17.7: Social Issues: Tension and Disparity

American Vibe Check · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    17.7: Social Issues: Tension and Disparity

    Learning Objectives

    Upon completing this section, you should be able to:

    1. Identify the differences between biological, cultural, and structural theories of inequality.
    2. Explain the pros and cons of affirmative action policies.

     

    Now that we have a sense of the demographics of the contemporary United States, let's examine some social issues that stem from that demographic diversity, such as cultural tensions, economic inequalities, and political conflicts. 

    The Social Construction of Bias

    To understand the persistent disparities and tensions in American society, social scientists must distinguish between the internal attitudes held by individuals and the external institutional structures that reinforce social hierarchies. While the previous sections defined the demographic makeup of the nation, this section explores the mechanisms of prejudice and discrimination that can complicate relations between categories. Prejudice and discrimination are often conflated in casual discourse, yet they represent distinct sociological phenomena. Prejudice is a matter of internal attitudes—a "pre-judging" of an individual based on their membership in a specific group—while discrimination is an external behavior involving the unjust denial of rights, liberties, or opportunities to members of certain groups. These mechanisms often come up in discussions of race, but they function similarly across the dimensions of sex and gender, class, religion, age, and even other identity categories, creating a complex web of systemic inequality.

    So where do prejudicial attitudes come from, and why are some individuals more bigoted than others? Scholars have pursued these questions since the mid-twentieth century, coming up with a variety of theories.

    From a psychological perspective, one of the earliest explanations centered on the authoritarian personality. According to Adorno (1950), individuals who develop this personality type often do so in response to childhood socialization by parents who practiced harsh discipline and demanded absolute obedience. These individuals learned to emphasize rigid adherence to rules, and have a low tolerance for "out-groups," leading to strong levels of not only racial prejudice but also sexism and religious intolerance. Another popular framework among psychologists is called scapegoat theory, which posits that individuals facing social and economic frustrations often seek to blame their troubles on groups with less power to resist that blame. While historically applied to racial and ethnic minorities, scapegoating is increasingly observed in the context of classism and religious intolerance, where poor immigrants with unfamiliar religions are blamed for the economic volatility affecting the working class that may actually be a result of decisions by political elites.

    Sociological perspectives shift the focus from the individual mind to the cultural environment. Social learning theory for example, suggests that people are not born with biases but rather "absorb" them from their parents, peers, and the media through a process of socialization. In the current era, this process is accelerated by digital social learning; social media algorithms often act as "echo chambers" that prioritize inflammatory content, reinforcing existing stereotypes about gender roles, religious groups, or the poor  (Noble, 2018). Supporting this view, studies find that individuals' levels of prejudice fluctuate based on the attitudes of their immediate geographic or social environment - people who move to areas where people are less prejudiced, become less prejudiced themselves, who those who move to areas of high prejudice, take on more prejudicial attitudes (Aronson, 2008). A second sociological explanation is group threat theory, which argues that prejudice arises from competition over scarce resources like jobs, housing, and political influence (Quillian, 2006). When one group perceives another—whether a different race, a different religion, or a younger cohort—as a threat to their economic or cultural status, hostility and bigotry often follow as a defensive mechanism to maintain the existing hierarchy.

    Although prejudice remains a pervasive element of American life, its nature has undergone a significant transformation since the mid-twentieth century. In the era of overt "Jim Crow" racism for example, bigotry was blatant and often legally codified. However, as overt bigotry became socially unacceptable following the Civil Rights movement, it was largely replaced by symbolic prejudice—a "kinder, gentler" ideology that avoids scientifically discredited notions of biological inferiority of racial minorities, women, and the poor, but still helps to maintain systemic inequality. In the context of race, this is known as colorblind racism, where individuals use neutral-sounding language to attribute inequality to cultural failings or a lack of motivation, rather than considering institutional barriers.  In the context of gender, overt sexism—the belief that women are biologically incapable of leadership—has largely transitioned into benevolent sexism, which idealizes women in traditional, subordinate roles while penalizing those who challenge the gender status quo. In terms of socioeconomic status, subtle classism can be detected the "blaming the victim" narrative, where the poverty of the lower class is attributed to a lack of willpower rather than the de-industrialization and wage stagnation of the post-industrial economy. In all these forms, symbolic prejudice serves the same political function as overt bigotry: it allows the dominant group to defend the status quo without appearing to be unjustly discriminating in the traditional sense.

    Individual and Institutional Discrimination

    While prejudice is an internal attitude, discrimination is the actual behavior of treating people differently based on their group membership. As sociologist Robert Merton theorized, these two variables do not always align; an individual may be prejudiced but refrain from acting on it due to social pressure, or they may discriminate unintentionally due to implicit bias. These are unconscious stereotypes or assumptions that lead to micro-aggressions which are subtle, often unintentional slights that signal to a marginalized individual that they do not truly belong in a given space. For example, a woman in a corporate meeting might notice that her ideas are ignored until they are repeated by a male colleague, or a person with a disability might experience one when a stranger speaks to their companion instead of to them directly.

    Social scientists emphasize that the most damaging form of differential treatment is institutional discrimination however. This refers to organizational policies and practices that produce unequal outcomes for different categories of people, even if the individuals within those institutions have no personal prejudice. A classic example is the history of redlining in the real estate market, where banks and insurance companies historically denied services to residents of certain neighborhoods. Because these neighborhoods were disproportionately inhabited by people of color and the poor, these practices contributed to the hyper-segregation of cities like Milwaukee and Chicago, cutting off residents from the broader economy. In the contemporary era, institutional discrimination often manifests in the "glass ceiling" that limits the promotion of women and minorities into executive roles, or in the "algorithmic bias" of hiring software that may inadvertently filter out older applicants or those from lower-income ZIP codes.

    The raw data regarding life chances in the United States provides a clear view of systemic disparity across all demographic facets. In the economic sphere, the racial wealth gap is perhaps the most significant indicator of institutional racism, with white households holding roughly six to eight times the net worth of Black households on average. However, this economic inequality is mirrored in the gender wage gap, where women continue to earn only approximately 80 cents for every dollar earned by men. When class is factored in, the United States has the highest level of income inequality among all post-industrial nations, with the "top 1%" of households holding a rapidly increasing share of the nation's total wealth while the poverty rate climbs.

    A chart showing the magnitude of the racial wealth gap.

    Why do these inequalities stubbornly persist? Historically, many Americans used biological essentialism to explain why certain groups remained at the bottom of the socioeconomic ladder. This view, most notably revived in the controversial book The Bell Curve (1994), argued that disparities in IQ and income were the result of innate differences. However, most social scientists condemned this as a form of "blaming the victim" and noted that research from the Human Genome Project has confirmed that skin color is unrelated to intelligence.  A second, more popular explanation focuses on cultural deficiencies. This "culture of poverty" view suggests that groups like the poor, or certain communities of color, remain disadvantaged because they fail to value education, hard work, or strong family ties.

    Applying Social Research: The Poor Neighborhoods of Middle-Class African Americans

    A third explanation for persistent inequality focuses on structural factors.  According to a recent longitudinal study by the Pew Charitable Trusts that tracked people over multiple decades, the neighborhoods in which children are raised have huge effects on their overall life chances.

    Because of continuing racial segregation, many middle-class black families find themselves having to live in poor urban neighborhoods. About half of black children who are born to middle-class parents grow up in poor neighborhoods. Meanwhile, hardly any middle-class white children grow up in such neighborhoods.

    In the study’s statistical analysis, author Patrick Sharkey explains that neighborhood poverty rate (a structural factor) was a much more powerful predictor of children’s later socioeconomic status in adulthood, than parents’ education level, or parents' marital status (cultural factors). 

    Why do poor neighborhoods have this effect? In these neighborhoods, even middle-class black children often receive inadequate schooling at run-down schools, and they come under the influence of youths from poorer families who care less about schooling and who get into more trouble. The various problems associated with living in poor neighborhoods (crime, drug addicts, lack of healthy food options, lack of safe outdoor play areas) also cause a good deal of stress, which can cause health problems and impair learning ability.  Sharkey added, “What surprises me is how dramatic the racial differences are in terms of the environments in which children are raised. There’s this perception that after the civil rights period, families have been more able to seek out any neighborhood they choose, and that the racial gap in neighborhoods would be whittled away over time. That hasn’t happened.”

    Data from the 2020 Census confirm that the racial gap in neighborhoods persists. A study by the Russell Sage Foundation found that middle-class African American and Latino families are more likely to live in poor neighborhoods than are working-class white families. More generally, the study concluded that the average wealthy black or Hispanic person lives in a poorer neighborhood than the average low-income white individual.

    One implication of this kind of research is that improving the quality of life and economic opportunities available in poor neighborhoods would produce more upward mobility for the poor than just persuading them to value education, hard work, and family ties.

    Source: Sharkey, 2009

     

    Controversial Solutions

    The debate over how to address these inequalities has always been controversial.  Affirmative action refers to policies intended to improve access to education and employment opportunities for groups that have historically faced unjust institutional discrimination - as well as sometimes violent persecution by bigoted individuals. Such policies focused on racial quotas when they began in the 1960s, and then broadened to include sex and other demographic categories.

    Although some affirmative action programs remain in effect today, court rulings, state legislation, and executive actions have limited their number and scope.  The use of quotas was banned by the Supreme Court all the way back in 1978 in a college admissions case called Regents of the University of California v. Bakke. Yet the Court’s decision still permitted certain demographic criteria such as race to be considered for instrumental purposes, such as the educational benefit that a school might seek to cultivate in just having a diverse student population for students to interact with and learn from. Yet opponents of affirmative action cite several reasons for opposing such policies (Connors, 2009). They say it amounts to “reverse discrimination” and is therefore both illegal and immoral, because the people benefiting from affirmative action may be less qualified than many of the people they compete with. In addition, opponents say that whether or not beneficiaries are less qualified, the appearance of benefiting from affirmative action implies that they need extra help (even if they don’t), and this implication stigmatizes the group benefiting from affirmative action as “less qualified,” even when they’re not.

    A growing populist conservative movement has brought more attention to the issue, and as a result of growing opposition the legal terrain for such programs has shifted dramatically in recent years. The Supreme Court’s 2023 decision in SFFA v. Harvard effectively reversed the Court’s 1978 decision to permit some consideration of race, ending any sort of  “race-conscious” admission policy in higher education. Consequently, universities have shifted toward socioeconomic-based affirmative action, though recent data suggests black and Latino enrollment at elite institutions has seen a measurable decline since then (The Chronicle of Higher Education, 2025).  Subsequently, other federal and state government actors have taken steps to dismantle diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives in both the public and private sectors.  In states like Florida, Texas, and Utah, "anti-DEI" laws have mandated the closure of multicultural centers at public universities and prohibited diversity trainings. Proponents of these bans argue that DEI programs are themselves discriminatory, and promote workers based on their identities rather than their individual merits.  High-profile corporations (e.g., Target, John Deere, and various tech firms) significantly scaled back their diversity commitments in 2024-2025 following pressure from investors and social media activists. Supporters label this a "return to meritocracy," while opponents argue that it will actually reward privileges like membership in informal social networks, rather than objective qualifications (Kendi, 2024).

     

    When social scientists discuss privilege, they are not talking about individual wealth, or a lack of personal struggles or adversity.  In fact, privileged identities can sometimes produce concrete disadvantages in certain situations.  The term doesn’t refer to concrete situational benefits, but rather it refers to the absence of systemic oppression based on some aspect of identity.  Abstract social systems can be hard to see from an individual’s point of view, and many people are unaware of the ways in which various kinds of privilege may affect their lives behind the scenes (McIntosh, 2007). But to people without those privileges, the oppressive consequences of abstract systems may be all too visible, like the black homebuyer whose application is refused due to redlining.

    Social scientist Robert Terry (in Bowser & Hunt, 1981) once summarized white privilege as follows: “To be white in America is not to have to think about it.”  Except perhaps for white supremacists, the meaning of being white seems inconsequential or superficial to many white Americans, and they may go about their daily lives seldom even considering their racial identity.  For people of color though, race and ethnicity is a daily fact of their existence.  Perhaps because whites do not often think about being white, many studies find they tend to underestimate the degree of racial inequality in the United States by assuming that minorities are better off than they really are. In a 2025 survey, 62% of white respondents believed racial equality had already been “achieved,” whereas only 19% of black respondents agreed, highlighting a significant perception gap in American society (Pew Research Center, 2025).

    References

    • Alexander, M. (2020). The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness. The New Press.

    • Barkan, S. E. (2026). Sociology: Understanding and Changing the Social World.

    • Bonilla-Silva, E. (2022). Racism without Racists: Color-blind Racism and the Persistence of Racial Inequality in America. Rowman & Littlefield.

    • Bowser, B.P. & R. G. Hunt (Eds.)(1981) Impacts of racism on white Americans (pp. 119–151). Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.

    • Geronimus, A. T. (2023). Weathering: The Extraordinary Stress of Ordinary Life in an Unjust Society. Little, Brown Spark.

    • Kendi, I. X. (2024). The DEI Retreat: Why Corporate America is Moving Backward. The Atlantic.

    • McIntosh, P. (2007). White Privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack.

    • Pew Research Center. (2025). The Widening Gap: Perceptions of Race in the Mid-2020s.

    • Quillian, L. (2006). New Approaches to Understanding Racial Prejudice and Discrimination. Annual Review of Sociology.

    • Sharkey, P. (2009). Neighborhoods and the Black-White Mobility Gap. Pew Charitable Trusts.

    CC licensed content

    17.7: Social Issues: Tension and Disparity is shared under a CC BY 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by LibreTexts.