The Green Bag: An Entertaining Magazine for Lawyers (February, 1895)

Page 1

cy Vor. VII. No. 2. feen Bag... BOSTON. FEBRUARY, 1895. SAMUEL J. TILDEN AS A LAWYER. By A. Oakey HALL. “ Who to party gave up what was meant for mankind.” — GOLDSMITH’s Retaliation. HE name and fame of Samuel Jones Tilden have entered biography and history mainly as of the politician and states- man. Even many lawyers of the older gen- eration scarcely think of him as having once been a very distinguished member of the “New York Bar. This presents an opposite view to that presented by the career of Henry Erskine, who is best remembered as a King’s Counsel and Lord Chancellor, but hardly ever referred to as once an M.P., and a vigorous party man in days when partisan asperities and conflicts were notable. Mr. John Bigelow, in his volumes presenting the literary and political career of Mr. Tilden, whose life-friend and exec- . utor he was, presents in his preface this apology: “It is with extreme regret that I find myself constrained to put these vol- umes to press without including in them a memorial of Mr. Tilden’s strictly profes- sional career.” Those paragraphs serve to show that in the opinion of the editor he regarded his friend and testator as the Am- erican people came to regard him, more in his aspect as statesman than as lawyer. Be it the province of the GREEN BAG, then, to commemorate Mr. Tilden in the latter capacity. : He was of English and Puritan ancestry. His great-great grandfather emigrated to Massachusetts only three years later than the famous debarkation at Plymouth Rock. On his mother’s side his great grandfather was William Jones—a Welshman —who served as lieutenant-governor of the colony of New Haven. The second generation of Tildens removed from Scituate, Mass., to Lebanon, Conn., and its descendants became revolutionary patriots. Mr. Tilden’s grand- father finally became a farmer across the boundary line separating Connecticut and New York, in a newsettlement that he named, in memory of the old homestead, New Leb- anon. There Samuel Jones was born in the closing year of our naval war with Great Britain; and there he spent sixteen years of boyhood. Among his playmates was Prince © John Van Buren, his elder by a few years, the Tilden and Van Buren family being | neighbors. Like the last named he attended the Kinderhook Academy, and matriculated later at Yale College; but not to become its alumnus in company with such classmates as Messrs. Evarts and Edwards Pierpont, each becoming federal attorney-generals, and the after Chief-Justice Waite. Young Tilden transferred his collegiate allegiance to the New York City University, and attended law lectures therein. From law school he passed into the law office of John W. Edmonds, his father’s friend, who during subsequent years was a Supreme Court judge and reporter of cases. That preceptor always bore testi- mony to his pupil’s deep draughts at-the legal Pierian springs. The year 1841 dated Mr. Tilden’s admission to the bar, and he opened an office in Pine Street, and also pol- itically allied himself with Tammany Hall, in which he made campaign speeches, and ob-

Page 2

50 tained acquaintanceships that led to client- age. He was soon accepted as a specialist in municipal law; and city contractors gave him lucrative business. Like many another young lawyer, in the fourth year of his novi- tiate at the bar, he entered the lower house of the Legislature, in which body his legal attainments secured him an appointment upon the Judiciary Committee, and many of its reports still on file in the State library vindicate this. While an Assemblyman he was recalled to New York to fulfil a re- tainer he had received from the then cor- poration counsel to defend the city in an action brought by a contractor to recover a claim for constructing a sewer,—a claim regarded as fraudulent. Having already won suits for contractors, he was regarded as acquainted with their ways and perhaps subterfuges. It had been’an academic tradi- tion that Mr. Tilden exhibited remarkable qualities as a mathematician. He had al- ready proved these in suits wherein calcula- tions about excavations, work per measure and supplies by superficies, had become nec- essary. His power of such calculation and his patience of investigation — that became throughout life his marked characteristic and so invaluable to the lawyer —served to expose the fraudulent claims of the contrac- tor, and he won his defense for the city by occasioning a large reduction of the bills. Returning to the Assembly, he engaged in marshalling a bill for a Constitutional Con- vention, whereof in the following year he became a delegate, and once more demon- strated legal ability, especially as a draughts- man of amendments. Conveyancing, as is well known, is regarded at the English bar as a necessary adjunct to professional suc- cess; and in that branch of jurisprudence Mr. Tilden became proficient and noted for great accuracy. His professional fame had so increased throughout the State by 1855 that a section of the Democratic party nom- inated him for attorney-general. He shared the defeat of all other like candidates by The Green Bag. the new Know-Nothing or Native American party. Hewas never fortunate in profes- sional candidature; for a few years later, when nominated for counsel to the corpora- tion of the City of New York, he was again unsuccessful. Each choice, however, dis- tinctly showed high popular estimation of his legal ability. This in growth he first displayed to wide public notice by his efforts in a famous quo warranto procedure in 1856, in which Mr. Tilden’s remarkable mathematical training again showed to advantage, and brought success. He had now formed a partnership with a shrewd young lawyer named Andrew H. Green, who had already made intellectual mark in the educational government of the city. The firm were retained by Azariah C. Flagg, who claimed to have been elected city comptroller. So-did his competitor, named Giles. The former had been State comptroller, and was a Reform candidate in the municipal canvass. He was declared elected by a majority less than two hundred, and by a final return of only one election district. The Giles supporters brought guo warranto, and apparently had sworn evi- dence that votes credited to Mr. Flagg be- longed to Giles. Mr. Tilden could only oppose perjury and forgery, as he claimed the Giles case to be, by bringing mathemati- cal demonstration into play. Oddly enough all Mr. Tilden’s great professional victories were obtained through that forte. The elec- tion tallies of his client had been purloined. He devoted with Mr. Green, who possessed a like mathematical knack that later in life proved of great use to himself and the pub- lic, two entire nights towards analyzing the Giles figures, and finally hit upon a process of reconstructing the missing tallies. His governing mathematical principle in the case was, inasmuch as twelve names appeared upon the one regular party ballot, that wherever any one candidate upon it had a vote, eleven others should have the same vote. Seizing that idea, he went through all the combina-

Page 3

Ceo Shae : Sr; E SS ae rae Pas Bb Prusel

Page 4

Page 5

- tions, eighty-four in number, so as to com- pletely reproduce the purloined tallies.. In -summing up to the jury, he claimed to have given a mathematical demonstration that the relator’s case was constructed upon forgery. The jury within a quarter-hour of retiring gave verdict for Mr. Flagg. Popular sym- pathy and the press were on his side, and Mr. Tilden’s professional victory remained for a long time a ruling topic. Clients re- newedly besieged his office. Two years later he was retained in an ad- ministration probate case by the heirs of a Dr. Burdell, who had been murdered, as was afterwards clearly demonstrated, by a physi- cian employed for that purpose by Dr. Bur- dell’s landlady, a Mrs. Cunningham, on a promise to divide the slain doctor’s estate with the principal felon. She, as accessory to the crime, confessed, as a fact for the first time known, while a coroner’ inquest pro- ceeded, that she was the widow of Burdell through a secret marriage, and was then enceinte by him. She was tried and acquitted mainly upon the testimony of the physician who did the deed; for at that time the lat- ter was unsuspected. As claimant widow she endeavored to administrate upon. the estate of Dr. Burdell. Affirmative testi- mony of the officiating minister, the mar- riage certificate, and evidence of Mrs. Cun- ningham’s daughter — of light character by the way—and the clergyman’s servants, seemed at first invincible. Mr. Tilden’s idea was, ‘‘ Yes, there was a ceremony, but Dr. Burdell was personated, the clergyman and he being strangers, and the latter had not even seen the former in his coffin; nor was a photograph of the alleged bridegroom in existence to exhibit for identification to the clergyman. Mr. Tilden, in contesting the claims of the alleged widow, made what can be best described as a concordance of every fact which her counsel brought for- ward; he relied upon the affinity of what seemed truth, and traced other lines of testi- mony back into the complicated and per- Samuel J. Tilden as a Lawyer. counsel to these. 51 plexed phases of fabrication, fairly ravelling the threads of falsehood and pretences. With great patience he traced the alleged bride- groom into a town two hundred miles from New York (the place of alleged marriage), on the day before the ceremony, and showed him in still another place at the very time it was being performed. Mr. Tilden won deci- sion for his clients from the probate judge, whose findings, with a full detail of all the romantic facts, can be found by the curious in the third volume of Bradford’s Surro- gate reports—that of themselves abound throughout in legal romance. The result was intensified in public interest when in the following year Mrs. Cunningham-Burdell went through the farce of childbirth with a two-day-old baby borrowed from a mater- nity hospital. The trick of thus producing an heir was however exposed by the treach- ery of her accomplice doctor, who discovered that his share of estate had gone through her probate failure. He subsequently committed suicide after flight to South America. The attorney-general who had beaten Mr. Tilden at the polls shamefully mismanaged the case of murder against the woman who instigated the crime. Had Mr. Tilden been elected, he would have prosecuted instead, and doubtless by his legal acumen have procured conviction. ; Mr. Tilden’s legal fame brought to him as clientage large corporate interests, and especially those connected with railway en- terprises. He had in the opinion of Wall Street clients shown skill as a financier. Corporations detected his capacity for con- centrated labor, and his faith in the mathe-— matical consistency of truths; and this de- tection made him sought after as standing From 1858 to 1875, at least half of the great railway corporations operating north of the Ohio and between the Hudson and Missouri Rivers at some time employed his professional acumen and activity. He mastered all questions which could arise in the organization, administra-

Page 6

52 The Green Bag. tion, and financial management of railways ; and he came to thoroughly comprehend their history and requirements. He knew how to avoid a wasteful litigation whenever railroads came within purview of an examination of their chartered rights or liabilities. His professional fame reached even to London, where European creditors and debenture holders of the Erie Railroad once invited him to act legally in their behalf. By reason of complications in other clientary directions he was obliged to decline the enormous fee that they proffered. Another great law case in which he suc- cessfully brought to bear for clients his mathematical precision and algebraic facil- ity in reaching unknown quantities amid confusing complications wherein supposi- tion only could lead towards developments of facts, was the suit in the Supreme Court of New York in 1858, brought by the Dela- ' ware and Hudson Canal Company against the Pennsylvania Coal Company, the defend- ant retaining Mr. Tilden. The claim was for extra tolls consequent upon an enlarge- ment of plaintiff’s canal, and thereby claimed to benefit the contract for tolls, that was entered into before the improvement. Nearly a million dollars were at stake. Mr. Tilden tabulated all the trips on plaintiff’s canal during ten years of contract, and contrasted the percentage of time consumed in trans- portation over the old or the new canal, and demonstrated that by the enlargement in question his client’s disbursements for trans- portation were enhanced, and therefore they had suffered loss. ‘Those tables shall be answered,” cried his opponents. To which Mr. Tilden, who possessed a slyness of humor for which he never received due credit, replied with an anecdote to this effect: the famous John Randolph of Roanoke having made a speech in Congress, .was complimented for it by a constituent who remarked, ‘“ Your argument has never been answered.” “ An- swered, sir,” the eccentric piped in his shrill voice, ‘it was not made to be answered.” So with these tables, added Mr. Tilden, “I did -not construct them to be answered. They cannot be confuted, for they are made according to the best process of scientific analysis, and step by step are proved from the records of the plaintiff, and have been introduced in strict conformity to the rules of evidence.” Mr. Tilden’s mathematics again won a victory for his clients, whose books show a payment to him of a fee of fifty thousand dollars. At one time his capacity to deal with cor- porate clients, — whose fees accumulated the large fortune he left after excellent invest- ments, — was only limited by his physical ability. | At another period he was called upon to argue a case involving the whole doctrine of trusts, either comprised under English chancery law or under the modifications thereof in the peculiar New York Revised Statutes. His brief is indeed a treatise on the subject, which increased the surprise of his fellow-members of the Bar, when the trusts of his will establishing a great library for the City of New York were, on a contest, declared invalid, some years after his decease, by ‘a majority in the Court of Appeals. Some of his political enemies said — and not very amiably—‘ He could not have been a great lawyer, for his will was broken on purely legal grounds.” So was the will of Lord Chancellor Westbury, and not even Lord Campbell, had he been alive to add another biography to his marvelous ‘“ Lives of the Chancellors,’ would have been bold enough to.allege that Lord Westbury was not an eminent jurist. Mr. Tilden, before writing an opinion for clients or previous to preparing for a trial or an argument, invariably first mentally tried the opinion or case against himself, ex- amining how his views could be combated. An excellent method and worthy of adop- — tion by all lawyers. As Abraham Lincoln ~ once said, ‘“ How can an engineer testify to ~ the safety of a bridge unless, before: it is —

Page 7

eas a. ris = rf z * _ which he was engaged. charge whatever. Le oes ina le Se = ie Pe te ere eee Samuel J. Tilden as a Lawyer. | me. XS used, he shall attempt to prove its unsound- ness?” Of Mr. Tilden could be quoted the line: “T am no orator as Brutus is”; but cer- tainly a succeeding line, “I only speak right on,” can be appropriately quoted for appli- cation. He was an impressive speaker, be- cause earnest and imbued with convictions; but he did not possess graces of oratory. He was deficient in fancy and imagination, and in what dramatic critics of actors style color. He therefore was not so successful with juries as with judges. In the use of rhetorié he hammered on anvils, rather than employing the paraphernalia of gold-beat- ers. He was ever a stickler for the ethics of his profession, and such was his passion for the supremacy of legal principles that he would often, to promote justice, serve with- out fee or hope of reward, and accepted employment only when he was persuaded of the justice and morality of the side for Upon this topic it will be appropriate to quote a communica- tion by Judge Sinnott of New York: — ‘¢T entered Governor Tilden’s office in 1857, and continued there until he retired from prac- tice. I was admitted to the bar in 1859, and from that time forward, and even from before that time, had a very intimate knowledge of all his business, both professional and private. I do not believe there is any lawyer of prominence in this country who has given more professional services gratuitously than he did. He was a man careless of charging for any short service or ad- vice, and | have known clients for years to come in almost daily and take up perhaps an hour at a time on matters where his advice saved them large sums of money, without his making any In no case, occurring in Gov- ernor Tilden’s office, from 1857 to 1872, did he ever make a charge where he had not rendered a substantial, continued, and important service, and in. no case did he make a charge where the benefit accruing to his clients would not have justified a higher charge according to the ac- | cepted scale of prices in this city for similar ser- vices. I] have never known, in all that time, a single iustance in which a client paid his bill unwillingly, or was otherwise than entirely satisfied, and even thankful. And no such case could have occurred without my knowledge. He never took a case on speculation nor for a contingent fee, and never until it had been first examined with a view to discover whether the person applying to him had not only the merits in law, but the equity on his side. He always manifested extreme consci- entiousness and sensitiveness in regard to accept- ing any professional employment where his polit- ical position or influence could possibly affect the course of justice. I have never known him to appear before a public officer or a legislative or municipal body to advance any.private inter- est, or to assert any private claim. Not only that, but I have never known him to advise in such a case, no matter how privately or indirectly. He could have made a fortune from that class of business alone, if he had been willing to enter into it. Finally, I say, as one knowing what he says, that Governor Tilden has never, since I have known him, been interested, directly or in- directly, nearly or remotely, professionally in any job.” 7 When the Civil War seemed imminent, Mr. Tilden, giving an opinion to some bank- ing clients, wrote strongly as a lawyer, as _a politician, that nullification and secession found no color of claim in the constitution ; and that coercion to preserve the Union was entirely justified by due construction of that instrument. And in his opinion he be-. lieved that any war struggle would be a prolonged one. About the same time he publicly disagreed with the early moder- ate call for Northern troops, and believed President ‘Lincoln should have summoned half a million volunteers. During the war he as a lawyer joined in legal opinion with Messrs. Vallandigham, David Dudley Field and Garfield (who successfully argued the famous Milligan Indiana case before the Fed- eral Supreme Court), that the maxim zuter arma silent leges did not apply in peaceful territory outside of martial territory, and that the trial of civilians by courts martial in Northern states was unconstitutional. He

Page 8

54 was often summoned to Washington for consultation with Secretary Stanton, who held a high opinion of Mr. Tilden’s legal attainments, as can be testified to by that veteran of still youthful feeling, Charles A. Dana, long an assistant secretary of war, and to whose cool, conservative judgment the impetuous Stanton, his chief, owed much: as some day, a historian of the period, con- ning documents on file at the National Capi- tal, must strongly testify. Mr. Tilden is on record as early advising, as an amicus curiae as it were, the return to freedom of Messrs. Slidell and Mason, because illegally captured and restrained. He also joined Charles O’Conor and George Shea (counsel for cap- tured Jefferson Davis) in opinion that only the civil arm (as in the case of Aaron Burr), and not the military arm, could legally deal a blow for his treason, if such a blow -were deemed politic under all circumstances. When Horatio Seymour became governor of New York during the war, he frequently consulted with Mr. Tilden on legal matters, and particularly so during the draft riots of 1863. For the half-dozen years that fol- lowed the closing of the civil contest, Mr. Tilden closely pursued his _ professional avocations, in which he then simply refused more retainers than he accepted. When taxed for his income, although believing that it was an unconstitutional measure both in plan and details, he made a return purely out of patriotic motives. The fiscal authori- ties contravening his return, saw fit to initiate legal procedures, and then he declared his intention of now raising the constitutional objection. Upon this becoming known to the Washington Treasury, it did not from politic motives press the suit, because it was not deemed advisable to court his legal skill and assiduity in raising and considering the question of constitutionality thatt the Ad- ministration had always avoided discussing. It is known that he prepared an elaborate brief against the constitutionality of any direct income tax, which doubtless may Ihe Green Bag. t “ again be used by counsel who are preparing to raise the same question regarding the pending income tax. Between the years 1871 and 1874 Mr. Tilden’s time was mainly occupied by legal efforts in connection with Charles O’Conor and Wheeler H. Peckham, — who recently failed of confirmation after enjoying the legal honor of selection by the President as. suc- cessor to Justice Blatchford on the Supreme Court Bench, —against persons charged by the municipal government of New York City with peculations from, and frauds upon, the local treasury. His mathematical abil- ity again came successfully in play; and having been afforded access to certain bank accounts of those who were implicated, he was able to trace home to them by ingeni- ous manipulation of figures obtained from deposit tickets and cheques, large sums of | money. There were many civil suits for the repossession of the misgotten sums, upon one of which he made an appellate argu- ment that bristled with apt citations which exhibited his habitual patience of research and his aptness of illustrating the old saying about a cited case: ‘It stands on all fours.” His legal exertions in this behalf were given without fees and purely from regard to pub- lic benefit. But his reward came in an elec- tion to the office of governor, in which post again from time to time his legal abilities came into play towards exposing abuses of government and defining legal action. His knowledge of jurisprudence permeated all of his executive documents, showing conclu- sively, as in the instances of Wirt, Webster, Sumner, and Conkling,’that statesmanship need not dim the light of legal science. With Mr. Tilden’s race for the Presidency contemporaneous history has made every one more or less familiar; and this article aims to deal only with the legal incidents of that event. The first of these occurred when the strife between him and his antag- onist reposed in a balance that required the weight of only that one vote which had

Page 9

a Dna ae ee oe ee es ee A Soy 354 3 fe Pats - sete aid Sh ores ied Prghse eAN, A : ‘ Samuel J. Tilden as a Lawyer. a... once elected Marcus Morton governor of the Bay State. : Mr. Tilden, when the proposition was mooted — upon violent protestations of elec- toral frauds in three states preferred by his political supporters —that the famous elec- toral commission be appointed to declare result, prepared an opinion that, as to its con- clusions, however critics may agree or dis- agree, they will admit the learning and logi- cal force with which that opinion presented premises and illustrations. He combated strongly the constitutionality of Congress abdicatjng its powers of counting electoral votes and awarding them to an impromptu body born of occasion. He accompanied it with a remarkable table and notes as to the course pursued on each previous occa- sion in choice of President —a table that His politi- remains of great historic value. cal opponents retorted that he combated the commission because he wished to throw the election into the House of Representa- tives, in which his party held a majority: by vote of states; yet whatever was the motive for the Tilden brief, its legal aptness de- stroyed the time-honored, but often inaccur- ate, saying, ‘“‘ A lawyer in his own case has a fool for client.” During the discussion before the electoral commission Mr. Tilden filed an elaborate brief, afterwards pub- lished, regarding the Florida election, and discussing the oft-mooted legal question of the right to go behind certificates of elec- tion, and consult naked returns. All of Mr. Tilden’s notable briefs are installed on the shelves of the New York Law Institute; and each one indicates the extent and grasp of his legal attaifiments and adds to his en- during fame as lawyer.

Page 10

5° The Green Bag. LEGAL REMINISCENCES. IX. THE COMMON LAW AND THE CIVIL LAW: ENGLISH AND FRENCH SYSTEMS OF JURISPRUDENCE. By Hon. L. E. CHITTENDEN. ONCE had an opportunity of contrast- ing the English common law with the civil law as it was then administered in France, which was both entertaining and instructive. The experience gave me a clear impression of the impartiality and solidity of the common law, as interpreted by Eng- lish judges, and it also gave me my first knowledge of some of the usages of the French courts of justice, which at the time appeared extraordinary. My client was a corporation, the owner of a patent upon a machine, which, after many years of trial, had gone into an extensive public use. The machine had been patented in the United States, Great Britain, and France, and was manufactured and sold in all those countries. When the patent was about to expire in the United States, an ap- plication had been made for its extension for a further period of seven years. Al- though the extension had been opposed, I was able to prove so strong a case of merit, that by having the machine operated in the presence of the commissioner of patents, we obtained a decision in our favor, and the patent here was duly extended. An application was then made for a pro- longation of the British patent. This ap- plication was not advised by our experienced patent attorney in London, whose opinion was, that the utility of the invention would be affirmed, but that the English judges would decide that the inventor had been liberally rewarded by his profits during the original term for which the patent was granted. 3 However, the value of the patent for the prolonged term of seven years was so great, that the corporation decided to make the ap- plication, though without much hope of suc- cess. I was so familiar with the history of the invention, that I was requested to visit Lon- don, and give to the attorney and counsel there such assistance as I could in the pre- sentation of our application. ‘The case was thorougly prepared. The value of the invention to the people of Great Britain was conclusively proved. The point of difficulty was the profits already made. Former decisions of the tribunal indicated that if we did not present a plain and full statement of the profits which could not be justly criticised, the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council, before whom the appli- cation was pending, would reject it. We, therefore, under the direction of an expert accountant, prepared such a statement. Our junior counsel was the now celebrated Mr. Webster, then just coming into public notice as a painstaking advocate, much esteemed by the judges. He had mastered every detail of our case. Our leader was _then probably the most powerful advocate at the English bar. He was a man of pro- found scientific research and thought, the author of one of the great intellectual suc- cesses of the century — his treatise on ‘‘ The Correlation of the Physical Forces,” or the convertibility of heat, light, and force into each other. He was at that time (1868) the head of the patent-law bar, and within a few days after our trial was elevated to the bench, where he still lives to administer justice with honor to Great Britain and the name of SIR WILLIAM GROVE. Our patent was upon a revolving hook, scarcely larger than a dime, which was so

Page 11

Legal Remtntscences. 57 constructed that it performed a most effi- cient service, and involved extraordinary mechanical functions. Under the advice of Mr. Grove we had employed as a mechan- ical expert, a gentleman who was afterwards knighted and raised to higher honors in the scientific world by his inventions, and his influence in the use of life-saving appliances and the prevention of accidents in railway travel. I refer to the late Sir Frederick Bramwell. In our consultations, I was impressed with the clearness of his views and the simple and clear terms with which he expressed them to others, and I told him that, in my opinion, we had been most fortunate in securing his services. He re- plied that it was not yet certain that we had secured them, for if his brother, Baron Bramwell, sat in the Privy Council, when our case was heard, he would not appear as a witness, as he never did so in a case to be decided in whole or in part by his brother! His brother did not sit, and Sir Frederick was called by our counsel. The respect shown to his opinion by all the judges was an instructive illustration of the value of the evidence of an expert who was loyal to principles rather than parties. Sir Frederick appeared to have the confidence of all the judges, and his opinion on mechanical ques- tions was decisive. The following was an episode in his examination: — In illustrating the functions of the hook, Sir Frederick said that it was fixed to the end of the shaft, that the point of the hook entered a loop, and travelled forward as the hook revolved until the stitch was made. “You state an impossibility!’ exclaimed Lord Justice James, who seized his umbrella, the handle of which was a hook, and formed a loop with his handkerchief, into which he thrust it. ‘“ Now,” he continued, ‘‘do you not see that if this loop kept travelling for- ward, it would wind the thread upon the shaft, and it could never get out of the loop?” “And still, I insist that this hook does get out of the loop, and form, not only one stitch, but two or three thousand stitches in a minute without failure,” said Sir Frederick, “and I will make your lordship see and admit it.’ “Then you will make me admit a me- chanical impossibility,” said the judge. ‘Proceed; you act as if you believed what you assert.” “T think your lordship was born in a country of windmills,” said Sir Frederick. “You know they are constructed with a revolving top, through one side of which there is an opening for a door. Suppose that door opens to the north. You are tra- velling directly south. You enter the door. While you are crossing the structure, the .top makes a half revolution; the door now opens to the south. You have not halted, you have walked in a straight line, and now you walk out and continue your journey. | This hook performs a corresponding func- tion, and in this consists its ingenious novelty.” We made excellent progress, and had everything our own way until we came to the showing of profits. Lord Justice James looked at the footing which showed a bal- ance of some thirty thousand pounds. “Thirty thousand pounds!” he exclaimed, ‘That is large pay for so small a hook.” I saw that our case was gone. Mr. Grove -- made a powerful argument in which he showed that the simplicity of our machine made it the greatest boon ever conferred upon’ the poor sempstress; but his words fell upon unwilling ears. Mr. Webster added a few observations, and the curtain fell, which separated the bench from the audience. And the same curtain fell upon our case. When it was raised a few minutes later, Lord Justice James observed ‘“ that their lordships did not care to trouble the counsel for the - opponents to make any reply. The origin- ality and value of the invention were clearly proved, and the petitioners deserved the commendation of the court for the full and

Page 12

58 | fair presentation of the accounts. But it was not the practise of Her Majesty to grant any prolongation where the inventor had been adequately rewarded during the life of the patent. Their lordships were of opinion that in this case the inventor had been ade- quately and generously rewarded. Their lordships would therefore humbly advise Her Majesty to dismiss the petition with costs, which their lordships fixed at five hundred pounds.” This defeat was a disappointment to the petitioners, but I could not say that it was undeserved. The whole course of the trial impressed me as a fine exhibition of judicial. dignity and impartiality, and in subsequent interviews with our counsel, I learned that they concurred with me in the opinion that the judgment was a just and proper one. My client was the owner of a trade-mark. It had created the trade-mark and the manu- factured article to which Upon principles of law professed to be rec- ognized:among all commercial nations, this trade-mark was property. It had been pirated in France in the most outrageous manner for no other purpose than to enable the pi- rates to impose upon the public a worthless imitation as a genuine article of great utility, exclusively manufactured by its owners. _. It was not at that time known to me as it is now that in France no action upon a pat- ent or to protect a trade-mark was ever decided in favor of a foreigner against a Frenchman. My client consulted an Eng- lish solicitor who resided in Paris, who pre- pared his case with great labor and corres- ponding expense. He showed by the records that our client’s right to the exclu- sive use of the trade-mark had been estab- lished by judicial decisions in the United States, in England, and in Scotland, — that its ownership was acquiesced in every- where save in France, where it was pirated for the sole purpose of imposing an inferior article on the public as genuine. Counsel it was affixed. The Green a ees 7 of celebrity at the Paris bar were then con- sulted whose opinion was clear that sucha transaction was prohibited by the code, and could be restrained by legal proceedings. These had been begun; the trial of the case was approaching; I went to Paris to render such assistance as I could in its preparation. | A consultation with the avocat was neces-— sary. In this country, if a suitor wants a> consultation. with his lawyer, he goes to his office and has it. Notso in Paris. Itisa difficult thing to get, and is to be had only in one and the time-honored way. There was then, and I suppose still is, in France, a fifth wheel to the carriage of civil justice, called an avoué. What he is used for I never could clearly ascertain. I did learn that he was expensive and _ indispens- able. As well as I could make it out, the attorneys and the avocats are not permitted to communicate with the judges except in court. There is no knowing what would happen if they should. If either wants any one of the many things always wanted in the progress of the cause, instead of going to the judge and asking for it, he must do as the party did in the poem, who “went and told the sexton, and the sexton tolled the bell.” The attorney must go and tell the avocat, who will go and tell the avoué, who will go and tell the judge! And there is only one way for the client to get speech of his avocat. He must make his request to the attorney, who carriés it to the avoué, and the avoué to the avocat, who appoints the consultation. After several days’ delay, it was finally determined that there should be a consulta- tion at which I should be present. It took place at the chambers of the avocat. At the appointed hour I was driven to a house on one of the quais. I climbed the single stairway in a large apartment building to the cinguiéme étage, in company with butchers’ meat and all manner of market supplies, meeting on their way down buckets. of coal cinders, baskets of empty bottles,

Page 13

Legal Reminiscences. | 59 ~ anda miscellaneous assortment of bad odors and broken food on their way to the street. On the fifth floor there was the name of the avocat and a bell. As I touched the latter the door opened and disclosed a person of gigantic dimensions. He was fearfully and wonderfully adorned and ornamented. He evidently expected me, for he ushered me into an inner room, and made heroic efforts to announce my name. He failed. The attorney now came forward and pre- sented me to the avocat, who in turn pre- sented me to the president of the College of Avoués, a dignified gentleman, employed in our suit. The avocat set the example, and we were quickly in consultation. My French halted fearfully, but I managed to make myself understood. The avocat had discovered a serious difficulty. How it was to be obviated he did not see, but there must be some way, and if necessary he would take the opinion of one of his eminent brethren, who made a specialty of trade-mark cases. I begged him to inform me of the nature of the difficulty. He said there was a special provision of the French code which limited the protection in France of the trade-marks of foreigners to citizens of countries in which the trade-marks of Frenchmen were reciprocally protected, and in our case there was no proof that the trade-marks of Frenchmen were protected in the United States. I replied that such an obstacle ought not to prove fatal, as the highest judicial tribunal of the United States had decided that a trade-mark was recog- nized as property upon the principles of commercial law, and that the trade-marks of aliens would be protected-in the United States in all cases, whether other countries protected them or not; and I assured them that the proof would be furnished by a vol- ume of the reports of that court in which the decision was officially reported. The volume, I said, must be in their libraries, to which they assented, and this difficulty seemed to be obviated. We then discussed the case. I was so familiar with it that in spite of my unaccus- tomed French, I made my views clear. The avocat was delighted. ‘There was only one thing to be done,” he said; “an early interview must be arranged wth the judge, who would hear the case, and / must state my views to him in the same manner that I had in the consultation.” { thought I must have mistaken his meaning, but the avoué assented and said that he had no doubt that he could procure an invitation for me to breakfast with the judge. I am not easily shocked, but when I really appreciated all that was implied in their proposal, it was some time before I recovered my equilibrium. At length I spoke. ‘ Are you gentlemen seriously pro- posing that I should meet the judge who is to decide this case and discuss it with him in the absence of the adverse party and his counsel?”’ I asked. “Certainly, and why not?” replied the avoué. ‘It is probable that our adversaries have had more than one interview with him. It is not only proper, but the interests of our client will be promoted by the dis- cussion.” | “You will have to excuse me,” I said. ‘Ifa lawyer should attempt such an inter- view in the United States, he would be ex- pelled from the Bar, and would deserve the expulsion.” They did not seem to comprehend, nor pay much attention to my objection, but continued to converse on the subject. Soon after I took my leave, supposing that this matter was ended; but it was not— far from it. For, not many days afterwards, I re- ceived, through the secretary of our legation in Paris, a polite invitation to breakfast at the private apartment of one of the judges, on the following Saturday, with the usual request ‘for a reply. As the proceeding was novel to me, I consulted Mr. Washburn, our minister, who advised me to accept the in- vitation, and be circumspect in mf inter-

Page 14

60. course, as the best way out of the difficulty. I did so, and kept the appointment. We had an excellent breakfast and much general conversation. As I did not refer to the suit, the judge himself introduced the subject. He had examined the papers, understood the questions which the case presented, and took the position of an ad- versary, prepared to controvert our right to maintain the action. I declined the discus- sion, explained how I was drawn into the situation, and my strong sense of its impro- priety. He rather ridiculed my views, and explained why such discussions were not regarded as improper. It was ‘the theory of the civil law,” he said, “that the judge should be able to decide an action in con- formity with right and justice after hearing all that the parties wished to say about it, and that there was no possibility that a judge should be improperly influenced, and that there was sometimes an advantage in having a party state his own case.” I still persisted that I should leave the argument of our case to the avocat, the conversation turned to other topics, and we had a pleasant interview. The observations of the. judge explained why the judges received hearsay, everything which the parties offered as evidence, with- out objection. It was the theory of the civil law that the judges would be able to separate the wheat from the chaff, and that irrelevant testimony could do no harm, as they would consider nothing which had not a legitimate bearing upon the issues. This theory was well enough, but the final decision in our case did not support it. The trial came on; our property in the trade-. mark was substantially admitted —the in- feriority of the French counterfeit to the American machine was clearly proved. Our case seemed to be clear, but the judgment of the court was against the foreigner and in favor of the French pirate, or as the judges called him, the French ouvrier. There was a French patent upon one part of the rachine protected by the trade-mark. The Green Bag. The law of France for the protection of the French workmen required that patented machines must be manufactured in France. Our client had established a factory in Paris, in which many thousands of these machines had been made. The hook referred to was of an irregular and peculiar shape, which could not be well shown in a drawing. Under the advice of counsel, that it in- volved no violation of the French law, our client had imported one of these hooks through the Custom-House to serve as a pattern. As soon as another hook could be made, and within forty-eight hours, the im- ported hook was exported and sent to the United States. There was no doubt about its identity, or the fact of its exportation, but the French court decided that the bring- ing of this hook into France, and its use as a pattern, was such a violation of the law of France as forfeited not only the right to the trade-mark, but also all rights secured by the letters-patent; and that the French pi- rates could use the trade-mark, and impose a worthless manufacture as the genuine upon the French public with impunity. Our action was therefore dismissed with costs. With this experience in French justice my client was satisfied; it never went after any more, and I have never since advised an American to attempt to enforce his pat- ent or trade-mark in France. This same ex- perience brought to my mind an incident in Charles Reade’s novel “Hard Cash”: * Captain Fullalove, the former master of a merchant ship, had undertaken to educate and develop the intellect of a colored bro- ther named Vespasian. As they were pass- ing Westminster Hall, the captain pointed to the venerable pile, and observed to his pupil, ‘‘There’s where you can buy British justice. It comes high, but it’s prime!” While I agree with Captain Fullalove, I might make a similar observation about the Palais de Justice, with an amendment: ‘““There’s where you get French justice. It comes high, and it zs zot prime!”

Page 15

Detecting Human Blood. a DETECTING HUMAN BLOOD.! NOTHER safeguard has been thrown out against murder. Daniel Webster’s saying that ‘ murder will out” gathers more and more truth as time progresses. When he first made it, it was epigrammatic and effective, but it was inaccurate. It has been since time began less true that murder will out than it has been that burglary, or chicken stealing, or forgery will out. The mur- derer knows that the penalty of his crime is death. No man likes to pay that penalty. Every man will go to the most extravagant extreme to avoid paying it. When a man’s life instead of merely his liberty depends on carefully planning a crime beforehand and carefully hiding it afterward, he will make ereater efforts toward both these ends than he would in any other circumstances. It is true that about as large a proportion of mur- der mysteries as of burglar mysteries are solved, but the proportion is not quite as large, and it should be remembered that the forces of law and order exert twenty times as much energy toward tracing a murderer as they do toward tracing a burglar. Jus- tice often miscarries for lack of proper sci- entific aid. In one case in a great American city the whole thing went wrong, and the accused man — of whose guilt scarcely any one had doubt — was not even indicted, because sci- ence had no means of differentiating be- tween the blood of human beings and the blood of animals. It was clear that the man had had every opportunity for committing the crime, and indirect evidence of a motive for it existed, but when the matter was placed before the grand jury the only direct evidence,that he had been concerned in it was his possession of a knife stained with blood. He acknowledged that the knife was his and that it was he who had stained it with blood, but that it was the blood of a ? Edward Marshall, in the Galveston News. pet dog, upon whose broken leg he proved, that he had performed a rude operation, and although all the scientific knowledge in the city was brought to bear upon the subject, not one learned man was found who was certain enough of his learning to swear the life of the accused away by testifying posi- tively that the blood was human and not animal. In fact, this point has been one which has baffled scientific criminology ever since criminology became scientific. The minds of the greatest scientists in the world have been devoted to this problem, but have always failed to find a solution for it. Rec- ords exist of cases in which this very point puzzled prosecutions as long as a century ago. It remained, in fact, for a New York scientist to make this discovery less than three weeks ago, and in this article is given positively the first hint of it which has been heard by the public. The scientist is Dr. Cyrus Edson. He is already famous as a sanitationist, and through this expert knowledge has risen to the high position of president of the New York State Board of Health and commis- sioner of health in New York City. He is an investigating scientist. His wide reputa- tion and his prominent public position have caused him to be frequently called as an ex- pert in murder cases. Often the value of his testimony has hung upon the differentia- tion between the blood of animals and the blood of man. Notwithstanding that he had made a deep study of the subject, and knew that a well-defined and important difference existed, his means of defining that difference in his own mind and before the eyes of a jury was so delicate and so likely to be af- fected even unto inaccuracy by outside and slight conditions, that he never felt justified in giving positive testimony on this point. He was in the same position as that in which other scientists have found themselves. He

Page 16

62 was morally certain that his ideas were cor- rect, and knew that he could scientifically prove it, but still the basis of his reckoning was so narrow that he was unwilling to stand upon it when human life and liberty were at stake. In explaining Dr. Edson’s discovery, two things should be noted. First, the fact that it is as simple as the alphabet (at least one- third of the important discoveries have been), and, second, the formation and character of the blood must be fully understood. Blood is composed of watery elements and corpus- cles. disk. Viewed from the side it seems a per- fect circle. Viewed on end it looks like a dumb-bell. The only difference in the blood of different creatures is in the size and shape of the corpuscles. The blood corpuscles of a fish are large and flat, and in their centre is a small spot or nucleus. The blood of all birds and fowls is similar, but the corpus- cles are smaller. The blood of all animals, aside from birds, fishes, and reptiles, has smaller corpuscles without the nucleus. The presence of this nucleus has for many years made it possible to throw out the blood of fishes and birds in murder cases. Not long ago a case attracting much attention was tried in England. The issue hung on the statement of the defense that the blood on a knife found in the possession of the pris- oner was that of a turkey. This was abun- dantly disproven, because of the absence of the central nucleus in the corpuscles. Mi- - croscopic examination showed this plainly to the jury, and, as no claim had been made that the blood was that of any other animal, the argument was thrown out, and the man convicted and hanged. But no point exists by which it is equally possible to show the difference between the blood of a human being and the blood of a four-footed beast. It has been proven that a difference exists in the size of the blood corpuscles of all animals, including man. The corpuscles have been accurately measured by micro- wise. A. blood corpuscle is a bi-concave. The Green Bag. scopic examination, and no doubt whatever exists as to the truth of these measurements. It has long been quite possible for a scien- tist to take the blood found on a prisoner’s person, and measure its corpuscles so ex- actly that the scientist would have no moral doubt in pronouncing them human or other- But, as the figures following will show, the difference in measurements is so slight —a particle of dust, an unexpected refraction of light, the most minute optical illusion, might throw his calculations all awry — that no scientist has been willing to swear to the accuracy of his deductions on this basis. Here are his measurements: A blood corpuscle of a man has a diameter of I-3200 of an inch, the diameter of a dog’s blood is 1-3570 of an inch, that of a mouse I-3840 of an inch, that of an ox 1-4580 of an inch, that of a sheep 1-5000, that of a goat 1-5200 of an inch. A microscope will measure with fair ac- curacy to within 1-200000 of an inch, but as has been said, these measurements are so very delicate that a shade or the most min- ute difference in focus would derange and destroy their accuracy. For this reason they have not been useful in murder cases. Dr. Edson, in reflecting upon this subject not long ago, thought fantastically of the advantage that would accrue to justice if one could only enlarge these corpuscles so that a minute error in measurement would be less important. Suddenly, it occurred to him that by the very simplest method they might readily be enlarged, and it is because he thought of this simple method, and not because of any extraordinary learning in- volved in carrying it out, that he has made an important discovery. For many years it has been customary in cases of forgery to throw the suspected sig- nature in enlarged form upon a screen with a magic-lantern. He saw at once that this might as readily be done with blood corpus- cles as with a forged signature. ‘So he did it. First; he set about to measure 3,000

Page 17

FT ee, ae Lek Sa . tion in murder cases. Detecting Human Blood. 63 corpuscles of each kind of blood which seemed most likely to be brought into ques- He found the diame- ters to be as quoted above. Then by means of the camera lucida, an attachment to his microscope, he cast the image of an aver- age corpuscle of each variety onto a sheet of white paper, from which, with infinite care, he cut a disk exactly corresponding to it in size, but enlarged by means of com- passes. He saw to it that his focus was absolutely the same while he carried on this work, and he knew when he had finished that he had six disks of paper which bore exactly the same relation to each other in point of size that the blood corpuscles did to each other. He then took these disks of paper, pasted them on glass, and used them as a lantern-slide. This enabled him to throw them, on a screen magnified as many times as he chose. It would have been simple for him, had he so desired, to arrange an apparatus by which he could have made the smallest of them as large as the side of his study. He was contented, however, with magnifying them until the largest one measured about two feet across. It was then possible for him to take a foot-rule and measure the black spots on his screen with a certainty that the differences in size could not be affected by any small, extraneous influence. This method of cutting paper disks he selected as the most desirable, although at first it seemed that photography afforded the best means of accomplishing his ends. The adjustment of the photo- graphic focus, however, is so delicate a mat- : ter, that he soon realized that this would add to the possibilities of inaccuracy, and therefore abandoned it. When Superin- tendent Byrnes was told of Dr. Edson’s new method, he greeted the news with pleasure. Said .he: “Dr. Edson’s discovery is most important. Few people will realize -how — important it is until they know that within a year, at least fifteen murder cases have oc- curred in or near New York in which the identification of blood played a very import- ant part.”

Page 18

The Green Bag. ~ THE INTRUDING HERMIT. A Man shall have a Quare Impedit of an Hermitage, and a writ to put him into Corporal Possession. —¥.N. B., 34 E. | k. yy en holy hermit feels inclined To solitude and prayer, Still let him ever keep in mind Of trespass to beware. While he devoutly seeks to dwell From earth’s contagion free, He may not with another’s cell Take wanton liberty. IT. If far from vanity and strife He find a lonely spot, Which promises a tranquil life In wood or field or grot, Where well he deems that he may make Retreat in peaceful age, Yet let him not too rashly take That. for an hermitage. ITI. For should another holy saint Allege a prior claim, And make unto the court complaint, And duly prove the same, | The wrongful tenant surely shall By writ® evicted be Out of possession corporal With all indignity.

Page 19

Diet ee dete ed . Sa os 5, ee ee RP ee aE Ie OT ale eee TE NESTS ee ee on PR Ey a TN Lhe Enghsh Law Courts. 65 THE ENGLISH LAW COURTS. I.—THE PRIVY COUNCIL. SERIES of sketches of the English & Law Courts cannot make a better com- mencement than with the Privy Council, which is inferior to few of our legal tribunals in antiquity, coequal with the House of Lords in point of dignity, and superior to every court in the land in the range and the vari- ety of its jurisdictions. The origin of the jurisdictions of the Privy Council has some- what acutely divided historical opinion. The earliest theory on the subject is that of Pownall (Administration of the Colonies, 1774). In substance it is as follows: At ‘' the time when the first colonial settlements were effected, the distinction between ad- ministrative and judicial functions was very imperfectly apprehended. In_ settlements regulated by royal instructions the governor acted also as judge in chancery. In settle- ments constituted by charter there was no court of chancery at all. The governor was not necessarily a lawyer, and only a careful legal training would have qualified him for deciding as judge questions on which he had already formed and might even have pro- nounced an opinion in his administrative capacity. An appeal from the decisions of the colonial governor was therefore clearly essential. Now the one precedent of a judicature within the realm possessing for- eign jurisdiction which presented itself to the English sovereign and his advisers was that of the Privy Council over the Channel Islands. Jersey,’ known to the Romans as Cesarea, of which the modern name is prob- ably a corruption, had definitely passed with her sister islands under the yoke of the Nor- man.in the beginning of the tenth century, * Falle’s account of Jersey (Durell’s Edition, 1837). Guide to» Jersey, 1855. Le Cras, The Laws, etc., and their administration in Jersey, 1839. Report to the Privy Council on the Laws of Guernsey, 1819. (912 A.D.). When his other continental possessions had fallen from him, the Chan- nel: Islands still adhered, or were forcibly linked to the. fortunes of King John. In 1204 the royal conqueror honored Jersey with his presence, granted her a charter, recognized her laws, established a royal court, and directed that the appeals which were formerly brought before him as Duke of Normandy should now be heard before himself and his Council in England. Now the English sovereign claimed—a claim that the colonists acquiesced in,‘ and which the House of Commons itself (Pownall, 49; Burge, Colonial Law I., Prelim. Treat. ; Jour- nal Ho. of Com., April 25, 1621; April 29, 1624) had tacitly admitted—that his colonial settlements and possessions were the de- mesnes of the Crown, lying quite beyond the jurisdiction or cognizance of the state. The historical relation between the feudal duchies of King John and the plantations and pos- sessions of King Charles I. being so intimate, no great effort of administrative imagination was necessary to make the analogy com- plete. Thus it came to pass that appeals from the courts, constituted in the various colonies after the old Norman model, were taken not to the House of Lords, not to the Courts of Law and Equity, but to the sover- eign himself and the concilium privatum assiduum ordinartum, which plays so impor- tant and intricate a part in the legal history of England. Pownall’s theory, although characterized t Pownal§ says (p. 50), “The plantations were settled on (the king’s) lands by the king’s license and grant; the constitutions and powers of government were framed by the king’s charters and commissions; and the colonists, understanding themselves as removed out of the realm, considered themselves in their executive and legislative capacity of government in immediate connection and sub- ordination to the king, their only sovereign lord.”

Page 20

66 bya superficial ingenuity which is singularly | attractive, and has enlisted the sympathy of more than one able writer on colonial law (e. g. Burge and Clark), has been partially rejected by Macqueen (Appellate Jurisdic- tion of the House of Lords), whose criti- cisms may thus be summarized: (a) It is incorrect to say that at the time when ap- peals from the colonies to the Privy Coun- cil were settled, there was no other prece- dent than in the Roy- al Court of Jersey for ‘an appeal to a judica- ture within the realm possessing foreign ju- risdiction. (0d) There is no proof that Jer- sey and Guernsey were at that time remnants of.the duchy of Normandy. ‘(c) It is incorrect to say that appeals from Jersey. and Guernsey were brought before the king in council. | In support of this proposition Mac- queen cites from the Rolls of Parliament, vol. 1,416, the case of a petition from the Channel Islands against Sir Otho de Grandison for pro- curing the delay and denial of justice, which ‘was presented to the king and his council (27 Parl. 18 Ed. 2, 1324, 5), and ordered to be brought before Parliament. by a writ of error from the chancery. After so much destruc- tive criticism it was necessary that Mac- queen should evolve a theory of his own. In substance it is as follows: The kings of England had three councils, (1) the com- mune concilium, consisting of the sovereign and both Houses of Parliament, (2) the The Green Bag. LORD BROUGHAM. = magnum concilium, the House of Lords or Court of Parliament, and (3) the concilium privatum assiduum ordinarium, which was the permanent Privy Council of the Crown. There is clear evidence that the last named were the constant assessors of the House of Lords, investigated and even determined writs of error in Parliament under the au- thority of a reference by the peers, and, at all events since 33 Edw. I., acted as the triers of domestic and foreign petitions. the Privy Council in these matters was at first derivative only, and no inherent civil jurisdiction was claimed or exercised. But the _ intervals gradually becoming longer between the sessions of Parlia- ment, rendered the mode of redress un- satisfactory, and by a change almost con- temporaneous* with the establishment of the Court of Exche- quer Chamber to ad- judicate on writs of error from the Queen’s Bench (27 | Eliz. c. 8), the Privy Council came to discharge in their own right those functions which would have devolved upon them as triers had Parliament been summoned. The trial of foreign petitions by parliamentary commissioners was _ aban- doned, and the separate and independent jurisdiction of the Privy Council was ex- ? Appeals from the Channel Islands to the Privy Coun- cil are said to have been granted in the time of Henry VIIL., but the earliest instance in the Privy Council Records is in 1572. The authority of. 0 a eC eee ee,

Page 21

NE Oe ae ee ee De ee ae a ae OEE Pe ge hnaee od a ee eae, ee Sree Poe The English Law Courts. 67 tended first to the colonial and then to the East Indian possessions of the Crown. As if the variance between Pownall and Mac- queen did not render the difficulty. sufh- ciently acute, the statute 25 Hen. VIII. c. 9 appears to suggest another explanation of the origin of the appellate jurisdiction of the Privy Council. Under. that act a sub- ject aggrieved by the decision of any court in any part of the King’s dominions might appeal to the King in Chancery. Every such appeal was referred by a commission under the Great Seal to: the Court of Delegates, ordinarily consisting of three puisne judges, one from each of the common term courts, and three or more civilians, usual-' ly members of the bar; and the deci- sions of the Court of Delegates. were, in spite of a distinct prohibition in a stat- ute of Elizabeth, re- viewed upon petition by the Privy Council. We have, therefore, three distinct theo- ries with regard to the ‘:phenomenon in question.. Are they so hopelessly irrecon- cilable as to make it impossible to indi- cate the general course of development which the appellate jurisdiction of the Privy Council has pursued? We think not. 1. The right of the sovereign to entertain an appeal from any colonial court is undis- putcd, and indeed (Chalmers’s Opinions of Eminent Lawyers) indisputable. 2. The conflicting theories relate to different points LORD COLERIDGE, of time. Macqueen-speaks of the fourteenth century; Pownall of the seventeenth; while the Court of Delegates lasted till the begin- ning of the reign of William IV. It is certain that in less than a century the body to which the Crown entrusted the administration of colonial affairs was repeatedly reconstituted. Why may not the judicature for colonial affairs have undergone similar changes in the course of three centuries? The mod- ern history, at least, of the Privy Council as a court of law is so well known as to need only a brief re- capitulation. 2 and 36° Wills) TV vee transferred to the King in Council the jurisdiction of the Court of Delegates. C. 67, 3, and 4 Will. IV.c. 41, created the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council, in which is now vest- ed all the former ju- dicial authority of the Privy Council, the Commissioners of Appeals in prize causes, and the Court of Delegates. The Judicial Committee comprises the Lord President of the Council, the Lord Chancellor, the Lords Justices, and such other members of the Privy Council as shall hold or shall have held certain judicial or other offices enum- erated in the acts. The fourth section of _this statute is declaratory of the sovereign’s right to refer to the Judicial Committee ‘any other matters whatever.’ We shall return to this provision later,on. Under 6 and 7 Vict. c. 38 an appeal. may, by order

Page 22

68 in Council, or by special direction of Her Majesty under her sign manual, be heard by not less than three members of the Judi- cial Committee. 14 and 15 Victoria pro- vides that no appeal shall be heard unless three members of the Judicial Committee, exclusive of the Lord President of the Coun- cil, are present. Under 7 and 8 Vict. c. 69 Her Majesty may, by general order in Council published in the “ London Gazette,” within one calendar month from the making of it, or by special order in Council, provide for the admission of an appeal, although there is no court of error or appeal in the colony from. which it is brought. By 34 and 35 Vict. c. 91 Her Majesty was empowered ‘to appoint within twelve months after the passing of the act, by warrant under her sign manual, four additional judges, each being or having been a judge of one of the supe- rior courts at Westminster, or a chief justice of Bengal, Madras, or Bombay, to act as members of the Judicial Committee. Fin- ally, under the appellate jurisdiction acts, 1876 and 1887, provision was made for the ultimate substitution of two additional lords ordinary of appeal for the four paid judges appointed under the Judicial Committee Act, 1871 (34 and 35 Vict. c. 91), and thus for the ultimate fusion of the Judicial Committee and the House of Lords. . Having thus sketched the history of the Privy Council as a court of law, and the statutory development of the Judicial Com- mittee, we are now in a position to consider its jurisdiction more minutely. The cases which the Privy Council decides are prac- tically divisible into four classes: _I. Peti- tions for the prolongation of letters patent for inventions; II. Appeals from the eécle- siastical courts; III. Colonial and Indian appeals; and IV. References by the Crown on the advice of a responsible minister. We may deal shortly with these in turn: — I. Prior to 1835 the term of letters patent (fourteen years) could not be extended except by special act of Parliament. The The Green Bag. frequency, however, with which application was made to the Legislature for statutory assistance, suggested the propriety of fram- ing some general measure providing for the extension of letters patent; and accordingly Lord Brougham’s act (5 and 6 Will. IV., c. 83, s. 3) enabled the Judicial Committee, after due inquiry, to report to Her Majesty in favor of a. prolongation not exceeding seven years. A later statute (6 and 7 Vict., c. 69, s. 2), empowered the Judicial Com- mittee to advise an extension for a period not exceeding fourteen. years, where it was shown that the patentee had been unable to obtain a due remuneration for the expense and labor in perfecting his invention during the original term, and that: a grant of seven years would not suffice for his reimburse- ment. II. The Privy Council is the ultimate Court of Appeal from the _ ecclesiastical courts, such as the Archdeacon’s Court and the Court of Arches. As we shall describe the ecclesiastical courts. in a separate paper, any further notice of them may be waived for the present. III. By far the most important of the functions of the Privy Council is its juris- diction in colonial and Indian appeals. This jurisdiction is practically of a twofold character. The letters.patent, royal instruc- tions, local or imperial acts, and orders in Council, under which courts of law are es- tablished in the British, possessions ard de- pendencies abroad, frequently grant to liti- gants.a right of appeal to the Privy Council in certain cases and under certain specified conditions. Thus it is sometimes provided that an appeal may be taken from any judg- ment affecting a sum in excess of a claim to property or civil right amounting to 4500 in value, if leave to appeal is asked within fourteen days from the date of the judg- ment appealed against, and security, fixed by the court below, is found within three months of the petition for leave to appeal. Apart altogether, however, from any en-

Page 23

— eS aero. ee wes ere ee ee Lhe English Law Courts. 69 abling charter or statutory rights, the Queen in’ Council—i.e., for this purpose the Privy Council— may give special leave to appeal (a) in civil cases of substantial, general, or constitutional importance, and (b) in criminal cases where it is shown that by a disregard of the forms of legal process or by some violation of the principles of natural justice, substantial and grave injustice has been done to the appellant. Such leave may be granted even although the constitution of the possession or depend- ency where the case is tried contains no provision whatever for any appeal being brought. A few in- stances of this spe- cial leave jurisdiction may be of interest. The High Court of Judicature for the Northwest Provinces of India ordered an infant to be taken from the custody of her mother, a Mo- hammedan, on the erounds that the mi- nor’s deceased father had been a professed Christian, and that the mother, who (as the Court held) was living in adultery, was inducing her daughter to adopt the Moham- medan faith and habits (ve Skinner, 1870 L. R.3 P. C. 451). Again, in The Speaker of the Legislative Assembly of Victoria v. Glass, (1871 L. R. 3, P. C. 561), a question was raised involving the right of the Legislature of Victoria to commit ‘for contempt and breach of the privilege of that assembly under the general warrant of the speaker. Lastly, in Neo v. Neo (1873 L. R. 5 P. C. SIR GEORGE JESSEL. 89), the Supreme Court of the Straits Settle- ments refused leave to appeal to the Queen in Council, on the ground that it did not possess the power to grant it. In each of these cases special leave was given. On the other hand, such leave was refused in Prince v. Gagnon (1883, L. R. 8 App. Cas. 102), in which only a sum of about £1000 was involved, and no grave point of law or of | public interest carry- ing with it any after consequences de- pended on the de- cision, and in ex parte Kensington(8 Jurisp. N.S. 1111), where a claim was. resisted, not on its merits, but on the ground of a mere formal defect of procedure on the part of claimant. These were all civil cases. Criminal cases stand on a somewhat different footing. It was at one time (Reg. v. Eduljee Byramjee, 276) said that ‘no appeal lies in cases of felony to the Queen in Council from any of the do- minions of the Crown of Great Britain which are governed by the law of Eng- land.” This doctrine may now be con- sidered as overruled. But the Privy Council is by no means ready to give special leave in criminal cases lightly. The circumstances under which it will enter- tain criminal appeals are well stated by Sir J. T. Coleridge in The Attorney-General for New South Wales v. Bertrand (1867 L. R. 1 P.C. at p. 530): ‘ Any application to be allowed to appeal in a criminal case

Page 24

70 The Green Bag. attached thereto. Jhe ordinance under comes to this Committee laboring under a great preliminary difficulty—a_ difficulty not always overcome by the mere suggestion of hardship in the circumstances of the case. When the suggestions, if true, raise ques- tions of great and general importance and likely to occur often, and also where, if true, they show the due and orderly administra- tion of the law interrupted and diverted into a new course which might create a prece- dent for the future, and also where there is no other means of preventing these conse- quences, then it will be proper for this Com- mittee to entertain an appeal if referred to it for its decision.” Now let us. illustrate the application of this principle on both sides. A solicitor of the Supreme Court of British Honduras was convicted of perjury upon a most improper and unfair charge by the Chief-Justice of the colony, and was sentenced to six months’ imprisonment, which he underwent.' He was thereafter struck off the rolls of the Court in respect of the said conviction. The solicitor obtained special leave to ap- peal to the extent of showing that the con- viction was so improperly obtained that it ought not to be conclusive for the purpose of striking his name off the rolls (ve A. M. Dillet, 1887, 12 App. Cas. 459). Again, in the Falkland Islands Co. v. Reg. the deci- sion of the colonial court —— a summary con- viction for penalties for killing animals feve nature — involved the right of the Falk- land Islands Co. to hunt and take wild cat- tle upon grazing stations and the land * The Judicial Committee have no jurisdiction to enter- tain an appeal from orders by a court of record in the colonies inflicting fines for contempt (Rainy v. The Jus- tices of Sierra Leone, 8 Mod. P. C. 4), if it appears, upon the face of the order, that the party has committed a con- tempt, that he has been duly summoned, and that the punishment awarded was of an appropriate kind. The law bearing upon this point is rather obscure, but this note appears accurately to express the ratio decidendi of the following cases: Smith v. Justices of Sierra Leone, 3 Mod. P. C. 361; ve Stewart, L. R. 2 P. C. 88; ve Wallace, L. R. 1 P. C. 283; ve Macdermott ib. 260; ve Pollard L. R. 2 P. C, 106, and see Australian case, Reg. v. Morrison, 3 Wom L, 3. dismissed, an appeal. which the conviction was made granted no appeal. The Judicial Committee advised Her Majesty to grant an appeal in analogy to proceedings by certiorart in England, on the understanding that the question of title and right would appear on the face of the record which was ordered to be brought up. On the other hand, in the following cases the Privy Council refused to entertain, or In Levien v. Reg. (1867 L. R. 1 P. C. 536) special leave to appeal from a conviction for libel by a colo- nial court having been given, the prisoner subsequently obtained a free pardon. The Judicial Committee thereupon declined to enter upon the merits of the case, or to pro- nounce an opinion upon the legal objections to the conviction, the prisoner having already obtained all the substantial, if not the tech- nical, benefit which could be conferred by a successful appeal. Riel’s case (1885 L. R. 10 App. Cas. 675) is also in point. Louis Riel was tried before a Canadian magistrate and a jury of six for high treason, and _ sen- tenced to death. The sentence was con- firmed by the Court of Queen’s Bench in Manitoba. The prisoner then applied for special leave to appeal to the Privy Council, on the grounds that the stipendiary magis- trate had no jurisdiction, and that even if he had there were irregularities in the proceed- ings which vitiated the trial; e.g. no previous inquest, no indictment preferred by a grand jury, and that no notes of the evidence had been taken as required by the statute. These points had been fully considered by the Court of Queen’s Bench, and a defense of insanity set up for the prisoner at the trial had been rejected by the jury.. The peti- tion was dismissed. Deeming’s case (App. Cas. 1892, p. 422) is the last one that we will refer to in this connection. Deeming was convicted and sentenced to death at Melbourne on May 2, 1892, for the murder of Emily Mather at Windsor. An application was made on his

Page 25

i. —s ae ee a. - : 4 7 ‘? ~— Pee ¥ 7 ; 4 pe ’ 77 Peg gested that on the ’ was not The English Law Courts. 71 behalf to the Judicial Committee for special leave to appeal against the conviction. In substance it was of a two-fold character. First, it was alleged that certain affidavits were on their way from this country to Aus- tralia, which might convince the colonial authorities that Deeming was insane, and so induce them to advise Her Majesty to exer- cise her prerogative of mercy. Then it was, rather by implication | than otherwise, sug- evidence before the colonial court Deem- ing wads improperly convicted. The ap- plication was refused. In giving the decision of the Judicial Com- mittee, Lord Hals- bury, then Lord Chancellor, pointed out that the first ground on which the application was based : one with which the Privy Council could have any concern (but was matter for the con- sideration of the ex- ecutive); while, in regard to the second, the Privy Council were merely being invited to review the | verdict of the jury on question of fact. Deeming was therefore executed with the approval of the whole civilized world. IV. In addition to these jurisdictions, the Privy Council has authority, as we have seen, to consider any other matters referred to it by the Crown. The most recent in- stance of the exercise of this power is the case of Mr. Yelverton, the ex-chief-justice of the Bahamas. Mr. Roger Dawson Yel- verton, barrister at law, was appointed chief- LORD BRAMWELL. justice of the Bahama Islands during the lifetime of the late Conservative government. He sailed for the “ Land of the Pink Pearl,” and entered upon his judicial duties. On one occasion a colonist who had been a liti- gant in the Supreme Court sent him a pres- ent of pineapples. The chief-justice re- turned the gift, and made some observations on the subject from the bench, in the course of which he said that he had ‘to sustain the rectitude” of the. resident magistrates. Mr. Moseley, the ed- itor of a local paper, “The Nassau Guar- dian,’ published in his columns a letter from a_correspond- ™ ent, in which Mr. — Yelverton’s conduct was ironically com- pared with that of Chief-Justice | Gas- coigne, who taught Prince Hal, in the reign of Henry IV., that the law was above the Crown, and sarcastic com- ments were made up- on the pineapple in- cident and on Mr. Yelverton’s fitness for his post. Mr. Yelverton summoned Mr. Moseley to his chambers, and demanded the name of the writer and the delivering- up of the offending. manuscript. Mr. Moseley refused compliance with the de- mand. ‘Thereupon he received notice to appear before the chief-justice, and was promptly committed for contempt. The Governor, Sir Ambrose Shea, released him; and the legal question raised by this unfortunate conflict, viz., whether the con- tempt of court alleged to have been com-

Page 26

72 mitted was a crime which the Governor had power to pardon, was referred to the Judicial Committee by Her Majesty on the advice of the Colonial Secretary, and an- swered in the affirmative. A second refer- ence (on the question whether Mr. Yelver- ton ought to be removed from his office) arose from the Bahamas case, and was heard late in 1893 before Lords Herschell, Watson, Bowen, Hobhouse, Shand, Cole- ridge, Morris, Sir Richard Couch, and the Earl of Jersey, who, although a layman, had been a colonial governor, and was therefore added to the Commit- tee. But any formal decision was avoided by Mr. Yelverton’s resignation. Another case (a similar kind) came before the Privy Council in 1891. Mr. Henry Frederick Gibbons, barrister at law, had been ap- pointed judge of the Eastern District Court of Jamaica in November, 1881. He was transferred to the Northern District in Janu- ary, 1882, and to the Southern District in November, 1883. On 20th of September, 1884, Mr. Gibbons had an altercation and fracas in the precincts of the court-house at Mandeville with a solicitor named Daly Lewis. The governor, Sir Henry Norman, called upon him for an explanation, and ultimately suspended him from office on the advice of the Privy Coancil of Jamaica. Thereupon Mr. Gibbons returned to Eng-_ land, and demanded an investigation into his conduct. Lord Derby, then Secretary of State for the Colonies, directed Sir Henry Norman to appoint a committee to inquire and report; and Sir Henry Norman ap- pointed the chief-justice (Sir Adam Gib Ellis), Mr. Justice Curran, and another gen- tleman to act as commissioners. Mr. Gib- bons was present during the inquiry. In due time the report of the commissioners was made and sent to England, and on 20th April, 1885, the Colonial Secretary required Mr. Gibbons to resign as an alternative to being dismissed. . Mr. Gibbons resigned and returned to England. Shortly afterwards The Green Bag. he raised an action against Sir Henry Nor- man, which was referred by consent to the arbitrament of Lord Herschell. After a careful inquiry Lord Herschell decided in favor of the Governor, on the ground that his act had been ratified by the Secretary of State. His lordship, however, also found that Mr. Daly Lewis, and not Mr. Gibbons, was to blame for the fracas; and an effort was, therefore, subsequently made to induce the Privy Council to reopen the whole ques- tion of the circumstances under which Mr. Gibbons was dismissed. This their lordships refused to do, (1) because the dismissal was an administrative act which could not be re- viewed in any court of law, and (2) because his letter of resignation put Mr. Gibbons out of court. Lord Watson, however, observed that the matter could have been dealt with, if it had been referred to the Privy Council .by the Crown. The Privy Council sits, as often as is nec- essary to overtake its list of causes, every legal term. Its sittings are held in the council room at the Privy Council office in Downing Street. The councillors present do not wear wigs or robes, but sit on either side of an oblong table, separated from the rest of the room by a wooden barrier, in the middle of which is placed a desk (like that from which an Episcopal clergyman reads “the lessons”), and from behind this coun- sel address the court. The subjoined dia- eram may bring out the different points more clearly. Privy CounciIL Room. Passages, Table. Passages. Lu} Counsel’s Desk. | Reporters. |

Page 27

=. a i Se ae ae ae ee tee |S eS. se ae . The English Law Courts. 73 At the conclusion of the argument of an appeal, counsel are directed to withdraw, a practice doubtless due to the fact that the Judicial Committee is a board, and a pretty numerous one, whose deliberations can best be carried on in private, and the committee either make up their minds on the spot or decide to postpone judgment. The deci- sion of the Judicial Committee is delivered by one of their num- ber only, so that no divergencies of opin- ion are disclosed. The origin of this rule probably i is that in strict theory the Judicial Committee advise her Majesty as to the course which should be tak- en, and do not give a formal judgment like other courts of law. But, as Mr. Westlake has well pointed out, this mode of procedure detracts from the au- thority of Privy |, Council decisions without adding any- thing to the dignity of the body giving them. In one of Mr. Gladstone’s Home Rule bills a_ posi- tion was assigned to the Privy Council not unlike that now occupied by the Supreme Court of the United States. But as neither of these measures has any immediate (some would add, or remote) prospect of passing into law, we need not further consider them here. The history of the English Common Law and Equity Courts stretches so far back into the past that it would be difficult, if not impossible, to give any adequate account of LORD ESHER. their judges and barristers. But the com- paratively modern origin of the Judicial Committee to a large extent obviates this difficulty. Amongst the leading members of the Judicial Committee a foremost place must be assigned to Henry Lord Brougham. Born in Edinburgh on 19th September, 1778, and educated at the High School, Brougham joined the Scotch bar in 1800. Except in criminal cases, however, he did not acquire a large practice north of the Tweed, his reputation for eccen- tricity having appar- ently repelled the cautious Scots from entrusting him with their civil suits. But he was one of the brilliant band of liter- ary lawyers (Jeffrey and Harry Cockburn were amongst the others) who raised the ‘“‘ Edinburgh Re- view” to the highest ‘pitch of journalistic fame. In 1807 he was admitted to the English bar, and soon became the leading advocate for the de- fence in the far too numerous libel prose- cutions then instituted by the Crown. He also attained the distinction of being the ad- viser of Caroline of Brunswick, then Princess of Wales, and when she became Queen, de- fended her in conjunction with Denman dur- ing those famous trials which made them both the most popular lawyers of the age. It was as counsel for the Queen that Brougham uttered the memorable passage which has bulked so largely in the subsequent history of forensic casuistry: ‘‘ An advocate, by the

Page 28

74 sacred duty which he owes his client, knows in the discharge of that office but one per- son in the world — that client and none other. To save that client by all expedient means, to protect that client at all hazards and costs to all others, and among others to himself, is the highest and most unquestioned of his duties, and he must not regard the alarm, the suffering, the torment, the destruction he may bring on any other. Nay, separat- ing even the duties of a patriot from those of an advocate, and casting them if need be to the wind, he must go on reckless of the consequences if his fate it should unhappily be to involve his country in confusion for his client’s protection.” Lord Brougham subsequently attempted to explain this wholly indefensible language. ‘The real truth is,” he said, “‘ that the statement was anything rather than a deliberate and well- considered opinion. It zasa menace, and it was addressed chiefly to George IV., but also to wiser men such as Castlereagh and Wel- lington. Iwas prepared, zz case of necessity, that is, in case the bill (for the Queen’s divorce) passed the Lords, to do two things: first to resist it in the Commons with the country at my back, but next, if need be, to dispute the King’s title, to show he had for- feited the crown by marrying a Catholic, in the words of the succession act, as tf he were naturally dead.’ One might be dis- posed to regard Brougham’s language as simply an instance of the unbridled license which led him to denounce Peel— whose shoe’s latchet he was unworthy to unloose —as ‘‘the mean, base, fawning parasite” of Wellington. But heafterwards expounded the advocate’s duty, as he conceived it, in not wholly dissimilar terms; and—to the credit of the English bar be it said —the exposition was promptly condemned by Chief-Justice Cockburn, who declared that a barrister must exercise his art with the weapons of a soldier and not with the poi- -soned dagger of an assassin. Brougham became Lord Chancellor in 1830, and played Cairns or Jessel. The Green Bag. an important part in the judicial work of the Privy Council, and in the judicial and legislative work of the House of Lords, till 1860. He died on 7th May, 1868. During his chancellorship his utmost energies were applied to securing the enactment of: the Reform Bill, and to the support of other ministerial measures, and to the reform of the Court of Chancery, from which he swept away a great number of sinecure places entailing enormous expense on_ suitors. He took an active part in the creation of the Judicial Committee, and was the author of the Act of 1835, by which the prolongation of letters-patent was brought within its juris- diction... Perhaps the judgment of Lord Brougham’s that has excited most discus- sion was that in Waring v. Waring, where he held that even the least degree of mental disease would destroy testamentary capa- city. This doctrine was, however, over- thrown by the decision of Chief-Justice Cockburn in Banks v. Goodfellow. Lord Brougham was not a great lawyer or judge in the sense in which we apply the term to But he had one of the keenest and brightest intellects and one of the best stored minds. ever possessed by man. Another judge who has taken a prom- inent part in Privy Council appeals is Lord Penzance (Sir J. P. Wilde). Born in 1816, and educated at Winchester School and Trinity College, Cambridge, Wilde was called to the bar of Lincoln’s Inn in 1839, and joined the Northern Circuit. In 1840 he was appointed junior counsel to the ex- cise and customs, and soon acquired a large mercantile and admiralty practice. He took “silk” in 1855, was appointed Baron of the Exchequer in 1860, succeeded Sir Cress- well Cresswell in the Court of Probate and Admiralty in 1863, and was raised to the House of Lords with the title of Lord Pen- zance in 1869. We shall have to refer to some of his judgments-.in dealing with the ecclesiastical courts, and the Probate and

Page 29

Lhe English Admiralty Courts. Inthe meantime it may suffice to say that, like his brother, Lord Chancellor Truro, he has been both a care- ful administrator and an able expounder of legal principles. At the present day, per- haps the most striking figure in the Privy Council (or in the House of Lords) is Lord Watson. For many years at the Scotch bar, to which he belongs, for his connection with Law Courts. 75 takes part. Not only in Scotch, but in Eng- lish and Irish appeals to the House of Lords, and in Indian and colonial appeals and pat- ent petitions to the Privy Council, Lord Wat- son has displayed a versatility of intellect and a power of mastering and expounding the principles and the practice of legal systems, in which by the very necessity of the thing he was absolutely unlearned at the date of DOWNING STREET, LONDON (IN WHICH THE PRIVY COUNCIL IS SITUATED). the English bar is titular, Mr. Watson, as he then was, proved a somewhat indifferent success. As Lord Advocate under the Con- servative government he prosecuted the poi- soner Chantrelle, and also the City of Glas- gow Bank directors, with ability. On the death of Lord Gordon, he was promoted in 1878 to the House of Lords as a lord of appeal in ordinary, and since that date he has acquired an almost unique position both in that tribunal and in the Judicial Com- mittee, in whose deliberations he usually o his promotion to the bench of the supreme tribunal. To say that he is the first Scotch. or Irish law lord who has been a notable figure in the House of Lords or Privy Coun- cil is the truth, but far from the whole truth. Lord Watson has been for some years, and is still the dominant spirit in both tribunals, and he is certainly the judge with whom counsel fear most to grapple. A position so commanding has not, of course, been left unassailed by hostile critics; and Scottish legal fledglings, peeping down over the rim

Page 30

79 of their little nests at the larger world beneath, are wont to chirrup surprise at the respect paid to their countryman in England in spite of his original unfamiliarity with English practice and his Doric accent. But The Green Bag... Lord Watson’s record is-in the Law Re- ports; English lawyers know its volume and its worth, and he can afford to disregard the carpings of critics whose brains he could ‘“‘srind to powder with a lady’s fan.” LEX. THE LAW OF THE LAND. IX. THE SCIENTER. BY WM. ARCH. McCLEAN. E dare to believe we know somewhat of the nature and character of the scienter. Our presumption owes its exist- ence toa memory. The Professor was lec- turing on that portion of Chitty’s Pleading in which the scienter is explained. It had been gone over carefully, yet a certain stu- dent —do not ask us who, for we will abso- _ lutely refuse to be more personal —had not heard, by reason of some inattention, and was surprised with a request to tell his con- ception of the scienter. Desiring to, be obliging, he volunteered that “it was a knowing.” This was met by the Professor with: “A knowing— quite likely —very good — but of what?” “Why, it was just a knowing,” and the class audibly smiled at the knowledge. Then and there the scienter was clearly and forcibly explained in a way that the certain student was not likely to forget. The owners of domestic animals, such as dogs, horses, and oxen are not liable for injuries committed by them unless it can be shown that they had notice — the scienter— of the animals’ mischievous pro- pensity to do injury. The scienter is a question for the jury. The scienter does not merely consist in the fact that an injury has been done by a do- mestic animal, but that the owner Anew of a mischievous propensity of the animal to do injury, and knowing this, kept the animal at his risk, to be responsible for injuries com- mitted by it. The law gives the animal a fair chance to behave. The animal may have a pedigree it is proud of, may have the blue blood of an illustrious ancestry, may have always conducted itself in a digni- fied and peaceful way, may have never met an occasion to have aroused the mischievous propensity. At last, like mankind, the temp- tation presents itself, and the animal breaks over the traces. It is not the first fall that causes the trouble, but the subsequent steps downward with the owner’s knowledge. A certain respectable dog entered the lot of an old lady, probably an Irish descendant of Mother Goose, for her name was Mul- herrin, and killed her goose. It could not have been the goose that laid the golden - eggs, for the judgment given the old lady for her goose was four dollars. There was no evidence in the case against the dog, his respectability was not attacked, no proof submitted of his mischievous propensity to do harm, nor that the owner had any notice thereof; hence the judgment was reversed, and the old lady had no damages to console her for the loss of her goose. Of all domestic animals the dog seems to r

Page 31

The Law of the Land. have had the greatest trouble to establish his magna charta of rights. that dogs, being of no intrinsic value, but being kept only through the whim or ca- price of their owners, cannot be the subject of larceny. Under George III. the dog’s legal status was advanced, and to steal a dog was made subject to penal+ punishment by fine or imprisonment, and for the second offense, in addition the dog-stealer was to be whipped. Yet it has been held that dogs were entitled to less legal regard and pro- tection than more harmless and_ useful domestic animals. Continuing to grow in favor in ‘the eyes of the law, courts have held that the same liberty did not appertain to the horse. as to the dog, for dogs are a domestic ani- mal, which everybody in every place owns, and keeps, and suffers to go at large. The custom is almost as old as time, for Tobit had his dog. The universality of this cus- tom has made the practice lawful, unless where it is interdicted by statute. Legislatures have at times required a uni- ‘form good moral character of dogs. A local statute of Pennsylvania at one time directed that dogs should be chained or. housed at night. Where dogs killed sheep, it was held that under this statute it was unnecessary to prove that the’ dogs were addicted to killing sheep and that their own- ers had knowledge of this viciousness. The law dispensed with the scienter. The fact that the dogs were abroad at night, not chairied or housed, was sufficient to make their owners liable for the damages done. Generally it is now held that dogs belong to the class of domestic. animals which are not ordinarily dangerous, but when they . become mischievous, and knowledge of this is brought home to the owner, he is liable in damages for the misdemeanors of his dog. It has been declared that the scienter is not the negligent keeping of the dog, but the keeping of him with knowledge of his vicious disposition: The circumstances may be Blackstone says. ik such that the scienter virtually proves itself. If the dog has been muzzled and is then let loose without a muzzle, or if a dog is chained in the daytime and let loose at night, these facts of themselves can establish the scienter. There have been circumstances in which it has been held not only that no scienter need be proven, but that the public is entitled to notice from the owner of a domestic ani- mal likely to be vicious. Inan English case it was said: ‘‘In case of a dangerous animal likely to do mischief to another in a private close, it should seem that public notice ought to be given, although no one has a right to enter. If there be a foot-path in a close and a dangerous animal is put in there, the owner must give notice or he will be liable to an action for any injury committed.” It was decided that a bull that broke into a neighboring field and gored a horse till he died, created a liability to pay for the horse by the owner of the bull, with- out regard to his being aware of any vicious propensity in the bull or otherwise ; the ground of the decision being that the ani- _mal was naturally inclined to roam, and often guilty of mischief when going off on one of his larks, therefore it was the duty of the owner to keep him on his own land. The foregoing forces the conclusion that when you see a sign in a field, ‘‘ Beware of the Bull,” and you enter, that it will make no difference whose ox is gored, there will be no damages. A plaintiff suffered his horse to go at large in the streets of a city, and was com- pelled to pay damages for injury done by - the horse kicking a child, without it being proved or averred that the owner knew the horse was vicious and had a habit of kick- ing. The horse might have been of good repute, but there was danger to let him run | loose ‘in the streets, from the nature and disposition of the horse to gambol, plunge, and kick up his heels. It is not necessary that the injury results from a mischievous or vicious disposition of ©

Page 32

78 | which the owner has knowledge. The pro- pensity from which the injury comes need not be the result of a wicked or perverted character, a ferocious nature. It is only necessary to show that the propensity brings to pass an injury, and that such a disposi- tion to do that which proved to be harm is known to the owner. A court aptly illus- trates this point by saying that one might have a domesticated bear that manifested its affection by hugging until ribs be broken. The owner might be able to prove that the habit of embracing persons did not proceed from the savage nature of the bear, but un- der the influence of civilization from a cul- tivated affection. But this proof would not avail the owner in a suit by a party em- braced. Such a propensity would be held to be mischievous, because hurtful to those who were the object of the bear’s affection. Likewise it will not avail to say that your dog bites people only in fun, that his snap- ping and missing your leg by a _hair’s breadth is only out of the exuberance of his affection for you,°to be playful and good natured. This was tried in a case. The defendant contended that although several persons had been bitten by the dog, of which he had information, yet it appeared in every instance the biting occurred while the dog was in a playful mood, and consequently that damages could not be recovered where it was shown that the dog had a propensity to bite only in play. To recover it must appear that the dog was in the habit of biting mankind while in an angry mood, actuated by a ferocious spirit. The court refused to affirm such a position to be the law, remarking, an action can be main- tained against the owner by a party injured upon evidence that the dog, with the knowl- edge of the owner, had a mischievous pro- pensity to bite mankind, whether in anger or not. In either case the persons bitten would suffer injury, a mischievous propensity being a propensity from which injury is the nat- ural result. In this case the plaintiff was chief caused the trouble. The Green Bag. bitten in the hand, the hand broke out, the man became nervous, lost sleep, suffered pain, employed a physician, paid for medi- cines, lost two or three weeks’ wages, and was out of pocket in money, about twenty- five dollars. The verdict of the jury was for three hundred dollars, the court direct- ing that the damages could not be meas- ured by mere expenditure of money to cure from effect of the bite. Compensa- tion should be made for the pain and the anxiety of mind which must necessarily fol- low the bite of a dog. Ina case where a small girl was badly bitten, a verdict of $1,450 damages was sustained. The amount of the damages vary greatly in the many cases of injury from bite of dog, from sev- eral times the expenses of a trip to Paris, to the Pasteur Hospital, down to passage one way and steerage back. There is a case on record of a good bull —a probable freak of nature. He was gentle and quiet, a very respectable bull. However, he lost all sense of propriety and decorum at the sight of anything red, of which failing his owner admitted he was aware. The plaintiff came walking along the street, wearing a red handkerchief. He had a right to be walking in the street and to wear all the red handkerchiefs in Chris- tendom in defiance of all the bulls, if he so desired. The gentle, quiet-bull, that had never been known to gore any person, could not submit to such assertion of a citizen’s right, and he attacked and gored the plain- tiff. The defense was that the red handker- The plaintiff recovered, for while the bull had no hostile feeling against the man he injured and no disposition to gore mankind, yet, because of his mischievous propensity to rush at a red | object, of which the owner knew, it was held that when he caused injury to the plain- tiff through that propensity his owner should pay the damages. In a Vermont case it appeared that Mrs. Oakes was driving cows home from pasture

Page 33

Some Peculiarities of French Legal Procedure. 79 when the ram of Spaulding attacked and injured her. It was shown that the ram had a ram-like propensity to butt mankind, and that the defendant knew it; but it did not appear whether the previous buttings of the ram proceeded from an ugly disposition or out of the abundance of playful spirit. Yet it was held that the defendant was liable. It would not cure the hurt nor assuage the pain of the woman to be told that the ram, when he butted her, was only in one of his accustomed sportive moods. It might have been fun for the ram, but it was hurtful to Mrs. Oakes. It was a mischievous propen- sity, whether proceeding from ugliness of temper or good nature, which, if known to the owner of the ram, made him liable for damages resulting from such propensity. The report of the last case throws no light on the nature of the injuries sustained. The damages recovered amounted to $1,500. The question that presented itself after reading it was how were the damages meas- ured? It would certainly make a consider- able difference as to the direction toward which the ram projected itself — front, side, or rear. A forward somersault should be less expensive than one backwards, and a dottble one should bring just twice the price of a single one. The angle of curvatures of the horns of that particular ram might have had much to do with the measure of damages. The character of the butting would be an important element. A hop, skip and jump, throwing one across a quarter- acre lot, ought to have brought more money than a steady pushing across a field. An unexpected delivery ought to have brought a better sum than taking one on the fly. The numerical quantity of the buttings might have come at so much a hit. An itemized statement of the $1,500 damages would certainly have been interesting. SOME PECULIARITIES OF FRENCH LEGAL PROCEDURE. HE trial of the assassin of President Carnot has been made by cable de- spatches as widely known to the American public as that of Guiteau was to Europeans ; and in each case the differing and somewhat antagonistic modes of procedure produced surprise and comment. The first striking peculiarity of a French prosecution to an American is its procedure upon the initial ideas that an accused must prove his inno- cence, and is compelled to become a witness in his own case against himself. At the time of Guiteau’s trial Parisian journalists ex- pressed surprise at the impartial spirit of the Federal prosecution of a dastard who had assassinated the head of a nation. They also could not understand why, as in France, prosecutions were not directly impressed throughout by the power and majesty of the Government. For in France actions, whether civil or criminal, must have in atten- dance besides judges and procureurs or pri- vate advocates some official who represents directly the Minister of Justice and has certain defined responsibilities of interference with the trials. The Dictionnaire d’Admti- — nistration, article Ministére public, thus re- cites: ‘‘The French Government maintains a constant and regular supervision over the administration of justice by means of the Ministére public—a state department, mem- bers of which sit in every Court throughout France to represent there the cause of public order and the interests of society in gen- eral.” As regards criminal prosecutions these representative members differ little

Page 34

80 from our own district-attorneys. And there is a faint resemblance between the Ministére Public of France and the Solicitor to the Treasury in England. But that those mem- bers of the state department have relation to private civil suits is little understood in either England or this country. Yet in French civil cases they side with plaintiff or defen- dant as they see fit; being in such relation called partie principale. If they make gen- eral comment merely on matters before the court, they are called partie jointe. The Minister of Justice may direct these members aud is entitled to give them instructions on every point connected with their duties. And not alone in civil suits affecting Govern- mental interests, as may the Federal Attorney- General, but in points of private differences between citizen plaintiff and citizen defen- dant. These members hold office at the will of the President on advice of the Minister of Justice. There is thus allowed a direct pressure of Government in all legal differences between private parties or corpo- rate bodies — pressure, too, in addition to what judges may bring to bear. Civil and criminal courts are various in France as inthe United States ; with particular names, not necessary to mention; but in mat- ters of uzsz prius jurisdiction (oras the French statutes say, ‘courts of first instance” ), as well as of appeal, those courts assimilate in jurisdiction, pleas and procedures much in the main as do English or American courts. There is a marked, interesting, and doubtless salutary peculiarity of the court of the juge de paix (our justice of the peace) who has exclusive jurisdiction of hundred-franc suits, and of double that sum with concurrent right of appeal in cases involving that amount. But he is practically an arbitrator between these minor suitors in that he is bound by law to try and effect in a friendly way —and gratis— a reconciliation between parties wishing ‘‘to go to law.” And indeed every French plaintiff, upon bringing suit, must set forth “failure of reconciliation.” The Green Bag. The most recent statistics show that in one year these juges de paix (and there are 30,000 of them over the Republic) arbitrated two and a quarter million civil cases, out of which one-third were reconciliations. These justices are removable at will, but all other judges in France can only be re- moved for misconduct. The justices in the provinces have annual salaries ranging — calculated in our currency — from $350 to $1000. In Paris they draw $1500. But then all judicial salaries in France are very low. The highest known is $5000; but $2000 is an average. The president of the Court of Cassation, the head of the judiciary — the only court having sovereign authority over the whole of France — enjoys the largest sum of salary. _ Law is more of a luxury however in that republic than in any other country — not excepting Turkey, ‘‘the land of blood-money.” Inasmuch as public fees, are vexatiously high, and the charges of advocates enor- mous, because the ‘Order of Advocates,” that regulates costs and fees is a wonderful mon- opoly, and the pecuniary interests of the French Bar are sedulously looked after by a Sub-Committee of Discipline. A_ witty Maitre (or Q.C as one would say in London) once said to a suitor: ‘‘ Monsieur, there are three essentials to our success in your case, time, resignation and money.” He might have added. Time is the lever, resignation the fulcrum, and money the lifting power. But all this would not show any especial peculiarity of French systems over others elsewhere. However, the various states of the Union do not extort governmental fees or revenue from suitors as are extorted in Paris or London; while at the same time their statutes duly regard also expenditure of “time and resignation.’’ Hence it is no marvel that when Hamlet is performed at the French capital, that part of the Dane’s soliloquy which refers to ‘‘the law’s delay” is always especially applauded by the par- quette. «

Page 35

Some Peculiarities of French Legal Procedure. If the first view of an.English barrister begets in the American spectator a thought of a perruquier, the first sight of a French advocate brings to his mind a suggestion of a baker or a male cook; for instead of a horsehair wig, that advocate wears a cap in shape much like the one worn by the priest at mass. The advocate has the English barristerial gown, but he wears it with much more grace than his British brother. For there never yet was a Q.C. who did not, while excited by oratory, look like anything else to an unprejudiced spectator but a guy. The’ president of the Court of Assize, which takes jurisdiction of indictments (and a Grand Jury system is put aside by usurp- ation of the official pleader of the original charge), generally acts in a threefold capa- city: he draws the jury instead of a clerk from the box, he swears the jury, and he substantially leads the prosecution by ex- amining accused and witnesses — for the procureur or the advocate defending may be both said to practically cross-examine on matters that the president judge has first brought out. He draws the names of 36 jurymen; each side may _ peremptorily challenge twelve, and an accused has to take . the chances of uninvestigated bias among the twelve who get finally selected. And this is the odd and rather prolix oath each juror takes as the president recites it: ‘You ‘swear before God and man to examine with the most scrupulous attention into the charges that will be brought against—”’ (giving full name of the prisoner, who is seated between two gendarmes capped and in uniform in the dock, and not barbarized as in England by having to stand) ; “‘ not to be- tray the interests of the prisoner, nor those of society which accuses him; not to com- municate with him until after your verdict; to listen neither to hatred or malice, fear nor affection” (N.B. the American formula of ‘hope of reward” is not used), ‘‘and to make your decision after duly weighing the charges and the defense according to your con- SI science and inmost conviction with the im- partiality and firmness becoming to an honest man of independent mind.” This oath-taking will have been preceded by placing on the records the name, age, and occupation of the accused. After the jury take seats, the president, who is generally a champion mental analyst, calls up the prisoner, and proceeds not to directly examine, but to cross-examine him —and interjecting copiously hearsay tes- timony and suggestion — with the intention of making him either admit his guilt or so contradict himself as to imply it. Of course a wordy duel results between judge and accused, with sometimes shrewdness, cunning and clever perjury combatting experienced skill in questioning and in laying rhetorical traps or puzzles, the whole procedure being a dilution of the rack or wheel of the middle ages. There can be no objections or ex- ceptions, but there are often courteous in- terruptive suggestions from counsel. The judge is paramount; responsible only to the Court of Criminal Appeal, to which is sent in writing all that the trial has evolved, and before which there can be practically a re- trial, with the prisoner again re-examined by the appeal judges, guided by the written evidence before them, and counsel pro or con may again be heard. The appeal procedure is upon what common law knows as “case”, and not under any “bill of exceptions,” the Government and not the counsel for accused always making up this appeal case; and it is invariably made up to advantage the Gov- ernment. Se HsAiorrsa: ie After the prisoner has undergone his torture — the rack being verbal and not mechanically framed with wood and iron; and the cutting weapons being of irony, sar- casm and inuendoes — the trial proceeds pretty much as with English or American courts by examinations of witnesses, with little attention shown to the distinction be- tween original or secondary evidence. More importance is given in the French

Page 36

82. ‘criminal procedure to speeches of advocates ; but since 1880 the judge has been precluded from summing up, as is the English _ phrase, or “charging,” as is the American phrase. Prior to 1880 the judge, after pre- liminarily torturing the prisoner, possessed the opportunity to become tortuous toward any side that he chose for emphasis and animadversion, but usually aiding the pro- cureur. Upon the wall of the court-room ‘are to be read usually these lines: Hic poenz scelerum ultrices posuere tribunal, Sortibus unde tremor, civitas unde salus ; but the eye of the judge would be perhaps fixed upon the three last words as his excuse for his partisanship. The safety of the state before the justice to an accused being their full, free meaning. | _ Human nature is the same in a French ' jury room as in a Saxon one, but its mem- bers may legally strain their quality of justice and usurp that of mercy by finding ‘‘ exten- uating circumstances” along with a verdict of guilty, which finding takes the place of the merely emotional American suffix to such a verdict of “recommendation to mercy” — the phrase whereby many a Thomas Didymus of a juror compromises with his conscience. If the American spectator of the average French trial of a criminal looks for any gleam of pity in the eyes of the prosecuting judge, he may possibly recall the sarcastic lines of the poet Nathaniel Parker Willis: - ¢ She hooked me kindly, as the fisher hooks the worm, Pitying him all the while.” If the conviction be of a capital crime, The Green Bag. the cruelty to the accused is maintained by omission to fixthe date of execution. This is left to the discretionary fiat of the W/zxzstre de Justice, The awful hour may arrive within a few days — as in the case of Cesario the Lyons assassin —or it may not come within weeks. The condemned in his cell is suffer- ing the mental tortures of a Damoclean hanging sword. Each night as he lies on his pallet he whispers to himself, ‘ Will the guillotine cast its shadow on the dawn?” This mental torture is regarded as an ex- cellent part of expiatory punishment. But at last some morning the culprit is awakened suddenly to see beside him priest and prison attendant, and then he becomes alive indeed to the sudden shock. ‘ Quelle matiére, quel dommage/” once exclaimed a Monsieur de Paris, of the guillotine, to a reporter of the New York “Herald” who by questions seemed to remonstrate against the cruelty of sus- pense —“‘ is not all this an incident in every life? Was not Monsieur born with a sen- tence of death upon his head? Monsieur may live to be a centenarian or he may enter Pére la Chaise as an infant. Does he know the hour of his death until it dawns?”” Even the ‘‘ extenuating circumstances” carry with them the torture of the galleys. In com- paring the (perhaps. too lenient in some cases) procedures of American or English criminal jurisprudence with these French > procedures, it may be that the French “ qual- ity of mercy is strained,” while the American quality of mercy “droppeth” too much “like the gentle dew” on the head of a malefactor. “@ 6 BS & we,

Page 37

Charles O’Conor. 83 CHARLES O’CONOR. ik. By Irvinc BROWNE. R. O’CONOR was a member of the committee appointed to frame the judiciary article in the convention of 1846. I have carefully looked over all that he is reported to have said and done in the con- vention on this subject,’ and there is nothing to substantiate the claim which Mr. Bigelow reports that he made to him, but a great deal to the contrary; so much, in fact, that I°am inclined to think Mr. Bigelow must have misunderstood him. Mr. O’Conor did not assent to the article which was adopted. On the contrary, he presented a minority report on behalf of himself alone. This, it is true, proposed to vest judicial power in the Supreme Court and certain inferior courts, and to form a court of appeals, but it is evident that he regretted the imminent changes which he found himself unable to withstand. In the course of his remarks he observed : — “But conceiving, as he did, that this report destroys nearly all the good features in our existing and past judicial systems, and furnished nothing that can be deemed an equivalent,” he deemed it his duty to state his objections. ‘‘ He thought it would be impossible to do the business of the state under such a system, and that what was done would be badly done.” Hespoke of the proposed Court of Appeals as ‘‘a kind of mongrel court between the two we have had, without the merits of either.” ‘The courts we had prior to 1821 were perfectly unexceptionable.” _ He spoke of the old Court of Errors as ‘admirably framed,” ‘emphatically the court of the people,” ‘the best court in the state,” ‘“ hourly in- fusing new blood into the law.” He said ‘the sad mistake was in abolishing” ‘‘ that court, the Supreme Court and the Chancellor’s * Constitutional Debates, Atlas ed., Albany, 1846. a Te Court, and in substituting for the three this single eight-judge court.” He strongly in- sisted on a single supreme court for the whole state. He said that “in the Con- stitution of 1821, and its predecessor, was embodied the best model for a judicial system.” ‘The Court of Chancery, or a separate tribunal, had been unceremoniously brushed away, and apparently with much personal satisfaction to members here,” and he paid a glowing tribute to the chancellor. He favored an ultimate court of more than eight judges,t and contended that some of them ought to be laymen. ‘“‘ He was one of the enemies of this new judicial system, be- cause he did not believe in its capacity.” He uniformly voted in the convention against the codifiers. He voted against the judiciary article, and finally he declared that ‘he thought the convention had altogether failed to present to the people a Constitution which would meet the exigencies of the times, or in any degree remedy the difficulties in this respect, which led to the calling of this con- vention — that it did not in any moderate degree meet his approval, and was a most signal failure. It would therefore be his duty to vote against the Constitution, and to induce his fellow-citizens to take the same course when they came to vote on it.” To be perfectly fair to Mr. O’Conor in this matter, I subjoin the continuation of his remarks referred to in Mr. Field’s letter, which will show the extent of his efforts at law reform, and also serve as an example of his forcible and excellent style: — ‘“‘ Although it had been his fortune to. practice for a good many years in the rigid and techni- ™He desired sixteen judges, elected by senatorial dis- tricts, for four years. Argus Report, p. 541. Among his vagaries he wished to give that court power on motion to determine the venue of suits in the Supreme Court! (Argus Report, p. 641).

Page 38

84° cal forms of the common law, and though he did not hesitate to say even here, that he was as ca- pable of fencing with them as his neighbors, and of taking care that his clients should not suffer from their misapplication, yet he had long thought that there was no propriety in the existing distinctions, in the forms of practice and pleading between these two tribunals—that of law and that of equity ——and therefore, wth the same view as the committee, that of ultimately blending them together, and forming one consts- Lent, uniform and harmonious method of practice in the administration of justice, he had brought Jorward, as well as the committee, a system tend- ing to that end. His method of effecting the result differed from that of the committee in this one important respect—din no part of the article which he had presented had he introduced the phrases courts of law, and courts of equity, jurisdiction in law, or jurisdiction in equity. “‘ By denying to the distinction a constitutional recognition it was left fully and unquestionably within the power of the Legislature, should they in their wisdom, on a full examination of the subject, find it proper to blend the system, to do so. It left the law-making and law-reforming power unembarrassed by any language in the Constitution which might be a barrier to such blending. It also left to them the power of re- tracing their steps, if, after making the experi- ment, z¢ should be found that the project of blena- ing the two systems was impracticable—was, as some supposed, a dream of visionary enthu- siasts in law reform. If, enlightened by the de- velopments of experience, they should find the distinction salutary, they would be free to erect anew this barrier between law and conscience, which nothing but the iron test of mischiefs actually experienced from its abolition could con- vince him was necessary. It was, in a princi- pal measure, with the view of avoiding the per- manent establishment in the Constitution, be- yond the reach of legislative power, of these two modes of proceeding, that he had felt himself constrained to write out anew the whole article ; otherwise he would probably have confined him- self to his right to propose, in committee of the whole, amendments of the article reported. by the chairman. In other respects he mainly con- curred with the committee. Whilst he con- curred most fully in the remarks of the honor- able chairman as to the expediency of assimilat- Field assures me that ‘“ Mr. The Green Bag. ing the modes of taking testimony in those dif- ferent classes of cases called cases at law and cases in equity, and especially that the trial by jury should be extended as far as possible, still he had omitted that provision from his system, because he conceived that these minute details belonged to the field of ordinary legislation, or to that of court rules, and not to the Constitu- tion.” (Argus Report, p. 375.) These remarks were made a month and a half after the introduction of the resolution by Mr. White which gave rise to them. IE is evident that Mr. O’Conor was a follower and not a leader in these reforms, a modifier, an adapter and a keen critic rather than an originator. The foregoing will certainly serve to dis- abuse any New York lawyer of the im- pression that Mr. O’Conor could ever seriously have claimed for himself the credit of the “authorship ” of the great legal re- forms of 1846 and 1848. So much for his course in the constitutional convention as to the judiciary article. As to the code of civil procedure adopted in 1848, his spirit is sufficiently indicated by Mr. Field’s letter and in his animadversions upon the new system of pleading which it introduced. It is sufficient to add that Mr. David Dudley O’Conor did not invent the code reforms, but opposed them with might and main from beginning to end.” Of course Mr. Field refers te the code system independent of the judiciary article, in respect to which he has ex- plained Mr. Conor’s position in his foregoing letter. The code enacted the substance of the judiciary article as well as the minutie of practice. The Hon. Martin I. Townsend, who was a member of the convention of 1867-8, also writes me that “D. D. Field, Michael Hoffman and Arphaxed Loomis reformed our law practice.” ‘The venerable — Benjamin D. Silliman, at a dinner given him by the Bar of New York and Brooklyn, in 1889, spoke of Mr. Field as “the chief author” of ‘the change created by the code .

Page 39

Charles of procedure of 1848.” This, undoubtedly, is the universal belief in New York, and the unquestionable fact. This search into ancient history has served to inform me of Mr. O’Conor’s views upon another great legal reform of our state, namely, that in respect to the property rights of married women. He opposed it. He made a long and earnest speech about it, very beautiful in point of style. He admired the law as it then was, and declared that “He was no true American who de- sired to see it changed.” He repeated in substance the stock argument that it would be cruel to wives to give them the right to their own property, because it would make their husbands so angry, and thus “tend to impair domestic harmony.” ‘The hammer fell” in the midst of this touching harangue, but by unanimous consent he _ proceeded, and closed with the following dismal pre- diction: ‘From amid the less pure and in- corrupt habits and manners as then existing around him, he would look back to the present day with emotions akin to those which affect our minds when contemplat- ing the first family in happy Eden before the tempter came.” Up to that time the distinguished speaker had not indulged him- self in any practical attempt to realize Eden with a common-law wife; but the reality introduced by the incendiary change must have proved less objectionable than his anticipations indicated, for in 1854 he took unto himself awife who possessed all the dis- advantages. brought in by the reformed law. Mr. O’Conor however was with the majority in his views, for the proposition, afterwards effected by legislation, was rejected by the convention by nine majority. One Mr. Simmons, a bachelor lawyer, pronounced it “‘a strumpet provision.” But in small matters Mr. O’Conor was apparently very gallant to women. Thus he was among sixty-one members who voted against forty- seven, in favor of giving the ‘“ ladies” a gallery in which they could listen to the O’ Conor. debates, under the protection of a door- keeper. (Atlas Report, p. 67.) It must have been improving to the inmates of that gallery to listen to Mr. O’Conor and Mr. Simmons on their “ rights.” It is interesting also to note that Mr. O’Conor advocated giving the defendant’s counsel in criminal trials the closing address to the jury. (Atlas Report, p. 1051.) SLAVERY — THE JACK AND LEMMON CASES. In his Memorial of Mr. O’Conor, prepared by Mr. Frederick R. Coudert for the Bar Association of the City of New York, he tells how Mr. O’Conor was moved to tears while reciting some fragments of William Samp- son’s article, ‘The Irish Emigrant.” ‘“ He had now lost control of himself,” and “tears stood in his eyes,” as he recited: ‘‘ He was born in a land which no longer was his; in the midst of plenty his children ate the bread of poverty; he toiled for a landlord whose face he never saw; he heard there was a great country beyond the sea where ” . and Mr. O’Conor exclaimed: ‘ Are we not both sons of the Irish Emigrant?” One would suppose that a person of such tender sensibilities, who was ‘always overcome by pathos,’ would have had some sympathy with the four millions of black slaves in this country at that time. On the contrary, he always admired, and defended the system of human slavery, and thought its subjects very reprehensible for trying to run away from it. This in an Irishman and a lawyer seems anomalous. It was, however, fortunate for one suitor that there lived one lawyer at the North who entertained such sentiments; otherwise Mrs. Lemmon could not easily have found an advocate to urge the rendi- * Mr. O’Conor’s inconsistency was shared by Mr. Russell, - who in the amusing debate on a doorkeeper for the ladies’ gallery, observed: “In this country, where the sex have higher privileges than in any other upon the face of the earth, and where they are held in higher estimation by men (a feeling which should be universal),” etc.; and then the faithless flatterer voted against giving them their rights in the Constitution ! . : 35)

Page 40

86 ee tion of her slaves, whom she had brought to New York, with such zest and conscientious conviction that those colored persons were standing in their own light when they de- clined to be remanded to the delights and advantages of the. state in which they had been. : Mr. O’Conor first appeared as a champion of slavery in 1835, when he was only thirty- one years old; in the case of the slave Jack (12 Wend. 311; 14 id. 507). It was there held, by the Supreme Court, that where a slave escapes from one state into another, and is pursued by his owner, and brought before a magistrate, who, in pursuance of. the act of Congress, examines into the mat- ter, and certifies that the slave owes service or labor to the owner, and grants permission to carry him back, the claimant may not be prevented from removing him by a writ de homine replegiando sued out under author- ity of a state law. The Court of Errors unan- imously affirmed this, solely on the ground that the plaintiff, having by his pleas ad- mitted his slavery and escape, the defendant was entitled to judgment, declining to pass on the constitutionality of the act of Con- gress or the State statute. The case is worthy of study as an example of the intri- cacy and the foolishness of special pleading in the old times, when a question of plead- ing seemed more important to the courts than the question of a human being’s right to his own freedom. _ Senator Bishop remarked that if ‘all the States in the Union are to be permitted to legislate upon this subject,” ‘it will in the end lead indirectly to the abolition of slavery, and that the most fearful consequences in regard to the permanency of our institutions will ensue. I regard this as but the enter- ing wedge to other doctrines which are de- signed to extirpate slavery; and we may find, when it is too late, that the patience of the South, however well founded upon prin- ciple, from repeated aggression will become exhausted”, He cited a decision from Pick- ‘sued out the writ, The Green Bag. ering to sustain his argument. But he also said: ‘Slavery is abhorred in all nations where the light of civilization and refinement has penetrated, as repugnant to every prin- ciple of justice and humanity, and deserving the condemnation of God and man.” He based his opinion solely on the ground of the constitutional compact. Iam informed by a gentleman, who was at the time a partner of Mr. Sedgwick, who that Mr. Sedgwick “thought O’Conor very bitter in his pursuit of the slave.” But we get Mr. O’Conor’s mature and personal opinions of slavery more clearly in the Lemmon case. He entered into and argued this celebrated cause con amore. The case was argued in the Court of Appeals in 1860, and is reported in 20 New York, 562." The facts were these: The plaintiff’s wife, a citizen of Virginia, intending to go to the State of Texas, came to New York to embark, and brought with her eight negro slaves, her property. She intended to re- main there only long enough to find a pro- per ship, and intended to take the slaves with her. One ‘Louis Napoleon,” a “marksman,” sued out habeas corpus to re- lease them from the detention of their mis- tress. This was based directly on the New York statutes of 1817, 1830, and 1841, to the effect that any slave “imported, intro- duced, or drought into’’ this state, shall* im- mediately become free. The contention on the part of the slave-owner was that the phrase “brought into” signified a bringing _ with intent to remain and reside, and that under the federal constitution slave-owners had the right to preserve their property in 1 The slow and stately progress of justice in those days is curiously illustrated by the history of this case. The slaves were released by the judge who granted the writ in November, 1852. This was affirmed by the general term in December, 1857. The case was finally decided by the’ Court of Appeals in March, 1860. Mrs. Lemmon’s riches must have taken to themselves legs long before even a decision in her favor could have done her any good. The case was held “under advisement” by the general term five years !

Page 41

Charles O'Conor. 87 slaves brought into a free state simply for the purpose of passing through to another destination. Mr. O’Conor is not blamable for advocating Mrs. Lemmon’s claim on statutory and constitutional grounds, but he improved the occasion to declare and elab- orate his belief that the institution of negro slavery was ‘just, benign, and beneficent,” and to use language, in the support of this unnecessary claim, unparalleled in any court of justice in a free state, to my knowledge, - and that very unpleasantly affected the mass of Northern people at that critical period. He started off in his points with the argu- ment that the negro is essentially, and must always remain, an inferior being unfit to ‘‘sustain a civilized social state,” and there- fore it was right to enslave him. He ro- bustly declared, ‘‘ That alone and unaided he can never sustain a civilized social organ- ization is proven to all reasonable minds by the fact that one single member of his race has never attained proficiency in any art or science requiring the employment of high intellectual capacity. A mediocrity below the standard of qualification for the impor- tant duties of government, for guiding the affairs of society, or for progress in the abstract sciences, may be common in indi- viduals of other races; but it is universal among negroes. Not one single negro has ever risen above it.” As to. the constitu- tional obligations he observed, ‘ Portia’s mode of keeping promises (Merchant of Venice, act 4, scene I) is allowable only in respect to facts having the form of contracts, but which are of no binding force or obliga-. tion in law or morals. The American citi- zen, who, applying Shakespeare’s doctrine, carries in his bosom a chapel illuminated by the higher law, and devoted to those infernal deities, Evasion and Circumvention, may be justified if the constitutional compact be void; but if it be valid, he violates honor -and conscience.” In his opening argument at the outset he challenged his opponents to point out any line of the Holy Scriptures which pronounces or implies that human slavery is wrong. From this carefully pre- — pared masterpiece of rhetoric and mis- directed ingenuity I extract the following choice passages. | After some sarcasm on “ Louis Napoleon,” who sought to “disturb” Mrs. Lemmon’s “domestic relations,” and “invade” her ? domestic peace,” he observed, among other things : — | ‘What is there in our judicial history,.what is there in our common law, as it is called, or in the sources of our law, to entitle a court of jus- tice, at this day, of its own authority, and _irre- spective of obedience to the mandates of positive legislation, to pronounce negro slavery unjust, or contrary to the fundamental principles of our in- stitutions? What is there to warrant any court of justice in this state, or in any state of the | | Union, to pronounce sucha sentence as that, pre- ° liminarily to an inquiry into the import of the few simple words of plain English contained in this statute? I maintain that there is nothing to war- rant it. Still it is manifest that there is no prin- ciple in the English common law which inhibits slavery as immoral or unjust, as repugnant to nat- ural right or divine law. In the earliest stages of our existence as a people. ... negro slavery was recognized as just and lawful-inthis colony. Ne- groes were held in bondage without a doubt or a scruple as to its justice or morality... It will be seen therefore that in its origin our law did not receive from any quarter asone of its ele- ments any principle repugnant to slavery as a civil institution.,,;, We received none from divine authority ; we imported from England no pro- hibition of slavery, and the moment we began to make laws, and to lay the foundation of our social order, we established for ourselves a use- ful civil institution, the status of negro slavery.” | Of Lord Mansfield’s celebrated utterance in the Somerset case, he remarked : — “ Certainly so. much of it as was law had but little significance, while so much of it as was poetry has had considerable effect; it has won for him much unmerited applause. . . We have as authority for our position that it is not evil per se, the voice of all mankind in past ages, and of all portions of mankind amongst whom law is

Page 42

88 The Green Bag. — administered at this day. It may be enacted that one shall not hold a slave in a particular state; but the general proposition that slavery is unjust in such a sense that judicial tribunals are bound to treat it as repugnant to natural law, and to deny all rights of property growing out of it, not expressly created by the local law, finds not a living advocate entitled to respect, and not one single judicial authority — I mean one single judicial decigion. Some of the ravings of certain persons may indeed be found tending in that di- rection ; but it has never been determined by the judicial tribunals of any country that any right, otherwise petfect, loses its claim to protection by the mere fact of its being founded on the owner- ship of a negro slave. ‘The proposition that freedom is the general rule and slavery the local exception, has no foundation in any just view of the law as a science. It is one of the fraudulent catch-words of the day, contrived for the worst of purposes and never employed by good men, except when laboring under a delusion. . . The condi- tion of a stranger coming from another state, who is the owner of a slave, in respect to his property in the service of the slave, is exactly the same as his condition would be if he were the owner of a horse or the owner of a barrel of flour under like circumstances. . . I do not know that they can be said to have made any progress. If they have, certainly it has been through the beneficent oper- ation of the slave-trade, and their pupilage under the system now established in the slave-holding states of this Union. There, and there alone, have negroes attained to anything like a comfort- able state of existence. ‘Thtough these instru- mentalities alone have any of the race attained the blessings of civilization, the light of Christian- ity, etc... I say therefore that to the black man, when held in slavery, the white man, his master, makes a due return. He-treats him pre- cisely as the more intelligent must and should treat his dependent inferiors. Occasional vio- lations of propriety do not affect this question.” Africa “seems to have been, in reference to the negro, very much what the quarry is to the architect or the sculptor—a place whence to draw a crude material, useless in ‘its native state, but susceptible, under wise control, of being made useful to the human family. [Sensation.].. . Negro slavery conflicts with no general law which has ever been recognized. It conflicts with no > law of nature which has any authority among men ; and lastly in its own characteristics it is not in conflict with any principles of natural justice that are perceptible to a sound mind. It is a source from which might be derived the greatest blessings to millions of the negro race; and it is by no means credible, if we will be enlightened by the history of the past, that any considerable number of the race could attain an equal measure of enjoyment without it... Negro slavery can- not be abolished. Since the foundation of this republic it has ever been a main pillar of our strength, an indispensable element of our growth and prosperity. It is now an integral part of our - being as a nation. ‘To eviscerate it by fraud, or tear it out by violence, would be a_ national suicide. To vindicate its essential justice and morality in all courts and places before men and nations, is the duty of every American citizen ; and he who fails in this duty is false to his country, or acts as one without understanding. . . . By appealing to patriotism, I seek only to awaken attention. I would, by its aid and through its benign influences, give to every American citi- zen, ere it be too late, this admonition : Do not turn aside from the truth of history, the teachings of experience, the rational deductions of common sense, and from a mere caprice, without moral necessity, inflict upon your country’s material in- terests and her honor a fatal blow. Do not so act in your capacity as a citizen, that if arraigned before the judgment-seat of practical wisdom, you would find no refuge from a traitor’s doom except in the plea of insanity.”’ These extracts will suffice. Ax pede Her- culem, and it is indeed a Hercules of foren- sic debate that we recognize in this wonder- ful but wrong-headed and _ wrong-hearted argument. It would be cruel to the great lawyer's memory, as a lawyer, statesman and moralist, to cite these opinions if he had ever changed his mind and repented, but he went to his grave with the same sentiments. It is evident that if he ever entertained an angelic visitant he could not consistently request him, in the words of the pious Abou ben Adhem, to “ write him as one who loves his fellowmen.” It is a striking commentary on Mr. O’Conor’s utter

Page 43

Charles O’ Conor. 89 inability to read the signs of the times, that within three years from the time when he so confidently pronounced that “negro slavery cannot be abolished,” it was abolished, and that nobody to speak of, North or South, wishes to see it reinstated ! Although Mr. O’Conor’s argument seems to imply his conviction of the utter unfitness of free negroes to participate in civil govern- ment, yet in the constitutional convention of 1846 he had introduced the article on the ‘elective franchise which was adopted, pro- viding that these inferior creatures might vote ifthey were freeholders to the amount of $250 and taxed therefor, and freeing all others from direct taxation. At that time, therefore, he seems to have conceded that all privileges in which a negro.might reason- ably share were not embraced in the system of slavery. Atthat time Mr. O’Conor seems to have been more liberal than some other members, for one pronounced negroes ‘““merely an excrescence upon our society ” ; another invoked the “curse of Canaan” against them; another said that giving them the elective franchise would be joining “the cow and the ass in the same yoke”; and still ‘another “believed that slavery had been permitted, in the providence of God, as a means of preparing a portion of the Ethiopian race for the great mission of civilizing the tribes of Africa.” During the civil war Mr. O’Conor favored the cause of the South. So well understood were his sentiments on this subject, that when the Democratic party nominated Horace Greeley for the presidency in 1872, a bolting convention at Louisville nominated Mr. O’Conor. ‘This was against ‘his earnest and sincere protests, but as some ardent Whigs in Massachusetts persisted in voting for Daniel Webster, although he had not been nominated by any party, and in fact, was dead, so 21,559 gentlemen of Mr. O’Conor’s way of thinking voted for him in spite of his protests. | To do Mr. O’Conor justice, it must be owned that he never sought nor desired public office of any kind. I say this in spite of Mr. Bigelow’s statement that in conversation with him, Mr. O’Conor seemed to think it strange that he had not oftener been taken up for office.. He may have thought so and yet not have cared for office. Mr. Bigelow, in his paper in ‘‘ The Cen- tury” on O’Conor, narrates fhat Aaron Burr helieved that Chancellor Walworth decided all his causes against him from personal pique, because of Burr’s advice ~ to him not to publish his rather egotistical address. When the Chancellor’s grandson was in late years indicted for murdering his own father, Mr. O’Conor saved his neck (without fee) on the grounds that the de-| ceased treated his wife very badly and the son was subject to epilepsy! “I hope Mr. O’Conor was not consciously avenging Burr, who would probably have thought it venial to kill a Walworth, and I do not think he was, for he paid the Chancellor great com- pliments in the constitutional convention of 1846. That however was when he was setting rid of him and his court. Mr. O’Conor was above the middle height, spare and erect. His head was well-balanced and fine, his mouth large and compressed, his eyes (I should say) a steely blue, — or perhaps most people would call them gray, —very brilliant and intelligent, severe at will, but ordinarily not unkind. He wore a fringe of beard all around his face. He gave much less thought to the suit he wore than to any of his other suits. He generally went in rather rusty black, and I should guess that a contractor might have made money by agreeing to pay his tailor’s bill for $100 a year. He was no believer in Dr. Holmes’s aphorism that “the hat is always felt,” for he wore one that looked as if it might have come in with the Forrest cases, although it indubitably sur- vived them. He wore this well back on his head, in this resembling Horace Greeley, with whom he probably disagreed in every-

Page 44

gO thing else, unless it was his leniency toward Jefferson Davis. (They both went on his bail bond.) He moved on the street, on the few occasions on which I have seen him, with an abstracted air, but with a fine scholarly dignity. An excellent portrait of him accompanies Mr. Bigelow’s sketch. Undoubtedly, in the popular estimation, Mr. O’Conor was like an iceberg — lofty, pure, shining to be sure, but cold, inacces- sible and unpleasant to run against. On the other hand, his great countryman and an- tagonist, Brady, was regarded as a sunlit and smiling eminence, whose sides attracted dwellers and nourished the kindly fruits of the earth. It may well be doubted whether _ Mr. O’Conor was a lovely and amiable char- acter. One may be permitted to doubt that he yearned, like Abou ben Adhem, to be written as ‘one who loved his fellow- men.’ One may say, without much fear of contradiction, that he was a natural aris- tocrat, and of a somewhat haughty and re- served disposition. He did not mingle easily and familiarly with the community, and cared little for their applause and less for their censure. In his last years, seeking retirement and a healthful air, he insulated himself on Nantucket, where nobody could swim out to call on him, and he there led the life of a recluse. He seems to have been possessed, like Mephistopheles, by the spirit of denial. One of his most dis- tinguished contemporaries and writes me: “ Mr. O’Conor was a very in- consistent and eccentric man. He seemed never to have a fixed opinion unless it was adverse to the opinion of the rest of man- kind. He championed slavery as a ‘ benign institution’; he maintained that the Federal executive should consist of several persons ; and was ‘ agin everybody,’ as the poor voter, who came to the polls in Bryant’s time, proclaimed himself to be.” One of. the oldest surviving members of the constitu- tional convention of 1867-8. writes me: “I never heard that O’Conor was in favor of survivors | The Green Bag. anything but human slavery.” The former of these gentlemen is a Democrat, the latter is a Republican. On the other hand, Mr. James C. Carter, who knew him as well as anybody knew him, under the beneficent rule zz/ nzsz, etc., while admitting that Mr. O’Conor stood in popular repute as I have stated above, contended that he assumed an austerity that was not natural to him. This somewhat remarkable explanation is made as follows: ‘In. his professional life, in his. office, or in the courts where he was most frequently met, he was wont: to surround. himself with a forbidding and mysterious air, and appeared severe, austere, repellant. Many took this as a manifestation of his real character, whereas in truth it was but one of the instrumentalities of his art by which he often bewildered and confounded his adversaries. At the same time, in the circle of his friends, in his or their homes, he was like the gentlest of men, warm, friendly, generous, magnanimous.” Mr. Frederick R. Coudert, also, on the same fost mortem occasion, after narrating how Mr. O’Conor severely scolded a little shoeblack who in- truded on him in his office, and how soon after he sought him out in the street and gave him a new outfit from a neighboring ~ clothing-shop, observes: ‘If this was meant as an atonement for his impatience, it was a royal atonement. But it was rather a mani- festation of his true nature — the other scene was a simulacrum —a false pretense. ‘For there were false pretenses in Mr, O’Conor, and all who knew him knew that he was full of false pretenses of that kind.” And Mr. Coudert seems to intimate that the scene in the office was enacted for the benefit of the clerks. Thus Mr. O’Conor is made to have assumed a failing instead of a virtue, and run counter to Hamlet’s advice to his mother, and to the general conduct of man- kind. It must be confessed that if these latter gentlemen are right, this was a very unusual, unamiable and unpleasant form of hypocrisy, and considering the unwavering

Page 45

Charles O’Conor. gl consistency with which Mr. O’Conor kept it up, it must have been extremely irksome to him. One could heartily wish that these generous and eloquent defenders could have explained away, on the same hypothesis, his public views of human slavery. It is but echoing the opinion of foes and friends alike to say that he was the very soul of personal purity and_ professional honor, Truly, a mixed character, lacking in candor and simplicity: if posterity does him in- justice, he himself must be much to blame for it, and of this his defiant spirit will be as regardless now as it was when it inhabited its earthly tenement. Mr. O’Conor was not a humorous man, but still he had a grim kind of pleasantry, ard undoubtedly a biting and tormenting wit. His power of sarcasm was very afflu- ent and very “handy.” One can easily believe that his speeches against Edwin Forrest were characterized by a “savage eloquence,” as Mr. Bigelow tells us. From Mr. Bigelow’s account he does not appear to have been widely acquainted with mis- cellaneous literature, nor to have been a reading man, but he must have read well in his youth to acquire so good a style. seemed, however, to regard reading as a vice, for he told Mr. Bigelow that ‘He thought the cheapness of printing in Amer- ica had made overmuch reading one of the most pernicious forms of dissipation.” An eccentric opinion, in which Mr. Bigelow ~ avows his concurrence! Thinking so, why has this accomplished gentleman contributed so much to our literature? When Mr. O’Conor retired to Nantucket, it seems as if he might gracefully have laid aside his reserve, natural or artificial, and “condescended to men of low estate” on the little island; but I am informed that he did not, but retired himself, not only from the world and the late theatre of his brilliant achievement, but from Nantucket itself and its small population of curious observers of the lion of the sea-girt desert. The truth is, He I think, that he was not a democrat, but an aristocrat, and not an easy and _ tolerant aristocrat. I would not call him arrogant, but supremely indifferent to his neighbors, and profoundly conscious of his own un- questionable superiority. He did not make his retirement a mask for continued control in the affairs of his late domain, like Charles V. in the ‘convent of Yuste, but he did sometimes yearn to be out in the world again. On one occasion he told Mr. Bige- low that he was “spoiling for a fight,’ and on another, having come to New York, and overcome a hackman who overcharged him, he avowed that it was worth the journey. from Nantucket just to beat that fellow! At Nantucket, however, he unostentati- ously ‘exemplified the most beautiful and lovable trait of his character — his fidelity to early benefactors. When he first entered on practice in New York, Mr. Pardon, a merchant, indorsed his note for some three hundred dollars, to enable him to buy his first law-books. Some sixty years later, in charge of his house at Nantucket he put his adopted daughter, a great-granddaughter of that unforgotten benefactor, and dying, he left her that house with its furniture, his library, his watch, and one-third of the rest of his estate. Some years before his death Mr. O’Conor was so seriously ill that his life was despaired of for a long time, and the country expected the news of his demise at any moment. But he, doubtless mindful of the old writer’s assertion that ‘‘man doth not yield himself unto death save through the weakness of his feeble will,’ and not being quite ready to go, resolved that he would not, and he did not. His recovery was an amazing assertion of the power of the human will,—in Mr. O’Conor’s case an imperial attribute. If old Glanvill cotild have witnessed his death, he would have confessed that his assertion was wrong in at least one instance. To prove himself an exception to most men in many points, he built a great country-house

Page 46

oe. at Nantucket, when he was eighty years old, and managed to live in it two years. With all his beneficence and open-handed generosity, Mr. O’Conor left a very large fortune — for a lawyer. It has been esti- mated by those in a position to know, at eight hundred thousand dollars. He owned eleven acres of land, with his town house, on Washington Heights, worth from three to four hundred thousand dollars, and he once owned a house in Fifth Avenue. His li- brary is said to have cost him one hundred thousand dollars, but it realized at auction sale less than thirty thousand dollars— another proof that law books are poor property. NotTE., — While Mr. O’Conor was engaged in his criti- cisms on the Court of Appeals, a remarkably clever skit appeared in the Albany Law Journal (Vol. 12, p. 127), entitled “ Verses in an Album,” but who wrote it, or whether it was originally contributed to that journal, I cannot tell after this lapse of time. The verses are as follows : — ’Tis human to err, I know, And I’ve heard of the nods of Homer, But to call me fallible — O That is an absurd misnomer! For I never nod, not I, ’pon honor, I nod? Go to, I’m Charles O’Conor. The rest of the bar, ’tis true, ' In its want of wisdom feels. That a decent respect is due To the voice of the Court of Appeals. The Green Bag. But my court of last resort, ’pon honor, Of first and last is Charles O’Conor, My brethren everywhere — Weak men and sore deluded — By what the court declare In honor feel concluded. But I, the head of the bar, ’pon honor, I’m only concluded by Charles O’Conor. If the bench would avoid rebuff, Let ’em always manage to fix it To sneeze when I take snuff And follow my ¢pse dixit ; So shall they acquit themselves with honor, And gain the affirmance of Charles O’Conor. ’Tis an ancient silly saw, Who wrote it deserved the rod, Which tells, in speaking of Law, That “ its seat is the bosom of God.” Its seat — and I say it upon my honor — Is found in the bosom of Charles O’Conor. With me the profession will die, Who denies it utters a whopper, And the Court that’s against me — ah why Will our Judges have motives improper ? I’m never improper, not I, ’pon honor, I’m proper, and modest : Yours, CHARLES O’CONOR. My attention has been called to two errors in the first. part of this sketch. Mr. O’Conor was never “ district attorney of New York,” but in the year stated he was appointed United States district attorney for the southern district of New York. Mr. Brady did not come into the Forrest case until after the trial. The defense was con- ducted by John Van Buren.

Page 47

ee . Current Topies, . . = ‘imu f a 7 =! BY IRVING BROWNE. Me on ss “ag oe CURRENT TOPICS. ‘*THE DoGs OF CELEBRITIES.” — Under this titlé the «« Strand Magazine” for October gives many pictures of dogs, in some instances accompanied by their owners, as Patti with her «‘ Araboe,” Baroness Burdett-Coutts with her «« Pet,” and Mr. Justice Hawkins with his ** Jack.” His lordship is presented in profile, in wig, gown and bands, with one arm affectionately thrown around «+ Jack,” who faces the audience. This is a pleasing portraiture. °’Arry *Awkins his halso fond hof ha ’orse, we believe. ‘The Strand” says: — **But before we proceed further it would be idle to neglect the dog, whose legal wisdom is supposed to surpass that of many a junior barrister — ‘Jack,’ the inseparable associate, both at home and on the Bench, of Mr. Justice Hawkins. The anecdotes—many of them no doubt apocryphal— which are related in legal chambers and Temple common-rooms of ‘ Jack,’ whose portrait conjointly with that of his learned master is here given — would fill a whole issue of this magazine. ‘ Jack’ accompanies his master everywhere — except to church. Evidently his taste does not extend in that direction. Mr. Justice Haw- kins in a letter to the writer says: ‘I can say that a more intelligent, faithful, and affectionate creature never had ex- istence, and to him I have been indebted for very many of the happiest hours of my life.” Great lawyers before this have been fond of dogs. Eldon was portrayed with his dog «+ Pincher,” and according to a remark which the chancellor pretended he had overheard, was at least by one person thought to look the wiser of the two. Erskine had a favorite dog, always present at consultations, dressed in wig and bands, to the scandal of the solicitors, who said that the dog seemed to pay more attention to the business than his master. Would that «‘ The Strand ” would give us some of those anecdotes of ‘‘Jack.” TECHNICALITIES. — The modern codes of practice were intended to abolish technicalities in pleading, and are supposed to have done so, and to have ef- fectuated the result that the parties to a suit are fully apprised beforehand of the real character of the claim and the defence, and cannot suffer from surprise in this regard. It is true that the codes have enacted that the pleadings shall contain respectively a plain and concise statement of the facts constituting the cause of action and the defense. But it seems that the courts have been astute to defeat this requirement and design, in their construction of what may be proved under a bare general denial. It would seem, for example, that under a general denial in an action on a promissory note, nothing by way of defense should be allowed except to show that the defendant did not execute the paper. By express statute, at least in New York, he cannot prove payment, nor usury, nor outlawry, nor any other affirmative de- fense. But suppose the note has been fraudulently al- tered since he signed it— can he show that under a general denial? The courts hold that he may, on the theory that his denial that he executed that contract as charged covers the case. But how does this apprise _ the plaintiff of the defense of alteration? Clearly it does not, and the real defense must frequently sur- prise him. There is something wrong here, and it ought to be corrected by requirimg such a defense to -be pleaded. BROUGHAM’S Nose. — Among the most delightful reading are the memoirs and letters of the «* Bawston set,” — Prescott, Sumner,. Ticknor, Lowell and Motley — especially the pictures of foreign society which all of them except Lowell afford. Running over Motley’s Correspondence recently (which is much more entertaining than Lowell’s), we find some admirable portraits of Lord Brougham, which exery. lawyer ought to read. Motley says: “ Let me give you a photograph while his grotesque image still lingers in the camera-obscura of my brain. He is exactly like the pictures in ‘Punch,’ only ‘ Punch’ flat- ters him. The common pictures of Palmerston and Lord John are not like at all, to my mind, but Brougham is al- ways hit exactly. His face, like his tongue and his mind, is . shrewd, sharp, humorous. His hair is thick and snow- white and shiny; his head is large and knobby and bumpy, with all kinds of phrenological developments, which I did not have a chance fairly to study. The rugged outlines or headlands of his face are wild and bleak, but not forbid- 93

Page 48

94 The Green Bag. ding. Deep furrows of age and thought and toil, perhaps of sorrow, run all over it, while his vast mouth, with a ripple of humor ever playing around it, expands like a placid bay under the huge promontory of his fantastic and incredible nose. ‘ His eye is dim, and could never have been brilliant, but his voice is rather shrill, with an un- mistakable northern intonation; his manner of speech is fluent, not garrulous, but obviously touched by time; his figure is tall, slender, shambling, awkward, but of course, perfectly self-possessed. Such is what remains at eighty of the famous Henry Brougham.” ...‘* Lord Brougham interests me as much as any man. He is now eighty years of age, but Ido not see that he is much broken. His figure is erect, not very graceful, certainly, but active. His face is so familiar to every one, principally through the pictures in ‘Punch,’ as hardly to require a description. The whole visage is wild and bizarre,.and slightly comical, but not stern or forbidding. Like his tongue and his mind, it is eminently Scotch, sharp, caustic, rugged, thistleish. The top of the head is as flat as if it had been finished with a plane. The brain chamber is as spacious as is often allotted to any one mortal, and as the world knows, the owner has furnished it very thoroughly. The face is large, massive, seamed all over with the deep furrows of age and thought and toil; the nose is fantastic and incredible in shape, There is much humor and benevolence about the lines of the mouth. His manner is warm, earnest, eager, cordial. I was with him half an hour yesterday, and he talked a‘good deal of the question of Cuba and the slave-trade. He was of opinion that the claim to visit must be given up; that there was no logical defence for it; but he spoke with a sigh and almost with tears of the apparent impossibility of sup- pressing the slave-trade, or of preventing in America the indefinite extension and expansion of slavery.”... ‘* Then came Lord Brougham, looking as droll as ever. There certainly never was a great statesman and author who so irresistibly suggested the man who does the comic business at a smalltheatre as Brougham. You are compelled to laugh when you see him as much as at Keeley or Warren. Yet there is absolutely nothing comic in his mind. On the contrary, he is always earnest, vigorous, impressive, but there is no resisting his nose. It is not merely the con- figuration of that wonderful feature which surprises you, but its mobility. It has the litheness and almost the length of the elephant’s proboscis, and I have no doubt he can pick up pins or scratch his back with it as easily as he could take a pinch of snuff. He is always twisting it about in quite a fabulous manner.” (Motley must mean, like an elephant in a fable! Otherwise he would not have been guilty of such’a use of the word “ fabulous.’’) On arriving at Holland House for dinner, “there were but two persons in the room. In the twilight I did not recognize them, but presently I observed the familiar proboscis of Lord Brougham wagging in a friendly manner towards me.” Brougham was doctored at Oxford, in 1860,.at the same time with Motley, and the latter thus describes him on the march through the streets to the scene: “Nothing could be more absurd than old Brougham’s figure, long and gaunt, with snow-white hair under the great black porringer, and with his wonderful nose wagging _lithely from side to side as he hitched up his red petticoats and stalked through the mud.” Motley also draws attractive pictures of Lyndhurst at eighty-six, as, for example: “Nothing can be more genial, genuine and delightful than Lyndhurst’s manner... I like his society because of the magnificent spectacle he affords of a large, bright in- tellect setting in ‘one unclouded: blaze of living light,’ without any of the dubious haze which so often accom- panies the termination of a long and brilliant career. Every- body looks up to him with reverence-and delight. He is full of fun, always joking, always genial, and alive to what is going on around him from day to day. He has made two or three very good speeches this session, and is going to make another, and there is not a sign of senility in any- thing that he says.” Motley records that Brougham and Lyndhurst were always chaffing one another. He heard Lyndhurst declare that Brougham once went upon the wool- sack in plaid trousers, and with his peer’s robe over his chancellor’s robe. Brougham denied the trousers, but did not deny the double robes. «* Lady Stanley observed that the ladies in the gallery all admired Lord Chelmsford for his handsome leg. <A virtue that was never seen in you, Brougham,’ and so on.” We get a glimpse of Judge O. W. Holmes in a letter from his father to Motley in 1860: “IT am just. going to Cambridge to an ‘exhibition,’ in which Oliver Wendell Holmes speaks a translation (ex- pectatur versio in lingua vernacula), the Apology for Soc- rates; Master O. W. Holmes, Jun., being now a tall youth, almost six feet high, and lover of Plato and of art.” (!) GLADSTONE’S Horace. — The G. O. M., not being very busy of late, has made a metrical trans- lation of the Odes of Horace. It is an astonishingly clever performance. Mr. Gladstone evidently lacks some of the niceties of a practised versifier, but he is generally skillful and remarkably faithful to the sense, and always vigorous. His metres are varied, but he makes no attempt to imitate the original metres, and he struggles for conciseness, sometimes at a great cost. Occasionally he misses the sense, as for ex- ample, notably, in the last line of the first ode of the first book, which he renders; “Count me for lyric minstrel thou, The stars to kiss my head will bow.” Such is not the sense of «* Sublimi feriam sidera ver- tice.” The phrase does not mean that the stars will stoop, but that the poet will strut and exalt his head to them. As we have not had many cares of state on our mind of late, we think we can do this better, as for example:

Page 49

The Lawyers Easy Chair. “Grant me the lyric poet’s praise, And to the stars my head I'll raise.” Among recent American translators, Mr. Sargent renders the passage thus: “But I shall touch the starry skies If thou vouchsafe to write my name Among the bards of lyric fame.” But Mr. Sargent does not tell us what he will touch the skies wh. Mr. Field gives it thus: “And if you place me where no bard debars, With head exalted I shall strike the stars.” The first line of which is rather uncouth in sense and in sound. Again, in the fourth ode of the first book Mr. Glad- stone renders : “-Pallida mors equo pulsat pede pauperum tabernas Regumque turres, o beate Sexti,’”’ — * Oh Sextius, Furtune’s favorite, the kingly tower alike And pauper’s hut pale death will strike.” Mr. Sargent renders this: _“ Pale Death before them stalks impartially, Whether the portals be Of peasant or of prince — hovel or tower — Alike all feel his power, Oh, happy Sextius! ” Mr. Sargent is diffuse and Mr. Gladstone misses the ‘idea of the crushing foot of Death. Let us diffidently move the following amendment: “Oh, happy Sextius!, pale Death’s foot will strike The tower of kings and peasant’s hut alike.” THE CHANCELLOR'S TERM. — Something has been said recently in these columns concerning the notion prevalent in England that the term of judicial office is shorter in this country than there, and the opinion was here expressed that this is an error. Just now an incident has occurred which emphasizes the fact of the uncertainty and brevity of the Lord Chancel- lor’s term of office, and the absurdity of allowing the first law-officer of the kingdom to be subject to the fortunes of his political party, as it would be absurd for the Chief-Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States to come in and go out with each changing administration at the White House.. We are indebted to the ever excellent «* Notes from Lon- don’ in the ‘* Scottish Law Magazine” for the fol- lowing account of the incident in question : — _ These two officers, the greatest functionaries of the whole system, played a little comedy at the Guildhall on the occasion of the Lord Mayor’s banquet, which sounds like a version of the amenities that occurred between Betsy Prig and Sairey Gamp when their relations became 95 too strained for silence. If it wasn’t a quarrel in public, the printed word must convey a very wrong impression, It may have been only their fun; but, as one reads, the feeling is strong that, if it were, they have not mastered — the art of humorous expression; and their chaffing, if such it were, like that intellectual entertainment often does, seemed to end in right-down earnestness and bad temper. It was a question of who should respond for the judiciary | as the real head of it. The poor sheriff got mixed, and, knowing the Lord Chief Justice was to respond, apologized to the Lord Chancellor for the toast not being entrusted to him. This was not pleasing to the new Lord Chief Jus- tice, who naturally magnifies his office. The instincts of the fighting advocate were roused, and he said, ‘I beg to say that the Sheriff had no cause of complaint. My noble friend, great and distinguished as he is, is, after all, only a fleeting, temporary, political, quasi-judicial person. I claim to be one of the permanent judges of the land.’ “To whom the Lord Chancellor in reply, ‘The Lord Chief Justice has said that I'am but a fleeting character in the judicial world. However true that may be, I reflect that at least my career has not been so fleeting, but that this is the third Lord.Mayor’s banquet at which I have -been presént, and I think that under those circumstances I might well believe you would all desire that it should be left to the Chief Justice to respond for the Bench on the first occasion on which he appears in his present office.’ “There is a healthy ring of genuine human nature in this little outburst, which comes as a great relief from the solemn conventionalities and platitudes about the fearless- ness and incorruptibility of the judges and the devotion and courage of the Bar with which we are usually wearied on these occasions.” How long a period three Lord Mayors’ banquets cover we do not know, but it isa queer standard by ‘which to measure the term of the Lord Chancellor’s office. But Lord Chief Justice Russell is right; the Lord Chancellor is only a ‘fleeting, temporary, po- litical, quasi-judicial person,” and the soup that he eats at the Mansion House should be mock-turtle. DIVORCE IN OHIO. —Recent statistics of divorce in Ohio expose a most shocking state of affairs, as disclosed in one of our Ohio exchanges, namely, about one divorce to every twelve marriages in the year from July, 1893, to July, 1894, or 2,753 divorces in all! In 1892-1893 the number was 2,913, and in 189I~ 1892 it was 2,737. In three years, 8,403 divorces! The total number of suits brought during the year was 3,696, and 2,918 were pending when the year began. There were 858 cases dismissed during the year. In one county 399 divorces were granted. The women get about 73 per cent of the divorces. It is significant that 1,380, or more than half the whole number, were granted for absence and neglect, while only 385 were granted for adultery, and the

Page 50

*“\ extended consideration. 96. The Green Bag. usually prolific cause of ‘‘ cruelty” furnished only 567. The causes were as follows : — Granted Granted to Husband. to Wife. Adultery 196 189 Absence and neglect . 400 980 Cruelty . , , , 51 516 Drunkenness ‘ 47 276 Fraud i. R ‘ : IO I2 Miscellaneous. , 26 50 Total . 730 2,023 It looks very much as if this country would equal its former record of 322,000 in twenty years. NOTES OF CASES. WIFE HARBORING A DoG.—JIn Strouse wv. Leipf, Alabama Supreme Court, 23 Lawyers’ Rep. Anno- tated, 623, it was held that a wife is not liable for harboring a vicious dog on her own premises, al- though by law she holds her estate separate, and her husband is not liable for her torts in which he does not participate. This is an elaborate examination by Stone, J., at the conclusion of which he observes : — “Tet us recur to the facts of this case. The dog had been on the premises for several years. No present act of negligence is charged against husband or wife which led to the escape of the dog and the consequent injury of the plaintiff. The fault charged was and is that a dog with known vicious propensity-was kept on the premises, and that, escaping therefrom, he inflicted the injury complained of. The wrongful act was the keep of the dog. This pertained to the government of the household and premises, — the economy and administration of the dgmes- tic affairs. It was not the act of a moment, or the work of an hour or a day. It was continuous in its nature, and must be charged to the account of the head — the govern- ing head —of the family. For this injury no suit could have been maintained at common law against the husband and wife jointly. It would have been adjudged to be his act, his wife, at most, acting conjointly with him, and under his presumed control. Nor has the statute wrought any change in this bearing of the question. If the wife had any part or lot in the keep of the dog, it cannot be classed as her tort, ‘in the commission of which he did not participate.’ She could not keep the dog without his con- sent ané participation.. Hence the case is not brought within the provisions of the statute. ‘‘ A further argument: Let us suppose the husband had ‘been sued, and he had pleaded:in bar that the wife owned and kept the dog. Every one will say such defense would be frivolous. The husband, the head and governor of the family, must be held accountable for the economy and administration of the household. This power and right have not been taken away or impaired by the statutes securing to married women their separate estates. We are aware that we have given to this subject a somewhat We have done so because it brings before us, for the first time, the inquiry to what extent, if-any, our married women’s laws have changed the relations of the husband to the household and its govern- ment. We have felt that so grave a question should not be slurred over, but should be clearly and definitely settled; and, notwithstanding our statutes have revolutionized the property rights of the wife, they have effected no change in the headship — the dominion and control — of the husband over the household, or in the government of the home and its appurtenants.” The contrary of this has been held in Shaw v. McCreery, 19 Ont. 39; 42 Ab. L. J. 241; Quilty v. Batty, 135 New York, 201. In a recent Colorado case, husband and wife were held properly joined in such an action, it not appearing to whom the dog belonged; and in McLaughlin v. Kemp, 152 Mass. 7, it was held a question of fact whether the wife harbored the dog with knowledge of its vicious pro- pensities. SUNDAY BARBERISM.— The Michigan Supreme Court, in People v. Bellet, 57 N.W. Reporter, 1094, held that a. statute forbidding barbers to exercise their calling on Sunday is valid, not depriving the citizen of property without due process, nor abridging his privileges or immunities, nor being class legisla- tion. The Court said on this last point : — * By class legislation we understand such legislation as denies rights to one which are accorded to others, or inflicts upon one individual a more severe penalty than is imposed upon another, in like case, offending. In Liber- man v. State (26 Neb. 464), an ordinance of the city prohibited the keeping open of any business house, bank, store, saloon or office, excepting telegraph offices, express - offices, photograph galleries, railroad offices, telephone offices, hotels, restaurants, cigar stores, eating houses, ice- cream parlors, drug stores, etc. It was contended that the ordinance was open to the objection that it did not operate upon all citizens alike; that the respondent was compelled to close his place of business on Sunday, while drug stores, tobacco houses and others in competition in business, were not required to do so. But the Court held the act valid. In the present case it may have been the judgment of the Legislature that those engaged in the particular calling were more likely to offend against the law of the State providing for Sunday closing than those engaged in other callings. If so, it became a question of policy as to whether a more severe penalty should not be provided for engaging in that particular business on Sunday than that inflicted upon others who refuse to cease from their labors one day in seven.” THE LAW OF THE RoAD.— The statute law of New Hampshire requires persons driving on highways and meeting others to turn to the right of the center of the travelled part. But in Brember v. Jones, the supreme court of that State recently decided that where it appeared that there was sufficient room for both par-

Page 51

The Lawyers Easy Chair. 97 ties to pass, and that the collision might have been avoided if plaintiff had exercised due care, he could not recover, though defendant did not turn to the right. The court observed : *«’To warrant a recovery where both parties are present at the time of the injury, as well as in other cases, ability on the part of the defendant must concur with non- ability on the part of the plaintiff to prevent it by ordinary care, ‘Their duty to exercise this degree of care is equal and reciprocal. Neither is exonerated from this obligation by the present or previous misconduct of the other. The law no more holds one responsible for an unavoidable, or justifies an avoidable, injury to the person of one who care- lessly exposes himself to danger, than to his property, similarly situated, in his absence. He who cannot prevent an injury negligently inflicted upon his person or property by an itftelligent agent ‘ present and acting at the time’ (State v. Manchester L. & R. Co. 52 N. H. 528, 557: White v. Winnisimmet Co., 7 Cush. 155, 157; Robinson v. Cone, 22 Vt. 213), is legally without fault, and it is im- material whether his inability results from his absence, previous negligence, or other cause. On the other hand, his neglect to prevent it, if he can, is the sole or co-opera- ting cause of the injury. No one can justly complain of another’s negligence, which, but for his own wrongful in- terposition, would be harmless (Parker v. Adams, 12 Metc. { Mass.], 415; Nashua Iron & Steel Co. v. Worcester & N. Rk. Co, 62 N. H. 159, 163). z. **No negligence on the part of the defendant is shown, other than the legal negligence of not seasonably turning to the right of the centre of the highway. Whether the defendant’s legal negligence, in violating the law of the road, rendered him liable to the plaintiff in damages, de- pends upon the determination of the question whether the injury could or could not have been avoided by the exer- cise of ordinary care by the plaintiff, whether it was or was. not the legal cause of the injury. The fact that the de- fendant was violating the law of the road does not, as matter of law, warrant a recovery by the plaintiff (Damon v. Scituate, 119 Mass. 66, 68). If the parties were re- versed, and the defendant was seeking damages from the plaintiff, the defendant’s legal negligence, in disregarding the statute, would not necessarily, and as matter of law, defeat a recovery (Steele v. Burkhardt, 104 Mass. 59; Spofford v. Harlow, 3 Allen, 176). The question would still be, whose fault causegl the collision? (State v. Man- ‘chester & L. R. Co. 52 N. H. 528, 557). The fact that a party was acting in violation of law when an injury was done to his person or property by the wrongful act of vanother does not deprive him of his action for damages, unless the injury resulted from the unlawful act (Wood- man v. Hubbard, 25 N. H. 67; Norris v. Litchfield, 35 N. H. 271, 277; Nutt v. Manchester, 58 N. H. 226; Sewell v. Webster, 59 N. H. 586; Wentworth v. Jeffer- son, 60 E. H. 158; Lyons v. Child, 61 N. H. 72: Welch v. Wesson, 6 Gray, 505).”’ In England the law of the road is. to turn to the left. Pictures of English milking scenes represent the milker on the left side of the cow. We formerly supposed this was the engraver’s mistake, but it is the English custom. The «‘Troy Times” had a picture of Gov. Morton in the act of taking the oath of office, with his left hand up. Would that oath be legal? 5 “ EXTORTION — EvipENCE. — In People v. Gard- ner, a recent decision of New York Court of Appeals, two interesting points were passed upon. The first. was that an attempt at extortion may be committed when the defendant supposed he was committing it, although in fact he was being decoyed. A woman, who kept a house of prostitution, testified that the defendant approached her and promised that if she would pay him money he would refrain from accus- ing her of that offence, and that in consenting she was acting merely as a decoy for the police. The statute provides that extortion may be committed by obtaining property from another by force or << fear,” and that an ‘‘ attempt” is ««an act’ done with intent to commit a crime, and trusting, but failing to effect its commission.” The defendant’s counsel argued that «* the fact that his threat did not inspire fear in- ducing any action on the part of Mrs. Amos, an element essential to constitute the completed crime of extortion, renders it impossible to sustain an in- dictment and conviction for the lesser crime of an attempt at extortion.” This view was taken by a majority of the judges of the General Term, but their decision is reversed by the Court of Appeals, Judge Earl delivering the unanimous opinion, holding that an attempt is not deprived of its criminal character by the fact that in the nature of things unknown to the defendant it could not succeed, likening the case to an attempt to pick an empty pocket. Judge Earl said: “Tt is now established law, both in England and in this country, that the crime of attempting to commit larceny may be committed, although there was no property to steal, and thus the full crime of larceny could not have been committed” (see People v. Moran, 123 N. Y. 254). .. “In Reg. v. Goodchild (2 Carr. & Kir. 293), and Reg. v. Goodall (2 Cox, Cr. C. 41) it was held under a statute making it a felony to administer poison or use any instrument with intent to procure the miscarriage of any woman that the crime could be committed in a case where the woman was not pregnant. It has been held in several — cases that there may be a conviction of an attempt to ob- tain property by false pretenses, although the person from whom the attempt was made knew at the time that the pretenses were false, and could not, therefore, be deceived.” It was also held that no error was committed by the trial judge in forcibly compelling the prisoner to stand up in court, so that he could be identified by a witness. This was put on two grounds: first, that the court could control the conduct of the prisoner in court as to sitting or standing, etc.; and second,

Page 52

98 The Green Bag. that this did not compel him to give evidence against himself. We agree with the «¢ New York Law Jour- nal,” that ‘‘ there is something to be said on the other side,” but we think the holding is right, be- cause.it did not compel the prisoner to do or to dis- close anything that is unusual or usually concealed, like exposing an arm to show tattoo marks or fitting a foot into a shoe or a mould of a track. PRIZE FIGHTING.— We have observed, and ex- pressed the observation, that judicial decisions seem to be much influenced by the financial or other in- terests of the particular locality in the particular subject of the litigation. Thus the Maine courts sedulously protect ownership in ice; those of Penn- sylvania allow much latitude to the smoke of iron- furnaces although it amounts to a nuisance; English courts seem to allow fox-hunters to ride rough-shod over other people’s lands in chase of the noxious and dangerous fox; Texas courts frequently regard a ‘mule as worth more than a man; and now the su- preme court of Louisiana has thrown its protection about the great New Orleans industry of prize-fight- ing. In State v. Olympic Club (46 La. Ann.), 24 Lawyers’ Rep. Ann. 452, it was held as follows : “yz. A criminal statute denouncing what is commonly called prize-fighting to be a misdemeanor, or punishable by fine or imprisonment, coupled with a proviso that the provisions of the act shall not apply to exhibitions and glove contests between human beings, which may take place within the rooms of regularly chartered athletic clubs, presents a question of fact to be determined by the court or jury as to whether any given contest or Series of contests come within the designation of the statute as a prize fight or within the scope and meaning of the proviso as a glove contest. “2, As the State of Louisiana is in court seeking the forfeiture of the defendant’s charter on the ground that the corporation has committed acts w/tra vires of its charter, and is met with the provisions of an act of her own legis- lature which, in terms, authorizes just such contests as the witnesses describe the club contests to have been, this court will be excused for declining to disturb a finding of a jury in favor of the defendant on a question of fact. 3. Conceding such contests to be violative of good morals and of a sound public policy, the remedy comes plainly within the prerogative of the legislative department of the government, which alone can be looked to for relief.” We take it that this statute does not authorize a substantial prize-fight even under the guise of ‘‘a glove contest” in the rooms of an ‘athletic club.” We take it also that these ‘‘ glove contests” are dangerous. We know they have frequently re- sulted in death. But at all events a blow that renders a man insensible for several minutes must be dangerous. In spite of the apparent doubt of the court in this case, we have no doubt that these con- tests are generally bloody. If they are not, the cul- tured gentlemen who attend them .complain loudly and want their money back. The following extract from the opinion in question makes us ashamed ot some lawyers : ‘‘The next witness whose testimony has attracted our notice is a prominent lawyer, who furnishes a like descrip- tion of the Olympic contests as the first witness did. The men who participated in those contests were men of scien- tific training, almost without an exception. He does not think any of the contestants were hurt very much. He saw one or two of them bleeding from the nose or mouth,’ and possibly saw one bleeding from the ear. States that he witnessed the Sullivan-Kilrain fight in Mississippi. The next witness is a leading lawyer of the New Orleans bar. He states that he witnessed several of the Olympic Club contests, and instances the Corbett-Sullivan contest, which he describes‘much in the same manner as other witnesses have done. ‘That he saw nothing that was objectionable or brutal in that contest. He testifies — as other witnesses . had done —that the assemblage of people who witnessed these contests was orderly and well-behaved; or, as the first witness states, these assemblages of people, in point of personal respectability and behavior, were above the average of ordinary political assemblages. ‘This witness is a mem- ber of the school board, and a gentleman of first respecta- bility. The next witness is also a prominent city lawyer of high reputation and a man of affairs. He states that he has witnessed quite a number of the Olympic Club contests, and his description of them, and the manner in which they were conducted, is quite the same as that of other witnesses whose testimony we have commented on. _ His description ofthe effect of these contests upon the contestants physi- cally is unique: ‘ Q. The exhibitions, which you have de- scribed, were they at any time bloody, or was-blood shed during any of those contests? A. Well, when two men get opposite to each other and begin boxing, unless gne has a pretty tough nose, there is going to be a bloody nose. I have had a bloody nose myself twenty times when I was taking boxing lessons,’ etc. With regard to the cruelty or brutality of the Olympic contests, this witness’s statement is also quite unique: ‘Q. Was there anything brutal or inhuman about it? A. In my judgment, no, sir. As com- pared with that popular game nowadays known as football, which I think the American people have gone crazy about, the contests that I have seen at the Olympic Club are supe- | rior in every respect, and in point of humanity as appealing to the zesthetic senses.’ ” | We may subscribe to the comparison made by the last witness in respect to foot-ball, if not in respect to political meetings ; but still we may be pardoned for believing that courts ought to lean toward dis- countenancing these plainly brutal affairs.

Page 53

Se es ee oe... Green Bac. PUBLISHED MONTHLY, AT $4.00 PER ANNUM. SINGLE NUMBERS, 50 CENTS. ee Communications in regard to the contents of the Magazine should be addressed to the Editor, HORACE W. FULLER, 15% Beacon Street, Boston, Mass. The Editor will be glad to receive contributions of articles of moderate length upon subjects of inter- est to the profession; also anything in the way of legal antiquities or curtosities, facetia, anec- dotes, etc. LEGAL ANTIQUITIES. Among the Greeks it was customary to impre- cate the most formidable curses on those who should attempt to violate the wishes of the testa- tor. According to ‘Tacitus, wills were unknown among the Germans. RECENT DEATHS. THE LATE RIT. HON. SIR JOHN THOMPSON. N the GREEN Bac for March, 1891, the writer of these lines had occasion to give a brief biographical sketch of the Canadian statesman whose life closed so tragically at Windsor Castle on the 12th of December last. When that article was written, Sir John Thompson was minister of - justice in the government of Sir John MacDon- ald: and nobody could then predict that Sir John MacDonald and two successors in the office of premier should pass away before the close of the parliamentary term. Death, however, has claimed Canada’s three prime ministers, Sir John Mac* Donald, Sir John Abbott, and Sir John Thompson, within the past four years. Readers of the article to which allusion has been made are already aware of the principal events of the career of Sir John Thompson down to 1891 —his birth, his rapid rise in his profes- sion and in provincial politics, his distinguished success on the bench, and his more distinguished triumphs in the House of Commons of Canada, where at almost one bound he took a front rank as a parliamentarian. When Sir John MacDon- ald died in June, 1891, the Governor-General called upon Sir John ‘Thompson to form a new administration. With modesty rare among pub- lic men, he declined to accept the high trust, but urged that some older and more experienced man should assume the leadership. ‘The result was that Hon. Mr. Abbott (afterwards Sir John Abbott) formed a new government, Sir John Thompson retaining his old portfolio of minister of justice. A few weeks, however, demonstrated that although not the nominal leader, his great gifts made Sir John Thompson the real leader of his party. In November, 1892, Sir John Abbott was obliged through ill-health to retire from the. government, and Sir John Thompson had to ac- cept the premiership. In the House of Com- mons he had acquired as complete a mastery as had been exercised by Sir John MacDonald in his palmiest days. : In 1893, Sir John Thompson acted as one of the British arbitrators in the Bering Sea Com- mission at Paris, and as a member of that august international tribunal he acquired fresh honors for himself and new distinction for his country. In recognition of his services Her Majesty the Queen was pleased to appoint him a member of -her privy council—the highest distinction to which a colonial statesman can aspire. The parliamentary session of 1894 was a most laborious and trying one for the Canadian premier ‘in consequence of the many important measures passing through parliament and of the prolonged illness of some of his colleagues ;. and over-work brought on the insidious malady which caused his death. After the close of the session he en- deavored to recruit his health ; and in the autumn he visited Europe. On the 12th of December, a few weeks after he had attained his fiftieth year, he was sworn in as privy councillor by the Queen, and a few. hours after the ceremony, in her his- toric castle, he suddenly expired. ‘Truly did Lewis Morris sing of, him :— ‘‘ Dead at the crest, the crown, And blossom of his fortunes, this strong son Of our great realm sank down Beneath the load of honors scarcely won.” His death caused most profound grief through- 99

Page 54

100 out the whole British Empire, but more espe- cially in Canada, where he was so well known and so greatly esteemed. The Queen as a special mark of royal favor never before shown to any of her subjects, ordered one of her greatest warships to convey the remains to Halifax ; and there, in the home of his boyhood, with funereal pomp and pageantry surpassing anything ever before witnessed in Britain’s immense colonial empire, all that was mortal of Canada’s noblest and clean- est statesman was laid at rest. w: FACETIA:. THE following letter was recently received by a lawyer in New York State : — Mr. : Come Down to Day. Case Salt & Batray, or Send Police Justis Down ameatley Knocked Down in my Own Hotell 3 times without any Provocation I am not able to come up_ I want you to take Him Beforr Half the Pepel. Yours Last winter Mr. Justice Harlan delivered a lecture On the Bering Sea Arbitration before a large audience of law students in a western city. His Honor, after taking up the legal side of the question, described graphically and learnedly the habits, migrations and peculiarities of the seal, with elaborate references to other animals which seemed to offer instructive analogies. nom A few days after, a student who had read law a few months was asked how he liked the lecture. ‘Qh, very much,” replied he, “very much in- deed — very instructive — in fact I think I learned more Natural History from Justice Har- lan than from all of Blackstone.” OLD Grizzle was a man of will, And money, too, galore. He quarreled with his relatives, With him, they calmly bore. For men must die, and Grizzle did, But with his latest breath, He gave his money to the poor. He had a will in death. One of the most famous French advocates, Langlois, was asked by the President of the Par- liament of Paris why he took upon him to plead The Green Bag. bad causes. He answered, with a smile, that he did it because he had lost a great many good ones. NOTES. SoME of our modern judges would do well to bear in mind the story of Lord Mansfield’s advice to an old army officer, who knew little of law, and who had been appointed governor of a West India Island. The most appalling duty which the governor had to perform was the administration of justice, and in his ignorance he addressed Lord Mansfield in a tone of great concern, saying he knew nothing of law, and asking what he should do as the presiding officer of the local Court of Chancery on the island to which he was going, ‘Tut, man,” said Mans- field, “decide promptly, but never give any reasons for your decisions. be right, but your reasons are sure tg be wrong.” A TERRIBLE disease seems just at present to be epidemic among the members of the Bar. A ‘poetic mania”’ has seized them. ‘The malady has appeared in a malignant form in Kansas, two prominent lawyers being the victims. We are indebted to the Kansas City “Star” for the following account of its ravages : — The damage suit of J. J. Smith against Kansas City, Kas., which was tried in the Court of Common Pleas in Kansas City, Kas., last week, is the cause of considerable merriment among the members of the Wyandotte County Bar. Mr. Smith was repre- sented by Colonel L. C. True, and the City by City Counsellor Reese. It is the first case on record in that court in which the argument was made in poetry, the plaintiff getting a verdict apparently on the strength of the poetic appeal to the jury. When the evidence was all in Colonel True de- livered his argument. It was a short statement of the case and included this novel address to the jury : — Is there no place on the face of the earth Where charity dwelleth, where virtue has birth? Where bosoms in kindness and mercy will heave, And the poor and the wretched shall ask and receive ? Is there no place on earth where a knock from the poor Will bring a kind angel to open the door? Ah! search the wide world wherever you can, There is no open door for the moneyless man. Go look in your church of the*cloud-reaching spire, Which gave back to the sun his same look of fire, . Your decisions may’

Page 55

Editorial Department. - IOI Where the arches and columns are gorgeous within, And the walls seem as pure as the soul without sin; Go down the long aisle —see the rich and the great, In the pomp and the pride of their worldly estate; Walk down in your patches, and find if you can Who opens a pew for a moneyless man. Go look in the banks, where Mammon has told His hundreds and thousands of silver and gold; Where, safe from the hands of the starving and salir Lies pile upon pile of the glittering ore; Walk up to the counter— Ah! there you may stay, Till your limbs have grown old and your hair turns gray, And you'll find at the bank not one of the clan With money to lend to a moneyless man. The jury returned a verdict for $1,200 in favor of Mr. True’s ‘* Moneyless Man” in the shortest kind of order? Yesterday was motion day in the Common Pleas Court, and City Counsellor Reese argued a motion for a new trial in another case. He-began this way: ‘¢Colonel True, in his argument in the Smith case a few days ago, quoted from the case of the « Money- less Man,’ reported in the Boys’ and Girls’ Recitation Book, price five cents. ‘¢ The unfair impression that the quotation made on the jury, the Court; and also on myself was so apparent, that it left a lasting impression on me, and in a dream on the same night I repeated the above stanzas to an intelligent little terrier dog. When the canine said — for dogs will talk in a dream — « If that poetry is worth $1,200, I’ll give you some that is worth $10,000,’ I patted the dog on the head and said ‘Go ahead.’ The dog raised himself on_ his hind feet, put my best spectacles on his nose and. said : — ‘ Gentlemen of the jury, attend, if you can, To the sad tale of woe of the moneyless man; He stands here before you, in want, as you see; He pleads not his merits; he pleads poverty; He can’t go to the church, his patches preclude; He can’t go to the bank, get a note there renewed; His only last chance for wealth is the town; _ ‘Take pity on me, and make it come down. _ Gentlemen of the jury, have pity, pray do; ‘f my story be false, my counsel is:'True; Look not on my failings, pass over my sin; Look, look, I beseech you, just look at my shin ; Poor shin, badly skinned on the sidewalk down there, Please give me a plaster of dollars, and spare Not the city. It’s big; but pray help, if you can, My noble good lawyers, and the moneyless man.’ ‘¢ The little dog then lay on his back, with his four feet in the air, and winking his other eye, said: ‘ That may not be poetry, but you must admit that it is good dog-erel.’? * Well, Joe,’ said I, « there is not much poetry in it, but there is lots of truth,’ and then — well, I woke up.” Mr. Reese’s effort did not meet with such success as Mr. True, at least it did not convince Judge Anderson, and the motion for a new trial was over- ruled. An appeal will be taken to the Supreme Court. Mr. Reese’s poem will accompany the tran- script, as it is a part of the record in the case. Tue following circular, received by mail, is so unique that we cannot refrain from giving the issuer of it a little free advertising : — ‘¢ THE COLORED LAWYER RICHARD E. KING, EsqQ.,. Law Office, Residence and Restaurant,. Are connected and established at. 43 WeEsT StT., Opp. CALVERT ST., ANNAPOLIS, | MARYLAND. Who is the first Colored Lawyer ever admitted to the Bar of Anne Arundel County, Md. Here the colored people and the kind public can have all kinds of legal business promptly transacted. Where all kinds of good meals and lunches are served at all hours, cheap for cash. Will practice in all the Courts in Maryland, Virginia and in Washington, D.C., also before the Committees of Congress and the Bureaus of the U.S. Executive Departments. Special attention paid to collection. of bounties, pensions, debts, rents; houses and lands to let and for sale; drawing or: contracts, deeds, mortgages, bills of sales, leases, wills or other instruments. All titles and conditions of property secured, and estates settled. All legal and serviceable advice given in all business transactions. — | Also a bureau of employment is established here, where many good servants are always for hire. This law office will be known and conducted as the colored people’s headquarters for the transaction - of business. ; Hot coffee, tea, chocolate and Geek milk always — ready.” A SINGULAR CASE. — It may be safely saidthatthe | case of State v. Hall, in which the opinion of the Supreme Court of North Carolina was filed lately, has had no parallel. Hall, standing on the North | Caroline side of the line, fired and killed a man just overin Tennessee. He was tried and convicted in North Carolina. Onappeal, this was reversed on the ground that “in contemplation of law,” Hall was in Tennessee when the killing was done. He was then arrested and held as a fugitive from justice. The judge below refused to discharge him. On appeal the Supreme Court by a major-

Page 56

102 - The Green Bag. ity of one decides that he must be discharged because, not having been in Tennessee at the time of the killing, he cannot be a fugitive from justice. Justice Clark dissents (Justice MacRae join- ing in the dissent) on the ground that if, in con- templation of law, Hall was in Tennessee at the time of the killing, so that he cannot be tried in North. Carolina, in the same contemplation of law he must be a fugitive from justice, for he can- not now be found in Tennessee, but is in North Carolina. He says, “If a mob occupying the Jersey side of the Hudson should shell the city of New York, or from the opposite shore of the Delaware should cannonade the city of Philadel- phia, under the decisions of the courts they would be liable to no punishment in New Jersey, be- cause “in contemplation of law” the mobs were in New York and Pennsylvania. But if it is true, as contended by counsel, that the members of the mob cannot be extradited because the mob never was in those cities, it would be a singular state of things, and would place those cities, aswell as Savannah, Memphis, St. Louis, Louisville, Cin- cinnati, and hundreds of other border towns, at the mercy of any mob which might assemble with weapons of long range, across the state line.”’ ‘ Civilized man must recoil from the practical ruling that the territory adjacent to state bound- aries is a ‘No man’s land’ and that murder is privileged if committed across a state line.’’ ‘The two dissenting judges think that, as murder has been committed, if the murderer cannot be tried in North Carolina, he should be delivered up to Tennessee to be tried. ‘That extradition is not a criminal, but a remedial statute, and should be liberally construed to effect the object intended, which is, that an offender shall not escape trial because not to be found in the state where he committed the crime, when he can be found in another state of the Union. The majority of the court rely upon precedents. ‘The dissent rests upon the reason of the thing, and what is deemed by it the true construction and intent of the Constitution. LITERARY NOTES. THE New SCIENCE REVIEW for January has two interesting communications in the direction of that consideration of ‘*Mental Training,” by W. G. Jordan, in.the October number, which attracted.such wide-spread attention. These are, ‘* The Dangers of Examinations,” by Major-General A. W. Drayson, and **The Amateur in Science,” by Grant Allen, both of them highly worthy of perusal by all advo- cates of an advanced education. ‘¢* The price of liberty,” said Jefferson, ‘is per- petual vigilance.” The price of science is perpetual heresy. —GRANT ALLEN, in Zhe Mew Science Review, for Fanuary. AN old-fashioned sea story full of interest and adventure, with a strong love motive, is begun by W. Ciark Russell in the January COSMOPOLITAN. ‘¢ Quida” succeeds Froude, Gosse, Lang, and other distinguished writers with an installment of the ‘¢Great Passions of History” series. The present ‘¢ Theatrical Season in New York” is critically con- sidered by James S. Metcalfe, editor of «* Life,” and there are stories by Tourgée, Howells, and the famous French writer Francois Coppée. McCiureE’s MAGAZINE for January demonstrates anew the thoroughness of Miss Tarbell’s study of Napoleon’s career, both by her remarkable summary of his services to France as a far-sighted ruler and law-giver and founder of institutions, and by the re- markable discovery she made of a contemporary document written by a grenadier of the Consular Guards, describing the battle of Marengo, and the famous stand of the Consular Guards. A new Jungle story by Kipling, and a thrilling battle story by Conan Doyle, show these authors at their best. Wirth the first number in January, LITTELL’s LIVING AGE entered upon its two hundred and fourth volume. The field of periodical literature, especially in England, is continually broadening, and including more and more the work of the foremost authors in all branches of literature and science. Presenting, in compact and convenient form, all that is most valu- able of this work, THE LIvING AGE becomes more and more a necessity to the American reader, for, by its aid alone, he can conveniently as well as economi- cally keep well abreast with the literary and scientific progress of the age and with the work of the ablest living writers. THE extent of the United States is recalled vividly by Julian. Ralph’s article, «‘ Charleston and the Caro- linas,” in the January HARPER’s. While winter is having its way in some two million square miles of Uncle Sam’s territory, yet there is a sunny side even to the first three months of the year, and the center of all this charm is Charleston. This number is rich

Page 57

Editorial Department. in illustrated articles, and in addition to the serials contain five short stories by well known authors. THE January REVIEW. OF REVIEWS, in its ‘‘ Prog- ress of the World” (editorial) department, discusses present problems in public health administration, municipal reform in the United States, the movement for deep waterways from the great lakes to the Atlan- tic Ocean, the Nicaragua Canal question, the pro- posed arbitration of the boundary dispute between Venezuela and Great Britain, the payment by our government of damages to Canadian seal poachers, the prospects of civil service reform, the demand for a bank-note currency, the change in the Canadian Premiership, the disposition of English visitors to instruct Americans, and the recent action of the American Federation of Labor. : W. D. McCrackan, A.M., one of the ablest of contemporary writers upon the principles and institu- tions of representative government, contributes a thoughtful and forcible paper to the January ARENA on ‘‘ Politics as a Career.” Among the encouraging conclusions reached by this life-long student of every form of democracy, ancient and modern, is that no honest man can enter political life in America to-day except as a reformer, and that as a reformer he will be treated with scorn and contumely and have little or no influence. THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY never flags in its task of giving to the general public the new and broader views of Nature, including man, that scien- tific investigators are opening up. In the leading article of its January number many of the wonders that astronomers have discovered are brought within the view of amateurs with small telescopes. It is the second of a series of papers illustrated with star-maps which Garrett P. Serviss is contributing under the title «« Pleasures of the Telescope.” In «* Twenty- five Years of Preventive Medicine” a history of sanitation in this country is given by Mrs. H. M. Plunkett «* Ethics in Natural Law” is the title of an essay in which Dr. Lewis G. Janes criticises the famous Romanes lecture by Prof. Huxley. THE CENTURY for January presents a varied:list of attractions. In addition to the Napoleon, which marches along rapidly toward Bonaparte’s first mili- tary success, and which is richly illustrated by the work of contemporary and other artists, there are illustrated articles on Canton, dealing with the pun- ishment of criminals and with the interesting river population, on ‘*The Armor of Old Japan,” on 103 ‘¢ Festivals in American Colleges for Women,” set- ting forth the recreations of Bryn Mawr, Mt. Hol- yoke, Smith, Vassar, Wellesley, and Wells Colleges, besides a fully illustrated article by Mr. Hiram S. Maxim on his «‘ Experiments in Aérial Navigation.” AN article in the January ATLANTIC which will be likely to attract the attention of thoughtful readers is Mr. John H. Denison’s ‘*The Survival of the American Type.” always found in writers on public affairs he describes the political situation, especially in the larger cities. The whole paper is suggestive, and will probably excite comment of various kinds. > IN the January number of SCRIBNER’S MAGAZINE, Noah Brooks begins a group of three papers on American Party Politics with a most informing ac- count of-‘* The Beginnings of American Parties,” relating the political complications with the same nearness of view as though he were a contemporary observer. The group of papers will furnish an ad- mirable introduction to the leading historical plan of the year which begins in the March number — Pres- ident Andrew’s brilliant narrative of ‘+The Last Quarter-Century in the United States.” BOOK NOTICES. LAW. Hanp-Book oF THE Law. or CONTRACTS. By Won. L. Ciark, Jr., West. Publishing Co., St. Paul. . Law sheep. $3.75. This is the last addition to the ‘* Hornbook Series’ issued by the West Publishing Co., for the use of law.students. Mr. Clark presents the prin- ciples of the law of contracts in a clear, concise manner, accompanying them by full explanations and illustrations. The citations are numerous, including nearly ten thousand cases. The work is admirably adapted to the student's needs, and will find favor with our law teachers. THE FEDERAL INCOME Tax EXPLAINED. By JOHN M. Goutp and GeEorGE F. Tucker. . Little, Brown, & Co., Boston, 1894. Cloth. $1.00. This little manual will prove of much value and assistance not only to the legal profession but to all who are so unfortunate(?) as to come within the pro- visions of the Income Tax. The decisions and practice affecting the income tax laws of the time of the Civil War have been used by the authors to elucidate the present statute, and as those rulings and decisions will undoubtedly be adopted and fol- With a courage and frankness not | ris:

Page 58

104 lowed by the courts in passing upon the present act, the victims of this distasteful legislation will be able to judge pretty accurately of their status under the Act of 1894. Messrs. Gould and. Tucker are the first in the field, but will doubtless be followed by other writers upon this important subject; still, for a book of ready reference, we think this compact, clear and concise work is likely to hold its own against all competitors. A ‘TREATISE ON THE LAW OF BENEFIT SOCIETIES AND LirE INSURANCE. Voluntary associations, regular life, beneficiary and accident insurance. By Freperick H. Bacon, of the St. Louis Bar. SEcoNnD Epirion. ‘The F. H. Thomas Law Book Co., St. Louis, 1894. ‘Two vols. Law sheep. $12.00 mev. The great number of new decisions on the law of beneficiary insurance during the past six years has rendered a new edition of, this valuable work of Mr. Bacon a positive necessity. Upward of twelve hun- dred new cases and nearly five hundred pages of new text have been added, and much of the old text has been re-written. In its present form the treatise is an exhaustive discussion of the law of benefit socie- ties and life insurance, to date, and as such should be welcomed by the profession. | AMERICAN PROBATE LAw AND Practice. Appli- cable to all the states. By FRANK 5. RICE. Matthew Bender, Albany, N.Y., 1894. Law sheep. $6.50 met. This treatise is an attempt on the author’s part to - collate, classify, and exhibit the rules that character- ize and govern American Probate Courts, and to furnish a practical guide to the whole field of Probate Law and Practice. The principles of the law are stated tersely and precisely and the text is remark- ably free from all technical obscurities. The work covers a field which has been neglected by our law writers, and should be of great assistance to the practitioner. We have no doubt it will well stand the test of constant use and reference. The typographical work and: paper leave nothing to be desired. PRACTICE IN ATTACHMENT OF PROPERTY FOR THE STATE OF New York. With complete forms. By GrorGE W. BrapNeR. Matthew Bender, Albany, N.Y. Law sheep. $350 mez. The object of this work is to present to the practi- tioner the rules of law governing the attachment of property in the State of New York. It is, we believe, the only work of the kind giving the complete prac- The Green Bag. tice and forms in attachment down to date. The author seems to have done his work carefully and thoroughly, and New York lawyers will undoubtedly find the book of great assistance. A REVIEW IN Law AND Equity For Law STUDENTs. Together with a summary of the rules regulat- © ing admission to practice throughout the United States. By GrorGE E. GARDNER of the Massachusetts Bar. Baker, Voorhis & Co., New York, 1894. Half sheep. $2.75 mez. Students preparing for admission to the bar will find this work of especial value, as it contains a brief, simple statement of the leading principles of both: law and equity. One has only to master its contents to be fully equipped for any examination to which he may be subjected. Some of the subjects treated in the book, which embraces an entire course of law studies, are the following: The Feudal System, English Tenures, Real Property, Personal Property, Contracts, Quasi-Contracts, Evidence, Equity, Plead- ing, Torts, Bills and Notes, Agency, Bailments, Corporations, Criminal Law, Domestic Relations, Wills, Devises, Legacies, Partnerships, Sales, etc., etc. GENERAL DicEst of the Principal Courts in the United States, England and Canada. Refers to all reports official and unofficial, first pub- lished during the year ending September, 1894. ANNUAL, being VoL. IX of the series. Lawyers Co-operative Publishing Co., Roches- ter, N.Y. | This Digest thoroughly covers the case law for the year ending September, 1894, and even outdoes its only competitor in the number of its references. It is essentially what its name implies, a General Digest, in which the matter is well arranged and classified, and is, besides, apparently reliable and accurate. The publishers deserve a good word for the evident pains they have taken to make the work complete in every respect. Books RECEIVED. A System or LEGAL MEpIcINE. By Allan McLane Hamilton, M.D., and Lawrence Godkin. ‘Two vols. E.B. Treat, New York. COMMENTARIES ON THE LAW OF INJUNCTIONS. By Chas. Fisk Beach, Jr. ‘Two vols. H. B. Par- sons, Albany, N.Y. RECOLLECTIONS OF SIXTEEN PRESIDENTS. | By Richard W. Thompson. ‘Two vols. ‘The Bowen Merrill Co., Indianapolis.