Opening the book…
Whom do we trust?
More than ever before, we have an incredible amount of information at our fingertips, and a simple internet search on any given research topic might result in a number of contradictory studies.1 In these cases, we are witnessing the scientific community going through the process of reaching a consensus, and it could be quite some time before a consensus emerges. In the meantime, we should strive to think critically about the information we encounter by exercising a degree of healthy skepticism. When someone makes a claim, we should examine the claim from a number of different perspectives: what is the expertise of the person making the claim? This is especially important when we consider how much information in advertising campaigns and on the internet claims to be based on “scientific evidence” when, in actuality, it is a belief or perspective of just a few individuals trying to sell a product or draw attention to their perspectives.
We should be informed consumers of the information made available to us because decisions based on this information have significant consequences.2 One such consequence can be seen in politics and public policy. Imagine that you have been elected as the governor of your state. One of your responsibilities is to manage the state budget and determine how to best spend your constituents’ tax dollars. As the new governor, you need to decide whether to continue funding early intervention programs. If you are committed to being a good steward of taxpayer money, you would want to look at research. Which programs are most effective? What characteristics of these programs make them effective? Which programs promote the best outcomes? After examining the research, you would be best equipped to decide which programs to fund.
While this is a bigger example, it is very relatable to criminal justice professions. A police agency or correctional facility also operates with taxpayer-funded budgets, and research informs decisions about safety, effectiveness, and fairness. Research can help practitioners identify strategies that reduce injuries to officers, correctional staff, and community members. For example, studies can evaluate de-escalation techniques, crisis intervention approaches, or officer safety practices to determine what works best in different situations. When criminal justice professionals use evidence-based practices, they are better equipped to respond to incidents in ways that protect themselves and others.
Research also plays an important role in protecting constitutional rights. Criminal justice professionals regularly make decisions that affect people's freedoms, privacy, and due process rights. Research can help agencies evaluate whether their policies and practices are being applied fairly and consistently. It can also identify unintended consequences, such as practices that disproportionately affect certain groups or increase the risk of wrongful arrests or convictions. By using research to guide decision-making, practitioners can better balance public safety goals with their responsibility to uphold the rights guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution. In this way, research is not just a tool for improving outcomes; it is also a tool for promoting professionalism, accountability, and public trust.
In the end, research is what makes the difference between facts and opinions.3 Facts are observable realities, and opinions are personal judgments, conclusions, or attitudes that may or may not be accurate. In the scientific community, facts can be established only using evidence collected through empirical research. This distinction is important for criminal justice practitioners because many decisions in the field are based on information, policies, and procedures that have real consequences for safety and justice. Imagine asking a field training officer, supervisor, or instructor why a particular practice is used. Which answer would give you more confidence? "I do not really know. That is the way we have always done it," or "We implemented this practice after attending training based on research that showed it improved outcomes by providing a structured approach for situations like this. Since implementing the practice, we have seen a significant reduction in the behavior we were trying to prevent." Most people would have greater confidence in the second answer because it is supported by evidence rather than tradition or personal opinion. This does not mean that experience is unimportant. Experienced practitioners have valuable knowledge, but research helps determine whether a practice is actually producing the intended results. By combining professional experience with research evidence, criminal justice professionals can make more informed decisions that improve safety, effectiveness, and fairness.
Types of Sources4
When learning about a criminal justice topic, you will encounter many different types of sources. Each type serves a different purpose, and understanding these differences can help you find and use information more effectively.
In general, you should focus on peer-reviewed sources whenever possible. Peer-reviewed articles have been evaluated by experts in the field before publication. These experts review what the author wrote and provide feedback to the author. Authors are often required to revise their work before it is accepted for publication. This review process helps improve the quality of research, although it does not guarantee that a study is perfect. Peer-reviewed sources undergo greater scrutiny than most other sources, so they are often considered more trustworthy for making evidence-informed decisions.
Most scholarly research is published in academic journals, which are publications that contain articles written by researchers and experts in a particular field. Some journals cover a wide range of topics within a discipline, while others focus on a specific area. In criminal justice, for example, some journals publish research on many topics, while others focus on areas such as policing, corrections, juvenile justice, or victimology.
Journal articles are written primarily for other scholars and professionals. Because of this, they often include references to previous studies, use discipline-specific terminology, and explain how the research connects to what is already known about a topic. These references allow readers to examine the evidence for themselves and follow the development of ideas within the field.
Because peer-reviewed journal articles are carefully evaluated before publication, they are a primary source of evidence used by researchers, practitioners, and policymakers. When you are looking for scholarly information about a criminal justice issue, peer-reviewed journal articles are often the best place to start. If you are unsure whether a journal is peer-reviewed, check the journal's website, use your library's database filters, or ask a librarian for assistance.
You should also focus on sources that are directly related to criminal justice. However, some topics overlap with other fields, such as psychology, sociology, public health, or social work. In those cases, research from related disciplines can provide valuable information and help you better understand complex issues.
Scholarly Sources
As you search for sources, you will encounter several common types of scholarly publications.
Empirical Studies
Empirical studies report the findings of a research study. Researchers collect or analyze data and use that information to answer a specific question. For example, an empirical study might examine whether body-worn cameras affect citizen complaints, whether a treatment program reduces recidivism, or whether a policing strategy changes crime rates.
Empirical studies are often the foundation of evidence-informed practice because they provide direct evidence about a topic.
You can often identify the type of article by looking at its structure.
Empirical studies usually contain sections such as Methods, Results, or Findings because the authors are reporting data they collected or analyzed.
Review Articles
Review articles summarize and discuss what researchers have learned from many studies on a topic. Instead of collecting new data, the author reviews existing research and identifies major findings, patterns, and areas where researchers disagree.
Review articles are often a good starting point when learning about a new topic because they provide an overview of the available evidence.
Systematic Reviews
A systematic review is a specialized type of review article that follows a structured process to locate, evaluate, and summarize research studies. Systematic reviews are designed to reduce bias and provide a clear picture of what the available evidence shows about a specific question.
For example, a systematic review might examine whether a particular correctional intervention reduces recidivism across multiple studies.
Meta-Analyses
A meta-analysis combines the results of many studies using statistical methods. Rather than looking at the findings of a single study, a meta-analysis examines the overall pattern across multiple studies.
Since they draw from a large body of research, meta-analyses can provide a stronger understanding of what the evidence suggests about a topic. They are often considered among the most useful sources for evidence-informed decision-making.
Although review articles and meta-analyses are useful starting points, they should not be treated as the final word on a topic. They reflect the author's interpretation of the available evidence, and researchers may disagree about what the evidence means. For this reason, it is important to read critically and compare information from multiple sources.
Theoretical Articles
Theoretical articles focus on explaining concepts, ideas, or theories rather than reporting new research findings. These articles help researchers and practitioners understand why certain behaviors, patterns, or outcomes may occur.
While theoretical articles may not provide direct evidence, they can help explain how researchers interpret and understand criminal justice issues.
Review articles, systematic reviews, and theoretical articles often do not include methods and results sections in the same way. Instead, they focus on summarizing, evaluating, or explaining existing research.
Other Scholarly Sources5
While peer-reviewed journal articles are usually the best source of scholarly information, you may encounter other types of sources during your research.
Academic books are another important source of scholarly information. Some books focus on a single topic in depth and are written by one or more experts. These books are often published by university presses and are typically reviewed by other scholars before publication. Since they allow authors more space to explore a topic, academic books can provide detailed background, history, and analysis that may not fit into a journal article.
You may also find edited books, which contain chapters written by different authors on a related topic. These chapters can provide useful information, but the review process is often less rigorous than that used for peer-reviewed journal articles.
Other sources, such as textbooks, academic encyclopedias, government reports, and research reports from professional organizations, can be useful when you are first learning about a topic. These sources often provide summaries, definitions, statistics, and background information that can help you understand a criminal justice issue. However, they are generally best used as starting points that lead you to more detailed scholarly research.
Other Types of Sources
You may also encounter gray literature, which includes reports, policy briefs, and research published by government agencies, nonprofit organizations, and think tanks. Some of these sources contain valuable information, especially official statistics and reports. However, they are not usually peer-reviewed and may reflect the mission or perspective of the organization that produced them. As a result, they should be evaluated carefully.
Other materials, such as newspaper opinion pieces, blogs, conference presentations, dissertations, and theses, can sometimes provide useful insights or point you toward additional sources. However, because they often have not gone through the same peer-review process as journal articles, they should generally not be relied on as your primary source of evidence.
Sources Citing Other Sources
When reviewing scholarly information, it can also be helpful to look at how often a source has been cited by other researchers. Frequently cited articles and books are often influential within a field and may help you identify important studies on a topic. However, citation counts alone do not determine quality, so they should be considered alongside other factors such as relevance, credibility, and research quality.
As a general rule, start with peer-reviewed journal articles, use academic books when you need more depth and context, and use other sources to expand your understanding and locate additional research.
Understanding the different types of scholarly sources can help you become a more effective consumer of research. Rather than relying on a single study, evidence-informed practitioners look at multiple sources and consider the broader body of evidence when making decisions.
Finding Scholarly Sources of Information6
When you need information about a criminal justice topic, the goal is not to become a researcher. The goal, instead, is to find trustworthy research that can help you better understand an issue and make informed decisions. Finding useful scholarly sources typically involves four basic steps:
- Finding the right database
- Using effective search terms
- Skimming articles to see whether they are relevant
- Reviewing references to find additional sources
Most libraries and schools provide access to online databases that contain scholarly journal articles, government reports, and other academic sources. These databases make it possible to find high-quality information without searching through shelves of books. The databases available to you will vary from one library to another because access depends on which resources an institution pays to provide. For that reason, the specific databases and search tools you use may differ from the ones used by students at other colleges or libraries. If you need help finding or using databases, your library and learning support services are valuable resources. Librarians can help you identify appropriate databases, develop effective search strategies, and locate relevant sources.
Another useful tool is Google Scholar (https://scholar.google.com/), a search engine designed specifically for academic sources. Google Scholar searches across many disciplines and can help you locate journal articles, books, reports, and other scholarly materials. Unlike some databases that require you to use specific search formats, Google Scholar is designed to understand everyday language, making it a good starting point when you are exploring a topic.
As you search for information, pay attention to the sources that researchers cite in their reference lists. These references can lead you to additional studies and help you develop a broader understanding of the topic. By starting with strong scholarly sources and following related references, you can find reliable information that supports evidence-informed criminal justice practice.
- (Spielman et al., 2020).
- (Spielman et al., 2020).
- (Spielman et al., 2020).
- Section reused from Chen et al. (2024).
- Adapted from Chen et al. (2024).
- Adapted from Chen et al. (2024).
This page titled 3.1: How to Find Sources of Information was last modified on Tue, 03 Nov 2026 03:24:41 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Denise Borchert, Western Technical College.
The book could not be loaded just now.