8.2: Access Discrimination- Getting in the Door

The Psychology of Women - An Inclusive Approach · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    8.2: Access Discrimination- Getting in the Door

    Access discrimination refers to discriminatory practices in hiring and recruitment that limit who enters a job or profession in the first place. It is most likely to occur when employers hold strong gender-role stereotypes, when applicants seek jobs that are considered inconsistent with their gender, and when positions are prestigious or high-status (Heilman, 2001). Access discrimination is not always overt or conscious. It can operate through assumptions about who "fits" a role (glass ceiling, occupational segregation), in multiple iterations that look very different but result from the same root discriminatory structure (labyrinth), keep women in dead end jobs (sticky floor), or when given access, set women up to fail (glass cliff).

    Metaphors for Structural Barriers

    Researchers have developed several metaphors to capture the different ways structural barriers operate across women's careers. The most familiar is the glass ceiling, the idea that an invisible barrier prevents women from reaching the highest levels of career success (Hymowitz & Schellhardt, 1986). While the glass ceiling concept drew important attention to the underrepresentation of women in leadership, it has been criticized for implying that discrimination begins only at the top. In reality, women encounter obstacles at every career stage, which is why Eagly and Carli (2007) proposed the metaphor of the labyrinth. The labyrinth captures the dead ends, detours, and obstacles women navigate throughout their careers. For example, a woman might enter a company only to discover that promotion decisions there favor men. She moves to a smaller firm that offers fairer practices but lower pay, rebuilds her trajectory there, then finds that taking family leave stalls her progress again. Each obstacle is surmountable on its own, but the cumulative effect is a career path full of detours that her male colleagues never had to navigate.

    Other metaphors capture barriers at different points in the career trajectory. The sticky floor describes jobs with little chance of advancement, such as cashier, waitress, or home health aide (Booth et al., 2003). Though women in general are more likely to occupy these positions, here we also have an intersection with racial identity as these are positions in which women of color are disproportionately represented. For example, home health aides are overwhelmingly women, and disproportionately Black and Latina women, yet the work requires significant skill in caregiving, medical monitoring, and emotional labor. Despite the high skill demand, it has one of the lowest median annual wages (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2025).

    Trans women, more likely to face repeated hiring discrimination, may be pushed out of formal employment entirely. Documented in Jennie Livingston’s landmark film Paris is Burning (1990), the connection between employment exclusion, sex work, and trans women has deep historical roots. Jules Gill-Peterson (2024) researched this history, arguing that the channeling of trans women into sex work is a product of structural exclusion from formal labor markets. Colonial governments, policing practices, and employment discrimination worked together to mark trans-feminized people as outside the formal economy, leaving few alternatives. Evidence for this can be seen in today’s patterns. Shircliff and colleagues (2023) found that trans women and nonbinary people who experienced workplace discrimination were significantly more likely to engage in sex work. So for trans women, the sticky floor metaphor does not quite capture reality. The issue is not simply lack of advancement, but exclusion from formal employment altogether.

    The glass cliff, on the other hand, describes the pattern in which women and racial minorities do get access to leadership positions during times of crisis, but in service of setting them up to be scapegoated when things go wrong. For example, Ryan and Haslam (2005) found that women were more likely to be appointed to corporate leadership positions in companies that were already performing poorly. A frequently cited example is Marissa Mayer, who was appointed CEO of Yahoo in 2012 when the company had already been in decline for years. Despite attempts at a turnaround, Yahoo was sold to Verizon in 2017, and Mayer faced intense public scrutiny for the company's trajectory. However, women have sometimes been able to use leadership appointments at tenuous companies to the benefit of themselves and their companies. Ursula Burns, appointed CEO of Xerox during a period of financial difficulty, successfully led the company through a major restructuring. But the pattern overall suggests that women are disproportionately placed in precarious positions.

    The glass escalator (Williams, 1992) describes the opposite pattern where men in female-dominated fields tend to be swiftly promoted into supervisory and administrative roles. A meta-analysis of over 70 hiring experiments across 26 countries found that discrimination consistently works to preserve existing gender distributions. Women face hiring penalties in male-dominated occupations, and men are favored in female-dominated ones (Galos & Coppock, 2023).

    Importantly, the glass escalator metaphor can also be applied to post-transition trans men and women. Remember previous research found that trans men who transitioned while employed reported gaining workplace credibility and authority in ways that parallel glass escalator dynamics (Schilt, 2010), then additionally Schilt and Wiswall (2008) found that trans women reported losing professional authority after transition. Large-scale survey data confirm this pattern. Shannon (2021) analyzed data from over 27,000 transgender respondents and found that the more a trans person was perceived by others as their identified gender, the more their earnings reflected the typical pattern for that gender: trans men who were read as men earned more, and trans women who were read as women earned less. These findings demonstrate that workplace advantages and penalties are driven by how others perceive someone's gender, not by the person's actual abilities.

    In terms of race, research has long demonstrated that Black men do not receive the benefit of the glass escalator the way that white men do (e.g., Wingfield, 2009). More recent work demonstrates a similar pattern for white versus Black women. Alegria (2019) described the experience of white women in tech as a "step stool" rather than an escalator: they were moved into midlevel management, but these promotions shifted them away from technical work rather than advancing them within it, and there was no clear path to executive leadership. Women of color in the same industry did not experience even this limited boost. Quantitative research supports this pattern. Corbett et al. (2024) analyzed five years of promotion data from a U.S. technology firm and found that white women were overrepresented in midlevel management positions while women of color remained concentrated at the bottom of the organizational hierarchy, even when their performance ratings were comparable. The step stool, it appears, is reserved for white women.

    Occupational Segregation

    Beyond the barriers individuals face in hiring, the workforce as a whole is marked by occupational segregation, the concentration of women and men into different types of jobs. There is remarkably little overlap between the most commonly held jobs for men and the most commonly held jobs for women. Women are concentrated in education, healthcare, and administrative support; men are concentrated in construction, manufacturing, transportation, and technology. This pattern reflects what researchers call the devaluation of feminized work. Society tends to assign less economic value to work culturally associated with women, regardless of the skill or training involved. Occupational segregation contributes to the wage gap (which we will examine in detail in Section 6.4), but the gap is not simply a matter of women’s typical roles being undervalued. The wage gap exists within both male-dominated and female-dominated occupations.

    Perhaps more telling, when occupational feminization occurs (that is, when more women enter a field over time), wages in that field tend to decline, even when the work itself has not changed. Research using 50 years of U.S. Census data found that as occupations feminize, pay declines, even after controlling for the education and skill the jobs require (Levanon et al., 2009). More recent analysis confirms this pattern persists, though it has been partially masked by the rising educational requirements of feminizing occupations (Mandel, 2018). The reverse pattern, wages rising as a field becomes more male-dominated, is rare. This suggests that it is not the content of the work that determines its value but the gender of the people performing it.

    Occupational segregation also shapes the experiences of trans and nonbinary workers. Trans women who transition into female-coded roles may experience both the access barriers facing cisgender women and the additional burden of anti-trans discrimination. Correspondence studies have begun to document this directly. Granberg and colleagues (2020) sent over 2,000 fictitious job applications in Sweden and found that transgender applicants received significantly fewer positive responses from employers than cisgender applicants. Trans men entering male-dominated fields may gain access but face disclosure risks (Schilt, 2010). And nonbinary workers in heavily gendered industries, whether construction or nursing, often face pressure to present in binary-conforming ways simply to be hired at all (Paine et al., 2024).

    Section Key Terms


    This page titled 8.2: Access Discrimination- Getting in the Door was last modified on Fri, 11 Sep 2026 19:01:09 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Rochelle Burnaford.