Opening the book…
Identifying Arguments
Summary: Identifying arguments involves recognizing statements where someone attempts to establish truth based on another statement. This section discusses premise and conclusion indicators, which aid in distinguishing arguments from non-arguments. By understanding these indicators and applying substitution tests, students can accurately identify arguments.
Learning Objectives:
- Recognize statements constituting arguments.
- Understand premise and conclusion indicators.
- Apply the substitution test to determine argument presence.
Identifying Arguments: An argument is present when someone seeks to establish a statement as true based on another statement. This can be determined by recognizing premise and conclusion indicators within sentences.
Premise and Conclusion Indicators:
- Premise Indicators: Words like "since," "because," and "for" introduce statements providing reasons or support.
- Conclusion Indicators: Words like "so," "therefore," and "hence" mark statements someone aims to establish as true.
Substitution Test: To verify if a word functions as a premise or conclusion indicator, substitute it with another from the list. If the resulting sentence makes sense, it likely indicates an argument.
Exercise: Identify arguments and their conclusions:
- The woman in the hat is not a witch since witches have long noses and she doesn’t have a long nose. (Conclusion: The woman in the hat is not a witch.)
- I have been wrangling cattle since before you were old enough to tie your own shoes. (Not an argument)
- Albert is angry with me so he probably won’t be willing to help me wash the dishes. (Conclusion: Albert probably won't help wash the dishes.)
- First I washed the dishes and then I dried them. (Not an argument)
- If the road wasn’t icy, the car wouldn’t have slid off the turn. (Not an argument)
- Albert isn’t a fireman and he isn’t a fisherman either. (Not an argument)
- Are you seeing that rhinoceros over there? It is huge! (Not an argument)
- The fact that obesity has become a problem in the U.S. is shown by the fact that obesity rates have risen significantly over the past four decades. (Conclusion: Obesity is a problem in the U.S.)
- Bob showed me a graph with the rising obesity rates and I was very surprised to see how much they’ve risen. (Not an argument)
- Albert isn’t a fireman because Albert is a Greyhound, which is a kind of dog, and dogs can’t be firemen. (Conclusion: Albert isn't a fireman.)
- Charlie and Violet are dogs and since dogs don’t sweat, it is obvious that Charlie and Violet don’t sweat. (Conclusion: Charlie and Violet don't sweat.)
- The reason I forgot to lock the door is that I was distracted by the clown riding a unicycle down our street while singing Lynyrd Skynyrd’s “Simple Man.” (Not an argument)
- What Bob told you is not the real reason that he missed his plane to Denver. (Not an argument)
- Samsung stole some of Apple’s patents for their smartphones, so Apple stole some of Samsung’s patents back in retaliation. (Conclusion: Apple stole Samsung's patents.)
- No one who has ever gotten frostbite while climbing K2 has survived to tell about it, therefore no one ever will. (Conclusion: No one will survive frostbite while climbing K2.)
Table 1 contains a list of some common premise and conclusion indicators:
| Premises indicators | Conclusion indicators |
| since | therefore |
| because | so |
| for | hence |
| as | thus |
| given that | implies that |
| seeing that | consequently |
| for the reason that | it follows that |
| is shown by the fact that | We may conclude that |

"Loud Yelling Please" by Enokson is licensed under CC BY 2.0.
4.3: Identifying Arguments is shared under a not declared license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by LibreTexts.
The book could not be loaded just now.