The Green Bag: An Entertaining Magazine for Lawyers (October, 1895)
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
‘Phe: Green Bag. mote: VibscaNo.. to. BOSTON. OcTOBER, 1895. “THE GREAT COMMONER.” By Henry COvyLe. “ HE lives of great men,” observes a writer, ‘‘are a constant inspiration, both’to young and old. They teach Gar- field’s oft-repeated maxim, that ‘the genius of success is still the genius of labor.’ They teach patriotism — a deeper love for and de- votion to America. They teach that life with some definite and noble purpose, is worth living!” Carl Schurz, in his life of Clay, remarks: “Few public characters in American history have been the subject of more heated con- troversy than Henry Clay. There was no measure of detraction and obloquy to which, during his lifetime, his opponents would not resort, and there seemed to be no limit to the admiration and attachment of his friends. While his enemies denounced him as a pretender and selfish intriguer in poli- tics, and an abandoned profligate in private life, his supporters unhesitatingly placed him first among the sages of the period, and * * * sometimes even among its saints. The animosities against him have naturally long ago disappeared; but even now * *™ * we may hear old men, who knew him in the days of his strength, speak of him with an enthusiasm and affection so warm and fresh as to convince us that the recollection of having followed his leader- ship is among the dearest treasures of their memory. The remarkable fascination he exercised seems to have reached even be- yond his living existence.” Henry Clay was born on the 12th day of April, 1777, in a place called ‘‘ The Slashes,” a part of Hanover County, in Virginia. His father was a Baptist clergyman, who labored hard and earnestly, receiving but little earthly reward. When Henry was only four years old, his father died, and Mrs. Clay was left with seven children, two of them being younger than the future states- man. The widow was a hard-working wo- man, and she creditably reared her large family; Clay’s whole life was colored and influenced by her high courage and energy. Men, in the fierce battle of life, may for- get to be kind and compassionate, but they never forget the teachings and prayers of a good mother. It was at his mother’s knee that Lincoln learned to read and write in the little breaks that the busy woman could make between her many tasks. ‘God bless my mother!” he exclaimed one day, when he was president; ‘‘all Iam or can be I owe to her.” When Henry was about fourteen years old, he went to work ina store in the city of Richmond, and remained there about twelve months. His education was limited, and many years later he described himself at this period as ‘a lank, awkward youth.” About this time his mother married again, and through his step-father’s influence he entered the office of the Chancery Court, Richmond. He now began the study of law, but with no regularity, and with no fixed design of becoming a lawyer. Attorney-General Brooke, who had formerly been governor of Virginia, became interested in the young 441
Page 2
ay *5 + 5 ae Mie fe.
Page 3
Page 4
442 student, and invited him to enter his office. Clay gladly accepted the offer, and in No- vember, 1796, he was admitted to practice, through the influence of his distinguished friend. Soon after her marriage, his mother re- moved to Kentucky, and Henry followed her there, locating himself at Lexington. His fees at this time were very small, and he was often unable to pay his board; but he diligently pursued his studies, and prepared himself for the part he was soon to be called upon to perform in the great arena of life. The Kentucky bar had in its ranks a num- ber of distinguished lawyers, but the young man fearlessly fought his way to the top, and rapidly acquired practice, fame and wealth. Clay was employed on many important cases, and became famous as a criminal lawyer. Early in his professional career he secured the liberty of two clients who were charged with deliberate murder. Clay ad- dressed the jury in his most passionate and eloquent manner, and they were so moved, that, in spite of the evidence, they rendered a verdict of manslaughter only; the case was tried again, and he finally secured their acquittal. It was said that not one of his clients who were tried for capital crimes ever received sentence of death at the hands of the law. Henry Clay’s political career began soon after his removal to Kentucky. In 1797, when the plan for a new constitution for that State was under discussion, he advocated the abolition of slavery. He said, at this time, ‘‘when we consider the cruelty of the origin of negro slavery, its nature, the character of the free institutions of the whites and the irresistible progress of public opinion throughout America, as well as in Europe, it is impossible not to anticipate frequent in- surrections among the blacks in the United States; they are rational beings like our- selves, capable of feeling, of reflection, and of judging of what naturally belongs to The Green Bag. them as a portion of the human race. By the very condition of the relation which ex- ists between us, we are enemies of each other. They know well the wrongs which their ancestors suffered at the hands of our ancestors, and the wrongs which they be- lieve they continue to endure, although they may be unable to avenge them. They are kept in subjection only by the superior in- telligence and superior power of the pre- ' dominant race.” During the delivery of this speech, every muscle of the orator’s face was at work. He was thoroughly in earnest; his whole frame was agitated, as if each part was in- stinct with a separate life; his small, white hand, with its blue veins apparently dis- tended almost to bursting, moved grace- fully, but with all the energy of rapid and vehement gesture. He made a powerful impression, but the majority of the people were slave-holders, and for a time he was very unpopular. But Clay cared nothing for this; the clear conception, the high purpose, the firm re- solve, the dauntless spirit speaking on the tongue, beaming from the eye, informing every feature, urged the whole man onward, when he knew he was right. Purity of mo- tive was the most prominent characteristic of his public career. One of his personal friends gives the following anecdote : “On one occasion he did me the honor to send for and consult with me in refer- ence to a step he was about to take. After stating what he proposed, I suggested, whether there would not be danger in it, whether such a course would not injure his own prospects, as well as those of the Whig party in general. Huis reply was, ‘I did not send for you to ask what might be the effects of the proposed movement on my prospects, but whether it is right; for I would rather be right than president!’” Clay, through all his public career, fav- ored the gradual abolition of slavery, and was Criticised severely by his Southern
Page 5
The Great friends. A short time before his death, he said, ‘Among the acts of my public life which I look back to with the most satis- faction, is that of my having co-operated with other zealous and intelligent friends to procure the establishment of that system in this State. We were overpowered by num- bers, but submitted to the decision of the majority with that grace which the minority in a republic should ever yield to the de- cision. I have, nevertheless, never ceased, and shall never cease, to regret a decision the effects of which have been to place us in the rear of our neighbors, who are ex- empt from slavery.” Hon. R. C. Winthrop, who knew Clay personally, says, ‘“‘Mr. Clay’s personal love of human freedom was recognized by Wil- liam Ellery Channing —one of whose .im- pressive sermons I took him to hear at the old Federal Street Church — when he ad- dressed to him his letter against the annexa- tion of Texas. It was recognized, too, by Joseph John Gurney, when he addressed to him his letters on emancipation in the West Indies. He himself gave signal testimony to it, as we have seen, in relation to the con- stitution of Kéntucky.: °°"): *".. "Nor should: it be. forgotten 3? * =" * “that when the late William Lloyd Garrison was imprisoned in Baltimore, Henry Clay is un- derstood to have made an _ immediate, though unsuccessful effort to stand bail for his release.” In 1797 he married Lucretia Hart, a young lady of good family; soon after the honeymoon he purchased Ashland, a beau- tiful estate, and here he entertained many of his distinguished friends. During this year he opposed the alien and sedition laws of John Adams’s administration, and he became very popular. In the presidential election of 1800 he supported Jefferson; his party carried the State, and finally the entire country. In 1803, when Clay was but twenty-six years old, he was elected a member of the Commoner. 443 Kentucky legislature, and his nomination and election were altogether unsolicited by himself. He remained in the legislature for some years, and took an active part in the discussion and settlement of several im- portant measures. In the year 1806, the young lawyer was © elected amember of the United States Sen- ate, although he lacked three months and seventeen days of thirty years, which is the legal age of a senator; he served but for one short session, however, it being the balance of an unexpired term of a senator who re- signed, and the mistake was not discovered until after his return to Kentucky. In 1807 he was again elected to the State legislature, and was chosen speaker of the house. It was in the course of this session that he opposed the proposition “to prohi- bit the reading in a Kentucky court of any British elementary work of law, or the cita- tion of any precedent of a British court.” The measure found favor with the majority of the house, but Clay soon convinced them of their error, and introduced an amend- ment ‘‘ to exclude from the Kentucky courts only those British decisions which have been made since the Declaration of Indepen- dence.” Notwithstanding the great popu- larity of the original resolution, the elo- quence of Clay secured for his amendment a large majority. About this time he fought a duel with Humphrey Marshall, a brother of the dis- tinguished Chief Justice. Mr. Marshall was a bitter Federalist, and gave to his tongue and pen a degree of license that led to much ill-feeling. In the course of a speech of Mr. Clay, Marshall indulged in rude and sar- castic remarks. Clay retorted in kind, and he finally challenged Marshall to a duel. They met and fought with pistols, and each was slightly wounded. Clay was intolerant and aggressive, de- lighting in gladiatorial combats, and ming- ling personal imputations with argument, striving to overwhelm his antagonist by ac-
Page 6
444 cumulating accusations and disparaging al- lusions to the unworthiness of his motives. In denunciation he was unsparing and mer- ciless. His armory was filled with all the weapons available in sarcasm and ridicule, and no man better understood the advan- tage of depreciating his adversary’s charac- ter, while he assailed his public conduct. Clay excelled in denouncing his enemies ; in retort he was merciless; he did not hesi- tate to allude to physical defects or natural infirmities of any description. Senator Buchanan, of Pennsylvania, disliked Clay very cordially. On one occasion, when the Democrats were in the majority, Clay com- plained of some act of Senator Wright, al- luding to him as the leader of the Senate. From the spot where Clay was standing, Wright and Buchanan were nearly in a range in the semi-circle. Buchanan rose to reply, supposing himself to have been referred to. Mr. Clay, with an expression of derision and contempt, said, ‘“‘ Mr. President, the senator from Pennsylvania is giving himself a deal of unnecessary trouble. I made no allu- sion to him, sir. I spoke of the leader of the Senate,” pointing directly at Mr. Wright. Mr. Buchanan,with much embarrassment, replied, ‘‘Mr. President, I did not intend to arrogate to myself any such distinction. I _ make no pretensions to be the leader of the Senate. [‘I should hope not,” said Clay, without rising.| But Senator Clay certain- ly looked at me!” “No, Mr. President,” said Clay, ‘I did nothing of the kind. It was not that I looked at the senator [here he held his hands up, making a cross with two fin- gers]; it was the way the senator looked at me." A pompous senator from Connecticut was haughty and overbearing to all col- leagues, and Clay.in the course of a speech referred to the senator, imitating his lan- guage and manner, and applied the verses of Peter Pindar’s mag-pie: The Green Bag. u ‘¢ Thus have I seen a mag-pie in the street, A chattering bird we often meet, A bird for curiosity well known, With head awry, And cunning eye, Peep knowingly into a marrow-bone.” This sally convulsed the house, and com- pletely vanquished the senator from Con- necticut. Clay was again chosen a member of the United States Senate in 1809, to serve out an unexpired term; he remained there two years, supporting the administration of President Madison. On the 4th of Novem- ber he entered the House of Representatives, and on the same day was chosen speaker, receiving seventy-five votes out of a total of one hundred and twenty-eight. He was an ideal leader; his oratory was almost fault- less, his manner fascinating, his vorce full of melody, and he always spoke in a confident, positive tone, impressing all with a convic- tion that he must be in the right. His frank bearing, his self-developed vigor, his spontaneous eloquence and com- mand of language were western characteris- tics, and reached the heart of the common people. While Calhoun engaged the atten- tion of philosophers, and Webster had the ear of lawyers and the mercantile classes, Clay, ‘‘the mill-boy of the Slashes,” was out in the open air with the people, excit- ing at will their sympathies and friendship. He never hesitated in the use of words, * * * but he was defective in early cul- ture, and occasionally his most finished speeches lacked that rare felicity always ex- hibited by his scholarly rivals, Webster and Calhoun. In reply to John Randolph, who, in the course of a speech, sneered at his lack of education, he said, ‘The gentleman from Virginia was pleased to say that in one point, at least, he coincided with me in an humble estimate of my grammatical and philological acquisitions. I know my de- ficiencies. I was born to no proud patri- monial estate. I inherited only infancy, ig- norance and indigence. I feel my defects.
Page 7
Lhe Great But as far as my situation in early life is concerned, I may, without presumption, say it was more my misfortune than my fault. But, however I regret my want of ability to furnish the gentleman with a better speci- men of my powers of verbal criticism, I will venture to say it is not greater than the dis- appointment of this committee as to the strength of his argument.” When Clay took his seat in the House, the great question was whether the United States should longer submit to encroach- ments by Great Britain, and some of his ablest speeches were made in support of the war-policy; finally war was declared in 1812. In the course of the spirited debates that preceded that great event, Clay com- pelled Randolph to submit to the rules of the house, a not very easy task, as the sena- tor from Virginia had long been to the house like ‘‘a bull in a china shop.” During the war, Clay vigorously sup- ported the administration, and his glowing words stirred the heart of the nation. A\l- most everything he said and did was illum- ined by a grand conception of the destiny of his country, a glowing national spirit, a lofty patriotism. Whether he thundered against British tyranny, or urged the recog- nition of the South American republics, or entreated for compromise and conciliation regarding the tariff or slavery —there was always ringing through his speech a fervid plea for his country, a zealous appeal in be- half of the honor and the future glory of the great republic. Clay was a second time chosen speaker, in 1813, but in the following January he re- signed to accept the appointment of com- missioner to treat with Great Britain for peace. Hewent to Europe, and peace was finally concluded on the 24th of December, 1814, at Ghent. He was firm and intensely patriotic at all times, and it was a just judg- ment which he pronounced upon himself when he said, “if any one desires to know the leading and paramount object of my Commoner. AAS public life, the preservation of this Union will furnish him the key !” Soon after he returned from abroad, Clay was re-elected to Congress, and on the 4th of December, 1815, he was chosen speaker for the third time, which office he held for the following ten years, with the exception of one term; he took a conspicuous part in all the great debates that occurred during that period, and his fame and influence con- tinued to increase. President Madison of- fered him a place in his cabinet, or any foreign mission he might select, but he de- clined the honors. When General Lafayette came to Wash- ington, in December, 1824, he visited the House of Representatives, and Mr. Clay, as speaker, made the address of welcome, in the course of which he said: — “The vain wish has been sometimes in- dulged that Providence would allow the pat- riot, after death, to return to his country, to contemplate the intermediate changes which had taken place; to view the forests felled, the cities built, the mountains lev- elled, the canals cut, the highways con- structed, the progress of the arts, the ad- vancement of learning, and the increase of population. General, your present visit to the United States is a realization of the con- soling object of that wish. You are in the midst of posterity. Everywhere you must have been struck with the great changes, physical and moral, which have occurred since you left us. Even this very city, bear- ing a venerated name, alike endeared to you and to us, has since emerged from the forest which then covered its site. In one respect you behold us unaltered, and this is in the sentiment of continued devotion to liberty, and of ardent affection and pro- found gratitude to your departed friend, the father of his country, and to you, and to your illustrious associates in the field and in the cabinet, for the multiplied blessings which surround us, and for the very privi- lege of addressing you which I now exer-
Page 8
446 cise. This sentiment, now fondly cherished by more than 10,000,000 of people, will be transmitted, with unabated vigor, down the tide of time, through the countless millions who are destined to inhabit this continent, to the latest posterity.” .Clay was very witty, and many anecdotes are told of him, illustrating his readiness of reply. Atthe time of the passage of the tariff bill, as the House was about to ad- journ, a friend of the bill observed to Clay, “We have done pretty well to-day.” ‘Very well indeed,” rejoined Clay, ‘very well; we made a good stand, considering we lost both our Feet;” alluding to Senator Foot of New York, and Senator Foot of Connec- ticut, both having opposed the bill, although it was confidently expected a short time previous that both would support the meas- ure. On another occasion, Senator Smyth, of Virginia, a gentleman of unusual ability and erudition, had been speaking for some hours, vexing the members with the length and number of his quotations and citations of authorities, and turning to Mr. Clay, he said, “You, sir, speak for the present generation, but I speak for posterity.” ‘ Yes,” replied Clay, ‘‘and you seem resolved to speak until the arrival of your audience.” When Senator Lincoln, of Maine, was considering before the House the Revolu- tionary Pension bill, and replying to an ar- gument which opposed it on the ground that those to whom it proposed to extend pe- cuniary aid might perhaps live a long time, and thus cause heavy drafts to be made upon the treasury. In one of his flights of eloquence, he said, ‘‘Soldiers of the revo- lution, live forever!” Mr. Clay succeeded him, in favor also of the humane provision, but he did not respond to Lincoln’s de- sire relative to the length of the lives of those soldiers for whose benefit it was de- vised, and when he closed, he turned to him and said, with a smile, “I hope my worthy friend will not insist upon the very The Green Bag. great duration of these pensions which he has suggested. Will he not consent, by way of a compromise, to a term of nine hundred and ninety-nine years, instead of eternity ?” The House of Representatives was called upon to choose a President of the United States in 1825, the people having in the preceding year failed to make a choice. Clay had been one of the candidates be- fore the people, but the number of votes he received was not large enough to bring him before the House. He gave his sup- port to John Quincy Adams, who appointed him Secretary of State. © He was accused by his enemies of hav- ing been bribed into voting for Adams, but he answered this calumny as follows: “I have wished the good opinion of the world, but I defy the most malignant of my ene- mies to show that I have attempted to gain it by any low or grovelling acts, by any mean or unworthy sacrifices, by the viola- tion of any of the obligations of honor, or by a breach of any of the duties which I owed to my country. If I know myself, if my head was at stake, I would do my duty, be the consequences what they might.” Soon after Clay became Secretary of State, he fought a duel with John Randolph ; this was the result of some vile language used by Randolph in the Senate. In 1828 Clay was again a candidate for the highest office in the gift of the people, but he was defeated, and he retired to private life. Of his journey home to Ashland, he wrote to a friend : — “My progress has been marked by every token of attachment and heartfelt demon- strations. I never experienced more testi- monies of respect and confidence, nor more enthusiasm — dinners, suppers, balls, etc. I have had literally a free passage. Taverns, stages, toll-gates, have been generally thrown open to me, free from all charge. Monarchs might be proud of the reception with which I have everywhere been honored.”
Page 9
The Great In private life Clay was generous and charitable to a fault. His door and his purse were alike open to the friendless stranger and the unfortunate neighbor. Frank, open, and above the meanness of de- ception himself, and consequently never searching for duplicity and treachery in those around him, he more than once suf- fered from the vile ingratitude of men who had been cherished by his bounty and up- held by his influence. | One of his household gave the following picture of Clay, as she knew him: ‘“ Life with him was solemn and earnest, and yet all about him was cheerful. I never heard him utter a jest; there was an unvarying dignity in his manner; and yet the playful child regarded him fearlessly and lovingly. Few men indulged their families in as free, confidential and familiar intercourse as did this great statesman. Indeed, to those who had an opportunity of observing him in his own house, it was evident that his cheerful and happy home had attractions for him superior to those which any other place could offer.” In the year 1831, Clay returned to the Senate, in which body he remained until the summer of 1842. During these eleven years he was prominent in public affairs and made many powerful speeches on the great ques- tions of the day. In 1835 he received a severe blow in the loss of a favorite daugh- ter; all his daughters died early, and of his three sons, one was in a lunatic asylum, another was dissipated, and a third, his favorite son Henry, was killed at the battle of Buena Vista in 1847. The most remarkable controversial per- sonal] discussion that ever occurred in Con- eress took place in 1838 between Clay and Calhoun. The debate lasted several days, and it was indeed a conflict of giants. This quarrel grew out of the change of the rela- tions of Calhoun with the Democrats; it was the most elaborate and finished effort of Clay’s career. The exciting debate final- Commoney. 447 ly ended in a spirit of courtesy and good will, but the controversy was renewed again with great bitterness. When Clay resigned his seat in 1842, and took leave of the Sen- ate in a speech of great pathos and power, Calhoun, overcome by his feelings, tendered his hand to his retiring enemy, and the rec- onciliation was complete. 3 From 1822 to 1848, a period of twenty-six years, Henry Clay lived the strange life of a candidate for the presidency, and such were his sincerity and healthfulness that he came out of this fiery trial still a patriot and a man of honor. When charged inthe Senate with using his position for his own ends, he replied. ‘For many a long year, Mr. Presi- dent, I have aspired to an object far higher than the presidency; that is, doing my duty under all circumstances, in every trial, irre- spective of parties and without regard to friendships or enmities, but simply in refer- ence to the prosperity of the country.” In the elections of 1832, 1839 and 1844, Clay was a candidate for the presidency, and each time was defeated, but not con- quered. Inthe contest of 1844, the party which had placed Clay in nomination started with vast chances in its favor, which were greatly increased by the dissensions existing in the other party. Yet Clay was beaten, and by a man far inferior to him in every respect; there is no doubt that his want of success was due to his views on the slavery question. The following is an extract from his great speech on the Oregon question before the House, March 16, 1846: — ‘But I oppose war, not simply on the patriotic ground of a citizen looking to the freedom and prosperity of his own country, but on still broader grounds, as a friend of improvement, civilization and progress. Viewed in reference to them, at no period has it ever been so desirable to preserve the general peace which now blesses the world. * * * Chemical and mechanical dis- coveries and inventions have multiplied be-
Page 10
448 yond all former example —adding, with their advance to the comforts of life in a de- gree far greater and more universal than all that was ever known before. Civilization has, during the same period, spread its in- fluence far and wide, and the general pro- gress in knowledge and its diffusion through all ranks of society, has outstripped all that has ever gone before it. The two great agents of the physical world have become subject to the will of man, and have been made subservient to all his wants and en- joyments; I allude to steam and electricity, under whatever name the latter may be called. The former has overcome distance both on land and water, to an extent which former generations had not the least concep- tion was possible. It has, in effect, reduced the Atlantic to half its former width, while, at the same time, it has added three-fold to the rapidity of intercourse by land. Within the same period, electricity, the greatest and most diffuse of all known physical agents, has been made the instrument for the trans- mission of thought, I will not say with the rapidity of lightning, but by lightning itself. Magic wires are stretching themselves in all directions over the earth, bringing men closer together.” | At the Philadelphia convention in 1848, Clay was again defeated, and this was the culmination of his mortification and wrath at the final overthrow of all his schemes. He passionately aspired to be president; he wished this for many reasons; he was sure that his theory of the policy of the govern- ment would insure prosperity to the coun- try and the people; then he desired to re- ward his friends and punish his enemies. Clay had resigned his seat in the Senate previous to the election, and he retired to Ashland; but he could not long remain in- active, and he soon returned to the Senate. Clay’s last public effort was in support of the ““compromise measures” in 1850. His health was now failing and he visited New Orleans and Havana the following winter. The Green Bag. Ashland was mortgaged for $50,000, and upon his return from the South he discov- ered that this had been removed privately by his friends. ‘‘ Had ever a man,” he ex- claimed, ‘‘such friends or enemies as Henry Clay!” ‘The careless reader of our history in future centuries,’ wrote Horace Greeley, ‘will scarcely realizethe force of Clay’s per- sonal magnetism, nor conceive how millions of hearts glowed with sanguine hope of his election to the presidency, and bitterly la- mented his and their discomfiture.” Clay resigned his seat in the Senate Sep- tember 20, 1851, and in his valedictory ad- dress, he said: ‘My acts and public con- duct are a fair subject for the criticism and judgment of my fellowmen; but the private motives by which they have been prompted are known only to the great searcher of the human heart and myself. * * * What- ever errors, and doubtless there have been many, may be discovered in a review of my public service to the country, I can, with un- shaken confidence, appeal to that divine ar- biter for the truth of the declaration that I have been influenced by no impure purpose, no personal motive; have sought no personal aggrandizement, but that, in all my public acts I have had a sole and single eye, and a warm and devoted heart, directed and dedi- cated to what, in my best judgment, I be- lieved to be the true interests of my coun- try: While on a visit to Washington the fol- lowing June, he was taken suddenly ill. A friend who had just returned from Kentucky, and who bore a message from his wife, went to visit him. Clay said to him, “I am not afraid to die, sir; I have hope, faith, and some confidence. I do notthink any man can be entirely certain in regard to his future state, but I have an abiding trust in the merits and mediation of our Saviour.” He met his end with composure, sur- rounded by a few friends. On July 1, 1852, his body lay in state in the Senate Cham-
Page 11
Bench and Bar Witty Encounters. ber, and the following day it was removed to Ashland, where the funeral was met by 100,000 people. ‘The great man had missed the presidency, but he had not missed the love of a whole nation.” It was said of him, “his last years were his best; he ripened to the very end.” “Of our public men of the sixty years preceding the war,’ said James Parton, ‘‘Henry Clay was certainly the most shin- ing figure. Was there ever a public man, not at the head of a state, so beloved as he? Who ever heard such cheers, so hearty, distinct and ringing, as those which 449 his name evoked? Men shed tears at his defeat, and women went to bed sick from pure sympathy with his disappointment. He could not travel during the last thirty years of his life, but only make progress- es. When he left his home the public seized him and bore him along over the land, the committee of one State passing him on to the committee of another, and the hurrahs of one town dying away as those of the next caught his ear. The country seemed to place all its resources at his disposal; all commodities sought his acceptance.” BENCH AND BAR WITTY ENCOUNTERS. HAT entertaining volumes might have been made for the delectation of the legal profession— and for laymen as well —if from the earliest times of the insti- tution of courts and of their officers some record could have been kept of the asides between judges and counsel, or between members of bench or bar themselves (or litigants or witnesses) during argument or trial hours. These asides might have in- cluded epigram, sarcasm, wit, and trenchant repartee. One meets with specimens of them in legal biographies and in many pub- lished recollections. These, too, abound in anecdotes. But their paucity compared with the estimation of what must have been their frequency only serves to increase curiosity now alive and create longing for more. To the clever things uttered in court-rooms might be added the clever things done — the caricatures and drawings of counsel or judges, for instance, on the margin or in the body of briefs and notes of testimony or ar- gument. It is mentioned in recent newspa- pers, of Sir Frank Lockwood, Q. C., who was lately Solicitor-General of England, that ushers in the courts, after their duties of at- tendance end, find on the floor near where he has sat as acting counsel, slips of blotters and papers that contain humorous or seri- ous etchings made by him with lightning- like rapidity, and illustrative of passing events in the court-room, or of officials, witnesses and jurors. He has not hesitated even to polish off with deft pen a lordship or two in robes upon several occasions. Few who know of Sir William Jones only through his treatise on Bailments can credit that he was one of the sweetest poets at the close of the last century. He has been known to often pen verses ad captandum in court; and to an effort on one such occasion is ascribed his couplet reading: ‘¢ Seven hours to law, to soothing slumber seven, Ten to the world allot, but all to Heaven.” Which reads as a great improvement over another similar couplet ascribed to Coke, a century before Jones: ‘« Six hours in sleep, in law’s grave study six, Four spend in prayer, the rest on Nature fix.” _ Sir George Rose was a brilliant Chancery Q. C. of the era of Lord Eldon, who in the awful presence of the latter wrote on his notes these epigrammatic lines regarding a
Page 12
450 pending equity case — which lines, although heretofore given in legal literature, may in this connection again see light: — ‘*Mr. Leach has made a speech Which is witty, neat and strong. On the other part brother Hart Has been heavy, dull and long. Brother Parker made the case darker Which was dark enough without. Then on his close the court uprose And Eldon muttered — ‘ Doubt.’” No doubt many a judge, wearied by the prolixity of an arguing counsel, and who has already extracted the kernel of the nut that counsel is cracking with repeated blows, has whiled away the moments by pencilling some doz mot or epigram and handed it to associates for their enjoyment. Perhaps they of the Bench are often thus recreating when counsel, seeing busy pens moving above him, fondly fancies that the Judges are taking copious notes of his argument and citations. New Orleans lawyers narrate of their once _Chief-Justice George Eustis —sire of the American Ambassador to France —that his great amusement during tedious arguments was to indite pleasantries on his official note- book. They also narrate that Judah P. Benjamin, when at the New Orleans Bar — long before he became Federal Senator, then Attorney-General of the Confederacy and subsequently a great Q. C. in England — was noted for his exchange of repartees with Judge Eustis. A capital impromptu satire on Chief Baron Pollock— grandfather of the great QO. C. who has recently been a guest of the Harvard Law School alumni— is ascribed to George Augustus Sala, constructed while acting as reporter of a cause celébre for the ‘“‘ London Telegraph.” At the time the Chief Baron had become —to quote a Biblical phrase — ‘well stricken in years” and was very deaf; so that he would often misunderstand and confuse matters in his rulings. The im- promptu lines may serve as an instance of The Green Bag. what is lost through absence of court re- porters, to chronicle smart forensic sayings. The preservation of the line is due to bar- rister Percy Fitzgerald— who, however, is better known as author and playwright than as lawyer. | It seems that in observing the mistakes of the Chief Baron through his diminution of hearing, Fitzgerald, in an aside, had re- minded Sala of the sketch in the Pickwick Papers by their mutual friend, Charles Dickens, of deaf Justice Stareleigh when presiding at the Trial of Bardell v. Pickwick. That fictional Judge, when witness Nathaniel Winkle of the club was called to the box, had after many vain attempts to hear the name called, finally noted it as Daniel. Thus the Sala impromptu: The plaintiff, John Doe, is as deaf as an adder, More deaf the defendant, one Roe, and what’s sadder, Much deafer than both is the judge, enthroned high This intricate action of trover to try! Doe claimed many drachmas for rent. left, unpaid. Deaf Roe in defence with great emphasis said : ‘¢It is always by night that my corn I do grind.” Quoth the judge looking down, ‘‘ Why not be of one mind? After all she’s your mother ; why can’t you agree To keep her between you and let the law be?” These irrelevant misunderstandings among the deaf triune were indeed trenchantly hit off. Chief Justice Xavier Martin, of Louisiana —first reporter of its court, and to remove whom, because he was an octogenarian, purblind and deaf, and would not resign, the State Constitution was changed in 1846, —was continually blundering through his deafness. When the eloquent Sergeant S. Prentiss, who had come down from Vicks- burg, in Mississippi, to argue a case before the Martin Court, the senile Chief Justice whispered to an associate on the bench, “New face; don’t know him. What's his name?” ‘This being given, all the con- versation perfectly audible in the court-room that was crowded by auditors attracted by the fame of one of the most matchless
Page 13
Bench and Bar Witty Encounters. orators the Union ever knew— Chief Justice Martin, hearing the word Prentiss, said testily, “Yes, yes, Mr. Sargent: but who is he apprentice to?”’ | ‘“‘ Himself,” responded, in an aside, Alfred Hennen, arbiter elegantiarum of the then bar, ‘Prentiss is the apprentice to the Muse of Eloquence.” Elijah Paine, best known to the Bar of New York City half a century ago as author of a ponderous book of practice, was later a judge of the Superior Court of that city by gubernatorial appointment to fill a vacancy. He was fast becoming deaf and often mis- took ringings in his ears for spoken words; and upon one occasion soon after his debut startled the court room by suddenly ex- claiming to the crier beside him, at the very moment when counsel paused to consult a volume and quietude reigned. ‘‘ Demand more silence,” adding ‘‘I may be somewhat hard of hearing, but I do not want confusion.” It was this judge of whom Daniel Lord, junior, having said to John Van _ Buren (while both were engaged in a trial and each fairly shouting) “ this is another Elijah fed by ravings,’ was responded to by the _witty Prince thus: ‘ And the pleasure we delight in physics Paine.” But deaf as some judges might be, it was dangerous for a juror to play —a common one—the game of deafness as an excuse for release upon Sir Henry Hawkins, the eminent English judge, who would often catch a juror after hearing his excuse by emitting in a faint whisper scarcely to be heard by his clerk a few paces off, ‘“‘ excuse granted; you may go,’ and when the trapped juror answered, ‘‘ Thank your lord- ship,” showing he was not deaf, Sir Henry would gruffly say, ‘‘ Now take the box.” It was before Sir Henry —who was fond of holding criminal assizes—— that a Hebrew barrister made this appeal for clemency for his client, convicted of perjury: ‘ He is the best man in the kingdom for de trut’. He always spoke de trut’, and indeed he was so A51 fond of it that he would tell more than de trut’.” Arguing a case once in the Federal Su- preme Court, a western lawyer thinking to compliment Justice Story, then on the bench, quoted almost entirely from some of the judge’s law books: and venturing to pun, as looking at the shining scalp of the great jurist (which to veterans who remember him seemed always blushing) said ‘ but to at least one of your Honors these references may seem anoldstory.” Reverdy Johnson, who sat near by, whispered to the advocate, “Your whole argument is built Story upon Story.” Vice Chancellor and also Civil Judge Anthony S. Robertson, of New York City, was noted for indulging in bench repartees and witticisms without compromising his own dignity or that of an occasion. He was listening patiently at chambers to an argumentative conflict over the amount of a fee claimed by a counsel. At the close of the contention he remarked, ‘‘ Let me have your papers and the affidavits of the expert, and I will see what is feasible as to the fee and endeavor to see my way to a just solu- tion between the contention on the one side that the fee is a phenomenal one and on the other side that there should not be a nominal fee.” He was very much beloved by all the profession, who scarcely ever referred to him otherwise than as “ Tony.” He had a brother Justice, James R. Whiting, who had been a District Attorney, and for his bitter prosecutions was named “ Little Bitters,” being abnormally short of stature. Judge Whiting was not college bred, but had an ambition to be thought literary, and was much given to quotations which often became curiously verbally mixed. Called upon to speak regarding the death of a _ judicial brother he rounded his peroration with, ‘our brother has gone where the weary cease from troubling and the wicked are at rest.”
Page 14
452 “The judge has given a non-jurisdictional post mortem sentence,” remarked Judge Tony, who was not altogether friendly with Whiting. And later when the latter, wearied of the Bench, left it in disgust, and a lawyer meeting Judge Tony in the court, rather un- grammatically announced: ‘ Judge Whiting zs resigned,’ was answered, “And so am I to the news.” The Southern congressman who is credited with inventing the question put to the Speak- er, “Where am | at?” was anticipated a quarter century ago before Judge Lewis B. Woodruff, Federal Circuit Judge in New York. The latter was continually given to making interruptions during arguments, and also interlocutory digressions which often embarrassed the counsel. After a rather long interruption during an argument by the late William O. Bartlett, an eminent law- yer, Judge Woodruff said, “And now you may resume the thread of your argument.” Bartlett, a master of repartee, said, ‘‘ That thread is now so interwoven into the woof and warp of your Honor’s excellent cloth of observations that I have lost it. But will your Honor kindly tell me where I was at?” Chief Baron Kelly, during argument, was given to much wool-gathering, and one could see from his countenance when the fit of ab- sent-mindedness was upon him. But he was sometimes like the fox in the fable, who out- stretched and with closed eyes was neverthe- less wide awake for the innocently straying chicken. On such a last-mentioned occa- sion, Mr. Cole, Q. C., repeated a point when the Chief Baron, still with closed eyes, lan- guidly remarked, ‘‘ Mr. Cole that is the third time you have said that — why repeat?” ‘If your lordship pleases, I wanted at least one of them to carry attention.” | ‘“‘T heap a coal of fire upon your head by informing you that each shot took effect. I can readily shut my eyes to bad law and sophistry.” George Wood, an eminent lawyer at both Lhe Green Bag. the Philadelphia and New York bar, was never suspected of waggery. Yet according to Marshall Bidwell, whom, as a great Cana- dian barrister the provincial revolution en- gineered by Mackenzie in 1837 exiled to New York to become one of its grandest and most impressive-looking ornaments — with his massive gray head, Roman features and spotless white cravat of the Prince Regent folds, — George Wood one day, while they were associated in a pending case, suddenly whispered, ‘“‘ Don’t be alarmed at brother Og- den’s earnestness on the other side. There is only one case in his favor, and if he knows of it he cannot get the volume.” “Why not?” ‘“‘ Because I have drawn it from the library and I am now sitting on it.” Richard Busteed, when Corporation Coun- sel of New York city, once claimed that Chief- Justice Thomas J. Oakley, who was never jocular, had lost him a verdict by perfunc- torily saying, without meaning any slur, in the midst of the counsel’s very amusing ad- dress to a jury, — ‘‘ Now we will take a lunch- eon recess to give the jury opportunity to laugh.” Busteed, after the civil war, was made, by President Johnson, Judge of the Federal Dis- trict Court in Alabama. There he was re- garded as a carpet-bagger, and the Confed- erate lawyers took every occasion to hetchell him. Busteed was an erratic man, and fad- dish. He insisted upon having his judicial chair in Mobile draped with the American flag. On one occasion the judge was com- pelled to kindly rebuke a member of the bar who, insolently pointing to the exposed flag observed, ‘‘ Yes, the court makes me see stars.” Whereunto Busteed calmly observed, ‘And have a care lest the court should in self-respect be compelled to make you also see stripes.” Before Mr. Chauncey Depew drifted from general law practice into special legal prac- tice for the Vanderbilt interests, and lastly into railway management, his well known wit
Page 15
Bench and Bar Witty Encounters. and readiness of repartee was remarked. When just admitted to the bar, he was before a Peekskill justice of the peace and was per- haps youthfully overbearing when the Jus- tice of the Peace remarked — with emphasis on the word me — “ D’ye expect me to teach you manners, young man ?”’ Theanswer was, “IT have no such expectation, your honor, and I do not believe any one else has such hopeless expectation.” A member of the New York bar, who was professor in one of the Metropolitan law schools, on one occasion when the late Judge George G. Barnard was a member of a court in banco, fairly lectured the Bench on the law applicable to his appeal; when Barnard thus pleasantly interrupted: ‘“‘Be kind enough to remember, Professor, that we have all at least attended a primary law school.” A counsel once arguing the question of premeditation in murder and whether,a de- sign to kill could be formulated on an in- stant of thought, had said before the Court of Appeals that no instance of such a possi- 453 bility of design and fulfilment concurrent was extant, was interrupted by Chief-Justice Hen- ry G. Davies—a great churchman — with, “Oh yes; in the first chapter of Genesis: ‘And God said let there be light: and there was light.’”’ : ‘Quite so, Chief Justice,” was the repar- tee, “but my client had no divine aid; for the indictment on page 3 of the Bill of Ex- ceptions charged him with ‘being moved and instigated thereunto by the devil.’” When the vast scope of the constant attri- tion of judicial and legal minds that is afford- ed under the court machinery of this entire Union is considered, only then due estima- tion can be had as to the extent and quality of the rhetorical result of “keen encounter of wits” in its two or three hundred court- rooms habituated by men of mental training in thought and fancy, as well as of the inter- est which full reports of such encounters, if possible to be made, would disseminate to readers.
Page 16
454 The Green Bag. THE FAILURE OF PUNISHMENT. VERY now and then the conscience of the community is horrified by some abominable crime. Public interest becomes violently excited, and all the details are read with avidity. Should the criminal be dis- covered, his trial is watched by the eyes of the nation, and if his crime be murder, the public conscience of the majority is appeased when he is sentenced to death. Formerly the execution was a festive occasion for all but the prisoner. People went to view it as they go to see a horse-race, a circus per- formance, or any other pleasant show. Seats were paid for, and places taken early. Rude jokes were cracked, and ribald songs sung. Refreshments were devoured at the foot of the gallows, and the Bill Sykes of the hour was cheered by his friends, and exhorted to die “game.” If he showed signs of fear, the mob cursed and howled. Bravado, inso- lence, and impudence were expected from him for their approval, and he seldom dis- appointed them. We find that punishments after the Chris- tian era were little, if any, less cruel than those under Paganism. Virginity was the su- preme theoretical virtue of the early Church, the foundation of her wealth and strength. Thus the first Christian emperors issued edicts by which panderers were condemned to have molten lead poured down their throats, and not only was the ravisher put to death, but the ravished also if she con- sented to his act. Nevertheless, nowhere are fouler records of immorality to be found than among those who were the most stren- uous upholders of chastity. The compara- tive immunity of monks and priests made them the most debauched and most de- bauching classes of the community. They were not slack, however, in imposing pains and penalties upon others. The punish- ments inflicted by the Church exceeded the civil manyfold, both in number and severity, but they did not succeed in checking eccles- iastical offenses. For instance, when witches were punished with most cruelty was pre- cisely the time when witches most abounded. Each auto-da-fe was followed by an abundant crop of fresh victims. We look on these fol- lies of our predecessors with scorn and pity, and perhaps, in the future, our errors, to which we so fondly ae. to-day, will be similarly regarded. It has been found by ages of experience that the most horrible punishments or suf- ferings were least deterrent. In many cases they seem to have had a strange fascination for weak minds that boldly courted them, just as the Circumcelliones, in the fourth century, courted suicide. These insulted the Pagan customs to provoke martyrdom — killed each other for the glory of God— and, as St. Augustine informs us, assembled by thousands at a time, and ‘leaped with paroxysms of frantic joy from the brows of overhanging cliffs till the rocks below were reddened with their blood.” Healthy minds regard horrors with wholesome abhorrence, but not so the unhealthy. And we are still so ignorant of the extent to which these lat- ter exist, and of the peculiarities of mental and moral weaknesses, and the influence upon them of current events, that it becomes doubtful whether severe punishments do not incite to new crimes, and, indeed, whether all forms of punishment, except restrictive ones, may not be mistakes. It has been proved over and over that crime is in its nature epidemic, and from this it would appear to be the outcome of dis- ease. Lunatics in this country were regu- larly whipped in former times, and those who had infectious complaints, such as smallpox,
Page 17
The Fatlure of Puntshment. were similarly treated if they broke bounds even during delirium. In the parish con- stable’s account for 1710, at Great Staugh- ton, Huntingdonshire, is this entry: ‘ Pd. Thomas Hawkins for whipping two people that had the smallpox, 8d.;” and in 1714: “Pd. for watching, victuals, and drink for Mary Mitchell, 2s. 6d.: pd. for whipping her, 4d.” Yet the people who ordered and performed these atrocities were not destitute of humanity, but were gravely wanting in perception. If it were possible to abolish crime by se- verity, then despots should be the greatest social purifiers. Henry VIII, in the twenty- second year of his reign, made poisoning treason, and the penalty, to be slowly boiled to death; but so ineffective was this that, in the first year of his son’s reign, it was re- pealed. We have had all kinds of maiming and lopping by law. Eyes, lips, ears, noses, hands, tongue, besides an unnameable one. When men were disemboweled and hanged for petit treason, women were disemboweled and burnt. To be hanged, drawn and quar- tered was common. English women were burnt for witchcraft and for all kinds of trea- son, whether poisoning a husband or defam- ing the Queen, until the thirtieth year of George III. Next they were drawn and hanged; and now they are hanged only, and for murder alone. Who can say whether the repeal of this last might not be as wise as that of the previous ones? Had we the same moral courage as our ancestors, we should try it. We are aware that this proposal would be indignantly rejected by a large number. Many would bang us with that verse of Scripture, “‘Whoso sheddeth,” etc. But they were the same sort who clamored for the burning of inoffensive women, on the eround that “Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live.” Those who believe in the amelio- ration of harsh laws rather than in extreme punishments, who hold that men can be drawn into goodness, but can never be 455 driven, are forever encountered by these Biblical “bangs.” We protest against yield- ing to the narrow zealots who meet every suggestion for the improvement of social conditions in this age by a quotation from the Pentateuch. In addition to the maim- ing and capital punishments named, and often for the most frivolous offences, such as stealing a sheep or killing a hare, there have been a host of excruciating tortures inflicted to extort confession. When Felton was threatened with torture, he said: ‘If I be put upon the rack, I will accuse you, my lord of Dorset, and none but yourself.” Secretary Winwood wrote of a prisoner in James I’s reign: ‘‘ Peacham this day was examined before torture, in torture, between torture, and after torture; notwith- standing, nothing could be drawn from him.” Queen Elizabeth once tortured all the ser- vants of the Duke of Norfolk, yet no lawyer found fault with this violation of the laws. As an able writer says: ‘ The truth is, law- yers are rarely philosophers; the history of the heart read only in statutes and law cases, presents the worst side of human nature; they are apt to consider men as wild beasts.” _ Minor punishments were liberally pro- vided by borough towns. These, like little independent states, while acknowledging a suzerain, made their own laws and admin- istered their own punishments. Fear was the ruling feature of their systems, as in those of the higher powers. Now a single hanging creates a sensation. But in 1787, thirteen men and women were conveyed to the gallows at once at Worcester, not one of whom had committed murder. In the bor- ough towns there were the tumbrel for such as pilfering millers, the ducking-stool for scolding wives, the brank for taming shrews, the cage or pillory, the skimmington, and the stocks for all. In the ballad, Titus Oates is made to say: — «¢ See the rabble all round me in battle array, Against my wood castle their batteries play ; With turnip granadoes the storm is begun.”
Page 18
450 The Green Bag. Immorality was punished sometimes by the stocks and a whipping. Cardinal Wol- sey, when incumbent of Lymington, was set in the stocks on a Fair day for drunkenness. Then there were also the dark house or dun- geon, the drunkard’s clock, the whipping- post, entries in the Hustings Book, brand- ing, and all sorts of arbitrary fines and imprisonment. Nothing was too high or too low for the borough magnates, except such matters as had to go to sessions. A man who had associated with another man’s wife ‘‘in a very suspicious manner,” was im- prisoned for more than a year. A walk on the Sunday, a hasty word, or absence from church, were also duly punished. Even love matters were not above the cognizance of justices. , | The game-laws have been very fertile in punishments, and still occasion a large part of the crime of country districts. To take an egg out of the nest of a swan, falcon, goose-hawk, lanner or goose, was visited by a year and a day’s imprisonment and a fine at the will of the Crown. For ‘killing or wounding any deer in any park or enclosed eround” was, by a statute of George I, transportation to the plantations for seven years. As time proceeds, these cruel pun- ishments, so incommensurate with the of- fences for which they were designed, have dropped one by one away. With this ame- lioration, the habits and happiness of the people have correspondingly improved. Our morals are purity itself compared to those of the past. And why? Because we are better instructed in secular knowledge; be- cause we have more freedom, and so acquire habits of self-control and self-respect; be-_ cause we have got rid of prying agitators and social spies. But the madness of those who would restore the old state of things is like that which afflicted the inhabitants of the Neapolitan districts for two centuries ending with the seventeenth — the madness of self-destruction. ‘Theirs was attributed to the bite of the tarantula; ours is a more virulent poison of the mind. Lecky tells us “the patients thronged in multitudes to- wards the sea, and often, as the blue waters opened to their view, they chanted a wild hymn of welcome, and rushed with passion into the waves.” So amongst us are thous- ands who advocate those harsh measures and backward marches which would ulti- mately engulf us in all the horrors of anar- chy and general criminality. —LADY COOK, in the Humanitarian.
Page 19
Lhe Supreme Court of Matne. 457 THE SUPREME COURT OF MAINE. By CHARLES HAMLIN. HE first organized government within the limits of Maine exercising judicial powers appears to have been established by Sir Ferdinando Gorges, who, under his nephew, William Gorges, set up a court at Sacg in 1636. The members of the court, seven in number, were styled commissioners, and resided in different parts of the province styled New Somersetshire, extending beween the Piscataqua and Kennebec rivers. Of these commissioners, Purchase was from Brunswick, Cammock and_ Josselyn from Scarboro, Bonithorn and Lewis from Saco, and Godfrey from York. The court thus established by William Gorges assumed gen- eral jurisdiction, and exercised governmental as well as judicial authority, endeavoring to introduce good order among the detached settlements along the coast from the Piscata- qua River to Pemaquid. An early step thus taken by this court was an order, dated Feb- ruary 7, 1636, directed to Thomas Lewis, requiring him to ‘‘ appear the next court day at the new dwelling-house of Thomas Williams (Winter Harbor), there to answer his contempt, and to show cause why he will not deliver up the combination | regula- tions of government adopted by the compa- nies settled at Agamenticus and other places] belonging to us, and to answer to such actions as are commenced against him.” The records of this time are fragmentary, but there remains enough to show that the forms of procedure were simple and free from technicalities — due to the absence of lawyers. Actions of trespass, slander, incon- tinency, for drunkenness and “ rash speeches” occurred frequently. The name of the territory was changed to the Province of Maine under the patent is- sued to Sir Ferdinando, dated April 3, 1639, and he was empowered, among other things, to establish courts of justice, ecclesiastical, civil and temporal, and to appoint magis- trates, judges and officers, with the right of appeal to the Lord Proprietor. Under this charter he appointed an executive council. The board, consisting of able men, was com- posed of Thomas Gorges, deputy governor, and his councillors, Vines, Champernoon, Jos- selyn, Bonithorn, Hooke and Godfrey. Inthe records of their courts they are styled com- missioners. Besides the usual civil and crim- inal powers, the court was also invested with admiralty and probate jurisdiction. The first session of the court was held June 25, 1640, when Roger Garde was sworn in as register, and Robert Sankey as __ provost marshal. Eighteen civil actions and nine complaints were then entered. At the Sep- tember term, the deputy governor presided, and there were pending twenty-eight civil actions, nine of which were tried before a jury, and thirteen indictments. The council ordered one general term to be held annu- ally, on the twenty-fifth day of June, at Saco, and divided the province into two districts ; the dividing line being the Kennebec River, with three terms of court in each district to be held by an inferior court. At the same term, letters of administration upon the es- tate of Richard Williams were granted to Payton Cooke, gent., being the first granted in the Province of Maine. Besides these courts, commissioners were appointed from time to time, in the different towns with powers similar to trial justices of the present day. Their jurisdiction in civil
Page 20
458 matters was limited to forty shillings, and an appeal laid to the higher court. The records disclose the same simple forms of procedure that had previously prevailed. They exhibit also the first bill in equity in Maine, filed June, 1640. It is probably the first in New England. The names of the parties are John Kinkford vs. George Cleeves and Richard Tucker. The cause of action related to accounting for some clapboards, ‘‘notwithstanding the said George Cleeves and Richard Tucker did formerly know that the said clapboards were in con- troversy, neither can the plf. enjoy them; and they utterly refuse to give the com- plainant any satisfaction for the same”. . . It required forty years’ incessant effort, and at the cost of nearly all his estate, by Gorges, to establish a government giving protection to the scattered colonies of Maine. As will be readily seen, the future of the judicial department depended upon the suc- cess of his government as an _ entirety. Judgments of a court without power to en- force them, or doubts and strife as to the lawfulness of its right to hear and determine causes, must, of necessity, create confusion and uncertainty. That is what did happen soon after the Civil War broke out in Eng- land, in the spring of 1642, when Gorges, returning to the mother country to espouse the royal cause, died in 1647. Sir Alexander Rigby, at the instigation of Cleeves, pur- chased the Plough Patent of 1630, as it was called, and the latter, sent over in 1643 as Rigby’s deputy, held courts at Casco and Scarboro’ for seven or eight years, in con- flict with the courts of Gorges, held by Vines. This was the beginning of thirty years’ conflict ending in 1677, when Massa- chusetts purchased of Gorges’ grandson all his interests in the province for 41250 ster- ling. During the last-named period, the law did not exist among the people as a science, nor was its practice regulated by men trained to the profession. After the purchase of Maine by Massa- The Green Bag. chusetts, in 1677, the way was fairly open for the peaceful rule of the Bay Colony. Courts were immediately established, over which Thomas Danforth presided, and, in 1680, he was appointed president of the province. He proceeded at once to York, where he held an assembly of representa- tives called to reorganize the government. The judicial system then prevailing in Massachusetts was not extended over Maine, as it was decided that the purchased terri- tory must be governed according to the charter granted to Gorges. Provision, however, was made for appeals in all cases from the superior courts, and death penalties were subject to the concurrence of a majority of the Assembly. And it was ordered that the laws, orders and precedents that had been practiced before, and were of use in the province, should remain in full force until the General Assembly or Council should take order therein. . This jurisdiction continued eleven years from the purchase, until it was interrupted by the second Indian war, which devastated the whole eastern country. . During the existence of the colonial gov- ernment no educated lawyer except Thomas Gorges, the first deputy of the proprietor, practiced in the courts of Maine. He was educated at the Inns of Court in London. and presided in the General Court of the province four years only. * Il. There was another province, lying between the Kennebec and Penobscot rivers, known as Pemaquid. It was occupied by perma- nent settlers as early as 1625. In 1630, the year that Boston was founded, it had a pop- ulation of about five hundred persons. It was at one time the seat of the most con- siderable transactions of any settlement upon the New England coast. The general reader will find an interesting account of ancient Pemaquid by Mr. Thornton in the fifth
Page 21
The Supreme Court of Maine. volume of the Maine Historical Collections. We do not know what courts were estab- lished, or what laws were enacted. No record of them remains. Mr. Thornton, however, contributes to history the valuable infor- mation that Abraham Shurt, agent of the proprietors, is the author of the brief and comprehensive formula by which the ac- knowledgment of deeds in Maine and Mas- sachusetts has ever been certified.. He cites as proof the certificate of Shurt to the deed of the Indian sachems of the Pemaquid ter- ritory to John Brown, dated July 24, 1626. A few other facts in the history of Pema- quid will serve our present purpose. In 1632 a charter was granted by the council of New England to Aldworth and Elbridge of Bristol, England. This passed, in 1650, from their heirs, and became in after years the subject, together with other titles derived from the Indians, English patentees and possessory rights, of a furious and bitter controversy, which was only settled by the interference of Massachusetts, and then by compromise, in 1812. The commissioners of Charles II visited the province in 1664. They reported: ‘“ The people for the most part are fishermen, and never had any gov- ernment among them.” In 1673, when the government of New Yorkwas granted to James, Duke of York and brother of the king, Pemaquid became an appendage to the colony of New York, and was represented in its General Assembly. June 24, 1680, courts were established by the council sitting in New York. The noted Sir Edmund Andros was governor at this time, and, as such, issued a commission to Henry Josselyn, who had formerly been one of Gorges’ commissioners, residing at Scar- boro’, and others, to be a court of session, and, ‘“‘to act according to law and former practice.” This court held its sessions in June and November. Justices of the peace were also appointed from time to time, with authority to hear and determine civil and criminal causes. Thomas Gyles lived, at the 459 time of the first Indian war, at Merry Meet- ing Bay; he afterwards settled at Pemaquid, and was made chief justice of the court there. He was killed by the Indians in 1689. John Jordan, of Cape Elizabeth, was ap- pointed by Governor Andros a special jus- tice for the province, which then acquired the name, County of Cornwall, the principal place being Pemaquid and made a port of entry and shire-town. In Septethber, 1686, the Duke of York, who had now become James II, transferred the jurisdiction of his eastern territory to Massachusetts, which immediately assumed the government over it, and she lost no time in giving stability to the institutions in’ her new acquisitions. The second: Indian war, which broke out soon after, 1689, interrupted her plans, and instead of establishing a peaceful govern- ment, she was called upon to defend the territory, and to rescue the inhabitants from imminent peril, and ‘before it was over the new charter of I69I was granted, which united with the old Bay Colony that of Plymouth, the whole poigetsing of Maine, and also Nova Scotia. Il. It is worthy of note that the political status of the Province of Maine, during the fifty-two years briefly sketched above, was that of a palatinate, of which Gorges was’ lord palatine; his royal judicial powers are found recited at large in the curious Palati- nate of Maine; and is the only instance of a purely feudal possession on this continent." Under the charter of 1691, above named, granted upon the accession of William and Mary, occurred the second important period in the courts of Maine, when there was established a system which, with few changes, continued for the next one hundred 1 Ex-Goy. Gen. J. L. Chamberlain’s Centennial Address, Phila. Nov. 4, 1876.
Page 22
460 and thirty years, or until the admission of Maine as a state into the Union. After enunciating a declaration in the nature of a bill of rights, great doctrines foreshadowing the principle upon which the war of the Revolution was fought eighty-four years afterwards, laws were passed for the establishment of courts, viz.: justices of the peace for the trial of small causes; quarter sessions, corresponding to courts of county commissioners of the present day; inferior Court of Common Pleas; and the Superior Court. A Court of Chancery was created, but was disallowed by the Home Govern- ment. The governor and council Were made by the charter a Court of Probate; and a Court of Admiralty was also established by the Crown. The Superior Court was com- posed of Wm. Stoughton, chief-justice, Thomas Danforth, Wait Winthrop, John Richards, and Samuel Sewall. Judge Lynde, elevated to the bench in 1712, was the first educated lawyer placed upon it; and William Cushing, appointed in 1772, was the first lawyer promoted to the bench from Maine. This court held two sessions a year in the principal counties, but trials of causes arising in Maine, which formed only one county till 1760, were held in Boston or Charlestown. It was not until 1699 that a term was granted to this state, which was held at Kittery un- til 1743, when it was removed to York. This continued to 1760, when the counties of Cumberland and Lincoln were established. The first term in Cumberland County was held in 1761, in Lincoln not until 1786; both held in: June, but only for jury trials. The court thus established, in 1699, for Maine, consisted of a chief and four other justices, and so continued during the exist- ence of royal authority in the colony. By the Constitution of 1780, the title of this court was changed to that of the Supreme Judicial Court. The judges first appointed under the new constitution were Wm. Cush- ing, Nathaniel Peaslee Sargent, James Sul- The Green Bag. livan, David Sewall and Jedediah Foster. Three judges constituted a quorum of the court, which sat in all the counties, and they decided all questions of law arising during the progress of jury trials. In consequence of a large accumulation of business in the courts, the number of judges was increased, in 1800, to seven, with two quorums, so that the court could be held in two places at the same time. In 1805 the mzs¢ prius system was introduced, with five judges; three sitting zz banc to decide questions of law, and one or more presiding at the trial terms. These judges, until 1792, appeared on the bench in robes and wigs; in summer the robes were black silk, in winter, scarlet cloth. The wig disappeared with the vener- able Cushing. 7 The records of: this court for all the counties were kept in Boston until 1797, when they were transferred to the custody of the clerks of the Common Pleas of the several counties, except those of Hancock, Lincoln and Washington, where the clerks | were appointed by the justices to reside and to keep their records in such place in Lin- coln County as the court should direct. The court appointed Jona. Bowman, Jr., clerk for these counties, his residence to be at Pownalborough, now Dresden, where the court-house, now a large, four-story dwelling- house, remains to be seen as the only rem- nant of a once promising city. In Maine, the uzs¢ priws system was retained and ad- ministered by a chief and two associate justices until 1847, when an additional justice, Samuel Wells, was appointed. A Common Pleas, called the Inferior. Court, consisting of four judges, was organ- ized for each county. The first judges of this court, ‘substantial persons,’ in the language of the statute, all resided west of Biddeford. John Frothingham of the Cum- berland bar, appointed to its bench in 1804, was the first regular practitioner in Maine to sit in this court. wo terms a year were
Page 23
The Supreme Court of Maine. — 461 held in York and two in Wells until 1736, when one term was held annually in Fal- mouth, now Portland. Sir William Pep- perell was then its first chief-justice. After Cumberland and Lincoln counties were organized in 1760, two terms of this court were established in those counties. Lincoln County then embraced the old Sagadohoc, or Duke of York’s province, and also all of the state lying east of the Penobscot River. This court continued with the same juris- diction to the end of the royal government, and was revived under the Constitution of 1780. In 1804, the number of judges was reduced to three in each county; and in 1811 the circuit system was adopted, under which Maine was divided into three circuits, in each of which a chief justice and two as- sociate justices were appointed. After the separation from Massachusetts, the legisla- ture of Maine in 1822 created a Court of Common Pleas consisting of one chief-justice, Ezekiel Whitman of Portland; Samuel E. Smith of Wiscasset and David Perham of Bangor, associate justices. Under the circuit system of 1811, the judges appointed in Maine were: for York, Cumberland and Oxford, Benj. Greene, chief, Dana of Fryeburg and Widgery of Portland, associates; for Lincoln, Kennebec and Somerset, Nathan Weston, jr., chief, Ames and McLellan, associates; for Han- cock and Washington, Wm. Crosby, chief, Kinsley and Campbell, associates. These, except Campbell, Kinsley and Widgery, were all educated lawyers. The trials in these courts were by the intervention of a jury, consisting generally of twelve men, al- though in some instances composed of a less number. It was not until after the charter of 1691 that the forms of writs and procedure in court acquired any system. In 1701, the General Court established forms of writs, and authorized the courts to frame rules of prac- tice. No rules of practice were adopted, ex- cept as relates to irregular practitioners in Suffolk, until after the Revolution. In 1721, says Dummer, ‘No special pleadings are admitted, but the general issue is always given, and special matters brought in evidence.” In 1701, the attorney’s oath, as the same now exists, was prescribed. This intermediate system continued in use in Maine until 1839, when the Court of Common Pleas was abolished, and a new system called the District Court was created. The date of the act is February 25, 1839, and under its provisions the state was again divided into three districts as before. This system lasted only for the brief period of fourteen years. The causes which led to its being abolished, in 1852, and the creation of the Supreme Judicial Court, the system which exists at the present time, will be found in the life of Chief-Justice Appleton, appearing in a subsequent number of THE GREEN BAG. Under the charter of I69I a court was established under the name of ‘A Court of General Sessions of the Peace.” Its powers were much like those of county commis- sioners of the present day, but it was com- posed of justices of the peace in each county, having power to appoint clerks, officers, summon juries, and establish rules of prac- tice. Its jurisdiction was renewed under the Constitution of 1780, and continued until 1804, when it was transferred to the Com- mon Pleas, except as to county buildings, roads and granting licenses, etc. Other changes in the organization of this court, in- cluding that of its name to Court of Sessions, took place, from time to time, by substitut- ing a fixed number of judges in 1807, its reéstablishment in 1811, abolition in 1814, and restoration in 1819 with a chief justice and two associates in each county. After the separation many changes oc- curred. In March, 1831, a radical change was made. The governor was authorized to appoint in each of the several counties three suitable persons as county commissioners,
Page 24
462 The Green Bag. and this name of the court has ever since re- mained. In 1842, the office was made elective, the effect being to supplant those persons who were lawyers with others not trained to the law. | The jurisdiction of the Probate Court in Maine was confided, under the charter of 1691, to the governor and council, who ap- pointed probate judges in each county. Prior to this the recorder of the province, who was generally the clerk of the County Court, recorded wills and administrations with the records of that court. The records of York County show, as early as 1635, how the juris- diction was exercised from the first incep- tion of the government in Maine. In June, 1635, the inventory of the “estate of Richard Williams, servant to Mr. Matthew Craddock,” was taken and confirmed by de- position in 1660. The conflict of jurisdic- tion, which harassed the province after the revolution of 1642 in England until the charter of 1691, was made the ground for acts of confirmation. Accordingly we find, in May, 1648, a decree passed confirming to Payton Cooke the administration granted him by the court in 1640, held under Gorges’ authority. In March, 1784, after the Constitution of 1780, the legislature passed the first probate act, establishing a Probate Court in each county. The judge and register were appointed by the governor and council, and an appeal was allowed to the Supreme Court. For nearly a century, beginning with Joshua Scottow in 1687 to. Jonathan Sayward 1775, there were only nine judges of this court in the Province of Maine. Scottow was both register and judge, and one register, Joseph _ Hammond, became judge after five years’ service. After the separation from Massachusetts, this court was continued by the act of March 20, 1821. The judges had the same tenure of office as the judges of common law courts, — for life, but were paid, as also were the re- gisters, by fees assessed upon the business of their courts. In 1826 the fee table was abolished, and fixed salaries —an excellent provision — established in their place. In 1839, the life tenure was abridged to seven years, and in 1855, both judges and re- gisters were made elective by the people every four years. This court remains substantially in the same form and with the same powers as thus established ; with, however, the added duties of a court of insolvency, taking the place of a bankrupt court since the repeal of the United States bankrupt law. IV. The Supreme Judicial Court of Maine was organized in 1820 by the appointment of one chief-justice, Prentiss Mellen, and Na- than Weston and Wm. P. Preble, associate justices. Their tenure of office was during good behavior, but not to exceed seventy years in age. The mzs¢ priws system was retained until 1847, when an additional jus- tice, Wells, was appointed. Chief-Justice Mellen presided until 1834, when, having at- tained the age of seventy, he became consti- tutionally disqualified, and was succeeded by Nathan Weston, with Parris and Emery, associates. A constitutional amendment having been adopted in 1839, limiting the judicial tenure to seven years, he retired in 1841, when he was succeeded by Ezekiel Whitman, who resigned in 1848. ‘ In 1852 an important change, quite radi- cal, was made in the judicial system of the State. The District Court, created in 1839, was abolished, as before stated, and the busi- ness of that court was transferred to the Supreme Court, then increased to seven judges. The change thus introduced, with the addition of another justice, is the system which now prevails. Chief Justice Whitman’s successor was Ether Shepley, an associate justice, who re- tired at the end of seven years, in 1855, and was succeeded by John Searle Tenney, who also served one term, until 1862, and Chief-
Page 25
PRENTISS MELLEN,. 463
Page 26
404 Justice John Appleton was appointed his successor for three terms, retiring in 1883, after a judicial service of thirty-one years. The present chief-justice is John Andrew Peters, now serving his second term. It is proposed to give in the following pages a sketch of the lives of the chief jus- tices, and the present associate justices. The following is a chronological table of the Supreme Judicial Court justices from the beginning to the present date, 1895. CHIEF JUSTICES. Prentiss Mellen, Portland, July 1, 1820, to Oct. 22, 1834. Nathan Weston, Augusta, Oct. 22 1841. ; Ezekiel Whitman, Portland, Dec. Io, signed Oct, 23, 1848. Ether Shepley, Portland, Oct. 23, 1848, to Oct. 22, 1855. John Searle Tenney, Norridgewock, Oct. 23, 1855, to Oct. 23, 1862. John Appleton, Bangor, Oct. 24, 1862, to Sept. 19 1883. John A. Peters, Sept. 20, 1883. 19, 1890. , 1834, to Oct. 21, 1841. Re- Reappointed Sept. ASSOCIATE JUSTICES. William Pitt Preble, Portland, July 1, 1820. Res’d June 18, 1828. Nathan Weston, Augusta, July 1,1820. Ap’dC. J. Oct. 22, 1834. Albion K. Parris, Portland, June 25, 1828. Res’d Aug. 20, 1836. Nicholas Emery, Portland, Oct. 22, 1834, to Oct. 21, 1841. Ether Shepley, Saco, Sept. 23, 1836. Ap’d C. J. Oct. 23, 1848. John S. Tenney, Norridgewock, Oct, 23, 1841. Ap’d C. J. Oct.:23, 1855. Samuel Wells, Portland, Sept. 28, 1847. Resigned March 31, 1854. Joseph Howard, Portland, Oct. 23, 1848, to Oct. 22, 1855. Richard D. Rice, Augusta, May 11, 1852. Re- signed Dec. 1, 1863. John Appleton, Bangor, May 11, 1852. Ap’dC. J. Oct. 24, 1862. Joshua W. Hathaway, Bangor, May 11, 1852, to May I0, 1859. Jonas Cutting, Bangor, April 20, 1854. Reap’d April 20, 1861, and April 20, 1868. | | Charles W. Walton, Deering, May 14, 1862. The Green Bag. Seth May, Winthrop, May 6, 1855, to May 7, 1862. Woodbury Davis, Portland, Oct. 10, 1855. Rem’d April, 1856. Reap’d Feb. 25, 1857. Resigned 1865. Daniel Goodenow, Alfred, Oct. 10, 1855, to Oct. 10, 1862. Edward Kent, Bangor, May 11, 1859. II, 1866. Reap’d May Reap’d May 14, 1869, May 16, 1876, May 15, 1883, and May 15, 1890. Jonathan G. Dickerson, Belfast, Oct. 24, 1862. Reap’d Sept. 24, 1869, and Sept. 20,1876. Died in office, Sept. 1, 1878. Edward Fox, Portland, Oct. 24, 1862. 1863. William G. Barrows, Brunswick, March 27, 1863. Reap’d March 24, 1870, and March 24, 1877. Charles Danforth, Gardiner, Jan. 5, 1864. Reap’d Jan. 5, 1871, Dec. 31, 1877, and Dec. 31, 1884. Died in office, Mar. 30, 1890. Rufus P. Tapley, Saco, Dec. 21, 1865, to Dec. 21, 1872. Resigned William Wirt Virgin, Portland, Dec. 26, 1872. Reap’d March, 1880, and March 30, 1887. Died in office, Jan. 23, 1893. John A. Peters, Bangor, May 20, 1873. Reap’d May 20, 1880. Ap’d C. J. Sept. 30, 1883. Reap’d Sept. 19, 1890. Artemas Libbey, Augusta, April 24, 1875. Reap’d Jan. 11, 1883, and Jan. 10, 1890. March 15, 1894. Joseph W. Symonds, Portland, Oct. 16, 1878. Res’d March 31, 1884. Died in office, Lucilius A. Emery, Ellsworth, Oct. 5, 1883. Reap’d Oct. 4, 1890. Enoch Foster, Bethel, March 24, 1884. Reap’d March 24, 1891. Thomas H. Haskell, Portland, March 31, 1884. Reap’d March 31, 1891. . William Penn Whitehouse, Augusta, April 15, 1890. Andrew Peters Wiswell, Ellsworth, April 10, 1893. Sewall C. Strout, Portland, April 12, 1894. PRENTISS MELLEN, the first chief-justice, and the third son of the Rev. John Mellen, was born October I1, 1764, at Sterling, in Massachusetts. With a most affectionate and filial regard, he cherished the memory of his father, who was distinguished for learning, simplicity of manners, and Christian purity of life, often speaking of him asa fine specimen of the New England clergy. From his mother, the daughter of the Rev. John
Page 27
Lhe Supreme Court of Maine. Prentiss, he inherited the prudence and piety which entered deeply into the building up of his beautiful character, combined with a play- ful wit which he used to the delight of all, without giving pain to any. He was prepared for college under the personal instruction of his father, and was graduated at Harvard College in 1784. His elder brother, Henry, and John Abbott, long a professor at Bowdoin College, were among his classmates. His commencement part was a forensic disputation in English, upon the question, whether the knowledge and practice of religion are not promoted more by diversity in sentiment and modes of worship, than by an entire uniformity. The year following he was a private tutor at Barnstable, in the family of Joseph Otis, and at the same time began the study of law in the office of the eccentric lawyer, Shearjashub Bourne. He was admitted to the bar at Taunton, in October, 1788. By the custom then prevailing, students were required, upon their admission to the bar, to treat the judge and all the lawyers. We have his testimony that this ceremony was observed “ with about half a pail of punch, which treating aforesaid was commonly called ‘the colts’ tail’.” He began practice in his native town, but after a few months removed to Bridgewater, where he continued until November, 1791, when he went to Dover, N.H. He spent the winter and spring there with his brother, and in July, 1792, under the advice of Judge Thacher, then a member of Congress, he went to Biddeford, where he soon entered upon a successful practice which placed him at the head of the bar in Maine, and at the head of its highest judicial tribunal. He thus describes his humble beginning in Biddeford: “I opened my office in one of old Squire Hooper’s front chambers, in which were then arranged three beds and half a table and one chair. My clients had the privilege of sitting on some of the beds,” | Judicial Court. In 405 His celebrity as a leader soon called him into the neighboring counties in Maine and New Hampshire. In 1804, he began mak- ing the circuit of Maine with the Supreme 1806, he removed to Portland, and from that time until his ap- pointment to the bench in 1820, he practiced with eminent success in every county, being retained in nearly every important case. The law term for Maine was then held in Boston, where the records were also kept. His competitors were men of high legal attainments, of great natural abilities, and able -and eloquent as advocates. Among them was the accomplished Parker, after- wards chief-justice of Massachusetts; the grave and cautious Whitman, his distin- guished successor on the bench; the sensible and acute Longfellow; Orr, shrewd, skillful and prompt; and the adroit and eloquent Wilde, late of the Supreme Court of Massa- chusetts. ‘‘His most constant opponent,” said Professor Greenleaf, ‘‘ was Judge Wilde ; their forensic warfare, adopted by tacit con- sent, was to place the cause on its merits, produce all the facts, and fight the battle in open field. A generous warfare like this could not but create a generous friend- ship.” , At the bar his manner was fervid and im- passioned; his countenance lighted up with brilliancy and intelligence; his perceptions were rapid, and his mind leaped to conclusions to which other minds traveled more slowly. As a consequence, he was obliged sometimes upon more mature reflection to modify such conclusions. On one occasion Chief Justice Parsons remarked to him when he was ar- dently pressing a point, “You are aware, Mr. Mellen, that there are authorities on the other side.” ‘‘ Yes, yes, Your Honor, but they are all in my favor.” He identified himself with the cause of his client, and never for a moment neglected it, or failed to improve every opportunity in his opponent’s weakness or errors, to secure a victory. His voice was musical, his per-
Page 28
400. son tall and imposing, and his manner fas- cinating. At times he was eloquent. In all his conflicts with his brethren, which at times were ardent, and sometimes impet- uous, he was singularly fortunate in never, even unintentionally, inflicting the slightest wound upon their feelings. He was ever gentlemanly and kind. The same traits of impassioned eloquence reappear, at a subsequent generation, in Ser- geant S. Prentiss, the famous orator of Mis- sissippi, when he charmed and electrified the country by his wonderful powers. Prentiss used to attend the Mellen-Prentiss family re- unions at Portland, where he was recognized by the Chief Justice as a relative * and fa- vorite kinsman. In 1808, 1809, and 1817 he was a mem- ber of the executive council in Massachu- setts, a presidential elector in 1816, and elected to the U. S. Senate in 1817, where he had Harrison Gray Otis for his colleague. The latter situation he held until Maine was organized as a separate state, when, in July, 1820, he was appointed chief-justice of the new State. The same year he received the honorary degree of Doctor of Laws. from both Harvard and Bowdoin colleges. His associates on the bench were Nathan Weston and Wm. P. Preble. For this elevated and honorable station, he was eminently qualified by the high order of his legal attainments, his long ex- perience, readiness in dispatch of business, and love of justice and equity. Yet his love of equity was not that morbid sentiment which often leads to a blind sacrifice of the principles of law. Hence, he always held the established principles and rules of the law as too sacred to be disregarded; and no judge bowed with more profound respect to the settled law of the land. His thorough knowledge of practice, his familiarity with decided cases, and his quick * The late Henry E. Prentiss, of Bangor, was a second cousin of S. S. Prentiss. His ancestor, Caleb Prentiss, mar- ried Pamela, sister of Chief-Justice Mellen. The Green Bag. perception of the points and merits of a case, were peculiarly valuable at a time when the new State was forming its system of jurispru- dence. The enduring evidence of his sound judgment, his just discrimination, great learning, and the lasting impress of his powerful mind are to be found in his judi- cial opinions, which are contained in the first eleven volumes of the Maine Reports. Of the sixty-nine cases in the first volume, the opinions in fifty were drawn by him; of eighty-four opinions in the second volume, he drew seventy-four; and this industry and application is apparent through the whole series, in the last of which, of the one hun- dred and six opinions, he drew seventy-four. None of them are of a light or hasty kind; many of them involved points of the highest importance, requiring profound study, nice discrimination, and keen analysis. Perhaps as ready an illustration of all these elements combined is the case of Prop’rs Kennebec Purchase v. Laboree, 2 Greenl. 275, so often cited upon the constitutionality of retrospec- tive statutes, where vested rights are in- volved. He grew up with the law of the State which he largely shaped; he was as familiar with the modern as with ancient decisions, and kept pace with the progressive learning of his profession. His useful career upon the bench ended October I1, 1834, when he reached the constitutional limit of seventy years, beyond which no judicial office could then be held in Maine. On his retirement from the bench, the Cumberland Bar addressed him with ex- pressions of the high sense it entertained of his services and merits, as an upright judge, and of his qualities as a man, to which trib- ute of affection and respect he responded with deep sensibility. His last public service, rendered at the age of seventy-five years, was in revising the statutes of the State. He earnestiy en- gaged in this task, and with the aid of his
Page 29
WESTON, NATHAN 467
Page 30
468 colleagues, Samuel E. Smith and Ebenezer Everett, submitted a report to the legislature. January 1, 1840. The work embraced one hundred and seventy-eight chapters arranged under twelve titles, and constitutes the Re- vised Statutes of 1841, being the first revision. He died December 31, 1840, at Portland, his burial place being marked by a marble monument with suitable inscriptions, erected by the Cumberland Bar. His portrait adorns the Supreme Judicial Court room at Port- land. And now after the lapse of half a cen- tury, the perusal of his record, like a sweet strain of some half-forgotten song, revives the memory of his beautiful and exalted char- acter, and reminds us how well he served the state which he loved and honored. NATHAN WESTON, the second chief-jus- tice, like Lord Tenterden and other eminent jurists, is better known as a judge than as a practicing lawyer. He was raised to the bench before he had acquired a high repu- tation as a jury lawyer; but his eminent career of thirty years upon the bench evi- dently demonstrates that his was the judicial temperament from birth, while he brought to the discharge of his duties as judge, a high degree of scholarship and ample prep- aration. In passing, we may say that the believer in heredity hardly needs to be reminded that his grandson Melville Weston Fuller, Chief-Justice of the U. S. Supreme Court is ‘to the manner born.” Nathan Weston was born in that part of Hallowell which now constitutes the city of Augusta, July 27, 1782. He was. the fourth in descent from John Weston, who emigrated from Buckinghamshire in England twenty years after the landing of the Pilgrim Fathers at Plymouth, and finally settled at Reading, Massachusetts, about twelve miles from Boston. The family was distinguished for their piety, and somewhat remarkable for longevity. His father was an enterpris- Lhe Green Bag. ing, active man of varied experience through a long life. After a campaign or two in the old French war, prior to the capture of Quebec, he removed to Maine which then contained a small and scattered population. Before the Revolution, he was the owner of Abicadassit Point on the Kennebec River, where he resided, engaging principally in commerce, and sometimes furnishing masts for the king’s ships from the fine timber of that region. Having removed to Augusta he became a public man, and served as a - member of the House, Senate and Council of Massachusetts. Judge Weston’s mother was Elizabeth Bancroft. She was a sister of the Rev. Aaron Bancroft, of Worcester, Mass., the father of the historian Bancroft. He often ascribed his thirst for knowledge and his as- pirations in his literary and _ professional career to the influence of his mother, who had a strong and cultivated mind, imbued with piety. She impressed upon the minds of her children lessons of morality, truth, patriotism, devotion to the country, a strict Puritanical observance of the Sabbath ‘and inculcated the truth of God’s word. He fitted for college under the instruction of the learned and talented preceptor, Samuel Moody, at the Hallowell Academy. Being industrious and quick to apprehend, he made great progress and was easily pro- ficient both-there and at Dartmouth College, where he maintained a high rank through- out the course, and graduated with distin- guished honors, in 1803, with a class of forty-four members. After spending a few months in the study of the law with Benj. Whitwell in Augusta, he entered the office of George Blake, U. S. District Attorney, in Boston, where he com- pleted his studies, and was admitted to the Suffolk Bar, July, 1806. In the office of Mr. Blake, a learned lawyer, an able advo- cate and a leader of the democracy, he had ample opportunity for instruction and im- provement.
Page 31
The Supreme Court of Maine. Among the privileges he then enjoyed was that of hearing the eminent lawyers at the Boston Bar. sons, afterwards chief-justice; Dexter, who had been in both houses of Congress, and the cabinet of the elder Adams; Sullivan and Gore, each of whom was subsequently elevated to the governor’s chair in Massa- chusetts; and the elegant and brilliant Otis, at that time the delight and favorite of the city. Upon his admission to the bar, his teacher, Mr. Blake, who appreciated his talents and acquirements, proposed favorable terms of a partnership ; but he declined, although urged to accept the proposal, choosing to push his fortunes in Maine. He first opened an office in Augusta, but in a few months was persuaded by friends in that part of the country to remove to New Gloucester, in the county of Cumberland, where he found an opening made by the removal of Judge Whitman to Portland. | He had a successful business there, and was chosen a representative of the town the next year. In 1810, he returned to his native town, and the next year, at the age of twenty-nine, was appointed chief-justice of the Circuit Court of Common Pleas for the second circuit, comprising the counties of Kennebec, Lincoln and Somerset. His as- sociates were Benjamin Ames and Ebenezer Thatcher. | Judge Weston presided with dignity and ease in the new court, faithfully and promptly discharging the duties of the office to the ac- ceptance of the bar and the people until 1820, when on the organization of the new State, he was appointed an associate justice of the Supreme Judicial Court. He was commended to this honorable position, at the side of Chief-Justice Mellen, by his experience and the satisfaction he had given in the discharge of his official functions in the Circuit Court of Common Pleas. Judge Mellen, in 1834, by reason of the constitutional limit of his age, he was ap- pointed chief-justice of the Supreme Judicial Among others were Par-. Upon the retirement of 469 Court, his associates being Judges Parris and Emery. In 1825, he was, by the nearly unanimous vote of the legislature without distinction of party, nominated for governor. Retaining however, a preference for the judicial de- partment, he declined the proffered honor. His term of service as chief justice was seven years, at the end of which, in October, 1841, a constitutional amendment having been adopted, limiting the judicial tenure to seven years, he retired from the bench. He was nominated by Governor Kent as his own successor, but the council who belonged to the opposite party failed to confirm him. He was placed so early upon the bench that he was removed from active political life. He was appointed a trustee of Bowdoin college in 1820, and served during his life. In 1843, the college conferred upon him the title of LL.D., he having been previously thus honored by Dartmouth and Waterville. He was also a trustee of Waterville College, now Colby University, for thirty-two years. He was a sound and able lawyer. At nist prius he presided with perfect ease and dignity, calmness and ability. His long ex- perience enabled him to rule promptly and accurately upon all points of law raised at trials. Hewas a model of patience in the hearing of causes; his charges to the jury were clear, full and methodical. To the members of the bar, he was frank and cour- teous at all times. Of him as a man and judge, in a carefully considered review of his life, ex-Chief-Justice Appleton thus speaks: ‘With a mind emi- nently judicial, accustomed to the labors of the bench, its duties were easy and their performance a pleasure. As a judge, kind, prompt and ready in his rulings, he presided with an ease and courtesy which inspired the confidence of the young, and with a dignity which commanded the respect of all. Patiently he listened to the arguments of counsel. His charges were in language clear and distinct. With a tenacious memory, he
Page 32
470 retained the facts developed in the testi- mony; with unusual quickness of percep- tion, he rapidly seized upon the salient points at issue, and then, disentangling the mass of facts which encumber a case and distract attention, selecting those upon which a right decision of the case depends, applying to them with clearness and precision the prin- ciples of law applicable thereto, without in- terfering with their province, he aided the jury in aiming at the great end for which alone they exist —a just determination of controverted facts. He wasa learned man. Of studious habits, he early made himself master of the law. The quaint and rugged style and the vast and antiquated learning of Coke, the clas- sical pages of Blackstone, the dark mysteries of special pleading, almost forgotten or dimly remembered by the bar in these days of innovation, and the principles of com- mercial law, the grand product of modern civilization, were alike at his command”... Of his opinions says the same writer, “he discussed the questions involved with abun- dant research and ample learning, stating the questions for determination with preci- sion, laying down the legal principles upon which the case must rest with a purity and elegance of diction which Addison might almost have envied, and with a strength of . argument which carried conviction.” His opinions extending through the first twenty volumes of the Maine Reports, ex- hibiting a comprehensive knowledge of the law, are always clear to the point. They are the daily resort of the profession, and, while like Lord Eldon’s, not adding much to the law, they are lucid expositions. A good example may be seen in Cram v. Ban- gor House Prop’rs, 12 Maine, 354, in which a corporation was held bound by the acts of its agent, acting within the scope of his em- ployment, but with a seemingly deficient execution of his power. Many of them are not less distinguished for their elevated moral tone than for their sound legal logic. The Green Bag. In social life, the charm of his conversa- tion and the amiability of his disposition he retained to the day of his death, which took place in 1872 at the extreme age of ninety years. While he was not much given toa display of wit, he exhibited flashes of shrewd humor, the want of which, as Prof. Irving Browne well says, ‘‘is a serious defect in the human character.” The tender of quite a large sum of money was once made to him to redeem a mortgage which he held in trust for another party, and for whom he was surety upon a note. The gentleman making the tender offered to carry the money for the judge and deliver it to the benefi- ciary, if he so desired —saying the burden of so much money might be irksome, etc. With a twinkle in his eye, the judge replied: ‘Whenever I have put my name for ¢his party to a piece of commercial paper, whether as maker, payee, indorser, drawer, surety, joint-promisor, guarantor, or other- wise, I have not failed to observe that I had to payit. This is the first time I ever knew the money to come the other way. No, sir, thank you! I will keep it myself.” . EZEKIEL WHITMAN, the third chief-jus- tice, was born in East Bridgewater, Mass., March 9, 1776, and died there August r¢ 1866. His first American forefather, John Whitman, came to this country about the year 1635, and settled at Weymouth. His descendants were remarkable for their lon- gevity. John, a_ great-grandson of the founder, died in 1842, at the extreme age of one hundred and seven years. The tenac- ity of life of others was equally notable. Twelve great-grandchildren of Thomas, John’s eldest son, lived to the average age of eighty-eight and two-thirds years. Josiah Whitman, second, the father of Ezekiel, married Sarah, daughter of Caleb Sturtevant, of Halifax, Mass., a lineal descendant of EI- der Robert Cushman of Plymouth. Both | parents died during the early childhood of
Page 33
EZEKIEL ‘WHITMAN. 471
Page 34
472 Ezekiel, leaving him and a sister in straight- ened circumstances. Thus cradled in poverty and obliged to contend with hardship and privation, he found a friend in need in his uncle, the Rev, Levi Whitman of Wellfleet, who gave him his rudimentary instruction, . and treated him with great kindness that was eratefully repaid in following years, when their relative circumstances were reversed. The training he there received had an im- portant influence on his after-life, for had he been left to follow his own inclinations, he would have followed the sea, or gone upon the stage. Of this uncle he gives a charm- ing description in a speech at the two hundredth anniversary of Bridgewater, June 3, 1856; Goldsmith’s country parson “ pass- ing rich with forty pounds a year” was his prototype; and loving to dwell with those good old times he adds, “it may, however, have been flip or good old cider that ‘went round,’ instead of ale, in our ancestors’ days.” He does not appear to have been a diligent and enthusiastic student, although the ad- venturous orphan was a lad of good parts. He entered Brown University in 1791, with a class numbering twenty-six members, hav- ing fitted himself for matriculation in fifteen months under the Rev. Kilborn Whitman of Pembroke. The standard of the college course in those days, however, as well as the expense, was low. He taught school during his first winter’s vacation, in Marshfield, where it is related he got into trouble for audibly whispering in church, “Spell it,” while the minister, Mr. Leonard, was stam- mering over the utterance of a difficult word. He supported himself through college by teaching, and was graduated in 1795. Peleg Chandler, a classmate, gives in a letter an interesting account of his first meeting Whit- man, and a vivid idea of his poverty.. While on his way to Providence, Chandler over- took a young man “‘ with a large bundle tied up ina bandana handkerchief hung over his back on a cane; he had on no coat, nor Lhe Green Bag. nankeen breeches, and I think he had his stockings and shoes in one hand, suspended by his garters.” Entering into conversation with this youthful oddity, he soon found out that his name was Whitman, and that both were seeking entrance to the same college. They became fast friends, and agreed to chum together. Chandler adds in the same letter that “he was independent, eccentric, but never vicious. His regard for truth was sacred. His probity commanded universal confidence.” Such a graduate was presumptively sure of success in life. He began the study of law absolutely penniless, in the office of Benjamin Whitman of Hanover, where he remained but a short time, and then went into the office of Nahum Mitchell of East Bridge- water. Mr. Mitchell soon found his student had solid judgment, keen perception, and unusual abilities, for he confided many cases before magistrates and referees to his care. While pursuing his study of law he was sent to Kentucky to settle the affairs of a de- ceased citizen of Bridgewater. This employ- ment occupied him about one year. He journeyed alone on horse-back and returned by way of Cumberland Gap and Washing- ton, where he attended the special session of Congress convened to discuss French viola- tions of American neutrality, visiting the Senate and listening to the address of Presi- dent Adams. He used to delight to rélate his experiences of this part of his life; and in after-years, when holding court at Paris, found willing listeners among the young members of the family of Doctor Cyrus Hamlin, Sheriff of Oxford County, where he boarded during term-time. He was admitted to the bar of Plymouth County, in 1799, but determined to seek a settlement in Maine. No one was better qualified by instruction, discipline and self- reliance than he to carve his way to fortune and fame in the wilds of Maine. He evident- ly entertained a different view of the state jacket, or stock. He wore an old pair of | than that by Webster, who said to his friend
Page 35
The Supreme Court of Maine. McGaw: “You may go down East, if you think best, and grow up with the country, where there’s no money now and nothing but black flies and mosquitoes ; as for myself, I am going where the money is already made.” His law library consisted of Blackstone, Nisi Prius Digest of Espinasse, and four books of forms by Samuel Freeman, styled ‘“The Clerk’s Assistant,” ‘‘ Probate Auxil- lary,’ ‘‘Town Officer,” and “ Justice’s As- sistant.” These, of course, were only the tools of trade, but the want of others com- pelled brevity both of argument and plead- ing. The application of testimony and law to the case in hand was close and direct. The opinions of the judges were often made up without reference to the arguments of counsel. ‘It is of no use to argue the case,’ said Whitman to his associate in a trial before Judge Parsons, ‘for the old fellow has got his opinion already drawn up in his pocket.” Like Judge Parsons, Whit- man did his work in the directest, plainest and simplest way. He came to Maine, in April, 1799, where he found his college friend and chum, Chan- dler, at New Gloucester, then a half shire- town with Portland. Chandler and Samuel Thatcher were the only lawyers there, and there being no others to the north, he settled in Turner; but, after a short sojourn of three months, he returned to New Gloucester, tak- ing the office vacated by Thatcher’s removal to Warren; and, having decided to make his home here, he married a daughter of Cush- ing Mitchell of his native town. Here repu- tation, popularity and business flowed in up- on him. But lawyers in those days must have been satisfied with small fees and mod- erate living, for we learn that two dollars and a half was the usual charge for arguing a case in the Common Pleas, and twenty-five to fifty cents for drafting deeds and similar papers. Like other leaders of the bar, his office was constantly sought by students, and he never had less than two or three at the 473 same time. His half-brother, Josiah W. Mit- chell and Simon Greenleaf (author of Green- leaf on Evidence) were fellow-students there ; the one a genial, rollicking fellow, the other a studious, plodding, pious young man. Of them he said the former possessed greater natural talent, but the latter a persistent in- dustry which yielded greater results. His success at the bar was rapid, and he soon be- came a leader in politics. Like Parsons, he was solid and practical, cool and impartial, penetrating and just; he stripped off all dis- guises, and held up facts to the light of sim- ple truth. In argument he was lucid, log- ical, conclusive. Mere rhetoric and diffuse- ness he despised. In talking to the jury his manner was that of a friend anxious to show the real merits of the controversy. He was tall and manly in person, honest and intelli- gent in countenance. His addresses invari- ably carried great weight and force. He was the candidate of the Federal Party for Congress in 1806, but was defeated by Daniel Illsley, a Democrat, by a few votes. At the next election in 1808, he was returned by a majority of three hundred, having moved the previous year to Portland, where his ability and character brought him an in- creased clientage. The life of representative in Congress did not prove agreeable to him; on the contrary, it was irksome and unpleas- ant. There were three sessions of the Con- gress of which he was a member, and the journeys in those days were tedious and ex- pensive. He was defeated at the next elec- tion by William Widgery, after two trials, the first being a tie. From that time to 1815, he attended exclusively to his profes- sion, and that year and the next he was a member of the executive council of Massa- chusetts. He was a member of the consti- tutional convention at Brunswick in 1816, to consider the question of separation. He was the Federalist candidate for its president, but William King was chosen by a vote of 97 to 85. He led the minority against the au- thority of the convention to. act, basing its
Page 36
474 Opposition upon the ground that the requt- site five-ninths of the whole vote of the peo- ple was not in favor of separation... The pro- test of the minority drafted by him was sus- tained by the legislature of Massachusetts. In 1816, 1818, and 1821, he was again a rep- resentative in Congress where he took strong ground in favor of restricting slavery in Mis- souri. He favored a bankrupt law; advocated a reduction of the duty on molasses; and strenuously opposed Jackson’s course to- wards Florida as illegal, unjustifiable, and ar- bitrary. In 1819 he was a member of the constitutional convention which prepared the constitution of Maine. In 1822, Maine having been erected into a state, he was appointed chief-justice of the Court of Common Pleas by Gov. Parris, a Democrat of the most pronounced type. The Governor had been a student in the office of the Chief-Justice and selected his teacher for the important office, notwithstanding their political antagonisms, because he knew he possessed the highest qualifications for the discharge of its duties; for, says a mem- ber of the Cumberland Bar, one in every way well qualified to judge, ‘he was a man of strong convictions upon all subjects, hav- ing the courage to assert and maintain them on all proper occasions, caring not for pop- ularity, but living true to his own views, doing what duty called for, and leaving results to care for themselves.” Judge Whitman presided in the Common Pleas for about twenty years, and was ap- pointed, in December 1841, chief justice of the Supreme Judicial Court by Governor Kent, to succeed Nathan Weston who suc- ceeded Judge Whitman as a lawyer at New Gloucester when he removed to Portland. The latter office he held until 1848, when he resigned at the age of seventy-one years, having been a judge nearly twenty-seven years in all. His name as counsel appears in all of the Massachusetts State Reports un- - til the separation, and after his first term in Congress the most important causes were ~ The Green Bag. intrusted to his care. As a judge of the Common Pleas, riding the western circuit, he was everywhere respected and honored as a wise, learned and upright judge. These qualities,combined with the confidence which the community had in him, that ‘he bore not the sword in vain,’ have given him a place in the judicial history of Maine unex- celled for painstaking care and sound com- mon sense in the decision of causes. He felt at all times the full weight of the re- sponsibility resting on him, and he was con- scientious in the highest degree lest injustice or oppression might flow from his official acts. His opinions, to be found in Vols. XXI-XXIX, Maine Reports, are character- ized by simplicity and directness of applica- tion. His exalted character and distinguished judicial services were justly recognized the same year, 1843, by his alma mater and Bowdoin College, in conferring upon him the degree of Doctor of Laws. He retained his residence in Portland until 1852, when he removed to his native place, and there lived in retirement and comfort until his death, at the age of eighty-nine. He was buried in Evergreen Cemetery, near Portland, sur- rounded by the graves of his immediate family. The tributes he paid his ancestors in the Bridgewater speech, above referred to, pic- ture many of his own traits of character. He tried to follow the golden rule as nearly as possible. Holding firmly to his opinions, he was tolerant and charitable towards others. He said in an oration before a Masonic lodge, of which he was a member, ‘If the omniscient eye of heaven can behold our multiplied transgressions, and yet restrain the arm of wrath and righteous indignation, how much more ought we, who are all sub- ject to like infirmity, to be willing to forbear one toward another!” A more kindly man never lived. He would not speak ill of others nor listen to remarks of that kind from others. Inthe same oration he says, ‘‘ There can be nothing more idle and wicked than
Page 37
ln Memoriam. the disposition many possess to pull down the reputation of their neighbors.” He was liberal in his religious views, but insisted upon upright conduct and purity of life. The writer was told the following incident of him by the member of the bar before mentioned. Being asked at dinner what he had done with a woman charged with the larceny of some bread and who had called upon him the night before at his house and told him of her necessities, confessing that she stole the bread to feed her starving, helpless children, he said, as the tears rolled down his cheeks: ‘TI let her go.” He was slow of speech, but terse and to the point, as illustrated by his remark to the jury in a trial against Gen. A., accused of tortiously taking lumber belonging to another. Counsel requested that he should charge the jury that, if A. should be found guilty, then upon the question of damages, they should presume he took an average of 475 both good and poor quality of lumber. He replied, ‘‘ Yes, gentlemen, you may consider, whether a man who steals lumber would naturally take good lumber, or slabs.” He hated fraud and deceit. He delighted to drag the unclean monster from its hiding place and rid the temple of justice of its unsavory presence. Truthful himself, he expected others to be so. Among the last of the ‘old-school lawyers” in the State, after an incumbency of the judiciary extend- ing over twenty-six and a half years, his retirement, when in possession of unimpaired, - intellectual strength and vigor, was looked upon as. a public loss and misfortune. He was no less popular than respected. As Lord Mansfield has beautifully said: ‘ His popularity was that which follows, not that which is run after —that popularity which, sooner or later, never fails to do justice to the pursuit of noble ends by noble means.” IN MEMORIAM. RUDOLF VON. GNEIST. B tte world owes much to Germany: she reared Men of Titanic mould when other lands Bore Dwarfs. Crowned in her might to-day she stands A very queen of States, serene, revered. And thou, great Soul, who late thy bark hath steered From Earth’s low marge to the Elysian sands, Are not the least in her heroic bands. Not thine a sword to make thy country feared, But thine to lend a sapient mind to frame The fabric of her laws both strong and well,— A prouder meed no patriot could claim! Thou wert not insular; a love of right World-wide constrained thee here. Now perfect sight Reveals thee Justice on her citadel. OTTAWA, CANADA. CHARLES Mors.
Page 38
476 The Green Bag. THE MALTA WAR IN COURT. AINE has suffered and survived no | less than eleven wars within her bor- ders. Eight of these were bloody and de- structive, and three were more or less farcical. The one under view in this article occurred in 1809. It arose from an attempt at accu- rate and equitable adjustment of lines in the Patent of the Plymouth Colony in Maine. The territory embraced in this patent was fifteen miles in width on each side of the Kennebec River, from Swan Island (just above the junction with the Androscoggin) to the great westward bend of the river. What land remained undisposed of in 1789 was in that year released by the General Court to the “ Fifty Associates; ”’ the con- dition being that they released their claim to all exterior lands, and quieted settlers within the limits. Many settlers under the colony and under purchase from the Duke of York’s territory adjoining on the east, together with squat- ters and purchasers of lots from the Indians at the eastern border, had mixed their lots up in a most irreconcilable manner; and the courts of Kennebec and Penobscot counties, from this time forth, for years, echoed with the voices of the rival claimants. To avoid threatened civil disorder, the government of the Commonwealth, in 1808, enacted a law called the Betterment Act, for the relief of mis-located residents. ‘This measure, how- ever, was not regarded by the settlers as adequate to the conditions; and secret as- sociations were formed to prevent the ser- vice of precepts, and to drive away all sur- veyors. At Warren, in the county of Lincoln (now in Knox county), a military force was summoned to assist the sheriff in his duty; but the parties came to terms, and the escort was not required. ) . In Malta, adjoining the east line of Au- gusta, four miles from the Kennebec, lived Aaron Choate, who had agreed to purchase the lot he had been occupying; and three men, representing himself and the proprie- tors, were on September 8th, 1809, engaged in its survey. While the surveyors were fixing the topography of a brook, Choate walked a short distance ahead; when he was surprised by several armed men, in the dis- guise of Indians. A pistol was placed at his breast, and his silence ordered on pain of instant death. The band then formed in line; and a few moments later, Paul Chadwick, of Malta, one of the chain-bearers, appeared in view. At the words from one of their number, “ Fire low,” three guns were discharged, and Chad- wick fell. These savages then gathered about their victim, made taunting remarks, then departed. The wounded man was taken by his companions to a house in the vicinity, where he died two days later. Choate and the victim had recognized three of the band, and the others were soon found out. They remained concealed in the woods, where they were fed by their friends, for a few days, but were finally persuaded by them to give them- selves up. Accordingly, a week after the murder, all except one—who had ab- sconded — appeared before a justice for ex- amination. They were repentant, even to tears, and each confessed to have been pres- ent when Chadwick was shot. All were committed to wait the action of the grand jury at the next regular session of the court on the 3d of October. Now that they were in jail, their friends began to regret their surrender, viewing with alarm the preparations for their trial, and the strength and strictness with which their place of confinement was guarded. Then rumors of an attempt at their rescue began to reach the authorities ; and it was reported that a large number of armed men disguised as Indians had been seen in the woods be- tween Augusta and Malta, who, it was stated, were preparing to rescue the prisoners, burn
Page 39
Lhe Malta War in Court. the county buildings and the dwellings of such resident proprietors and their agents as they could find. | To repel the threatened incursion, a can- non from old Fort Western, on the east shore, was mounted on cart-wheels, loaded with musket-balls, and placed on the west shore, in a position to sweep the bridge. The day and night patrols were enlarged, and sentinels posted at exposed points; while alarmed citizens kept anxious watch at their dwellings, as court-day approached. Various alarms had arisen, but no enemy appeared until the night of the 3d of Octo- ber. About midnight, the sentinels at the east end of the bridge caught a man spying about the locality. Three of them were at- tempting to bear him away, when a party in Indian guise rushed down the hill, and not only rescued him, but made a prisoner of the officer in command. The insurgents were later ascertained to be about seventy in number, Alarm guns were fired, the court-house bell was rung, and in a very short time the light infantry was out, and the street filled with people. The uproar soon became general, for no one knew where the threatened conflagration might be started. The insurgents, however, had retired to shelter; but all through the remainder of the night the authorities were engaged in issuing orders, and in sending messengers to the militia in the neighboring towns, summoning them to meet a large force of insurrectionists, arrayed in mimicry of the patriots in the Boston Tea-Party, but with purposes vastly more destructive and inde- fensible. Several companies arrived during the next day, and on the 5th, six companies were in town. Ample guards were placed, and a field-piece commanded the entrance of the jail. | The eight accused men were arraigned, pleaded not guilty, and were bound over to a special term appointed to be holden by 477 adjournment for: the trial on the 16th of November following. However popular and far-reaching the in- surrection might have become, this prompt display of force quite checked its further manifestations; and the military companies which had so bravely marched up the hill, after a few days, one after another, were dis- missed, and gaily marched down again. All these companies, however, alternated by twos, amounting to a hundred men, as guards at the county buildings and other assailable points about the town, until the end of the trial, on November 25th, when all danger had passed. The counsel for the prisoners consisted of Prentiss Mellen, Samuel S. Wilde, Thomas Rice and Philip Leach, — the first of whom became the State’s earliest chief-justice, and two or more known as authorities to stu- dents of provincial law. Solicitor-General Daniel Davis alone conducted the prosecu- tion. Four judges,— Theodore Sedgwick, Samuel Sewall, George Thatcher and Isaac Parker, — were on the bench. Forty-four witnesses were examined, and the trial lasted ten days, including two occupied by the jury in their deliberations. The Commonwealth attempted to prove ‘premeditated malice;” and the report of the trial certainly shows reasonable evidence in support; the wonder being that the mal- ice was not extended in its effect to others of the surveying party. No hostility was shown to Choate, whom they had merely taken under control to prevent an alarm to the others; but fierce and bitter taunts were hurled at the prostrate victim, while the other two surveyors were permitted to escape; and: the band departed without token of either fear or relenting. An explanation of this action may be found in a statement which shortly became current, that the murdered man was one of a band associated under the name ‘ Malta Indians,” who were bound by an oath, writ- ten and signed with blood, to prevent sur-
Page 40
478 veys and resist proprietors in enforcing claims to their lands; and because of this was regarded as a traitor deserving death, because of having violated his oath in the first particular. The charge to the jury was made by the junior justice, Parker, whose summing up of the evidence appeared to leave no escape to the eight prisoners. After many hours of deliberation, the jury came into court and inquired whether, if they ‘‘were agreed as to some of the prisoners,’ but not ‘as to the rest,’ the verdict would be received as far as they were agreed. The court de- clined to receive a verdict unless it should include all the prisoners. To the apprehension of the average jury- man, this ruling does not quite fit the facts. In the first place, the victim had received only a bullet wound, from which he died, while only three guns were fired; second, | of the nine assailants, only three carried euns, three being armed with pistols, and the remaining three bearing scythes bound on short poles. It was evident, therefore, that six who could be pointed out, and two who could not be pointed out, were not mur- derers, but accomplices only in the crime. The offence of the first three was different to that of the others. Further, there ap- pears no reason why the entire eight, if dis- charged as not guilty of murder, should not have been held for a lesser crime. The ruling of the court, and its neglect in not ordering the prosecution of the offenders on another charge, virtually vindicated them not only from the murder, but from complicity therein. Neither was there any notable ef- fort made thereafter to apprehend that one of the band who not only did not give him- self up, but absconded previous to the sur- render of the others, thus causing the in- ference that he knew himself to be the guilty person. There is in the action of the court a sug- gestion that it regarded the murder as a secret-society penalty, —the act of a com- The Green Bag. munity, — as difficult to be fixed upon any one in particular as a railroad disaster, from bad condition of road or rolling stock, is to fix upon a whole corporation or a board of directors. In an admonition to the prison- ers, also given by Judge Parker, the duties and the advantages of the citizens in a free commonwealth, and the most unfortunate condition of those who forfeit their rights, are set forth with admirable clearness, force and compactness. This disturbance of the public peace in- duced the enactment of a statute making it a high crime for any person to disguise him- self in the likeness of an Indian, or other- wise, with intent to molest a sheriff or sur- veyor in the discharge of his duties. So the judicial proceedings in this case, and the subsequent action of the General Court, afford an eminent example of ‘ how not to do it” with dignity and the desired effect. Surely no reader will assert that the sway of Massachusetts in the District of Maine was ~ not a mild one. As to the Kennebec purchase, the violent among the settlers upon its lands were so impressed by these occurrences that there was no further forcible opposition to the legal readjustment of their boundaries. In a few years, indeed, the inhabitants of Malta grew so much ashamed of the rep- utation of their town, that in 1820 they in- duced the first legislature of the State of Maine to change its name to “Gerry.’” Un- fortunately, it sometimes became necessary to add the explanation, ‘‘ formerly Malta;” and they found themselves in a degree still tied to the old disgrace. By another change, in 1822, the town became Windsor; so that they were able to mention it as “ formerly Gerry” with entire equanimity,—for in doing this they at once recalled and con- demned a disreputable political action in a neighboring State, while their own Malta stain lay buried in shadow. GEORGE J. VARNEY.
Page 41
London Legal Letter. 479 LONDON LEGAL LETTER. Lonpon, Sept. 7, 1895. NSTEAD of invoking the saints, the junior members of the bar feel at this season of the year much more like anathematizing them. Years ago, when it was the univer- sal custom to observe as days of idleness all feast days and saints’ days, the courts likewise refrained from work, and being to a certain extent identified, at least on their ecclesi- astical side, with the church, the holidays were protracted to the extremest period of the saints’ pleasure. Thus it has happened that out of the full term of the year the courts are closed for about four months, or more than one-third the time. The terms of court are still called by the names of the saints, or have other ecclesiastical designation, as “Hilary,” ‘ Easter,” “Trinity,” and “ Michaelmas.” At the end of the Trinity term the courts are absolutely closed for more than twelve weeks at a stretch —from the 12th of August this year until the first week in November. This is all well enough for the judges and for a few of the over- worked queen’s counsel; but for the average even fairly successful practitioner it means not only a period of en- forced idleness, but an absolute deprivation of an oppor- tunity to earn an income. Year after year litigants who have cases awaiting trial and lawyers who would be glad to go on with their work, protest against the wasteful extrava- gance of time involved in the “long vacation,”’ but nothing comes of these protests. The inns of court are practically deserted, except for the groups of American tourists who wander through them, red-covered guide-books in hand, gazing up at the silent rooms where Blackstone wrote his Commentaries, or where Goldsmith made merry, or where Charles Lamb had his much-loved residence, or into the dining-hall of the Middle Temple, still standing in perfect preservation and in all the glory of its oak-carved decora- tion, where the Twelfth Night was performed under Shakes- pere’s personal stage direction, and where Queen Elizabeth tripped the measures of the dance with the stately full- bottomed-wigged legal luminaries of her day. Even the law libraries, where students and text-book writers and re- porters would be glad to work, are closed part of each day » and wholly for some weeks. One judge, it is true, sits once each week for an hour or two to hear pressing motions, but even the Masters are absent, and so all pleadings and interlocutory proceedings are held in abeyance. This abso- luté blotting out of time is one of the abuses which young and ambitious lawyers are most vigorously insisting shall be abolished; but it unfortunately happens that those in whose hands is the remedy are those who most enjoy and are best able to afford the holiday, and who therefore cling to a privilege of which they assume they have earned the right to enjoy. For two days just before the vacation, the Lord Justice of Appeal in one of the divisions of the High Court of Ap- peals had under consideration the interpretation of certain life insurance policies issued by the Equitable Life Assur- ance Society of the United States. These policies were in the form common to policies of a like nature where a hus- band insures his life for the benefit of his wife, and in case she predeceases him for the benefit of their children. In this case the husband, the wife and the children were all residents of England, and the policies were taken out in England through the local agent of the American company. The husband survived his wife, and the questions arose, (a) when the beneficial inierest of the policy vested in the children, and (b) in what manner; in other words, did the children who were alive at the mother’s death take the in- terest, or those who survived the father? And did such of the children as were entitled to the benefit of the policy take their benefit as joint tenants or tenants in common? The manner in which these propositions were discussed was remarkable for two things. First, the judges, all three of them, had a turn at criticising the drafting of the policy, and there was a unanimous opinion that it was about as poorly expressed an instrument as was possible under the — circumstances. They found no difficulty in deciding that it was in reality two instruments.within‘one a contract of insurance between the husband and the company, and also a settlement by the husband upon the wife with remainder over to the children; and in this light it was discussed by the Chancery bar counsel on both sides and the Lords Jus- tices themselves with an apparent relish of the subtleties of equity expressions and the refinements of technical phrase- ology which they imported into the document. The second remarkable feature of the proceedings was the fact that not an intimation was made by counsel that the Court of Ap- peals of New York had some time ago settled the very ques- tions that were bothering the Court. The learned Queen’s counsel for the plaintiff and his prompting junior had lying before them the New York Court of Appeals reports con- taining the cases of Whitehead v. The New York Life, The United States Trust Company v. The Mutual Benefit Life, and Walsh v. The Mutual Life Insurance Company, but they apparently lacked courage to draw the attention of an English court to these decisions. It is a pity that the opportunity to see what authority the Lords Justices of an English court of appeals would give to the decisions of the New York Court of Appeals was missed. ‘The points in controversy were finally decided in accordance with the view the New York Court of Appeals have taken of them, but the local judges reached their conclusions by a widely dif- ferent course of reasoning, in which views were intimated directly at variance to those expressed by the New York courts. This is unfortunate, for the American life insurance companies are becoming very popular in England, and sooner or later questions must arise which will have a widely different judicial interpretation in the two countries. Every one on this side of the Atlantic who has any offi- cial or legal connection with the United States is constantly applied to for the collection of ‘funds in Chancery,” which are supposed to be lodged in bank here to the order of the Lord Chancellor, and only awaiting rightful claimants in America. In the majority of cases the claim is a family
Page 42
A80 matter, and the tradition of it is handed down from one generation to another. It grows with the years in value and proportion, and looms up bigger and bigger in the haze which surrounds it. It is usually based upon the testimony of some long since deceased great-aunt or great-uncle, who is said to have described how some ancestor, desirous of remembering his relatives in America, and not knowing where they might be found, had the money put in Chan- cery for them, where it has lain all these years! Upon such children’s stories as these are based demands whose persis- tence is only equalled by their unreasonableness. A request for a detailed statement as to where the ancestor died, his Christian name, the date when and the proceedings on which the money was paid into court, and other elementary essential facts is resented as an impertinence. The same vague statements are repeated and renewed offers are made of an increased contingent interest inthe fund; which rarely is less than a million of dollars, and is more often a million sterling. Only a few weeks ago a claim was received here for money which was paid into a bank in London to the credit of the ancestors of the claimant in 1690—a date five years earlier than that of the establishment of the Bank cf England, and when traders and merchants used to lodge their money with the goldsmiths in Lombard Street. Another correspondent stated that a great-uncle, when a lad, went upon a ship lying in some port in England, out of curiosity to see what a ship was like, and while inspecting the vessel it sailed for America. The involuntary passenger, who is said to have landed at Baltimore, appears to have had such an aversion to the ship that played this shabby trick upon him and to all ships in general that, when late in life he received word that his father in England had left him some money, he promptly destroyed the letter and the evidence of the legacy, fearing that if his children got word of it they might be tempted to cross the ocean! One of them, it seems, notwithstanding this precaution, found out the secret, and one of his remote descendants is now en- deavoring to recover the money which, of course, is “ in Chancery.” Letters of similar import to this, and illustra- ting every phase of cupidity and credulity, are received by almost every post at the United States Embassy and the Con- sulate in London. Both the Ambassador and the Consul- General have been compelled to prepare a printed circular which they use as a general reply to these applications, and in which they state that it is extremely probable that there is no such fund as represented in existence, and requesting that no expense be incurred in the fruitless attempt to real- ize something out of it. In some instances the property over here consists of an estate belonging to some branch of a family which has numerous representatives in the United States. Lawyers perhaps are familiar with the incidents of the trial of two men, one of whom was a lawyer in good stand- ing in the United States, and the other a colonel of a we GS CRE : AN Ar The Green Bag. regiment in the Civil War, who were indicted for, and found guilty at the Old Bailey, of obtaining money under false pretenses. ‘They had to come over to England to represent the heirs in America of an estate here. They kept the credulous claimants in the United States in constant expectation of the realization of an immense fortune. Meetings were held and assessments were levied and willingly paid, and the large sums thus realized were sent to England to furnish the agents with money to prose- cute the claim. There was, of course, nothing in the claim for any one— except the agents, and the latter are now picking oakum at Pentonville. Notwithstanding this inci- dent, a claim is now being pushed with unusual energy to the Antrim estate, or fund, which is supposed to have been left by an Earl of Antrim to a branch of the family which would seem to have emigrated ez d/oc to the United States. One correspondent gravely asserts that the fund amounts to £15,000,000, and that a meeting will shortly be held in the United States to raise money to employ a solicitor in London to collect the fund. It is sincerely to be hoped that some man of courage in the legal profession will interfere to prevent innocent people from being defrauded in this way. For a few shillings it can be ascertained that there never was £15,000,000 at any one time in the Antrim family, and that no Lord Antrim ever left one one-hundredth part of this sum, orany part whatever, out of the family succession. The Antrims are an old Irish family, and their affairs have, it is probable, been managed for generations by the same firm of solicitors. These solicitors would not have the confidence of the family if they were not honest men, and being honest men, they will, by return post, assure any reputable correspondent that there is no shadow even of a foundation for the claim that is now being made. Furthermore, the Supreme Court Fund rules of 1886 provide that on the first day of March in every third year, the paymaster shall prepare and publish a list of the accounts or funds in Chancery of all sums over £50, or $250. There is nothing in the list to the credit of any descen- dants of the Antrims. It is very appropriately stated in the last published list, ‘in order to remove misconception which appears to exist as to the magnitude of the funds (the amounts are not given), that of the balances standing to the credit of the accounts, one-half do not.exceed £150, and only one-sixteenth exceed £1000. ‘Thes average amount is about $1800, and there are but two which are as large as $75,000.” It isa matter of regret that these facts cannot be widely known in the United States, and that those who persist in indulging in the delusion that they are entitled to inheritances in Great Britain cannot be persuaded to submit their claims to reputable law- yers before taking other steps. Honest advice on such pretensions would show that not one in ten thousand has any foundation. STUFF GOWN. cre
Page 43
' wricmeesnecasenetti i e a—. Notes of Cases, ete. ah =" its a ov" BY IRVING BROWNE. ro “a as ri oe CURRENT TOPICS. THE PUBLIC LIBRARIAN. THE Law LIBRARIAN. — It would seem an appro- His books extend on every side, priate retribution on one who has always believed that And up and down the vistas wide it would be the better for the Law if all the law re- His eye can take them in; ports of the last half century should be burned up and He does not. love these books at all, ‘ Their usefulness in big and small never reproduced, that he should be appointed a pub- ie counts as but a vin. li¢ law-librarian. Especially so, when that one has always cherished, if not a lively animosity, at least And all day long he stands to serve an ill-concealed impatience toward the genus libra- The public with an aching nerve; , ; He views them with disdain — rian, founded on the observation that most of them The student, with his huge round glasses, seem to deem it their office to prevent the public from The maiden fresh from high-school classes, seeing the books. Yet this is exactly what has hap- With apathetic brain; pened to the present writer. He is placed in charge of a law-library of some ten thousand volumes, and The sentimental woman lorn, capes ; : ; : The farmer recent from his corn, is informed that his first and chief duty is to increase The boy who thirsts for fun, its numbers very largely! (Publishers will please not The graybeard with a patent-right, all rush at once.) This to a person who believes The pedagogue from school at night, The fiction-gulping one. that all the law ought to be found in four or five mod- erate-sized volumes! (Mr. Carter says it can all be They ask for histories, reports, found in four or five hundred.) It is not an Easy Accounts of turf and prize-ring sports, Chair, this librarian’s chair. For once, the occupant The census of the nation; begins to have a sympathy with Tite Barnacle, and Fhilcsopay and acience, too, , , y The fresh romances not a few, to be disposed to say to the crowd of inquirers for Also “ Degeneration.” things that he cannot tell them, «‘ I say, you mustn’t come here saying you want to know, you know.” It “ They call these books,” he snarls, and throws is so very humiliating to be detected in knowing so 5 seit ee pba tale and rows ‘ , : re ‘ efore the ticket-holder; little! It is pitiful, also, to look at these highly re- Fie'll Hike tevcuat thetn nt fis bead, spectable old authorities, so much esteemed for so He wishes they might strike him dead, many years, and to reflect that they are «* back num- And with the reader moulder. bers.”” The law-school graduate of last year never heard of Bacon’s or Viner’s Abridgement, and ° pi ‘i He seeks a spot whence sweet and faint ‘¢wants to know” what «*B. & P.” or **Sch. & A leathery smell exudes: Lef.” means. He demands a book about electricity, And there, behind the gilded wires, ‘¢ trusts,” or sales on margins. Sometimes an old For some loved rarity inquires, gentleman from the country, who has made a motion Wipih commen gaat: Cake. to get ten dollars costs, inquires for «‘ 1 Code Rep. But now, as for the shrine of saint, He wishes Omar would return, N.S.,” not being aware that even that has lost its au- This vulgar mob of books to burn, thority, because not even codes are permanent. But While he, like Virgil’s hero, there are compensations in every employment. The Would shoulder off this precious case To some secluded private place, law librarian may console himself with the reflection With temperature at zero. that his books do not tend to debase or demoralize the community. It is better to deal out books whose And there in this seraglio purpose it is to elucidate the principles of truth and Of books not kept for public show, justice, than trashy novels, flippant histories, and He'd feast his glowing eyes, — : ; : ae Forgetting that these beauties rare biographies of famous nobodies. -In short, it is much Aha nspa thal and passing fair, . better to be a law-librarian than Are but the Sultan’s prize. 481
Page 44
482 But then a tantalizing sense Invades expectancy intense, And with extorted moan, ** Unhappy man!” he sighs, “‘ condemned To show such treasure, and to lend — I keep, but cannot own.” ‘¢ WHOLESOME VANITY.” — Chief-Justice Bleckley defends his employment of this expression in his me- morial of Judge Erskine, saying that it ‘‘ was more carefully considered than any other in the whole com- position,” and ‘‘ was absolutely essential to a com- plete and perfectly candid estimate.” ‘* While pride and vanity are different, they are not inconsistent. The first makes no appeal to the opinion of others ; the second does. Erskine had both, and in him both were wholesome and respectable. You are the very man,” he continues in a letter to the writer, «« I should have chosen as a witness to the accuracy and just ap- plication of the phrase, and I feel a sore disappoint- ment at your volunteering to testify for the ‘ other side.’ But the most reliable experts sometimes break down.” We succumb to the Chief-Justice’s larger ac- quaintance with Judge Erskine, especially when he concedes that he ‘‘has the same sort and degree of vanity himself.” That renders it **‘ wholesome and respectable.” HARD ADJECTIVES. — Adverting to our remarks in our last issue we would by no means hold Judge Thompson responsible for Mr. Bishop’s denunciation of the courts, but it reminds us of Mr. B’s objurgations against the decision in People v. Baker, 76 N.Y. 78. He calls it «‘an absurd ruling,” ‘* made without rea- soning, and evidently without thinking,” ‘‘ marvel- ous oversight,”’ ‘‘ mental oblivion”; and of the Wisconsin Cook case, which follows it, he declares that «‘ the Wisconsin laws are commensurate in wick- edness and foolishness with the power of the State.” This is deliberately written of an exceedingly careful and elaborate opinion delivered by Judge Folger, and concurred in by all the other judges save one. We think the decision wrong, but such railing as this can produce no impression, except that the critic is too violent and prejudiced to form a just judgment. When one reads Mr. Jeremiah Travis’s criticisms of the courts, it seems to him that the author has searched the dictionary for abusive phrases. This last author literally swore himself out of breath, and damned his own book. Mr. Travis is not a strong man ; he is simply a violent man; but David Dudley Field was a strong man, and Messrs. Bishop and Thompson are strong men, and in all of them is lacking the tolerance of weaker men’s opinions es- sential to the widest propagation of their own views. WALWORTH’S STATURE. — Mr. W. L. Stone writes us that Walworth was not ‘* small’ nor «* lean,” as The Green Bag. was asserted in the biographical sketch in this maga- zine. He thinks that he was about five feet ten inches tall. He admits, however, “ that before he died he had shrunk somewhat,” and that «*‘ he may have been lean in his last days.”” The biographer was speaking of him in his last days, when he pre- sented the appearance described in the sketch. Men differ widely about the height of other men. We have seen Webster described as a man of medium height, which certainly he was not. KENT’S CAREER. — In turning over the eighth vol- ume of Humphrey’s Tennessee Reports, recently, we found a very excellent obituary of Kent, written in 1847, in which it is said: ‘* To him the credit certainly is due of having laid the foundation of a system of equity jurisprudence, not only in New York, but throughout the United States. The cases in Johnson’s Chancery Reports are, in the first place, all reasoned out upon principle,” etc. ‘* And most unquestionably, no other decisions have exerted so marked an influence upon the legal mind of the Uni- ted States, or are so universally recognized as author- ity.” The biographer also says: ‘* We consider Chancellor Kent as being one of the great lights and benefactors of this continent.”’ There is less doubt of that than of his statement that he never had an enemy. It was undoubtedly true that he was ‘‘a bad listener in conversation.”’ Although true that ‘¢ he never had much taste for the contentions of po- litical bodies,’’ yet he was an acute and interested politician in a quiet way, and some of his surviving contemporaries believe that he was a retired poten- tiality in New York politics. Every young lawyer in this country should read this sketch, full of wisdom, temperate in tone, felicitously expressed, and learn therein the lesson of a great, albeit a noiseless ca- reer. How much better to be an oracle for ages than to roar (or bray, as the case may be) in the courts for a season, to the admiration of the open-mouthed, who come into the temple of justice mainly to get out of the cold! ENTERPRISING PUBLISHERS. — One of the queerest examples of enterprise in law-book publishing which has come to our notice is the announcement, by the Edward Thompson Company, that they will issue a new edition of their «* American and English Ency- clopedia of Law,” before the first is finished! They propose to give a new volume for the corresponding old one and five dollars! This is certainly an unpre- cedented attraction, and can be repeated indefinitely. In connection with this, though by no means on the same plane, is the announcement of the West Pub- lishing Company of ‘* The Century Digest,” contain-
Page 45
The Lawyers Easy Chair. 483 ing an abstract of all the American decisions for the century, taken from forty-six hundred volumes, and numbering half a million! Brethren, there is time to fly! The ferry facilities from Buffalo to Canada are ample. Let us escape from this hellno lLbrorum! NOTES OF CASES. THE SIREN TURNTABLE. — In Walsh v. Fitchburg R. Co., 145 N. Y. 3013 27 L. R. A. 724, the New York Court of Appeals adhere to their doctrine, pre- viously indicated, that children ride on railway turn- tables at their own risk; thus preferring the doctrine of Illinois, New Hampshire and Massachusetts to that of the United States Supreme Court and of a majority of the State courts which have passed upon the ques- tion. They hold that the owner of the machine does not ‘‘entice” adventurous youth to dare its giddy round, and that it is very different from the case of spreading tainted meat over traps to allure dogs. The decisions to this effect seem to us an illustration of what Charles Lamb called ‘‘ imperfect sympa- thies.” It is the most natural thing in the world that the small boy should essay a ride on a turntable, and it is very easy for the owner (of the turntable) to keep it locked, and not at all unreasonable to require him to do so. In the principal case, the machine was in an unfenced lot, near foot-paths which the public were permitted touse. With deference we dis- sent from the observation of the court, ‘‘ It was not of the nature of a trap for the unwary.” The fre- quency of this class of cases is a standing refutation of that argument. This class of cases is easily dis- tinguishable from those which hold that an owner of land is not bound to fence a pond or a dangerous ex- cavation thereon, as against an infant intruder, whom he does not invite, attract or suffer thereon. This is just now held by the Supreme Court of Nebraska, in Richards v. Connell, citing in support of it, Har- greaves v. Deacon, 25 Mich. 1; Klix v. Meinan, 68 Wis. 271; 60 Am. Rep. 854; Clark v. Manchester, 62 N. H. 578; Overholt vw. Vieths, 93 Mo. 422; Gillespie v. McGowan, Ioo Pa. St. 144; 45 Am. Rep. 365; Pierce v. Whitcomb, 48 Vt. 127; 21 Am. Rep. 120; McEachern v. Railroad Co., 150 Mass. 515; Gay v. Railway Co., 159 Mass. 238; 38 Am. St. Rep. 415; Beck wv. Carter, 68 N.Y. 283; 23 Am. Rep. 175. And there is also a mani- fest distinction between this class of cases and that of young children straying on a railway track. See Gunn vw. Ohio R. R. Co., 36 W. V. 165; 32 Am. St. Rep. 842, and cases there cited. THE UNSPEAKABLE PLUMBER. — The plumber at all events is one who sets traps for the unwary, and he ought to be regulated; and so the New York Court of Appeals, in People v. Warden, etc., 144 N. Y. 529; 27 L. R.A., 718, have decided that a statute making it unlawful to do business as an em- ploying or master plumber without a certificate of competency obtained from an examining board, and registration with the board of health, and requiring compliance with the regulations of both boards, but having no application to plumbers who do not em- ploy others, is a constitutional exercise of the police power to protect health. The measure was defended as one of health and police by the court. Three of the seven judges, however, dissented, on the ground, as expressed by Peckham, J., that the measure ‘¢tends directly to the creation and fostering of a monopoly.”’ So it does, in one sense, and so do law schools and medical colleges, but such mono- polies are wholesome. A ** civil service” plumber would be a good innovation. The majority opinion answers the argument about monopoly as follows : — “Nor is it a ground of objection that, as the statute was intended to apply only to master or employing plumbers; the inference follows that a monopoly in the business is created or sanctioned. It may or may not have been wiser that the legislature should require examinations by and cer- tificates from the examining boards in the case of every person engaged in the business of plumbing; but if the act is a step in the direction of something which will inure to the public health and comfort, that it does not go as far as it might is not a reason for invalidating it. I am able to see how this act may limit the number of master plumbers, and with great wisdom; but I am not able to see how any monopoly will necessarily follow. The purpose of the act is in the direction of limiting the business to those persons who will perform the work, presumably, with some regard to the public health and comfort, and it would be a misuse of language to speak of such provisions as creating, or even tending to create, a monopoly. As well might it be said that to compel physicians or druggists to take out licenses is a provision giving a monopoly of the particular business to those who become licensed. If the measure is not so obvious a precaution in the case of plumbers as in that of physicians or of druggists, is that a reason for condemning it, if it may reasonably be considered as some precaution? I think not, and I think the measure, as one relating to the general health of cities, is evident, and intended to be so, from the provisions of the act, which require the board of examiners to contain the chief examiner of the city sewers and the chief inspector of plumbing of the board of health; which require not only registration with the board of health, but that the business shall be conducted under rules and regulations prescribed by that board; and which authorize that body to cancel registrations for violations of rules and regulations for the plumbing and drainage of the city.” There is no trade in which so much deleterious and impudent robbery is transacted as in plumbing, and any attempt to regulate and restrain it should be fostered. The plumber’s sins, like the doctor’s mis- takes, are ‘‘ out of sight.”
Page 46
The Green Bag. A RE IGious Use.—The origin of the maxim, ; «Cleanliness is next to godliness ” is unknown, but there is no doubt of its soundness, and the New York Court of Appeals have commended it to a relig- ious society, in Health Department of the City of New York v. Rector, etc:, of Trinity Church, 145 N. Y. 32; 27 L.R.A. 710, in which they hold that a statute requiring water to be furnished on each floor of every tenement house is a valid exercise of police power with respect to health, and also with respect to public safety regarding fires and their extinguish- ment. The horrors of the Trinity Church tenement houses are but little known, but they are almost as great as those of the prison ships of the Revolution, which lay and rotted with their human freight in New York harbor, and to the victims of which a sumptuous monument stands in Trinity Church-yard, directly opposite Pine Street (placed there to pre- vent the extension of that street through those grounds). At last the public authorities have done their duty in the premises in a small measure. The corporation consequently may have less money to spend on church construction and decoration, but there will be more human beings to be ministered unto. Judge Peckham, in the course of a long and powerful opinion (and by the way he is a good Epis- copalian), observes among other things : — “ We may own our property absolutely, and yet it is sub- ject to the proper exercise of the police power. We have surrendered, to that extent, our right to its unrestricted use. It must be so used as not improperly to cause harm to our neighbor, including in that description the public generally. There are sometimes necessary expenses which inevitably grow out of the use to which we may put our property, and which we must incur, either voluntarily, or else under the direction of the legislature, in order that the general health, safety, or welfare may be conserved. The legislature, in the exercise of this power, may direct that certain improvements shall be made in existing houses at the owners’ expense, so that the health and safety of the occupants, and of the pub- lic through them, may be guarded. ‘These exactions must be regarded as legal so long as they bear equally upon all members of the same class, and their cost does not exceed what may be termed one of the conditions upon which in- dividual property is held. It must not be an unreasonable exaction, either with reference to its nature or its cost. Within this reasonable restriction, the power of the State may, by police regulations, so direct the use and enjoyment of the property of the citizen that it shall not prove per- nicious to his neighbors, or to the public generally. “Laws and regulations of a police nature, though they may disturb the enjoyment of individual rights, are not un- constitutional, though no provision is made for compensa- _ tion for such disturbances. They do not appropriate pri- vate property for public use, but simply regulate its use and enjoyment by the owner. “The State, or its agent in enforcing its mandate, takes no property of the citizen when it simply directs the making of these improvements. As a result thereof, the in- dividual is put to some expense in complying with the law, by paying mechanics or other laborers to do that which the law enjoins upon the owner; but, so long as the amount exacted is limited as stated, the property of the citizen has not been taken, in any constitutional sense, without due process of law. Instances are numerous of the passage of laws which entail expense on the part of those who must comply with them, and where such expense must be borne by them, without any hearing or compensation, because of the provisions of the law. “‘ Hand-rails to stairs, hoisting shafts to be inclosed, au- tomatic doors to elevators, automatic shifters for throwing off belts or pulleys, and fire escapes on the outside of cer- tain factories, — all these were required by the legislature from such owner, and without any direct compensation to him for such expenditure. Has the legislature no right to enact laws such as this statute regarding factories, unless limited to factories to be thereafter built? Because the fac- tory was already built when the act was passed, was it be- yond the legislative power to provide such safeguards to life and health, as against all owners of such property, un- less upon the condition that these expenditures to be in- curred should ultimately come out of the public purse? I think to so hold would be to run counter to the general course of decisions regarding the validity of laws of this character, and to mistake the foundation upon which they are placed. ** Any one in a crowded city who desires to erect a build. ing is subject at every turn, almost, to the exactions of the law in regard to provisions for health, for safety from fire, and for other purposes. He is not permitted to build of certain materials, within certain districts, because, though the materials may be inexpensive, they are inflammable; and he must build in a certain manner. ‘Theaters and ho- tels are to be built in accordance with plans to be inspected and approved by the agents of the city; other public build- ings, also, and private dwellings within certain districts are subject to the same supervision.” « And in carrying out all these various acts, the owner is subjected to an expense much greater than would have been necessary to have completed his building, if not compelled to complete it in the manner, of the materials, and under the circumstances prescribed by various acts of the legisla- ture. And yet he has never had a hearing in any one of these cases, nor does he receive any compensation for the increased expense of his building, rendered necessary in order to comply with the police regulations. I do not see that the principle is substantially altered where the case is one of anexisting building, and it is to be subjected to cer- tain alterations for the purpose of rendering it either less exposed to the danger from fires, or its occupants more se- cure from disease. In both cases, the object must be within some of the acknowledged purposes of the police power- and such purpose must be possible of accomplishment at some reasonable cost, regard being had to all the surround, ing circumstances. “Under the police power, persons and property are sub- jected to all kinds of restraints and burdens in order to se- cure the general comfort and health of the public. The court cited Commonwealth v. Roberts, 155 Mass. 281; 16 L. R. A. 400, holding that an act of the legislature, which provided that every building in Boston used as dwelling house, situated on a street in which there was a public sewer, should have sufficient water-closets connected therewith, was valid as to existing houses and applied in its penal- ties to their owners, if such houses continued with- out the closets after its passage.
Page 47
The Green Bag. PUBLISHED MONTHLY, AT $4.00 PER ANNUM. SINGLE NUMBERS, 50 CENTS. Communications in regard to the contents of the Magazine should be addressed to the Editor, Horace W. FuLuLer, 15% Beacon Street, Boston, Mass. The Editor will be glad to receive contributions of articles of moderate length upon subjects of inter- est to the profession; also anything in the way of legal antiquities or curiosities, facetie, anec- dotes, etc. , THE GREEN BAG. To THE EDITOR OF THE GREEN Bac. Sir; In the August number of the GREEN Bac, in the contribution entitled, ‘ Exterritoriality of Orientals in England,’ occur passages of which the following are samples : — ‘¢ But now, with the oblique light shed upon it by the Oriental mind, exterritoriality is rapidly becoming a license to seduce, a charter to kill if not to murder, and a monopoly to commit suicide without the incon- veniences of a coroner’s inquiry in prospect, besides furnishing a protection for the more everyday pastime of incurring debts and refusing to pay. The Chinese and Japanese Embassies have developed with per- turbing facility into a veritable Alsatia, wherein the law applicable to common Englishmen may be con- temned.”’ ‘¢The case of Oriental embassies, as has been shown, stands by itself. The exceeding extent of the modern privilege of exterritoriality arises from the fact that Europeans have not abused it. There is no such basis of experience in the case of Oriental embassies.” As one who has seen as well as read something of exterritoriality and its working, I feel bound to say that the contributor is thoroughly misin- formed, and that the whole tone of the article, as well as the passages in question, are offensively and almost wantonly unjust. Not to mention minor criticisms, it is sufficient to say that the writer has just reversed the actual situation; that the abuses of exterritoriality are to-be found mainly in the conduct of Occidentals; and that the teachings by example of the Occidentals in this matter can never be equalled by their Orien- tal pupils. From books alone your contributor might have learned of the charge of rape against the Russian consul at Philadelphia in 1816; of the notorious and long-standing abuse of exterri- toriality in Morocco and other ‘Turkish dominions by the system of “ protected”’ natives falsely reg- istered as belonging to the consular and diplo- matic suites; of the flagrant abuse of the asylum in Chili by our Minister Egan, and elsewhere at other times. From other sources than books he might have learned of the general, if casual, abuse of exterritoriality in the Orient ; of which a paral- lel to his own instances is found in the dangerous facility for law-breaking enjoyed by sailors from warships, and of which an analogous instance is found in the harbor of refuge accorded to Chinese thieves and other criminals on the peninsula of Kowloon, near Hongkong, owing to its having become British territory. As for the “ everyday pastime of incurring debts and refusing to pay,” the case may be cited of a European Secre- tary of Legation of the highest birth, who lived in luxury in an Oriental country and went home leaving creditors in the lurch to the extent of several thousands of dollars. As for “the license to seduce,” and to commit other wrongs, it would be a day of disappointment (and perhaps of much-needed shame for us), were the records of the East and the West to be fully disclosed and compared. No experienced diplomatist would think of raising the issue. I am, Sir, yours, etc., }. Peas LEGAL ANTIQUITIES. Pipe in law is a roll in the Exchequer, called also the Great Roll. Pipe office is where the Clerk of the Pipe makes out leases of Crown Lands: he also makes up all the accounts of sheriffs. Spelman thinks it is so called because | papers were kept in a large cask or pipe. 485
Page 48
486 Lhe Green Bag. FACETIZ. Brerore the Supreme Court of North Carolina, lately, a Mr. Ward, a young lawyer, was arguing a homestead appeal, and cited four or five cases as precedents. One of the court asked him if the principle stated was the point decided in those cases, or was it merely incidentally referred to, or obiter dicta. In entire good faith, and uncon- scious of humor, he replied, “‘ Yes, your honor, it is the very point decided, though they go on and talk about one thing and another, as they usually do.” SOME years ago there was a prohibition election in Raleigh, N. C., and both sides claimed the in- fluence of Col. T. C. Fuller (now Judge Fuller, of the United States Land Claims Court). Rev. Dr. Skinner, a leading divine, in conversation with Mr. Fraps, who kept a saloon, and who was a great admirer of Col. Fuller, told him that that gentle- man endorsed the movement. Mr. Fraps de- murred. Finally, Dr. Skinner stated that he had it direct from Col. Fuller himself! Mr. Fraps shook his head: “Ah, Doctor, he ¢aéks mit you, but he drinks mit me.” Mr. B. F. Moore, a distinguished lawyer in North Carolina, had a double, — Major D. G. MacRae, — who was something of a wag. As the latter was passing through the Capital Square in Raleigh, some years ago, a countryman met him and said, “ Mr. Moore, I have come to pay that hundred dollars I owe you.” “Very well,” was the reply, “let us step in here and take a drink.” Somewhat surprised, the debtor accepted the in- vitation. ‘Then, after a few remarks about the crops, the countryman again pulled out his money to pay; but the supposed Mr. Moore waved his hand, and said, “Take another drink first.” Then, after further talk about the weather and politics, the debtor again offered payment. Noth- ing would do, however, but “ take another drink.’’ This being accomplished, the countryman said he _ must go, and insisted peremptorily on paying over the money to “Mr. Moore.” ‘See here,” said MacRae, “ do you still think I am Bat Moore?” ‘“‘ | know you are,’ said the man. “Well,” said MacRae, “haven’t I proved to you I am not? _ Did you ever know Mr. Moore to refuse to receive any money?” ‘No,’ said the man, “never!” ‘Well, did you ever know or hear of his treating anybody?” ‘ Never, in all my born days ;”’ and, musing, “I swear you can’t be Mr. Moore, but who in h—l are you?”’ Swirt GALLOway, prosecuting for the State in Duplin County, N. C., had a case in which some of the witnesses swore that a certain hog was a doar and others a “ barrow.” Finally, he asked an old negro witness if he knew the difference, and what it was. ‘ Sartinly, Marse Swift; when a he hog have dost his manhood he is a barrow.”’ NOTES. WE commend the following to the considera- tion of our New Jersey brethren. It may give them an idea worth carrying out : — A “combination atlas map of Trumbull Coun- ty,” published at Chicago, IIll., under the super- vision of L. H. Evans, in the year 1874, tells a queer story of early frontier justice. ‘“‘ The first trial tribunal was composed of a self- organized body of men, who tried and convicted a man for stealing from a fellow-boarder. He was convicted and sentenced to be divested of his ap- parel, tied to a tree, and subjected to the bites of mosquitoes for the period of an hour. ‘It was soon discovered, however, that the man would have little or no blood left at the expiration of his term of punishment, and he was released at the end of the first half-hour. He was never known to steal again.” From Brierley Hill comes a good story: “ It is a well-known provision of the law,’ says a tocal paper, “that a dog is entitled to bite one citizen free ; but his owner is liable to be punished for the second taste his pet may take.”” Well, if the local paper says this is the law, let it pass. We thought otherwise. ‘The other day a case came before two new magistrates in a provincial town, in which a man was summoned for keeping a savage dog. While in court, the dog showed every desire to clear the deck by snapping and yelping. In giving judgment, the chairman said, ‘‘ although they could not convict, because there was no evidence that the dog had bitten anyone before, they considered the animal’s conduct so bad “hey should endorse his license.’ — Law Notes
Page 49
Editorial Department. LITERARY NOTES. AMONG the ‘* topics of the times ” reviewed in the editorial department of the September REVIEW OF REVIEWS, the recent convention of the Catholic Total Abstinence Union in New York City, Russia’s abo- lition of private saloons, the Atlanta Exposition, the dedication of the military park at Chickamauga, the Northfield Conference, the ‘‘ New Puritanism” in politics, the massacres in China, the extent of fhe Liberal reverse in Great Britain, and the Cuban rev- olution receive extended treatment. Or the manuscripts left unpublished by Robert Louis Stevenson at his death (not many, by the way), the first to reach the public is a collection of very original «* Fables” in the September number of Mc- CLURE’S MAGAZINE. One of them is a conversa- tion between John Silver and ‘* Cap’n” Smollett of ‘¢ Treasure Island,’ which is as délicious in its way as anything those worthies do or say in ‘* Treasure Island ” itself. In the same number, Anthony Hope relates another adventure of the ever-charming Prin- cess Osra, an encounter in the forests of Zenda with an attractive and most courteous highwayman. There is also a romantic tale of court intrigue, by Stanley J. Weyman, and a new Drumtochty story by Ian Maclaren, the author of ‘* Beside the Bonnie Briar- Bush.” ‘¢Wuy Women Do Not Want the Ballot” is thoughtfully discussed by the Rt. Rev. Wm. Cros- well Doane, Bishop of Albany, in the September number of the NORTH AMERICAN REVIEW. This number also contains an exceedingly valuable paper styled «* Trend of National Progress,” by Prof. Rob- ert H. Thurston, of Cornell University, in which the future progress of the United States is most happily outlined. THE ATLANTIC MONTHLY for September contains the first installment of a three-part story, by Charles Egbert Craddock, entitled «* The Mystery of Witch- Face Mountain.” The second of Dr. John Fiske’s historical papers has for a subject ‘*‘ John Smith in Virginia,” in which he reopens vigorously the discus- sion in regard to this interesting character. Brad- ford Torrey contributes another Tennessee sketch, ‘¢ Chickamauga,” which will be of special interest in view of this summer’s memorable gathering at Look- out Mountain. The paper in the August issue by James Schouler, upon ‘‘ President Polk’s Diary,” is ably supplemented in this issue by ‘* President Polk’s Administration,” by the same author. The usual in- stallments of the two powerful serials now running will add interest to the issue. FicTion and travel are the strong points of the September COSMOPOLITAN, which, by the way, illus- - trates better than any previous number the perfection of its plant for printing a magazine of the highest class. Conan Doyle, H. H. Boyesen, and Clark Russell are among the story-tellers. A well-known New York lawyer relates the story of «¢ A Famous Crime,’’ — the murder of Dr. Parkman by Professor Webster. A delightful sketch of ««An English Coun- try-House Party” is from the pen of Nina Larré’ Smith, — the house at which she visited being no less than the historic Abbotsford, still occupied by the di- rect descendants of Sir Walter Scott. «* The Realm of the Wonderful ” is descriptive of the strange forms of life discovered by science in the ocean’s depths, and is superbly illustrated in a surprising and mar- velous way by the author, who is a member of the Smithsonian staff. ‘An article on Cuba is timely. THE leading feature of THE BosTonraAN for Au- gust is the giving up of sixty-eight pages to a very comprehensive condensation of the «‘ History of Blue Lodge, Royal Arch, and Knight Templar Masonry in the United States,” fully illustrated, with interior and exterior views of Boston’s Masonic Lodge-rooms, and of many of the old buildings which have figured in the city’s Masonic life, which cannot be found else- where, — such as the former Masonic Hall (afterwards the United States Court-House), which stood at the corner of Tremont Street and Temple Place, and the Winthrop House, which occupied’ the site where the Masonic Temple now stands, and which was burned in 1864. MARK TWAIN contributes to the September Har- PER’S MAGAZINE a paper in which he gives an account of some curious personal experiences in telepathy, or second-sight, or coincidence, or whatever it may be. These are in continuation of an account published in December, 1891, of some earlier experiences of the same sort which Mr. Clemens gave under the title ‘¢ Mental Telegraphy.” THE success of a magazine serial dealing with contemporary American affairs has been abundantly demonstrated by the wide and permanent interest that has been aroused by President Andrews’s << His- tory of the Last Quarter Century in the United States,” now running in SCRIBNER’S MAGAZINE. The September instalment includes episodes of such variety as the third-term contest of President Grant, Conkling’s great feud with Garfield, the assassination of Garfield, the Star Route and Whiskey Ring frauds — all of which topics are illustrated with a unique series of pictures collected with great aah from authentic sources.
Page 50
488 HELEN H. GARDENER’S summing up of the cam- paign of legislation on the protection of young girls — the so-called ‘‘age of consent’? question — is one feature of the September ARENA that will be sure to attract the widest attention in the three States dealt with in this issue. She treats of the legislation se- cured, raising the age of protection in Colorado, Ne- braska and Missouri, and the full reports of the proceedings will afford both those in favor of the “movement and those opposed to it an opportunity to weigh the arguments pro and con. THE CENTURY for September contains a new por- trait of Henry Clay, accompanying a paper of family recollections collected by Miss Madeleine McDowell, a granddaughter of the statesman. Of this portrait, which was painted by Matthew Harris Jouett, Miss McDowell says: ‘It hung for many years in the home, near Lexington, of another of Mr. Clay’s ad- mirers. But in Kentucky, where the possession of the blue-grass land is a fruitful source of litigation, and of bitter and enduring enmities as well, even po-_ litical sympathies were not always able to prevail against the strain. The inevitable lawsuit occurred, and the portrait was banished to the garret. After- ward it was given to a friend, who, on inquiring about: it, was told that it should never again darken the walls where it had hung. This gentleman, before the humor of the owner should be changed, put the picture into his buggy, and drove with it to his home in a neighboring county.” BOOK NOTICES. History OF THE LAW or REAL Property IN NEW York. By Ropert LupLow Fow.er. Baker, Voorhis & Co., New York, 1895. $3.00 net. This work of Mr. Fowler is valuable not only as a legal treatise, but as an historical contribution upon a subject of exceeding interest. Beginning with the law of real property in New Netherland, the growth and development of the law in New York is traced down to and through the revised Statutes. New York lawyers will find the work of much practical value, and others cannot fail to be deeply interested in it. AMERICAN ELEctrricaL Cases, Vol. III (1889- 1892). Edited by Witiiam W. Morritt. Mat- thew Bender, Albany, N. Y.,1895. Law sheep, $6.00. This volume brings the decisions covering the law of electricity almost down to the present time. We The Green Bag. have heretofore commented on the value of this series to the profession, and the present volume has been prepared with the same care and discretion which characterized its predecessors. The selection of cases is admirable and the editor has faithfully performed his task. HAND-BOOK OF THE LAW OF SALES. By FRANCIS B. Tirrany. West Publishing Co., St. Paul, 1895. Law Sheep, $3.75. HAND-BOOK OF INTERNATIONAL Law. By Cap- TAIN Epwin F, Guieason. West Publishing Co., St. Paul, 1895. Law sheep, $3.75. These two works are the latest issues in the ‘¢Horn Book Series” which the West Publishing Co. are publishing for students’ use. Mr. Tiffany’s volume on ‘‘ Sales”? seems to be admirably adapted for its purpose, and Captain Gleason gives a clear idea of the principles governing international law. Roap RIGHTS AND LIABILITIES OF WHEELMEN. By GeorGE B. CLEMENTSON. Callaghan & Co., Chicago, 1895. Law sheep, $1.50, mez. This is a very timely little work, and will prove valuable not only to the profession but to the vast army of bicyclists who have taken possession of our highways and byways. Mr. Clementson sets forth the rights and liabilities of this class of travelers very clearly and concisely, and with his book for a guide wheelmen will be fully posted as to their legal status. It is, we believe, the first work upon this important subject. THE BrREHON Laws. A Legal Handbook. By LAWRENCE GINNELL of the Middle Temple. Imported by Charles Scribner’s Sons. Cloth, $2.40. . The lover of legal antiquities will fairly revel in this book, for the Brehon (Irish) laws are old enough to satisfy the most exacting antiquarian, having reached their full proportions and maturity about the time that Alfred was reducing to order the scraps of elementary law he found existing amongst his people. Mr. Ginnell has collected a vast amount of interesting information in this volume and he communicates it in such a happy manner that the reader is fairly fasci- nated by his recital. We have not the space for such comment as we would be glad to make on the subject- matter of the book, but we heartily commend the work to everyone who is at all interested in the story of ancient law, and we assure them they will find it one of absorbing interest.