Opening the book…
Exploring the Challenges of Parenting in Contemporary Society
Parenting is often described as deeply meaningful, but it can also be stressful, expensive, and shaped by pressures beyond the control of individual families.
Parenting Under Pressure: Stress and Well-Being
A recent national advisory from the U.S. Surgeon General’s report "Parents Under Pressure" found that parents today experience significantly higher levels of stress than other adults, highlighting parental stress as a growing public health concern (Office of the Surgeon General, 2024). According to 2023 data cited in the advisory, about one-third of parents (33%) reported high levels of stress in the past month compared with only 20% of non-parents, and nearly half of parents (48%) said that most days their stress feels completely overwhelming—almost double the rate among other adults. This gap illustrates how contemporary parenting involves stressors above and beyond those faced by the general adult population.
Parents and caregivers also experience unique demands related to child-rearing that contribute to elevated stress levels. These include financial strain, economic instability, and poverty; intense time pressures; worries about children’s health and safety; social isolation; and newer stressors linked to technology, social media, cultural expectations, and concerns about children’s futures. Together, these overlapping pressures help explain why parenting today is often described as both emotionally meaningful and chronically stressful.
Finally, the advisory highlights that many children are cared for by relatives or non-parent caregivers when parents cannot assume full responsibility. Approximately 2.4 million children in the U.S. are being raised by grandparents, other relatives, or close family friends without their biological parents in the home. These caregivers play a critical safety-net role but often face barriers navigating service systems and securing the support they need, despite the importance of their caregiving work.
While the Surgeon General’s (2024) advisory highlights widespread stress among parents, sociological research shows that the emotional impacts of parenting are not experienced uniformly across social groups. Drawing on General Social Survey data, Augustine and Brantley (2023) find meaningful variation by race and gender in how parenting relates to self-reported happiness (Augustine & Brantley, 2023). Their analysis reveals that White mothers tend to report lower happiness than their non-parent peers, whereas no such happiness gap exists between Black mothers and non-parenting Black women. Among men, White fathers report similar happiness levels as non-parents, but Black fathers are significantly more likely to say they feel "very happy" compared to non-parenting Black men. The authors suggest that cultural expectations, community support, and differing models of parenting help explain these patterns. For example, Black mothers often report stronger community support and view themselves as role models, while many Black fathers embrace a parenting model centered on relationships.
Postpartum Mental Health: Depression and Psychosis
The transition to parenthood can bring significant emotional and psychological challenges. While many new mothers experience temporary mood changes commonly known as the baby blues, some develop postpartum depression, a more serious condition involving persistent sadness, anxiety, exhaustion, and difficulties with everyday functioning. Postpartum depression can affect a mother's well-being and relationships and may require professional treatment. An estimated 10–20% of women experience depression during pregnancy or the postpartum period (Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, n.d.).
A much rarer condition, postpartum psychosis, which affects approximately 1 to 2 in every 1,000 births. Unlike postpartum depression, postpartum psychosis can involve hallucinations, delusions, severe confusion, and a loss of contact with reality, typically developing within the first few weeks after childbirth. Although uncommon, the condition can pose serious risks to the parent and infant if left untreated and requires immediate psychiatric care (National Institute of Mental Health, n.d.). Early recognition, appropriate treatment, and support from family members and healthcare professionals are essential for recovery.
From a sociological perspective, postpartum mental health is shaped not only by biological and psychological factors but also by social circumstances. Cultural expectations that mothers should feel happy and fulfilled after childbirth may discourage some from acknowledging emotional difficulties or seeking help. Limited paid leave, financial pressures, inadequate social support, and barriers to mental healthcare can create additional challenges for new parents. Recognizing postpartum mental health as both a medical and social issue highlights the importance of accessible healthcare, supportive family relationships, and public policies that support parents during the transition to parenthood.
Family Circumstances and Parenting Stress
Family structure can intensify or reduce parenting stress because different household arrangements shape caregiving roles, support networks, and access to resources (Office of the Surgeon General, 2024). Single-parent households, for example, may experience heightened stress due to sole caregiving responsibilities, financial hardship, and reduced practical support. LGBTQ+ parent families may face discrimination or social stigma, which can add another layer of stress. In contrast, multigenerational households can sometimes buffer stress by distributing childcare responsibilities and providing emotional, social, and practical support.
Family disruption can further increase stress for both caregivers and children. Experiences such as illness, divorce, separation, parental incarceration, child welfare involvement, intimate partner violence, or immigration-related family separation can create instability in daily routines, caregiving arrangements, housing, income, and emotional security. For example, the Surgeon General’s advisory notes that newly divorced individuals report significantly higher perceived stress than both the general population and people who have been divorced for longer periods (Office of the Surgeon General, 2024).
The Rising Cost of Raising Children and Paying for Childcare
Raising children in the United States requires substantial financial resources, shaping how parents plan their families, participate in paid work, and manage household budgets. One 2025 analysis estimated that two working adults would need an additional $27,743 per year, on average, to support one child under age five. This estimate includes additional spending on housing, food, transportation, healthcare, miscellaneous necessities, and childcare, although costs vary considerably by state. In California, the estimated annual cost was substantially higher, at $35,651 (DeJohn, 2025).
Childcare constitutes one of the largest and most immediate expenses facing families with young children. Pew Research Center reported that the median cost of paid care for one child ranged from 8.0% to 19.3% of a county’s median household income, depending on the child’s age, type of care, and county size. Center-based infant care was especially expensive, reaching 19.3% of median household income in the largest counties. Lower-income families may spend an even greater share of their income on care (Leppert, 2024).
Child Care Aware of America estimated that the national average price of childcare was $13,128 in 2024. This represented approximately 10% of the median income of married couples with children and 35% of the median income of single-parent families. Between 2020 and 2024, childcare prices increased by 29%, compared with a 22% increase in overall consumer prices (Child Care Aware of America, 2025). More recent data indicate that the national average rose slightly again, to $13,184 in 2025.
These costs are particularly significant because the United States does not provide a national system of universally available childcare or guaranteed paid parental leave comparable to those offered in many other affluent countries. As a result, much of the financial and practical responsibility for caring for young children falls on individual families, with consequences for parents’ employment, economic security, and stress levels (Adema et al., 2023).
The cost of childcare has consequently become an important political and social-policy issue. In New York City, Mayor Zohran Mamdani campaigned on establishing free childcare for children from six weeks through age five. In 2026, the city and New York State began taking steps toward that broader goal by announcing publicly funded childcare for two-year-olds. The initial phase will create 2,000 free 2-K places in selected communities, with plans to expand the program and strengthen existing services for three- and four-year-olds. The initiative illustrates how governments may respond to childcare costs by treating early care as a public responsibility rather than solely a private family expense.
From a sociological perspective, the cost of raising children is not simply a matter of individual budgeting. It reflects broader decisions about wages, employment, gender, public investment, and the extent to which society collectively supports caregiving. Because families differ greatly in income and access to assistance, rising childcare costs can deepen existing inequalities while limiting parents’ choices about work and family life.
State Institutions and Family Separation
Some of the most serious challenges facing families are created or intensified by state institutions. Immigration enforcement, detention, deportation, incarceration, and child welfare involvement can reorganize caregiving, remove parents from households, and shift responsibilities to grandparents, relatives, foster caregivers, or other support networks. These examples show that parenting is not only shaped inside families. It is also shaped by laws, courts, police, prisons, immigration agencies, schools, and social-service systems.
Immigration Enforcement
Immigration enforcement can disrupt family life in ways that heighten stress for both parents and children. Actions by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE)—including workplace raids, detention, and deportation—can separate children from one or both parents with little warning. Even when families remain physically together, fear of enforcement can generate chronic anxiety, discourage people from accessing healthcare, schools, and social services, and undermine parents’ sense of security and stability. These experiences demonstrate how state institutions and immigration policies can reshape family structures, caregiving arrangements, and everyday life, particularly within immigrant and mixed-status families.
In their Contexts article "Detention, Disappearance, and the Politics of Family," sociologists Amina Zarrugh and Luis A. Romero (2019) examine immigrant detention alongside forced disappearance to show how state removal affects not only those who are detained but also the families and social networks left behind (Zarrugh & Romero, 2019). Families may struggle to locate detained relatives, obtain information, maintain contact, and manage the emotional and practical consequences of a sudden absence.
The 2025 episode of The Daily titled "Family Separation 2.0" illustrates these dynamics through one family’s experience of contemporary U.S. immigration enforcement (The New York Times, 2025). Producer Jessica Cheung tells the story of a longtime U.S. resident who was detained and targeted for deportation through the perspective of his daughter. The episode demonstrates how detention and deportation can affect established families whose members have built lives, careers, and relationships in the United States, making immigration enforcement a deeply personal family experience as well as a political and legal process.
Parental Incarceration
Sociologist Anna Haskell, in an ASA interview titled "Shackling Children’s Futures," illustrates how parental incarceration represents one of the most consequential yet often overlooked forms of family disruption. When a parent is incarcerated, children may be placed with grandparents, other relatives, or foster caregivers, while remaining caregivers—most often mothers or extended kin—take on increased financial and emotional responsibilities.
Duration: 4 minutes and 7 seconds. Haskins finds that parental incarceration is associated with poorer educational outcomes for children, contributing to long-term disadvantage. Addressing these harms, she argues, requires policy approaches that recognize the interconnected roles of the criminal justice system, schools, and families (American Sociological Association, 2020).
A growing body of research links parental incarceration to adverse educational, behavioral, and health outcomes for children (Wakefield & Wildeman, 2013). National estimates suggest that millions of U.S. children have experienced a parent behind bars, exposing many to instability, stigma, and economic strain. Studies consistently link parental incarceration to elevated risks of behavioral problems, emotional distress, and weakened school engagement. Scholars also emphasize that the impact is stratified by race and social class: children in heavily policed and economically marginalized communities are disproportionately exposed to parental imprisonment, thereby reproducing broader patterns of inequality across generations.
Importantly, researchers note that the consequences are not inevitable but are mediated by caregiving stability, continued parent–child contact, and access to supportive school and community resources. Policy discussions increasingly frame parental incarceration as a form of "hidden inequality" within family life—one that blurs the boundaries between criminal justice policy and family well-being.
Transnational Parenting and "Satellite Babies"
Another challenge facing some contemporary families is parenting across national borders. Sociologists have documented the experiences of Chinese American "satellite babies"—children born in the United States to Chinese immigrant parents who are sent to China during infancy to be cared for by grandparents or other extended family members. After several years, the children generally return to the United States to live with their parents and begin school.
These arrangements emerge from a combination of economic pressures, limited access to affordable childcare, demanding work schedules, immigration circumstances, and cultural traditions of intergenerational caregiving. Parents may understand the decision as a temporary strategy that allows them to establish financial stability in the United States while ensuring that their children receive attentive care from trusted relatives. Rather than reflecting a lack of parental commitment, satellite parenting often illustrates the difficult trade-offs immigrant families make as they pursue long-term security and opportunity (Ng, 2019; Wang, 2018).
Transnational caregiving arrangements can nevertheless create distinctive emotional, cultural, and developmental challenges for both parents and children. When satellite children return to the United States during their preschool or early school years, they must adjust to a different language, education system, culture, and caregiving environment. Some are also separated from the grandparents who have served as their primary attachment figures. Their biological parents, meanwhile, may experience guilt, uncertainty, and a new learning process as they establish daily routines and rebuild relationships with children from whom they have lived apart.
The experiences of satellite families demonstrate how parenting is shaped by forces extending far beyond the household. Moreover, transnational parenting therefore challenges the assumption that families must live together in one household or even one country to maintain caregiving responsibilities and emotional ties.
Unequal Childhoods Within the Same Family
Inequality does not exist only between families; it can also develop among children raised within the same household. In his book "The Pecking Order," sociologist Dalton Conley argues that siblings may experience substantially different childhoods even when they share the same parents and family home (Conley, 2004). Drawing on survey and interview data, he demonstrates that siblings may receive different amounts of parental attention, financial support, encouragement, expectations, and access to opportunities. Together, these differences can create a family "pecking order" that shapes children’s education, health, income, and experiences later in adulthood.
Differences among siblings may be influenced by birth order, gender, personality, family size, and the timing of significant events such as divorce, illness, unemployment, or financial hardship. For example, a child who is very young during a period of economic instability or intense parental stress may grow up with fewer resources than a sibling whose early childhood occurred during a more secure period.
Conley’s research therefore challenges the assumption that siblings raised by the same parents necessarily grow up under the same conditions. Families are dynamic social environments and each child occupies a somewhat different position within them. As a result, unequal life chances can emerge not only between households but also among siblings within the same family.
Thinking Sociologically: Adolescents, Public Space, and Social Control
In her article, “Can We Just Let Teens Exist in Public?”, Beck (Beck, 2026) argues that the growing use of curfews, chaperone requirements, and restrictions on unaccompanied minors reflects a broader shift toward intensive adult supervision. Although such policies are often introduced in response to disruptive behavior, they may restrict all adolescents because of the actions of a relatively small number.
Teenagers are increasingly excluded from malls, parks, restaurants, movie theaters, and other public or semi-public spaces unless accompanied by an adult. This raises an important sociological question: How can young people develop judgment, independence, and social responsibility when they have few opportunities to practice these skills?
These policies also reflect a shift from communal supervision toward the expectation that individual parents must constantly monitor their own children. Adolescents may consequently be treated less as developing members of a community and more as potential risks requiring surveillance and control.
Restrictions on public space may be especially significant at a time when adolescents have fewer opportunities to socialize informally outside school, organized activities, and digital platforms. From a sociology of the family perspective, these policies reveal tensions between protection and autonomy, parental and community responsibility, and young people’s gradual transition toward adulthood.
References
Adema, W., Fluchtmann, J., Lloyd, A., & Patrini, V. (2023, January 12). Paid parental leave: Big differences for mothers and fathers. OECD.
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. (n.d.). Pregnant and postpartum women and behavioral health integration.
American Sociological Association. (2020). Shackling children’s futures [Video]. YouTube.
Augustine, J. M., & Brantley, M. (2023). Black-White differences in parental happiness. Socius: Sociological Research for a Dynamic World, 9, 1–14.
Beck, J. (2026, January 24). Can we just let teens exist in public? The Atlantic.
Child Care Aware of America. (2025, May). Child care in America: 2024 price and supply.
Conley, D. (2004). The pecking order: A bold new look at how family and society determine who we become. Pantheon Books.
DeJohn, J. (2025, November 11). Cost of raising a child in each U.S. state—2025 study. SmartAsset.
Leppert, R. (2024, October 25). 5 facts about child care costs in the U.S. Pew Research Center.
Office of the Surgeon General. (2024). Parents under pressure: The U.S. Surgeon General’s advisory on the mental health and well-being of parents. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
National Institute of Mental Health. (n.d.). Perinatal depression.
Ng, K. (2019, October 8). “Satellite babies” are raised abroad, then return to the U.S.—and their parents. The Atlantic.
The New York Times. (2025, May 2). Family separation 2.0 [Audio podcast episode]. In The Daily.
Wakefield, S., & Wildeman, C. (2013). Children of the prison boom: Mass incarceration and the future of American inequality. Oxford University Press.
Wang, L. K. (2018). Chinese American “satellite babies,” raised between two cultures. Contexts, 17(4), 24–29.
Zarrugh, A., & Romero, L. A. (2019). Detention, disappearance, and the politics of family. Contexts, 18(3), 32–35.
This page titled 10.8: The Challenges of Parenting in Contemporary Society was last modified on Thu, 12 Nov 2026 02:38:39 GMT and is shared under a CC BY 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Sarah Earl-Novell.
The book could not be loaded just now.