From LibreTexts, under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.
6.3: Research Design Should Match the Research Purpose
Opening the book…
In criminal justice, researchers use different designs for different purposes. Some designs are useful for exploring a problem that is not yet well understood.1 Others are better suited for describing a group, examining patterns, or testing whether a program or intervention produces a particular outcome. No single design is appropriate for every situation. The value of a research study depends, in part, on whether the design fits the question the study is attempting to answer.
Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed-Method
The research question helps determine which research design is most appropriate for a study. Different research questions require different approaches to collecting and analyzing information. For example, a researcher who wants to understand how formerly incarcerated individuals experience the reentry process may use interviews or observations, while a researcher who wants to examine whether a reentry program reduces recidivism may use a survey, an experiment, or another design that allows outcomes to be compared. The type of question being asked should guide the choice of research design.
As you learned earlier, criminal justice researchers may use qualitative, quantitative, or mixed-methods approaches.3 It is important to remember that these approaches are tools for answering research questions rather than competing ways of conducting research. Qualitative approaches are often useful when researchers want a deeper understanding of experiences, perspectives, or social processes. Quantitative approaches are often useful when researchers want to measure patterns, compare groups, or examine relationships among variables. In some cases, researchers combine both approaches using a mixed-method to gain a more complete understanding of a problem.
No single research design is best for every study.4 A design that works well for one research question may be a poor choice for another. When evaluating research, practitioners should consider whether the design fits the purpose of the study and whether it allows the researcher to answer the question being asked. Understanding this connection between the research question and the research design helps practitioners better evaluate the strength and usefulness of the evidence they encounter in criminal justice practice.