Children develop their understandings of themselves through relationships, experiences, and participation in social environments.
Families, peers, schools, communities, cultural groups, and media provide opportunities for children to explore who they are, how they relate to others, and where they experience belonging.
As discussed in previous chapters, identity development is not a process in which children simply adopt the expectations of the people around them.
Children actively interpret messages, explore relationships, express preferences, and develop understandings of themselves within their social worlds.
Their experiences may involve multiple dimensions of identity, including family relationships, cultural heritage, language, race, ethnicity, gender, disability, interests, and community membership.
These dimensions may become more or less important in different contexts and at different points in development.
Social Expectations and Children's Developing Identities
Every social environment communicates expectations about behavior, participation, relationships, and belonging.
Children may encounter different expectations across their families, classrooms, peer groups, and communities.
For example, a child may be encouraged to observe carefully before speaking during family gatherings but encounter classroom expectations that emphasize immediate verbal participation.
Another child may have considerable responsibility for helping with family activities while encountering school environments in which adults make most decisions.
These experiences are not necessarily contradictory. Children often learn to navigate multiple expectations and social roles.
However, difficulties may arise when educators interpret unfamiliar practices as evidence of limited ability, motivation, or family support.
Recognizing the social context of children's behavior helps educators respond more thoughtfully.
Racial and Ethnic Identity
Racial and ethnic identities may influence how children understand themselves and experience relationships within families, peer groups, schools, and communities.
Children encounter messages about racial and ethnic identities through conversations, cultural traditions, books, media representations, educational materials, and everyday social interactions.
Some messages affirm identity and belonging. Others may communicate stereotypes, exclusion, or unequal expectations.
DeCuir-Gunby (2009) examined the relationship between racial identity development and educational experiences among African American adolescents.
Martinez and Dukes (1997) explored relationships among ethnic identity, self-esteem, academic confidence, and purpose in life among adolescents.
These studies demonstrate why identity and belonging are important areas of developmental and educational research.
However, findings involving adolescents should not be assumed to apply identically to preschool-aged children.
For younger children, educators can consider how everyday experiences of recognition, representation, and participation contribute to their developing understandings of themselves and others.
Representation and Belonging
Representation involves the ways people, identities, relationships, and experiences are included or portrayed within social environments.
For example, classroom books may show children and caregivers with different family structures, languages, cultural experiences, and abilities.
Meaningful representation can create opportunities for children to recognize familiar experiences and learn about others.
However, representation should avoid reducing individuals to a single characteristic.
A child should not be expected to represent an entire cultural, racial, linguistic, or identity group.
Educators can support belonging by recognizing the diversity within groups as well as across them.
Gender Expectations and Socialization
Note
As you watch the overview of gender theories, reflect on your earliest memories related to gender:
- When was the first time you understood how your gender would affect your life?
- How did your understanding of gender develop as you grew older, and as the world changed around you?
- Were your own experiences related to gender positive or negative?
Children encounter gender-related expectations through family experiences, peers, educational environments, media, and other social institutions.
These messages may influence which activities children are encouraged to explore, how behaviors are interpreted, and which roles are presented as appropriate.
For example, adults may unintentionally encourage some children toward construction activities and others toward caregiving play based on gender expectations.
Such expectations can narrow opportunities for exploration.
A developmentally responsive approach recognizes children's interests and abilities without assuming that gender determines what activities or roles they should pursue.
Children may also communicate aspects of their gender identity and expression through preferences, language, appearance, relationships, and play.
Gender identity, gender expression, and sexual orientation are related but distinct concepts.
Gender identity refers to a person's internal understanding of their gender. Gender expression refers to ways gender may be communicated through appearance, behavior, or other forms of expression. Sexual orientation concerns patterns of romantic or sexual attraction and should not be inferred from a young child's clothing, play interests, friendships, or gender expression.
Educators do not need to assign identities to children based on observations.
Their responsibility is to provide respectful, developmentally appropriate environments where children can participate without restrictive stereotypes or exclusion.
Identity, Disability, and Participation
Children with disabilities may also encounter social expectations that influence belonging and identity.
For example, a child who uses an augmentative communication device may participate successfully in classroom conversations when educators and peers understand how to communicate with them.
In contrast, an environment that assumes all children must communicate verbally may unintentionally limit participation.
Disability-related experiences are not uniform.
Children and families may have varied understandings of disability, different support needs, and different ways of describing their experiences.
As discussed in Chapter 7, inclusion involves meaningful opportunities for participation, relationships, and belonging rather than simply being present in a classroom.
Language and Identity Across Social Settings
Language can communicate belonging, relationships, and social expectations.
As discussed in Chapter 8, multilingual children may use different languages with different family members, peers, and educators.
The original Chapter 9 discussed code-switching, which may involve changing languages or linguistic varieties according to conversational context.
For example, a child might speak Spanish with a grandparent and English with a classmate, moving between languages during shared play.
These changes may reflect social relationships, communication goals, and familiarity with particular settings.
However, educators should not interpret language differences as evidence that children are confused or that one linguistic variety is inferior.
Children's language practices are important resources for communication and identity.
Cultural Expectations About Childhood
Ideas about childhood responsibilities and independence vary across societies and historical periods.
Barbara Rogoff (2003) examined how children learn through participation in culturally organized activities.
In some communities, children may contribute to household responsibilities at relatively young ages.
In other contexts, adults may emphasize prolonged supervision and limit particular responsibilities until children are older.
Neither pattern should be interpreted without considering context, children's individual abilities, safety, and social expectations.
The important lesson is that educators should distinguish between developmental knowledge and expectations that may be specific to a particular cultural environment.
This understanding helps prevent assumptions about what children are capable of knowing or doing.
Discrimination, Social Experiences, and Identity
Children develop their identities through relationships, interactions, and messages received within families, schools, peer groups, communities, and broader society.
These experiences can communicate important messages about who children are, how they are perceived by others, and whether they are recognized and valued within their social environments.
While many experiences affirm children's identities and sense of belonging, others may involve stereotypes, prejudice, discrimination, or unequal treatment.
As discussed in Chapters 2 and 5, stereotypes and biases can influence how individuals perceive and respond to others. Chapter 7 further explored how institutional practices and educator expectations may influence children's educational experiences.
Our focus here is not to redefine these concepts, but to examine how such experiences may influence children's developing identities and their understanding of belonging within society.
How Children Interpret Social Messages
Even young children notice differences and similarities among people. They may also become aware of social expectations and messages associated with race, ethnicity, gender, language, disability, family structure, and other aspects of identity.
These messages can be communicated directly through words and behaviors or indirectly through classroom materials, media representations, peer interactions, and institutional practices.
For example, a child may notice that characters who share their family's cultural background rarely appear in classroom books.
Another child may hear classmates suggest that certain activities are appropriate only for boys or girls.
A child who communicates using assistive technology may notice whether peers and educators consistently include them in conversations and collaborative activities.
These experiences can influence how children understand themselves and their place within a group.
However, children are not passive recipients of social messages. They interpret experiences through their existing knowledge, relationships, and developing understanding of the world.
Direct and Indirect Experiences of Discrimination
Children may encounter discrimination through their own experiences or through circumstances affecting important people in their lives.
Direct discrimination involves unfair treatment experienced by the child.
For example, a child may be excluded from a group activity because of a disability, language difference, or perceived identity.
Indirect or vicarious experiences of discrimination occur when children are affected by discriminatory treatment experienced by caregivers, family members, or others with whom they have meaningful relationships.
Heard-Garris and colleagues (2018) conducted a systematic review examining the relationship between vicarious racism and children's health.
Their review identified 30 studies and found that indirect experiences of racism were associated with several child health outcomes, particularly social-emotional and mental health measures.
However, the researchers also identified limitations in how studies defined and measured vicarious racism, emphasizing the need for additional research.
These findings help us understand that children's development is influenced not only by what happens directly to them but also by circumstances affecting their important relationships.
For example, a caregiver who experiences discrimination in employment may encounter additional stress or uncertainty. These circumstances may influence family routines, available resources, or emotional experiences.
This does not mean that discrimination experienced by a caregiver will inevitably produce negative outcomes for a child.
Individual responses vary, and supportive relationships, resources, and environmental circumstances also influence children's experiences.
Discrimination, Stress, and Child Development
The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) recognizes racism as a social determinant of children's health and development.
In its policy statement The Impact of Racism on Child and Adolescent Health, Trent and colleagues (2019) examine how institutional, interpersonal, and internalized racism can influence children's experiences and well-being.
The AAP reaffirmed this policy statement in August 2025.
The statement emphasizes that experiences of racism may contribute to stress and influence children's health and development through multiple pathways.
However, educators should avoid assuming that children who experience discrimination will demonstrate particular behaviors, emotional responses, or developmental outcomes.
Children's experiences are shaped by many interacting influences, including relationships, resources, opportunities, and individual characteristics.
An ecological perspective helps us understand these interactions without reducing children or families to the challenges they encounter.
Identity, Representation, and Belonging
Children's developing identities are also influenced by whether their experiences and relationships are recognized within the environments in which they participate.
For example, a child may experience greater connection to classroom activities when books, conversations, and materials reflect meaningful aspects of their family and community experiences.
Representation can also provide opportunities for children to learn about people whose experiences differ from their own.
However, meaningful representation requires more than displaying images of diverse groups.
Educators should consider whether children are portrayed as capable individuals with varied interests, relationships, and experiences.
They should also examine whether classroom practices provide genuine opportunities for participation.
For example, including photographs of children with disabilities is not a substitute for ensuring that children with disabilities can meaningfully participate in classroom activities.
Belonging develops through relationships, recognition, and participation—not simply through being physically present or represented in classroom materials.
Supportive Relationships and Protective Experiences
Although discrimination and exclusion can influence children's experiences, these circumstances do not define their identities or developmental potential.
Families and communities may provide important sources of cultural connection, encouragement, shared knowledge, and belonging.
Educators and peers can also contribute through respectful relationships and meaningful opportunities for participation.
The American Academy of Pediatrics (2019) emphasizes supportive family and community relationships, positive identity development, and other protective factors when addressing the effects of racism.
Within early childhood settings, educators can contribute by:
- Recognizing children's individual strengths and meaningful relationships.
- Including authentic representations of varied families, identities, and communities.
- Responding when children experience exclusion or unfair treatment.
- Examining their own expectations and assumptions.
- Providing meaningful opportunities for participation.
- Listening to children's experiences and family perspectives.
- Collaborating with families without defining them primarily through difficulties or disadvantages.
These practices do not eliminate broader institutional inequalities.
However, they are important ways educators can contribute to supportive environments while recognizing their responsibility to examine and address barriers within their programs.
Connecting to Professional Practice: A Classroom Example
Meet Amara
Amara is a five-year-old child who enjoys science investigations, storytelling, and building with classmates.
During a group activity, another child tells Amara that she cannot be the engineer because girls do not build bridges.
Amara stops participating and moves to another area of the classroom.
The educator notices the interaction.
Rather than describing Amara as uninterested in the activity or focusing solely on correcting the other child's words, the educator considers how the interaction may have influenced Amara's experience of belonging.
The educator responds to the restrictive stereotype, reinforces that all children can participate in engineering and construction experiences, and invites the group to reconsider how roles are assigned.
The educator also provides opportunities for Amara to participate without requiring her to immediately explain her feelings in front of classmates.
Applying Our Understanding
- Socialization: The peer's statement communicates a learned expectation about gender and participation.
- Identity: The interaction may influence how Amara understands her opportunities within the group.
- Belonging: The educator considers whether the classroom provides meaningful opportunities for everyone to contribute.
- Professional practice: The educator responds to exclusion while supporting respectful relationships and continued participation.
This example demonstrates that supporting children's identities involves more than correcting stereotypes. It also requires examining how social messages influence children's opportunities, relationships, and experiences within educational environments.
Pause to Reflect!
- How might direct and indirect experiences of discrimination influence children's developing identities and sense of belonging?
- What does Heard-Garris and colleagues' (2018) research contribute to our understanding of the relationship between caregiver experiences and children's well-being?
- Why is it important to avoid assuming that discrimination will affect every child in the same way?
- How might classroom materials, peer relationships, and educator expectations communicate messages about identity and belonging?
- What is the difference between including diverse representations in a classroom and creating meaningful opportunities for participation?
- In Amara's case, how might the educator's response influence both Amara's experience and the developing peer culture of the classroom?
- How can educators recognize the influence of broader social conditions while maintaining a strengths-based understanding of children and families?
Figure 9.1.1: Identity and Belonging Across Social Environments

Three connected scenes illustrate children's experiences across family, school, and community environments. On the left, a young girl wearing a purple sweater interacts with family members, including adults and children, in a welcoming home setting. In the center, the same child collaborates with classmates using colorful magnetic building blocks while an educator observes and supports their interactions. On the right, the child joins a diverse group of peers outdoors, sharing a nature-themed book. The illustration emphasizes how family relationships, classroom experiences, peer interactions, and community participation contribute to children's developing identities and sense of belonging.
Figure description: A three-part illustration shows a child participating in family relationships, collaborative classroom learning, and an outdoor community activity. The scenes emphasize that children develop their identities and sense of belonging through experiences across multiple social environments. Family connections, peer participation, educator relationships, and community opportunities each contribute to children's developing understandings of themselves and others. Original AI-generated educational illustration.
Case Study: One Child, Multiple Identities
Meet Elena
Elena is a five-year-old child who enjoys storytelling, drawing, and building.
At home, Elena frequently tells stories with family members in Spanish.
At school, she participates in a classroom where most instruction occurs in English.
Elena also enjoys constructing elaborate buildings with blocks, although some peers have suggested that construction is an activity for boys.
During a community library event, Elena proudly shares a drawing based on one of her family's stories.
Applying Chapter Concepts
Language and identity: Elena uses different linguistic resources across social settings.
Gender expectations: Peer comments may influence whether Elena feels welcome in particular activities.
Family experiences: Storytelling provides knowledge and relationships that Elena brings to school.
Community belonging: The library event offers an opportunity for Elena's interests and family experiences to be recognized.
Professional practice: Elena's educator can recognize these connections without requiring her to choose between identities or conform to stereotypes.
References
DeCuir-Gunby, J. T. (2009). A review of the racial identity development of African American adolescents: The role of education. Review of Educational Research, 79(1), 103–124.
Heard-Garris, N. J., Cale, M., Camaj, L., Hamati, M. C., & Dominguez, T. P. (2018). Transmitting trauma: A systematic review of vicarious racism and child health. Social Science & Medicine, 199, 230–240. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.socscimed.2017.04.018
Martinez, R. O., & Dukes, R. L. (1997). The effects of ethnic identity, ethnicity, and gender on adolescent well-being. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 26, 503–516.
Rogoff, B. (2003). The cultural nature of human development. Oxford University Press.
Trent, M., Dooley, D. G., & Dougé, J. (2019). The impact of racism on child and adolescent health. Pediatrics, 144(2), e20191765. https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2019-1765
Note: The American Academy of Pediatrics reaffirmed the 2019 policy statement in August 2025.