Opening the book…
9.5.1 Phenomenological setup
Consider a system near equilibrium characterised by thermodynamic variables \(\left\{A_{i}\right\}\) with thermodynamic forces
\[ X_{i}=\frac{\partial S}{\partial A_{i}}, \quad J_{i}=\frac{d A_{i}}{d t}, \tag{9.23} \label{9.23} \]
where \(S\) is the total entropy. The fluxes are assumed to depend linearly on the forces:
\[ J_{i}=\sum_{j} L_{i j} X_{j} . \tag{9.24} \label{9.24} \]
The entropy production rate is therefore
\[ \dot{S}=\sum_{i} J_{i} X_{i}=\sum_{i, j} L_{i j} X_{i} X_{j}, \tag{9.25} \label{9.25} \]
so the second law of thermodynamics \((\dot{S} \geq 0)\) requires only that the symmetric part of \(\mathbf{L}\) be positive semidefinite. The reciprocity \(L_{i j}=L_{j i}\) is an additional, stronger statement that follows from microscopic reversibility-not from thermodynamics alone.
The Onsager matrix L encodes all transport phenomena: thermal conductivity, electrical conductivity, thermoelectric coefficients, diffusion, and their cross-effects.
We now present two independent proofs of the reciprocal relations, each illuminating a different facet of the underlying physics.
9.5.2 Proof A: Green-Kubo formula and time-reversal parity
Green-Kubo formula for \(L_{i j}\)
Let the perturbation Hamiltonian be \(H^{\prime}(t)=-\sum_{j} X_{j}(t) B_{j}\), where \(B_{j}\) are observables conjugate to the forces. The Kubo formula for the quantum retarded response function is
\[ \chi_{i j}(t)=\frac{1}{\hbar} \theta(t)\left\langle\left[J_{i}(t), B_{j}(0)\right]\right\rangle_{0}, \tag{9.26} \label{9.26} \]
where \([\cdot, \cdot]\) is the commutator. In the classical (low-frequency) limit, via \([,] / i \hbar \rightarrow\{\),\(\} , and using\) the cross-FDT Equation \ref{9.21}, the dc transport coefficients become
\[ L_{i j}=\int_{0}^{\infty}\left\langle J_{i}(t) J_{j}(0)\right\rangle_{0} d t \tag{9.27} \label{9.27} \]
Time-reversal parity of fluxes
Let \(\Theta\) denote the antiunitary time-reversal operator. The equilibrium state is \(\Theta\)-invariant:
\[ \left\langle\Theta \mathcal{O} \Theta^{-1}\right\rangle_{0}=\langle\mathcal{O}\rangle_{0} \quad \text { for any observable } \mathcal{O} . \tag{9.28} \label{9.28} \]
We assign each flux a definite parity under time reversal:
\[ \Theta J_{i} \Theta^{-1}=\epsilon_{i} J_{i}, \quad \epsilon_{i}= \pm 1, \tag{9.29} \label{9.29} \]
which gives the dynamical relation
\[ \Theta J_{i}(t) \Theta^{-1}=\epsilon_{i} J_{i}(-t) . \tag{9.30} \label{9.30} \]
Position-like quantities (density, concentration) have \(\epsilon=+1\); velocity-like quantities (heat or charge currents) have \(\epsilon=-1\).
Symmetry of the current correlator
Define \(C_{i j}(t)=\left\langle J_{i}(t) J_{j}(0)\right\rangle_{0}\). Applying time-reversal invariance Equation \ref{9.28}-Equation \ref{9.30}:
\[ \begin{align*} C_{i j}(t) & =\left\langle\Theta J_{i}(t) J_{j}(0) \Theta^{-1}\right\rangle_{0} \\[4pt] & =\left\langle\left(\Theta J_{i}(t) \Theta^{-1}\right)\left(\Theta J_{j}(0) \Theta^{-1}\right)\right\rangle_{0} \\[4pt] & =\epsilon_{i} \epsilon_{j}\left\langle J_{i}(-t) J_{j}(0)\right\rangle_{0} . \tag{9.31} \label{9.31} \end{align*} \]
Applying stationarity, \(\left\langle J_{i}(-t) J_{j}(0)\right\rangle_{0}=\left\langle J_{j}(t) J_{i}(0)\right\rangle_{0}=C_{j i}(t)\) :
\[ C_{i j}(t)=\epsilon_{i} \epsilon_{j} C_{j i}(t) . \tag{9.32} \label{9.32} \]
Deriving the reciprocal relations
Substituting Equation \ref{9.32} into the Green-Kubo formula Equation \ref{9.27}:
\[ L_{i j}=\int_{0}^{\infty} C_{i j}(t) d t=\epsilon_{i} \epsilon_{j} \int_{0}^{\infty} C_{j i}(t) d t=\epsilon_{i} \epsilon_{j} L_{j i} \tag{9.33} \label{9.33} \]
Hence the Onsager-Casimir reciprocal relations:
\[ L_{i j}=\epsilon_{i} \epsilon_{j} L_{j i} . \tag{9.34} \label{9.34} \]
When all relevant fluxes share the same time-reversal parity \(\left(\epsilon_{i} \epsilon_{j}=1\right)\), this reduces to the original Onsager symmetry \(L_{i j}=L_{j i}\). The mixed-parity case \(\left(\epsilon_{i} \epsilon_{j}=-1\right)\) yields the Casimir antisymmetry \(L_{i j}=-L_{j i}\) [8], relevant for cross-effects between charge and heat currents in a magnetic field.
9.5.3 Proof B: Entropy-production and Gaussian fluctuations
This alternative proof works entirely at the level of fluctuation statistics, without invoking the Green-Kubo integral explicitly. It follows closely the original reasoning of Onsager [1, 3].
Equilibrium fluctuation measure
Near equilibrium, the joint distribution of the variables \(\left\{A_{i}\right\}\) (each with zero mean) is approximately Gaussian:
\[ P\left(\left\{A_{i}\right\}\right) \propto \exp \left(\frac{S}{k_{\mathrm{B}}}\right), \quad S \approx S_{\mathrm{eq}}-\frac{1}{2} \sum_{i, j} g_{i j} A_{i} A_{j}, \tag{9.35} \label{9.35} \]
where \(g_{i j}\) is a symmetric positive-definite matrix (the inverse of the fluctuation covariance matrix, \(g=\langle A A\rangle^{-1}\) ). The thermodynamic forces Equation \ref{9.23} are therefore linear in the \(A_{i}\) :
\[ X_{k}=\frac{\partial S}{\partial A_{k}}=-\sum_{j} g_{k j} A_{j} . \tag{9.36} \label{9.36} \]
Orthogonality relation
Lemma 9.2 (Gaussian orthogonality). Under the distribution Equation \ref{9.35},
\[ \left\langle A_{i} X_{j}\right\rangle=-k_{\mathrm{B}} \delta_{i j} . \tag{9.37} \label{9.37} \]
Proof. \(\left\langle A_{i} X_{j}\right\rangle=-\sum_{k} g_{j k}\left\langle A_{i} A_{k}\right\rangle=-\sum_{k} g_{j k}\left(g^{-1}\right)_{k i}=-\delta_{j i}\). \(\square\)
Connecting time derivatives of correlators to \(L_{i j}\)
By the Regression Hypothesis (Section 9.3), the decay of \(\left\langle A_{k}\right\rangle\) conditioned on an initial fluctuation \(\left\{A_{i}\right\}\) follows the same linear law as a macroscopic relaxation:
\[ \frac{d}{d t}\left\langle A_{k}(t) A_{i}(0)\right\rangle=\sum_{j} L_{k j}\left\langle X_{j}(t) A_{i}(0)\right\rangle . \tag{9.38} \label{9.38} \]
Setting \(t=0\) and using the orthogonality relation Equation \ref{9.37}:
\[ \left.\frac{d}{d t} C_{k i}(t)\right|_{t=0}=\sum_{j} L_{k j}\left\langle X_{j} A_{i}\right\rangle=-k_{\mathrm{B}} L_{k i} . \tag{9.39} \label{9.39} \]
Time-reversal symmetry of the correlator
The three-step argument exploiting microscopic reversibility:
1. Time-reversal invariance. Under microscopic reversibility, for even-parity variables:
\[ \left\langle A_{i}(t) A_{k}(t+\tau)\right\rangle=\left\langle A_{i}(t) A_{k}(t-\tau)\right\rangle . \tag{9.40} \label{9.40} \]
2. Stationarity. Shifting the time origin by \(\tau\) :
\[ \left\langle A_{i}(t) A_{k}(t-\tau)\right\rangle=\left\langle A_{i}(t+\tau) A_{k}(t)\right\rangle . \tag{9.41} \label{9.41} \]
3. Commutativity. Classical phase-space functions commute:
\[ \left\langle A_{i}(t+\tau) A_{k}(t)\right\rangle=\left\langle A_{k}(t) A_{i}(t+\tau)\right\rangle . \tag{9.42} \label{9.42} \]
Combining these three steps:
\[ C_{i k}(\tau) \equiv\left\langle A_{i}(t) A_{k}(t+\tau)\right\rangle=\left\langle A_{k}(t) A_{i}(t+\tau)\right\rangle \equiv C_{k i}(\tau) . \tag{9.43} \label{9.43} \]
Hence for even-parity variables the cross-correlator is symmetric: \(C_{i k}(\tau)=C_{k i}(\tau)\).
Concluding reciprocity
Differentiating both sides at \(\tau=0\) and applying Equation \ref{9.39}:
\[ -k_{\mathrm{B}} L_{i k}=-k_{\mathrm{B}} L_{k i}, \tag{9.44} \label{9.44} \]
and therefore
\[ L_{i j}=L_{j i} . \tag{9.45} \label{9.45} \]
The analogous argument for odd-parity variables (which pick up a sign under time reversal) yields the Casimir extension \(L_{i j}=-L_{j i}\) in the mixed case, consistent with Equation \ref{9.34}.
Remark 9.2. Proofs A and B are complementary, not redundant. Proof A makes the role of the current-current Green-Kubo correlator explicit and extends immediately to quantum systems via Equation \ref{9.26}. Proof B is closer to Onsager's original argument and makes the Gaussian fluctuation assumption and the orthogonality relation Equation \ref{9.37} explicit-ingredients that are sometimes hidden in the Green-Kubo approach.
This page titled 9.5: Onsager-Casimir Reciprocal Relations was last modified on Mon, 02 Nov 2026 06:09:34 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Pabitra N. Sen.
The book could not be loaded just now.