The Green Bag: An Entertaining Magazine for Lawyers (December, 1895)
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
Vou. VII. No. 12. fihe Green Bag.” BOSTON. DECEMBER, 1895. ALEXANDER HAMILTON THE LAWYER. By A. OakEY HALL. KETCHES innumerable and several. bi- J ographies of Alexander Hamilton have made his statesmanship familiar to the Ameri- can people. George Ticknor Curtis’s His- tory of the Constitution; Hamilton’s Life, by one of his sons, issued in 1840; anda recent volume by the late Chief-Justice George Shea of New York, entitled “The Life and Epoch of Alexander Hamilton,” may in such con- nection be notably referred to. Bancroft and Hildreth in their respective histories of the United States and Lossing in his Pictorial Field-book of the Revolution have further commemorated Colonel Alexander Hamilton as aide-de-camp on General Washington’s staff during the colonial war with Great Brit- ain. But neither his biographers nor the historians have fully sketched Alexander Hamilton the lawyer, or made other than cursory allusions to his professional exis- tence. It is the intention of this article to attempt to supply that deficiency and to dwell mainly upon those incidents of his life that bear upon his long unconscious prepa- ration for his very brief yet illustrious career as a lawyer during the last twenty-two years of his mortality. He was born eleven days after the new year of 1757 began; when George Wash- ington, twenty-five years old, was a surveyor, as unconscious of his future greatness as was Ulysses S. Grant when tanning skins in Illinois. The father, James Hamilton — a Scotchman — emigrated while a bachelor to a West India island as a merchant, where he married a French Huguenot widow who im- parted her beauty, grace and sweetness of temper to Alexander, her youngest son; while the latter inherited Scotch tenacity of purpose, thrift, and a fine constitution from his sire. The mother died while Alexander was a child, and he thus missed juvenile at- trition with her marked intellectual attain- ments; and her father was a carefully edu- cated French physician. Alexander’s life battle began early, for when he was only thirteen years old, the French war brought to his father such business reverses as com- pelled the boy to enter as a clerk the store of Nicholas Cruger, whose descendants now live in New York City, opulent and socially distinguished. Alexander’s education had been limited; yet he had not altogether re- quired teachers, for he early evinced a thirst — for knowledge that was not only assuaged by the few books that came in his way; but by an early developed power of observation and thought. He was forced to that proper study of mankind which becomes more val- uable to the lawyer than ready accession to books. At fourteen years of age Hamilton was found as restless and ambitious as if he were a Yankee boy. The proof lies in this extract from a letter that he wrote to a young comrade who had emigrated to New York City : — “Dear Ned: I confess a weakness. My ambition is so prevalent that I contemn the erovelling condition of a clerk to which my fortune condemns me, and would willingly risk my life, though not my character, to ex- alt my station.” That juvenile letter, by its choice of Saxon words, seems to show that he had undoubt- 537 . th ee oe Sy a et Oe ae eee
Page 2
*N) Tan)
Page 3
Page 4
538 Lhe Green Bag. edly made acquaintance with Rasselas and the Spectator. In all his after life of mar- velous fecundity with his pen, his style was Addisonian, and his rhetoric rich with John- sonian purity of language devoid of turgidity or pomposity of expression. But although under aspirations he did ‘‘contemn the grov- elling condition of a clerk,” he so conscien- tiously mastered its details and duties as to be left, not yet fifteen years old, in sole con- trol of the business when Mr. Cruger, his employer, voyaged to the American colonies for a short commercial visit. But Hamilton’s faculties so attracted the attention of mater- nal relatives who were possessed of means, that they raised pecuniary supplies for him, and sent him to the American colonies fur- nished with letters from his employer and the rector of the island parish. He landed at Boston; and but that his recommenda- tions were addressed to New Yorkers he might have become an ally of Otis, Quincy and Adams instead of becoming a patriot comrade with Morris and Livingston. Arrived in New York, he determined to enter a college, and after attending a pre- paratory school at Elizabethtown, he tried Princeton College, where he proposed to the astonished faculty to be accepted with the understanding that, if he could by extra reading thereafter jump a class, such proce- dure would be allowed. The college rules forbade such a revolutionary course; and so Princeton lost the opportunity of placing on its catalogue the name of Hamilton be- side the names of the Dayton, Ogden, and Frelinghuysen of that era. But King’s Col- lege, now Columbia, was more complaisant ; and with the above understanding he there matriculated and found himself a college- mate with that ‘‘Dear Ned” to whom he had addressed his discontent and strivings. With some of the blood of his maternal grandfather, the physician, in his veins, he not only underwent the collegiate course, but attended its medical lectures; and with a possible eye to following his grandsire’s profession. But the echo of the first few words of the Aeneid of Virgil lingered in his ears, ‘‘ Arma virumque cano” ; and when the Sons of Liberty invited the clever col- legian of seventeen to join them, he thought not of becoming a surgeon to care for the wounded in the approaching conflict, but of fighting among the wounded. He was an orator without knowing that he had the gift of persuasion or the capacity to become eloquent. But he addressed a meeting of patriots in the Fields, the site of New York’s City Hall Park, with such effect that the as- semblage marveled at the youth and ability of the young West Indian of the neighbor- ing college. He wrote anonymous articles in the patriot newspaper, and issued an anonymous pamphlet endorsing the cries of rebellion that were. borne westward from Boston. In time it became known that the young patriot orator of the Fields was this American Junius. War was sounding at the doors of the college. It had to close. While was whispered J/eges szlent, he an- swered the cry of zzzer arma; and raised an artillery company while exchanging the col- lege curriculum for lessons from an European military emigré in engineering and artillery practice. When a British fleet appeared off New York harbor and began operations that in the end were summed up in the bon-mot, “Tord Howe he came in; and lord! how he went out,” Hamilton, not yet of age, be- gan that military career which every Ameri- can generation thoroughly knows. A career that made him spectator of the Battle of Long Island; a participant in the affairs on Haarlem Heights and at White Plains in a brief campaign that won him the acquain- tance and admiration of Washington, whom he accompanied on the march to Trenton, where he became aide-de-camp and private secretary to the Commander-in-Chief; and with a brief intermission continued in that service until at Yorktown he heard an American band triumphantly play the Yankee Doodle that an English band had
Page 5
Alexander Hamilton the Lawyer. 539 derisively played some years previously at Concord and Lexington. That intermission was the result of an in- cident little known, but which illustrates the tenacity of purpose and quickness of action that were peculiar to Hamilton, and which forms one of the very few littlenesses in Washington’s life. It seems that on one occasion the Commander-in-Chief being at a headquarters house, and in an upper. story of it, despatched an orderly to Aide-de-camp Hamilton, bidding him come up stairs for sudden duty. Lafayette was met on the stairs coming down as Hamilton was going up. The former had recently arrived and had taken a fancy to the latter that culmi- nated in an historic friendship. They passed a few moments in conversation and parted. The meeting detained Hamilton, and at the head of the stairs, as he reached it, stood Washington, who made a petulant remark to Hamilton, saying (as was his account long afterward to his son John C.), “ Col. Hamilton, this. delay to my message is inex- cusable.” The tone was resented on the spot, and Hamilton perhaps too warmly retorted with a verbal resignation, retraced his steps, and retired to the camp where was the regiment of which he was yet colonel. The proverbial mildness of Washington al- most immediately returned, and he sent to Hamilton a brother comrade as peace-maker. The lover’s quarrel was soon made up, and like the proverbial lover’s quarrel led to stronger affhliations. Well may one con- templating the incident—to which perhaps a Napoleon or a Wellington would have given a less pleasant termination under sim- ilar circumstances —recall the lines of Tom Moore: — «¢ Alas, how light a cause may move Dissensions between hearts that love: Hearts that the world had tried And sorrow but more closely tied ; That stood the storm when waves were rough Yet in a sunny hour fall off.” Perhaps it was the after sorrows soon following. the temporary estrangement that closer tied the hearts of Washington and Hamilton. After his participation in the victory at Yorktown, and while negotiations for peace progressed, he determined to leave the pro- fession of arms and to grasp the mightier pen as a lawyer. He had in 1780 married an accomplished daughter of General Philip Schuyler. The union was a purely love- match. There was already, when peace came, a first-born; and the young father felt not only need of occupation but of sup- port. To himself insensibly, while a West Indian clerk he had been a student of com- mercial law; while in the army he neces- sarily became a student of the law of nations. He was always a student of human nature. What wonder, therefore, that in only four months’ time he fitted himself for examina- tion as an attorney of the Supreme Court of the state of New York; signing its roll in a July and in the following October acquir- ing, the dignity of counselor. He at once stepped into an almost phenomenal practice, especially attracting commercial clients, and those having claims against the expiring Continental government. The fame of his college oratory now revived for the thirty- year-old lawyer with his clear, elegant and affluent style of speech and his commanding manner. Of that, and of his personnel at this time, there is of record a pen-picture made by his sister-in-law, Mrs. Catharine Van Rensselaer Cochrane: “He had a small, lithe figure, instinct with life. He stood erect and was steady in gait. His presence was military without the intolerable accuracy of a martinet. His address was graceful and nervous; as indicating the beauty, ac- tivity and energy of his mind. He had a bright, ruddy complexion, light-colored hair, a mouth infinite in expression, its sweet smile being most observable and much | spoken of, eyes lustrous with deep meaning on glancing with quick, canny pleasantry ; and the whole countenance decidedly Scottish in form and expression. — His political ene-
Page 6
540 mies regretted the irresistible charm of his manner and conversation, and that correct sense of what is appropriate to occasion and its object which as an attribute we call good taste. A mood of engrossing thought would often come upon him even while he trod the streets, when his pace would become slow, his head would be bent slowly downward, and with hands joined together behind him, his lips, as he wended his way, would move in apparent concert with the thoughts mov- ing in his mind.” With such a picture in view we may perfectly recall Hamilton as he stood in the corridor of the court-house awaiting his call to the bar or when trying his first case. It may be digressively interesting to note that the son and namesake, Alexander Ham- ilton, Jr., was during the fifties a leading member of the New York bar; and so far as comparison with old prints and personal descriptions could go, was a perfect duplicate in face, size and bearing, of his illustrious sire. At the same time he could be often seen in the court-rooms beside another law- yer of note who was known to be a natural son of Aaron Burr, and to resemble the lat- ter most exactly, as well as to have inherited all his shrewdness. Both have ne since joined the majority. The first case above referred to came for him in the minor court of the city, held by the Mayor, and known as Mayor's Court. It had jurisdiction under the colonial char- ter given to the Duke of York’s city; and quite anomalously, although an inferior court, it took jurisdiction of actions in ejectment. His client was a Tory merchant who had quitted New York for England in company with so many Tory refugees whom the tra- ditional ceremonies of New York’s Evacua- tion Day annually bring to mind. He was retained against a widow tenant whom the Attorney-General of the day defended. Hamilton’s appearance on the side of wealth and power against a woman, as his debut, has in it no hint of romance; but doubtless The Green Bag. his retainer came because the circumstances of the action would infuse unpopularity into a jury-box, and as policy the retainer was best given to an undoubted and favored patriot. There were no reports of cases in that tentative era of courts of law to tell of his suc- cess inthe action; and only tradition handed down from his compeers,— notably by James Kent through his son William, whom many eraduates of Harvard Law School during the professorship of the latter can recall. Sim- ilar traditions tell the later generations that Alexander Hamilton did not want for retain- ers; and that clients flocked to his modest chambers in Garden Street. His practice was somewhat interrupted by his election to the expiring Continental Congress. But neither his professional nor public duties kept him from an industry with his pen. He early, with John Jay and William Morris, recognized that federal government was on the cards of American destiny; and he be- gan to argue in the newspapers for a union of states, not as a confederacy, but in a National Republic. No lawyer, or even law student, needs to be reminded how earnest- ly and zealously Hamilton worked to bring about a convention of the states, “to form a more perfect union, establish justice, in- sure domestic tranquillity, provide for the common defence and promote the general welfare.” Nor to be reminded how, after he had composed and drafted the preamble to the Constitution, from which the foregoing is quoted, and while the instrument was pending for approbation and adoption, he penned the letters that posterity reads in the volume of The Federalist. Respecting that preamble: When once called to ac- count for its tautology in the expression “to form a more perfect union,” and when asked if perfection itself could bear the com- parative word ‘more,’ Hamilton retorted by pleading Shakespeare for the necessity sometimes of a double superlative, and quoting the line from the tragedy of Julius Cesar, ‘‘ most unkindest cut of all.”
Page 7
Alexander Hamilton the Lawyer. When the Colonial Commander-in-Chief became the National Chief, the old aide-de- camp became, as it were, a civilian aide, as Secretary of the Treasury, and took his facile pen into the cabinet, to accentuate a President’s message, to indite a marvelous funding scheme, to outline the first protec- tive tariff, and to draft a currency scheme that still attracts the admiration of that financial world which, although ever quar- relling within itself, has no jealousy of Ham- ilton’s fiscal plans. Was he not in all these matters really studying and practising the art of the con- veyancer, who in Hamilton’s day and gener- ation was placed at the head of the profes- sion, even beyond the barrister? Through all his career, whether as clerk studying lex mercatoria or the law of charter-party, of prizes and prize money, and of the then cal- low insurance law; or whether practically studying the law of war and international codes; the rights and wrongs of personal liberty and of government under the Consti- tution, was not Hamilton — what no earnest lawyer ever ceases to be —a law-student? When, quitting public life at the national capital, he returned to New York, it was to pick up the dropped threads of legal prac- tice, and with them work the loom of litiga- tion. Of this resumption of legal pursuits it is recorded in the memoirs of Talleyrand, who during his exile in America became intimate with and an admirer of Hamilton, that walking late one night apast the small brick house in Garden Street, where Hamilton had resumed his law chambers, Talleyrand saw Hamilton’s shadow on the office curtain, busily working at his desk. On the next day he remarked, “ Last night I saw one of the wonders of the world, —a man laboring at midnight for the support of his family, who had made the fortune of a nation.” His reputation as a lawyer had now be- come commensurate with his fame as soldier and statesman; for it was to him that, when 541 John Jay, the first Chief-Justice, retired to diplomacy, the vacant post was offered. That high post which fell for only one year to puisne Justice John Rutledge, of South Carolina, and next to Oliver Ellsworth, of Connecticut, for six years, who made way for the American Mansfield, John Marshall. But Hamilton declined the appointment, feeling that as a jurist his forte was the bar and not the bench. Although he never entered the court as judge, yet for years he seemed part of the court, for every incum- bent of that post had occasion at each suc- ceeding term to construe the constitutional work of the man who declined that office. Although never a judge, he lives under judi- cial decisions as a creator of constitutional law within every volume of. the reports of the Supreme Court. But early in this century the Reporter came into duty in the New York courts, and his collation of cases show Hamilton busily engaged before bench and jury, and oftentimes meeting at the bar Aaron Burr, his very opposite in integrity, rectitude and loyalty, and in freedom from chicanery. Veterans of that period have left on record that it was not alone jealousy politically of Hamilton that inspired Burr’s deadly hatred, but also jealousy of him at the bar. There is fortunately preserved an eulogy of Hamilton the lawyer, made by his early contemporary at the bar, James Kent, who in 1836, when Chancellor, in the course of an oration made before the Law Association of New York, said, “Among his brethren Hamilton was indisputably pre-eminent. He at once rose to the loftiest professional eminence by his profound penetration, his power of analysis, the comprehensive grasp and strength of his understanding, and the frankness, firmness and integrity of his char- acter. In reference to his associates, we may say of him as was said of Papinian, omnes longo post se intervallo reliquerit. 1 have always regarded Mr. Hamilton’s argu- ment, near the close of his life, in the cele-
Page 8
- forensic effort. 542 brated libel case of Crosswell, as his greatest The subject of grave and lofty import related to the liberty of the press, and to the right of a jury in a crim- inal case to determine the law as well as the fact. He never in any other of his cases at the bar commanded higher rever- ence for his principles or equal admiration of the power and pathos of his eloquence. I also heard him in our mutual youth, in January, 1785, when for the first time I at- tended a term of the New York Supreme Court, and saw and heard then, in an inter- esting case brought to a hearing, how he commanded great attention by his powers of argument and oratory. Hamilton was then at the age of twenty-seven. He rose with firmness and dignity, and during two hours was fluent, argumentative, ardent, and accompanied with great emphasis of manner and expression. His speech was marked for a searching analysis of the case,—he was resisting a motion for a new trial made as against evidence where Hamilton at zzsz prius had obtained a verdict rather by the force of his character and the charm of his eloquence than by preponderance of proof.” Of the uzsz prius case, out of which arose the argument just referred to, which was eject- ment for a large tract of land on the upper Hudson River, his son John C. Hamilton found a trial brief among his father’s papers. On its margin, as doubtless written in a spirit of raillery while his opponent (the afterwards Chancellor Livingston) was sum- ming up, appear in Hamilton’s character- istic copper-plate style of hand-writing, these sentences: “Recipe for obtaining good title in ejectment: two or three void patents, several old ex-parte surveys, one or _ two acts of usurpation acquiesced in for a time but afterwards proved such. Mix well with half a dozen scriptural allusions, some ghosts, fairies, elves, hobgoblins and a guan- tum suff. of eloquence.” Hamilton’s manuscripts and even his sig- nature, oddly shows that he omitted to cross Lhe Green Bag. his “t's” and dot his “i’s.” Doubtless he contracted this habit when a boyish clerk. But whether the omission was from econ- omy of time or caprice is unknown. When on one occasion Charles Sumner in the Senate claimed Alexander Hamilton as an anti-slavery man, he was sharply called down by a Southern senator, who begged his authority. The Massachusetts senator sent out to the Congressional Library for the second volume of Hamilton’s biography by his son, and read from it how, at the close of the last century, Hamilton founded in New York a Manumission Society for slaves, and obtained the signature of La- fayette to its roll as an honorary member. Also how he never would own a slave, but having hired one as a servant and finding that the master was about to sell the negro, Hamilton bought the slave and immediately manumitted him, but retained him in his service on wages. | In the illustrated volume that was pub- lished half a century ago entitled “‘Homes of American Statesmen,” appears a sketch of the celebrated Hamilton country place on the Hudson River Turnpike, running northward from the suburban village of Bloomingdale on New York Island. The site would be about where One Hundred and Thirty-third Street of New York City now runs. The avenue leading from the road to the house—a double one of the olden style, fronted with Doric pillars—was dotted with thirteen poplar trees — the prized tree of the land of his French ancestry on his mother’s side—that Hamilton himself had set out, one for each state of the Union. Only a year ago, when the Metro- politan march of realty for investment be- gan to despoil the old Hamilton acres, those trees were purchased in their grand old age by a patriotic ex-congressman, and at much expense and care were uprooted and borne for re-erection elsewhere. Hamilton’s library in this mansion over- looked the Hudson River and the romantic
Page 9
Alexander Hamtlton the Lawyer. 543 recesses of Weehawken, that, once an Indian | the murder of Alexander Hamilton —that wigwam-ground, nestled beneath the begin- ning of the Palisades; and often when there writing he could have seen, at an oblique angle to the northward, the very spot where in the duel he met his death at the pistol of Aaron Burr. ‘That tragedy has been so dramatically narrated by James Parton in his life of Burr, that no other pen is bold enough to engage in any new account of it. No lawyer versed at examining evidence can peruse that account, or indeed any re- liable narrative of the duel given by Hamil- ton’s contemporaries, without arriving at the conclusion that, so far as goes the malice aforethought which is necessary to the old common law definition of murder, Aaron Burr, in adroitly compassing the quarrel or in ‘preparing the challenge, premeditated demoniacal preamble to his after-crimes of endeavoring to snatch the presidency from Thomas Jefferson by an electoral trick, and of treason to his native country. Whenever Alexander Hamilton is men- tioned in the presence of any member of the bar, and is commented upon, as he most generally is, as alone soldier and statesman, let him not omit to proudly ex- claim, “ Hamilton was also a member of my profession and an honor to it.” But really, no American can contemplate Alexander Hamilton without applying to him the couplet of Dryden that he para- phrased from Juvenal’s third satire :— ‘¢A man so various that he seemed to be Not one, but all mankind’s epitome.” |
Page 10
544. The Green Bag. LEGAL REMINISCENCES, By L. E. CHITTENDEN. XI. | CANNOT comprehend why anybody should care for a continuance of these ‘‘Reminiscences,’ but so long as,. like Oliver Twist, your readers are asking for more, perhaps I shall run less risk in going on with them than in inquiring too closely why anybody calls for them. On one point I wish to take the readers of the GREEN BAG into confidence. I have no imagination—lI cannot invent, and when the springs of memory are dry my pen must be laid aside. I supposed they were exhausted long ago. But after a rest they again show some activity, and here are some of the long-buried facts they have recently brought to light. Longer ago than I care to name, one of our best Vermont judges was invited to one of our cities to become the counsel of a large corporation. It was not the increased compensation, but his increasing years, and the difficulty of reaching his numerous posts of duty which led him to accept the invita- tion and decline a re-election. We parted from him with regret, for he was a model judge who would have honored the highest court in the Republic. There was great difficulty too, in selecting his successor. We were agreed upon our brother who possessed the most legal learning. - He was a fearful special pleader — the one who had made life a burden to his antagonist in Moss v. Hindes, mentioned in these reminiscences. But he was the mildest-mannered man at the bar. Would he be able to maintain the dignity of his court and enforce order and obedience upon brow-beating lawyers and their brass-fronted clients? This was a serious question, but we took the risk and he was elected. He relieved all our doubts in the first entire satisfaction of the public. case in equity which came before him. A corporation had for many years managed the steamboats on Lake Champlain to the It was their claim that they had never lost or in- -jured a passenger, and the cleanliness, disci- pline and comfort of their steamboats, under Captain Dick Sherman and his asso- -ciates, were known as widely as the natural beauty of the route, and put much money into the treasury of the corporation. One season, at the opening of navigation, it became known that this corporation had fallen under the control of Wall-street specu- lators — that the old officers were to be dis- charged, and the steamboats were to be run for the last dollar that could be squeezed out of them. A lawless imitator of Gom- modore Vanderbilt, without his common sense, was made president of the corpora- tion. He did not care for contracts, courts, or newspapers, and as for the public — “ let the public be d—d.” His exactions were so great that after one season the money was subscribed, a new and faster steamboat was built, her command was given to an old and favorite captain, and she was made ready to run in opposition to the old com- pany as soon as navigation opened. The president of the old company did not propose to have his profitable monopoly broken up by an opposition. Under some pretense that he had bought some of the new company stock, he sent a powerful steamer with a gang of ruffians, which made fast to the new one and in spite of the resist- ance made by her officers and crew, took possession and towed her out of the juris- diction into another state. It then transpired that the captain of the new steamer, anticipating this act of piracy,
Page 11
Legal Reminiscences. had filed his petition in equity before the new judge and secured an order against the lawless president commanding him to refrain from any interference with the new steam- boat, except under a proper judicial order, and this injunction had been properly served upon him. He took the responsibility of seiz- ing the boat in violation of the injunction. Upon an affidavit of the fact of the seizure and removal, the judge notified the presi- dent to shew cause why he should not be dealt with. This notice was also disre- garded, and then the sheriff was ordered by the judge to arrest the president and bring him forthwith into the judicial presence. The president came with an array of counsel and followers that filled the court- room. The judge listened to their clamor for a few minutes and then commanded silence. When quiet was restored he ad- dressed the leading counsel for the respond- ent. ‘Mr. S.,” he asked, ‘“ what answer do you make to the petitioner’s affidavits of the service of the injunction order and the seizure and removal of the steamer?” ‘We have a most conclusive answer,” the counsel replied. ‘We have bought and own.the steamboat and removed her be- cause she was our property.” “Did you know of the injunction order?” asked the judge. ‘We did, and I advised that it be disre- garded for I knew”— He was about to say that the judge would not have granted it if he had known the facts, when the judge interposed — “That will do, Mr. S.,” said the judge, ‘you will please be seated while I prepare an order,’ in tones so gentle that they were almost effeminate. ‘But we protest against any order! we are here to show cause against it!” ex- claimed the counsel. ‘You must resume your seat, Mr. S., or the sheriff must take you in charge. The court is engaged and cannot hear you now,” came from the judge in the same gentle tones. 545 The counsel thought it prudent to sub- side — his client began to look anxious and started for the door. ‘The presence of the respondent and his counsel is necessary,” said the judge. ‘The sheriff will take both into custody!” Both took their seats. The judge directed the clerk to enter an order in the case. ‘This order,’ he said, ‘directs the sheriff to arrest the respondent who ordered the steamboat removed and the counsel who advised him to violate the in- junction, and confine them in the county jail, without bail, until the steamboat is brought back to the place from which, and surrendered to the parties from whose pos- session she was taken. When that is done the court will hear any questions that may arise. Until the status guo is restored, the parties cannot be heard.” They were immediately arrested. The judge would not even hear an application for a few hours’ delay in which to bring back . the vessel. It was only when others inter- fered and begged him not to subject an old lawyer to the indignity of incarceration, that a short delay of their actual commitment was secured. The steamboat was returned and for two seasons ran her brilliant career of compe- tition. The gentle-spoken judge was annu- ally re-elected until he was made governor of the state. I never heard any subsequent doubt suggested of his ability to maintain the dignity of the judiciary or enforce obedi- ence to his orders. I never heard that the enterprise of violating one of his injunctions was tried a second time. | | A question in hydraulics once promised to disturb our judicial peace, and but for an accidental observation of an old-time judge, might have cost the State much money. The river system of our State was a Provi- dential arrangement for the beauty of its landscape and the salubrity of its climate. Rills from ten thousand mountain springs united in a brook, which, increasing as it dashed over falls and down rocky precipices,
Page 12
546 aerating its waters to perfect purity, became a river, fertilizing rich intervales as it flowed quietly to its discharge in the western lake or eastern larger river. Dams erected at the greater falls gathered the waters into a flume, whence they furnished power for the mills which served so many and such useful purposes. The building of these dams was a terror to the owners of farms abutting on the river above, who claimed that their obstruction set back the water so that it submerged their low lands for so long a time that the newly- planted seed was destroyed, the lands made wet and cold, and their fertility was ulti- mately exhausted. Actions to recover dam- ages for the injury were commenced, and one of them came to trial before Judge B and a jury. The plaintiff proved his case not only by abutting owners, but by disinterested wit- nesses, who gave positive evidence that the waters were set back farther and submerged the low lands for a much longer period since the erection of the dam, than ever previously, within human memory. The witnesses were men of integrity who testified to what they believed was the truth. The defense was, that by actual measurement, the lowest point on the plaintiff’s farm was ninety feet higher than the top of the dam, between which and the farm of the plaintiff there were several perpendicular falls. This fact did not con- vince the plaintiff or his witnesses, whose testimony was strengthened by that of two experts in hydraulic science, who testified and made complicated arguments to show that the waters acted just in that way in obedience to natural and inevitable laws. They rejected with scorn the admission that after a freshet, the waters might be drawn off somewhat more slowly, and insisted that the obstruction was transmitted through the ultimate particles of the water, far up the stream and theoretically to its head. The judge listened to all this evidence with patience and judicial gravity. But Lhe Green Bag. when, the defense was about to commence its rebutting evidence, he asked, — “Will your evidence occupy much time, brother B.?” “We have about twenty witnesses,” the counsel replied, ‘“ but I hope to have a con- sultation at the intermission for dinner when we may decide not to call some of them.” “Then we will take an adjournment now,” said the judge without a ripple on his solemn face, ‘“‘to give the counsel time to consider how many witnesses it will require to satisfy this jury that water will not run up-hill /” _ The stone from David’s sling was not more fatal to the Philistine giant, than this observation to the plaintiff’s case. Coun- sellor B saw that his antagonist was paralyzed, and called only one witness. The judge submitted the case to the jury under a charge so fair that it was not open to ex- ception, and the finding of the jury, which ended the case and all others of its kind was, that water does not run up-hill / Questions in hydrostatics are sometimes very difficult of solution. I think there are readers of the GREEN BAG who will remember how one of them disturbed the peace ofa party of guests at a famous hostelry in the White Mountains some years ago, who were accustomed after dinner to assemble on the broad piazza to discuss and decide questions in moral, political and natural science. They had decided that fossils were not created in the rocks in their fossil form, but were the remains of animals that once lived, when a guest quietly asked whether in a wave there was any lateral movement or only a vertical one, of the particles of water? On this question the discussion was at first earnest and animated and the company was about equally divided in numbers. Then each side, in order to confound the other, sent to the city for the books in which such ques- tions were discussed. But when they arrived it was found that the authorities were divided about as equally as the company. Then it was agreed to settle the question by actual
Page 13
Legal Reminiscences. experiment and the whole party went in procession to the lake to see. Light chips of wood were strewn over the surface, a big stone dropped in and the waves were pro- duced. The waves moved outward fast enough, but the chips only danced up and down. Then the supporters of the lateral movement said that experiment was not fair, and pointed to the waves caused by the wind which floated the chips ashore — to which the adverse party replied that that was the effect of the wind and not of the waves. After many days’ discussion and the loss of much temper, the question was referred to the mover, who was a hydraulic engineer 547 of reputation. He said ‘‘ ke didn’t know; if he had known, he would not have asked the question.” I do not know daeter in that company the question was ever decided. I left it in the full tide of a heated discussion with all the gentlemen for disputants and all the lady guests for auditors. The incident was another evidence of the wisdom of the fathers who founded our Republic and made our consti- tutions, whose opinion it was that there was no better way of deciding a disputed ques- tion of fact than to submit it to a jury of the vicinage, under the charge of a competent, disinterested and impartial judge. THE GREAT INDIA-RUBBER CASE. By ANDREW DUTCHER. HILE Daniel Webster was justly called the “Great Expounder” of Constitutional law in this country, and by his services in both Houses of Congress and as Secretary of State, was recognized through- out this country and in Europe as a leading statesman of his time, his ability, although not so conspicuous to the public, was equal- ly shown by his forensic efforts at the bar. Among the many noted cases in which he was engaged, and one of the most im- portant, and the last that he argued, was that of Charles Goodyear against Horace H. Day, at Trenton, New Jersey, in March, 1852. The writer, then a young lawyer residing at Trenton, was naturally much. interested in hearing legal arguments of eminent coun- sel, and the opportunity enjoyed in this case, and the incidents occurring during the trial, are remembered with more distinct- ness, and are more indelibly impressed up- on his mind, than any other trial that he ever attended or is likely to witness again; and the time of a young lawyer is not easily employed more profitably, than in attending such legal contests and listening to such arguments. The action was in equity and was browse in the United States Circuit Court for the District of New Jersey by Charles Good- year, against Horace H. Day, for infringe- ment of the plaintiff's patents and for an injunction and accounting, and by a decision in the plaintiff's favor, settled the validity of his patents. The case was argued bifowe Mr. Justice Grier of the U. S. Supreme Court, and Hon. Philemon Dickerson, U. S. District Judge for New Jersey. The four counsel who argued the cause were James T. Brady and Daniel Webster for Goodyear, and Rufus Choate and Fran- cis B. Cutting for Day. Edward N. Dick- erson, then an ambitious and rising young patent lawyer, was attorney of record for Goodyear. Besides those named, there were many prominent lawyers connected with the case. Among them were Mr. Staples, Mr. Van
Page 14
548 Winkle and Mr. Stoughton of New York, and others in Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Philadelphia and other places. It may be no exaggeration to say that a stronger array of legal talent was never engaged in a single case between private parties in this country, and at the head of all confessedly stood Daniel Webster. The case excited great interest, not only | at Trenton, but throughout the State and in other parts of the country, especially in New York and the eastern cities, principally on account of its great importance to the India-rubber manufacturing interests. The distinguished counsel engaged at- tracted members of the bar and many others from the localities named, the great- est desire being to see and hear Mr. Web- ster. | The Court opened in the State Supreme Court Rooms, at the State House, which were then used for holding the United States Court; but those rooms not being arranged for many spectators, when the hearing was begun, the Court adjourned to the County Court House, where the com- modious Court Room would accommodate a large audience and it was densely packed during the trial. A rather amusing incident occurred be- fore the hearing of the case was commenced. In some preliminary. skirmishing on the part of the defense, a reply became _neces- sary on behalf of the complainant. His at- torney and counsel named were sitting by the side of a long table, Mr. Dickerson in front nearest the Court, Mr. Brady behind him, and Mr. Webster back of the latter. Mr. Webster and Mr. Dickerson both rose simultaneously to speak, but Mr. Dicker- son’s voice was first heard. He had not seen Mr. Webster rise and Mr. Brady im- mediately pulled him down and told him that Mr. Webster would reply. Mr. Dick- erson apologized profusely to Mr. Webster, but the latter, who had become seated, was evidently angry at what he considered a Lhe Green Bag. usurpation of his province by Mr. Dicker- son, would not rise again, and the exhibition of anger he showed and the withering look he gave Mr. Dickerson, was beyond de- scription and was doubtless remembered by the latter. Mr. Brady replied for his side, and probably smoothed the matter over, as during the progress of the trial afterwards © harmony seemed to prevail and the incident apparently forgotten, or at least overlooked by the senior counsel. The argument of the four counsel occu- pied eight days, each one consuming about two, Mr. Webster being slightly the shortest. Mr. Brady opened for the complainant (plaintiff) and presented that side of the case with his usual great ability. His argu- ment showed that he was thoroughly famil- iar with the facts appearing in the volumes of printed evidence containing in the aggre- gate over 4000 pages; that he understood the law pertaining to patents and the points involved, in short, that he had thoroughly mastered the case, and was able to present it to the court in the most convincing man- ner in behalf of his client. While referring to the testimony and commenting upon it, Judge Grier reminded him that he need only refer the court to such parts of the evidence as were important to determine the case, and said that the court could not be ex- pected to read it’ all, as they would never have time to do it, but if counsel would call the attention of the court to the material points in it, and inform the court in about what part of the library it could be found, whether in the north, south, east or west side, they would endeavor to look it up during the summer and consider it. Mr. Brady was followed by Mr. Choate for the defendant. Owing to his position as a public man, his well-known ability as a lawyer, and his high reputation for elo- quence and great command of language, by his facility to use and know when to apply all the words in the dictionary, he attracted more attention and curiosity to see and hear
Page 15
The Great India-Rubber Case. than any of the counsel except Mr. Webster. His argument was mainly upon the power of a court of Equity to grant a perpetual in- junction in a patent case without first hav- ing the question of infringement determined by ajury. He insisted that it could not be done, and in support of his position cited elaborately from the English practice and decisions, and taking the ground that the United States courts in equity had no greater equity powers than the English courts had at the adoption of the Constitu- tion, no additional powers in that respect having been conferred upon the courts by Congress. His argument was eloquent and exhaustive, instructive and interesting, and showed great research and learning. It was presented with all the ingenuity the distin- guished lawyer and orator possessed, and in the choicest and most expressive language. It seemed too learned and refined to be fully appreciated by the unprofessional specta- tors, and it also evidently failed to convince or seriously impress the court, as was shown by remarks made by Judge Grier and ques- tions asked by him during the discussion. The remainder of Mr. Choate’s argument was mostly of a pathetic character, endeav- oring to make Day a martyr in attempting to show how he had suffered by Goodyear’s treatment, and although expressed with all the eloquence and pathos the great orator was capable of, he did not seem to make much impression, and was so neatly turned by Mr. Webster, that whatever effect it had produced was dissipated, and general sym- pathy was changed to Goodyear. Mr. Choate was followed by Mr. Cutting, who made the closing argument for the de- fendant. He went more into the facts of the case and endeavored to sustain Day’s claims on the merits. His argument showed careful preparation, familiarity with the facts and thorough knowledge of patent law. He carefully analyzed the evidence, skillfully ap- plied the law, reasoned ingeniously, and on the whole his argument was doubtless as 549 able as could be made on that side, but did not make the impression on the memory that the others did. Mr. Cutting was not much known in Trenton, and not having been in public life like Webster and Choate, did not attract the attention they did, nor to the extent that Mr. Brady did, the latter having several times appeared in the courts of New Jersey, was better known at Trenton and throughout the State. After Mr. Cutting concluded, Mr. Web- ster commenced the closing argument for Goodyear. It was known that he was to speak that day, and the great numbers pres- ent not only from Trenton and other parts of New Jersey and elsewhere, especially from New York, showed that he was the great attraction at the trial. The large court-room was packed to its utmost capacity, and it is safe to say that never before or since contained within its walls so many distinguished legal lights as were in attendance, and it is doubtful whether any trial in this country ever drew together more lawyers than were then pres- ent. It seemed that the whole bar of New Jer- sey, including most of the judges of the higher courts, the state officers and mem- bers of the Legislature then in session, came to hear the great expounder who confessed- ly stood at the head of the American Bar. Mr. Webster’s argument is in print, and it would be superfluous to review it here. Only a few points in it in connection with incidents that occurred during its delivery will be noticed. It is no disparagement of — the other eminent counsel to say Mr. Web- ster was greatest of all. Brady was clear, strong and exhaustive, Choate learned, bril- liant, witty and pathetic, Cutting logical, thorough and evidently made the best that could be done with his side, but Webster seemed to combine the qualities of all the others. He had the subtlety of Bacon, without his craftiness, and the powers of Demos-
Page 16
55° thenes without his vehemence or apparent studied eloquence to convince. His mind was as liquid as water, changing with ease from the most profound reasoning and searching analysis to the sarcastic and hu- morous, and from the most bitter invective veiled in mild language to the most affect- ing pathos. No one can do justice to a description of Mr. Webster without having seen and heard him on.a great question which brought out all his versatile powers, and after hearing him when he was over seventy years of age, in the last case and one of the most cele- brated he was ever engaged in, the writer confesses his inability to do him justice. His commanding figure, fine physique, large head, deep-set, large, lustrous eyes and alto- gether strongly-marked, expressive features, and his powerful, sonorous and _ flexible voice, at once commanded attention, but it was his mental power and great intellectual strength brought into full play on a great subject that seemed to overshadow all his other qualities. His manner of speaking was deliberate, was void of vehemence, without much gesticulation, but apparently just enough to emphasize every point made. While his action was not remarkably grace- ful, it was always appropriate and impres- sive, and free from any of the arts often used by orators to captivate an audience. He never hesitated for a word, but seemed to get the right one every time. This was il- lustrated when others were describing what Goodyear claimed, Webster interrupted and said it was the ‘“‘ invention,” that covered the whole. A United States Senator who was in the Senate during Mr. Webster’s last five years there, and present during this argument, told the writer that when he heard Mr. Webster talk on ordinary occasions he did not seem above the general range of senators, and it was only on great questions and subjects that his powers were brought out, and it always seemed that they were never ex- The Green Bag. hausted, but if the occasion required he could be still stronger. He said he never had an idea what power there was in a man until he heard Webster’s reply to Daniel S. Dickerson who charged him with corruption in settling the northeastern boundary ques- tion when Secretary of State undér Tyler. He said the whole Senate sat aghast as if they expected some thunder-clap to break in their midst. When Mr. Webster came to Trenton, it was said that he knew very little of the case, and that he picked it up and arranged his argument from Mr. Brady’s comprehensive and exhaustive opening, and from consulta- tions and close application with his associ- ates before the other side closed. The arrangement of his argument, as well as the matter of it, shows how thoroughly he had mastered the case, how skillfully he arranged his points and how ably he applied his great legal knowledge. His allusion to Goodyear’s sufferings and the devotion of his wife, in the early part of his argument, brought tears to many in the court-room, and set a sympathetic current in favor of Goodyear, and followed by his effective reply to Choate’s effort to gain sympthy for Day, won the case for the for- mer so far as the audience was concerned. By the long labor and difficult and pro- tracted experiments of Goodyear in perfect- ing his inventions, he became greatly im- poverished and so involved in debt that he was confined in the debtors’ prison in Boston. Mr. Webster depicted most graphically the poverty, reproach and suffering which Goodyear underwent, in his intelligent, pa- tient, persevering efforts to produce in the manufacture of rubber a new and useful re- sult, for a period of ten years; he said, ‘It would be painful to speak of his extreme want—the destitution of his family, half clad, he picking up with his own hanés, little billets of wood from the wayside to warm the household — suffering reproach — not harsh reproach, for no one could bestow
Page 17
The Great Indta-Rubber: Case. 551 that upon him —receiving indignation and ridicule from his friends,” and after all, writ- ing in a good spirit and cheerful vein, an affecting letter from the debtors jail in Boston. In speaking on this matter further of Goodyear, he continued as follows: ‘He says it is as good a lodging as he may ex- pect this side the grave; he hopes his friends will come and see him on the subject of India Rubber Manufacture; and then he spoke of his family and of his wife. He had but two objects, his family and his dis- covery. In all his distress and in all his trials, she was willing to participate in his sufferings, and endure everything, and hope everything; she was willing to go to prison if it was necessary, when he went to prison; she was willing to share with him every- thing, and that was his only solace. “May it please your Honors, there is nothing upon the earth that can compare with the attachment of a wife; no creature who for the object of her love is so indom- itable, so persevering, so ready to suffer and to die. stances, woman’s weakness becomes fearless courage; all her shrinking and _ sinking passes away, and her spirit acquires the firmness of marble, adamantine firmness, when circumstances drive her to put forth all her energies under the inspiration of her affection.” While depicting Goodyear’s sufferings and making the beautiful allusion to the devotion of his wife, Mr. Webster had the advantage of Goodyear’s presence in his wasted appear- ance, bent form and with his white locks, which added to the effect in his favor, while Day, younger, robust with his apparent thrift, was not calculated by his appearance to gain favor with the spectators. Mr. Webster reviewed the material parts of the testimony very thoroughly and dis- sected that of the defense with great care and ability, showing its fallacies, contradic- tions and want of credibility in the most con- clusive manner. Among the witnesses on Under the most depressing circum- that side whose testimony was considered by the defense important in their favor, was that of Richard Collins of Baltimore, who claimed that as far back as 1833 he had in- vented the same thing in regard to vulcan- izing rubber that Goodyear claimed by his invention. | Mr. Webster’s ability, sarcasm, ridicule and humor were used effectively in dissect- ing Collins’ testimony and showing its worth- lessness. After pursuing him at some _ length, “Judge Grier interrupted him and said: ‘ Mr. Webster you need not trouble yourself fur- ther with the testimony of Richard Collins.” The learned Judge said further, that he had tried a great many patent cases and he had never tried one but some /e//er had come forward and sworn that he had invented the same thing in some garret in Boston, New York, Philadelphia, New Orleans or Balti- more and lately all those /e//ers came from Baltimore, and that counsel need not trouble himself with any such testimony as the court would not pay any attention to it. Mr. Webster in his usual impressive man- ner said ‘“‘I am very much obliged to your Honor for I wish to abbreviate my labors in this case, as well as those of your Honor. It seems to be your Honor’s opinion that I may let Mr. Collins go, and I propose to send Mr. Elisha Pratt and Mr. Stoddard to bear him company on his way. I shall say no more about them.” | Mr. Webster’s powers of invective were shown in unexceptionable language in com- menting on Day’s course, showing the latter’s inconsistencies, his falsehoods and attempts to defraud Goodyear by every device that his fertile‘mind could produce. It did not seem that anything more scath- ing and severe could be said, and the full force and effect of what was said can be appreciated only by hearing Mr. Webster’s ‘voice and seeing his manner and the expres- sion of his face. No written description can do justice to the occasion.
Page 18
552 All that has been stated in regard to this great argument gives a very meagre view of its strength and brilliancy. It was crowned throughout by the most profound reasoning and correct application of the law, and the highest encomium that can be placed upon it is, that it was Websterian from beginning to end. It was the last legal argument he mdde and was a fitting close to his great and bril- liant professional career. At the commencement of Mr. Webster’s argument he said, ‘if I should detain the Court by the part which I have to perform in this discussion, for any great length of time, I hope the Court will believe that what I have to say is long only because I have not had time to make it short.” His close was as follows: ‘‘ I have now gone through this case, and it may seem that I have done so too much at length. I find my apology in the importance of some of the topics it involved. I have to express my thanks, in common with the other gen- tlemen on. both sides of this cause, for the kindness and indulgence awarded me _ by your Honors. I feel how many obligations I am under in this respect. And as this is the first time that I have presented myself professionally in the State of New Jersey, and as I have cultivated a very long ac- quaintance with the good people of this State, more intimately than with those of any other State, with the exception of that in which I have so long lived, and as I have great regard for them, I am not willing to leave this performance of my duty, and to leave the State, without congratulating the citizens of New Jersey, with the certainty, The Green Bag. that while this tribunal shall continue to be constituted as it now is constituted, the ad- ministration here of the laws of the United States will be such as to secure all the peo- ple in the full enjoyment of their constitu- tional and political rights and to give them that happiness so felicitously expressed in the wish of Lord Coke ‘of living always un- der the protection of the law and the glad- some light of Jurisprudence .’”’ It may be said by some who chance to read this article, that for an account of the incidents of the great trial, there is too much of Webster in it. If such is the case, the only excuse offered is because at the time he seemed to tower above the others, and made the most lasting impression on the mind of the writer, of what constitutes the model lawyer. While the others were all eminent in their profession, and presented the case with great ability, it seemed that in all the qualities that make what is called a first-class “ all around lawyer” Mr. Brady came nearest to Mr. Webster, although he had not the eloquence and brilliancy of Mr. Choate, nor did he excel in the close reasoning powers of Mr. Cutting. The manner in which the whole case was conducted, was a model to follow. The dig- nified courtesy of the court, the respectful manner of the counsel to the court and to- wards each other, in short the whole conduct of the trial, was calculated to impress a young lawyer with the highest type of a lawyer and of professional ethics, which might be prof- itably imitated, and, in the conduct of atrial, observed by our courts and members of the bar at the present time to a much greater extent than now exists.
Page 19
ee ee Se 5 cites Lhe Supreme.Court of Maine. 535 THE SUPREME COURT OF MAINE. III. By CHARLES HAMLIN. HARLES WESLEY WALTON, the senior associate justice both in years and term of service, was born at Mexico, Oxford County, Maine, December 9, 1819. ‘He is the son of Artemas G. and Abigail (Stevens) Walton, and their third child and only son. His early education, besides the little acquired in the common school of those days, scanty enough at the best, was fourteen years in a printing-office at Dover, New Hampshire, and Paris, Maine, and in Boston. He was thus bred a printer, and it was there that he got a taste for study and knowledge that, like Franklin, led to a de- sire to improve his condition in life. Ac- cordingly he began the study of law, was a student in the office of the late Isaac Ran- dall, of Dixfield, and having been admitted to the Bar in 1843, was his partner for awhile. Besides practicing law he served in all of the town offices,. clerk, moderator, agent, selectman, collector, treasurer and school committee. As a school teacher his seven years’ experience well fitted him for the duties of the latter office, while the practical acquaintance he obtained of town business in all of them became useful to him both at the bar and on the bench. It must not be supposed that he found the profes- sion lucrative in those times, for he desired to be elected clerk of courts, the income and emoluments of which were tempting; but fortunately for him he was defeated in - the election, and so his talents were not bur- He was | ied in a merely clerical place. soon after, in 1847, made county attorney, and served as such four years. His ability and success at the Bar brought him in due time the desired results, and demanded a wider field for practice, and he therefore re- moved to Auburn, Androscoggin County, in 1855, and again became county attorney in 1857. In 1860 he was elected to the Thirty-seventh Congress, succeeding Hon. John J. Perry. He was placed upon the committee of private land-claims as a rec- ognition of his standing as a lawyer. After serving in Congress something more than a year, he accepted an appointment to the bench of the Supreme Judicial Court, May 14,1862. This appointment, made by Gov- ernor Washburn, has been continued with- out interruption to the present time, a judi- cial life of more than thirty-three years, and in excess of any other judge who has pre- sided in this court. During this long term of service on the bench, Judge Walton has had as associates, who no longer live, Chief Justices Tenney and Appleton, Associate Justices Rice, Cutting, Davis, Goodenow, Kent, Dickerson, Fox, Barrows, Danforth, Tapley, Virgin and Libbey. To have made himself one of the ablest lawyers in the State, to have gained a seat on the floor of Congress, and to have won and retained the confidence and respect of his associates on the bench, many of whom have a national reputation, would seem to have filled the measure of the printer boy’s ambition; but a true estimate of his place in the history of the Maine Bench shows something more —a strong judge, of marked individuality, and one who has given posi- tive additions, and of permanent value, to the body and growth of the law. And an inquiry into the source and cause of Judge Walton’s exalted judicial position will prove interest- ing. It is not what is called a liberal or college education, however desirable it may be as regards success in the world, that gives a man the confidence and favor of the community, or advancement to posts
Page 20
554 The Green Bag. of honor. It is native talent, reliability, perseverance, and an indomitable will that bring him to high places. A contest con- tinually goes on, especially in this country, between an academic and self-education — the education that comes from without and the education that comes from within. Over-education has a tendency to dissipate, scatter the strength of intellect, and the much cultivated youth, although holding high rank in the scale of proficiency and amount of knowledge, is liable on entering his professional life to continue to lean rather than to lead, and so take a secondary place in the struggle for distinction. On the other hand, the independent youth with- out external advantages, brought up in the school of stern necessities, whose life is a continued contest with difficulties, such an one, from the habit of self-reliance, becomes more competent to direct others, and to wear more easily offices of trust and re- sponsibility.2. It is remarkable how many of our distinguished men have been self- educated, or at least without college educa- tion. Franklin was a philosopher, Lincoln a statesman, Patrick Henry an orator, but not by the grace of classical education. In this field of wholesome competition between the well-taught and the self-taught; be- tween advantages on the one side and en- ergy on the other; between early develop- ment under assistance, and slow maturity under difficulties — a condition that need not be regretted —it is easy to perceive from which school Judge Walton was graduated. It is obvious, too, that such an education has been useful, because it was simple, limited, practicable, acceptable, and adapted to his wants, and brought home to his particular case by subdivision and selection, or, to use the words of Sir Arthur Helps, ‘“‘ by working ina 1 Bigelow, Limits of Education. 2 Lord Jeffrey, in his review of Franklin’s Works (Edin- burgh Review, 1806), makes the following remarks: “ Regular education, we think, is unfavorable to vigor or originality of understanding.” well-worn groove.” He has ever devoted himself entirely to the business of his office, nor suffered his time and attention to be distracted by other pursuits. Then add to all these things that he is industrious, firm, prompt, frank, self-possessed, and not given to wasting his dignity by an over-refined delicacy that often weakens and seldom adds to the usefulness of a judge. page When Judge Walton went upon the bench, admission to the Bar could be obtained by the production ofa certificate of good moral character from the municipal officers, and the payment of twenty dollars into the county treasury. This was a great change from the previous conditions that required not less than three years’ study with some reputable attorney and counselor, followed by a rigid examination. It was of this change that Judge Cutting spoke, when in Simmons v. Jacobs, 52 Maine, 156, he Said with his inimitable sarcasm: ‘We do not impeach the omnipotence of the Legis- lature for creating attorneys, as the world was created out of nothing.” A loose state of practice then prevailed among some at- torneys thus admitted to the Bar, and it is not strange that to the orderly and method- ical young judge it proved to be irksome and unbearable. He began at once to rem- edy the situation. It was not an easy or agreeable task, but in the end he succeeded by the use of suggestions, advice and ad- monition. His own promptness naturally led him to prefer ready lawyers, and those of resource who followed his suggestions. Says one of them after nearly thirty years’ experience: ‘He is at once the best judge for young lawyers, who pay him the defer- ence he deserves, and the most patient to show them and tell them, direct the issue and keep them in line, that I ever saw; while those that are opinionated, pert, and think they must evade his questions and not observe his advice, have found difficulty in practicing before him.” To anew the Judge at his best requires
Page 21
on CHARLES W. WALTON,
Page 22
550 some familiarity with his written opinions, cases, now become precedents of authority, beginning with the case of Wills v. Greely, 50 Maine, 78, and extending through thirty- six volumes. They are all marked with one quality, clearness and brevity of statement. Not a waste word can be found in one of them. As has been said of Tacitus: ‘‘ The love of brevity distinguishes him from all other writers. . . . and was, perhaps, carried _ farther by that constant habit of close think- ing which could seize the principal idea and discard all unnecessary appendages.” But the criticism made of Tacitus’ writings is not true of the Judge,— that ‘one contin- ued strain of studied brevity fatigues the ear and tires the reader by an unvaried and disgusting monotony.” ‘The late Judge Lib- bey, speaking of his terseness, in which he thought he excelled all other judges, said he admired it because he prized lucidity above all other qualities, both in speech and writ- ing. In making a selection of his opinions, which are recognized for their learning and ability, as well as extensively cited and fol- ~ lowed in other courts, mention of the follow- ing cases will suffice the present purpose: - Wyman v. Brown, 50 Maine, 139, holding that an estate of free-hold may commence in futuro; State v. Wright, 53 Maine, 328, deciding that jurors are not judges of the law as well as of the facts; Smith v. Morrill, 54 Maine, 48, relating to blank indorse- ments of promissory notes, and the admis- sibility of evidence to explain them; Hatch v. Atkinson, 56 Maine, 324, showing the necessity of delivery in cases of a gift, do- natio causa mortis, and a much quoted de- cision; Goddard v. Grand Trunk Railway, 57 Maine, 202, asserting and vindicating the doctrine of punitive damages. The simple reading of these few cases, taken at random, will demonstrate how this learned judge has devoted a life to the study of fundamental principles which in the end will irresistibly control in the administration of the law. The intrinsic value of these The Green Bag. is enhanced when it is remembered that a great deal of force is added to them by having a man of force and likelihood behind them. It must not, however, be supposed that the Judge has entirely confined himself to “volumes which you must count by hun- _ dreds,. by thousands; filling libraries, exact- ing long labors, the labors of a lifetime, abstracted from business, from _ politics.” His practical knowedge of business is of daily use and leads inevitably to sound con- clusions, without reliance upon legal pre- cedents alone, as in the case of the Franklin Co. v. Lewiston Institution for Savings, 68 Maine, 43, in which he lays down the safe and conservative rule that savings banks cannot purchase stock in another corpora- tion on credit by giving its note therefor. For the benefit of the current reader, the following extract from the case of Towns- hend v. Howard, 86 Maine, 288, is pro- duced to exhibit the terseness of his opin- ions already alluded to :— “Walton, J. The question is whether a will made by the late George H. Towns- hend was afterwards legally revoked. We think it was. A will can be revoked in whole or in part, by cancellation or obliter- ation: Ri. Se. 74, 29° 3. To. cancels to cross out. To obliterate is to blot out. The former leaves the words legible. The latter leaves the words illegible. By either method a will can be revoked in whole or in part. If that which is essential to the validity of the whole will is cancelled or obliterated, azzmo revocandi, the whole will is revoked. If only a single clause is so cancelled or obliterated, then that clause only is revoked. And such cancellations or obliterations are as effectual when made with a pencil as when made with a pen.” His pithy remark in Greenleaf v. Grounder, 84 Maine, 51, needs no explanation. ‘And the fact that the witness was not called at the former trial, and that, so far as ap- pears, no search was made for him, or
Page 23
; ; P - The Supreme Court of Maine. efforts made to procure his testimony, con- firm us in the belief that his testimony is not true, and that it is wewly invented, not newly discovered.’ In the same volume, at p. 592, is the opinion in Grotton v. Glidden, an action of trespass for assault and battery. The Saxon words in the following portion of the opinion will not be easily matched in any of the reports :— ‘In the present case, the evidence shows that the plaintiff and the defendant had been on unfriendly terms for many years. The defendant had fastened upon the plaintiff the name of ‘Hog Back,’ and had expressed great Satisfaction on learning that the latter was about to move out of the neighbor- hood. The plaintiff had called the defend- ant a hypocrite in religion, and expressed a long-felt desire to punch his head. They met in the highway, and the result was, first an altercation and then a fight, each one being as ready and as willing to enter into the fight as the other. The plaintiff got the worst of it. The defendant testified that he escaped with no other damage than a torn shirt-collar. The plaintiff went home with two black eyes, a scratched face, a bruised head; a lame back, and a kick on the lower part of his abdomen, which caused him to pass bloody urine. Surely if the defendant escapes with a verdict against him of only fifty dollars, he may think him- self lucky. His plea of ‘self defence’ makes quite as feeble an impression on the court as it seems to have made on the jury.” He has never drawn a dissenting opinion. He generally succeeds in convincing those opposed to him unless he becomes. con- vinced himself of error. His manuscript is the delight of the reporter and the joy of the printer. It is clear and plainly written as copper-plate, and the rules of the com- posing-room never forgotten. This will be better appreciated when it is stated that all his opinions are carefully copied by himself from the original for the use of the reporter and printer. his life abounds in them. Sot Biographies are pleasant reading, espe- cially those of great judges which are filled with the incidents of court life, relieving its monotony and tedium with flashes of wit and humor which reveal the agreeable side of the stern judge. It is to be regretted that more of such incidents in the life of Judge Walton have not been preserved, for Here is the mon- ograph of a shrewd, observing juryman :— ‘Judge Walton at seventy-four is right in his prime. His ear is quick, his eye is keen. He runs the whole show so quietly that no- body seems to know that he is the moving spirit. He finds time to read the news- papers while court is sitting. When he is reading the papers he sometimes says to a witness without looking up, ‘ You need not answer.’ ‘He has the dignity that becomes a judge of the Supreme Judicial Court of Maine, but he sometimes enlivens dull proceedings by sallies of wit and humor. He talks to the boys in the bar just as a big, good-natured boy would talk to a group of little young- sters. When he says to the lawyers, ‘ pro- ceed,’ or ‘stop,’ or says ‘gentlemen of the jury,’ the tones of his deep voice are musi- cal, and what he says is expressed in the clearest-cut English. The clerk’s desk is in front of the judge’s seat, and the bar is in front of the clerk’s desk. The bar is not that kind of a bar that Tom Watson said was in the basement of both ends of the capitol at Washington, but is a pen for the lawyers, where they have their books, writing materials, chairs and table. When two of ‘em get to disputing, a word from the judge quiets the disputants. The rest all grin and the proceedings go on.” How “proceedings go on” sometimes when attorneys are absent is thus told by the daily scribe of the press : — “Judge Walton is on the bench of the Supreme Court here this term, which is the same as saying that more good things have been said from that bench this week than
Page 24
558 will be heard there from the end of the present term until Judge Walton returns to the Portland court-room again. “Tuesday, when the work of assigning cases was in progress, a case was called with which Hon. A. A. Strout is connected, and the opposing attorney said: ‘If it please the court, Brother Strout is fishing.’ “The court looked grave, and another at- torney said: ‘He’s after a bear.’ “«T suppose,’ said the court, ‘that you mean that he is on his vacation.’ «Ves, your Honor.’ - 3 “<«This matter of a vacation has grown up within the past few years,’ said the court. ‘We didn’t know the meaning of the word vacation a few years ago, I can understand that some people may take a - vacation, but I do not understand how it is that professional people can do it. How doctors and lawyers and ministers can go off, leaving their professional business to look after itself, 1am not able to compre- hend.” | ‘““The case was continued, however, and Mr. Strout’s interests will not suffer because of the fact that he is off fishing, with strong designs on a bear.” * And the same writer tells how the Judge talks upon the relations of the press to the court )— “Wednesday morning, after the cases were disposed of and all motions heard, Judge Walton looked at the reporters and astonished them by saying, ‘ Now, gentle- men of the press, can I do anything for you?’ “«No, your honor,’ replied one of the scribes, feeling that something must be said. “Then the court proceeded to give the re- porters a very bright, if sometimes sharp, lecture on their duties as the court looked at the matter, and of what ought and what ought not to be printed. | “Then, half relenting, Judge Walton closed by saying, ‘Well, I know you are all in The Green Bag. competition and while you’ll applaud me, you'll all go out and keep on in your pres- ent ways. You have to give the public what the public wants to read.’ “There are few brighter men in this State than Judge Walton, and there is certainly no more upright and honored judge on the bench.” : A pure, grim humor sometimes pervades his replies. He had imposed sentence upon a criminal convicted of a flagrant offense, who was well along in years and infirm in health. The sentence seemed severe to members of the Bar present. One of them, on account of his prominence, feeling on easy terms with the court, said to the Judge that the sentence was manifestly too long. “He won't live a quarter of the time.” “Well,” replied Judge Walton, “I don’t want to be too severe. I will change it and ‘make it for life, if you say so.” One time in the lobby an ornamental member of the Bar, in order to show that his professional income was very large, was stating to some legal brethren, and his con- versation being partially directed to Judge Walton, “It seems rather a large story to tell, but my expenses are six thousand dol- lars a year; it costs me that much to live.” The Judge replied instantly, ‘‘ Brother S., it is too much; I wouldn't pay it; it isn’t worth it.” Nothing pleases the Judge more than direct, truthful answers to his questions. Sam F. was drawn to serve on the erand jury, and desiring much to get excused, procured his friends and members of the | Bar to intervene for him, but without suc- cess. As a last resort he applied to the Court himself. The Judge inquired what his business was and what reasons he had for being excused. Sam naively told him he was steward of the Commodore Club, at Moose Pond, and that he had been obliged to leave a party of its members, who had just arrived from Boston, in order to be present in court. To the surprise of all
Page 25
_ longevity. The Supreme Court of Matne. present, the Judge began to ask about the club, its efforts to re-stock the pond with fish, and finally asked, “ Are they having a good time?” Said honest Sam, ‘‘ Yes, they be.” Then said Judge Walton, ‘I'll excuse you till the next term. I wish I could be there myself.” The following pen-portrait is appended for the reader’s benefit, sketched during the Judge’s late session in York County :— ‘‘A man tall and spare, five feet and eleven inches perhaps, erect and dignified carriage, high, bold frontal development, thin gray locks, carefully combed, a long, narrow, iron-gray whisker and moustache, dark blue eyes, rather small, sallow complexion, and large, knotty hands. Dressed in priestly black with coat of the regulation Prince Al- bert pattern, his costume is complete with a high standing collar and four-in-hand black tie. In the examination of books, docu- ments, etc., a pair of spectacles lend added dignity to his rather pleasant features, and when upon the street a high silk hat of extreme glossiness adds not a little to the. judicial whole of the man.” In 1885 he was honored with a degree of LL.D., by Bowdoin College. LUCILIUS ALONZO EMERY, the second as- sociate justice, was born at Carmel, Penob- scot County, Maine, July 27, 1840. He is the only son: and first-born of James and Eliza (Wing) Emery. His father removed to Hampden in 1850 and was prominent as a merchant, ship-builder and town officer. On his mother’s side the family is noted for their love of intellectual pursuits and for Having fitted for college at Hampden Academy, he entered Bowdoin College, where he was graduated in 1861, with a class distinguished for its members becoming eminent as college presidents, professors, soldiers and lawyers. He began reading law with Hon. A. W. Paine, Bangor, an old, distinguished practitioner, and was admitted to the Penobscot Bar in August, 1 559 1863. In the following October he opened. an office in Ellsworth, Hancock County, where he has ever since resided. His sound legal attainments and ability in the trial of cases were soon recognized, for he was. elected county attorney in 1866, and before the expiration of his term, in 1868, he was invited by Hon. Eugene Hale, then entered upon a Congressional career, to become his partner. This partnership lasted fifteen years and was dissolved only by the pro- motion of Judge Emery to the bench of the Supreme Judicial Court. Besides a fine practice, in the meantime he was a member of the Maine Senate in 1874-75, and in 1876 was elected attorney-general of the State by the Legislature, and serving the State as such the next succeeding three years. He was again eleeted, in 1880, to the State Senate, and during the session of ~ 1881-82 served as chairman of the joint committee on the judiciary, the leading committee in the Legislature. In the fall of 1883, he was so generally recommended by the Bar of the State, that Governor Robie appointed him an associate justice. His appointment bears date October 5, 1883, thus succeeding Judge Peters, who had be- come the Chief-Justice. In 1889 he: was elected professor of medical jurisprudence in the Maine Medical School at Bowdoin College, a chair formerly filled by Chief- Justice Tenney and the late Judge Charles W. Goddard. His legislative labors and experience are notable for his efforts to ameliorate and simplify the law and to extend the equity powers of the court. His extensive practice had well fitted him, and he had the rare courage, for a lawyer, to attempt and carry through the changes which seemed to him to be required. During his first year in the Senate, he procured the enactment of a bill permitting the amendment of writs to cure the misjoinder or nonjoinder of plaintiffs. It remains a part of the permanent legisla- tion of the State, and is embodied in R. S.,
Page 26
560 c. 82, § 11. At the same session he advo- cated, as member of the judiciary com- mittee, giving the court full equity powers, which it now has (R. S., c. 77, § 6, clause xi). At the following session in 1875, he carried through the Senate a bill to abolish imprisonment for debt. The bill was de- feated in the House, where it was presumed that so humane legislation would be most popular, but ten years later imprisonment for debt was abolished almost without oppo- sition. His favorite measure was thus vin- dicated, — he then being, perhaps, a little in advance of the times. When chairman of the Senate judiciary committee in 1881, he was largely instrumental in framing and carrying through the Legislature the Equity Procedure Act, to make proceedings in equity more simple, speedy and effective. The great change, found in R.S.,c. 77, § 10 et seg., was this: Under the old system each justice of the court was only a master in chancery, and the only chancellor was the law court. Under the new system each justice is a chancellor, and can make final decrees. The law court thus becomes only a court of appeals. Rules adopted by the court at the May Term, in 1890, to carry into effect this new statute with a subsequent revision, were framed by Mr. Justice Emery, and his asso- ciate Mr. Justice Haskell. During his term of office as attorney-general he conducted the prosecution of two important and cele- brated cases, one civil and the other crim- inal. The first is a railroad tax case under the name of State v. Maine Central R. R. Co., reported in 66 Maine, 488. A statute imposing a state tax on railroad franchises had been passed, and it was resisted by the older railroads. He brought suit against the Maine Central in the State Court to re- cover the tax assessed upon the company, and the action was sustained by the court in an elaborate opinion by Chief-Justice Apple- ton, already alluded to in the sketch of that judge, ante, p. 510, as one of his leading The new Chancery © The Green Bag. opinions. The case was removed by the railroad company on writ of error to the United States Supreme Court, which court also sustained the action and the claim of the State. It is reported in 96 U.S. 499, The statute was a new one, and the case a leading case. Attorney-General Emery was the pioneer counsel. The other case, the trial of Edward M. Smith at Ellsworth, for murder, before Peters, J., was a remarkable one. The murder was a shocking tragedy, and the whole community was interested in the trial, which lasted fourteen days, the evi- dence being wholly circumstantial and con- sisting of a large number of circumstances of great variety. The crime was committed in a house oc- cupied by Mr. Trim, his daughter, and a little grand-daughter, in a country district, in Bucksport. The house was discovered on fire in the early hours of the morning, and was burned to the ground. It was found that Mr. Trim and his daughter had been murdered, and the house fired to burn their bodies, thus concealing, for a time, the real cause of their death. The defendant was convicted after an able and almost in- domitable defense. The Attorney-General was highly commended for his prosecution of the case in behalf of the State. It will thus be seen that Judge Emery went upon the bench well fitted by his edu- cation, practice and experience to-make an honorable career for himself as well as ren- der good service to the State. His ambition lay in this direction, and he brought with him, besides, a disposition for unremitting labor so necessary to the judicial office. His ideal of the judicial functions and responsi- bilities is high and dignified. Himself per- sonally polite and a lover of correct deport- ment, he encourages their practice by others, since politeness and good deportment render the administration of law easier, enhance its ~ usefulness, and add weight and influence to the respect that is due to the court. He believes the law grows, and with it should
Page 27
EMERY, LUCILIUS A
Page 28
be 562 grow dignity in its practice. Those who do not respect themselves and the public posi- tion they occupy are less likely to attain a successful administration of their office. He has made a close study of the habits and customs that prevail in other and foreign courts, and has observed the ease and com- fort of some English courts, such as arise from the single daily session, and the use of the gown. As regards the latter, if not the former, I do not doubt that his associates during the long, heated terms of the law court in hot weather, would often gladly agree with him to adopt them. He is social and agreeable, fond of his friends and ‘their adoption tried,” and pleasant in his manners while presiding on the bench. He never shows temper. His rulings in the progress of a trial are prompt and fearless. His charges to the jury are clear and ample, the ° issues well defined, and the jury are unerr- ingly brought to the point at issue between the parties without intrenching upon their province to find the facts. It must not be supposed, however, that he is.devoid of feel- ing or interest, for nothing escapes his obser- vation. Holding the scales of justice evenly balanced, it is his calm judgment and reason ‘that are his sole guides. He is commended by able lawyers with extensive jury practice for his method of addressing the jury, which he has adopted after much reflection and in- flexibly adheres to.. Hence exceptions to his rulings and directions to the jury embody only legal propositions for revision by the full bench. Believing the law is a science he is a dili- gent reader of all that pertains to it. While administering the “whole learning of the law,’ he does not hesitate to favor its reform _ when his judgment and his experience con- cur in the change. Some of his best service to the State, before going upon the bench, was his advocating the act giving the court full equity powers. That service he has since supplemented by sitting as chancel- lor and in his written opinions in equity Leen eee eee ee eee eee ee ee ee ee EE EE eee, EEO a Lhe Green Bag. causes, reference to which are made be- low. , He never indulges in levity or repartee on the bench. With him the trial of a case is serious business, requiring thoughtful atten- tion of all concerned, — himself attending only to the “trepidations of the balance,” that ‘‘ justice to the parties shall be admin- istered freely and without sale, completely and without denial, promptly and without delay.” When occasion calls for reproof it is generally in the form of a suggestion; when addressed to the whole bar it is more pointed and direct. In a recent term at Auburn, while hearing petitions for divorce, and which he does not grant without good and sufficient cause, he remarked to the bar: “You can’t expect much from me on the sround of failure to support. You better prove desertion.” The court was no false , prophet. Only one attorney relied on that clause, and he didn’t get his client untied. During the proceedings the Judge com- plained that they didn’t have witnesses enough. ‘I see you have gotten into the habit of bringing only one witness,” he re- marked to the assemblage of lawyers. ‘ Well,” said one, ‘different judges differ. We have usually had two.” ‘ Well,” said Judge Em- ery, ‘put me down for three.” It is universally admitted that Judge Em- ery writes good opinions. His reputation as a jurist might safely be measured -by this part of his work, for he has certainly done his full share. They cover a wide field, em- bracing many and different branches of law and equity. His style is simple and natural, readily understood, and the process of rea- soning easily followed. He begins with a comprehensive summary of the facts, then follows the statement of the issues, and lastly : his conclusions and the reasons for them. His statement of the case rarely leaves any- thing for the reporter of decisions to do in the preparation of the case for the book be- yond the head-note. He does not cite many decisions, and frequently none at all.
Page 29
mee Lhe Supreme Court of Maine. In making a selection of his opinions that have become permanent both for ability and importance, I think the general reader will find the following cases amply sustain his judicial reputation. Eames v. Savage, 77 Maine, 212, discussing constitutional law and deciding that executions against towns may be issued against and levied upon the goods and chattels of their inhabitants, and held to be due process of law. Andrews v. King, 77 Maine, 224, was a petition for certiorari to quash the proceedings of the mayor and aldermen of Portland in removing the city marshal from his office. The opinion dis- cusses and decides the nature, powers and procedure of special courts in such cases, holding that a hearing by the aldermen alone, the mayor being required to sit on the hearing, is not sufficient, even if by the officer’s con- sent. Boston & Maine Railroad v. County Commissioners, 79 Maine, 386, vindicating and sustaining the application of the police power of the State in requiring railroads to build and maintain townways and highways, within the limits of a railroad location, where the way crosses the track at grade, although the railroad charter provides that it is not to be altered, amended or repealed. Ayer v. W. Un. Tel. Co., 79 Maine, 493, holding that the rule requiring telegraphic messages to be repeated at the expense of the sender as a stipulation against the company’s mis- takes is void, being against public policy. McPherson v. Hayward, 81 Maine, 829, deals with the redemption of an equitable mortgage and is his first published decision upon this branch of the law after full equity powers had been conferred on the court. The case was ably argued by counsel for both parties, and subordinate questions of laches and parties are considered by the court. Thorndike v. Camden, 82 Maine, 39, defines the powers of towns over money in their treasury, and discusses the duties of assessors and collectors of taxes. Symonds uv. Jones, 82 Maine, 302, contains an exten- sive exposition of trade-marks and labels, 563 and their transfer and use. Boston & Maine. Railroad v. Small, 85 Maine, 462, contains a. pointed criticism of Six Carpenters’ Case, 8 Coke, 146. A much considered case is Warren v. Westbrook M’fg. Co., 86 Maine, 32, treating of the partition of waters by a court of equity, where there are two natural channels in a river caused by an island. While not much given to athletics and out-door life, he employs his leisure in social pursuits and with the best authors, keeping himself abreast with the times in all that re- lates to his chosen profession and current literature. His favorite studies are history and philosophy. He has been a diligent reader of the history of the law, and is a dis- ciple of Sir Henry Maine. Mill and Spencer. may be found on his table by the daily caller. His favorite author among the novelists is Thackeray, while he is also fond of Scott, Kingsley, and Lever. His writings do not disclose familiarity with the poets other than Shakespeare and Milton. Inclining to conservatism in politics, as lawyers are apt to be, and well grounded as a strict Orthodox in his religious views, he seems content in his judical office, its re- sponsibilities and dignity. The third associate justice, ENOCH FOSTER, of Bethel, Oxford County, was born at Newry.in that county, May 10, 1839. He is the youngest child of Enoch and Persis Foster. The Foster families came from England and first settled in Rowley, Mass., but his ancestors settled in Andover of that State and came from there to Maine. His father, whose name he bears, was a large and prosperous farmer. The home of his boyhood, situate on the direct route from Bethel to Umbagog Lake, a noted re- sort for fish and game, recalls the oft-repeat- ed allusion to the resemblance of this part of Oxford County to European mountain scenery, and to which is applied the name of American Switzerland. To the west and north are the White Mountains and other
Page 30
564 lofty summits between which flows the Androscoggin River with its many tribu- taries. Nature there is on a grand scale. It required hardy and brave pioneers and settlers to subdue the unbroken forests and convert into rich intervales the dense and _ tangled undergrowth where now rich mead- ows make the homes of their thrifty dwel- lers. It is the birthplace of strong and independent men,—the Grovers, Kimballs, Twitchells and Chapmans, who have be- come prominent as soldiers, teachers, legis- lators, physicians, lawyers, and merchants. Cuvier Grover was a most reliable brigadier- general in the Army of the Potomac and division commander under Sheridan in the Shenandoah Valley; Lafayette, the first rep- resentative in Congress and then senator from Oregon; and Talleyrand, a distinguished professor in Delaware. The Twitchells were also soldiers. Two of them, A. S. and Major A. B. Twitchell, served with credit in the Seventh Maine Battery. The Kimballs and Chapmans were also soldiers and mer- chants. Robert A. Chapman, of Bethel, was distinguished for his standing as a mer- chant and business. man,— qualities in- herited by his descendants,—and for his fine address and impressive manners. When the farmer’s boy had outgrown the common school, he went to Gould’s Acad- emy in the adjoining town of Bethel, where, under the tuition of Prof. N. T. True, an inspiring teacher and remembered for his memoriter instruction in Latin and Greek, he fitted for college. He made rapid prog- ress, for he was a good scholar, and taught in the public schools. He entered Bow- doin College in 1860, having as class-mates who have attained distinction in the law,— Frederick H. Appleton of Bangor, James “McKeen of the New York Bar, Charles F. Libby of Portland, and Joseph Bennett of the Boston Bar. Prof. Chas. Jewett of Long Island College Hospital, Brooklyn, N. Y., and John C. Harkness, President of Dela- ware State Normal University, were mem- The Green Bag. bers of his class and distinguished men. His class, which was graduated in 1864 with thirty-three members, furnished seventeen for the military service in the civil war of the rebellion, among them Lieut. Foster, who was mustered December 13, 1861, into Co. H of the 13th Maine Regiment of Infantry, as second lieutenant. This regiment be- came a part of General Butler's command in taking New Orleans, and served in the Department of the Gulf. He was promoted first lieutenant, and also served as provost- marshal under General Banks. Upon his own application he was relieved from the latter position in order to take part in the Red River campaign. When he returned from the war, he be- gan the study of the law in the office of Hon. Reuben Foster, in Waterville, Kenne- bec County, and completed his course of study at the Albany Law School, where he took his degree, and began practice in 1865 at Bethel. | His position at the bar was sure and solid. His ability and reliability were soon recog- nized, for in 1867 he was elected county attorney for three years, after which he was re-elected and continued in that office until he took his seat in the Maine Senate in January, 1874. He was re-elected to the Senate the following year, after which he devoted himself to his profession until March 24, 1884, when he was first appoint- ed Associate Justice of the Supreme Judi- cial Court, succeeding Hon. W. G. Barrows, who declined a reappointment. In the Senate he was chairman of the committee on legal affairs, and advocated, among other measures, a change in the system of taxation of railroads and telegraph com-. panies. During the ten years of practice before his promotion to the bench, he had a good- ly clientage, and he appeared upon one side or the other of nearly all the important cases in his county. His success at the bar depended on strong and not showy quali-
Page 31
bY nN oO — - Lom] 1S) o) ZA. fd ,
Page 32
506 The Green Bag. ties. He gained the confidence of the jury by the soundness of his presentation of a case rather than by attempting a display of brilliancy. Although often opposed by able men, some of them distinguished as brilliant advocates and quick to séize. upon the weak places in an adversary’s position, it was found that Mr. Foster was generally successful with the jury. His individuality, which is marked and strong, added to an iron will, made a great impression upon the common people. As an illustration of this power, an amusing story is told of a Newry juryman in a case in which Judge Foster was counsel and attorney for one of the parties. When the jury retired at the close of the charge, the foreman called for a bal- lot, and stated that the question, on which they were to vote, was whether the verdict should be for the plaintiff or the defendant. Thereupon the Newry juryman jumped up and said that ‘he didn’t know what they meant by plaintiff and defendant, but he was for Enoch Foster every time.” As may readily be believed, the Judge was an effective campaign speaker. I think there are few men in his cou..ty who accom- plished more than he in political meetings. He argued, as he did to a jury, with power and feeling, and this was supplemented by the earnestness of his convictions and the faith that the community had in the man. As often happens with men who succeed in the serious affairs of life and present a staid and sober mien, a closer acquaintance will develop a lighter side, disclosing a keen sense of the ludicrous, which breaks out, on suitable occasions, into droll humor. This is true of Judge Foster, who has a droll sort of humor that is very taking. He will enter- tain in a delightful way a group of friends with a quaint Jonathan-like style, but its effect is as largely in his manner as any- thing. According to the rule of the stand- ard critic, he never laughs at his own stories, and were it not for the twinkle of his eye or the premonitory smile on his lip, no one would suspect the coming joke and mirthful incident with which you will be delighted. He rarely indulges in wit, for that. comes from a heart that may be hard as rock, and cold as ice. His light vein is pure humor, the sunlight of a warm, kind heart, and it can come from no other. It has been truly said that, ‘‘wit never caused a tear of sym- pathy since the world was made.” Humor cheers and charms. Sheridan was a wit, Lincoln was a humorist. Simple and un- affected in his manners, he is agreeable to all. On the bench there is no effort to maintain a dignity otherwise than is natural and desirable in the judicial office. His charges to the jury are full and elaborate, taking them from point to point in a logical order that facilitates their understanding. As his instructions are carefully considered and well prepared, there is nothing of par- tiality or haste in them. The contentions of each side are fully stated and the jury are ‘assisted in the application of the rules of law with such care and minuteness that they cannot misunderstand their duty. During his eleven years of judicial life, Judge Foster has drawn an unusually large number of opinions upon important ques- tions. The ability and sound judgment evidenced in them constitute his high rank as a jurist. A few of them, and which are now relied on as leading cases and frequently cited in our own and other courts, will be briefly noticed. : Lockwood Co. v. Lawrence, 77 Maine, 297, was a case in which it is held that nui- sances and injuries affecting waters, including the obstruction, diversion or pollution of streams, afford sufficient ground for equi- table interference, on the ground of restrain- ing irreparable mischief. It arose from the defendants, acting independently of each other, casting their saw-mill refuse into the river above the plaintiff’s cotton-mill, which commingled and united into one indistin- guishable mass, filled the plaintiff's pond, raceways and wheels, thereby stopping the
Page 33
The Supreme Court of Maine. wheels and preventing its mill from running and operating. As will be seen, the contest was between textile mills on the one hand, a comparatively new industry, and lumber manufacturers, an old business, on the other hand. Many objections were raised to the maintenance of the plaintiff’s bill, but they were all met and disposed of in the opinion, which reviews the authorities at length and gave the plaintiff the relief sought for. As an authority upon the questions raised and discussed, it received general commendation and recognition. Wormell v. Me. Cent. R. R. Co., 79 Maine, 397, discusses the question of contributory negligence of a servant, and holds that he cannot recover damages of the master where want of due care on his part contributed to the injury, even if in the performance of duties outside his regular employment. It was the case of a workman in car-shops who was in the yard, shackling cars by direction of the foreman. The opinion holds that it was a case where it required no special skill or training to foresee that injury would result, the causes being open to observation; also that it is a question for the court to deter- mine whether there is sufficient evidence of due care on the part of the plaintiff to sus- tain a verdict in his favor; and that evidence so slight as not to have legal weight is in- sufficient. Warren v. Kelley, 80 Maine, 512, involved the consideration of both admiralty and constitutional law. It was a case where it was sought to uphold the rights of parties who had furnished repairs of a domestic vessel to enforce their lien therefor in the State court under a State statute. The opinion discusses and treats at length the embarrassing and conflicting decisions upon the question of admiralty jurisdiction in such cases, and holds that it is exclusively in the Federal court, thus pronouncing our statute to be unconstitutional. And this part of the statute has been accordingly re- pealed. The case was ably argued by coun- 507 sel for both parties, the plaintiff, who ob- tained a verdict, by Mr. -Wiswell, and the defendant by Mr. Putnam, both of whom have since gone upon the bench, one a member of this court and the other of the Circuit Court of Appeals. The case con- cludes with a statement of the rule of dam- ages in actions of trespass and its modifying exceptions, for which it is often cited by counsel. | Phinney v. Phinney, 81 Maine, 450, is another constitutional question, relating to the obligation of contracts as affected by subsequent legislation, and the court, in the opinion drawn by Judge Foster, held the act of the Legislature was unconstitutional. The case arose upon a bill in equity, under an Act of 1887, by a creditor who sought to realize a judgment out of his debtor’s equity of redemption in a mortgage given in 1875 for the support of the mortgagee. The object of the bill was to enable the creditor, pending proceedings for foreclos- ure, to step in, postpone the time for the expiration of the right of redemption, and enable him by fulfilling such requirements as the court might impose, to hold the property by virtue of his attachment. The statute provided that ‘‘ pending such pro- ceedings, the right of redemption shall not expire by any attempted foreclosure of such mortgage.” But the opinion meets this statute provision, so far as it applied to mortgages in existence at the date of the act, in the following clear language: ‘‘ While a State may, to a certain extent, and within proper bounds, regulate the remedy, yet if by subsequent enactment it so changes the nature and extent of existing remedies as to materially impair the rights and interests of a party in a contract, this is as much a vio- lation of the compact as if it absolutely de- stroyed his rights and interests.”. . . ‘The constitutional prohibition secures from at- tack not merely the contract itself, but all the essential incidents which render it valu- able and enable its owner to enforce it.”
Page 34
568 The Green Bag. Libby v. Tobey, 82 Maine, 397, recalls the era of mining companies in Maine, fifteen years ago, when a new Eldorado dawned upon the vision of every owner of a sheep-pasture or other rocky spot of land or ledge. In eastern Maine, Blue Hill, Sul- livan, Gouldsborough and Deer Isle were found to possess veins and deposits of copper and silver, and active operations in mining were begun and carried on. Corporations with capital running into many thousand dollars were formed under the State law, and shares of stock could be found in the hands of nearly everybody. Speculation in mineral rights ran rife, and fortunes (on paper) were easily made. When the bubble burst and investors found their fortunes had vanished like a vision in the night, and melted like a palace of snow, there arose the troublesome question of their liabilities as stockholders to creditors who had ob- tained judgments against these corporations and were seeking to enforce them against individual stockholders. This question was a difficult and perplexing one to the legal fraternity because it had become complicated by changes in the statute from time to time. In the case cited, it received at the hands of Judge Foster a careful consideration, and the conclusions which he arrived at are so clearly demonstrated and the result so satis- factory that his opinion has become the settled law of the State. He holds that the individual liability of the stockholders for the debts of the corporation is created solely by statute, and it is to be strictly construed as between the shareholder and creditor, since there is, at common law, no contract, express or implied, between them. As an interpretation and judicial construction of corporation law, the opinion contains the decisions of other cognate and collateral questions which arose for determination in the case. In the same volume, at page 472, will be found his opinion in the case of State v. Stain and Cromwell, most carefully consid- ered, and concurred in by every member of the court. The unbiased reader will find here the true and real merits of the trial of the murderers of treasurer Barron, stated and discussed ina convincing manner. The respondents were convicted upon two classes of evidence, confessions and their identifi- cation and presence at Dexter on two pre- vious occasions the year before, and in and about the bank building on the day when the murder was committed. Of these two classes of evidence examined and weighed by Judge Foster with his well-known and pains-taking care, he says: ‘“ ... While not in any sense dependent upon each other, [ they ] are nevertheless in a most remarkable and striking degree in all their essential par- ticulars entirely consistent, and in harmony with each other.” The case is notable from the fact that ten years had elapsed after the crime before the murderers were convicted, and in the meantime the theory of suicide had taken possession of the minds of people in the town of Dexter, where the crime was com- mitted,—a thing still persisted in by some, al- though proven to be unsustained by the facts. Recent attempts to procure a pardon of the convicts has reopened a discussion of the case, and in this connection one recalls the remark of Wilkie Collins in his ‘‘ Rogue’s Life,” that the person who first gets his ver- sion of an affair out upon the public will generally be believed. It was in this man- ner, through the press, that one of the coun- sel who defended these men conducted his defense both before and during the progress of the case. The public mind was thus preoccupied before it even knew what the testimony of the State was. In Bulger v. Eden, 82 Maine, 352, will be found an interesting comparison of au- thorities bearing upon the frequent contests in the court over the liabilities of municipal corporations for the torts or negligent acts of their officers. ‘The opinion clearly de- fines the well-known distinction which exists between their acts as public officers, on the ‘ oo ‘zs wu 2 > eee or =. s -
Page 35
The Supreme Court of Maine. 569 one hand, and as agents of the town on the other hand; and has become practically a vade mecum for the active practitioner. In Libby v. Me. Cent. R. R. Co., 85 Maine, 34, the plaintiff, a postal clerk, re- covered a verdict of $9558, for injuries re- ceived by the wrecking of the train on which he was employed, and which ran into a wash-out caused by a sudden and violent storm and flood. The plaintiff rested his case on the defendant’s negligence, both for improper construction and maintenance of a culvert and want of proper inspection. These questions, including the law regulat- ing the relation between the passenger and common carrier, are fully reviewed with references to many decided cases in the American and English courts. Judge Foster’s opinion, sustaining the verdict for £6000, holds upon the facts that: ‘ Under circumstances of more. than ordinary peril, the company should inspect its line with more than ordinary promptitude, particu- larly those portions which are the most liable to injury by storm or flood. The ereater the peril, the greater the vigilance demanded.” Judge Foster has written many other opinions for the court in personal injury cases, but the following, in Mundle v. Hill Mfg. Co., must suffice for the present pur- pose of showing the reader his familiarity with, and clear statement of, this branch of the law of torts. The plaintiff in this case recovered a verdict for injuries to her foot. While walking across the mill floor in the dressing-room, where she was employed, she stuck a splinter into her foot, causing a painful wound of long duration. The de- fective condition of the floor was not denied, but it appeared that the plaintiff knew its condition and did not make any complaint or request for its repair. Under these facts the opinion treats and discusses the principles of the law which apply to voluntarily assuming risks, and holds that where the employee has full knowledge: and | appreciation. of the danger to which he is exposed and consents to serve in the way and manner in which the business is con- ducted, he has no legal ground of com- plaint, even if reasonable precautions have been neglected by the employer, and an injury has been received. The distinction | between contributory negligence and volun- tarily assuming risks, not always observed in such cases, is carefully drawn and well defined in the case. Peabody v. Maguire, 79 Maine, 572 (sales), Green v. Jones, 76 Maine, 563 (specific performance), and Owenv. Roberts, 81 Maine, 439 (insolvency as affecting at- tachments by foreign creditors) are, among others opinions of the Judge, frequently cited. ; Those who are acquainted with his opin- ions characterize them as sound and strong in judgment, inclining to fullness, with good power of statement. His style is natural, lucid, accurate and well sustained, and he moves with a good vocabulary without attempting to be ornate. Not given to pro- lixity, he sometimes and when necessary discusses decided cases in the reports in a manner reminding one of the essay style, which delights the searcher for law by his analysis and comparison and at the same time makes him a favorite of the young lawyers. There is a noticeable ease in these dis- cussions of decided cases. It arises from diligent study, a tenacious memory of all - that he reads, and a good system of annota- tion to which he has adhered from the beginning. | His manuscript is neat and perfect, and reminds one of Lavater’s saying: ‘ Individ- ual handwriting is inimitable—the emana- tion of the mind.” . ; | Although he did not complete his college course, by reason of his entering the mili- tary service, his alma mater did not fail to recognize his worth and merit and conferred on him the usual degree at the graduation
Page 36
579° of his class. In 1893 he was elected a member of the board of overseers. THOMAS HAWES HASKELL, the fourth as- sociate justice, was born in New Gloucester, Maine, on the 18th of May, 1842. He is the youngest son of Peter and Betsey (Hawes) Haskell, and was reared as a farmer’s boy. His paternal ancestors were Welshmen: two brothers of whom immigrated to Cape Ann from Wales. Some of their descendants ‘settled in New Gloucester before the Revo- lution. Peter Haskell’s mother, Salome Parsons, was the daughter of Col. Isaac Parsons of New Gloucester and a sister of the mother of Peleg W. and Theophilus Chandler, well known Boston lawyers. Col. Parsons was an own cousin of Chief-Justice Parsons, and removed from Gloucester, Mass., to New Gloucester, Maine, then a frontier town, about 1760. Judge Haskell’s mother was the daughter of Capt. Thomas and Betsey (Whitman) Hawes of Welfleet. She and Chief-Justice Whitman (azze p. 470) were the only chil- dren of Josiah Whitman of Bridgewater, Mass., who died while they were young. Judge Haskell fitted to enter Bowdoin College in 1862, but instead entered the 25th Maine Regiment of Infantry, Col. Francis Fessenden, and served as a non-commis- sioned officer with his regiment in Virginia. It was a nine months’ regiment, and after his discharge, in the summer of 1863, he en- tered the office of Judge Morrill, of Auburn, Androscoggin County, as a student at law. He was admitted to the Bar of that county, in 1865. For a time he remained with his instructor, but moved to Portland in 1866, where he has ever since resided, and con- tinued an active practice of his profession until called to the bench, March 31, 1884, succeeding Hon. Joseph W. Symonds, who had resigned. He has held no political office outside the line of his profession, except as a member of the city council of Portland. He served as county attorney The Green Bag. for a part of a term, in 1870, being ap- pointed by the court to fill a vacancy, and again in 1878; and was appointed to the office by the Governor in 1879, serving until the expiration of the term. He was also a commissioner of the Circuit Court of the United States. He was for a time the law partner of the late Judge Goddard of the Superior Court for Cumberland County, and of Hon. W. W. Thomas, Jr., late our Minister to Sweden, and of Hon. Nathan Webb at the time he was appointed United States District Judge for Maine in 1882. In 1881 he was appointed by Governor Plaisted upon a commission to investigate abuses in the Reform School. He made a separate report that was full and exhaus- tive; and he drew and secured the passage of the law, approved March 15, 1883, c. 250, now governing. that institution, estab- lishing regulations for the prevention of abuses, establishing a mechanical school, and providing for a woman visitor and also a letter-box for the boys where they can deposit letters without scrutiny of the offi- cers of the school. He early developed in the profession an aptitude for pleadings, and became pro- ficient and successful in the branches of the law relating to admiralty, corporations, bankruptcy, criminal and commercial law. “Don’t do too much for your boys,” said a shrewd merchant, ‘if you expect them to make anything of themselves.” No doubt, confidence and self-reliance come largely in that way, but the successful lawyer must have a fearless and independent spirit to build upon; and I found that was the case. with Judge Haskell the first time that I saw him. It was when I was holding a bankrupt court as register in a neighboring city, he ap- peared in opposition to a very able lawyer, skilled in all the tactics that long practice affords, who sought to protect a preferential mortgage. The proceedings before me con- sisted in taking examinations of witnesses
Page 37
THOMAS H. HASKELL.
Page 38
572 by Judge Haskell, who readily succeeded in laying the foundation for vacating the pre- ference, notwithstanding the interruptions, bluster and threats of his antagonist. I could but admire his coolness and courage, for older lawyers and even judges dreaded to encounter this member of the Bar. As the proceedings lasted several days the young lawyer was put upon his mettle, but he came off triumphant, for his antagonist yielded in the end and complimented him in an unusual degree. It gave him also an enviable reputation, that only time generally affords. He was a good lawyer and gained the confidence of those who were associated with him as counsel and client, for ability, integrity and industry, — qualities all and each of which are necessary to create and hold the esteem of the Bar, upon whose recommendation he was promoted to the bench. He has fine powers of observation and is well informed in other things outside his profession. In this respect he exceeds the average professional man. He is many- sided, and would have succeeded well as a naturalist, bank president or manager and financier of a corporation. He loves a fine horse or a bit of intricate machinery. In- -ventive and ingenious, without mechanical training, he could both plan and build a house with enough closets and bow-windows to satisfy any woman. To these powers add a methodical and critical faculty developed, strengthened and broadened and you have the qualities of mind which are readily seen in the way he has built his library, both law and miscella- neous. While on the one hand you cannot find there a single useless volume, many of which will gather in lawyers’ book-cases, on the other hand, there are rare and origi- nal editions and some valuable for their previous. ownership, attested by the auto- graphs of Simon Greenleaf and others dis- tinguished in the profession. He has a good combined selection of American and English books for every-day use, and his lhé Green Bags” = private library has been brought together in the same choice and orderly method. He has good taste in all the details of book-making, as will be seen in Haskell’s Reports of Fox’s Decisions in the United States District Court for the District of Maine, which he prepared and edited in 1887-8. His tasteful execution of a report- er’s work in these two volumes gave him the credit of a connoisseur for skill and ability, and myself a good excuse, when I began my duties as reporter of decisions of this court, to call upon him for advice and information, which he always accorded in a friendly and helpful way. These two volumes of Has- kell’s Reports, work which he did after he went upon the bench, are not exceeded by any reports, that I have seen, for aptness and precision in the head-notes. Grasping the salient points of each case, they have the happy medium between over-concise- ness and prolixity that commends a volume of reports to the busy lawyer, and is thus a vast saving of time. In his prefatory note he modestly claims that he has only en- deavored to-verify citations and quotations, to guard against all errors of the press, and says: ‘I only desire that my work may be charitably received and prove valuable to my professiona! brethren.” During the fifteen years that Judge Fox presided. in the United States Court, it is well known that he exacted great prompt- ness in the practitioner at the bar of his court. As he said of his predecessor, Judge Ware, ‘He always sat velzs levatis’”’; and the habit of industry and readiness which he there acquired, Judge Haskell brought with him to the bench of this court. Besides the usual zzs¢ prius terms of court held by him, he began at once after his ap- pointment upon law cases. His first opin- ion, Berry v. Titus, 76 Maine, 285, was announced June 2, 1884. ‘This case, treat- ing of review, exceptions and practice, was followed in quick succession by five others in the same volume, Parsons v. Clark, p.
Page 39
The Supreme Court of Maine. 476 (riparian owners) ; Pendergrass v. York Mfg. Co., p. 509 (nonsuit) ; Turner v. Hal- lowell Sav. Institution, p. 527 (wills); At- water v. Sawyer, p. 539 (inn-holders), and Burgess v. Stevens, p. 559 (mortgages, foreclosure). His opinions in the next ten volumes (77-87) are of the usual variety to be found in courts of common law also having equity jurisdiction, and the topics are those that are of daily occurrence, in and out of court. One of his best considered and most impor- tant cases, which first came to my hands as reporter, appears in the eighty-first volume at page 538. It is Weeks, Ptr. for Mandamus v. Smith, to compel the Secretary of State to restore to his office the ‘‘ Medical Regis- tration Act” of 1887, as an act regularly approved and in force as a public law. After the passage of the bill by the Legisla- ture it was vetoed by the Governor, whose veto. was sustained. It was claimed, how- ever, by the petitioner, that it had been ap- proved by the Governor and had become a law and was deposited in the Secretary’s office before he had vetoed it. The bill was passed to be enacted March 17, as appeared by the certificate of the presiding officer of each house of the Legislature. Upon it was also indorsed a certificate of the Sec- retary of State of the same date: “ Returned to the Senate by the Governor. Signature refused. Failed of passage over his veto.” Above this certificate appeared these words: ‘‘ Approved, March 16, 1887,” and the sig- nature of the Governor, with a heavy line in ink drawn through the March 16, and the name of the Governor. 3 It became an interesting question at the outset whether the records in the Secretary’s office were subject to be controlled by parol evidence. The opinion holds that they can- not thus be overturned; and that when they are fair upon their faces, showing no infirm- ity that would invalidate the record if not explained, they are conclusive of what they purport to be. This result is reached from 573 a full examination of the authorities, both American and English, and from which is also adduced the decision that it is a judi- cial question, whether an act of the Legisla- ture has been constitutionally passed, to be decided by the Bench from an understand- ing of public matters, regardless of plea or proof. This case was ably argued by emi- nent counsel, and the court dismissed the petition, having decided that the act never became a law. This case is quoted by the Supreme Court of the United States in its decision on the McKinley Bull, and _ its doctrine approved. See Field v. Clark, [AS A) up OF 7. The eighty-second volume contains more than his share of cases, and three that help make the book valuable. Allen v. Maine Central Railroad, page !11, is an admirable opinion for its power of statement, terseness of style-and plain application of the law in cases of contributory negligence. | James v. Wood, page 173, treats of the illegal capture of game. Hutchins v. Ford, page 363, finds the Judge at home upon a familiar topic, marine insurance and _bar- ratry, in which he holds that a policy writ- ten by the Portland Lloyds covers barratry of the mariners, but not of the master when the insured is an owner of the vessel. The opinion is full, covering each point raised, amply fortified with decided cases, and although requiring labor and_ research, shows an easy handling of the subject, as might be expected. He was one of the committee of judges who formed the equity rules published in this volume. Of his fif- teen opinions in the eighty-third volume, one, Webster v. Tuttle, page 271, treats of constitutional law and the quieting of land titles; Morrill v. Everett, page 290, the re- demption of land sold on execution, is a well-wrought, finished application of equity law and collateral questions arising in the suit; and Bank wv. Maxfield, page 576, dis- cusses commercial paper and the right of national banks to take mortgages.
Page 40
574 The Green Bag. The eighty-fourth volume contains thir- teen opinions upon as many different branch- es of the law. The first is Plummer vz. Jones, page 58, which decides when various sections of the “ Registration Act” of 1891 went into effect. quaint selections from Coke and Plowden well fitting to the subject. Auburn v. Paul, page 212, relates to the oft-recurring ques- tions of taxation and constitutional objec- tions arising inthem. Breckenridge v. Lewis, page 349, holds that one who entrusts his signature to another for commercial use, that is, to have some business obligation written over it, becomes holden on a prom- issory note fraudulently written by the per- son so entrusted with it, and negotiated to an innocent holder. Ela v. Ela, page 423, declares that probate procedure should be conducted upon the rules of broadest equity when the statute does not prevent; and was a wholesome application of the doctrine in this case. 7 The eighty-fifth volume contains the work of a busy year. Among his twenty-four cases in this book there is Donnell v. Wylie, page 143, a good statement of the rule re- lating to voluntary unexecuted promises; Hurd v. Bickford, page 217, vindicating an original vendor’s right to reclaim property purchased by fraud, although the last ven- dee is ignorant of the fraud,—a question about which courts differ; Attorney-Gen- eral v. Newell, page 273 (quo warranto, elections and false returns) ; Hewett v. Co. Com., page 308 (certiorari, and the practice therein) ; Hazen v. Wright, page 314 (real actions and effect of a plea of ul dissetzin) ; Paris v. Norway Water Co., page 330, solv- ing a question of taxation of water-pipes as real estate in the town where they are laid. Volume eighty-six, containing twenty-five opinions, still maintains the usual variety of topics. Some of them, noticeable for their intrinsic interest, are White v. Mooers, page 62 (specific performance); Barron v. Bur- rell, page 66 (creditor’s bill to compel pay- The opinion quotes some | ment of unpaid stock); State v. Edwards, page 102 (constitutional law, tolls of grist- mills) ; Pease v. Burrows, page 153 (a pe- culiar case of libel in which it is held that the court may, in its discretion, permit the cross-examination of a witness to show men- tal illusion; yet it is not evidence of the facts so stated, and the jury are to be so in- structed) ; Bettinson v. Lowery, page 218, (what judgment should be entered in re- plevin when the writ is quashed); Holt v. Knowlton, page 456 (when contracts are to be governed by the laws of Maine, but formulated in another State); Sawyer v. Long, page 541 (chattel mortgages as af- fecting after-acquired property). This vol- ume closes with a report of his decision in the matter of the estate of John B. Brown. - The decision was not appealed to the law court, but passed into judgment upon the conclusions found by the Judge sitting as chancellor. His strongest opinion in this volume, I think, is the case of Morey v. Milliken, page 464. The law relating to preferences in insolvency and bankruptcy and the decis- ions slumbering in many reports, are deftly brought together in so felicitous a summary that it will not fail to become a generally cited authority hereafter. His analysis of the testimony is clear and satisfactory, copi- ous and convincing. ‘The case came to the law court on a bill of exceptions with a statement of facts. Under the practite pre- vailing in Maine, such findings of facts are not subject to review in the law court; and one might think that a judge who has de- voted so much time to questions of prac- tice, where the tendency is to restrict and not amplify remedies, becoming narrow and technical instead of being fond of justice in spite of technicalities, would have found dif- ficulties in his way that would prevent a de- cision on the true merits of the case, and which turned on the question whether the creditors, in the case at bar, at the time they received security upon an existing debt from
Page 41
—— their debtor, had reasonable cause to believe he was insolvent. The opinion holds that they had express notice by a letter which brought the security to their hands, and disposes of the technical objection above al- luded to by the plain rule, that when but one inference only can be drawn from the facts of the case, it is a matter of law. Of his opinions, and only a few cursory glances are attempted here, it may be truly said that they disclose force, diligence and vivacity. .There is nothing feigned in them ; on the contrary they possess a genuineness of his own, hearty, and sometimes idiomatic way, based on the primary virtue of justice and the courage to be just. He has an alert mind. ‘ He is one of the quickest,” says a well-known Federal judge, ‘‘to see the point upon which a case turns.” His style reminds one at times of the old Eng- lish judges, and almost rivalling in brevity his associate, Mr. Justice Walton. Eight lines in the case of Hart v. McLellan, 80 Maine, 95, will show this: ‘Haskell, J. Assumpsit against the indorser of a negoti- able promissory note’ payable at a place certain. A careful consideration of the evi- dence fails to show legal notice to the de- fendant of the dishonor of the note. The notice seasonably mdiled was not addressed to a post-office in the city of the defendant’s residence, nor, as the authorities cited by defendant’s counsel clearly show, was rea- sonable diligence used to ascertain the de- fendant’s proper address. Judgment for defendant.” Then, again, when the opinion is full and copious with authorities, it broad- ens and deepens like a New England brook before it joins the bay, coming from pure springs, dashing down over the hill-side to join the vast ocean of the live law. Speaking of cruel and abusive treatment in Holyoke v. Holyoke, 78 Maine, 404, as a cause for divorce, he says: ‘‘ This phrase does not necessarily imply physical violence, thought it may include it. Words and de- portment may work injury as deplorable as The Supreme Court of Maine. er ee ee 575 violence to the person. ‘I will speak dag- gers to her, but use none,’ says Shakespeare. Temperament and character so widely differ, ' that conduct cruel to one, might scarcely annoy a more callous nature. Having in mind the sacred character of the marital relation, and its influence on the happiness and purity of society, as well as upon in- dividuals, not overlooking considerations that may not be freely discussed, each par- ticular case must be judged of by its own particular facts and circumstances. “Divorce should not bea panacea for the infelicities of married life; if disappointment, suffering, and sorrow even be incident to that relation, they must be endured. The marriage yoke, by mutual forbearance, must be worn, even thought it rides unevenly, and has becomes burdensome withal. Public policy requires that it should beso. Remove the allurements of divorce at pleasure, and husbands and wives will the more zealously strive to even the burdens and vexations of life, and soften by mutual accommodation so as to enjoy their marriage relation. ‘Deplorable as it is, from the infirmities of human nature, cases occur where a wilful disregard of marital duty, by act or word, either works, or threatens injury so serious, that a continuance of cohabitation in mar- riage cannot be permitted with safety to the personal welfare and health of the injured party. Both a sound body and a sound mind ‘are required to constitute health. Whatever treatment is proved in such par- ticular case to seriously impair, or to seri- ously threaten to impair either, is like a withering blast, and endangers life, limb, or health, and constitutes the (6) cause for divorce in the act of 1885. Such is the weight of authority.” a His familiarity with decided cases gives him the power of selecting the best materi- als and cases; and he loves to give credit to attorneys who furnish full and orderly briefs. Without “an almost ignominious love of detail,” as Sir Arthur Helps says, he sees all
Page 42
576 there is in a case, and counsel find it so in their practice before him. The curious reader will find an apt illustration of this in Rockland v. Farnsworth, 86 Maine, page 534, a tax suit. A love of order and system, combined with industry, enable him to turn off his judicial labors with ease; and when he re- turns at night to his home, the cares of office do not follow him. Rather indiffer- ent to fame, he would be among the last to The Green Bag. adopt Benvenuto Cellini’s advice, “that all men after they have reached forty should write down their own lives”; nor is it diffi- cult for the believer in heredity to see how his favorite judge has become, to use at military phrase, “a chief of staff” of the court in the midst of his varied usefulness on the bench. He received the degree of Master of Arts from Bowdoin College in 1894. A WAGER ABOUT NAPOLEON THAT DIVIDED THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA. ELL nigh universal as is the attention at present paid to everything Na- poleonic, it can be easily demonstrated by reference to the records of his own times, that during the life of the great Corsican, Americans entertained a no less keen inter- est in his fate than they now do in his his- tory. Indicative of this fact is the cause célébre in the annals of Pennsylvania juris- prudence known as Phillips 7. Ives, decided in 1828, found in the first volume of Rawle’s Reports. The case was appealed from the District Court of Philadelphia to the Su- preme Court of Pennsylvania, having been brought by Phillips against Ives to recover the amount of a wager, the terms of which had been reduced to writing and were as follows : — ‘¢May 14th, 1821. This day Stephen Ives bet one hundred dollars to fifty dollars with John Phil- lips, that Napoleon Bonaparte will, at or before the expiration of two years from the above date, be re- moved or escape from the Island of St. Helena. It is understood between the parties that if Bonaparte should die within the above period of two years, and on the Island of St. Helena, Mr. Ives. loses the bet. (Signed) Stephen Ives. John Phillips. This bet is made in the presence of John F. Swift.” As the reader knows, when the paper was signed, Napoleon had been dead for more than a week, but the transmission of news was then too slow to prevent Ives from mak- ing a public test of his faith in the ex-em- perors good fortune and in his ability to escape from the cage of his British captors. The genius that compelled the whole force of the British Empire to play turnkey against him, and to spy his actual presence in Long- wood at least once every twenty-four hours, secured admiration in Ives sufficiently en- thusiastic and faithful to have enrolled him among ‘“‘the old guard.” However willing he was to stake heavy odds to prove his confidence in a living hero, Ives refused to pay a wager made after death had already taken from him any possibility of winning it. Phillips was inclined to play Shylock, and asked the law to give him the money nomi- nated in the bond, and a jury gave it to him, but the lower court divided over the matter and, notwithstanding the verdict, gave judg- ment against Phillips, whereupon he appealed to the Supreme Court of the State. At the argument before the final tribunal Phillips was represented by Josiah Randall, father of Hon. Samuel J. Randall, late Speaker of
Page 43
A Wager About Napoleon. the House of Representatives. Mr. Randall cited two English cases, both decided before the Revolution, and consequently binding precedents in Pennsylvania, and relied on them to govern the action of the court. In one of them, that of Andrews v. Herne, de- cided in 1662, upon a wager of: twenty pounds to twenty shillings, made six months before the Restoration, that Charles Stuart, who was then in exile, would be king of England within twelve months, the court held such a wager recoverable at law, and gave judgment for the plaintiff. The con- duct of these parties involved high treason to the de facto government, and consequences far more grave to all interested than any that could arise to the United States by rea- son of the wager concerning Bonaparte. The other case, which was intended to meet the objection arising from Bonaparte’s death prior to placing the bet, was that of the Earl of March against Pigott, decided by Lord Mansfield in 1771. There plaintiff and de- fendant agreed at New Market, after dinner; to run the life of Sir William Codrington against Mr. Pigott’s father (as the phrase went), wagering sixteen hundred guineas to five hundred that Codrington Sr. would out- live Pigott Sr. The latter had died at two o'clock in the morning of the very day on which the bet was made, but this fact was not known to the parties. The Court decid- _ ed that Lord March should win the bet and have the five hundred guineas. | P. A. Browne, Esq., who appeared for Ives and who was a distinguished lawyer, the author of Browne’s Reports, opened ar- gument against the wager with these two canonical cases commanding his forensic 577 battery. He sought to outflank them by dwelling on the immorality and demoraliz- ing tendency of wagers, and claimed that this particular one was void because it inter- fered with the feelings and interest of a third person. In the course of his remarks he averred that the agreement between the par- ties to the suit before the court had an in- ternational phase in its possible results, and was an encouragement to one of the parties to do an act that might lead to war between the United States and the powers of Europe. He declared that many schemes, some of them deeply laid and well arranged, had been formed to carry off Napoleon from St. Helena, which were not put into effect mere- ly because they had not received his sanc- tion. | | The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, in a weak opinion by Judge Huston, in which he was joined by two others of its five judges, and which was dissented from by Chief-Jus- tice Gibson and Justice Smith, declared that the court below, in not permitting Phillips to reap the fruits of his prudent wager, was right, and laid down the principle that no wager concerning a human being could be recovered in any court of justice. This case is also of present interest from its having been in part the foundation of the © law that designates the purchase of stock on margin as a gambling transaction, and one that brokers cannot enforce against their customers by process of law, it having been relied upon by the Supreme Court of Penn- sylvania in Brua’s Appeal, decided in 1867, when they laid down the above principle much complained of to-day by the Stock Exchange. OWEN B, JENKINS.
Page 44
578 Lhe Green Bag. THE OPENING OF PARLIAMENT. SKETCHED BY A PARLIAMENTARY JOURNALIST. HE opening of Parliament by the Queen is one of the most brilliant and im- pressive spectacles in the world; and even when performed by Royal Commission it is —though, naturally, shorn of much of its splendor by the absence of the sovereign —a stately and interesting ceremony. Parliament is summoned in the name of the sovereign, but really by the cabinet. A proclamation signed by the Queen is published in the ‘ London Gazette’’— the official organ of the Government — calling together the lords, spiritual and temporal, and the representatives of the people, for the transaction of divers urgent and impor- tant business in the Palace of Westminster onacertain day. Tuesday or Thursday is usually chosen; and two o'clock is always the hour fixed for the opening ceremony. In the morning, the extensive cellars beneath the Houses of Parliament are searched by a number of Yeomen of the Guards, or the Guards of the Tower of London, clad in their quaint and picturesque uniforms. This searching of the cellars originated after the attempt of Guy Fawkes to blow up the two Houses and their members in the days of James I; and such is the un- willingness of Parliament to part with any of its ceremonies, which, though now use- less for their original purpose, give a charm to its proceedings, that this custom has sur- vived for nearly three centuries, and will probably last as long as Parliament itself. The members of the House of Commons begin to assemble about nine o’clock. They are obliged to come down thus early in order to secure seats in the Chamber, for, curiously enough, it accommodates only about half of the 670 members of the House. A member secures a seat by placing his hat upon it. But, according to the rules and regulations of the House, it must be his ” real working hat, and not a colorless substi- tute. This means that if a member were to bring a second hat with him, and were to leave the House for a walk in the streets, he would forfeit all right to the seat on which he had placed the other hat. Mem- bers must, therefore, stay about the precincts of the House, no matter how early they may have made their appearance; but this they can do very comfortably, having at Westmin- ster all the advantages of a first-class club, dining-rooms, tea-rooms, smoking-rooms, library, bath-rooms and a large staff of atten- dants. The only members of the House who have not to fight for seats are ministers, for whom the Treasury Bench, or the front bench near the table and to the right of the Speaker, is reserved; and ex-ministers, who occupy what is called the Front Opposition Bench, at the opposite side of the table and, therefore, to the left of the Speaker. As two o’clock approaches, a most im- posing array of shining silk hats, with just a slight sprinkling of low hats and soft felts, is seen on the benches on each side of the House, while the members are gathered together in groups, irrespective of party, chatting, joking and laughing, relating their experiences during the recess, or discussing political prospects of the session. Suddenly the animated buzz of conversation in the chamber is stilled by cries of: ‘ Way for the Speaker! Way for the Speaker!” which resound in stentorian tones through the lobbies outside; and the cry is followed by a rush of members to their places. The benches are now thronged, and members respectfully stand uncovered to receive the Speaker. Arrayed in a flowing silk gown, knee- breeches, silk stockings, shoes with silver buckles, on his head a huge wig, with wings that fall down at each side over his should-
Page 45
The Opening of Parliament. 579 ers, and carrying his. three-cornered hat in his right hand, the Speaker — attended by - his chaplain in a Geneva gown, and the Sergeant-at-arms, in court or levée dress, a sword by his side, and carrying the huge bronze mace on his right shoulder — marches slowly and solemnly up the floor of the Chamber, and as he approaches the chair which he is to occupy, he makes it three low obeisances. Prayers are then recited by the chaplain, the members still standing and facing the Speaker; but, at a particular passage in the service, they all turn round and face the wall. Service over, the chaplain retreats down the floor, with his face to the Speaker, to whom he bows at every few steps of his retrograde movement, till he finally disappears through the glass swing doors of the Chamber. The Chamber is now crowded with mem- bers. In single file they pass the Chair, and shake hands with the Speaker. . But before half the members have tendered their greet- ings to the Speaker, a cry again resounds through the lobby outside. ‘This time it is “ Black Rod! Way for Black Rod!” It puts an end to the shaking of the Speaker’s hand, for the members at once return to their seats. ‘‘ Black Rod,” however, would not appear to be a welcomed visitor to the House of Commons if one judged merely by the reception accorded him. The moment the shout of ‘‘ Way for Black Rod,” reaches the Sergeant-at-Arms, he springs from his chair, rushes to the open door, slams it with a most inhospitable bang right in the face of the approaching ‘ Black Rod,” and securely locks and bolts it. It was certainly a narrow squeak — a mo- ment more and ‘“ Black Rod” would have been’ down on the Chamber, horse, foot, and artillery. Members, however, do. not look in the least alarmed; and to tell the truth they do not need to be affrighted. The House of Commons is full of odd ways, peculiarities, and traditions; and as “ Black Rod” is the messenger of the Upper Cham- ber, this ceremony of slamming the door in his face is the immemorial way in which the Commons show their independence of the Lords. By this time the Sergeant-at-Arms is peer- ing through a grating in the the door out into the lobby. Presently three faint knocks are heard at the door. The knocks are intended to indicate that ‘ Black Rod” requests admission to the House of Com- mons, and does not demand it as a right. In response to this humble summons, the doors are flung wide open by the Sergeant- at-Arms, at a signal from the Speaker, and in walks ‘ Black Rod.” | His mission on the present occasion is to summon the Commons to the House of Lords to hear the Queen’s speech. He marches up the floor, making three low bows to the Chair, and on reaching the table deliv- ers his message to the Speaker, while all the members are on their feet with heads uncov- ered, as a mark of respect to the sovereign. Should Parliament be opened by the Queen in person, “‘ Black Rod” says: ‘“ Mr. Speaker, the Queen commands this honorable House to attend Her Majesty immediately in the House of Peers”; but in the absence of the Queen, the summons comes from the Lords Commissioners; ‘‘ Black Rod” on the “command” to a “ desire.” “Black Rod” then retreats backwards down the floor, and it is only when he reach- es the door that he turns his back on the | Commons. The Speaker, attended by the Sergeant-at-Arms bearing the mace on his shoulder, and accompanied by the members in a mass behind, follows ‘“ Black Rod” out through the lobbies to the Bar of the House of Lords. When the Queen opens Parliament in person, the spectacle in the Upper Chamber is very brilliant; and so keen is the desire of the Commons-to witness the ceremony, that they hustle and jostle and shoulder each other, and press closely on the heels of the Speaker, in their eagerness to secure good
Page 46
580 places in the very limited space allotted to them in the House of Lords. | At the opening of Parliament by the Queen in 1851, Mr. Joseph Hume complained in the House of Commons that he had been. roughly treated in the Upper Chamber dur- ing the ceremony. ‘“ I neither saw the Queen nor heard her voice,” said he, plaintively. ‘I was crushed into a corner; my head was knocked against a post, and I might have been much injured if a stout member, to whom I am much obliged, had not come to my assistance.” On another occasion a member had his coat torn and his shoulder dislocated during the scrimmage. When the Sovereign is present, the spec- tacle in the House of Lords is full of color and ablaze with jewels. The Queen sits on the throne, a magnificent oaken chair, richly carved and raised on a crimson dais at the end of the chamber. She wears a miniature crown of diamonds round a white cap, from which long white streamers depend at each side. The robe of state, a long, sweeping, ermine cloak, is thrown loosely over her shoulders, so as not to hide the broad blue ribbon and the star of the Order of the Gar- ter, which she wears over her customary black dress, the splendid necklace of dia- monds, and the flashing Koh-i-noor on her breast. The Prince of Wales in his robes sits on a chair to the right of the throne, while grouped around are the officers of state in scarlet and gold. The crimson benches are crowded with the peers in their scarlet robes, with the bishops in their black, flowing robes and lawn sleeves of liberal amplitude; and the galleries around are bright with the fair. faces, the variegated dresses, the diamonds and flowers of peeresses and other ladies of high degree. This brilliant picture is magni- Lhe Green Bag. ficently framed by the dark oak panelling of the chamber. The speech, which, written by the prime minister and approved by the cabinet, gives a forecast of the business of the session, is usually read by the sovereign, or by the Lord Chancellor, at her command. When Her Majesty is absent the most conspicuous figures in the ceremony are five personages sitting all in a row on a bench beneath the throne, and wearing scarlet robes trimmed with white fur, and black three-cornered hats. The center figure is the Lord Chancellor, the president of the House of Lords; and the four others are the Lords High Commissioners, who are appointed by the Queen to act on her behalf when she does not open Parliament in person. The Clerk of Parliament, by which title the chief clerk in the House of Lords is designated — a gentleman robed in gown and wig like a barrister in a court of justice ——reads the Royal Commission, a huge piece of parch- ment liberally spotted with red sealing-wax, which is the royal authority for the opening of Parliament. Then the Lord Chancellor, still retaining his seat, his head covered by his curious black hat, reads ‘“ The Queen’s Speech,” and Parliament is opened. The Speaker and the members of the House of Commons troop back again to their own chamber. The Speaker takes the chair, bows to the assembly, and without a word disappears from the House. The Com- mons assemble again at four o’clock; the Speaker reads the Queen’s speech; an ad- dress in answer to the speech is moved and seconded by two members of the party in | office; and a debate ensues in which the policy of the government is criticised by the opposition, and defended by the minis- terialists.
Page 47
Old World Trials. 581 OLD WORLD TRIALS. XII. SWINFEN v. SWINFEN. HE case of Swinfen v. Swinfen possesses so much intrinsic and extrinsic interest that I shall deal with it in some detail. The plaintiff, Mrs. Patience Swinfen, pro- pounded the will of her father-in-law under which she took estates worth about £ 60,000. The will was disputed by the heir-at-law, Frederick Hay Swinfen, and in July, 1855, the master of the rolls directed an issue to try its validity. The issue came on for trial at the Gafford Assizes, before Mr. Justice Crenwell and a jury, in March, 1856. Sir Frederick Thesiger was leading counsel for the plaintiff, Sir Alexander Cockburn, then attorney-general, represented the defendant. At the close of the first day of the trial ne- gotiations for an arrangement took place be- tween Thesiger and Cockburn, and ultimately the following terms were finally agreed upon and embodied in a memorandum : — ‘Terms of compromise. Juror to be with- drawn. Estate to be conveyed by plaintiff at law to defendant in fee, free of incum- brance if any, erected since the death of Samuel Swinfen (the testator) such convey- ance to date from Michaelmas 1855. | De- fendant to secure to plaintiff an annuity on her life on the estate of £1000 a year. Plaintiff's costs as between attorney and client not exceeding 41250 to be paid by defendant. Power to either party to make this agreement a rule of court. In event of any question arising on the above terms, the same to be referred to Sir Fred- erick Thesiger and the Attorney-General. The house and grounds to be occupied by plaintiff without payment of rent till Mich- aelmas next.” This memorandum was em- bodied in an order of mzs¢ prius which was afterwards made a rule of court. It may well be doubted whether any compromise before or since has given rise to such a crop of litigation. The negotiations had been entered into in consequence of an observa- tion made by the learned judge as to the course that the case seemed to be taking, and were conducted and concluded in the absence of the plaintiff. The plaintiff did not, however, on her return repudiate the compromise that had been arrived at. Soon afterwards Mrs. Swinfen seems to have de- termined upon a different line of action. She refused to execute the compromise, and the Court of Common Pleas declined, on a. technical ground, to order her attachment for the refusal. The Court of Chancery, ‘following the law,” refused to enforce itona bill for specific performance; a new trial of the issue was directed. Mrs. Swinfen ob- tained a verdict, which was upheld on ap- peal, and the Swinfen estates came into her possession and power at last. Now for this happy issue she was, and indeed admitted herself to be, largely indebted to the energy ‘and ability of Mr. Charles Raun Kennedy, barrister at law, whose acquaintance she had made in April, 1856, and who acted for her in all the proceedings subsequent to the re- fusal of the Court of Common Pleas to order an attachment. A warm friendship sprang up between counsel and client. Mr. Ken- nedy had taken no fees for his services ex- cept such as were paid by way of costs by Mrs. Swinfen’s opponents. In May, 1859, however, he thought it time to make some provision for the future, and induced Mrs. Swinfen to convey the estate recovered in the litigation, to himself in fee, subject to her own life-interest and other charges. The draft of this deed was prepared by Mr. Kennedy, but it was engrossed by a separate solicitor selected by Mrs. Swinfen, who, in
Page 48
582 The Green Bag. the’ course of a long interview, fully ex- plained to her its nature and effect. It ap- pears that Mrs. Swinfen had also repeatedly and in unequivocal terms expressed her in- tention of giving Mr. Kennedy 420,000 when she came into her estates. Before this promise was fulfilled, Mrs. Swinfen, who had been a widow since 1854, gave herself in marriage to one Charles Wilsone Brown. Mr. Kennedy then sought to enforce pay- ment of his long-promised outstanding fee. But the court held that no binding contract could be founded on a promise to pay a barrister for his services — a doctrine with which the case of Kennedy v. Brown is now in legal minds inseparably associated. The next scene in the play was the filing of a bill by Charles Wilsone Brown and Patience, his wife, to set aside the deed of May, 1859, and here again Mr. Kennedy was unsuccessful. The Master of the Rolls, Sir John Romilly, held (1) that the influence arising from the relation between the parties still. subsisted strongly at the date of the deed, and there- fore that the transaction could not stand as a gift; (2) that theprevious promises of Mrs. Swinfen to pay Kennedy 420,000 for his services were insufficient to support the deed founded on contract; and (3) that the deed could not be upheld as having been exe- cuted in the fair performance of a moral ob- ligation. Brown v. Kennedy is a case not less important than Kennedy v. Brown. So far Mrs. Swinfen had won all along the line, but an action which she raised against Sir Frederick Thesiger—then Lord Chelms- ford — (Swinfen v. Lord Chelmsford) for having exceeded his authority as counsel, was dismissed, and the immunity of English barristers was settled on the principles after- wards affirmed and amplified in Strauss v. Francis (1866, L. R. 12 B. 379) and Mun- ster v. Lamb (49 Law Times, 252). LEx. Pu os
Page 49
oY . Current Topies, . . —_—-—— Notes of Cases, ete. ———e ts zs ite ste ste BY IRVING BROWNE. fie ss CURRENT TOPICS. MarsHAL Ney. — Although Dr. Owens seems to have given credulity a rest during the past season, yet midsummer was not suffered to go by without some madness, and so the public have been called upon to believe that Marshal Ney was not executed by the Bourbons after Waterloo, but escaped to this country and died in North Carolina, in 1846, in the order of pedagogy. This is a very ingenious tale, and not too improbable for belief by the people who take stock in the Bacon business. Substantially told, it is as follows: when the Marshal was led out to be shot, he whispered to the firing-party, «‘ Aim high.” Contrary to all custom, their pieces had not been handed to them ready-loaded, but they had been permitted to load them, and so they humanely omitted the bullets. (Ney’s caution was therefore su- perfluous.) At the explosion he fell and pressed up- on his breast a theatrical preparation to simulate blood. If his body was examined, the surgeon must have been in the plot, and so must the burying party, for he mounted a fast horse and rode eighty miles that night, took ship for this country and settled in North Carolina. To disarm inquiry (?) he took the name of Peter S. Ney. He set at work to qualify himself as a school teacher, and passed the rest of his life in that vocation, in which he was very successful. He had a remarkable knowledge of Napoleon and his campaigns. He was a remarkably skillful swords- man. He fainted (not feinted) away on hearing of Napoleon’s death, and afterwards tried to commit suicide. He looked upon the wine when it was red, more or less. He was recognized on several occa- sions, but prevailed on those persons to depart on their own recognizance and keep their counsel. On his deathbed he declared that he was Marshal Ney. He had prepared a memoir of his life and adventures, but it has disappeared, which is an unfortunate over- sight. | It is said that after Louis Napoleon came to power the Marshal’s coffin was opened and discovered to be empty. The reason given for his secrecy was his fear that if the Bourbons learned of the fraud, they would confiscate his property, which had been allowed to descend to his family, He asserted that it was agreed between Napoleon and himself, on the first abdica- tion, that the former should return to France when the time was ripe. It is difficult to reconcile this with Ney’s hesitation about going over to Napoleon, and with Napoleon’s hesitation about employing Ney in the Waterloo campaign, which he did not overcome until the very eve of Quatre Bras, two days before the great battle. Ney was the son of a cooper, and his early educa- tion had been narrow, and yet this person is repre- sented as having become a liberal scholar and an ef- fective teacher. Why this engaging story has been kept so still all the years before and since the peda- gogue’s death is not explained. In short, the tale is not more plausible than Archbishop Whately’s contention that Napoleon never lived. We feel moved to try our own hand at these matters, and to suggest that Napoleon did not die at St. Helena, but was brought back alive in the pageant of 1840, hav- ing at the time of his pretended death been given a sleeping potion (@ /a Juliet), which should prove potent unless his body was exposed to the air. We discover ourselves believing this already. How else can one account for the perfect preservation of the great man’s remains when his coffin was opened just previous to the removal to France nineteen years later? He was only in a trance, natural or artificial, accidental or designed, and this being granted, the rest is easy as winking. Really we must work this up. To be sure, it will be a little difficult to account for his inaction during the Crimean war, and we must assume that he was really dead in 1870, for if he had been alive the army never would have been penned up in Metz or Sedan, nor have surrendered so tamely. But how we would have liked to see him pitted against that paper-strategist, von Moltke! Yet how do we account for Peter’s tale, assuming that it has been truthfully reported? Why, on the safe old the- ory that he allowed his imagination to run riot when he had dallied long with the wine-cup. There isa kind of poetical balance effected by the story, for as the world was once assured of a lost Bourbon up in Canada, so now it is treated to a lost Bonapartist down in Carojina. Let one cancel the other.
Page 50
584 COOPER AS A LITIGANT. — Owing to Mark Twain, James Fenimore Cooper is enjoying a late resurrec- tion. Comment on his career is not exactly a cur- rent topic, but it may pass as a ‘* preserved ” current. Mark Twain makes merry over Leatherstocking’s marvelous skill in hitting the painted head of a nail at the distance of a hundred yards, with a rifle ball, and attributes to him the ocular properties which Sam Weller disclaimed in court on the Bardell-Pick- wick trial. But it is indisputable that there are now and always have been plenty of marksmen who could hit anything that they can see, at that distance ; and now comes Mr. Seymour Van Santwood, a lawyer of Troy, N. Y., who testifies, in the ‘¢ Troy Times,” that he knows by experiment, that he can see a white- painted ordinary nail-head at that distance, although he modestly admits. that he could not hit it. Despite Mark Twain, Leatherstocking will long remain ‘‘ one of the prize-men in fiction,” as Thack- eray called him. In that famous death-scene of Col- onel Newcome, so much cited and admired, where the Colonel exclaims, ‘‘ Adsum!” Thackeray un- questionably cribbed from Cooper, who had previ- ously made Leatherstocking, in the death-scene in ‘¢ The Prairie,’’ exclaim ‘«* Here!’’? The resemblance is too close to have been accidental, and Thackeray was always a devout admirer of Cooper’s work. It is not generally known by this generation who know not James, that he was one of the sturdiest lit- igants who ever flourished in the State of New York. He was continually suing the newspapers for intem- perate criticisms of his novels and his ‘* Naval His- tory,’ and of himself under guise of such criticisms. It must be admitted that the criticisms in question were very savage, and that the newspapers in his time were fully as violent and partisan as they now are; but it is apparent that Cooper had not learned the art of regarding such criticisms as good advertise- ments, and submitting to them if not welcoming them, as the later writers have done (always except- ing Charles Reade), on account of the enhanced sales which they never fail to bring to their literary wares. Cooper’s slander or libel suits are reported in no less than five volumes of New York reports, and they af- ford amusing reading. In Cooper v. Greeley and Mc- Elrath, 1 Denio, 347 (1845), the novelist sued the proprietors of the «« New York Tribune,” for stating that he would not be likely to bring a libel suit, which he had begun against them, to trial ‘¢in New York, for we are known here, nor in Otsego, for he 7s known there.’ The court held this last expression libellous on demurrer. The original libel suit, as we infer from this report, grew out of still another libel suit, which he had brought against Thurlow Weed, and which was tried at Fonda, which Weed had tried — to postpone on account of illness in his family, which The Green Bag. resulted in an inquest and judgment for $400, and in relation to which the ‘‘ Tribune” people had said playfully : ‘«* Knowing what we positively did and do of the severe illness of the wife of Mr. Weed, and the dangerous state of his eldest daughter, at the time of the Fonda trials in question — the jokes attempted to be cut by Fenimore over their condition, his talk of the story growing up from one girl to the mother and three or four daughters, his fun about their prob- ably having the Asiatic cholera among them, or some other contagious disease, etc., etc. — however it may have sounded to others, did seem to us rather inhu — hallo there! We had like to put our foot right into it again, after all our tuition.” The «« Tribune” people, in their plea in this case, averred that Cooper, being known to the inhabitants of Otsego, had acquired ‘¢the reputation of a proud, captious, censorious, ar- bitrary, dogmatical, malicious, illiberal, revengeful, and litigious man,” and was *‘in bad repute” there, and that was all they meant by the words sued for! Seward appeared for the defendants. Those were the days when the philosopher Greeley, the humani- tarian Seward, and the party manager Weed were very friendly and harmonious, loving one another’s friends and hating one another’s enemies. Jewett, J., required nine pages of print to convince himself and the court that the publication was libellous. It seems that Cooper had brought separate suits against the proprietors and the editors of the «* Even- ing Journal,” for the libel referred to above, for in 2 Howard’s Practice Reports, 40, is reported an unsuc- cessful motion to consolidate them. On this motion the famous Nicholas Hill, Junior, appeared as coun- sel for Cooper, and Marcus T. Reynolds for Weed. R. Cooper was Cooper’s attorney. In 1840, was reported the case of Cooper v. Bar- ber, 24 Wendell, 105. The defendant, as editor of the «* Otsego Republican,” had published an article from the ‘* Chenango Telegraph,” averring that ‘¢ This gentleman, not satisfied with having drawn down upon his head universal contempt froni abroad, has done the same thing for himself at Cooperstown, where he resides.” Barber added some remarks of his own about a controversy between Cooper and some other Cooperstowners in relation to Three-Mile Point, a piece of land projecting into Otsego Lake. There was a verdict for plaintiff, and the Supreme Court now denied a new trial. Here Bronson, J., observed : ‘«* Good morals, as well as the law, forbid that the addition of some truth should be deemed a palliation of the wrong of publishing a libel.”” The European contempt referred to probably grew out of Cooper’s patriotic Naval History. In 1840, in Codper v. Stone, 24 Wendell, 434, we find the report of a libel suit against the editor of the ‘¢ New York Commercial Advertiser,” for criticisms
Page 51
The Lawyer's Easy Chair. 585 on the Naval History and ‘* Home as Found,” on account of Cooper’s apologies for the conduct of Cap- tain Elliott, who flunked in the Battle of Lake Erie. The article in question was a trenchant piece of writ- ing. It accused the historian of a disregard of jus- tice and propriety, represented him as infatuated with vanity, mad with passion, and the sympathetic apol- ogist of another stigmatized with ingratitude and per- fidy, and charged him with publishing as true, state- ments and evidence falsified and encomiums retract- ed ; «* deliberately penning an untrue account of the battle,”? as the court say. The declaration was held good on demurrer, the matter in question not being privileged. On this argument the family appeared as counsel — R. Cooper, and the plaintiff zz pro. er. Of counsel for the defendant was Marshall J. Bidwell, a celebrated New York City lawyer, a Canadian ref- ugee. Mr. Stone in this article charged that Cooper was ‘‘his own worst enemy,” ‘‘remained in the cock-pit rather than to go aloft,” and had ‘ well nigh made shipwreck of his reputation as a writer.” The court said, ‘‘ This is the first attempt to try the question of privilege by a demurrer to the declara- tion.” We infer that Cooper recovered three hundred dol- lars in this action, for in the court of errors, in Stone uv. Cooper, 2 Denio, 293, is reported an appeal from an award of arbitrators for that amount, in regard to which Stone had published in the «* New York Spec- tator” the following : — ‘¢Mr. J. Fenimore Cooper need not be so fidgety in his anxiety to finger the cash to be paid by us to- ward his support. It will be forthcoming on the last day allowed by the award, but we are not disposed to allow him to put it into Wall Street for shaving purposes before that period. Wait patiently. There will be no locksmith necessary to get at the ready.” For this Cooper sued, alleging that the reference to the locksmith intended a disgraceful charge of break- ing a lock to get at money on execution against An- drew M. Barber, the defendant in the first suit above mentioned. This clause was thrown out by the court, but Cooper had a verdict of $250, which Cowen upheld. This was reversed by the court of errors, fifteen to five, the chancellor writing with the majority, and the court holding that ‘ shaving,’’ in the sense of buying existing securities at a larger rate of discount than the lawful interest, ‘‘is a legitmate and legal business,” practiced by ‘* respectable brok- ers in Wall Street,” and therefore nothing illegal, immoral, or disgraceful was charged. Four senators delivered concurring opinions. But Barlow, senator, wrote on the other side, declaring that «« One who has justly acquired the reputation of a shaver is uni- versally regarded with dislike and suspicion by all well balanced minds and in all well regulated com- | States have provided for the case by statute. munities.” In this case Walworth gives a learned history of usury. On this argument the great Joshua A. Spencer appeared for Stone. What became of © the action after this we cannot trace in the reports. These Cooper cases have been regarded as leading cases in New York, and have been much cited; as for example in More v. James Gordon Bennett, 48 N. Y., 472. It is recorded that Cooper had Stone indicted in Otsego County for libel, and that the de- fendant was acquitted. On this trial, parts of the book in question, ‘¢‘ Home as Found,’ were read to the jury, and it was thought that this settled the is- sue against Cooper. 3 As has been shown, Cooper was a gritty litigant, and on the whole it is apparent that he had good cause for going to law. We do not know that he had received a legal education, although he acted as his own counsel on some of his trials, but as he was a fogy of the strictest order, he not only opposed the march of modern improvement toward his own vil- lage — fighting off the railroads all his life — but he was a zealous hater of law reform, and in one of his last trashy novels, ‘¢‘ The Ways of the Hour,” he roundly abused the New York code of procedure, trial by jury and the popular election of judges. He deemed trial by jury unfit fora democracy. The plot of this novel, which involved a murder trial, is gro- tesque, and shows a laughable ignorance of legal prin- ciples and procedure and a considerable want of com- mon sense. Although Cooper idealized the Ameri- can Indian, he did not like the «* Anti-Rent Indians,” being an aristocratic landlord, and he denounces them heartily in one of his tales. Cooper was not so good a lawyer as Gerrit Smith, another great New York landholder, and a famous abolitionist, who de- fended the ‘+ Jerry Rescuers,” and in that case de- livered, as Judge Marvin informed the writer, one of the most superb legal arguments to which he ever listened. NOTES OF CASES. LARCENY — BRINGING GOODS INTO STATE. — ‘¢The glorious uncertainty of the common law”? is well illustrated by the decisions upon the question whether a person may be indicted for larceny com- mitted by bringing into the State goods which he has stolen in another State. The common law doctrine was that one could not be indicted in one country for larceny committed by bringing into that country goods which he had stolen in another, and this has been held in Virginia to apply as between the States of the Union. Strouther v. Com., 22 Southeast. Rep. 252, stress is laid on the fact that a sufficient remedy is provided by extradition. Some of the Disa-
Page 52
586 greeing with this doctrine are Stanley v. State, 24 Ohio St. 166; 15 Am. Rep. 604; State v. Ellis, 11 Vermont, 650; State v. Underwood, 49 Me. 181; - Watson v. State, 36 Miss. 593; State v. Johnson, 2 Oreg. 115; State v. Bennett, 14 lowa, 479; Ferrell v. Com., I Duvall, 150; Com, wv. White, 123 Mass. 430; 25 Am. Rep. 116; Worthington v. State, 58 Md. 403; 42 Am. Rep. 338; Powell vw. State, 52 Wis., 217; State v. Newman, 9 Nev. 48; 16 Am. Rep. 3; People v. Williams, 24 Mich. 164. On the other hand, agreeing with the Virginia case are Lee uv. State, 66 Ga. 203; 37 Am. Rep. 67; People v. Gardner, 2 Johns. 477; State v. LeBlanch, 2 Vroom, 82; Simmons v. Com., 5 Binney, Pa. 617; State v. Brown, 1 Haywood (N. C.), 100; Simpson v. State, 4 Humph (Tenn.), 456; Beall v. State, 15 Ind. 378; State v. Reonnals, 14 La. Am. 298. So here we have arrayed the States—or all of them which we have discovered — twelve adjudging the.act lar- ceny, and nine that it is not. The theory upon which the Virginia doctrine is maintained is clearly an- nounced in the Maryland case above, namely, that although a thief may not be punished in one State for a larceny committed in another, yet if he brings the stolen goods into the former State, he may be punished as for ‘‘a new larceny.’ This is a very shadowy distinction. The only real larceny is in the foreign State. Certainly the thief does not ‘ take and carry away the goods of another” in the second State, for he brings them into that State with him- self. We think the Virginia decision is right, and that the doctrine of constructive and fresh larceny is unsound. ‘¢ KINDERGARTEN.’’— In Sinnott wv. Colomber, California Supreme Court, 28 L. R. A. 594, it was ‘held that the court would take judicial notice of the meaning of this word, observing : — ‘‘ We think we may take judicial cognizance of its signif- _ icance, as the supreme court of Colorado has apparently - done. Re Kindergarten Schools, 18 Colo. 234, 19 L. R. A. 469. Thus informed, we find that the term ‘ kindergarten’ (meaning literally ‘a garden of children’ ) was devised by Friedrich W. A. Froebel, German philosopher and educa- tor, to apply to a system which he elaborated for the in- struction of children of very tender years. ‘Children’s gar- den’ ought to be taken in its allegorical sense. The child is a plant, the school is a garden, and Froebel calls teachers ‘gardeners of children.’ Compayré, History of Pedagogy, § 537, Payne’s translation. ‘He,saw that the child’s in- born desire for activity manifests itself in play, and that children love to play together. His system, therefore, guides this inclination into organized movement, and in- vests the games (unknown to the child) with an ethical and educational value, teaching, besides physical exercises, the habits of discipline, self-control, harmonious action and purpose, together with some definite lesson of fact.’ Sen- nenschein’s Cyclopaedia of Education, p. 169.” ~The Green Bag. BicycLEs. —In Thompson v. Dodge, Minnesota Supreme Court, 28 L. R. A. 608, it was held that a person driving a horse has no rights in the highway superior to those of one riding a bicycle. The court said : — ‘In the use of a public highway, there are certain rights of the road which must be observed by all persons, and a violation of those rights constitutes actionable negligence. A bicycle is a vehicle used now very extensively for con- venience, recreation, pleasure, and business, and the riding of one upon the public highway in the ordinary manner as is now done is neither unlawful nor prohibited, and they cannot be banished because they were not ancient vehicles, and used in the Garden of Eden by Adam and Eve.” So in Pennsylvania recently a wheelman recovered for the destruction of his wheel which he left standing against the curbstone, and which a heavy wagon ran over. . ‘¢ INFLAMMATORY.’ — This was the adjective ap- plied by Mr. Clair, of Nebraska, an attorney, to a charge made by Judge Scott to a grand jury, on a mo- tion to quash an indictment. The Judge considered the dignity of the court infringed and undertook to punish Mr. Scott for contempt of court. The matter went to the Supreme Court, and it was there held (40 Neb. 534) that the adjective was well deserved and that the attorney should go Scott free. The charge was on the subject of bribery, and was a red- hot one, and wound up with the following explosion of rhetorical rockets : — ** A little well directed effort on your part, as grand jur- ors, in the direction here indicated, would doubtless open up a field into which a stone could not be thrown without hitting a criminal. You should see to it that the stone is thrown, and thrown hard. You owe it to yourselves, the people whom you represent in your present service, and to your sworn obligations to make that effort, and to make it with such an uncompromising zeal that hereafter a mark more indelible than that put upon Cain shall be A&tamped upon their foreheads, marking them as ‘ ticket of leave men’ and moral blisters upon the body politic. There comes up from the people a command for a forward march all along the line of your duty. You should give heed to that cry, for it comes from a patient and long-suffering en- durance which has at last reached its limit.” The court cited definitions of «« inflammatory ” from Webster's Dictionary, and concluded that it was ** an impassioned appeal, if not indeed express direction, to the grand jury to present, by indictment, certain persons not named, but who are assumed to be guilty of the crime of bribery. In that sense, if not inflam- matory, it is at least what, in the science of medi- cine, is denominated heroic treatment.”? Judge Scott meant well, but erred through that which Talleyrand so much deprecated — zeal. We congratulate Mr. Clair on his pluck. He is Young-man-not-afraid-of- the-Judge.
Page 53
The Green Bag. PUBLISHED MONTHLY, AT $4.00 PER ANNUM. SINGLE NUMBERS, 50 CENTS. Communications in regard to the contents of the Magazine should be addressed to the Editor, ‘ 4 ‘ Se The Editor will be glad té receive contributions of articles of moderate length upon subjects of inter- est lo the profession; also anything in the way of legal antiquities or curiosities, faceti@, anec- dotes, etc. “THE GREEN BAGQG.” TOR the coming year we are able to offer our readers a great number of choice legal tid- for 1896 will not only be kept up to its standard of the past, but will be more readable and en- joyable than ever before. contents will remain unchanged. SHORT ARTICLES upon topics of general interest | to the profession will be contributed by well-known members of the Bar. Many of these will prove of more than ordinary interest. The series of OLD Wor.pD TRIALS will be con- tinued and include many English and German causes célebres, The ILLUSTRATED articles will be an especial | feature. Among these may be mentioned a con- tinuation of the series on THE ENGLISH Law Courts. These will include :— The Queen’s Bench Division ; The Ecclesiastical Courts ; The.Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Divisions ; The County Courts ; The Criminal Courts ; The articles on ‘THE SUPREME Courts of the several states will be continued. An extremely interesting description of THE Law Courts or BeELcium will appear in an early number. A series of articles entitled, CHAPTERS IN THE ENGLISH Law or Lunacy, will prove an interest- ing feature. An article on ‘THE BENCH AND BAR oF NEW York will attract much attention. All the above named articles will be profusely illustrated. There will also be the usual supply of Facetize and anecdote. The character of its | HORACE W. FULLER, 15% Beacon Street, Boston, Mass. LEGAL ANTIQUITIES. Tur German laws refer to cases in which a a woman might demand justice of aman person- ally in the lists, and not only are instances on rec- ord in which this was done, as in a case at Berne, in 1228, in which the woman was the victor, but it was of sufficiently frequent occurrence to have an established mode of procedure, which is preserved - to us in all its details by illuminated manuscripts of bits and can promise them that THE GREEN Bac | the period. ‘The chances between such unequal _ adversaries were adjusted by placing the man up to navel in a pit three feet wide, tying his left hand behind his back, and arming him only with a club, while his fair opponent had the free use of her limbs, and was furnished with a stone as large as the fist, or weighing from one to five pounds, fastened in a piece of stuff. In certain cases the man was provided with three clubs. If in deliv- ering a blow he touched the earth with hand or arm, he forfeited one of the clubs; if this hap- pened thrice his last weapon was gone, he was adjudged defeated, and the woman could order his execution. On the other hand, the woman was similarly furnished with three weapons. If she struck the man while he was disarmed she, forfeited one, and with the loss of the third she was at his mercy, and was liable to be buried alive. FACETIA. ‘‘] HEARD a report,” said a witness in a cele- brated case. ‘Never mind what reports you heard,” interrupted the lawyer. ‘State only what you know.’ “ But it was the report of a gun,” remarked the witness, whereat Bench and Bar laughed without reproval. At a late term of Emanuel County court, Ga., a lawyer had been absent from the court-room, as he feared, beyond his leave. As he hastened back he inquired of an old negro who was leaning against the gate: “Uncle, can you tell me what case they are trying now?” Whereupon, the 587
Page 54
588 The Green Bag. darkey answered, “It’s one o’ dem cases of de- licious mischuff.’”’” The lawyer hurried on, to find the court engaged’ in trying a man for alleged bigamy. A LIQUOR case was on trial, and one of the offi- cers who had made the raid testified that a num- ber of bottles were found on the premises. “‘ What was in the bottles ?’”’ asked the judge of the witness. “‘ Tiquor, your honor.” “What kind of liquor?” : “7 don’t know, sir.”’ “ Didn’t you taste it or smell of it?” “ Both, your honor.”’ “What! do you mean to say that you are not a judge of liquor?” “ No, sir; I’m not a judge; I’m only a police- man.” The witness was excused from answering any further questions. | JosEpH H. CuoaTeE is an expert in handling two-edged-sword repartee. His skill is such that he seldom meets one who is able to hold his own with him. He met his match not long ago while trying a case before the Surrogate. An old woman was being questioned by him | ‘ about how the testator had looked when he made a remark to her about some relatives. ‘““ Now, how can I remember. He’s been dead two years,” she replied testily. ‘“‘Js your memory so poor that you can’t re- member two years back?” continued Choate. The old woman was silent and Choate asked: “Did he look, when he spoke, anything like me? ”’ ‘Seems to me he did have the same sort of a vacant look!”’ snapped the witness with fire in her eyes. The court-room was convulsed, and Choate had no further questions. AT a certain assize held recently in the south of England, the jury could not agree, and were - locked up. After a long and animated discussion, a division was taken, when ten were found to be for convic- tion and two for acquittal. : Another long and acrimonious debate followed, and eventually a big, burly farmer, who was _lead- ing the majority, went over to the diminutive individual, who, with a companion, formed the minority, and, assuming his most aggressive atti- tude, said, ‘“‘ Now, then, are you two going to give in?” “No!” defiantly replied the small man. “Very well,” was the answer; “then us ten will!” And they did! NOTES. ACCIDENT of birth has played an important part in destiny in all ages, but never more pointedly than in the case of Sir William Scott (Lord Stow- ell), the great admiralty judge. His mother — wife of John Scott, a coal-fitter in Newcastle-upon- Tyne — was near confinement in 1745, when the Stuart Pretender was marching towards London from Edinborough, taking Newcastle in his way, and intending to besiege it. It was deemed best to remove Mrs. Scott, but her modest residence was. jn a narrow lane, between which and the river ran the town wall, the gates of which were closed and fortified. ‘The expectant mother, being placed in a basket, was hoisted over the wall into a boat that ferried her over to the other side, which was County Durham. ‘lI'wo days thereafter the future jurist was born — a twin, with a sister. He always jocularly said that through the brief voyage he was. born for admiralty. When he became adolescent, although returned to Newcastle, a scholarship in Corpus Christi college at Oxford, that belonged to Durham, fell vacant, and having been born there he became eligible for the appointment, and, on his father’s application, received it. There he laid the foundation for his learning and conse- quent rise, which enabled him to aid his younger brother, who became Lord Eldon. In 1844 it occurred to the New Orleans elect- ors that a judge of its Commercial Court ought to be a merchant, and they therefore elected George Strawbridge, who had emigrated thither from Philadelphia to engage in commerce. In suits relating to promissory notes, bills, charter parties and insurance he made an excellent judge, but with the abstruseness of law he had no affiliation. An important case of garnishment under the civil
Page 55
Editorial Department. code came before him, in which for various suitors the eloquent Sergeant S. Prentiss, the poet- lawyer Richard H. Wilde, Judah P. Benjamin, and John Slidell were engaged. Facts were ad- admitted, but each argued questions of legal con- construction. On the fifth day of arguments one of the counsel paused a moment and said, “ And now I ask your Honor’s particular attention to my next part.”” Judge Strawbridge looked wearily at him and said in a disconsolate voice, “ Oh, don’t appeal to me yet, for all of you have been out of my depth ever since the first day.” ‘Then our filed briefs can become diving-bells for your com- prehension,” returned the witty Prentiss. THE New Orleans incident may recall an anec- dote furnished by Lord Brougham about Lord Chief Justice Ellenborough. Several conveyancers were making tedious technical arguments before him, when, late in the day, one, referring to an in- terlocutory remark of the Judge, said, “Is it your lordship’s pleasure to hear us on that point? ’’ and the latter answered, ‘“‘ Pardon me, but we have no pleasure whatever in the argument.” THE following extracts from a petition for the foreclosure of a mortgage recently filed in a Ne- braska court deserves a place in the GREEN Bac’s collection of legal curiosities: “The defendants and , nor any other person, has not paid the amount secured by said mortgage, as required by the conditions thereof, whereby said mortgage deed has become obsolete.” “Thus the plaintiff therefore prays that the plaintiff may foreclose the following, and collect the remaining of their interest in said mortgaged premises, and that said premises may be sold ac- cording to law and out of the proceedings thereof this cross-petitioner may be paid the amount ad- judged to be due him on said note and mort- gage.” “That the defendants and be ad- judged to pay in deficiency the amount which may remain after paying of said debt, and such other relief as may be just and equitable.” Mr. Kerr, whose annotations of Blackstone in bracketed additions to the text are so convenient and valuable, while Recorder of London hearing a contest of band performers for wages, was bothered * 589 by one set of musicians speaking of themselves as violin players, when another set called themselves musicianers. He therefore asked the Attorney — the father of the present eminent solicitor, Sir George Lewis — “ What, if any, difference is there between a fiddler and a musicianer?” “ Precisely that,” answered Lewis, “which exists between bagpipes and ‘the Dorian Mood,’ referred to by Milton in his Paradise Lost, ‘of flutes and soft re- corders.’’’ Recorder Kerr smiled at the punning compliment and remained unusually “ soft ’’ during the remainder of the case. > o- LITERARY NOTES. THE complete novel in the November issue of LIpPINCOTT’s, ‘‘In Sight of the Goddess,” by Harriet Riddle Davis, deals with life at the Capital. The principal characters are amember of the cabinet, his daughter, and his private secretary, who might also be called society manager for the family; the action is chiefly between the two last. The tale is written with abundant local knowledge and striking ability. THE leading article in THE BOSTONIAN for No- vember is on ‘‘ Football at Harvard College, ” written by R. Robert Dundee, of whom it may be said that he «¢*knows whereof he writes.’’ Other features of interest are, ‘‘ Recollections of Ex-Governor Alex- ander H. Rice,” ‘‘ Memories of the Past,” «* The Old Salt House,” ‘‘ Indian Summer,” one or two remark- ably good stories, etc., etc. WITH the November number THE ARENA closes its sixth year, and for the coming year announces a reduction from five dollars to three dollars in its sub- scription prices. The magazine has come to be a great power in the cause of progress and reform, and no thinking man can fail to appreciate its merits. Among the important contributions of this issue is a very suggestive paper by Prof. George D. Herron on ‘The Sociality of the Religion of Jesus” ; Senator J. T. Morgan, who is recognized as one of the ablest thinkers in our Senate on international questions and constitutional problems, discusses the Silver Ques- tion; Ex-Governor James M. Ashley, an old-time Republican, congressman and governor, writes on ‘¢ The Impending Political Advance”; Prof. Frank Parsons, of the Boston University School of Law, contributes a masterly paper on Municipal Lighting.
Page 56
i 590 PRESIDENT ANDREws’ installment of contempo- rary history, «* The Plumed Knight and His Joust,” in the November SCRIBNER’S MAGAZINE, is a most vivid and dramatic presentation of the chief events of the years of Blaine’s greatest popularity, including the famous Mulligan letter scandal and the exciting Blaine-Cleveland campaign. As part of the record of the time, this installment also includes the thrilling Arctic story of the rescue of Greely. The illustra- tions of the number are even more profuse than they _ have usually been of late, and the contributing artists are among the best. APPROPRIATE to the election season, the Novem- ber CENTURY gives attention to the ‘Issues of 1896.” The space is divided between two of the younger public men of national fame, who have won reputation as writers, speakers, and faithful executors of public trusts. The Hon. Theodore Roosevelt offers a Republican view of the issues of the coming Presidential contest, and Ex-Governor William E. Russell, of Massachusetts, describes the situation from a Democratic standpoint. Prof. James Bryce, the English Liberal, presents a forcible statement of ‘«« The Armenian Question.” He appeals with consid- erable feeling for the aid of public opinion in America ‘in the interest of the persecuted Christians suffering from Turkish brutality. In the «‘ Open Letters ” de- partment, the Duke of Westminster, the Conservative leader and philanthropist, briefly appeals to the American public on the same lines. THE ATLANTIC MONTHLY for November contains among other features three short stories of excep- tional quality : ‘‘In Harvest Time,” by A. M. Ewell, ‘¢ The Apparition of Gran’ther Hill,” by Rowland E. Robinson, and ‘¢ The Face of Death,” by L. Dougall. There also is an installment of Gilbert Parker’s se- rial «‘ The Seats of the Mighty,” and Charles Egbert Craddock’s «‘ The Mystery of Witch-Face Mountain ” is concluded. A SERIES of papers on the «* Principles of Taxation,” by Hon. David A. Wells, begins in the November POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY. Being based on the wide study which Mr. Wells has given to this sub- ject and .his experience as chairman of the U. S. Revenue Commission of 1865-66, Special Commis- sioner of Revenue, later as chairman of a commission for revising the tax laws of the State of New York, and in other like positions, this series promises to be the most important contribution to the solution of pressing financial problems that has appeared in many years. The Green Bag. THE Christmas HARPER’S MAGAZINE is a beauti- fully illustrated and varied number. It contains the opening chapters of a new novel by William Black, called <«‘ Briseis,” illustrated by W. T. Smedley. Mr. Caspar W. Whitney also begins the recital of his adventures in the unexplored Northwest in pur- suit of big game, Poultney Bigelow’s history of ‘¢ The German Struggle for Liberty” and the «< Per- sonal Recollections of Joan of Arc” are continued. There is a farce by W. D. Howells, and short stories are contributed by Brander Matthews, Kate Douglas Wiggin, Thomas Wharton, and Katherine S. Mac- Quoid. THE publishers of LITTELL’s LivinG AGE announce a reduction in the price of that unique eclectic from eight dollars to six dollars a year ; the change to take effect with the first of the new year. THE LIVING AGE, now nearing the close of its fifty-second year, has ever been the faithful mirror of the times, reflect- ing only that which was highest and best and most desirable in the whole field of literature. It has received the commendations of the highest literary authorities, the most distinguished statesmen, the brightest men and women of the country, and has proven a source of instruction and entertainment to many thousands. WitTH the November number MCCLURE’s MAGA- ZINE commences the publication of a new Life of Abraham Lincoln which promises to be unique in many ways. It is to contain a complete series of the portraits of Lincoln, over forty in number, more than twice as many as have appeared in any previous biography, and including many important portraits that have never before been published. . BOOK NOTICES. LAW. THE ANNUAL OF THE LAW OF REAL PROPERTY. Edited by TitcuMan E. BaL_arp and EMERSON E. BaLiarp, Volume III, 1894. The Ballard Publishing Co., Crawfordsville, Ind., 1895. Law sheep. $6.50. : This volume is prepared on the same general plan as those which have preceded it, and covers every real estate case reported during the year 1894. We have commended the series in noticing earlier vol- umes. The Messrs. Ballard are doing a real service to the profession in collecting and so admirably in- dexing the yearly decisions upon this important sub- ject.
Page 57
— Editorial Department. oo THE CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STaTEs at the End of the First Century. By GrorcrE S. Bout- WELL. D. C. Heath & Co., Boston, 1895. Cloth. $3.50. In this volume Ex-Governor Boutwell of Massachu- setts, has gathered and set forth in a concise form the substance of the leading decisions of the Supreme .Court of the United States, upon all the constitutional questions upon which it has passed up to the present time. The work is one of great value not only to the legal profession, but to the general pubiic. ‘THE AMERICAN Dicest (Annual, 1895). <A digest of all the decisions of all the United States Courts, the Courts of Last Resort of all the ,otates and Territories and the Intermediate Courts of New York State, Pennsylvania, Ohio, Illinois, Kansas, Missouri, Texas and Colorado, United States Court of Claims, Court of Ap- peals and Supreme Court of the District of Columbia, etc., from Sept. 1, 1894, to August 31, 1895. West Publishing Co., St. Paul, Minn. 1895. Lawsheep. $8.00 mez. _ The profession generally will agree that the West Publishing Company know how to make a digest, and if we must have these ponderous tomes thrust upon us year after year, it is fortunate that their pre- paration is in such competent hands. The present volume of some 2700 pages is in every respect what a digest should be and is indispensable to every law- yer. MISCELLANEOUS. A GENTLEMAN VAGABOND and some others. By _ F. Hopkinson SmirH. Houghton, Mifflin & Co., Boston and New York, 1895. Cloth. $1.25. Several short sketches, all of them written in the author’s best vein, make up the contents of this volume. Mr. Smith is a remarkable writer, and as a delineator of character is unequaled. Nothing could be better than his portrayal of Major Slocomb, the ‘¢ gentleman vagabond,” in the opening story. The gem of the collection is, perhaps, «* John Sanders, laborer,”’ a touching story of the sacrifice of a life for a poor little dog. DororHy aND Anton. By A. G. Prympron. Roberts Brothers, Boston, 1895. Cloth. $1.00. Miss Plympton writes delightfully for children, and this story of ‘* Dorothy and Anton” is one of her best. It is intended as a sequel to ‘* Dear Daughter Dorothy,” although it is complete in itself. Dorothy is a sweet little creature, with a heart full of love and o we 591 sympathy for others. happiness into at least two lives. Mr. Rappit AT Home. By JOEL CHANDLER Har- RIS. Illustrated by Oliver Herford, Houghton, Mifflin & Co., Boston and New York, 1895. Cloth. $2.00. Every child who has read ‘ Little Mr. Thimble- finger-and his Queer Country” will be eager to pos- sess ‘‘ Mr. Rabbit at Home,” which is a sequel to that delightful book. Buster John, Sweetest Susan and Drusilla again revisit the queer country and are regaled by Mr. Thimblefinger, Mr. Rabbit and others with a number of fascinating stories. These stories all have the charm of novelty, and are written in Mr. Harris’s inimitable style. No better book could be found for a Christmas gift for the little ones. A QuesTION oF FairH. By L. DouGaLi. Hough- ton, Mifflin & Co., Boston and New York, 1895. Cloth. $1.25. A man’s faith in a woman put to the test and found wanting is the key-note to this story. While we are inclined to sympathize with the young man whose curiosity led him to inquire into the reasons of the nocturnal wanderings of his lady-love, and her meetings with a strange man, and who refused to be wholly satisfied with her evasive answers, the young lady herself seemed to find’ his doubts inexcusable and dismissed him.. The story is interesting, but is by no means equal to ‘‘ Beggars All,” which made the author famous. m= THROUGH FOREST AND PLAIN. SAN and FREDERICK BOYLE. erts Brothers, Boston, 1895. Every boy who reads this book will fully endorse the opinion of one youngster who, after devouring its pages, exclaimed ‘It is just splendid !” The thrilling adventures and hair-breadth escapes of a party of botanists in Central America are graphically described, and at the same time a vast amount of valuable botanical information is imparted in an interesting manner. The book is a capital one for children in every respect, and will make an acceptable Christmas gift. Jor: A Boy of Galilee. By ANniE FELLOws JounstTon. [Illustrated by Victor A. Searles. Roberts Brothers, Boston, 1895. Cloth. $1.50. The memorable events in the life of Christ are made the basis of this story. Joel, a lame lad of Capernaum, is a witness of the marvelous doings of the Saviour and becomes his follower and disciple. The narrative is interesting, and the book well adapted for Sunday reading. By ASHMORE Rus- Illustrated. Rob- And in this story she brings
Page 58
992 The Green Bag. A Jotty Goop SumMER. By Mary P. WE ts | Goostir. By M.Carrir Hype. Roberts Brothers, SmiTH. Roberts Brothers, Boston, 1895. Cloth. “$1.25. | This story will be welcomed by the young people, especially by those who have read ‘+ Jolly Good Times To-day.” Amy Strong and her little friends continue ‘their interesting and amusing doings, and have about as ‘‘ jolly’ times as can be imagined. It is an ex- cellent book for Christmas gift to either boys or girls. Tue Nimeie Dot.ar, with other stories. By CHARLES MINER THompson. Houghton, Mifflin & Co., Boston and New York, 1895. Cloth. This is a capital book for boys. Every one of the stories is brimful of fun, and each is so good that it is hard telling which is the best. The boy must be hard to please who will not find a feast of real enjoy- ment in every page of this volume. MunicriPAL GOVERNMENT IN CONTINENTAL EUROPE. By Apert SHaw. The Century Co., New York, 1895. Cloth. $2.00. The present general interest in the subject of municipal reform in this country has led to the study of methods of administration that obtain in the cities of the Old World. Many of the problems that con- front American law-makers have been met and mas- tered in European cities, and it is recognized that many valuable lessons can be drawn from the ex- periences of Glasgow, Paris, Berlin, and other pro- gressive municipalities. Dr. Albert Shaw’s study of ‘¢ Municipal Government in Great Britain ” is already passing into its third edition, and now it is supple- mented by the present volume, which carries the inquiry to the leading Continental cities. Dr. Shaw ‘gives the foremost place in his book to Paris, «* the typical modern city,” believing that a knowledge of its affairs is essential to an intelligent survey of municipal progress on the Continent. ‘* Whether one goes to the Low Countries and Scandinavia, to Switzerland and Italy, or to Germany and Austria- Hungary,” says Dr. Shaw, ‘‘ he finds evidences on all hands of the abounding influence that the modern Paris has exerted upon the outward forms of European cities.”” While the author has explained carefully and at length the structure and working of the municipal machinery of the cities he has chosen, he has made it no less essentially a part of his task to describe the transformation of street-systems, and the measures by which death-rates have been reduced. The appendices of the volume give the budgets of Paris and Berlin, and the French Municipal Code. An exhaustive index adds to the usefulness of the work. Boston, 1895. 50 cts. A touching story of a boy's love for his baby brother. Too poor to provide for him, he leaves the little one at the door of a rich family by whom he is taken in and cared for. The two brothers meet con- stantly during the ensuing years, but the older does not divulge his relationship until he has won a name and fame for himself. The story is charmingly writ- ten and will delight both old and young. TuHIs GOODLY FRAME, THE EarTH. By FRANCIS Tirrany. Houghton, Mifflin & Co., Boston and New York, 1895. Cloth. $1.50. This interesting work is something more than the ordinary book of travel. The author does not con- tent himself with a mere description of the daily pro- gram of the traveler, but gives the reader his impressions of scenes, incidents and persons in a journey which included Japan, China, India, Egypt, Palestine and Greece. The.book is fascinatingly written and will delight all who are fortunate enough to read it. STANDISH OF STANDISH, a Story of the Pilgrims. By JANE Goopwin AusTIN ; with photogravure illus- trations from designs by Frank T. Merrill. Two volumes. Cloth. Houghton, Mifflin & Co., Boston and New York, 1895. 7 This charming story of the Pilgrim Colony and its hero, Myles Standish, derives an added interest from the beautiful holiday attire in which it now appears. Everything which the printer’s and engraver’s art can accomplish has been employed to make it attractive. | The binding is exquisitely dainty and the illustrations are artistic gems. BOOKS RECEIVED. INTRODUCTION TO AMERICAN Law. By ‘Timoruy WaLKER, LL.D. Little, Brown and Co., Boston. NEGLIGENCE OF IMPOSED DUTIES, CARRIERS OF FREIGHT. By Cuarues A. Ray, LL.D. Law- yer’s Co-operative Publishing Co., Rochester, N.Y. | A TREATISE ON THE LAW OF FORMER ADJUDICA- TION. By JoHn M. VAN FLEET. Two vols. The Bowen-Merrill Co., Indianapolis. A TREATISE ON THE LAW OF REAL PROPERTY. By James M. Kerr. Three vols. Banks and Bros., New York and Albany.