The Green Bag: An Entertaining Magazine for Lawyers (November, 1895)
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
‘T he -Grcen. Bag. Vout. VII. No. 11. BOSTON. NOVEMBER, 1895. THOMAS CHANDLER HALIBURTON. (SAM SLICK.) By J. A. CHISHOLM. as ‘Sam Slick,’ from the name of the principal character in the ‘“ Clockmaker ” sketches, played a very important part in the history of Nova Scotia for a period of over thirty years. He figured in political, in legal, and in literary affairs, and in each sphere of action he acquired very con- siderable repute. The reputation which he won as a legislator is greater than his repu- tation as a lawyer and judge; and the suc- cess of his literary work far surpassed the utmost measure of his success at the bar, on the bench, in the legislature of his native Province, or in the House of Commons of England. It is indeed as the author of the “Sam Slick”’ papers, that his name is most likely to be long preserved. But it is in his capacity as lawyer, judge and politician that he will be most interesting to readers of THE GREEN BAG. Thomas Chandler Haliburton was. of Scottish descent, the Haliburtons being an old family with whom Sir Walter Scott was connected through his grandmother. Sir Walter compiled a work entitled ‘The Memorials of the Haliburtons” for private circulation. Inthe eighteenth century some members of the family emigrated to America and settled in New England. ‘‘ Sam Slick’s” grandfather, one of these emigrants, being a strong loyalist, removed from Boston to Windsor, N. S., about the time of the revo- lutionary war. His father, William Otis Haliburton, was a judge of the Court of } UDGE HALIBURTON, popularly known Common Pleas in Nova Scotia — an inferior court which was abolished in 1841. The subject.of this sketch was born at Windsor, on December 17th, 1796. He en- tered King’s College at Windsor at the early age of fourteen, and was graduated B. A. in 1815. As a student he is said to have been very proficient in the classics. After his graduation he devoted himself to the study of the law, and in 1820 he was called to the bar of Nova Scotia. He prac- ticed his profession in the old town of Annap- olis Royal. By his contemporaries he was considered a good lawyer; but the field in which he practiced was so restricted that small opportunity was given for the develop- ment of such legal talent as he might have possessed.. As might be expected, the young lawyer took a warm interest in the political affairs of his country. Responsible government had not yet been established in Nova Scotia, and the Executive Council ad- ministered the public affairs with little or no regard for the wishes of the members of the popular or elective chamber. But, although the Assembly did not make and unmake ad- ministrations, it nevertheless exercised con- siderable influence over the public opinion of the Province, and it gathered to its walls many of the brightest minds of the colony. In the summer of 1826 elections were held throughout the Province, and Mr. Halibur- ton was returned as one of the members for the County of Annapolis. 489
Page 2
Ros i
Page 3
THOMAS C. HALIBURTON.
Page 4
490 He was a man of strong conservative in- stincts, utterly opposed to hasty and head- ‘long change, but quite sensible of the neces- sity for reform where abuses existed. Al- though he was not one of the so-called re- formers of his day, he nevertheless advoca- ted measures of reform along safe and con- servative lines, which conferred a great boon upon his countrymen. His prudence is well illustrated by his first speech in the As- sembly—that on the customs bill. The cus- toms imposts were collected at the time by the Imperial authorities, who paid the sala- ries of the officers. The right of the colo- ny, to wholly control the customs was as- serted somewhat defiantly by some members of the Assembly. This procedure Mr. Hali- burton opposed, and he advocated instead the appointment of acommittee to present an address to His Majesty asking in moderate and courteous but not less effective language the adjustment of the customs difficulty in the manner desired by the colonists. Bea- mish Murdoch, Q.C., who was himself a member of the Assembly at the time, gives the following description of Mr, Haliburton as a speaker: — ‘““As an orator, his attitude and manner were extremely impressive, earnest and dignified; and although the strong propen- sity of his mind to wit and humor was often apparent, it seldom detracted from the seri- ousness of his language when the subject - under discussion was important. Although he sometimes exhibited more auteur in his tone than was agreeable, yet his wit was us- ually kind and playful. He was not remarkable for readiness of reply in de- bate; but when he had time to prepare his ideas and language, he was almost always sure to make an impression on his hearers.” In the session of 1827, an occasion arose which gave Mr. Haliburton an opportunity to display his splendid powers of declama- tion. A petition from the Roman Catholics of the Province was presented to the Assem- bly on the 12th of February, praying for the The Green Bag. removal of the test oaths. A _ fortnight later the petition was taken into consider- ation, and a resolution in accordance with the prayer of the petition was submitted. The resolution was moved by Mr. Richard John Uniacke in a speech of singular beauty and strength, and was seconded by Mr. Haliburton. Mr. Murdoch speaks of this speech as the finest piece of declamation he had ever listened to; and it is said that the celebrated Joseph Howe, himself the great- est of Canadian orators, while detailed to report the speech, was so captivated that he had to lay down his pen. No verbatim re- port of this speech has been preserved, but the following extract from a synopsis of it is taken from a contemporary record, and will convey some idea of the effort: — ‘In considering this question he should set out with stating that every man hada right to participate in the civil government of that country of which he was a member, without the imposition of any test oath, un- less such restriction was necessary to the safety of that government; and if that was conceded, it would follow that these tests should be removed from the Catholics un- less their necessity could be proved in re- spect of that body. He stated that the religion which they profess was called Cath- olic because it was at one time the universal religion of the Christian world, and that the bishop of Rome, from being the spiritual head of it, was called Pope, which signified father. Then, after tracing the origin and history of the temporal power to the time of Henry VIII, he said that in subsequent times it had been thought necessary to im- pose test oaths, lest the Catholics, who were the most numerous body, might restore the ancient order of things, and particularly as there was danger of a Catholic succession ; but when the Stuart race became extinct, the test oaths should have been buried with the last of that unfortunate family. What- ever might be the effect of emancipa- tion in Great Britain, here there was not the
Page 5
Thomas Chandler Hatburton. 4QI slightest pretension for continuing restric- tions; for if the whole house and all the council were Catholics, it would be impossi- ble to alter the constitution —the governor was appointed by the King, and not by the people, and no act could pass without his consent. What was the reason that Protes- tants and Catholics in this country mingled in the same social circle and lived in such per- fect harmony? How was it that the Catho- lic mourned his Protestant friend in death, whom he had loved in life—put his hand to the bier — followed his mortal remains to their last abode and mingled his tears with the dust that covered him, while in Great Britain there was evident hostility of feeling, and the cause must be sought in something beyond the mere difference of religion? Th estate of Ireland afforded a most melancholy spectacle: the Catholic, while he was bound in duty — while he was led by inclination, to support his priest, was compelled by law to pay tithes to the Prot- estant rector; there were churches without congregations —pastors without flocks, and bishops with immense revenues without any duty to perform; they must be something more or less than men to bear all this un- moved — they felt and they murmured; while on the other hand the Protestants kept up an incessant clamor against them that they werea bad people. The property of the Catholic church had passed into the hands of the Protestant clergy —the glebes —the tithes—the domains of the mon- asteries — who could behold those monaster- ies, still venerable in their ruins, without re- egret? The abodes of science—of charity, and hospitality, where the way-worn pilgrim and the weary traveler reposed their limbs and partook of the hospitable cheer; where the poor received their daily food, and in the gratitude of their hearts implored bless- ings on the good and pious men who fed them; where learning held its court, and science waved its torch amid the gloom of barbarity and ignorance. “ Allow me, Mr. Speaker, to stray, as I have often done in years gone by, for hours and for days amidst those ruins, and tell me (for you, too, have paused to view the des- olate scene), did you not, as you passed through those tesselated courts and grass- grown pavements, catch the faint sounds of the slow and solemn march of the holy pro- cession? Did you not seem to hear the evening chime fling its soft and melancholy music o’er the still sequestered vale, or hear the seraph choir pour its full tide of song through the long protracted aisle, or along the high and arched roof? Did not the mouldering column—the gothic arch — the riven wall and the ivied turret, while they drew the unbidden sigh at the work of the spoiler, claim the tribute of a tear to the | memory of the great and good men who founded them? | “Tt is said that Catholics were unfriendly to civil liberty; but that, like many other aspersions cast upon them, was false. Who created Magna Charta ? . Who established judges, trial by jury, magistrates, sheriffs, etc.? Catholics! To that calumniated peo- ple we were indebted for all that we most boasted of. Were they not brave and loyal? Ask the verdant sods of Chrysler’s farm, Ask Chateauguay, ask Queenstown Heights, and they will tell you they cover Cath- olic valor and Catholic loyalty — the heroes who fell in the cause of their country! Here, there was no cause of division, no property in dispute their feelings had full scope. We found them good subjects and good friends. Friendship was natural to the heart of man; it was like the ivy that seeks the oak and clings to its stalk, and embraces its stem, and encircles its limbs in beautiful festoons and wild luxuriance, and aspires to its top, and waves its tendrils above it asa banner, in triumph of having conquered the King of the forest. “Look at the township of Clare :— it was a beautiful sight: a whole people having the same customs, speaking the same lan-
Page 6
492 guage, and uniting in the same religion. It was a sight worthy the admiration of men and the approbation of God. Look at their worthy pastor, the Abbe Segogne: see him at sunrise with his little flock around him, returning thanks to the giver of all good things; follow him to the bed of sickness — see him pouring the balm of consolation into the wounds of the afflicted; into his field where he was setting an example of industry to his people; into his closet, where he was instructing the innocence of youth; into his chapel, and you would see the savage, rushing from the wilderness with all his wild and ungovernable passions upon him, stand- ing subdued and awed in the presence of the holy man! You would hear the Abbe tell the savage to discern God in the stillness and solitude of the forest —in the roar of the cata- ract —in the order and splendor of the plane- tary system —and in the diurnal change of night and day. That savage forgets not to thank his God that the white man has taught him the light of revelation in the dialect of the Indian. “ After giving a detailed account of the expulsion of the French Acadians in 1755, Mr. Haliburton said that he did not ask for the removal of the restrictions as a favor; he would not accept it from their commis- eration: he demanded it from their justice. Every man who lays his hand on the New Testament, and says that is his book of faith, whether he be Catholic or Protestant, Churchman or Dissenter, Baptist or Metho- dist, however much we may differ in doc- trinal points, he is my brother and I embrace him. We all travel by different roads to the same God. In that path which I pur- sue, should I meet a Catholic, I salute him; I journey with him; and when we shall arrive at the fammantia limina mundi — when that time shall come, as come it must; when the tongue that now speaks shall moulder and decay— when the lungs that now breathe the genial air of heaven shall refuse me their office — when these earthly Lhe Green Bag. vestments shall sink into the bosom of their mother earth, and be ready to mingle with the clods of the valley, I will, with that Cath- olic, take a longing, lingering, retrospective view. I will kneel with him; and instead of saying, in the words of the presumptuous Pharisee, “Thank God I am not like that papist,” I will pray that, as kindred, we may be equally forgiven: that as brothers we may be both received.” That Mr. Haliburton would have been a permanent success as a politician, had he not adopted another career, cannot well be doubted. He had great aptitude for polit- ical affairs and enjoyed a large degree of popularity. But in 1829, he accepted the position of Chief Justice of the Court of Common Pleas for the midland division of Nova Scotia, and withdrew from the larger field for which his talents and education so well fitted him for useful service. He held the office of Chief Justice until the abolition of the court. His duties as judge of an in- ferior court were not such as called for any great legal abilities; and they were light enough to afford him sufficient leisure for the composition of some of his more fa- mous works. When the Court of Common Pleas was abolished in 1841, Judge Halibur- ton was made a puisne judge of the Su- preme Court, and held the latter position until 1856, when he resigned and removed to England. ‘ As Judge of the Supreme Court his du- ties required him to preside on circuit throughout the Province and to sit with his brother judges at Halifax on the hearing of appeals and such other business as properly came before the Court in banco in the first instance. It is no injustice to the memory of this celebrated man to say that his work as a judge was not enduring. There are no great decisions of his to which we can point as land-marks in the development of our law. Nevertheless he did his work well, and was a long way off from failure. Bright, cultivated and versatile, he could not be
Page 7
Thomas Chandler Milibuvtdn. a failure. But he found literary work more congenial than the ceaseless search for prece- dents. About a dozen of his decisions have been reported, and they are all to be found in James’ Nova Scotia Law Reports. A word about a few of them may not be out of place. In the Easter term of 1854, the court had to deal with the construction of an insurance policy in the case of Creighton v. The Union Insurance Co. The reporter states that Judge Haliburton ‘delivered a long critical examination of the case, with reasons in extenso,” the substance only of his reasons being given in the official re- port. The following extract is given to show how he approached the difficulties of the case in hand. ‘‘T concur in the opinion expressed by his Lordship, the Chief Justice — not merely for the reasons assigned by him, but for some others of a different nature. I shall, therefore, in conformity with my _ usual practice, merely mention those additional principles which have operated on my mind. The Attorney-General stated that decided cases were now more liberally interpreted than formerly; ke might have said that the law had of late been differently expounded. Mr. Justice Bliss seems to think that we are bound by the opinion of Sir James Mans- field, in Spitta v. Woodman. I beg leave to dissent from that proposition. The uncon- ditional surrender of private judgment to decided cases has drawn down the approbri- um of British statesmen on the study of the law; and it has been broadly asserted that its tendency is to cripple and confine the mind. Most of these remarks have more in them of flippancy than of truth. It does not follow that the study of the law limits the mind; but the mind may cramp itself by the mode in which it studies. If decid- ed cases are immutable, and so considered by the Courts where they are decided, as well as in those of more limited jurisdiction, 493 surrendering up our judgments to those of other men. But I view the subject in a dif- ferent light; and regard decided cases not as law—but evidence of law—or ex- positions of law. Englishmen boast of their common law as though it were peculiar to themselves; we, however, know that a com- mon law extensively prevailed in Greece - and Rome, and now has éxistence in every civilized country of Europe, in the United States, and the North American colonies. The law has been defined by an ancient author of great celebrity to be ‘the decision and adoption of certain principles subse- quently sanctioned and recognized by the Courts.’ | “He then winds up by stating it to be ‘the golden rule of reason.’ Lord Coke calls it ‘ the right reason.’ ‘When Lord Thurlow was at the bar his - practice was to take a case as he found it, and study it so inductively, till he reached his conclusion; when this was done he con- sulted Lord Kenyon—a great case man; and nothing proves more conclusively the value of decisions than the fact that in most instances he arrived at pretty much the same result as that set forth in the cases, al- though in a large number of instances his conclusions were sounder. Viewed in this light, the study of the law, so far from limiting, must enlarge the understanding. The com- mon law is elastic, it is remarkable for its plasticity and adaption to all varieties of cir- cumstances. In anew country like this — changing in its aspects, conditions, re- quirements, with every returning year; where new interests, new combinations, and new difficulties are perpetually arising, it is impossible to apply stringent rules with the same unvarying fixity that marks their ap- plicability to the circumstances of older and more stable countries. How can the same commercial rules be applied to a_ sparse- ly populated country — designated only by its latitude and longitude and a few log huts like our own, we commit the fatal error of | — as apply to Gibraltar or Malta?”
Page 8
494 In the case of Murdoch v. Pitts, he de- cided at the trial that a promise to pay “as soon as possible” took a case out of the statute without proof of the defendant’s abil- ity to pay. Steps were taken to set aside the verdict, and the other members of the court in banco held that the verdict should be set aside on the authority of the case of Tanner v. Smart, 6 B. & C. 603. Judge Haliburton in a dissenting judgment strong- ly combated the authority of the English case as applied to the case in hand, and the following quotation from his decision will be more interesting on account of the vigor of its rhetoric than on account of the sound- ness of its law: — ‘There have been a host of irreconcila- ble decisions under the statute of limita- tions. The objects and principles of the statute seem to have been lost sight of by the courts previous to the case of Tanner v, Smart, which decides that a mere admis- sion is not sufficient, but there must be an admission from which a promise may fairly and clearly be inferred. This decision was necessary from the previous unsettled state of the law; some of the decisions have held that any promise at all was sufficient to take a case out of the statute, and one on the other hand went the monstrous length of holding that a fraudulent man who admitted the justice of the claim, but declared that he would not pay it, should escape under the statute, which was only intended to shield a man who may have lost his receipt, as he would be very likely to have done after six years had elapsed, from paying his debt twice over; and to prevent the numerous cases of injustice which would arise from permitting parties to proceed without re- striction for the recovery of stale and neg- lected claims. The colonial courts fol- lowing implicitly these decisions, and thus surrendering their discretion and judgment to others, have been dragged through all these mutations. ‘But, although the decision in Tanner v. Lhe Green Bag. Smart was necessary at the time, too much has been made of it, and, in fact, whenever it comes up we hear of nothing else. It is ap- plied like Procrustes’ bed. If a case is too large for it, a piece is cut off, and if too small, it is stretched to the requisite dimensions. But, giving to that case the whole force which is claimed, I do not consider that the evidence in this case comes within it. “The construction to be put on the words used is a question for this Court, and if we tie ourselves down too closely to the case of Tanner v. Sharp, we are giving to ita legislative authority to which it is not enti- tled. My own opinion is that it may. be called a protrusive decision, advancing far into the powers of legislation, and not so much explanatory of the statute as imposing to it additional conditions.” Shortly after his retirement from bench. he went to England. time an unseemly wrangle between himself and the provincial government arose in re- gard to his pension, and the matter was finally decided in his favor by the Privy Council. In 1859, he was returned to the English House of Commons, as Conserva- tive member for the borough of Launceston, and he continued to represent that borough to the time of his death on August 27, 1865. That he failed of success in the Imperial Parliament was unexpected by his political patrons; but it should not have been,sur- prising. It must be remembered that he was over sixty years of age when he entered the English Commons, that the conditions there were new to him, and that his experi- ence in the Assembly of his native province was of only three years’ duration. Indeed, we have a more recent instance where a Can- adian public man of longer experience, and probably of greater capacity for public af- fairs, was translated from Canadian into Eng- lish public life with results very disappoint- ing to his friends. As the most illustrious man of letters that Canada has so far produced, Judge Hali- the About that ©
Page 9
Thomas Chandler Haltburton. burton will be long remembered. His ear- liest work was a history of Nova Scotia, pub- lished in two volumes in 1829 by Joseph Howe. Hisaccuracy as an historian has been attacked, and his account of the deportation of the Acadians in 1755, in which he de- nounced the act as harsh, has given rise to criticism from those who defend what even from their own point of view still remainsa most cruel expedient. In 1835 he began the “Clockmaker” papers in Joseph Howe’s newspaper, the “ Nova Scotian,” and they at once attracted attention by their inimitable humor. Among his other principal works are ‘‘Bubbles from Canada,” ‘‘ The Letter Bag of the Great Western,” ‘‘ The Attaché,” “The Old Judge,” ‘Wise Saws and Mod- —_ / ‘ 7 , Ih an i LO Y . ‘ . ' ie Tt) De) 2 RY ‘ ——— ty q 4 \ =e anit by ral UA Ne i : ) Oo hy - 2 : “ 7 f y / ( ‘ 495 ern Instances,” ‘‘Nature and Human Nature,” “Rule and Mis-rule of the English in Ameri- ca,’ and ‘“‘ The Season Ticket.” The limits of the present article will not allow, nor does it fall within its scope, to make any ex- tended comment on the above works. A few years ago a Haliburton Society was formed at Windsor, N.S., and that Society has published a very excellent “study” of Haliburton and his literary works from the pen of Mr. F. Blake Crofton, of Halifax, N.S. Judge Haliburton was twice married; first to Miss Neville, the daughter of an English military officer; and secondly to Mrs. Wil- liams, widow of E. H. Williams, of Shrews- bury. - - Wit a ( v
Page 10
496 The Green Bag. THE IMPRISONMENT OF DR. CORNELIUS HERZ. HE imprisonment of Dr. Cornelius Herz deserves some attention for more reasons than one. On grounds of humanity, there is much to arrest attention in this strange spectacle, unusual in England, of a man dangerously ill imprisoned in his bed- room for nearly three years, without trial or opportunity of defense. But apart from the hardships of the individual, there is another aspect of the situation deserving to be re- garded. It is of course well known that the whole law and practice of extradition is the young- est of the brood of Justice. But one result of this, in connection with the Herz case, appears to escape observation. It is simply that every case which in any important par- ticular leaves the path of mere routine, is bound to be a leading case, and set the fashion. The vast majority of the cases, with the exception of a few dozen, have arisen within the last twenty-five years. 1870 is practically the beginning of the practice. If the present deadlock be not mended in some way, it will be the settled rule in Eng- land that sick men, whom it is impossible to bring to trial, are to be kept under lock and key at the good pleasure of a foreign government. Knowing what we know of foreign governments less civilized than the French, it can hardly be said that this pros- pect is reassuring. The notions of foreign princes and potentates on the point of lib- erty of the mere private person are not al- ways suited to English air. The present question has arisen on the Franco-British Treaty of Extradition, but it may arise in some other case under the Treaty with Germany, with Russia,-with any of the Great Powers. Its importance is therefore perfectly general, as all extradition treaties are formed on the same lines. The British Government agrees with the Govern- ment of some other state (usually civilized, but sometimes so by stretch of courtesy only) for the mutual surrender of criminals, or rather of accused persons, on requisition to be made in a prescribed manner. On receiving this foreign requisition, the British Government is empowered by statute to delegate the holding of a preliminary in- quiry to a special magistrate: for England, a magistrate sitting at the Police Court in Bow Street. If the magistrate, on holding this inquiry, should be satisfied that a prima facie case has been made out against the accused —such a case as would warrant him in sending the accused for trial before a British jury —he is to order his surrender. But, it may be asked, what is to prevent a foreign Government, distinguished by its tyrannical rule, from utilizing this procedure in order to get into its power its political opponents? The answer is that the Extra- dition Acts of Parliament which prescribe the procedure to be adopted by British courts, and the various extradition treaties, all contain. provision to prevent extradition being misused in this way. Acts and treaties provide that political offenders are not to be surrendered, even though accused of ordi- nary crimes, if the magistrate who holds the preliminary investigation, or the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs, is satisfied that the real object of the foreign Government is to punish for a political offense. Again, the Secretary of State has a controlling power over the whole process of surrender, and need not allow extradition in any case in which he thinks it should not be granted. These rules have worked well enough in most cases, though, of course, failures on the part of the authorities on this side of the Channel to detect, or to hold proved, the
Page 11
The Imprisonment of Dr. Cornelius Herz. existence of political motive in the prosecu- _ tion must inevitably occur. What the Herz case has conclusively established, apart from the difficulty of proving political motive in a case in which it notoriously exists, is the presence of two serious defects in the Extra- dition Acts and in the whole series of ex- tradition treaties. The defect in the Acts is due to the alto- gether indefensible restriction of the prelim- inary magisterial inquiry to the not very dignified precincts of Bow Street Police Court; even where the dangerous illness of the accused prevents his being brought with- in miles of London. ‘The remedy for this obviously would be to allow the case to be investigated, with his consent, in his absence. The still more glaring defect in the extra- dition treaties is the absence of a provision requiring the foreign Government to with- draw its requisition when the dangerous ill- ness of the accused has been proved to the satisfaction of the British Government. The invidious task should not be imposed on the Secretary of State of refusing to allow extra- dition in such cases: the foreign Government should be required to refrain from demand- ing it. A bare enumeration of the facts of the case will show the absurdities and inconven- iences, to say the least of it, of the working of the present system. It is now two years and a half since Dr. Cornelius Herz was arrested at Bournemouth by the Scotland Yard authorities, at the in- stance of the French Government. He was accused of complicity in frauds, said to have been committed in connection with the Pan- ama Canal enterprise. It now seems toler- ably clear that, while much of the disaster which covered with grief the closing days of Ferdinand de Lesseps might fairly be attrib- utable to mismanagement on the part of some one, the allegation of actual fraud has never been supported; nevertheless, such was the accusation. What followed? The arrest was effected early in 1893. Since 497 then Dr. Cornelius Herz has been usually confined to his bed, and always to his room. The reality and the serious nature of his ill- ness has been attested by Sir Richard Quain and other eminent British physicians. It is hardly credible, but it is true, that in. the face of these well attested facts, and in the face of the repeated demands of this prisoner of British justice to have his case tried, it has not been tried, and he has not been re- leased. A technical defect in a British Act of Parliament, and a most marvelous delicacy of feeling for the susceptibilities of French administrators — which would be hurt if our Foreign Office asked them to withdraw their requisition for surrender — has kept an in- valid under arrest for the greater part of three years. But. it may be said, and with truth, ‘‘ The French Government is a civilized Govern- ment. Why would they seek to persecute an innocent man?” This question is sim- ple enough, but so is the answer. In the first place, no police, even the English, likes to give up its quarry. A case means, or may mean, promotion. French tribunals, it is whispered by French lawyers, are not anxious to surrender a case of which they have once been “ sazszs.””, Much more are policemen, inferior mortals to judges, touched here with the ardor of the chase. But more than this, a purely political motive comes into operation. None of the fleeting French ministries would like to face the odium of relinquishing the demand for the surrender of a ‘‘ Panamaist’’ — or to incur the certain- ty of being accused of winking at the escape of a ‘“‘cheguard.’ Votes are the object in view. Enemies of a given minister, who themselves have no reason for believing Dr. Cornelius Herz more guilty than his ac- quitted companions, would jump very quickly at such a convenient stick with which to beat a minister. His acquitted companions, be it noted, for here a startling fact confronts us: all the other persons accused along with Dr. Cor-
Page 12
4098 nelius Herz are now free, and reside in Paris or London. Some of them were convicted, in the heat of popular passion, seeking for some whole burnt-offering to be offered on the brink of the bottomless pit of Panama. But their release was ordered by the Court of Cassation, on June 15, 1893, on the ground that no legal justification existed for their conviction, and that they had been im- properly tried. It is another curious fact that in a decree of the 27th January, 1893, the President of the French Republic, and the Minister of Justice, while removing Dr. Cornelius Herz from his membership of the Legion of Honor, declared that the charge on which he was removed was barred by limitation under the French Codes, and therefore was one for which he could not be tried, if he were in France. | The ministry, however, was not content with proceeding by administrative decree. Some months after its issue, notwithstanding his absence through illness in a foreign ter- ritory, the prosecution of Dr. Herz was pro- ceeded with in the French courts. This process, which seems strange to English eyes, could be availed of by his prosecutors in France, although not open to his defense in England. Within a few days of the issu- ing of a certificate already referred to, signed by Sir Richard Quain and other physicians in attendance on Dr. Herz, the French court convicted the absent man on the stated as- sumption that he was contumaciously ab- staining from going to France. The court sentenced the accused, so summarily con- victed, to five years’ imprisonment — the highest term possible for the alleged offense. The court displayed its impartiality (already shown by its ignoring the certificate of the English physicians) by refusing to hear the advocate who appeared for Dr. Herz. His advocate challenged the jurisdiction of the court on the ground that at the time of the alleged offense his client was a grand officer of the Legion of Honor, and so subject only The Green Bag. to a special tribunal. It is worth noting, that owing to a multitude of delays on the part of the prosecution, Dr. Herz’s appeal against this sentence only came before the Court of Cassation in August, 1895. It was rejected on the unprecedented ground that, as Dr. Cornelius Herz was a foreigner, he did not enjoy the same. privileges as a Frenchman would if the Frenchman were, like Dr. Herz, a grand officer of the Legion of Honor. This striking specimen of judi- cial interpretation seems to have surprised most French lawyers. Meanwhile, some slight attention had been aroused in England. As a result of inquiries addressed to Ministers in the House of Commons it was announced in the first ses- sion of 1895 thata bill would be introduced to correct the Extradition Acts. It was un- derstood that this bill would meet the case of Dr. Herz. But, in fact, it only provided for holding the magisterial inquiry out of London : it merely removed from Bow St. its peculiar privilege of being the seat of the Extradition Court. It did not provide for the holding of the preliminary magiste- rial inquiry in the absence ofa sick prisoner, although he demanded it never so loudly. Obviously it could not touch the case of Dr. Herz. The question now remains, — What steps can be taken to meet the evident failure of justice which has arisen, and must again arise, in cases of the illness of a prisoner whose surrender is demanded under treaty by a foreign Government. Another ques- tion, one of possibly greater urgency, is what is to be done for this untried prisoner who has been in confinement without trial for nearly three years ? The first question suggests its own reply. For the safety of the future, the Extradition Acts should be amended by permitting the preliminary investigation to be held in the absence of the accused, if he is shown to be seriously ill, and if he demands that the in- vestigation should be held in his absénce.
Page 13
The Imprisonment of Dr. Cornelius Herz. 499 Extradition treaties with France and other countries might be usefully amended by the inclusion as already suggested of a provis- ion that the demand for surrender should be withdrawn on proof, satisfactory to the British government, that the prisoner is dan- gerously ill. The second question,— What is to be done for the relief of Dr. Cornelius Herz ?— is one more of administration than of law. There is now no time for general legislation which would meet the concrete case. The only possibility of prompt action lies in the reserve powers of the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs. On the ground that polit- ical motive is apparent throughout the pro- ceedings, the Secretary can arrest the whole process of extradition. Here he will be within his strict right, as defined by the law of England as well as the law of nations. On the other hand, he is entitled, under the ordinary usage of diplomatic intercourse — herein, of course, the law of England is silent —to represent to the French Govern- ment the grave inconvenience attaching to the present position in which the Govern- ment of a free country— the home of con- stitutional liberty, is placed. That is, that the British Government is reduced to retain- ing for an indefinite period in prison a sick man who cannot be tried, and who, as un- tried, is presumably innocent. Diplomatic remonstrance was recommend- ed to the late Government by a former So- licitor-General. Butshould remonstrance be unavailing — and even a published request of a British ministry might not excuse or palliate inthe eyes of the intelligent French elector the withdrawal of a charge against a ‘‘Panamaist’’ — then it will remain to be con- sidered what proofs there are of political motive in the institution, or the continuance of the prosecution of Dr. Herz. Is it really necessary to recite proof of a. self-evident fact ? It is notorious that the Panama Canal scheme, itself originating quite as much in political as financial mo- tives, has been in its fall as well as its rise iden- tified with political and vote-seeking pro- jects. The downfall of ministers—though, to be sure, that in France does not seem to require a cataclysm—the political death of party leaders, the fortunes of political journalists, all centred for years around the last dream of Ferdinand de Lesseps. It is of common knowledge that accusations of complicity with ‘‘Les Chequards” were. made, and often untruly made, for political purposes. Common sense alone is sufficient: to show that the persons truly or falsely supposed to be responsible for the loss of the untold millions taken from the pockets of a million French electors, and for the perhaps equally bitter loss of the glorious mirage of the profits of Panama, have to fear the votes of the elector as well as the process of the Ministry of Justice. Again, to come to the question from a different standpoint, what can be the motive of the French demand for the surrender of this last of the accused? The vindication of Justice ? But then we have the fact that the other defendants, of whom the accused was alleged to be an accomplice, were re- leased two years ago, by the order of the highest tribunal in France. A nervous anxiety to display to the elec- tor the utmost conceivable vigor in prose- cuting an accused Panamaist is visible not merely in persisting in the demand for the extradition of the accused Dr. Herz, but in the conduct of the prosecution in the French courts. The accused, kept in his bed by illness, is prosecuted in his absence. <A cer- tificate of that illness and of its serious na- — ture, from English physicians of the highest standing, is summarily set aside. The sever- est possible penalty is demanded by the prosecution and is inflicted by the court. A British Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs may very well admit the universally admitted, and put an end to this political persecution of a man who cannot be tried, but who can be and is imprisoned. By ex-
Page 14
500 ercise of a wise discretion a real stain on the administration of justice in England can be removed. As has been truly pointed out in a memorial now being signed by members of the House of Commons, no treaty of ex- tradition can be held to bind a Government to a course of conduct which it never con- templated. The latest announcement in the House of Commons is that a new convention is being negotiated with the French Government, so as Lhe Green Bag. to allow the British Act of 1895, which au- thorizes the holding of a magisterial inquiry elsewhere than in Bow Street, to come into operation. It is not clear from the replies of the present Under-Secretary for Foreign Affairs whether the convention will modify the position of Dr. Herz. It is therefore well to recollect that the resource powers of the Secretary of State can always be fallen back upon, M. J. F. HENRY CLAY. WILBUR LARREMORE. OT for their fruits alone, not for their deeds We crown the patriot spirits of the past; For one, whose sky with changes overcast, Yet sought to pluck the flowers of hope as weeds, And strove to stunt humanity in creeds, This age that tastes the Future’s promise vast, And knows no word it says can be the last, His own age in admiring love succeeds. Faithful and pure; according to his light He toiled to make a nation strong and blest; The growing portent filled his heart with fright, But still his great words calmed the nation’s breast ; What though his dreams were vain beneath the sleight Of destiny — he loved and did his best.
Page 15
Heaven. . Appeals to the Highest Court. 501 APPEALS TO THE HIGHEST COURT. By GErEorRGE H. WESTLEY. HE student of ancient and mediaeval jurisprudence will find no two phases of his subject of more fascinating interest than those of the trial by ordeal, and the appeal to the high court of Heaven against human injustice. With the former of these history has made us all more or less familiar. The trial by ordeal was an acknowledged institution of superstitious times. When two persons appeared before a judge with a case which he was unable to decide, he would remit the matter to the supreme court of Then would follow one of those strange ceremonies. A familiar form was to present plaintiff and defendant each with a sword and let them fight it out, the winner of the duel being adjudged the winner of the case. Another method was to have the accused plunge his arm into a cauldron of boiling oil, and still another, to offer him blessed bread which he was to swallow, after saying, “Tf I be guilty, may this bit of bread choke me.”’ Weare told that Richardis, wife of Charles the Fat, in order to prove her innocence, had to walk in a waxed linen dress between two blazing fires. And again that the Empress Cunegunda, being charged with infidelity, was compelled to walk barefoot over red-hot ploughshares. The trial by ordeal appears to have arisen from the belief that God would defend the right, if need were, by a miracle. With the second phase I have mentioned we are not so familiar. In olden times, when religious intolerance prevailed, and when might was right, and the. weak were often overborne by the strong, it sometimes oc- curred that the victim of an unrighteous judge would, in righteous indignation, cry out for justice to the great Judge of all the Eee eee earth. Instances of this nature are not rare, although they have not often been drawn from their obscurity and collected together. One of the most striking appeals against human injustice was made in 1313, when, because of their wealth and power, but for no crime, the Templars were condemned by Pope Clement V and King Philip the Fair of France. Du Molay, the grand master of that order, was arrested and burntalive. As he stood on his funeral pyre, he said in calm, clear tones, ‘‘ Before heaven and earth, on the verge of death where the least falsehood bears like lead upon the soul, I protest that our sole guilt has been that we trusted the seductive words of the Pope and the King.” Then raising his voice he cried, ‘“‘ Clement, iniquitous and cruel judge, I summon thee to meet me before the throne of God!” Some accounts say that he included Philip also. However, before a year had passed | both the Pope and the King were dead. A still more remarkable incident of this nature occurred in Gothland. It appears that a certain John Turson, being accused of a crime, was at once dragged before a magistrate. Although the man was not guilty, that worthy, who was found seated on horseback, condemned him to an imme- diate death. Turson protested his innocence, but finding his words in vain, he summoned his judge to appear with him before the judgment seat of God. As the executioner struck off Turson’s head, the magistrate fell from his horse and broke his neck. Knyghton, the old chronicler, tells us that a year after the death of Robert Gros- téte, Bishop of Lincoln, who had many a struggle with Pope Innocent IV, he, the dead bishop, appeared before his old enemy and said to him, ‘‘ Stand up, wretched one,
Page 16
502 and come to judgment!” As the Pope hesitated the ghostly bishop raised his pas- toral crosier and struck Innocent on the breast, so that he died on the following day. This was in 1254. The case of Nanning Koppezoon, who was executed by the governor of Holland in 1575, offers a striking illustration on this subject. We are told by Mr. Motley that this unfortunate man bore with perfect for- titude a series of incredible tortures. I need not describe these with all their sick- ening detail, it will suffice to suggest the brutal ingenuity of his persecutors if I sim- ply mention one of them. A large vessel being inverted on his naked body, under it were placed a number of rats. Hot coals were then heaped upon the vessel until the rats, rendered furious by the heat, gnawed into the very bowels of the suffering victim in their agony to escape. When, after sur- viving these horrors, the wretched man was finally led to execution, Julian Epeszoon, the Calvinist minister, endeavored by loud praying to drown his voice, that the people might not rise with indignation. With his last breath the dying prisoner solemnly summoned the unworthy pastor to meet him within three days before the judgment seat onhigh. ‘Itis a remarkable and authentic fact,’ continues Mr. Motley, ‘that the clergyman thus summoned went home pen- sively from the place of execution, sickened immediately and died on the appointed day.” About the middle of the eleventh century, Meinwerk, Bishop of Paderborn, was drawn into a quarrel with a certain monk who abused him with great violence and brought against him many unjust charges. Wearied out with vainly refuting these charges, the good Bishop at length said, “Well, let us appear together before the Judge of both, and let Him decide between us.” Strangely enough on the day the bishop died, the monk died also. When in 1651 Limerick was besieged by The Green Bag. Ireton, Cromwell’s commander, a large bribe was offered Terence O’Brien, Bishop of Emly, to exhort the people to surrender. This the Bishop refused, and when at length on the yielding of the city, he fell into the hands of Ireton, that stern Puritan at once sentenced him to death. Turning to the commander the prelate said, ‘I summon Ireton, the arch persecutor, to appear in eight days before the heavenly tribunal, to answer for his deeds of cruelty.” The eighth day arrived and Ireton, stricken with the plague, was’a corpse. We may find several remarkable incidents of this sort no further back than the eigh- teenth century. Sophia Dorothea of Zelle, after being divorced from George I, retired to the castle of Ahlen where she lived in confinement for thirty-two years. Just be- fore her death, in 1726, the recollection of her wrongs coming strongly upon her, she wrote a letter to the King denying the charges that had been made against her, and solemnly citing him to appear before the judgment seat of God, there to answer for his conduct towards her. Eight months later while George was riding to Hanover, this letter was thrown in at the coach win- dow, and dropped in his lap. Reading it, he became so terrified by its contents, that he fell into a convulsion, and was taken from the coach a corpse. But the most remarkable case of all I have reserved for the last. It occurred in Germany in 1703. It appears that in the church of Barlt there were two pastors, who differed widely in their religious opinions. Wattenbach was a man of very liberal views, while Hoesch was a severely orthodox Luth- eran. Naturally the two could not get along together, and at length Hoesch, with the as- sistance of the provost Hahn, set about to have the obnoxious pastor deposed. It was a long and bitter fight, and it went through several stages until finally the case reached the royal court. Hereon a charge the par- ticulars of which are not given, Wattenbach
Page 17
Appeals to the was tried, and sentenced to expulsion from his pastorate. When he heard this, he asked if there was any appeal from the decision. On being answered that there was none, he said solemnly, ‘‘I, John Caspar Wattenbach, refer my cause to Heaven. I cite the pro- vost Hahn to appear this day twelve weeks, the Chancellor who has given judgment, to appear this day fourteen weeks, and my prosecutor, the fiscal officer, at the same time, and all my witnesses who can testify to my innocence to attend within a year and a day before the Divine tribunal.” At these solemn words there fell upon the court a death-like stillness. The Chancellor was the first to break the silence, and he rebuked the speaker for his profane language. Wat- tenbach replied that the sentence of the court had destroyed his repute and cast him and his family into utter poverty. Having no other redress, he said, he was compelled to make this appeal. Leaving the court room shortly after, Wattenbach returned to Barlt, and removed his family from the par- sonage. Sixteen days later he died. The twelve weeks alloted to Provost Hahn Flighest Court. expired on the 24th of June. 593 The day was Sunday, and the provost preached on a pas- sage from Luke 1, 57-80, that being the gospel for the day. He had never felt in better health or spirits in his life. In the afternoon he sent a message to the Chan- cellor, reminding him jokingly of Watten- bach’s summons. Before the messenger re- turned he was taken with an apoplectic fit and in a few minutes he died. Exactly two weeks later, their time having also elapsed, the Chancellor and the prosecu- tor passed away, and before the year and a day had gone by, every one of the witnesses summoned by Wattenbach to attest his in- nocence were dead. Strange as this story is, it appears to be authentic. The provost Burchard who was present at Wattenbach’s earlier trials, gives us the account of it, and the parish registers of Barlt certainly confirm many of his state- ments. If we could believe the death of Hahn to be a mere coincidence, it would of course be easy to account for the subsequent deaths on the score of nervous terror. But was it a coincidence?
Page 18
594 The Green Bag. THE SUPREME COURT OF MAINE. II. By CHARLES HAMLIN. THER SHEPLEY, the fourth Chief- Justice was a native of Groton, Mass., where he was born Nov. 2, 1789. He was the second son of John Shepley and Mary Gib- son Thurlow. On his mother’s side he was the grandson of Captain Thurlow of the Revolutionary Army. The Shepleys came from Yorkshire, Eng- land, and their earliest representative appears at Salem, Mass., about 1637. In 1700 the name of John Sheple is found at Groton. Ether was his lineal descendant in the sixth degree. The race was sturdy and vigorous, and the family one of the best from which New England derives all that it reveres for character and ability. For many years the Shepleys were prominent in public affairs. Mr. Willis in his “* Lawyers of Maine” says Ether’s father was an orderly sergeant:in a company in the Revolution, held several town offices, was a farmer, fond of reading and a man of general information. Ether Shepley was fitted for college at Groton Academy under Caleb Butler, and having entered Dartmouth was graduated in 1811. Daniel Poor, the missionary, Pro- fessor Park of the Harvard Law School, and Amos Kendall, Postmaster-General, were among his classmates. For two years he read law in the office of Dudley Hubbard, at South Berwick, assisting that gentleman in his large collection business. Later he pursued his studies with Zabdiel B. Adams in Worcester county, and Solomon Strong in Hampshire. He began to practice at Saco in 1814, after his admission to the bar. He soon took the lead among the young practitioners and easily retained that posi- tion by his industry, close application and practical ability, all which served to give him a high social standing in the commun- ity. In 1819 he became interested in poli- tics, the prominent question being that of the separation, and was chosen to represent Saco in the General Court, and member of the convention that drafted the Constitution of Maine. In February, 1821, he was ap- pointed U. S. District Attorney and served with ability for twelve years, through Mun- roe’s second term, the whole of Adams's, and the first four years of Jackson’s administra- tion. In 1833, he was elected to the U. S. Sen- ate as the successor of John Holmes, and proved to be an able representative, distin- guishing himself as a supporter of President Jackson. The Democratic leaders in the Senate felt themselves unequal in debate to Clay and his followers who were allied with Calhoun; they welcomed the advent of a speaker like Mr. Shepley. Early as January, 1834, he made a three days’ speech sustain- ing the President’s removal of deposits, the all-exciting event of the time. ‘In the new senator,” writes Gov. I. Washburn, Jr., “they found a Democrat of the strictest sect; a man who believed in the uses and functions of party, and of the merit that attached to an intelligent allegiance to party, and who was prepared to do manful battle for it.” .. . “ But he never permitted his action to be con- trolled by his party ties in opposition to his real convictions.” . . . “ His clear and logical mind would be satisfied only with the order- ly marshalling of facts, and the sober and severe processes of dialectics. He partici- pated but seldom in the general debates, and spoke only at considerable length on important and pressing questions.” His most cogent and thoroughly convine-
Page 19
Lhe Supreme Court of Maine. ing speech in the Senate was on the French Spoliation Bill. Of the subject he was a complete master. Speaking of the indem- nity due to our citizens from the United States for the wrongs which France admitted she inflicted on them, he uses the memora- ble words, ‘Our government pocketed the consideration and repudiated the debt.’ In closing his speech, Dec. 22, 1834, on this Bill, his last sentence is ‘‘ an apple of gold in a picture of silver.” He said, “ Things are so rightly ordered here, that to do justice to all others ts to serve ourselves best.” . Congressional life, however, did not ac- cord with his taste or training; and the State became the gainer when he accepted an ap- pointment on the bench of the Supreme Ju- dicial Court of Maine, tendered him by Gov. Dunlap in September, 1836, to fill a vacancy caused by the resignation of Judge Parris. His first term of service was at Bangor. It began about the end of October and lasted until late in December. He found the docket full to repletion with cases growing out of the eastern land speculations. Judge Nich- olas Emery quaintly said “ It needed to have its backbone broken.” Judge Shepley did break it. He showed immediately that he was a power on the bench, which, although gracious and ever courteous, was not to be trifled with, and who was resolved ‘“ that the — facts were to be elicited only after the rules of law.” He held. rigidly to the practice of the principle that justice was to be found in a faithful adherence to legal principles and rules. It was a frequent saying of his, “The law is the rule of decision, and the law is the justice of every case.” | He became the successor, with the gen- eral concurrence of the bar and the public, of Chief-Justice Whitman, in 1848, upon the latter's resignation. His long experience as a jurist and judge, the fidelity and acuteness he had always exhibited, made his appoint- ment an eminently fitting one. His learn- ing, impartiality, decision, promptitude and ability are amply illustrated in the twenty- 505 seven volumes of the Maine Reports, from the fourteenth to the fortieth, inclusive. His opinions are characterized with that clear- ness, directness, and force that no one can mistake the point he endeavors to establish. He keenly enjoyed the excitement of a skilfully conducted trial and watched its movements with as keen a zest as that of the stoutest Roman in presence of the glad- iatorial combats of the arena; but he never lost sight even for a moment, of the law and the justice involved in the contest. Strongly attached to professional and ju- dicial life, he would not permit any outside allurements to withdraw him from it, and resisted all solicitations to accept political positions under the general government. Not only did he decline the office of Attor- ney-General of the United States, but also that of Governor of Maine. Asa judge he abstained from politics, nor would he give recommendations to his best friends for po- litical office. His pastor, the Rev. Edward Y. Hincks, of the State Street Congregation- al Church, in Portland, and of which Judge Shepley was one of its founders, says in a sermon delivered Jan. 21, 1877, ‘He was an eminent member of a class of laymen who, during the past generation, adorned the Congregational churches of New Eng- land,—men of high station and eminent ability, who laid their gifts in humble devo- tion at their Master’s feet.... He had the passionate love of righteousness which was the noblest element of the Puritan charac- tere At There was no acerbity or asceticism about him. Hewas tender and lovable inthe home- circle, loving young people, and to his pas- tor an ever kind and sympathizing friend. He was a wide but discriminating reader, keeping abreast with all the periodical litera- ture, and specially interested in works on religion and theology. Books on philoso- phy, science, history and biography, as also fiction, occupied much of his time. He took a deep interest in the cause of
Page 20
506 , education. For more than _ thirty-seven years he was a member of the Board of Trustees of Bowdoin College. He was an original and also an active and useful mem- ber of the Maine Historical Society, organ- ized April 11, 1822. He was the first pres- ident of the Portland Natural History So- ciety and remained such from 1843 to 1848. He received the degree of LL.D. from Colby University in 1842, and from Dartmouth in 1845. | When he retired from the bench in 1855, the Cumberland bar, voicing the general sentiment regarding him, adopted resolutions fitting the occasion and recognizing with the liveliest sensibilities the debt which it and the whole State owed to him for his long continued labors and services upon the bench, his eminent learning and ability, his unbending integrity, the untiring and con- scientious devotion to duty with which he discharged all the functions otf his elevated and responsible station, looking with pride to his judicial career marked by a dig- nity which ever commanded respect and by a learning which ever justified confi- dence. He died January 15, 1877, full of honors and years at the house of his son Judge George F. Shepley, U. S. C. Court for the N. E. Circuit, in Portland. Just men carried him to his burial, attended by lawyers, physicians, clergymen, civic officials and crowds of citizens. | Of this sedate and sober-minded judge we would hardly expect much of humor and wit. Nothing of the kind has come down by way of tradition to the present genera- tion ; yet the reader will not fail to perceive a slight touch of grim humor in the follow- ing extract from his opinion in Pratt v. Leadbetter, 38 Maine, 17 : — ‘‘Upon the construction of this will there have been, it is said, different opinions and doubts among members of the profession for thirty years. If it be so, it may not have been wholly without a precedent; for Lord The Green Bag. Eldon commences his opinion in the case of the Earl of Radnor v. Shafto, 11 Ves. 453, with the remark: ‘ Having had doubts upon this will for twenty years, there can be no use in taking more time to consider it.’ “With the best light to be obtained by a ' more limited consideration and examination, the Court has come:to a very satisfactory conclusion respecting the correct construc- tion of the devise to Othniel Pratt.” _ His associate on the bench, the late Judge Howard, says, ‘‘ He had no taste for indulgences outside of his duties, not even for recreations so fascinating and usually esteemed so necessary to the health of body and mind. He appeared to need nothing of the kind. Unremitting labor in his high vocation gave him constant delight. In all his ways he had the inspiration of great faith, and the accomplishments that are born of it. He loved the law, conscientious- ly sought its distinctions, and gained them with liberal rewards.” We conclude with the following extracts from Judge Howard’s eulogy, which give Chief Justice Shepley’s true and exalted place in Maine’s judiciary. ‘The mental powers of Judge Shepley were vigorous and strong, and his intellectual vision very clear. He saw as with a light ahead, the solution of seemingly abstruse problems, with broad distinctions, often not readily perceived by others. If he was sometimes apparently positive in his manner and opin- ions, it was because he had great confidence in his own matured reasonings and conclu- sions. His will was sustained by an energy that never flagged in the accomplishment of his duties. | ‘Learned broadly in law and equity, as much in the spirit as in the letter, he ap- plied his great knowledge with matchless skill and force to the work before him; for he estimated largely the value of human pursuits by their bearing upon human rights and interests. His independence and im- partiality were always refreshing. . . .
Page 21
Lhe Supreme Court of Maine. 507 ‘‘ His decisions will stand the severest ju- | and the happiness of mankind. He had a dicial tests; and it is believed that time | genius for knowing and doing with all his will but deepen the paths bravely marked | might. Heaven endowed him with this ETHER SHEPLEY. out by him in the advance of jurispru- | spirit, and bestowed upon him the faculty dence. . : . to give it effect.” ‘“No judge was ever more conscientious His last public service was in 1856, to in maintaining that the faithful observance | revise the laws of Maine, under a resolve of and administration of laws are essential to | the legislature passed April 1 of that year, the character and stability of government, | and which required him to make his report
Page 22
508 in the following November. This he ac- complished, and it was embodied in the Re- vised Statutes of 1857. JOHN SEARLE TENNEY, the fifth Chief- Justice, was born in Rowley, now Byfield, Massachusetts, January 21,1793. His pre- liminary studies were pursued at the cele- brated Dummer Academy in Byfield. He graduated at Bowdoin College with the highest honors in 1816, being distinguished in the Greek classics. After graduation he had charge of the Academy in Warren about nine months, and he then entered upon the study of the law in the office of Thomas Bond at Hallowell. Upon being admitted to the bar he settled in 1820 at Norridgewock, the shire-town of Somerset County, where he ever after lived. For twenty years he pursued a successful prac- tice and established a high reputation for his sound knowledge and skill. It was not until he had practised some ten or twelve years that he acquired reputation as ‘an advocate ; and according to tradition - was forced into making an argument by the stratagem of a friend, the late Timothy Boutelle of Waterville, who knowing him well and having confidence in his ability, arranged to have him manage a case in 1832,in which Hon. Peleg Sprague, then a Senator in Congress and one of the most eloquent men in the country, was oppos- ing counsel. The case was closely con- tested, as might well be supposed ; but Judge Tenney was successful. He at once took a high stand as an advocate as well as a sound lawyer. Asa speaker he was not distinguished for the graces of oratory either in manner or matter. Still, he was ready and fluent, with a good command of lan- guage. His arguments were specimens of close, compact logic, as well as clear and forcible statements of his cause, and he never failed to secure the attention of the court and jury. His standard of profession- al honor and integrity was so high that it The Green Bag. admitted of no dereliction whatever from perfect rectitude. His clients were sure, not only of his entire fidelity, but that his best ability would be exerted in their behalf. But his zeal for them, great as it was, did not for a moment lead him to forget the respect due to himself or the fidelity due to the court. A contemporary and _ fellow- townsman says of him that he possessed one characteristic in a pre-eminent degree, that is, the extreme carefulness with which he examined a client’s case before advising him to run the hazard of alawsuit; every source of information he caused to be explored, and every point thoroughly investigated, and so he came to the trial of a case fully prepared for every contingency. He devel- oped his cases admirably to the jury in ex- amining his witnesses, and in his arguments would gather his facts together and rolling them into a ball hurl them at his adversary with resistless and crushing force. ‘ He was a four-masted schooner among the com- mon coasters,” says another leader of the bar, well known for his felicitous power of description. He never lost his self-posses- sion through excitement, nor suffered his reason to become obscured by passion. Judge Danforth, an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court and a student in his office says: ‘“ During a close observation of his practice for many years, I never, to my recollection, saw him in anger but once. That was caused by an opposing counselor repudiating an agreement he had fairly made. The scene which followed I shall never for- get . . . He certainly learned to his cost, that however courteous Judge Tenney might be, he had in store weapons of keener edge and sharper point to be used when occasion demanded.” ‘ He acted with the Whig party and was once its nominee for Congress, when that party was in the minority, but was defeated, although running largely ahead of his ticket. He was elected to the Legislature in 1837, and gained a wide reputation for a speech
Page 23
The Supreme Court of Maine. 509 delivered in the House, upon the question of a contested seat, which was decisive of the case. In October, 1841, he was appoint- edan Associate Justice of the Supreme Judi- cial Court, succeeding Judge Nicholas Em- ery, an appointment entirely unsolicited on his part, —a voluntary offering to his fit- ness for the place. To employ the words of Judge Dan- forth again, and we know of none more authoritative: ‘Into this position he car- ried the same_ ster- ling, unflinching in- tegrity, the same nice sense of honor that. had characterized his professional life. Here, too, was exhi- bited that same self- possession, the same patience under trying and difficult duties, by which he had been hitherto distinguish- ed. His courtesy toward the members of the barnever failed. In his courtesy, how- ever, he never forgot his dignity, or rather that never forgot it- self. His dignity needed no continual watching lest it might become soiled unawares. It was natural to the man, —a part of his very being, existing within him, the result of native force, and an innate sense of the right and proper, ever present, regulating and controlling all his conduct without effort, and almost unconsciously to himself. This true dignity Judge Tenney possessed, or rather it pos- sessed him in an eminent degree as was manifest on all occasions. . . . In his opin- ions upon questions of law, he manifested JOHN SEARLE TENNEY. the same conscientious carefulness, the same accurate thought and painstaking labor that was devoted to all his duties. The style of his composition was not always lucid, his sentences were occasionally involved and sometimes heavy,—but the thought was always well digested, the logic clear, strong and conclusive. His opinions bore the marks of much labor, and were never hastily thrown off, nor laid aside until the sub- ject: matter was ex hausted.” : His opinions may be found extending from volume twenty to volume fifty-two of the Maine Reports, and treating a wide variety of subjects, they extend through a space of time much in excess of the aver- age judicial life. He was reappointed in 1848 and in 1855 suc- ceeded Ether Shep- ley as Chief-Justice. In 1862, he closed his judicial career of twenty-one years full of honors, with the ermine unsullied and enjoying the respect | of his associates, the members of the bar, and the people of the State. He served as a State Senator in 1863 and 1864 and then retired from public life to en- joy that social ease and comfort which he had sorichlyearned. Inprivate life he was genial and affable to all. His conversational pow- ers were great, while, at the same time, he had the happy faculty of drawing from others whatever stores of knowledge they possessed. He never under-rated his interlocutor. While easy in his intercourse with all men, recog-
Page 24
‘510 nizing no inferior and no superior, he was noticeable for his appearance. His frame was massive; his figure imposing; his face handsome and majestic, betokened the stu- dent by the full eye, beardless chin and high forehead. His honors and dignity impressed all alike but never overawed even the young- est. He appeared young down to the close of his public life. In 1849 he was made a trustee of Bow- doin College. In 1850 he was appointed Lecturer on Medical Jurisprudence at the same College, performing the duties for nearly fifteen years. The same year he re- ceived from his Alma Mater the degree of b..D. He died at Norridgewock, August 23, 1869. At the following September term of the Supreme Judicial Court, the bar of Som- -erset County, Danforth, J., presiding, attended memorial exercises in honor of his death and presented resolutions fitting to the occa- sion. They declare that his eminent learn- ing, his power of analysis, his sound and solid judgment, and his clear and accurate discrimination were equalled only by the breadth and comprehensiveness of his intel- lect, and by the purity of his character as a magistrate and citizen. Judge Danforth followed with a eulogy which will remain as a perpetual memorial and touching tribute to - the virtues of his honored and revered friend and teacher.. All of his associates upon the bench have passed away and but a few of his contemporaries remain at the bar. By them he is remembered with affection and great respect. It is his written opinions, however, which evidence his knowledge of the law and strength as ajudge. They are characterized by strength rather than by ease of composition and by soundness of conclusion than rapidity of reaching results. To the profession they are a living source of authority, adding harmony to the growth of the law. To the younger members of the bar who practiced before him, his majestic form, The Green Bag. bland countenance and almost paternal man- ner coupled with his great and distinguishing love of justice and long, successful life upon the bench, will ever constitute a beau-ideal of the ‘‘ good judge.” JOHN APPLETON, the sixth Chief-Justice, was born at New Ipswich, N.H., July 12,1804; was graduated at Bowdoin College in 1822; was admitted to the bar in 1826; appointed on the bench of the Supreme Judicial Court in 1852; became Chief-Justice in 1862, and retired at the close of his sixth appointment in 1883, having been at the bar twenty-six years, and a member of the bench thirty-one years,—an active professional life of fifty- seven years in all. If we look beneath this brief summary of an unusually long legal and judicial life, we shall find it filled up with events full of in- terest and: labors rendering it noteworthy in annals of the law. John Appleton was well born. He came of an ancestry whose lineage carries us back to Norman ancestors, of knightly rank in feudal ages, then appearing later on in the person of Samuel Appleton as a Puritan immigrant, a ‘godly, noble, enterprising ex- ponent of civil and religious liberty,” taking the Freeman’s oath May 25, 1636, in the colony of Massachusetts. He died in 1670, at Rowley, leaving a son bearing his name, who served with the rank of major in King Philip’s war, and conspicuous also in politi- cal affairs. Under the leadership of Samuel and John Appleton the town of Ipswich voted, in reference to the order of Governor Sir Edmund Andros: ‘That considering said act has infringed upon our liberty, as it is contrary to the acts of His Majesty, by vio- lating the statute law of the land, which de- clares that no taxation shall be laid unless with the consent of the people; they do therefore vote first, that they will not choose a commissioner, and decide that the Select- men shall not lay such a tax till it is deter- mined on by the people.” This has been
Page 25
~The Supreme Court of Maine. 511 well called the Declaration of Independence in embryo, although it happened in the pre- ceding century. Sir Edmund Andros was son was Major Isaac Appleton who died inI747. Isaac was born in 1664,at Ipswich, and married Priscilla Baker, a granddaughter JOHN APPLETON. deposed during the English Revolution of 1688, and Major Appleton had the stern satisfaction of handing Andros into the boat which conveyed the crest-fallen tyrant to the castle. Major Samuel Appleton died in great honor in the year 1696. His third of Lieutenant-Governor Symonds, whose wife was a daughter of Governor Winthrop. Isaac Appleton, second, was born in 1704, at Ipswich, and married Elizabeth Sawyer of Wells, Maine. He was the father of ten children. Of these, Francis, who settled at
Page 26
512 New Ipswich, N. H., was the second. He was born in 1732, and married a lady named Hubbard, by whom he became the father of four children, of whom John was the third. John Appleton married Elizabeth Peabody, by whom he was the father of an only son, the future Chief-Justice of Maine. Judge Appleton’s mother died when he was only four years old, and he was left with an only sister thus early in life to the care of others. After passing through the com- mon schools and academy of his native town he entered Bowdoin College of which his _ uncle, the Rev. Jesse Appleton, was president and was graduated in the class of 1822, when only eighteen years old. In his col- lege course he laid deep the foundation of his knowledge of the classics, especially the Latin from which his frequent and felicitous quotations, both oral and written, are notice- able. | : He began the study of law in the office of George F. Farley, at Groton, Mass., and afterwards continued it at Alfred, the shire- town of York County, Maine, under the instructions of his relative, Nathan Dane Appleton. He was admitted, in 1826, to the bar at Amherst, N. H., shortly after he arrived at his majority. He began the legal practice, the same year, at Dixmont, Penob- scot County, Maine, and after a few months removed to Sebec, Piscataquis County, where he resided six years. Here the young law- yer did not find the time weighing heavily on him for want of occupation, although it was a sparsely settled town and business could not have been pressing, for he had early acquired the habit of close study and was a most diligent reader of all that relates to the profession of the law, especially of those writers who sought, like Bentham, to discard its excrescences and useless absurdi- ties. Removing to the city of Bangor in 1832, which ever after remained his home, he formed a partnership, with his future brother- in-law, Hon. Elisha H. Allen, under the The Green Bag. name of Allen & Appleton, and entered at once into an extensive practice. This firm continued until Mr. Allen was elected to Congress in 1840. Mr. Allen subsequently became Chancellor of the Sandwich Islands and Minister of Hawaii to the United States. Subsequently he had for partners John B. Hill and his cousin Moses L. Appleton, the latter remaining with him until 1852, when Judge Appleton was appointed to the bench. Their clientage was unusually large,— hundreds ofsuits in each term being intrusted to their care. On account of the insolvency of the times, collections were made then large- ly by suits, but fees were small.. ‘In respect of experience and multiform legal knowl- edge,’ as the Judge once naively said, “ it was largely remunerative.” The research and activity which it stimulated, placed them in the very fore-front of the legal fraternity. What the advocate should be in the mind of this able lawyer he tells us in a beautiful tribute to the memory of one of his associ- ates upon the Maine Bench, Hon. Edward Kent, in which he unconsciously has given us a pen-picture of himself. He says: “As an advocate, he was earnest, fluent, a thorough master of the facts to be discussed, omitted nothing which could conduce to the result sought to be attained. Judicious, frank and open, scorning all artifice and concealment despising all trickery, he addressed himself to the merits of his cause, and to the calm judgment of the jury. His commanding presence, the recognized purity of his life and the integrity of his character, gave force and strength to an argument in itself forci- ble and strong without the added weight of those great accessories.” Judge Apple- ton “was (at that time) the leading advocate in this section of the State,” says Mr. Frank- lin A. Wilson, of the Penobscot Bar, whose discriminating judgment rarely fails in such matters; and he further adds that: ‘‘He was in the full vigor and prime of life, graceful in motion, eloquent in speech, persuasive and successful; and to my youthful mind
Page 27
Lhe Supreme Court of Maine. he seemed to be pre-enfinent in a bar which contained lawyers of such ability and learning as Edward Kent and Jonas Cutting, , both of whom were afterwards associated with Chief-Justice Appleton upon the bench of the Supreme Judicial Court of Maine. His services were in demand upon one side or the other of almost every case tried in court at that time.” As all these elements of temperament, training and character enter into the foun- dation and success of his judicial career in after-life, and to enable us to still better ap- preciate them, we will quote the words of another, couched with deeper analytical power and written by an acknowledged mas- ter of the subject,—an active practitioner before him and his associate on the bench for upwards of ten years, —his present suc- cessor, Chief-Justice Peters : — “His management of causes was reliable, safe and successful. He was deeply interest- ed in the work in hand. The court-room seemed a home to him, and the trial ofa cause an apparent delight. Possessing then, as ever afterwards, fine physical health, his powers of both mental and bodily endurance were simply marvelous. He would pass from case to case, entering upon one trial with the same zeal and vigor he had just ex- pended upon another, whether his previous efforts had been attended with victory or defeat. He did not forget that a battle well prepared is half won, and he was a master of the principle of promptness to the end of his life. He was active in both the prepara- tion and the execution of business. I should doubt if he ever asked for the continuance or postponement of a case in court for his own personal convenience... . “He was distinguished for his prepara- tion of the law of a case, as well as of its facts, and his opponents learned to be on the look-out against his assaults and sur- prises. He continued the same studious, active, attentive and successful lawyer until he exchanged his duties at the bar for those of the bench. ... There were distinguished lawyers and advocates in this bar at that BOI ahs hci a , but no one of them possessed a better professional aptitude or had at- tained a better professional fame than John Appleton.” The bench is what the bar chooses to make it. This tireless, hard-worked lawyer did not forget what he owed the profession in this respect. The two fundamental re- forms which he largely assisted in bringing about are those relating to the abolition of the District Court and the removal of the disability of parties as witnesses in their own cases. Notwithstanding the great eminence he acquired as a judge, I think he took nearly, if not fully, as much satisfaction to himself in seeing his advanced views adopt- ed by the legislature. While at the bar he moved and promoted the plan of consolidat- ing the District and Supreme Judicial Courts, by abolishing the one and concentrating in the other the jurisdiction belonging to both; also consolidating into three districts the law court which sat in each county. He was chairman of a commission appointed by the legislature to consider and report a plan, and drafted the act by which the present system was established in 1852. Of these labors he has said, since he retired from the bench: “The delays incidental to and resulting from two Courts with appeals to and exceptions from one to the other, led to the entire transference of the jurisdiction of the District to that of the Supreme Court, with a saving of the delay, expense and vexation incident to protracted litigation; © so that I think it may be truly said that there is no State in New England where a judgment may be obtained so speedily and with so little expense as in this good State of ours, when parties and counsel desire it.” At the time (1883) when he thus spoke there were only 950 actions pending on the docket of the Supreme Court, whereas a few years after he began practice at Bangor (1837) there were 1,484 actions on the 513 7”
Page 28
514 docket of that Court, and 3,512 actions on the docket of the District Court. While he modestly attributes the result as due to the prosperity of the times, the community at large did not fail to see that it was largely due to the reform he had brought about in the manner indicated. The rules of evidence engaged his atten- tion much earlier. In 1833 he began writ- ing upon this subject to the “ Jurist,” and his articles were collected and published, in 1860, at Philadelphia, in ‘‘ Appleton on Evi- dence,” by Johnson & Co. In it will be found the arguments and discussions which finally led to the change by which parties to causes, both civil and criminal, are ad- mitted to testify in their own behalf. This rule now prevails, with some modifications, in all the courts of the country, both State and National; and the credit of the same is due to Chief Justice Appleton, more than any other one man. It must not be supposed that so impor- tant‘a change did not encounter opposition. On the contrary, the hostility was active and lively. It was not adopted generally until time and experience in Maine and England had proved it to be wise and salutary. As illustrating this opposition, the following in- cident told by the Judge himself will be in- teresting :— ‘But the Bar were not alone smitten with the terror of change. Many years ago I sent to the editor of the ‘North American Re- view’ —a learned professor of the leading University in this continent, a review of Greenleaf’s treatise on evidence, criticising the work, and advocating the general prin- ciple that all who can by any of the organs of sense perceive and perceiving can make known their perceptions to others should be received as witnesses to make known such perceptions, leaving their force and effect to the tribunal, whose duty it might be to judge of the trustworthiness of testimony. The article was sent back as dangerous and inflammatory in its character, with the cour- where the editor was less timorous. The Green Bag. teous and complimentary suggestion on the part of the professor that he should as soon athink of turning a mad bull loose ina crock- ery shop as aid in spreading such heresies. But it was published in another review Some of the cracked earthen-ware in the shop has been demolished, more should be—the china is safe. “The article was not without its effect. Read and concurred in by Mr. David Dud- ley Field, the chairman of the committee of codification, it was communicated to his as- sociates, by whom its leading principles were adopted and incorporated in the statutes of New York.” He was appointed to the bench of the Su- preme Court, May 11, 1852. Maine was then a Democratic State, and the appoint- ment was given to him, then in the minority or Whig party. During his thirty-one years’ service on the bench, it may be said he had no friendships and no enmities. He endeavored to mete out impartial justice; protecting the young and inexperienced in his beginnings, and giving to the veteran experienced in foren+ sic strife no more than his just rights. He shrank from no labor, nor evaded any respon- sibility. It is easy now to see that he would bring to the bench the same industry that marked his life at the bar. And such was the fact. This talent, almost amounting to genius, enabled him with an extraordinary, quick intellect to dispatch easily a large amount of business. He carried the same degree of zeal into his written opinions; and there, aided with a masterly knowledge of authorities, he was able to dispose of law cases with promptness. His motto in this respect was “ Vulla dies sine linea.” Buf- fon says ‘the style is the man”; so his written opinions often resemble himself in clear and forcible expressions, rising at times to a spontaneous grace of composition. This together with their wide range -of topics, will be found in the following cases,
Page 29
Lhe Supreme Court of Maine. all treating important questions which ex- cited great public interest: Donahoe. v. Richards, 38 Maine, 379 (1854), in which the court hold that a school committee are invested with quasi-judicial powers and not + subject to revision by the court when hon- . estly and fairly used. Opinions of the Justices, 44 Maine, 521 (1857), relating to the case of Dred Scott. Judge Appleton wrote a separate answer containing a masterly grasp of the law, his- tory and research of authorities. His fame as a jurist might well rest alone upon this single opinion as a good example of the breadth of his learning, ready application of authorities, and soundness of judgment. A leading case often cited in other States is Allen v. Jay, 60 Maine, 124 (1872). It holds that towns, as municipal corporations, are not constitutionally authorized to loan their credit to individuals to engage in manufacturing, or other private business. Another important case, involving the taxing power, is State v. Me. Cent. R. R. Co., 66 Maine, 488 (1877). The defend- ant corporation claimed that it was exempted from taxation under a consolidation act, but the court decided otherwise; holding in its opinion that a surrender of the taxing power by the State can be established only by the most clear and explicit language. The student of history will find these opin- ions are landmarks in the growth of Ameri- can jurisprudence. The last named case was affirmed by the United States Supreme Court on an appeal, and is reported in 6 Otto, 499. While there is never any acerbity or want of true judicial dignity in his written opin- ions, there is an occasional light and harm- less touch of playful humor to be found in them, and by means of which the practi- tioner can instantly recall the point decided. It is the overflow of the full mind and a genial temper. ‘Almost all who sign as surety,” says the Judge in Mayo v. Hutchin- son, 57 Maine, 547, ‘‘have the occasion to 515 remember the proverb of Solomon: ‘He that is surety for a stranger shall smart for it, and he that hateth suretyship is sure.’ But they are nevertheless held liable upon their contracts, otherwise there would be no smarting, and the proverb would fail.” In overruling a faulty plea in abatement ten- dered by two defendants who used inter- changeably the singular pronoun “he” with the plural ‘‘they,” he concludes with the scriptural injunction, ‘“ Let htm who thinketh that he standeth beware lest he falleth.” He disliked tobacco, but appreciated the uses of the cigar. In an action upon a re- ceipt to the sheriff who had attached some fragrant Havanas and which were not forth- coming to be sold on execution, he remarks, as if glad they no longer existed: ‘The five thousand Spanish cigars were sold; each had accomplished its destiny, ‘ tenuesque recessit Consumpta in ventos.’” He never showed temper or irritability. He was a model inthis respect. Nor was he ever wanting in true courage. His life was a daily proof that he possessed a moral courage of the highest degree. - He trained himself to look upon the best side of men at all times, thus no record remains of words sharp and caustic only for their wit. Yet he could give and take a good joke. We give a few illustrations: Said a merchant to the Judge, ‘This bankrupt law is robbing our firm of thousands of dollars.” “Oh no! neighbor Jones!” replied the Judge, “it is the insolvency of your debtors.” During an intermission of the law-court, just after the long and somewhat tedious pauper case of Alton v. Lagrange, the Chief-Justice turned to his associate on the bench, Judge Kent, and remarked, ‘‘I think the pauper in this case, Rand, was once a client of mine.” ‘And that is the reason probably why he is a pauper now,” quickly added Mr. Jus- tice Kent. | A master in chancery once asked his opinion of the reasonableness of a cer-
Page 30
516 tain lawyer’s account for services rendered in a case. The lawyer was noted for his knowledge of all the fee table and his claim was objected to as being excessive. With a twinkle in his eye the Judge answered, ‘Well! I think Brother C, is velzable in his charges.” His definition of the ‘ independent” in |. politics is too good to be lost. He defined them thus: “They are the kind of politi- cians who go with you when you do not need them, but are sure to be against you when you want them.” No sketch of this great man would be perfect without some reference to another trait in his character; his kindness to young men of the bar. He will always be remem- bered with:affection for this endearing char- acteristic.. A beautiful tribute to his memo- ry, in this respect, may be found in a letter of Hon. W. P. Frye, United States Senator, 83d volume, Maine Reports, page 600. Upon retiring from the bench in Septem- ber, 1883, he was tendered a reception and dinner by the Penobscot Bar which was also attended by distinguished members from other parts of the State. The speeches then made and his reply were touching and eloquent,—a fitting finale to his long and successful life. Besides his active judicial duties he was constant in attendance as a trustee of Bow- doin College, by which institution he was given the degree of LL.D. He was a regular attendant and suppor- ter of the Unitarian church and a loyal ad- herent to the preaching of Rev. Dr. Hedge, Professors Allen and Everett, and their suc- cessors. He passed the remainder of his life, at home and among friends, enjoying the rich fruitage of an old age’ respected by the world and loved by all. Upon his death, which occurred February 7, 1891, memorial exercises were held be- fore the full bench, June term following, at The Green Bag. Bangor. They were marked with eulogies both fitting and eloquent. These with a beautiful, able and touching response by Chief Justice Peters will be found published in the eighty-third volume of the Maine Re- ports. JOHN ANDREW PETERS, the seventh and present Chief Justice, was born 9th of Octo- ber, 1822, at Ellsworth, Hancock County, Maine. He is the second son of Andrew and Sally (Jordan) Peters, and comes of Revolutionary ancestry. One of them, An- drew Peters, was a major in Clinton’s Bri- gade, in the battle of Long Island,.August 27,1776. His maternal grandfather, Mela- tiah Jordan, was a prominent citizen and was -appointed Collector of Frenchman’s Bay District, August 4, 1789, about four months after the government was inaugurat- ed under the Constitution. His commission was signed by George Washington, Presi- dent, and countersigned by Thomas Jeffer- son, Secretary of State. He continued un- der that commission until he died, Decem- ber, 1818. Commissions of that kind, up to 1825 when the law was changed, continued during life or good behavior. He was highly beloved for kindness of heart, sociability, and genial suavity of manners which, with a | character for strict integrity, endeared him to all who knew him. His paternal grandfather, John, of Blue- hill, was a land surveyor. He was intrusted by the Commonwealth of Massachusetts with difficult and important services in the Dis- trict of Maine, which he discharged with ac- curacy and ability. Among the services was that of the original lotting of townships in. eastern Maine, his assistants being his sons, John, Jr., and James Peters, and his son-in- law, Reuben Dodge. The lines thus run remain undisturbed to this day. The father, Andrew, like others of his racégjwas a merchant dealing in lumber, mills and shipping. He was a man of com- manding figure, of fine regular features. de-
Page 31
Lhe Supreme Court of Maine. 507 noting a natural repose, somewhat grave de- portment and noted in all his transactions for his readiness of decision, honesty and MURRNBe srrsrtriincn rearitn Peeve t pHs SRN abit fio BhaH Sis FreerLssii tier tty tro His aptitude as a scholar decided his par- ents to give the son a liberal education. He was accordingly put to school at Gorham JOHN ANDREW PETERS. fidelity. The *mother was of a lively tem- perament, good nature and quick sensibility. These qualities, with a fine sense of humor and ready sympathy, were ever apparent. Mirthful and fond of wit, she had the faculty of drawing the same qualities from others. Academy, where he fitted for Yale, graduat- ing there in 1842 with high honors. The title of his graduating part at Yale was “ The Pro- fession of Politics,” and was a statesmanlike production. Having decided to enter the legal profession he took a course at the
Page 32
518 Harvard Law School and thus came to the bar, being admitted in August, 1844, at Ells- worth, fully prepared and equipped for an active and highly successful practice which soon followed upon his removal to Bangor the same year. To his chosen profession, which he loved, possessing a keen, critical and judicial judg- ment, and a wide and accurate knowledge of the law, he added the habit of industry. He was thus able, with a good legal mind and an instinctive knowledge of men, to command the confidence of courts and cli- ents from the beginning. He was quickly recognized as a very able lawyer and duly appreciated for those qualities by which he has become conspicuous. Judged by the results accomplished, the verdicts won and judgments in law cases rendered in his favor, I should say, after an active practice of near- ly thirty years, that he was facile princeps. At the beginning of his practice he was a partner for a short time with the late Judge Hathaway; and for the five years before going upon the bench himself, his partner was Franklin A. Wilson, Esq. His management of the trial of a case was natural, simple and easily understood by the | jury. He always brought out the facts in their historical and logical order; rarely ever calling witnesses in rebuttal, he grouped his evidence with a master’s hand and passed from point to point with the unbroken pha- lanx of a well-ordered battle. It was a pleas- ure to witness him trying a case. There was nothing dull or commonplace in it. He led the column, and the spectator soon be- came aware that, although like Phillips he possessed the “ars celare artem,” yet he was the principal actor. I have seen him in a ten days’ trial, opposed by numerous coun- sel, single-handed holding his sway over the jury almost without intermission, their eyes bent on him with only an occasional glance upon the witnesses. Perhaps this is only saying that, according to an admitted test of ability, he is the best examiner of wit- Lhe Green Bag. nesses that I have ever seen; but there was no weariness or loss of interest in it. His cross-examination was the perfection of skill and legal ability. If his opponent’s case had a weak spot he was sure to find it when he came to cross-examine, — sometimes to the merriment of the court and jury. Cases were thus sometimes turned into victory or defeat. I recall an instance. In Prentiss v. Shaw, an action of trespass for an assault and battery, the plaintiff, who had been rid- den on a rail, claimed large damages for a dislocated hip. An eminent surgeon testi- fied in his favor, sustaining the claim of dis- location, after a post tnjuriam examination of the leg. The defense seemed hopeless ; but a few questions adroitly put to the hon- est doctor by Mr. Peters, soon elicited the fact from the witness that he had treated dislocations caused by rheumatism and the opinion that this case might possibly have occurred from the same cause. It was a famous case in its day. The jury gave the plaintiff a verdict amounting to a sum equal to only a trifle more than-the value of a single day’s work. His arguments were always strong, logi- cal, clear, forcible, and replete with incidents and illustrations appealing to the good sense of the jury. He has a fund of maxims and anecdotes from Shakespeare to Poor Rich- ard’s Almanac, to which references serve to lighten the task of listening; and drays ex- planations from all sources. Distinguishing the testimony of one brother from that of another, one being fat the other lean, he concluded with the quaint remark, ‘ One is the son of the father, the other is son of the mother.” As the parents were known to the jury, the remark was significant. He did not seek criminal defenses, but would never permit a person to go undefended when he believed him to be innocent. An old client of his was indicted in the United States District Court, sitting at Bangor, for selling liquor without a license. It was in the early days of enforcement of the internal revenue
Page 33
The Supreme Court of Maine. law, when the statute made one sale prima facie evidence of the offense. Without offer- ing a single witness in defense, he placed his reliance upon the jury. The complainant had shown himself to be an informer, and that was all the counsel for the defendant cared to know. He denounced the witness with hot and fiery words as sordid, detesta- ble, corrupt and thoroughly unreliable. For half an hour he poured out his contempt upon the case in language that astonished all by its burning eloquence, and withering scorn. His face was illuminated with the intensity of his action; his eyes were filled with the glow of strife. Suddenly stopping, his voice vibrating with emotion, he said: ‘Gentlemen: my soul is stirred from its very depths with the meanness of this crea- ture in the semblance of a man. Yet it pains me to be compelled to speak unkindly even of him, for I love my fellow-man. Aut would you believe him?’ ‘The scene was dramatic and never to be forgotten. The jury returned a verdict of acquittal, hardly leaving their seats after the closing argument _of the District Attorney and a charge by the Court strongly in favor of a conviction. I doubt if any other defense would have pre- vailed. Certainly his argument was widely different from his usual methods in which his playful wit is used to the delight of all without giving pain to any one. Adhering strictly to the practice of his profession, he was soon retained in all the important causes pending in Penobscot and Hancock Counties, covering all branches of. law and equity. Some are noted for the magnitude of the verdicts that he won, like Boody v. Goddard, and Dwinel v. Veazie. In the latter case there were three trials, the verdicts aggregating more than twenty thou- sand dollars. In the meantime the personal popularity and following which so eminent an advocate engendered became a potent factor in poli- tics. Although a Whig, he was the unani- mous choice of the Union party and by it 519 elected to the Maine Senate two successive terms in 1862 and 3. The next year, 1864, he was chosen by a large majority a mem- ber of the House, where he took an active part in the debates. Among them was one upon the removal of the capitol from Au- gusta to Portland. He led the opposition with his usual success, in a speech which at- tracted wide attention for the ability dis- played and capacity to handle subjects out- side the legal forum. He was elected Attor- ney-General of the State by the Legislature for the years 1864-5 and 6, and performed the duties satisfactorily. Having thus en- tered upon a public and political life, his election to Congress followed with ease and certainty as the choice of the Republican party. He was first elected in 1866 to the Fortieth Congress, and served upon the Committees on Patents and Public Expendi- tures. His second election was in 1868 to the Forty-first Congress. His third election was in 1870 to the Forty-second Congress, serving upon the Committee on the Judiciary and as chairman of the Joint Committee on the Congressional Library. It would be difficult to single out a member during these six years who had greater personal influ- ence. Good natured, humorous and imper- turbable, nothing obstructed his pathway to success whenever he advocated the passage: of some desirable measure. The following incident related to the writer by General Garfield in 1876 will illustrate this: “‘Observing an aged lady dressed in deep mourning who, sitting in the gallery, was a constant attendant upon the daily sessions of the House, the Judge learned by inquiry that she was interested in a pri- vate Bill for a pension. After an examina- tion that disclosed it was meritorious, and needed but one thing,-a champion, he called it up from the calendar, and by a few words of explanation and personal appeal obtained unanimous consent for its consideration with- out a report from the committee; and it was instantly put upon its passage under a sus-
Page 34
520 pension of the rules. Then followed a scene in the House, the like of which has never before nor since been witnessed. Stepping down from his seat, the Judge paused in front of the Speaker, and waving his hand in the air towards the gallery where the claim- ant sat, he exclaimed: ‘ There, old woman! You have got your bill!’ The astonishment of the House and the merriment which fol- lowed, can be imagined better than de- scribed.” He introduced and procured the adoption of the statute, then prevailing in Maine, by which parties are permitted to testify in their own cases. His previous experience as At- torney-General readily supplied him with ample arguments to overcome all opposition to this new feature of National legislation. His eulogy upon Senator Fessenden was highly appreciated by a full House, and placed him in the estimation of associates, like Bingham, Blaine and Garfield, in the front rank of able orators. The following epitome is found in Blaine’s “Twenty Years of Congress,” Vol. 2, page 290: ‘Another marked character came from New England, John A. Peters, of Maine, a graduate of Yale, a man of ability, of humor, of learning in the law. He had enjoyed the advantage of a successful career at the bar and was, by long training and in- deed by instinct devoted to his profession. In his six years’ service in the House he acquired among his fellow-members a per- sonal popularity and personal influence rarely surpassed in Congressional experi- ence. He made no long speeches and was not frequently on the floor, but when he rose he spoke forcibly, aptly, attractively, and with that unerring sense of justice which al- ways carried him to the right side of a ques- tion, withsunmistakable influence upon the best judgment of the house.” And Mr. Blaine adds: ‘Since his retirement from Congress his career on the Supreme Bench of Maine, and more recently as its Chief- Justice, has given roundness and complete- The Green Bag. ness to a character whose integrity, gener- osity, and candor have attracted not only the confidence and respect of an entire State, but the devoted attachment of a continually enlarging circle of friends.” Enthusiastically sustained by his constitu- ents, to whom he rendered a constant and erowing usefulness as a Congressman, he never was content to give up his chosen profession. He therefore declined another election. In May, 1873, he was appointed an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the State, his fitness being recognized by universal consent and approbation. Judge Peters has presided twenty-two years on the Maine bench, serving half of the time as. Chief-Justice. “To summarize, it may be said he has worked hard all his life ; he has made his own way in the world against constant competition; he obtained a great place at the bar; he went into poli- tics and became a strong figure in the House of Representatives; he has won the prizes of his profession, ending with the greatest of all, the Chief-Justiceship. This is great praise, yet justly due and fairly won. It is slight, however, compared with the grand service to the State rendered by him as ‘‘ the good judge.” Of this service I will speak sparingly now. The book is not closed. If younger readers desire a description of the good judge drawn by the hand of a master, consummate in delineation, let them read the address by Mr. Choate on the judicial tenure in the Massachusetts Constitutional Convention of 1853. It is there that they will find the reasons and the causes why the whole community turn to Judge Peters with unvarying respect, veneration and love. To analyze a little in detail, I would say, he has always been famous for that alertness of mind which is to a lawyer a most useful quality. He grasps a new subject, or new set of facts, or a new proposition, at once, and turns readily from one to another. In- tricate matters become plain when he ex- pounds them. His exposition of law and
Page 35
The Supreme Court of Maine. fact to the jury leaves nothing to be desired in point of clearness and comprehension. He has a mind as transparent as a sheet of plate glass. It is achromatic, and whatever is seen through it is seen in its true light, and free from prismatic hues. He is something more than a judge; he has a judicial mind, and has moderation and common sense, and the power of seeing both sides. The result is, he is trusted. He has, withal, the confi- dence of his associates on the bench and of the community. To be believed to be such is the crown of success, as Mr. Choate has well said. To his abundant learning, his unques- tioned ability and integrity, and his genial manners I should add the possession of a rare tact in conducting a trial. said his predecessor, Chief Justice Appleton, “his adverse rulings are made more satis- factory to the losing party than the favora- ble ones of anybody else to the winning party.” In his wise and firm administration of the ‘‘whole learning of the law” he has made it his business not to suffer justice to the liti- gant, that unvarying goal, to be overcome by any technicality. His love of equity has, however, never been a morbid sentiment leading to a blind sacrifice of the principles of law, resembling in this, as in many other respects, that lovable character, Chief Justice Mellen. Of his written opinions, it may be said that they are valuable acquisitions to all branches of the law by reason of their strength, soundness and depth of research. Nothing issues from his pen that is not fin- ished and perfect. Like polished gems they shed light upon whatever they touch. His style of writing is always strong, clear and accurate in statement. He possesses an ease which, with an exquisite touch, ren- ders ordinary common-place things and characters interesting from their truth of the description. At times he rises above the level of the cold judicial style. A good ex- “ By this,” ‘a month, or even for years. 521 ample of this, and of his predominating love of justice, is found in Gross v. Rice, 71 Maine, 241, which holds that a statute is unconstitutional that requires, ‘‘ No convict shall be discharged from the State prison until he has remained the full term for which he was sentenced, excluding the time he may have been in solitary confinement for any violation of the rules and regulations of the prison.” From the opinion by Judge Peters I make an extract; ‘ Although the process author- ized by the statute and prison rules for prison discipline may be ever so just and humane, yet so far as punishment was imposed after (not during) sentence, it was not ¢/e process, nor the due process of law demanded by the constitution. ... What we do say is, that under a sentence of four years a prisoner cannot be held longer than four.years; that all punishments must be inflicted upon a convict during his term, and neither directly nor indirectly afterwards. ... The common law requires that the punishment of persons convicted of crime shall be definite and cer- tain. Praemunire was an exception, as for that offense a convict could be imprisoned during the pleasure of the king. The sen- tence must inform the convict as to the kind and duration of his imprisonment. This is too clear to need authority or argument... But if this statute is constitutional, then.there can be no definite sentences awarded. The will of the warden would in effect control the maximum duration. It is plainly to be seen that, in this way, the warden could ex- tend a punishment indefinitely. If he can prolong a sentence a day, he can a week, or And that too for transgressions not of an aggravated char- actOreiss ‘What a wide field this idea of such un- limited power over a convict opens into! How uncertain and varying would be the results! How much would be made to de- pend upon the good or bad judgment of a warden! How much upon the whim or ca-
Page 36
522 The Green Bag. price, the passions and temper, not only of the warden, but of his agents and servants and employees. It is not an answer, that an appeal lies from the warden to the over- seers. [he convict is in no position to make an appeal. ‘Bondage is hoarse, and may not speak aloud’ says the great poet.”. ... The law of water and water-courses forms a large body of the decisions of the Maine court. I hazard but little in saying that no state has furnished a superior line of author- ity, or been more often quoted by other courts. A new question arose upon this branch of the law in Pearson v. Rolfe, 76 Maine, 380: I refer to the opinion of Chief-Justice Peters as exhibiting his strong handling of the sub- ject in a manner that has forever settled the principle in this state. The question relates to the rights of navigation and ripa- rian owners. The decision holds that when- ever logs cannot be driven over a particular portion of a fresh-water rivet above the ebb and flow of the tide, while in its natural con- dition, such portion of the river is not at such times navigable or floatable ; and the use of the water at such time and place, so far as he needs the same for his own pur- poses, belongs exclusively to the riparian proprietor, who in this case was the mill owner and had erected a dam. But I must forbear from further citations of his opinions as being foreign to the pur- pose of the present article. Of his charges to the jury, the reader will find some selec- tions in Drew v. Hagerty, 81 Maine, 231, which will richly repay a careful study of the law in causa mortis and inter vivos gifts. I have alluded to his ease and perspicuity of style ; there is, besides, an individuality that stamps it wholly as his own ; a happy faculty of condensation at the conclusion of a sentence, or an idea, that, like the Goddess of Liberty on the American coins, fits it for circulation. His opinions are studded with them like jewels. They are live epigrams. Speaking of a description in a deed, claimed to be void for uncertainty, he says, ‘It is not a roving half-acre.” Of an early Eng- lish Act, he says, “Its meaning is greater than its words.” Again, ‘Easements are of flexible adaptation,” and of accepting a char- ter, ‘‘ Late events show the earlier intention.” ‘They were appropriators and not owners,” he thus calls the claimants of property under tax-titles. Of an amended declaration he remarks, “It was a skeleton bare, it is now the skeleton clothed.” And occasionally we find a pithy idea thus expressed, ‘“‘ There are but few strictly and purely legal presump- tions.” These are but indications of Bacon’s “ full mind.” There is also the ‘‘ready man.” His conversation and speeches for fifty years are replete with wit, humor and mirthful- ness. In the presidential campaign of 1864 he said: “If McClellan couldn’t take Rich- mond making Washington his base, you may safely swear he will never take Washington, making Richmond his base.” In the fusion campaign of 1855 that elect- ed Samuel Wells governor, he addressed a large gathering at night when his fellow cit- izens rallied ex masse with torch-lights in the street. Upon being introduced he bowed and began with, ‘‘ Fellow Democrats.” But at that moment a sudden gust of wind extinguished the torches. It became inky dark. For an instant it was very still. Peters might have been astonished ; but he wasn't. He began again. ‘Fellow Demo- crats,’ he shouted. ‘The wind has blown out our lights. It is so dark that I cannot see my hands before my eyes. I cannot see you, fellow Democrats, but I know you are all here. J can smell you.” He never carries into social life the anx- ieties of his position and duties, or any trace of them. One who should meet him for the first time, and who did not know him, would be sure to think he belonged to the leisure class. He has always had easy and leisurely manners, and a way of meeting mere acquaint- ances asif they were friends, yet with sim- plicity and with no affectation.
Page 37
The Supreme Court of Maine. He received his commission as Chief Jus- tice August 29, 1883. The degree of LL.D. was conferred upon him by Colby University in 1884, by Bowdoin College in 1885, and by Yale in 1893. In 1891 he was elected a trustee of Bowdoin College. No sketch of Chief-Justice Peters would be complete without reference to his after- dinner speeches. No matter what the occa- sion, whether it be a bar gathering, or a meeting of Bowdoin or Yale alumni, his presence is always the forerunner of the most enjoyable hour of the feast. His mirth and good-natured humor never fail to bring down the house with uproarious applause. He has the happy faculty of utilizing the occasion with thought appropriate to the time, while his talk is unstudied and mixed with wit and jest which captivate and en- 523 trance his listeners. He never says any- thing that wounds the feelings of others and at the same time he is audacious in punctur- ing shams and all kinds of pretense. The presence of grave college-presidents, his dignified associates on the bench and sober and solemn members of the bar, does not deter him, for they all enjoy the fun and join in the laughter that will break out in spite of themselves. These speeches have never been reported. They are as unreportable as the bubbles of champagne, the delicious flavor of Chateau Yquem, or the flash of diamonds and the songs of birds. Even if it were possible to re- produce his words, there would be still want- ing their setting with the occasion, and over all the speaker himself, beaming, debonair, bland — the inspiration of the hour. CASSIUS ON CAESAR’S DEATH. By Benjy. F. BuRNHAM. Brutus: Cassius, go you into the other street, and part the numbers. Those that will hear me speak, let them stay here; those that will follow Cassius, go with him; and public reasons shall be rendered of Ceesar’s death. — JuLius Ca@sar: Act III, Scene 2. Friends! Romans! Nobler title hath no man Than that which hails him citizen of Rome. Are you not patriots all? I know ye are. But if, too fondly proud, I’m self-deceived, And there stand here a single human form That shrines a heart not throbbing with Rome's weal, Let such one close his ears and slink away, Whiles I, with this poor tremulous voice, Yet with most honest purpose do protest My solemn yearning that in this grave hour We think no thought, precipitate no deed, That is not offspring of brave reason’s throes.
Page 38
524 | The Green Bag. Pain hath a wholesome office. Giddy Joy Deranges oft the mind’s glad mustered force. In mourning mood the soul is at her best. Serenely then doth Sympathy enthrone Sweet Charity upon the judgment seat. My candid brother, if thy good right hand Become, through reckless, overgrasping use, _ Diseased, — offensive past medicament, — But ere insidious poison pulsing on, Enleavens dire destruction through thy frame, Some surgeons with unflinching nerve confront, Pounce on the inflated nuisance, cut it off, And then, with burning cautery applied Along the quivering, expiating flesh, Arrest the covert intercourse of death, Are not those faithful fortitudes thy friends? So were our trusty senators convened In conclave o’er the body politic ; And searching with unshrinking scrutiny A member boasted to be Rome's right hand, Detected subtle symptoms moribund : In its disordered, unrestrained outreach Usurping functions of the corporate whole. To amputate that hand incurable Was a most grievous duty to be done; But its behest the hero statesmen heard, Albeit bemoaned they the exigency. No less they cherished all the memories Of that hand’s ministrations to the State; No less they listened to the whisperings Of private friendship’s gratitude and grace; But louder came to patriot ears the call Of country. So the consequent response. There needs no prescience to forecast the doom Of commonwealth whenever government Becomes not by and for the people all. — Lo, Brutus now holds forth in yonder street! Go we and listen, for methinks he saith He loved not Czsar-less but Rome the more.
Page 39
London Legal Letter. 525 LONDON LEGAL LETTER. Lonpon, Oct. 2, 1895. N incident of what may very properly be called the silly season — that long hiatus in domestic life when the urban denizens leave their comfortable homes for un- comfortable lodgings at the seaside, when the law courts are hermetically sealed, when the theatre audiences are made up of country cousins, and even staid, respectable and leading newspapers open their columns to lengthy com- munications on such trivialities as “The Age of Love,” — illustrates the differences between the customs of the English and American people, and the law which has grown up in the two countries out of these divergent customs. The other day it was announced that Mrs. Langtry had lost £40,000, a cool $200,000 worth of jewels. She had gone abroad, and before doing so had deposited a -box containing these jewels with her bankers. A few days thereafter a messenger appeared at the bank with what purported to be an order from Mrs. Langtry requesting the delivery to him of the jewels. The bank gave them up, and it was not until weeks had elapsed, and Mrs. Lang- try had returned to town, that it was discovered that the order was a forgery. It had been very cleverly executed upon a sheet of note paper which had either been pur- loined from Mrs. Langtry’s writing-table or made in exact imitation of that used by Mrs. Langtry'and bearing her ad- dress engraved thereon. In America, it is fair to presume, there would be a grave question as to the responsibility of the bank. Here its exemption from liability arouses no controversy, except perhaps among laymen. ‘The loss will unquestionably fall upon Mrs. Langtry; and that her legal advisers appreciate this is evident from the fact that they are making diligent efforts to recover the valuables and that Mrs. Langtry is offering a reward of £500 for such information as will lead to the conviction of the offender. Banks in England and banks in America are very different institutions, and are governed by widely dissimilar laws. The American bank is purely and simply a moneyed in- stitution, and deals in nothing but cash and its representa- tives. Here even the modern joint-stock banks preserve some of the features of the old-fashioned family banking firms, and receive into their custody the valuables of their clients of whatsoever nature, just as two hundred and fifty years ago the banks of that time were accustomed to nightly take their coin and currency to the Goldsmiths Company for safe keeping. This part of the business of the modern bank is rarely charged for, particularly where the customer maintains a satisfactory balance to his credit; and thus Mrs. Langtry’s bankers escape liability on the ground that, being gratuitious or “naked” bailees, they are not chargeable with ordinary negligence, but only with gross negligence. The leading case (Giblin v. McMullin, L. R. 2 P. C. 317) goes much further even than Mrs. Langtry’s. There a customer deposited his strong box, containing securities, with his bankers, who received nothing for their services, he himself retaining the key. Certain debentures were abstracted by the cashier; and it was held by the Privy Council that as there was no proof of gross negligence the bank was not liable. Such gratuitous bailment by banks is not customary in the United States, the convenient and impregnable safe deposit institutions being resorted to for the sake of greater safety. But it is not only in this respect that the banking customs and the laws of the two countries widely differ. j Here if A gives B an open cheque payable to B or his order the bank upon which it is drawn will pay the cheque without making the slightest inquiry as to the identity of B. It suffices if the paying teller is satisfied of the genuine- ness of the drawer’s signature. Of course if the drawer’s signature is forged and the bank cashes the cheque, the bank is responsible to the drawer; but there its liability rests. The present Bills of Exchange Act provides that ‘‘where a banker upon whom a cheque is drawn pays it in good faith and in the ordinary course of business, it is not incumbent on the banker to show that the indorsement of the payee was made by or under the authority of the per- son whose indorsement it purports to be, and the banker is deemed to have paid the bill in due course, although such indorsement has been forged or made without authority.” And the act makes this remarkable definition of what is meant by “good faith” in the preceding sentence: “A thing is deemed to be done in good faith within the meaning of this act where it is in fact done honestly, whether it is done negligently or not.” This, standing alone, would seem to be a startling and monstrous perversion of the law in favor of the banker; but it is not as bad as it looks. The same Bills of Exchange Acts provide a way by which the drawer of a cheque may effectually protect himself if he desires to do so, and that is by “crossing ” his cheque “ generally ”’ or “specially.” The cheque is crossed ‘“ generally ” when two parallel lines, usually about an inch apart, are drawn across the face of the cheque; thus crossed the cheque will not be paid across the counter of a bank, but only through the clearing house. The “specially” crossed cheque is one upon which and within the crossed lines the. name of a particular bank is written. When thus crossed the cheque can be paid only to the bank thus designated. Then, the law says, provision has been made by which the drawer of a cheque may protect himself; and if he fails to avail himself of this protection, but issues “open” or un- crossed cheques, he must take the responsibility, and not the bank. This custom thus sanctioned by law works ad- mirably and to a greater degree of convenience to the pub- lic than the American system, where, before a payee of a cheque may get it cashed, he must be known to the cashier or be vouched for — often to the extent of the voucher having to add his name to that of the endorsement of the payee, and incurring thereby an unpleasant responsi- bility. And in connection with Mrs. Langtry is another bit of gossip which is, or should be of interest to American lawyers. It is announced that, having acquired a domicile in California, she intends to obtain in that State a decree of divorce against her husband on the ground of his desertion of her and failure to support her. Such a decree, based upon such grounds, would, for reasons which are apparent
Page 40
526 The Green Bag. to the public, be a travesty on justice, and would tend to still further lessen, if possible, the estimation in. which American divorce decrees are held in England. So much has been said about the anomalous character of divorce legislation in the Western States and the ease with which divorces may be obtained, that the subject is looked upon as exhausted and the evil one that must, perhaps on account of its iniquity, be left to work out its own remedy. But there is one feature of the subject to which, it is submitted, at- tention has not been drawn, and that is the responsibility of the judges who preside over the courts in which these facile divorces are granted. It seems to be naturally as- sumed by them that if the technical rules of procedure are complied with they have no option but to grant the de- cree. Such an exercise, or rather failure of exercise, of a judge’s prerogative is beyond the comprehension of an English lawyer. To him a judge is a judge in the broad- est meaning that can be given to the word. The function of the judge of any one of the English courts, from the High Court to the pettiest magistrate, is to administer justice — and not merely to see that certain technical rules of practice are complied with. If the judges of the courts in those States which have become most notorious for the looseness of their divorce practice could be induced to take this view of their functions, the evil would be greatly lessened if not altogether done away with. An illustration of how the system works at present and why the English people have a contempt for divorce practice in America has recently occurred here. In 1881 one John Reid Mc- Allister married, in a suburb of London. Two years afterwards he went to Omaha, leaving his wife to follow him when he had made the necessary arrangements for her home there. He sent her money sufficient for her support, and then, after having been in America a little over a year, wrote to his wife to join him. She packed her trunks, in which were a number of articles made by her own hands for his wear, and was about to sail when she received a cablegram, “ Don’t sail. Am leaving Omaha.” From that time until 1891 she never heard from him, and then through a third person she received a copy of a decree of a divorce which had been granted to him in June, 1888, by the “ District Court of the Third Judicial District of Omaha for Douglas County, the Hon, Eleazer Wakeley, one of the judges, presiding.” The decree, as usual, recites that the court finds that “due notice of the filing and pending of the petition was given to the defendant according to law and she has failed to answer or demur to said petition. And that said parties were married as set forth on the pe- tition and that the plaintiff has been wilfully abandoned by the defendant, without just cause, for the term of two years prior to the filing of the petition, and that the defendant has committed adultery with one Mr. Roland as alleged in the petition.” It is of course unnecessary to say that there is not a word of truth, except as to the marriage, in any allegation of this recital. The wife, as a matter of fact, resided during the whole period of her husband’s absence, first with his ceedings were regular on their face. mother and then with her own father. The mother-in- law’s house was on the same street and nearly opposite the house where Mrs. McAllister’s father has now been residing for nearly seventeen years.. The address of the wife. was. constantly known to the husband. The Mr. Roland whom it is conjectured the decree refers to, is a physician who attended the wife during the fatal illness of a child who was born two days after the father left for Omaha. This physician, in all, paid three visits to the wife, and some one was in the room on each occasion, and the wife has never seen him on any other occasion. The details of this story are possibly no more striking than those of numerous other tales of a similar character which might be cited, and they are mentioned now only to draw attention to what is considered in this country a scandal- ous dereliction of duty on the part of the judge who pro- nounced the decree. It may be admitted that the pro- The return of the sheriff undoubtedly showed that the defendant could not be found, and an order of publication was doubtless ob- tained. Then the plaintiff gave such evidence as he had been instructed was sufficient to entitle him to a decree, and the decree was pronounced. But, it is submitted, this is not in accordance with the spirit of the law, no matter how closely it adheres to the letter. It was un- questionably the duty of the judge, particularly as the proceedings were undefended, to see that justice was ad- ministered, and that no advantage was taken of the absent defendant. The statutes of Nebraska (Sec. 1428) pro- vide that suits for divorce shall be conducted in the same manner as other suits in courts of equity. They further provide (Sec. 1456) that no decree of divorce shall be made solely on the declarations, confessions or admissions of the parties, but the court shall in all cases require other satisfactory evidence of the facts alleged in the petition. In this case proof should have been. required that the plaintiff had used every reasonable endeavor to inform the defendant of the filing and pending of the petition, and satisfactory evidence, other than that of the plaintiff, that the wife had deserted her husband and of her alleged adultery. The consequence of the miscarriage of the laws of Nebraska, under color of which this fraud was perpe- trated, are most deplorable. The decree will not be recog- nized here, where the wife is still bound by the marriage. By a wise provision of the statutes of Nebraska the decree of divorce may be set aside at any time on the ground of fraud. In this case the second wife whom the plaintiff has since married would be nothing more than his mistress, his children would be illegitimate and he would be liable to a criminal prosecution for bigamy. The GREEN Bac is regularly read by hundreds of judges in whose hands are the power of divorce under laws which render such perversions of justice as is here out- lined possible. Is it too much to hope that some of them may determine to pursue such a course henceforth as will make a repetition of the McAllister case, or the occurrence’ of a Langtry case, impossible within their jurisdiction ? STUFF Gown.
Page 41
— oo Notes of Cases, ete. e ang a ine et BY IRVING BROWNE. CURRENT TOPICS. Up To SNuFF.— Lord Chief Justice Russell certainly is, as we glean from a report in the London «* Law Journal” of a meeting of the Hardwicke Society, at Which there was a notable attendance of big-wigs. The account says: ‘* During the evening Mr. Edward Atkin, senior member of the committee, made an in- formal presentation of a silver snuff-box to the presi- dent, as the representative of the society. The box is to be known as,‘ the Russell Snuff-box,’ and is intended to commemorate the elevation of Lord Rus- sell of Killowen.to the dignity of Lord Chief-Justice of England. It was subscribed for by members of the society.” The president then proposed the health of ** Our Guest,” the Lord Chief Justice, and invited him ‘to take the first pinch of snuff from the Russell snuff-box, which his lordship did amid loud cheers.” Then his lordship responded felicitously, saying among other things: ‘‘ The little incident with which the speech of the president concluded peculiarly gratified him. It flattered one of his weaknesses. The days were gone by when a snuff- box was considered part of the necessary equipage of a gentleman. The lines — ‘Sir Plume, of amber snuff-box justly vain, And the nice conduct of a clouded cane,’ were a relic of the past. Still, the handling of a snuff-box was eminently judicial. It had a soothing effect upon the mind; it was a mode of occupying one’s self and distracting one’s self when M:Call, and Crump, and Lawson Walton were making their most brilliant points. He really regretted to know that that habit of snuff-taking had fallen almost into com- plete desuetude at the Bar. He remembered Sir James Bacon telling him, on one occasion, that when he was a junior, there was not a single man in the court, from the judge on the bench to the usher, who did not carry a snuff-box, and he ended by saying, « Here I am, the only man left with a snuff- box.’”” Lucky Q. C.’s to be thus named by his lord- ship! Good for a great many retainers, one would say, anda much better advertisement than to be - ized tobacco. ‘‘named” by the Speaker. In speaking of things that had been done by the famous society he said: ‘«It passed resolutions of sympathy with that great Republic of the West whose honored representative was there that night in the presence of his old and highly esteemed, friend, Mr. Bayard; and it patted the people of the United States upon the back when they re-elected that distinguished man and great character, Abraham Lincoln, as President of that country.” The health of our minister being drunk, Mr. Bayard, «‘who was most cordially received, re- sponded.” We and the old folks seem to be growing verychummy. Snuff-taking in this country has fallen into ‘‘ innocuous desuetude,” except in some of the southern States, where the inhabitants practice ‘« snuff-dipping,” which consists, we believe, in dip- ping a stick in snuff and prodding the gums with it. We doubt that there is a snuff-box on the Supreme Court bench. But itis pleasant to read of these friendly proceedings, and to take snuff with a- friend is more agreeable for some than to take a cigar with him; and it is certainly much more cleanly than to take a chew with him. The ability to ‘take snuff. without sneezing, however, is probably one of the lost arts. Mr. Moore, in his recent history of ‘«* The American Congress,” says of a time about three-quarters of a century ago: ‘* It was the custom in both houses of Congress to have great silver urns, filled with the choicest and most fragrant * Maccaboy’ and ‘Old Scotch’ snuff, placed where the members could help themselves freely to the nose-titillating pulver- Snuff-taking was then a very common habit with the congressmen, and it was no unusual thing to see a speaker, who was pouring out words of eloquence on the floor of the House or the Senate, stop suddenly, walk over to the snuff-urn, fill his nose, sneeze two or three times, flourish a bandanna handkerchief, and then walk back to his place and resume his remarks. Some of the old members had considerable reputation as graceful snuff-takers. Mr. Macon, who presided over the Senate so long, took snuff with such perfection that he was admired by all the senators; and Mr. Clay, who imitated the French, was not far behind him in grace and polished ease.” ba
Page 42
528 The Green Bag. THE NEGRO’S RIGHTS. — There has been recent occasion to find a little fault in these columns with Noah Brooks. for some utterances against Charles Sumner; and now comes Mr. E. H. Bristow, defend- ing Chief Justice Taney against the charge attributed by Mr. Brooks, that he decided that ‘+ the negro has no rights which the white man is bound to respect.” It is familiar history to lawyers that the Chief-Justice did not make that statement as an expression of his own opinion, but as the result of a historical review of the opinions of a former time; and as such it was eminently correct. We hardly think that Mr. Brooks isopen to the charge of mis-statement or miscon- struction in this instance. What he said was that the Chief-Justice made ‘his decision to the effect that the negro has no rights that a white man is bound to respect.” The decision was to that effect, and the North so construed it, for it decided that under the laws of Missouri the negro was not a citi- zen and could not wage his suit in court. This is probably all that Mr. Brooks intended to convey. Taney, it is said, did not approve of slavery; he emancipated his ownslaves. There is no expression in his famous opinion indicating his approval of the system. deductions which seemed inevitable to him. Un- doubtedly he sincerely thought that a decision the other way would precipitate disunion and war. But such a decision could not have had that effect more distinctly than the one made. It is not on the face of the opinion that one finds anything dishonorable or immoral, but in the secret history of it, as exposed by Mr. Justice Curtis and recorded by his biogra- pher, Mr. Ticknor, there is shown an evident want of candor and fair dealing on the part of the Chief-: Justice, which was resorted to in order to lug in-the question of citizenship. But after all, there was no -more log-rolling than in the Dartmouth College case, and the affair has turned out as God meant it should. It is due to the Chief Justice to point out that he did not use the expression in question as his own view, and to Mr. Brooks that the latter did not allege that the Chief-Justice did. LIBEL BY MONUMENT. — Is there such a thing? Our friend Appleton Morgan thinks so, for he sends us, with a suggestion to that effect, a copy of an in- scription from a stone in the old burying-ground at Brimfield, Mass., which runs as follows: ** Mr. Ezra Wood died 6 November 1812, aged 20. His death was occasioned by a blow of a stone on the head from the hand of Hiram Stebbins, maliciously thrown at him.” Then comes a stanza, alleging that ‘* His Saviour-called him home,”’-—as he did Stephen, it appears. No doubt this was a libel, unless it could He merely states the facts and the legal be justified. It is a wonder that the allegation was not of a ‘‘rock,” for stones were commonly called ‘¢rocks in old New England, and generally they were ‘‘ heaved,” @ /a the Trojan heroes. But no fault should be found with this monument, —it is only giving stone for stone. LorD JUSTICE BowEN.— The London ‘+ Law Jour- nal” gives a copy of the Latin inscription on a marble tablet placed by the Benchers in the vestibule of the chapel of Lincoln’s Inn, It seems-rather late in the day to put epitaphs in Latin (especially when it must necessarily be somewhat hoggish) instead of English, which will probably outlive Latin; and it seems es- pecially inappropriate to do so in the case of one whose chief, if not his only fame, will rest on his translation of the first six A©neids into English verse! At least the Benchers might well have made some allusion to this elegant performance in the Latin epi- taph. But perhaps they thought the translation sac- rilegious. A New LEGAL RELATIONSHIP. — ‘* Law-Book News” speaks of Mr. Charles F. Beach, Jr., as ‘author, or at least god-father, of many legal treat- ises.” This is not strictly accurate. He is their father-in-law. The slur on Mr. Beach is undeserved. His books are good, whether he did all the work him- self or not. Raphael did not always paint the whole of a picture; but he designed it, and he and his pu- pils executed it. ‘¢ CURRENT EVENTS OF INTEREST TO LAWYERS AND LAW-STUDENTS.” — Under this head, the very comely and readable «‘ The Law-Students’ Helper,” of Detroit, announces that ‘‘ July 7th—A daughter is born to the President and Mrs. Cleveland.” NOTES OF CASES. THE HusBAND —SEDUCER.—JIn Kroessin v. Keller, 27 L. R. A. 685, the Minnesota Supreme Court hold that a married woman cannot maintain an action of crim. con. against another woman, in the absence of proof that the husband was enticed away, or induced to abandon or desert his wife. The Court distinguish the class of cases, of which Westlake v. Westlake, 34 Ohio St. 621 ; 32 Am. Rep. 397, is the pioneer, and which has been so generally. followed, on the ground that it was a case of desertion induced by the defendant. The Court admit that the New Hampshire and Indiana cases warrant the plaintiff's contention. The decision in the principal case is based on the notion that ‘* such actions would seem to be better calculated to inflict pain upon the inno-
Page 43
The Lawyer's Easy Chair. 579. cent members of the families of the parties than to secure redress to the persons injured. The power to bring such actions would furnish wives. with the means of inflicting untold misery upon others, with little hope of redress for themselves.’? This seems to us little short of puerile. ‘*THE GOLD CuRE.”—Are the courts growing more tender of drunken adults than of sober infants? It would seem so from Mayor v. Keeley Institute, Maryland, 27 L. R. A. 646, which holds that a statute authorizing any habitual drunkard to be sent for treatment and cure to an institution within the State maintained for such persons, at the expense of the county or city of his residence, if neither he nor his petitioning kin is financially able to incur the ex- pense, does not make an unconstitutional use of money raised by taxation. Here is paternalism for you. Truly ‘‘the devil lays pillows for drunken men to fall on.”” The court observe : — “Tf the legislature has authority, which we do not ques- tion, to treat habitual drunkards as a class of citizens who are entitled to be restrained or medically cared for by placing them in institutions for treatment, it would natu- rally follow that in so far as the iaw applies to the citizens of Baltimore, the expense of the treatment of its habitual drunkards ought reasonably to be borne byit. It was held, as already stated inthe Regents’ Case, supra, that the gov- ernment ‘has the sole right, as trustee of the public inter- est, to inspect, regulate, control, and direct the corporation, its funds and franchises.’ It is one of the gravest con- ditions of the century in which we live, and of which leg- islators have been compelled to make observation, that the victims of the excessive use of alcoholic stimulants, nar- cotics, etc., have grown to be legion, not of healthy, robust manhood, but of broken, debauched, and decrepit men, against whom and for whom, as a class, public sentiment has a right to appeal to the legislature for protection. Lord Bacon has said, ‘That all the crimes on earth do not destroy so many of the human race, nor alienate so much property, as drunkenness.’ Mr. Justice Harlan, de- livering the opinion of the court in Mugler v. Kansas, 123 U. S. 623, says: ‘There is no justification for holding that the State, under the guise merely of police regulations, is here aiming to deprive the citizen of his constitutional rights; for we cannot shut-out of-view the fact, within the knowledge of all, that the public health, the public morals, and the public safety may be endangered by the use of in- toxicating drinks; nor the fact, established by statistics ac- cessible to every one, that the idleness, disorder, pauperism, and crime existing in the country are in some degree, at least, traceable to this evil.’ Mr. Tiedeman, in his work on the Limitation of Police Powers, says: ‘It is the policy of some States; notably New York, to establish asylums for the inebriate, where habitual. drunkards are received and subjected to a course of medical treatment, which is calcu- lated to effect a cure of the disease of drinking, as it is claimed to be. A large part of human suffering 1 is the al- interest of society to reduce this evil as much as pcssible,. The establishment and maintenance of inebriate asylums can, therefore, be lawfully undertaken by the State,’ ” This is well, but it would seem better to suppress the sale of intoxicants than to try to mend up the sufferers ; better to stamp out the origins of the dis- ease than to endeavor to cure the patient. ACCIDENT — VOLUNTARY EXPOSURE TO DANGER. — The most impudent class of persons in the com- munity are insurers against accident, and the most bare-faced and impudent contention they ever made in the courts is to be found in Hess v. Van Auken, New York Common Pleas, in a late number of the Miscellaneous Reports. A cashier of a bank went to a saw-mill to get: some boards cut*of a certain: length for the bank. He stayed during the cutting, and slipping on a con-. cealed block on the floor, fell against a circular saw and his hand was cut off at the wrist. The insurers contended that he had ‘ voluntarily exposed” him- self to the danger, but the court could not see it. Judge Bookstaver observed that the respondent’s ‘¢ contention seemed to be that the plaintiff walked into the mill and cut off his hand.”’? The respondent also had the impudence to request the trial judge to charge that he was ‘‘ operating the saw’? when hurt. PAYMENT OF WAGEs.—In re House Bill No. 1230, 28 L. R. A. 344, the Massachusetts judges answer the legislature, on requirement of their opin- jon, that a statute requiring manufacturers to pay wages of their employees weekly, although applying to individuals as well as to corporations, is valid under the Constitution which authorizes legislation over ‘* all manner of wholesome and reasonable orders, laws, statutes and ordinances,” ‘* for the good and welfare of the commonwealth,” and makes no express pro- vision for freedom of contracting. This is probably the first time that such legislation has been upheld in respect to individuals. The Court say: “Tt is well known that in some of the States of this country legislation similar to that proposed has been held unconstitutional by the courts, sometimes on the ground that it is partial in its character, but more frequently on the ground that it interferes with what is called the liberty of contract, which, itis said, either as a privilege or as property, is secured to the inhabitants of a State by its con- stitution, or by the Constitution of the United States. In some of these decisions a distinction has been suggest- ed or made between the rights of natural persons and the rights of. corporations, and such legislation has been deemed valid with respect to corporations whose charters were subject to alteration, amendment, or repeal by the leg- islature, or which, being foreign corporations, were per- most direct result of drunkenness, and it is certainly to the ; mitted to do business in the state under such conditions as
Page 44
539 The Green Bag. the legislature might impose, while the legislation has been deemed void with respect to natural persons. Some re- cent decisions on this subject are the following: Leep v. St. Louis, I. M. & S. R. Co. 58 Ark. 407, 23 L. R. A. 264; State v. Peel Splint Coal Co. 36 W. Va. 802,17 L. R. A. 385; Hancock v. Yaden, 121 Ind. 366, 6 L. R. A. 576; State v. Brown & S. Mfg. Co. 18 R. I. —, 17 L. R. A. 856; Shaffer v. Union Min. Co. of Alleghany County, 55 Md. 74; Tilt v. People (Ill; Feb. 1795) 40 N. E. Rep. 462.” - The judges cite their recent holding that a law for- bidding the employment of women, although adult, more than ten hours a day, is valid ; and this too we believe stands alone, at least in relation to individ- ual employers. (Com. v. Hamilton Man. Co. 120 Mass. 383.) The way in which the court .gets around the argument that a woman has a right to work as many hours as she chooses seems to us a quibble. The Court concede that she has, but say that the law in question merely forbids her employ- ment by any single employer for more than ten hours ! The advantages of a police and health bill which for- bids a woman to work more than ten hours a day for a particular employer, but allows her to work, say, six hours more for another employer on the same day, are not obvious. We regard the opinion as unsound. Adult and sane people have a natural right to contract without leave of any constitutional per- mission. If A is willing to work for monthly pay- ments he certainly ought to be allowed to do so, and if he is not willing he can stop. The argument that the law is valid because it is wholesome is not very convincing, for a law compelling men to go to church and to vote would be wholesome, but it would not be valid. We do not see that the peculiar language of the Constitution gives the legislature any wider pow- er of law-making than under ordinary constitutions, but it certainly is an implied power, under any con- stitution, that the legislature may make wholesome and reasonable laws for the good and welfare of the commonwealth. But we do not think it ‘* reason- able ” to enact that a housewife shall pay her cook, or a farmer his haying-hand every week. It is not necessary, for the employee has a simple remedy — he can quit. It is not reasonable, for it makes a uni- form rule that may not be convenient for many, and is inquisitorial when applied to all. The Court say: «¢ We know of no reason derived from the Constitu- tion of the commonwealth or of the United States why there should be a distinction made in respect to such legislation between corporations and persons engaged in manufacturing, when both do the same kind of business.” The Constitution may not point out any distinction, but there is one in the nature of things. The legislature has an arbitrary right to regulate the conduct of corporations, which are its creatures, and exist only by its will, unless it has failed to reserve such right, but it has no such corresponding right in respect to individuals. We find an incon- sistency between the reasoning of this opinion and ‘that in Com. v. Perry, 155 Mass. 117; 14 L. R.A. 325, which disapproved a law forbidding an employ- er to deduct wages of weavers for bad work. In that case the prohibition in the Federal Constitution of laws impairing the obligation of contracts was recog- nized, but in the opinion in question it seems to be ignored because there is no similar provision in the Massachusetts Constitution. In the Perry case the court characterized the right assailed by the statute as ‘‘an interference with the right to make reason- able and proper contracts in conducting a legitimate business,” and derived that right from the constitu- tional guaranty of the right of ‘* acquiring, possess- ing and protecting property.” It might well be that a manufacturer could not pay his employees weekly, and the requirement that he should would break up his business and prevent him from acquiring property. _ REASONS FOR DISCHARGE OF EMPLOYEE.—In Geor- gia, in 1891, a statute was passed requiring incorpor- ated railroad, telegraph and express companies to give to discharged employees or agents the reasons for their discharge when removed, under penalty of $5,000 for refusal to comply, to be recovered by the party aggrieved. This law has been declared invalid in Wallace v. Georgia etc. Ry. Co. 22 Southeast- ern Rep. 579. The Court wrote no opinion, but in its official syllabus observed : *‘ Liberty of speech and of writing is secured by the Con- stitution, and incident thereto is the correlative liberty of silence, not less important nor less sacred. Statements or communications, oral or written, wanted for private infor- mation, cannot be coerced by mere legislative mandate at the will of one of the parties and against the will of the other. Compulsory private discovery, even from corpora- tions, enforced, not by suit or action, but by statutory ter- ror, is not allowable where rights are under the guardian- ship of due process of law.” The New York Law Journal points out that this is analogous to the decision of the Missouri Supreme Court, in State v. Julow, 31 South- eastern Rep. 781, holding void a statute which assumed to prohibit employers from dismissing ser- vants on account of their membership in labor un- ions. Under the Massachusetts opinion above cited, we do not see why both these statutes would not have been upheld as for the ‘‘ good and welfare’ of the State. Constitutional provisions for ‘‘ general wel- fare” are very elastic and have always been fruitful of discussion.
Page 45
~The Green Bag. PUBLISHED MONTHLY, AT $4.00 PER ANNUM. SINGLE NUMBERS, 50 CENTS. Communications in regard to the contents of the Magazine should be addressed to the Editor, HorAcCE W. FULLER, 15% Beacon Street, Boston, Mass. The Editor will be glad to receive contributions of articles of moderate length upon subjects of inter- est lo the profession; also anything in the way of legal antiquities or curiosities, facetia, anec- dotes, etc. “THE GREEN BAG.” To the Editor of the «* Green Bag.” As a contribution to the curiosities of legal prac- tice in the ‘‘ wild and woolly West,” I send you the following two incidents which have happened within my knowledge and which I can vouch for as true. A few years ago, a thriving city of the second class in Kansas found it necessary to raise a loan of $50,000. Ata meeting of the council to arrange details, the question was discussed as to the rate of interest the bonds should draw. Some were in favor of five per cent, while others urged that the rate should be five and a half, in order to secure bigger money on the sale of the bonds. During the pro- ceedings the city attorney advised the council that the proposed bonds must bear not less than six per cent, and gave as his reason that such was the legal rate of interest prescribed by statute. The same attorney, in defending a case against his city, demurred to the petition as follows :— . sé Plaintiff US. In the District Court of The City of County, Kansas. Defendant. And now comes said defendant and demurs to the pe- tition of plaintiff, herein filed, on the ground that said pe- tition does not set forth facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action. City Attorney for Defendant, the City of . State of Kansas, » County of » SS. The City of by its attorney being duly sworn, says that the statements made in the foregoing de- murrer are true as he verily believes, City Attorney for Defendant, the City of Sworn and subscribed, etc.” There are as many good lawyers in Kansas to the square inch as in any other State in the Union, but — there are others. N. LEGAL ANTIQUITIES. THE Court of Star Chamber seems to have been, or pretended to be, a careful guardian of private morals ; for it desired the principals of the Inns of Court and Chancery not to suffer the gentle- man students to be out of their houses after six o’clock at night ‘‘ without very great and neces- sary causes, nor to wear any kind of weapon.” And we read of the Earl of Surrey, Thomas Wyatt, and young Pickering, being summoned for breaking windows, and eating flesh in Lent; all were committed to the Tower, but soon dis- charged. | FACETIZA. Stir Henry Hawks has a reputation as a witty judge. Recently a prisoner pleaded guilty of lar- ceny, and then withdrew the plea, and declared himself to be innocent. ‘The case was tried, and the jury acquitted him. Then said Sir Henry Hawkins :— 7 ‘«« Prisoner, a few minutes ago you said you were a thief. Now the jury say you are a liar. Conse- quently, you are discharged.” A LAWYER, residing in the North of England, and noted for his laconic style of expression, sent the following terse and witty note to a refractory client, who would not succumb to his reiterated demands for the payment of his bill. “ Sir, if you pay the enclosed you will oblige me. If you do not, I shall oblige you.” A CERTAIN lawyer in Mobile, Alabama, always identifies himself squarely with his clients. In stating a damage case lately he said: ‘“ We got on the Dauphin Street car down town and when we reached Bayou Street signalled to the conductor to let us off, as we lived near there. He paid no attention to us and we attempted to get off. It so happened that we slipped and our leg: was caught by a wheel and crushed. Zhe fact is we were somewhat drunk at the time.” 531
Page 46
532 ‘ The Green Bag. ne ee ee ee a ee ae ee ee ee ee Le a eee _A story is told of one of her Majesty’s judges who is as remarkable for the quickness of his eyes and ears as for the keenness of his intellect. The other day a stranger in court, espying a friend, addressed him in a stage whisper with : — “ Halloa, old man! I haven’t seen you lately, Are you all right?” The remark was hardly heard beyond the near- est bystanders, and there was, consequently con- siderable bewilderment among those engaged in the case before the court when the judge looking up from his notes, observed : “ Tf the old man is all right, he had better go outside and say so.” “SUPPOSE a witness, that you yourself had called in a case, failed to testify as you believed he would, and, in fact testified the other way, what would you say?” asked an examiner. Various emotions passed over the face of the student, who, at last, taking in the enormity of the treachery of the witness, cried out indignantly, “ | should say it was misplaced confidence!” / — WN. Y. Law Journal. AT Ithaca, New York, a number of years ago, a prominent citizen was under arrest for the vio- lation of the excise law. ‘The case had been put over once or twice and it was discovered on the opening of the Court that the plaintiff's attorney was not ready to go on nor was he in Court. The District Attorney arose and moved that the case be dismissed. Hardly had he made the motion for dismissal, when a voice was heard, “ I second the motion, Mr. Judge.’”’ ‘The one who had so energetically seconded the motion of dis- missal: was no other than the eccentric defendant in the suit. ~ OnE of the ablest and most brilliant lawyers at the York County (Maine) Bar was John Holmes of Alfred who. was widely known for his wit and sar- casm. An opportunity was seldom lost by him of exhibiting his opponent in a ridiculous position. An instance of this kind occurred while a mem- ber of the Senate of the United States, in the dis- cussion on Nullification. Mr. Tyler of Virginia, afterwards President, alluded to a satirical remark of John Randolph, in which that gentleman had some time before designated certain active politi- cians as partners under the firm name of “ James Madison, Felix Grundy, John Holmes and the Devil,’’ and asked Mr. Holmes with the view of making a severe cut, what had become of that celebrated firm. Mr. Holmes immediately sprang to his feet, and said, “‘ Mr. President, I will tell the gentleman what has become of that firm: the first member is dead, and the second has gone into retirement, and the last has gone to the Nul- lifiers, and is now electioneering among the gentle- man’s constituents! and thus the partnership is legally dissolved.”’ ‘The laugh produced on the occasion was wholly at the expense of Mr. Tyler. JupGE WILLIAM E. CLARKE of Marengo County, Alabama, is a man of marked individuality, and conducted the court in the Mobile circuit with promptness and decision. During one of the many trials of a famous insurance case in Mobile, some years ago, a juror was objected to as az agnostic. He was excused at the request of both sides. At recess for dinner, a juror going down the steps with the Judge said that he had observed a man was excused because an agnostic, and asked, “What is an agnostic, Judge?’ Judge Clarke took the matter under advisement for a moment, and then replied sententiously, “ An agnostic zs @ ad—d fool!’ In some theological quarters this definition would probably be accepted as strictly correct. NOTES. It is seldom that locality disintegrates crime, but a New York penal statute now makes shaving the beard on Sunday on one side of the Brooklyn Bridge a penal while it is allowable on the other side. Why it should be unnecessary for one citizen to employ a tonsorial artist in one place during church time but necessary for another citizen is a question soon to be considered by an appellate judge. A Brooklyn barber was caught “red handed ”’ by the police while lathering a cus- tomer on a Sunday morning and haled before a justice of the peace, who said “ this is indeed a barber-ous statute, but I must enforce it with a small fine. But, Mr. Policeman, hereafter don’t ar-
Page 47
Editorial Department. 530 rest the barber until he has completed the shaving. The latter’s offence will be no greater after he has used the razor than it was while he was only em- ploying soap and brush.” THE following anecdote bears upon the thin partition dividing from illegality the proneness of some judges to impress on juries their opinion upon facts. Half a century ago, in New York City, James J. Roosevelt was, as justice of the Supreme Court, about to charge in Oyer and Terminer, a jury who had been listening to evidence against a man indicted for poisoning his wife. He thus began his address: “I am hardly fitted by my feelings ' to calmly submit the case: these have been so wrought up by the evidence describing this wretched man sitting hypocritically by the bedside of his wife, cheering her with words of comfort, while feeding her with poisoned soup.” The Justice had only ended this opening sentence when the accused’s counsel, James T. Brady, a more intrepid and alert defender than whom New York never knew, arose. “I beg pardon, your Honor for interruption, but I must object to your assuming at the outset that my - client fed poison to his wife. We have disputed that there was poison in the soup.” “ Quite right,” returned the Justice ; “you do so contend, but I believe the evidence to the contrary. However, gentlemen, don’t be influenced by my opinion on the matter, for that is wholly within your province.” This of course killed exception. But the manner of the Judge was so pathetic that the jury con- victed. THE lawyers in the Wyoming legislature are to a man advocates of further extending suffrage to women. But they are met by frontier laymen with speeches of which the following from a Laramie newspaper is a fair specimen : — ‘¢T think women were made to cdey men. They generally promise to obey, at any rate; and I think you had better either abolish this Female Suffrage act, or gel up a new marriage ceremony lo fit wt.” ‘*It ain’t no party question, this bill ain’t. 7 wouldn’t let it come up in that shape. 7 would know better than that. This woman suffrage business will sap the foundation of society. Women can’t engage in politics without losin’ her virtue. It won't do her no good anyhow. She can’t earn a dollar no easier than half a dollar if she does vote. : ‘¢No woman ain’t got no right to set on a jury unless she is a man, and every lawyer knows it, and I don’t bleeve it anyhow. I don’t think women juries has been a success here in Wyomin’. They watch the face of the judge too much when the lawyer is addressin’’em. That shows they ain’t fit for juries in my way of thinkin’. I don’t bleeve she’s fit for’t nohow. Wot right has she got on a jury nohow?” THE word culprit is often mistakenly used by counsel and judges, as made convertible with the word prisoner or accused, whereas, in its origin, it is synonymous with convict through confession. In early Norman times the minutes of the criminal court were kept by the clerks in French. ‘The pleas to indictments were entered either “ culp- able’? or ‘non-culpable.” If the former, the clerk made this entry, “cul,” short for full word of plea, adding the word “ prét,” French for ready, and together signifying on the record, guilty and ready for sentence. The minutes showed many enterings of culpret written hastily as one word. In time the “e’’ changed into an “i” and a culprit was known as a guilty man ready for punishment. The word cu/padle appears upon the minutes of French magistrates and courts, as also the word /7é¢, to this day. EXAMINATIONS into the mental position and surroundings of jurors summoned in New York City for criminal trials in order to answer challenges for cause or to the favor are permitted by judges to become so liberally exhaustive that recently counsel for defense in a pending cause célébre asked a candidate for the jury-box, ‘“ What con- stituted your breakfast this morning? ’”’ Objection was made by prosecuting counsel, and the judge called upon the questioning lawyer to show the relevancy of his query. ‘I am informed,” said the latter, “ that this juror is in the habit of eating pork-chops for breakfast, a most bilious food, and I cannot. trust the life or liberty of a client to a man whose brain may be vitiated by the influence of bile.’ The judge, however, allowed the question for what it was worth, when the juror answered, ‘I ate three pork-chops for my break- fast, and these always. agree with me. I know
Page 48
534 many hoggish men who do not eat pork.” He became admitted to the jury box, and was the only one who voted for acquittal in the challenger’s favor, and procured disagreement. ‘The verdict of the spectators to the prisoner seemed to be, “‘ Saved by pork-chops.” LITERARY NOTES. AN article in the October REVIEW OF REVIEWS by Percy R. Meggy, Secretary to the New South Wales Civil Service Inquiry Commission, throws light from the antipodes on some of the difficulties of the: ever- present Civil. Service problem. Dr. HENRY SMITH WILLIAMS writing of ‘‘Politics and the Insane”’ in the NORTH AMERICAN REVIEW for October, emphatically declaims against the preva- lent custom of allowing partisan politics to enter into the management of asylums where the dependent in- sane are cared for. IN an article at once crisp and solid, Fred. Perry Powers discusses in LIPPINCOTT’Ss MAGAZINE for October ‘*Ethics and Economics,” and shows that the world’s business must of necessity be conducted on business principles, and that considerations of philanthropy and sentiment, while of value in their proper place, are secondary, not primary. This paper is well fitted to prick some popular delusions. IN the October POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY Herbert Spencer shows in his paper on ‘é Pro- fessional Institutions’? how the man of science and the philosopher are derived from the priest. The oldest science, astronomy, was first employed to fix the times for religious rites. The root of mathe- matical science can also be traced down to the an- cient priestly vocation. AMONG the articles and stories announced for the November number of HARPER’S MAGAZINE are «‘A Pilgrim on the Gila,” by Owen Wister, a longer tale of the West than he has hitherto written ; a paper by W. D. Howells on <‘‘ Literary Boston Thirty Years Ago;” a description of his involuntary exile at a Central American port by Richard Harding Davis, called «‘Out of the World at Corinth;” and short stories by Harriet Prescott Spofford, Brander Mat- thews, and Julian Ralph. The Green Bag. SCRIBNER’S MAGAZINE for October contains the first adequate account that has been published of the University of Chicago. Its author, Robert Herrick, is one of the Faculty. Having been a Harvard man, he is able to contrast the oldest and the youngest university. This article is a most effective account of the actual university life that has been created out of nothing in three short years. The reader will real- ize that a tremendous educational force has grown beyond doubt of success in the middle of the conti- nent, and that it is dealing with a class of students, men and women, and with social conditions that are seldom met with in Eastern universities. Mr. Orson Lowell has made a remarkable series of pictures from life to illustrate this article. THE fiction of the October CENTURY consists of the closing chapters of Marion Crawford’s dramatic novel ‘¢Casa Braccio,” with a remarkable scene in St. Peter’s at Rome, where two of his characters are accidentally locked in for the night. Mr. George A. Hibbard contributes a social sketch on a popular theme, entitled «‘An Earlier Manner,” and Mrs. McEnery Stuart a very laughable sketch entitled ‘¢Sonny’s Schoolin’,”’ of particular interest to parents and educators ; and there are three other brief and vivid stories by George Wharton Edwards in his series ‘‘The Rivalries of Long and Short Codiac.” Ex-Gov. JAMES M. ASHLEy contributes a timely paper to the October ARENA entitled ‘* Should the Supreme Court be Re-organized?”? Gov. Ashley’s paper will be read ‘with great interest. The same issue also contains a startling paper by A. R. Bar- rett, an Ex-Government Examiner for Failed Banks, entitled «* The Era of Fraud.” It should lead to prompt action, looking toward protecting the people from unscrupulous guardians of their funds. THE October ATLANTIC MONTHLY is rich in good fiction. Mrs. Ward’s powerful serial, ‘‘ A Singular Life,” is concluded. There is a further installment of Gilbert Parker’s «‘ Seats of the Mighty,” which in- creases in interest with each succeeding issue. Fur- ther chapters of Charles Egbert Craddock’s ‘*Mystery of Witch-Face Mountain” also appear. One of the most: striking contributions is another Japanese study by Lafcadio Hearn, entitled «*« The Genius of Japanese Civilization.”” The third of Mr. Peabody’s papers, ‘‘An Architect’s Vacation,” tells of «* The Venetian Day.”
Page 49
ee a oe a eee i) "4 - Editorial Department. BOOK NOTICES. LAW. A TREATISE ON THE LAW OF THE DOMESTIC RE- LATIONS ; embracing Husband and Wife, Parent and Child, Guardian and Ward, Infancy, and Master and Servant. By James Schouler, LL.D. FirtH Epirion. Little, Brown & Co., Boston, 1895. Law Sheep, $6.00. Ir is now twenty-five years since the first edition of this work of Mr. Schouler made its appearance. The treatise was at once recognized as the standard authority upon the law of Domestic Relations and later editions have only served to strengthen its claim upon the profession as the leading work upon the subject. The present edition brings this law down fo the present year. It is discouraging to learn from the author that the law of Husband and Wife is even more chaotic than it was twenty- five years ago, but Mr Schouler, so far as possible, brings order out of this chaos, and furnishes a clear and comprehensive analysis of the law as ad- ministered in England and the United States at the present day. A TREATISE ON THE CONSTRUCTION OF THE STATUTE oF FRaups as in force in England and the United States. By Causten Brown. Firru Epition. Little, Brown & Co., Boston, 1895. $6.00 nez. Tus is another work which has long been es- teemed by Bench and Bar as authoritative upon the subject of which it treats. There is no treatise better known to the legal profession, and this new edition will be heartily welcomed. Some nineteen hundred cases have been added and the text has been care- fully revised. A TREATISE ON THE LAW RELATING TO ELECTRICITY. By Simon G., Croswell. Little, Brown & Co., Boston, 1895. Law Sheep, $6.00 mez. A connection for some years with the Law Depart- ment of the Thomson-Houston and General Elec- tric Companies, suggested to Mr. Croswell the idea of writing this treatise, there being no work upon the subject fully adapted to the needs of cor- porations and the profession. The varied uses of electricity have given rise to much litigation, and our courts have been called upon to-decide many important and novel questions arising therefrom, and numerous statutes have been passed regulating their introduction and operation. In this work Mr. Croswell has collected in an orderly arrange- ment, all the laws relating to electricity, except the Patent Law Cases, and gives to the practicing law- 535 yer a thoroughly reliable and comprehensive text book, which will fully meet his needs. Prominent among the subjects included in the treatise are the nature and qualities of the various franchises neces- essary for electric lines and the mode of acquiring them, including the important federal franchise. of telegraph companies ; the liability of electrical com- panies for negligence in the construction and main- tenance of their lines and machinery ; the municipal ownership of electric light plants; the placing of wires underground ; the conflicting rights of electric railways and telephones in the same highways, etc. ; there are also important chapters on the taxation of electric companies and on electric railway accidents. Law oF NATURALIZATION IN THE UNITED SfATES oF AMERIcA and of other Countries. By PREN- TIss WepsTER. Little, Brown & Co., 189 5. $4.00 net. Mr. Webster gives us in this volume a clear and con- cise exposition of the laws governing the naturaliza- tion of aliens in the United. States and in other countries. It is a subject of legal as well as_poli- cial importance, and one which, so far at least as the United States are concerned, calls for sober reflection on the part of our citizens. Mr. Webster leaves his readers, by comparisons, to draw their own conclusions concerning the present condition of things, and suggest the remedies, if any, which should be applied. MISCELLANEOUS. A SINGULAR Lire. By Elizabeth Stuart Phelps. Houghton, Mifflin & Co., Boston and New York, 1895. Cloth, $1.25. Mrs. Phelps (Ward) has never written anything better than this story of ‘*A Singular Life.” It is a work which appeals to the best in cne’s nature and one which strikes a telling blow at dogma and bigotry. Emanuel Bayard, a young divinity student, is refused ordination by a Congrega- tional Council on account of his so-called heretical views, and finds his life work as a self-constituted preacher and teacher among the lowest classes in a seaport town. Patiently and lovingly he labors among them, and so endears himself to the rough fishermen that they come to reverence and almost worship him. Just as his work is crowned with more. success. than he had ever dared to hope for, comes his death, a violent one, at the hands of the liquor interest, to which he had given offense by de- stroying the traffic. «* One of the summer people, a stranger in the town, strolling on the beach that day asked what that extraordinary display of the
Page 50
7 iy re 530 signs of public mourning meant. An Italian, stand- ing near by, made answer,—‘‘ The Christman is dead.” The story is feelingly told, and will add largely to the author’s reputation. THE WisE Woman. A novel. By Clara Louise Burnham. Houghton, Mifflin & Co., Boston and New York, 1895. Cloth, $1.25. The Wise Woman is a delightful old lady who seems to be the confidant of all who are in trouble or perplexity, and who has the happy faculty of | straightening matters out to the satisfaction of those concerned. The story is quite an interesting one and will serve to pleasantly while away a leisure hour. Tue Vittace Warcu-Towrer. By Kate Douglas _Wiggin. Houghton, Mifflin & Co., Boston and New York, 1895. Cloth, $1.25. Six stories make up the contents of this volume, all of them told in Mrs. Wiggin’s inimitable manner. Pathos and humor are skilfully blended. . Nothing could be more touching than «* The Fore-room Rug,” while «* The Eventful Trip of the Midnight Cry” is brimful of genuine humor. No one, Miss Jewett, perhaps, excepted, can depict New England life and character as does Mrs. Wiggin, and there is a charm and freshness in all she writes which endears her to her readers. THE Lir—E or Nancy. By Sarah Orne Jewett. Houghton, Mifflin & Co., Boston and New York, 1895. Cloth, $1.25. Several of the stories which make up this volume have already appeared in print, but they are all worthy of preservation in book form. Miss Jewett is a story-teller Jar excellence, and her readers are in- debted to her for many an enjoyable hour. «* The Life of Nancy ” will add to their debt of gratitude, for it contains some of the best things she has yet written. A Mapberra Party. By S. Weir Mitchell. Century Co., New York, 1895. $1.00. . The Leather, This dainty little volume, the latest issue in the ‘¢ Thumbnail Series,” contains a sketch and a story, neither of which has been heretofore published. In the sketch, which gives the title to the book, Dr. Mitchell quaintly narrates the history of Madeira wine, through the lips of a party of Philadelphia gourmets. ‘*A Little More Burgundy,” the story which follows the sketch, is a thrilling tale of the T, he Green Bag. | French Revolution, and is something quite different from anything Dr. Mitchell has heretofore favored us with. The volume is a delight to the eye and its contents furnish the reader with a rare treat. THE Cominc OF THEODORA. By Eliza Orne White. Houghton, Mifflin & Co., Boston and New York, 1895. Cloth, $1.25. ' There is one thing to be said in praise of Miss White’s stories, the tone of all she writes is perfectly healthful and wholesome. ‘*The Coming of The- odora” is a simple story of home life, told in a simple and unpretentious manner. A sister gives up her vocation to enter her brother’s house as a mem- ber of the family because she feels that she is really needed, and then, of course, finds that she and her brother’s wife cannot get along amicably, and so finally goes back to her duties as a teacher. There is a love episode in Theodora’s life which comes to naught, and this is the only incident outside a rather humdrum existence. Out of these slight materials Miss White has made a very readable story. Houghton, Mifflin Cloth, CLARENCE. By Bret Harte. & Co., Boston and New York, 1895. $1.25. This isa story of absorbing interest.» A husband who espouses the Union cause in the Civil War, and a wife who becomes a spy in the interests of the South are the central figures. Dramatic incidents and situations abound and the reader’s attention is held to the very end. The book is one of the best Bret Harte has yet written. FRoM JERUSALEM To Nic#A. ‘The Church in the first three centuries. By Philip Stafford Moxom. Roberts Brothers, Boston, 1895. Cloth, $1.50. The eight lectures contained in tlfis book were delivered by Dr. Moxom under the auspices of the Lowell Institute, in Boston during the past winter. They contain, described in-an interesting, scholarly ~ manner, the story of the rise of the Christian Church during the first three centuries of its existence. The lay reader will find much that is valuable and instruc- tive in this volume, and the pulpit will benefit by a careful perusal. Church history is a subject that neither minister nor laymen: are generally well versed in, but by Dr. Moxom’s aid they have an opportunity to familiarize themselves with the early years of the Christian Church without wading through the vol- uminous and sometimes not easily obtainable church histories. Dr. Moxom’s style is delightful, and it is a pleasure to receive information from so interesting a teacher.