The Green Bag: An Entertaining Magazine for Lawyers (January, 1895)

Page 1

—_ + VoL. VII. No. 1. BOSTON. aoe oarecn. Hag. JANUARY, 1895. EE ee CHARLES O’CONOR. HARLES O’CONOR was born in the city of New York, January 22, 1804. The Encyclopedia Britannica and Apple- ton’s Dictionary of Biography state that his father emigrated from Ireland in 1801, but in Mr. Bigelow’s interesting sketch in the Century Magazine (1884-1885, p. 725), he records that Mr. O’Conor resented the imputation that he was an Irishman, and told him, as Mr. Bigelow thinks, that his father and his grandfather were born in this coun- try. It would seem that Mr. Bigelow must have misunderstood Mr. O’Conor on this . point. Appleton’s Dictionary states that Mr. O’Conor’s father was born in Dublin, in 1770. To Mr. Coudert he spoke of himself as the son of an Irish exile, as will be seen later. It has always been popularly under- stood that Mr. O’Conor was proud of his de- scent from the Irish kings, as nearly all the Irish are. Undoubtedly he did not intend to deny that he was of Irish descent. It is re- corded that he changed the spelling of his name by dropping an , to conform it to the ancient style. His father’s later years were passed in lit- erary and editorial work. Among other things he wrote a work entitled “The In- quisition examined by an Impartial Observ- er,’ of the character of which I have no knowledge, but in which, if one may infer anything from his celebrated son’s peculiar characteristics, one may reasonably suppose that he whitewashed that somewhat obnoxi- ous institution. The dates and events of his life are few. He was admitted to the Bar in 1824; in 1855 - s By Irvinc BROWNE. he was appointed district attorney for New York; he once was a candidate for the office of lieutenant-governor of New York, and, although defeated, ran several thousands ahead of his ticket; in 1846 he was a mem- ber of the State Constitutional Convention, but he was not a member of the Convention of 1867-68, as is erroneously stated in the ‘‘ Britannica.” He practiced law in the city of New York until 1881, when he removed to Nantucket, where he died in 1884. He was married in 1854, but had no children. It is evident from this bare record that we have to consider the career of a mere lawyer, and not that of a statesman or a jurist; but it will be disclosed that we have to deal with an intellect of the first order, and an indomit- able, combative, and imperious nature. He was one of the most remarkable of self- made men. He owed everything to himself. He told Mr. Bigelow that “he hardly had any education.” All that he got he wrested from Fortune by the strong hand and the tireless brain. He came up to the very front of the legal profession in this country from obscurity and through poverty and dreadful discouragements. His tale of his early life to Mr. Bigelow is extremely touch- ing. To Mr. Bigelow he denied that he thought he possessed any peculiar aptitude for the law, but had no doubt that he would have met the same measure of success in any walk —as blacksmith, physician, or in any other calling. He attributed all to in- dustry. This alone shows that Mr. O’Conor, although a proud, opinionated and imperious man, was not unduly vain. He would not I

Page 2

- ae The Green Bag. add, but others will, that his industry was effectively aided by a rugged honesty and the keenest sense of gratitude for early bene- factions which came to him by reason of his apparent trustworthiness. From his ob- scure and struggling youth to his rich and honored old age, among all the harsh traits of his character, and the unpleasant incidents of his career which it is the duty ofan impartial biographer to chronicle, let it be recorded to his credit, that he never forgot a friend nor a favor, never turned a deaf ear to the appeal of distress or struggling merit, never used his tremendous powers against any but the powerful, and never blazoned forth his own good deeds. His somewhat rugged, austere and reserved character was adorned by an unswerving fidelity and an open-handed gen- erosity to the struggling and unfortunate. There probably never went into a court room, in this country or any other, a better “all-round lawyer” than Charles O’Conor. In the preparation and management of a case, in the examination of witnesses, in tact, in fertility of resources, in courage, in compo- sure, and in the conduct of the appeals, he could not be surpassed. In the highest at- tributes of eloquence he was lacking, although his style was elegant, his elocution was ani- mated and graceful, and his arguments were manly and cogent. He superintended the smallest details and foresaw the most remote possibilities, but he lacked just the one spark that inflames the hearts of hearers. As Na- poleon, on setting out for Moscow, before- hand looked after every harness-buckle and wagon load of provender, as well as ap- pointed every halting and meeting place of his half million men, so that everything should proceed with the precision of the heavenly bodies, yet failed for once because he did not sufficiently take into account the cold, so Mr. O’Conor, with a mental grasp of small things and large very unusual and almost unparalleled, found the only obstacle to the successes which genius alone achieves in the coldness of his nature. He was truly \ a learned lawyer —a learned lawyer in the proper sense of the term, so that in Mr. Carter’s words, “He could have stepped into Westminster Hall and argued a special demurrer with success against Sergeant Williams.” So Mr. Evarts generously said, he ‘‘was in my judgment and to my per- ception, the most accomplished lawyer in the learning of the profession, of our Bar. Indeed I cannot be mistaken in saying that he was entitled to pre-eminence in this pro- vince of learning among his contemporaries in this country, and among the most learned of the lawyers of any country, under our system of jurisprudence.” And so John K. Porter ranked him with Alexander Hamilton and Nicholas Hill, calling them the three greatest lawyers this country has produced. He was not distinguished as a constitutional lawyer, because he argued comparatively few constitutional questions; but with all his powers it may be doubted whether he could have held his own against Webster or Evarts in their magnificent exhibitions, any more than he could have maintained himself against Choate’s inspired and humane elo- quence in the Dalton divorce case. He pos- sessed the largest measure of talents, but stopped just short of the divine endowment of genius. He ranks with Scarlett and Ben- jamin, not with Erskine, Webster and Choate. It may be doubted whether his judgment was equal to his other endowmentss He sometimes made and persisted in serious blunders, which a man of less strength would have avoided or abandoned, thinking to carry his point by the force of his intel- lect and his reputation. But comparisons are deceptive and odious. He was unique in his sphere — “ teres et rotundus.” It would be a tedious task to enumerate celebrated or important cases in which Mr. O’Conor was engaged. It may be said, without exaggeration, that he was in every one of the most important cases in the New York courts of the period of thirty years ago. He was the leading counsel in the Parrish,

Page 3

+ a a is

Page 4

Page 5

Charles O’Conor. : 3 Lispenard, and Jumel will cases, and as- sociated in the Mason will case. He was one of the principal counsel in the North American Trust and Banking cases, which present themselves in many phases in the New York reports. He was counsel for Mr. Tilden before the Electoral Commission. In the famous Almaden mine case, in the United States Supreme Court, he charged his largest fee, $50,000. This was when gold was at a premium of 250, and his clients sent him a check payable in gold for his bill, as they well might, for the pecuniary interests involved were enormous. Mr. James C. Carter, once his partner, informs me: “A case which I think he wanted very much to try and argue, but which never came on for trial, as you know, was the case of the in- dictment of Jefferson Davis for treason. The Mason ‘will case was another of the great will cases occurring thirty years ago, which I well remember, and I have a strong impres- sion that he was engaged in that case. In the cases arising out of the Schuyler frauds —the fraudulent issue of stock of the N.Y. and New Haven Railroad, he was also en- gaged, at least, in the last of them, in which he induced the Court of Appeals to some- what withdraw from their prior decisions, and hold that a bona-fide holder of over- issued stock had a claim.” Mr. O’Conor left by will to the New York Law Institute two silver vases hereinafter more particularly mentioned, the sum of $20,000, and a scarcely less valuable gift, eighty bound volumes of his cases and arguments, which are pre- served in the library of the Institute. A ref- erence to these will convince any one that considering the number, variety, and import- ance of his causes and the success which he attained, his career is unparalleled in Amer- ican advocacy. A good example of Mr. O’Conor’s learn- ing, mental force and literary style is his argument before the Court of Claims, at Washington, in the case of the Brig-of-war General Armstrong, involving a grave ques- we tion .of international law and the right of the citizen to redress against his own govern- ment. This is to be found, very intelligently reported, in Mr. Wm. L. Snyder’s excellent compilation, ‘Great Speeches of Great Lawyers.” | THE FORREST CASE. The cause in which Mr. O’Conor ac- quired most of his contemporary popular fame was the celebrated action of Mrs. Forrest against her husband, Edwin Forrest, the actor, for absolute divorce. This cause lasted a great many years, and in various phases went repeatedly through all the courts. It was defended with great persistence and skill by James T. Brady, a foeman in every . way capable of testing Mr. O’Conor’s mettle. For once at least the latter met his match, not only in the lawyer, but in the party, for Forrest himself was as resolute and pugna- cious as the great lawyer himself, and fought the battle to the last ditch with an animosity and recklessness of expense unparalleled at that time in the history of our courts. After Mrs. Forrest obtained her decree, years were spent in contesting the question of alimony, and Forrest, like his favorite dramatic hero, did not yield until every horse in the stables had been killed under him, and he brandished his arms after they had been deprived of his sword. In this case Mr. O’Conor evinced the finest qualities of the advocate and of ad- vocacy. He had however the popular side from the start, for he championed a wronged woman, and the defendant was a very un- pleasant and unloved character. Out of this case eventually sprang a very exciting scandal touching Mr. O’Conor’s conduct. The impression early went abroad, somehow, that he was to serve Mrs. Forrest gratui- tously, and hence he was lauded and wor- shipped by all the women in the States, and by all the ministers of the gospel, and by many of the men, for his ‘ disinterested- ness.” There never was any foundation

Page 6

4 The Green Bag. whatever for the impression, and it does not appear at the last that even his client so understood it. But it seems that ‘she was disappointed in the amount of his bill.” Every lawyer knows that this is the invari- able feeling of the woman-client in any case. Women regard it as unmanly to compel them to yield their lawyer much if anything, even if it is got out of their husbands. Mr. O’Conor had waged a long and costly fight and had scored a great success. He ob- tained a very large allowance of alimony for Mrs. Forrest, — some $64,000. He charged her, as I have always understood, some $40,000, which, however, included a considerable outlay for the unavoidable expenses, and a large amount of loans to his client. No lawyer will say that this was excessive, even if it included no loans, especially as every cent of it was wrung from Forrest; but on the other hand no lawyer will pretend that his conduct was “ disin- terested.”” He was not “ disinterested.” He was serving for pay, and he was no more “disinterested” than Brady on the other side. Nor will any lawyer nowadays pretend that he deserves any special credit for those efforts. He simply did his duty like an intrepid, conscientious and _ skillful advocate; he amply deserved compensa- tion,— and he got it. But that was not the way his worshippers felt about it at the time. Thirty ladies voted him one silver vase, and sixty lawyers another, for his “disinterested” service, in 1852, and Mr. O’Conor accepted them; at a later day, in 1876, this foolish piece of emotion rebounded against Mr. O’Conor. He had been severely criticised in the newspapers for having taken pay when it was “understood ” that he was not to have any. This accusation led him at the time to demand an investi- gation of his conduct, by the New York City Bar Association, in compliance with which a committee was appointed to hear and determine, but inasmuch as nobody appeared to make any charges, the deter- mination could only result in his complete and undoubtedly deserved’ exculpation. The entire matter was purely one of business. Mr. O’Conor charged his client interest on his advances and outlay, as he should have done. Perhaps, in 1852, he could not eracefully refuse the vase, but he did not deserve it and should have given no assent, even by silence, to the idea of ‘ disinterested- ness.” If he deserved a testimonial, Brady deserved one still more, for he advocated the unpopular side, and fought a losing battle from the outset. As to Mrs. Forrest, her notion seemed to be that having ac- cepted the vase for being ‘ disinterested,” Mr. O’Conor ought not to have asked any, or at all events so much compensation for being interested. In this view -the vase would have been indeed an empty honor. . Probably in accepting the honor Mr. O’Conor did not for a moment dream that its donors or anybody supposed that he did not intend to be fairly paid for his services, and if he had so supposed he would have refused, but his language was a little unguarded and ambiguous. In the following paragraphs are given some contemporary details of this curious affair, embodied in articles in the “ Albany Law Journal,” some of which were evidently © written by myself. I have not changed my mind about the merits of the matter, al- though if it were to be written now I might express myself with a smaller degree of vehemence and satire :— ‘The article which recently appeared in the New York Zimes, relating to Charles O’Conor’s connection with the well-known Forrest divorce case, has called forth an elaborate defense on the part of Mr. O’Conor, and a demand by him for an investigation of his conduct by the New York Bar Association. ‘The article in question stated, on the apparent authority of Mrs. Forrest, that it was understood when the divorce suit was begun that nothing should be charged for counsel fees; but that of the final judgment of $64,000 in the case, for arrears of alimony, Mr. O’Conor

Page 7

Charles took $40,000, and the Attorney, Mr. Chase, $19,000, thus leaving her but $5,000. Mrs. Forrest states that in Mr. O’Conor’s bill there were some charges for loans made to her; and while expressing her gratitude for his services, she says that she was entirely surprised at the course which he took in making his charges for professional services. In this connection the article in the ‘ Times’ states that it was understood by the public during the pendency of the Forrest case that Mr. O’Conor’s services were gratuitous ; and that for this act he received great credit and honor. Some of the most estimable ladies of New York, and many members of the Bar, expressed’ their admiration for his unselfish course by presenting him with testimonials. “Mr. O’Conor’s reply to the article relating to his connection with the Forrest case is marked with the usual forcible and dramatic style of its author. So far as we have examined his defense, he denies that he agreed to serve in the Forrest case gratuitously, or that he supposed the public or Mrs. Forrest thought he was so doing. He admits the bill of nearly $40,000, but states that the greater part was for sums loaned Mrs. Forrest when she was in need, and for expenses incurred for her. He claims that he was exceedingly generous to her, and to her friends. Much of Mr. O’Conor’s defense is taken up with matters of very remote relevancy to the real issue. A committee of investigation was appointed by the Bar Association, consisting of Judge Bosworth, Judge Mitchell, John E. Parsons, Joseph H. Choate, Benjamin D. Silliman, and William M. Evarts. This committee will undoubtedly do ample justice to Mr. O’Conor’s case. If the charges are substantiated, Mr. O’Conor has already indicated what the penalty should be. He says: ‘If I am guilty of what is charged... I ought to be expelled from membership in your Association, and from the Bar itself, as a disgrace to both.’” — Vol. 13, p. 259. “The Committee of the Bar Association ap- pointed to investigate the charges against Charles O’Conor, reported on Tuesday evening, that there were no matters before them to consider except what Mr. O’Conor himself had presented, and no accusers, and they did not advise the constitution of any tribunal for the purposes of investigation. ‘The report of this committee was a O’Conor. | 5 objected to quite vehemently by Mr. O’Conor. He demanded the fullest investigation, and said that he thought it was for the interest of the profession that the matter should be thoroughly looked into. The report of the committee recommended that Mrs. Forrest be invited to make a communication on the subject to the Bar Association. Mr. O’Conor objected to having the Association call upon Mrs. Forrest to bring charges against him. He said that his con- troversy was with the newspapers which had printed the charges. After much discussion which, as far as we can learn, was largely con- fined to Mr. O’Conor himself, a resolution was passed by the Bar Association whereby a new Committee was appointed to ‘investigate the charges referred to in Mr. O’Conor’s statement, and to invite the accusers before them.’ “ Lawyers are notoriously inexact and careless in keeping their own accounts. Mr. O’Conor seems to be an exception, or possibly he has had the assistance of an extremely mathematical managing clerk. We find in his account against Mrs. Forrest that he charges the lady with $2.86 for several years’ interest on $7 paid for a copy of an opinion; and with $1.02 interest on $4.41 for “cash, postages, etc.” ; and with $1.45 in- terest for one month on $250 paid for counsel ; and with twenty cents interest on $7.50 paid for printing points! After this exhibition of thrift and exactness, how can Mr. O’Conor claim to have been ‘ disinterested’ in his conduct of Mrs. Forrest’s case? But who would have suspected such shop-keeping care in the descendant of the Irish Kings ? “No onedenies Mr. O’Conor’s right to demand pay in the Forrest case. The question is, did he sanction the belief, which undoubtedly obtained, that he was working gratuitously? Mr. O’Conor claimed at the time to have been acting ‘ dis- interestedly,’ and on account of this ‘ disin- terestedness’ allowed himself to be presented with a silver vase from thirty ladies of New York, and with a silver pitcher from his profes- sional brethren. The thirty ladies in the pre- sentation letter spoke of his ‘noble conduct,’ his ‘generous espousal’ of his client’s cause, and his ‘chivalrous defense’ of the weak. It is apparent that the writers supposed that Mr. O’Conor had been working gratuitously. This

Page 8

6 The Green Bag. was in 1852. What said Mr. O’Conor in reply? Did he undeceive the thirty confiding ladies? Oh, no. He took the vase, and wrote a letter. In the letter he modestly insisted that any of his ‘peers at the Bar would have assumed the office and deemed it, as:I did, @ d00n rather than a burthen. Of the result he says, it ‘was ample reward for whatever of labor devolved upon me, yet I most gratefully accept the unhoped for addition now so delicately tendered.’ In the presentation address accompanying the silver pitcher, Mr. Lord said Mr. O’Conor had ‘ ful- filled with success that office of the profession which allies it to chivalry,’ and alluded to his ‘disinterestedness.’ What did Mr. O’Conor say to this? Did this Bayard confess that he was a mere mercenary, and protest that he expected to be paid for tilting his chivalric lance at the vociferous Mr. Forrest? Oh, no. He took the pitcher, also, bearing the arms of his royal Irish ancestors, and inscribed with their motto, ‘ From God cometh the succoring cham- pion,’ and bearing a further inscription attesting his ‘zeal, adisinterestedness, etc.’ And then he beautifully observed: ‘The Bar has ever de- voted itself with courage and disinterestedness to the defense of the feeble and oppressed. It was my good fortune to be selected on an exciting occasion fo exemplify the fact, and my whole merit consists in this: “hat J did not fail in a duty which the first rule of our profession rigidly exacts from all tts members. Will this exact, severe, and rigid gentleman, this royal Milesian Cato, who has arraigned the Court of Appeals of this State for corruption, now proffer some parol evidence in explanation of these writings? We would suggest. a letter to Judge Davis, or an extra edition of ‘ Harper’s Weekly’ prepared by Mr. Albert G. Browne, Jr. We await the ex- planation in breathless suspense.”’ — Vo/. 13, 279. “The Committee appointed by the New York Bar Association to arrange a tribunal to hear and determine the charges against Charles O’Conor have succeeded in getting a number of excellent men to serve upon the tribunal. The tribunal will consist of John A. Dix, Wilson G. Hunt, William Adams, D.D., Howard Potter, and John K. Porter. There is an admirable combination of characteristics in this tribunal. The com- mittee of selection say that they have been solicitous ‘to provide a court, whose intelligence and impartiality shall be above suspicion, and whose judgment, whatever it may be, can be | accepted as final.’ The members of the tribu- . nal have accepted the duties imposed upon them, and a preliminary meeting has been held.” — Vol. 13, p. 299. | “ The tribunal appointed to consider the charges against Charles O’Conor’s professional conduct while acting as counsel for Mrs. Forrest, had a hearing of the case on Saturday last, and no one appeared to substantiate the charges against Mr. O’Conor. Mr. Sedley, the near relative of Mrs. Forrest, said he would not present his version of the affair to a tribunal chosen entirely by Mr. O’Conor’s friends. Mrs. Forrest had written a letter to Mr. O’Conor, which was read. This letter expressed regrets that her statements had been printed in the newspapers, and reiterated the fact that she was grateful to Mr. O’Conor, although she was disappointed at the size of his bill. Chief Justice Daly, who made the pre- sentation of the silver vase in behalf of the ladies, testified that during the whole trial he had the impression that Mr. O’Conor was to receive a fee. ‘This is the main point in the case, and if it is established that no deception was practiced upon the public by Mr. O’Conor, then he will, of course, be honorably acquitted.’ — Vol. 13, p. 319. “The exoneration of Charles O’Conor by the tribunal appointed to consider the charges against him in the Forrest divorce case was foreshadowed by the reports which reached us last week. On Wednesday evening the “Bar Association of New York city accepted the report of the special committee in the O’Conor case, and of the tribunal. The tribunal finds: 1. That there is no evidence that Mr. O’Conor became counsel of Mrs. Forrest with an under- standing that his services were to be gratuitous. 2. That the testimony of Judge Charles P. Daly, who presented the silver vase for the ladies, shows that the presentation was not made with the impression that Mr. O’Conor’s services were gratuitous. 3. That Mr. O’Conor did not make exorbitant charges for his services. The committee who arranged the tribunal of in- vestigation close their report with the following eulogium: ‘Through many years the name of Charles O’Conor has been known to our com-

Page 9

Charles munity, and the whole country as synonymous with eminent ability and spotless purity. Sucha reputation could not be marred without injury to the profession he so long adorned and pain to his countrymen. But conscious of his integrity and sensitive to the slightest imputation upon it, he persevered, even against the judgment of wise professional brethren who loved and honored him, in demanding investigation of the charges referred to. And now five of our fellow-citizens, eminent for wisdom and goodness, have fully heard the evidence, and have unanimously pro- nounced the charges without foundation.’ ”’ — Vo/. 13, P- 392. THE TWEED CASES. So much for the disagreeable contact into which Mr. O’Conor came with his former worshipers among the laity. Now let us speak of a matter in which he came into equally unpleasant relations with the courts and many of the Bar. This was in the prosecutions growing out of the cele- brated Tweed scandals in the city of New York. It is unnecessary to tell any middle- aged lawyer who Tweed was, but it may be well to explain to the legal youth of this day that he was a person who, under the pe- culiar possibilities of this favored land, arose from the degree of stone-mason to be the “boss” of the city and State of New York, and who plundered the city of untold millions for the benefit of himself and his creatures, but who, after some years of abject fear and helplessness on the part of the public, was prosecuted, convicted, sen- tenced to prison for a long term, escaped by connivance, fled the country, was brought back, and died pending a new trial. Mr. O’Conor, being at the head of the bureau of municipal correction, charged with the pros- ecution at law of the so-called Ring-thieves in the city of New York, was directed to prosecute Tweed for a great number of misdemeanors of which he had been guilty in his bandit career. They were all joined in one indictment in 226 counts, and there was a verdict of guilty on 204. Thereupon - Democratic school. O’Conor. 7 Judge Noah Davis, who presided at the trial, sentenced him to imprisonment for twelve years for twelve offenses, and to a fine of $250 in each; and on the other counts to fines aggregating $12,500. The maxi- mum allowed for one offense was one year’s imprisonment and a fine of $250. Appeal was taken to the Court of Appeals, and in the famous case of People ex. rel. Tweed v. Liscomb, 60 N.Y. 559; s.c.19 Am. Rep. 211, the court unanimously laid down the doc- trine, that in such a case. sentence may not pass fora longer term than the maximum pre- scribed for a single offense. The opinions were written by Judges Allen and Rapallo, both Democrats, and were concurred in by the five other judges, of whom two were Re- publicans. Hereupon arose a terrific clamor of the populace and the newspapers. The decision was stigmatized as a stretch of political mercy towards an offender of the In the course of his opinion, Judge Allen rather mischievously cited as authority against the doctrine of cumulative sentences, some expressions of Mr. O’Conor himself, in his brief in a former case in that court, a civil action against a railroad company to recover 526 penalties for as many different offenses in taking excessive fare. Mr. O’Conor there argued, as counsel for the defendant, that only one penalty was recoverable, and cited the law applicable to indictments as analogous. He said: ‘And accordingly, except under some statute, expressly authorizing such a course, it has not been the practice to allow the two distinct offenses to be tried at the same time either by indictment or penal action.” Judge Allen quoted this, with other and even stronger language of the “eminent jurist” with approval, and ob- served, “his arguments appear to me un- answerable.” This commending of the chalice to his own lips, or hoisting the engineer with his own petard, did not tend to soothe Mr. O’Conor’s spirit, perturbed by the signal defeat; and so, when Judge

Page 10

8 The Green Bag. Davis, also smarting, wrote him a letter drawing him out, he suffered himself to be drawn out to the length of two columns and a half in the “New York Tribune,” in a letter roundly abusing the court and imput- ing improper motives to them, which I char- acterized at the time as ‘vindictive and indecent allusions”: )(12 Albany Law Journal, 53). This started the ball, and then ensued a most ferocious and disgraceful attack on the court by disgruntled Judge Davis and others, embracing some news- papers which ought to have known better, including ‘“‘ Harper’s Weekly,” which hired (I assume he did not do it gratuitously) Albert G. Browne, once reporter of the Massachusetts Supreme Court, to vilify the court in that otherwise respectable journal, to the extent of six and a half pages! (See “Mr. Browne wipes out the Court of Appeals,” 12 Albany Law Journal, 308.) After all these years, I see no reason to 1 These are quoted in the following, from 12 Albany Law Journal, 57: — ‘Mr. O’Conor writes, that ‘ when dealing with peculators, the Court of Appeals have been ‘ admirably astute’ in the’ and that Mr. | same uniform direction of impunity ’ ; Tweed, ‘by using the courage of a Rinaldo, has, either in his own person or through a representative, ¢rice bearded public justice in that high tribunal and has, on each occasion, received its award that as against him or his the weapons devised by the people’s advocates were vain and hurtless.’ ** As a remedy in the future for this state of affairs, Mr. O’Conor does not advise more care in the preparation of their cases by the ‘ thick-witted advocates for the people’ ; but animated with the spirit of a crusader, he invokes ‘from the suffering class @ determined resistance to the power by which they are enthralled, and an inflexible resolve to reform existing abuses,’ “Mr. O’Conor then proceeds to account for this fearful state of affairs. He writes: ‘Because the local judges had, in most instances, received their offices through Tweed and his associates, the lawyers, who were charged with the duty of prosecuting for the public, anticipated difficulty in the earlier stages of the suits; but they had no suspicion that ke agencies hud influenced the construction of the highest court. They felt assured that in all cases against the robbers, whatever might happen elsewhere, the judg- ment of that tribunal would not merely be in accordance with law, but that in pronouncing it the judges would be animated by an earnest love of justice and an active zeal for wits advancement.” He regrets that his assurances in this regard have not been realized.” modify what was written at the time: “Mr. O’Conor was wrong in this” — namely, his assertion that under the decision of the Court of Appeals, Judge Davis was liable to an action by Tweed for false imprisonment — ‘just as he has been in everything else connected with the case, except his original declaration in the Fisher case, that cumula- tive sentences are illegal.” (12 Albany Law Journal, p. 81). ‘After all, this crusade of Mr. O’Conor is a very ridiculous display. If any other lawyer in the state had been guilty of it, he would have been treated with no consideration whatever. Judge Davis would have committed him. But Mr... O’Conor has a high and commanding posi- tion at the Bar, and so believes himself in- fallible.” “The palpable object of the letters has, and we confess to our surprise, most signally failed. The newspapers have, with scarcely an exception, denounced both their motive and spirit, and have censured Mr. O’Conor and Judge Davis in unstinted terms. But the fact has been very generally recognized that the latter deserved the greater condemnation, not only because of his position, but because it was so apparent that he was the instigator of the whole affair” (12 Albany Law Journal, p. 49). In the course of the same litigations, Mr. O’Conor again disapproved of the Court of - Appeals. This was in what is known as the ‘“ six-million-dollars suit,” brought undér a statute specially enacted in 1875, to enable the city and county to recover the spoils from the receivers. Fearing that, if prose- cuted in the name of the city and county, the action would not be effectively pressed, Mr. O’Conor caused it to be brought in the name of the people of the State. Mr. George Ticknor Curtis at the time having pointed out that this was erroneous, Mr. O’Conor replied in a letter, in terms ‘‘ more pointed than polite,” maintaining the regu- larity of his course. The Court of Appeals, however, in People v. Ingersoll, 58 N.Y. 1; S.C. 17 Am. Rep. 198, disagreed with him,

Page 11

Charles O’Conor. 9 holding (Chief Judge Church and Rapallo, J., dissenting), that the State could not ‘maintain the action because it had no title to the moneys. For this Mr. O’Conor al- lowed himself severely to reprimand the Court in an interview with a “Herald” re- porter. On this occasion the “ Albany Law Journal” observed: ‘‘We fear that ripe age and distinguished ability have not improved Mr. O’Conor’s discretion.” (That was not written by the present writer. ) _Mr. O’Conor, in 1875, published the various arguments and opinions in the ‘‘six- millions suits” in a volume entitled ‘‘ Pecu- lation Triumphant, being the record of a four years’ campaign against official mal- versation in the city of New York, A.D. 1871 to 1875,’ with a ‘ Memorandum” containing no offensive comments, but thus patting on the back the dissenting judges: ‘“Qur ancestral jurisprudencies denied to us by a lean majority of one, over-ruling Church, our universally reverenced Chief Judge, Ra- pallo, the chosen representative of our great metropolis, and Miller, the most recent recipi- ent of our people’s favor.” The Chief and Judge Rapallo seem to have risen in his favor since the ‘“‘ cumulative sentences” decision! In 1875, an act was passed, giving to the people of the State instead of the city the right to sue, and a recovery was finally had, under the leadership of Mr. Wheeler H. Peckham. But owing to the delay caused by Mr. O’Conor’s blunder, the ill-gotten wealth of the defendants had been dissipated by the time a recovery was had, and the city realized nothing, as I am informed. It is probable that there was not at the time and has never since been any considerable difference of opinion among the lawyers and judges of this State as to the soundness of the doctrine declared by the Court, in either case, nor as to the grave impropriety of Mr. O’Conor’s conduct in the matter. He subsequently, in a Christian spirit, for- gave the Court for his abuse of them, and invited them to dinner in New York. The o- Chief Judge, I believe, accepted, but some of them would not go. It is a mark of Mr. O’Conor’s sense of justice— although not a broad sense—that he attributed all the merit of the dethrone- ment of Tweed to Samuel J. Tilden, as we learn from Mr. Bigelow’s sketch. MR. O’CONOR’S WILL. It is really fortunate that Mr. O’Conor. was not in a position to comment on the audacity of the courts in even entertaining an argu- ment against the validity of his will! His old enemy, the Court of Appeals, — although but two- of the judges whom he had cen- sured and impugned were left in it, in Sloan v. Stevens, 107 N.Y. 122, were called on to construe a codicil to his will. The official syllabus is as follows : — “The will of O’C. contained various devises and bequests to different parties, and also this clause : ‘I hereby release all claims or demands which I may have at my death against any person or persons named in this will.’ At the time of the execution of the will, the testator was con- ducting, as counsel, a litigation for defendant ; the latter was not named in the will. At the close of the will, the testator revoked all former ‘wills and codicils.’ By a codicil, subsequently executed, which the testator described therein as the ‘first codicil to his last will,’ he released three persons named from all claims against them. ‘Two of these were named in the will; one was not. Immediately following this was a provision giving to defendant, whom he described as his ‘faithful and honorable friend,’ all books, papers, etc., relating to the claim in litigation. In an action to recover for legal services ren- dered by the testator in said litigation he//, that defendant was not released from liability by the said provision of the will.” Judge Finch, in the opinion, concedes the general rule that the will includes the codicil, the two constitute one act, and the execution of the codicil is a republication of the will as of that date, ‘and the two instruments are to be read together as if their provisions had all been embodied in

Page 12

IO one, then for the first time executed,” and conceded ‘that the testator thoroughly knew the rule and appreciated its force,” citing Van Cortlandt v. Kip, 1 Hill, 590, in which, it seems (although the Court did not allude to it), Mr. O’Conor himself had contended for that doctrine! But the great lawyer did not suffer from the citation of his own contention as in the Tweed case, for the court steered him out of the diffi- culty by applying the rule that the testator’s clear intention to the contrary of the usual inference must prevail. In effect they held that in the light of the circumstances it would be absurd to suppose that Mr. O’Conor meant what he had said! It is noteworthy that Judge Rapallo, who wrote - a concurring opinion in the Tweed case, did not vote in this case. CODIFICATION. It is amusing to read the following in Mr. Bigelow’s paper: “ He said that as far as he knew, he as much as any one was entitled to the credit of originating the reform of our system of procedure in-1847— 8, the abolition of forms of action, and the abolition of the Court of Chancery. He said he made the plea for those reforms in the Constitutional Convention of 1846. He would on no account, he said, claim for him- self, or have anyone claim for him the credit of these, but he was quite willing to be instru- mental in defeating the pretentions of any other person to their authorship. ‘The line of remark had been suggested by the news then just received that Governor Cornell had ve- toed the Field-Throop Civil Code’— an act on the governor’s part with which he repeat- 1 There is an inaccuracy here: there never was any such thing as “the Field-Throop Code.” The implication that Mr. Field ever collaborated with Mr. Throop would plant a thorn in Mr. Field’s pillow and cause the ample ghost of Mr. Throop to wander at night, like Hamlet’s, in search of an avenger. What Governor Robinson vetoed, was Mr. Throop’s code of civil procedure (with which Mr. Field had nothing to do), and Mr. Field’s three codes — the penal code, the code of criminal procedure, and the civil (gener- al) code. It was this fell swoop that caused such “sat- isfaction’”’ to that ardent “reformer,” Mr. O’Conor! The Green Bag. edly expressed the greatest satisfaction. Recurring to this subject of codification later, he said he doubted whether our civil law could be codified successfully; he in- clined to think it could not,’ and proceeded to place his doubts upon grounds substan- tially the same as those which have been more recently set forth in Mr. James C. Carter’s exhaustive and masterly discussion of that subject.” To set up Mr. O’Conor, or for him to set himself up as the originator, or even as a champion of our practice codifica- tion, is ridiculous. Old lawyers will not have forgotten his celebrated letter on code plead- ing, and his avowal of his utter inability to “state the facts” in any case, and his fling at ‘the pleadings which come from the office of the chief codifier himself.” But even according to Mr. O’Conor, as stated in Mr. Bigelow’s paper, the old system of pleading was at least as bad as the new, for he said ‘‘ he never knew a case in which the parties had been pleading for an issue a year that he could not find a defect of sufficient gravity to set their proceedings aside.” In that letter Mr. O’Conor bewailed the new system because ‘‘a demurrer to any plead- ing under the Code is a very dangerous step,’ and ‘‘there are no precedents which would be of use to one beginning to draw pleadings under the Code.” It is difficult to imagine the state of mind of a lawyer who approved a system of pleading in which it was not “ dangerous to demur.” But Mr. O’Conor prided himself on his skill in plead- ing. Mr. Carter assures us: ‘ His pleadings were beautiful examples of art, and in his ‘Mr. Bigelow informs us that John C. Spencer once proposed to him that he join him and Benjamin F. Butler in preparing a code of the common law, but facing the probability that “they would conclude that the fruits of their labor would not be worth reporting to the Legisla- ture,” they abandoned the idea. They were too modest. 2 Whether to indicate his approval or his disapproval of the old system, or his opinion of his own skill, does not clearly appear, but he told Mr. Bigelow that “he never knew a case in which the parties had been pleading for an issue a year, that he could not find a defect of suf- | ficient gravity to set the proceedings aside.”

Page 13

Charles O’Conor. 5 II later years, when he had more leisure, to draw a bill in equity or an answer was a genuine delight to him.” (The italics are mine.) What a pity to have all this spoiled by the compulsion to ‘state the facts” ! It is true that Mr. O’Conor, in the Consti- tutional Convention of 1846, favored the blending of law and equity in one form of procedure, but this was the only point on which he was in harmony with the reformers, and this was not original with him. (See the letter of Hon. David Dudley Field, in the foot note.) 7« Two great measures of legal reform have been undertaken in New York, one the reform of procedure, the other the codification of the Common Law. In re- spect of the latter, 1 have never heard that Mr. O’Conor advocated or approved such a codification. ‘In respect of the former, all that he ever did, so far as I know, was to advocate, together with several other members, on two occasions, the blending of law and equity in one form of procedure. The only proposition he made was to offer the following as one of the judiciary sections: ‘A code of procedure in civil suits shall be established within two years, subject to alteration by law. The Supreme Court, subject to control by law, shall establish uniform rules of practice for all civil courts in this State, except the Court of Appeals.’ His speech on that occasion contained among other things the following, which may be taken as his most pointed utterance on the subject : — *,... The Convention had been informed by the chair- man that the committee had determined by a considerable majority to bring together the administration of what was called law and equity and to direct justice in these two forms to be administered in the same courts, acting, as the chairman informs us, in some measure under the idea that at some period these two forms or methods of administer- ing civil justice might be perfectly blended, so that there should no longer be recognized or known such a distinc- tion as law and equity —a distinction which it must be admitted it would be highly desirable to abolish. He deemed it an evil that we should have recognized in the constitution by an express provision the truth of that saying which the unlearned in the metaphysics of law or legal practice are apt to indulge in when they find fault with a legal decision — to wit, that law is one thing and equity or good conscience is another. He thought there was no ground for the distinction, and that civil justice in all its forms and phases might be and ought to be adminis- tered in the same tribunals and in one uniform mode of procedure.’ — Argus Report, p. 378. “It thus appears, that these views had already been discussed in the Convention and so stated by Mr. Ruggles, chairman of the committee on the judiciary. Once after- wards, on the 1oth of August (p. 440), the question came up again, and Mr. O’Conor repeated the same views, and at the same meeting Mr. Stetson offered the following, page 444: — - “¢ And to the end that ultimately the jurisdiction of law and equity may not be separately administered, and that the two may be blended into one harmonious system, the legislature shall provide by law, as far as may -be, a common form of procedure for remedies arising under both jurisdictions.’ “See also pages 486 and 560 of the Argus Report of the Convention. In both instances his motion was de- feated, and I do not find that he returned to the subject. Finally he voted against the Constitution altogether (page 838). He seems to have given law reform the go-by ever afterwards. If he once lifted a finger to help it, the move- ment is unknown to me. The real authors of the two law- reforming provisions in the State constitution were Mr. Campbell P. White, a New York merchant (see pages 77, 82, 460, 642), and Mr. Levi S. Chatfield, a lawyer from Otsego, afterwards Attorney General (see page 643). Other members of the Convention held and advocated similar views, such men as Mr. Hoffman, Mr. Taggart, Mr. Nicole, Mr. Harris, Mr. Kirkland. ‘So much for the Convention of 1846, and Mr. O’Conor’s action therein. My part in law reform is partly explained in my article, published in the ‘ American Law Review’ for August, 1891, and afterwards separately pub- lished. But even this does not tell the whole story. From the time that I came to New York as a law student I have had hold of the subject, more or less. The idea of a code is older than Justinian. It is the taking it up and carrying it to a successful accomplishment that is the real task. ‘ Hic labor, hoc opus est.’ Long before the Con- vention of 1846, that is in 1842, I submitted a reforming scheme to the Legislature, which was the forerunner, if not the cause, of the movement in the Convention. “‘T went to O’Conor to get him to sign the memorial to the Legislature which begot the first code of civil procedure, after I had obtained the signature of Vice- Chancellor M’Coun, and Mr. O’Conor said coldly, ‘I suppose I must sign this.’ That I suspect was his last and only act in support of law-reform. This memorial was as follows : — “<‘To the Senate and Assembly of the State of New York: “¢The memorial of the undersigned, members of the Bar in the city of New York, respectfully represents that they look with great solicitude for the action of your honorable bodies in respect to the revision, reform, simpli- fication and abridgment of the rules and practice, plead- ings, forms, and proceedings of the courts of record. They are persuaded that a radical reform of legal procedure in all its departments is demanded by the interests of justice and by the voice of the people; that a uniform course of proceeding in all cases legal and equitable is entirely practicable, and no less expedient; and that a radical reform should aim at such uniformity, and at the abolition of all useless forms and proceedings. ‘‘¢ Your memorialists therefore pray your honorable bod- ies to declare, by the act appointing Commissioners, that it shall be their duty to provide for the abolition of the present forms of action and pleadings in cases at common law, for a uniform course of proceeding in all cases, whether of legal or equitable cognizance, and for the abandonment of every form or proceeding not necessary to ascertain or preserve the rights of the parties.’ ”’ Mr. Field also wrote, in a letter to the New York “ Evening Post,” in January, 1846, five months before the convening of the Convention, as follows : —

Page 14

12 “‘T have said little about the court of Chancery, not from insensibility to the magnitude of its abuses, but because a radical reform must first be made in the practice of the other courts. Until that happens, the court of chancery, bad as it is, is a necessary evil — its interposition is indispensable so long as the narrow and technical forms of the common law are suffered to continue. But when Lhe Green Bag. these forms are opened so as to admit of remedies as extensive as injuries, then the court of chancery will be- _ come unnecessary. ‘Till that this arrives, and / hope the first legislature under the new constitution will bring it, my plan allows the continued separation of legal and equitable remedies, to be administered either by the same or by different judges.” , NOTABLE AND CURIOUS CASES IN THE COURT OF CLAIMS. OLUMES could be written about the claims against the Government, which have been brought before the Court of Claims, the Court of Private Land Claims, or before Congress itself. Some of the pe- titions are evidently the work of cranks, others of ingenious rascals, while yet others are legitimate. It sometimes seems as if the last class were the least likely to gain satisfaction. Some of the just claims, I am pleased to say, belong to estates where heirs have not spent all their strength and substance in the prosecution, but who have been able to earn a competence for themselves. An instance of this is the somewhat peculiar claim of the Childs family in Philadelphia. It was in 1777 that the Continental Con- gress sent two spies to Montreal to report upon the preparations then being made by the British Government to subjugate her rebellious colonies. The men were ap- pointed by General Washington, and a Mr. George W. Childs was one of them. The men did their work to the satisfaction of the General, who gave them certificates to the effect that their wages were well earned. Whether his comrade fared better I do not know, but the compensation promised Mr. Childs was not paid by the Continental Con- gress, and his heirs petitioned the Fifty- second Congress for two million dollars, which they affirm to be the principal and interest due them. Another interesting claim is that of Rich- ard W. Meade, father of the hero of Gettys- burg. It seems that at the time when the United States purchased Florida, she agreed to assume all the claims which American citizens had against Spain. Among these claims was one for $373,879 which had been allowed by Spain to Mr. Meade, and which under the terms of the treaty should have been promptly settled. Mr. Meade, it seems, was unable to obtain from the Spanish Gov- ernment the proofs upon which his accounts had been settled with Spain, and without these the United States courts refused to act. The case has been before Congress nearly a score of times; dnd has been re- ported favorably nearly every time, but it | was never acted upon by both Houses of the same Congress. The original claimant died years ago, and if ever the heirs are able to get their claim through, they will be the richer by several millions of dollars. One of the most curious claims ever put into a Congressional bill was originally pre- sented by Mr. Weaver, who is now better known as a recent: Presidential candidate on the people’s party ticket. It was afterward reintroduced by Mr. Smith of Illinois. The bill proposed to pay to Federal soldiers the difference in value between the gold dollar and the depreciated currency in which they were paid during the war. This deprecia- tion ranged from twenty-five to two anda half cents on a dollar, and it was estimated that it would take about $500,000,000 to satisfy the terms of the bill. At present there is no limit to the number of times a claim may be presented to Con- gress. Every political change of adminis- tration is sure to bring back thousands of

Page 15

Notable and Curtous Cases in the Court of Claims. applicants whose petitions have been re- . jected by the outgoing power. I have said that some of these claimants are cranks. A citizen of the middle West has spent at least three times as much money in postage as he claims the Govern- ment owes him, in writing letters to the Treasury, to United States officials, and even to the Chinese and Korean legations. Nearly two million claims have been filed in the Treasury Department alone, and the way in which many of them are addressed is odd enough. It must have taken the “blind reader” of the post-office department ‘to make ‘second auditor” oratorio,” Tresur.” Saddest of all are the just claims which will probably never be satisfied, and whose inheritors have died in poverty. Major Joseph Wheaton is recorded as a gallant soldier in the Revolution who served throughout the war. During 1780-1783 Congress passed an act guaranteeing half pay for life to every officer who stayed in the service to the end of the fight for liberty. Major Wheaton never received a dollar of the money promised. Moreover, during the war of 1812, this gallant officer used thirty thousand dollars of his own money with which to purchase army supplies, at a time when the army must have perished without this aid. He was then acting as assistant quartermaster-general. This money, like- wise, was never refunded to him, although or out of ‘“sekun oder of the Congress doubtless intended that it should. be. Some time after the major’s death a bill for the relief of his daughter finally suc- ceeded in passing both Houses during the same session, but by a fatal error reference was made, not to the Treasury, but to the Interior Department, for payment, and I be- lieve the daughter died in poverty, although the undoubted heir to plenty. There are said to be more than fifteen thousand claims, acknowledged to be per- fectly just, dating from revolutionary times om out of ‘‘second | ‘prosecute their claims. oe to the last war, which cannot get a satisfac- tory settlement from Congress. One of the oldest is that of James Bell, a Canadian, who spent a fortune in building and fitting out three vessels for the Yankees during the Revolution. He was afterward arrested for treason, his unspent property confiscated, and his life spared only through the clemency of the English king, who, it is said, was the man’s cousin. Bell was re- leased on parole, and at the close of the war returned to this country. Pointing to Wash- ington’s proclamation, that whoever assisted us in our struggle for freedom should be rewarded if we were successful, he asked for aid. He died without it and very poor. A very small portion of the claim has been paid to some of his descendants, but the bulk of it is still an acknowledged debt. Over in Georgetown there lives, or did a year or two ago, an old lady whose husband was a soldier in the Northern army. During the war the Federal troops used her farm as a camping-ground, and her live stock and other movable property as their own. The damage is put at $20,000, and the justness of her claim is undisputed, but she will prob- ably never get her money. Now and again there comes a claim which the government has tried to satisfy, but which the claimant persists in prosecuting to the last cent. One of these, apparently, is the famous Reid claim, which is said to have furnished the plot for Mr. Crane’s play, “The Senator,” In September, 1814, British buccaneers destroyed the brig ‘General Armstrong” in the neutral port of Fayal. The owners tried to recover damages, but their efforts had been fruitless up to 1835, when they all engaged Samuel C. Reid of New York to The agreement, signed by the fifteen owners, consigned to Reid their rights in the claim, with the agreement that he was to bear all the ex- penses of the prosecution and retain half of the money he might recover. It was not

Page 16

14 until 1857 that England and the United States submitted the loss of this vessel to the arbitration of Louis Napoleon, and it was not until 1882 that Congress directed the Secretary of State to adjust the claims of the captain, owners, officers, and crew of the brig. Long before this, Mr. Reid had assigned his claim to his son, Samuel C. Reid, Jr. The Court of Claims fixed the value of the vessel at $70,739, and put the owners’ share at $43,000. For want of evi- dence to adjudicate the relative interests of the heirs of the fifteen owners, Secretary Frelinghuysen decided that their estates should share alike. Mr. Reid got his half of the whole at once,— $21,500. He also got something for his services from the share of the officers and crew, so that one would think he might have been satisfied. The owners’ shares were not all paid out, however, as some of them had died without heirs. This part of the award, of course, reverted to the United States; and it is for all, or at least the major part, of this that Mr. Reid continues his suit. The McGarrahan claim is another inter- esting case, but one which is so perennially before the public that it seems useless to give more than a brief outline of what the claimant really wants. His claim is for title to land for which nobody disputes, I believe, that he has paid good money. At the time of the purchase, however, the title was not good. Since then it has become vested in the United States, and the present question is, Shall the man who actually bought and paid for the property in good faith receive the final title, or shall it go to a mining com- pany who are simply squatters? To show how investigators may be taken in, I will give a brief résumé of the Weil and La Abra bills, as they are called. The his- tory of these cases runs back to 1868, when by a treaty with Mexico the United States secured something like four million dollars’ worth of awards. The La Abra Silver- Mining Company was awarded $683,041 for The Green Bag. ‘ alleged damages arising from the closing of a silver mine. In the Weil case the award. amounted to $487,819, and was for cotton and mules said to have been seized by Mexican troops. When the United States had paid to each claimant about one-third of his award, suspicions of fraud were aroused, and further payment was sus- pended. This was in 1877. After a long fight in Congress, early in 1892, the matter was finally referred to the Court of Claims. If the Court finds that the awards were pro- cured by fraud and perjury, the unpaid bal- ance will be returned to Mexico; otherwise, payment on the claims will be resumed. The suspicions are founded in the mine case on what seems to be conclusive evidence, that it had never been seized at all, but had been voluntarily abandoned as valueless, and that the claim had been a fabrication of the former superintendent of the mine, inspired by the appointment of the commis- sion to consider claims arising out of the Mexican war. The ex-superintendent, I believe, died before any payment had been made on the award. In the La Abra case, then, there hiad once been a mine, though a valueless one. The Weil claim, however, had even less foundation in fact, if the latest evidence proves to be correct. The claim was based on the allegation that Weil lived in New Orleans, was engaged in running cotton through Mexico during the war, and had lost a heavy mule train and seven hundred bales of cotton through seizure by the Mex- icans. Cotton was then worth fifty cents a pound. The proofs at the time seemed so complete that the award was promptly made, and question would probably never have been raised, had it not been for the mixed conditions of Weil’s business affairs, which caused a quarrel over the disposition of the proceeds. It now looks as if Weil had never owned a mule or a pound of cot- ton in his life. The Court of Private Land Claims was

Page 17

Old World Trials. organized, | believe, in 1891, for the purpose of adjudicating claims to private ownership in land before it was ceded to the United States. There have been filed in this court upward of forty cases, over thirty of which are located in New Mexico, the total area claimed amounting to nearly two and a half million acres. These, of course, are grants alleged to have been made to private parties 15 before New Mexico became the property of the United States, and the only way of prov- ing the truth or falsity of the claims is to patiently and carefully overhaul old Spanish records and archives, much worn and very badly arranged. In this way not only the fact of the grants but also their proper boundaries and areas have to be established. — Kate Field’s Washington. OLD WORLD TRIALS. VIII. THE CASE OF FREDERICK AND MARIA MANNING. N 25th October, 1849, Frederick Man- ning and his wife Maria were tried before Chief Baron Pollock, Mr. Justice Maule, and Mr. Justice Cresswell, and a jury of the City of London, at the Old Bailey, now the Central Criminal Court, for the murder of a person named Patrick O’Connor under the following circumstances : Frederick Manning had at one time been a guard in the service of the Great Western Railway Company, but had been discharged on suspicion of having been concerned in a series of robberies committed on that line. Maria Manning was a Swiss by birth, and her maiden name was De Roux. After Frederick Manning’s dismissal from the post of railway guard, this worthy couple had opened an inn at Taunton, whence they had removed, at the time when the pres- ent story opens, to No. 3 Miniver Place, Bermondsey, near London. Patrick O’Con- nor, with whose murder the Mannings were charged, was an officer in the Customs. He lodged not far from Miniver Place, and carried on an adulterous intercourse with Mrs. Manning, whose conduct seems to have been regarded by her husband with perfect equanimity. He was a man possessed of considerable property, a fact well known to Maria Manning, who by his express per- mission had a right of entry to his room - . at any moment, whether he was at home at the time’ or not. On 9th August, 1849, O’Connor left his lodgings about five o’clock with the avowed intention of going to “dine with Maria.” He had received a letter of invitation from her in the morning. This letter he had shown to a companion, to whom he an- nounced that he meant to accept the invi- tation which it contained. He was seen to walk in the direction of Miniver Place. But he.never returned to his lodgings. After a few days his mysterious disappearance began to attract public attention, and hand-bills were printed and circulated offering a re- ward for his discovery. An ugly rumor got abroad that Maria Manning had visited O’Connor’s rooms on the evening of his disappearance; the rooms were searched and it was found that his drawers and boxes had been broken into and their contents rifled; of course the police at once repaired to 3 Miniver Place to arrest the Mannings. The birds had flown, and flown in different directions. It was thought advisable how- ever to search the nest. A certain damp- ness in the cement between the flagstones on the kitchen floor arrested the attention of a police officer: the flagstones were torn up, and the dead body of O’Connor was found underneath. He had evidently been

Page 18

16 -shot through the temple, and no less than eighteen severe wounds had been inflicted” on his head. It only remained to track the criminals. Mrs. Manning was the first to be arrested. A few days after the murder, a lady who gave the name of Smith called on a stock-broker in Edinburgh and asked him to sell for her some shares in the Amiens and Boulogne Railway —of course she left her address. Shortly after her visit, this gentleman received a printed circular cautioning stock-brokers against dealing in certain foreign railway shares, alleged to have been stolen in London. The numbers of the missing shares corresponded with those that ‘Mrs. Smith” had left behind her. The stock-broker gave her address to the police, she was promptly arrested, tacitly admitted that she was Maria Man- ning and accounted for her presence in Edinburgh by saying that she had fled from the brutality of her husband. Frederick Manning was at length tracked to Jersey. He had taken refuge in the house of an old peasant at Beaumont, in the parish of St. Peter’s, in that island, and had ordered large supplies of brandy from a neighboring public house with a view to create and maintain a fictitious courage. The publican however, unaccustomed to such large orders, and attracted by the news that the Bermond- sey murderer was lurking in the island, betrayed his patron to the police, and The Green Bag. Manning was duly arrested. He at once confessed the crime, which he said that he had committed at the instigation of his wife. | The prosecution of the Mannings was conducted by Sir John Jervis, the Attorney- General of the day. Serjeant Wilkins de- fended Frederick Manning, and Serjeant Ballantine, author of the famous ‘ Expe- riences,’ appeared for Maria. In a manner befitting the descendants of Adam and Eve, the guilty pair endeavored to shift the responsibility for the outrage on to each other’s shoulders; and a vigorous attempt to save the life of Maria Manning on the ground that, being an alien, she was entitled to trial de medietate linguae, i.e. by a jury half composed of aliens. But it was all in vain, and the Mannings were sentenced to | die. Mrs. Manning spent the last days of her wasted life in alternations of despair, denunciations of ‘‘base, base England,” and scrupulous attention to her toilet. The convicts made several ‘‘ statements” before their execution, but the only reliable facts to be deduced from them were that O’Con- nor’s grave had been dug some days before the murder, that the wretched man had walked over it and into it, and had asked why the flagstones had been taken up and . that Mrs. Manning had told him the drains were under repairs ! LEX.

Page 19

Lhe Case of the Sloop “Active.” ki THE CASE OF THE SLOOP “ACTIVE.” BY HAMPTON L. CARSON. N the office of the clerk of the Supreme | in the midst of the American Revolution. Court of the United States, among a mass of interesting but unpublished matter relating to the naval history of the Ameri- can Revolution, can be found the original | documents in a cele- brated admiralty cause entitled ‘“‘ The Case of the Sloop ‘ Active.’” Although historians and law- yers are more or less familiar with the main incidents of the narrative; yet many well-informed _ stu- dents of history are ignorant of its de- tails. It is the pur- pose of this paper to present in a concise form the substantial features of the con- troversy. The case presents a most notable col- lision between the United States and the State of Pennsylvania. Indeed, it may be said to constitute the only instance of armed resistance on the part of Pennsylvania to Federal authority; for though the Whiskey Insurrection, which convulsed the adminis- tration of Washington, took place on Penn- sylvania soil, yet it was but the tumult of an unorganized mob, and did not represent a rebellion on the part of the State. The case presents also an admirable illus- tration of the evolution of national author- ity. It lasted more than thirty years, be- ginning in 1778 and terminating in 1809. It originated in a controversy as to a prize, It outlived the old Court of Appeals in Cases of Capture, the establishment of | which it did much to hasten; it survived GEORGE ROSS. the collapse of the Confederation, and was brought twenty years later before the Su- preme Court of the United States for final determination. It exhibits at the outset the political impotence of the Continental Congress uttering a feeble pro- test against State power while fully con- scious of its own rights, and cowering beneath the prospect of a clash of author- ity. It displays, a few years later, the increasing strength and courage of the infant nation, — the eristle hardening into bone,—and it ter- minates, after a series of sharp conflicts be- tween State and Federal officers, in the absolute triumph of the national power. It displays all the inherent qualities of a romance, and its scenes are crowded with the most distinguished personages, who are arrayed against each other in situa- tions which are highly dramatic. It opens with a tale of heroism cheated of its re- ward by jealousy and chicane, contending with indomitable perseverance against great odds, until at the end of a struggle of thirty years the hero of the drama receives the fruits of his valor, and justice prevails over

Page 20

18 the plots which had been devised to entrap her. In the early part of September, 1778, Gideon Olmsted, a sturdy Connecticut fish- erman, and three associates were captured by the British upon the open sea, in the neighborhood of Cape Charles, and were carried to Jamaica. They were put on board the sloop “ Active” and forced, much against their will, to 3 assist in the naviga- tion of the vessel to New York witha car- go of arms and sup- plies for the British Army, then occupy- ing that city. One night Olmsted boldly resolved to seize the vessel, and unfolding his plan to his friends, they rose upon the master and crew, more than thrice their number, con- fined them to the cabin below the hatches, took posses- sion of the sloop, and steered for Little Egg Harbor in New Jer- sey. A two days’ strug- gle ensued in which shots were ex- changed, and desper- ate efforts were made by the men below to recapture the vessel. The British melted pewter spoons into bullets, forced up the hatches, and swept the deck with their fire. Olmsted was severely wounded, but succeed- ed in turning a swivel gun heavily loaded down the companionway, and thus secured control. The British captain then cut a hole through the stern and wedged the rudder so as to prevent Olmsted from steering, releas- ing it only when the pangs of hunger and WILLIAM HENRY DRAYTON. thirst compelled submission. Having com- pleted his capture, and being in full sight of land, Olmsted was pursued and _ forcibly. taken, against his indignant protest, by an armed brig named the ‘‘ Convention,” fitted out by the State of Pennsylvania, and com- manded by Captain Thomas Houston, who insisted upon carrying the “Active” into Philadelphia, where he claimed her as his prize. A claim was also made by the cap- tain of an American privateer, ‘‘ Le Ge- rard,’ cruising by agreement in concert with the ‘ Conven- tion”’ and in sight at the time of the al- leged capture. It was argued that Olm- sted’s victory had not been complete, and that it was absurd to suppose that four men could have sub- dued fourteen. To this it was replied that the facts were as stated, and that the British captain had surrendered. The depositions of the witnesses, nOW on file at Washington, certainly sustain this assertion. The case was tried before Judge George Ross and a jury, under the terms of an Act of Assembly, which had been passed but nine days before the trial, by which it was provided that while an appeal upon ques- tions of law could be carried to Congress, yet, the “finding of the facts by the jury shall be without re-examination or appeal.” The jury found (most unwarrantably, it seems to us) that the Connecticut captors were entitled to but one-fourth of the prize,

Page 21

i Nie pT OIC ARTS RE ER NE EY EEE LT OT I I The Case of the Sloop “Active.” 19 and they divided the residue between the State of Pennsylvania, the owners of the privateer, and the officers and crews of the “Convention” and ‘Le Gerard.” The Judge, who was one of the signers of the Declaration of Independence, did not con- ceal his sympathy with the heroic conduct of Olmsted, but found himself unable to overcome the local prejudices of the jury in favor of the mariners of their own State, and, moreover, felt himself coerced by the ex- press language of the law into a’ confirma- tion of the verdict. Olmsted and his as- sociates were too spir- ited to submit, and promptly appealed to Congress. Secu- rity was_ required, and in his plight the unknown and friend- less Olmsted applied to Benedict Arnold, himself a native of Connecticut, then military commander of Philadelphia, who had recently em- barked upon a course of speculative enter- prises, induced in a large measure by the life of extravagance and display which he led after his marriage to Peggy Shippen, the acknowledged belle of Philadelphia. Arnold, with a keen scent for gain and cer- tain of success, purchased in common with Stephen Collins, a merchant, a share in the controversy for a low and inadequate price." tArnold’s conduct in this transaction was made the basis of one of the charges preferred against him by the Supreme Executive Council of Pennsylvania, but it was dismissed by the court-martial for want of jurisdiction. He was then indicted for the crime of maintenance, but the bill was ignored by the Grand Jury, by direction of Chief- Justice McKean.— Arnold’s Trial, p. 118, privately printed, New York, 1865. ae OLIVER ELLSWORTH. The matter was duly referred by Con- gress, then sitting in the State House, to the standing Committee on Appeals, styling themselves ‘The Court of Commissioners of Appeals for the United States of Amer- ica,” consisting of William Henry Drayton, of South Carolina, but lately the Chief Jus- tice of his State; John Henry, Jr., of Mary- land; William Ellery, of Rhode Island, one of the signers of the Declaration of Inde- pendence; and Oli- ver Ellsworth, of Connecticut, after- wards Chief Justice of the United States.: After full argu- ment and due consid- eration, on the 15th of September, 1778, they solemnly re- versed the judgment of Judge Ross, and directed the marshal of the State Court to sell the sloop and cargo, and after de- ducting the costs to pay over the entire fund to Olmsted and his friends. Unhappily the matter did not end here. Prior to this time judgments of reversal in admiralty matters had been cheer- fully submitted to by the State Courts, but now a serious collision occurred. The first intimation of the coming storm was given by General Arnold,” who warned t Journals of Congress, Vol. IV., p. 445. 2 His letter is dated the 3d of January, 1779. The original is on file at Washington, D.C., among the MSS. in the office of the clerk of the Supreme Court of the United States, and is printed in full by Hon. J. C. Bancroft Davis, in a pamphlet privately printed by him, entitled “The Committees of the Continental Congress chosen to hear and determine Appeals from Courts of Admiralty and the Court of Appeals in Cases of Capture, established by that Body.” See also Appendix to 131 United States Reports.

Page 22

20 Lhe Green Bag. the commissioners in writing that Judge Ross was about to defy them by getting possession of the money, with the avowed purpose of standing out obstinately against any orders that might be given; that he had openly directed the marshal to deliver the money to him at nine o’clock on the following morning, and had boasted that no order of the Congressional committee should take the case out of his hands. He begged them to meet that evening and adopt preventive measures, and added that he had been informed upon good authority that a member of the Pennsylvania Assem- bly had applied to the judge to get the money paid into his hands, and, if he should succeed, it would probably reach the Treasury, and then the claim- ants would have the whole State of Penn- sylvania to contend with. His anxiety was not without: cause, but the commission- ers acted with delib- eration. The next morning they sent for Andrew Robeson, registrar of the State Court of Admiralty, who informed them under oath that he had witnessed, but an hour before, the payment by the marshal to Judge Ross of the sum of forty-seven thousand nine hundred and eighty-one pounds, two shillings, and five pence, Pennsylvania currency, arising from the sale of the cargo. As the sloop had not been sold, the commissioners drew up an order, in the nature of an injunction, commanding the marshal, at his peril, to ' maintain his custody of the whole of the THOMAS MCKEAN, moneys arising from the sale of the sloop and cargo, until their further order.t In reply, he audaciously sent them a copy of the written receipt of the judge. The commissioners then solemnly declared that they were unwilling to resort to any summary proceedings, lest consequences might ensue dangerous to_the public peace of the United States, and positively declined to hear any other appeal until their authority as a court should be so settled as to give full efficacy to their decrees. Thus did they veil their con- sciousness of their own judicial feeble- ness behind patriotic fears of provoking a contest between State and Congressional authority. The fact stands out in bold relief, that a Pennsyl- vania judge had suc- cessfully defied the Continental Con- eress. - A-statement of the proceedings in the entire case was pre- pared and made the subject of a commu- nication to Congress, who referred it to a special committee, con- sisting of Mr. Burke, Mr. Paca, Mr. Dyer, 1 See the Whole Proceedings in the case of Olmsted et al. v. Rittenhouse’s Executors, by Richard Peters, Jr., Phila- delphia, 1809. United States v. Peters, 5 Cranch’s United States Supreme Court Reports, 115. 2 The marshal was the well-known Matthew Clarkson, who had served as an aide-de-camp to General Arnold, and with him had been severely wounded at Saratoga. Hewas serving at this time at Philadelphia as provost-marshal, and shared to some degree the hostility to his chief. There is not the slightest evidence, however, to implicate him in the speculations or frauds of his principal, while his conduct in obeying the mandate of Judge Ross, in defiance of the Court of Appeals, was directly opposed to the pecuniary interests of Arnold. 7

Page 23

The Case of the Sloop “Active.” 21 and Mr. Smith. Inthe meantime Judge Ross had, with great dignity and firmness, placed upon the records of his court a vindication of his action, alleging that after mature consid- eration he was of opinion that though the Court of Appeals had full authority to alter or set aside the decree of a judge upona pure question of law, yet there its power ended; that the verdict of the jury was made con- clusive upon the facts without re-examina- tion or appeal, under the terms of the State law erecting his tribunal, and he would sub- mit to no usurpation of powers On the 6th of March, 1779, Con- gress took steps to assert its final au- thority, and after a. spirited review of the facts, declared that it necessarily had the power to examine as well into verdicts on facts as decisions on law, and to decree finally thereon, and that no finding of a jury in any Court of Admiralty, or court for determining the legality of captures on the high seas, can or ought to destroy the right of appeal and the re-examina- tion of the facts expressly reserved to Congress. That no act of any one State can or ought to destroy the right of appeal to Congress, which was invested by these United States with the supreme sovereign power of war and peace. That the power of executing the law of nations was essential to the sovereign supreme power of war and peace; that the legality of all captures on the high seas must be determined by the law of nations, and that the authority to ultimately and finally decide on all matters and questions touching the law of nations oo RICHARD PETERS rested in and was vested in the sovereign supreme power of war and peace. Thata control by appeal was necessary, in order to compel a just and uniform execution of the law of nations; that this control must extend as well over the decisions of juries as judges, otherwise juries would be pos- sessed of the ultimate power of executing the law of nations in all cases of capture, and might at any time exercise the same in such manner as to prevent a possibility of being controlled, a construction which in- volved so many in- conveniences and ab- surdities as to destroy an essential part of the power of war and peace entrusted to Congress, and would disable Congress from giving satisfac- tion to foreign na- tions complaining of a violation of neu- tralities, of treaties, or other branches of the law of nations, and would enable a jury in any one State to involve the United States in hostilities ; a construction which for these and many other reasons was inadmissible. It was also asserted that Congress had hitherto always exercised the power of controlling, by a committee of its own members through appeals, the several admiralty jurisdictions of the States. It was therefore resolved that the committee before whom had been deter- mined the appeal from the Admiralty Court of Pennsylvania, in the case of the sloop. ‘“ Active,” was duly constituted and author- ized to determine the same. Upon this resolution the vote stood twenty-one yeas to six nays, all of the Pennsylvania mem- bers, and Mr. Witherspoon, of New Jersey,

Page 24

22 The Green Bag. ~ voting in the negative, while the power of Congress was sustained by such men as Samuel Adams, John Jay, Richard Henry Lee, Thomas Burke, Henry Laurens, and William Henry Drayton." The reasoning of Congress, while readily commanding assent in our day, proved but a paper victory. | On the memorial of Olmsted, who bitterly complained that the decree of the appellate body had not been complied with, commit- tees were twice ap- pointed by Congress to confer with a com- mittee of the Pennsyl- vania_ Legislature. Resolutions, assert- ing the absolute power of control of Congress by appeal in the last resort “over all jurisdic- tions for deciding the legality of captures on the high seas,” were transmitted to all the States, with the request that they take effectual meas- ures for conforming thereto.» An active correspondence was entered into between Joseph Reed, presi- dent of the Su- preme Executive Council of Pennsylvania, and Thomas Burke, Esgq., in behalf of the Congress, in which, while each was tender in his treatment of the question involving the harmony of the Union, both were firm and outspoken in the maintenance of what ‘Journals of Congress, Vol. V., p. 64, et seq. Many years afterwards the reasoning of Congress was expressly adopted and sustained by the Supreme Court of the United States in determining a somewhat similar case. See opinion of Paterson, J.,in Penhallow v. Doane, 3 Dallas, 54. ? Journals, Vol. V., 165. JOHN MARSHALL. they believed to be the respective rights of the parties to the controversy.’ On the 8th of March, 1780, Pennsylvania passed a new act, abolishing trial by jury in admiralty causes and restoring the prac- tice of the civil law, and a similar act was passed by South Carolina on February 26, 1782. The remaining States declined to act. Nothing, however, of a conciliatory na- ture was done by Pennsylvania in Olmsted’s behalf; on the con- trary, her Assembly by resolution author- ized Judge Ross to pay over the money realized from the sale of the cargo and the sloop, which _ had been disposed of dur- ing the discussion in Congress, to David Rittenhouse, the cel- ebrated astronomer, who, though study- ing the stars by night, was willing to act as State treasurer by day. Payment was made, and a bond of indemnity given to the Judge as to that portion of the fund which had been awarded to claimants other than the State. In the meantime the Constitution of the United States had been adopted, and by the terms of the second section of the Third Article, the judicial power of the United States was expressly extended to all cases of admiralty and maritime jurisdiction. The power of the newly-created nation stood be- hind this constitutional provision, and it re- mains to be seen what change was wrought 1 Letters of January 28, 1779; January 29, June 5, 1779; Pennsylvania Archives, 1778, 1779, pp. 170, 171, 172, 468.

Page 25

The Case of the Sloop “Active.” 23 in Olmsted’s fortunes by this positive declar- ation in the fundamental law. In 1790 Judge Ross died, and suit was brought against his executors in the Court of Common Pleas of Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, by Olmsted, who still toiled wearily in search of justice. A judgment was recovered by default. Thereupon Ross’s executors sued Rittenhouse to the use of Olmsted up- on the bond of in- demnity, This aspect of the con- troversy came be- fore the Supreme Court of Pennsyl- vania in 1792, and Chief-Justice Thomas McKean, whose name with that of Ross is at- tached to the Dec- laration of Inde- pendence, declined to sustain the suit, on the ground of the lack of juris- diction of the Com- mon Pleas over an admiralty matter. He held that this objection ran equally against the validity of the judgment against the executors of Ross, and at the same time expressed in an extra-judicial fashion a de- cided opinion against the powers of Con- gress. In the conclusion Associate Justices Shippen and Yeates concurred, although dissenting from his reasons.’ Baffled but undismayed, Olmsted quietly awaited the course of events. Three years t Russell e¢ a/, Exrs. v. Rittenhouse, 2 Dallas, 160. FORT RITTENHOUSE. | later, in the case of Penhallow v. Doane, the | Supreme Court of the United States held that the District Courts of the United States had power and authority to carry into exe- cution the decrees of the defunct Court of Appeals in cases of capture... The heart of the doughty old mariner was warmed by fresh hopes. Presenting himself before Judge Richard Peters, the United States District Judge for Pennsylvania, in 1803, he obtained a decree against Mrs. Sergeant and Mrs. Waters, the daughters and ex- ecutrices of David Rittenhouse, by which they were directed to hand over the certifi- cates of Federal debt in which their ’ father had invested the money received by him astreasurer of the State. To meet this decree, the Legislature of Pennsylvania, at the instigation of Thomas McKean, the Governor, smarting under the inattention paid to his decision as Chief Justice of the State Supreme Court, passed an act requiring the ladies to pay over the funds in dispute to the State Treasury, and directed the Governor to protect their persons and_ property against any process issuing out of any Fed- eral Court.2, Here was a gage of battle flung down by the State, accompanied by a note of defiance. The nominal parties to * 3 Dallas, 54. ? Act 2d of April, 1803.

Page 26

24 the controversy were a man of ’76, and two women who had inherited the lawsuit, but the real contestants were the State of Penn- sylvania-and the United States. For five years no process was issued upon the decree entered by Judge Peters, because, as he himself stated, for prudential reasons he deemed it best to withhold it, so as to avoid embroiling the government of the United States and that of Pennsylvania. Rallying his energies for a supreme and final effort, Olmsted applied, in 1808, to the Supreme Court of the United States for a mandamus, which was awarded by Chief Justice Marshall, in one of his characteristic judgments. ‘With great attention and serious concern” he examined the ques- tion of jurisdiction, and after a calm but convincing course of reasoning in support of Federal power, he solemnly declared, “Tf the Legislatures of the several States may at will annul the judgments of the Courts of the United States, and destroy the rights acquired under those judgments, the Constitution itself becomes a solemn mockery, and the nation is deprived of the means of en- forcing its laws by the instrumentality of its own tribunals. So fatal a result must be deprecated by all; and the people of Penn- sylvania, not less than the citizens of every other State, must feel a deep interest in resisting principles so destructive of the Union, and in averting consequences so fatal to themselves. ...” ‘The State of Pennsyl- JAMES MADISON. The Green Bag. - vania can possess no Constitutional right to resist the legal process which may be di- rected in this case. It will be readily con- ceived that the order which this Court is enjoined to make by the high obligations of duty and of law, is not made without ex- treme regret at the necessity which has in- duced the application. But it is a solemn duty, and therefore must be performed. A peremptory mandamus must be awarded.” ' There could be but little doubt as to the result, when John Marshall sounded such a note, but the State still maintained an attitude of defi- ance. Judge Peters issued his writ, but when service of the attachment was at- tempted, the marshal found the house of Mrs. Sergeant and Mrs. Waters, at the corner of Seventh and Arch _ Streets, long known as “ Fort Rittenhouse,” sur- rounded by the State militia under the command of General Bright, who had been called out by Gov- ernor Snyder with the sanction of the Legislature, in fulfilment of their pledge of protection. In vain did the marshal read his commission and. his warrant, and adda speech on the duty of obedience; every effort to enter the house was resisted by pointed bayonets. : He withdrew for a time, but fixed that day three weeks for the service of the war- rant, and summoned a fosse-comitatus of two thousand men. Bloodshed was imminent, and the City of Philadelphia was torn by the ™ United States v. Peters, 5 Cranch, 115.

Page 27

The Case of The Sloop “Active.” apprehension of civil war. The Governor appealed to President Madison and begged him to discriminate between opposition to the laws and Constitution of the United States and resistance to the decree of a judge founded on a usurpation of power, but Madison replied that the Executive of the Union was not authorized to pre- vent the execution of a decree of the Su- preme Court, but was specially enjoined by _ statute, wherever any such decree was re- sisted, to aid in its enforcement. The Legislature then pru- dently opened a door for retreat. In a new act, they still insisted on the right of the, State; but “as sundry unfore- seen difficulties ” might arise in the way of enforcing it, and as the State was bound to protect at all events the per- sons and property of the executrices of Rittenhouse, they appropriated a large sum to meet contin- gent expenses, and otherwise to be used ‘as to the Governor might appear advisable and proper.” The marshal, cleverly resort- ing to stratagem as a means of escaping a bloody collision in the streets, secured ac- cess to the rear of the house of the ladies, a day or two before the time appointed for the array of his posse, and having taken them into custody, held them as prisoners. A writ of habeas corpus was then sued out before Chief-Justice Tilghman, of the State Supreme Court. The case was argued with ereat warmth by Walter Franklin, the At- torney-General of Pennsylvania, and Jared WILLIAM LEWIS. 25 Ingersoll on the one side, and on the other by Alexander J. Dallas, the United States District Attorney, and William Lewis, who had represented Olmsted for thirty years, and to whose stubborn qualities as a legal pugilist the final result was largely due. The Chief-Justice, in a sensible and well-- reasoned opinion, made it plain that the Federal Courts were successors to the Con- tinental admiralty jurisdiction, and therefore the validity of the decree of the Conti- nental Court of Ap- peals was a question exclusively for them, with which he had no right to meddle. He therefore remand- ed the prisoners to the custody of the marshal.‘ The Gov- ernor then paid over the money in dispute to the marshal, out of the legislative ap- propriation, and thus saved the ladies from imprisonment. But the drama had not yet closed. An- other act remained. The litigation had ended with the tri- umph of the nominal plaintiff, but it remained for the United States to vindicate their authority. War- rants were issued against General Bright and his men for forcibly obstructing Federal process. The trials came on before Mr. Justice Washington, who was on all points opposed in opinion to the prisoners, and strenuous in his efforts to uphold the su- premacy of Federal law. The jury, how- ever, held out for three days and nights, refusing to convict. The Judge refused to discharge them. When two of them fell Olmsted’s Case, Brightly’s Reports (Pa.), I. \

Page 28

26 sick he sent a doctor to them, but declared that they should never separate until they had agreed. Finally they brought in a spe- cial verdict, that the defendants had resisted the marshal, knowingly and wilfully, but that they did it under the authority of the State of Pennsylvania. On these facts they left it to the Court to direct the form of the verdict according to his view of the law. Thereupon he directed a verdict of guilty, Lhe Green Bag. The fisherman had triumphed. His per- tinacity in maintaining his legal rights had equaled his persistent valor, when gashed and bleeding upon the sea, im securing his prize against superior numbers. Born in 1748, and dying at the age of ninety-eight, in 1846, at East Hartford, Conn., he lived for many years after his legal victory. to enjoy his reward. But better and more lasting than the fruits of heroism was the BUSHROD WASHINGTON. y which was entered, and after a suitable ad- monition General Bright was sentenced to three months’ imprisonment and a fine of two hundred dollars, and the men to one month’s imprisonment and a fine of fifty dollars each; but these were immediately remitted by the President, on the ground that the defendants had acted under a mis- taken sense of duty.’ t The sources of the foregoing account are the original papers in the case of the Active in the Clerk’s Office of the Supreme Court of the United States: Journals of Con- gress, Vol. V.; Ross e¢ a/. Exrs. v. Rittenhouse, 2 Dallas, 165; United States v. Peters, 5 Cranch, 115; The Whole vindication of national power. The price- less principle had been established that the Constitution and laws of the United States shall be recognized as the supreme law of the land, ‘‘and the judges in every State shall be bound thereby, anything in the Con- stitution or laws of any State to the contrary notwithstanding.” Proceedings in the Case of Olmsted v. Rittenhouse, by Richard Peters, Jr., published at Philadelphia in 1809; Trial of General Bright in the Circuit Court of the United States for the District of Pennsylvania, printed at Philadel- phia in 1809, two scarce pamphlets in the library of the Philadelphia Library Company.

Page 29

The Thirteen Maxims of Equity. 27 THE THIRTEEN MAXIMS OF EQUITY.’ By ROBERTSON PALMER, OF THE CHICAGO Bar. peeny follows the law, regards what should be done. To reach the substance every form looks through, On strictly equal plane puts every one; - Who seeks her aid, himself must justice do. With hands unstained her suitors all must be; With equal right the first in time prevails ; With equal right the law controls decree ; The wakeful, not the sleeping turns her scales. To each she will impute a purpose fair, Each legal right her ample power protects. She acts alone on persons everywhere, The very thing that should be, she directs. *The maxims of equity as indexed by the American and English Encyclopedia of Law are as follows : — I. Equity follows the law. 2. Equity regards that as done which ought to have been done. 3. Equity looks to the intent rather than to the form. 4. Equality is equity. 5. Hewho seeks equity must do equity. 6. He who comes into equity must come with clean hands, 7. Between equal equities the first in time shall prevail. 8. Between equal equities the law must prevail. 9g. Equity aids the vigilant, not the sleeping. 10. Equity imputes an intention to fulfil an obligation. 11. Equity will not suffer a right to be without a remedy. * 12. Equity acts in personam. ‘ 13. Equity acts specifically.

Page 30

28 The Green Bag.~ THE COURT OF STAR CHAMBER. XI. By Joun D. Linpsay. HE cases which have been cited are but a very few instances of the op- pression of the Star Chamber during Charles I.’s reign. Macaulay says: — “The tribunals afforded no protection to the subject against the civil and ecclesiastical tyranny of that period. The judges of the common law, holding their situations during the pleasure of the king, were scandalously obsequious. Yet, obse- quious as they were, they were less ready and less efficient instruments of arbitrary power than a class of courts, the memory of which is still, after the lapse of more than two centuries, held in deep abhorrence by the nation. Foremost among these courts in power and in infamy were the Star Chamber and the High Commission, the former a political, the latter a religious inquisi- tion. Neither was a part of the old Constitution of England. The Star Chamber had been re- modeled, and the High Commission created, by the Tudors. ‘The power which these boards had possessed before the accession of Charles had been extensive and formidable, but had been | small indeed when compared with that which they now usurped. Guided chiefly by the vio- lent spirit of the primate, and freed from the control of Parliament, they displayed a rapacity, a violence, a malignant energy, which had been unknown to any former age. ‘The government was able through their instrumentality to fine, imprison, pillory, and mutilate without restraint. A separate council which sat at York, under the presidency of Wentworth, was armed, in defiance of law, by a pure act of prerogative, with almost boundless power over the northern counties. All these tribunals insulted and defied the authority of Westminster Hall, and daily committed ex- cesses which the most distinguished Royalists have warmly condemned. We are informed by Clarendon that there was hardly a man of note in the realm who had not personal experience of the harshness and greediness of the Star Cham- ber, that the High Commission had so conducted itself that it had scarce a friend left in the king- dom, and that the tyranny of the Council of York had made the great charter a dead letter on the north of the Trent.” Between the dissolution of the short-lived assembly convoked by Charles in the spring of 1640, and the meeting of that ever-mem- orable body known as the Long Parliament in November of. the same year, ‘ which,” says Macaulay, ‘‘in spite of many errors and disasters is justly entitled to the reverence and gratitude of all who, in any part of the world, enjoy the blessings of constitutional Government,” the oppression of the Star Chamber was exercised at its greatest height. Members of the House of Commons were called before it and questioned concerning their parliamentary conduct, and thrown into prison for refusing to reply. The Lord Mayor and Sheriff of London were threat- ened with imprisonment for remissness in collecting the payment of ship money, which was levied with increased rigor. Wentworth, it is said, observed with characteristic inso- lence and cruelty that things would never go right till the aldermen were hanged. The Star Chamber was finally abolished by one of the first statutes passed by the Long Parliament, — ‘that great Parliament destined to every extreme of fortune, to em- pire and to servitude, to glory and to con- tempt; at one time the sovereign of its sovereign, at another time the servant of its servants. This statute was the 16 Charles I. ch. ro. It recited the different statutes bearing on )T the subject, declared that the proceedings, censures, and ‘decrees of the court have by experience been found to be an intolerable burden to the subjects, and the means to introduce an arbitrary power and govern- t Macaulay.

Page 31

iieieahemmniieatcnr And ORE ere . The Court of Star Chamber. 29 ment,” and enacted that the Court of Star Chamber, and all similar courts, and particu- larly the Courts of the Council of the Marches of Wales, the President and Coun- cil of the North, the Duchy of Lancaster, and the Court of Exchequer of the County Palatine of Chester be abolished, and that no similar court be established for the future. The words of the act are, “The like jurisdiction now used and exercised” in the courts named “shall be also repealed and absolutely revoked and made void.” * Those unfortunate victims who, after un- dergoing ignominious punishment and cruel mutilations, had been sent to languish in distant prisons, were set at liberty and con- ducted through the streets of London in triumphant procession. Says Macaulay: ‘The abolition of those three hateful courts, the Northern Council, the Star Chamber, and the High Commission, would alone entitle the Long Parliament to the lasting gratitude of Englishmen.” But while we can but with justice look back to the Court of Star Chamber with a feeling of loathing for its tyranny and op- pressions, we must not forget the great ser- vices which it rendered for many generations, and the lasting benefits it contributed to our system of law. Stephen says: — ‘The common law was in all ways a most de- fective system. It was incomplete. Its punish- ments were capricious and cruel. Its most characteristic institution, trial by jury, was open to abuse in every case in which persons of local influence were interested. Juries themselves were often corrupt, and the process of attaint, the only one by which at common law a false verdict could be impeached or a corrupt juryman be punished, was as uncertain and as open to corrupt influences as other forms of trial by jury.” “When a corrupt jury,” says Hudson, ? “ had * The Court of Star Chamber was dissolved, but the other courts were not dissolved in terms. The “ Court holden before the President and Council of the Marches of Wales” seems to have survived for forty-eight years, as it was abolished in 1688 by 1 Wm. & M. ch. 27. muh te YS given an injurious verdict, if there had been no remedy but to attaint them by another jury, the wronged party would have had but small remedy, as is manifested by common experience, no jury having for many years attainted a former. As also at this day in the principality of Wales, if a man of good alliance have a cause to be tried, though many sharp laws have been made for favorable panels, yet it is impossible to have a jury which will find against him, be the cause never so plain; or if arraigned for murder he shall hardly be convicted, although the fear of punishment of this court carries some awful re- spect over them.” “ According to our modern views, the proper cure for such defects would be intelligent and comprehensive legislation as to both crimes and criminal procedure, but for many reasons such an undertaking as a criminal code would have been practically impossible in the Tudor period. In these circumstances the Star Chamber not merely exercised a control over influential noblemen and gentlemen which put a stop to much oppression and corrupt interference with the course of jus- tice, but supplied some of the defects of a system which practically left unpunished forgery, per- jury, attempts and conspiracies to commit crimes, and many forms of fraud and force. “In the latter stages of its history, no doubt the Court of Star Chamber became a partisan court, and punished with cruel severity men who offended the king or his ministers. Nothing can be said in excuse of such proceedings as those against Prynne or Lilburne ; but it is just to ob- serve that the real objection made was to the punishment of the acts themselves, rather than to the cruelty of branding or whipping. ‘The pun- ishments inflicted by the common law were in many cases more cruel than those of the Star Chamber, yet they seem to have elicited no in- dignation. ‘There is also some reason to believe that the cruel punishments inflicted under Charles I. were at least to some extent an innovation on the earlier practice of the court.” ! 1 Hudson is quite enthusiastic. He says: ‘Since the great Roman senate, so famous to all ages and nations, as that they might be called jure mirum orbis, there hath no court come so near them in state honour and judicature as this; the judges of this court being surely in honour, state and majesty, learning, understanding, justice, piety and mercy, equal and in many exceeding the Roman senate by such much, by how much Christian knowledge exceedeth

Page 32

30 Bacon describes the Star Chamber as “one of the sagest and noblest institutions of this kingdom.” Coke says: “It is the most honorable court (our Parliament excepted) that is in the Christian world, both in respect of the judges of the court, and of their honorable proceeding according to their just jurisdic- tion, and the ancient and just orders of the court. . . This court, the right institu- tions and ancient orders thereof being ob- served, doth keep all England in quiet.” The principal share in the earlier stages of the enlargement of the doctrine of crim- inal conspiracy must be ascribed to the Star Chamber. The modern law of conspiracy has grown out of the application to cases of conspiracy, properly so called, and as defined by the 33 Edw. I., of the early doctrine that since the gist of crime was in the intent, a crim- inal intent manifested by any act done in furtherance of it might be punishable, al- though the act did not amount in law to an actual attempt. In accordance with this view the Star Chamber on the authority of Anon. 27, ass. p. 138, b. vl. 44 (1354) finally settled in the Poulterer’s case, 9 Rep. 55, Moore, 814, human learning.” After giving an account of the chan- cellor as Chief-Judge of the court he says: “ As concerning the great and eminent officers of the kingdom, the Lord Treasurer, Privy Seal, and President of the Council, their places or voices in this court when the superior sitteth are of no more weight than any other of the table; so that the displeasure of a great officer cannot much amaze any suitor, knowing it is but one opinion, and the court is not alone replenished with nobles, dukes, marquises, earls and’ barons, which hereby ought to be frequented with great presence of them, but also with reverend and bishops and prelates, grave counsellors of state, just and learned judges, with a composition for justice, mercy, religion, policy and government, that it may be well and truly said that Mercy and Truth are met together, Righteousness and Peace have kissed each other.” Lhe Green Bag: that although the crime of conspiracy, prop- erly so called, was not complete unless in a case of conspiracy for maintenance some suit had: been actually maintained, or in a case of conspiracy for false and malicious indictment the party against whom the con- spiracy was directed had been actually in- dicted and acquitted, yet the agreement for such a conspiracy was indictable as a sub- stantive offense, since there was a criminal intent manifested by an act done in further- ance of it, viz., by the agreement: and from this time by an easy transition the agree- ment or confederacy itself for the commis- © sion of what had been previously called in law conspiracy, came to be regarded as a complete act of conspiracy, although traces of the original distinction between a com- pleted conspiracy, and a mere agreement or confederacy to commit it, long continue to be found. Not only the Poulterers’ case, which is the source of all the modern law of con- spiracy, but all the other reported cases of conspiracy decided before the abolition of the Star Chamber were in that court. Undoubtedly the decisions of the Star Chamber were often influenced by consider- ations that have no place in a judicial tribu- nal, and its sentences, especially during the reigns of James I. and Charles I., were cruelly harsh and unjustifiable. But there is one consideration that must not be overlgoked, one that unhappily cannot be applied to many if any of our modern tribunals, — and I doubt if the pages of history furnish a parallel,— namely, that throughout its ex- istence, so far as the records show, its deter- mination upon questions of law were, with- out a single exception, founded upon sound reason and the principles of absolute justice, and were legally unassailable.

Page 33

i j ' An Early Case of Trespass in Maine. 3! AN EARLY CASE OF TRESPASS IN MAINE. By Gero. J. VARNEY. ' HE number of distinct governments more or less inimical to each other that have been endured by the southwestern section of Maine is uncountable, — less from the number (nearly a dozen) than from their often coincidence, resulting in confusion of authority and jurisdiction. There had been governments by local association from the first settlement of a eroup of families; but in 1636, Sir Fer- dinando Gorges, having had his grant of the province of Maine confirmed, with rights of government, sent over a governor and es- tablished the first court in Maine, —the province being, under this organization, New Somersetshire. This territory ex- tended from the Piscataqua River to that of the New Plymouth colony on the Ken- nebec. | His governor stayed only until the next year; but it was not until 1640 that the lord-proprietor sent another to represent him,—this time his “trusty and well-be- loved cousin, Thomas Gorges, Esq.,” —-who, like himself, was of the established church. At a session of court held in September of that year there were tried an action for drunkenness, another for the sale of the liquor that was its cause, one for debt, one for slander, two for swearing oaths, two for profanation of the Sabbath, and the one we are to consider,—the case of Richard Tucker, proprietor of the Presumpscot lands, against Thomas Purchas, proprietor of the broad peninsula of Pejepscot, occupying the area between the Androscoggin River and the sea, from the lower falls to the mouth of the river. The court record runs thus: — “ Richard Tucker cometh into this court and declareth that nine years since, or thereabouts, there came one Sir Christopher Gardiner to plaintiff in the name of the defendant, Thomas a pa Purchas, and borrowed of him a warming-pan, which cost here in this country 12s. 6d., which the defendant hath all this time and still doth wrongfully detain from the plaintiff. And also the said Sir Christopher did six months after or thereabouts, buy of the plaintiff a new fowling- piece for 40s. which he promised to pay within a month after, which money, both for the warm- ing-pan and the piece, the plaintiff hath often- times demanded of the defendant, who doth still refuse to pay the same, to the damage of the plaintiff at least 5.4 sterling, for which the plain- tiff commenceth his action of trespass on the case against the defendant in this court, and humbly desireth a legal hearing according to law.” | The Sir Christopher Gardiner here re- ferred to is that picturesque personage who arrived at Boston in 1630, — whose dudish debut and indecorous doings in the Puritan precincts are described and narrated in Longfellow’s ‘Rhyme of Sir Christopher,” the landlord’s contribution to the Tales of the Wayside Inn. As there delineated, — _ * His rapier dangling at his feet, Doublet and hose and boots complete, Prince Rupert hat with ostrich plume, Gloves that exhale a faint perfume, And superior manners now obsolete, —” he is a strikingly attractive figure, and must have caused a sensation among the Puritan maidens, — until certain other things were learned that properly rendered him ob- noxious to all good citizens. Sir Christopher was a traveled man, hav- ing penetrated the Orient as far as Jerusa- lem,— where he was made a knight of the Holy Sepulchre. Moreover he was of the family of the persecuting bishop, Stephen Gardiner, in the reign of the bloody Mary. These things gave him a decided Roman Catholic flavor to the taste of the Bay people; besides which, letters surreptitiously opened by the authorities on the way to

Page 34

"9 The Green Bag. him showed that his visit was at least partly in the interest of Sir Ferdinando Gor- ges, who had a claim on the Bay colony’s lands; and the strange knight was suspected to be in a scheme to divert this property from its possessor. The Puritan stomach was nauseated; and the authorities were soon furnished with cause for action by letters to Governor Win- throp from two women in England, each claiming to be his wife. One besought the governor to send her recreant husband back to her, while the other requested that he be put to death off-hand. The knight is represented as having brought quite a retinue with him, and ap- pears to have had a town house, though his country seat figures chiefly in Longfel- low’s rhyme, — which says: — ‘¢ His dwelling was just beyond the town, At what he called his country seat, —” though this was found by the officers who came in search of him to be “little more than a cabin of logs,” with ‘«¢ A modest flower bed in front of the door.” The knight was accompanied in his mis- sion by a lady whom he represented as his cousin, but whom the suspicious Bostonians believed to sustain a more intimate relation. Observing the approaching officers, the gay Sir Christopher took a precipitate de- parture from the rear of his house; and, unable to find the person for whom they had been sent, they seized, instead, ‘¢ A little lady with golden hair,” and brought the ‘ weeping damsel ” before the governor. The poem goes on to say that the latter “read her a little homily ‘¢ On the folly and wickedness of the lives Of women half cousin and half wives ; And seeing that naught his word availed, He sent her away in a ship that. sailed For merry England over the sea.” Meanwhile ‘¢ Sir Christopher wandered away Through pathless woods for a month and a day,” but was finally captured,—it is said, by means of Indians with whom he had found refuge, under the temptation of the reward offered by the Bay people. The accepted authority says that he was sent back to meet alike his pining spouse and the re- vengeful one, in a ship which sailed from Salem. ) Here comes in—beside the outrage on the rights of a well-born Englishman — a conflict of testimony in the matter of dates of sailing and the fates of the unwilling sailors; for in Tucker’s action he declares that Sir Christopher obtained the articles from him about ‘“‘ nine years ago,’ — which shows the knight to have been otherwheres than in England; while his ‘lady cousin” had previously been married to Thomas Purchas in Boston — in 1631, — according to other trustworthy chroniclers, and as ap- pears to be proved by the York County records, which also show that she bore her lord three children. It was for the comfort of this lady that the warming-pdn was borrowed; to whom, in the year just indicated, Sir Christopher made a visit at her legal residence in the mansion of her husband in what is now the good old college town of Brunswick, Maine. The fowling-piece, it is stated, was bought six months later. Tucker was raising grain extensively on his land along Back Cove, opposite the present city of Portland; while Purchas carried on an extensive salmon fishery in its season, and a profitable trade with the Indians ‘at all times. He had been one of the commissioners-assistant of the governor whom proprietor Gorges sent over in 1636; but. on the departure of this governor the government lapsed; therefore Purchas turned to Massachusetts, and, in 1639, be- came an adherent of that government, for his own protection against the intrusion of fishing vessels, the encroachments of neigh- boring proprietors, and the ever dangerous Indians.

Page 35

Legal A nthropometry. So in this court Tucker had a fair field, and Purchas no favor. “T. Purchas denies ever authorizing Sir C. Gardiner to buy any warming-pan or fowling-piece for him, etc.,” is the court record of the defense. The charges are somewhat mixed in their nature, and the verdict of the six judges, “councillors” or ‘‘assistants,”’ is therefore lumped. It runs: ‘ Verdict for fs the plaintiff, 24. 12s. 6d. for the two articles, 12s. 6d., costs of court.” The designation of the offense by the plaintiff, and the judgment of the court, are subjects for the scrutiny of the more tech- nical intellects of the legal profession of to- day—who will doubtless take into view, also, the kind of ‘‘ goods” that Sir Chris- topher palmed off upon the rural fisherman, and the rights of the innocent holder. LEGAL ANTHROPOMETRY. R. Edmund R. Spearman contributes to the ‘London Law _ Journal,” the following interesting paper, which will be read with interest by the legal profession in America. ‘“‘ It is now just five years since my trans- lation of M. Alphonse Bertillon’s descrip- tion of his system of legal or police an- thropometry was published in your columns. That description was originally compiled in the form of an address for the meeting of the International Penitentiary Congress at Rome in 1885, and my translation was pre- pared at the request of the French Govern- ment, which had, and has, the greatest interest in calling the attention of other gov- ernments to the Bertillon system, and to endeavor to obtain its adoption by its neighbors. Unfortunately the original impression of my translation, printed for private administrative use by the French Government, was issued without any revi- sion on my part, and, although of course handsome in appearance, had such errors of typography as to prejudice, at first sight, the English official world; alas, only too ready for an excuse for delay or do noth- ingness in this as in other matters. To somewhat repair this initial disaster in a crusade which I had taken in heart, I had recourse to the hospitality of your columns, and afterwards I issued the translation in > pamphlet form, but not in such attractive shape as might have been the French pamphlet, if properly supervised. How- ever, the publication in the ‘ Law Journal” of August 31, September 7, and September 14, 1889, was a landmark in the history of a great reform in criminal procedure. Previ- ously the only attention paid in England to M. Bertillon’s wonderful innovation were various communications of my own to the press and some questions in Parliament by friends of mine, rising at my special request. I fear these earlier attempts were little ap- preciated either by the general public or even by the class more specially interested in the administration of the law. My ap- peals to the Home Office and to Scotland Yard met with careless incredulity and indifference. With the publication of M. Bertillon’s own succinct description all in- telligent and reasonable persons at once awakened to the importance of the anthro- pometric idea. The question was widely debated, and my subsequent contributions to the periodical literature met with a gen- eral chorus of sympathy. When, in the early years of the French Anthropometric Bureau, I became acquainted with M. Ber- tillon and his system, and, with my long experience of the terrible defects of our English administration in this matter of criminal identification, I resolved on de- voting my energies to having anthro- pometry introduced into England, not the

Page 36

34 least annoying of the official objections I encountered was the assertion that it would be illegal in England to take the Bertillon anthropometric measurements. Without setting myself up as a legal authority, I still contend that it is contrary to common sense to consider it any more illegal to take the width of a prisoner’s head than (as is always the practice) to take his stature. To clear the ground of this frivolous objection, and to finally clinch the matter, by persist- ently knocking at the door of St. Stephen’s my efforts secured the distinct enunciation in section 8 of 54 and 55 Vict. c. 69, that the taking of anthropometric measurements should be henceforth sanctioned. The great reform itself, however, still waits. This matter should especially interest the legal fraternity, as serious defects in the ad- ministration of the criminal law come nearest home to the general public, bring- ing the law itself into disrepute, and en- tailing odium on the whole legal world, even that portion most remote from the routine of the criminal law, the public not making nice discriminations in this regard any more than did the Merry Monarch when he proposed to remedy the public ills by hanging a few lawyers. It must be understood that the great success of the Bertillon system in France entails an ever-increasing danger to England so long as our machinery remains in arrear. The most dangerous of all criminals are inter- national ones, birds of passage who can ply their vocation in more than one land. If these malefactors discover matters too hot for them in one state, they will surely fly to another if the second affords a safe refuge. This process is going on at this moment so far as France and England are concerned. M. Bertillon’s system has now eleven years of service, and half a million of measurements are already docketed in the Paris Prefecture of Police. Such a thing as concealment of identity by any person who has been in the clutches of the law cords after the Commune catastrophe. methods The Green Bag. in France since anthropometry was intro- duced is now practically impossible. So immense is the importance of the service rendered to France by M. Bertillon that one of the chief reforms introduced in the perfecture by the new prefect, M. Lupine, was to place M. Bertillon in charge of the whole service of identity, including those terrible masses of sommiers gudiciaires (now over eight millions in number) which have been steadily accumulating, since inaugur- ated by Fouché in 1805, the individual biographies of every French criminal of the nineteenth century, and which were carefully restored from the duplicate re- Al- though the sommuers judiciaires are the . subject of such admiring use by the sensa- tional novelist and dramatist, they were > bidding fair, without M. Bertillon’s re- habilitation, to become the sport of many of the criminals themselves. Thus the French counterpart of our John Smith, Jean Baptiste Lefevre, counts no less than two thousand representatives among the sommiers. It is M. Bertillon’s triumph that neither two thousand Jean Lefevres nor any other mass of humanity confuses his scientific discrimination. By means of his accurate and unchanging bone meas- urements, and, above all, by his elaborate yet simple system of classification, he picks out in a few minutes any previous récord of each new person brought to his notice. Out of all the half-million and upwards, he das never mistaken one single prisoner for another. ‘Nhat a crying shame for the London administration at this late day to have such a flagrant instance as that of the poor man Blake this past summer at the Central Criminal Court, and at the very moment when my elaborate statement of the working and results of the Bertillon system appeared in the “New Review” ! No wonder Blake’s solicitor wrote to the press so indignantly about the high-handed of our policemen and prison

Page 37

wardens in swearing so confidently to iden- tity of prisoners, even after intervals of years. The legal fraternity should insist that this crude, barbarous method of iden- tification should be swept away without further delay. I cannot repeat here de- tails of the Bertillon system as already given in your columns and_ elsewhere. Suffice it to recall that M. Bertillon’s method is sczentific and absolutely zzfal- lible. He records for each arrested person certain bone measurements, so selected as to serve readily for sorting into minute categories. By the laws of arithmetical progression, M. Bertillon enables us so to classify even millions of measurements into groups so uniform and so small as to enable anyone after search of a few minutes to turn out any particular record when the same subject again appears. Moreover, M. Ber- tillon’s records of personal appearance are so accurate and minute in character that even the most incredulous can have no doubt of the truth; when bodily peculiari- ties are recorded to the tune of millimétres, the game of concealment is up,.and error is London Legal Letter. 35 out of the question. The legal fraternity cannot fail to be interested in the visit of Sir Charles Russell and Sir Richard Web- ster to the Paris Anthropometric Bureau during the session of the Bering Arbitra- tion Tribunal. Our illustrious legists were unstinted in their approval of anthropom- etry. In fact, no lawyer could fail to see both the importance and perfection of M. Bertillon’s system at a glance. It only needs the mere comparison of the auto- matic anthropometry to the English reli- ance on loose memory of an _ ignorant warden to have the latter laughed out of court. The recent discussions of criminal anthropometry in the scientific centres, especially the interest by that enthusiastic anthropologist Mr. Francis Galton, is wel- comed as indicating the growth of public opinion in this matter, but it is incumbent on the legal fraternity to take heed that the scientists only contribute essentials and not embarrassing superfluities. It must be the Bertillon system pure and simple, or the benefit of international uniformity will be lost.” LONDON LEGAL LETTER. Lonpon, Dec. 1, 1894. ORD HERSCHELL’S latest additions to the ranks of Queen’s Counsel have evoked a good deal of criticism. It has always been said that Lord Herschell was wont to complain of the indiscriminate manner in which his predecessor, Lord Halsbury, distributed the dignity of “ silk,” but it is difficult to detect any difference between the policy of the two Lords Chancellor. It has almost come to this, that any barrister of ten years’ standing who has any professional or polit- ical position at all can have a silk gown for the asking: as Mr. Crump complains in the “ Law Times,” they are becoming cheap commodities ; “they are given to retire upon, to decorate pro- fessors, to ornament an inferior judge, to grace officials,” and the natural consequence of this o _ enlargement of the ranks of Queen’s Counsel has followed: a great number of them have nothing to do; they cut themselves adrift from the more laborious functions of junior practice, and dis- cover when it is too late that they have exchanged a competence for titled indigence. We have a great and substantial grievance to complain of at present. Since the Inns of Court a year or two ago facilitated the passage of solicitors from the lower branch of the profes- sion to the higher, there has been a constantly increasing stream of ambitious solicitors invading our ranks and rendering the competition for work much more intense. Men who come to the bar in this way have generally at their command many ramifications of interest and influence, so that it looks as if in the future anyone desirous

Page 38

36 Lhe Green Bag. of becoming a successful barrister would require to undergo a period of probation in the lower branch of the profession. Although a member of another Inn, I had an opportunity the other evening of viewing the Middle Temple Hall lighted as it now is by electricity ; the installation has proved an im- mense success, contrary to very general expecta- tion, for it was feared that the cold rays of the modern illuminant would strike unsympathetically against the dark oak carvings and massive woodwork of the time of Queen Elizabeth. Some criticism has been excited by the selec- tion of Lord Cross to succeed Mr. Cohen, Q. C., as ‘Treasurer of the Inner Temple for 1895. Lord Cross is a barrister, but he never became a Queen’s Counsel. As a junior he got into poli- tics and there made his mark as the possessor of the useful and practical talents, for brilliant he . never was, but he attracted Lord Beaconsfield’s attention when that eminent statesman was Mr. Disraeli, and was made quite unexpectedly Home Secretary. The duties of that responsible office he discharged with infinite credit, and made an impression so favorable at court that for a num- ber of years he has had the honor of arranging the Queen’s private investments. His business capacities are exceptional, and to this he chiefly owes his success. He is a man somewhat of the stamp of the late leader of the House of Com- mons, the Hon. William Henry Smith, another of Mr. Disraeli’s sagacious selections for Cabinet office, and that polished cynic has been credited with the sarcastic observation that he could never remember which was Mr. Smith and which Mr. Cross. Lord Cross is one of the most regular at- tendants at the Sunday morning service in the Temple Church, where, in his seat close by the NS pulpit, his well known figure is a characteristic feature of the legal congregation. London has been thrown into a turmoil for weeks over the triennial School Board election, which has just taken place and relieved us from the continuance of a very tiresome controversy. When I say that the question of religious instruc- tion was seized upon as the occasion of a trial of strength between the two political parties, for notwithstanding a considerable confusion of ordi- nary political classifications this was substantially the situation, you can imagine how embittered every one has been. We lawyers were hoping that the personalities of the contest would pro- duce a plentiful harvest of libel and slander ac- tions, but I hear that most of the wordy quarrels have been more or less amicably adjusted. If it were not for divorce cases, which seem to multiply, and defamation actions, there would scarcely be any work for barristers to do. There is beyond dispute a painful stagnation in litigat- ing activity. Lawyers would seem to have killed their goose, for people nowadays much prefer to suffer wrongs patiently than allow the profes- sion to unloose their purse strings. I am told that there was great rejoicing at Lincoln’s Inn on grand night last term, when the equity pundits discovered that the meager dainties of the table- d’héte, introduced as an experiment, had’ been displaced by the old-fashioned banquet in all its barbaric sumptuousness ; if there was an absence of variety there was plenty, and, after all, severe intellectual labor no less than manual toil breeds appetite. This is a very short letter, but, could, you be- lieve it, there is but very little of interest taking place. I cannot trespass on political grounds, and your readers would resent dry points of law. * * * 6A, we,

Page 39

7 _ for choice between result of the election is to demonstrate that the dates. _ grossly and persistently libelled than Judge Haight _ by the New York «* World.” He was accused of cor- CURRENT TOPICS. ELECTION OF JUDGES.— The result of the late judicial elections in the State of New York has been to confirm the Zasy Chair in its old opinion, that direct election by the people is the best way to choose judges. We know it seems to be deemed of late rather the elegant thing to denounce this method, even in the States where it prevails, and to point to England, the Federal Supreme Court, and Massachusetts as a demonstration of the better policy of appointment. But when we compare the quality of the, appointing power in those instances with that of the partisan and wild-cat governors of many States, the argument loses its apparent force. After all, experience is the best test, and in New York, considering the great number and the good quality of the judges since 1846, it is evident that the governors would not have chosen so well. In the last two years that State supplied an excellent object-lesson on the subject, with a result in favor of the people. In the election just passed both parties nominated worthy candidates. In several instances the nominee of one party was adopted by the other party. In the case of the Court of Ap- peals, the Democratic party made two _ perfectly unexceptionable nominations, the first nominee de- clining torun. The Republicans named and elected a gentleman of the highest character and abilities, who has been on the bench twenty-two years. He _ and his antagonist had sat in the Court of Appeals at the same time. There really was little room them personally. Another people in such matters are not apt to be unduly in- fluenced by newspaper and platform abuse of candi- There never was a judicial candidate more ruption and dishonesty, and of being a ‘‘corpora- tion judge”; charges utterly absurd in the estimation of all his townsfolk and of every man who knows him. By them, without respect to party, he is deemed a man of the purest integrity, the keenest sense of justice, the most moderate judgment, the coldest impartiality, and the most conscientious —e BY IRVING BROWNE. ce ne .. ake mee determination to do right. We have reason to believe that his excellent antagonist, Judge Brown, has despised and denounced those base attacks. No one even deemed it worth while to reply to them. The result was that they did not harm Judge Haight ; he was elected by a plurality a thousand larger than that of Lieutenant-Governor Saxton. Sometimes ‘¢a lie well stuck to” is zot so ‘* good as the truth.” ‘¢BORN FREE AND EQUAL.”—A writer in Mr. Astor’s ** Pall Mall Magazine ” sneers at the assertion in the Declaration of Independence of the American Colonies, that «* all men are born free and equal.” Probably the English snob, or the American truckler, who wrote the article would have sneered just the same if he had quoted the passage correctly. The Declaration does not assert anything of the kind. It is speaking of the natural, not of the social, condition of mankind. It says that ‘‘all men are created free and equal,” and so they are, and as the Declaration continuing says, ‘‘endowed by Nature with certain inalienable privileges, among which are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.” (We quote from memory.) When Mr. Astor desires to play the lick-spittle to the English, he should be careful not to misrepresent matters. Now let him set his writer to commenting on the English poet’s - declaration that ‘* Britons never can be slaves.” ‘¢ JUDICIAL IRRITABILITY.” — Several law journals have recently been speaking upon this subject, in- spired by some remarks in the ‘«‘ Sun” newspaper upon a judge who increased the punishment of a convict because of contempt of court, in that he laughed at the sentence. The judge was unwise. Indeed it is difficult to see how contempt of court can be predicated of such conduct. It may well be that the prisoner laughed purely out of light-heartedness because he got off so easily. Or it may have been hysterical, like laughter so common at funerals. Such severity of judges toward helpless criminals deserves censure. But great allowance should be made for judicial 37

Page 40

ay The Green Bag. irritability toward counsel both in criminal and civil cases. It must be very exasperating to an experi- enced judge to be forced to sit and appear patient while listening to an exposition of the most elemen- tary principles, and to the «‘ damnable iteration” of matters which would be sufficiently impressed by one telling. We once heard a lawyer explain to the New York Court of Appeals, for half an hour, the inferiority of negative to positive evidence. If we were a judge of that court, and any lawyer should so much as open his lips to say that the testimony of _ the witnesses who did not hear the engine bell ring or the whistle sound, was weaker than the testimony of those who did hear it, we should find it very diff- cult to restrain ourselves from throwing an inkstand at his head, although it may be conceded that it would be more dignified to fold our gown about us and stalk off the bench. Then again, it must be extremely irritating to be compelled to listen to genuine wit on the part of advocates and appear stupid and as if we did not. understand it. of the unwritten laws of the bench that counsel ought not thus to try the court. All jokes should be sub- mitted in the printed brief alone, and there counsel may dare to be as funny as they can. (Holmes — for fear Mr. Dana may take us up.) This is really a very foolish regulation. Law is certainly no more serious than religion, and when the clergyman says a good thing in his sermon, it is permitted, indeed he expects, that the hearers will rustle in the pews and smile. He usually pauses at this point, mops his marble brow, and takes a ladylike sip of water. But judging is certainly a very irritating business. It must irritate a judge terribly to see that counsel take it for granted that he does not know anything,. and still more to be obliged to confess to himself that the inference is only too well founded. It must irritate a judge to hear counsel pretending to quarrel, knowing that it is merely Pickwickian, and that they will drink together most amicably at recess. It must irritate a judge to hear counsel floundering awkwardly in some matter with which he happens to have been perfectly familiar before said counsel was born. It must irritate a judge to hear counsel cite such-and-such a case as the ‘‘ leading case,” when he knows that it is founded on a case of his own twenty years earlier. It must irritate a judge to be cau- tioned how he decides this case — that the eyes of the community, and particularly of the counsel are upon him. It must irritate a judge to have to listen hour after hour, and day after day, and year after year to interminable beatings of the same old straw. And so on ad infinitum. But the Bench has certain oppor- tunities for vengeance. Thus Mr. O’Conor, who was too apt to lecture the court, and caution them about the awful consequences of deciding against his | It is one - view of the law — which, of course, in the nature of things must always have been the right view — irri- tated the Court of Appeals (or at least Judge Allen) in the famous Tweed case about cumulative sen- tences, and Judge Allen irritated that great lawyer a great deal more by quoting from a former argument of his in another case to the direct contrary, and adopting that as the infallible rule of law. Mr. _ O’Conor would not speak to the court as they passed by, for a long, long time. We must not be too hard upon our judges. They are not angels, not even Jobs. Frequently when they appear im- patient, and are really irritated, it is because of a manifest waste of public time by unwise counsel. It may be that in the multitude of counsel there is safety; there certainly is tediousness. As we gen- erally kick our judges up to the bench in order to get rid of their rivalry at the bar, and divide their busi- ness, we should be very long-suffering with them. If poets and judges are an zrritabile genus, we must put up with them patiently. ‘¢ CONVINCED AGAINST His WILL.” — The inter- esting editorial writer of the New York « Law Journal ” quotes : — ‘‘ A man convinced against his will Is of the same opinion still.” Now a man cannot be ‘‘ convinced against his will,” and if he could be, he would not be ‘ of the same opinion.” What the poet said was :— ‘“‘ He that complies against his will Ts of his own opinion still,” NOTES OF CASES. NovEL CLAIMS OF LIBEL. — There havé been two recent singular complaints of libel in the English courts. One was by a Mr. Monson, who complained that his figure was represented in a waxwork show. Of this the «* London Law Journal” says : — ‘“‘Though members of the Royal Family, His Holiness the Pope, and His Eminence Cardinal Vaughan stand, by their counterfeit presentments, in the same place, and, as we learn on the same authority, submit without complaint to thus furnish instruction to the public and profit to the proprietor, Mr. Monson’s wrath is not assuaged by the pre- cedent, or soothed by the company which it secures him, He breathes of wax and threatens litigation; but will the law avail for his redress? To make the image of a man in wax is, beyond doubt, a cause of action if the melting the wax before a fire, or sticking pins into its substance, should — cause the man himself to fade away or suffer wounds; but — this species of damage has now for some centuries past — been classed as too remote. It is plain libel, too, to pic- —

Page 41

ae examine it without expense. Lhe Lawyers Easy Chair. ture anyone, whether by a drawing or a statue, in such a way as to hold him ‘up to hatred, contempt, or ridicule, as Mr. Lindley Sambourne found not long ago when he drew a member of Parliament in a fashion which would have blasted the fairest reputation of a portrait painter. Burn- ing a man in effigy, says a great authority, may be a libel; and if burning, why not pillorying? Were the showman to put his effigy in the Chamber of Horrors it might furnish a ground for claiming damages. But, in fact, the image is to be put in the most public part of the exhibition, where the timorous can see it without alarm, and the thrifty may Placed in the midst of the royal and saintly company to which we have referred, if he be graced with Hyperion’s curls, the front of Jove himself, the eye of Mars, or merely presented as he is, or as near thereto as the moulder can conveniently approach, of what can this objector complain? He loathes the celebrity which makes his features valuable property, and would probably shrink away from public notice for a time. But the law takes no account of a man’s modesty. Until quite recently it placed no price upon a woman’s.”’ All this comment is very sound, but we do not learn how the case came out. The other action was against the authorities of the British Museum for a libel contained in a book on its shelves. There was 2 recovery, the jury finding that the authorities had been negligent. Is it possible that they must read every book through, before they safely take it in? This would seem a somewhat onerous requirement. The plaintiff in this case was an American woman, formerly known as Mrs. Victoria Woodhull. MERCANTILE AGENCIES — LIABILITY TO SUB- SCRIBER. —In City Nat. Bank v. Dun, U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, second district, the defendants, who conducted a mercantile agency, agreed at the request of the plaintiff, in order to aid it in determin- ing the propriety of giving credit, to communicate to the plaintiff such information as they might possess concerning the mercantile credit of merchants, etc. ; that such information should be obtained and com- municated by subagents appointed in behalf of the plaintiff by the defendants; and stipulated the de- fendants Should not be responsible for any . loss caused by the neglect of any such subagent, and that the defendants should in no manner guarantee the actual verity or correctness of any such informa- tion. In consequence of a request for such infor- mation concerning Kitts of Oswego, a report con- cerning him was made up by Burchard, the defendants’ agent at that place, and was by him sent to the defendants, and by them to the plaintiff. Burchard and Kitts: were connected in business, and for the purpose of promoting his own interests, Burchard made false statements in that report. The plaintiff, relying on the report, discounted the acceptances of Kitts, which were valueless. It was held that the Sa defendants were not liable for the loss; that in transmitting the information which they had obtained they completely fulfilled the terms of their contract with the plaintiff; that the accuracy of the informa- tion so obtained was at the risk of the plaintiff; that in making the report, Burchard was not acting within the scope of his authority as agent of the defendant ; that he was not employed as the agent of either party in reference to the discounts which he caused to be effected; that he was merely an agent under the agreement of subscription to furnish infor- mation; that the defendants were agents of the plaintiff, and as it appeared from the agreement that the service required could not be rendered by the agent, but must mainly be rendered by subagents, the defendants were not liable for the errors or misconduct of the subagent, if they had used due © care in his selection. CRIMINAL LIABILITY OF DRINKER. — In State v. Cullins (Kans.), 24 L. R. A. 212, it was held that the purchaser of intoxicating liquor, sold illegally, is not a participant with the seller, and not punishable as an offender. The court distinguish between mala prohibita and mala in se, and cite State v. Rand, 51 N. H. 361; 12 Am. Rep. 127; Com. wv. Willard, 22 Pick. 476; Wakeman v. Chambers, 69 Iowa, — 169; 58 Am. Rep. 218; Harney wv. State, 8 Lea, 113. The principle is like that which screens the woman in cases of abortion. Verily the law is tender. toward the drunkard in criminal jurisprudence. RES GESTAE. — It seems that the tendency of the courts is toward leniency in the admission of proof of facts and circumstances in criminal cases, savoring of a self-serving nature and so far separated from the main transaction in time as not to be strictly of the nature of ves gest@. In Jones v. State (Alabama), 15 S. W. Rep. 891, on a trial for murder by shoot- ing, it was held error to exclude the declaration by ~ the defendant before the shooting that the gun was not loaded. The declaration was made on a railroad train on the way to the scene of the shooting, and the occasion of it was the gun’s falling down in the car and a caution to the defendant about the danger of its being thus fired, to which he replied that it was not loaded. The exact time elapsing between the time of this declaration and the time of the shooting does not appear, except that it was ‘¢a few hours,” but it appears that the gun was not charged in that interval. The Court very properly said : — “‘The degree of the guilt of the prisoner depended on the inquiry whether, at the time of the homicide, he be- lieved the gun was unloaded, and the reasonableness of the belief. The declaration was uttered a few hours before the

Page 42

AO The Green Bag. homicide, on the train on which the prisoner was an employee, in the course of continuous travel to the station at which the homicide occurred. It was a natural, instinc- tive response to the direction of his attention by the wit- ness to the falling of the gun, intended to allay the appre- hension of danger he reasonably supposed had been excited in the mind of the witness. The declaration may not, strictly speaking, form part of the ves geste; but it is con- nected with, and cannot be disconnected from, the inquiry, what was the state of the prisoner’s mind at the time of the homicide — did he then believe the gun was unloaded? The evidence, without conflict, shows that he saw the gun unloaded on the night before, and did not know, and had no opportunity of knowing, that it was subsequently re- loaded, when the declaration was uttered. The truth and spontaneity of the declaration are apparent, and it is cor- roboratory of the evidence of the prisoner that at the time of the homicide he did not believe the gun was loaded. We have no purpose to relax the general rule that declara- tions made by defendant in his own favor, not forming part of the ves geste — self-serving declarations, as they are termed — are inadmissible as evidence for him. But when, as in the present case, the inquiry is as to the state or con- dition of the mind of the defendant, his declarations uttered instinctively, with no purpose of producing a particular effect in the future, and which have a tendency to elucidate or illustrate his mental condition, are admissible.” NUISANCE. — OFFENSIVE TRADE.— In Rowland v. Miller, 139 New York, 93; 22 L. R. A. 182, it was held that an undertaking establishment in which hu- man dead bodies are prepared for burial or other sep- ulture, and sometimes subjected to embalming and post-mortem examination, is a business <<‘ injurious or offensive to the neighboring inhabitants,” within the terms of a restrictive agreement, although it may not constitute a legal nuisance. The Court observed : — “ The business carried on by the Taylor Company is not among those kinds particularly specified in the agreement. But the claim of the plaintiff is that. it is prohibited by the general clause in the agreement, as ‘injurious or offen- sive to the neighboring inhabitants.’ This clause enlarges the scope of the agreement. It is a too narrow construc- tion to hold that it prohibits only trades or kinds of bus- iness which are nuisances fer se for reasons already given, and for the further reasons that nearly, if not quite, all the trades and business specially named are not such nuisances. Any kind of business may become a nuisance by the man- ner in which it is carried on, from its location, and a bus- iness may be offensive to neighboring inhabitants, and yet fall far short of being a legal nuisance, which a court of equity will abate as such. This clause in the agreement must have a reasonable construction. We cannot suppose that the parties had in mind any business which might be offensive to a person of a supersensitive organization, or to one of a peculiar and abnormal temperament, or to the small class of persons who are generally annoyed by sights, sounds, and objects not offensive to other people. They undoubtedly had in mind ordinary, normal people, and meant to prohibit trades and business which would be offensive to people generally, and would thus render the neighborhood to such people undesirable as a place of residence. It can- not be doubted that the business of the Taylor Company was, within this definition, offensive to the neighboring res- idents. People of ordinary sensibilities would not willingly live next to a lot upon which such a business is carried on. An ordinary person, desiring to rent such a house as plain- tiff’s, would not take her house,if he could get one just like ‘it, at the same rent, at some other suitable and convenient place. Indeed her house would be shunned by people gen- erally who could afford to live in such an expensive house. The courts can take judicial notice of the offensive character of such a business. Judges must be supposed to be ac- quainted with the ordinary sentiments, feelings, and sen- sibilities of the people among whom they live: and hence, in this case, the learned judge, after the character of the business carried on by the Taylor Company had been proved, could have found, as matter of law, that it was in violation of the restriction agreement, without any further proof.” Vox ET PRETEREA NIHIL. — In Murphy v. Jack, New York Court of Appeals, April, 1894, it was held that an attachment may not issue on an affidavit made by the attorney, upon information and belief, and based solely upon a communication made to him by the plaintiff by telephone, without proof of the identity of the plaintiff, as by recognition of his voice. The Court said: — “There would be no objection to the information having been conveyed through the medium of the telephone, if it had been made to appear that the affiant was acquainted with the plaintiff, and recognized his voice, or if it had appeared in some satisfactory way that he knew it was the plaintiff who was speaking with him. None of these facts however were averred. There was absolutely nothing upon which the judge could pass to show that it was the plaintiff who was speaking, and not some undisclosed person who, in the plaintiff’s name, furnished to the attorney the infor- mation made use of. The perfection to which the inven- tion of the telephone has been brought has immensely facilitated the inter-communication of individuals at distant points, and inasmuch as the voice of the speaker ig heard, in most if not in all cases, the identification of the speaker should be possible. The very facility of communication and of identification permits, and therefore imposes a duty upon the party who invokes judicial action upon the strength of information so received, to state his knowledge or his grounds for believing that it actually came from the party required to furnish it. To authorize an attachment to issue upon the affidavit furnished here was in disregard of the rule which requires that the source of information shall be disclosed in such a way as to enable the court to decide upon the probable truth of the statements, andthe authenticity of the jurisdictional facts. Judicial action upon such a source of information as was here disclosed was justified below by analogy with telegraphic communi- cation. The analogy is incomplete. If the information comes through the telephone it is quite possible to identify the speaker. Then, too, there is not in the case of a telephonic communication any record, like the message which, in the case of the use of the telegraph, remains for reference and verification.”

Page 43

‘judicial wigs. The Green Bag. PUBLISHED MONTHLY, AT $4.00 PER ANNUM. SINGLE NUMBERS, 50 CENTS. Communications in regard to the contents of the Magazine should be addressed to the Editor, HORACE W. FULLER, 15% Beacon Street, Boston, Mass. A Happy New Year TO ALL! 3 THE GREEN BAG. END in your remittance for THE GREEN Bac for 1895 promptly, and receive, free of charge, the fine photogravure picture of THE SUPREME CouRT OF THE UNITED STATES. a LEGAL ANTIQUITIES. Tue following description of a court scene in 1761 (given by the first President Adams), on the occasion of the application for ‘ Writs of As- _ sistance,’”’ presents a vivid picture of the Court and Bar of that day: ‘In this chamber near the fire were seated the five judges, with Lieutenant Governor Hutchinson at their head, as Chief Justice, all in their new, fresh robes of scarlet English cloth, in their broad bands and immense In this chamber were seated at a long table all the barristers of Boston and its neighboring County of Middlesex, in their gowns, bands, and tie-wigs. ‘They were not seated on ivory chairs, but their dress was more solemn and more pompous than that of the Roman senate, when the Gauls broke in upon them.” FACETIZA. Jupce Underwood of Georgia, like other judges, sometimes gave charges to juries which were not the product of reflection. On one oc- casion he was presiding at Calhoun, in the Cher- okee circuit, for a brother judge, his own circuit being the Rome circuit. A case of some little consequence was being tried before him, Col. E. J. Kiker representing the plaintiff. The Judge adopted fully Col. Kiker’s view of the case, and so charged the jury. The jury, however, took a different view and returned a verdict squarely in the teeth of the charge. Brother Kiker im- mediately moved for a new trial, of course having the greatest confidence that it would be granted. Several days thereafter, the motion having been perfected, it was assigned for argument, and Brother Kiker arose and read his motion for new trial, basing it entirely upon the fact that the jury had found contrary to the Judge’s charge. Said Judge Underwood after the charge was read, “Brother Kiker, did I charge that?” ‘Yes sir, you did, and you have so certified, and the jury found for the defendant,” said Col. Kiker glee- fully and triumphantly, thinking there was no- thing to do but take an order setting aside the verdict. ‘Well then, Brother Kiker,” said the Judge, ‘if I charged that in this case, and the jury found against it, all I have got to say is, that that jury had more sense that I did, and I con- gratulate them that their good sense went to such an extent as to prevent them being mislead by the Court into a wrong verdict. I don’t care to hear from the other side, I over-rule the motion for new trial.” A New York man pleaded in his petition for divorce that “the defendant would not sew on this plaintiff’s buttons, neither would she allow him to go to fires at night.” The court decided that the plaintiff was entitled to a decree on the ground that his oppression was cruel and inhu- man. — Fx. - Lorp COLERIDGE was at Mount Vernon with Mr. Evarts, and talking about Washington, said : ‘‘T have heard that he was a very strong man physically, and that, standing on the lawn here, he could throw a dollar right across the river to the other bank.” Mr. Evarts paused a moment, to measure the breadth of the river with his eye. It seemed rather a “tall” story, but it was not for him to belittle the Father of his Country in the eyes of a foreigner. | ‘Don’t you believe it?” asked Lord Coleridge. “Yes,” Mr. Evarts replied, “I think it’s very likely to be true. You know a dollar would go farther in those days than it does now.” 4I

Page 44

42 In a Western Court a negro was convicted of stealing a mule. Before the sentence was pro- nounced the judge gave him an opportunity to speak for himself, and he said: ‘I wouldn’t er tuck de mule nohowef I hadn’t er red in de Tes- termint whar Jesus tuck a mule.” ‘The judge re- marked: ‘“ Yes, but he didn’t ride him to Kinston and try to sell him;” and thereupon he gave the negro three years in the penitentiary. — A WARRINGTON justice once reproved a would- be-suicide thus: ‘Young man, you have been found guilty of attempting to drown yourself in the river. Only consider what your feelings would have been had you succeeded.”’ Nort very long ago, troubles in a well-known Washington family were the cause of divorce pro- ceedings. ‘The wife got a judgment, though the husband had filed a strong cross bill. In a few months the ex-wife was again married, this time also to a Washington man. One evening, re- cently, at a large reception the two met unex- pectedly, and an acquaintance, not well up in the family history, was proceeding to introduce them. “‘Oh, we’ve met before,’”’ said the last husband, “‘we’re husbands-in-law.” CHANCELLOR Henry Batuurst was held in low esteem by the Bar on account of his ignorafice. At the close of the trial of the Duchess of King- ston for bigamy, he gravely addressed her grace in the following terms: ‘* Madam, the lords have considered the charge and evidence brought against, and have likewise considered of every- thing which you have alleged in your defense ; and upon the whole matter their lordships have found you not guilty of the felony wherewith you stand charged ; but, on dismissing you, their lordships earnestly exhort you not to commit the same crime a second time.”’ A Goop story is told of an English lawyer, who, having succeeded in making a litigant of every farmer in his county, having grown rich at their expense, and thus established a valid claim to their consideration, consented to sit for his por- trait, which was to adorn the court-room of the The Green Bag. county town. ‘The picture was duly painted by a London artist, and previously to being hung was submitted to a private view. ‘ Most uncom- mon like, to be sure,’’ was the general verdict. But one old chap, regarding the canvas critically, dissented from the prevailing opinion, as follows: “That be somewhat like his face, but it aint the man,—this man has got his hand in his own pocket, you see; now, I have knowed him for five and thirty years, and all that time he’s had his hand in somebody else’s pocket. This chap aint him.” CurRAN’s ruling passion was his joke, and it was strong, if not in death, at least in his last ill- ness. One morning his physician observed that he seemed to “ cough with more difficulty.” “That is rather surprising,’? answered Curran, ‘for I have been practising all night.” While thus lying ill, Curran was visited by a friend, Father O’Leary, who also loved his joke. “JT wish, O’Leary,” said Curran to him ab- ruptly, “ that you had the keys of heaven.” « Why, Curran ?”’ “Because you could let me in,” facetious counsellor. “Tt would be much better for you, Curran,” said the good-humored priest, “ that I had the keys of the other place, because I could then let you out.” said the NOTES. A CORRESPONDENT, writing from New Zealand, : says the police in that colony have the power, if they think a man is injuring his own health or neglecting his family as the result of habitual drinking, to take him before a magistrate and get his drink stopped for twelve months within a radius of twenty miles. After that, any hotel- keeper supplying such a man with drink, and any person privately giving him drink, is liable to a fine; and if a prohibited man is found the worse for drink, he is to be arrested at once, and sent to gaol for three months’ hard labor. — Tit Bits. In Waldeck, a little German principality, a decree has been proclaimed that a license to marry will not be granted to any individual who has the habit of getting drunk; and if one who

Page 45

Editorial Department. has been a drunkard applies for such license, he must produce sufficient proof of rcformation to warrant his receiving it. Dr. FRANKLIN thought that judges ought to be appointed by lawyers, for, added the shrewd man, in Scotland, where this practice prevails, they always select the ablest member of the profes- sion, in order to get rid of him and share his practice among themselves. Lorp ERSKINE’s humanity toward animals is perpetuated in his bill “ For the prevention of cruelt¥ to animals,” in one of his speeches upon which measure he passionately observed: ‘As to the tendency of barbarous sports, of any de- scription whatsoever, to nourish the natural char- acteristic of manliness and courage —the only argument I ever heard on such occasions — all I can say is this, that from the mercenary battles of the lowest of beasts—human boxers— up to those of the highest and noblest that are tor- mented by man for his degrading pastime, I enter this public protest against such reasoning. I never knew a man remarkable for heroic bear- ing whose very aspect was not lighted. up by gentleness and humanity ; nor a &7//-and-eat-him countenance that did not cover the heart of a ‘bully or poltroon.”’ LITERARY NOTES. ONE of the most readable of our legal exchanges is THE BRIEF, a new English law journal. Like THE GREEN BaG, it devotes itself to the bright and « en- tertaining” phases of the law, its contents being made up of legal gossip, anecdotes, legal miscellany” etc. We wish our trans-Atlantic contemporary the greatest possible success. If it keeps on as it has begun it will certainly achieve it. THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY for December contains a valuable and interesting paper on ‘ Re- sponsibility in Crime from the Medical Standpoint,” by Dr. Sanger Brown. He takes the ground that it is the physician’s province to determine the part played by bodily defect or disease in the commis- sion of crime, and that then society in general must, with this information, determine the degree of re- sponsibility and decide upon the punishment. The other contents of this number cover a wide and varied field, and are of unusual interest. =a _thony Froude. 43 ‘¢ MENTAL Training: A Remedy for Education” is the title of a radical paper by William George Jor- dan in the current NEw SCIENCE REVIEW. Mr. Jordan makes a strong plea for a mental training that will exercise all of man’s faculties and quicken his mind so that it will be ready on the instant. The method proposed is a system based on analysis, law and analogy, three cardinal points of the process. It is Clearly outlined and illustrated in a very practical way and contains many original ideas and sugges- tions. Itis based on the truest psychology and is thoroughly natural and simple in its working. The system covers constant exercises in training the senses, in observation; the use of words, illustration, des- cription, quickness in expression, etc., all following a prescribed order. In its completeness it is a forti- fied attack on the weaknesses of our educational system that deserves and will probably receive careful criti- cism. THE December number of the NORTH AMERICAN REVIEW is noteworthy for a number of important and very valuable articles. Hon. Wade Hampton contributes a timely paper on ‘‘ Brigandage on our Railroads”; and the Comptroller of the Currency, Mr. James H. Eckels, discusses ‘* Our Experiments in Financial Legislation.” ‘«* Consular Reform,” by Henry White, is a strong plea for reform in our Con- sular service. Henry Cabot Lodge pays a fitting tribute to Dr. Oliver Wendell Holmes, and Prof. Goldwin Smith has a delightful paper on James An-. The other contents of this number are unusually readable and interesting. THE Christmas number of HARPER’S MAGAZINE comes in a cover printed in colors from a special design, and is unusually strong in artistic features. More than one hundred pictures, signed by well- known names, illustrate its stories, poems, and gen- eral articles. The special features of the number are ‘¢ The Simpletons,” by Thomas Hardy; «‘ An Ara- bian Day and Night” (illustrated), by Poultney Bige- low; ‘* Evolution of the Country Club (with eight full- page illustrations), by Caspar W. Whitney; ‘The Time of the Lotus” (illustrated), by Alfred Parsons ; ‘¢ Taming of the Shrew” (with nine illustrations by Edwin A. Abbey), by Andrew Lang; «* Show Places of Paris by Night” (illustrated by C. D. Gibson), by Richard Harding Davis; and short stories by Robert Grant, Gertrude Hall, L. B. Miller, Julian Ralph, Harriet Prescott Spofford, and Ruth Mce- Enery Stuart. IN McCuure’s MAGAZINE for December, Miss Tarbell’s second paper on Napoleon treats of Napo-

Page 46

44 leon’s passionate love for Josephine in the early period of their relations, and of Napoleon’s swift rise to fame and supreme power through his brilliant achieve- ments in the Italian and Egyptian campaigns. There are fourteen more portraits of Napoleon, showing him at different times in this most interesting part of his career, and six other portraits, including one of Josephine, most of these pictures being after portraits from life by the great painters of the time, including David, Gros, Appiani, Laurent, and others. Then there is an excellent Christmas story, and a story which, while not a Christmas story in point of time, is pre-eminently one in spirit and conclusion; and, finally, a dramatic story ot the Napoleonic era by Conan Doyle. More dramatic, though, than any story, is Cleveland Moffett’s history, drawn directly from the archives of the Pinkerton Detective Bureau, of «‘ The Overthrow of the Molly Maguires.” THE complete novel for the December issue of LIPPINCOTT’sS is ‘‘ Mrs. Hallam’s Companion,” by the well-known writer, Mrs. Mary J. Holmes. A short story by the author of ** Dodo ” will attract general attention. In this case expectations will not be disappointed, for Mr. E. F. Benson has written nothing better than «*A Creed of Manners.” To what heights gentlemanhood can rise is the burden of this beautiful and touching little sketch. THE Christmas number of SCRIBNER’S MAGAZINE ’ presents aremarkable list of popular writers, includ- ing Rudyard Kipling, Robert Grant, H. C. Bunner,, Brander Matthews and.George W. Cable.. In illus- trations it shows a number of novel features. Oliver Herford produces a series of fantastic drawings which are curiously interwoven with the text of Brander Matthews’ story in a manner new to magazine illustra- tion. One of the richest illustrated articles ever pub- lished inan American magazine is the account of the great English painter, George Frederick Watts, R. A., by the eminent art critic, Cosmo Monkhouse, who writes from the fullest knowledge, and with the ap- proval of the artist. There are twenty pictures rep- resenting the most characteristic phases of Watt’s art, both the wood engravings and the process plates showing a delicacy that is seldom seen. THE ‘Progress of the World,” the editorial de- partment of the REVIEW OF REvIEws for December, sums up the significant results of the November elections, discusses the probable action of Congress on the ** Baltimore plan” of bank-note issues, com- ments on the progress of the civil service reform movement, and again emphasizes the extent of Eng- The Green Bag. land’s encroachments in Venezuela; the department also chronicles important movements in European politics, and the history of the war in China is brought down to date. ‘*Industrial Agreements and Conciliation” is the title of an interesting article by the Hon. C. C. Kingston, Premier of South Australia; this magazine is publishing a series of articles by leading Australian statesmen on questions of immediate interest to American readers. LITTELL’s LIVING AGE for 1895. For over half a century THE LIvING AGE has held a place in the front rank of American periodicals — coming week by week freighted with the most valuable literary products of foreign lands. It selects with rare judgment and discrimination the most masterly productions, scientific, biographical, historical, pol- itical; the best essays, reviews, criticisms, tales, poetry, in fact everything the intelligent reader most desires to obtain. To the busy man of affairs, and to the mistress of the family with time as fully oc- cupied with domestic cares an_ social duties, such a magazine is invaluable and to all classes of intelli- gent readers it proves a welcome visitor. An unpar- alleled offer is made to new subscribers whereby they may obtain the weekly issues of this sterling periodi- cal from the beginning of the current series, Ist of January, 1894, to the end of the year 1895, postpaid, for only $10.00. THE ARENA with its big Christmas number of over 200 pages opens the eleventh volume, and its in- creasing bulk as well as the repute of its contribu- tors, and the standard and character of its literature, indicate its extending influence and prosperity. In the December issue there are contributions from some of the greatest writers of our day, and some pf the most delightful and entertaining of the younger American essayists and fictionists.- In the former class are Professor Max Miiller, the great Oriental scholar and authority on language and comparative religion, of Oxford University, and Count Leo Tol- stoi, the famous Russian novelist and social reformer. In the latter are Hamlin Garland, the author of ‘¢Main Travelled Roads”; Will Allen Dromgoole, the. Southern story writer; Rev. Minot J. Savage, the famous Boston preacher, and B. O. Flower, the editor of the Review. THE CENTURY for December is a Christmas num- ber and attracts attention by a special cover in a novel and artistic design, and by the richness of its numerous and beautifully printed illustrations, of which twenty-five are of page size. Among the

Page 47

Editorial Department. 45 topics treated are the life of Napoleon Bonaparte, old Maryland homes and ways, the Italian Premier Crispi, science and religion, the labor question (in Kipling’s story) ; the painter Van Dyck, with three beautiful examples of his work engraved by Cole; Christmas poems by George Parsons Lathrop and Julia Schayer; Christmas stories, by Ruth McEnery Stuart, Sarah Orne Jewett, and Grace Wilbur Conant; Christmas pictures by Dagnan-Bouveret, Scheurenberg, Von Uhde, Wenzell, and F. S. Church; and other stories by Nannie A. Cox, Lucy S. Furman, Kate Chopin, and George A. Hibbard, besides serials by Marion Crawford and Mrs. Burton Harrison, in all ten pieces of fiction. BOOK NOTICES. Law. AMERICAN CasSES ON Contract. Arranged in accordance with the analysis of Anson on Contract. Edited by Ernest W. Hurrcut of the Cornell University School of Law, and Epwin H. Wooprurr of the Leland Stanford Junior University. Banks & Brothers, New York and Albany, 1894. Law sheep. $6.00 net. The students in our law schools are receiving special attention at the hands of our law writers, and every subject comes in for its share of illustration in the way of ‘* Selected Cases.” This volume of Cases on Contract is intended to accompany Anson on Contract, Lawson on Con- tract, or other elementary works, or to be used in connection with lecture courses, or without either text or lectures, as the teacher or student may desire. The cases have been selected with special reference to the needs of law students, and are intended to illustrate the essential principles of the law of contract. Where these principles are well established the editors seek by the cases to present the principles in concrete form, illustrating and apply- ing them. Where the principle is in dispute or doubt cases are given illustrating and discussing the ques- tion as viewed by different jurisdictions, and notes are appended directing attention to other and complete authorities. American cases have been printed to the exclusion of English cases, because it is believed that our own Federal and State Courts have examined and decided with equal ability, and for us higher authority, most of the principles applicable to the law of contract ; and also because there are already enough available collections of English cases. The aim of this com- pilation is to present a collection of American cases fully illustrating the subject of contract. THE Srupy or Cases. A course of instruction in reading and stating reported cases, compos- ing head-notes and briefs, criticising and com- paring authorities, and compiling digests. By Eucene WampaucH, LL.D., Professor of Law in Harvard University. Second edition. Little, Brown & Co., Boston, 1894. Cloth. $2.50 net. Sheep. $3.00 met. The purpose of this volume is an admirable one, the author’s endeavor being to instruct law students, by practice, rather than by precept, how reported cases should be read, digested, criticised and com- pared. Too little attention has heretofore been paid by our law teachers to this important subject, and as a consequence young lawyers have entered upon the practice of their profession laboring under a great disadvantage when it came to the analyzing and com- parison of cases. Mr. Wambaugh’s volume is divided into two hoes Book I. is devoted to a general consideration of the study of cases, and Book II. to cases for study. The student is urged, after a careful reading of the first chapter, to plunge at once into the cases printed in the second book, for by actually studying cases, and not by reading about the proper way of studying them, one best learns how they ought to be treated. Mr. Wambaugh has done his work thoroughly, and yet by his clear and concise statements has kept his matter within reasonable limits. We know of no book which will give the student more valuable aid in his preparation for practice, and even veteran prac- titioners will find much in its pages well worthy their attention. CouRTS AND THEIR JURISDICTION. A treatise on the jurisdiction of the courts of the present day, how such jurisdiction is conferred, and the means of acquiring and losing it. By Joun D. Works. Robert Clarke & Co., Cin- cinnati, 1894. Lawsheep. $6.00. Judge Works gives us in this volume a very clear and concise treatise upon the subject of jurisdiction, one which we are confident will prove to be exceed-. ingly useful to every practising lawyer. The author is not a superficial writer, but he goes to the very root of the matter in hand, and finds a reason for every why and wherefore, if there is one to be found. The arrangement of subjects is excellent. The treatise first discusses the general principles affecting juris- diction in all classes of cases, then follows an inquiry into the means of acquiring and losing jurisdiction, including the issuance and service of process ; next, the different classes of cases, writs, and proceedings, involving questions peculiar to themselves, are taken up separately and considered in a careful and thorough

Page 48

46 manner. Ample and well selected authorities are cited in support of the propositions advanced. The work should find immediate favor with the profession. THE AMERICAN STATE REpoRTS. Containing the cases of general value and authority decided in the courts of last resort of the several States. Selected, reported and annotated by A. C. FREEMAN. Vol. XXXIX. Bancroft, Whitney Co., San Francisco, 1894. Law sheep. $4.00. - The excellence of this series of reports is fully maintained in the present volume. Mr. Freeman’s work is always well done, but his annotations to the present selection of cases are even more exhaustive than usual. We have said many a good word for these reports, and they are certainly deserving of high praise. MEDICAL JURISPRUDENCE, FORENSIC MEDICINE AND ToxicoLocy, Vol. II. By R. A. Witruaus, A.M., M.D., and Tracy C. BEcKEr, A.B., LL.B. William Wood & Co., New York, 1894. Lawsheep. $6.00. In our April number (1894) we noticed the first volume of this important treatise, and the second vol- ume fully bears out the commendation we then ac- corded the work. In it the subject of Forensic Med- icine is further treated. Dr. Edward S. Wood contributes very interesting chapters on ‘‘ Examina- tion of Blood and Other Stains,” and «* Examination of Hair.” Dr. W. Thornton Parker has a valuable paper on ‘‘ Simulated Diseases,” and Dr. W. B. Outten one on ‘Railway Injuries.” * The other contents cover many important lego-medical ques- tions. As we have heretofore said (April, ’94) the work is one of sterling merit, the greatest care and research having evidently been bestowed upon its preparation. To criminal lawyers it will be invalu- able, while the general practitioner will find it of the greatest assistance. We recommend a careful exam- ination of the work by the profession. . AMERICAN RAILROAD AND CORPORATION REPORTS. Being a collection of the current decisions of the courts of last resort in the United States pertaining to the law of railroads, private and municipal corporations, including the law of insurance, banking, carriers, telegraph and telephone companies, building and loan as- sociations, etc., etc. Edited and annotated by Joun Lewis. Volume IX. E. B. Myers & Co., Chicago, 1894. Law sheep. $5.00 mez. All corporation lawyers will find these reports of much value and assistance. The selection of cases Lhe Green Bag. is evidently carefully made, and the annotations are full and well prepared. The cases reported cover almost every conceivable point likely to arise in Corporation and Railroad Law. CASES ON CONSTITUTIONAL LAw, with notes. Part Three. By JAMes BRADLEY THAYER, LL.D. Chas. W. Sever, Cambridge, Mass. $2.50. Prof. Thayer certainly deserves the thanks of the profession for this admirable selection of cases and for the exceedingly valuable notes which accompany them. One part more (to be issued about February 1, 1895) will complete the work. In its finished form it will be a most valuable addition to our legal literature, and both student and practitioner will be quick to appreciate its merits. MISCELLANEOUS. PHILIP AND His WirE. By MARGARET DELAND. Houghton, Mifflin, & Co., Boston and New York, 1894. Cloth. $1.25. In this, her latest work, Mrs. Deland struggles with a great social problem, and fails to reach any- thing like a satisfactory solution. She takes as the motto for her book, «* Marriage is not a result, but a process,’”’ and as may be inferred the story raises the oft-repeated question, ‘‘ Is mar- . riage a failure?’ When two individuals of such oppo- site natures as Philip Shore and Cecilia Drayton unite in marriage, the result cannot be expected to be very satisfactory, and in their case things come to’ the worst possible pass. Neither of them enlists the reader’s sympathy ; in fact, we have no patience with either of them. Philip is a prig, and by many will be considered even worse than that, while Cecilia is al- most equally unattractive. The other actors in this little drama are much more natural and pleasing, and possess more real interest for the general reader. ¢ The book is one of undoubted power, and Mrs. Deland as usual is deeply in earnest in her work, but she has chosen a disagreeable subject, one which we fail to see any good in publicly discussing. We like her better in ‘* Sidney” or ‘«* John Ward, Preacher.” Tur Frencu Revowtion Tested by Mirabeau’s Career. By H. Von Hotsr. Callaghan & Co., Chicago, 1894. ‘Two volumes. Cloth. These volumes contain twelve lectures delivered by Mr. Von Holst at the Lowell Institute, Boston, Mass., upon the history of the French Revolution. The main features of that stupendous uprising are illus- trated by the opinions of Mirabeau, the foremost political genius of its first age. Owing to the limited time allowed for each lecture the author was of course obliged to greatly condense his material, but he has,

Page 49

Editorial Department. nevertheless, given us a remarkably clear and inter- esting account of the causes which led to this fearful upheaval, and carries us with unflagging interest through the exciting scenes which followed. The book is a most valuable contribution to historical literature, and gives, perhaps, a better insight into French character and methods of that time than any work here- tofore published. Unlike most histories, it has a charm of style and diction which renders it almost as fascinating reading as a good novel. CATHERINE DE Mepici. By HONORE DE BALzac. Translated by KATHERINE PREscoTT WORMELEY. Roberts Brothers, Boston, 1894. Cloth. $1.50. In this work Balzac gives us some novel ideas of the character of Catherine de Medici, who, he asserts, has suffered more from popular error than any other woman in French history. The novel is a powerful one, intensely dramatic and of absorbing interest, dis- playing Balzac’s wonderful mastery of every subject upon which he writes. Miss Wormeley’s translation is in every way admirable, and the reading public are deeply indebted to her for so ably interpreting the works of this great writer. GEORGE WILLIAM CurTIs. By Epwarp Cary. Houghton, Mifflin & Co., Boston and New York, 1894. Cloth. $1.25. This is the latest contribution to the «* American Men of Letters” series, and Mr. Cary pays a most fitting tribute to one of the noblest men not only in the world of letters but in public life. Mr. Curtis’s life was a remarkable one, and should be closely studied by young men as a shining example worthy of imitation. Mr. Cary writes of him coz amore, and has gathered together a great deal of very interesting material in regard to his literary and political, as well as his home life. The book is an inspiration, and will give its readers a clear insight into a truly beau- tiful character. THE LITERARY SHopP, and other tales. L. Forp. York, 1894. By JAMES Geo. H. Richmond & Co., New In this volume Mr. Ford gives a delightful insight into the foibles of magazine editors and their con- tributors. Many interesting reminiscences of well known writers are given, and the author is in many instances frankly outspoken in his opinions. Some of his statements his readers will feel disposed to take issue with. An assertion that in the last half-dozen years we have but precisely one writer to show the fin- est American literary endeavor, and that writer a wo- man, will probably call forth a decided protest. The 47 book, however, is so charmingly written, and so full of pure, unadulterated humor, that one has but little inclination to quarrel with Mr. Ford. THE Srory OF LAWRENCE GARTHE. By ELLEN OtnEy Kirk. Houghton Mifflin & Co., Boston and New York, 1894. Cloth. $1.25. This is a realistic story of New York life, power- fully written and of great interest. The author’s for- mer works have given her an enviable place among our novelists, and the story of Lawrence Garthe is fully equal to anything we have had from her pen. It deserves a high rank among the novels of to-day. A CHILD OF THE AGE. Roberts Brothers, ‘$1.00. It is difficult to believe that this book is the work of a mere youth, but Mr. Adams had not, we be- lieve, attained his eighteenth year when it was writ- ten. Remarkable power is displayed by the author who, had he lived, would undoubtedly have attained a high position in the world of letters. The story is morbid and has but little plot, but there is a certain fascination about it which thoroughly enchains the reader’s attention. By Francis ADAMS. Boston, 1894. Cloth. THE WoruLp BEAUTIFUL. Roberts Brothers, $1.00. By Livian WHITING. Boston, 1894. Cloth. The papers which make up the contents of this attractive volume have for their keynote the truism, - that, after all, it rests with ourselves as to whether we shall live in a World Beautiful. They are pleas- antly written, and one cannot but receive encourage- ment and inspiration from them. THE POWER OF THE WILL, OR Success. By H. _RIsBoROUGH SHARMAN. Roberts’ Brothers, Boston, 1894. Cloth. 50 cents. Mr. Sharman maintains that the secret of all true and permanent success is the cultivation of the ‘+ will,” and that what is commonly called < luck” generally shows a marked preference for those who have duly cultured and restrained their mental and moral faculties. The book is an interesting and a helpful one, inculcating lessons which will benefit its readers. THE GREAT REFuSAL, being letters of a dreamer in Gotham. Edited by Paut Extmer More. Houghton, Mifflin & Co., Boston and New York, 1894. Cloth. $1.00. These letters, so Mr. More says, were written by a New York gentleman, of rare culture and prodig-

Page 50

48 ve The Green Bag. : ious learning, who died while comparatively young. They betray throughout the nervous, sensitive, dreamy temperament of the author. Numerous poems are scattered through the work, some of them evincing abilities of high order. The letters, ad- dressed to a lady-love, are exceedingly well written, and are well worth the reading. VOYAGE OF THE LIBERDADE. SLocum. Roberts Cloth. $1.00. Captain Slocum’s narrative of his adventures in the little craft built by himself, and measuring only thirty-five feet in length, has all the charm of ro- mance, and yet is literally true. The life of the seafar- ing man is graphically depicted, and the story abounds in terrible experiences and hair-breadth escapes. It will be read with interest by old and young alike. By Captain JosHua Brothers, Boston, 1894. A CENTURY OF CHARADES. By WILLIAM BELLAMY. Houghton, Mifflin & Co. Boston and New York, 1895. Cloth. $1.00. In this little volume Mr. Bellamy has provided en- tertainment for many a long winter’s night. One hundred original charades, which will tax the readers’ wit and ingenuity to their utmost, are furnished by the author, and many of them evidence not only the composer’s skill, but also his decided propensity for punning. The book is a delightful one for the family circle, where it will furnish much pleasure and amuse- ment. FATHER GANDER’S MELODIES, for Mother Goose’s Grandchildren. By ADELAIDE F. SAMUELS. Illustrated by Littian Trask Hartow. Rob- erts Brothers, Boston, 1894. Cloth. $1.25. While by no means equal to the world renowned productions of the original ‘*Mother Goose,” this little collection of nonsense jingles will delight its youthful readers. The illustrations are capital, and the book very attractive in every way. THE Minor Tactics or CuEss. A treatise on the deployment of the pieces in obedience to strategic principle. By FRANKLIN K. YOUNG and Epwin C. Howe... Roberts Brothers, Boston, 1894. Cloth. $1.00. _ This little volume is a veritable mzultum in parvo on the subject of chess. Small enough to be carried easily in one’s pocket, it contains more real informa- tion and sheds a clearer light upon the scientific principles of the game than any work we have ever read. Any lover of chess, playing over the games herein given and carefully following the analyses of the several moves will learn more in an hour than from days’ perusal of the larger and more pretentious treatises. ‘* The Art of War,” declared Napoleon, ‘¢can be comprehended only by the exhaustive study and comparison of the campaigns of the great cap- tains.” In the same way, by the study and compari- son of the recorded games of men who have risen to eminence as chess players, it is possible to discern a similarity in the methods of calculation and pro- cedure, which, if properly comprehended and reduced to a system, must become available as the basis, not only of a theory, but of the true theory of chess play, and to deduce from this system certain principles whose truth and applicability must be universally obvious at all times and in all circumstances of practice. This is what the authors of this volume have tried to do, and we think the verdict will be that they have been eminently successful. We com- mend the book to all lovers of the noblest of all games. WueEN Mo_ty was Six. By Eviza ORNE WHITE. Houghton, Mifflin & Co., Boston and New York, 1894. $1.00. Miss White is thoroughly in her element when she writes of children for children, and the little ones will be delighted with this story of Molly’s red-letter days, one in each month of the year. There is «*A birthday,” in January, ‘* A valentine” in February, an ‘* Afternoon tea” in March, and so on. The charm of the book is its naturalness and simplicity. Molly and her playmates are vea/ little girls, and not the insipid, colorless creatures so often introduced into juvenile literature. Books RECEIVED. JEWETT’S MANUAL FOR ELECTION OF OFFICERS AND VOTERS OF THE STATE OF NEw York. Matthew Bender, Albany, N.Y. Paper. 75 cts. A Review In Law AND Equity For Law STUDENTs. By Gro. E. GARDNER. New York. $2.75. | THE FEDERAL INCOME Tax EXPLAINED. By JOHN M. Goutp and GerorGcE F. Tucker. Little, Brown & Co., Boston. Cloth. $1.00. AMERICAN PROBATE LAW AND PRACTICE. By FRANK S. Rice. Matthew Bender, Albany, N.Y. Law sheep. $6.50. HANDBOOK OF THE LAW OF Contracts. By WituraM L. CLarK, JR. West Publishing Co., St. Paul. Law sheep. $3.75. PRACTICE IN ATTACHMENT OF PROPERTY FOR THE STATE OF NEw York. By GEORGE W. BRADNER. Matthew Bender, Albany, N.Y. Law sheep. $3.50. Baker, Voorhis & Co., | be bee See a ®t -