6.6: Environmental Rating Scales Related to Approaches to Learning
Opening the book…
Introduction
Children’s approaches to learning develop through their experiences with people, materials, activities, and routines. An environment that offers meaningful choices, accessible materials, time to explore, and responsive educator support can encourage children to ask questions, try new ideas, and persist when challenges arise (National Association for the Education of Young Children [NAEYC], 2020).
Environmental rating scales and interaction measures help educators examine these learning conditions. Rather than assessing an individual child’s abilities, these tools focus on the quality of the setting and the experiences provided within it. Findings can help educators identify strengths, recognize barriers to participation, and make intentional improvements.
This section explores environmental measures related to approaches to learning and explains how educators can use the information to support children’s curiosity, initiative, persistence, creativity, and engagement.
Learning Objectives
Course Competency 6.6: Explore the types and purposes of environmental rating scales related to approaches to learning.
By the end of this section, you will be able to:
Explain how environmental assessment differs from developmental screening and individual child assessment.
Compare the purposes and focus of environmental rating scales and interaction measures.
Describe how learning environments and educator interactions support approaches to learning.
Identify considerations for selecting, using, and interpreting environmental measures.
Use environmental assessment findings to plan improvements in early childhood practice.
What Are Environmental Measures?
Environmental measures are tools used to examine the quality of an early childhood setting, including its spaces, materials, routines, activities, and interactions. Some provide a broad picture of the learning environment, while others focus more closely on educator–child interactions (ERS Institute, n.d.; Teachstone, n.d.-b).
These measures help educators consider whether children have opportunities and support to explore, make choices, solve problems, and stay engaged. For example, an assessment may examine whether materials are accessible, children have enough time to develop their play, and educators encourage children to test their ideas.
Program quality includes both process quality and structural quality. Process quality refers to children’s everyday experiences, including their interactions with educators, peers, and materials. Structural quality refers to program characteristics such as group size, staff-to-child ratios, and staff qualifications. Environmental measures differ in how much attention they give to these aspects of quality (Zaslow et al., 2010).
Environmental Assessment and Individual Child Assessment
Environmental assessment focuses on the conditions provided for learning. Developmental screening and ongoing child assessment focus on an individual child’s development and learning. These approaches provide different, complementary information.
Table \(\PageIndex{1}\): Different Purposes of Environmental Assessment, Developmental Screening, and Ongoing Child Assessment.
Assessment approach
Primary focus
Example question
Environmental assessment
The quality of the setting and interactions children experience
Do children have meaningful choices, time to explore, and support to work through challenges?
Developmental screening
Whether a child may need further evaluation of development
Do screening results suggest a developmental concern that needs follow-up?
Ongoing child assessment
A child’s strengths, interests, progress, and support needs over time
How does this child approach unfamiliar activities, and what helps the child persist?
Note
This comparison synthesizes environmental measurement and child assessment guidance (ERS Institute, n.d.; NAEYC, 2020; Teachstone, n.d.-b).
Educators can use these sources of information together. If observations show that children frequently abandon activities, an environmental assessment may help educators examine possible contributing conditions, such as interrupted play, inaccessible materials, or limited support during challenging tasks.
Note
Assess the Environment, Not the Child
An environmental assessment score describes the setting or interactions observed. It does not measure an individual child’s curiosity, motivation, persistence, or ability. Educators use the findings to improve learning conditions while continuing to observe and support each child.
Types of Environmental Measures Related to Approaches to Learning
Environmental measures differ in what they examine. Some assess the overall learning environment, while others focus on the interactions children experience with educators. Both can help educators identify conditions that support approaches to learning.
Environment Rating Scales (ERS)
The Environment Rating Scales (ERS) examine multiple aspects of an early childhood setting, including spaces, furnishings, care routines, materials, learning activities, interactions, and program structure. Different scales are designed for infant and toddler settings, preschool classrooms, family child care homes, and school-age programs (ERS Institute, n.d.).
ERS findings can help educators examine whether the environment offers accessible materials, varied learning opportunities, and routines that support children’s participation. These conditions matter when children choose activities, explore ideas, and continue working through challenges.
Classroom Assessment Scoring System (CLASS)
The Classroom Assessment Scoring System (CLASS) focuses on the quality of educator–child interactions. Its emphasis differs from measures that broadly examine physical spaces and materials. CLASS tools vary by developmental level and edition. CLASS Second Edition includes Infant–Toddler and Pre-K–3rd tools; programs should select the version appropriate to their setting and assessment requirements (Teachstone, n.d.-a, n.d.-b).
CLASS findings can help educators reflect on how they respond to children’s interests, support participation, and extend thinking. For example, an educator might consider whether conversations encourage children to explain an idea, try another strategy, or take an active role in learning.
Table \(\PageIndex{2}\): Environmental Measures and Their Connections to Approaches to Learning.
Measure
Primary focus
Appropriate setting
Connection to approaches to learning
Infant/Toddler Environment Rating Scale, Third Edition (ITERS-3)
The quality of infant and toddler environments, routines, activities, and interactions
Group settings serving infants and toddlers
Helps educators examine opportunities for safe exploration, active participation, and responsive support
Early Childhood Environment Rating Scale, Third Edition (ECERS-3)
The quality of preschool environments, routines, activities, and interactions
Preschool group settings
Helps educators examine choices, materials, play opportunities, and support for sustained engagement
Family Child Care Environment Rating Scale, Third Edition (FCCERS-3)
The quality of environments and experiences in family child care
Family child care homes, often serving mixed ages
Helps educators examine how spaces, materials, and routines support exploration and participation across ages
School-Age Care Environment Rating Scale, Updated Edition (SACERS-U)
The quality of environments and experiences in school-age care
Before-school, after-school, and other school-age care programs
Helps educators examine opportunities for initiative, collaboration, problem-solving, and independent activity
Classroom Assessment Scoring System (CLASS)
The quality of educator–child interactions
Settings matching the developmental level of the selected CLASS version
Helps educators examine how interactions support children’s engagement, initiative, and thinking
Note
Tool descriptions and settings are based on ERS Institute (n.d.) and Teachstone (n.d.-a, n.d.-b). Connections to approaches to learning are instructional applications informed by NAEYC (2020), rather than official scoring categories.
These tools examine conditions that can support approaches to learning; they do not directly measure each child’s curiosity, creativity, or persistence. Educators select the appropriate tool and edition for their setting and use its findings alongside observations of children and information from families.
What Do These Measures Assess?
Environmental measures examine features of a setting that shape children’s everyday learning experiences. Although each tool has its own focus and criteria, findings can help educators consider how the environment and their interactions support approaches to learning.
Having materials available is only part of the picture. Children also need opportunities to use them, time to develop their ideas, and responsive support when they encounter challenges.
Table \(\PageIndex{3}\): Learning Conditions Related to Approaches to Learning.
Area to examine
What educators consider
Connection to approaches to learning
Spaces and accessible materials
Can children reach, choose, and use materials? Can children with different abilities participate?
Accessible spaces and materials support initiative and exploration.
Variety of learning experiences
Do children have opportunities to investigate, create, build, pretend, and solve problems?
Varied, open-ended experiences encourage curiosity and creativity.
Schedules and routines
Do children have time to become involved in activities? Are transitions predictable and manageable?
Time and predictability support sustained engagement and persistence.
Emotional climate and responsive support
Do educators respond warmly, recognize children’s cues, and support them during frustration?
Supportive relationships help children feel comfortable trying unfamiliar activities and seeking help.
Meaningful choices and participation
Can children contribute ideas and make choices within appropriate limits?
Meaningful participation supports initiative and ownership of learning.
Interactions that extend thinking
Do educators invite children to explain, predict, investigate, and try different strategies?
Thoughtful interactions support flexible thinking and problem-solving.
Note
These learning conditions synthesize developmentally appropriate teaching guidance (NAEYC, 2020); they are not an official assessment checklist.
These areas provide a way to connect environmental assessment findings to teaching decisions. They are not a substitute for a tool’s official criteria, and not every tool assesses every area listed.
Why Use Environmental Measures?
Environmental measures help educators examine the learning conditions children experience and identify specific ways to improve them. Findings are most useful when they lead to reflection, planning, and changes in everyday practice.
Educators and programs can use environmental measures to:
Identify strengths. Recognize spaces, routines, materials, and interactions that support children’s exploration and engagement.
Recognize barriers to participation. Examine conditions that may limit children’s choices, access, or opportunities to develop their ideas.
Guide intentional improvements. Select manageable changes, such as extending play periods, making materials easier to reach, or supporting children’s problem-solving.
Focus professional learning. Identify areas where coaching, training, or shared reflection could strengthen practice.
Review progress. Revisit learning conditions after making changes and consider whether children have more opportunities to participate, explore, and persist (Teachstone, n.d.-b; Zaslow et al., 2010).
For approaches to learning, these measures help educators look beyond a child’s behavior to consider the conditions surrounding it. If children rarely initiate activities, for example, educators might examine whether choices are meaningful, materials are inviting and accessible, and adults allow children time to act on their interests.
Use Findings to Guide Improvement
An assessment score is a starting point for reflection. The purpose is to use the findings to strengthen children’s everyday experiences. A useful improvement plan identifies what will change, who will support the change, and how educators will review its effects.
Choosing and Using Environmental Measures
An environmental measure is most useful when it matches the setting, answers a clear question, and provides information educators can use to improve practice. Selecting a tool requires attention to its purpose, quality, and relevance to the children and families served.
Match the Tool to the Purpose and Setting
Begin by identifying what the program wants to examine. A broad environmental rating scale may be appropriate for reviewing spaces, materials, routines, and interactions. An interaction measure may be more useful when the goal is to strengthen how educators respond to children and extend their thinking.
Select the tool and edition intended for the children’s developmental levels and program type. Review the manual for administration procedures, observer qualifications, and interpretation guidance. Formal assessment may require training or certification; informal reflection using a tool’s concepts does not replace a properly administered assessment (ERS Institute, n.d.; Teachstone, n.d.-b).
Consider Reliability and Validity
Reliability refers to the consistency of assessment results. For example, trained observers using the same criteria should reach reasonably consistent judgments about the same observed experiences.
Validity concerns whether evidence supports interpreting and using results for a particular purpose (Zaslow et al., 2010). A tool designed to assess educator–child interactions should not be used to draw conclusions about an individual child’s developmental abilities.
Follow the tool’s procedures rather than changing criteria or scoring rules. Educators can adapt classroom practices in response to findings while preserving the assessment procedures needed for meaningful interpretation.
Use a Culturally and Linguistically Responsive Approach
Interpret findings with attention to children’s languages, family practices, abilities, and community contexts. Consider whose experiences are represented in the materials and whether children have meaningful ways to participate (NAEYC, 2020; Zaslow et al., 2010).
For example, a multilingual child may show initiative through gestures, actions, or a home language. An educator who recognizes these forms of communication can respond to the child’s ideas and support continued engagement. Family perspectives can help educators understand participation that might otherwise be overlooked.
Cultural responsiveness also requires examining whether the selected tool is appropriate for the setting and recognizing limitations in its evidence or criteria.
Recognize the Limits of the Results
Environmental assessment provides information about the conditions observed during a particular period. Daily variations, attendance, activities, and observer judgments can influence what is captured. A single observation may not represent the full range of children’s experiences.
Use findings alongside ongoing observations, family input, educator reflection, and other relevant program information. Look at specific findings as well as overall scores to determine what needs attention (Zaslow et al., 2010).
Note
One Measure Cannot Answer Every Question
An environmental measure does not provide a complete picture of program quality or explain every child’s behavior. It should be used for its intended purpose and combined with other information to guide thoughtful improvements.
The Educator’s Role: From Findings to Improvement
Educators turn environmental assessment findings into changes in everyday practice. This involves examining children’s experiences, choosing a focused improvement, and reviewing whether the change supports participation and learning (NAEYC, 2020; Teachstone, n.d.-b).
Review the Findings
Identify strengths and areas needing attention. Look beyond the overall score to consider specific spaces, routines, activities, and interactions. Connect findings with classroom observations: When do children initiate activities, stay engaged, or seek help? When do they encounter barriers?
Identify a Priority
Choose a manageable improvement that addresses a meaningful need. For example, educators might focus on making materials accessible, reducing interruptions during play, or giving children more opportunities to solve problems before adults step in.
Describe the priority in terms of children’s experiences: “Children will have more opportunities to choose and use materials independently” gives clearer direction than “Improve the materials score.”
Make Intentional Changes
Plan what will change, who will help, and what resources are needed. Changes may involve rearranging a space, adjusting a routine, introducing adapted materials, or practicing a different interaction strategy.
Use responsive support. Some children may need a visual cue, a demonstration, or help getting started before they can participate more independently.
Observe and Reflect
After implementing the change, observe how children respond over time. Are more children participating? Do they initiate activities, try different strategies, or remain engaged longer?
Use these observations to decide whether to continue, adjust, or expand the improvement. When repeating a formal environmental assessment, follow the tool’s administration procedures.
The Environmental Improvement Cycle
Environmental improvement is an ongoing process. Educators use assessment findings and children’s responses together to guide their next decisions.
Figure \(\PageIndex{1}\): Educators use an ongoing cycle to review findings, identify a priority, make changes, and observe and reflect (OpenAI, 2026).
Note. This instructional cycle synthesizes improvement practices informed by NAEYC (2020) and Teachstone (n.d.-b); it is not an official scoring procedure for an environmental measure.
Partnering With Families
Families offer valuable perspectives on what captures children’s interest, how they approach challenges, and what helps them participate. Educators can use this information alongside environmental assessment findings to plan improvements that reflect the children and families in the program (NAEYC, 2020).
Invite Family Perspectives
Ask specific, strengths-based questions that connect to children’s everyday experiences:
What does your child enjoy exploring or figuring out?
When something is difficult, what helps your child keep trying?
How does your child communicate ideas or ask for help?
What familiar activities, materials, languages, or experiences could we include in the classroom?
Offer accessible ways for families to contribute, such as conversations, translated messages, photographs, or brief written responses. Participation should be voluntary and should not depend on families purchasing materials.
Share Findings Clearly
Explain what the environmental assessment examined and how the program will use the findings. Use plain language and concrete examples rather than relying on scores or tool terminology.
For example, an educator might explain: “We noticed that some materials were difficult for children to reach independently. We are rearranging the shelves so children can make more choices during play.”
Make clear that environmental findings describe learning conditions and interactions, rather than rating individual children or families.
Use Family Input and Follow Up
Family input can help educators select meaningful materials, recognize children’s communication, and understand interests that may be less visible in the classroom. Combine these perspectives with observations and assessment findings when planning changes.
After making an improvement, share what educators are noticing and invite families to describe related experiences at home. Children may participate differently across settings; these differences provide useful information for continued reflection.
Example \(\PageIndex{1}\)
Building on a Familiar Interest
An environmental assessment identifies limited variety in the classroom’s open-ended materials. An educator asks families what their children enjoy creating and investigating. Several describe children pretending to cook and building with boxes.
The educator adds pretend cooking materials that reflect family experiences, along with sturdy boxes for construction. Over the following weeks, the educator observes whether these additions invite more children to initiate play, contribute ideas, and remain engaged.
Putting It Into Practice
Environmental assessment findings become useful when educators connect them to children’s experiences and make intentional changes. The following example shows how an educator uses findings, observations, and family input to support approaches to learning.
Example \(\PageIndex{2}\)
More Time to Investigate
In a preschool classroom, children often begin building roads and bridges in the block area but must clean up before developing their ideas. When structures collapse, the educator frequently steps in to fix them.
An environmental assessment identifies frequent interruptions during play and limited opportunities for children to work through problems. Classroom observations show that some children stop building after a collapse or wait for the educator to repair their structures. Families share that several children enjoy building at home and often return to unfinished projects.
The educator uses the environmental improvement cycle:
Table \(\PageIndex{4}\): Using Environmental Assessment Findings to Support Persistence and Problem-Solving.
Step
Educator action
Review findings
Connects assessment findings about the schedule and interactions with observations of interrupted projects and children waiting for help
Identify a priority
Chooses to give children more time and responsive support to develop and test their building ideas
Make changes
Adjusts the schedule to provide a longer play period and creates a designated space for selected unfinished structures. When problems arise, pauses, acknowledges frustration, and invites children to consider another strategy. Offers hints or demonstrations when needed
Observe and reflect
Documents whether children return to projects, test different approaches, seek help, and remain involved after setbacks. Uses these observations to adjust the support provided
Note. Original classroom example illustrating developmentally appropriate teaching and reflection informed by NAEYC (2020). This example is not an official assessment item or scoring guide.
Connecting the Changes to Approaches to Learning
The changes create opportunities for children to demonstrate initiative by choosing and returning to projects, curiosity and creativity by testing designs, and persistence by trying another approach after a setback. Longer play periods also allow children to sustain their engagement.
These observations help the educator judge whether the changes are useful. They do not establish that every child will respond in the same way or that a higher environmental score alone guarantees progress.
Vocabulary Alert:
Environmental assessment: The process of examining the quality of a setting’s spaces, materials, routines, activities, and interactions.
Environmental rating scale: A standardized tool with criteria for assessing multiple aspects of a learning environment.
Interaction measure: A tool that focuses on the quality of educator–child interactions.
Process quality: The quality of children’s everyday experiences, including interactions with educators, peers, and materials.
Structural quality: Program characteristics such as group size, staff-to-child ratios, and staff qualifications.
Reliability: The consistency of assessment results when a tool is used under appropriate conditions.
Validity: The extent to which evidence supports interpreting and using assessment results for a particular purpose.
Culturally and linguistically responsive practice: Practice that recognizes and responds to children’s and families’ cultures, languages, and experiences.
Continuous quality improvement: An ongoing process of reviewing information, making intentional changes, and examining their effects to strengthen program practices.
Exercise \(\PageIndex{1}\)
Check Your Understanding
Distinguish assessment purposes. How does environmental assessment differ from developmental screening and ongoing child assessment?
Compare tools. What is the main difference between the Environment Rating Scales (ERS) and the Classroom Assessment Scoring System (CLASS)?
Apply environmental findings. A preschool classroom has many interesting materials, but most are stored where children cannot reach them. Children frequently wait for an adult to select an activity. What change could the educator make, and which approaches to learning could it support?
Use responsive interpretation. During classroom play, a multilingual child contributes ideas through gestures, actions, and a home language. An educator describes the child as showing little initiative because the child rarely speaks English. What should the educator reconsider, and how could family input help?
Plan and review improvement. An environmental assessment identifies frequent interruptions during play. Children often leave projects unfinished and rarely return to them. Use the environmental improvement cycle to describe how the educator could respond.
Answers
Answers to Check Your Understanding
Environmental assessment examines learning conditions, including spaces, materials, routines, activities, and interactions. Developmental screening identifies whether an individual child may need further evaluation. Ongoing child assessment documents a child’s strengths, interests, progress, and support needs over time. These approaches provide complementary information.
ERS examines multiple aspects of the overall environment, including spaces, materials, routines, activities, and interactions. CLASS focuses on the quality of educator–child interactions. Educators select the appropriate tool and version for their purpose and setting.
The educator could place developmentally appropriate materials on accessible shelves and use picture labels or adapted storage as needed. This would give children more opportunities to choose and begin activities, supporting initiative, curiosity, and engagement. Materials requiring adult supervision would remain appropriately managed.
The educator should recognize that initiative can be expressed through multiple languages and forms of communication. Gestures, actions, and home-language contributions may demonstrate active participation. Families can explain how the child communicates interests and ideas, helping the educator recognize these contributions and respond meaningfully.
Possible responses include:
Review findings: Connect the assessment findings with observations of when play is interrupted and how children respond.
Identify a priority: Increase opportunities for children to develop and revisit their ideas.
Make changes: Provide a longer play period, reduce unnecessary transitions, and establish a way to save selected projects or document them with photographs.
Observe and reflect: Examine whether children remain engaged longer, return to projects, and try additional strategies. Adjust the plan based on their responses.
These changes could support engagement, initiative, creativity, and persistence, with individualized assistance for children who need it.
National Association for the Education of Young Children. (2020). Developmentally appropriate practice [Position statement]. View the NAEYC position statement
OpenAI. (2026). The environmental improvement cycle [AI-generated image].
Zaslow, M., Tout, K., & Martinez-Beck, I. (2010). Measuring the quality of early care and education programs at the intersection of research, policy, and practice (OPRE Research-to-Policy, Research-to-Practice Brief OPRE 2011-10a). Office of Planning, Research and Evaluation, Administration for Children and Families, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. View the quality measurement research brief