Finding relevant sources/citations is an act of translation. You need to translate what’s in your head to a computer. In Google Scholar or databases, you can start with the words from your Venn diagram. These terms are keywords and using them is like doing Ctrl+F to find any resource that has those exact letters in the title, abstract, or even the full text. Using keywords means you’ll need to think of synonyms and spelling variations. From our example, synonyms might include:
However, thinking of all the synonyms that an author might have used is quite difficult. Databases, unlike Google Scholar, have experts who categorize resources to make them easier to find, rather than relying on algorithms. All resources in databases are filed by their subject. You can think of this like a “tag”, except only experts apply these, not authors nor users. These are sometimes called subject headings or subject descriptors. You can use the database’s thesaurus to find (and include) related terms. For example, if you search for the subject heading therapy in APA PsycInfo, you'll find dozens of narrower terms (in this case, specific types of therapy) which you can include in your search.
Compare
The following table compares keywords and subject headings.
Keywords vs Subject Headings
Keywords
Subject Headings
What?
Specific words
Topics/subjects
Who creates?
You (natural language)
Experts (controlled vocabulary)
Homonyms automatically included?
No
Yes - All variations covered
Connects to related, narrower, broader subjects
When to use?
Starting place
Topic is new
Topic is specific (e.g. location or organization)
Topic has established academic research on it
Highly relevant results
One of the best ways to see how keywords or subject headings impact your search differently is to try them both and note how they impact your search differently. Often it's best to use a combination of both.
Activity: Keywords & subject headings
Try searching in a database for a keyword from your Venn diagram.
Your keyword:
How many results do you get?
Next, use the database’s thesaurus to find a subject heading representing your keyword.
Corresponding subject heading:
What narrower & related terms are in the thesaurus?
Would you be interested in articles on any of the narrower and/or related terms instead of your initial term? If so, grab all that interest you.
Now how many results do you get?
Keyword searching might retrieve more results since it will find articles that just use the word once but aren’t about that subject. However, keyword searching will miss results that use a slightly different word, such as a synonym or narrower term. Subject headings help retrieve more relevant results. And the thesaurus can help you find related terms that can improve your search results.
Keywords vs Subject Headings for your first quick scan
Keyword from your Venn diagram
Number of results in keyword search
Subject headings (include narrower & related terms)
Number of results for subject search
Which seems more useful?
Ex: therapy
Ex: 495481
Ex: Treatment
Ex: cross cultural treatment; psychotherapy; trauma treatment; trauma-informed care
Ex: treatment + narrower terms - 146419
Ex: Subject heading
In our example, the subject heading seemed more useful because it helped us find additional, helpful terms, and because it found fewer results (but hopefully more topical results) than the keyword search. That will not always be the case, as it depends on your topic, the database, and the terms.
In this section, we've just been adding one term at a time so we're not yet ready to review the results in any depth.