13.3: Standards of Proof

Introduction to Criminology · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    13.3: Standards of Proof

    Standards of Proof [133]

    The standard of proof asks how convinced the trier of fact must be in order to make a finding. Canadian criminal law has three core standards:

    1. Proof beyond a reasonable doubt which is the standard to be met by the Crown against the accused;
    2. a balance of probabilities or Proof on a preponderance of the evidence which is the burden of proof on the accused when he has to meet a presumption requiring him to establish or to prove a fact or an excuse;
    3. Evidence raising a reasonable doubt which is what is required to overcome any other presumption of fact or of law. Once a prima facie case has been established by the evidence of the crown, there is no need to prove innocence. Rather the accused need only raise a doubt in the evidence.

    The US has a fourth standard known as "clear and convincing evidence" which is a middle ground between the two standards. When a proposition at issue in a case, such as an element of an offence, must be proven, the standard must be reached using the weight of the totality of evidence presented, not on each individual piece of evidence.

    Totality Principle

    When weighing evidence against any standard of proof, the general rule of totality will govern. Each piece of evidence or each fact cannot be considered in isolation to establish a fact. They must be considered in the context as a whole. This principle is central to consideration of Circumstantial Evidence .

    Standards

    The standard of proof for establishing a fact in most cases will be on a balance of probabilities. However, there are “certainly rare occasions when the admission of the evidence may itself have a conclusive effect with respect to guilt” where a standard of proof beyond a reasonable doubt may be required. Those exceptions that have a "conclusive effect" include confessions and hearsay evidence that satisfies the co-conspirators' exception.

    Generally, the standard of proof beyond a reasonable doubt will apply to essential elements of the offence, but not to any other facts.

    "Some Evidence" and " prima facie Case"

    The standard of "some evidence "prima facie case" are unique standards of proof that apply to certain evidentiary tests.

    These two standards are obviously lower than that of balance of probabilities.

    Balance of Probabilities

    The "balance of probabilities" is described as being "more probable than not", "more likely than not", or more technically, the chance of the proposition being true is more than 50%. This standard is known as the civil standard as it exclusively used in civil trial cases.

    Generally, where there are factual questions that are preconditions to the admissibility of evidence should be on a standard of balance of probabilities. This standard should only be increased "in those certainly rare occasions when the admission of the evidence may itself have a conclusive effect with respect to guilt".

    Admissibility Usually on a BOP

    In most circumstances the standard of proof required for the admissibility of evidence is on a balance of probabilities. Only in "rare occasions" where the admission of the evidence is determinative of guilt will the court apply a standard beyond a reasonable doubt. [5]

    Sufficiency of Proof

    Before any evidence gets to a trier of fact there is often a requirement to discharge an evidential burden for the trier of law (i.e., the judge).

    In a preliminary inquiry, the state must show on the whole that the evidence they will present is sufficient to potentially convict the accused. The purpose of this initial evaluation is to avoid frivolous suiting being brought in that has no chance of success.

    The standard of proof needed before evidence can be put to the jury is "whether the evidence is sufficient to justify him in withdrawing the case from the jury, and this is to be determined according to whether or not there is any evidence upon which a reasonable jury properly instructed could return a verdict of guilt."

    In a case where some of the evidence is not directly to the issue of the case, the state must satisfy the judge that "the evidence, if believed , could reasonably support an inference of guilt." [2]


    This page titled 13.3: Standards of Proof was last modified on Mon, 16 Nov 2026 23:25:19 GMT and is shared under a CC BY 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by George Cartwright.