St. Louis Post-Dispatch
October 10, 1895
Historic newspapers carry the language, views and graphic reporting of their time, including racist content. They are shown to teen and adult profiles.
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
‘ . . 5 . } 7 * 7 — n Board of Directors Cannot Interfere With His} Control and Management. * His Contract Binding on the Company as Well as on Pulitzer. J * udge Wood Delivers an Able Written — Cover- ing the Case. * 1 ( Circuit Court Judge Wood this morning granted an injunction restraining Joseph Pulitzer, and Messrs. Williams, White and Carvalho from interfering with Col. C. H. Jones in the control and management of the Post-Dispatch. It was a little after 10 o’clock when Judge Wood took the bench in Court- room No. 2 to announce his decision in the petition of Col. C. H. Jones against Joseph Pulitzer and the Pulitzer Publishing Co., praying for a temporary injunction, which he has had under advisement since Oct. 2. The court-room was crowded, and the nervous hum of voices was immediately stilled by the appearance of the Judge. i Prominent among those in the crowd were Messrs. F. N. Judson, J. M. Lewis and Chas. 8. Taussig, attorneys for the plaintiff; Sam- uel Priest, F. W. Lehman and G. A. Finkeln- burg, attorneys for the defendants; Col. Willams and 8. 8. Carvalho, two the plaintiffs; John FH. Overall, Circuit Clerk Thomas B. Rodgers, O, J. Macaulay ot the United Press, Judge “Thos. Harvey. Frank Ryan, Cortes A. Kitchéh; Col Robert Kertm Col. Nat Frank, Chas. Broadhead, Col. Ed Turner of Plattsburg, Chas. W. Bates, Chas. McIn- tyre, Chas. Nagel, Jesse McDonald, J. E. Merrill, Judge wm, C. Jones, Hiram J. Grov- er, Geo. D. Reynolds, Geo. A. Shives, Geo, R. Lockwood, Circuit Judges Russell and Fisher and John F. Lee. Judge Wood consumed about 15 minutes in reading his decision from typewritten manucript, and its conclusion was signal- ized by a shuffling of feet on the part of the crowd that wanted to hurry out of the room. So great was the noise created that the court ordered the bailiff to restore quiet. This accomplished, Gen. J. M. Lewis for the plaintiff, moved that the indemnity bond be fixed at $5,000. Attorney Lehman, for the defendants, characterized the sug- gestion as ridiculous. The bond ought not to be a cent less than $100,000, he declared. A parley of considerable moment ensued between Messrs. Lehman and Finkelnburg on the one side and Messrs. Judson and Lewis on the other, which was finally cut mort by Judge Wood fixing the amount at $25,000. As this is a holiday, Col. Jones’ at- torneys asked that they be given until Saturday to arrange the bond. The request was granted, and on the suggestion of Judge Finkelnburg the court also notified the plaintiff’s counsel to submit at the same time Saturday morning a draft of the tem- porary injunction and he would carefully consider its terms and arrange them in ac- cord with his decision just announced. As they were leaving the room a Post- Dispatch reporter asked Attorneys Fink- Sam of emburg and Lehman what step they would |. next take and they replied in chorus that they did not know. a JUDGE WOOD’S OPINION. The Legal Points Exhaustively Oov- ered and Submitted in Writing. Following is Judge Wood's opinion: “The issues of law and fact raised on this application for a temporary injunction may, I think, be briefty stated thus: “First—Is the contract of February 6, 1895, which is set out in the petition, a valid and subsisting contract between plaintiff and defendant, The Pulitzer Publishing Co.? “Second. Will defendants, unless re- strained by the Court, take from plaintiff the control and nidnagement of the Post- Dispatch? “Third: If in the opinion of the Court these questions should be answered in the. affirmative, is it then the duty of the Court to preserve the status quo of the parties by enjoining the threatened action of defend- >} @nts until the cause can be formally and 7 fully heard on its merits? “Tt is not claimed by defendants that mers hag been a violation of the contract on ‘the part of plaintiff. At appears from the petition and evidence submitted on this motion that from the or- r ot the detendant corporation to 3 plaintif st 1 et. 94 u as Ar ees’ 4 N 1 A hing : t 75 7 2 - 4 he alone managed and directed the affairs of the corporation and treated its assets as his individual property, and his right to do so was recognized by the other directors and stockholders; that the by-laws of the cor- poration in force at the date of the contract in question provided that the President and Directors should govern the company and that they should directly, or through the President, appoint all officers and agents of the company, and fix their salaries; that de- fendant directors believed that President Pulitzer had authority to make for the company the contract of Feb. 6, 1895, is evi- denced not only by their acquiescence, but by their actions and the language used in re- pealing the old by-laws and enacting new ones March 16, 189%. While the name of the company is not attached to the contract it is apparent from the subject matter that it was intended and understood by the parties to be a contract between the plaintiff and defendant company. It provides for plaintiſf becoming editor and manager of the Post- Dispatch (the property of defendant com- pany), as also director and President of said company. “Mr. Pulitzer evidently thought he was acting for the best interest of the com- pany in making this contract and endeav- ored by its erl. to thoroughly pro- ig Bete >. that at the time of. 2398 of. “the gon- tract Pulitzer tha. ox to plaintiff a note. -signed by himself and addressed to de- tendant Williams, who was then Vice- President of the corporation, saying: 1 hereby appoint Col. Charles H. Jones ed- itor and manager of the St. Louis Post- Dispatch. Please notify the others.“ By the word ‘others’ he evidently had refer- ence to the other directors. That shortly after this notice of appointment was given to defendant Williams, he was instructed by Pulitzer to install plaintiff as editor and manager of the Post-Dispatch, which he did on or about February 14, 189%. That at the time the contract was,entered into defendaht Pulitzer also forwarded to de- fendant Williams an announcement to the public, which said Williams on February 14. 1895, and before installing plaintiff, had published in the Post-Dispatch. Said an- nouncement is as follows: Continued ill-health and loss of sight have render- ed it impossible for me to give personal attention to the conduct of the Post-Dispatch. I have not been able to visit the city for many years. Authority implies duty. 5 I relinquish duties to which I am no longer equal at a distance and responsibilities which should only accompany the actual supervision of affairs. With this day Col. C. H. Jones, having acquired a proprietary interest in the Post-Dispatch, becomes itg editor and manager, with respousibility and control over its columns. In facilitating the return of Col. Jones to the field of his former labors I feel I am not only placing the journal in able hands, but am conferring a benefit on the city. His courage. and aggressiveness against every form of public wrong, his effective championship of local interests and his natural Democratic instincts are khown te me. He win conduct the paper on the lime of its successful record, infusing into its management * dlood and fresh energy. He will continue the papers battle for all that it true and enlightened, all that is bumane and progressive, all that is just, moral and intel gently conservative in government and society. He will enlist in the ever-continuing struggle against hypocrisy, privilege, class and corruption and, above all, he is pledged to maintain the fearless and absolute independence of the paper. JOSEPH PULITZER. With this evidence before me I am con- strained to think that the other directors had notice of plaintiff’s appointment as edi- tor and manager of the Post-Dispdtch. De- fendant Carvalho assisted in drawing the contract and afterwards became a stock- holder in the company. That long after plaintiff took charge of the paper Mr. Davis, the brother-in-law of Pulitzer, and seeming- expressed to plaintiff his satisfaction wit plaintiff’s appointment, control and ment of the Post-Dispatch and his gratifica- tion at the results accomplished by the new management. Defendant Williams indicated | e his knowledge and approval of the contract in his letter of April 30, 1695, es follows: Col. Chas. H. Jones: Dear Sir—Please have the ‘Post-Dispatch ad- I dave seen only mutilated copies been here, but so far as I have seen you are taking the same side and making the dame Twould if I were absolute owner of the paper, der ite circulation and its advertising 4 Of course, as Mr. Pulltser’s employe, 1 would be — — cratic influences (very ly the only bona-fide stockholder at the.date | n of the contract besides Pulitzer and wife, 2 i Judge Wood Reading the Opinion. I am glad to see that you have the courage of your, "nen gp. and your opportunity. Yours respect- lly, (Signed) SAMUEL. WILLIAMS. In short, I think it clear that both direc- tors and stockholders were advised of the contract and ratified it as the contract of the company. If, therefore, it be conceded that President Pulitzer had no authority to make such a contract for the company, its ratification by the company makes it the contract of the company. It follows, there- fore, in determining whether the temporary injunction should be granted the court must consider the contract in question as. 1 tragt between plaintiff and defendant, The Pulitzer Pubi g Co. “The substa contract is as follows; That the.plaintiff purchased one-sixth of the stock of the Publitzer Publishing Co. at a price of $80,000; that as part consideration for this purchase the party of the second part should be ap- pointed editor and manager of the Post- Dispatch, a newspaper published by the Pulitzer Publishing Co., for the term of five years from date, at an annual salary of $10,000; that the first party should elect the second party director and President of the Pulitzer Publishing Co. and give him con- trol and management of said newspaper during said period, provided said appoint- ment and salary should cease and deter- mine if the second party failed to properly perform the duties of Editor and Manager, or should at any time accept any public office or engage in any other business; that the said second party should devote all the time, ability and energy he possesses to the growth, prosperity and success of the Post-Dispatch, and conduct same with strictest integrity and economy. “That as a test of the ability of the party of the second part to properly manage and edit said paper, said appointment and sal- ary should cease in the event that the gross revenues of the paper during the year 1895 should be less than they were for the year 1894; ‘that said appointment and salary should cease in the event the net profits of the paper for 1896 should be less than in the year 1898; that in case of the death of the second party, his resignation, failure of health or retirement, or inability to per- form the duties and labors of editor and manager at any time within three years from date of contract, the first party should have the option to repurchase for the sum of $30,000 the above-mentioned stock; that in case of this happening after three years and within two years thereafter, the first party should have the option of purchasing said stock, but the value should be fixed beh arbi- tration. “As will be seen, the plaintiff! was re- quired to become a large stockholder in the company as a condition precedent to his appointment; is required to devote his en- tire time and ability to editing and man- aging the paper and the test of his ability to properly edit and manage the paper is fixed in the contract itself. This was cer- t. 1 open to the objection of gainst public policy. I perceive wth under the circumstances dis- | evidence, this character of contract defendant Pulitzer was actuated by ‘motives other than the best interests of the stockhoMers of the company. Pre the evidence and answers of de- fendant directors I think it evident that unless restrained by the court they will oust plaintiff from the control and manage- ment of the Post-Dispatch notwithstanding the existence of said contract between plaintiff and defendant corporation. The instance the corporation is not bound by bee contract, taken in connection with the duct of these directors at the board m tion Mr. Pulitser ig now trying to sume the dt n n eee mt of Feb. forse ne, de tala esis, Mee injury to real or personal property is threatened, een relief, of any part thereot,consists in restrain- or the sovenants th the accomplishment ot certain ings, clearly: indicate such intention. . 8 deed, it is a little diMeult to avoid the con- clusion that under the cloak of the corpora- termined. Having reached the conclusions above stated, should the Chancellor issue a temporary injunction to preserve the status quo of the parties until the cause can be formally and fully heard upon its merits? Sections 5510 and 5491 of our statutes provide as follows: 5510. The remedy by writ of injunction or prohi- bition shall exist in all cases where an irreparable and to prevent the doing of #hy legal wrong what- ever, whenever in the opinion of the court an ade- quate remedy cannot be afforded by An action for damages. 5491. When it shall appear the plaintiff is entitled ta t 2 ing the commission or continuance of some act of the defendant, the commission and continuance of which, during the litigation, would produce injury to the plaintiff, or when, during the Mtigation, it shall appear that the defendant is doing or threatens or is about to do, some act in relation to the plaintiff's rights — * the subject of the action and tending to ren the 9 ectual, a temporary injunction may be granted to restrain such act. : “The Circuit Court of the United States, in Andral vs. Redfield, 12 Blatchford 425, announced the doctrine in reference to the issuance of a temporary injunction as fol- lows: a The granting of 4 preliminary injunction has for its precise object the retaining of all things in their then condition until the case can be de- liberately heard or examined upon the issues for- mally made for hearing or trial. It is provisional merely. It is granted as a matter of distretion. It is often and properly granted where the ques- tion is important and doubtful. When the case comes to be finally beard on the merits and judg- ment is to be pronounced, the conrt is bound to apply to it the rules that govern the rights of the parties; and there is nottiing provisional in such judgment. They finally settle those rights. Until that ean or should be done a temporary in- junction is often a Giscreet exercise of the power of the court to see that nothing is done pendente lite which will tmpede the doing ot what may be finally adjudged to be right in the matter in controversy. But for this preliminary injunction the defendant might have pressed the action at law to trial and judgment before this case could be heard and decided, sq as to become the subject of further review it the parties so desired. De- cisions of the court granting or refusing a pre- liminary injunction are not conclusive either upon the court or the parties, and are not intended to be so, in a subsequent disposition of the cause by decree. We are, thereforé, not wanting in due respect to the court or Judge by whom the pre- liminary injunction was granted. Ou the contrary, our convictions tend to the belief that in sitting with us on the hearing of this demurrer his con- clusion et a judgment. “I believe this to be the Acer 8 in Missouri. While the rule js settled that a court of equity will not enforce spe- cific performance of an ordinary contract for personal service, I am inclinéd to believe this rule does not apply to contracts like the one in question, where the purchase of proprietary interest is coupled with the em- ployment and the termination or continu- ance cf the contract, cohtingent upon the results by plain- tiff. * “I think it manifest that if ousted from the control of the paper at this time, plain- tiff could have no adequate r at law for this violation; of the contract... Scarce in New Tork, andthe Price. SILVER 1 MUCH IN REQUEST. Advances in London. 1 THE REASON 8 PLAIN. |, New York Bullion Dealers kept Busy. Filling the Demand for the Mets! in London. Special to The Post-Dispatch. NEW YORK, Oct. 10—The price of bar silver advanced in London yesterday a six- teenth of a penny. The price in New York was 67% cents an ounce, with 69 cents bid and 69% cents asked at the close, with no dealings. There is a dearth ‘of silver here. The Mercantile Safe Deposit Com which at times has 1, — ounces bullion sil- ver in its vautts, has out now certificates for only 66,250 ounces, and of this lot 30,000 ounces were taken by one house yesterday and the heap will be further reduced to-day. Students of the silver market are not surprised at the advance. The low prices caused the Western mines shut 2 long 2 The rainy season in Mexico curtailed production there.” The only con siderable source of supply now open ts “me silver mined as the by-product in the gold country. In the second place, China is tak- ing silver to make its payments in Japan. The Chinese financial agents have worked under cover and have succeeded in obtain- YOUNG DR. O'REILLY POUND. Deputy Sheriff Gets Personal Service in the Morrissey Case. Dr. Thomas O'Reilly was located by Dep- uty Sheriff Hammond at the home of his Seventeenth and Washington ave- rsday, and for the first time since | Lewis case has i was one of the most important wit- oe n the case, having been in the house, | So Fy street, at the time ex-Senator R. Morrissey was. 2 th 3 At is was 8 e oc his 22 x * eg ea. as. to to ILLINOIS WOMEN'S ü CLUBS, First Annual Mestng at at Peoria of the et. 10.—The first annual the Federation of Wom- en’s Clubs 1 as called to order this morn- 8. quite well at- invocation was ofte pastor of the. nc of Peoria. This wae: the ad vane a 1 in the State hav . — 4 „ large quantities of coin and bullion with- | would ing our disturbing the market. Besides, the silversmiths of the world are * large quantities of the metal to be used in making novelties for the holiday trade, and to meet the demand caused the grow popularity of silver for arti of pe wear. A 1 reason for the advance is a de- mand from India for sflver — to be used in marketing the cotton Te is suspected also that the shrewd Lon- don investors are hoarding the white metal in anticipation of an advance. New York has shipped much silver of Tate. The this year exceeds that of 1884 b New York bullion dealers are kept busy filling the London demand. Normannia, sailing to-day, will take out 118,000 ounces. ARE FAR APART AGAIN. - The City Hall Fire-Proofing Trouble ot Likely.to Be Settled. — — Yesterday morning it looked as if a com- promise on the City Hall fire-proofing mat- j ter would be effected. Now it seems to de many warm and permanent friend ; ht . 2 said the true aim of clubs should be to love | © and know. responded, gurate 3 over ey — ine ton the women’s clu notably” from forth sone ori own wn. through ut she reco 8 * Ole he also spoke of the fe isted — Sega wy ew — 3 e seeming t ion —.— the World's intments made by so ee ons of t . oe 1 =. a TO ROOT OUT bine ABUSES, Local Civic Federation Files Ar- ticles of Incorporation. ' MANNER OF ORGANIZATION. —̃ —ͤ— w The Officers Are Charless Cabanne, Al- bert Matthews, L. 8. Richardsen and W. Palmer Clarkson. St. Louis will have a Civic Federation im- ilar to the Chicago organization known by . that name, which has done so much towards rooting out the rottenness and corruption that has so long characterized the municipal governments of that city as well as nearly every large city in America. Articles of incorporation were filed with the Clerk of the Circuit Court this morning. The incorporators are: N. G. Ne Robert Rutledge, J. T. Donovan, J. Le Hoogner, unders, J. T Murray Carleton, V. O. Ba ley, J. Oharless Cabanne, Dr. G. E. Jonathan Rice, Ben Eismann, Joseph lmer Clar lin, Al Matthews, W. S. McPheeters, James . G. Tyrrell and James H. The officers are J. Charless Cabanne, Pres- ident; Albert Matthews, Vice President: L. S. Richardson, Secretary; W. er Clark- son, Treasurer. Representative then of every creed, politi- cal pa and organizati sel, as can be completed the federation will an active cam tral Committee of fifty an Eanisations of fifty in every ward. in the city. 1 of the, ward — FS thus — ogg the” ship of the latter to — eight for the inc 5 3 m, reas a0 b The name of the The ane Federation is. Its Ene e Ghiil be at St. Louie, 0. The purposes of this association shall First, The formation of an influen non-political, non-sectarian association embracing all the forceg that are now po . caropt to advance c, industrial and of uis, and to use and aid such forces Ag promoting the honesty, and economy of its municipal government the highest welfare of its — — cat methods addressed zens of St. Louis without 2 9 race, creed or political afffliations. and sympathy between persons who 4 parts 1 the city, each o „ have similar inter: ? St. Louis, an te promote oe are. promotion and blication of the science of mun 3 ais 5. Wi fu My a AS eS ee Tus . „ e 2 . l a: Pei A it cana. Sok a rn Se 3 8 ime 1 open Get 9 E. pee ts ihe 7 . 8 bo aii 1 ase ts ; . 4 wR A> 1 4 ak 2 N 2 * ma . gees me lies Rat iat, a 2 1 * , eR Ros „ ae ; ay. ”
Page 2
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 3
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 4
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 5
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 6
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 7
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 8
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 9
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 10
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 11
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 12
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.