11.3: Pre-Australopithecines

Our Human Story: An Introduction to Biological Anthropology · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY-NC 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    11.3: Pre-Australopithecines

    From Forest to Grassland: The Adaptive Radiations that Mark the Dawn of Humanity

    Seven million years ago, Africa was transforming. Ancient forests that had blanketed the continent for millions of years began shrinking, replaced by vast grasslands that stretched for miles across the horizon. This environmental upheaval triggered one of the most significant events in hominin evolutionary history---the emergence of the first beings that would eventually give rise to humans. But identifying these earliest ancestors is no easy task. First, we need to understand a crucial distinction between the ancestors and relatives that make up our family tree. As we’ve established, the admission ticket to this tree is evidence of bipedalism, but not all experiments in bipedalism led to us. To better grasp this concept, consider your own family tree:

    Direct Ancestors are like your parents, grandparents, and great-grandparents—people you directly descended from. Without them, you wouldn't exist.

    Close Relatives are like your aunts, uncles, and cousins—people related to you but not part of your direct family line. They're family, but you didn't descend from them.

    The same principle applies to human evolution. Hominin ancestors are the species that directly led to modern humans, while hominin relatives are species that existed in the past, shared the planet with some of our ancestors, but eventually went extinct without contributing to our lineage.1 This distinction matters because determining whether a fossil represents a direct ancestor or just a close relative is often extremely difficult. When paleoanthropologists find ancient bones and skulls, they must ask: "Could this be from a population that led directly to us, or is this from a 'cousin' species that died out?" Without genetic evidence, this becomes a significant challenge. Researchers can only rely on comparative data from the existing fossil record and living humans and apes. This task is further complicated by fragmentary fossil remains, heated scientific debates, and in some cases, unprofessional behavior that hinders scientific progress.

    To understand this pivotal moment in our evolutionary story, it helps to remember that hominin evolution was not a straight line. Instead, it can be thought of as a series of adaptive radiations---periods when species rapidly diversify to fill new ecological niches. The late Miocene period (around 7-6 million years ago) gave rise to the first of these radiations, followed by a second one during the early Pliocene (roughly 5.3 to 2.6 million years ago). Together, these periods produced an intriguing cast of potential candidates for the title of “first hominin.” These fossils continue to spark both curiosity and contested debates in the world of paleoanthropology today. Our story begins with this first adaptive radiation.

    Sahelanthropus tchadensis: A Mysterious Fossil from Central Africa

    The first potential candidate for earliest hominin comes from the central African country of Chad. In 2001, researchers working in a remote desert region unearthed the remains of Sahelanthropus tchadensis. Considering that the majority of early hominin fossils have come from eastern or southern Africa, this discovery initially seemed poised to help fill an important gap in the human fossil record.2 The fossil itself, however, is known only from fragmentary and distorted skull, jaw, dental remains, and (as was revealed later) a femur.

    The fossil evidence for Sahelanthropus presents a somewhat puzzling mix of characteristics. On one hand, it retained many primitive traits such as a small brain (about 350cc, which is roughly the same size as a chimp’s) and a V-shaped dental arch typical of apes and early hominins. But in contrast, several derived traits have been identified, such as small canines, the absence of a honing complex, as well as a seemingly more centralized foramen magnum, the latter of which has been interpreted by its discoverers and others as evidence of bipedalism.

    However, the story of Sahelanthropus took an unexpected turn when research on a femur which had been put aside in the species’ original description has suggested that Sahelanthropus was not bipedal, casting doubt on one of the key pieces of evidence for its hominin status. Adding to the uncertainty, the skull’s heavy distortion makes it difficult to determine the true placement and angle of the foramen magnum, leaving paleoanthropologists (and all of us), without a clear answer about how this ancient species moved through its world.

    Without clear evidence of upright walking, researchers must rely on other features to determine where Sahelanthropus may fit (or if it fits) in our family tree. Its intriguing combination of traits such as its prominent brow ridges alongside a somewhat flattened face that hints at human-like features, creates a taxonomic puzzle that continues to challenge our understanding of these opening chapters of our human story.

    A detailed fossilized skull against a black background, showcasing cracks and texture on the surface.
    Figure \(\PageIndex{1}\): Sahelanthropus tchadensis skull by Didier Descouens, CC BY-SA 4.0 via Wikimedia Commons

    Dated at 6-7 million years old, Sahelanthropus lived at precisely the time when genetic evidence suggests the human and ape lineages were splitting from a common ancestor. This critical timing makes it the oldest possible human ancestor we’ve discovered. However, much more skeletal evidence and better access to the original fossils will be needed to definitively determine its place in human evolution.

    Orrorin tugenensis: A Contender from Kenya

    The second candidate vying for the title of first hominin is a 6 million year old fossil that was discovered in the Tugen Hills of Kenya in East Africa, known as Orrorin tugenensis. As you can see from Figure 11.3.2 below, this species is known from a small collection of fragmentary yet important bones including a partial femur (thigh bone), pieces of the upper arm bone (humerus), jaw fragments, and some teeth.

    Illustration of various bone fragments labeled A through G, showcasing different skeletal remains.
    Figure \(\PageIndex{2}\): Fossilized remains of Orrorin. By Lucius, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia

    Arguably the most important feature related to Orrorin is the upper portion of the femur which has a long femoral neck very similar to ours and a groove for the lesser gluteal muscles to attach. This arrangement makes it so that our hip muscles don’t have to use as much energy to keep us balanced while walking on two feet. By contrast, in chimps and most other mammals, the femoral neck is short and lacks a groove. The similarity of Orrorin’s femur to our own and to other bipedal hominins provides compelling evidence of bipedality. However, without the lower portion of the femur or any significant cranial remains to assess the positioning of the foramen magnum, researchers can’t be completely certain about Orrorin’s locomotion or its precise relationship to later hominins. This hasn't stopped its discoverers, Martin Pickford and Brigitte Senut, from making some bold claims about Orrorin's relationship to modern humans. Based on the morphology of its teeth, which appear more similar to ours than Lucy's do, and the structure of the femur, these scientists have suggested that Orrorin is more directly related to us than Lucy is. More fossil evidence for Orrorin will be needed to support these claims.

    A curved, ancient bone artifact, possibly a tool or handle, shown against a plain background.
    Figure \(\PageIndex{3}\): Orrorin tugenensis femur cast (BAR 1002'00) on display at the Smithsonian's National Museum of Natural History By Jonathan Chen - Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia

    The Challenge of Access and Scientific Progress

    The story of Orrorin highlights a frustrating reality in paleoanthropology: the fossils remain largely inaccessible to the broader scientific community. It’s not even clear where the Orrorin remains are currently stored.3 This situation serves as a stark reminder that scientific progress depends on collaboration and open access to evidence. For our understanding of human origins to advance, the fossils documenting the very opening chapters of our evolutionary story need to be shared and examined by multiple researchers, allowing for thorough analysis and productive interpretations, even if scientists don’t reach full agreement.

    The cases of both Sahelanthropus and Orrorin illustrate one of the central challenges in paleoanthropology: determining what characteristics are most important for defining membership in the hominin lineage. Is it just bipedalism? Or are other features such as dental modifications, facial structure, and brain size important? Could it be all of the above? As new fossils from this crucial period are discovered, each find forces us to reconsider our assumptions about what it means to be on the path to humanity—and this constant questioning is exactly what good science demands.

    That means that the uncertainty surrounding these early species doesn’t diminish their importance. If anything, it makes them even more fascinating. Whether or not they turn out to be true hominins, these ancient species serve as humbling reminders that the story of human origins is far more complex and nuanced than we once imagined.

    A Second Adaptive Radiation: A Revolutionary Discovery in the Pliocene

    As Earth’s climate continued to exert its relentless selective pressures, the transition from the Miocene (23 – 5.3 mya) to the Pliocene epoch (5.3 – 2.6 mya) ushered in a new chapter in human evolution. This period is marked by the appearance of a new genus: Ardipithecus. These pre-australopithecine species emerged from a very geologically active region—Ethiopia’s Middle Awash Valley in the Afar region. Here, volcanic eruptions and tectonic shifts not only buried and preserved these ancient remains, they've actually provided scientists with the perfect conditions for radiometric dating. The species within the Ardipithecus genus display an interesting mosaic of ape-like and human-like characteristics, with adaptations for both bipedalism and life in the trees. Given that forests still dominated the landscape during this time, this dual lifestyle makes sense. But what these discoveries revealed about the evolution of bipedalism would completely overturn decades of scientific thinking.

    Meet “Ardi”: The 4.4 Million Year Old Game Changer

    A partially damaged skull with exposed features, displaying both bone and remnants of decay against a black background.
    Figure \(\PageIndex{4}\): Skull Cast of Ardipithecus ramidus Rama, CC BY-SA 3.0 via Wikimedia Commons

    The starring role in this chapter of the hominin evolutionary story belongs to Ardipithecus ramidus, nicknamed "Ardi," who lived 4.4 million years ago. This female skeleton represents one of the most significant fossil discoveries in paleoanthropology for several important reasons. First, the amount of evidence recovered is impressive. Scientists found more than 125 bone fragments from a single individual, plus additional bones and teeth from at least 35 other individuals. This extensive collection makes Ardi the oldest substantially complete skeleton ever discovered. Second, for a specimen of this age, the preservation is remarkably good. The skeleton includes essential bones from the hands, feet, limbs, and pelvis, as well as most of the skull and teeth. This level of completeness is unusual for fossils this old and provides researchers with detailed information about how these ancient hominins lived and moved.

    Fossils displayed on a table, showing skeletal remains including arms, hands, and legs in a museum setting.
    Figure \(\PageIndex{5}\): Ardipithecus ramidus fossils on exhibit in the National Museum of Ethiopia by Sailko, CC BY 3.0 via Wikimedia Commons

    Ardi’s Anatomy: A Body Built for Two Worlds

    Examining Ardi from head to toe reveals a hominin perfectly adapted for a dual existence that challenges everything we thought we knew about early human evolution:

    Head and teeth – Ardi’s foramen magnum sits in a central position consistent with bipedal locomotion, clear evidence she walked upright. Yet like Sahelanthropus, her brain remained small (around 300-350 cubic centimeters, similar to a chimp’s) with a mildly projecting lower face. Her canines lacked the honing complex and diastema found in apes, and wear patterns on her teeth suggest an omnivorous diet.

    Arms and Hands – Here’s where Ardi becomes truly extraordinary. While her lower arm bones were extremely long compared to her upper arm bone, her hands present an evolutionary puzzle: short palm bones (like humans) combined with long, curved finger bones designed for powerful grasping (like apes). Yet her wrist bones reveal she didn’t knuckle-walk like modern chimps and gorillas. Ardi's hand was neither an ape hand nor a human hand, but something entirely unique in the fossil record.

    Hip and Pelvis – Ardi’s pelvis was more elongated than both modern humans and later hominins like Lucy, but it clearly showed adaptations for upright walking, including wider and more robust hip bones that could support her weight on two legs.

    Legs and feet – Her femur (thigh bone) is robust and displayed the characteristic bicondylar angle of a biped. Most fascinating of all, her feet were rigid enough to support upright walking, yet featured elongated toes and a fully divergent, grasping big toe—a feature not found on any other bipedal hominin.

    A side view sketch of a human skeleton, standing upright with one arm bent and the other relaxed by its side.
    Figure \(\PageIndex{6}\): An illustrated reconstruction of Ardi’s full skeleton. Ori~, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

    Rewriting Human Origins

    Ardi’s significance extends far beyond her impressive fossil record. As the closest known hominin to the common ancestor of chimps and humans, she has forced scientists to reconsider how bipedalism evolved. For decades, researchers assumed our earliest ancestors were chimpanzee-like creatures who gradually adapted to life on the ground. Ardi proves this model wrong. Instead, the first hominins possessed a distinctive combination of arboreal and bipedal adaptations that enabled them to both walk upright on the ground and move through the trees with remarkable skill---a locomotive pattern unlike anything seen in any living primate today.

    Perhaps the most revolutionary aspect of these discoveries is what they reveal about early hominin habitats. All of these ancient species lived not on the open savannas that scientists, including Charles Darwin, long believed drove human evolution, but in forested environments. This finding has fundamentally challenged the “Savanna Hypothesis”---the idea that our ancestors developed bipedalism as forests retreated and they needed to cross open grasslands.

    Instead, it appears that our upright gait first evolved beneath a canopy of trees, possibly as an adaptation for moving between patches of forest for accessing food sources in both arboreal and terrestrial environments and probably for safety as well. This revelation has required us to develop entirely new models for understanding how and why humans began walking on two legs. But as paleoanthropologist Jeremy DeSilva reminds us, “There are more fossils yet to be found and much of the human story yet to be written” (2021:86).


    1. Wood, B. (2014). Welcome to the Family. Scientific American, 311(3), 42–47.

    2. Lee, S. with S.Y. Yoon (2015). Close Encounters with Humankind: A Paleoanthropologist Investigates Our Evolving Species. New York: W.W. Norton & Co.

    3. DeSilva, J. (2021). First Steps: How Upright Walking Made Us Human. New York: Harper Collins.


    This page titled 11.3: Pre-Australopithecines was last modified on Thu, 20 Aug 2026 00:23:02 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Rachel Mitchell.