The Green Bag: An Entertaining Magazine for Lawyers (September, 1895)
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
Vot. VII. BOSTON. The (sreen Bag. SEPTEMBER, 1895. JOHN BARBEE MINOR, PROFESSOR OF COMMON AND STATUTE LAW, 1845-1895, UNIVERSITY OF VIRGINIA. By ‘THomas J]. MICHIE. N the early summer of the present year, the writer of this article, an alumnus of the University of Virginia, and an admiring pupil of John Barbee Minor, was visiting rel- atives in the typical Virginia college town of Charlottesville. The great event of the college world, and indeed of the town life, was then in progress— the finals, perhaps better known to Northern readers as the commencement. The chief feature of this celebration, and by far the most interesting to the great number of busy men of the world, lawyers, politicians and men of af- fairs, who have during the last fifty years, at one session or another sat under John B. Minor, was the unveiling of a bust of him by the distinguished Virginia artist Valentine, author of the fine recumbent figure of Lee at Lexington. The ceremony of unveiling took place in the public hall of the Univer- sity, on Wednesday, June 12. The large hall was filled to overflowing. The veil was lifted by James B. Green, chairman of the Minor bust committee. Mr. Green is blind, and after a few appropriate remarks, as he lifted the veil he said: ‘‘ Thou art unveiled to all but me; but a niche in my heart is filled by thee.” Mr. Thornton, chairman of the faculty of the University, then accepted the bust, on behalf of the visitors of the University, the faculty, alumni and students, and introduced as the orator of the day, the senior senator of Virginia, John W. Daniel. Mr. Daniel is well known to the legal profession as the ee author of “‘ Daniel’s Negotiable Instruments.” Mr. Daniel’s address was worthy of the oc- casion, and I will perhaps have an opportu- nity to quote from it in the course of this article. The bust was dedicated by the alumni of the Law School to the University, and has been placed in the library among other worthies of the institution, alumni, pro- fessors and students, — Poe, Cabell, Grady, Jefferson, etc. The library is one of the chief features of the University, not so much as a valuable col- lection of books, though the collection is good, numbering upwards of fifty thousand volumes, and embracing the libraries of Jef- ferson, Madison, and Austin of Boston, but for its unique architectural features. It is situated at the top of the rotunda, the prin- cipal building of the University, and, as the name implies, is circular, commanding, from its many windows, a beautiful view, uninter- rupted in every direction. Upon one side, in the distance, can be seen Monticello, the home of Jefferson; on the other the Ragged Mountains, the scene of Poe’s tales; and in front the famous lawns of the University. The walls of the room itself are, as has been said, decorated with portraits of professors, students and benefactors of the college. In this room the bust of Mr. Minor will stand, a testimonial to future generations of students, of the love, affection and admiration borne by his disciples for their great teacher. In common with all those who have been so fortunate as to have benefited by the teach- 401
Page 2
ee ep hres Thi . ] Peak. Vt . P . Dy i hee ee wr . +e i, Re ee ere a 15 Pa Ras wey Oa het! ;
Page 3
Page 4
402 ings of this distinguished professor, the writer has always been an ardent admirer of the original of this representation. Upon this occasion he conceived the idea of writ- ing a short sketch of Mr. Minor’s life. Cir- cumstances have prevented the fulfilment of this design until the present date (August). When undertaken he little anticipated that the sketch would become an obituary. Such however is the fact, Mr. Minor having died on Monday, July 29, 1895, after the completion of the longest and ablest career as a teacher of law known to Anglo-Saxon jurisprudence. The writer has been tempted to say, the sad fact, but why so?) The man’s course was complete, his memory is dear and living to a larger number than often falls to the lot of man, — his enemies are none. He is at rest, and why should his friends, among whom he counted every student that attended his school for fifty years, grieve for him? It is true that they must feel a personal loss, but they may console themselves by remember- ing the perfect life, which it remains for me to imperfectly sketch. John Barbee Minor was the youngest son of Launcelot and Elizabeth Minor, and was born at his father’s home, ‘‘ Minor’s Folly,” in Louisa County, Virginia, on June 2, 1813. He obtained his early education at home and at a neighboring school, until delicate health in his seventeenth year compelled him to suspend his studies for a time, in order to lead a more active out-of-door life. He spent most of the next year on horseback, acting as collector for numerous country newspapers, riding from county to county, visiting the patrons of his clients. In the fall of 1830 he, with two older cousins, walked to Kenyon College, Ohio, where he studied for a year. Among his classmates was David Davis, afterwards a justice of the United States Supreme Court, and a United States senator... Another was Stanton, Lin- coln’s secretary of war. With both of these he maintained the friendship there formed for many years. At the close of the college Lhe Green Bag. session, he made a pedestrian tour alone, through New York and Ohio, visiting Nia- gara and all points of interest on his route, and observing particularly the people of those States, who at that time, before the days of rail- roads, differed more materially perhaps from the people of his native State than they now do. This experience, together with his year on horseback in the Virginia counties, undoubt- edly gave him a much wider knowledge of man than that usually acquired by a student of his age, and in after years he profited by it as a lawyer and teacher. Upon his re- turn he entered the University of Virginia as a student, where he remained until 1833, graduating in several academic schools and taking the degree of B.L. John A. G. Davis was professor of law at the University at that time, and about a year after graduating Mr. Minor married his sister. Mr. Minor began the practice of law. at Buchanan, Botetourt County, Virginia, but removed, in 1840, to Charlottesville, where he formed a partnership with his elder brother, who was afterwards Professor of Law at William and Mary College. Mr. Minor was an ardent advocate of the com- mon-law system of pleading and could never discuss the code system with patience. [I re- member well his illustrating in class, the ef- fect of a careful pleader upon the bar at large. He said that when he first went to Buchanan, the procedure in the courts was very loose, but by always insisting upon conformity with the strict rules of common law, in the cases in which he was engaged, he alone succeeded in reforming the entire procedure of that court, so that upon his departure it was said that the pleading in the courts of Buchanan was the best in the State. It is thought by many, that it is due to Mr. Minor’s influence and the influence of his many students throughout the State that Virginia is not now numbered among the code States. In the year 1845 Mr. Minor was elected Professor of Law at the University of Vir-
Page 5
—_ H. St. George Tucker, former President of the Vir- ginia, to succeed the Honorable ginia Court of Appeals. For the first few years of his professorship, he had entire charge of the Law School. It was then di- vided, he becoming Professor of Common and Statute Law. Throughout the troublous years of 1861 to 1865 he again alone main- tained the Law School of the University, against many difficulties. In 1866, he was again relieved from double duty, by the ap- pointment of an additional professor. Since that time the school has steadily grown having now a faculty of four apart from the chair of Medical Jurisprudence, the max- imum number of students being one hun- dred and fifty-one. In the vacation of 1870 Mr. Minor established a summer law-school, which he continued until his death. He be- gan with a school of twenty, which steadily increased, attaining a maximum of one hundred and twenty-one. It will thus be seen that for the last twenty-five years of Mr. Minor’s life, he allowed himself a vaca- tion from teaching, of only one month a year, and during this time, he was constantly at work upon his great book. He might well say, as he frequently did, that he lived by work. The degree of LL.D. was con- ferred upon him by the Universities of Wash- ington and Lee and Columbia. He always preferred, however, to be called simply “ Mr. Minor,” disliking even the designation of professor, which, he very truly said, has be- come the property of the bootblacks, ton- sorial artists, patent medicine quacks, and dancing masters, to the exclusion of its true proprietors. In praise of Mr. Minor as a teacher, it would be hard to say too much, and indeed no student of his will admit that it is pos- sible. We do not allow that he has a superior, and since Kent, but one equal— Professor Dwight of Columbia, for whom Mr. Minor always had a sincere admiration. The most salient feature of Mr. Minor’s teaching was his analytical method. Follow- John Barbee Minor. 403 ing the analysis of Blackstone, founded on Hale, he carried it to an extent never dreamed of by either. The advantages of this system of instruction can only be com- prehended by those who benefited by it, and [I will have more to say of it when I come to speak of Mr. Minor’s book, ‘The Institutes.” As a lecturer Mr. Minor was unsurpassed. His manner was entirely con- versational — rarely raising his voice. His habit was to question the members of his class on the subject of his lectures, requir- ing from them the most concise replies, — usually no more than “Yes” or “No.’ Indeed it was not well to be too fluent, as he had no patience with a parrot-like repetition of the text-book. Upon these replies he built up his lectures, amplifying, explaining and illustrating in his inimitable manner. Perhaps the best proof of his merit as a lecturer is, that no student of his ever re- turned to the University without going to hear “old John B.” lecture, a compliment seldom paid to professors, I think. Mr. Minor’s influence with his students was very great. His personality was such that it could not fail to impress strongly any who knew him. This influence must have been indirectly of great service to his coun- try, as he had numbered many public men among his students. Indeed, at the present time, at least two cabinet ministers, one Justice of the United States Supreme Court, both Senators from Virginia, together with many other senators, representatives and state and federal judges are counted among his graduates. For the first thirty years of his work as a teacher, Mr. Minor was collecting material for his work on Common and Statute Law. For several years previous to 1873, synopti- cal notes of his lectures were lithographed for the benefit of his classes. In that year he published the first edition of the first and second volumes of his work under the style of ‘Minor’s Institutes of Common and Statute Law.” Their fourth edition ap-
Page 6
404 peared in 1891 and 1892. In 1878 the first | edition of the fourth volume was published, its third edition in 1893 in two parts. Owing to the exigencies of the class-room, the third volume was delayed until after the publication of the fourth, appearing first in an incomplete form, but it has now appeared in 1895, bound in two books as a “second edition, revised and corrected.” The whole work covers nearly five thousand pages. Of its value to the practitioner I can do no bet- ter than quote Senator Daniel, himself an active practitioner and legal author. He says: ‘“‘It cannot be surpassed as a vade mecum of the law. It is like a statue— solid, compact, clear cut. Jefferson lamented that Matthew Bacon adopted the alphabeti- cal, or dictionary system, in his abridgement. How a scientific mind like his would have delighted in a scientific work like this! Adopting the system of analysis which was delineated by Hale and amplified by Black- stone, he built upon it those expositions of common law principles, and statutory altera- tions, which reveal the law to the mind’s eye as a topographical map of a country cast in bas-relief. It has been said of Francis Bacon’s Essays, that of all compositions they contained the most matter in the fewest words. Minor’s Institutes contain more law in fewer words that any work with which | am acquainted. The Roman Forum had an empty place lacking Cato’s figure; and a lawyer's library without this work has one The Green Bag. also.” The analytical arrangement of the work I have often heard commented upon as very repellent to lawyers not familiar with Mr. Minor’s method of teaching, but this is its chief merit as a text-book for the student. In other classes at the law-school of the University we used at the same time such standard works as Greenleaf on Evidence, Smith’s Mercantile Law, Adams’ Equity, Vattel’s Law of Nations, etc., and though I would be the last to decry the merits of these great works, | must say, and every student of the University will agree with me, that as an aid to the student they are far inferior to Minor’s Institutes. This perhaps appears undue partiality, but nevertheless | cannot modify the statement an iota. The book was written for students and is the re- sult of fifty years’ experience as a professor of law, and upon its value as a text-book for students I think it must rest its chief claim for immortality. I would like to say something of Mr. Minor’s personal charm, of his family life and the respect and affection borne for him by all who knew him, but this article has already exceeded the space allowed it by THE GREEN BAG, and [| can only refer to the resolutions of the numerous bar associa- tions, of the faculty and visitors of the Uni- versity, and to the cloud of testimonials which have appeared in the periodicals and newspaper since his death, bearing witness to the regard in which he was held.
Page 7
London Police Courts. i LONDON POLICE COURTS. By Wiiitam Hottoway, B.A., Author of “ Leaves from a Lawyer’s Diary,” etc., etc. N this article I shall endeavor to describe the system administered by our London stipendiary magistrates. Many persons, espe- cially those of the criminal class, who have come to regard them as an inevitable evil, one of the vices of a constitution, calling loudly for reform, will be surprised to learn that they are comparatively a modern crea- tion. Until 1792 the police of the metropolis was administered by the Lord Mayor and twenty-six aldermen, sitting in rotation every forenoon at the Guildhall and Man- sion House for the City; and at Bow Street by three magistrates sitting in rotation every day for Westminster and those parts of Middlesex, Surrey, Herts, Essex and Kent lying within the metropolis. Old Bow Street Police Court was nearly opposite the present one, and close to Co- vent Garden, then, as now, one of the worst neighborhoods. in London. Is it the irony of Fate or some economic law, that among the choicest flowers of our English gardens are found our rankest human weeds, that the howl of the midnight ruffian and the oath of the harlot are heard side by side with the strains of Mozart and the voice of Patti? “Throughout a great part of the eigh- teenth century,” says Sir James Stephen (History of the Criminal Law of England, I, 229-230), the business of magistrates in that part of London which was not included in the City was carried on by magistrates who were paid almost entirely by fees. What the fees precisely were, and by what law their execution was justified, I am not able to say, nor is it worth while to inquire.” Townsend, a well-known Bow Street run- ner, who had been in the police since 1782, in giving evidence before a committee of the House of Commons in 1816, said: ‘ At that time, before the Police Bill took place at all, it was a trading business; and there was Justice This and Justice That. Justice Welch in Litchfield was a great man in those days, and old Justice Hyde and Justice Girdler, and Justice Blackborough, a trading justice of Clerkenwell Green, and an old ironmonger. The plan used to be to issue out warrants and take up all the poor devils in the street, and then there was the bailing of them, two shillings — four pence, which the magistrates had; and taking up one hundred girls, that would make, at two shillings four pence, eleven pounds, thirteen shillings and four pence. They sent none to gaol, the bailing them was much better.” ‘Look with thine ears: see how yond justice rails upon yond simple thief. Hark in thine ear! change places, and, handy- dandy, which is the justice, which the thief ?” The author of “Tom Jones,” “that exqui- site picture of human manners,” thus de- scribes his experience as a justice for West- minster: ‘‘ By composing instead of inflam- ing the quarrels of porters and beggars (which, I. blush to say, has not been usually practiced), and by refusing to take a shill- . ing from a man who most undoubtedly would not have had another, I reduced an income of about five hundred pounds of the dirtiest money upon earth to little more than three hundred pounds, a con- | siderable proportion of which remained with my clerk; and, indeed, if the whole had done so, as it ought, he would be but ill paid for sitting almost sixteen hours in the twenty-four in the most un-
Page 8
406 wholesome as well as nauseous air in the uni- verse, and which hath in his case corrupted a good constitution without contaminating his morals.” Five hundred pounds, I may state, is the salary which, with three exceptions, the Leg- islature has since assigned to- the chief clerks of the metropolitan police courts. At Bow Street and Great Marlborough Street the salary is indefinite, and at West Ham it is eight hundred pounds. Fielding adds: ‘“ A predecessor of mine used to boast that he made one thousand pounds a year in his office, but how he did this (if indeed he did it) is to mea secret. His clerk, now mine, told me I had more busi- ness than he had ever known there; I am sure I had as much as any man could do. The truth is, the fees are so very low, when any are due, that if a single justice of peace had business enough to employ twenty clerks, neither he nor they would get much by their labor. The public will not there- fore think that I betray a secret when [| in- form them that I received from the govern- ment a yearly pension out of the public _ service money.” ‘«« God moves in a mysterious way His wonders to perform.” Fate, which had condemned Fielding, like his contemporaries, Johnson and Goldsmith, to toil for the booksellers, ordained also that the hand which drew Sophia and Amelia should sign mittimuses for blear- eyed Molls and Molly Segrims. But vex not his ghost, oh, let him pass! «¢ Here lies poor Ned Purdon, from misery freed, Who long was a bookseller’s hack ; He led such a damnable life in this world, I don’t think he’ll wish to come back.”’ Fielding was succeeded as justice for Westminster by Saunders Welch, who, Bos- well tells us, “ established a regular office for the police of that great district, and dis- charged his important duties for many years faithfully and ably.” He was the friend of Johnson, who, when Saunders Welch’s | _ take any fee within their jurisdiction. The Green Bag. health gave way, obtained for him through Chamier (Under-Secretary of State) leave of absence to go to Italy, and a promise that the pension of two hundred pounds a year should not be discontinued. Johnson, who “ had an eager and unceas- ing curiosity to know human life,” told Boswell that ‘‘ he had attended Mr. Welch in his office for a whole winter to hear the ex- aminations of the prisoners, but that he found an almost uniform tenor of misfortune, wretchedness and profligacy.” In spite of one or two magistrates like Fielding and Welch, the state of the metrop- olis was so serious that 32 Geo. III. c. 53 was passed, establishing seven public offices: at Queen’s Square, St. Margarets West- minster; Marlborough Street, Oxford Road (as Oxford Street was called then) ; Hatton Garden, Holborn; Worship Street, Fins- bury Square ; Lambeth Street, White- chapel ; High Street, Shoreditch ; and Union Street, Southwark. Three magis- trates, two clerks, and six constables were attached to each office. The fees were paid to a receiver, as they are now, and by him distributed among the different offices, none of them receiving more than two thousand pounds. The salary of the magistrates was four hundred pounds each, and no other Middlesex or Surrey justice was allowed to Two of them are still remembered, Monias Léach and Patrick Colquhoun, author of a treatise on the Police of the Metropolis, which passed through seven editions in ten years, and of which the Select Committee of the House of Commons (1838) say: ‘ The merit of being the first to point out the ne- cessity and practicability of a system of preventive police upon an uniform and con- sistent plan, is due to Mr. Colquhoun.” Leach is described by his biographer in the Dictionary of National Biography (that most catholic work which embraces murder- ers in its fold) as “‘an able man,” but it is added, ‘ill health made him irritable.” The last
Page 9
London Police Courts. feature would scarcely distinguish him from many of his successors on the bench, but he is remembered as the editor of Hawkins’ “Pleas of the Crown,” and of numerous Reports. It was while the court was in Hatton Garden that the father of the present Sir George Lewis, whose offices are still in Ely Place, laid the foundation of the business which Sergeant Ballantine describes with loving care, and to which he, Sergeant Parry, Mr. Montague Williams, and other mem- bers of the race of Chaffanbrass, owe their rather doubtful fame. A singular thing about the Old Bailey, the final cause of the police courts, and which once shared with them the favors of a certain class of counsel more largely than now, is the blight which seems to fall upon its practi- tioners. Whether a legacy of death hangs round those grey walls, or that the shadows of a hundred years fall like a pall upon the living, the fact is unquestionable. Except parts of Erskine’s closely reasoned, but rather turgid speech for Hardy, and Sergeant Shee’s de- fence of Palmer — an admirable piece of rea- soning and eloquence (the peroration is one of the most beautiful and pathetic passages in ‘the language)—and neither Erskine nor Shee was an Old Bailey man, none of the speeches delivered there survive —can be quoted as literature. Omnes illacrimabiles Urgentur ignitique longa Nocte. They are buried in «¢A gulf profound as that Serbonian bog Betwixt Damiata and Mount Casius old, Where armies whole havesunk ... . A universe of death which God by curse Created, evil for evil only good, : Where all life dies, death lives, and Nature breeds Perverse, all monstrous, all prodigious things.” Although the new police courts did much to relieve the mischief which led to their creation, grave evils remained. This was partly the fault of the criminal law —even 407 now, as Sir Edward Fry called it, a thing of “threads and patches,” but then still more defective. For instance, it was not an of- fense to receive cash, or bank-notes, or bills, knowing them to be stolen, as for that pur- pose they were not regarded as chattels. According to Colquhoun, there were up- wards of three thousand receivers in the metropolis alone. The thefts, in small sums, from houses, shops, warehouses, etc., were something like seven hundred thousand pounds a year. An immense trade was done in counterfeit coin, two persons to- gether being able to produce from two hun- dred to three hundred pounds of base silver coin in six days. As usual, the unfortunate attorney was the scapegoat. ‘No sooner,” says Colquhoun, “ does a magistrate commit a hackneyed thief, or receiver of stolen goods, a coiner or dealer in base money, or a criminal charged with any other fraud or offense punishable by law, than recourse is immediately had to some disreputable at- torney, whose mind is made up and prepared to practice every trick and device which can defeat the mode of substantial justice.” Tindal might well speak of ‘ Christ, our attorney, suffering for us.” The plunder from ships in the Thames alone was so enormous — nearly half a million a year —that in 1798 a marine office, with two magistrates, was established at Wapping New Stairs. At first it confined itself al- most wholly to offenses committed on the river or connected with the stores in arse- nals, but gradually its jurisdiction extended until it became the present Thames Police Court. The glories of Ratcliff Highway have faded, but readers of De Quincey’s immortal history of the murders of Mar and William- son, can form an idea of what it was eighty years ago, when the largest ships discharged up stream, and the purlieus of the docks were “ full of strange oaths,” and the haunt of sailors of every race. Then, and until the advent of the large cargo steamers and short
Page 10
408 voyages, the Thames was the busiest police court in London, and it was not uncommon to hear as many as sixty summonses in a single day for wages alone — often for con- siderable amounts. Thirty or forty years ago it supported four solicitors, all making good incomes; now it provides a bare living for two gentle-. men who, with the aid of the police, main- tain a close preserve, from which trespassers are jealously excluded. Some years ago a friend of mine, an able man and an excellent lawyer, endeavored to establish himself in Arbour Square, but was boycotted so effec- | tually (one of the two gentlemen remarking ‘that he would sooner do a case for nothing than let it go to him) that he was obliged to abandon the attempt. Another difficulty to which Colquhoun refers is the absence of any provision for backing warrants, but this was supplied by 2 and 3 Vic.c. 71; I1 and 12 Vic.c. 42; II and 12 Vic.c. 43, and 42 and 43 Vic. c. 49. These statutes, added to 10 Geo. 1V.c. 44, placed our police upon its present footing. Part of their effect is to enable the Queen to establish thirteen police courts (in addition to Bow Street), and to appoint any number of magistrates up to twenty-seven; the chief magistrate with a salary of one thousand eight hundred pounds, the others one thou- sand five hundred pounds each. There are now fourteen courts, with Bow Street, but only twenty-six magistrates. ‘ Magnum vectigal est parsimonia”’ is an old liberal doctrine, but when Mr. Asquith,’ who isa scholar, recognizes that thrift is not parsi- mony, we may hope to see the end of a system which sends magistrates racing across country, from court to court, like the Jew in Beranger’s ballad, ‘‘ qu’un tourbillon toujours emporte,” leaving complainants and de- fendants to curse the false economy of an undermanned bench. The powers and duties of magistrates are derived in the first instance from the com- 1 This article was written in 1893. Lhe Green Bag. ey mission of the peace, which directs them to ‘‘keep the peace,” and “to keep and cause to be kept” all statutes for the main- tenance of the same, and to bind over or commit any person guilty of threats of as- sault or fire. In addition to this an ever increasing load, ‘‘tam immensus aliarum super alias acervaturum legum cumulus,” both ministerial and judicial, is laid upon them by the babblers at St. Stephen’s, upon whom, in a pious moment, the late Thomas Carlyle prayed that our ‘only general” might ‘‘ live to turn the key.” In indictable cases the magistrate’s duty is clear, to commit, if there is a prima facie case, although I have known so experienced a magistrate as Mr. Hannay tell a defendant that he had no doubt his intention was to defraud (which he had no right to say un- less he meant to commit), and then dismiss the charge on the ground that no jury would convict. One of the weakest parts of the system is the way in which depositions are taken. Statements are often put on the file which could never become evidence. Of course in indictable cases, such a thing can do little | harm beyond burdening the depositions uselessly ; but injustice is often caused by the omission of material facts. No means exist of compelling magistrates’ clerks, many of whom, as Sir James Hannen said of the present Attorney-General, ‘‘ sometimes seem to preside over the court,” to make a ‘note of anything which they may consider unim- portant. The consequence is that any wit- ness who may have made an inconvenient admission, and who finds that it is omitted from the depositions, to which he can have access at any time through his solicitor, ‘‘plucks up heart of grace” and repudiates it altogether. I have no wish to attack magistrates’ clerks. ‘They are an industrious and under- paid body. One, Mr. Martin, joint author of “‘ A Magisterial and Police Guide,” is an accomplished lawyer. But it must not be
Page 11
Ebenezer Rockwood Hoar. forgotten that while a barrister, to become a clerk, must be of fourteen years’ standing, although seven years are sufficient to qualify him for the bench, the post may be filled by a solicitor just admitted, and with no experience at all of criminal work. With regard to witnesses, a great deal of nonsense has been talked about their treat- ment by counsel and solicitors: To hear the dithyrambs of the press one would think we had returned to the days of Peach- am, ‘examined before torture, in torture, between torture and after torture.’ My own experience is that witnesses are quite able to take care of themselves. There is one class, the police, of which I ought to say a word in _ conclusion. They have been attacked as if they had 409 been born with a ‘‘double dose of orig- inal sin.” My experience is that they are much as other men are. No doubt they are inclined to make rather ample drafts on the | magisterial faith, which are, perhaps, hon- ored a little too readily. Possibly magis- trates feel that if they begin to doubt ‘anything, they may end, like Gibbon, by believing nothing. Of course it is obvious that, by making a man one of a class, with his chance of promotion depending upon his reputation as a smart officer, as well as upon the good will of his comrades, you give him a direct interest in securing a conviction and in supporting others in doing so. If I were asked for my advice, it would be that of Talleyrand, ‘“ Surtout pas trop de zéle.” EBENEZER ROCKWOOD HOAR. By Darwin E. Ware. N conscience, as on rock New England’s hills, His life was built. With reason’s inward sight He saw, as though from a cold mountain height, When the white day pure winter’s radiance fills. Hot with the wrath of justice, against ills Wrought out of wrong he waged a fearless fight, And stood unflinching for imperiled right, Freedom and country, — one who greatly wills. Sparkling his wit as beads of foaming wine, - But keen to pierce as pointed rapier blade ; Tender in heart, wise, cheerful to the end, To Concord’s soil as native as its vine, There with most precious dust New England laid The statesman, jurist, judge and steadfast friend. Atlantic Monthly.
Page 12
AIO Lhe Green Bag. IMPRISONMENT FOR DEBT. By BENJAMIN F. WasHER. ‘¢ Behind him stalks Another monster, not unlike himself, _ Sullen of aspect, by the vulgar called A catchpole, whose polluted hands the gods With haste incredible and magic chains Erst have endured. If he his ample palm Should haply on ill-fated shoulder lay Of debtor, strait his body, to the touch Obsequious (as whilom knights were wont), To some enchanted castle is conveyed, Where gates impregnable and coercive chains In durance strict detain him till, in form Of money, Pallas sets the captive free.” — Phillip’s Splendid Shilling. E, living in this country at the day when personal liberty has reached its highest culmination, and where every act — executive, judicial and legislative — is care- fully and scrupulously weighed in the balance of individual freedom, can hardly appreciate or fully understand the real meaning and com- plete significance of incarceration for debt. To layman and barrister imprisonment of this character is looked upon as one of the humors of modern legal proceedings. We have heard of wandering minstrels or stranded base-ballists languishing in ‘ castle keep ” on account of an unpaid obligation ; we have witnessed a transient guest within our city taken into custody for a previously contracted hotel account or cigar bill, and have from experience in a_ representative character come to know the end—the in- solvent debtor’s oath and liberation. But that this process was ever urged against citizens in all walks and stations of life; that every one who contracted a debt, or assumed a liability became amenable to a criminal prosecution in the event of default, and that nothing but a statement of an ac- count unliquidated was necessary to a con- finement in prison, and, perchance, death, seems to us as unlikely as it is repulsive. The principle at once impresses us as lack- ing in justice, as being deficient in equity, devoid of all morality and adverse to all policy. Nothing that one can imagine could so completely wreck commercial credit or un- dermine financial transactions as to hold not only the property of an individual sub- ject to his liabilities, but to give to a rapa- cious creditor the person of the debtor. It calls into the realm of the business world not only the commercial representative, it makes parties to contracts not only those who have entered into them, but it brings into those transactions the weeping wife, the hungry children and the sympathetic friends and relations of the one whom for- tune has denied the ability to pay. By this pernicious system the unfortunate are con- demned to further and more terrible misfor- tune and to the pangs and sufferings of poverty is added the sting of disgrace. The doctrine of imprisonment for debt is fallacious in its every particular. Under what theory a man unable to meet a matured liability will be rendered capable of liquidat- ing the same by being deprived of his freedom and facilities for work is more than modern intelligence can explain. The old lawyers and law makers sought to work out the problem through the medium of fraud. They claimed that he who assumed a monetary responsibility, and failed to meet the same, was guilty of perpetrating a fraud on his creditor. The case may have been wanting in all the elements of fraud. The motive may have been the purest, the inten- tions the most honest and fair, the efforts at payment the most strenuous and diligent, but if the final outcome was failure the transaction was fraudulent. What a techni- cally perverted meaning! To-day fraud in some aspects merits and receives incarcera-
Page 13
Imprisonment for Debt. tion, but it is only where the elements of criminality exist, and every unfortunate debtor is not branded a felon. Lig The history of imprisonment for debt forms an interesting but revolting chapter in the book of the law which can hardiy be employed to substantiate the eloquent Burke in his statement that law is ‘‘the col- lected reason of ages, combining the prin- ciple of eternal justice with the _ infinite variety of human concern.” The jurisprudence of Rome, of Greece, of England and even of America is blotted and stained with the pollution of its touch. In Greece, before the advent of Solon, arbitrary and absolute dominion over the life and liberty of a debtor was vested in the creditor. Refusal to pay meant condemnation to a life of the basest slavery. The creditor could take possession of his debtor’s person, yoke him to the oxen of the field or compel him to perform the most menial of household duties. The food and raiment of the poor insolvent was left to the discretion of the creditor, and many felt the scourge of hunger and the pains of exposure as well as the indignation aroused by insulting wealth and arrogance. In Rome, however, this debased practice developed with the greatest rapidity, and as- sumed the most alarming and cruel propor- tions. A Roman writer born about the first half of the second century of the Christian Era, in a compilation of facts, conditions and circumstances relating to the Roman Empire which he had observed or become familiar with through his stay at Attica or in Rome, gives the provision of the Twelve Tables in reference to incarceration for debt, or, as he terms it, “Legis actis per manus injec- tionem.” He puts the following statements in the mouth of a character in one of his works: — No account was ever asked of him. | AII taken before the magistrate, who consigned his body to the keeping and control of the creditor. The delinquent was thereupon taken to the house of his creditor, and there con- fined in chains of not over fifteen pounds weight for sixty days, during which time he was forced to live at his own cost, or accept whatever the generosity of the creditor saw fit to allow him. | | ‘When the sixty days had passed, the debtor was conveyed to the marketplace be- fore the praetor, and his debts proclaimed for three consecutive days. If avindex ap- peared for him, he was liberated. This in- tervener was a third person, who came for- ward, attacked the claim and. judgment as invalid, and agreed to pay double the amount of the indebtedness if he should not prove it so. ‘Tf no vindex presented himself, the per- son of the debtor was again placed in the custody of the creditor, who could dispose of him as a generous or cruel impulse might dictate. He could inflict on him the death penalty, or send him to a life of misery and bondage beyond the Tiber. In the event two or more creditors prosecuted their claim to judgment at the same time, like proceed- ings were had in all the cases, and the two _ reprieves bringing no settlement of the de- “Ifa magistrate decree judgment against | a party for admitted money, the judgment debtor had thirty days in which to settle. mands, the body of the debtor was divided amongst them according to the amounts of their respective demands.”’ If this account be true, the practice, for diabolicalness, finds no parallel in the history of the world. Men have, in the insanity engendered by intense religious enthusiasm, committed deeds of blood at which we shud- der, but the barbarity of their acts becomes insignificant when compared to an officer of justice, calmly and in the performance of the duty imposed on him by the positive law of the land, condemning a man to be quartered, and the reeking parts to be de- livered to the Shylocks who stood ready to receive their portion in return for a few At the expiration of this time he was again | pieces of silver.
Page 14
AI2 Imprisonment for debt in England, besides being a depraved and deformed offspring of the English law, at the same time offers a striking example of judicial usurpation; of the courts taking unto themselves authority unwarranted by law, and asserting a power neither vested by statute nor sanctioned by policy. The power exercised was the result of the gradual encroachment upon the rights of the people by the judges of the past act- ing through the medium of misconstruction and misinterpretation of the law and aided by that most efficacious of processes —a legal fiction. It represents the power of precedent, good or bad, and of pernicious principles established by the judiciary, being finally sanctioned by legislative enactment. Until the reign of Henry II, imprison- ment for debt had no being in the English law. During the reign of that monarch the power of the barons asserted itself, and Par- liament passed an act authorizing the feudal lords to imprison tenants for duties unper- formed or taxes unpaid. Insulted by this display of Parliamentary favoritism, the mer- chants demanded that a like privilege be vested in them, under pain of deserting the government if their request was not granted. Such a claim so potently urged could not be » disregarded, and the rights of the masses - were again ignored to appease this compar- atively small portion of the community. The courts acting on these special grants of power, every case presented was con- _ strued with an intellect perverted by a desire of self aggrandizement and a conscience stunted by servile dependency. Any case prosecuted by a plaintiff of influence or pres- tige was held to come within the scope of the statute, which was given an interpreta- tion liberal at times to the extent of being entirely ignored. Parliament had not the temerity to so trample upon the rights of the individual, but the judiciary having blazed the way, the legislative function progressed another step in the direction of universal application of The Green Bag. the rule authorizing imprisonment for debt, and therefore passed an act extending this method of enforcing satisfaction of claims to all obligations of debt (in its narrow common law meaning) and detinue. It was again the courts’ time for action and, emboldened by the success of their former encroachment, they proceeded to apply the practice to all cases and controversies in which the remedy was sought. The various legal tribunals adopted different means of accomplishing the result. The King’s Bench, exercising criminal jurisdiction, held that a debtor re- fusing to satisfy an obligation was a dis- turber of the peace and a violator of the in- tendment of the statute, and hence ordered his confinement. The Court of Common Pleas came to the conclusion that the ordinary process of the court was insufficient to meet the exigencies of certain cases, and invented the bill of Mid- dlesex and Latitat under which the debtor was first taken into custody, and the court, through this medium, secured the appear- ance and, subsequently, jurisdiction over the person of the party. The Court of Excheq- uer worked out the problem by resorting to sophistry of this character. The creditor was debtor to the king, and one refusing to meet liabilities accruing to the creditor ren- dered him less able to perform his obliga- tions to the crown, and, as the dignity of the treasury had above all things to be upheld, the process of imprisonment was granted the creditor in order to coerce the payment of demands due him. ‘The courts having thus developed the system in all its completeness and entirety, the legislature, during the reign of Henry VIII, feeling itself in a position to pass a general law providing for impris- onment for debt without incurring the right- eous indignation and just condemnation of the people, gave to the action of the judi- ciary the sanction of parliamentary enact- ment. Since then public opinion in Eng- land has greatly modified the harshness of this remedy, but it still prevails in that coun-
Page 15
Imprisonment for Debt. 413 try to an extent that reflects rather severely on its civilization and culture. Statistics show that during the past year no less than six thousand poor insolvents have been con- fined in prison for debts unpaid, ranging in amount from three shillings to twenty-five pounds. In America, strange as the fact may ap- pear, the practice also throve. The creditors, usually a wealthy and influential class in the community, favored the importation of the law from England. The legislatures of the various states as well as Congress vested the court$ with power to employ the proceeding in the enforcement of a money demand. The punishment provided for was slight, but, mild as it was, it was taking liberty when property alone had been contracted for, and soon became obnoxious. The first blow struck at the iniquity was in the halls of Congress. In 1832 a measure was proposed in the Senate abolishing all imprisonment for debt under process of a federal court, and, be it said to the fame and glory of our na- tional legislature, the bill was passed. Here the reform began. The debate and discus- sion that the measure engendered stimulated the various state legislatures to thought upon the subject. It aroused the people to the evils and injustice of the practice, and im- pressed upon all the necessity for a change in the law of the states governing the sub- ject. The masses of men, or the representatives of the masses are not often wilfully or know- ingly unjust or despotic, and when the system of incarceration for debt was presented in its true aspect and the science and theory of the law made manifest, its abolition was inevita- ble. State after state either wiped the law from the statute book or modified it so ma- | terially that it could work no hardship. And to-day America has virtually thrown off this legal leech, which sucks the blood of the body corporate, and must eventually para- lyze the community or nation that permits ,it to live and flourish. A proposition of this character should be considered theoretically. \To argue theory is often to explode a fallacy; to talk practice is apt to sanction error—the theory of im- prisonment for debt is this: A having am- ple facilities of discovering B’s present con- dition and future possibilities, advances him, on the faith of these, a sum of money. B by an unfortunate investment loses the money, or otherwise becomes unable to repay the sum borrowed. What is the natural conclu- sion?. Simply this: A has entered into a transaction with his eyes open, being in no way compelled to lend B money, but, satis- fied that B will liquidate the demand, sup- plied him with funds. Subsequent events develop the fact that he erred, and, like most errors in the business world, the result has been a pecuniary loss. To most sound- minded men this would seem reasonable and just, but the advocates of the principle say, ‘“No, A has suffered a loss at B’s hands; it is true through no intentional wrong of B, but yet B is liable to make good the amount.” Therefore, as a consideration is a benefit to one or a disadvantage to the other, and as A cannot secure the benefit by reason of B’s insolvency, therefore the other alternative of the proposition must be applied and B put under the decided disadvantage of depriva- tion of liberty and loss of reputation. We must. presume that this is the reason- ing urged in behalf of the system, and it needs but be stated to be pronounced falla- cious in its every particular.
Page 16
A414 | Lhe Green Bag. OUR LINCOLN. 4 By BENONI—BENJAMIN. Fae voice of prophecy was his: A criszs ts at hand; A house divided ’gainst itself cannot divided stand ; One tendency must bind the parts to make the Union strong ; The confitct’s trrepressible between the right and wrong. Through mists that dimmed so many eyes how clearly he discerned That every man has right to eat the bread his hand has earned. When days were darkest, his the faith, so simple yet sublime, That somehow God would lift the weight from all men in due time. He led us onward step by step, slow too when we were slow, But when we turned toward freedom’s goal, struck freedom’s grandest blow. Back through the years fourscore and more he saw the fathers’ plan — A Nation whose chief corner-stone should be the Rights of Man. And then he saw thick clouds and darkness cover all the land, And heard the awful silence that presaged the storm at hand. And when the war-god sped the lightning ‘cross the southern sky, He raised the fathers’ flag above the fathers’ house full high, And to the Northlands blew a bugle-note so loud and clear, That all the Northlands heard it and responded with one cheer. They came by thousands at his call, the Nation’s life to ive: By thousands, too, the last full measure of devotion gave. And at his bidding, by the graves of our heroic slain, We made the high resolve: 7hese dead shall not have died in vain ; This Nation, under God, shall have of freedom a new birth ; Self government — the people's — shall not perish from the earth. For years, how fondly did we hope, how frevently all pray, That speedily the mighty scourge of war might pass away. In vain our hope and prayer: A great offence we must atone; God wills that nations too must reap the harvest they have sown ; All sunk must be the wealth piled up by unrequited torl ; For all the blood drawn with the lash our blood must drench the soil;
Page 17
Our Lincoln. AIS — The judgments of the Lord are true, He's righteous in Fts wrath ; Fle gives no peace until the sword of justice hews the path. Thus had our Lincoln pondered o’er the cause of all our woe, When he with the occasion rose and struck the fateful blow. With faith that right makes might, he felled disunion’s upas-tree ; — In giving freedom to the slave, saved freedom for the free. Thenceforth were we thrice armed; we had, though still beneath the rod, The judgment of mankind and favor of Almighty God. At Gettysburg the tide of Southern valor reached its height, And spent its crimson surges ’gainst the rock of Northern might. Again the Father of Waters went unvexed unto the coast ; And from Atlanta to the sea Old Glory led our host. The dove of peace went forth once more above the waters dree ; At Appomattox found her quest beneath the apple-tree. And then, a lasting peace assured — with malice toward none, Nay more, with charity for all—our Lincoln’s work was done. And as he stood on Pisgah’s mount and saw the whole land free, Death came and crowned him with the crown of immortality. The mystic chords of patriot love touched by 4zs spirit hand, The chorus of the Union swell all over this broad land. From Plymouth Rock to Golden Gate, from lakelands to the bar, We greet one flag with star for state,—free state for every star.
Page 18
416 The Green Bag. THE ENGLISH LAW COURTS. IV. THE CHANCERY DIVISION. HE Chancery Division of the High Court of Justice is the legitimate de- scendant of that hoary sinner, the old Court of Chancery, whose misdeeds Dickens so graphically described in *t Bleak House.” A sketch of the origin and history of this venerable tribunal is a necessary prelude to an account of its offspring, and a series of brief biographies of the leading expon- ents of equity juris- prudence in England. The common law of England at a com- paratively early stage in its history acquired the rigidity of a jus strictum. Ifthe study of the civil law had been as prevalent and as thorough in this country as it was in France, Scotland and elsewhere, this defect — would doubtless have been avoided or alleviated, by the adoption of the devices whereby the Roman law obviated the necessity for any distinction between common and equity. But unhappily the Roman law was under a cloud in England just at the very time when the common law most needed its assistance. The pretensions of the Holy Roman See to exercise jurisdiction over the national church of England had made men intolerant of every form of Roman influence. And ac- cordingly England’s jurisprudence was left to work out its own salvation from the | I YJ = BA AMA { iy , law SIR THOMAS MORE. bonds of the common law. The difficulties against which it had to contend were very serious ones. The fixity of the principles of the common law was bad enough; but to this was added an inflexible, cum- brous procedure, fail- ure to comply with which, orto fall within whose purview, was fatal to the most righteous claim. The evil, as we have hint- ed, manifested itself in two forms. Every species of civil wrong was assumed to come within a few particu- lar classes, for each of which an appropriate writ or dreve existed. A litigant might se- lect the wrong breve ; or the injury of which he complained might be one for which no breve existed. In eith- er case he was liable to be left without re- dress. The former of these contingencies was ultimately met by the Common Law Procedure Act of 1852, under which it became unnecessary for a plaintiff to men- tion any form of action in his writ of sum- mons. The latter was dealt with at a much earlier stage in English history, and the statute dealing with it holds an_ impor- tant place in the development of English equity jurisprudence. The statute in ques- tion, the zz consimil: casu— 13 Edward I, stat. I, cap. 24, 11 — provided that ‘ when- soever from henceforth it shall fortune in the
Page 19
The Englhsh Law Courts. chancery” (from which by the way the ori- ginal common law writs were issued), “that in one case a writ is found and in like case (<n consimili casu) falling under like law and requiring like remedy none is found, the clerks in chancery shall agree in making the writ, or the plaintiff may adjourn it until the next parliament, and the cases in which the clerks cannot agree are to be written and re- ferred by them unto the next parliament, and by agreement of men learned in the law a writ is to be made lest it should happen that the court should long time fail to minister justice un- to complainant.” Here we have the beginning of a sort of equitable interference withthe common law. But the statute zz consimtle casu proved abortive. In the first place the judges in many cases refused to recognize the writs issued by the clerks in chancery. In the second place,the mul- tiplication of new forms of action was | | PHILIP, EARL OF HARDWICKE. too rapid and too complex for the clerks — in chancery to grapple with, accordingly | the practice petitioning the sovereign in council for re- dress, where other relief could not be had. The sovereign, too deeply occupied with the high things of foreign policy to find time to overtake such petitions, referred them to their chancellors, and in the reign of Edward III (ordinance of 22 Edward f/f) the Court of Chancery was firmly established as a permanent jurisdiction, se- grew up among suitors of | 417 empowered to grant relief in cases where common law remedies were not available. We cannot here enter into minute details as to the development of procedure in the old Court of Chancery. The original course was for a suitor to present his bill or petition to the chancellor, who perused it, and if he thought the case was one for extraordinary relief, a writ of swbpoena was issued by his order in the king’s name, calling upon the defendant to ap- pear in chancery, an- swer the complaint and abide by the order of the court. In time a _ personal examination of the bill or petition by the chancellor was dis- pensed with, — the signature of counsel to it being accepted as a guarantee that the case was one in which the immediate issue of a writ of szd- poena should be au- thorized. In 1852 a further change was introduced. The chancery jurisdiction | act passed in that year superseded the writ of subpoena by the mere endorsement of the substance of the writ on a copy of the bill or petition served on the defendant. In this way the bill or petition became the first step or pleading in a chancery suit. Under the Judicature Acts, 1873-75, law and equity were fused: it was provided that in every civil cause or matter, not particu- larly mentioned, they should be administered concurrently, and that where there was any conflict or variance between the rules of the two systems, the rules of equity should pre- parate from the court of common law, and | vail, and the Court of Chancery was merged
Page 20
418 in the Chancery Division. At the present time the Chancery Division has a practically exclusive jurisdiction over the following matters: (1) administrations; (2) the dis- solution of partnerships and the taking of partnership and other accounts; (3) the re- demption and foreclosure of mortgages ; (4) the raising of portions and other charges on land; (5) the sale and distribution of the proceeds of prop- erty, subject to any lien or charge; (6) the execution of trusts, charitable and private; (7) the rec- tification, the setting aside, and the cancel- lation of deeds and other written instru- ments; (8) the spe- cific performance of contracts between vendors and purchas- ers of real estate, in- cluding contracts for leases; (9) the par- tition or sale of real estate, and (10) the wardship of infants and the care of in fants’ estates. The Chancery Di- vision has now also, as we have seen, a concurrent jurisdiction with law, in all matters whatsoever, subject to the provisions of the judicature acts. Some accounts of the defects of the old Court of Chancery and of the working of the modern Chancery Division will be given incidentally in the course of the biographical sketches which we now proceed to attempt of a few of the leading Lord Chancellors, Vice-Chan- cellors, and Judges of these tribunals LORD CHANCELLORS. Cardinal Wolsey, Sir Thomas More, and the other ecclesiastical Chancellors — not LORD THURLOW. The Green Bag. to speak of Francis Bacon—belong too largely to general English history to ren- der any notices of them here desirable — we may commence with LORD NOTTINGHAM. Heneage Finch, the Earl of Nottingham, and “The Father of English Equity,” was born December 23, 1621. Educated at Westminster School and Christ Church, Oxford, he joined the Inner Temple, in 1638, and was called | to the bar in 1645. He soon acquired a large practice, as any- one who refers to “ Siderfin’s Reports ”’ will see at a glance. One of his miost famous forensic ap- pearances was in 1659, for Mr. Street, who had:been return- ed for Worcester to the parliament of Richard Cromwell, son of the great Pro- tector, and was pe- titioned against on the ground that he had borne arms as a cavalier. Finch was known at the bar as ‘the silver-tongued lawyer” (a title which was revived in our own time in the person of the late Lord Chief-Justice of England), and ‘‘the English Cicero.” He rose to the highest legal office in the state with great rapidity. In 1660 he received the solicitor- generalship and the honor of a baronetcy. In 1670 he became Attorney-General. In 1673 he received the Great Seal, and held it at first as Lord Keeper and afterwards as Lord Chancellor, till his death in 1682. He was made Earl of Nottingham in 1681.
Page 21
The English In regard to Nottingham’s character, abil- ities and judicial work there can be but one opinion. In private life he was a model of all the virtues. The foul and venomous tongue of Restoration. society could lay nothing to his charge. He was the patron of literature and learning. In the words of Blackstone he was ‘‘endued with a pervad- ing genius that enabled him to discover and pursue the true spirit of justice notwith- standing the embar- rassments raised by the narrow and tech- nical notions which then prevailed in the courts of law, and the imperfect ideas of redress which had possessed the courts of equity. The reas- on and necessities of mankind arising from the great change in property, by the ex- tension of trade and the abolition of mili- ‘tary tenures, co-oper- ated in establishing his plan, and enabled him in the course of nine years to build a system of jurispru- dence and _ jurisdic- tion upon wide and rational foundations,” North, the culogist of his successor Guilford, described Notting- ham as a formalist and a hairsplitter. But a perusal of his decisions will satisfy anyone that this charge is unfounded‘ and that he always endeavored to decide cases on prin- ciples which—to use his own words-— “might stand with the reason of mankind when debated abroad.” We owe to him the * See anexcellent account of Nottingham in D. M. Kerly’s “istory of Equity, a work which well deserves to have a transatlantic reputation. Law Courts. 419 settlement of the leading doctrine of equity, in regard to trusts, and the enactment of the statute of Frauds, directed against the en- forcement of verbal contracts, the validity of verbal conveyances of interests in land, the creation of trusts of land without writing, and the allowance of nuncupative wills. ‘In modern times, says Mr. Kerly, in the able work already referred to, “this statute has not infrequently been decried, especially so far as it restricts the verbal proof of con- tracts, but in estimat- ing its value and operation at the time it became law, it must be remembered that the evidence of the parties to an ac- | tion at law could not then be received, and the defendant might have been charged on the uncorroborat- ed statement of a single witness, which he was not then al- lowed to contradict, as Lord Eldon argued many years © after- wards, when the ac- tion upon the case for fraud was introduced atlaw. It was there- fore a most reasonable precaution while this unreasonable rule continued to lay down the rule that the defendant should be charged only upon writing, signed by him.” EARL OF HARDWICKE. Philip Yorke, Earl of Hardwicke, was the son of a lawyer, who filled the office of Town Clerk of Dover, and was born in 1690. He was educated at a school at Bethnal Green,
Page 22
_ desired. He was soon ed to Parliament as ~ to the solicitor-gen- A420 The Green Bag. where he gave the highest promise of future eminence, was afterwards placed for several years in the office of a well known attorney, Mr. Salkeld, brother of the famous Sergeant whose ‘“‘ Reports” are in every good English law library; and was called to the bar of: the Middle Temple in 1715. Before his call, he had made the acquaintance of Lord Macclesfield, Chief Justice of the oe Bench, and the friend- ship of this distin- guished man, togeth- er with his own fami- ly’s legal influence, speedily gave him the introduction to private professional practice which was all that he needed or recognized as a rising figure at the bar. In 1719 he was return- member for Lewes. In 1720 he was raised eralship and the hon- or of knighthood. In 1724 —at the age of thirty-four ! — he be- came Attorney-Gen- eral. In1733 he was made Chief Justice of the King’s Bench, and as Lord Hardwicke, in 1737 he was appointed Lord Chancellor ~ —an office which he held till 1756 — hav- ing in the mean time (1754), been created Earl of Hardwicke and Viscount Royston. He died on 6th March, 1764. Hardwicke had the misfortune to have many bitter enemies, some disclosed, others anonymous, and they unhappily supplied the materials out of which his biographies have been written. Horace Walpole charges him with baseness, and asserts that ‘in the LORD HATHERLEY. House of Lords he was laughed at, in the Cabinet despised.” An anonymous corres- pondent of Mr. Cooksey, who published a sketch of him in 1791, has gathered with malicious industry every story and piece of idle gossip to his discredit on which he could lay his hands; and Lord Campbell, who was © always ready to accept scandal without sift- ing it, has relied too much upon these writers. Lord Chesterfield gives a juster estimate of Hardwicke’s char- acter, saying that “he was never in the least suspected of any kind of corruption,” that “he was an agree- able, eloquent speak- er in Parliament,’’ and “that he was a cheer- ful, instructive com- panion, humane in his nature, decent in his manners, and un- stained by any vice (except avarice).” Even the charge of avarice resting on. such testimony is not very formidable. This opprobrious term is apt to be ap- plied to a man who, having no great pri- vate resources; hus- bands his profession- al income with care. The Earl of Hard- wicke’s memory is now cleared, however, from the reproaches which some of his contempo- raries heaped upon it. His private character stands as Lord Chesterfield described it, minus the avarice. His personal qualities and attractions were thus not less accurately than elegantly summed up by Savage : — ‘s Were all, like Yorke, of delicate address, Strength to discern, and sweetness to express, Learned, just, polite, born every heart to gain.”
Page 23
The English -_— As a public prosecutor, in an age of sedition and political unrest, he was conspicuous for his fairness. Both in the House of Commonps and in the House of Lords, he exercised im- mense influence over the minds of his col- leagues and fellow members. He acted as a great conciliatory force, not only in the Cabinet, but in his relation with the Crown. Sir George Jessel considered him to have been the greatest equity lawyer that ever held the seals, putting Lord Cairns second, and Lord Eldon in a rather low place. Hard- wicke’s chief defect as Chancellor was his habit of requiring cases to be reargued, and of postponing indefinitely the delivery ‘of his judgments. A still worse eminence in this bad practice was obtained by Lord Eldon. It became a fruitful source of those arrears which have harassed and discredited the work of subsequent Chancery judges so seriously. In the time of Hardwicke there was a strong movement among equity law- yers in favor of greater definiteness in the — the Dean of his college, he left it with the principles on which the Court of Chancery acted, and he did his best at once to encour- age this movement and to confine it with- in proper limits. ‘Some general rules,” he said, ‘‘there ought to be, for otherwise the great inconvenience of jus vagum et incer- tum will follow, but yet the praetor must not be so absolutely and invariably bound by them as the judges are by the rules of the common law, for if he were so bound... he must pronounce decrees which would be materially unjust, since no rule can be equally just in the application to a whole class of cases that are far from being the same in every circumstance. This might lay a founda- tion for an equitable relief even against decrees in equity and create a kind of super- fectation of courts of equity.” The most noteworthy of Hardwicke’s decisions are Chesterfield v. Janssen, in which he analyzes the various kinds of frauds against which equity would relieve, and Penn v. Baltimore, a case described by Hardwicke himself as ‘“worthy the judicature of a Roman senate Law Courts. A21 rather than of a single judge,” in which he held that it was within the jurisdiction of the court to grant specific performance of an agreement as to real property situate in America, comprising two provincial govern- ments and three counties. LORD THURLOW. Edward Thurlow was the son of an Eng- lish rector. Born at Ashfield, in Suffolk, in 1732, he was educated at King’s School, Canterbury, and Caius College, at Cam- bridge, from whose books, to avoid expul- sion, he was obliged to withdraw his name in 1751. The incident which led to this denouement was amusing and characteristic. As a punishment for some act of insubor- dination, Thurlow was told to translate a paper of the Sfectator into Greek. He per- formed his task, but instead of taking his — pencil theme, as he ought to have done, to tutor. The Dean called upon him for an explanation, whereupon Thurlow stated that he had acted not disrespectfully, but with a compassionate desire to save the Dean from being puzzled. In fairness to Thurlow it. should be recorded that he afterwards made the amende honorable for this and other de- linquencies. When he became Chancellor he sent for his old superior, and on his entering the room where he was, said, adopting an insolent query of his under- craduate days, ‘‘ How d’ye do, Mr. Dean?” ‘My lord,” was the answer, ‘“‘ 1 am not now a Dean, and do not deserve the title.” ‘ But you are a Dean,” Thurlow replied, handing him a paper of nomination, ‘“‘and so con- vinced am I that you will do honor to the appointment, that I am sorry any part of © my conduct should have given offence to so good a man.” 7 Thurlow was called to the bar in 1754, and joined the Home Circuit. Although he gained considerable credit and a little prac-
Page 24
A22 The Green Bag. tice by the success with which he put down Sir Fletcher Norton, then the bully of the bar, in the case of Luke Robinson v. the Earl of Winchilsea, a chance conversation with an attorney in a debating-club, which procured him a brief in the Douglas Peer- age case, is the circumstance to which his In 1768, Thur- rise is generally attributed. low, who had taken silk six years before, became member for Tamworth. In 1770, he was made Solici- tor-General. In the following year he was appointed Attorney- General. The lead- ing cases that he con- ducted, or assisted in conducting, as Law Officer of the Crown, were the prosecutions of Almon, Woodfull, and Miller, for pub- lishing Junius’ letter to the King, of the Duchess of Kingston for bigamy, and of Horne Tooke (who ever afterwards bore towards him a male- volent and unfounded hatred) for libel. In 1778, Thurlow, raised to the peerage as Baron Thurlow of Ashfield, succeeded Lord Bathurst as Chancellor, and held this office till his double dealings with the opposition compelled Pitt to insist on his removal. He died on September 12, 1806, at Brighton, and was buried in the Temple Church, in London. For some time after his entrance into the House of Lords, Thurlow was re- garded by his brother peers with antipathy, partly as a zovus homo, it may be, but chiefly because of the insolence, brutality and frequency of his attacks upon them. On overt) LORD CAIRNS, one occasion the Duke of Grafton, stung into indignation by Thurlow’s observations, com- mented on his plebeian origin. The sequel is well told by Mr. Fox (English Judges, p. 662), quoting from Butler’s Reminiscences. ‘His lordship rose from the woolsack and advanced slowly to the place from which the Chancellor generally addresses the house, then fixing upon the Duke a look of lower- ing indignation, ‘I am amazed,’ he said, ‘at His Grace’s speech. The noble Duke can- not look before him, behind him, or on either side of him, without seeing some noble peer who owes his seat in this house to his successful ex- ertions in the profess- ion towhich I belong. Does he not feel that itis as honorable to owe it to these as to being the accident of an accident? To all these noble lords the language of the noble Duke is as applicable and as insulting as it is to myself. But I don’t fear to stand single and alone. No one venerates the peerage more than I do. But, my lords, I must say that the peerage solicited me, not I the peerage. Nay more, I can say, and will say, that as a peer of Parliament, as Speaker of this honorable house, as Keeper of the Great Seal, as guar- dian of His Majesty’s conscience, as Lord High Chancellor of England, nay even in that character alone in which this noble Duke would think it an affront to be con- sidered, but which character none can deny me, as a wan, | am at this moment as res-
Page 25
The English Law Courts. pectable, and beg leave to add, I am at this time as much respected, as the proudest peer-I now look down upon.’” It is painful to be obliged to remark that in spite of these high self-encomia, Thurlow was not politically honest, and no one re- gretted his downfall. As a judge he relied too much on the industry of Hargrave, to whom many of his most elaborate decisions were due. But he was, for all that, a strong and competent Chancellor. In the case of Fox v. Mackreth, he laid the foundation of the doctrine that no person in a fiduciary position is entitled to deal for his own ad- vantage with the subject of his trust. In Ackroyd v. Smithson, he developed the doctrine of ‘ conversion,” while we owe to him that ‘‘ restraint on anticipation,” which so many settlements still impose as a fetter on the freedom of married women in dealing with their separate estate. Thurlow had a stern and rugged appearance, and bushy eye-brows, whose conjoint effect, in the language of Charles James Fox, made him “look wiser than any man ever was.” <A redeeming point in his. character was his affection for the gentle and retiring poet Cowper. LORD ELDON. John Scott, Earl of Eldon, the son of a coal ‘‘ fitter” in Newcastle-on-Tyne, and the brother of the great Lord Stowell, was born 1751. He was educated first at the New- castle Grammar School under the Rev. Hugh Moises, who did not neglect the caution of the preacher against sparing the rod; and afterwards at Oxford, where he was elected to a fellowship in 1767, and graduated as B.A. in 1770, In 1771 he gained Lord Lichfield’s prize for the best prose essay on ‘““The advantages and disadvantages of for- eign travel.” In the following year he carried off another prize in the shape of Elizabeth Surtees. 423 This success was not at first highly appre- ciated by the parents of either party. But the couple were ultimately forgiven, and Scott entered the Middle Temple as a can-_ didate for admission to the bar. He was called in February, 1776, and at first devoted himself to circuit and common law’ work; but failing to make much impression on the court of King’s Bench he soon transferred himself to the chancery side, where he made his mark by the preparation of an argument which had the good fortune to secure the assent of Lord Thurlow, in the case of Ack- royd v. Smithson. The success with which he argued the Clitheroe election case was, however, the determining point in his career. He rose rapidly in professional favor and repute; and in 1783 became member of Parliament for Weobly. In 1787 he was ap- pointed Chancellor of Durham. In the fol- lowing year Mr. Pitt made him Solicitor- General. In 1793 he succeeded to the at- torney-generalship and was charged with the conduct of the state prosecution, in- stituted against Hardy, Horne Tooke, and the other democrats whose revolutionary in- stincts, aroused by the stirring events which were in progress in France, led ‘them perii- ously near the edge of high treason in Eng- land. It was on the occasion of these trials that Scott laid down the doctrine of ‘‘Con- structive Treason,’ which is familiar to all constitutional lawyers. His speeches will be found in Howell’s ‘‘ State Trials,’ and are eminently worthy of being studied. In 1799 his reward reached him. He was made Chief-Justice of the Common Pleas in place of Sir James Eyre, as Baron Eldon, and in the summer of 1801 accepted the Great Seal, which he held with various in- terruptions till 1827. He became Earl of Eldon in 1821, and died in 1838. Eldon’s political career as Lord Chancellor fills a large part of the history of his days. He was one of the old school of Tories, to whomevery change in administration andeach concession of political freedom or privilege ©
Page 26
424 spelt revolution. He opposed the repeal of | the Test and Corporation Acts, the emanci- pation of the Romans Catholics and the Re- | form Bill with equal bigotry and honesty, and the resolute zo possumus which he op- posed to all the movements of his day con- tributed largely to the defeat and disintegra- tion of the Tory party. As a judge he is entitled to the high credit of having strength- ened the growing fixi- ty of the principles of equity. ‘The doc- trines of this court,” he himself said in Gee v. Pritchard (2 Swan, 414), ‘ought to be as well settled and as uniform almost as those of the com- mon law, laying down fixed principles, but taking care that they are to be applied ac- cording to the cir- cumstances of each case. I cannot agree that the doctrines of this court are to be changed by every succeeding judge. Nothing would inflict on me greater pain than the recollection that I had done any- . thing to justify the reproach, that the equity of this court varies like the chancellor’s foot.” This reproach certainly cannot be laid at Eldon’s door; what he may, however, be LORD SELBORNE, justly charged with, is the fostering if not the parentage of that terrible accumulation ed. of arrears of which the equity judges are > only now getting rid. We have already | noticed Lord Hardwicke’s contributions to | the increase of this malign brood. Lord | Eldon was an even greater sinner. “It is unnecessary,” says Mr. Kerly (wubz sup. 270), ‘to dwell upon the complaints made Lhe Green Bag. inthe House of Commons and in the press of the day of the number of causes waiting after hearing for Lord Eldon’s judgment, of cargoes rotting while he considered to whom they belonged, and of frantic appeals from ruined families, that some end might be put to the fatal continuance of their suits... The facts are indisputable that a common administration suit, where the parties were not hostile, took from three to five years; that eminent counsel stated that no man could begin a contest- ed suit and hope to see its end; that cli- ents were advised to compromise good claims and to plead to bad ones rather than risk a suit, and that on the average causes took at least three years to reach the top of the list after they were ready forhearing. The de- lay after the causes were ready for hear- ing were the worst delays of all.” In order that we may overtake as many occupants ‘of the woolsack as possible, we shall treat the remaining Lord Chancellors, whose names, even at the cost of some repetition, call for notice in this paper, in a somewhat more cursory style than we have hitherto adopt- Thomas Wilde, Lord Truro, the brother of Lord Penzance, the second son of a Lon- don attorney, was born in 1782, educated at St. Paul’s School, and called to the bar of the Inner Temple in 1817. Overcoming by unremitting perseverance an impediment in his speech (a defect, by the way from which curiously enough Sir William Erle
Page 27
The English also suffered), he gained a footing at the bar by his appearance as junior counsel for the defence in Queen Caroline’s case, and rose with remarkable rapidity through the usual grades of professional distinction to the woolsack. He was a most patient, com- petent, and enlightened judge. He died in 1865. Robert Monsey Rolfe, Baron Cranworth (1790-1868), did his most distinguished judicial work as a Baron of the Court of Ex- chequer. He held the Great Seal from 1852 to 1858, and again on the resignation of Lord Westbury, from. 1865 to 1867. He,was a Liberal in politics. His death in 1868 was attributable to the phenomenal heat of the weather. He died without issue. Frederick Thesiger, Lord Chelmsford, was the seventh son of Charles Thesiger, Collec- tor of Customs in the island of St. Vincent, and was born in London in 1794. He'was educated at Greenwich, and before betaking himself to the law served as a midshipman at the bombardment of Copenhagen. He was at first designed for the West India Bar, and joined the society of Gray’s Inn merely with a view to acquiring the formal degree of barrister at law. But the pleader in whose chambers he read strongly advised him to try his fortune in London first. A\l- though hopeless of success, Thesiger hear- kened to his counsellor, and commenced his career as an English barrister in the end of 1818. His unfavorable expectations were disappointed. He picked up some briefs at sessions; then he made a good appearance in defending Hunt, who was tried along with the infamous Thurtell (the author of the modern English scaffold) in 1824, for the murder of Mr. Weare, and in 1832 won a ereat ejectment case at Chelmsford —a vic- tory from which he derived his title, and which he always considered to be his palm- ary triumph. Probably outside critics would assign this place to his cross-examination of the forger Provis in the Smyth estate case. Thesiger became successively Solicitor- Law Courts. A25 General (1844), Attorney-General (1845), on the death of Sir William Webb Follett — an infinitely greater Jawyer—and Lord Chancellor as Baron Chelmsford in 1858, under Lord Derby’s ministry. The most in- teresting event in his subsequent career was his being passed over by Mr. Disraeli, in 1868, for the Chancellorship, in favor of Lord Cairns. ‘He dismissed me,” Chelms- ford said, speaking of the Conservative Pre- mier, ‘with no greater ceremony that if I had been his butler.” Chelmsford’s friends raised a great outcry over this dismissal, and it is still sometimes ignorantly spoken of as ajob. In point of fact, however, Mr. Dis- raeli knew what he was about and acted with perfect propriety. Although a facile and pleasing speaker and a fairly valuable poli- tical henchman, Chelmsford was not the kind of Chancellor that Disraeli needed. The Conservative party were weak in the country and in the House of Lords, and their leader required a representative in that House who would do his work not only com- petently, but supremely well. No man with such an end to attain could hesitate for a single moment between Chelmsford and Cairns. Chelmsford was in his seventy- fourth year, and he was only an average debater, an average politician, an average lawyer, and an average man. Cairns was only forty-eight; he was a debater of the highest ability ; he was a statesman as well as a politician; he was, in Disraeli’s own lan- guage, “great in counsel’; as a lawyer he has had no equal in the present century, ex- cept Jessel, and he was also naturally a man of the greatest force and breadth of charac- ter. It is ridiculous to impute unworthy motives to Mr. Disraeli when reasons of such solidity and sufficiency for his promotion of Lord Cairns over Lord Chelmsford’s head can be given. | Lord Campbell (1781-1861) need not long detain us here. The story of his life is familiar to everybody. The son of an established church minister in Fife, he began
Page 28
426 his course at the bar in 1806 as a reporter, making a few odd extra professional guineas as dramatic critic to the ‘ Morning Chron- icle.” A marriage with Mary Scarlett, daughter of the future Lord Abinger, Lord Chief Baron of the Exchequer, gave an im- petus to his career, and he followed his pre- decessors through the grades of honor which lead to the woolsack, deviating from the or- dinary triumphal paths only to pick up the Lord Chancellor- ship of Ireland and Lord Chief- Justice- ship of the Queen’s Bench by the way. It was as Chief-Jus- tice that Campbell did his best work. But he succeeded as well in his Chancel- lorship as an industri- ous, competent com- mon lawyer could hopeto do. His zzsz prius reports contain Lord Ellenborough’s decisions, the lives of the Chief-Justices and the Chancellors, which, in Wetherell’s language, ‘‘added a new terror to death,” are his only magna opera. Hewas found dead in his chair on the morning of Sunday, June 24, 1861. He had always wished to die suddenly, and his prayer was granted. The puisne judgeships of the Chancery Division have in our own time been occupied by many interesting — figures. Perhaps the most picturesque of these was the last of the Vice-Chancellors — Sir James Bacon. An acute though not extremely accurate lawyer, he will be remembered chiefly by his vivacity, his brilliant wit, the literary flavoring which he imparted to LORD HALSBURY. The Green Bag. all his judgments, and the ripe old age to which he retained his seat on the Bench. His son is one of the most successful of the County Court Judges.. We must notice also Sir Joseph Chitty, whose phenomenal prac- tice at the bar seemed at one time to mark him out for a law-officership of the Crown. Sir Ford North, who was originally appointed a Judge of the Queen’s Bench Division, but was shortly after- wards transferred to the more congenial atmosphere of Chan- cery. Mr. Justice Romer who is the greatest judge of facts in the equity courts, and has scarcely a rival in his: mastery of patent cases. He has two cardinal vir- tues in an equity judge. He seldom postpones his decis- ion, and his judg- ments are almost in- variably short. Mr. ‘Justice Romer has done more than any living judge to wipe out Chancery arrears and prevent fresh masses of them,from accumulating. He has a fine presence and an exquisite delivery. Mr. Justice Stirling divides with Lord Watson the honor of being a Scotch judge on the English Bench. In spite of the fact that the English Bar is a hunting-ground for Scotch talent, comparatively few members of that hardy and audacious race have in recent years reached the judge’s seat. Mr. Justice Stirling is able and sound, but has not many other distinguishing features. We may conclude this sketch with a brief notice of the evangelical Chancellors.. The first of the group, Lord Hatherley, Sir William Page
Page 29
The English Law Courts. | Wood, was born in 1801, called to the Bar in 1827, took silk in 1845, was made Solici- tor-General in 1851, Vice-Chancellor in 1853, a Lord Justice of Appeal in 1868, and Lord Chancellor in the same year. He resigned in 1872, and died in 1881. The second Lord Cairns is too familiar a figure to readers of THE GREEN BAG to need the facts of his life to be recorded. The third Lord Selborne (Sir Roundell Palmer), was Lord Chancellor in 1872, and again in 1880. These three great judges possessed very different characteristics, and did very differ- ent work. Hatherley’s name is most strongly associated in the mind of his profession with the elevation, so fiercely denounced by Sir -Alexander Cockburn, of Sir Robert Collier to the Privy Council by a technical evasion of the Judicial Committee Act and by Lord Campbell’s unfair comments on his habit of delivering judgments ore ¢enus. The fusion of law and equity and the establishment of the present English judicature system were the chief works of Selborne and Cairns. But 427 they were all three alike in their devoted Churchmanship and Evangelicalism. Hath- erley and Cairns taught in Sunday-schools almost to the end of their brilliant careers, and Selborne has contributed to religious literature three works of permanent value. “Hymns of Praise,” ‘A Defence of the Church of England against Disestablish- ment,’ and ‘“ Ancient Facts and Fiction concerning Tithes.” Lord Herschell, who became Chancellor in 1886, and again in 1892, has made a great name for himself as a sound commer- cial lawyer, and also as an administrator who declines to apply “the spoils system” unduly in the distribution of legal patron- age. . Lord Halsbury, who was Tory Chancellor in 1885, and again in 1886 to 1892, is one of the cleverest men upon the Bench, and surprised everybody by developing singular judicial qualities during his tenure of the Great Seal. LEx.
Page 30
428 The Green Bag. THE ETHICS OF LAW.' By Coit. J. T. Homes. T is the wisdom of the Odyssey, un- changed by the flight of time, that, ‘¢ True friendship’s laws are by this rule expressed, Welcome the coming, speed the parting guest.” With whom, what class, or guild, or call- ing, or profession, in the affairs of this life, can they find more appropriate illustration than with the ministers of justice ! That justice, a crowning attribute of Deity, committed, in part, to human keep- ing, for the centuries, is the touchstone of the law. Every rule that favors and facili- tates its administration in and through the conduct of judges and lawyers and officials lies within the domain of the theme pro- posed. NG Professor Swing defined in attractive lan- guage: ‘ Geography is a map of the world; ethics is a beautiful map of duty. This ethics is not Christianity, it is not even reli- gion; but it is the sister of religion, because this path of duty is in full harmony, as to quality and direction, with the path of God.” “The science of right conduct and char- acter.’ — The ethics of law must, therefore, be the science of right conduct and char- acter in the enactment and the enforcement of law, and the ‘“ character” must affect both actor and enactment. Perhaps the most accurate recorded de- finition — it is said to be most “ satisfying” —is that of Professor Birks. ‘‘ Ethics is the science of ideal humanity.” The legal profession, being an intensely practical body of humanity, substitutes that word practical for the professor’s. ideal. The code of morals in law, or medicine, or religion, which remains in the region of the ideal is largely useless. t An address delivered at a Columbus, Ohio, Bar banquet, Feb. 8, 1895. This is not dispensing with the ideal, or giving rein to licentiousness. Nothing hu- man is perfect, and so the highest standard of ethics attainable in practice is a response to the calls of human and divine laws. If driven to a single word as a definition, that word in English would possibly be “ duty.” The eleven commandments contain the grandest code of ethical rules that the world has ever seen. | Their spirit, friendly to human life, to human society, to good government, to hu- man happiness, pervades the body of our human laws, written, unwritten, and mixed. Their details and refinements, ever of binding obligation on the life and the con- science, circumscribed and embraced by the limits of duty, are infinite. “Learn to do well; seek judgment, re- lieve the oppressed, judge the fatherless, plead for the widow,” are telling types from the pen that was touched with fire from the skies. In this code of duty are loyalty to law, loyalty to judges, loyalty to the talents and essential integrity of professional brethren, loyalty to clients and to their honorable causes. It is the fact, and the consciousness of judge, jury, officers, and counsel that duty has been performed, when the millionaire or the penniless infant, the powerful corpora- tion or the natural person steps into the cor- ridor, victor or vanquished, after the forms and substance of law have been invoked and finally exhausted, when thereunder justice has been done, that true ethics are _illus- trated. The abuse of the power of the law-giver, the wabbling, and indirection, here and
Page 31
Thee Ethics of Law. whether there, of the law’s’ executors, clothed with the ermine or holding the brief, - cannot modify or shade these rules any more than crime can spot the law, or the impris- oned or executed murderer abrogate social rights. It is germane to the subject to say, no matter whose the original ‘‘ happy thought”’ which this occasion bodies forth — a living reality —he was thinking for the good of his fellows, of his clients, of his city, of the commonwealth — discharging duty, the measure of all true ethics, and, unknown though he may be, he has, for one, my sin- cere thanks. It is said that whenever a salt spring breaks out at a distance from the ocean, its vicinity immediately abounds with salt plants, although none ever grew there before. In some regions, when the spruce pine and the white birch are destroyed, poplars spring up instead, though none were ever seen there before; where the fires sweep away the original wood, the new saplings are often of wholly different species. It would be well to nurture this new growth which comes out of soil o’erswept by the vivifying heat of that ‘‘ happy thought.” Usage and some respectable authority recognize ‘bad ethics,” but there is an anachronism, or better, a solecism in the phrase. It is the inversion, in a sense, of the sentiment of a waggish cynic of fifty years ago, who described some of his neigh- bors as ‘religious devils.” The ethics of the law are presumptively good, and therefore, the other kind goes over the garden wall. Divorced from the members of the pro- fession, the ethics of law would be a dried ‘“ barren ideality.” When with uplifted hand, in the days of supple body, of youthful face, of eyes un- 429 dimmed that looked far into the future, of hopes that bounded and thrilled, each took the simple, solemn formula as his rule of professional life: ‘“ I do solemnly swear that I will support the Constitution of the United States and of the State of Ohio, and that I will honestly and faithfully demean myself as an attorney and counselor at law in these courts,” he adopted, in few words, the code of ethics which the oath of the Genevan Advocate makes binding on the conscience through the professional duties of each day until the final sunset. It is an epitome which never loses its in- terest or its eloquence. “T solemnly swear before Almighty God to be faithful to the Republic, and the Can- ton of Geneva; never to depart from the respect due to the tribunals and authorities ; never to counsel or maintain a cause which does not appear to be just or equitable, unless it be the defense of an accused per- son; never to employ, knowingly, for the purpose of maintaining the cause confided to me, any means contrary to truth; and never to seek to mislead the judges by any artifice or false statement of fact or law; to abstain from all offensive personality, and to advance no fact contrary to the honor or reputation of the parties, if it be not indis- _pensable to the cause with which I may be charged; not to encourage either the com- mencement or continuance of a suit from any motive of passion or interest; not to reject for any consideration personal to my- self the cause of the weak, the stranger, or the oppressed.” ~ “Clear, stern, lofty language”; it has in it the square and compass, the plummet and anchor of the truest, purest legal ethics. The gifted Duffield said: “It has in it the sacred savor of ‘Divine inspiration, and sounds almost like a restored reading from Sinai’s original, but broken tablets.”
Page 32
430 The Green Bag. WHEN MIGHT WAS RIGHT. By ARCHIBALD R. WATSON. HAT there should ever have been an age when the violence of combat was sanctioned by the law, seems strange in these days of crusade against pugilists and duel- lists. In early times, however, when igno- rance held extensive sway, and superstition caused humanity to quake with the dread of unknown evils; when a martial spirit ruled the mind of man, tinctured with fanciful religious conceptions, it was not necessarily contempt of court to resort to an argument of arms in its presence. Far from it; for, under circumstances, the grave and dignified justices, ermined and bewigged, would even “arrange the preliminaries,” and then ob- _ serve With that disinterested interest which becomes the judiciary, the belligerent liti- gants. With weapons sharper than tongue of shrewdest lawyer, with repartee readier than anything presently forensic, and with confi- _ dence more sublime than any modern justice seeker, the plaintiff and defendant appealed to a heavenly tribunal to judge between their conflicting pretensions and manifest its deci- sion in the overthrow of him whose arm was raised unrighteously. What a glorious, chiv- alrous thing, was this simple and bold de- vice! What an exalted notion that of an original resort to a dispensary of justice, omniscient, omnipotent and incorruptible! And was not ample sanction and perhaps suggestion, afforded by the scriptural prece- dent of David and the giant? Thus far the enthusiasm of our ancestors carried them when trial by wager of battle was introduced. But here they stopped to think. How about witches? It was a well known fact that dogs’ teeth, bits of stone and such things if worn about the person, would enlist the sympathies of these unearth- ly creatures. In view of the absolutely im- partial attitude of Heaven, might not the tide of war, 27 a doubtful case, be turned in favor of the disputant who possessed these sym- bols of sorcery? Legal ingenuity triumphed. A prefatory oath was devised, embracing, with true legal comprehensiveness, ‘all possi- ble cases.” The parties were made to pro- claim: “ Hear this, ye justices, that IT have this day netther cat, drank, nor have upon me, neither bone, stone, nor grass; nor any en- chantment, sorcery or witchcraft, whereby the law of God may be abased, or the law of the devil exalted. So help me God and his saints.” And so the farce proceeded. From sun- rise until sunset, the conflict, if not sooner terminated, might continue. By this means was the guilt or innocence, right or wrong of the litigants decided. As legally contro- verted facts are now-a-days determined by their probability, as established by evidence, this monument to the ignorance, superstition and ferocity of our progenitors has been destroyed. Wager of battle is no longer in vogue. Wrongs are redressed and rights ‘recognized by means of gentler arts, just as effective, and, as we like to say, ‘‘ much more civilized.”
Page 33
London Legal Letter. 431 LONDON LEGAL LETTER. LonpOoN, Aug. 1, 1895. HE law of the bag has never been set out in print in this country or, so far as | am aware, in America. May I therefore give it pub- licity in the forum of ‘THE GREEN Bac, the place of all places where it should first appear? It may be retorted that the bag has no law, which of course is true; but only in the sense and to the extent in which it may be said that the relations between solicitors and barristers are not matters of law. Custom governs them, and it is custom and not law which provides the limitations upon the intercourse between client and counsel, and the garb which a barrister shall wear when in court, and how he shall comport himself in his social meetings with “the other branch of the profession,” and the amount and the manner of ' the payment of his fees, as well as scores of other things more or less important in the daily life of an English lawyer. But this custom has all the weight and authority of law, and doubtless, if oc- casion should arise, would be construed as if it were law. In the first place, then, only barristers use bags ; and by bags are generally understood the stuff- goods bags of the pattern which adorns the title- page of ‘this magazine. Solicitors go about with leather hand-bags which are sold in the portman- teau shops as “ brief-bags.” The stuff bags are to be procured only at the quaint, Dickens-looking wig-shops in the various alleys and courtyards of the Inns of Court. In the next place, and with all due deference to the GREEN Bac, there are only two colors known in stuff bags—blue and red, ‘The blue bag is used exclusively by juniors, and a junior is one who has not “ taken silk,” or, in other words, become a Q.C. As many able barristers do not care to take silk, there are hun- dreds of gray-haired juniors. All Queen’s Coun- sel use red bags, but all who use red bags are not Queen’s Counsel. ‘This sounds a good deal like the Athanasian Creed, and is, perhaps, quite as comprehensible ; but I may make it plainer by-saying that the blue bag is used almost exclu- sively by men who have been only a comparatively few years atthe bar. While a Q. C. has the red bag by virtue of his position, the junior has it only by favor, and by favor of the Q. C. Ifa junior in a case in which he is led by a Queen’s Counsel attracts the attention of his leader and gives him commendable assistance, the Q. C. may, if he likes, present the junior with a red bag; but in such a case the bag is sent to the chambers of the junior by the Q.C.’s clerk, who is ex- pected to receive a guinea for the favor —as his perquisite. ‘Thenceforward the junior will carry his own bag, as it has changed color; whereas a small boy or a clerk was necessary as a bearer of the blue bag. Such, in brief, is the law of the bag. It may be childish and absurd, particularly in the eyes of Americans, but so are many other of the customs which have grown up in the Temple dur- ing. the past three or four hundred years, and not even the most radical of modern reformers would care to abolish them. The Society of Co-operative Legislation, in which it is hoped all English-speaking people will take an interest, has now got fairly to work — at least it has begun to map out a programme of work, and there is no doubt that the programme will be well carried out. Sub-committees have been appointed on (@) Forms and Methods of Legislation; (4) Mercantile Law; (¢c) Com- parative and Historical Jurisprudence; (@) Pro- cedure, and (¢) Foreign and Colonial Correspon- dence. ‘The names of those who have agreed to serve on these committees embrace eminent bar- risters and solicitors, text-book writers and uni- versity professors. Many of them are well known in America, as, for instance, Lord Davey, Professor Thos. Erskine Holland, professor of international law at Oxford ; Sir Courtenay Ibert; Sir Wm. R. Mason, Warden of All Souls, Oxford; Judge Chalmers; Arthur Cohen, Q. C.; Lord Justice Lindley ; Master Macdonnel; Mr. Justice Mat- | thew; Dr. Stubbs; Professor Dicey; Professor Jenks ; Professor Maitland ; Sir F. Pollock ; Lord Watson ; Professor Westlake ; Lord Justice Rigby ; Lord Shand, and Mr. Justice Wright. The com- mittees have met and each has taken up one or two subjects upon which certain members of the
Page 34
432 Committee will compile papers. ‘These papers, after being submitted to the General Committee, will then be given to the members of the society ; and it is hoped that in the course of a compara- tively short time the fruits of these labors will form a substantial addition to the accessible sources of information on comparative law and _legis- lation. | It is a matter for congratulation that from the outset the committee have undertaken work that will have a practical and not a purely speculative value. ‘The Committee on Forms and Methods of Legislation, for example, in endeavoring to procure information as to how laws are enacted in other countries, what revision bills have before they are introduced into the legislative body, under what circumstances they may be offered, to what scrutiny and redrafting they are subject in committee, and how they are passed through suc- cessive stages until finally they develop into laws. The Committee on Mercantile Law will consider the question of the laws of bankruptcy in various countries, and of bills of exchange and _ negotiable instruments and a part of the broad question of partnership. ‘The Committee on Procedure has begun with even a still more practical subject, and that is the question of fees and costs in litigious matters. It is proposed to issue to lawyers in various countries a series of questions as to how fees and costs are arrived at, and to ascertain if possible, by submitting a hypothetical case, what they would amount to in a given suit. It is prob- able that no report the Society may make will be read by lawyers and laymen with so much interest as this on fees. ‘The fees and costs here in Eng- land appear to many Americans and to all Englishmen to be excessive. ‘They certainly are restrictive if not almost prohibitive of litigation, for no one can contemplate the consequences of The Green Bag. ————— an unsuccessful appeal to the courts without con- sidering the possibility of bankruptcy. And yet there are those in this country who, having had an experience of the charges of American lawyers, prefer the English system, for here the litigant may make some calculation of the prospective cost. He knows what will be charged for each visit to his solicitor and, at least approximately, what fees for settling pleadings, advising on evi- dence, retainers for attendance in courts and re- freshers, will be paid to counsel; and when it is all over he knows that he may have the satisfac- tion of having an itemized bill of the charges, and if he is not satisfied with it, he may have it taxed. But his experience in America teaches him that his lawyer there will make his charge in a lump sum, that it will be based upon no fixed rule, that it will amount to as much as there is a hope of collecting, and that from it there is no appeal. How unsatisfactory this is may be gathered from a recent New York lawyer’s charge which has occasioned considerable comment here. In 1890 a firm of merchants in London obtained judgment here in the English court against a New York business man for 4184, or about $894. ‘The de- fendant appeared and defended the suit. Not being able to collect the judgment here, the English solicitors sent it to a New York firm of lawyers. ‘They brought suit on the judgment, collected the money and remitted it, less $1000, which they charged for their services to their London clients. Fortunately the proceedings were protracted for four years and a half,’ and the judgment carried with it interest at six per cent upon the sum claimed, otherwise there would have been nothing to remit. As it is, the unfortu- nate London plaintiff, after nearly five years’ delay, received $139.85, while the New York lawyers pocketed $1000 ! STUFF GOWN.
Page 35
cy , Seana Topics, . . CURRENT TOPICS. LITERARY ADVERTISING. — If this is not the golden age of modern light literature — and clearly it is not — it is at least the golden age of literary advertising. What matters it that the literary giants of the cen- tury have passed away, leaving no competent success- ors, if the press can inflate the latter to dimensions for- eign to their nature and capacities? Take for a prominent example ‘+ Trilby ’”— in its best aspect a feeble imitation of Thackeray (even to the name of ‘¢ Little Billee’’), and for the rest a clever sketch of Bohemian artist-life, with a perfectly absurd and in- credible plot ; by what right has it found a larger sale than any other novel of the last quarter of a century? Why should it distance the exquisite ‘* Lorna Doone ”’ and the heart-breaking ‘‘ Tess”? By no right, but simply by. dint of printers’ ink. So of Mrs. Hum- phrey Ward’s unspeakably dreary tales. So of Rob- ert Louis Stevenson’s adventurous romances. The taint of the puffer is over them all. The public are told when the novelist sets at work; what he eats, drinks, wears, and where and how much he sleeps ; an interview is furnished to enable him to puff him- self. We are told where he has gone to get ‘local color.” The kettle is kept stirring, until the cover is taken off finally. Then we are told how much he receives (generally about four times the value of the thing), and how many copies Mudie or the Mercan- tile takes in, and how you can’t get a copy of the first edition for love or money, and how many thousamds a week it is selling, and so on. Correspondents spring up in the newspapers to discuss or conjecture. (On some of the letters probably no postage is paid.) The Critic, for example, has had a distinct depart- ment of ‘* Trilbyana”’ for months, and has even is- sued a-ssmall book as a tender to the famous novel. So one can hardly take up a newspaper or magazine without learning of the birth of a new and successful author, or the rehabilitation of an old and unfortunate one. They come thicker than summer clouds or au- tumn leaves or Canada flies. The number of new poetical stars discovered would keep an astronomical observatory busy, but they mostly turn out rockets — one cannot be found bright enough even for a lau- When one of the newcomers makes a fair success, immediately his waste-basket is eagerly ran- sacked, by the publisher or himself, for all the trash he has ever perpetrated, and then that is spawned on the market. As one who has read four hundred nov- els in the last twelve years, the writer hereof may reasonably believe that his statement should cause some surprise when he confesses that, standing by the counter of a public library, and listening to the titles of books demanded by high-school misses, raw boys, and sentimental old maids, wan widows, and worn wives, he does not recognize one title in four. If the novelist can gain the stage as a helper, even in the form of a burlesque, his fortune is indeed secured, as witness ‘¢ Mr. Barnes of New York” and * Trilby.” The magazine interview, especially when illustrated, is worth (and costs) much money to the aspirant. An American lecture tour, or even a. tour without lectures, is valuable even more as an advertisement than for its immediate product. An authoress’s di- vorce has been utilized as an advertisement of her works. The anonymous dodge is also highly es- teemed, as witness ‘‘ The Bread Winners” and the current life of Joan of Arc. When a prize to the right guesser is added, this is very fetching. So is a well-advertised prize contest for best authorship — it carries the rejected as well as the accepted. Even the death of the author adds to his ‘* boom,” and his first edition brings a fanciful price. Think of a copy of Poe’s worthless «‘ Tamerlane” selling for $1875 ! This instrumentality of puffery is used even in the law-book market. The patient legal camel is kept well informed of the monstrous paper burden pre- paring for his aching back. Almost every law-book publisher runs his own law periodical, to advertise and. puff his own books, and damn (at least with faint praise) those of his rivals. This is sometimes done very politely —reminding one of the extreme and deadly courtesy of the hero of the clever story, ‘«The White Company.” (We get nothing for this puff.) «* Blow your own horn” is a shrewd maxim, and so, for example, the enterprising West Company blows its own ‘‘ Horn-Books.” It-is bad enough that books should be published. We sometimes sigh - for an inquisitorial bonfire of them. But it would be 433 reate.
Page 36
434 a public blessing if the entire herd of hired puffers could be afflicted with pen-paralysis, although even then they probably would dictate to type-writers, and the last state would be worse than the first. JUDGE THOMPsSoON’s Book. — Now, having freed our minds on the subject of puffery, we desire to try our own hand at it, not on a retainer, but from a sense of duty to our profession. A great legal ship has lately been launched, or at least partly, for it is so big that it has to be sent off the ways in compart- ments. Judge Seymour D. Thompson’s work on Corporations is half out of its shell — to change the figure — and will be wholly delivered in the autumn. This is the largest legal treatise ever published in America, or anywhere else, probably, and the most important since Kent’s Commentaries and Story’s Equity Jurisprudence. The subject is the most vital one in this time and this country, and it is discussed, as the result of sixteen years of thought, research, and labor, by one who is a master of the subject, and probably the ablest master of it now living, or who has ever lived, in America. We have examined the first three volumes with considerable care, and put them to a practical test in study and in writing upon some of the minor topics treated, and although our expectation was large, it is not ‘n the least dis- appointed. The summary and plan of the work laid out in the first volume is in itself a masterpiece of analysis and arrangement, and it almost follows that the man who could draw it up-can write up to it with the same wisdom — ex fede Herculem. It is evident that when these six volumes are completed the last word will have been uttered on Corporations, at least (as the author would probably say) until the courts are called on to decide more cases, and it would be as foolish for a lawyer to try to do without them as it would be to try to navigate a ship without a compass through the Archipelago. It is not our office, nor have we the space, to point out its merits, save in a general way, but it requires small space to allude to - its sole demerit, which, after all, is a mere matter of taste. To aur taste, then, Judge Thompson exhibits a too frequent tendency toward polemics and a lack of temperateness in criticism, — a characteristic very noticeable also in another celebrated writer, ‘Mr. Bishop, in whom it shows to a ridiculous extent. Judge Thompson’s honest indignation against judicial construction which helps corporations in wrong and oppression, as he deems it, leads him sometimes to indulge in language more remarkable for robustness than politeness. This is not the way in which legal classics are written. Kent and Story did not thus write. The style that would be perfectly suitable in the «*‘ American Law Review,” and is intended to Ihe Green Bag. produce an impression of advocacy, will not effect so lasting an influence as a calm and judicial tone. Suppose Judge Thompson should really be wrong and the judges right? This is not impossible, but Judge Thompson writes as if it were not possible. We love one who has the courage of his honest con- victions, in debate or in polemical writing, but when he embalms his convictions in print and sheepskin, with a reasonable hope of influencing the legal world, he should temper the wind to the shorn lamb of the bench, and as it were, blow through a seive. It is however a great triumph to write six thousand pages and commit no more serious fault in them than this, and it will be considered by many a failing that «+ errs on virtue’s side.” At all events, Judge Thompson, by vast labor, by exceptional ability, and by consid- erable self-sacrifice, has (to change the figure again) produced the most stupendous monument of legal learning and mental vigor that has been reared any- where in the world in half acentury. He has a right to be proud of it, and he has made the legal world greatly his debtor. THE INCOME TAx.— The enterprising publishers who issued Mr. Carrington’s and Mr. Roger Foster’s ‘* treatises ” on the late lamented Income Tax Law,— an English edition of the latter was issued in June,— should not have been ‘knocked silly’? and have al- lowed another publisher to put forth a treatise on ‘¢ How to get it Refunded.” There is nothing like presence of mind in emergencies. NOTES OF CASES. THE DuTY OF RETREATING. — The old common _law is generally believed to have held that if a man was murderously assailed he could not stand his ground and forcibly resist, but must run away if he could, or ‘* retreat to the wall,” as the old phrase was, if he could safely do so. Probably most of the old cases held this, and probably the doctrine has been pretty generally accepted in this country until a recent period. The old text-writers differed, however, Hale laying down the duty to retreat, East holding the contrary. This was a singular inconsis- tency in the common law, for under that law one might not do for himself what he might do for his wife, his child, or even a stranger, that is, forcibly prevent a felony. The law was inconsistent also in its application of the doctrine, making a distinction between an assault in one’s own house and an assault outside, even on his own land; even holding that a man threatened with highway robbery, with a good horse under or in front of him, and thus well pro-
Page 37
The Lawyers Easy Chair. 435 vided for retreat, was not bound even to try to run away. Mr. Bishop, who is always original, scouts the doctrine of retreating (as does Wharton), and holds that one failing to resist a murderous attack and endeavoring to get away is guilty of misprision of felony ! The states of Iowa.and Alabama are prominent adherents to the old dogma of the necessity of re- treating. In State v. Donnelly, 69 Iowa, 705; 58 Am. Rep. 234, it is held that where one is felonious- ly and dangerously assailed, he is bound to retreat if he can do so without danger; citing People v. Sul- livan, 7 N. Y. 396, and cases from Georgia, Missis- sippi and California. (The doctrine of the Sullivan case is that «* the right to defend himself would not arise,until he had done every thing in his power to avoid the necessity of defending himself.’’ In Shorter v. People, 7 N. Y. 193, the court said, ‘* After a conflict has commenced, he must quit it, if he can do so in safety, before he kills his adversary; but this was odzter because the assault by the deceased was only with the naked hand; and the defendant pursued him with a deadly weapon; so the questigqn of retreat was not involved.) The Alabama court carries the duty of retreating to extreme length. Thus in Lee v. State, 92 Alabama, 15; 25 Am. St. Rep. 17, it was held that one must retreat even from his own land, if beyond the curtilage ; and in Martin v. State, go Alabama, 602 ; 24 Am. St. Rep. 844, it was held that when one assailed in his own house retreated from it, he lost the protection of his ‘* cas- tle,”’ and must continue his retreat and could not de- fend himself with a deadly weapon unless it appeared to be reasonably necessary to avoid great bodily harm. | But there is an important and increasing line of recent decisions which deny that one thus assailed must retreat at all, and hold that he may ‘ stand his ground.” In Runyan v. State, 57 Indiana, 80; 26 Am. Rep. 52, the court said: «* A very brief examination of the American authorities makes it evident that the an- cient doctrine, as to the duty of a person assailed to retreat as far as he can before he is justified in re- pelling force by force, has been greatly modified in this country, and has with us a much narrower appli- cation than formerly. Indeed the tendency of the American mind seems to be very strongly against the enforcement of any rule which requires a person to flee when assailed, to avoid chastisement or even to save human life, and that tendency is well illustrated by the recent decisions of our courts, bearing on the general subject of the right of self-defence. The weight of modern authority, in our judgment, estab- lishes the doctrine that when a person, being with- out fault and in a place where he has a right to be, is violently assaulted, he may, without retreating, repel force by force, and if in the reasonable exer- cise of his right of self-defence, his assailant is killed, he is justifiable.” And so a charge that ‘‘ before a man can take life in self-defence, he must have been: closely pressed by his assailant, and must have re- treated as far as he safely or conveniently could, in- good faith, with the honest intent to avoid the vio- lence of the assault,’’ was held error. This doctrine is reiterated by the same court in State v. Page, 4o N. E. Rep. 745, where the duty of retreating is lim- | ited to cases of non-felonious assaults and mutual broils and combats. The court observe : — “But if applied to all cases where a person going his lawful way is assaulted, without reference to the question whether a felony or a mere trespass on the person is man- ifestly intended, it (the duty of retreat) would require a man to flee before another who murderously assailed, or a traveler to flee before a highway robber, or a woman to flee before her would-be ravisher, before resorting to extreme measure of defense. It is safe to say that the law puts up- on a person no such necessity. The old writers on ‘justi- fiable homicide ’ — that is, homicide committed in the re- sistance of felonies —— make no mention of the duty of re- treating.” ® The same doctrine was adopted by the Ohio su- preme court, in Balker v. State, 29 Ohio St. 184; 23 Am. Rep. 731, where the subject is learnedly exam- ined, and the decision was that where a person in the lawful pursuit of his business, and without blame, is violently assaulted by one who manifestly and ma- liciously intends and endeavors to kill him, the per- son so assaulted, without retreating, although it be in his power to do so without increasing his danger, may kill his assailant if necessary to save his own life or prevent enormous bodily harm. The court re- mark : ** We can safely say that the rule announced is at least the surest to prevent the occurrence of occa- sions for taking life; and this by letting the would- be robber, murderer, ravisher and such like know that their lives are in a measure in the hands of their intended victims.” It has even been held that the person threatened may assume the defensive-offensive and make his as- sailant retreat in case of reasonable apprehension. So the Michigan supreme court, in Pond v. People, 8 Mich. 177, held: «+ If any forcible attempt is made, with a felonious intent against person or property, the person resisting is not obliged to retreat, but may pursue his adversary, if necessary, till he finds him- self out of danger.”” This was followed, People v. Dann, 53 Mich. 490; 51 Am. Rep. 151, when the deceased came armed upon the defendant’s premises to take away property purchased by him at an invalid execution sale. In Kentucky the courts go still further, and hold,
Page 38
430 The Green Bag. as in Bohannon v. Commonwealth, 8 Bush, 481; 8 Am. Rep. 474, that where a man has been threat- ened by another with murderous violence, he may arm himself and go about his legitimate business, and if «* he casually meets his enemy, having reason to believe him to be armed and ready to execute his murderous intentions, and he does believe, and from the threats, the previous assault, the character of the man, and the circumstances of the meeting, he has the right to believe, that the presence of his adver- sary puts his life in imminent peril, and that he can secure his personal safety in no other way than to kill him, he is not obliged to wait until he is actually as- sailed. He may not hunt his enemy ard shoot him down like a wild beast; nor has he the right to bring about an unnecessary meeting in order to have a pre- text to slay him; but neither reascn nor the law de- mands that he shall give up his business and aban- don society to avoid such meeting.” In Missouri, the doctrine of the last case has re- ceived an extension, and it was held in the very re- cent case of State v. Evans, 28 S. W. Rep. 8, that one whose life has been threatened may arm himself and knowingly go into the vicinity of the threatening party ; and that the mere fact that he does so in the expectation of being attacked will not deprive him of the right to take life in self-defense. In comment- ing upon this case a recent writer of the Harvard Law Review suggests a doubt whether the right of the threatened person to go into his enemy’s presence is not dependent on the necessity of his doing so in the pursuit of his legitimate business. But I agree with the editor of the New York Law Journal that no such distinction is reasonable, and that no person can by murderous threats exclude another from any part of the habitable globe, so long as he does not provoke an assault. The doctrine intimated by the Review would be extremely inconvenient in case the threatening party were a commercial traveller or a or a post-office carrier. May not one go to church or to the theatre although he knows his enemy is lying in wait for him there ? The liberty of the cit- izen may not be thus circumscribed. In some of our frontier communities such a rule would amount to a serious embarrassment if not a total suspension of commercial industry and enterprise. The most recent and authoritative judicial declara- tion on this subject is found in the case of Babe Beard, in the United States supreme court. This was a case of homicide upon the defendant’s premises and in resistance to an unlawful carrying away of his property, and must be regarded as a notable exten- sion of the ‘‘ castle’? doctrine. Mr. Justice Harlan said : — “The Court, several times in its charge, raised or sug- gested the inquiry whether Beard was in the lawful pursuit of his business, that is, doing what he had a right to do, when, after returning home in the afternoon, he went from his dwelling-house to a part of his premises near the or- chard fence, just outside of which his wife and the Jones brothers were engaged in a dispute—the former endeav- oring to prevent the cow from being taken away, the latter trying to drive it off the premises. Was he not doing what he had the legal right to do, when, keeping within his own premises and near his dwelling, he joined his wife, who was in dispute with others, one of whom, as he had been informed, had already threatened to take the cow away or kill him? We have no hesitation in answering this ques- tion in the affirmative. * * * In our opinion, the Court below erred in holding that the accused, while on his premises, outside of his dwelling house, was under a legal duty to get out of the way, if he could, of his assail- ant, who, according to one view of the evidence, had threatened to kill the defendant, in execution of that pur- pose had armed himself with a deadly weapon, with that weapon concealed upon his person went to the defendant’s premises, despite the warning of the latter to keep away, and by word and act indicated his purpose to attack the accused. “The defendant was where he had a right to be when the deceased advanced upon him in a threatening manner amd with a deadly weapon; and if the accused did not pro- voke the assault and had at the time reasonable grounds to believe, and in good faith believed, that the deceased intended to take his life or to do him great bodily harm, he was not obliged to retreat, nor to consider whether he could safely retreat, but was entitled to stand his ground and meet any attack made upon him with a deadly weapon, in such way and with such force as under all the circum- stances he, at the moment, honestly believed, and had reasonable grounds to believe, was necessary to save his own life or to protect himself from great bodily injury.” The necessity for retreating is necessarily ignored, although the point is not explicitly passed upon in Tillery v. State, 24 Tex. App. 251; 6 Am. St. Rep. 882, and Bemarda v. State, 88 Tam. 183; and in Perkins v. State, 78 Wis. 551, it was held error to charge that self-defence ‘ will not justify the killing if the necessity for the killing can be avoided by re- treat” ; and in State wv. Reed, 53 Kans. 767; 42 Am. St. Rep. 322, it was held * that if one is unlawfully attacked by another, he may stand his ground and use such force as reasonably appears necessary to re- pel the attack and protect himself.” It seems to the writer that the modern doctrine is the more reasonable. As the question of the safety of retreat is one that must be instantly decided by the person assailed, he should be left to judge of it, and if he chooses to stand his ground he is exercising the right of the citizen and should be absolved. There is no pretence that one assailed with bare fists may not resist with bare fists and is not bound to run away, and it seems a travesty on justice to say that a would-be murderer has larger privileges and must be afforded a greater opportunity to commit wrong.
Page 39
The Green Bag. PUBLISHED MONTHLY, AT $4.00 PER ANNUM. SINGLE NUMBERS, 50 CENTS. Communications in regard to the contents of the Magazine should be addressed to the Editor, HORACE W. FULLER, 15% Beacon Street, Boston, Mass. The Editor will be glad to receive contributions of * articles of moderate length upon subjects of inter- est to. the profession; also anything in the way of legal antiquities or curiosities, faceti@, anec- dotes, etc. THE GREEN BAG. : THE GREEN Bac finds the following in a letter to it from a New York lawyer: “Recently I, had as a guest, under introductory letters, a London solicitor whom I was escorting around the courts. Upon first starting on our tour something occurred causing him to ask, ‘Is there really a forgetfulness of civil war times and a fraternization of Northern and Southern men?’ Following up the remark, I led him into a room of the Common Pleas, and pointing out a swarthy judge with a Roman face and picturesque black locks of hair, I said, ‘That is Judge Roger A. Pryor, who on the night before the firing on Fort Sumter, made in Charleston a most fiery speech against the North, and who, as an aide on the staff of Confederate General Beau- regard, made afterwards the demand for the Fort’s surrender. He is now one of our most admired jurists, by popular election. At the Clerk’s desk, before him, sits William S. Keily, keeping the minutes, who was at one time in the Confederate army of Northern Virginia. The lawyer address- ing Judge Pryor is Counselor Swayne, son of. a Lincoln justice of the Supreme Court, and the crutch on the chair beside him is needed to sup- port him because of a wound he received as a Union officer. But come now into the Court of Oyer and Terminer.’ And there I showed him District Attorney Fellows, familiarly styled Colonel because he held that rank in an Arkansas Con- federate army. ‘The prisoner he is trying is an ex-Union soldier, and the gentleman he is convers- ing with is J. Fairfax McLaughlin, another Con- federate soldier who is now Clerk of the Surrogate’s Court.’ In the portion where lawyers have seats, I pointed out Major J. D. McClelland, a now one- armed ex-Northern soldier; Burton S. Harrison, now a leading member of the Bar, who was private secretary to Jefferson Davis; and not far from him, leaning on his crutch, General Sickles who, since his recent retirement from Congress, has rejoined the Bar of the city at which he was once corporation counsel. ‘Say no more,’ said the solicitor, ‘I fully recognize the fraternization.’ ”’ LEGAL ANTIQUITIES. In the Jewish Commonwealth, judgment seats were placed on the gates of the cities( Ruth iv. 2), intimating quick despatch, that causes should not spend so long as to become aged and gray-headed in courts, lest they force the client to say to his lawyer, as Balaam’s ass said to his master, “ Am I not thine ass, which thou hast ridden upon, since the first time till the present day” (Num. xxii. 36). FACETIA. _ SEVERAL years ago in one of the southern coun- ties of Ohio, a case was being tried before a Court and Jury wherein a poor widow named Coine was plaintiff, and a railroad company defendant. The widow was seeking damages for the death of her husband, and plaintiff's counsel, in arguing before the jury, was dwelling upon the poverty of his client and her nine helpless children, one at the breast (the case had not then been as long drawn out as that of Jarndyce v. Jarndyce), and had drawn himself up for a final pitiful appeal to the sympathies of the court and jury, when opposing counsel desired to ask him a question, and was courteously requested to proceed with his question. “Your Honor, I desire to ask Judge R. how there can possibly be so great poverty where there’s so much Coin ?” This spoiled the finale of counsel’s argument, and he soon subsided. SoME months ago a young lawyer of Milwaukee, not over bright, faced Judge J. at the opening of 437
Page 40
438 Editorial Department. court and presented an affidavit of prejudice in a case marked for trial on that day’s calendar. The Judge, who dislikes affidavits of this nature more than anything else in the world, held it up and said to the rest of the Bar assembled in the room, as well as to the young lawyer: ‘“ Well, here is an- other of these affidavits; don’t you know, sir, (looking directly at the young man) that I do not know either of the parties to this action.” The young man looked downcast for a moment, and then looking suddenly up as though a happy thought had struck him, said: “No, your Honor, but they know you.” The court and bar were considerably startled, but the matter ended in a universal shout. A WELL known barrister relates the following story with great gusto. Some time ago he had under cross examination a youth from the country who rejoiced in the name of Samson, and whose replies were provocative of much laughter in the court. “And so,” questioned the barrister, “‘ you wish the Court to believe that you are a peacefully dis- posed and inoffensive kind of person? ”’ Yes," ‘And that you have no desire to follow in the steps of your illustrious namesake and smite the Philistines ? ”’ ‘No, I’ve not,’’ answered the witness. ‘ And if I had the desire I ain’t got the power at pres- ent.”’ “Then you think you would be unable to cope successfully with a thousand enemies and utterly rout them with the jawbone of an ass?”’ «‘ Well,” answered the ruffled Samson, “I might have a try when you have done with the weapon.” BEFORE a Western judge a lawyer was pleading a case and was making a regular red-fire-and-slow- curtain speech, which stirred the jury to its pro- foundest depths. In the course of his peroration he said :— “And, gentleman of the jury, as I stand at this bar to-day in behalf of a prisoner whose health is such that at any moment he may be called before a greater Judge than the judge of this court, [—”’ The judge on the bench rapped sharply on the desk, and the lawyer stopped suddenly and looked at him questioningly. “The gentleman,” said the court, with dignity, ‘will please confine himself to the case before the jury and not permit himself to indulge in invidious comparisons.” It almost took the attorney’s breath away, but he managed to pull himself together and finish in pretty fair shape. {Nn a bill for pulling down the Old Newgate in Dublin and rebuilding it on the same spot, it was enacted ‘that the prisoners should remain in the old jail till the new one was completed.” NOTES. In the days of John Eliot, a court was estab- lished at Nonantum, over which presided Waban, an Indian justice of the peace. By him justice was speedily and impartially administered. His sagacious and sententious judgment in a case between some drunken Indians would do no discredit to ‘a much higher civilization than that at Nonantum: ‘Tie um all up,” said he, “and whip um plaintiff, and whip um ’fendant, and whip um witness.” THE new Recorder of the City of New York, on the first day of his beginning his term, was reported as having reproved a young lawyer for indulging in extraneous pleasantry. He might be reminded of Lord Chief Justice Erle — in office in England thirty years ago — who said to a coun- sel who apologized for a sally of wit that disturbed the court-room with laughter: “The Court is very much obliged to any learned gentleman who beguiles the tedium of a legal argument witlr a little honest hilarity.”’ LORD CHIEF BARON POLLOCK, when age began to invade his body, was wont to have a nap pretty regularly about the middle of the sitting. His waking was often comical: when he would start and seizing his pen say to the counsel, ‘“ What was your last citation?’ and some of his friends thought he ought to resign. One of these ex- pressly waited on Sir Frederic Pollock and hinted at resignation. “Oh! you think me too old, eh?”’ he said, “‘ come waltz with me ;” and then seizing his interlocutor by the waist began capering with him about the private chambers. Next he put
Page 41
Editorial Department. 439 himself into boxing attitudes and fairly boxed the other to the door. On another occasion he said, ‘‘If every man were to take advantage of every tempting occasion ‘to have the law’ of his neighbor, life would ‘not be long enough for the litigations which would result, for all flesh and blood would be turned into plaintiffs and defen- dants.”’ Ex-JusticE WILLIAM StrrRonG died on August 19th. He was born in Somers, Conn., May 6, 1808, and was the eldest of eleven children of Rev. W. L. Strong. The son was graduated at Yale in 1828, and engaged in the study of law, teach- ing at the same time. He finished his legal studies by a six months’ course in Yale Law School, and decided to prac- tice in Pennsylvania, where he was admitted to the bar in 1832, and settled at Reading. In 1846 he was a candidate for Congress, and was twice elected on the Democratic ticket, serv- ing from 1847 until 1851. In his second term he was appointed chairman of the committee on elections. He declined a third election and re- tired from active politics, but when the Civil War began he gave up a high judicial post, which he was occupying, and gave all his support and in- fluence in aid of the government. In 1857 he was elected a justice of the supreme court of Pennsylvania, and he served eleven years, attaining a high reputation as a jurist. In 1868 he resigned his seat on the bench and opened an office in Philadelphia, at once obtaining a large and lu- crative practice. In February, 1870, he was appointed a justice of the Supreme Court of the United States, and served until December, 1880, when he resigned. THE following extract from a pleading on file in the Supreme Court of North Carolina, is taken from 112 N.C. 476: The plaintiff says, ‘“ Every such allegation is unjust to her credulity, manifests a lamentable want of the gallantry and courtesy to a lady which usually guides the strong arm of the draughtsman of pleadings in courts of justice, and she respectfully and kindly submits that such harsh and cruel accusations are not in keeping with that elegant, lofty and polished sentiment which is the crowning glory of the American law.”’ Two prison romances were simultaneously en- acted during the first week of June. Two men were discharged from the penitentiary of New York City within a week of their statutory release in conse- quence of discovery by the authorities that they were innocent of their alleged crime of burglary — the real culprits having been tardily discovered. Informed of this, the innocent men, then hard at work in a stone-quarry, wept — the warden join- ing in their tears. For said one, “‘ my innocence will add years of life to my heart-broken mother.” The second romance culminated at New Buffalo, Michigan, in the marriage of a recently discharged convict to a woman who had remained faithful to him during his twenty years of confinement. Jealousy of his rival incited his killing the latter for undue attentions to the woman. But he was convicted only of manslaughter committed in the heat of passion. The bridegroom came out of prison silver-haired and bowed with physical weakness, and the bride’s face was furrowed with the lines of sorrowful remembrances. During his long confinement she regularly visited him and had devoted herself to earning and saving a competence that should support them when united. Thus the wonderful annals of legal romance receive two additional chapters. LITERARY NOTES. For seven years SCRIBNER’S MAGAZINE has had the habit of publishing a midsummer Fiction Num- ber, in which have appeared some of the most not- able short stories that have been written by Ameri- can authors. The August issue is no exception to this remarkably successful record. Any number of the magazine would be notable-with an array of contributors which includes Anthony Hope, H. C. Bunner, Hopkinson Smith, Richard Harding Davis, Octave Thanet, Noah Brooks, George Meredith, George I. Putnam and Theodore Roosevelt. The number contains seven short stories, six of them il- lustrated by artists of the first rank, including W.H. Hyde, Reinhart, C. Y. Turner, Orson Lowell and others. Mr. Henry DwIiGut SEDGWICK of Stockbridge, Massachusetts, contributes to the Midsummer Holi- day (August) CENTURY a delightful series of «* Rem- iniscences of Literary Berkshire.” Mr. Sedgwick is a nephew of Catherine Sedgwick, and has enjoyed the acquaintance of nearly every one of the many not-
Page 42
440 able literary men and women who have visited Berkshire within the past half-century or more. Mr. Sedgwick tells a series of interesting incidents and anecdotes concerning Fanny Kemble, Macready, President Van Buren, Dr. Channing, G. P. R. James and many others, and the article is full of por- traits and other illustrations, including beautiful pic- tures of Miss Sedgwick and Mrs. Kemble. HERBERT SPENCER opens the August PCPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY with the fourth of his papers on «¢Professional Institutions,” in which he shows that the functions of the orator, poet, actor and dramatist are all developed from the acts of the primitive tribesman in welcoming his victoriously returning chief. Andrew D. White, writing on «*The Continued Growth of Scientific Interpretation,’ describes the battle by which reason conquered tradition in English theology. In an illustrated article on ‘‘Art and Eyesight,” Dr. Lucien Howe shows that artists are by no means exempt from the irregularities of vision that other per- sons have, and hence that, to see their pictures as they see them, one must for the moment induce the same irregularity in his own eyes. In the series on the Development of American Industries since Columbus. John G. Morse describes ‘‘Apparatus for Extinguishing _ Fires,” with many pictures of apparatus ancient and modern. Prof. E.L. Richards sets forth the importance of the ‘Physical Element in Education.” ROBERT LovuIs STEVENSON’s last story, ‘¢ St. Ives,” was left at his death practically completed, so it is stated by those who have seen the manuscript. Many chapters had even received the author’s final revision. Stevenson had been at work upon this novel for more than a year, and the first half of it had been entirely rewritten several times. ‘<< St. Ives’? will be published serially in McCLUuRE’s MAGAZINE, THE idea that ten cents for THE COSMOPOLITAN means inferiority from a literary point of view is dis- pelled by the appearance in the August number of such writers as Sir Lewis Morris, Sir Edwin Arnold, Edgar Fawcett, Tabb, W. Clark Russell, Lang, ‘Sar- cey, Zangwill, Agnes Replier, etc. Nor can we en- tertain the idea of inferiority in illustration with such names as Hamilton Gibson, Denman, Van Schaick, Lix, Sandham, etc., figuring as the chief artists of a single month’s issue. THE most striking paper otf general interest in the August Avena,—the one that will surely be read from Atlantic to Pacific, —is Mrs. Helen H. Gar- dener’s review of recent age-of-consent legislation in The Green Bag. the United States. She deals with the bills that have been introduced in the various States, and gives the history of the three bills passed in New York, Arizona and Idaho, raising the age to eighteen. Mrs. Gardener bases this demand for fuller protec- tion to young girls, not upon any moral or religious views, as these vary according to birth and training, but upon the legal rights which are recognized in property and citizenship. THE August ATLANTIC MONTHLY contains several articles which are calculated to create widespread in- terest. One of the most striking contributions is by Jacob D.-Cox on ‘‘ How Judge Hoar Ceased to be Attorney-General.” Mr. Cox was a member of Grant’s Cabinet with Judge Hoar, and this paper is an important chapter in our recent political history. UNDER the title of ‘* Female Criminals,” Major Arthur Griffiths, Her Majesty’s Inspector of Prisons, furnishes an article to the August number of the NORTH AMERICAN REVIEw presenting in a peculiarly attractive style his observations respecting many and varied types of female offenders. McCuure’s MAGAZINE for August is a great short story number. Besides a new Zenda story by An- thony Hope, and a new Jungle story by Rudyard Kipling, there is a California story by Bret Harte, and a story of adventure by Stanley J. Weyman. HARPER’S for August is strong in fiction. The ‘¢ Personal Recollections of Joan of Arc” relate the story of Joan’s examination by the bishops, her ap- proval by the church and the beginning of her cam- paign against the enemies of the French king. Mr. Hardy’s ‘‘ Hearts Insurgent” is continued, and there are four short stories: ‘* Bobbo,” by Thomas Whar- ton, is a humorous tale of Paris life; «* An Evangel in Cyene,” by Hamlin, Garland, is a study of a rural community in Illinois ; «‘ Jimty,” by Margaret Sutton Briscoe, is a love-story of Old Virginia and New York; and «‘ The Little Room,” by Magdalene Yale Wynne, is a mystical New England sketch. ‘ THE complete novel in the August issue of Lip- PINCOTT’S, ‘* Little Lady Lee,” by Mrs. H. Lovett Cameron, narrates the vicissitudes of a faithful heart which found its true mate after its, owner, obeying the customs of English high life and match-making fathers, had lost her freedom. ‘+A Friend to the Devil,” by Maurice Thompson, is an amusing story of Georgia superstitions. The ‘‘ Applied Art” of which William T. Nichols treats was akin to that of the late M. Worth of Paris, but it did not prevent the artist from winning his ladylove.