5.2: Understanding What Researchers Study

Criminal Justice Research in Practice: An Applied Guide for Future Practitioners · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    5.2: Understanding What Researchers Study

    Once researchers have developed a research question and, in some cases, a hypothesis, they must decide what information they need to collect to answer that question or test that prediction. This is where variables and units of analysis become important. For criminal justice students, understanding variables and units of analysis is important because these concepts help you understand exactly what a researcher is studying and what conclusions can reasonably be drawn from the findings. When reading a research article, it is easy to focus on the results and overlook how the study was designed. However, identifying the variables tells you what factors or characteristics were measured, while identifying the unit of analysis tells you who or what was actually studied. Together, these concepts provide important context for interpreting the research accurately.

    As a future criminal justice practitioner, you will likely encounter research that is used to support policies, programs, and professional practices. Knowing how to identify variables and units of analysis will help you read that research more critically, recognize its limitations, and make better-informed decisions. These skills are an important part of information literacy because they allow you to move beyond simply accepting research findings and instead understand how those findings were developed and what they really mean.

    Concepts & Conceptualization

    A concept is the notion, mental image, or general idea that comes to mind when we think about a particular topic.1 Concepts help us organize and understand the world around us by grouping together related ideas, characteristics, or observations. Concepts help us think about complex issues, but they are often too abstract to measure directly. For example, consider the concept of emergency service demand in a 911 dispatch center. When you hear that phrase, you might think about the number and types of calls a dispatch center receives, such as medical emergencies, traffic crashes, domestic disturbances, burglaries, welfare checks, or suspicious activity reports. However, different people may have different ideas about what "emergency service demand" means. Some may focus on the total number of calls received, while others may focus on the types of emergencies being reported, the severity of incidents, or the amount of dispatcher time and resources required to handle those calls. People may understand the concept differently, so researchers must clearly define what they mean by emergency service demand before they can measure and study it.

    Concepts can be interpreted in different ways. Without understanding how a researcher has defined key concepts, it would be nearly impossible for readers to understand the meaning of that researcher’s findings and conclusions.2 Researchers must clearly define what they mean when they use a particular concept. This process of clearly and concretely defining a concept is called conceptualization. Through conceptualization, researchers explain exactly how they understand a concept and identify the specific aspects they want to examine. Once a concept has been clearly defined, researchers can determine how to measure it and use it in a study. When reading a research study, it is important to remember that the meaning you associate with a concept may not be the same as the meaning intended by the researcher. For this reason, readers should pay attention to how the researcher defines a concept. Understanding the researcher's definition helps ensure that you accurately understand the study and its conclusions.

    Operationalization

    Once a researcher has defined, or conceptualized, a concept, exactly how did they measure it?3 This is done through a process known as operationalization. Operationalization is the process of turning a concept into something that can be observed and measured.4 Research studies begin by clearly defining a concept and then how the researcher measured it. Finally, they identify specific indicators, which are the observations or pieces of information that represent the concept. Because many concepts are complex, researchers often use several indicators rather than relying on a single measure.

    For example, a researcher may be interested in the concept of recidivism. You have likely discussed recidivism in previous classes. What comes to mind when you hear that term? Before recidivism can be studied, the researcher must decide exactly what it means for the purposes of the study. This process, known as conceptualization, might involve defining recidivism as a return to criminal behavior after a person has been sanctioned or released from custody. The researcher must then decide how recidivism will be measured, the process known as operationalization. One researcher might measure recidivism as being arrested again within three years of release from prison, while another might measure it as being convicted of a crime within two years. The specific measures used, such as rearrests or reconvictions, serve as indicators of the concept. As a reader, it is important to understand how the researcher measured recidivism because different definitions and measurements may lead to different findings and conclusions.

    Often researchers will identify indicators by turning to the information they discovered during their literature review. Previous studies include specific examples of how others have defined important concepts.5 You may see a new research study explaining the definition of a concept or indicator the same way another study does. Researchers may also develop new definitions or indicators that improve or expand on other ones.

    Variables

    Now that you are familiar with how researchers move from broad concepts to specific measures, we can take a closer look at variables. Variables are the characteristics, factors, or conditions that researchers measure in a study.6 A variable is something with a quality or quantity that can vary. They are called variables because they can differ from one person, group, place, or situation to another. Each variable consists of possible values or categories, called attributes.7 One way to connect variables and attributes is to think of a variable as a grouping of two or more characteristics, and of attributes as the characteristics that represent the values or categories of a variable.8 This may be easier to picture with a non-criminal justice example first.

    A simple example of a variable is hair color. Hair color is a variable because it can be different from one person to another. Some people have brown hair, some have blonde hair, some have black hair, and others have red or gray hair.

    The different possible characteristics of the variable are called attributes. In this example, the variable is hair color, and the attributes are brown, blonde, black, red, gray, and any other hair colors included in the study. Researchers could record a person's hair color by selecting the attribute that applies to that individual. This example shows that a variable is simply something that can vary, while attributes are the specific categories or values that the variable can take.

    An example within criminal justice would be offense level. Offense level is a variable because different individuals may be convicted for different levels of offenses. The attributes of this variable might include felony, misdemeanor, and non-criminal infraction (ticket or forfeiture). A researcher studying cases handled by a state circuit court might record the offense level for each case. In this example, offense level is the variable, and felony, misdemeanor, and non-criminal infraction are the attributes. Just like hair color, an offense level can vary from one case to another, which makes it a variable.

    When you read a research study, variables tell you what is being measured, and attributes show the different categories or values within that variable. Identifying variables and attributes can help you make better sense of research findings. It allows you to see exactly what the researcher studied, how information was organized, and how different groups were compared. As a future criminal justice professional, these skills will help you read research more confidently, evaluate claims more carefully, and make decisions based on evidence rather than assumptions.

    Levels of Measurement

    The next step is understanding how those variables are measured. Researchers can measure variables in different ways depending on the type of information they are collecting. Levels of measurement are the way attributes of a variable are related to one another.9 Based on their characteristics, variables are generally categorized into one of four possible levels of measurement: nominal, ordinal, interval, and ratio.

    Nominal – Nominal variables place people, objects, or cases into categories. The categories have names, but there is no ranking or order. An example of a nominal level is eye color. There are categories (blue, green, hazel, etc.) but no ranking order. An example in criminal justice is type of crime. There are categories of crime (violent, property, drug, public order) but no ranking order.

    Ordinal – Ordinal variables place people, objects, or cases into categories that can be ranked from low to high, but the distance between categories is not necessarily equal. An example of an ordinal variable could be a grading scale. A (90% to 100%), B (80% to 89%), C (70% to 79%), D (50% to 69%), and F (Below 50%). The categories have a ranking, but the distance between the categories does not have to be equal. Note: D and F are larger than the others but still fall into the ranking order from high to low. In criminal justice, a risk assessment may rank offenders by their likelihood of reoffending. Offenders may fall into categories of risk levels such as low (1 to 10 points), medium (11 to 20 points), medium high (21 to 26 points), or high (26 points or higher). Again, these rankings go from high to low, but the category measurements (number of points) vary, making them ordinal.

    Interval – Interval variables are numeric measurements that have equal distances between attribute values, but they do not have a true zero point. Temperature is a great example of an interval variable. Temperature is measured in Fahrenheit or Celsius. The difference between 40 and 50 degrees is the same as the difference between 70 and 80 degrees. However, 0 degrees does not mean there is no temperature, which is why this is an interval measure. Interval variables are less common in criminal justice research than nominal, ordinal, and ratio variables.

    Ratio – Ratio variables are numerical measures with equal distances between values and a true zero point. Years of formal education (being in school) can be measured. There is equal distance between measurements (as a year is always the same length), and there is an absolute zero (having not been in school at all yet). This can translate into a criminal justice example: number of times arrested. Each time arrested counts as one (this is equal… someone cannot be half arrested), but there are people who have never been arrested and would fall into the 0 (true zero) category.

    In a research class for future researchers, levels of measurement would be covered in much more detail. As a consumer of research, having a basic understanding of levels of measurement can help you recognize the differences between them when reading a study.

    Identifying Who and What is Being Studied

    When reading criminal justice research, it is important to pay attention not only to the topic or issue being studied, but also to the people, groups, organizations, or places being studied. Some studies focus on individual people, such as offenders, victims, correctional officers, or probationers. Other studies focus on larger groups, organizations, communities, or even entire populations. Understanding the focus of a study helps readers interpret research findings correctly and avoid drawing conclusions that go beyond what the evidence actually supports.

    This skill is especially important for future criminal justice practitioners. Throughout your career, you will likely encounter research that is used to support policies, programs, training, and day-to-day practices. For example, a patrol officer may read a study about factors associated with repeat offending, another study evaluating the effectiveness of a department-wide training program, and yet another examining crime trends across an entire state. Although all three studies may be relevant, they focus on different things and answer different questions. Understanding who or what is being studied helps you determine whether the findings are applicable and if they apply to an individual, an agency, a community, or a broader criminal justice issue.

    Levels of Analysis

    In the hard sciences, researchers can study phenomena at very different levels – from stars to planets, to microscopic cells and microbes.10 In a similar way, social scientists study the social, and in many of our cases the criminal, world using different levels of analysis. Criminal justice research can examine issues at different levels, from individual people to larger groups, communities, and entire populations. The three broad levels of analysis are micro, meso, and macro.

    Micro – Studies focused on individuals. When researchers study individual people, they are focusing on the smallest level of analysis. In criminal justice, this might involve studying individuals such as officers or jurors. For example, a researcher might examine whether participation in a treatment program affects an individual's likelihood of reoffending, or whether participation in a victim support program affects a victim's satisfaction with the criminal justice process. In these studies, the individual person is the focus of the research.

    Meso – Studies focused on groups and organizations. Some research focuses on groups, organizations, or communities rather than individual people. In criminal justice, researchers might study police departments, correctional institutions, specialty courts, schools, neighborhoods, or community organizations. For example, a researcher might compare use-of-force incidents across police departments or examine how different prosecutors’ offices make charging decisions. In these studies, the focus is on the group, organization, or community rather than any single individual.

    Macro – Studies focused on large systems and populations. Other research examines broader patterns across large populations or social systems. These studies may focus on cities, states, regions, or entire countries. For example, a researcher might compare incarceration rates across states, examine national crime trends, or study how changes in state laws affect criminal justice outcomes. Rather than focusing on individuals or organizations, these studies seek to understand patterns and issues that occur on a larger scale.

    As a reader of research, it is important to recognize the level at which a study is focused. This helps you understand what conclusions the researcher can reasonably make and prevents you from applying findings to people, groups, or situations that were not actually studied.

    Units of Analysis

    You have seen that researchers can study issues at different levels, from individual people to organizations and entire populations; it is important to identify exactly who or what is being studied in a particular research project. This is known as the unit of analysis. The unit of analysis helps readers move beyond the general focus of a study and identify the specific person, group, organization, community, or population from which the researcher collected data. Understanding the unit of analysis is important because it helps you determine what conclusions can reasonably be drawn from a study and how broadly those findings can be applied.

    When reading a research study, the unit of analysis is the person, group, organization, place, or population that the researcher is ultimately trying to learn about and draw conclusions about.11 For example, a study may be interested in offenders, police departments, neighborhoods, or states.

    Some of the most common categories of units of analysis include:12

    1. Individuals – Focuses on individual people such as witnesses, victims, correctional officers, or probationers
    1. Groups – Focuses on collections of people who share something in common, such as juries, gangs, or correctional staff (everyone who works in a prison)
    1. Organizations – Focuses on formal entities such as police departments, courts, correctional institutions, or nonprofit victim services agencies.
    1. Social phenomena – Focuses on social behavior, interaction, trend, or problem such as crime, voting, substance use, cyberbullying or recidivism.
    1. Policies and principles – Focuses on laws, policies, procedures, programs, or guiding principles, such as a use-of-force policy, a diversion program, or a state sentencing law.

    It is important to acknowledge that the unit of analysis is not necessarily where the information comes from, but the thing the researcher is collecting data about. When you read a research study, one of the easiest ways to identify the unit of analysis is to ask yourself:

    Who or what is the researcher trying to learn about and draw conclusions about?

    Do not focus on who completed the survey, interview, or questionnaire (methods of collecting data we will talk about soon) right away. Instead, focus on who or what the researcher is ultimately studying. If the study is trying to understand offenders, then offenders is the unit of analysis. If the study is trying to understand police departments, then police departments are the unit of analysis. As you read, look for clues in the research question, purpose statement, and findings. Ask yourself: Are the conclusions being made about people, groups, organizations, communities, or larger populations? The answer will usually point you to the unit of analysis. A good habit is to finish reading the study's purpose and then complete this sentence:

    This study is trying to tell me something about __________.

    The word or phrase that fills in the blank is often the unit of analysis. It is best to identify this before moving on to the “methodology” or how the research collected data. Once you identify the unit of analysis, it becomes easier to understand what the findings mean and avoid applying the results to people or groups that were not actually studied.

    Understanding variables and units of analysis can also help you avoid common mistakes when evaluating research. For example, a study examining neighborhood crime rates is studying neighborhoods, not individual offenders. Likewise, a study examining police departments is not necessarily drawing conclusions about individual officers. By paying attention to the unit of analysis, you can better determine whether the author's conclusions match the data that was collected. Similarly, understanding the variables being measured helps you evaluate whether the study is actually addressing the research question and whether the findings are relevant to a particular criminal justice issue.


    1. (Hassan et al., 2025).
    2. (Hassan et al., 2025).
    3. (Hassan et al., 2025).
    4. (Williams, 2022).
    5. (Williams, 2022).
    6. (Hassan et al., 2025).
    7. (Hassan et al., 2025).
    8. (Chen et al., 2024).
    9. (Hassan et al., 2025).
    10. (Chen et al., 2024).
    11. (Blackstone, 2012).
    12. (Blackstone, 2012).

    This page titled 5.2: Understanding What Researchers Study was last modified on Tue, 03 Nov 2026 03:24:37 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Denise Borchert, Western Technical College.