41.1: Models of the Atom

Physics: A Foundation for Scientists and Engineers · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    41.1: Models of the Atom
    Five models of the atom in a row, joined by arrows from left to right.
    Figure 41.1. Five models of the atom. Each was overturned by an experiment it could not explain: Thomson’s discovery of the electron, Rutherford’s gold-foil scattering, the stability and sharp spectra of atoms, and finally the wave nature of the electron.
    Figure descriptionFive models of the atom in a row, joined by arrows from left to right. Dalton, 1803: a solid shaded gray sphere. Thomson, 1897: a pale red sphere of positive charge, marked with plus signs, with small blue electrons scattered through it, labeled plum pudding. Rutherford, 1911: a tiny red nucleus at the center of a mostly empty atom, outlined by a dashed circle, with electrons circling it like planets on three tilted elliptical orbits, labeled tiny nucleus. Bohr, 1913: a red nucleus surrounded by three concentric circular orbits, with one electron on the middle orbit, labeled allowed orbits. Quantum, 1926: a red nucleus inside a blue haze that is densest at the center and fades outward, labeled electron cloud.

    The idea that matter is built from indivisible pieces is ancient, but the first modern atomic theory came from John Dalton in the early 1800s. Dalton proposed that each element is made of identical atoms that cannot be created, destroyed, or subdivided, and that compounds form when atoms of different elements combine in simple whole-number ratios. In this earliest picture (sometimes called the billiard-ball model) the atom was a tiny, uniform, solid sphere, the first of the five models in Figure 41.1.

    That picture survived until 1897, when J. J. Thomson discovered the electron and proved that atoms are in fact divisible. Because bulk matter is electrically neutral, Thomson reasoned that the negative electrons must be embedded in a spread-out cloud of positive charge, like raisins in a cake. This is the plum-pudding model.

    Rutherford's gold-foil experiment, drawn schematically.
    Figure 41.2. Rutherford’s gold-foil experiment (schematic). Most alpha particles pass nearly straight through the mostly empty atom (gray), but those aimed close to the tiny, dense nucleus are deflected through large angles, and a near head-on particle is scattered almost straight back (red). Only a minuscule, massive, positively charged core can turn a fast alpha particle around like this, which is fatal to the plum-pudding model.
    Figure descriptionRutherford's gold-foil experiment, drawn schematically. A beam of alpha particles travels from left to right toward a single small dark dot labeled nucleus. Most of the paths, drawn in gray, pass well above or below the nucleus and are bent only slightly. Two red paths that pass close to the nucleus are bent noticeably, one upward and one downward. A third red path aimed almost head-on at the nucleus is turned right around and sent back toward the upper left. Only a tiny, dense, massive core could reverse a fast alpha particle like that.

    The plum pudding was overthrown by one of the most famous experiments in physics. In 1911 Ernest Rutherford’s team fired energetic, positively charged alpha particles at a thin gold foil. If the positive charge were smeared out as Thomson imagined, every alpha particle should have sailed through with only a tiny deflection. Instead, while most did pass nearly straight through, a small fraction bounced back at large angles (Figure 41.2), as if they had struck something tiny, hard, and massive. Rutherford concluded that an atom’s positive charge and nearly all its mass are concentrated in a minuscule central nucleus, with the electrons occupying the comparatively vast space around it. The atom, it turned out, is mostly empty.

    Checkpoint 41.1

    Most alpha particles passed straight through the gold foil, but a few rebounded at large angles. Explain in one or two sentences why this result is fatal to the plum-pudding model but is exactly what a tiny, dense nucleus predicts.

    Answer

    Rutherford’s nuclear atom had a serious flaw, though: a classical electron orbiting a nucleus should continuously radiate energy, spiral inward, and collapse in a fraction of a nanosecond. In 1913 Niels Bohr fixed this by a bold postulate: that the electron may occupy only certain allowed orbits, in which it does not radiate, and that light is emitted or absorbed only when it jumps between them. The Bohr model, which we develop in Section 41.3, gets the hydrogen spectrum exactly right. Yet even it is not the final word: the modern quantum (or electron-cloud) model, built by Schrödinger and others, replaces the electron’s sharp orbit with a smeared probability cloud, as we saw for trapped particles in Chapter 40. We will arrive at that picture by the end of the chapter.

    Answers to Checkpoints

    Checkpoint 41.1. In the plum-pudding model the positive charge is spread thinly through the whole atom, so its electric field is everywhere too weak to deflect a fast, heavy alpha particle by more than a tiny angle. A rebound requires an enormous force, which only a very small, dense concentration of positive charge and mass can supply. The rare large-angle scatters are the few alphas that happen to pass very close to such a nucleus; the rest miss it and pass straight through.


    This page titled 41.1: Models of the Atom was last modified on Thu, 12 Nov 2026 04:27:05 GMT and is shared under a CC BY 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Michael Ragsdale.