Opening the book…
The violence and institutional failures described above do not occur in isolation. Where someone falls on the gender spectrum, and how much they conform to or deviate from culturally prescribed gender expectations, can influence how they are treated. These patterns of treatment reflect gender bias, which refers to the ways in which stereotypes (what we think and believe about gender groups), prejudice (how we feel about gender groups), and discrimination (how we treat people differently based on gender) function together to produce and sustain unequal gendered outcomes. Because the gender binary is deeply embedded in Western cultures, gender biases tend to operate in binary terms, rewarding conformity to gendered expectations and punishing deviations from them.
These three components can also operate independently. A hiring manager who genuinely believes in gender equality can still unconsciously favor male applicants for leadership roles (Moss-Racusin et al., 2012), and a teacher who holds no explicit bias may still call on boys more frequently in math and science classrooms (Sadker & Sadker, 1994). Together, these components of gender bias are part of larger systems of gendered power that influence which behaviors are valued the most and which are punished.
Systems of Gendered Power
R.W. Connell (1995) introduced the concept of hegemonic masculinity to describe how masculinity maintains dominance over subordinate groups. In Western contexts, hegemonic masculinity is associated with traits such as physical toughness, competitiveness, and heterosexuality, as well as behavioral expectations like suppressing vulnerability, and avoiding anything coded as feminine (Pascoe, 2007). This form of masculinity helps legitimize patriarchy, a social system in which men hold primary power and authority.
Importantly, hegemonic masculinity is not a description of how most men behave. It is a cultural ideal that few men live up to, and yet it is the standard by which all other expressions of gender, both masculine and feminine, are measured. Those who fail to conform to this ideal are subordinated, including women as a group, but also gay men, men of color (Collins, 2004; R.W. Connell & Messerschmidt, 2005), and men who display traits coded as feminine (R.W. Connell, 1995). Because it operates as a system of social recognition and power, access to privilege shifts depending on how one is perceived within the gender hierarchy. Research on trans masculinities, for example, suggests that trans men may gain access to certain forms of male privilege when they are socially recognized as men (Schilt, 2010). Conversely, trans women may lose access to such privilege or face increased scrutiny for engaging in femininity (C. Connell, 2010), whereas cis women may be criticized if they choose to violate gender norms and behave in ways associated with men, such as seeking leadership roles or being assertive (Heilman et al. 2004; Rudman, 1998). As a result, patriarchy and hegemonic masculinity mean that women, both cis and trans, are blocked from avenues of power.
If patriarchy is the system, and hegemonic masculinity is the standard for comparison, then misogyny is how they are upheld and enforced. Philosopher Kate Manne (2018) differentiates misogyny from sexism. Sexism refers to the beliefs and assumptions that make male dominance seem justifiable. Sexist beliefs can take overtly hostile forms or seemingly positive ones, a distinction we return to in Chapter 5. On the other hand, Manne describes misogyny as the “law enforcement branch” of patriarchy. It is the set of social mechanisms, such as harassment and backlash against women who step outside their prescribed roles, that police and punish those who violate its gendered expectations while rewarding those who comply.
Equality versus Equity
Seeing gender bias as part of these larger systems of power, and not just as individual attitudes, also changes how we think about solutions. An assumed logical starting point when only considering individual attitudes might be equality, treating everyone the same regardless of gender. Equality is essential in contexts like equal pay for equal work or equal protection under law. But identical treatment that ignores wider systems of power simply preserves the advantage of those who were already ahead. Consider access to education. What happens when a school district provides every student with the same resources regardless of neighborhood? Students in wealthier areas still have access to things like private tutoring, college-educated parents, and technology in their home. The “equal” solution does nothing to address the systemic barriers creating inequality.
Equity, by contrast, involves recognizing differences in circumstances and adjusting support accordingly. For example, women in male-dominated fields are less likely to receive the informal mentorship that facilitates career advancement (Ramaswami et al., 2010). Providing mentorship programs specifically for women in male-dominated fields addresses a structural disadvantage that already exists. An equity-based approach like this recognizes that systemic gender bias and the systems of power described above have produced unequal environments before an intervention begins. The analysis of these systems owes its existence to decades of feminist activism and scholarship that identified and challenged such systems.
Section Key Terms
This page titled 1.4: Gender Bias, Systems of Power, and the Importance of Equity was last modified on Fri, 11 Sep 2026 19:00:56 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Rochelle Burnaford.
The book could not be loaded just now.