Opening the book…
After some relationship-building, perhaps by meeting for coffee, in-person or virtually, or perhaps sharing a meal, you may be ready for a more formal conversation, often referred to as a “discovery call.” By now, you are likely to have a good idea of your potential client’s pain points and how you can meet their needs.

During this conversation, be sure to talk about:
Roles and Responsibilities
In my experience, the person who holds the authority for the project needs to be involved throughout the project. If the decision-maker signs the contract then passes off the project to someone else, be sure they are informed about the progress throughout the engagement. This will avoid the situation where the leader comes in at the end and is dissatisfied.
- Who on the client side has the authority for the project?
- What staff will be involved in the development and implementation of the project?
- What is the technical capacity of the staff to support the evaluation?
- Explain the roles of any staff or subcontractors who will work on the project on your side.
Continue to Explore their Pain Points
In the initial exploratory call with your potential client, you learned about some of the challenges their nonprofit or community organization is experiencing. During the discovery call, you want to dig deeper, exploring these challenges further and making the connection between the struggles they are having and the solutions you offer.
- What is the problem that keeps you up at night?
- Where does your team struggle the most?
- What steps have you tried to solve the problem on your own?
- Have you worked with a consultant before? How did that go?
Understand their Goals
To be successful, you need to understand the nonprofit’s goals for the engagement. They may not fully understand, or they may think they know what they want and need, but may be misguided. Asking thoughtful questions will help them articulate their goals.
- What goals or outcomes are you trying to achieve within your organization?
- What are some of the external or internal pressures that are motivating you to explore hiring a consultant currently?
- In thinking about your work, how would you know you are successful?
- If you were to write the last paragraph of your evaluation report, what would it say?
Explore their Communication Preferences
Communication is the key to a healthy consulting-client relationship (see extended section on communication later in the chapter). Discussing how you will communicate will help set you up for success. If they prefer communicating via email and you prefer phone calls, you need to discuss and agree on how you will set up communication. If the potential client prefers in-person communication, and you are not local, you should discuss it before proceeding with a contract. If you have a team, be sure to designate the main point of contact.
Reporting is part of communication, and you should explore that too. For example, if you are working with a foundation that has a more formal operating style, they may prefer detailed meeting notes and status reports formatted in Microsoft Word. For clients with a less formal approach, high-level meeting summaries in a shared Google doc and monthly status updates via email may suffice. Consider asking:
- How do they prefer to communicate (emails, virtual meetings, in-person meetings, etc.)?
- How often do they like to meet during an engagement?
- How do they handle conflict or disagreements (internally and with consultants)?
Understand their Style
Style relates to communication, which includes formality of language and even dress at in-person meetings. If you have a more casual approach but your client is more formal, you may not be seen as “professional.” To help understand their style, ask:
- Does the potential client use a formal, corporate style of working, or are they more casual?
- What is the tone used in their social media and on their website (formal, funny, engaging, etc)?
- How does your style complement or clash with the preferred style of the organization?
- What is their preference for the format of status updates and reports?
- How do they prefer to work with consultants (as “experts” or advisors)?
Understand their Limitations
Understanding the organizational constraints is critical to a successful relationship with community-based nonprofits. This is an area that some consultants avoid, but understanding constraints, particularly budget constraints, is important. You don’t want to be in the situation where you propose a complicated project that is over their budget and/or doesn’t fit the capacity of their staff to support the work. Some questions to ask about limitations include:
- Who else needs to be involved in this decision?
- What are your budget considerations?
- What is the timeframe for deciding on whether to hire a consultant?
- What is the capacity of the staff to support this work and how?
- What is their policy on AI?
Understand their Goals
Effective consulting starts with understanding what a nonprofit hopes to achieve and whether the solutions you are discussing will actually help. Be aware that clients do not always fully understand their needs, so good questions can clarify their goals and point to the most useful scope of work.
The stated scope should be treated as the start of a diagnostic conversation, not the final definition of the work. Sometimes a small adjustment is enough (they ask for a logic model, but they actually need a Theory of Change); other times, the client needs a different engagement altogether (they ask for a survey, but what they really need is a full evaluation plan). Listening carefully and naming that gap can build trust by showing that the consultant is focused on real needs rather than simply agreeing to the initial ask. Consider exploring:
- What goals or outcomes are you trying to achieve?
- What internal or external pressures are leading you to seek consulting support now?
- How will you know this work has been successful?
- If this engagement goes well, what would you want the final report to say about your organization or program?
Set Boundaries
Scope creep (the expansion of project goals, tasks, and/or deliverables outside of the contract) is something you will experience during your career as a consultant. Discussing this upfront is wise. If later changes are needed, it is advisable to require a signed change order document that defines the requested change, and includes compensation for added or revised tasks.
- Set boundaries about “emergencies.” One consultant we know charges double her normal hourly rate for tasks or products the client needs that are outside of her original contract that require a quick turnaround or weekend work. It is not something that has been requested often, but when it has, this boundary has been set and respected.
- Discuss budget and payment schedule. Although discussing money and payment is something many people are uncomfortable with, you must develop this muscle if you are to operate as a business. Don’t be shy about asking for their budget. If their budget is low and the list of deliverables is long, you will know right away that further discussion is needed. You will need to either agree to reduce the tasks and deliverables or expand the budget. If the potential client can’t adjust or is unwilling to do so, be sure to explain the issues and potential pitfalls and refer them to someone else. A low-budget, not-too-technical project would be a good opportunity for a student or new consultant looking to build their portfolio.
A Final Tip for Your Discovery Call
Be sure to listen more than you talk. Listen deeply and practice reflective listening. Be brief and let them know you will follow up with them in a few days. At that time, share a resource you have developed, a podcast episode, or an article that might be helpful to them. The goal is to be helpful and continue developing the relationship.
This page titled 10.2.2: How to Handle a Discovery Call was last modified on Wed, 11 Nov 2026 03:53:22 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Ann Price.
The book could not be loaded just now.