Podcasts · The Meaningful Money Personal Finance Podcast

QA63 - Listener Questions, Episode 63

21 Oct 2026 · 36 min · Episode 642

In this Meaningful Money Q&A, Pete Matthew and Roger Weeks answer six listener questions about UK investing, pensions and retirement planning. They explore investment fund risk ratings, funding the years before the State Pension, balancing pension saving with spending and family gifts, and how salary sacrifice, relevant UK earnings and pension carry forward work. The episode also examines how Armed Forces Early Departure Payments relate to the tax-free pension cash allowance, plus whether a £2,880 SIPP contribution could benefit a non-taxpayer approaching retirement. A practical UK personal finance podcast for anyone seeking clearer answers on investment risk, pension tax relief and making retirement income last.

Shownotes: https://meaningfulmoney.tv/QA63

01:45 Question 1

Dear Roger, Pete and Producer Kate,

Thanks for all the work you do in producing a great podcast. In a world where financial literacy is often kept behind a paywall, the clarity and confidence your show provides is more than just 'good content'; it's a public service that is genuinely levelling the playing field for all of us.

I wondered if you could impart some of your wisdom from advising clients over the years. At my workplace I'm that guy who tries to encourage the rest of the workforce to engage with their finances. I mainly do this through an internal discussion forum, getting some external speakers in once in a while and me generally trying to signpost good information for people to go and educate themselves. Rest assured the Meaningful Money podcast is top of the bookmarks list, closely followed by Bank of Dad for younger team mates.

I've hit a situation a few times now that I feel you must have seen on countless occasions in your careers and it is to do with risk ratings for investment funds.

The situation typically plays out like this. After being convinced that they should engage with their pension, and that the default fund may not be right for them, they go and prepare to move into a 100% equity global tracker and duly read the factsheet. And then they stop. They look at the section normally entitled something like "risk rating". Using the Vanguard platform as an example (but I think most are similar) a 100% equity fund is nearly always 6 out of 7 or 7 out of 7 on the risk scale.

To the newly self-aware but nervous investor they recoil in horror. The old objections start to flood in like: "But I'm not a gambler" "Does high risk mean I could lose it all?" "If a well diversified portfolio everyone says I should get is 6 or 7 what the heck is Bitcoin, day trading and all the other things I'm told to stay away from? Is this as bad as them?"

To me it seems there's a big problem with the way these ratings are presented. To my eye it would appear anything "low risk" is cash or cash like, anything in the middle is incredibly bond heavy and anything with a chance of beating inflation over a long time period is presented as very risky. It strikes me it should be reframed as maybe a "long term reward rating" or a "volatility index" because 'risk' has such an ingrained negative connotation.

I was wondering if you have any background into why these scales are presented in such an off putting manner and if you have any great ways of handling objections at the last minute based on your experience?

Thanks, Tom

12:45 Question 2

Hello Pete and Roger,

Love the show and the invaluable insights you provide on a weekly basis, keep up the good work!

I am 55 & my wife is 54 both hoping to retire when I turn 60. No children, so no big inheritance concerns.

I am in the LGPS Scotland pension scheme and projections at 60 suggest I will receive roughly £19k pa + a tax-free lump sum of around £50k.

My wife is in the NHS Scotland pension scheme and her projections suggest an annual pension of circa £9k with a tax-free lump sum of £15k.

I have been paying the maximum amount under salary sacrifice to the LGPS AVC scheme since we became mortgage free so there…

Links in the notes 1

• https://meaningfulmoney.tv/QA64

The episode on the publisher’s site ↗ (opens in a new tab)