8.6: Reading Results and Discussions

Criminal Justice Research in Practice: An Applied Guide for Future Practitioners · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    8.6: Reading Results and Discussions

    As a future criminal justice professional, you will often encounter research studies that make claims about topics related to your field. To evaluate these claims effectively, you need to understand how researchers present their findings and how to interpret the information they provide. Rather than focusing only on the authors' conclusions, it is important to examine the evidence, findings, and explanations presented throughout the results and discussion sections of a research report.

    What Should You Look for in the Results Section?

    The results section explains what the researchers found after analyzing their data.1 Researchers do not typically present all of their raw data, such as every survey response or interview transcript. Instead, they summarize the information and report the findings that help answer the study's research questions. When reading the results section, focus on the questions the researchers are trying to answer. Researchers often remind readers of the research question, explain the answer in words, present the supporting statistics, and then summarize the findings. Even if you do not understand every statistical detail, you should still be able to identify the main finding and understand how it relates to the research question.

    Ask yourself:

    • What question is the researcher trying to answer?
    • What did the researchers find?
    • What evidence supports that finding?
    • Does the evidence seem strong enough to support the claim being made?

    How to Read a Table

    Many students skip tables because they appear complicated. However, tables are often one of the fastest ways to understand a study's findings.2 Tables provide a condensed summary of important information and can help you identify patterns before reading the researchers' interpretation of the results.

    When reading a table, start with the title. The title tells you what information is being presented in the table.3 Next, look at the rows and columns to see what is being compared. Some tables provide basic information about the people who participated in the study. These tables often use N to show the number of participants and % to show the percentage of the sample in each group. For example, a table might show how many participants were male or female and what percentage of the sample each group represented.

    As another example, a criminal justice study might report that 60% of participants were police officers, 25% were probation officers, and 15% were correctional officers. This type of table helps you understand who participated in the study before you evaluate the findings.

    Looking for Relationships in a Table

    Some tables are designed to help readers compare groups and identify relationships between variables. In these tables, readers can compare numbers across rows or columns to see how outcomes differ between groups.4

    Imagine a study examining whether participation in an offender reentry program is related to recidivism. One column might show participants who completed the program, while another column shows participants who did not. If the recidivism percentages are lower for program participants, the table suggests a relationship between program participation and lower recidivism rates.

    As you read these tables, ask yourself:

    • Which groups are being compared?
    • What differences do I see in the numbers?
    • Are the differences large or small?
    • Do the findings appear to support the researchers' claims?

    Paying Attention to Statistical Significance

    Many quantitative research tables include information about statistical significance, which helps readers determine whether a finding is likely to represent a real relationship rather than a pattern that occurred by chance alone.5 Before analyzing data, researchers establish a significance level, which is the risk threshold they are willing to accept that their conclusion may be wrong because the results occurred by chance.6 A significance level of .05 means researchers accept a 5% risk of making that error. The lower the probability that results occurred by chance, the greater the confidence that the findings reflect a real relationship rather than random variation.

    You do not need to be a statistician to be a good consumer of research. Many researchers will explicitly state in their publication whether their findings are statistically significant. When reviewing a study, pay attention to whether researchers report that a finding is statistically significant.7 If they do, the relationship is less likely to be the result of random chance. If a finding is not statistically significant, readers should be cautious about drawing strong conclusions from the result.

    Considering Practical Significance

    When reading research, it is important to remember that a finding can be statistically significant without being very important. Statistical significance tells researchers that a result is unlikely to have occurred by chance alone. However, statistical significance does not tell us how strong, meaningful, or useful the finding is in the real world.8

    Researchers use the term practical significance to describe the real-world importance or usefulness of a finding. A result may be statistically significant but still have little practical value. This can occur when a study finds a very small relationship or difference that becomes statistically significant because the study included a large number of participants.

    A finding can be statistically significant but not practically significant. For example, imagine a study finds that officers who complete a new report-writing training program finish their reports 30 seconds faster than officers who do not complete the training. The difference is statistically significant, meaning it is unlikely to have occurred by chance. However, saving 30 seconds per report may not meaningfully improve officer performance, public safety, or agency operations. In this case, the finding has statistical significance but little practical significance because the effect is too small to make a meaningful difference in the real world.

    In contrast, a finding may have both statistical significance and practical significance. For example, suppose a study finds that participation in a reentry program reduces recidivism from 40% to 25%. The reduction is statistically significant, suggesting that it is unlikely to have occurred by chance. It is also practically significant because a 15% decrease in recidivism could lead to fewer arrests, lower correctional costs, and improved public safety. The finding has meaningful real-world implications, since it is considered both statistically and practically significant.

    These examples demonstrate an important point for criminal justice professionals. Statistical significance helps determine whether a finding is likely real, while practical significance helps determine whether that finding is important enough to influence policies, programs, or professional practice.

    When evaluating research findings, ask yourself:

    • Is the finding statistically significant?
    • How strong is the relationship or difference?
    • Would the finding make a meaningful difference in practice?
    • Is the benefit large enough to justify the resources needed to implement a change?

    Understanding practical significance can help you avoid assuming that every statistically significant finding is automatically important. As a critical consumer of research, you should consider not only whether a finding is real, but also whether it is meaningful enough to influence policies, programs, or professional practices.9

    Reading Qualitative Results

    Not all criminal justice research relies on numbers. Qualitative studies often explore people's experiences, perceptions, and perspectives through interviews, observations, documents, and case studies. Instead of presenting findings primarily through statistics, researchers often use participant quotes, stories, and detailed descriptions to illustrate important themes.10 When you read qualitative research, do not focus only on the quotes. The quotes are evidence, but the researcher must explain why those quotes matter and how they connect to the study's findings. Researchers are responsible for interpreting the evidence and helping readers understand the meaning behind the participants' words.

    For example, a study on prosecutor stress might include quotes describing long work hours, staffing shortages, or deadline concerns. As a reader, you should look beyond the individual quote and consider the larger theme the researcher is identifying. What pattern is emerging across multiple participants? What does that pattern tell us about the issue being studied?

    What Should You Look for in the Discussion Section?

    After presenting the findings, researchers move into the discussion section. The discussion usually begins with a summary of the study's results and an answer to the research question.11 This is where they explain what the findings mean and why they matter. Researchers then explain the broader implications of their findings. They may discuss how the results support or challenge existing theories, how the findings can be applied in practice, or what the results suggest about a particular problem or policy.

    As a future criminal justice professional, pay close attention to these practical implications. Researchers may suggest changes to training programs, correctional interventions, victim services, crime prevention efforts, or public policies. Understanding these implications can help you evaluate whether the evidence justifies the recommendations being made.

    Looking for Limitations

    Good researchers also acknowledge the limitations of their studies. They discuss factors that may have influenced the results and explain how those limitations should affect the interpretation of the findings.12 Researchers may also suggest directions for future research and identify questions that still need to be answered.

    When reading the discussion section, ask yourself:

    • What limitations did the researchers identify?
    • Could these limitations affect the conclusions?
    • Are there alternative explanations for the findings?
    • What additional research might be needed?

    Becoming a Critical Consumer of Research

    Throughout this chapter, you learned how researchers move from raw data to findings and from findings to conclusions. You also learned how quantitative and qualitative data are analyzed, how researchers present their results, and how statistical and practical significance can help readers evaluate research. These skills are important because, as a future criminal justice professional, you will regularly encounter research findings in reports, policy discussions, professional publications, and media stories. Understanding research is not just about knowing what researchers concluded. It is about determining whether the conclusions are supported by the evidence.

    When reading research, your goal should be to think critically about the information presented. Researchers collect evidence, analyze that evidence, identify findings, and draw conclusions. As an informed consumer of research, you should carefully evaluate each step of that process rather than automatically accepting the conclusions. This means examining the evidence, reviewing the findings, and determining whether the conclusions are reasonable based on the information presented.

    As you read a research study, ask yourself the following questions:

    • What did the researchers actually find?
    • Do the findings support the conclusions?
    • Are the claims larger than the evidence supports?
    • Did the researchers acknowledge limitations?
    • Are alternative explanations possible?

    These questions can help you distinguish between evidence-based conclusions and conclusions that may go beyond what the data can support.

    You should also apply the same critical thinking skills when examining tables, charts, and graphs. Visual displays can make findings easier to understand, but they still require careful evaluation. Rather than looking only at the researchers' interpretation, examine the information presented for yourself.

    Ask questions such as:

    • What is being measured?
    • What population was studied?
    • What groups are being compared?
    • What trend or pattern appears in the data?
    • Does the figure actually support the author's claim?

    As a future criminal justice professional, you will likely make decisions that affect individuals, communities, and organizations. Those decisions should be based on evidence rather than assumptions, opinions, or headlines. By understanding how research is conducted, how findings are presented, and how conclusions are drawn, you can become a more thoughtful and informed consumer of research. The ultimate goal is not simply to know what a study says, but to determine whether the evidence justifies the conclusions being made and whether those conclusions should influence criminal justice policy, practice, or decision-making.


    1. (Jhangiani et al., 2019).
    2. (DeCarlo, 2018).
    3. (DeCarlo, 2018).
    4. (DeCarlo, 2018).
    5. (DeCarlo, 2018).
    6. (Bhattacherjee, 2019).
    7. (DeCarlo, 2018).
    8. (Jhangiani et al., 2019).
    9. (Jhangiani et al., 2019).
    10. (Arthur & Clark, 2021).
    11. (Jhangiani et al., 2019).
    12. (Jhangiani et al., 2019).

    This page titled 8.6: Reading Results and Discussions was last modified on Tue, 03 Nov 2026 03:24:45 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Denise Borchert, Western Technical College.