From LibreTexts, under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.
4.1: From Paradigm to Research- How Knowledge is Built in Criminal Justice
Opening the book…
The image below illustrates how researchers move from broad ideas about the world to specific research studies. Research does not begin with data collection. Instead, research is often guided by a series of connected steps that start with a paradigm, continue through a theory and hypotheses, and eventually lead to research.
Figure \(\PageIndex{1}\): From Paradigm to Research (Image generated by the author with Canva AI.)
Paradigms
The process begins with a paradigm, which is the broadest level of understanding. A paradigm is a perspective or lens through which one views reality.1 Rather than being right or wrong, true or false, a paradigm is a framework of assumptions, concepts, values, and practices that shape the types of questions we ask and how we answer them. A paradigm is a general way of thinking about reality, knowledge, and how we learn about the world. Since there are multiple viewpoints, there are numerous paradigms. Not everyone will group paradigms in the same way, especially since ideas can overlap. Additionally, many subcategories can be used to further distinguish theories from one another. However, there are some traditional and common paradigms in criminology.
Figure \(\PageIndex{2}\): Common criminological paradigms and the assumptions that tie theories together within each paradigm. Reproduced from Peterson & VanderPyl (2025), CC BY 4.0.
Paradigm
Assumptions
Pre-classical criminology
Crime is a result of paranormal forces or demonic possession. This outlook on crime is grounded in religion and superstition.
Classical school of criminology
Crime is a result of free will and an individual’s choice to offend. This outlook on crime is grounded in personal choice.
Positivist criminology
Crime is a result of internal or external forces that can be biological, psychological, or sociological. This outlook on crime is grounded in determinism and the scientific method.
Critical/conflict criminology
Crime is a result of society labeling and legislating behavior as “criminal.” This outlook on crime is grounded in a social construction of crime.
Paradigms shape what researchers believe is important to study and what counts as valid evidence.
What is Theory?
Within a paradigm, social scientists develop or use theories. Theories are systematic explanations of natural or social behavior, events, or other phenomena.2 A theory is an organized set of ideas that helps explain why something happens and, in some cases, helps predict what might happen in the future.3 Theory provides a way to look at the world and understand human interaction.4 Theories help researchers make sense of patterns they observe in society. While a paradigm provides a broad perspective, a theory offers a more focused explanation of a specific issue. In criminal justice, theories may attempt to explain why people commit crimes, why some neighborhoods experience higher crime rates, or why certain interventions reduce offending.
Based on the definition of a theory, it may seem like just about anyone can come up with a possible explanation for what is happening and claim it is a legitimate theory.5 While it is true that anyone can come up with an idea to explain some phenomenon, legitimate theories involve scientific and systematic study. You can think of your uncle’s idea on why people commit sexual assault as a “lower case t” theory, while feminist criminologists’ descriptions and unpacking of gender roles based on decades of research is an “upper case T” theory. In other words, a good theory involves more than just personal speculation. A review of common theories is included at the end of this section.
Hypothesis
From a theory, researchers develop hypotheses. Social scientists start with a question such as why what they are witnessing is happening and how they can explain this phenomenon.6 To respond, they then create an educated prediction, called a hypothesis, based on what they observed. A hypothesis is a reasonable explanation for why a phenomenon is occurring. It is not random. It must fit what they are seeing and be simple enough to test. Researchers test predictions or propositions about the relationships among two or more concepts to help explain phenomena.7 Hypotheses translate broad theoretical ideas into statements that can be examined using evidence.
Research
This is the topic of the next chapter, but very briefly, research is the scientific process of collecting and analyzing evidence to determine whether a hypothesis is supported. Theories and observations are the foundations of scientific knowledge.8 The findings may support the hypothesis, partially support it, or fail to support it. To be supported, a theory needs to fit the available evidence, or data, that researchers obtain from observations.9 If it does not fit the evidence uncovered through research, the theory needs to be adjusted or reworked to do so. In any case, the results contribute to our overall understanding of the theory and may lead researchers to refine existing explanations or develop new ones.
For criminal justice professionals, understanding this sequence is important because it helps explain where research findings come from. Research studies do not appear in isolation. They are often built on theories, which are influenced by broader assumptions about knowledge and society. As evidence-informed practitioners, understanding the connection between paradigms, theories, hypotheses, and research allows you to evaluate research more critically and make better decisions based on evidence rather than assumptions, tradition, or personal opinion.