8.2: Impact of the Environment and Toxic Stress on Brain Development
Opening the book…
Content Note:
This section discusses childhood adversity, abuse, neglect, and toxic stress.
These topics may bring up difficult feelings or connect with personal experiences.
Take breaks as needed and approach discussions with care and respect.
You are not expected to share personal experiences to demonstrate your understanding.
Introduction
Young children’s brains develop through ongoing interactions with people, places, and everyday experiences. Responsive relationships, predictable routines, opportunities for play, and environments that meet children’s physical and emotional needs help support this development.
Children also experience stress. Brief, manageable challenges, such as separating from a caregiver or trying an unfamiliar activity, provide opportunities to develop coping skills with adult support. More intense or persistent challenges may place greater demands on children’s developing stress response systems. The effects depend on several factors, including the intensity and duration of the experience and the support available to the child.
This section examines how environmental conditions and stress responses influence brain development. It also explores adverse childhood experiences, protective factors, and the ways early childhood educators can provide responsive relationships and supportive learning environments. Understanding these connections helps educators respond to children’s needs without labeling children or assuming that early adversity determines their future.
Learning Objectives
Course Competency 8.2: Explain the impact of the environment, including the effects of toxic stress, on brain development.
After completing this section, you will be able to:
Explain how relationships, daily experiences, and environmental conditions influence early brain development.
Distinguish among positive, tolerable, and toxic stress responses.
Describe how prolonged activation of the stress response system can affect children’s development and learning.
Explain the relationship among adverse childhood experiences, toxic stress, and protective factors.
Identify ways educators can support children through responsive relationships, predictable routines, family partnerships, and connections to additional resources.
How the Environment Influences Brain Development
Brain development occurs through the ongoing interaction of biology and experience. Genes help guide development, while children’s experiences influence how connections among brain cells form, strengthen, and become organized. As discussed in Section 8.1, brain development involves forming, strengthening, modifying, and selectively eliminating connections. Biological processes and patterns of neural activity, including activity influenced by experience, help shape these changes (Stiles & Jernigan, 2010).
A young child’s environment includes more than the physical space. It includes relationships, caregiving practices, daily routines, language, cultural experiences, and access to basic necessities. These influences work together to shape children’s opportunities to explore, connect with others, and learn.
Responsive Relationships and Everyday Interactions
Responsive relationships are central to early brain development. When an infant looks toward an adult and the adult smiles or speaks, or a toddler points to an animal and an adult names it, they participate in a back-and-forth exchange often called serve and return. The child communicates through a look, movement, sound, or word, and the adult responds with attention and interest.
These exchanges support developing language, social connection, and emotional regulation. They occur throughout ordinary caregiving experiences, including feeding, diapering, dressing, playing, and sharing books. Adults do not need to respond perfectly to every signal. What matters is an ongoing pattern of attentive, caring interaction (Center on the Developing Child at Harvard University, n.d.).
Young children also rely on adults for co-regulation, the support adults provide to help children manage emotions, attention, and behavior. A calm voice, comforting presence, or familiar routine can help a child settle after becoming upset. Through repeated experiences of receiving support, children gradually develop their own regulation skills (Rosanbalm & Murray, 2017).
Physical Conditions and Opportunities for Learning
Children’s physical surroundings and access to resources also influence development. Adequate nutrition, sleep, health care, safe housing, and protection from harmful substances help support the developing brain and body. Comfortable spaces, manageable noise levels, and opportunities for movement can make it easier for children to participate in daily activities (National Scientific Council on the Developing Child, 2015).
Play and exploration provide meaningful opportunities to use developing brain connections. Reaching for a toy, filling and emptying containers, listening to a familiar song, or solving a problem with a peer engages different abilities. These experiences are most supportive when they match children’s developmental abilities, interests, cultures, and individual needs.
A supportive environment does not require expensive toys, constant entertainment, or formal academic instruction. Everyday experiences with caring adults and accessible materials provide valuable opportunities for learning.
Predictability, Safety, and Manageable Challenges
Predictable routines help children learn what to expect. Familiar caregivers, consistent responses, and clear transitions can support a sense of security. Within this foundation, children can encounter manageable challenges, such as waiting briefly for a turn, attempting a new task, or coping with a disappointment.
Children’s responses to these experiences vary. Temperament, developmental abilities, previous experiences, and available support all influence how a child responds. Educators can observe children’s cues and adjust the challenge or provide additional assistance.
Persistent danger, severe deprivation, or prolonged instability can place greater demands on developing stress response systems. Families’ access to housing, food, health care, and community support can affect these conditions. Understanding environmental influences therefore requires attention to both children’s immediate experiences and the broader resources available to their families (National Scientific Council on the Developing Child, 2014, 2015).
Emphasis: Everyday Experiences Matter
Brain development is supported through repeated experiences of responsive care, exploration, and adult assistance with challenges. Early difficulties do not determine a child’s future. Supportive relationships and improved conditions can promote continued learning, adaptation, and recovery.
Understanding Positive, Tolerable, and Toxic Stress Responses
Stress is the body’s response to a challenge or perceived threat. When children encounter something unfamiliar, frustrating, or frightening, their stress response systems help them respond. A temporary increase in alertness, heart rate, and stress hormones can be useful. With time and appropriate support, the body can return to its usual state.
The terms positive, tolerable, and toxic describe patterns of stress response. They do not simply label events. The same experience may affect children differently depending on its intensity and duration, the child’s developmental needs and previous experiences, and the support available (National Scientific Council on the Developing Child, 2014).
Table \(\PageIndex{1}\): Comparing Positive, Tolerable, and Toxic Stress Responses
Stress response
Intensity and duration
Role of adult support
Early childhood example
Positive
Brief, mild to moderate activation of the stress response system during an ordinary challenge.
A responsive adult offers reassurance and assistance, helping the child manage the challenge and recover.
A toddler becomes upset when a caregiver leaves, then settles with a familiar educator and joins an activity.
Tolerable
More intense activation in response to a serious difficulty. The response can subside when safety and effective support are available.
Supportive relationships help buffer the effects and support recovery during and after the experience.
After a frightening storm damages the family’s home, caregivers provide comfort, explain what will happen next, and establish familiar routines in a safe location.
Toxic
Excessive or prolonged activation of stress response systems associated with strong, frequent, or prolonged adversity without sufficient buffering support.
Available support is insufficient to help the child manage the demands and recover. Improving safety, strengthening relationships, and addressing underlying conditions are essential.
A child repeatedly experiences violence and has limited access to a consistently protective adult, leaving the child frequently on alert.
Note
Summary based on National Scientific Council on the Developing Child (2014). Early childhood examples are illustrative and do not establish a diagnosis.
Positive Stress: Managing Everyday Challenges
Positive stress responses are part of healthy development. Trying something new, experiencing a brief frustration, or receiving a vaccination may temporarily activate a child’s stress response system. With responsive support, children can recover and gain experience managing challenges.
Educators support this process by acknowledging feelings, offering help, and adjusting expectations to the child’s abilities. A manageable challenge for one child may be overwhelming for another. Adults should use children’s cues to guide their responses.
Tolerable Stress: Coping With Serious Difficulties
Tolerable stress responses occur in connection with more serious experiences, such as the death of a loved one, a serious injury, or a natural disaster. These situations can produce substantial distress. Supportive adults help children regain a sense of safety, meet their needs, and recover over time.
The term tolerable does not mean that the experience is easy or harmless. It describes a stress response whose potential effects can be buffered through adequate support. Children may need ongoing assistance even after the immediate event has ended.
Toxic Stress: When Demands Exceed Available Support
A toxic stress response can develop when adversity repeatedly or persistently activates the body’s stress response systems without sufficient support. Examples of conditions that may contribute include ongoing abuse, severe neglect, or repeated exposure to violence.
Toxic stress is not another name for ordinary frustration, occasional crying, or all stressful experiences. It also cannot be determined from a single behavior or a family circumstance. Poverty, a caregiver’s mental health condition, or a family separation alone does not establish that a child is experiencing toxic stress. The child’s actual experiences, access to protection, and available supports matter.
Educators can help by providing consistent, responsive care and partnering with families to identify needs and resources. Some situations also require additional professional services or protective action.
Note
Adult Support Buffers Stress
Buffering means reducing the effects of stress through responsive relationships and practical support. Comfort, predictable routines, and help meeting basic needs can support recovery. When danger or severe adversity continues, supportive interactions must be accompanied by efforts to address those conditions.
How the Stress Response System Works
The stress response system helps the body respond to challenges and perceived threats. It involves communication among the brain, nerves, and hormone-producing glands. This system is protective: it prepares a person to act when something may be dangerous.
For young children, a perceived threat might involve a sudden loud noise, a frightening interaction, or separation from a familiar caregiver. Children’s responses depend on their developmental abilities, previous experiences, and how they interpret the situation.
Activating the Body’s Alarm System
When the brain detects a possible threat, the hypothalamus, a small region involved in regulating body functions, helps activate two connected pathways:
A rapid response through the sympathetic nervous system. Nerve signals stimulate the inner portion of the adrenal glands, located above the kidneys, to release hormones including adrenaline. Heart rate and breathing increase, and energy becomes available for immediate action (Chu et al., 2024).
A slower hormonal response through the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis. The hypothalamus signals the pituitary gland, which then signals the outer portion of the adrenal glands to release cortisol. Cortisol helps make energy available and regulates several aspects of the stress response (Chu et al., 2024).
Together, these responses prepare the body to respond to a challenge. A child may become more alert, tense their muscles, cry, move away, or seek an adult. Some children become unusually quiet or still.
Returning to a Settled State
As the threat passes, the body’s recovery processes help reduce activation. The parasympathetic nervous system helps slow the heart rate and supports functions such as digestion. Feedback within the HPA axis helps regulate further cortisol release (Chu et al., 2024).
Young children are still developing the ability to manage these changes. Responsive adults provide co-regulation by offering comfort, reducing overwhelming stimulation, and helping children understand what is happening. Recovery may take time, and children differ in the support they need (Rosanbalm & Murray, 2017).
Figure \(\PageIndex{1}\): The stress response involves rapid nervous system and slower hormonal pathways. Safety, responsive adult support, and the body’s regulatory processes support recovery (OpenAI, 2026).
Note. Simplified explanation of stress response physiology based on Chu et al. (2024). The role of adult co-regulation is informed by Rosanbalm and Murray (2017).
When Activation Continues
When threatening or overwhelming conditions occur repeatedly or persist, the stress response system may have fewer opportunities to recover. Over time, prolonged activation can alter how the system responds to later challenges. Some children may become highly reactive to reminders of danger; others may show less visible distress or appear withdrawn.
Stress hormones are not inherently harmful. Cortisol, for example, has important everyday functions. The concern is prolonged or poorly regulated stress activity during development, rather than the presence of a particular hormone.
Repeated activation can place demands on systems involved in attention, memory, emotional regulation, sleep, and physical health. A child who is focused on detecting danger may have difficulty attending to a story, exploring unfamiliar materials, or participating with peers. These responses may reflect adaptation to stressful conditions, although similar behaviors can have many other explanations (Forkey et al., 2021; National Scientific Council on the Developing Child, 2014).
Connecting Physiology to Educator Responses
Consider a toddler who startles when a tray falls, begins crying, and reaches for an educator. The educator moves close, speaks calmly, and offers comfort. As the toddler settles, the educator follows the child’s cues before supporting a return to play. This interaction illustrates activation followed by adult-supported recovery.
If a child remains distressed or repeatedly reacts strongly to everyday situations, educators can observe patterns, adjust the environment, and communicate with the family. Behavior alone does not reveal a child’s stress hormone levels or establish that the child has experienced trauma.
Emphasis: Support Recovery Before Expecting Participation
When a child is overwhelmed, begin with safety, connection, and co-regulation. Adjust demands and allow time to settle before expecting the child to listen, solve a problem, or rejoin an activity.
Effects of Prolonged Stress on Development and Learning
When stress response systems remain activated repeatedly or for extended periods without sufficient support, they can influence developing brain networks involved in learning, emotional regulation, and responses to danger. The effects vary with the timing, intensity, and duration of adversity, as well as the child’s individual characteristics and access to protective relationships and resources (National Scientific Council on the Developing Child, 2014).
Children’s responses are not always immediately visible. A child may become highly active and reactive, while another becomes quiet or withdrawn. Some children show different responses across settings or at different times.
Attention and Memory
Children need to direct attention, hold information in mind, and connect new experiences with previous learning. Prolonged stress can interfere with these processes. A child who is closely monitoring adults’ voices or movements for signs of danger may have less attention available for a conversation, story, or play activity.
Working memory may also be affected. A child might have difficulty remembering a direction while completing a task or keeping track of the steps in a familiar routine. Stress can make it harder to demonstrate an existing skill, so inconsistent performance does not necessarily mean that the child has lost the skill or cannot learn it (National Scientific Council on the Developing Child, 2014).
Emotional Regulation and Flexible Thinking
Prolonged stress can affect children’s ability to manage strong emotions, pause before acting, and adjust to change. Small frustrations may bring intense reactions, especially when the child is tired, overwhelmed, or reminded of a frightening experience.
For example, an unexpected schedule change may be difficult for a child who relies on predictability to feel secure. The child may cry, resist the transition, or become unusually still. Calm adult support and advance preparation can help the child manage the immediate demand while continuing to develop regulation skills.
Relationships and Social Participation
Previous experiences influence what children expect from other people. When care has been frightening, inconsistent, or unavailable, some children may have difficulty trusting adults, accepting comfort, or seeking help. Others may stay close to a familiar adult and become distressed when that person moves away.
Peer interactions can also be challenging. A child may interpret an accidental bump as a threat, react strongly when another child approaches, or avoid group play. Educators can support participation through consistent responses, sensitive guidance, and opportunities to build relationships at the child’s pace (Forkey et al., 2021).
Physical Well-Being and Engagement
Prolonged stress can influence sleep and other body systems that support daily functioning. A child who has difficulty sleeping may arrive tired, become frustrated more easily, or have less energy for exploration. Changes in appetite or physical discomfort may also affect participation (Forkey et al., 2021).
These connections illustrate why learning cannot be separated from physical and emotional well-being. A child may need rest, food, comfort, movement, or a quieter space before being ready to participate fully.
Interpreting Behavior Carefully
Difficulty concentrating, strong emotional reactions, withdrawal, and disrupted sleep can have many explanations. They may relate to developmental differences, illness, sensory needs, changes in routines, stress, or several factors together. Educators should describe what they observe, consider the context, and collaborate with families rather than assume a cause.
For example, “Maya covered her ears and moved under the table when the room became noisy” provides useful information. “Maya has toxic stress” makes a conclusion that classroom observation alone cannot establish.
Emphasis: Development Remains Open to Change
Early adversity can increase developmental risks, but it does not determine a child’s future. The brain continues to adapt through experience. Greater safety, responsive relationships, practical resources, and appropriate professional support can promote recovery and continued development.
Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) and Toxic Stress
Adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) are potentially traumatic experiences that occur before age 18. They include abuse, neglect, and circumstances that can undermine a child’s sense of safety, stability, and connection. ACEs describe experiences or conditions in a child’s life; toxic stress describes a pattern of excessive or prolonged stress response activation without sufficient buffering support (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2026; National Scientific Council on the Developing Child, 2014).
Experiencing an ACE does not automatically mean that a child develops a toxic stress response. Children’s responses depend on the nature of the experience, their developmental needs, and the protection and support available during and afterward.
Understanding the Original ACE Study
The original CDC–Kaiser Permanente ACE Study examined associations between adults’ reports of childhood adversity and their later health and well-being. Across its two survey waves, more than 17,000 adult health plan members participated (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, n.d.).
The study examined experiences within three broad groups: abuse, neglect, and household challenges. These categories helped researchers investigate patterns across a large group of people.
Table \(\PageIndex{2}\): Categories Examined in the Original ACE Study
Category
Experiences examined
Abuse
Emotional, physical, and sexual abuse.
Neglect
Emotional and physical neglect.
Household challenges
Violence against the mother or stepmother; household substance misuse or mental illness; parental separation or divorce; and an incarcerated household member.
Note. Categories summarized from Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (n.d.). Neglect was assessed during the second survey wave. The original categories do not encompass every form of childhood adversity.
Family circumstances must be understood in context. For example, a caregiver’s mental health diagnosis does not by itself establish that a child receives unsafe or unresponsive care. Separation or divorce may reduce a child’s exposure to conflict or violence. Educators should consider children’s actual experiences and available supports rather than make assumptions about a family.
What ACE Research Can Tell Us
ACE research identifies patterns of increased risk across groups. Higher numbers of reported ACE categories have been associated with greater risk for a range of later difficulties, including some mental and physical health conditions, substance misuse, and challenges in education or employment (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2026).
These associations help explain why preventing adversity and strengthening family and community supports are important. They also show that childhood experiences can have implications extending beyond the immediate situation.
However, an association does not establish that a particular experience caused an individual person’s later difficulties. Health and development are influenced by many interacting factors, including access to resources, ongoing conditions, and supportive relationships.
What an ACE Score Cannot Tell Us
An ACE score typically counts how many categories of adversity a person reports experiencing. It does not fully capture the frequency, severity, timing, or duration of those experiences. It also does not adequately represent the protective relationships and positive experiences in a person’s life (Baldwin et al., 2021).
An ACE score cannot:
Diagnose trauma or a toxic stress response.
Measure an individual child’s brain development or stress hormone activity.
Accurately predict an individual child’s future health or determine the child’s learning potential.
Provide a complete picture of a child’s strengths, needs, or family circumstances.
Support decisions should draw on the child’s current functioning, strengths, relationships, circumstances, and identified needs rather than an ACE score alone (Baldwin et al., 2021).
Using ACE Knowledge in Early Childhood Education
For educators, the value of ACE research lies in understanding the importance of prevention, supportive relationships, and access to resources. Educators can use this knowledge to create responsive environments for all children, recognize when additional support may be needed, and partner respectfully with families.
Educators should not use ACE checklists to question children about potentially traumatic experiences, assign risk labels, or collect unnecessary personal histories. Any formal screening process requires a clear purpose, appropriate preparation, privacy protections, and a plan for responding to identified needs.
Note
ACEs, Toxic Stress, and Trauma Are Related but Distinct
ACEs describe potentially traumatic experiences during childhood. Toxic stress describes excessive or prolonged activation of stress response systems without sufficient support. Trauma refers to the lasting adverse effects that an experience or set of circumstances can have on a person’s functioning and well-being. These concepts overlap, but they are not interchangeable.
Protective Factors, Positive Experiences, and Resilience
Children’s development is influenced by both the challenges they encounter and the supports available to them. Protective factors are conditions, relationships, and resources that reduce risk or help children and families manage adversity. These supports can exist within the child, family, early childhood program, and broader community.
Protective factors do not erase difficult experiences or guarantee that a child will avoid lasting effects. They can reduce exposure to adversity, buffer stress responses, and create opportunities for recovery and continued development.
Responsive Relationships and Positive Experiences
A stable, responsive relationship with a caring adult is an important source of protection. Adults help children feel connected, respond to their needs, and provide assistance when situations become overwhelming. Children benefit when supportive relationships extend across home, early childhood settings, and the community (National Scientific Council on the Developing Child, 2015).
Positive childhood experiences include experiences of being cared for, feeling a sense of belonging, participating in enjoyable routines, and receiving support during difficulties. For young children, these experiences may include:
Being comforted by a familiar adult when distressed.
Sharing songs, stories, play, and family traditions.
Having their home language and cultural identity respected.
Exploring and making choices with appropriate adult support.
Experiencing predictable routines and warm interactions.
Positive experiences are valuable in their own right. They should not be treated as points that cancel out adverse experiences. Children need both supportive experiences and protection from ongoing harm.
Family Strengths and Practical Resources
Families bring knowledge, relationships, cultural practices, and problem-solving strategies that can support children during difficult times. Educators can build on these strengths by asking what helps the child feel comfortable, which routines are meaningful, and whom the family identifies as trusted sources of support.
Practical resources also matter. Reliable access to food, housing, health care, transportation, and child care can reduce pressures on families and make responsive caregiving easier to sustain. A caregiver may understand a child’s needs but face barriers to meeting them. Effective support therefore includes attention to material conditions as well as caregiving practices.
Community resources may include early intervention services, mental health care, family resource centers, culturally responsive organizations, and opportunities for social connection. Access depends partly on whether services are affordable, welcoming, available in the family’s language, and reachable when needed (Forkey et al., 2021; National Scientific Council on the Developing Child, 2015).
Understanding Resilience
Resilience is the process of adapting positively in the context of significant adversity. It develops through interactions among individuals and their environments and can change over time (National Scientific Council on the Developing Child, 2015).
Resilience is not a fixed personality trait or an expectation that children should manage hardship independently. A child may function well in one area while needing substantial support in another. Appearing calm, compliant, or successful does not necessarily mean that a child is unaffected by adversity.
For young children, resilience is supported through repeated experiences of receiving help, participating in manageable challenges, and returning to a sense of safety. Adults carry much of the responsibility for creating those conditions.
Supporting Adaptation in Everyday Practice
Consider a family temporarily living with relatives after losing housing. The child’s educator maintains a familiar arrival routine, offers a preferred book, and provides additional support during transitions. In conversation with the family, the educator learns that a familiar song helps the child settle and incorporates it into the day.
With the family’s agreement, the program also helps connect them with housing and transportation resources. The familiar routines and responsive interactions support the child’s immediate participation, while practical assistance addresses conditions contributing to family stress.
Emphasis: Resilience Requires Support
Strengthening resilience means increasing access to safety, responsive relationships, meaningful participation, and practical resources. Children should not be expected to adapt to ongoing harm without changes to the conditions around them.
The Educator’s Role in Creating Supportive, Trauma-Informed Environments
A trauma-informed approach recognizes that traumatic experiences can affect development and participation and uses that understanding to guide relationships, environments, and responses. It emphasizes safety, trust, collaboration, and meaningful choice while seeking to avoid practices that may intensify distress (Forkey et al., 2021).
Educators do not need to know a child’s trauma history to provide responsive care. Supportive practices can benefit all children while allowing educators to individualize assistance based on observed needs.
Build Safety Through Consistent Relationships
Children develop trust through repeated experiences of adults responding predictably and respectfully. Educators can greet children warmly, follow through on what they say, and explain what will happen next. When staffing changes occur, familiar adults can help children become comfortable with another caregiver.
Physical and emotional safety work together. Educators maintain appropriate supervision, respond promptly to distress, and protect children from ridicule, threats, and humiliation. They also respect individual preferences for comfort. Some children welcome a hug; others prefer an adult sitting nearby. Comfort should follow the child’s cues rather than require physical contact.
Make Routines Predictable and Flexible
Consistent routines help children anticipate daily experiences. Simple picture schedules, familiar transition songs, and advance notice of changes can make expectations easier to understand.
Predictability should allow room for individual needs. An overwhelmed child may need additional time, a quieter route between activities, or support from a familiar adult. When plans change, educators can explain the change in concrete language and identify what will remain familiar.
Provide Co-Regulation During Distress
When a child becomes overwhelmed, the educator’s first response is to support safety and regulation. Helpful actions may include lowering their voice, reducing language, moving nearby without crowding, and offering a familiar calming activity (Rosanbalm & Murray, 2017).
Educators can acknowledge feelings while maintaining clear limits: “You are upset. I will help keep everyone safe. I won’t let you hit.” Teaching problem-solving or discussing what happened is more effective when the child is ready to engage.
Breathing exercises, movement, and quiet spaces may help some children, but no strategy works for everyone. A quiet area should be accessible as a supportive option, with adult assistance as needed, rather than used as punishment or forced isolation.
Offer Meaningful Choices and Accessible Participation
Small, appropriate choices can give children some control over their experiences. An educator might ask, “Would you like to sit beside me or on the cushion?” or “Will you carry the picture card or hold my hand as we walk?”
Choices should be genuine and manageable. Safety requirements remain the adult’s responsibility. Educators can also offer different ways to participate, such as watching an activity before joining, using gestures instead of speaking, or engaging with a smaller group.
Materials, communication, and routines should reflect children’s languages, cultures, abilities, and family experiences. A sense of belonging grows when children can recognize themselves and their families in the learning environment.
Observe Patterns and Adjust Support
Objective observations help educators identify situations that may be difficult for a child and evaluate whether support is helping. Useful details include what happened before the behavior, how the child responded, what the adult did, and what followed.
For example, repeated observations may show that a child becomes distressed during crowded transitions but participates comfortably when moving with a small group. The educator can adjust the transition and observe the child’s response.
Observation guides support; it does not establish a trauma diagnosis. Educators should consider multiple explanations and collaborate with families and appropriate professionals when concerns persist.
Maintain Professional Boundaries and Team Support
Educators provide responsive care and facilitate access to additional assistance when needed. Diagnosing trauma and providing trauma treatment require appropriately qualified professionals. Programs can support educators through consultation, reflective supervision, shared planning, and manageable working conditions.
Consistent adult support is easier to sustain when educators also have opportunities to regulate their own emotions, seek assistance, and reflect on difficult interactions (Forkey et al., 2021; Rosanbalm & Murray, 2017).
Partnering With Families and Connecting With Additional Support
Families are essential partners in understanding children’s experiences and planning effective support. Respectful collaboration begins with recognizing family strengths, listening to concerns, and sharing observations without blame. Educators can offer assistance without requiring families to disclose private or painful experiences.
Communicate With Respect and Curiosity
Conversations about concerns should occur privately, using the family’s preferred language and an accessible communication method. Begin with the child’s strengths, describe specific observations, and invite the family’s perspective.
For example, an educator might say, “Lena enjoys playing beside you at arrival. This week, she has cried for about fifteen minutes after goodbye and has wanted me nearby. What helps her feel comfortable when you leave her with someone familiar?”
This approach opens a conversation without assuming that the child has experienced trauma. Families may identify helpful routines, recent changes, health concerns, or other information they choose to share. Educators can then agree on a manageable plan and a time to review how it is working.
Protect Privacy and Explain Its Limits
Information about children and families should be documented securely and shared only with people who are authorized to receive it for a legitimate professional purpose. Sensitive conversations should not occur in hallways, at classroom doors, or within hearing of other families.
Before sharing information with an outside provider, educators should obtain appropriate consent unless disclosure is required or otherwise authorized by law. Families should understand what information will be shared, with whom, and for what purpose.
Educators should also explain that confidentiality has limits when child safety or reporting obligations are involved. They should not promise a child or caregiver that information about possible harm will remain secret.
Connect Families With Appropriate Services
When concerns persist or extend beyond the educator’s role, additional support may be useful. Depending on the need, options may include a child’s health care provider, early intervention or preschool special education services, infant and early childhood mental health consultation, or community assistance with food, housing, and transportation (Forkey et al., 2021).
Discuss referrals collaboratively. Explain the reason for suggesting a service, ask about the family’s priorities, and explore barriers such as cost, transportation, language access, or scheduling. With permission, a warm handoff—helping the family connect directly with a service—may be more useful than providing a list of telephone numbers.
Continue classroom support while the family considers or accesses services. Follow up respectfully without pressuring the family to disclose treatment details or unnecessary personal information.
Respond When Safety Concerns Arise
Family partnership also includes fulfilling responsibilities to protect children. Educators must know the reporting requirements that apply to their role and location, including when, how, and to whom a report must be made.
FFor example, Wisconsin identifies child care workers and providers as mandated reporters. They must report to county child protective services or law enforcement when they have reasonable cause to suspect that a child seen during professional duties has been abused or neglected, or reason to believe that the child has been threatened with abuse or neglect and that it will occur (Wisconsin Department of Children and Families, n.d.).
If a child describes possible harm, listen calmly, avoid leading or repeated questions, and record the child’s words accurately. The educator’s role is to respond and report as required; investigating the allegation belongs to the appropriate authorities. Do not delay a required report while seeking proof or family permission. Internal program procedures should support the applicable reporting obligation.
When immediate danger or an urgent medical need is present, seek emergency assistance. Decisions about communicating with caregivers concerning suspected abuse should follow applicable requirements and guidance from the receiving agency, particularly when notification could increase risk.
Note
Support and Reporting Serve Different Purposes
A request for food, housing, or parenting assistance calls for a respectful response and connections to resources. Family hardship alone should not be treated as proof of maltreatment. When information meets the applicable threshold for a required report, offering voluntary services does not replace that responsibility.
Putting It Into Practice
Understanding environmental influences and stress responses helps educators make intentional decisions. The following scenario illustrates how an educator can respond to a child’s needs while remaining open to different explanations for the child’s behavior.
Classroom Scenario: Supporting Mateo During Transitions
Mateo, age 30 months, recently began crying and covering his ears when cleanup music starts. He sometimes pushes materials away and stays near the book corner while other children move to wash their hands. Earlier in the morning, he often explores materials and plays comfortably beside a familiar peer.
His educator, Janelle, records what happens before, during, and after several transitions. She notices that Mateo becomes distressed when loud music begins suddenly and several children move through the same space. He settles more readily when she sits nearby and speaks softly.
Janelle does not assume that Mateo has experienced trauma or is showing a toxic stress response. She uses her observations to identify immediate supports.
Respond With Co-Regulation
When Mateo becomes distressed, Janelle moves nearby, lowers her voice, and says, “That was loud. I’m here.” She gives him space and offers to sit with him in the book corner. She allows time for him to settle before helping him move to the next activity.
If Mateo pushes materials toward another child, Janelle calmly blocks the materials and says, “I won’t let the blocks hit anyone. I can help you.” She maintains safety while continuing to offer support.
Adjust the Environment
Janelle replaces the sudden cleanup music with a quieter verbal cue and a picture showing what happens next. She gives Mateo advance notice, helps him put away a few materials, and arranges for children to wash their hands in smaller groups.
She offers a manageable choice: “Would you like to carry the picture or walk beside me?” These changes make the transition more predictable and reduce crowding.
Partner With the Family
In a private conversation, Janelle shares her observations and asks what helps Mateo during changes at home. His caregiver explains that the family’s work schedule recently changed and Mateo has been sleeping less consistently. A familiar song and a short explanation usually help him prepare for a transition.
Together, they agree to use similar words before changes and incorporate the familiar song quietly. Janelle does not request a detailed family history. She asks whether the caregiver would like help locating any additional resources and respects the family’s priorities.
Observe and Follow Up
Over the next two weeks, Janelle documents how Mateo responds. He begins moving toward handwashing after the picture cue and accepts help putting materials away. He still needs additional support on some mornings.
Janelle shares this progress with the family and continues the helpful strategies. If distress persists, increases, or affects other parts of Mateo’s day, she will revisit the plan with the family and discuss appropriate consultation or referral.
Reflect on the Educator’s Decisions
Consider the following questions:
Which observations helped Janelle identify changes to the environment?
How did she provide co-regulation while maintaining safety?
How did family knowledge influence the support plan?
What evidence suggested that the changes were helping?
Why would it be inappropriate to conclude that Mateo’s behavior demonstrated toxic stress?
Emphasis: Respond to Needs and Review the Results
Observe the context, provide responsive support, collaborate with the family, and evaluate the child’s response. Educators can make meaningful changes without determining a diagnosis or knowing every detail of a child’s experiences.
Vocabulary Alert
Stress response system: The coordinated activity of the brain, nervous system, and hormones that prepares the body to respond to a challenge or perceived threat.
Positive stress response: Brief, mild to moderate activation of the stress response system during a manageable challenge, with responsive support available.
Tolerable stress response: More intense activation associated with a serious difficulty, whose potential effects can be buffered by supportive relationships and opportunities for recovery.
Toxic stress response: Excessive or prolonged activation of stress response systems associated with strong, frequent, or prolonged adversity without sufficient buffering support.
Co-regulation: Support provided through responsive relationships, supportive environments, and guidance that helps children manage emotions, attention, and behavior.
Adverse childhood experiences (ACEs): Potentially traumatic experiences before age 18, including abuse, neglect, and circumstances that can undermine safety, stability, and connection.
Trauma: Lasting adverse effects of an experience or set of circumstances on a person’s functioning and well-being.
Protective factors: Conditions, relationships, and resources that reduce risk or help children and families manage adversity.
Resilience: The process of adapting positively in the context of significant adversity, supported by interactions between individuals and their environments.
Trauma-informed approach: An approach that recognizes the possible effects of trauma and emphasizes safety, trust, collaboration, and meaningful choice while seeking to avoid increasing distress.
Exercise \(\PageIndex{1}\)
Check Your Understanding
Explain how responsive relationships and physical conditions work together to support brain development. Include one example of each.
How do positive, tolerable, and toxic stress responses differ? Explain why knowing what happened to a child is not enough to determine the type of stress response.
A child frequently watches the classroom doorway, has difficulty following familiar directions, and rarely joins sustained play. How might prolonged stress help explain these observations? Why should the educator consider other explanations?
Explain the difference between adverse childhood experiences and a toxic stress response. Why is an ACE score insufficient for accurately predicting an individual child’s future or identifying all the support the child needs?
Apply What You Know
After a family moves into temporary housing, their toddler begins crying during arrival and resisting transitions. Describe how the educator could use co-regulation, environmental changes, family partnership, and follow-up observations to support the child.
Answers
Answers to Check Your Understanding
Responsive relationships provide back-and-forth interaction, comfort, and assistance with challenges. Physical conditions support children’s health and opportunities to participate. For example, an adult who responds to an infant’s gestures supports communication and connection, while adequate sleep and a comfortable play space help the infant remain available for interaction and exploration. These influences work together throughout daily experiences.
Positive stress responses involve brief activation during manageable challenges. Tolerable stress responses involve more intense activation during serious difficulties, with sufficient support to buffer potential effects and promote recovery. Toxic stress responses involve excessive or prolonged activation associated with adversity without sufficient buffering support. An event alone does not establish the response because intensity, duration, developmental needs, previous experiences, and available support vary among children.
A child focused on detecting possible danger may have less attention available for directions or play. Prolonged stress may also affect working memory and regulation, making participation more difficult. However, these observations do not establish toxic stress or trauma. Hearing differences, language comprehension, fatigue, sensory needs, developmental differences, and other circumstances could contribute. The educator should document patterns, provide support, and collaborate with the family.
ACEs describe potentially traumatic childhood experiences; a toxic stress response describes excessive or prolonged activation of stress response systems without sufficient support. Experiencing an ACE does not automatically produce toxic stress. An ACE score counts categories but does not fully represent severity, timing, duration, protective relationships, or adversity outside the questionnaire. It cannot diagnose a child or determine future outcomes. Support should reflect the child’s current strengths, needs, relationships, and circumstances.
Answers to Apply What You Know
The educator could offer a calm greeting, remain nearby, and follow the toddler’s cues for comfort. A consistent goodbye routine, picture cues, and advance notice could make transitions more predictable. In private conversation, the educator could ask the family which routines help and whether practical resources would be useful, without requiring a detailed personal history. Follow-up observations could track how long distress lasts, which supports help, and how participation changes. The educator and family could review the plan and consider additional assistance if concerns persist.
References
Baldwin, J. R., Caspi, A., Meehan, A. J., Ambler, A., Arseneault, L., Fisher, H. L., Harrington, H., Matthews, T., Odgers, C. L., Poulton, R., Ramrakha, S., Moffitt, T. E., & Danese, A. (2021). Population vs individual prediction of poor health from results of adverse childhood experiences screening. JAMA Pediatrics, 175(4), 385–393. ACE screening and individual prediction study
Center on the Developing Child at Harvard University. (n.d.). Serve and return.Serve and return overview
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (n.d.). About the CDC-Kaiser ACE study.Original ACE study overview
Chu, B., Marwaha, K., Sanvictores, T., Awosika, A. O., & Ayers, D. (2024, May 7). Physiology, stress reaction. In StatPearls. StatPearls Publishing. Stress response physiology
Forkey, H., Szilagyi, M., Kelly, E. T., Duffee, J., Council on Foster Care, Adoption, and Kinship Care, Council on Community Pediatrics, Council on Child Abuse and Neglect, & Committee on Psychosocial Aspects of Child and Family Health. (2021). Trauma-informed care. Pediatrics, 148(2), Article e2021052580. Trauma-informed care clinical report
National Scientific Council on the Developing Child. (2014). Excessive stress disrupts the architecture of the developing brain: Working paper no. 3 (Updated ed.). Center on the Developing Child at Harvard University. Working paper on excessive stress and brain development
National Scientific Council on the Developing Child. (2015). Supportive relationships and active skill-building strengthen the foundations of resilience: Working paper no. 13. Center on the Developing Child at Harvard University. Working paper on relationships and resilience
OpenAI. (2026). The stress response: Activation and recovery [AI-generated image].
Rosanbalm, K. D., & Murray, D. W. (2017). Co-regulation from birth through young adulthood: A practice brief (OPRE Brief No. 2017-80). Office of Planning, Research and Evaluation, Administration for Children and Families, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Co-regulation practice brief
Stiles, J., & Jernigan, T. L. (2010). The basics of brain development. Neuropsychology Review, 20(4), 327–348. Basics of brain development article