St. Louis Post-Dispatch
April 15, 1894
Historic newspapers carry the language, views and graphic reporting of their time, including racist content. They are shown to teen and adult profiles.
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
t 0 of Damages the Only Question Discussed by the Jurors. * — Dre Incidents During Attorney . Wilson’s Closing Speech. he . Jka denn IN THE COURT-ROOM WHEN THE 4 VERDICT WAS RENDERED. iy The Defendant More Gelf-Possessed Than of Any ot His Counsel — Arm-iu- Arm ‘With His Son He Walked out After Asking for a New Trial—Opinions as a og to the Probabilities of His Re-Election 10 «Congress Kentucky Aim — Plaintiff's Lawyers Bear the News to Their Client. _ . Wasurreror, D. O., April 14.—The greatest _ géandal suit that has been aired in the courts \ of this country since the Beecher-Tilton | (trial, ended at 4:85 this afternoon, wien the the Poliard-Breckinridge breach of tase rendered a verdict for the i Miss Pollard’s attorney, @losed his argument at 2:30. Judge Bradley then delivered his charge to the jury, and ee twelve men retired. They were out one hour and twenty-eight min- bailiff in charge the Judge that they Madeline Pollard. “were ready to report their verdict. It was F. 4:86 when they filed into the court- room. All the jarymen were frightfully nervous, Fore- * man Cole perhaps the most nervous ofall. * ‘ Cole held the formally signed declaration of ga % the verdict, a legal -like blue-covered docu- | tina quivering right hand. The Judge was nasty summoped. Breckinridge and * son Desha came and sat down made ‘by side. Counsel for Breckinridge, pt Shelby, who had gone to Lexing- Dn gathered around and took their accus- places, The whole row reserved for ‘the plaintif and her counsel was empty. Mus Pollard and her friend Miss Ellis, were up at the House of Mercy, not dreaming of a so soon, There seemed to be an ex- tingly long wait, though it was really oniy about five or ten minutes before Counsel - @arlisie for the plaintiff’ appea in Court. de silence in the court room was intense. strain was desperate. Everybody : „ that a verdict bad been reached. ‘blwe-colored paper in the Foreman’s told that. At last Mr. Carlisle, red in face and puM™ng, arrived. There wasa zu the court-room as he took his seat and = back bis overcoat. Judge Bradley and raising bis right forefinger, * that there is a verdict, and would audience before the verdict is that they must be careful to from any Gemonstrations of ap- or disapproval whatever. >. gEgorrvine THE VERDICT. 0 ot the court called out the names , Charles R. Cole, Joseph II. Oass Denham, F. A. Heitmul- R. Oator, Magh Reilly, A. . A. Dale, J. L. Carberry, 8. L. Hunt, s ©. Quinn, George B. Sheriff, Jr. „Here. Col. Breck- “a dit of elestic in his hand and nervously with it. He Knew werdict was long before it was ‘was absolutely prepared for it. ges the court and your honor,“ foreman, anconsciously repeating of the same meaning in these two ‘wags, It it please the court and nor we find a veraict for the plain - t **How mach?’’ Cole: Fifteen thousand dol- for a small fraction ofa (paralysis on the part of counsel. Astonishment and beyond the portals a im the corridor. - * * — Sentimem ee weed sel would file the motion on Monday. When there wasa sudden scattering to all the pointe of the compass of the people who had for more than five weeks sitting in attendance at this suit. 0 2 E COOL AFD SELF-POSSESSED. Breck i put on his soft bat, grasped his 2 and walked out. At the door edand gave a tip to one of the attendants just as if he had won the case and was distributing gratuities on acount of his joy. Buttoning his coat the silver-tongued orator of Kentucky, self-possessed and splen- did under the shock of his condemnation, strode to the sunlit piazea. He meta friend. “The verdict?’’ asked the friend breath- less. Oh, Ofteen thousand, he remarked. Ex-Judge Wilson turned up about this time and exchanged congratulations with Calderon Carlisie. Then ‘these two witha swarm of newspaper men at their heels crossed the street to their office and sald— well they said they were gratified, entirely satisfied and that they had nothing more to say and that their client had nothing what- evertosay. They called acarriage drawn twofine horses and adorned by a mag- nificent §coachman.,. At the threshoid of their office building they paused while Wilson made the excuse of hoarseness toa delega- tion that wanted him to speak at some pub- lic affair -to- night. THE VERDICT THE THING, NOT MOKEY. One of Wilson’s friends asked whether the amount granted by the jury had been in his ideas sufficient. ‘‘*Pshaw,’’ he said, the amount does not count. It wasthe verdict we wanted and we have got it.’’ den, with his friend and colleague, Car- Usle, he drove away at a spanking pace to the House of Mercy to communicate the good news to Miss Pollard. Ben Butterworth, the grand old Quaker, walked sadly away from the Court-house that wasthe scene of the most eloquent speech that bas been uttered for man a day. 1 can tell the inside story of this case some day. he said to the Post-DIsPaTCH corre- spondent. Some day, but not now, not now. Reason ofthe verdict? What could be expected? Ihe hue and cry was against the defendant.’’ A LOYAL WIFE. One person in this whole matter shares with Ben Butterworth the respect and admi- ration and sympathy of all Washington on the issue of this case, and that is Mrs., Breck- inridge. iss Pollard’s own counsel this evening said to the PosT-DISFATCH corre- spondent that they claimed credit on account ofhaving refrained during all the hottest passages of the battle from aragging in un- ecessarily the name of Col. Breckliaridge’s = wife, and they are justly entitled to the claim. All that ol. Breckinridge would say a bout the case was that he like his adviser Butter- worth knew the inside history of the action brought agains: himand that he might tell it sometime but that at present with the motion fora ne trial in prospect it would not be wise. He has no thought of resigning his seatin Congress or withdrawing from the field of political activity. Ex-Judge Wilson did not remain at his office iong enough after the verdict to get the magnificent floral tribute that had been walting for him all day at the Marshal's office. A number of Kentucky ladies in Washington, one ofthem the sister of Mr. Breckinridge’s late wife, sent a beautiful stand of roses, all agrowing and ablowing, to Wilson, thanking him in the name or American womanhood for nis efforts in Pollard. The signer was Nettie Lorica White. It was tied with pretty colored ribbon with a bunch of personal cards bearing the names of Mary Desha, sister of the mother of Kreckinridge’s son Desha; Mrs. Dan Waugh of Indiana, Miss Louise Lowell, the typewriter, who sworeto having written certain letters to Miss Pollard from Col. Breckinridge, which the Colonel repudiated. Miss Lowell has been so often talked of as Mrs. Lowell that she underscored the iss“ on her card, Mrs. L. White, Mrs. Nelson ‘Trusier of In- diana, Miss Carrie Wliison of 129 D street, N. W., May M. Steele, Mrs. B. L. Merrill and E. M. Candee. THE JCRY’S EXPEDITION A SURPRISE. The verdict was not a surprise, but the manner and the expedition ofthe rendering of the verd ct were certainly surprises, No- body thoug it, not even the Judge, that an agreement would be reached to-day. The expectation was that at the close of the ses. gion the jury would be compelled to spend Sunday in balloting and would have deen asked to render a sealed verdict on Monday. The jury took fifteen Dallots before reach- ing their conclusion. The difference was mainly over the amount of damages to be granted, and there was but oge man on the jury who favored the defendant. On the first ballot one juror voted for the defense and hung out for a_e time, but his col- leagues thought he did it more for the sake of argument than because he was strongly in favor of Col. Breckinridge. A number of ballots were required toreacha compromise on the amount of damages. Two or three jurors wanted to give the full umount of $50 000, while the others thought that merely nominal damages would serve to Xpress their opinion thatthe Congressman had treated Mise Pollard shabbily. Formal notice of a motion fora new trial was given by the defense. The verdict of $15,000 does not mean that Miss Pollard is going to get $15,000 right away. A great many people down here say that Col. Breckinridge has not got that much money to give her anyhow. — — WHAT BRECKINEIDGE SAYS. Popular Sentiment, Not the Testimony, Responsible for the Verdict. WASHINGTON, D. C., April 14;—Ool. Breck- inridge said to the Post-DisPaTCH corre- spondent to-night: The verdict was en- tirely unexpected and the damages awarded were most excessive if the verdict was to be given.’’ ** Will there be an appeal?“ „Tes, there will be an appeal as soon as my counsel see ft to make the motion, and they will do so with the rules and laws of the court. „What bav* you to say of the verdict?’’ „Well, as the case is stuhl pending in the Circuit Court and will de untii Judge Bradley decides upon the motion for a new trial it would not be becoming Of me to offer any criticism upon the conduct, rulings and charge of Judge Bradley and as these will be the subjects discussed either upon the motion for a new trial or upon an appeal I have nothing tosay about them. Upon the filing of the petition in this suit it was print- ed in every part of the United States and from that hour my enemies have made un- warranted attacks upon me through the public prints and all manner of statements have been made intended to militate against the chaucos of a fair and impartial trial.“ „A few days after the Oling of the petition there appeared in Tae New York Worvp and the St. Louis Posr-DisraTcon a statement which was afterwards copied by almost every paper inthe country. This statement was made by the plaintiff with the consent of ber counsel and was apparentiy indorsed by them asthe true version of the facts to be presented. This was done, | say, upon the apparent tnGorsement of ibe counsel who were supposed to be eminent men of the bar. Upon that statement the pubiic relied, more because of the standing of these coun. sel than upon the credit of the Plaintiff. These statements were made wholly with an intention of Gebaaching public sentiment and of corrapting any jury in their consideration of the tes „and it helped to produce . | re regard the verdict as the : de Wy produced at the Supposed popular N 1 these * 22 > ‘ays, and the defendant said his coun- 188 Pe x upon closing argument of Judge Wilson, although it may not de improper to say that his shameless charge Mr. Stoll, and his still more infamous substitution of the plaintiff’s sister for the plaintiff as the person described in the deposition of Mrs. Miller are fair specimens of the misrepresentations made by him dur- ing the course of his entire argument,’’ „What will be the effect of the verdict upon the chances of your re-election to Con- gress? was asked. „„ have daily receivea letters from every part of my district since the second Gay of the trial, when the difi- culty arose between my partner, Judge Shelby, and one of the counsel for plaintiff and they all assure me that no ver- dict against mein this trial would change the constancy of my friends. I have no fear of the result of my canvass for renomination and re-election.’’ counsel in the trial of this case, and upon the its AP | — a * * 1 —— 1 9 8 N her jealousy do ig my client?’’ ete, that the tion of her. * all the Diacker. In like a bird ina cage, beating against the of environ- ment. ALMOST A COLLISION. © He referred to Col. Hay, the handwriting expert, as a most agreeable person, who would make a man feel at home in his own parlor, more than any other man he new. He referred to the testimony which had been brought up in cross-examination given by Mr. Hay in the WashbUuriecase. He spoke of Col. Hay as having en ly changed his opinion while under @Zamination, but still having been 80 agreeable as to have Ge the committee feel entirely at home all the time, He re- ferred tothe Morey letter controversy also asthrowing discredit on expert testimony. Forgeries, he sald, were made for a purpose, but the man who did a forgery was apt to ~~ Pd ‘ 7 A 4. . 7 7 1 27 ark * 7 4 Cal. Wm. C. P. Brecklutidge. ae matic Situation of the Trial. Sensations fairly crowded into the last day ot the trial. There were some of the most dramatic s¢enes which ever stirred the dingy little court-room, reeKing as it was with the memories of celebrated cases. There was an approach toa personal collision between Judge Wilson and Attorney Charles Stoll durine the magnificent closing argument of the Washington lawyer, followed by talk of adue!. and Judge Bradley, in his charge to the jury, scores Col. Phil Thompsonas a lawyer is seldom spoken of in court. Mr. Wilson closed his speech of summing up with even more than the denuciatary vigor, heat and earnestness with which he began it. It was this vigor and manifest earnestness of his which aroused Mr. Stoll’s wrath and created the most dramatic scene of the trial. Stoll became excited because of what Wilson sald about the letter which Miss Pollard’s counsel have maintained all along wasa forgery. But before Stoll got excited Col. Breckin- ridge was so stirred up that he interrupted proceedings. Mr. Wilson was referring to the fact that the defendant’s testimony was contradicted by Mary Yancey and Sarah Guess. With reference to the defendant’s admission that he had been to Sarah Guess’ house before he knew the plaintiff he said: „So you see gentiemen, that the gentlemen was not let astray dy the plaintiff, he had been led astrayjbefore he ever met her. Mr. Breckinridge showed much interest in this statement of Mr. Wilson’s and interrupted the speaker. BRECKINRIDGE INTERRUPTS. „Now, if your Honor please, he sald, leaning forward in his chair and addressing the court. there is no such testimony in this case. I said I was at the house of Sarah Guess before I was there with this plaintiff, but 1 never sald 1 Was there with any other woman and there for the same purpose be- fore. iI was not asked that question. **I believe,’’ said Judge Bradley, that is all there is in evidence.“ eit is a fair matter of inference in arguing the case, said Mr. Wilson. There is no such testimony,’’ persisted Mr. reckinridse, aud it is not a fair in- ference, I never— „Tou had better have stated that,“ saia Mr. Wilson, when on the witness stand. **You Gid not ask that question,’’ said Mr. Breckinridge. Tam.“ continued Mr. Wilson, drawing a legitimate inference. You cannot, he re. peated, turning to the defendant, ‘‘testify now. 1am not testifying,’’ said Nr. Breckin.- ridge. This is not a fair inference, you did not ask me the question. Judge Bradley remarked that he thought this was a fair matter of argument. **There was not the slightest evidence that I had ever gone there for that pur dose, said Mr. Breckinridge again before subsid- ing. **Why,’’ asked Mr, Stoll, ‘di that question?“ een ‘*Suppose,’’ said Mr. Wilson, I had asked that question, whom you were there with, what woman you were there with, there would have been an uprising of lawyers.’*’ Mr. Wilson sald he knew what was proper asking the questions and had not r the limits of propriety. NOT WORTHY OF BELIEF. Gentlemen, there were written on stone the commandments,’’ said Mr. Wilson, pick which was: ‘Thou saalt not commitadal- tery.” This defendant admits that over and over again he has violated that one. Ont Game stone is written ‘Thou shalt 2 WILEON’S CLOSING SPEECH. put a little of his own handwriting in it. 1 pat would ow ae it wasa forgery. — I dld they get the Wesste Brown letter in order During Which Occurred the Most Dre to make comparisons? The téstimony showed that Mr. Stoll had got that letter and had carried it about with him in his pocket. „Mr. Wilson,’’ said Mr. Stoll, witha white face and quivering lips, do you mean to in- sinvate that I forged ,.that letter?’’ do not, sir,“ said Mr. Wilson, Ido say eg some skilled penmman forged the let- 1 „Do you mean to gay,“ said Mr. Stoll, that I wasa party to a forgery?’’ ‘‘Isay,’’ Mr. Wilson replied, that you ing up the thread of his argument, *‘one of | had that letter. Do you mean to say,’’ persisted Ar. Stoll, that I got it for that purpose?“ **l did not say that. I say you had the Wessie Brown letter and you did have ‘{t,’’ went on Mr. Wilson. dia“ said Mr. Stoll. Turning to the jury Mr. Wilson said that the defeuse had spent hours in traducing this laintifv—®. ‘*They are not,“ he said, going Ointimidate me from performing my duty, as I understand it to de. Mr. Wilson ciaimed the right to present the facts to the noon recess. pacific said to my innings. do * report of MF. had been re Thee is no gentiema Every one t a ence was part of as soon as intend. cured it. mention Mr. case, ton Irving cinnat] in Wilson if came drawn trom it time for the noo utes and did not Wilson called his attention to the time, utterance from to ‘the counsel, the hat nre adjou press efendant, he LOOKED THREATENING. There was much talk of a duel during the Mr. Stoll went out of court during the noon recesson the armof Maj. Butterworth, who seemed to be giving bim Afterward Mr. porter: Butterworth ts senior counselof the case, and bas control of it until it is finished. der his advice I shall do nothing. case lam my own master. 1 do not care to say what | shall re T As the officers of the court entered by the rear door for the afternoon session they saw Mr. Wilson and the portly Maj. Butterworth seated together in the vestibule. terworth had in his hand the stenographer’s Wilson’s remarks concern- ing Mr. Stoll, and was talking earnestly. rted that es 1 son of the ad carried a lenge from Mr. Stollto Mr. Wilson, but Mr» the testimony was unfit to be reviewed, it Breckinridge, when aske ode provides thata gentleman may carrya challenge from one another, but I cannot dothat, for Mr. Wilson THE MATTER.SMOOTHED OVER. who knew Mr. knew that he would not be the bearer of a challenge fora duel and the natural infer- was peacemaker. Perha the Mr. Wilson which followed court had the resuit of the conference. ous attorney rose beside the witness box, and in bis usual calm tones Degan tos In the heat of this discussion, in the pres- entation of facts,“ he said, have conveyed impressions that they did not I had no thought of insinuating that Mr. Stoll had forged that letter or had I had no intention to charge it upon him or to convey such an insinuation. I wished merely to show how easy it is for such things to appear. case I now come to. In the 18 lot cers pass several min- 4 the court until Mr. about it, sald: + Ce j Fee THE JUDGE’s Phil Thompson. usual e Stoll a tran- u] Parties had been obscure it would tracted but little attention. one of the parties had prominence, and because character of the details, attracted a vulgar crowd, The conveying suggestions to had not the decency to sign Stoll ‘*Maj, | tO Giscuss the case with no one. accurate to say that the communit was a third party to the case. Ex Un- that justic After the hen I wlll have case. Public opinion snould not to be vindicated the home and the family. Maj. Bat- sidered, It chal- | acter of either party. Although was to be said tothe entleman to | 48 Carefully and decently as possib Same restraint, and he regretted 0 Butterworth lowed to obscure the main issue. to be placed upon the testimony of and defendant, wherethey di acting the 0 The cumstances affecting their After Sos ak. parties briefly, **counsel may pro- rather monotonous tone. part of the as done detween the pa the world at large had no interest in the credit of the that they had handled it in delicate details le. Nearly all of the counsel had observed the could not be said of all the counsel. all eyes were turned to Col. Phil Thompson.) Any revolting standards of manhood which had been set up were not to be weighed as evidence, nor were collateral! details to be al- The credit CHARGES. A Very Direct Reference to Attorney At 2:80 Judge Bradley began his charge to the jury. Judge Bradley spoke at first of the pollution of the case. He said it contained few interesting legal points, and that it the have at- But, because deen of national he feared, of the it had large and sometimes court and even of the jurors had been deluged with letters, hich the writers cir names, believed the jury had followed the in junction It was in- at large pt to see rties. weigh a feather weight. Abstract principles were not nor the country girl, Personal opinions or wishes based on the relations between the parties or other facts were not to be con- It was only a questivun whether a contract tomarry existed and whether if broken there was an excuse for breaking it. The verdict was not to vindicate the char- much of parties that this (Hers plaintig ffered, was to be judged in the light of the character and lives of the two, as shown, and of other cir- credibility. the contentions of the two o read the legal instructions granted, which have already been printed. Col. Breckinridge sat between Maj. Bat- terworth and bis son Desha with his chin restingon his hand while the instructions were being read, The whole charge was in manuscriptand Judge Bradley read it in a In explainlag one of the instructions the Judge saidthat if the defendant had any I shall have-occasion to | knowlegge of improper conduct on the Stoll’s name again. I shall part of the plaintiff? when he promised to marry her, if he did, his action argument again. bad said to Mr. their honor mention it again because it 1s a part of the When We become connected witha case we cannot de very well trom it in argument. What more can I do as a lawyer. and what less would Mr, Stoll as a lawyer have me da?“ Thereupon Mr. Wilson dropped into his He did not mention the name of his opponent at once, but discussed the part played by the volumes of Washing- in the case and the abllities that Miss Pollard had given Dirth toa child at the 2 Convent near in- 885 oon occasion to correct him re point in the testimony, and the Kentuckian’s voice it was apparent that the white dove of peace had returned. THE EXPLANATION SATISFACTORY. It was learned auring the noon recess Mr. Butterworth that it appeared from anything be had ‘said that he intended to impute any im- proper conduct to Mr, correct and retract it. ulmselt as veiling satisfied with Mr. Wilson’s — | eXpianation, saying that it was no doubt in- tended to be full and compiete. When Mr. Wilson, resuming his argument, matter of card, he said that he did not believe sir. Stoll, with ail his sensitiveness, could object to mat he was about to Mr. t but that Attorney Carlisie or Attorney John- son had put it there. Judge Wilson,’’ inquired Mr, Stoll. have not the counsel forthe defendant purposely dented any such intention?“ **] know,’’ responded Mr. say thatthere was such an inference to be He proceeded to state that under such cir- cumstances when sailed it was but just and proper that Attorneys Carlisle and Johnson should have taken the witness stand to deny, as they did, that there had been any chicanery in the matter of the Christmas card. The defense had harshly criticised Dr. Mary Parsons for suppressing the record of the birth of Miss Pollard’s second child, he continued, while the defendant had admitted Mr. rom the tone of Stoll he would Stoll expressed say. Wilson, condoned those offenses. dissociated from a fallureto perform tract by legal inability to fulfill it, prob- Stoll had rding a minor engaged to be married. stand! damages as they saw fit. dence. The jury retired at 3:07 o'clock. — — he Christmas When the verdict in the Pollard-Breckinridge ‘*‘but I | politicians regarding the verdict. lican, said: ‘*‘Il am surprised the verdict. was as- think Judge Bradley’s action in some effecton the jury. Breckinridge’s faults, ges are rather excessive.’’ verdict. When 1 left 2 —ů ge WOM; , + ä , 7 renne Ain. wily F e eee eee ö y tha etl. : WNC E. D. Werne WW wT TT Tegan N hit ' TT, j ' 1 . — Na ih) ; al 1 i Tu: i 7 N Ki 10 T i ULE aL Ann it] WHA > woe aS stants — 1 tee 228 pft a Inn 1 Ait 2 9 pers See weet . ~ SS -_ — : * N — — 8 SN N ALU The Passing of Breckinridge. aN . . 3 — * rte * ! * enen A PATTY | te ee en * ERAN) J. es 1 ~ 16% . in : hy Nat 2 1 5 5 . ~\ aH νẽs ö tg ak I was confident our client wou out victoriou ury.’’ George Shanklin, a prominent sald: Pollard would never have secured damages. There was any amount dice worked into Colonel.“ Juage the verdict, and largel naa had acted toward the defendant entire trial. County Jud jury to give for after the way in which Jud had prejudiced the case agai ridge. HAS HAD Hits DAY, A well-Known and well-posted and office- holder, who lows: meaner’ n this district were ling for a halt. ofthe Democratic tt yee or" Asbland 2 than the success of Wty, 1 2 * ci — side of the story could te Col. Age has had his day and the result is a sweepin * ——— the story of M 0 ury as they appeared in testimony. 0 nted the letter which it was claimed was forged tothe jury, asking them spect it and compare certain words, and 8 spent some minutes on the task. then resuming sald that he proposed to the aspect o Beer. wae or lalse witness,’ and Ifa man shali ate of these commandments and be caus — a law, is it not pos under suc stral 1 . N. un very other point of the been disposed of, Mr. W mained but the state cnet —.— was a mutual contract to marry’ out, and he ch obere falsehood." a ba DINty of @ 01 * 1 U 5 t and Mr. Wilson post im of the , glari that he had pe suppress the m pu importance with rsuaded the Rev. Dr. Paxtos — ould ha more re record o secre cleared a record which the law demanded should be —— —4 8 5 oad wa hod ade blic and was of equal/, Can the the verdict should be for the defendant. a contract had been made and broken 5 were to find for the plaintiff’, awarding suc Their verdict must be formed upon the preponderance of evi- declined have his name mentioned,and who said he voiced the sentiment of a majority of the voters ot the city and county, talked as fol. It is about time that the gentlemen composing the close corporation that is Col. Breckinridge’s interests in Explaining an- other, he said tnat the defendant, quoting a Massachusetts opinion, could not be excused a marriage con- because his legal inability did not lessen the damage to the plaintiff from his failure to marry her. There must be grosser impropriety than that testified to by Julian regarding a mock arriage, to form an excuse for a fallure to ulfilla marriage contract, the Judge said and he quoted Jullan’s testimony. Lewd and lascivious conduct meant more than Jullan had testified to, or Kozell, who told only of such acts as were common between people To sum it all up. if a contract was not made, or if it was agreed to with the under- ng that it was not to be carried out, If KZNIUCKY fENTIMENT. How the Verdict Against Breckinridge Was Received at Lexington. LEXINGTON, Ky., April 14.—The news of the case was sisters at the convent had Deen ques- — -= — 1 —— 1 pases ote received here about (o' clock this afternoon. e ithaving been pretty generally concluded thatthere would bea hung jury. evening the Post-DISPATCH representative has been busy interviewing leading men and All the Judge George Denny, Jr., a leading Repub- at the size of While I expected the plaintiff would get damages I had no idea she would be awarded anything but a nominal sum. I the case throughout has been unfairto Breckinridge, and I believed it would necessarily have do not condone ut I think the dama- John T. shelby, the law partner or Breck. inridge, said: **l am greatly surprised at the Thursday a either come or there would bea hung attorney *Yes, the verdict surprised me. the trial had taken place in Kentucky Miss one cent of preju- the case against the H. Marshall Buford was surprised at attributed it to the demeanor and rulings of Judge Bradley. W. 8. Mcvuhesney, Jr., a leading politician, said he was not much surprised at the ver- after the way in which Judge Bradiey uring the Bullock said he expectedithe iss Poliard every cent she asked Bradley Breckin- politician to The in- t rty, the good of Kentucky and the pteuta tive of the District are of far more importance : * § + 8 rs, 5 8 if 15 i | 0 : ~ 4 Ky., April M.—The Couriers N * „ ~ NOW LET IT Pass, . The jury in the Pollard-Breckinridge | has brought in its verdict. The for weeks has crowded the co the morbid and the prurient and FF The press has ts legiti ——— duty in reporting the pro- Many news tunity 8 ba pers have seized the By adding to the functions of the rnalist those of he scavenger. sors to be. n aq now that even this ele- ment of the press, which has so much to discredit § sel journalism, will and it no longer ursue this foul matter. Let it be le ourt records, and some sunshine of yr — By 8 a ana with white the — — has : m contaminated. 8 een ys: ‘*The verdict in the was not or ZO ca dy de The verdict probably indicates the jury’sa fnri 8 conduct an Mr. Thompson’s cynical 3 more iss Pol the value they put on a contract of ma person such „ in tions —— Ag as the plaintiff and —— sus - The Commercial roles -Breckinrid ng. HIS OPPONENTS JUBILANT, : Paris, Ky., April 14.—The verdict in the Breckinridge-Poliard case is being thorough. ly Giscussed here to-night. The verdict isa surprise to the friends of Breckinridge. They confidently expected a hung jury. _His Oppo- nents are jubilant. “A CK = inridge to open his —— 2 Monday in May was ane friends are very qui : riends are t don't want to talk. 3 SUITED WITH THE VERDICT. FRANKFORT, Ky., April 14.—The people of this section watched with interest unsur- passed in its intensity for the verdict tn the Pollard- Breckinridge trial. The Daily Capitol appeared in an extra issue after the news was recety 122 man — of opinion openly ha verd just one, and that it will be folly for 2 even oe of appearin g inthis district asa candida — mu TRECKINRIDGE’S FUTURE. — results of the verdict in the Breckinridge case is to increas® the interest felt in the next Congressional racein the Asbland au- trict. Col. Breckinridge has declared his in- tention of running again, and there are sey. eral other candidates in the field. A good deal of feeling has already been aroused and ridge takes the stump. He a . nounced bmg pore * of meee every county in strict. Ordinar- ily a Democratic nomination 7 — equivalent to an el he normal Demo. cratic majority is about 6,000, but the publicans have se district, and the division of the vote, widespread Democratic growing oat of bitter personal enable them to win at the polls. . rs here are already there. cussion in town to-night. views are ex a Post-DIsPaTcH correspondent red a number of expressions kabzeck. Congressman Turple of alec Ran any opts on delitate question to discuss * men rect vory much, an Ple like zol. Bre N — want to say cay thing against 1 do ae pander to the depraved and —— 5 e iM) N 8 ** 9 8 ‘ ee wh 8 * * The Effect the Verdict: Have on Ries Wasninctox, D, ©., April 1. One ot the 5 re this will be added to when Col. Breckin.- how the could have done alse than they did, in view of the aan eo ine — 1 8 id downtell’ fost have admired him much, but le * t ard eee tainty that she would Gov. Jones of Vo is at the Met- ropolitan: ‘*You me ° ng any Opinion regarding the verdict. would hurt Col. Breckinridge, und 6a za nothing that can.“ Con Tracey of New Tork: not read the evidence 0 iy know whether or not the verdict a n but the whole coun is to be congratulated upon the fact that case is. finished and out newspapers.’ Fourth Assistan tmasior ning. to, si ; Sours, T hope it will teach & 2 les- son. ‘ Dein — DECLINES TO BE INTERVIEWED. M. Wasuineton, b. O., A — 8. 3 Gi * > Sted * n ; A 5 8 Se Sete * n 92 een Peet ne 4 SBS Stae 4 Fo) - 2 n ; > 8 ny : oy” * 72 22 of 3 * hts tates, an ee * Sage
Page 2
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 3
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 4
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 5
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 6
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 7
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 8
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 9
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 10
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 11
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 12
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 13
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 14
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 15
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 16
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 17
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 18
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 19
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 20
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 21
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 22
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 23
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 24
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 25
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 26
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 27
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 28
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 29
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 30
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 31
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 32
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 33
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 34
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 35
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 36
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 37
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.