Opening the book…
A Brief Historical Look at Research on Humans
Criminal justice is fundamentally a human profession. Whether working in law enforcement, courts, or corrections, criminal justice professionals make decisions that affect people's rights, safety, opportunities, and lives. Because of this, much criminal justice research involves human beings. Researchers may study police officers, correctional staff, crime victims, people who have committed offenses, jurors, communities, or others connected to the justice system. As future criminal justice professionals, it is important to understand how researchers are expected to treat participants ethically and why those protections exist. Learning about the history of research involving human subjects helps us understand both the value of research and the responsibility that comes with collecting and using information about people.
The ethical rules that guide research today did not appear overnight.1 They developed in response to serious mistakes and harms that occurred in the past. The examples below are some important historical cases that shaped modern research ethics. They are not the only examples. Many other cases have influenced how research is conducted today. However, these examples help illustrate why strong ethical standards are necessary when conducting research with human participants.
Some of the earliest documented examples of research involving human subjects occurred in medical studies. In the late 1700s, physician Edward Jenner tested an early smallpox vaccine by exposing an 8-year-old boy to the disease. While the study contributed to an important medical breakthrough, it took place long before modern ethical standards and participant protections existed.
For many years, research involving human subjects was conducted with little formal oversight. This changed significantly after World War II. During the war, Nazi doctors and scientists conducted cruel and deadly experiments on people who were imprisoned in concentration camps. These individuals were forced into research without their consent and suffered severe physical and psychological harm. After the war, the responsible doctors and scientists were tried in Nuremberg, Germany.
One important lesson from these trials is that having rules on paper does not automatically protect people. Germany already had written regulations stating that research participants should voluntarily agree to participate. The Nazi researchers ignored those rules. This reminds us that ethical research depends not only on regulations but also on researchers' commitment to respecting human rights and human dignity.
The Nuremberg trials led to the development of the Nuremberg Code, a set of ten principles designed to guide ethical research involving human subjects. One of its most important ideas is that people must voluntarily choose whether to participate in research. The Nuremberg Code continues to influence research ethics today, including research conducted in criminal justice and the social sciences.
Unethical research has occurred outside of medicine as well. In the 1960s, psychologist Stanley Milgram conducted a series of studies to examine obedience to authority. Participants were led to believe that they were delivering electric shocks to another person as part of an experiment. The shocks were not real, but the participants did not know that at the time. Many experienced significant emotional stress during and after the study. While Milgram's research produced important findings about human behavior, it also raised serious questions about deception in research and the responsibility researchers have to protect participants from psychological harm.
Another important example is the Tuskegee Syphilis Study, conducted in Alabama between the 1930s and 1970s. Researchers enrolled hundreds of poor African American men, some with syphilis and some without, to study how the disease progressed over time. Even after effective treatment became available in the 1940s, researchers intentionally withheld treatment from participants so they could continue observing the disease. The men were not fully informed about the study or the treatment options available to them.
In 1972, when the public learned about the Tuskegee study, there was widespread outrage. The study became a powerful example of how research can harm participants when ethical principles are ignored. It also contributed to public distrust of research and government institutions.
The Belmont Report
The Tuskegee study led to major changes in how research involving human subjects is reviewed and monitored in the United States. In 1974, Congress passed the National Research Act, which created a national commission to examine research ethics and participant protections. The commission later produced the Belmont Report in 1979, a landmark document that continues to guide research involving human subjects today.
The Belmont Report identifies three core ethical principles:
- Respect for Persons: People should be treated as autonomous individuals who can decide for themselves whether to participate in research. People with diminished autonomy require extra protections. Participants must give voluntary, informed consent.
- Beneficence: Researchers should maximize potential benefits and minimize possible harms. Researchers must use sound, safe research designs intended to “do no harm.”
- Justice: The benefits and burdens of research should be distributed fairly among different groups of people.
These principles remain especially important in criminal justice research. Many criminal justice studies involve individuals and groups who may be vulnerable because of their age, legal status, victimization, incarceration, or other circumstances. As future evidence-informed practitioners, understanding the history of research ethics will help you evaluate research more critically and think carefully about how knowledge is collected, interpreted, and applied in the criminal justice system. Ethical research is not only about following rules. It is about respecting people, protecting rights, and ensuring that the information used to guide criminal justice decisions is gathered responsibly and fairly.
- Following content on this page adapted from Williams, M., & Allen, M. (2022). Ethics in research. Research methods for criminal justice students. Weber State University. https://uen.pressbooks.pub/researchmethodscriminaljusticestudents/chapter/chapter-3-ethics-in-research/. Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
This page titled 9.2: Human Subjects was last modified on Tue, 03 Nov 2026 03:24:42 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Denise Borchert, Western Technical College.
The book could not be loaded just now.