Opening the book…
In a U.S. national sample of adults with a mood or anxiety disorder, 30.6% of men sought help of any kind, against 40.2% of women (Susukida et al., 2015). The explanation usually offered, and that has been previously mentioned in this text, is masculinity, since asking for help means admitting you cannot manage on your own. The full evidence is more complicated, however.
Susukida and colleagues (2015) studied 1,963 adults in a national survey who met criteria for mood or anxiety disorders in the past year, and found that men were less likely than women to consult a medical doctor (17.3 versus 24.9%), and less likely to use informal services such as self-help groups (8.5 vs 13.6%), but in that survey they were no less likely to see a mental health professional (16.0 vs 16.3%). Part of the difference was accounted for by men attending fewer routine medical visits, and for most people a family doctor is the referral point for mental health care. Attitudes toward help-seeking explained very little of the gap. Men did report more negative attitudes than women, 36.5 against 29.7%, but the difference was too small to account for the difference in behavior. This suggests that campaigns designed to change men's minds about therapy could begin by increasing GP visits.
However, some help-seeking may be dependent on the age of participants. Among U.S. adults screening positive for depression, women's psychotherapy use exceeded men's by 22 percentage points at ages 18 to 25 and not at all after 50 (Kleidermacher et al., 2026).
Wong and colleagues (2017) asked a different question, whether men who endorse masculine role norms more strongly may fare worse. They meta-analyzed 78 samples and 19,453 participants and found that conformity to masculine norms was modestly related to worse mental health and moderately related to avoiding psychological help. When they separated the individual norms, the effects were uneven. Self-reliance, power over women, and engaging in sex without emotional attachment were consistently associated with worse mental health outcomes, while putting one’s job ahead of everything else showed no significant relationship to any outcome they measured.
While women seek help more often than men, most women who need care still do not receive it. Across 21 countries and 56,927 respondents, only 6.9% of the mental and substance use disorders people had in the past year were treated in line with clinical guidelines (e.g., proper medication use or counseling therapy, or both). These numbers come from interviews conducted in people's homes rather than from clinic records. Trained interviewers administered a structured diagnostic interview to a probability sample of households, which means the count includes people who had never sought care and did not believe they needed any. What varied was whether they themselves felt they should see a professional, and in only 46.5% of cases did they. Of those who did, about a third reached a provider, and of the people who got as far as minimally adequate care, slightly more than half still fell short of guideline-consistent treatment (Vigo et al., 2025).
Women's relationship to the mental health system is stranger than simple underuse. Nationally, 17.7% of American women were taking an antidepressant in any given month between 2015 and 2018, against 8.4% of men, and among women over 60 the figure reaches 24.3% (Brody & Gu, 2020). In a more specific and vulnerable population, U.S. veterans treated for PTSD, women were more likely than men to receive every class of psychiatric medication studied, even after accounting for age, race, and other psychiatric diagnoses. What separated the classes was whether the guidelines endorse the drug. For the antidepressants recommended for PTSD, women's odds of receiving one were about 7% higher than men's. For benzodiazepines, which the guidelines advise against in PTSD, they were about 60% higher, and two other non-recommended drug classes showed the same pattern (Hadlandsmyth et al., 2022). Women were not simply getting more treatment. They were getting more of the treatment that is not supposed to be given. Whether women had already tried and failed the recommended drugs is a question this study cannot answer, though if that were the explanation, women should have been less likely to be taking them rather than more.
The Strong Black Woman schema
Black women are among the most undertreated groups for depression in the United States, and one of the explanations researchers have developed for this is the Strong Black Woman schema. Introduced in Chapter 8 in the context of the emotion suppression Black girls are taught, the schema is a set of beliefs about what being a Black woman requires. Studied as the Superwoman schema, it was built by Woods-Giscombé (2010) from eight focus groups with African American women, who named five obligations: to project strength, to suppress emotions, to resist vulnerability and dependence, to succeed despite limited resources, and to help others before oneself. The women in those groups named the benefits as well, including the preservation of self, family, and community. Seeking mental health support goes against all five obligations at once.
Among 95 African American women, stronger endorsement of the schema predicted more anxiety and depression, and it was inversely associated with two components of help-seeking attitudes, psychological openness and help-seeking propensity (Watson & Hunter, 2015). Interviews with 30 Black women found that positive attitudes toward therapy did not translate into going. Participants described masking or ignoring pain, an inability to ask for help, and a lack of self-care (Nelson et al., 2020).
Those studies are correlational, which leaves open whether the schema produces the avoidance or merely occurs with it. Howard and Hu (2026) tested the direction experimentally. They randomly assigned 136 Black women to write about six situations related to the schema's characteristics or six unrelated situations, and the women primed with the schema reported lower intentions to seek mental health help. Both groups’ attitudes toward therapy being worthwhile were equally positive. However, believing therapy is worthwhile and being willing to go are not the same thing, and the schema seems to affect willingness more than worthiness.
When White and colleagues (2023) examined the Superwoman schema’s components separately among Black college women, the caretaking and self-reliance subscales predicted more actual help-seeking, while the mask of strength subscale predicted less help-seeking and fewer intentions to seek it. What predicts avoidance is the obligation to perform strength in front of other people, and the authors suggest that interventions might build on the caretaking component while redefining the part that demands emotional invulnerability.
Section Key Terms
This page titled 12.5: Help-Seeking, Treatment, and Barriers was last modified on Fri, 11 Sep 2026 19:01:01 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Rochelle Burnaford.
The book could not be loaded just now.