7.5: Cybersecurity and Artificial Intelligence

Comparative Government - The Politics of Elsewhere · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    7.5: Cybersecurity and Artificial Intelligence

    Introduction

    Almost every part of modern government now runs on computer networks. Elections depend on digital voter rolls, hospitals store patient records online, and power grids, water systems, and banks rely on software to function. Cybersecurity refers to the practices, technologies, and policies used to protect these networks and the information they hold from attack, theft, or disruption. For much of its history, cybersecurity was treated as a technical problem for engineers. Today it is also a political problem. Governments must decide who is responsible for protecting digital systems, how much surveillance is acceptable in the name of security, and how to respond when another country is behind an attack.

    Comparative politics helps us see that countries answer these questions very differently. A country's regime type, its state capacity, and its economic system all shape how it approaches cyberspace. Comparing these approaches connects cybersecurity to the larger themes of this book: how institutions work, how governments hold or lose power, and how political and economic systems respond to global challenges.

    Cybersecurity and State Capacity

    Earlier in this book, we saw that strong states can carry out their policies effectively across their territory. The same logic applies to cyberspace. Protecting digital infrastructure requires skilled personnel, steady funding, coordination between government agencies, and cooperation with the private companies that own most networks. States with limited capacity often struggle to defend hospitals, utilities, or election systems, which makes them attractive targets for criminals and foreign governments alike.

    Estonia offers a useful example. After regaining independence in 1991, the small Baltic country built one of the world's most digital governments, moving services such as voting, taxes, and health records online. In 2007, after the government relocated a Soviet-era war memorial in Tallinn, waves of cyberattacks overwhelmed the websites of Estonian banks, media outlets, and government ministries. The attacks were widely linked to actors in Russia, although responsibility was never formally established. Estonia responded by investing heavily in cyber defense, and in 2008 NATO opened its Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence in Tallinn. The Estonian case shows how a crisis can push a state to build new capacity, and how digital government creates both efficiency and vulnerability.

    International organizations now try to measure this capacity. The International Telecommunication Union's Global Cybersecurity Index, for instance, ranks countries on their legal, technical, and organizational commitments to cybersecurity. Measures like this allow comparativists to ask why some governments invest more than others, and whether regime type, wealth, or past experience with attacks explains the difference.

    Regime Type and the Internet

    One of the clearest comparative divides in cyberspace concerns how governments balance security against individual rights. Scholars often describe two broad models, although most countries fall somewhere between them (DeNardis 2014; Segal 2016).

    The Open, Multistakeholder Model

    Many democracies favor an open internet governed by a mix of public and private actors. Under this model, governments set rules for security and privacy, but private companies, courts, and civil society groups also shape policy. The European Union is a leading example. Its General Data Protection Regulation, in effect since 2018, gives individuals rights over their personal data. Its NIS2 Directive, adopted in 2022, requires organizations in essential sectors such as energy and health care to meet security standards and report serious incidents. The United States relies more heavily on the private sector and on rules written sector by sector. It created the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency in 2018 to coordinate federal efforts, while states such as California have passed their own data privacy laws.

    Democracies are not free of tension between security and liberty. In 2013, former government contractor Edward Snowden revealed large-scale surveillance programs run by the U.S. National Security Agency, sparking debates across democracies about how much monitoring is acceptable. What distinguishes democracies is that courts, legislatures, and a free press can challenge these practices.

    The Cyber Sovereignty Model

    Authoritarian governments are more likely to treat the internet as territory to be controlled. China has developed the most extensive version of this approach. Its system of filters and blocks, often called the Great Firewall, restricts access to foreign websites and platforms. China's Cybersecurity Law, which took effect in 2017, explicitly invokes "cyberspace sovereignty," and its Data Security Law and Personal Information Protection Law, both effective in 2021, give the state broad authority over how data is stored and shared. Russia moved in a similar direction with its 2019 "sovereign internet" law, which allows authorities to route and filter internet traffic and, in principle, to disconnect the Russian internet from global networks.

    These tools serve the goals discussed in Chapter 4, where we examined strategies non-democracies use to stay in power. Controlling information makes it harder for opponents to organize, and digital surveillance can identify protesters and critics. Scholars call this pattern digital repression (Feldstein 2021).

    The Gray Zone

    The line between these models is not always sharp. Some democracies and hybrid regimes also restrict online activity. The digital rights organization Access Now documents hundreds of government-ordered internet shutdowns each year, and India, the world's largest democracy, has recorded more shutdowns than any other country in several recent years, often during protests or unrest in particular regions. Cases like these show that regime type shapes cybersecurity policy, but it does not determine it completely.

    Cyber Conflict Between States

    Cyberspace has also become an arena for competition between states. Cyber operations are attractive because they are relatively inexpensive, can be carried out from a distance, and are often difficult to attribute with certainty. Most fall below the threshold of open warfare, which allows states to pressure rivals without triggering a military response (Rid 2013; Kello 2017). Several incidents illustrate the range of these operations:

    • Stuxnet (discovered 2010): A sophisticated computer worm that damaged centrifuges at Iran's Natanz nuclear facility. It is widely attributed to the United States and Israel, although neither government has officially confirmed its role (Zetter 2014).
    • Election interference (2016): The U.S. intelligence community concluded that Russia used hacking and social media campaigns to influence the 2016 U.S. presidential election (Office of the Director of National Intelligence 2017).
    • WannaCry (2017): A ransomware attack that spread to computers in roughly 150 countries and disrupted Britain's National Health Service. The United States and the United Kingdom attributed it to North Korea.
    • NotPetya (2017): Malware that began in Ukraine and spread worldwide, causing billions of dollars in damage to companies. Western governments attributed it to Russia's military intelligence service (Greenberg 2019).

    Not all threats come from governments. Criminal groups also target essential services. In 2021, a ransomware attack on Colonial Pipeline, which supplies fuel to much of the eastern United States, forced the company to shut down its pipeline for several days. Cases like this blur the line between crime and national security and raise questions about how much responsibility governments should take for protecting privately owned infrastructure.

    Governing Cyberspace Across Borders

    Because networks cross national borders, no single government can secure cyberspace alone. International cooperation has grown slowly and unevenly. The Council of Europe's Convention on Cybercrime, known as the Budapest Convention, opened for signature in 2001 and remains the main treaty for cooperation among law enforcement agencies. In 2015, a United Nations Group of Governmental Experts endorsed voluntary norms for responsible state behavior, such as refraining from attacks on critical infrastructure during peacetime (United Nations General Assembly 2015). In December 2024, the UN General Assembly adopted a new Convention against Cybercrime. Supporters argued it would improve cooperation against online crime, while human rights organizations warned that its broad provisions could be used to justify surveillance of journalists and dissidents.

    These debates reflect the same divide described above. Countries that favor cyber sovereignty tend to support agreements that strengthen state control, while many democracies emphasize protections for privacy and free expression. The result is a patchwork of national laws and international norms rather than a single global system.

    Comparing Approaches

    Selected national and regional approaches to cybersecurity
    Country or Region General Approach Examples of Key Policies
    Estonia Highly digital government with strong national cyber defense Expanded cyber defenses after the 2007 attacks; hosts NATO's cyber defense center (2008)
    European Union Rights-based regulation across member states General Data Protection Regulation (2018); NIS2 Directive (2022)
    United States Private-sector-led, sector-by-sector approach Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (2018); state privacy laws such as California's
    China Cyber sovereignty and centralized control Cybersecurity Law (2017); Data Security Law (2021); Personal Information Protection Law (2021)
    Russia Sovereign internet and information control Sovereign internet law (2019)

    Artificial Intelligence and Cybersecurity

    Artificial intelligence adds another layer to cybersecurity governance. AI can assist governments and organizations with detecting unusual network activity, identifying vulnerabilities, processing large amounts of security data, and responding more quickly to potential attacks. At the same time, AI can strengthen the capabilities of attackers. The United Kingdom's National Cyber Security Centre concluded that AI is already being used to improve activities such as reconnaissance, social engineering, vulnerability research, basic malware generation, and the processing of stolen data (National Cyber Security Centre 2025).

    AI systems can also become targets themselves. Attackers may attempt to manipulate training data, exploit software vulnerabilities, or use techniques such as prompt injection to cause an AI system to behave in unintended ways. The National Institute of Standards and Technology has therefore developed an Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework and additional guidance specifically addressing risks associated with generative AI (National Institute of Standards and Technology 2023; Autio et al. 2024).

    Governments are also taking different approaches to regulating AI. The European Union's Artificial Intelligence Act creates a risk-based regulatory framework with different requirements depending on how an AI system is used (European Parliament and Council of the European Union 2024). China has adopted regulations governing generative AI services that address issues including data security, personal information, content, and national security (Cyberspace Administration of China et al. 2023). In the United States, NIST's AI Risk Management Framework provides voluntary guidance for organizations managing AI-related risks. These different approaches demonstrate how the politics of cybersecurity increasingly overlap with broader debates about government regulation, innovation, privacy, national security, and the appropriate role of the state.

    Cybersecurity therefore offers an important case for comparative government. Technology may cross national borders easily, but political institutions still influence who regulates it, what interests receive protection, and how governments respond when new technologies create both opportunities and risks.

    Connecting to Course Themes

    Cybersecurity touches nearly every topic in this book. It is a question of institutions, because legislatures, executives, courts, and bureaucracies must decide who protects networks and how. It is a question of regime type, because democracies and authoritarian states balance security and freedom differently. It is a question of political economy, because private companies own most digital infrastructure and technology firms hold enormous influence over how information flows. And it connects to collective action, because activists use digital tools to organize while governments use the same tools to monitor and repress them.

    Think Comparatively

    1. Why might a country with a highly digital government, like Estonia, be both better protected and more exposed to cyberattacks than a less digital country?
    2. Compare the European Union's approach to data protection with China's approach to cyber sovereignty. What values does each approach prioritize?
    3. Should governments or private companies be primarily responsible for protecting critical infrastructure such as pipelines and hospitals? How might the answer differ across political and economic systems?
    4. Internet shutdowns occur in both democracies and authoritarian regimes. What does this suggest about the relationship between regime type and digital rights?
    5. How do the European Union's, China's, and the United States' approaches to regulating artificial intelligence reflect their broader approaches to cybersecurity and the role of the state?

    This page titled 7.5: Cybersecurity and Artificial Intelligence was last modified on Sun, 18 Oct 2026 03:18:52 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Austin Minter.