In September 2017, during a Facebook board meeting, chief security officer Alex Stamos warned executives that Russian interference remained unresolved and potentially far more extensive than initially disclosed (Frenkel et al., 2018). The briefing triggered internal tensions; afterward, COO Sheryl Sandberg reportedly shouted, “You betrayed us and sacrificed us!” (Frenkel et al., 2018).
As The New York Times reported, Facebook’s crisis-management pattern followed a familiar script: express shock, minimize responsibility, insist on platform neutrality, and “muddy the waters” by highlighting competitors’ failures (Frenkel et al., 2018).
Before 2016, Facebook had neither the infrastructure nor the inclination to address political misinformation. The company’s longstanding internal rule—“Don’t poke the bear”—discouraged intervening in political content, especially when it involved popular or powerful figures (Isaac & Frenkel, 2018). Thus, when Donald Trump posted in December 2015 calling for a “total and complete shutdown of Muslims entering the United States,” Facebook allowed the post to stand, despite internal debate. It was shared over 15,000 timeswithin days (Isaac & Frenkel, 2018).
To counter rising political pressure, Facebook expanded lobbying operations. In October 2017, it hired Definers Public Affairs (DPA), a Republican-aligned communications firm, to shape narratives about Facebook’s critics and competitors (Frenkel et al., 2018). DPA staff operated a conservative outlet, NTK Network, which published negative stories about Google, Apple, and other rivals. After Apple CEO Tim Cook criticized Facebook’s business model, Zuckerberg instructed employees to adopt Android phones instead of iPhones (Frenkel et al., 2018).
DPA also advanced messaging targeting long-time Facebook critic George Soros. After Soros condemned Facebook at the World Economic Forum in Davos, DPA circulated research insinuating that Soros funded anti-Facebook groups (Frenkel et al., 2018). This tactic blurred into partisan political warfare.