Racial pseudoscience is only one thread in a much broader tapestry of misinformation and science denialism—the rejection of scientific consensus on climate change, vaccines, evolution, and even historical facts such as the Holocaust. Denialists frequently claim that science is biased or untested, but research has shown that their rejection usually occurs because the evidence conflicts with their ideological, cultural, or economic worldviews (Lewandowsky & Oberauer, 2016).
Why, then, do so many people fall for falsehoods?
In 2017, Stanford researcher Sam Wineburg and his team compared how three groups—college students, historians, and professional fact-checkers—evaluated the credibility of two organizations:
· the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), a respected professional association with 64,000 members; and
· the American College of Pediatricians (ACPeds), a fringe conservative medical group known for anti-LGBTQ positions, designated a hate group by the Southern Poverty Law Center (Southern Poverty Law Center, 2014).
Both websites were designed to look authoritative, which was the point. Wineburg found:
· All professional fact-checkers correctly identified AAP as more credible.
· Half of historians did; about 40% rated both as trustworthy.
· Nearly two-thirds of Stanford students (64%) incorrectly trusted ACPeds. (Wineburg & McGrew, 2017)
Wineburg concluded:
“Evaluating the source and credibility of information is a fundamental skill for historians. We expected both groups to perform well, but the results were the opposite.”
The study showed that even intelligent, highly educated individuals can be deceived online when they rely on surface features—professional design, official-sounding names, .org domains—rather than lateral reading, contextual verification, or digital literacy skills.