1.3: The Scientific Method- Converting Curiosity into Study
Opening the book…
The Scientific Method: Converting Curiosity into Study
Author: Anne E. Pfister, PhD
Time needed: 30-40 minutes
Supplies Needed
Worksheet
Videos
Introduction
During this activity, students learn to operationalize ideas and form a hypothetical research design using the scientific method. This introductory activity is designed to get students thinking about topics that interest them that fall within the realm of anthropological study. Most of all, it helps them identify what topics can be approached scientifically and which cannot.
Steps
Introduce the concepts of science and belief, explaining that humans use both systems to learn about the world. Explain that science is self-correcting while dogma is unwavering. Discuss examples (i.e. we have the science and technology to clone animals, should we clone humans? This illustrates how science depends on ethics, a belief system. Beliefs cannot be scientifically ‘tested’ while natural phenomena can be).
Review the steps of the scientific method and the assumptions of science introduced by Jonathan Marks in the beginning of Chapter Two: Evolution in Explorations.
View the short video Turtles and Snakes by Mark Rober to underscore how nearly any idea or curiosity can be converted into scientific study using the tenants of the scientific method:
Turtles or Snakes- Which do cars hit more? ROADKILL EXPERIMENT
I read a long time ago that people will swerve more to hit turtles over snakes... and as a firm believer in the scientific method, I decided to test this hypothesis.
Takeaway Ideas and Points for Review:
All humans use science and belief systems to explore the world and create theories about it.
Science is a specific way of investigating the world. Scientists use the scientific method because it helps us operationalize ideas and standardize approaches to answering difficult questions and creating theories about our observations.
Science is self-correcting – as new (and potentially contradictory) data are introduced, theories are amended or improved upon. Dogma is static and does not change.
For Further Exploration
The Scientific Method, SproutsThe Scientific Method: Steps, Examples, Tips, and Exercise
The Scientific Method: Steps, Examples, Tips, and Exercise
The scientific method is an important tool to solve problems and learn from our observations. There are six steps to it: Observe and Ask Questions, Research, Formulate a Hypothesis, Test your hypothesis, Conclude Share Results. The goal of the scientific method is find out the truth. Let's try.
References
Nelson, Katie, Lara Braff, Beth Shook, and Kelsie Aguilera. 2019. “Chapter 1: Introduction to Biological Anthropology” In Explorations: An Open Invitation to Biological Anthropology, edited by Beth Shook, Katie Nelson, Kelsie Aguilera, and Lara Braff. Arlington, VA: American Anthropological Association.
The Scientific Method: Converting Curiosity into Study Worksheet
How does the epistemology of science differ from other ways of knowing about the world?
Write two (or more) questions (related to humans/anthropology) – one that COULD be investigated scientifically and one that CANNOT be tested scientifically.
a.
b.
Design a mock study using some of the steps of the scientific method below to answer a provocative question you have about biological anthropology.
a. Identify the question or the potential relationship between two or more observable phenomena:
b. Formulate hypotheses about expected outcomes between variables, based on existing theory:
c. What primary methods would you use to collect observations pertaining to the question:
d. What aspects of the study are holistic? In other words, which other sub-fields of anthropology might be interested in the results of your study? Why?