7.5: Consulting Is Easy—and Hard - Learning the Trick Behind Teamwork
Opening the book…
At first glance, consulting seems easy, especially when problems are simple and clearly defined - an evaluation consultant can often work independently. Many consultants begin this way—operating as independent contractors or sole proprietors who provide specialized evaluation expertise to clients without involving a team or collaborators. However, consulting becomes more demanding when the problems being addressed are complex, interdisciplinary, or involve multiple stakeholders. Many evaluation projects require teams of consultants, partnerships across people or organizations, and engagement with clients or communities who bring different perspectives and expertise. As collaboration increases, so does the complexity of the work. The technical task is no longer the only challenge; how people work together becomes equally important. In this case, consultants find that while technical problems are clear and solvable, the interpersonal dynamics of collaboration make the work challenging.
Figure \(\PageIndex{1}\): More complex evaluation projects may require multiple methods of collaboration.
The key to navigating this challenge lies in understanding a simple but powerful distinction between Problem A and Problem B (Kirton, 2011). Consultants are typically hired to solve Problem A—the technical task or evaluation task at hand. But successful consulting also requires resolving Problem B: how best to manage the human dynamics that arise when people work together to solve Problem A. The “trick” to effective consulting is learning how to recognize and manage Problem B so that it does not interfere with solving Problem A. The following vignette illustrates how easily Problem B can derail a project—even when the team has the expertise needed to address Problem A.