7.5: Gendered Emotional Experience and Expression

The Psychology of Women - An Inclusive Approach · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    7.5: Gendered Emotional Experience and Expression

    The previous section looked at how language carries gendered assumptions. This one turns to a question of inner emotional experience versus outward emotional expression. The stereotype says women are simply more emotional than men. The reliable differences are in public expression and in communication, not in the underlying experience of emotion. Additionally, even the differences in expression that we do have evidence for are small and depend heavily on context.

    All emotions have a physiological dimension. A racing heart, a flushed face, a tightening in the chest, a wave of warmth, a churn in the gut. These bodily signals are part of what we experience as feeling, but the signals themselves do not arrive with names attached. They are also similar across very different emotional contexts. The physiology described above could happen when your crush gives you a compliment, or they could happen when you’re about to give a major presentation in a class! What stereotypes present as innate gender and racial differences in emotion often turns out to be a difference in what feelings people are permitted, or pressured, to show.

    Experience versus expression

    When we call someone "emotional," we tend to blur two separate things: what a person feels on the inside, versus what they show on the outside. Pulling these apart can help us to better understand how gender can shape emotion.

    Research Spotlight: Same Feeling, Different Display

    A foundational set of studies by Kring and Gordon (1998) had women and men watch emotional films while researchers measured three things at once: how expressive their faces were, how much emotion they reported feeling, and their physiological responses like heart rate, breathing, and skin conductance (a measure of physiological arousal that rises as the body sweats slightly during emotional arousal). The results separated experience from expression cleanly. Women were more facially expressive than men. But women and men did not differ in how much emotion they reported experiencing. And while physiological responses differed between women and men, with men having more reactivity to fear films, differences for happy and sad films were not significantly different, and neither sex was simply more physiologically reactive than the other. Other studies have found men sometimes showing larger physiological changes even while reporting or displaying less emotion (Deng et al., 2016), so the bodily data do not line up neatly behind the stereotype that women are the more aroused sex. In other words, women and men in these studies felt about the same amount; what differed was how much showed on the outside.

    Crucially, Kring and Gordon also found that the size of the expression difference depended on gender-role identification and family expressiveness, not on sex itself, which points to socialization rather than biology as the engine. The expression gap is also small and developmentally late, emerging more clearly with age and varying by context (Chaplin, 2015). The takeaway is that women and men have been taught to show feelings differently.

       

    This experience-versus-expression distinction also helps explain a puzzle in the self-report data. People generally believe women feel emotions more intensely than men, but when researchers ask large, representative samples how often they actually experience various emotions, the sweeping difference the stereotype predicts does not appear; the differences that do emerge are tied to specific emotions and to people's social position rather than to a general female "emotionality" (Simon & Nath, 2004). Experimental work shows why the self-report gap appears at all. Grossman and Wood (1993) found that the more strongly people endorsed gender stereotypes about emotion, the larger the reported difference between women's and men's emotional intensity; and when they gave participants instructions that made emotional responsiveness equally expected of everyone, the gender difference in self-reported emotion disappeared. In other words, much of the "women feel more" pattern in self-reports reflects what people believe they are supposed to feel, not a fixed difference in what they do feel.

    Verbal and nonverbal communication

    The stereotype that women talk more than men is one of the most durable in popular culture, and it is wrong. A meta-analysis by Leaper and Ayres (2007) found that, if anything, men were slightly more talkative than women, though the difference was negligible. What small differences exist are not about quantity but about style. Men used marginally more assertive speech (about task and self), women marginally more affiliative speech (about connection and the other person). Previous meta-analysis by Anderson & Leaper (1998) had also noted that across 43 studies, men interrupted more than women, but the overall effect was small (d = 0.15). The difference grew when researchers looked specifically at intrusive interruptions (d = 0.33, still modest), the kind that seize the floor rather than show support. And critically, the effect was larger in naturalistic settings and in groups of three or more, which fits the chapter's context-dependence theme. More recent research has supported this, showing that women in the US Congress are about 10% more likely to be interrupted than their male counterparts, and ironically that number jumps to more than twice as likely when the given congressional hearing is discussing women’s issues (e.g., reproductive rights, women’s health, or family policy). So, gender differences in verbal communication are incredibly context dependent.

    A separate claim, dating back to Lakoff (1975), that women use more tentative language (hedges, qualifiers, tag questions like "isn't it?") due to lower confidence, holds up as a small effect. Because this tentativeness varies so much with the conversational context (e.g., happening more in intense work meetings), researchers interpret it as a flexible, relationally attuned way of speaking that invites others into the conversation, rather than gendered personality differences in confidence (Leaper & Robnett, 2011). That is, it may fit women’s gendered norms to use more tentative language, but this likely reflects norms encouraging women toward communion and connection, rather than lack of confidence.

    Men tend to take up more physical space through expansive posture (what's popularly called "manspreading") and larger interpersonal distance. These behaviors are typically understood as masculine, even by children as young as 3 years old (Terrizzi et al., 2018). But the research suggests these are more precisely displays of dominance and power than as sex differences per se. For example, the same expansive, space-taking behaviors are shown by high-power people regardless of gender. A large recent analysis found that most measured sex/gender differences in nonverbal behavior reflected an individual’s power in the situation rather than gender (Galinsky et al., 2024). That is, men may tend to engage in these behaviors more frequently simply because they tend to be in power positions more frequently. Interestingly, children associate dominant postures with maleness as early as preschool (Charafeddine et al., 2020), which shows how early the connection between maleness and power displays are learned. Smiling and facial expressiveness where women tend to do more, again vary heavily with context. Women smile more in service or subordinate roles, and when they know they’re being observed, and less when alone or in equal-status settings (Fischer et al., 2015). In children, this translates to preschool children associating smiling and positive expression with femaleness as early as preschool (Portengen et al., 2024). Taken together, these findings suggest that existing power dynamics both feed into stereotypes of nonverbal communication, as well as filter down to the way our children are understanding what’s expected of men and women.

    Code-switching and code-mixing

    Emotional and communicative display is not only gendered; it is also shaped by culture and race. Code-switching refers to shifting between languages, dialects, or styles of speech depending on the social context, and code-mixing to blending them within a single conversation. Bilingual speakers may move between languages. Speakers of African American Vernacular English may shift toward the dialect treated as "standard" in white-dominated professional settings during a job interview, then back among friends. Linguists are clear that African American Vernacular English is a fully rule-governed dialect, not a deficient or "incorrect" form of English. The judgment that it is less professional reflects whose speech holds power, not any linguistic deficiency.

    Code-switching is a cognitively demanding skill, and for members of marginalized groups it is often not optional. McCluney and colleagues (2021) found experimentally that Black employees who code-switched toward white-coded speech norms were seen as more professional. That is a real benefit, but it is one that requires conforming to white norms, and the effort of doing so carries a psychological cost. For Black women specifically, code-switching intersects with both race and gender. Dickens and colleagues (2019) describe how Black women in predominantly White workplaces engage in ongoing "identity shifting," adjusting speech, self-presentation, and emotional expression to manage the hypervisibility and scrutiny that come with being tokenized along two dimensions at once. Recent interviews with Black women social workers found that constant code-switching, driven by everyday workplace microaggressions, produced feelings of invisibility, self-doubt, and a quiet, unspoken strain the researchers termed "silent struggles" (Cooke et al., 2025). What looks from the outside like a neutral communication skill is, for many women of color, a form of unpaid emotional and cognitive labor demanded by environments built around someone else's norms.

    Code-mixing is often studied under the broader label of code-switching. Linguistic researchers do not always distinguish between the two. The foundational research on Spanish-English bilinguals found that this kind of fluid blending, instead of signaling incomplete fluency, requires command of both languages and follows the grammatical rules of each (Poplack, 1980). More recently, Tulloch and colleagues (2022) found bilingual children switch between languages fluidly not because they are weaker in one language but because the precise meaning they are trying to convey is best expressed by a term from another language. In code-mixing, blending may be thought of as linguistic fluidity and fluency, though in some standard English dominated professional settings, it runs the risk of being judged as improper. And as with code-switching, the burden of adjusting falls most heavily on those whose first language or dialect is not the one in power.

    Emotion with Others

    Similar gendered patterns play out in our social interactions, where emotion is not only felt and shown but read, and returned. When empathy is measured by self-report, asking people how empathic they are, women score considerably higher. But when it is measured by performance in empathic accuracy (how well people infer others' feelings), there is little to no difference in accuracy between genders. The small reliable advantage women hold is specifically in decoding nonverbal emotional cues (e.g., a downward glance, and change in tone of voice), which is a narrower skill than empathy. Klein and Hodges (2001) found that women outperformed men on empathic accuracy only when participants were told they would be evaluated on it or were paid for accuracy. When evaluation or payment were removed the difference vanished. Newer work using physiological measures makes this more specific. Pang and colleagues (2023) found that women reported higher empathy than men on questionnaires while electroencephalography (EEG) responses to others' painful facial expressions showed no such gap. The stereotype of women as more empathic seems to reflect what women are expected to do as much as any fixed difference in ability.

    Research on helping and friendship each carry a gendered bias, but of different kinds. A classic meta-analysis found that men helped more in the studies reviewed, but only because most of those studies measured public, sometimes risky assistance to strangers, the kind of helping that fits the chivalrous masculine role, while the sustained care within close relationships that fits the feminine role was largely absent from the experimental literature (Eagly & Crowley, 1986). Historical research on helping had defined helping in a particular way and missed or ignored exploring how women help.

    On the other hand, in friendship research, men and women do not differ much in how many friends they have or how much they value friendship (Caldwell & Peplau, 1982). But they do differ in friendship-style, and research has historically framed women's typical friendship style of greater self-disclosure as superior to men's more activity-based style (Wood & Inman, 1993). Women's same-sex friendships tend to center on disclosure and intimacy, whereas men's friendships tend to focus on shared activity. However, talking through a hard week and spending every Saturday on a shared project are both ways friendships can deepen. Among emerging adults, shared activities predicted emotional closeness for men while disclosure predicted it for women, and the two groups reported roughly equal amounts of disclosure overall (Radmacher & Azmitia, 2006). When women's friendships are treated as the model of "real" intimacy, women's communality continues to look like a natural trait rather than a learned style that fulfills norm expectations. It also reinforces the gender role expectation that women will do the emotional work of relationships, a topic we will return to in chapter 9.

    The one domain where a sizable, well-replicated gender difference does hold is physical aggression. Men engage in more physical and direct aggression than women. This pattern appears early, and holds across cultures (Archer, 2004; Card et al., 2008). Even here the difference is sensitive to context, narrowing sharply under provocation (Bettencourt & Miller, 1996), and the popular refinement that girls are simply aggressive in a more relational way is far weaker in the evidence than the "mean girls" narrative implies. Because aggression and violence raise questions that extend well beyond emotion and communication, we take up the topic in depth in Chapter 10.

    Section Key Terms


    This page titled 7.5: Gendered Emotional Experience and Expression was last modified on Fri, 11 Sep 2026 19:01:02 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Rochelle Burnaford.