3.5: Evaluating Scholarly Sources

Criminal Justice Research in Practice: An Applied Guide for Future Practitioners · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    3.5: Evaluating Scholarly Sources

    Finding information is only the first step. Criminal justice professionals also need to decide whether that information is trustworthy, relevant, and useful. Decisions made in policing, corrections, courts, victim services, and other criminal justice settings can affect individuals, agencies, and communities. Using poor-quality information can lead to ineffective or unfair decisions.

    Questions to Ask When Evaluating Information1

    When reviewing research or other sources of information, consider the following questions:

    • Who is providing the information?
      Consider the author's background, experience, and expertise. Is the information coming from researchers, a government agency, a professional organization, or an unknown source? People with education, training, and experience in a topic are generally more likely to provide reliable information.
    • Where was the information published?
      Information published in peer-reviewed academic journals is generally considered more trustworthy than information published on websites, blogs, social media, or opinion pages. Government reports and publications from reputable organizations can also be useful sources of information.
    • Does the source appear fair and objective?
      Consider whether the source presents evidence in a balanced way. Does it acknowledge different viewpoints and limitations, or does it seem focused on promoting a specific agenda? Understanding potential bias can help you evaluate the information more critically.
    • Is the information current?
      Criminal justice policies, laws, technologies, and practices change over time. While older sources may still be important, professionals should also consider recent research and current information.
    • What evidence supports the claims?
      Ask yourself what information the author uses to support their conclusions. Are claims supported by research, data, and documented evidence, or are they based mainly on opinions and personal experiences? Stronger evidence generally leads to more reliable conclusions.
    • Do other sources reach similar conclusions?
      A single study or report rarely provides all the answers. Look for patterns across multiple sources. When several high-quality studies reach similar conclusions, confidence in those findings increases.
    • Is the information relevant to the decision or problem you are facing?
      Even high-quality information may not be useful if it does not apply to your situation. Consider whether the source addresses the specific issue, population, program, or practice you are trying to understand.

    Identifying Red Flags When Evaluating Information

    As discussed above, not all information is equally reliable. Some common "red flags" that may indicate information is not trustworthy include:

    • No sources cited: Reliable information is supported by evidence from credible sources. If an article or post makes claims without identifying where the information came from, it is difficult to verify its accuracy.
    • Unsupported claims: Be cautious when an author makes strong statements but provides no facts, data, research findings, or examples to support them. Claims should be backed by evidence, not just opinion.
    • Emotional or sensational language: Information designed to make readers angry, fearful, or outraged may prioritize persuasion over accuracy. Trustworthy sources generally present facts in a professional and objective manner.
    • One-sided arguments: Issues in criminal justice are often complex. Sources that ignore opposing viewpoints or fail to acknowledge alternative explanations may present a biased picture of the issue.
    • Extraordinary claims without evidence: The more surprising or dramatic a claim is, the stronger the evidence should be. Claims that seem too good, too bad, or too unbelievable to be true should be carefully scrutinized.
    • Cherry-picked information: Some sources selectively present only the evidence that supports their position while ignoring evidence that contradicts it. Reliable sources consider the full body of available evidence, even when some findings do not support their conclusions.
    • Lack of author credentials: Consider who created the information. Authors with relevant education, training, experience, or professional expertise are generally more credible than anonymous or unqualified sources.
    • Outdated information: Criminal justice policies, laws, crime trends, and research findings can change over time. Always check whether the information is current and still relevant.

    Developing the habit of critically evaluating information is an essential skill for criminal justice professionals. Making decisions based on reliable evidence helps ensure fairness, accuracy, and ethical practice in both academic work and professional settings.

    Evidence-informed criminal justice professionals do not accept information at face value. They ask questions, consider the quality of the evidence, and compare information from multiple sources before drawing conclusions. By carefully evaluating information, professionals can make decisions that are more informed, effective, and fair.


    1. Content on this page adapted from Chen et al. (2024).

    This page titled 3.5: Evaluating Scholarly Sources was last modified on Tue, 03 Nov 2026 03:24:41 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Denise Borchert, Western Technical College.