3.6: How Does Cultural Identity Relate to Special Education?

Introduction to Children with Exceptionalities · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY-NC 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    3.6: How Does Cultural Identity Relate to Special Education?

    Disability, like many other things, is in the eye of the beholder. An individual may be differently gifted or challenged; if that is outside the accepted norm for that society, this difference may be labeled as a disability. For example, in the movie Rainman (Levinson, 1988), Dustin Hoffman’s character is seen as disabled because he lacks certain social skills; however, he is extremely gifted and abled beyond most for memorizing facts that the mainstream public didn’t even notice.

    Like any other macro or micro cultural group, Special Education has developed its own terminology, membership, expectations, way of doing things, etc. When this serves to increase a sense of belonging and make things easier, it can be a benefit to those included in the culture. However, when it works to exclude people or frustrate them, it is counter-productive to help those who may benefit from services. Some may find it interesting that the culture which exists to promote inclusion and to help people succeed can also tend to be exclusive.

    Special Education in the United States has become defined in a very clinical, scientifically based way. This excludes any other perspective. It is done to reach a common consensus of the characteristics and causes of each disabling situation but can be exclusionary to any other belief system. “A disability is assumed to have a biological etiology and an identifiable set of symptoms that constitute that disability”. (Kalyanpur and Harry, p. 45) This approach makes it possible to clearly define a disability for classification purposes but ignores any contextual explanations for the symptoms. Diagnosing a disability may also be highly subjective, even though “professionals” are assumed to be objective.

    Although the United States Special Education system has worked diligently to standardize diagnoses, we should also recognize that individual, spiritual, group and time limit phenomena exist. Consider the following:

    • Individual Phenomenon ~ Attributes disability to each individual person who has the symptoms and addresses it within that person. Ignores the possibility that the disability symptoms are due to the environment, system of approach, etc. Instead of saying “what is wrong with that child?”, we could focus on “what can we change about the educational approach to better reach that child?”. The individual phenomenon can be likened to trying to fit a square peg into a round hole.
    • Spiritual Phenomenon ~ Some cultures believe that the “disability” is due to an occurrence of that child or someone from their family in a prior life. For example (Kalyanpur and Harry, pp. 51-52) a child born with a club foot may be due to an ancestor being buried in a coffin that was too short (pressing his foot into mis-shaped form), or an ancestor losing a foot in an accident. For those who believe in reincarnation, it might be thought that the child with the club foot is really the reincarnate of the uncle who lost his foot in war. When a child is born with a behavioral disorder, it may be attributed to the pollution during pregnancy or to the fact that the parents argued a lot before the child was born. The western world would argue the same thing but from a scientific and medical perspective (stress during pregnancy can result in the baby being born disabled).
    • Group Phenomenon ~ Some cultures believe that the “disability” in a child is due to the actions of ancestors or the situational environment prior to the child’s birth. Treatments suggested by USA Special Education culture do not address what these people believe to be the cause and therefore are seen as irrelevant. How can speech therapy help a child when the speech impediment is payback from the gods because of the grandfather’s habit of lying?
    • Time-limit Phenomenon ~ Western society views disability as something to fix, whereas some cultures view it as a lifetime situation (so why should we try to fix it?). For example, speech therapy in the aforementioned situation would be silly when the speech impediment is imposed by the gods... who do we think we are to alter that? This child will have that for life because he was chosen to bear the burden of the family; if we help him overcome it, it will be given to yet another family member. This child bears our burden, so we will all support this child.

    As teachers prepare to work with families, they must understand the various cultural beliefs and pre-conceived ideas that vary from culture to culture.

    Reflect and Apply

    Imagine that you are meeting with a family whose child could benefit from special education services. It becomes apparent that this family has a culturally based explanation of why the child has a disability. Select one of the alternative phenomena described above, insert it into your scenario, and describe how you would proceed in working with this child and family.

    ✏️ Write a short reflection (5–7 sentences) or discuss your ideas with a classmate or small group. Be ready to share with the class.


    3.6: How Does Cultural Identity Relate to Special Education? is shared under a CC BY-NC 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by LibreTexts.