principal conjectures of other editors, together with the soundness of his judgment in preparing the text itself, are such as to make the book as satisfactory for its purpose as it well could be. On the pub- lication, therefore, by the Clarendon Press of a new critical edition it is natural to ask, What occasion is there for its appearance in the way of newly acquired materials or otherwise? Is it intended to supplant or to supplement existing editions? And how is it fitted for either purpose ? In the preface Mr. Bywater declares that his design was to reproduce as closely as possible the early text as indicated by the tradition of the MSS., without entering on the questions of the genuineness and arrange- ment of different parts. This is from its very narrowness a new object, and if attained it would, in fact, only clear the way for the further questions which the schemes of former editors have comprised. There are also one or two other factors which tend to justify the undertaking and to make the result different. One of these is the appear- ance of new material in the shape of the commentaries of Aspasius on books i.—iv., vii. and viii., completely published in 1889. Another is the great importance attached by Mr. Bywater to the Laurentian MS. (Kb); and the grounds for this preference will doubtless appear in a dissertation on the MS., which he promises in the preface. Turning to the text, the reader is struck by certain strongly marked characteristics for which these considerations have prepared him, and by some others which are less ex- pected. There is, on the one hand, a very decided conservatism, which is shown in the rarity of the editor’s own conjectures and his unwillingness to adopt or even notice those of previous editors, more particularly such as aim at correcting dislocations or excising repetitions in the text. Such emen- dations belong, no doubt, to the questions which are outside the scope of the book; but in this connexion it is not easy to understand, for instance, Mr. Bywater’s own bracketing—probable as it is—of the Where dwells our spirits. type) ‘‘Om Mani Padme!” while on a third passage in 1098 a 12-16, which is an example

Page 12

372 THE ATHENZUM N° 3308, Marca 21, 91 of a kind of repetition common enough in (for the puoixdrepov airvov is not Td wept Tovs the ‘Ethics.’ There is, on the other hand, with regard to the MSS. themselves a strong daveivavras), and éxeivovs in the next line gives some support to the dative. It should tendency to innovation in the direction of | be added that in one passage (1154 a 34) following the readings of Kb, and of record- | Mr. Bywater’s ‘“‘scripsi ” is a mistake, for ing them even where they are not followed, | Susemihl prints ai for ai, though without a a large number of those mentioned being readings which do not appear in Susemihl. There are a good many references to Aspa- sius, and in nearly half of the cases his reading is followed. It is also a part of the scheme to record only the most probable of the variants, and this has been carried out in such a way that the critical notes are short, sometimes to meagreness; they give little of any MSS. except Kb, Lb, and Mb, and very little of the work of former editors ; and even within these limits it is not always easy to see what principle has regulated the exclusion or inclusion of particular readings. It should be remarked that where a reading has the authority of a MS. or an early com- mentator or translator the fact of its adop- tion by previous editors is never noticed: a plan of which the results are sometimes to be regretted. Among the passages affected by the editor’s close adherence to the MSS., and especially to Kb, the following may be noticed. In 1094 a13 he reads &) against the ée of the Aldine edition, and thereby throws the real apodosis out of construction. In 1107 a30 he reverts to the tautological kxowdrepor of the best MSS. as against xevwrepor, which has fair authority and makes better sense. In 1108 a 34, b5, he is wisely conservative, for in the former passage the text makes good enough sense, though it is not quite symmetrically expressed, while in the latter it is probably impossible to make the sense quite complete without somewhat violent treatment. On the other hand, in 1133 a15, 16, Berg’s insertion of 6 before éroée:, which is adopted, does not materially help the text, which is certainly in want of reformation; for what clearly ought to be insisted on is the necessity of an equivalent exchange, which is not represented at all by the text as it stands. In 1141 a 25-6 he has surely been led astray by his admiration for Kb. At any rate, it is not easy to be satisfied with his text, which runs, ra yap repi atro éxarta TO &d Oewpodrv dyaiv evar Ppdvipov, kat Tovrw eéritpeyer avta (where the indi- catives are due to Kb, and ra for 70 is Mr. Bywater’s own conjecture). Finally, in 1174 a 22 the reading xai r© ypdvy is adopted from Kb instead of the ordinary rot xpovov, with the note ‘fort. 7 xpov secludendum.” Here rot xpévov appears to be supported by the conclusion of the argument in ll. 27-29, which shows that what has been discussed is the second of the alternatives stated just before (2) €v dravre 8) TO xpovy 7} Tovre, 1.21). Mr. Bywater prints few conjectures of his own. One or two of these may, however, be given with advantage. In the passage 1124 b 27-31 he has been bold, and has suc- ceeded in producing a reasonable and pro- bable text from a perfect chaos of MS. readings. In 1144 a 26 his alteration of atrav (se. rv rpos Tov troreOevra oKoTbV GuVTELVOV- Twv) after rvyxavevv into avrod (sc. Tod cKoTod) is almost certainly right. The same can hardly be said of his conjecture 75 zepi tots Savetcavras for +O epi Tors 8. in 1167 b 29, where the change introduces a new subject note. It remains to say something of the contri- bution of Aspasius. It has been said that nearly half of the readings quoted from him have been adopted in the text. As might have been expected, a large number of these are also the readings of Kb. Some of the remainder are accepted on the unsupported authority of Aspasius; as, for instance, moAAnv for rooatrnv in 1094 b 15 (which, however, derives some support from a cor- rupt reading of Kb two lines lower); the very probable dv ra@etv for avrurabeiv in 1117 a14; and ¢rowAdyor for the Pvorot Adyou of most MSS. in 1154 b 7. A few others agree with the readings of Lb, Mb, or Ob, though the last of these MSS. is seldom referred to all through the book, and never in support of a reading which has the authority of Aspasius. There are in addi- tion not a few passages in which Aspasius confirms or justifies readings or conjectures adopted by Susemihl without MS. authority. A rather curious instance of this is in 1152 b 31, where Susemihl follows Rassow in inserting dei after aiperai, and Aspasius has amos, giving much the same sense. Another is in the definition of moral virtue, where Susemihl accepts the dative opirpévy instead of the nominative, on the authority of Alexander and the Aldine edition (Mr. Bywater adds I"), and Aspasius supports it. In this passage, by the way, Mr. Bywater adopts also from Aspasius the reading @ dv 6 ppdviysos dpicecev. A few words must be added with regard to the custom invariably observed in these notes of ignoring the editors if there is any earlier authority for the reading. Whatever may be said in favour of the principle, it often diminishes the value of the information given. The note, for instance, on 1127 b 14, ‘ ov*”n.— 15 dAafev éorw alio loco (post 1127 b 22 eipnpeéva) habuisse videtur Aspasius,” omits the information (which is not unimportant) that the same transposition was made con- jecturally by Imelmann; and when we find in 1151 b 24 that xa/pew is read, with only the note “‘ yaipew Asp. : xaipwv codd.,” some surprise at least is natural on learning that Ramsauer in a note and Susemihl in his text have adopted the very same correction from Muretus. There are several similar instances. Enough has been said to show that in both scope and treatment this book differs considerably from the ordinary critical edi- tion, and cannot fairly be considered as a rival. It may safely be assumed that Mr. Bywater’s work is exceedingly accurate, and though there are necessarily many passages about which there is room for two opinions, the text probably attains its object as nearly as that is attainable. Last, but not least, it is excellently printed, and every one who uses it will feel grateful to the editor for recognizing the immense im- portance of a good index. NOVELS OF THE WEEK. His Cousin Adair. By Gordon Roy. 3 vols. (Blackwood & Sons.) To Save Himself. By Capt. Claude Bray. 2 vols. (Bentley & Son.) Not a Moment to Spare. By Hugh Coleman Davidson. 2 vols. (Sampson Low & Co.) The Richest Merchant in Rotterdam. By A.N. Homer. 2 vols. (Same publishers.) Flower de Hundred. By Mrs. Burton Har- rison. (Cassell & Co.) The Anglomaniacs. (Same publishers.) Die Waffen Nieder! Von Bertha von Suttner. 2 vols. (Dresden, Pierson.) ‘His Covsiy Aparr’ belongs to that large class of superior family novels of which England produces such an unfailing supply for the recreation of young girls and their mothers. The type is a credit to the country, but it is slightly monotonous. The present writer shows the cultivated tastes, high moral principles, desirable liberality, and also nice appreciation of country life which characterize this school of fiction. She even ventures upon the daring experiment of allowing her hero, whose heart is elsewhere, to marry an actress, naturally from the sternest sense of duty. Miss Cicely Charteris is rather fast, we are given to understand, but, of course, perfectly proper. It is obviously necessary to get rid of her; unfortunately the melo- dramatic manner in which this piece of business is accomplished is a rash and scarcely successful experiment. The real heroine, however, is quite a satisfactory young person, who judiciously takes to nursing the sick as a temporary consolation for her troubles; she is left in the deserved enjoyment of more positive and personal rewards. Her prosperous and selfish girl cousins are cleverly drawn. Agnes, the shallow and attractive sister, is equally well touched. Gordon Roy is only betrayed into thorough sentimentality and unreality in the matter of Elfie and all that appertains to her; but fortunately she dies early, and long before the end of the story. ‘ His Cousin Adair’ is not a remarkable tale, but it may safely be recommended as pretty and thoroughly readable. Murder seems a favourite topic ; and Capt. Bray builds a painful romance upon the slaughter of a little boy. At the beginning of ‘To Save Himself’ we have the result of a trial in which a young wife has been charged with killing her child. There was not enough evidence, and she was acquitted. Capt. Bray is by no means a practised writer, and he has dealt hurriedly with situations which needed more elaboration. In exposing the ‘ mystery of the crime he jumps somewhat spasmodically from point to point, and makes his characters act with insufficient motive— sometimes in direct opposition to motives which they must have felt. The story might have been strong, for all its painfulness, if it had been worked out on the scale of its opening chapters. Yet another murder is the theme of Mr. Davidson’s two volumes. Murder, wrong suspicions, amateur detectives, a trial, a condemnation of the wrong man—how is it that fifty or sixty out of every hundred new novels appear to be bound down and limited to the same little group of hackneyed circumstances? Mr. Davidson writes well ae ae ee ae ee ft ane 2 ee OC ett we 6 6 & oh Ge okt ted oh cds be ei id ad ass & ae A a cs BH i cs nc

Page 13

N° 3308, Marcu 21, ’91 THE ATHENZUM 313 enough, in a natural and straightforward style. He would produce a much more in- teresting story if, when he next undertakes to write one, he would remember that mur- derers are a very small minority of the human race, and would look for incidents and interests in fresh woods and pastures new. There is a curious, though of course un- conscious, similarity in certain points between Mr. Homer’s novel and ‘The End of a Life,’ noticed here a few weeks ago. The central figure is an incarnation of malignant selfish- ness, spite, and vice glozed with esthetic culture and an assumed charity of soul; he is contrasted with a charming specimen of womanhood and her rather commonplace lover; and he endeavours by diabolically subtle villainies to wreck their lives. Here, however, likeness ends and contrast begins. “The Richest Merchant in Rotterdam’ has little psychological interest and evinces no psychological power ; its portraiture is not vivid, and it is marked by certain qualities of incident and treatment that belong rather to old-fashioned romance than to modern realism. This, perhaps, is not a drawback; but it would have been more of an advantage had the book been written in a style less diffuse and had its leading theme been less repulsive. There is some pleasant landscape, both Devonian and Dutch; and when, in the second volume, the author at last warms to his work, the story becomes exciting. The kidnapping of Philip and his imprisonment in the slimy cellar of a water-side scoundrel, though to- day somewhat improbable, are well told— especially the stirring and pathetic incident of his escape. Dramatic too, though less original, is his sudden return to his sweet- heart, and the mysterious death of Vander- hagen, the ‘richest merchant”; while Madge, the heroine, is a good and lovable example of right womanly sweetness and great-heartedness. Her father, however, is at once conventional and shadowy, and scenes which apparently are intended for comedy are merely farce, and that not funny. The book, in short, is one about which, not- withstanding its good points, the reader cannot feel enthusiastic—a result directly traceable to the false, fashionable artifice of using what is bright and wholesome and true as a background to that which is not only extremely questionable as reality, but, real or unreal, absolutely loathsome. To make morbid criminality interesting re- quires a master hand. ‘Flower de Hundred’ is the story of a Virginia plantation, beginning before the war and going through it; but the author has devoted herself not so much to the war as to a study of the society in and about the old Southern house which gives its fantastic name to the book. Mrs. Burton Harrison has evidently a pleasant taste for old books, old manners, and even old china, and this has led her to go back to the beginning, when the family of Throckmorton settled in Virginia soon after the execution of Charles I. The author’s talent is not par- ticularly well suited to her task, and her book 1s consequently not very brilliant. Even in handling the details of life five-and-twenty years ago she is oppressed with an honest desire to be accurately picturesque, and the however, she proves herself to be a culti- vated and well-informed writer. ‘The Anglomaniacs’ does not give on its title-page any information as to the author, but ‘ Flower de Hundred’ is stated to be by the author of ‘The Anglomaniacs.’ Here Mrs. Burton Harrison, if that be the writer’s real name, is seen to much greater advantage. In dealing with affairs of the present day she is thoroughly at her ease, and writes with plenty of vivacity. ‘The Anglomaniacs’ is, in fact, a very smart piece of work, full of happy touches of good-natured satire and shrewd observation. The author has been rather cruel to senti- mental readers in the ending of her story, and possibly she would have given herself a better opportunity if she had carried it a little further, and worked it out dif- ferently. Though one hesitates in saying that any short story should have been made longer, it is certainly disappointing that the hackneyed device of an intercepted letter should be allowed to be successful and sufficient. It will be a pleasure to meet Mrs. Harrison again if she will remember that she is the author of ‘The Anglo- maniacs,’ and forget that she is the author of ‘ Flower de Hundred.’ ‘Down with your Arms!’ is the title of a novel with a purpose, and Herr von Dunajewski, the Austrian Minister of Finance, was right when he said that who- ever after reading this book could still retain a passion for war was sincerely to be pitied. The book is remarkable in every sense; for considering the reverence that exists in Germany for war and everything that pertains to it, the writer must indeed have courage who could indite such a book; and that she was able to find a publisher for it is a hopeful sign regarding a new current of thought commencing in the Fatherland. To have written the book is to have done a brave deed—humanitarian in the best sense of the word. Madame von Suttner has striven to do in literature what Vereschagin strives to do in art. The book falls into two divisions: an able polemic against war in general, and the false ideas of patriotism whence it springs ; and then a series of documents humains, illustrating the horrors of war as seen dur- ing the last half century in Germany and Austria. As a novel proper the book is weak ; but the love story is merely a tag to the aim of the whole, and as such is, there- fore, above criticism. The work is exciting great controversy pro and con in Germany; but the fact that it has already gone through three editions in that country says much for it. THE LITERATURE OF THE NEW TESTAMENT. The Diatessaron of Tatian: a Preliminary Study. By J. Rendel Harris. (Cambridge, University Press.)—Since Moesinger revised and re-edited Aucher’s Latin version of Ephrem’s commentary on the ‘ Diatessaron,’ the literature relating to the subject has wonderfully in- creased. Zahn’s able reproduction of it from Ephrem, and more recently the Arabic version from the Syriac, edited by Ciasca at Rome, have led to a renewed study of the ‘ Diatessaron.’ German scholars in considerable numbers have examined its nature and age ; while a very few English ones, chiefly of the apologetic school, have rejoiced at the appearance of Moesinger’s indirect representatives of the original. Fur- nished with the accumulated literature of the subject, Prof. Harris has just published what he calls a preliminary study, consisting of notes condensed into a small volume, which is well worthy the attention of all who are interested in the textual criticism of the New Testament. The work is divided into ten brief chapters, the first giving an exaggerated idea of the life, influence, and repute of Tatian ; the last men- tioning unsolved problems, which we suppose will ever remain insoluble. An appendix supplies a transcription and photographic reproduction of a MS. marked Wd, containing a few frag- ments of St. Mark’s Gospel, selected because of coincidences betweenits text andthe ‘ Harmony.’ The treatise is scholarly—well executed from the author’s point of view. All known materials are used and minutely scanned. But several of them present little definite evidence illustrative of the exact readings which the ‘Harmony’ had. Such as they are, they are, certainly, not neglected. The professor in his endea- vour to rehabilitate Tatian and his ‘ Harmony’ has succeeded in throwing some rays of light on various textual details, with the help of the Arabic translation, Ephrem’s commentary, Apkraates’s homilies, and other documents. But he tries to make the ‘Diatessaron’ bear more than it can. In giving the historical notices of it he appears to advantage; other parts of his book are less satisfactory. In the sixth chapter the apocryphal or extra-canonical sayings are, on grounds largely conjectural, all of them traced to the ‘Harmony’ wherever they occur—in the Doctrine of Addai, the Clementine Homilies, the Apostolic Constitu- tions, the Curetonian Old Syriac. Indeed, a close examination soon discovers the author’s desire to refer as much as possible to his favourite document by the aid of ingenious suppositions. The Gospel according to the Hebrews is neglected, although there is old authority for the statement that some called the ‘Diatessaron’ by thatname. The ninth chapter is the least satisfactory because it consists so largely of conjecture. Mr. Harris would have done well to pass by the class of readings which Dr. Hort calls Western and depreciates, instead of styling the ‘ Diatessaron’ text a Western one. The chapter exhibits conjecture, ingenuity, and confidence. ‘‘ Seems,” ‘‘ probably,” ‘‘ must,” follow one another in rapid succession. We are told that Justin drew from a harmony ante- rior to Tatian’s and made up of the Passion Gospels at least, which ‘‘it may well be true was a Syriac work ; and a supposition of a translation of it carries it far back.” Such was the nucleus of Tatian’s ‘ Diatessaron.’ Nor can we commend the professor’s logic, for he trans- fers an argument from Tatian’s use of the four Gospels to their use by Justin, though years intervened between the death of the martyr and the origin of the work. Mr. Harris thinks it probable that Tatian’s doctrinal prepossessions did not influence the text of his harmony ; if so, why were the genealogies omitted? As to the language of the ‘ Diatessaron,’ he leaves it undetermined. It was Syriac—not Greek, as Harnack, who loves to contradict Zahn, sup- poses. Nor does Mr. Harris hazard any opinion on the priority or posteriority of the Curetonian Syriac to the ‘ Diatessaron.’ The leading motive underlying the present treatise is to exalt the credit and influence of the ‘ Diatessaron,’ by assigning to it as early a date as possible. In short, the ‘‘Preliminary Study” is apologetic. The zeal of its author’s search after evidence on the basis of the ‘ Diatessaron’ for the anti- quity of all the canonical Gospels has led him into a field where sober criticism refuses to follow. In describing MSS. and their cha- racteristic readings, in pointing out erroneous readings and how they arose, Prof. Harris is usually correct and clear; when he begins drawing inferences he is an ingenious guesser story goes along heavily. Undoubtedly, and the Arabic version, although both are rather than a cautious logician. or Se ee.

Page 14

374 THE ATHENAZUM N° 3308, Marcu 21, ’91 The Epistle to the Galatians. With Introduc- tion and Notes by E. H. Perowne, D.D. (Cam- bridge, University Press.)—This little volume bears on its pages the evidence of careful work ; and it will doubtless prove serviceable to the classes for whose use it is chiefly intended. If the Master of Corpus Christi has consulted but few commentaries of his predecessors, he uses his own discretion in following them, and he brings much good sense to the elucidation of the epistle. Adopting the ordinary text, he explains it in notes of conservative tendency and of sufficient length. The long introduction, on the other hand, is somewhat out of proportion to the commentary ; and five appendices explain certain important passages with greater fulness than a brief note allows. As has been said, the range of Dr. Perowne’s reading bearing upon the epistle is limited. He specities three epoch- making commentaries on the Galatian epistle ; but there are better than they. Those he chiefly follows are Dr. Lightfoot’s and that edited by Schaff. De Wette and Meyer are ignored. The note on chap. ii. 2, quoted in the greater part from Schaff, is perfunctory and insufficient; that on chap. iv. 24-26 is somewhat confusing. Ati. 23, where the word ‘* faith” first occurs in the epistle, the com- mentator says that it has three principal senses, the third of which he applies to the passage in question. Had he consulted a good lexicon, such as Grimm’s, he would have seen all the senses reduced to two; the third one, which he adopts, never belongs to the term in its New Testament usage, though he has Beza’s autho- rity for it. The meaning in v. 12 which he takes to be the right one is wrong. The verb alone, droxéyovrat in the middle voice, can hardly be taken in a passive sense. Here, as elsewhere, the Revised Version is subject to correction. Why spend a tolerably long note on the two words Abba, Father (iv. 7)? On the difficult passage iii. 20, which occupies one of the appendices, no fresh light is thrown; but the appendix on chap. ii. 16 is excellent and conclusive. Introduction to the Johannine Writings. By Paton J. Gloag, D.D. (Nisbet & Co.)—Dr. Gloag is one of the most prominent writers in North Britain on Biblical subjects, and we are glad to see that he is still actively pursuing his studies. His new venture touches more difli- cult books than he has dealt with before—books that need a critic’s best powers for their ex- planation and defence. The respected author is evidently master of the literature relating to the subject he has selected. He ranges over the whole province, wide as it is, neglecting little that has been said or written about it. His spirit is tolerant and fair, devoid of that bitterness which theologians have too often manifested. It is, therefore, pleasant to accom- pany him in the course of his weighing of con- flicting evidence. His attitude is apologetic, defending one side of all the questions raised— the conservative one. His aim is to vindicate the enuineness of the sacred documents described. onsequently, little that is new or original is presented. Old things are retold in the light of recent literature, but without any striking success. It cannot be said that the author has settled any perplexed question, and therefore his readers are often disappointed. Cogency, deci- sion, grasp, are wanting when Dr. Gloag comes to deal with difficulties. A dissertation on the day of our Lord’s death illustrates an easy way of escaping from a definite conclusion: ‘Until Biblical critics are agreed what fast was commemorated by the Orientals on the 14th Nisan, it is evident that the Paschal con- troversy has no bearing either on the authen- ticity of the Fourth Gospel, or on the question under discussion, the day of our Lord’s death.” Dr. Gloag rejects the two keys applied to solve the Apocalypse, saying of the first, ‘“‘Itis a mere gratuitous assumption to suppose that by the seven kings are denoted seven Roman em- perors”; and he has recourse to the ex- ploded theory that the number of the beast is Lateinos, not Nero. Again, speaking of the dis- similarities between the Fourth Gospel and the Apocalypse, he glides over them with facile satis- faction thus: ‘‘The difference in doctrine is slight, and is fairly accounted for by the apo- calyptic nature of the Revelation. The difference in spirit is more manifest, but is also accounted for by considering the subject-matter of the writings. The differences in language and style are still greater, but are lessened by consider- ing the different circumstances under which these works were written,” &. De Wette’s axiomatic principle admitted by the best critics is here set at nought. Few concessions are made to the modern criticism which the author opposes ; when allowed they are minimized. A certain degree of subjectivity is conceded toSt. John in recording the discourses of Christ, but it is soon dismissed on the basis of a note quoted from Weiss. Beyschlag’s more valuable and appropriate explanation is unnoticed. The weakest parts of the book are those dealing with internal evidence, on which the author relies less than upon the external. It will probably confirm those whose opinions are already fixed, but will hardly convince negative critics familiar with such subjects. Yet with all its faults the book is the best work which English theology has produced in favour of traditional views regard- ing the Johannine writings, and will doubtless be welcomed by all who do not sympathize with new notions about sacred books. The autho- rities oftenest referred to, who have most weight with Dr. Gloag, are a motley and somewhat feeble group, called to his aid from the obscurity to which the critical world had con- signed them, and needing thorough sifting ; whileafew eminentscholarsare often contradicted because their views are unwelcome to such as set out with foregone conclusions. Our author relies on numbers rather than critical ability. Does he put Dr. Salmon’s ‘Introduction’ on a level with Holtzmann’s ‘ Einleitung’; or Bishop Alexander on a par with Keim? Appearances favour the idea. OUR LIBRARY TABLE. Miss JEANNETTE Duncan’s volume, An Ame- rican Girl in London (Chatto & Windus), is a clever and lively book, showing that the writer retains the stock of spirits of which she had such abundance when she made ‘‘a social de- parture.” A good deal of the present book appeared in the Pictorial World, and bears traces of being written for periodical publica- tion. It would have been the better for a little condensation. The writer is ashrewd observer, and satirizes, with much liveliness and consider- able truth, Londoners and London ways. The illustrations by Mr. Townsend are often clever, but his drawing is shaky. Mexico, by Susan Hale (Fisher Unwin), is a well-written addition to the ‘‘Story of the Nations ” series. The law of proportion is not over well observed. The account of Spanish rule in Mexico is rather too brief, and the narrative of the war between the United States and Mexico is rather too long; but the latter fact is, perhaps, natural when the writer is an American. THE memoir of Dr. A. W. Potts prefixed to the volume of his School Sermons which Messrs. Blackwood have issued gives a capital account of an energetic and successful schoolmaster in whose character there were many fine traits. The sermons are favourable specimens of their class. Mr. Betton’s Literary Manual of Foreign Quotations (Putnam’s Sons) is a pleasant if rather superficial volume. It has an agreeable literary flavour about it; but there is little or no attempt at research, and when Mr. Belton comes across a saying of dubious origin like ‘‘ Gutta cavat lapidem non vi, sed seepe cadendo,” he does not attempt to trace it to its source. Again, although no people can rival the Spaniards in the matter of proverbs, not one appears to be given in this work. Another neglect of Spanish sources is shown in the citation of the words in ‘Don Carlos,’ ‘‘ Die Sonne geht in meinem Staat nicht unter,” without any mention of the fact that the boast was a commonplace in the Spanish literature of the day, which Schiller quite properly put into his drama. There is no need to go to Balthazar Schupp for it, as Biich- mann does. However, to turn over the pages of this volume is an agreeable occupation, and we are duly grateful to Mr. Belton. We have noticed but one misprint, and only two errors in matters of fact. Louis XV. did not witness the funeral of Madame Pompadour from a window in the Palais Royal; and Mr. Belton is also in error regarding the Pope’s blessing wrbi et orbi. WE have on our table The Boys and Girls’ Companion (C.E.S.8.1.),—‘' Bonnie Little Boni- bel” and Her *‘Day Off,” by M. D. Brine (Hodder & Stoughton),—An Englishman’s Ad- ventures on German Rivers, by L. Farnell, edited by Dr. A. Hamann (Berlin, Simion),— Under the Walnut-Tree, by F. Armstrong (Hogg),— Mabel’s Holiday, by E. M.and A. H. (S.P.C.K.), —Alison Walsh, by C. Evelyn (Nelson),—Music Hall Land, by P. Fitzgerald (Ward & Downey), —Was He Mad? by Victor R. (Routledge), — Very Much in Earnest, by A. Lyster (S.P.C.K.), —Pine, Rose, and Fleur de Lis, by S. F. Harrison(Toronto, Hart & Co.),—Love’s Victory, by J. A. Blaikie (Percival & Co.),—King Rolf ; or, a Norman Holiday in Sicily, by K. Geng- nagel (Siegle),— The Church-Worker, Vol. IX. (C.E.S.S.1.),— What to Read: Part IV., Sun- day Reading in Prose, edited by the Rev. F. Langbridge (R.T.S.),—and The Prayer of —" by the Rev. H. N. Grimley (Kegan aul). LIST OF NEW BOOKS. ENGLISH. Theology. Blake’s (B.) How to Read Isaiah, cr. 8vo. 2/6 cl. Carter’s (T. T.) Spiritual Instructions : Our Lord’s Entrance on His Ministry, cr. 8vo. 3/6 cl. Curtiss’s (S. J.) Franz Delitzsch, a Memorial Tribute, 3/ cl. Déllinger’s (I. von) Declarations and Letters on the Vatican Decrees, cr. 8vo. 3,6 cl. Dupanloup’s (Monseigneur) The Ministry of Catechising, er. 8vo. 7/6 cl. Liddon (H. P.), Maxims and Gleanings from the Writings of, 16mo. 2/ cl. Parker’s (J.) People’s Bible : Vol. 14, Ecclesiastes, &c., 8vo. 8/ Service Book for the Church and School, edited by G. S-. Barrett, cr. 8vo. 2/ cl. Smiley’s (Rev. F. E.) Evangelization of a Great City, 14/ cl. Swayne’s (W. T.) An Inquiry into the Nature of our Lord’s Knowledge as Man, 12mo. 2/ cl. Wesley and his Successors, a Centenary Memorial of the Death of John Wesley, 4to. 30/ cl. Wynne’s (Rev. F. R.) Our Sacred Commission, cr. 8vo, 3,6 Poetry. Metchim’s (B.) Wild West, Poems, illus. cr. 8vo. 2/6 cl. Philosophy. Coit’s (S.) Introduction to the Study of Ethics, cr. 8vo. 4/6 History and Biography. Amand’s (I. de Saint) Marie Louise and the Decadence of the Empire, cr. 8vo. 5/ cl. Anderson’s (J. H.) History of George III.’s Reig. 4/6 cl. Bridgett’s (T. E.) Life and Writings of Sir Thomas More, rd Chancellor of England, &c., cr. 8vo. 7/6 cl. Froissart’s (Sir J.) Chronicles of England, France, Spain, &c., cr. 8vo. 3/6 cl. Gardiner’s (S. R.) Student’s History of England, Vol. 2, 4/ cl. Mayne’s (Capt. C. B.) Late Battles in the Soudan and Modern Tactics, a Reply, cr. 8vo. 2/ cl. Smiles’s ‘S.) A Publisher and his Friends, Memoir and Cor- respondence of John Murray, 2 vols. 8vo. 32/ cl. Geography and Travel. Bartholomew’s (J. G.) School Hand Atlas, 2/6 cl. Ferguson’s (D.) Vicissitudes of Bush Life in Australia and New Zealand, 8vo. 10/6 cl. Gibson’s (A. G. 8.) Eight Years in Kaffraria, 1882-90, 3/6 cl. Windt’s (H. de) A Ride to India across Persia and Baluchi stan, 8vo. 16/ cl. Philology. Lewis’s (C. T.) Elementary Latin acme sm. 4to. 7/6 cl. Soames’s (L.) Introduction to Phonetics (English, French, and German), cr. 8vo. 6/ cl. f Virgil, Bucolics and Georgics, edited, with Introduction and Notes, by T. L. Papillon and A. E. Haigh, cr. 8vo. 3/6 Science. Cappie’s (J.) Inter-Cranial Circulation and its Relation to the Physiology of the Brain, 8vo. 7/6 cl. Greene’s Ww. T.) Birds I have Kept in Years Gone By, 5/ cl. Johnstone’s (A.) Botany, a Concise Manual for Students of neand Science, illust. cr. 8vo. 6/ cl. hp A 8 & ae te mee Oh Ob Oe ok ek me Oh mm Oe lw ee we ~t t ti h a 0 0 W a T XUM

Page 15

XUM N° 3308, Marcn 21, ’91 THE ATHENAUM 375. §aundby’s (R.) Lectures on Diabetes, including the Brad- shaw Lectures, August 18, 1890, 8vo. 7/6 cl. Van 't Hoff’s (J. H.) Chemistry in Space, translated and edited by J. E. Marsh, cr. 8vo. 4/6 cl. Wood's (S.) a Plain Guide to Good Gardening, cheap ed. 3/6 General Literature. Acworth’s (W. M.) The Railways and the Traders, cr. 8vo. 6/ Anstey’s (F.) Tourmalin’s Time Cheques, cr. 8vo. 2/ cl. Besant’s (W.) For Faith and Freedom, 12mo. 2/ bds. Boyle's (F.) The Evil Genius, 3 vols. cr. 8vo. 31/6 cl. Edwards's: M. B.) The 5g of the Ways, cr. 8vo. 6/ cl. Famous Golf Links, by H. G. Hutchinson, A. Lang, and others, cr. 8vo. 6/ cl. Fenn’s (G. M.) Sawn Off, a Tale of a Family Tree, cr. 8vo. 2/6cl. (Whitefriars Library.) Greenleeks Papers (The), edited by the Rev. T. Tipstaff, 6/ Holley’s (M. E.) Josiah Allen’s Wife as a P.A. and P.L., or Samantha at the Centennial, cr. 8vo. 2/ bds. Houdin’s (R.) Card Sharpers, their Tricks Exposed, trans- lated by J. Forster, illus. cr. 8vo. 2/6 cl. Lafargue’s (P.) Evolution of Property from Savagery to Civilization, cr. 8vo. 2/6 cl. Lassen’s (C.) Commercial Guide, Systematic Bookkeeping by Single and Double Entry, 8vo. 6/ cl. . Ritchie’s (D. G.) Principles of State Interference, cr. 8vo. 2/6 Schopenhauer’s (A.) The Art of Literature, translated, with Preface, by T. B. Saunders, cr. 8vo. 2/6 cl. Snow's (J.) The School of Art, 2/ cl. (Pseudonym Library.) Whitby’s (B.) The Awakening of Mary Fenwick, a Novel, 3/6 Yeo’s (H.) Newspaper Management, 12mo. 5/ cl. FOREIGN, Theology. Hilt (F.): Gregor v. Nyssa Lehre vom Menschen, 5m. Fine Art. Vibert (J. G.): La Science de la Peinture, 3fr. 50. Poetry. Delpit (A.): Poésies, 3fr. 50. History and Biography. Boissier (G@.): La Fin du Paganisme, 2 vols. 15fr. Broc ( Victe.de): La France pendant m Révolution, 2 vols. 15fr. Hamel (E.) : Thermidor, 3fr. 50. Hansische Geschichtsquellen, Vol. 6, 8m. Hérisson (Comte d’): La Chasse a l’'Homme, 3fr, 50. Kallsen (O.): Die Deutschen Stiidte im Mittelalter, Vol. 1, 7m. 50. Sergy (E.): Carmen Sylva, 3fr. 50. Philology. Mirchen (Die) d. Papyrus Westcar, hrsg. v. A. Erman, 2 parts, 41m. Muret: Encyklopiidisches Englisch-Deutsches u. Deutsch- Englisches Woérterbuch, Part 1, 1m. 50. Radloff (W.): Versuch e. Wérterbuches der Tiirk-Dialekte, Part 4, 3m. General Literature. Bréte (J. de la) : Le Comte de Paléne, 3fr. 50. THE CALENDAR OF ANCIENT DEEDS. Tue Calendar of Ancient Deeds, lately pre- pared by officers of the Public Record Oftice, under the superintendence of the Deputy Keeper, is modestly styled a catalogue ; but the character of the entries, the addition of an extensive index, and the familiar binding of the Calendars of State Papers will perhaps warrant the already general appellation. The appear- ance of the present volume is a somewhat notable event in the history of Record publica- tions. In the last Report of the Deputy Keeper an announcement was made, which had been already foreshadowed by preceding returns of the literary work of the Department, providing for the future issue of the calendars or indexes included in the annual Reports in a separate form. The many advantages of this plan will be obvious to all students of records, who are sure to appreciate this volume and its successors at their full value. It is, perhaps, too much to expect that these should be enriched by a pre- face descriptive of the precise position amongst records of their several contents, of their rela- tionship to other MSS. where they may happen to be enrolled or transcribed, or of their general historical value, because, in the case of ancient deeds at least, as the Deputy Keeper justly observes, ‘the legal and historical value of ordinary conveyances of land is hardly such as would justify a treatment of them as full as that accorded to documents relating to public affairs.” Therefore, if antiquaries may be permitted to read the concluding part of the above sentence in the light of a promise, they may well be content with the excellent précis of the three series of deeds which, it is said, form the first instalment of a catalogue of all the ancient deeds preserved in the Public Record Office. On the same grounds the student must, perhaps, be content with the present index, although in this case a considerable effort is required. It should be remem- bered, however, that hitherto these Reports have been practically unindexed, and even an index without Christian names is obviously better than none at all, while, moreover, the index of places and subjects is particularly in- telligent and valuable. In the present age of a rapid production of historical texts, antiquaries have become almost entirely dependent upon an exhaustive introduction and an analytical index. Doubtless this is a regrettable practice, but its prevalence is none the less a fact, and, what is more, a fact which many persons glory in. Now a reaction has set in; the authorities decline to provide éditions de luxe, and there is much grumbling amongst those who wish to keep pace with the times without any excessive personal exertions. The collection of ancient deeds preserved in the Public Record Office was derived at different dates from several distinct repositories, and, as the Deputy Keeper tells us, the great bulk were found to be ‘‘in no order whatever,” while the | ‘Petit Traité de Poésie Frangaise,’ which is one of the very best authorities on French prosody. In fact, the advocatus diaboli has urged, and will urge, against his admission to the highest or higher ranks of poets (for poetry was his proper and principal vocation) that his extra- ordinary science and deftness of craftsmanship rather interfered with the unforced and inevit- able touch required in the greatest verse. He began quite early, producing ‘ Les Cariatides’ when he was nineteen ; and his last volume, ‘Son- nailles et Clochettes,’ was published the other day when he was sixty-seven. But the greater and better part of his work in verse appeared in about thirty years from the volume above mentioned to the ‘ Trente-six Ballades Joyeuses’ of 1873, omitting the rather unlucky ‘Idylles Prussiennes,’ which came a little earlier. M. de Banville was a contributor to all three issues of the ‘ Parnasse Contemporain,’ and, indeed, | with M. Leconte de Lisle may be said to have | been at the head of the Parnassien school. | Posterity, if it is assisted by proper scholiasts, remainder were arranged ‘‘ according to several | different methods.”” As far as the work of re- arrangement and classification has proceeded, six great series of ancient deeds are now gener- ally recognized. Of these the first three are partially described in the present Calendar— namely, Series A or the Exchequer Collection ; Series B from the Court of Augmentations ; and Series C from the Chancery Records. Be- sides these three series there are two more, known as the D and E series, and composed respectively of the deeds preserved in the Queen’s Remembrancer’s Office in the Ex- chequer and in the Land Revenue Office, together with some 5,000 more formerly belong- ing to the old ‘‘ court of Whitehall,” commonly known as the Court of Wards and Liveries. All of these will perhaps be included in due course within the present Calendar. Several interesting questions arise in con- nexion with the existence of these private documents in official custody. How were they received? Why were they preserved ? In what cases were they enrolled, and where? Finally, what has become of the originals of a certain class known to have been enrolled in more than one series of Records? These questions and other points connected with the various formule and the terminology of the writing which, when wit- nessed, sealed, and delivered, constituted a deed, will some day require a fuller explanation than any we at present possess. In the mean time the historian and the genealogist will have had access to a rich mine of local information, and one which for several years to come is likely to prove inexhaustible. M. DE BANVILLE. WitH Théodore (Faullain) de Banville last week died the last (if we except M. Leconte de Lisle) and the most remarkable (if we repeat the same exception and add the name of Bau- delaire) of what has been called the middle generation of French poets of this century. Born in 1823 at Moulins of a good family, and the son of a post captain in the French navy, he himself never did anything but literary work, but his literary work was abundant, excellent, and various. He was both a dramatist and, for a time, a dramatic critic, his chief creative efforts being ‘Gringoire,’ which has been more than once translated or adapted in Eng- lish, and perhaps ‘Le Beau Léandre.’ He had always written more or less in prose, and during the last ten years or so he be- came rather more fertile than some of his admirers would have had him—in stories often graceful, but occasionally thin, and sometimes too much accommodated to the tastes of the vulgar—in sketches, souvenirs, and miscellanea of all kinds. His prose in itself was, however, very good indeed ; and he had earlier written a ' may perhaps enjoy most, according to its habit, his very delightful ‘Odes Funam- bulesques,’ 1857, a book of light verse to which it is very difficult to find any English parallel. But in his serious volumes (to which must be added ‘ Les Stalactites,’ very much in the vein of the ‘ Cariatides,’ that is to say, blendings of romantic treatment with a classical tone; the ‘Odelettes,’ strongly Ronsardian, as, indeed, was most of his work ; ‘ Les Exilés,’ ‘ Le Sang de la Coupe,’ the powerful ‘ Malédiction de Vénus,’ and others) there is to be found uniformly a most unusual power over language and metre, and less uniformly true poetical spirit. The ‘Nouvelles Odes Funambulesques,’ in which some dozen years later than the original volume he endeavoured to continue its style, did not escape the fate of continuations. But he was on the whole, as a writer, in prose inferior to few, and in verse to very few, of his contem- poraries. SALE. Tue sale of the Lakelands Library, formed by the late Mr. W. H. Crawford, of Cork, attracted, on account of its many great rarities, the attention of book collectors in all parts of the globe. The sale, begun on March 12th, will conclude on the 25th. In eight pages of in- troduction the auctioneers, Messrs. Sotheby, Wilkinson & Hodge, have pointed out the articles most worthy of attention. Among the principal articles were the Abbotsford Club Publications, which sold for 231. Asopi Fabule, the 1473 edition, went for 28/., and the 1482 edition for 17/.; La Blachitre, Voiages Perilleux, for 12/. 5s., purchased in Mr. Beck- ford’s sale for 51. 15s.; Oviedo, Coronica de las Indias y Conquista del Peru, for 23/. 10s.; and Apiani Astronomicum Cesareum, the first book printed at a private press in Germany, for 91. 15s. Apicius, Culinarius, first edition of this famous cookery - book, fetched 8l. 5s. Aretinus de Bello Italico, 301. Ariosto, Orlando, first edition, 35/. Augustinus de Virginitate, printed by Gutenberg, 14/. 15s. ; and his De Civitate Dei, printed by Mentelin, 201. 5s. Autograph Letters and Deeds, collected and facsimiled in his British Autography by J. Thane, 5601. Ausmo, Supplementum, first book printed at Genoa, 14/. 10s. Collections of old Broadside Ballads, 100/. Barclay’s Eglogues, 19]. 15s. Bartholomeo da li Sonetti Isolario, 291. Basan, Dictionnaire des Graveurs, 201. Bastard, Peintures et Ornements, 57]. Beau- mont and Fletcher’s Poems, in which Shak- speare is mentioned, 121. Bergomensis de Mulieribus, with the woodcut of Pope Joan, 201. 10s. Biblia Polyglotta of Cardinal Ximenez, 1001.; Biblia Latina of 1470-1, 521.; and 1476 edition, 38/.; First Scotch Breeches Bible, im- perfect, 19/. Blake’s Original Drawings of Angels and Devils, 235/. Andechs Heilig-

Page 16

376 THE ATHENAUM N° 3308, Marcx 21, ’91 thiimer, an unknown block of two leaves, 221. 10s. Boccaccio, Decameron, the famous Valdarfer edition, but wanting five leaves, 2301. ; the 1472 edition, 511. ; and 1527 Giunta, 261. ; Boccaccio, Fiametta, first edition, 171., and the same in English, 17/.; Bocace, Ruyne des Nobles, 13/.; and his Genealogie des Dieux, printed by Verard, 341. 10s. Bouchet, L’Amoureux, printed on vellum, with twenty miniatures, 2501. Breviarium Romanum, MS. of the fifteenth century, on vellum, 1651. Brey- denbach, Peregrinationes in Montem Syon, 241. 10s. Bry, Emblemata, 35/. Bryan’s Dic- tionary of Painters, illustrated, 371. Buck- hurst, Ferrex and Porrex, 20/. Bulzi Historia Universitatis Parisiensis, 211. Burns’s Poems, first edition, soiled and imperfect, 211. Czesar, first edition, 23/. Caoursin, Obsidio Rhodiz, 18]. 10s. ; and the English version of it, 351. 10s. A pack of forty-eight Taroc Cards, 391. Caviceo, Le Pelegrin, printed on vellum, supposed to be unique, 3551. Caxton’s Myrrour of the World, several leaves facsimiled, 1601. Charte Anglo-Saxonice et Latinz, 210/. Chaucer, Canterbury Tales, Pynson’s edition, im- perfect, 27/. Chesneau, Ecole Frangaise, 491. Chodowiecki, Etchings, 801. Christi Vita et Passio, ten miniatures, 521. 10s. Christi Lyden, printed 1483 in Haerlem, 30/. Christi Leven, first book printed at Amsterdam, 271. 10s.; and the Scoenhoven edition, 13/. 10s. Cronecken der Sasser, 28/. Chronicon Nurembergense, 201. 5s. Chronycles of Englond, printed by G. de Leeu, imperfect, 33’. Cicero de Officiis, first edition, printed on vellum, 801. Claren- don’s Rebellion and Life, illustrated, 511. Minia- ture of the Crucifixion by Giulio Clovio, 71. Cockain, Poems, 36/. Concilium von Constencz, 301. 10s. Dante of 1481, with the twenty rare engravings by Baldini, from designs by S. Bot- ticelli, 360/.; and another copy with only three of the engravings, 441. Davis’s Scourge of Folly, 241. 10s. Des Franchiéres, Fauconnerie, 201. Diirer’s Works, 861. Du Sommerard, Les Arts de Moyen Age, 68/.. The first four days of the sale of this fine library produced 7,5771. 7s. 6d. WILLIAM HUNNIS, GENTLEMAN OF THE CHAPEL ROYAL. II. UNDER ELIZABETH. WHETHER the period between March, 1556, and the accession of Elizabeth, was spent by William Hunnis in the Tower or not, we are certain he was freed at once by the new queen, ‘‘his sweet Lady Elizabeth,” and restored to his ‘‘living” as gentleman of the chapel, if he ever had been formally deprived of it. Early in the new reign, however, he suffered from a domestic loss. Like his predecessor William Crane in the office of Master of the Children of the Chapel, William Hunnis was a married man. Until I learned the fact, I had not thought the laws, or at least the customs of the time, would have permitted this. Nevertheless the testimony is irrefragable. On June 2nd, 1559, ‘*Margaret Hunnis, alias Brigham, alias Wariner, wyfe of William Hunnys, gentleman of the Queene’s Majesties Chappell,” made her testa- ment nuncupative, in which, by consent of her husband, she left to her ‘‘ Cousin Francis Brig- ham all that her tenements and mansion house lyinge and beyinge at Westminster, commonly cawled ‘The Allmes House,’” founded by Henry VII., and sold by Vincent to Brigham in 34 Hen. VIII. All her other goods, movable and immovable, she left to her husband William Hunnis, whom also she named her executor. This testament was proved by Thomas Willot for William Hunnis, October 12th, 1559. Her will was a lucky find, especially in connexion with the gossip of Dethicke, which implied undue familiarity between Hunnis and Brigham’s wife. But Chalmers’s ‘ Biographies’ and Wood’s ‘ Athenze Oxonienses’ say that ‘‘ Nicholas Brig- ham died in his prime in December, 1559, at Westminster, leaving some MSS.: (1) ‘De Vena- tionibus Rerum Memorabilium,’ a collection of notices of characters and events of which Bale has made much use; (2) ‘Memoirs,’ in the form of a diary in twelve books ; and (3) ‘ Mis- cellaneous Poems.’ None of these is probably in existence.” Wood thinks he was buried near Chaucer, whose tomb he had restored in 1556. But he is in error in the date ; he died in 1558, leaving, by a verbal will, everything to his wife. She was granted powers of administration Feb- ruary 20th, 1558/9, and at least before the follow- ing June Hunnis had married Brigham’s widow. The entry among the wills, December, 1559, is an objection to William Hunnis succeeding his wife, widow of Nicholas Brigham. Consider- able litigation ensued in consequence of her bequests. The young widower had, with other of her subjects, to wait some time before any practical recognition of his services was rendered him by Queen Elizabeth, beyond those connected with his living. The first I have found recorded is a patent in June, the fourth year of Elizabeth, to the office of supervisor and custodian of the orchards and gardens at Greenwich, called the ‘‘ great gardyne” and the ‘‘ new gardyne,” to hold during his life with a salary of 12d. a day and various perquisites. One duty was to present the queen with seven gallons of ‘‘sweet water” a year. I am aware that Cunningham, in his ‘Revels’ Book,’ asserts that this is another William Hunnis; but he had not made a thorough search, or hewould have found it expressly stated that the grant was to ‘* William Hunnis of the Chapell.” This, therefore, connects him with various pay- ments made ‘‘ to the supervisor of the gardens ” for ‘‘men gardeners and women weeders at Greenewich ”’; and also with the famous account for seventy-nine bushels of roses and many bushels of other flowers in June of the 14th Elizabeth, ‘‘in preparation of the Banketing Howse made at White Hall for the entertain- ment of the said Duke.” Not only were there to be wreaths and adornments of flowers, but the floor was to be strewn with ‘‘rose- leaves pickt, and sweetened with sweet waters,” under the supervision of Hunnis. One sug- gestive point in connexion with this patent of supervisor I have not yet worked out; but I may mention that his predecessor in office was one Philip Innes, whom Edward VI., in the fourth year of his reign, appointed for life to this post. But in 1562 the said Philip Innes appears before Elizabeth and ‘‘renders up his office in favour of one William Hunnys,” and his patent is then cancelled. The new patent is at the side named ‘‘the patent of Philip Innes alias Hunnys,” and this is scratched out, and below is written fair ‘‘the patent of Willian Hunnys.” Is it possible that this Innes was his father, and that he had been brought up as a ‘‘gardener’s son”? Had he improved his name into Hinnes, in which form it ap- pears oftener than in any other? I cannot yet say more than that the point is worth noting. In the first year of Mary there was another of the name, a John Innes, of Westminster, appointed to receive the ‘‘ first almsmans room in the cathedral church of Westminster.” Probably by the favour of Elizabeth, on the death of Richard Edwards, Master of the Children of the Chapel Royal, on the 31st of October, 1566, William Hunnis was appointed in his place on the 15th of November. But Elizabeth proved in his case not a ‘‘liberall dame,” as his perquisites, or rather his pro- visions, were materially curtailed, at the same time that the prices of food had much increased. This he very clearly explains in an interesting petition presented to the Council in November, 1583, where he states that he had to keep not only an usher, but a man-servant, to wait on the boys, and a woman servant to keep them clean, on an income of 6d. a day each for their food, and 40]. a year for their apparel and all other expenses, nothing being allowed for travelling and lodging when the Court required him to carry the boys with him to various places. On an examination of his demands, they appear both just and moderate. We do not wonder that he left no will, unless the verses: mentioned by Warton as written on the fly-leaf of Sir Thomas More’s works really represented one :— To God my soul I doe bequeath, because it is his owne, My body to be laid in grave, where to my friends best: nown, Executors I will none make, thereby great stryfe may growe, Because the goods that I shall leave will not pay all I owe. . Hunnis. But this point has been previously noted, and I only now allude to it in connexion with others: that are original. Having found from the Guildhall records. that he wasa ‘‘ Citizen and Grocer ” of London, I made application to the Grocers’ Company,, and the authority of Mr. Kingdon corrobo- rated that evidence. It is not clear whether he first entered the company by inheritance, by apprenticeship, by payment, or by election. It is just possible that in the stirring times of 1556 the company may have enrolled him in order to shelter him with their power, as they had! done to Fermor in a similar case. In May, 1566-7, he was formally admitted to the ‘* Livery and Clothing” of the company, the fourth among a list of eighteen citizens. He duly paid his brotherhood money, two shillings. In the year 1570 his name was entered among the group of those ‘‘dwelling at Westminster and extravagant’; and he paid four shillings. for the brotherhood money for the last two years, and two shillings towards defraying the expenses of the election feast. This is signi- ficant in relation to the entry in Guildhall, which states in 1570 that a ‘‘reversion of the office of collection of the cities rightes, duties,, and profittes, cominge and growinge uppon London Bridge, for wheelage and passage,” was: granted ‘‘to William Hunnys, citizen and grocer, and also master of Hir grace’s children of hir Chappell Royal,” upon letters of her Majesty in his favour. Various difficulties having arisen from the fact that the present collectors had been pro- mised that they should retain the post, not only for the twenty-one years for which tliey hele a patent, but for the term of their natural lives and of the life of the survivor, it was agreed that the bridgemaster should pay to Mr. Hunnis, in gratification of the queen’s letters, the sum of 40/. for a lease in reversion of the wheelage and passage of London Bridge. Whether this 40/. was in lieu of the rever- sion, or only as a douceur for the time likely to elapse before the reversion should fall in, is not clear from the passage, and I have not yet been able to work it out. With his various expenses among the boys of the chapel this: 40]. would not last long; and therefore he was driven to frame the petition of 1583. I do not now notice his poems, because I have only acquired any knowledge regarding them from printed material. But it is evident his poems read differently when connected with the events of his life. For instance, the open- ing device at the Kenilworth* festivities in 1575, when Sybilla prophesies good things to Eliza- beth, comes gracefully from one who had con- scientiously plotted to make her queen two years earlier than she became so—probably the only poet of that conspiracy then surviving. The rewards for his plays are printed by Cun- ningham, and his death is noted in 1597 in ‘‘ the Cheque Book of the Chapel Royal. ’ I know it is possible that some may object that the William whose name I find spelt in seventeen different ways is not the same as the ‘‘Thomas Hinnewes” tried for his life at Guildhall. But the connecting links are strong. This laxity of orthography made me look up all resembling names in wills, inquisitions, &c., * See ‘George Gascoigne’s brief rehearsal of as much as. was presented before her Majestie at Kenilworth during her- last abode there, July, 1575,” printed March 26th, 1576.

Page 17

N° 3308, Marcu 21, ’91 THE ATHENZXUM 377 about the period, to find a pedigree for him, but without success as yet. I have not found the name ‘‘ Hunnis ” appear before his time, and since then only twice ; the first being a Thomas Hunnis, who died in 1626, and might very well have been his son; the other a ‘‘Marchadine Hunnys, of Berks, Plebs; a Demy of Magdalene College, Oxford, 1605; M.A. 1610.” This may give a clue to the local origin of the name, but the Marchadine ‘‘Plebs” could not have been the son of William, as he was always entered “gentleman,” and had a coat of arms granted him in 1568 (Ash. MS. Bodleian Library). My original materials have been collected from the Manuscript Department of the British Museum, the Public Record Office, the Guild- hall Record Office, the books of the Grocers’ Company, and from Somerset House. Only want of space prevents me giving references in full. I sincerely hope, however, that I may have an opportunity of publishing ere long the whole series of papers in extenso, as an addition to the contemporary history of the poet. CHARLOTTE CARMICHAEL STOPES. THE HARRIS PAPYRI. Mr. JAMES Dovetas writes from Bombay :— The paper on Egyptian papyri in the Atheneum of the 3lst of January brings vividly to my memory aconversation with the late Mr. Harris in the year 1851. It was after dinner, and with his hookah, seated in his sanctum and surrounded by the idols of Egypt, he related to me that a native had one day brought him the arm-bone of a mummy along with some papyrus, for which he gave a trifle. The native described minutely the spot where he had found it, how he had to wrench the arm from the body to get it intact, and that there remained more papyri under the other arm. On examining it some months after by the aid of chemicals, he discovered, to his surprise, that it was a portion of Homer’s Iliad. His curiosity was excited, and the next time he went up the Nile—every season saw him there—he resolved to visit the spot so minutely described, and, sure enough, though 700 miles from Alexandria, he found the body, minus the right arm, and more papyrus. He paused in his narrative, after relating that this last was inscribed with the words, “ This is the Grammar of me, Tryphon, the Grammarian of Alexandria,” ceased his hubble-bubble, stalked across the room to a glass case, from whence he drew something likea moss-stick from an Irish bog, and threw it on the table, exclaiming, “ There, sir, is the right arm of Tryphon, the Grammarian of Alexandria.” I looked at the black and skinny fingers which had once beckoned the students from visions of lentil-soup and red mullet, “ food of great Callisthenes,” and seemed to listen to his dying injunction, which was, no doubt, to bury him with his own grammar, and the next greatest book in the world, Homer’s Iliad. These relics, then at Kum-el-dyk (Fort Napoleon), are doubtless those described by your correspondent. THE SPRING PUBLISHING SEASON. Messrs. Kecan Pavt & Co. will publish im- mediately after Easter a new novel in three volumes by Maxwell Gray, author of ‘The Silence of Dean Maitland,’ entitled ‘In the Heart of the Storm: a Tale of Modern Chivalry,’ —‘ There and Back,’ by Dr. George Mac Donald, in three volumes,—‘ Bonnie Kate,’ a story from a woman’s point of view, by Mrs. Leith Adams, also in three volumes,—and a new edition in one volume of ‘ A Sensitive Plant,’ by E. and D. Gerard. Messrs. Griffith & Farran promise the second volume of the English translation of Talleyrand’s ‘Memoirs,’—‘Cooee: Tales of Australian Life by Australian Ladies,’ edited by Mrs. Patchett Martin,—‘A Wild Blossom,’ by Mrs. Batchelor,—‘Sweet Con- tent,’ by Mrs. Molesworth, — ‘ Through Misty Veils: Verses of the Past and of Day- Dreamland,’ by Rowe Lingston,—‘The Shelley Birthday Book,’ compiled by J. R. Tutin,— ‘The Proverbial Birthday Book,’ arranged by M. E. Donald,—‘The Temple of Fame, and other Poems,’ by Ganymede,—‘ Younger Ame- rican Poets, 1830-1890,’ edited by Mr. D. B. W. Sladen, with an appendix of ‘ Younger Canadian Poets,’ edited by Mr. G. Bliss Roberts, —popular sixpenny edition of ‘The Three Commanders,’ by the late W. H. G. Kingston,—the ‘ Next Thing ” Series, a set of sixpenny and threepenny volumes for wage-earning girls by various writers,—‘ Recitation : a Handbook,’ by Mr. A. Burrell,—‘ Exercises in Speech and Simple Recitations for Standards I., II., and III.,’ for Standards III. and IV., and for Standards IV. and V. and Higher Classes, — ‘ Draw- ing under the Education Code,’—and the following theological works: a translation of ‘The Ministry of Catechising’ of Monseigneur Dupanloup ; ‘The Sacrifice of Praise ;’ ‘Simple Thoughts for the Church’s Year,’ by A. B. Tucker ; ‘The Clergyman’s Duty in relation to the Lord’s Day,’ an essay, by the Rev. Morris Fuller ; ‘Communion with God, Aids to Private Prayer,’ by Mrs. M. L. M. Dawson; ‘The Sacred Way from Advent to Advent,’ by Miss Gaye ; and ‘The Throne of Canterbury ; or, the Archbishop’s Jurisdiction,’ by the Rev. Morris Fuller. Messrs. Hutchinson & Co. announce ‘The Australasian Dictionary of Biography (including New Zealand and Fiji), 1855-91,’ by Mr. P. Mennell,—‘The Black Police: a Story of Modern Australia,’ by Mr. A. J. Vogan,—‘ The Handy Guide to Australia,’ by Mr. G.C. Levey, C.M.G., —‘ Barney Geogheghan, M.P., and Home Rule at St. Stephen’s,’ by Mr. E. Jenkins, author of ‘Ginx’s Baby,’—‘The Childhood and Youth of Charles Dickens,’ by Mr. R. Langton, illus- trated,—‘The Poets and Poetry of the Century,’ edited by Mr. A. H. Miles,—‘ The Life of E. L. Blanchard,’ by Mr. Clement Scott,—and in the ‘Library Edition of Novels”: ‘Sam’s Sweet- heart,’ by Helen Mathers; ‘By Order of the Czar,’ by Mr. Joseph Hatton; ‘Miss Harring- ton’s Husband,’ by Florence Marryat ; and ‘The Girl He did not Marry,’ by Miss Duffus Hardy. THE AMERICAN = COPYRIGHT New York, March 6, 1891. Art the Authors’ Club last night homage was paid to an eagle’s quill, displayed on the wall, with which President Harrison signed the new copyright law. This graceful trophy, 18 in. long, was presented by the President to Mr. Robert Underwood Johnson, of the Centwry Magazine, to whose unwearied engineering the success of the measure is largely due. Mr. Johnson received hearty congratulations in the club, where several Englishmen were present, among them Mr. Joseph Hatton. The new law was much discussed, and although no author is satisfied with it, all agreed that it is an im- portant gain. The protectionist feature of the law, requiring copyrighted books to be entirely manufactured in this country, was a necessary sop to the three-headed Cerberus whom three powerful trade unions had set at the door of Congress. They were such a stupidly furious Cerberus that, at the last moment, they came near tearing the Bill to pieces because the Senate insisted on allowing importation of two copies of a book not for sale. A representa- tive answered the leading typographer, ‘‘ Re- member, if you kill this Bill you will be held responsible for the destruction of a measure by which your business is more favoured than any other.” The lobbyist quailed. Then the other side had to be conciliated. Even after the Con- ference Committee had agreed, and the two houses accepted their agreement, and the Bill had been signed by the Vice-President, a motion to reconsider was introduced in the Senate between midnight and morning, and only failed from the momentary lack of a quorum. A quorum was speedily gathered; but Mr. Johnson was swift, and the Bill was ‘‘railroaded” (as a senator complained) to the Executive Mansion before the decision could be reversed. The senatorial opposition was bitter, and it was almost pathetic to see Senator Platt struggling for his Bill against its eloquent assailants, whose sarcastic exposures of its defects and partialities he could not refute. He won by sleepless persistence, and his Bill, whatever its faults, was the only one there was any possibility of passing. Last year I expressed in the London Athe- neum my strong objection to the Bill’s exaction of ‘‘simultaneous publication” of the forei book. Those objections were read to the Senate by the Hon. John W. Daniel, of Virginia, who made a very eloquent plea for a margin of six months within which the foreign author might mature his copyright here. This senator, himself the author of a well-known law book, was not answered of course, the injustice being indefensible, and he remained irreconcilable. But now that these efforts have been defeated, it is of importance that those in whose behalf they were made should understand that they are not left helpless by the Act. The new and unknown author is, indeed, subjected to the necessity of contracting with a publisher with out the advantage of bringing to the negotiation press notices of his book at home; he must take what he can get. But it is open to him to include in his American contract a provision that if his book shall find success his royalties must be proportionately increased. A sale of 3,000 or 4,000 being allowed the American house for its risk, expense, and fair profit, such house would agree that the author should then receive a graduated increase of profits up to 15 per cent. The foreign author has also some check on his American publisher in a privilege shared with the American author of changing his publisher. Should an American or English author believe himself unfairly treated, he may bargain with another publisher to bring out an edition of his book, and no injunction could issue against such edition. The first publisher could bring an action against the owner of the copyright, but then only if he had been guaranteed against a rival edition. He would have to prove that he had fulfilled his part of the contract. Under these circumstances it will be well for the foreign author to consider the importance of retaining his own copyright. It is, indeed, not probable: that an American publisher will run the risk of getting a bad reputation among foreign authors by unfairness that might lead him into a court of law ; but all possibilities must be considered. The American publisher will, of course, demand a guarantee against rival editions, and the foreign author will no doubt understand that such guarantee has its value. The American author, who has so long suffered by competition with his unpaid or underpaid foreign brothers, is but measurably relieved by this law. All foreign books that have not found publishers here at the time of their appearance in Europe may be freely pirated. Efforts to remedy this will be con- tinued in Congress, but their success will de- pend on the working of the new Act. Foreign authors will assist the future improvement of the Act by carefully noting their experiences under it. Another matter seems now to deserve attention, especially from English authors, who: have some organization—namely, whether they should not invent some method of verifying authors’ accounts with publishers. It is acknow- ledged that the method of examining books, easily kept for such examination, is worthless. It is difficult to see any objection to the use of the copyrighter’s trade-mark, to be pasted in each book, the issues to be returned or paid for, as in the case of patents. But whatever method be invented, it must be adopted by the English Society of Authors, and made a custom, so that no individual author shall offend his publisher by proposing it. There is no organization of authors in America—for various reasons none: is possible ; were it otherwise, our authors have been so largely driven, by the lack of inter- national copyright, into partnership with pub- lishers, that no independent move of the kind. suggested can be initiated in this country. a Near Ana ~_ eeprom os ee a ad rn wd mi erent SEAN eh reat cet ta eral ee een atte et eR eate. eS ON EN i ee Ht By

Page 18

378 THE ATHENAUM N? 3308, Marcr21, ’91 Telegrams from England inform us of the very natural desire of your printers and pub- lishers to retaliate on the protectionist features of the new Act. Itis doubtful, however, whether the English workmen would be sufficiently pro- tected to do more than keep an occasional luxurious American book at a high price for Englishmen. It could have little or no effect here, because, with the rates of work in England, your publishers already find little or no profit in importing sheets or plates from this country. Probably in most cases the English house prefers to set up in its own style and spelling the Ame- rican book. To American authors the proposed retaliation is a matter of perfect indifference, except that they are nearly all advocates of “* free trade,” and might regret to see England relapsing into our ignorant ‘‘ M‘Kinleyism ” just as there are signs of reaction from it in America. It is probable also that this typo- graphical interest will soon become of much less international importance to either country than it appears to possess at present. The multiplication of new processes for reproducing books and engravings, the inventions for swift type-setting, are becoming such as must diminish the importance of the victory obtained by this fraternity at Washington. As for English publishers, their plain course is to establish houses in this country, and themselves publish books which Americans .may try to obtain at less than their value, because of the compul- sory negotiation to which the foreign author is subjected. But it should be borne in mind by all parties in England that this Act is a compromise be- tween a large variety of discordant interests ; that it does not satisfy any one of those interests ; and that should it work badly in any direction, some combination will arise for its modification. Nor should it be forgotten that this Act, with all its faults, is the first sign of order amid chaos. It is just 109 years since Thomas Paine claimed consideration of America for the rights of literary property, and suggested the im- portance of literary. justice between nations, even when they were at war. After the Con- stitution was formed, President Washington, in a letter to Dr. Priestley, said that he did not see why legal rights in their inventions should not be conceded to foreigners. In 1837 Henry Clay introduced a Bill for international copy- right into the Senate, so that there has been an. agitation, with intervals of apathy, for fifty- four years before the present result could be reached. It were a mistake to suppose that nothing of importance has been gained for European and American authors, as some English journals, if fairly reported, are sup- posing. For foreign authorship and for foreign dramatists— whose rights both of publication and representation are secured—it is a better measure than their advocates here could have hoped. The only fault for which literary men need have much concern is the provision de- manding ‘‘ simultaneous ” publication, and this, as I have pointed out, may not prove a great hardship if authors are careful to reserve owner- ship of their copyright, to provide in their con- tracts for possible successes, and, in short, take pains with their affairs in this country as well as their own. MoncvureE D. Conway. Literarp Gossip. Ir is gratifying to know that the In- corporated Society of Authors can protect a publisher on occasion. Last week the Council called a special meeting to consider the conduct of a member who was alleged to have treated a publisher unfairly. For- tunately the member referred to spared the Council the trouble of an investigation by resigning his membership on the eve of the meeting. Tue forthcoming volume of the ‘ Dic- tionary of National Biography’ (to be pub- lished on Thursday next) extends from Henry II. to Hindley. Miss Kate Norgate writes on Henry II.; the Rev. William Hunt on Henry III.; Prof. T. F. Tout on Henry IV., Henry VI., and Hereward the Wake; Mr. C. L. Kingsford on Henry V.; Mr. James Gairdner on Henry VII. and Henry VIII.; Dr. 7ineas Mackay on Henry the Minstrel (Blind Harry); Mr. T. F. Henderson on James Hepburn, fourth Earl of Bothwell; Prof. J. K. Laughton on Arthur Herbert, Earl of Torrington; Mr. Sidney Lee on Lord Herbert of Cherbury and Henry Howard Molyneux Herbert, the late Earl of Carnarvon; Mr. R. E. Graves on John Rogers Herbert, the painter, and Nicholas Hilliard, the miniaturist; Mr. J. A. Hamilton on Sidney Herbert, Lord Herbert of Lea; Mr. A. H. Bullen on Robert Herrick; Mr. G. F. Russell Barker on the Right Hon. J. C. Herries and on Lord Hervey; Miss A. M. Clerke on Sir John Herschel and Sir William Herschel; Mr. Robert Dunlop on Frederick Augustus Hervey, Earl of Bristol and Bishop of Derry; Canon Overton on James Hervey, the devotional writer ; Mr. C. H. Firth on Sir Arthur Hesilrigge or Haslerig; Mr. G. J. Holyoake on Hetherington, the printer of unstamped newspapers; the bishop-elect of Peter- borough on Dr. Peter Heylyn; Dr. A. W. Ward on Thomas Heywood, the dramatist ; the Rev. W. D. Macray on George Hickes, the Nonjuror; Mr. Stanley Lane-Poole on Hicks Pasha; Mr. Lionel Cust on High- more, the painter; Mr. Leslie Stephen on Aaron Hill; Dr. G. Birkbeck Hill on Matthew Davenport Hill and Sir Rowland Hill; and Mr. H. Manners Chichester on General Viscount Hill. In the May number of Blackwood the author of ‘Culmshire Folk,’ John Orlebar, will begin a new serial novel, the scene of which will be chiefly laid in his favourite Culmshire region, while the plot will com- bine the interests of military and provincial life. Dr. C. Creighton contributes to the same number an article on the population of old London based on Speed’s statistics, bills of mortality, and a number of returns recently discovered among the MSS. at Hat- field House. Dr. Creighton from these materials has made elaborate calculations regarding the vital statistics and the growth of population of London during the Plan- tagenet and Tudor periods. Amone other contributions to Blackwood for May will be an essay on ‘ Civilization,’ by Sir H. E. Maxwell, M.P.; ‘Elizabeth Carter,’ by Mrs. Walford, another of the same writer’s studies of remarkable women which some time ago appeared in Black- wood ; ‘ Politics in Fiction’; ‘ Musical Instru- ments,’ by Miss Gordon-Cumming ; and an article on the Earls of Haddington, and of Leven and Melville, based on Sir William Fraser’s most recent privately printed volumes. Stir F. Potrock will contribute a short article on the American Copyright Act to the next number of the Contemporary Re- view. The April number of the Asiatic Quarterly will contain an article by General Légitime on ‘The Future of Hayti,’ and the first of a set of papers by General Tcheng- Ki-Teng on Chinese culture compared with European. Messrs. Macminnan & Co. will publish early in April a work by the Rev. Dr. Abbott, entitled ‘Philomythus; or, an Antidote against Credulity,’ containing a discussion of Cardinal Newman’s essay on ‘ Eccle- siastical Miracles.’ Mr. Crements R. Marxnam, C.B., will contribute to the April number of the English Tfistorical Review an article upon Richard III., in which he proposes not merely to acquit the king of the more serious crimes charged against him, but to show that the murderer of Edward V. and Richard, Duke of York, was, in fact, Henry VII., who had them killed in the summer of 1486. On Mr. Markham’s showing, the character which Richard III. has borne in history was the ingenious concoction of Archbishop Morton, who sought to shield Henry from suspicion by spreading abroad such calumnies against Richard that no crime could be thought too bad to have been committed by him. This revolutionary hypothesis, which is based upon a minute study of the evidence, may be expected to arouse some controversy. ReFERRING to our statement that he had ‘joined the staff of Punch,” Mr. James Payn, in his playfully ambiguous way, says: “I am quite sensible of the compli- ment, but it is undeserved. Mr. Punch’s staff is much too strong to need my joining.” For all this we are able to repeat our statement, or at least to congratulate Mr. Punch’s readers on Mr. Payn’s having lately contributed to our contemporary’s sprightly pages. Lippincott’ s Magazine for May will contain a complete novel, entitled ‘Vampires,’ by Julien Gordon (Mrs. Van Renselaer Cruger), author of ‘A Diplomat’s Diary,’ a work which has attracted great attention in America. Among the other contents will be a paper, ‘A New Literary Sensation,’ a sketch of ‘Julien Gordon”; and ‘Some Letters to Julien Gordon,’ a number of extracts from letters received by the author regarding her books. Tue Law Quarterly Review for April will contain articles on ‘Private International Law,’ by Prof. A. V. Dicey, Q.C.; ‘The Bering Sea Question,’ by Mr. T. B. Browning, of Toronto; ‘Patent Right in England and the United States,’ by Mr. Wood Renton; ‘The Press and the Law of Libel,’ by Mr. Hugh Fraser; ‘A Point in Villein Tenure,’ by Prof. F. W. Maitland ; ‘A Poor Man’s Lawyer in Denmark,’ by Mr. A. H. Jessel ; and ‘Registration of Title in Ireland,’ by Mr. C. Fortescue-Brickdale. Tue annual meeting of the Institute of Journalists was held on Saturday last at the Cannon Street Hotel. The report says that there are now three thousand members, and that the Institute is in a satisfactory state of development, and has already done much good work. At the banquet which succeeded the meeting the chair was occu- pied by Sir Algernon Borthwick, M.P. Tue annual report of the directors of Chapman & Hall (Limited) for the year 1890 states that the gross profits of the trading year amounted to 14,968/., after ' making provision for bad and doubtful ' debts and depreciation of copyrights and

Page 19

Ne 33808, Marca 21, ’91 THE ATHENZUM 379 stock. The expenses during the same period were 6,715/., leaving, with 1171. brought forward from last year, 8,370/. to be dealt with. The directors recommend that a dividend at the rate of 7 per cent. per annum be declared on the preference capital; that a dividend at the same rate be declared on the ordinary and deferred capital ; that 500/. be written off goodwill ; that 38/7. 16s. be written off fixtures; that 1007. be added to bad debt reserve; and that the balance of 108/. 6s. be carried forward to the current year. Tue free library movement is making progress. Peterborough has declared in favour of the Act, as also has the Man- chester suburb of Sale; and in the little town of Bowness, on the banks of Win- dermere, where there is already a small lending library, the subject is discussed. A new public library is to be built at Southampton. Mr. Jas. C. Scnores, who died in June last, had been engaged for some time in writing a complete and authentic history of his native town of Bolton. After his decease the whole of his MSS. and reprints were entrusted by his executors to Mr. W. Pimblett, who has continued and com- pleted the work. It will be issued in the summer. Mr. Scholes was enabled to write on events in Bolton down to the middle of the seventeenth century, including the storming and capture of the town by the Royalists, and the execution of the Earl of Derby at Bolton Cross; and the account of the memorials of the old parish church which will appear in the work is by him. Further, he had arranged and left practically ready for publication the records of the Bolton Lectureship Estate, with the lives of the lecturers, in addition to sketch- ing the public careers of nearly all the vicars of Bolton. The volume will be one of about five hundred pages, and will be illustrated. Tue report of the Council of the Society for the Preservation of the Irish Language says that during the past year over one thousand books more have been sold than in the previous year, thus bringing the total number of books sold since the society was founded to over one hundred thousand. Though difficulties and drawbacks still hamper and impede the spread of the national language, nevertheless the move- ment advances. Nearly one thousand pupils presented themselves for examination in Irish during the past year in the national schools. Tue Rev. Samuel Kinns, Vicar of Holy Trinity, Minories, has in the press a con- tribution to apologetic literature under the title of ‘Graven in the Rock.’ It is in- tended to prove the historical accuracy of the Bible, more especially of the Old Testa- ment, by reference to Assyrian and Egyptian monuments. Miss Hickey’s new volume, ‘ Michael Villiers, Idealist, and other Poems,’ will shortly be published by Messrs. Smith, Elder & Co. Messrs. Hurst & Buackerr will pub- lish early in April a new novel in two volumes by M. E. Le Clerc, author of ‘ Mistress Beatrice Cope,’ entitled ‘ A Rain- bow at Night.’ Lapy Beaumont writes :— ‘*T hasten to offer you my apologies for an inaccuracy in my letter of March 3rd. I find that the quotation from Congreve’s ‘The Mourning Bride’ has been misquoted from its earliest infancy. In one edition (of the seven- teenth century) I read, ‘Musick has charms to sooth the savage beast,’ and in the version I cited, ‘Music hath charms to soothe the stubborn breast’; but the first edition, and therefore the correct one, which was ‘ printed for Jacob Tonson at Graye’s Inn Gate, Graye’s Inn Lane, mpcxcrx.,’ has the following line : ‘Musick has charms to sooth a savage breast.’” Messrs. SonnenscuEtn & Co. are adding to their ‘‘ Social Science Series” a set of essays entitled ‘The English Republic,’ by Mr. W. J. Linton, the well-known wood- engraver and poet, who was at one time an ardent social reformer, and was associated with Mazzini and other exiles in this coun- try. The essays have been selected from the pages of the English Republic, a serial issued by Mr. Linton in the years 1851 to 1855, and will appear, with the author’s per- mission, under the editorship of Mr. Kineton Parkes. Baron Tavcunirz has secured for his series Mrs. Humphry Ward’s forthcoming novel. An interesting set of papers have been received from the Government of India on the subject of the provision made in the different provinces for the education, train- ing, and care of the blind, the deaf and dumb, and imbeciles. The subject-matter was investigated at the instance of the Royal Commission; but the Government of India think that the recommendations of the Commission are at present inapplicable to India, as the State there has not yet assumed the obligation of providing compulsory edu- cation for the community at large. More- over, the family system in that country imposes an obligation on all able-bodied persons to support the defective members of their family. It is, therefore, proposed by Government that its assistance should be limited to giving grants in aid of institu- tions which may be established by public charity for the education of the classes re- ferred to. This is satisfactory, for it is the process through which most public institu- tions in Europe and America have had to pass. The initiative is left to private enterprise, and in the course of time the State assumes the responsibility and care of education. Papre Cozza-Lvzzi has prepared for pub- lication in phototype the Vatican codex of the Prophets, which dates from the sixth or seventh century. It will be accompanied by a commentary from Prof. Ceriani, of the Ambrosian Library at Milan, and will appear shortly. In the May number of Blackwood’s Maga- zine will be published an article on the United States army, showing how the re- cruiting problem is solved in America, and describing the condition of the United States private soldier, which both in pay and treat- ment compares very favourably with that of Tommy Atkins. WE regret to hear of the death of Mr. William Richards, for over twenty years publisher of the Gardeners’ Chronicle. Tue Free Library at Inverness, which, owing to the state of its finances, has been closed for more than a year, has just been reopened, a donation of 1,750/. having been contributed to the institution by Mr. Andrew | Carnegie in addition to a number of books. Dr. Gaster has now completed his ‘ Rou- manian Chrestomathy,’ which will appear in the course of the next summer at Leipzig. Tue death is announced of Prof. Heller, a well-known scholar and one of the editors of the Wochenschrift fiir Klassische Philologie. Mr. Moncure D. Conway has prepared for the forthcoming Century an article on ‘Washington and Frederick the Great,’ giving an account of the ‘‘ mythical sword.” Tue chief Parliamentary Papers of the week are Further Correspondence respecting Behring Sea (1s. 2d.); Return showing the Sales of Glebes (1d.); Declaration between Great Britain and Zanzibar relative to the Exercise of Judicial Powers in Zanzibar (1d.); and Trade Reports on the Finances of Italy and Hungary (1d. each). SCIENCE oe The Riverside Naturalist. By E. Hamilton, M.D. (Sampson Low & Co.) Ir was a happy thought of Dr. Hamilton to provide an account of the riverside fauna and flora. Such a book is useful to the fisher- man who is blessed with a taste for natural history, while it is of sufficiently general interest to please all lovers of the country. Instead of appearing as a goodly octavo the book might with advantage have been cast into a smaller shape in order to admit of its being more conveniently carried in the pocket for outdoor use. of a considerable amount of padding — poetical scraps, foreign folk-lore, and the like—would have lightened it in every way. As it is, however, it is a laudable attempt to aid the angler-naturalist, and in the main it fulfils its purpose. Of course at certain times all our British birds and animals may be seen at the riverside. A selection must be made, and Dr. Hamilton has been judicious in his choice. Many anglers believe that the ostensible object of angling, catching fish, is really subservient to its secondary pleasures, the sense of freedom from cares and the enjoy- ment of nature’s ways and works, which may be so lavishly obtained at the riverside. For these contemplative anglers Dr. Hamilton successfully caters. Anecdotes, scientific facts, and poetical associations succeed each other in profusion throughout his pages. Only the best authorities are quoted — Yarrell, Dresser, and Seebohm for birds ; Giinther and Day in the case of fishes; Pictet and Eaton for the angler’s flies and their natural history. Thus the book is ad- mirably brought up to date, which is more than can be asserted of many other popular manuals of natural history. ‘ It is singular that so many gaps exist in the life-history of our native fishes and flies, which might presumably have been filled long ago when the enormous multipli- cation of anglers in modern times is taken into account. In the case of many trout flies, for example, much investigation is urgently required. Even the life-history of the angler’s May-fly (Ephemera vulgata or danica) is imperfectly known, though much The excision © i

Page 20

380 THE ATHENZUM N° 3308, Marcx 21, ’91 labour has been ungrudgingly bestowed on it of late years. How long its nymph state in the mud at the bottom of rivers lasts is still a moot question. Dr. Hamilton’s book ought to assist many a fisherman in gather- ing truer notions respecting the flies which he imitates than the loose popular fancies which float on every stream in the country. We have been assured that the caterpillar of the death’s-head moth changes into a mole, and this is a fair specimen of rural entomology. The most vague ideas prevail on the commonest creatures at the riverside, fishermen for the most part following the track of their predecessors, and accepting old-world beliefs with the ease exhibited by the tackle-sellers, who continue year after year dressing artificial flies from some tradi- tional pattern rather than comparing their handiwork with nature. More outdoor investigation concerning a _ fisherman’s river-side friends in the lower ranks of life is necessary, and Dr. Hamilton’s book is just the manual for such inquiring naturalists. As is only natural, few British quadrupeds are described as frequenting the river's side. The fear of man and his persecution has effectually driven many of the larger creatures into the woods or almost exter- minated them. Who can ever expect to see the marten or the pole-cat by the side of his trout stream? And yet it is a favourite habit of almost all the quadrupeds to seek their prey at the water’s edge. Night after night in Scotland the wild cat prowls round | the lochs, searching for wounded birds and | the like which take shelter in the sedges. But wild cats, again, are not to be found in England. Still, it is surprising that Dr. Hamilton has nothing to say about the hedge- hog. It is a quadruped and is frequently found near the water side. Few sights are more amusing than a hedgehog’s sly attempt to escape unnoticed when it has all but run against a fisherman’s legs on a summer evening. Fortunately no angler would injure either it or the pretty water vole, although the former is hateful to a game preserver, and the latter to a miller on account of its driving tunnels through his banks near a weir. Of birds Dr. Hamilton discourses at greater length, and although beset by the difficulty of enumerating the birds that frequent the riverside, he has put together an exhaustive list. It is a mistake to sup- pose that the kingfisher is becoming a scarcer bird. The Bird Bill has, on the contrary, caused it to increase in such dis- tricts as are suited to it. It is almost cer- tainly an error of Mr. Seebohm’s to assert that the bearded titmouse ( Calamophilus biar- micus, not biamarcusas Dr. Hamilton prints) is still found in Devonshire. The bird is wholly a bird of East Anglia, and is only known in Norfolk and Cambridgeshire. It is a pity that Dr. Hamilton ever meddled with etymology. Here is a glorious bit of con- fusion: ‘‘In Lempriere mergus is a cor- morant; the word mergus really means a diver, and Ovid could not give a better example of a diver than a dab-chick.”’ The interest of the author’s notes on birds is mainly literary. Any elementary manual may be referred to for particulars of their habits and nests. Such an extract as the following, however, possesses a value of its own. The building time of rooks is one scene of constant battles and thefts :— ‘*'This custom of the old birds was noticed by Ray, who, writing in 1776, says: ‘I have been told by a worthy gentleman of Sussex, who himself observed it, that when rooks build, one of the pair always remains to watch the nest ; else if both go, their fellow rooks ere their return will have robbed and carried away all the sticks and whatever they had put: together’; and he pertinently adds: ‘Hence, perhaps, the word rookery with us is used for cheating and abusing.’ ” It is curious that the author has admitted the dotterel to his list. This bird is rarely seen now except in the Eastern marshes on migration, and in the Lake mountains, where it breeds. Its numbers have been greatly reduced, partly because it has been netted in large quantities in the past, and perhaps still more because the feathers are eagerly sought at present by fly-dressers. With regard to the barn owl, it should have been added that this bird is frequently to be observed hunting the hedges in broad daylight on dull afternoons. The article on the nightjar is particularly good, embracing the latest investigations on its singular notes, and the engraving of the bird is remarkably characteristic. The reptiles are carefully treated, but Dr. Hamilton has evidently taken special pains with river fish. As the rough draught of the book was published in the Fishing Gazette, this was perhaps unavoidable. Not every fisherman will agree with his asser- tion, ‘‘ Wefeel quite sure that trout and gray- ling will live quite happily together.” They certainly will not do so in a small stream, into which it is a mistake to put grayling if trout are previously in possession. And this is the case irrespective of overstocking. The pages devoted to the Salmonide and the eels show how much these families still require patient investigation. Dr. Hamil- ton’s chapter on the senses and structure of fish embraces the result of all recent study of the subject. He generalizes, how- ever, on insufficient grounds when he states that he has known two occasions on which trout were detected asleep. They might have been motionless, unsuspicious of man’s presence and the like, without being asleep. It is conceivable, for instance, that they were not in good health. This point is far from being settled. Another much-mooted question is just touched by the author— “What is a bull-trout?” Theorists as a rule deem it but a Northern form of the sea- trout ; fishermen and all practical naturalists regard it as a distinct species, S. ertox. This seems the fairest mode of summing up. The author’s remarks on a descent of the salmon from its breeding waters before actually spawning will not be accepted by most salmon fishers, but are sufficiently striking to deserve quotation :— ‘*Tt has been stated that salmon, after having entered the fresh water, return at times to the estuaries previous to the spawning period. The late Mr. Robertson, head keeper on the Lochy, a most careful observer of the habits of salmon, informed us that he had often seen salmon returning to the salt water after a long spell of dry weather when a freshet has set in, to have a wash, as he called it, and in a few hours ascend again ; and when thus returning, the large fish particularly are very fond of showing themselves, : not by leaping, but by a kind of porpoise-like movement, a kind of roll. We once witnessed one of these second migrations as we stood waist- deep in a famous shallow, the fish surging on all sides, even running against our legs.” It is pertinent to ask in such a case, What proof exists that these were not fresh fish when the others had gone down to the sea as usual after spawning ? Omitting the chapter on molluscs, those on the flowers of riverbanks are carefully written and not meretranscripts ofa botanical treatise. Thus Dr. Hamilton draws his readers’ attention to the fact of the Utricu- larize nourishing themselves by means of the various insects and animals which they cap- ture, quoting largely from Darwin. Every fisherman ought to be able to identify river- side flowers by the aid of this book. The interesting theory that the American water- weed Anacharis alsinastrum, which haschoked so many trout streams, and earned the ana- themas of so many fly-fishers, is a blessing in disguise, is worth noting. Dr. Brandes, of Hanover, has remarked in his district that malaria and diarrhea, which used to appear annually in a sporadic or epidemic form, were observed to decrease with the growth of this American weed, and during the last four years have been altogether absent. This authority considers that the weed nourishes itself to a great extent on decayed vegetable matter, and thus destroys the germs of certain diseases. It is a pleasing belief, but requires corroboration. The remaining section of this book treats of the angler’s flies and the numerous water insects, which every frequenter of the water- side must have noticed. Often these are passed with an ignorant wonder, but Dr. Hamilton has done his best to explain enough of their habits and anatomy to enable all who care to realize something of their economy. Here, for instance, is an account of the governor, that well-known trout lure, the “ground bee, which has a great trick of tumbling into the water,” as a first-rate fisherman describes it. Similarly the ‘ grannom,” the “sedge” fly, and the “alder” are iden- tified by the aid of Ronalds and others. The book is copiously illustrated, although some of the cuts (such as those of the wry- neck and the goldfinch) are caricatures; and it ends with a good index. SIR W. ROWAN HAMILTON AND THE ‘DICTION- ARY OF NATIONAL BIOGRAPHY.’ 1, Winton Road, Dublin, March, 1891. In the volume preceding that last issued of the ‘Dictionary of National Biography’ is an article on Sir W. Rowan Hamilton, the distinguished mathematician and discoverer of quaternions. As the author of a_bio- graphy of Rowan Hamilton referred to in it, I feel I ought to place on record a correction of some errors occurring in its opening and some subsequent paragraphs. Trusting that you will allow me to do this in your pages, I ask you to reprint these paragraphs, and to add the obser- vations I am obliged to make :— “Hamilton, Sir William _ Rowan (1805-1865), mathematician, born in Dublin at midnight, between 3 and 4 Aug., 1805, was the fourth child of Archibald Hamilton, a solicitor there, and his wife Sarah Hutton, a relative of Dr. Hutton the mathematician. Archibald Hamil- ton was Scottish by birth, and went to Dublin when a boy with his father, William Hamilton, who settled as an apothecary there, and his mother, who was the daughter of the Rev. James McFerrand, arish minister of Kirkmichael, Galloway. The ev. R. P. Graves maintains that William Rowan Hamilton was Irish by descent, while admitting that both the paternal and maternal grandmothers en i ee i A le el Oe el ee, i a al ek

Page 21

N° 3308, Marcn 21, ’91 THE ATHENAUM 381 are Scottish; but the express statements of Professor Tait and Dr. Ingleby that the paternal grandfather went to Dublin from Scotland seem conclusive. The apothecary had also brought a second son, James, from Scotland, who studied for the church, became curate of Trim, co. Meath, and earned some reputation as a linguist.” There are in the above paragraph numerous misstatements. The most important, to which the others are incidental, is the assertion of the Scottish parentage of Sir W. R. Hamilton’s father. It will, therefore, be convenient to deal with this in the first place, and to correct the others as they crop up. The statements on this point are the following: ‘‘ Archibald Hamilton [the father of Rowan Hamilton] was Scettish by birth, and went to Dublin...... with his father, William Hamilton, who settled as an apothecary there......The apothecary had also brought a second son, James, from Scotland.” In dis- proof of these statements I have to allege: (1) That in the Entrance Book of Trinity Col- lege, Dublin, under date May 2nd, 1791, is re- corded the entrance, or matriculation, of the above James Hamilton, aged fifteen, son of William Hamilton, apothecary deceased, born in the city of Dublin. It is to be re- marked that the information on which this entry was founded was furnished by James Hamilton himself. It determines his birth to the year 1776. If by the expression ‘‘ second son,” above applied to him, is meant second in order of birth, the statement is incorrect : James was the elder brother of Archibald. (2) That I have seen in the List of Freemen, among the archives of the Corporation of Dublin, under date Midsummer, 1802, the name of Archibald Hamilton as admitted a freeman on the quali- fication of birth, 7. e., as being son of a free- man; and in the same record, under date Midsummer, 1774, the name of his father, William Hamilton, apothecary, as admitted on the qualification of service: this word im- plies that he had served an apprenticeship of seven years to a freeman-member of the Guild of Apothecaries, resident in Dublin, and brings his residence in that city back to the year 1767. In the same corporation record, under date 1777, is an entry of admittance as a free- man, on the qualification of service, of Francis Hamilton, younger brother of the above William Hamilton, who afterwards became Alderman of Dublin, and was father of Arthur Hamilton, called in the biography ‘‘ Cousin Arthur.” In ‘Wilson’s Dublin Directory’ of 1785, in the list of the merchants and traders of the city, is the name of Roger Hamilton, apothecary, with the address, 30, Jervis Street, which was the residence of his deceased eldest brother, William. The family was, it thus appears, established in Dublin. But, as confirming Irish extraction of an anterior date, we also know that the father of William Hamilton (concerning whom I have heard from Sir Rowan Hamilton’s sister Sydney that his Christian name was Francis) married a Miss (believed Margaret) Blood ; this lady was in her extreme old age (she lived to be above a hundred) seen by Sir W. R. Hamilton’s sister Eliza, as mentioned in my biography, and was of a well-known family settled in Ireland in the reign of James I., members of which from the beginning of this century up to the present time have recognized their kinship with Rowan Hamilton, both in letters and in familiar personal intercourse. In the cited paragraph it is stated thatthe Rev. R. P. Graves has admitted ‘‘that both the paternal and maternal grandmothers are Scottish.” This is not correct. I prominently drew attention to the fact that the paternal grandmother was Scottish, as perhaps accounting for the mistake that had arisen ; but I stated that the mother of Sir W. R. Hamilton was Sarah Hutton, of a family settled in Ireland, with which, as I learn from members now living, no connexion what- ever of relationship subsisted with Charles Hutton, the eminent mathematician, presumably referred to in the text of the ‘Dictionary.’ I made no mention of, or allusion to, her mother, the ‘‘maternal grandmother” of Sir W. R. Hamil- ton. The marriage of Grace McF errand, daughter of the minister of Kirkmaiden, the Maiden-Kirk of Burns (not Kirkmichael, as in the article), took place almost certainly in Dublin in 1774 or 1775, when she resided with Mrs. Gawen Hamilton in Rutland Square, which is in the same parish, St. Mary’s, as Jervis Street, the place of residence of her husband. It was on the death of her father that she was brought from Scotland and adopted by Mrs. Gawen Hamilton, of Killileagh Castle, and by her taken on a continental tour before her marriage. I have not been able to obtain a certificate of the marriage of Grace McFerrand with William Hamilton ; it was not improbably celebrated with Presbyterian rites, and no records of such — of the date required are now obtain- able. The facts I have certified are quite irrecon- cilable with the story of the ‘Dictionary’ article. But it may be asked how it came to pass that Prof. Tait and Dr. Ingleby made the statement with regard to Sir W. R. Hamilton’s parentage which I have now again, and with some additional circumstances, disproved. Let it be remembered, in the first place, that it was impossible for either of them to possess personal knowledge of the facts. I have been informed that Prof. Tait has referred to Mr. W. E. Hamilton, elder son of Sir William, as his authority, and I have reason to think that Dr. Ingleby derived his information from the same source. They would naturally consider such an authority sufficient. And Ido not suggest that the repre- sentation of Mr. W. E. Hamilton was not given in good faith. I believe it to have originated in impressions received from his cousin, the late Rev. James Alexander Hamilton, who had heard his father, the Rev. James Hamilton, speak of having been in Scotland at some early stage of his life, to which fact I have seen one refer- ence in the correspondence in my hands. But as against this representation of the son I can set the superior authority of the father. From Sir W. R. Hamilton, in his own handwriting, still existing, are statements to the effect that his particular branch of the Hamilton family came from Scotland to Ireland in the reign of James I. Such a statement was furnished by him to me in 1841 as part of the material for the biographical sketch contributed by me to the Dublin University Magazine, and which appeared in the January number for 1842. It may be seen repeated by him in a letter to De Morgan, printed in vol. ili. of the ‘ Life,’ pp. 392-3. It was natural that Prof. Tait, justly proud of the intellectual attributes of his countrymen, should be willing to claim for Scotland Rowan Hamilton as son of a Scottish father: I trust he will be consoled for disappointment as to this claim by finding that the Scottish deriva- tion of his master in quaternions is only put back for some generations. It has always been a pleasure to me to give ample expression to my sense of the warm fidelity of Prof. Tait’s championship of the greatness of Hamilton’s mathematical powers, and of the value of the quaternion calculus. If I believe that at one time he acted prematurely in announcing by advertisement his intended ‘Introduction’ to quaternions, without having previously gained Hamilton’s consent, I believe also that high praise is due to him for his immediately afterwards offering to comply with Hamilton’s wishes in the matter, and for his subsequently withholding, in a spirit of the strictest honour, the publication of his own work till after the posthumous publication of Hamilton’s ‘Elements’; when, if he had con- strued literally a permission given him by Hamilton, he might have anticipated that pub- lication (see ‘ Life,’ vol. iii. pp. 1383-4, and especially pp. 561-2). Yet estimating so highly as I do the merits of Prof. Tait in this con- nexion, I cannot but think that he himself would | be pained at reading some sentences in later columns of the ‘Dictionary’ article. I quote them with their context :— “In 1844, before the Royal Irish Academy, of which he was still president, he {Sir William] formally defined the term ‘ quaternions,’ by which the new calculus was to be known; but not till 1848 can the method be considered as systematically established, when he began, in Trinity College, Dublin, the ‘Lectures on Quaternions,’ which were published in 1853. Nearly the whole of this bulky octavo, occupying 808 pages, besides an introduc- tion of 64 pages, can be understood only by ad- vanced mathematicians. But for Professor Tait of X¥dinburgh, who interpreted the new science for more common-place mathematicians, Hamilton’s merits must long have remained unrealised or pac gee | unknown. The truth is that this great book of Hamilton’s, as well as his so-called ‘Elements of Quaternions,’ is frequently unpleasant in style, besides being obscure and difficult of interpretation. eee As a whole the method is pronounced by most mathematicians to be neither easy nor attractive the interpretation being hazy or metaphysical an seldom clear and precise.” The first of these extracts commences with a material misstatement. It was upon the 13th of November, 1843, that Hamilton made, at the Royal Irish Academy, the first public communi- cation of his discovery, fully setting forth at the time the bases of his calculus, having previously, on the 13th of October, the day of the discovery, made announcement of it to the Academy. In connexion with this point I refer to the ‘ Life, pp. 443-4, and, indeed, from p. 432 to p. 447; and, in particular, to the commencement of his letter, dated October 15th, 1858, to Prof. Tait, at p. 435, in which he says, ‘‘ The quaternions started into life, or light, full grown, on > the 16th of October, 1843.” It will also be seen by reference to the ‘‘ List of Papers, Memoirs, &e.,” at the end of vol. iii. of the ‘ Life,’ pp. 649, 650, that between 1843 and 1848, the year spoken of in the article as that of the first systematic establishment of the method, Hamil- ton published numerous papers on quaternions in the Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy, in the Philosophical Magazine, and in the Cam- bridge and Dublin Mathematical Jowrnal. And as for the extraordinary statement that but for what was published on the subject by Prof. Tait ‘‘Hamilton’s merits must long have re- mained unrealised or absolutely unknown” (1), it is enough to refer to the facts set forth abundantly in the ‘ Life’ that his discovery was immediately hailed with the applause it merited by the first mathematicians in England— Herschel, Cayley, and others—and had become known and celebrated over Europe and in America long before Prof. Tait’s first publica- tion on quaternions. Prof. Tait’s services in the field of quaternions stood in need of no such exaggeration. With regard to the article- writer’s characterization of Hamilton’s style in his mathematical works, it is not for me to say more than that I believe it is not justly charge- able with either obscurity or want of precision. I believe no sentence ever proceeded from his pen to which a second meaning could be ascribed, so habitually careful was he to express exactly what he intended, neither more nor less. This sometimes, doubtless, caused an inclusion of modifications which tended to apparent over- fulness, but no mathematician would be likely to object to such accuracy. In a subsequent paragraph of the article is the following sentence :—‘‘ The pension of 2001. which he had received since he was knighted was afterwards continued to his widow.” If this means that the pension was conferred in the year when he was knighted—and, if not, why is his knighthood mentioned {—the statement is incorrect. His knighthood was conferred in 1835, the pension in 1843. It was continued in equal moieties to his widow and daughter, by neither of whom was it long enjoyed. R. P. GRAVES. ts Sr th

Page 22

382 THE ATHENAUM N° 3308, Marcn 21, ’91 GEOGRAPHICAL NOTES. THE New York Nation records the death of Mr. A. M. Reeves, the author of ‘ The Finding of Wineland the Good’ (see Athen. No. 3295), who was killed in a railway accident in Indiana, near the end of February. Mr. Reeves was only in his thirty-fifth year. Whilst the French are endeavouring to open up a road between the Mobangi and the Upper Shari, the Germans are not inactive in the ‘¢ Hinterland ” of the Cameroons Protectorate. Lieut. Morgen, who left the coast in May last, is reported to have established a station at Ngila’s village, on the Upper Sanaga, and to have thence reached the Benue by way of Tibati and Banyo. He has thus joined his work to that of Dr. Zintgraf, who is now at Bali. Amap of the Mobangi-Welle, just published in Le Mouvement Géographique, addsvery consider- ably to our knowledge of that river, and ex- hibits quite unexpected features. It is based upon a number of latitudes determined by Lieut. G. Le Marinel, who accompanied Lieut. van Géle during his last expedition, which occupied from May, 1889, to June, 1890. Several of the tri- butaries of the Welle were explored, and the agreement of the results with Dr. Junker’s map is quite remarkable. M. van Kerckhove has been placed at the head of an expedition which is to explore the region between the Aruwimi and the Rubi, in the north-eastern part of the Congo State. M. van Kerckhove left Leopoldville on February 4th. He has with him a military force of three hundred men, including a company recruited by Capt. Avaert in Egypt. Dr. A. Woeikow in Petermann’s Mitteilungen furnishes an excellent summary of the deep-sea explorations carried on in the Black Sea by Capt. Spindler in the course of 1890. The accompanying map exhibits the depth of the sea, its temperature and density. Herr J. Menges in the same periodical gives an account of an excursion into Northern Somal Land. He says that life and property are perfectly secure in all places occupied by England, but that it would be an error to assume that. the English have won the good will of the population. The Somali, he tells us, hates the ‘‘ infidel” Eng- lishman, and the inhabitants of the coast towns would actually prefer to see back among them the corrupt Egyptians. The Mitthetlungen of the Vienna Geographical Society publishes an accountof a journey through Northern Montenegro, by Dr. O. Baumann, with an excellent map ; and an elaborate paper on rainfall in Croatia hy A. Franovic. An admirable sketch of the late Sir Henry Yule has been printed by Mr. Coutts Trotter. It was read before the Royal Society of Edin- burgh, and brings out with tact and judgment — strong points of Yule’s character and in- tellect. SOCIETIES. RoyvaAL.— March 12.—Sir W. Thomson, President, in the chair.—The Right Hon. Lord Hannen was balloted for and elected a Fellow.—The following papers were read: ‘On the Plasticity of an Ice- peg by the late Mr. J. C. McConnel,—‘ On the Effect of Temperature upon the Refractive Index of certain Liquids, by Mr. W. Cassie,—‘On the Bisulphite Compounds of Alizarin Blue and Ccerulin as Sensitisers for Rays of Low Refrangibility,’ by Mr. G. Higgs,—and ‘On the Mechanical Properties of Metals in relation to the Periodic Law,’ by Prof. Roberts-Austen. ASTRONOMICAL.— March 13.—General Tennant in the chair—Mr. T. R. Clapham and Mr. A. Ken- nedy were elected Fellows.—A paper by Prof. A. A. Rambaut was read ‘ On the Determination of Double Star Orbits from Spectroscopic Observations of the Velocity in the Line of Sight.’ The conclusion arrived at was that observations of the separation of the lines should be made at equal intervals of time before and after the epoch of maximum separa- tion in order to determine the ellipticity of the orbit and the position of its major axis.—A paper by Mr. S. W. Burnham was read ‘On the Companions of Aldebaran.’ He has, with the great Lick refractor, ob- served the nearer companion while passing through its periastron at a distance of only 0:13" from the large star, and from old measures of position, angle, and distance has obtaineda satisfactory orbit.—A paper by Prof. Bakhuyzen was read ‘ On Variations of Latitude deduced from the Observations of Polaris made at Greenwich, 1851-1889.’ The cause of the apparent variation has been much discussedin Germany. From the Berlin observations there appears to have been an increased variation of latitude in the years 1879, 1884, and 1889, and Prof. Bakhuyzen finds a similar change indicated by the Greenwich observations, although they are only made on one side of the pole, and the effects of refraction cannot, therefore, be satisfactorily eliminated.— The Astronomer Royal gave an account of the preparations making at Greenwich for joining in the work of the inter- national survey of the heavens. They find that the smallest patches of photographic action represent- ing stars subtend an angle of 2” of arc. Such a photographic trace of a star of the ninth magnitude can be obtained in seven seconds. As the exposure is increased the diameter of the patch of photographic action grows as well as the density.—Mr. Plummer said that the smallest star discs obtained at Oxford subtended an angle of 3”.—Mr. Ranyard mentioned that on the plates taken at the Lick Observatory, as well as on those taken by Mr. Russell, of Sydney, the images of the stars near to the edges of the plates were very much deformed, being stretched out on the Lick plates into an elongated patch with a cometary nucleus, and on the Sydney plates the stars at the edge of the field are represented by a cross, with the longer arm pointing to the centre of the plate. He thought that such dif- ferences would interfere with the determination of the magnitudes of stars from their photographic traces as obtained with different instruments and on different parts of the same plate.— Mr. I. Roberts said that his photographs showed conclusively that there was continual change going on in the trans- parency of the air for photographic rays even when the sky remained apparently clear and cloud- less. He instanced a photograph of the planet Sappho which had moved among the surrounding stars during the exposure. The trace left by the planet was like a string of beads, owing to the great inequalities in the transparency of the air corre- sponding to intervals of ten minutes ora quarter of an hour; so that a photograph could not be relied upon as indicating the brightness of stars by the length of time necessary to obtain a photographic trace of them.—The following papers were taken as read : ‘ Catalogue of 918 Orbits of Meteor Streams, from the Observations of Mr. W. F. Denning.’ by Mr. J. Kleiber,—‘ Mean Places of Comparison Siars for the Planets Victoria and Sappho, observed with the Transit Circle at the Cambridge Observatory,’— ‘Observations of the Satellites of Saturn : Conjune- tions with the Centre of the Planet, observed at Mr. E. Crossley’s Observatory, by Mr. J. Gledhill,— ‘Observations of the Variable Star S (10) Sagittz,’ by Mr. J. E. Gore,—‘ The Orbit of « Pegasi (8 989),’ by Mr. 8. W. Buroham,— Measures of Double Stars made in the Years 1882-1889 at the Sydney Obser- vatory,’—‘ Comparison of the Star-Places of the Greenwich Ten-Year Catalogue with those of the Second Melbourne General Catalogue, and with those of the Cape Catalogue for 1880,’ by Mr. A. M. W. Downing,—‘ Double Star Measures made at Windsor, New South Wales, 1889-90,’ by Mr. J. Tebbutt,— ‘Note on the Orbit of Juno,’ by Mr. A. M. W. Down- ing,—‘ Notes on the Preparations for the Work of the Astrophotographic Chart,’ by the Astronomer Royal,—‘ Observations of the Planet Victoria and Comparison Stars, made with the Transit Circle, during the Opposition of 1889, at the Radcliffe Observatory, Oxford,’—and ‘ Ephemeris for Physical Observations of Jupiter, 1891,’ by Mr. A. Marth. GEOLOGICAL.— March 11.—Dr. A. Geikie, Presi- dent, in the chair.—Mesers. F. J. A. Matthews, S. H. Reynolds, and J. Yates were elected Fellows; and Don Antonio del Castillo, Mexico, and Prof. K.A. Lossen, Berlin, Foreign Correspondents of the Society.—The following communications were read : *‘Manod and the Moelwyns,’ x Mr. A. V. Jennings and Mr. G. J. Williams,—and ‘The Tudor Specimen of Eozoon,’ by Mr. J. W. Gregory. SOCIETY OF ANTIQUARIES.—March 12.—Dr: J. Evans, President, in the chair—Mr. W. H. St, John Hope exhibited four silver waits’ collars of the city of Bristol. They consist of linked roundels bearing alternately in relief a rose dimidiating a pome- granate, and the letters c B knotted together. The original badges, enamelled shields of the city arms, are now mounted on large circular roundels of early seventeenth century date. The date of the collars and shields is, however, temp. Queen Mary.—The President exhibited, in illustration of the Director’s paper, a fine series of leaden pilgrims’ badges of St. Thomas of Canterbury.— Chancellor Ferguson com municated a report on a recent discovery of Roman remains in Carlisle—The Director read Part II, of ‘The Memorials of St. Thomas at Canterbury.’ He reviewed the notices later than 1550, Archbishop Parker stated that at the translation the skull was placed apart from the rest of the skeleton and called “corona,” a statement not reconcilable with contemporary narratives of the translation. Of the disposal of St. Thomas’s skeleton at the unshrine- ment there are two stories, a foreign and an English —the foreign, that the king burnt the skeleton ; the English alleging that it was burnt, but usually naming the Lord Cromwell as acting in the matter. The foreign story, already told in documents of the years 1538 and 1547, is repeated by John Sleidan in 1555, by Nicholas Harpsfield, or his editor Alan Cope, in 1566, and by Thomas Stapleton in 1588, The English story begins in a life of Sir Thomas More by Nicholas Harpsfield, written in Queen Mary’s reign, but not printed, which states that the bones of St. Thomas and those of St. Augustine were burnt, the story as to St. Augustine being found nowhere else. The current form of the English story is that of Stow, who could only have known it by hearsay long after the event. He first sets it forth in his ‘ Chronicles’ of 1580, and his words have been copied and paraphrased ever since, as by the augmenter of Wriothesley’s ‘Chronicle’ soon afterwards, by the augmenter of Holinshed’s in 1587, and by {Stow? himself in his ‘ Annuals’ in 1592, These together confirm the Paul’s Cross sermon of 1539, that the true skull was found with the skeleton, and that another skull long exhibited separately was thus proved to be false ; but they state generally that all were burnt, which latter statement must kave come from Sleidan, whom Stow names as one of his authorities in his ‘Summarie’ of 1565, The Cottonian sketch of the shrine must have been made in late Elizabethan times, if not later, the de- scription written thereon beginning “Tem. H. 8,” and being a “— or close paraphrase of Stow’s story, and the whole document being inconsistent with early evidence. A later life of Sir Thomas More, although paraphrased from that by Harps- field, states that the relics were buried. Lastly, the legal process of the king against Thomas Becket has long Seen detected asa hoax of the seventeenth century. LINNEAN.—March 5.—Prof. Stewart, President, in the chair.—Capt. T. Keene was admitted, and Messrs. T. B. Cato and E. N. Langham were elected Fellows.—Mr. D. Morris exhibited a dwarf species of Thrinax which he found growing plentifully in the island of Anguilla, West Indies, and which was apparently undescribed.—Mr. T. Christy exhibited the fruit of some undetermined species of plant which had been introduced into commerce by the name of Monchona, but the origin of which had not been ascertained.—Mr. J. E. Harting exhibited several instantaneous photographs (taken by Mr. W. H. St. Quintin in Yorkshire) of a living great bustard (Otis tarda), and gave a brief account of the recent visits of several of these birds to England. Between December 9th and February 5th no fewer than seven had bzen shot in Norfolk, Suf- folk, Essex, Sussex, Hants, Wilts, and Carmarthen- shire.—On behalf of Miss E. Barton, Dr. D. H. Scott gave the substance of a paper communicated by her, and entitled ‘A Morphological and Sys- tematic Account of the Fucaceous Genus Tur- binaria.’— Mr. G. Murray described some new species of Caulerpa, with observations on the position of the genus.—In elucidation of this paper Mr. E. M. Holmes exhibited a large series of specimens show- ing the extreme variability of the species of sea- weeds which had been referred to this genus.—A paper was read by Dr. J. Lowe on the specific identity of two forms of parasitic crustacea, Lernconema spratta, marae) and L. eucrasicholi, Turton— the only two of the genus which had been hitherto recognized in Britain, A third species had been described by Dr. Salter (Ann, Nat. Hist., 1850, p. 56) from the eye of the herring, and to this he gave the name of L. bairdii; but his figures show clearly that they were drawn from imperfect speci- mens of L. spratta, which had been forcibly re- moved from the fish's eye, leaving the head behind. The parasites in question had only been found on the sprat, herring, and anchovy. METEOROLOGICAL.—March 18.—Dr. C. T. Wil- liams, V.P., in the chair.—Messrs. H. Brevitt, J. Lovel, and L. G, Oliver were elected Fellows.—Mr. G. J. Symons read a paper on the history of rain gauges. It appears that Sir Christopher Wren, in 1663, designed not only the first rain gauge, but also the first recording gauge, although the instrument was not constructed till 1670. The earliest known records of rainfall were made at the following places: Paris, 1668; Townley, in Lancashire, 1677 ; Zurich, 1708; and Londonderry, 1711.—Mr. A. W. Clayden showed on the screen a number of transparencies of photographs of clouds,

Page 23

te ah OD Ch ame me me hee” aoewieesrtiscte Pe@ 6 Came tC Cae S&S rue NS & oo wre CU So N°3308, Marcu 21, 91 THE ATHENZUM 383 lightning flashes, and other meteorological pheno- mena.—The meeting was adjourned at 8.30, in order to allow the Fellows to inspect the exhibition of rain gauges, evaporation gauges, and new instru- ments. New SHAKSPERE.—March 13.—Dr. F. J. Fur- nivall in the chair.—Miss E. Phipson read a paper “On Shakspere’s References to Natural Pheno- mena,’ and, after noticing that the play of ‘ Ed- ward III.’ was especially rich in such allusions, went on to point out that while most poets only found pature useful for purposes of comparison, Shak- speare was fond of finding a sympathy between nature and the works of man. While Shakspeare was the richest in this sort of reference, Drayton (also a Warwickshire lad) came nearest to him ; and Chapman followed close. Peele and Greene were essentially artificial in their allusions, and Marlowe almost entirely classical. Shakspeare seemed to love the sun, which to him represented the spirit of good in the world, and to hate the night. He does not even praise the latter, as other poets are accustomed to do, for its divine gift of rest. It was probable that Shakspeare was a bad sleeper, he so thoroughly understood the value of repose. His familiarity with the look of first early dawn was suspicious ; the sonnets were one long wail of sleep- lessness ; and Caliban alone had pleasing dreams. There was no good evidence that Shakspeare had ever made a sea voyage, nor, from any allusion to the common objects of the seashore, any sign of a residence near the sea, though it was probably by a slip that he made the tide serve only once a day, the actual facts being doubtless well known to any Londoner. To conclude, there was an absence, throughout his plays, of any real mountain scenery. MATHEMATICAL. — March 12.— Prof. Greenhill, President, in the chair.—Mr. E. P. Culverwell was elected a Member.—Dr. Hirst spoke upon the loss to mathematical science caused by the premature death of Madame S. Kovalevsky, and gave several personal reminiscences.—The President also touched upon some of her mathematical work.—The following communications were made: ‘On Cusp-loci, which are enveloped by the Tangents at the Cusps,’ by Prof. Hiil,—‘ On the Partitions of a Polygon,’ by Prof. Cayley,—and ‘Some Theorems concerning ts of Totitives of n,’ by Prof. L. Tanner.—Mr. Love and Prof. Hill spoke in some detail on the motion of a liquid ellipsoid under its own attraction, with special reference to four theorems concerning the surfaces which always contain the same particles,— and Dr, Larmor made a few remarks on the ele- mentary treatment of the collision of two spherical bodies with reference to Newton’s experiments. ARISTOTELIAN.—March 16.—Mr. 8. H. Hodgson, President, in the chair.—Mr. S. Barnes was elected a Member.—Mr. R. J. Ryle read a paper ‘On the Philosophy of Roger Bacon.’ The published works of Roger Bacon deal chiefly with his scientific doctrines. These works do not contain more than a gy ve discussion of the philosophical questions of is day. His doctrine of “ Offendicula,” or hin- drances to the discovery of truth, is only in a loose and general way comparable with the more compre- hensive and systematic “ Idola” of Fraucis Bacon. He insists on language as the first gateway to wis- dom—at least for the Latins, who have to learn all the sciences from writings in foreign tongues. After language he places mathematics, as being indis- pensable for all other sciences, and as being neces- sary for the accurate study of all kinds of actions and reactions. He discusses the various modes of propagation of “impressions” from one point to another, and, in dealing with the controversy as to the origin of “diversity,” he combats the view that “form ” is the only source of it as at once unphilo- sophical and heretical. On similar grounds he opposes the doctrine of the infinity of the world. Throughout his writings he regards Aristotle as the greatest of philosophers, and ranks Averrhoes and Avicenna next after him. On the great medieval question of universals he takes the side of indi- viduals as to priority and worth in the system of the world, while he maintains the existence of uni- versals to be in individuals only. He gives practical proof of his own appreciation of inductive inquiry in many branches of science, more especially in astronomy and in optics. His treatise ‘ De Perspec- tivis’ on the latter subject held a position of well- recognized authority till the sixteenth century, though the rest of his works were almost lost in oblivion. His chapter ‘ De Scientia Experimentali,’ analyzed by Whewell in the ‘ History of Inductive Sciences,’ is in many parts worthy of comparison with Francis Bacon’s ‘Novum Organon’; but the resemblances of his doctrine to those of later times are often verbal rather than real. His philosophical eg og was in the main that of the schoolmen of is age, as appears from his habitual neglect of the cal,” as well as from his treatment of authority and of experience.—The paper was followed by a dis- cussion. HUGUENOT.—March 11.—Sir H. W. Peek, Bart., V.P., in the chair.—The following were elected Fellows: Col. C. J. Durand, Rev. F. Jansen, Messrs. T. W. M. de Guérin, C. E. Guillemard, and H. Ruff, Mrs. Orr, and Mrs. Rolt. The City of Manchester Free Reference Library was also placed on the list. —A paper was read on ‘A Family of Modellers in Wax,’ by Miss M. H. Gosset, giving an account of the introduction of wax-modelling into England by the Huguenots, the successfu! practice of the art by several members of the Gosset family, and its gradual decay. The paper comprired a very full list of all known examples of Matthew and Isaac Gosset’s work, including those in the royal collection at Windsor and private hands. Several portrait- medallions and very beautiful plaques of classical subjects, all in high relief, were exhibited; and in the discussion following the paper Dr. Ginsburg remarked on the earlier instances of Italian models, especially those from the hand of Lionardo da Vinci.—Independently of this subject there was also exhibited a curious series of caricatures in ivory of celebrated public men in France of the Huguenot period, by an unknown contemporary artist.—The Chairman expressed a hope that possibly other speci- mens of the same kind might be heard of and par- ticulars be ascertained of their origin. MEETINGS FOR THE ENSUING WEEK. Mon. London Institution, 5.—‘The Orientation of some Ancient Tem- ples,’ Prof. N. skyer. — Institute of British Architects, 8. — Society of Arts, 8 —‘ Photographic Chemistry,’ Lecture III.,Prof. R. Meldola (Cantor Lecture). : : - Geomenpniess) 8}.—‘ Travel and Ascents in the Basardiusi Dis- trict, Daghestan,’ Mr. G. P. Baker; ‘Notes on Exploration re eee aa in the Caucasus in 1890,’ Mr. D. W. Fresh- eld. Tvurs. Civil i s,8.—‘R ion and Storage of Petroleum Oil in Bulk,’ Mr. W. T. H Carrington. — Society of Arts, 8.—‘ Uses of Cloisonné for Decoration in Ancient and Modern Times,’ Mr. C. Heaton. Wep. Geological, 8.—‘ Notes on Nautili and Ammonites,’ Mr. 8.8. Buckman ; ‘ Drifts 0: mosen ead,’ Mr. G. W. Lamp- lugh!; Serge Chalk with Belemnitella quadrata at Taplow,’ Mr. A. Strahan. — Chemical, 8—Anniversary Meeting. — Literature, 8.—‘ Folk-lore,’ Mr. C. H. E. Carmichael. Srience Gossip, Mr. FREDERICK JAMES, chief assistant to General Pitt-Rivers, has been appointed to the Head-Curatorship of the Maidstone Museum, in succession to Mr. Edward Bartlett, who has received a post in the Government Museum at Sarawak. Tue Geologists’ Association have issued an attractive excursion programme for the coming season. At Easter they are to spend five days in exploring the Isle of Wight ; on April 11th a trip to Shortlands is planned, to inspect the most interesting of the cuttings on the railway now being constructed from Nunhead to Short- lands; on the 25th of the same month Dr. Sclater is tc discourse to the members on the ‘‘Larger Cats” in the lion-house of the Zoo- logical Gardens. Various other expeditions are announced for May, June, and July, including a Whitsuntide gathering at Northampton and a field day at Selborne. The ‘‘long excursion” is to be in August to the coast of Yorkshire. FINE ARTS —_—~— ROYAL SOCIETY OF PAINTER-ETCHERS. —- ANNUAL EXHIBI- TION : including also all the Plates of ‘Liber Studiorum’ which were executed by Turner himself. Boe OPEN at Lee Gallery, 5a, Pall Mall S. 5 East, from 10 till 6. [4 : J. BEAVAN, Secretary. DIAZ.—A COLLECTION of 38 PAINTINGS by DIAZ, one of the Masters of the Barbizon School, is NOW OPEN at the GOUPIL GALLERY (Messrs. Boussod, Valadon & Co.), 116 and 117, New Bond Street.—Admission, 9 till 6, 1s. Annals of the Artists of Spain. By Sir Wil- liam Stirling-Maxwell. 4 vols. (Nimmo.) Stnce its first publication in 1848 Sir William Stirling-Maxwell’s ‘Annals of the Artists of Spain’ has been the text-book on Spanish painters for English readers. Its appreciation is proved by the very high price it has maintained in booksellers’ cata- logues for many years past. Therefore its distinctions between the “sensible ’’ and the “ logi- reissue at a comparatively moderate sum will be:welcome to many who hitherto have been compelled to consult its pages in a public library. The favour with which Stirling-Maxwell’s work has been received can scarcely be said to be altogether due to its subject. Spanish painting presents a phenomenon somewhat similar to what has happened in Spanish literature. It claims a name—Murillo—of worldwide popularity, and another—Velaz- quez—exalted to the highest pinnacle by the few; the parallelin literature being Cervantes and Calderon. Besides these two prodigious reputations of Velazquez and Murillo the long list. of Spanish painters is eaviar to the general, and, if truth were told, it evokes no very spontaneous enthusiasm among the elect. The cult has been a fashion having little foundation of genuine appreciation, and is probably not unconnected with the fact that Theotocopulis and such like were picked up in continental sale-rooms for a few francs apiece. The zest for Spanish painting is a purely acquired taste. It is only the simple, unsophisticated child of the Peninsula who can regard the representation of the last physical: agony of the Redeemer, His form from forehead to feet bathed in blood, with ever renewed delight. Pleasures such as these are apt to pall on a taste accustomed to more varied and refined emotions, while the artifices by which painters like the ‘“‘divine’” Morales—harping always on the same string—attain their effects are too transparent for a generation regarding painting as one of the fine arts. If the Spanish school had not numbered among its professors two such masters as Velazquez and Murillo it is tolerably certain that no man gifted with the taste and judg- ment of Stirling-Maxwell would have devoted more than sixteen hundred pages to its his- tory. Even as it is, only literary ability of a very high order could have achieved a task of such difficulty with pronounced success. The work is confessedly based on the -‘ Dictionary of the Professors of the Fine Arts in Spain,’ by Cean Bermudez, on which the author bestows the highest en- comiums. But he has added much that is not found in Cean Bermudez, and he has drawn on the resources of a mind possessin a far wider culture than that of the Spanis historian. The bald narration of the ‘ Dic- tionary’ has been rendered into literary form that is really delightful reading. It is re- dolent with local colour. While reading its pages we find ourselves living in the period. There are few of the picturesque anecdotes of Vasari, and little of his high enthusiasm ; but then the artistic faculty of the Spanish artists was less brilliant than that of the Italians. The daring originality which found free scope in Tuscany could not exist in the land ruled by the Philips and the Charleses. If the ‘Annals’ could have included the history of the artists who worked under the Arabs and Moors, its earlier pages, at least, would have been steeped in brighter colours. There would then have been no stint of the romantic element. But priestly and kingly intolerance has taken good care that even the industry and research of a Stirling- Maxwell shall not revive those departed glories, The royal and sacordotal malice, however, was not absolutely omnipotent. It has baulked the learned and genial Scotch baronet in adding some delightful SEI INE IOP IIIS Bye Be Be EEA SREY INOS gfe: BAC BREA. e ies oa ee aes So ms nd! wo BSS i iad eminem ens nina

Page 24

384 THE ATHENZUM N° 3308, Marca 21,91 chapters to his chronicle, but it has not suc- ceeded in suppressing a few precious pas- sages in the records of the Arab historians and travellers. And still more fortunately some rare examples of Hispano-Arab art have escaped its destroying hands, and now rest securely in the cases of our national museums. Besides incorporating Stirling- Maxwell’s notes and emendations, the pre- sent edition of the ‘Annals’ contains a few additional engravings, and, as far as we observe, the plates used in the former edition show no signs of deterioration. THE INSTITUTE OF PAINTERS IN WATER COLOURS. (First Notice.) An improvement is manifest in this exhibition. Although there is only a reduction of a score or so in the number of the drawings, their general quality is better, and a higher standard has been adopted by the managers, who ought, however, to have been yet more exacting, and rejected at least two hundred of those they have hung. Before such a host as nearly eight hundred works the visitor’s attention flags long ere he has completed the tour of the three handsome gal- leries, which the Institute makes a great mistake in trying to fill. We have picked out about fifty of the best ; we shall deal with them this week, and next week we shall supply a running comment on the remaining examples that are more or less excellent. In the order of the Catalogue, Mr. J. H. V. Fisher’s September Morning, Flatford Lock (No. 17), comes first. The view of the river in bright grey twilight shows a due sense of the pathos of the scene and effect, and is tenderly and deftly handled. Mr. Fisher’s spring sub- ject, No. 335, is likewise fresh and delicate, but we do not like his In the Stowr Valley (452) so well.—Mr. J. W. Whymper’s Shore at Lynmouth (29), a good and bright coast piece, is in merit above the average of his too numerous works. Quite as good is The Mill, Old Haslemere (694). —Miss A. L. Mawe succeeds in architectural painting, to which many ladies are wise enough to devote themselves. Her Chapel of St. Erasmus, Westminster Abbey (81), reproduces the senti- ment and beauty of the place, its artistic dignity, and what remains of its once lovely colour since Scott daubed the building with shellac. Miss Mawe draws firmly, and the difficult per- spective of her subject is truly given.—Mr. Orrock’s Woodhouse Mill (187), on a rocky moorland hillock overlooking a wide champaign, is one of his best and most expansive studies. His large sense of style and Cox-like touch sometimes (but not in this instance) betray him into mannerisms. At Normanton (612) is also a pleasing work, but it is not so master- like. The lofty plateaux of the Midlands have few better interpreters than the artist of Keg- worth Lock (11). In Mr. Orrock’s On Dan- bury Common (60) the colour is clearer and the half-tones are less brown than in the capital instances named above.—Mr. J. Watts’s Bright January Morning (269) more than justifies its modest name. It is a woodland view. The trees and shrubs are delicately drawn, the sky is very tender, and the finish is choice. The Branscombe Cliffs (275) of Mr. J. White marks a departure from his wonted choice of subjects. From a lofty height of chalk we look down on purplish sands, a dark-blue and tur- quoise sea, its finely drawn fringe of silver on the beach, and the buttress-like bluffs of the coast. It is strong, broad, and rich. Beer (290) is nearly as good, but not so attractive.—The Breezy Sky (277) of Mr. A. W. Weedon exhibits a fine sense of the scale of nature’s effects, her ‘* distances,” and the impressive flight of cloud- shadowsoveravast beach of ruddy sand and a sea breaking heavily. We have not space to men- tion other drawings of his, although nearly all of them are acceptable.—Mr. W. L. Wyllie has depicted the Bay of Naples (282) delicately and solidly, and with a fine sense of air, colour, and the sea’s motion. It is a lovely study in silver- grey, giving the quickly rippling wavelets, the high-piled clouds of the horizon, and the prodi- gious spaciousness of air between them and us. In his Venice (296) the distance and the air are charming ; the nearer pavement is crowded with minutely drawn figures, each studied and full of action, and all appropriate to the place and time. A soft atmosphere laden with vapour brings every part into harmony with the rest, and gives the charm of breadth to a multitude of exquisitely drawn details. Mount Vesuvius (711) should not be overlooked while we are searching for sincere and studious art.—Another capital piece of art is Mr. H. Goodwin’s Winter Sunset, Hastings (308), where we look down through a misty and smoky veil of nacreous light upon the close-packed houses of the town, and the eye follows the sun’s track upon the sea to a belt of clouds which hides the horizon. The local colours and the grading and harmony of these elements mark the taste and skill of a fine artist, whose drawing of the rugged cliffs and downs is most creditable to him. Moonrise, Hastings (193), and Windermere, from Fairfield (453), by the same, splendidly drawn and beautifully graded panoramas (always a difficult thing to treat artistically), are distinguished by their atmosphere, and the foreshortening of the bright sheets of the lake.—The trees in Mr. Aumonier’s Sussex Lane (313) are a little woolly, but the mid-distance is soft and pure in colour, and, on the whole, it is ably com- posed. In many waysit contrasts with Mr. B. Evans’s Richmond, Yorkshire (341), where, as in one of Turner’s panoramas, we look from a height upon the river, bridge, and town. Almost stereoscopic in its solidity, and being deftly drawn and homogeneous withal, it is a pity that the trees are so woolly, their shadows so dark and hot, and the general colouring so lurid, that the veriest tyro cannot fail to see how much it owes to the lamp (a very smoky one it must be), and how seldom the very clever artist has trusted to anything but his recollection of nature. One of the most accomplished draughtsmen in the gal- lery, he relies too much on artifices. His Foun- tains Abbey (557) is another instance to which our remarks are applicable with greater force, because the subject is even finer than that of ‘Richmond.’ Mr. Evans should study the art of Mr. A. W. Hunt, whose views of Fountains and Richmond will be to him a revelation of fairyland.—The firmness and purity of Mr. Fulleylove’s well-studied view of Ely Cathedral (403), neat, solid, and simple in draughtsman- ship, would be, although prosaic, a good model for lovers of the lamp like Mr. Evans, who, as Sir Thomas Browne said of another sort of scholars, ‘‘have forgotten their allegiance to nature.” The light and shade of this large drawing are broad, but, especially where the towers are opposed to the sky, it owes less to nature than usual with the painter. It is a little hard. Warwick Castle (544) displays the artist’s characteristic sense of the grand elements of his subjects, and his tact in representing light.— “* When Evening’s Twilight gathers round ” (430), by Miss H. H. Hatton, old houses by a pool under a delicate rosy light, is to be admired for its poetic sentiment and natural colouring.—Mr. A. East paints London streets in a broad and masculine way, of which At the Eyre Arms (439) is a capital specimen, while Haverstock Hill (371) is only a little inferior to it.—A little mechanical and artificial is Mr. L. Rivers’s On the Norfolk Broads (505), a good study of twilight after sunset, when the afterglow is faint. But it has the charm of a poetic impres- sion, with breadth and force of tone and colour. Sunset (424) has similar technical qualities, and its pathos is sincere. —Mr. Hargitt’s Chee-Dale, Derbyshire (513), is enjoyable for its brightness and a firm touch. A little hard here and there, it is in all respects pure and, except that the trees are somewhat woolly, soundly painted. Not so effective, but quite as good, are The Road by the Sea (516) and In the Glen (739), by the same artist.—The Untrodden Snow (512) is a most skilful and true contribution of Mr. W. F. Bishop’s. Deeside at Braemar (605) is also his. One of the most original and individual sea- scapes here is Mr. J. Nash’s Too Late (539), a tragic motive vigorously and sympathetically expressed. The picture is very telling as a whole, and well drawn, massive in light, tone, and colour; but even if the sea is a little too dark, its intense blueness is undoubtedly not enough broken by reflections of other colours, and devoid of transparency where light must needs penetrate the crests of the waves. The black side of the nearer boat wants bright re- flections from the water, and itis hard to under- stand how with so little sail she can be cutting the water so quickly as the strong ripple spread- ing from her stem indicates.—The grandest and yet the simplest landscape here is Mr. H. G. Hine’s On the Malling Hills, near Lewes (640), the masterpiece of an accomplished hand to which we owe a score or two of similar pictures, where no mannerisms obtrude to make us tire of them, although the landscape, the colour, the air, and even the effects have been dealt with again and again in the like manner by the same artist. There could not be a greater proof than this of the value of style per se.—Our selected landscapes and seascapes conclude with Mr. W. Hatherell’s capital picture of A Quiet Spot (715). The colour, soft atmosphere, breadth, and geod keeping of this pretty ex- ample deserve praise. Among the best of the figure pictures is Mr. T. Riley’s Persephone (39), which is not the god- dess, but the deftly and carefully drawn figure. ofanude girl standing in the sun-flecked shadows of a forest. The subdued flesh tints are true, but there is nothing like design in this study.— Nature of quite another sort appears in the half- length, half-life-size portrait of a comely country boy wearing a chorister’s surplice, which Miss K. Sturgeon calls Tommy on Sunday (179). We should be glad to see more such good, unpre- tending, and spontaneous work elsewhere as well as here. The face is ingenuous and sincere. —The Harpist (283), by Mr. C. Green, a neat, but rather flat and hard figure of a somewhat stout lady in an Empire dress, is firmly drawn, spontaneous in design, and good in expression, but, unlike ‘Tommy on Sunday,’ it lacks fibre and a raison d’étre.—Near it hangs the equally accomplished, more solid and vigorous The Balcony (292) of Mr. J. Scott, a good figure of a Spanish damsel in an amber dress carefully studied: a bright picture, dexterously drawn and modelled. As we do notsee why the other lady sits by her harp, so we fail to see why her neighbour stands in a balcony. Technically, Mr. Scott is at his best here.—Sir James Linton returns to his best methods, and never painted better than in Miss Marjorie (426), a beautiful portrait of a fair young girl dressed in marone velvet, and reclining in a crimson chair as if musing in the interval of a lesson. It is much softer than anything we have had of late from the accomplished artist, broad, cleverly and exhaustively drawn. Miss Agnes Ashbee (634), a maiden in a rich greenish-grey dress, is as good as the last, while Mrs. F. G. Lang- ham (645), in brown and golden bronze, is softer, and not less firm and sound than Sir James’s work is wont to be when he is dealing with those romantic and heroic subjects he has (for a time only we trust) laid aside.—The most ambitious, and, on the whole, the most diffi- cult achievement here is Mr. W. Langley’s nearly life-size, whole-length figure of An Old Pilot (509), on the look out seaward from Mousehole. To use water colours on such @ scale demands most unusual skill, together with sustained power of no common order, and Mr. Langley never, to our knowledge, attempted so much before. We should have liked stronger

Page 25

N° 3308, Marce 21, 91 THE ATHENAUM 385 colours in higher keys, and also less monotony of tone than we find in this otherwise very masculine and successful picture, but, accepting the artist’s aims, it is impossible to say he has not succeeded in a task of prodigious difticulties. Most of all he has been fortunate in the truth- ful and very characteristic face, which is capit- ally drawn and modelled, and largely treated. ‘¢ When the Boats are away” (149), by the same —a confused design painted with firmness, but rather spotty—is not nearly so good as the figure of the Mount’s Bay man in his waterproofs. Mr. Buckman’s Love’s Secret (542) is a dainty figure of a pretty girl furtively reading a letter. —The Captain of the Troop (707) is not Mr. F. Dadd’s best picture, but it is the largest and most ambitious of them. A somewhat touching story is told in melodramatic manner. The many figures are well designed and com- petently drawn, but there are faces ‘‘to let” in the background, and some of them are of the stage, stagey. The design suffers most from these, although the "eae as a whole lacks that spontaneity which is the best element of such art as this. Thus much good workmanship is wasted on a theme Mr. Dadd has not taken to his heart.—Whoever likes a search- ing, bright, firm, and brilliant technique, and exquisite foreshortening in accord with spark- ling light, perfect veracity, and the power- ful hues of nature, will find these qualities in Miss K. M. Whiteley’s Ammonite and Minerals (331) and her equally exquisite Shells (302), perhaps the more difficult to draw of the two. We may likewise commend her Fossil Sponges (428), a really remarkable piece of ex- haustive draughtsmanship. — Mr. C. Smith’s Corner of the Studio (526) is a clever study of a lady standing in the full light of a lamp placed above her head, of which the colour and strong sharp shadows have been ably represented. Much skill was needed to make this effect bright in the lights and clear in the intensely contrast- ing shadows. THE PORTRAIT OF CHATTERTON. 24, Hereford Square, S.W., March 7, 1891. Arter Mr. Charles Kent’s complete vindica- tion of the Chatterton portrait I need trouble you with no more than my entire endorsement of his statements. Harry ASHWORTH TAYLOR. Liverpool, March 9, 1891. On reading Mr. Kent’s interesting state- ment regarding the portrait of Chatterton, it struck me that it might interest him and others to know that I have in my possession a copy of Prior’s ‘Poems,’ in one volume, 12mo., and printed in 1754, which presumably belonged to the ill-fated young poet. It has ‘‘ Thomas Chatterton, 1768,” written across the title-page, and this appears to be a genuine signature ; but I should be glad for it to be examined by some one who is well acquainted with Chatterton’s handwriting. J. F. Mansercu. THE COLLAR AND JEWEL OF THE LORD MAYOR OF LONDON. Burlington House, London, W., March 16, 1891. Wovu tp you kindly allow me to ask for some information respecting the above insignia from the readers of the Athencewm ? In 1545 a splendid gold collar of SS and Tudor roses was bequeathed to the Mayor of London and his successors by Sir John Alen, mercer. This collar was enlarged in 1567 by the addi- tion of four SS, two knots, and two roses. In 1746-7 it was ‘‘ new set.” There was no ‘‘ jewel” till 1558, when Sir M. Bowes gave ‘‘a Crosse of golde with dyverse precious stones and perles in it.” This cross was ‘‘newe made” in 1572, when its shape was presumably altered to a non-cruciform pattern. In 1607 a new jewel was bought, which, so far as can be ascertained, formed the basis of the existing jewel, but the present border of diamonds was reset in 1880. The points on which I seek information are : 1. What portraits or other representations of Lord Mayors are known which show the fashion of the jewel (a) from 1558 to 1572, and (b) from 1573 to 1607; also (c) from 1607 to the present day ? 2. What is the nature of the central portion of the collar of SS in such of the earlier portraits as show it? It now consists of a portcullis only, but in the picture of Sir Wolstan Dixie, 1585, at Christ’s Hospital, the badge is hung from a rose placed between two portcullises. Query, were the rose and one portcullis taken off when the collar was ‘‘new set” in 1746-7, or earlier ? 3. Can any one say what became of Sir Martin Bowes’s jewel? It was expressly ordered, when a new jewel was bought in 1607, to be ‘‘ kept by the Chamberlen to the Cittyes use as a remembraunce of him that gave it, and not to be sold.” But where is it now? It is not among the existing ensigns of the City of London. Would correspondents kindly communicate with me direct ? W. H. St. Joun Hore. SALES. Messrs. CuristrE, Manson & Woops sold on the 11th inst. a picture by T. Creswick, Near Barnard Castle, for 1411. The same auctioneers sold on the 14th inst. the following pictures from various collections : G. Morland, A Landscape, with sportsmen and dogs, and a grey horse near a cottage, 346l.; The Alehouse Door, 535]. J. B. Pater, A Féte Champétre, a composition of eleven figures, 3931. Boucher, Les Pécheurs, 3511. Teniers, Interior of a Guardroom, 136]. Rubens, The Redeemer triumphing over Death, 241/. Cuyp, A River Scene, 236/.; A Sunny River Scene, 2101. Sir W. Beechey, Master Henry F. Boyce, with a dog, 5461. A. Canaletto, A View in the Forum, Rome, 1361. On the 16th inst. the following pictures, the property of the late Mr. H. 8S. Beckles: E. Verboeckhoven, Repose, interior of a barn, with ewes, lambs, and poultry, 283/.; the Com- panion, 2731. At the Hotel Drouot, Paris, on the 3rd inst., from the collection of M. P. Burty, Corot’s Le Pont de Gretz realized 16,500 fr. Gint-Art Gossip. Mr. E. Burne Jones has made consider- able progress with two pictures, each of an unusually large size, one or both of which will, if finished, as will probably be the case, go tothe New Galleryin May next. The larger and more important is a commission from the Corporation of Birmingham, and _ will be placed in the public gallery of that city. The figures are nearly life size. It repre- sents the adoration of the Magi ; the schemes of colour and tone are intensely sumptuous, and the picture is marked by abundant poetry and originality. There is a great deal of spiritual suggestion about the harmonized masses of deep blues and greens and the various and subtle combinations of these hues, and the spectator will recognize the magic of the art employed upon them and their relationship to the warm and dark flesh painting. That harmony of strong colour which is one of the most re- markable elements of Mr. Burne Jones’s art is manifest in the way in which the beautiful figures assort with the verdure and foliage of the woodland glade forming the background of the picture, and, as subtle design requires, seen in sunlight subdued into keeping with the low- toned jewel-like tints of the figures, their attire and ornaments. A vista of the glade fills the space between the group consisting of the Virgin, Child, and Joseph, and that formed by the three Magi. The former group is on our left under a thatched shed open in front; roses are blooming in the wattled fence. The Virgin holds the naked Child upon her lap, and is seated on a heap of straw. Her head is slightly bent, in half-unconscious acknowledg- ment of the salutations of the kings; the abstracted look of her eyes indicates the de- tachment of her mind from the scene, which concerns her only as a fulfilment of a prophecy she could not have been ignorant of. e Magi are, so to say, introduced by a tall angel of that quasi-Byzantine type the painter adopted in the ‘Annunciation,’ as well as in those gigantic archangels which were recently de- scribed and represented in plates in the Port- folio, and which form important features of the mosaic decorations lately finished in the American church at Rome designed by Street. He is the angel of the guiding star, and, as such, seems to float above the Earth while, like a priest holding a chalice, he carries his radiant sphere poised on the tips of his fingers. He is bare-headed, and is clad from shoulder to ankle in a blue mantle embroidered in silver with emblematic spheres; his sandals are worked in silver thread. His feet point downwards, and he looks on the holy group with a reverent air. The Infant, whose attention has been aroused by the approach of the Magi, turns His thoughtful eyes upon them, while He clings to the edge of His mother’s mantle. Her dress, in this differing from the conventions of later art, is entirely blue with silvery lights, resembling those of shot silk, but softer. Caspar’s mantle is of a more vivid blue than the Virgin’s, and has a lining of another blue shot with bronze lights, and is worn over a robe embroidered with figures of knights slaying dragons. He stands with bowed head before the holy group, and, having placed his crown on the grass, opens the casket containing his gifts of gold, while reverently, yet with a searching expression, he bends his eyes upon the Child. He is not quite so old as in ancient pictures. The other kings, both of whom have taken off their diadems, stand side by side behind him. The nearer is Balthasar of Ethiopia, a negro and still young. He holds his gift of myrrh in a casket of quaint device, and his dress is of a greenish blue, or rather green shadowed with blue. The broad border at the foot of it is embroidered with figures of angels dancing joyfully with joined hands. Another part of his dress is embroidered, in various blues, with a ship in full sail upon a tempestuous sea, and Kufic inscriptions. Mel- chior of Arabia is armed cap a pie in mail and plate of polished blue steel, and in one hand bears his mural crown of gold, and in the other, in a curious casket, carries his offering of frank- incense. His mantle of dark, reddish purple is covered with large discs of silver chased in relief with emblematic figures of lions, a centaur, sphinxes, and birds. Joseph, whose unadorned blue robe is drawn like a hood about his head, stands behind the Virgin and in the front of the picture ; under his arm he carries a bundle of herbs and field flowers ; at his feet lies a woodman’s axe. Awake, O north Wind ; and come, thou South ; blow wpon my garden, that the spices thereof may flow out. Let my beloved come into his garden, and eat his pleasant fruits. This verse from the Song of Solomon is the descriptive motto of the second picture now on Mr. Burne Jones’s easels. The virgin bride, a beautiful and very elegant figure, stands on the edge of a little stream whose devious course divides a meadow resplendent in spring sunlight from a wood whose branches rock in the wind. A strong breeze shakes the maiden’s garments, making them flutter about her naked feet, and, having shaken her long brown hair from its fastenings, compels her to draw the tresses together about her neck. Much of the charm of the picture lies in her noble face and its in- tensely pure expression. Behind her, and as if floating on the gale which draws their blue and light purple mantles into great loops about their shoulders, are two fair damsels, emblems of the = SO ey a ee Seep RSS ee Pd ee SEE gad Sot eo ee — — ee eh Stina rons iin gino Ee re, ht aes + a vanaane Aenean eens ilies 2 = Sonera

Page 26

386 THE ATHENZUM N° 3308, Marca 21,91 North Wind and the South Wind. Each of them, as if to assist her voice, holds her open hands close to her face: the North seems to whistle between her lips; the South ‘‘with open mouth ” is crying aloud as if, according to the old saw, calling upon the Spring to follow in her track. THE Society of British Artists has appointed to-day (Saturday) for a private view of its exhi- bition, which will be opened to the public on Monday next. Tue Reliquary for April will contain the first of a series of articles on Irish cathedrals, be- ginning with the province of Ulster. It will also contain an article on ‘ Yorkshire Chalice Brasses,’ by Mr. Mill Stephenson ; ‘Old English Pewter,’ by Mr. T. M. Fallow ; ‘ Notes on Tiles, Dale Abbey and Morley, Derbyshire,’ by Mr. John Ward; and ‘Personal Names in 1302,’ by Dr. Atkinson. Mr. Stacey, Royal Arcade Gallery, Old Bond Street, exhibits Mr. F. Brangwyn’s sketches entitled ‘‘From Antwerp to the Lower Danube.” THE death is announced of Mr. John Dick Peddie, architect, a Royal Scottish Academician. This event occurred on the 12th inst. at Edin- burgh. Tue Manchester Free Library has just been enriched by the gift of the Hibbert-Ware manu- scripts, presented by Mrs. Hibbert-Ware, of Bowdon. These antiquarian collections were made by Dr. Samuel Hibbert-Ware, who died in 1848, and consist of twelve quarto volumes, containing a number of valuable drawings and sketches, made forty or fifty years ago, of anti- quities in England, Scotland, and Ireland. In the April issue of the Antiquary the Rev. J. Hirst will have a paper on the ‘ Limes Ger- manicus,’ that wonderful old Roman rampart that five German governments have just agreed to investigate systematically. Mr. Havertield, F.S.A., gives his quarterly notes on Roman Britain. A communication will appear on the most recent explorations in Egypt from the pen of Mr. A. E. Hudd, F.S.A., who is now at Luxor. Tue Museum and Art Gallery Committee of Birmingham have bought for the public collec- tion of that city Mr. Ford Madox Brown’s ‘Last of England,’ representing an English emigrant of the better class and his wife seated at the side of the ship which bears them away ; the former is looking homewards regret- fully and bitterly, the latter is more immediately occupied with the babe she protects from the cold wind. ‘The Last of England’ was pub- licly exhibited, for, we believe, the first time, at the International Exhibition, 1862. The faces are portraits of the painter and his (second) wife. The same collection has been enriched by the addition of a replica of Rossetti’s ‘ Beata Beatrix,’ the original of which is in the National Gallery, Trafalgar Square. Neither of these pictures will appear at Birmingham until the summer. WE are sorry to learn that one of our Liver- pool correspondents was misinformed with re- gard to the completion of the purchase of Mr. Holman Hunt’s ‘Triumph of the Innocents.’ A better authority, Mr. Reginald Bushell, writes :— “The amount subscribed by the public to date is only 1,8607. (not 4,000/.); add to this the 1,500. voted by the City Council and we have 3,360. in all. But this is far below the sum which Mr. Hunt asks for the picture ; and while we still hope to secure the picture, it is, I am sorry to say, only a hope at present,” Mr. Mark Knicuts, the author of * High- ways and Byeways of Old Norwich,’ &c., is preparing ‘Peeps at the Past; or, Rambles among Norfolk Antiquities,’ with thirteen illus- trations by Mr. E. Pococke. Messrs. Jarrold & Sons are the publishers. Amone the pictures mentioned by the French as usual, will be opened on the 1st of May, is C. de Montenard’s representation of ‘Les Arénes d’Arles’ during a ‘‘ course de taureaux”’ before a crowded house in brilliant sunlight (sunlight is the painter’s speciality). M. Monte- nard will likewise contribute a sea-piece repre- senting a Mediterranean pilot-boat struck by the mistral. M. Adrien Moreau will send two landscapes, ‘Les Vendages & Brolles’ and ‘ Apres le Grain.’ M. J. P. Laurens has finished his large historical picture entitled ‘ Bailly recevant Louis XVI. a l’Hétel de Ville.’ It is a member of an important series of subjects illustrating the history of the Franchises Com- munales from Louis VI. until Louis XVI. At Cittaducale, where stood the ancient Aquee Cutilize, some therme have been discovered and fragments of inscriptions. A CoRRESPONDENT from Alexandria writes :— “Tt might have been thought that the recent pro- tests against the neglect of the Egyptian monuments would have at least incited the authorities to pay some attention to those which may be said to be under their very eyes. Alexandria boasts few remains of antiquity, saving the world - famous so - called Pompey’s pillar, which stands, as is well known, on an open mound in the suburbs. Decency would dictate that the base of the pillar should be en- closed by an iron railing, or that the whole of the mound should be walled in as a public garden, in- stead of being, as it is, a place where the filth of the neighbourhood is deposited. Beyond, however, the question of propriety there is that of preservation. To-day when visiting the pillar I was offered a fragment of the granite base by a native. On en- deavouring to explain to him that he should not knock pieces off the stone, he replied, ‘That my business, allow travellers wantin’ piece of Pompey pillar.’ This assertion was doubtless incorrect ; but probably many of the ‘travellers,’ mostly carriage loads of sailors from the ships in the harbour, do purchase these little souvenirs. As far as the pillar is concerned, I believe this is an industry which has only recently come into existence—for I was never offered fragments on previous visits—and is only another instance of what has been generally re- marked, that depredation ison theincrease It is difficult to know who is responsible for the care of the monuments; it appears to rest between two de- partments, one managed by a military official, and another by an Egyptologist. The Egyptologists are notorious for their disregard of preservation. Pos- sibly the distinguished French writer exaggerated when he accused the German savant of wantonly defacing the inscriptions at Thebes in order that they might only exist in his work ; still, if there has been no actual defacement there has been no earnect at- tempt at preservation in all the long years that the Egyptian monuments may be said to have been in the hands of the Egyptologists. As toexpecting an officer of the Royal Engineers, who is really here to carry outa scheme of irrigation, to display ardour in the cause, it is simply preposterous. An officer of Engineers could doubtless be found who would most efficiently guard the monuments, but then that must be his sole duty. And, by the way, there is one Egyptologist who is capable of the task. If Mr. Flinders Petrie had the charge of the monuments, woe to the unlucky Arab who, between Wady Halfa and the lighthouse of Alexandria, chipped a frag- ment of their stones. Between the Egyptologists and the Engineers, unless something is done quickly there will be little left to preserve.” MUSIC —-— THE WEEK. Sr. James’s HaLti.—Mlle. Janotha’s Concert. Ir is, perhaps, not very gratifying to the self-esteem of English musicians to find themselves in any way dependent on external | sources for support; but this should not | hinder a due expression of acknowledgment when a foreign artist steps forward to per- troducing a cycle of songs by Lady Tenny- son. The announcement came as a surprise, for it was not generally known that the wife of the Laureate possessed any talent for composition; but it appears that she has set more than a dozen of his lyrics, some of which are not yet published, and seven of them were sung on the present occasion. It is understood, however, that Mlle. Janotha has had a large share in welding them into shape. They are to be published as “arranged”? by her, and, unless we are much mistaken, she is responsible for the musicianly, if, in some instances, over-ela- borate accompaniments, which frequently breathe the spirit of Schumann. ‘Two of the songs were sung by Madame de Swiat- lowsky, three by Mr. Bispham, and two by Miss Carlotta Elliot. Speaking generally, they are not of a nature to catch the popular ear, though musicians will not condemn them on that account. The composer seems to have set the lines to such musical phrases as she deemed suitable, without reference to rhythm or symmetry in construction. Of course this is quite in accordance with modern methods; but it is questionable whether Lady Tennyson has not gone to extremes in the matter. On this point we must speak with caution, as the music is not before us, and our impressions are derived merely from last week’s performance, which, as regards two of the executants, was far from satisfactory.. It may have been for this reason that the two songs, ‘To Sleep’ and ‘ Airy, fairy Lilian,” tastefully rendered by Miss Carlotta Elliot, seemed decidedly superior to the rest. The first is a tender and expressive little lyric, and the second is bright and genial, with an effective florid accompaniment. Madame de Swiatlowsky’s imperfect pronunciation of English and Mr. Bispham’s rather amateurish method pro- bably detracted from the legitimate effects to be gained in the other songs, which in- clude new settings of the familiar ‘ Break, break, break,” ‘‘ In Love, if Love be Love,’’ and ‘‘ Riflemen, form.” Miss Liza Lehmann introduced a piquant new song, ‘ Le Temps des Roses,’ by Gounod, and Miss Elliot a pleasing ballad, ‘One Word,’ by Miss Minnie Cochrane. Mlle. Janotha played some trifling pianoforte solos, and took part with Signor Piatti in Mendelssohn’s Varia- tions Concertantes for piano and violon- cello, Op. 17. Mr. Sims Reeves was to have sung, but an apology was circulated in his behalf. The Royal Amateur Orchestral Society was heard to moderate advantage in Mendelssohn’s ‘ Melusina’ Overture and other selections. THE ROYAL ITALIAN OPERA. WE are almost within a fortnight of the open- ing of the Royal Italian Opera season, and up to the time of writing Mr. Augustus Harris has made no official statement of any kind with respect to the arrangements. That the public is willing to accept his policy on trust is, how- ever, evident, as the subscription is exceptionally form an act of courtesy such as that under- taken by Mlle. Janotha on Friday evening last week. The Polish pianist had already | afforded ample evidence of sympathy and in- terest in English musical work and workers, | and it was quite in accordance with these | amiable feelings that she decided to give journals as intended for the next Salon, which, a concert mainly for the purpose of in- | large. In place of one set of subscribers for forty nights, as in the so-called palmy days, there are two sets for forty-eight nights each, and performances are to be given every evening | from April 6th to July 25th. Such a season at full prices is, of course, unprecedented ; but it must be borne in mind that Italian opera pure _ and simple will occupy quite a subordinate place in the scheme, unless Verdi’s ‘Otello’ and

Page 27

XUM Ne 3308, Marcu 21,91 THE ATHENAUM 387

Mascagni’s ‘Cavalleria Rusticana’ are mounted, which is possible, not to say probable. With regard to Wagner, when it was currently re- ported that Mr. Harris intended to produce ‘Tristan und Isolde’ we deprecated the idea, and for a time ‘Die Walkiire’ was fixed upon instead. But, for reasons into which it is un- necessary to enter, the choice has now fallen upon ‘Siegfried.’ This we regard as only less perilous than ‘Tristan.’ It is in the highest degree unlikely that the habitués of Covent Garden will take the trouble to grasp the philo- sophic significance of the third section of Wagner’s tetralogy, and the music consists wholly of monologues and duologues, which, however beautiful some of them undoubtedly are, can scarcely fail to prove wearisome and unmeaning to those unacquainted with the entire work. ‘ Tannhiuser’ and ‘ Der Fliegende Hollinder’ will probably be given early in the season ; and of course Gluck’s ‘ Orfeo,’ with the Miles. Ravogli, will be a strong attraction. Mr. Harris has secured rights in other operas of less importance ; but whether they will be pro- duced is open to question. With regard to the company, all the leading artists who took part in last year’s season are re-engaged, together with Madame Albani, Miss Eames (the Ame- rican soprano who has won distinction at the Paris Opéra), and several new-comers of lesser note.

Musical Gossip. THE prospectus of the forthcoming season of Richter Concerts came to hand just too late for notice last week. The series promises to be highly interesting, and though prominence will, as usual, be given to the works of Wagner, other composers will not be neglected. Among note- worthy items are Brahms’s ‘ Deutsches’ Requiem; Bruckner’s Symphony, No. 3, in p minor ; Cor- nelius’s Overture to the ‘Barber of Bagdad’; possibly a new work by Dvorak ; and Prof. Stanford’s ballad for chorus and orchestra, ‘The Battle of the Baltic.’ time are the entire Venusberg scene from the Paris version of ‘Tannhiiuser,’ the duet from which has not yet been heard in England, the introduction and first scene from ‘Das Rhein- gold,’ the fourth scene from the second act of ‘Die Walkiire,’ and the first scene from the third act of ‘G6tterdiimmerung.’ The concerts will take place on Monday evenings, commenc- ing May 25th and ending July 20th. THERE were no novelties in the programme of last Saturday’s Crystal Palace Concert. The most noteworthy item was Brahms’s Pianoforte Concerto in B flat, No. 2, which had not been | heard at the Palace since 1884. The executant on the present occasion was Mr. Marmaduke M. Barton, this being his first appearance at Sydenham. There are few more difticult works for the piano than this concerto of Brahms; but Mr. Barton is an exceedingly capable player, and technically his performance left little to be desired. Thesymphony was Sterndale Bennett’s Among the Wagner | selections which will be given for the first |

quiet and unpretentious work in @ minor, which | has rather dropped out of the concert-room re- cently. Palace since 1883. Other items were Schumann’s ‘Genoveva’ Overture and Beethoven’s ‘ Leo- nora,’ No. 3. | the beautiful tenor solo and chorus It had not been played at the Crystal | Monteith and Mr. J. G. Robertson, the latter in place of Mr. W. Nicholl, indisposed. A BEETHOVEN programme was presented at last Saturday’s Popular Concert, consisting of the Rasoumowsky Quartet in c, Op. 59, No. 3; the ‘ Kreutzer’ Sonata for piano and violin ; the Violin Romance in F, Op. 50; and the Theme and Variations in E flat, Op. 35, the last-named work being rendered with good technique and general intelligence by Mr. Leonard Borwick, making allowance for some false notes in the very difficult thirteenth variation. Mr. Norman Salmond, presumably for the sake of variety, introduced songs by other composers, his first selection being an air, ‘Al Nome tuo Temuto,’ by Righini, a sketch of whom will be found in Otto Jahn’s ‘ Life of Mozart.’ The air is ex- tremely melodious and refined, and shows Righini to have been an accomplished musician, though his works were only temporarily success- ful, in spite of the esteem in which he was held as a conductor at Berlin from 1793 to 1806. Born in 1756, the same year as Mozart, he survived his greater contemporary for twenty- one years. On Monday the concerted instrumental works were Beethoven’s Quartet in F minor, Op. 95 ; Mendelssohn’s Sonata in p for piano and violon- cello, Op. 58; and Mozart’s Trio in £, No. 6. There was no pianoforte solo, but Miss Fanny Davies was almost wholly acceptable in the piano parts of the two last-named works. Mr. Plunket Greene sang Schubert’s ‘ Litanei’ and three of Prof. Stanford’s Irish songs with note- worthy artistic feeling. Tue performance of Spohr’s ‘ Last Judgment ’ and Sullivan’s ‘The Martyr of Antioch’ at the Hampstead Conservatoire Hall on Monday evening, under the direction of Mr. G. F. Geaussent, was, on the whole, worthy of much praise. The soloists, Miss Monteith, Miss Marian McKenzie, Mr. Piercy, and Mr. Hilton, were all satisfactory. Miss H. Sass gave a matince musicale at St. James's (Banqueting) Hall on Tuesday, her programme containing Gade’s Trio in F, and Schumann’s Pianoforte Quartet in E flat. Among the artists who assisted her were Messrs. Kummer, Jacoby, and W. H. Squire. Tue Westminster Orchestral Society has greatly improved of late, and the playing at its concert on Wednesday night was very credit- able. — THE WEEK. Royatty.—Private Performance: ‘Ghosts,’ a Drama in Three Acts. By Henrik Ibsen. VAUDEVILLE.— Diamond Deane,’ a Play in Four Acts. By Henry J. W. Dam. Tue attempt to establish a free, or, as it is called, independent, theatre in London has created a ferment that must be suffi- ciently gratifying to the prime movers in a not very ambitious undertaking. All the unreasoning hostility of the English- man to innovation has been provoked, and in addition to the general condemnation of the theatrical reporters or critics, the leader-writers have entered the arena, and belaboured all concerned in the undertaking. To those who do not remember the fierce antagonism to which Wagner was exposed, the not undeserved outcry against the nudities of Walt Whitman or the diseased imagination of Baudelaire, the scream against ‘Songs and Ballads,’ and other similar manifestations, it might seem as if decency had been beaten to a mummy, and purity had received its death-blow. But

er en ee ee a eee eee ee

Page 28

388 THE ATHENAUM N° 3308, Marcu 21,91 unless the Lord Chamberlain is coaxed or coerced into interference by those who will afterwards laugh at him, the storm will blow over. The opening venture may be pro- nounced indiscreet. Ibsen’s ‘Ghosts’ has provoked a good deal of censure. It is an uncomfortable and, in a sense, unclean piece, against the public 'production of which men may reasonably protest. To use, how- ever, concerning it language so violent as has been recently employed is as unjust as it is silly. The subject of ‘Ghosts’ is un- suited to dramatic exposition, or, indeed, to presentation in any popular form. The play, none the less, has scarcely an objec- tionable passage, and, so far from being prurient, it points a lesson of Puritan stern- ness. It may fairly be urged against Ibsen that he is essentially provincial, and that his scientific knowledge is out of date. These things fairly stated are more damaging than the fiery denunciation that has been heard. Against ‘Ghosts’ aseries of charges may be sustained. It is dull—almost as dull as a modern English comedy; it is undramatic, most of its language being duologue ; its subject is revolting; and at one or two points it touches on subjects which are unmentionable in public. Only in a few instances does it rise into elo- quence. For acting purposes it is hope- less. To charge it, however, with im- morality is a mistake. It is fiercely moral. Not only is there not in it a passage that can suggest evil—it is one long pro- test against the employment of euphemisms to describe sordid vice. Some failed to see that the phrase “joy of life” used by the heroine was employed in a bitterly ironical sense. In a small Norwegian town a man possessing high spirits, infectious gaiety, intense selfishness, and great charm of manner sinks into a crapulous life. How foul this life is Ibsen shows with relentless severity, and the moral he points is that this so-called ‘“‘ gay dog,” ‘good fellow,” what you will, is a source of pollution and ruin to the family and of serious injury to the State. The legitimate outcome of this teaching is that our Lovelaces, Lotharios, and so forth are a despicable set who, instead of figuring as the heroes of comedy, should be attainted for treason to the State or banished as lepers from the community. However shocked he may be at the subject discussed, and however wearied of the treat- ment, the spectator at least quits the theatre with a sense that our ‘pleasant vices”? are more vicious than pleasant. That the projected series of experiments will be carried out in the face of the storm that has been raised seems doubtful. A certain measure of interest attended the opening performance, which was received with much favour by a large audience. In the case of plays so amateurish in many respects as those of Ibsen an amateur inter- pretation is not wholly unsuitable. It is certain that the interpreters of ‘Ghosts,’ unknown as they are to fame, gave a serious and competent rendering of the strange and uncanny characters whom Ibsen has planted in Mrs. Alven’s house on one of the western fjords of Norway. Mr. Dam, whose first drama, it is under- stood, ‘Diamond Deane’ is, is a young and capable American journalist. Signs of in- experience abound in his work, the cha- racters in which are conventional, and its framework is clumsy. It is new and fresh, however, and not wholly devoid of literary merit; and it leads up to an effective thea- trical situation, by which the audience was carried away. Diamond Deane is the name bestowed upon a female adventuress on account of her aptness in extracting dia- monds by her lures, or when these fail by her fingers. The story is that of a persona- tion by this woman of a married lady, whose domestic peace is for a while compromised. In the end all closes well, and the adven- turess, who rails constantly and needlessly at her surroundings, escapes the punishment she merits. Miss Millward played with power as the heroine, and Miss Dorothy Dorr, a new-comer from America, made a favourable impression as the wife. Mr. Conway reappeared in a fairly good part; and Mr. T. Thorne, Mr. F. Thorne, Mr. Scott Buist, and other actors took part in a competent interpretation. Bramatic Gossip. ‘THE Votcano’ of Mr. R. R. Lumley, pro- duced on Saturday last at the Court Theatre, spreads over three acts a farcical idea scarcely strong enough for one. It has some whimsical satire of aristocratic manners, and has a certain amount of briskness. Its best chance of success lies in the fact that it is written for the actors of the company, all the more important of whom are fitted to a nicety. Mr. Arthur Cecil, who plays a duke, the proprietor of a cheap society periodical, and Mrs. John Wood as a female interviewer, are very droll; and other actors play with judgment, tact, and success. The piece, however, which begins brightly, collapses in the end under its own weight. ‘Sprinc LEAVES,’ a one-act comedietta from the Dutch, by Mr. J. T. Grein and Mr. C. W Jarvis, is the lever de rideau at the Court. Leonard Fairweather wins, under false pre- tences, the hand of a romantic girl, who sees in him a poet. He has published a volume of verses, and has himself bought up the entire edition. His attempts to smuggle into a secret closet the books in batches entangle him in some not very comic situations. Tom Taytor’s ‘ Nine Points of the Law’ has been revived at the Criterion, with a cast including Mr. Giddens, Mr. Cyril Maude, Mr. Blakeley, and Miss Frances. THE first meeting of the Actors’ Association was held on Monday afternoon on the Lyceum stage. It was announced that Mr. Irving and Mr. Terry would hold office. In connexion with the Association it is hoped to found a school of dancing, fencing, and elocution. Tue Garrick Theatre was closed on Tuesday night, when Mr. Hare and his company acted, by royal command, at Windsor Castle in ‘A Quiet Rubber’ and ‘A Pair of Spectacles.’ ‘L’ENFANT Propicug,’ a piece expounded wholly in pantomime and music, is with its cast to be transferred from the Bouffes Parisiens to the Prince of Wales’s. A very slight know- ledge of French seems adequate to justify the patronage of Freneh plays. Inthe present case no knowledge at all will suffice. To CoRRESPONDENTS.—R. B. S.—A. H.—W. P.—W. A.— E. E.—S. G. P.—received. No notice will be taken of anonymous communications, TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION BY PosT. For Twelve Months ven ove app For Six Months ... eee ooo ove aH” wows SAMPSON LOW, MARSTON & (00.’s NEW BOOKS. —_———— The LANCASHIRE LIFE of BISHOP FRASER. By JOHN W. DIGGLE, M.A., Vicar of Mossley Hill, 7 saverpenl, Hon. Canon of ‘Liverpool, — of ‘ f * Godliness and Manliness,’ ‘True Religion,’ &e., yg Be raser’s Sermons. POPULAR eBVISED EDITION, with a New Portrait and other Illustrations. Crown 8vo. ‘cloth, 3s. 6d. *,* The SEVENTH LIBRARY EDITION, price 12s. 6¢., can ? still be obtained. ‘Many important and hitherto unpublished letters en- rich a mo Hew. which casts a flood of light on every phase of Fraser's career in Lancashire... This fascinating biography” Standar The BROAD CHURCH, or WHAT Is COMING. By the Rev. H. R. HAWEIS, Author of ‘ Poets in the Pulpit,’ &c. Crown 8vo. cloth, 6s. The ENGLISH CATALOGUE of BOOKS for 1890. Containing a complete List of all the Books published in Great Britain and Ireland in the Year 1890, with their sizes, prices, and publishers’ names ; also of the principal Books published in the United States of America, with the addition of an INDEX to SUBJECTS. Royal 8vo. 5s. DECORATIVE ELECTRICITY. By Mrs. J. E. ~" Tr With a Chapter on FIRE RISKS b: E. H. GORDON, B.A. M.Inst.0C.E., Director o oan Consulting Engineer to the Metropo- litan Electric Supply ~—- Illustrated by Herbert Tell. Demy 8vo. cloth, 1 The illustrations are ree ho new and original engravings on wood, by J. D. Cooper. SIR ROBERT PEEL. By Justin McCARTHY, M.P., being the Third Volume in ‘ The ae Prime Ministers Series.” Edited by STUART REID. With Photogravure Portrait. Siothe 3s. 6d. “Mr. McCarthy relates clearly and well the main incidents of Peel’s political life, and deals fairly with the great con- troversies which still hele about his conduct in regard to the Roman Catholic Relief Bill and the Repeal of the Corn Laws.”—Saturday The COBBLER of CORNIKERA- NIUM. By the Rev. A. N. MALAN, Author of ‘ Uncle Towser,’ &c. Illustrated. Crown 8vo. cloth, is. The CHESS PLAYER'S POCKET- BOOK, and Manual of the Openings. Edited by JAMES MORTIMER. Seventh Edition. 16mo. boards, Is, A HUNDRED YEARS BY POST: a Jubilee Retrospect. By J. WILSON HYDE, Author of ‘The Royal Mail and its Curiosities and Romance.’ Illustrated. Crown 8vo. paper covers, 1s. “A very interesting account of the more remarkable changes that have taken place in the postal service during the past century.”—Scotsman. NEW NOVELS AT ALL LIBRARIES. The RICHEST MERCHANT in ROTTERDAM. By A. N. HOMER, Author of ‘Red Ruin,’ &c. 2 vols. crown | 8vo. 21s, “The interest is well sust d.”—Glasgow Herald. NOT a MOMENT to SPARE. By HUGH COLEMAN tag agg Author of ‘The Old Adam,’ &c. 2 vols. crown 8vo. 21s. “The book is one that will be read without the skipping of a line.”— Scotsman, A BOLT from the BLUE. By Scott GRAHAM, Author of ‘The Golden Milestone,’ ‘The Sandcliff Myste: &c. 3 vols. crown 8vo. 31s, 6d. ** Well told. The YR in are all human, none of them being described as perfect, either in goodness or in badness. Several of the situations are strong in themselves and power- fully set forth, so that the story may be classed as above the average of society novels.”—Athenaum. NOW READY, PRICE ONE SHILLING, HARPER’S MAGAZINE. APRIL NUMBER. Contents. THE BEHRING SEA CONTROVERSY. . J. Phelps. The eng ee ARMY. General Lewall. 16 Illustrations drawn by T. de Thulstrup. The STATE of WISCONSI — W. F. Vilas. 11 Illus- rations. From Photogra graphs WESSEX FOLK. Part II. llustrated. Thomas Hardy. GLIMPSES of the BACTERIA. T. i Prudden, ‘D. 10 Illustrations drawn by H. D. Nichol THOMAS Ay hg sy POET, PREACHER. Rt. Rev IN the STRANGER PEOPLE'S” ccc a Story. art IV. Charles Egbert Craddoc The COURT THEATRE of MEININGEN. Charles Wald- stein. 10 Illustrations from Drawings by H. D. Nicholls. DON CARLOS: a Story. _—s nog om MARK FENTON: a Story. roy ARGENTINE PROVING ALS CHES. Theodore Child. 10 a drawn — de —, C. . 6 rown 8vo, London: Sampson Low, MARSTON & Co. (LIMITED), St. Dunstan’s House, Fetter-lane, Fleet-street, E,C, Sn

Page 29

~~ mn oe a a N° 3308, Marcu 21, ’91 THE ATHENAUM STANDARD WORKS FOR THE LIBRARY PUBLISHED BY RICHARD BENTLEY & SON. Each in 1 vol. crown 8vo. 6s. to be obtained at any Bookseller’s. The AUTOBIOGRAPHY and REMINISCENCES of W. P. FRITH, R.A. A New Edition, being the Eighth. DEAN HOOK: his Life and Letters. Edited by the Rev. W. R. W. STEPHENS, Vicar of Wool- beding, Author of ‘ Life of St. John Chrysostom,’ &c. With Index and Portraits. RECOLLECTIONS of a LITERARY LIFE. With Selections from her Favourite Poets and Prose Writers. By MARY RUSSELL MIT- FORD. With Portrait. The LIVES of PAINTERS: Hogarth, Sir Joshua Reynolds, Gainsborough, Fuseli, Sir Thomas Lawrence, Turner. By JOHN TIMBS, F.S.A. With Portraits. A MEMOIR of the late Rev. JOHN RUSSELL, (‘‘ Parson Russell”), of Tordown, North Devon. By the Author of ‘Dartmoor Days,’ ‘ Wolf- Hunting in Brittany,’ &c. With Portrait. LETTERS to a FRIEND. By the late Connop THIRLWALL, D.D., Bishop and Edited by the late Dean STANLEY. A much Enlarged Edition. The LIFE of MARY, QUEEN of SCOTS. From the French of M. MIGNET, by ANDREW SCOBLE. With 2 Portraits. The LIFE of OLIVER CROMWELL. From the French of M. GUIZOT, by ANDREW SCOBLE. With 4 Portraits. The LIFE of LORD WOLSELEY. By Charles RATHBONE LOW, F.R.G.S. With a Portrait. The LIFE of the Rev. RICHARD HARRIS BARHAM, Author of ‘The Ingoldsby Legends.’ By his Son, the Rev. RICHARD H. DALTON BARHAM. With Portrait. The LIFE of THEODORE EDWARD HOOK. By Rev. RICHARD H. DALTON BARHAM. A New Edition. of St. David’s, |The PRIVATE LIFE of MARIE ANTOINETTE. By HENRIETTE FELICITE CAMPAN, First Lady-in-Waiting to the Queen. With 2 Portraits. BY THE REV. RICHARD HARRIS BARHAM. THE INGOLDSBY LEGENDS. (MESSRS. BENTLEY’S ARE THE ONLY COMPLETE EDITIONS.) Illustrated by CRUIKSHANK, LEECH, TENNIEL, DU MAURIER, DALTON, BARHAM, and DOYLE, ‘* aseries of humorous legends, illustrated by three such men as Cruikshank, Leech, and Tenniel—what can be more tempting ?”—Times. I. The ILLUSTRATED EDITION. With 69 Illustrations on Wood by Cruikshank, Leech, and Tenniel. Printed on Toned Paper. Crown 4to, | cloth, bevelled boards, gilt edges, 21s. *,* Also in white cloth, for Presentation Copies, same price, Il. The CARMINE EDITION. Small demy 8vo. with a carmine border line around each page. With 20 Illustrations on Steel by Cruikshank | and Leech, with gilt edges and bevelled boards, 10s, 6d. III. The BURLINGTON EDITION. A Cabinet Edition. 3 vols. feap 8vo. 10s. 6d. IV. The EDINBURGH EDITION. An Edition in large type, with 50 Illustrations by Cruikshank, Leech, Tenniel, Barham, and Du Maurier, re-engraved on Wood for this Edition by George Pearson. Crown 8vo. red cloth, 6s. *,* Also bound in gold cloth, with paper label, same price. BOOKS FOR BOYS. CURIOSITIES of NATURAL HISTORY. By Francis TREVELYAN BUCKLAND, late Her Majesty’s Inspector of Fisheries. Popular Edition, with Illustrations. All the Series together, 10s. ; or separately, as follows :— FIRST SERIES.—Rats, Serpents, Fishes, Frogs, Monkeys, &c. Small 8vo. 2s. 6d. SECOND SERIES.—Fossils, Bears, Wolves, Cats, Eagles, Hedgehogs, Eels, Herrings, Whales. Small 8vo. 2s. 6d. THIRD SERIES.—Wild Ducks, Fishing, Lions, Tigers, Porpoises. Small 8vo. 2s. 6d. FOURTH SERIES.—Giants, Mummies, Mermaids, Wonderful People, Salmon, &c. Small 8vo, 2s. 6d. NO RELATIONS. By Hector Malot. In crown 8vo. crimson cloth, illustrated, 6s. . “ Messrs. Bentley have published a new edition in one volume of the English translation —‘No Relations’—of M. Hector Malot’s singularly popular story for — people, ‘Sans Famille.’ It needs no new recommendation in its present form. The illustrations are deli- cate and suggestive.”—Guardian. HE WOULD BE A SOLDIER. By R. Mounteney Jeph- SON, Author of ‘The Girl he left Behind Him,’ &c. A New and Cheaper Edition, with Four Illustrations, crown 8vo. 2s. 6d. SEVEN YEARS at ETON, 1857-1864. Edited by James BRINSLEY RICHARDS. Third Edition. Crown 8vo. 6s. London: RICHARD BENTLEY & SON, New Burlington-street, Publishers in Ordinary to Her Majesty the Queen. 389 ee re et ee ee ee eS eae ieee ah adatom eens nein Daan somameeredns

Page 30

390 THE ATHENZUM Ne 3308, Marcu 21, ’91 Just published, Ho™ LIFE on an OSTRICH FARM. By ANNIE MARTIN. Crown 8vo. illustrated, price 7s. 6d. “One of the most charming descriptions of African experience that have come under the notice of the reviewer, weary of bookmaking and padding. The work does not contain a dull page....A sparkling little book, of which it would be difficult to speak too highly.”—Athenaum. George Philip & Son, 32, Fleet-street, E.C. In the press, YROZET’S VOYAGE to TASMANIA, NEW ZEALAND, the LADRONE ISLANDS, and the PHILIPPINES IN THE YEARS 1771-1772. Translated and Edited by HY. LING ROTH, Author of ‘‘Ihe Aborigines of Tasmania,’ ‘ The Agriculture and Peasantry of Eastern Russia,’ &c. With a Preface by JAS. R. BOOSE, Librarian to the Roya! Colonial Institute. Embellished with beautiful Full-Page Autotype Plates, and other Illustrations in the Text. Price 10s. €d. net. The edition will be strictly limited to 500 copies, and each copy will be numbered. It is expected that at least half of the edition will be taken at the Antipodes. Early application is suggested. London : Truslove & Shirley, 143, Oxford-street, W. Every SATURDAY, 24 Pages, Price 4d., of all Booksellers, NOTES AND QUERIES: A Medium of Intercommunication for Literary Men, Artists, Antiquaries, Genealogists, &c. CONTAINING EVERY WEEK AMUSING ARTICLES ON SOME OF THE FOLLOWING SUBJECTS : ENGLISH, IRISH, and SCOTTISH HISTORY, Illustrated by Original Communications and Inedited Documents. BIOGRAPHY, Including unpublished Correspondence of eminent Men, and unrecorded Facts connected with them, BIBLIOGRAPHY, More especially of English Authors, with Notices of rare and unknown Editions of their Works, and Notes on Authorship of Anonymous Books, POPULAR ANTIQUITIES and FOLE- LORE, Preserving the fast-fading Relics of the old Mythologies, BALLADS and OLD POETRY, With Historical and Philological Illustrations, POPULAR and PROVERBIAL SAYINGS, Their Origin, Meaning, and Application, PHILOLOGY, Including Local Dialects, Archaisms, and Notes on our Old Poets, GENEALOGY AND HERALDRY, Including Histories of Old Families, completion of Pedigrees, &c, MISCELLANEOUS NOTES, QUERIES, and REPLIES, On points of EccLESIASTICAL History, ToPo- GRAPHY, FINE ARTS, NATURAL History, MIs- CELLANEOUS ANTIQUITIES, NUMISMATICS, PHOTOGRAPHY, &c, Published by JoHN C, FRANCIS, 22, Took’s-court, Cursitor-street, Chancery-lane, E,(, NEW NOVELS IN ONE VOLUME. Mrs. J. H. Neepett, Author of ‘Stephen Ellicott’s Daughter,’ ‘Noel Chetwynd’s Fall,’ &. Crown 8vo. 6s. MADELINE POWER. By Arruur W. Marcumont, Author of ‘Isa: a Novel.’ Crown 8vo. 5s, UNEQUALLY YOKED. By OLIPHANT, ANDERSON & FERRIER, 24, Old Bailey, E.C., and Edinburgh. New Popular Edition, price 3s. 6d. A ROMANCE OF THE CAPE FRONTIER. By BERTRAM MITFORD, Author of ‘ Through the Zulu Country,’ ‘The Weird of Deadly Hollow.’ “The love story is a particularly pleasing one.”—Academy. “We pause again and again to think over the lifelike personages who act in it,"and the vivid scenes, natural and human, in which it is transacted.”— Whitehall Review. “It is an eminently good and strong novel, crisply written in brisk and vigorous English.”—Sunday Times. ‘The book shouid be read by such as can enjoy a tale of stirring incidents.”—Manchester Examiner. ‘* A first-rate romance.”—Daily Graphic. “Claverton and Lilian Strange are characters which will not be easily forgotten.” —Figaro, “‘ Genuine interest, admirable descriptive power, clever delineation of character, and a succession of thrilling iucidents. coceee Thoroughly deserves the praises showered upon it.”—Scottish Leader. London: Wm. HEINEMANN, 21, Bedford-street, W.C. AT THE LIBRARIES. RICHARD DE LACY: a Tale of the Later Lollards. By C. E. MAURICE. With Etched Title and Frontispiece. Crown 8vo. cloth boards, 6s. ‘“Mr. Maurice has applied himself to the congenial task of reconstructing the age of Bishop Pecock, John Cade, Peter Payne, and the English Lollardry which asserted itself at Oxford and elsewhere a couple of generations after the death of Wyclif. He has done this with much skill...... The romance of the narrative will attract many readers...... Alice Large is sweet enough to make one wish that Mr. Maurice had cast others from the same mould.”—Atheneum. DARTON’S MANUALS FOR HOME WORK. CAMEO CUTTING. By John B. Marsh, Author of ‘Venice and the Venetians,’ &c. With numerous Illustrations. Cloth, 1s. 6d. ETCHING. By G. W. Rhead, Fellow of the Royal Society of Painter-Etchers. With numerous Illustrations. Cloth, 1s. 6d. ** Both eminently practical, simply and concisely written.”—Scotsman, “ Both written by experts.” —Glasgow Herald. A NEW VOLUME BY THE AUTHOR OF ‘HONOR BRIGHT,’ &c. THE TWO BLACKBIRDS. With Illustrations by A. G. Walker. Large crown 8vo. extra cloth boards, 3s. 6d. “The interest never slackens fora moment. It isa good story, a healthy story, and a readable story ; and who could want more ?””— Yorkshire Post. “‘ Decidedly charming.” —Atheneum. OTHER WORKS BY THE SAME AUTHOR. HONOR BRIGHT. 3s. 6d. Illustrated. Sixth FIVE, TEN, and FIFTEEN. 2s. Edition. “Will be thoroughly appreciated by younger readers.” ‘“‘ A thoroughly sensible and cheery story.” — Times. | Manchester Examiner. ALL’S WELL! ls. 6d. | N. or M. 3s. 6d. “Told in the author’s best style.’’-—Schoolmaster. “A most thoroughly charming and delightful tale.” HALT! ls. 6d. Guardian, PEAS-BLOSSOM. 3s. 6d. | ‘*A bright and vigorous story. A success.”—Spectator. “« An exceptionally readable volume.”— Times. | HARDY d FOOLHARDY 1 ONE of a COVEY. 3s. 6d. | ” oe LARRY’S LUCK. Is. “It is one of the best books of the season.” —Guardian, WELLS GARDNER, DARTON & Co. 44, Victoria-street, S.W.; and 2, Paternoster Buildings, E.C. AYRTON & THOMAS, PATENT AGENTS, Conduct every kind of British, Foreign, and Colonial Business CONNECTED WITH PATENTS, DESIGNS, AND TRADE MARKS. Provisional Protection lasting nine months, 3/. 3s. ; subsequently completing the application, 62. 6s. French Patent, with first year’s tax paid, 8/. Belgian Patent, 4. German Patent, 10/. 10s. Drawings, when required, at extra charge by arrangement. LIST OF CHARGES FREE UPON APPLICATION.—TELEGRAPH ADDRESS, ‘“‘ PROLONGED, LONDON.” 59 and 60, CHANCERY-LANE, W.C, SS s~ Bo: sha: San

Page 31

Ne 3308, Marcu 21,’91 THE ATHENZUM 391 FOR GAS TE A VISION OF SAINTS. By LEWIS MORRIS, Author of ‘The Epic of Hades.’ Third Thousand. ‘*St. Christopher has in it bits of finely natural description. St. Francis is put with a clearness and pleasantness which call for praise.”—Atheneum, “« As stories these sketches could not easily be surpassed, and their graceful music is sure to be highly popular.” ‘* Recalls the success of the ‘ Epic of Hades.’”—Literary World. Academy. ‘‘ A score of es show that he can still write blank verse which for harmony, purity of inspiration, and simplicity of diction cannot easily be matched.”—St. James's Gazette. London: KEGAN PAUL, TRENCH, TRUBNER & Co, Limited. Feap. 8vo. cloth extra, 6s. IMPORTANT TO ENGLISH AUTHORS, ARTISTS, PUBLISHERS, PRINTERS, &c. SPECIAL N OTICE—A Complete and Correct Copy of THE NEW AMERICAN COPYRIGHT ACT (with the Changes and Additions made in Committee), which comes into force on WEDNESDAY, July 1st, 1891, is given in No. 1290 of THE PUBLISHERS’ CIRCULAR AND BOOKSELLERS’ RECORD of this date (March 21, 1891). A Copy can be had, post free, by sending 2d. in stamps to the Publisher of the PUBLISHERS’ CIRCULAR, St. Dunstan’s House, Fetter-lane, London. CLERGY MUTUAL ASSURANCE ESTABLISHED 61 YEARS. FUNDS, £3,589,000. Offices—2 and 3, THE SANCTUARY, WESTMINSTER, 8.W. PATRON. His Grace the ARCHBISHOP of CANTERBURY. President—The Right Hon. and Right Rev. the LORD BISHOP of LONDON. Vice-President—The LORD HARRIS, Chairman—The Very Rev. the DEAN of WESTMINSTER, Deputy-Chairman—The Hon, EDWARD W. DOUGLAS. Physician—Dr, W. H. STONE, F.R.C.P. Actuary—FRANK B. WYATT, Eaq. OPEN TO THE CLERGY AND THEIR LAY RELATIVES. (For Qualification, see PROSPECTUS.) SOCIETY. The THREE DISTINCTIVE FEATURES of the Society, to which intending Assurers should SPECIALLY DIRECT THEIR ATTENTION, are :— 1. No AGENTS have ever been employed or Commission paid for the introduction of Assurances, It is estimated that by the non-allowance of Commission the last Bonus in 1886 was in- creased by no less a sum than 40,000. 2. The Expenses of Management are on a remarkably low scale. 3. The business is chiefly with the CLERGY, among whom the RATE OF MORTALITY IS MUCH LOWER than among the general population. In consequence of these special characteristics VERY LARGE PROFITS have arisen for distribution as Bonus among the Members. The NEXT Bonus will be declared in 1891—all with profit Policies in force on Ist June, 1891, will share therein. Policies in force FIVE YEARS are exempt from any extra Premium for foreign residence. ANNUAL COST or an ASSURANCE oF £1,000, ANNUAL COST or an ASSURANCE oF £1,000. WwitH FULL PROFITS. Reduced Premium under special conditions. Age next Age next Birthday. & s. @. Birthday. a ea 25 nnn 20 1 8 25 ose 1661 8 30 sbi 23 3 4 30 ant 18 10 10 35 ao 2610 0O 35 ose 21 4 2 40 oe 31 1 8 40 ane 2417 6 45 ome 36 3 4 45 rr 2819 2 50 “4 4313 4 50 Pr 3419 2 Prospectuses, Forms of Proposal, &c., may be obtained on application to the Office, 2 and 3, The Sanctuary, Westmirster, S.W. MATTHEW HODGSON, Secretary. Now ready, price 2s. ; or post free, 2s. 6d. HE NEWSPAPER PRESS DIRECTORY, 1891. 46th Annual Issue. c. Mitchell & Co. 12 and 13, Red Lion-court, Fleet-street, London, E.C. TO BE READY IN A FORTNIGHT. YHE WAY OUT of the WOOD. (A Review of the Present Industrial and Political Situation.) By KUKLOS. In paper covers, ls. ; cloth, 4s. Wertheimer, Lea & Co. London-wall Just published, price 1s., per post, Is. 4}d. (THE VICTORIA UNIVERSITY CALENDAR for the Year 1891. London : Macmillan & Co. _ Manchester: J. E. Cornish. Just out, cloth, 2s. 6d. pISEASES of the SPLEEN, and their 4, REMEDIES, Clinically Illustrated. By J. COMPTON BURNETT, J. Epps & Co. 170, Piccadilly, and 48, Threadneedle-street. M. Price ls. post free, CoOLD-CATCHING, COLD- PREVENTING, COLD-CURING. By JOHN H. CLARKE, M.D. “A book for every house.”—Christian World. J. Epps & Co. 170, Piccadilly, and 48, Threadneedle-street. Y LIONEL 8S. BEALE, MB. F.RS, Professor of Medicine in King’s Coilege. The LIVER. Pp. 230. 86 Illustrations, many Coloured. 5s. (Now ready. OUR MORALITY and the MORAL QUESTION. 2s. 6d. SLIGHT AILMENTS; and on Treating Disease. Third Edition. 5s. [Now ready. HOW to WORK with the MICROSCOPE. 100 Plates. 21s. (Harrison.) The MICROSCOPE in MEDICINE. 8 Plates. Fourth Edition. 21s. BIOPLASM : an Introducti © Medicine and Physiology. 6s. 6d. On LIFE and on VITAL ACTION. 5s. The MYSTERY of LIFE. 3s. 6d.—The “‘ MACHINERY” of LIFE. 2s. LIFE THEORIES and RELIGIOUS THOUGHTS 5s. 6d. London: J. & A. Churchill. Second Edition. 2 vols. demy 8vo. 32s. THE HISTORY of the ENGLISH CONSTITU- TION. By Dr. RUDOLPH GNEIST, Professor of Law in the Uni- versity of Berlin. Translated by PHILIP A. ASHWORTH, of the Inner Temple, Esq., Barrister-at-Law. “No foreigner has done more than Professor Gneist to examine and make clear the history and nature of the English Constitution....He discusses such vital questions as, Whither are we drifting ? How far do recent changes in the franchise accord with the whole spirit of the Con- stitution? What is in store for us with democracy supreme? On such questions as these the opinion ofa foreigner, who isa scholar but no book- worm, and who has sedulously studied our institutions, is certainly much more weighty than that of most Englishmen....At this time these volumes are especially instructive. They cast light on almost all the great questions of current politics.”—Times. London: Wm. Clowes & Sons, Limited, 27, Fleet-street. Third Edition, Revised, with Portrait, crown 8vo. cloth, 7s. 6d. us HISTORY of the ENGLISH PARLIAMENT, its Growth and Developement through a Thousand Years, 800- 1887. By Dr. RUDOLPH GNEIST, Author of ‘ The ne of the English Constitution.’ Translated by Prof. A. H. KEANE, B.A., F.R.G.8. “English readers will certainly welcome a history of the English Par- liament by the greatest living authority on the Continent.”—A m. “It completes the vast survey of our English institutions....to which so great a portion of Dr. Gneist’s laborious life has been devoted.” Daily News. London: Wm. Clowes & Sons, Limited, 27, Fleet-street. ACCIDENTS AT ALL TIMES—IN ALL PLACES, INSURED AGAINST BY THE if AILWAY PASSENGERS’ ASSURANCE COMPANY. Established 1849. Capital £1,000,000. 64, Cornhill, London. bs 7 AN, 58%; } Secretaries. ALLENS SOLID LEATHER PORTMANTEAUS. ALLEN’S VICTORIA DRESSING BAG. Cash ALLEN’S STRONG DRESS BASKETS. Discount, ALLEN’S NEW GLADSTONE BAG. 10 per cent. ALLEN’S NEW CATALOGUE of 500 Articles for Continental Travel- ling, post free. 37, West Strand, London. KF URNISH your HOUSES or APARTMENTS ROUGHOUT on MOEDER'S HIRE SYSTEM. The Original, Best, and most Liberal. Suits all. Founded a.p. 1868. Furnish direct from the Manufacturer from 101. to 10,0001. Cash Prices. No extra charge for time given. Catalogues, Estimates, Press Opinions, Testimonials, post free. F. MOEDER, 248, 249, 250, Tottenham Court-road, W. (Kindly note numbers. ) ALSO FOR HIRE ONLY. .PPS’S COCOA.—GRATEFUL and COMFORT: 4 ING.—‘ By a thorough knowledge of the natural laws which govern the operations of digestion and nutrition, and by a careful appli- cation of the fine properties of well-selected Cocoa, Mr. Epps has pro- vided our breakfast tables with a delicately flavoured beverage which may save us many heavy doctors’ bills. It is by the judicious use of such articles of diet that'a constitution may be gradually built up until strong enough to resist every tendency to disease. Hundreds of subtle che, Sim are floating around us ready to attack wherever thereisa weak int. We may escape many a fatal shaft by keeping ourselves well lortitied with pure blood and a properly nourished frame.”—Civil Service Gasette.— Made simply with boil aoe or milk. Sold only in packets, by Grocers, labelled—‘ JAMES EPPS & CU., Homeopathic C emists, London.” INNEFORD’S MAGNESIA, The best remedy for ; ACIDITY of the STOMACH, HEARTBURN, HEADACHE, GOUT, and INDIGESTION, , And Safest Aperient for Delicate Constitutions, Ladies, Children, and Infants. DINNEFORD’S MAGNESIA.

Page 32

392 THE ATHENAUM N° 3308, Marcu 21,91

PARIS EXHIBITION, 1889.—The CLARENDON PRESS obtained the ONLY GRAND PRIX, and TWO out of the five GOLD MEDALS that were awarded to British Printers and Publishers.

CLARENDON PRESS BOOKS.

RECENT PUBLICATIONS. bap published, in 2 vols. demy 8vo. cloth, 42s. with Ma at oo NEW WORK BY PROFESSOR FREE The, HISTORY of | SICILY from the EARLIEST TIMES. A. EMA C.L. LL.D., Regius Professor of Modern History. Weliow of Onn oollewe. a - be I. The NATIVE NATIONS: the Pheenician and Greek Settlemen 1. II. From the BEGINNING of GREEK SETTLEMENT to the "BEGINNING of ATHENIAN INTERVENTION. Other Volumes in continuation of the History of Sicily are in preparation. Just published, Sixth Edition, demy 8vo. cloth, 12s. 6d. PRINCIPLES of the ENGLISH LaW of CONTRACT, and of AGENCY in its RELATION to CONTRACT. By Sir WILLIAM R. ANSON, oo 7 .C.L., of the Inner Temple, Barrister-at-Law, and Warden of All Souls’ College, xfor Just published, demy 8vo. cloth, 12s. 6d. STUDIES in the ARTHURIAN LEGEND. aPy John Rhys, M.A., Fellow of Jesus College, and Professor of Celtic at Oxford “It is well for science that the scientific — of ‘ Arthurian Legend’ should fall into the very competent hands of Professor Rhys.”— Times. “Very learned, very scientific.”—Daily Telegraph. COMPLETION OF SKBAT'S ‘ py ag te <4 ENGLISH ETYMOLOGY.’ Crown 8vo. cloth, 1 PRINCIPLES of ENGLISH ETYMOLOGY. ssecond Series. he FOREIGN ELEMENT. By the Rev. WALTER W. EAT, Litt.D. Edin. XL A. Oxon., Elrington and Bosworth Professor of hein inthe Unive ae of Cambridge fhe a ELEMENT. Crown 8vo. cloth, 9s. ‘ourth Edition, Revised, crown 8vo. cloth, 8s. 6d. SELECTIONS from BERKELEY. With an Introduction and Notes, for the Use of Students in the Universities. By ALEXANDER CAM BELL FRASER, D.C.L. Oxon., Professor of Logic and Metaphysics in the ere ll of Edinburgh. THE ONLY ee EDITION OF PLAUTUS RUDENS. Demy 8vo. cloth, 8s. 6d. T. MACCI PLAUTI RUDENS. Edited, with Critical and Explanatory Notes, by EDWARD A. SONNENSCHEIN, M.A., Professor of Greek and Latin in the Mason College, Birmingham. “A very scholarly and erudite edition.”—7imes. First Series.

RULERS of INDIA: the History of the Indian Empire in a carefully planned succession of Political Biographies. Edited by Sir WILLIAM WILSON HUNTER, K.C.S.I. In crown 8vo. with Maps and Portraits. Half-Crown Tol _— NOW READY. The Marquess of Dalhousie. By Sir WILLIAM WILSON HUNTER. Akbar: and the Rise of the Mughal Empire. By Colonel MALLEsON, C.S.I. Dupleix; and the Struggle for India by the European Nations. By Colonel MALLESON, C.S.I1. Warren Hastings: and the Founding of the British Administration. By Captain L. J. TROTTER. The Marquess of Cornwallis: and the Consolidation of British Rule. By W. S. SETON-KARR. j The Earl of Mayo. By Sir William Wilson Hunter. Further Volumes will be published at short intervals. (Just published, Just published, extra fcap. 8vo. stiff covers, SHAKESPEARE’s HENRY THE EIGHTH. With Notes. Edited by WILLIAM ALDIS WRIGHT, M.A. D NEW EDITION of er amid ENGLISH DICTIONARY.’ mall 4to. 1 A MIDDLE ENGLISH DICTIONARY. Seakeaing Words used by English Writers from ~ Twelfth to the Fifteenth Century. 7 FRANCIS HENRY STRATMANN. -A New Edition, Re-arranged, Revised, and Enlarged by HENRY BRADLEY, Hon. M.A. Oxon, Joint-Editor of the ‘ New English Dictionary,’ and President of the Philological Society.

COMPLETION OF WICKHAM’S HORACE. Vol. II. demy 8vo. cloth, with a Map, 12s. Vol. I. 8econd Edition, 12s, QUINTI HORaTII FLACCI OPERA OMNIA. The Works of Horace. With a Commentary by E. C. WICKHAM, M.A., Master of Wellington College, and formerly Fellow of New College, Oxford. Vol. I. The Odes, Epodes, and Carmen Seculare. Vol. II. The Satires, Epistles, and De Arte Poetica. ‘“‘ This scholarly edition of a favourite classic.”— Times.

Crown 8vo. gilt top, 5s. (Uniform with ‘ Selections from Burns,’ by J. Logie Robertson, M.A.) SHELLEY.—ADONAIS. Edited, with introduction and Notes, by WILLIAM MICHAEL ROSSETTI. “Mr. Wickham —< to the elucidation of Horace a wide and exact learning in the | classical languages and literatures, and (what distinguishes him from other commentators | upon this poet) a special know ledge of the point of view naturally assumed by an English student in approaching Horace.”—Scotsman,

SOME FRENCH AND GERMAN EDUCATIONAL WORKS. MASSON’S FRENCH CLASSICS. Edited by GUSTAVE MASSON. LOUIS XIV. and his CONTEMPORARIES; as described in Extracts | from the best Memoirs of the Seventeenth Century. With English Notes, Genealogical | Tables, &c. Extra fcap. 8vo. 2s. 6d. | XAVIER DE MAISTRE, &. VOYAGE AUTOUR DE MA) CHAMBRE, by XAVIER DE MAISTRE. Ourika, by Madame DE DURAS; Le | Vieux Tailleur, by MM. ERCKMANN- CHATRIAN; La Veillée de Vincennes, by ALFRED DE VIGNY ; Les Jumeaux de |’Hétel Corneille, by EDMOND ABOUT; Mésaventures d’un Heolier, by RODOLPHE TOPFFER. Third Edition, Rev ised, Extra fcap. 8vo. 2s. 6d — VOYAGE AUTOUR DE MA CHAMBRE. Limp, ls. 6d. RACINE’S ANDROMAQUE, and CORNEILLE’S LE MENTEUR. With LOUIS RACINE'S Life of his Father. Extra fcap. 8vo. 2s. 6d. REGNARDS LE JOUEUR, _and BRUEYS and PALAPRAT'S LE | UR. Extra fcap. 8vo. 2: MADAME ‘DE SEVIGNE, and her CHIEF CONTEMPORARIES, | Selections from their Correspondence. Intended more especially for Girls’ Sehusels.

Extra fcap. 8vo. 3s. | BEAUMARCHAIS'S LE BARBIER DE SEVILLE. Edited, with Introduction and Notes, by AUSTIN DOBSON. Extra fcap. 8vo. 2s. MUSSET’S ON NE BADINE PAS AVEC L'AMOUR, and FAN- a Edited, with Prolegomena, Notes, &c., by W. H. POLLOCK. Extra feap. RACINE'S ESTHER. Edited, with Introduction and Notes, by GEORGE SAINTSBURY, M.A. Extra fcap. 8vo. 2s. QUINET'S LETTRES A SA MERE. By the Same Editor. Extra fcap. 8vo. 2s. SAIN [E- BEUVE. SELECTIONS FROM THE CAUSERIES DU | LUNDI. By the Same Editor. Extra fcap. 8vo. 2 BRACHET'S ETYMOLOGICAL DICTIONARY of the FRENCH | GE. , Translated by G. W. KITCHIN, D.D. Third Edition. Crown 8vo. 1s. Oa. BRACHET'S, HISTORICAL GRAMMAR of the FRENCH LAN- | en lated by G. W. KITCHIN, D.D. Fourth Edition. PRIME ¢ of I FRENCH LITERATURE. By George Saintsbury, M.A. SHORT HIS TC TORY of edt BENCH LITERATURE. By the Same Author. Crown 8vo SPECIMENS of FRENCH LITERATURE, from VILLON to HUGO. By the Same Author. Crown 8vo. 9s. Extra feap. 8vo. BUCHHEIM’S GERMAN CLASSICS. | Bdited by C. A. BUCHHEIM, Phil. Doc., Professor in King’s College, London. With Biographical, Historical, and Critical Introductions, Arguments (to the Dramas), and —: Commentaries. 8v0. c BECKER (the HISTORIAN). \- FRIEDRICH DER GROSSE. Edited, with Notes, an Historical Introduction, and a M 3s. GOETHE.—EGMONT: a Tragedy. 3s. HEINE.—PROSA. Being Selections from his Prose Works. H&INE.—HARZREISE. Cloth, 2s. 6d.; paper covers, ls. 6d. 4s. 6d. | LESSING.—NATHAN DER ‘WEISE: a Dramatic Poem. 4s. 6d. | LESSING. —mINNA VON BARNHELM: a Comedy. 3s. 6d. SCHILLER.-WILHELM TELL: a Drama. Large Edition. With | SCHILLER. —WILHELM TELL. Bopeol. ——. With Map. 2s. SCHILLER.—JUNGFRAU VON ORLEAN s. 6d. | MODERN GE RMAN R &ADER. A Graduated Collection of Extracts Par t L—PROSE EXTRACTS. With English Notes, a Grammatical Appendix, and a Complete Vocabulary. Fourth Edition. 2s. 6d. Part II.—EXTRACTS in PROSE and POETRY. With English Notes and an Index. Second Edition. 2s. 6d. LANGE’S GERMAN COURSE. By HERMANN LANGE, Lecturer on French and Germam at the Man- chester Technical School, and Lecturer on German at the Manchester Atheneum, I. GERMANS at HOME: a Practical Introduction to German Con- = ——. with an _——— containing the Essentials of German Grammar. Third Sdition. 8vo. 2s. 6d. II. GERMAN MANUAL: a German Grammar, Reading Book, and a Handbook of German Conversation. III. GRAMMAR of the GERMAN CANGUAGE. 8vo. 3s. 6d. | IV. GERMAN COMPOSITION: a Theoretical and Practical Guide to the Art of Translating English Prose into German. Second Edition, 8vo. 4s. 6d A Key to the above, price 5s. | NIEBUHR: Griechische Heroen- Geschichten {Tales of Greek Heroes). With English Notes and Vocabulary, by EM EIM. Second Revised Edition. Extra fcap, 8vo. cloth, 2s.; sti aan. yor Edition A. Text in German Type. Edition B. Tezt in Roman Type. GERMAN POETRY for BEGINNERS. Edited, with English Notes and a Complete Vocabulary, by EMMA S. BUCHHEIM. ” Extra feap. 8vo. 2s.

FULL CATALOGUE of CLARENDON PRESS PUBLICATIONS post free on application. London: HENRY FROWDE, Clarendon Press Warehouse, Amen Corner, E.C.

Editorial Communications should be addressed to “‘ The Editor”—Advertisements and Business Letters to “The Publisher” —at the Ottice, 22, Took’s-court, Cursitor-street, Chancery lane, E.C. Printed by Joun C. Faancis, Atheneum Press, Took’s-court, Cursitor-street, Chancery-lane, E.C.; Agents for Scortanp, Messrs. Bell & Bradfute and Mr. and Published by the said Joun C. Faancis at 22, Took's-court, Carsitor-street, Chancery-iane, E 0, John Menzies, Edinburgh.—Saturday, March 21, 1891.

YUM

OFT mod ry. Hist relat tine addr T ». valu d Fette Pp: tunit Opinu