Opening the book…
When we study the psychology of women today, we rely on the scientific method. This systematic process typically begins when a researcher makes an observation and asks a question about what they notice. The observation could happen in the course of daily life (e.g., noticing that your friends who are women seem more stressed than your friends who are men), or it could be an observation about existing research, like realizing a study only included cisgender heterosexual women but wrote conclusions as if generalizing to all women. The question arising from such observations could be anything from “What might happen if this study included a more representative sample of women?” to “Why do women seem to experience more stress on average?”
With their question in mind, the researcher then conducts background research to understand what is already known about the topic, and forms a hypothesis, which is a specific, testable prediction about what they expect to find. For example, a researcher might observe in the literature that women experience workplace discrimination more often than men do. They might then question what the effects of those experiences are and predict that "women who experience workplace discrimination will report higher levels of daily stress than women who do not."
Sidebar Note: Why Scientists Don’t ‘Prove’ Things
We never use the terms “prove” or “proven” in science. Think of the scientific process like an investigation. An investigator gathers evidence that either supports or contradicts a theory, but the case is never fully closed. New evidence can always emerge that changes our understanding.
A good hypothesis must be falsifiable, meaning that it must be possible, in principle, to find evidence that would refute the hypothesis. For example, an unfalsifiable hypothesis would be the claim that "women are naturally more nurturing than men because of maternal instinct, and any woman who does not display nurturing behavior is simply suppressing her true nature." Because there is no way to disprove this statement, it falls outside the bounds of science. Note here that the issue is not in the study of “natural instincts” but in the built-in escape clause. A good hypothesis must allow for the fact that it might be wrong, instead of explaining away a lack of evidence as further support for the hypothesis.
From their testable hypothesis the researcher then designs a study to collect and analyze data. The data must be able either to support or refute their hypothesis (otherwise the hypothesis is unfalsifiable). Findings are then shared with the scientific community for peer review and, ideally, replication. Replication is the process of repeating a study to test if the same results can be achieved again. Think of researchers like investigators looking for evidence, and replication is required to find the evidence needed to support a hypothesis or theory (see Figure 2.1).
Figure 2.1. The scientific method. Figure by Rochelle Burnaford, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0.
The scientific method might sound relatively straightforward in that there are sequential steps that must be followed, even if there are a lot of them. But remember that the psychology of women has a complicated history with scientific methodology. Postpositivist and feminist critics rightly challenged psychological science in two ways. First, for much of its history, psychology has treated the experiences of White, middle-class, Western men as representative of all humans. Researchers built theories of "normal" development, cognition, and behavior almost entirely from male samples, known as the normative male problem (Crawford & Marecek, 1989). Second, when researchers did study women, they frequently treated the experiences of White, middle-class, heterosexual, non-disabled women as representative of all women (Morawski, 1994; Reid & Kelly, 1994). This meant that the ways variables like race, ethnicity, socioeconomic status, sexual orientation, disability, immigration status, and culture shaped women's experiences were routinely left out. Yet scientific findings from such narrow samples were presented as if they reflected universal human experience.
Reliance on sampling from such demographics has been labeled the WEIRD problem (Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, and Democratic). The term was coined by Joseph Henrich and colleagues (2010), who demonstrated that most participants in psychological research came from WEIRD societies, despite these populations representing a small fraction of the global population. Scientific research in multiple fields has received push back since then for the continued reliance on WEIRD samples (Rad et al., 2018). Psychology, for example, frequently relies on introductory psychology students at major research universities as participants. A study conducted exclusively with college women at a wealthy, predominantly white university may tell us very little about the experiences of a Black single mother working two jobs, a Latina immigrant navigating a new country, a transgender woman facing barriers to healthcare, or a deaf woman advocating for accessibility in her workplace.
Good science requires that we constantly ask who was included in this research and who was left out. By applying the lessons of history detailed here and in Chapter One to the rigors of the scientific method we build scientific practices that are inclusive and representative.
Section Key Terms
This page titled 2.2: The Scientific Method and WEIRD Science was last modified on Mon, 14 Sep 2026 22:26:18 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Rochelle Burnaford.
The book could not be loaded just now.